CLASSISMFour Myths of Classism 1. We are a classless society. 2. We are a middle class nation. 3. We...
Transcript of CLASSISMFour Myths of Classism 1. We are a classless society. 2. We are a middle class nation. 3. We...
10/20/2014
1
CLASSISM
A Tutorial
10/20/2014 1
OBJECTIVE #10 Define classism and its’ dominant and subordinate groups.
10/20/2014 2
What is classism?
• System of oppression
• Dominant group = privilege – Valued
• Subordinate groups = disadvantage – Devalued
• Cultural Classism
10/20/2014 3
10/20/2014
2
CLASSIST BELIEFS
10/20/2014 4
Individualism • (1a1) : a doctrine that the interests of the individual are
or ought to be ethically paramount; also : conduct guided by such a doctrine
• (b) : a theory maintaining the political and economic independence of the individual and stressing individual initiative, action, and interests
(Merriam-Webster)
• (1a) Belief in the primary importance of the individual
and in the virtues of self-reliance and personal;
• (2a) A doctrine advocating freedom from government regulation in the pursuit of a person's economic goals.
(Free Dictionary)
10/20/2014 5
Meritocracy
• "This mythology ... denies the role of personal connections, wealth, background, gender, race, or education in an individual's success," writes Alice Marwick, a professor at Fordham University. "If, for example, women (or people of color, or gay people) are not getting venture-capital funding at the same rate as men, the myth maintains, it is due to their lack of ability rather than institutional sexism. It also justifies immense wealth as the worthy spoils of the smartest and best.“
(Alice Marwick, professor at Fordham University as quoted in Hu, 2014)
10/20/2014 6
10/20/2014
3
10/20/2014 7
The Upperclass
• Wealthiest 1% holds 34% of national wealth • Wealthiest 20% hold 85% of total household wealth in
U.S. • .75% of adult population earn more than $1 million
annually • 400 billionaires in the U.S.
– More than 12 of them worth more than $10 billion
• Income of top 1% rose by more than 180 percent
(1979-2000) – Income of middle fifth of population grew by 12.4%
10/20/2014 8
The Middle Class
• White collar jobs
• Fringe benefits
• Assets
– Savings
– Investments
– Home ownership
10/20/2014 9
Class & U.S. Population
Upper
Middle
WorkingClass
Poor
10/20/2014
4
The Working Class
• Blue collar jobs – Unpleasant / dangerous
working conditions – Less job security – Higher unemployment
• Lower savings or assets
– Less likely to own home
• More likely to spend
more of income on housing
10/20/2014 10
Class & U.S. Population
Upper
Middle
WorkingClass
Poor
The Poor
• Minorities
• Women
• Children
• Low paying jobs
• Low skill jobs
• Few / no benefits
• Hourly wages
• U.S. Census (2009)
– 14.3% living in poverty
• Rates of poverty – Non-Hispanic Whites = 8.6
to 9.4%
– African Americans = 24.7 to 25.8%
– Hispanics = 23.2 to 25.3%
– Asians = 12.5% (no change)
10/20/2014 11
OBJECTIVE #11
Describe the relationship between class and violence, health/mental health, income/economics, employment, and housing
10/20/2014 12
10/20/2014
5
Poverty & Health
• Higher rates of:
– infant mortality
– Eye and ear disease
– Arthritis
– Physical disability
– Diabetes
– Nutritional deficiency
– Respiratory disease
– Mental illness
– Heart disease
Lower levels of treatment for illness/disease
10/20/2014 13
Education, Recreation, & Training • Poverty decreases access to education, recreational activities,
and training
– Positive correlation SAT scores and family income
– Now and then
• 30 years ago, upper class children 2x likely to obtain training beyond high school and 4x likely to obtain a postgraduate degree
– Similar today, except…
• Getting into college has increased / completion has decreased
• Increased access to education/decreasing completion of degrees
10/20/2014 14
Housing
• Those in poverty more likely to live in areas high with environmental toxins
– Louisiana Cancer Ally
– Agriculture Street Landfill in New Orleans
• Southeastern State Study (GAO) – Blacks are majority in 3 of 4
communities built on landfills 10/20/2014 15
10/20/2014
6
NIMBY
• Suburban neighborhoods oppose low income housing
– “brings down the neighborhood”
– Lowers home values
10/20/2014 16
Gentrification
• Government funding to “revitalize” abandoned property or assets that have decreased in value
10/20/2014 17
Poverty & Employment
• More likely to be unemployed, or under employed
10/20/2014 18
10/20/2014
7
Poverty & Violence
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
WitnessedViolence
PhysicalAssault
PhysicallyAbusive
Punishment
Sexual Assault
Less than $20,000
$20-50,000
More than $50,000
10/20/2014 19
Poverty & Violence
• Women with low income (less than $7,500) 7x higher risk of being a victim of interpersonal violence than those making $75,000 or more – Results in $727 million in lost wages annually
• Abused and neglected children achieve lower levels of education in adulthood
• Youths in urban areas are more likely to be arrested then those in suburban and rural areas – Police bias and increase violence in urban areas
10/20/2014 20
OBJECTIVE #10 Dissect four myths that perpetuate classism
10/20/2014 21
10/20/2014
8
Four Myths of Classism
1. We are a classless society.
2. We are a middle class nation.
3. We are all getting richer!
4. We are all given an equal chance to succeed.
10/20/2014 22
OBJECTIVE #11
Contrast stereotypes in the media as they perpetuate attitudes about class.
10/20/2014 23
Class & the Media
• High status occupations
• Racialized jobs
10/20/2014 24
10/20/2014
9
Class Stereotypes & the Media
• Upper Class
• Middle Class
• Working Class
10/20/2014 25
Stereotypes of the poor
• Functionally and/or morally inferior
• “kind of people” with set profile and values
• “White trash” – acceptable derogatory language to define the characteristics of poor Whites
10/20/2014 26
The poor do not exist in the media.
• The poor are faceless.
• The poor are undeserving.
• The poor are an eyesore.
• The poor are to blame.
• The poor are down on their luck. 10/20/2014 27 [click] [click] [click] [click] [click]
10/20/2014
10
OBJECTIVE #12
Discuss framing techniques as they shape attitudes and stereotypes about class.
10/20/2014 28
Framing Techniques & Classism
Upper Class
• Consensus framing
• Admiration framing
• Emulation framing
Middle Class
• Middle class values framing
10/20/2014 29
Framing Techniques & Classism
Working Class
• Caricature framing
Poor/Homeless
• Thematic framing
• Episodic framing
10/20/2014 30
10/20/2014
11
References • American Psychological Association (2010). Violence and socioeconomic status. Retrieved from
http://www.apa.org/pi/ses/resources/publications/factsheet-violence.pdf.
• Appleby, G. (2011). Culture, social class, and social identity development. In G.A. Appleby, E. Colon, and J. Hamilton (Eds.), Diversity, oppression, and social functioning (pp. 27 – 29). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
• Crouch, J., Hanson, R.F., Saunders, B.E., Kilpatrick, D.G., and Resnick, H.S. (2000). Income, race/ethnicity, and exposure to violence in youth: Results from a national survey of adolescents. Journal of Community Psychology, 28. Retrieved from http://www.nctsnet.org/nctsn_assets/Articles/77.pdf.
• EndAbuse (n.d.). Race and violence: What we know and what we need to learn. Retrieved from http://highestgoodconsulting.org/pdf/RaceIncomeViolence.pdf.
• Horwitt, D. (2008). This hard-earned money comes stuffed in their genes. In K.E. Rosenblum and T.M. Travis (5th ed.), The meaning of difference (pp. 153-155). New York: McGraw-Hill.
• Hu, E. (2014, February 17). How The Meritocracy Myth Affects Women In Technology. Retrived from http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2014/02/06/272646267/how-the-meritocracy-myth-affects-women-in-technology.
• Kendall, D. (2008). Framing class: media representations of wealth and poverty in America. In K.E. Rosenblum and T.M. Travis (5th ed.), The meaning of difference (pp. 138 – 143). New York: McGraw-Hill.
• Kottak, C.P. and Kozaitis, K.A. (2008). On being different: diversity and multiculturalism in the North American mainstream (3rd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
• Mantsios, G. (2006). Class in America. In P.S. Rothenberg (Ed.), Race, class, and gender in the United States (pp. 182-195). New York: Worth.
• Mantsios, G. (2007). Media magic: making class invisible. In P.S. Rothenberg (Ed.), Race, class, and gender in the United States (pp. 636-644). New York: Worth.
• Parker, K. (2012). Yes the rick are different. Retrieved from http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2012/08/27/yes-the-rich-are-different/.
10/20/2014 31
American Perceptions
10/20/2014 32
American Realities
10/20/2014 33
10/20/2014
12
American Perceptions
10/20/2014 34