CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United...

23
City of drian Office of the Mayor December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois 60604 -3507 135 E. Maumee St. •Adrian, Michigan 49221-2703 (517) 264-4881 •Fax (517) 264-8016 Re: Former DURA Convertible Systems, 1365 Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan Dear Mr. Mankowski: As a follow-up to your discussion with our environmental consultant, ASTI Envi ronmenta l, on Friday November 20 , 2015, this letter has been prepared to request your assistance in evaluat ing and mitigating a potential public health concern associated within three deb ri s piles (approximately 4,000 to 4,500 cubic yards of debris) located at the former DURA Convertible Systems facility in Adrian , Michigan. These piles contain bu ilding debris left on-site after demolition activities by a previous owner. The property is currently owned by Lenawee County who received the property through ta x reversion. The Property is, however, located in the City of Adrian, and the city has been receiving complaints about its presence and concerns over potential environmental contamination possibly included within the debris. While the site is in an industrial area, there are residential homes contiguous to the site. To address the potential for the presence of asbestos in the debris, the City of Adrian Brownfield Redevelopment Authority retained ASTI Environmental to assess the three piles. We received ASTl's report and noted numerous samples contained asbestos. We believe the presence of this debris is both a physical and health hazard to the communi ty, and in particular since the property is not secured, the City is requesting your assistance in assessment and removal. Neither the county nor the City of Ad rian has the funding to address it, and ne ither participated in the demolition activities. We have attached ou r consultant's report for your review. Please call our city administrator, Shane Horn. ( 51 7. 264.4831 ) at your ea rli est convenience to discuss the matter. Sincerely, 1ttA( Mayor . City of Adria' Cc: Senator Debbie Stabenow Senator Gary Peters Mr. Robert Anderson, ASTI Environmental "respect for the individual voice, service for the common good"

Transcript of CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United...

Page 1: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

City of drian

Office of the Mayor

December 9, 2015

Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois 60604 -3507

135 E. Maumee St. •Adrian, Michigan 49221-2703

(517) 264-4881 •Fax (517) 264-8016

Re: Former DURA Convertible Systems, 1365 Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan

Dear Mr. Mankowski:

As a follow-up to your discussion with our environmental consultant, ASTI Environmental, on Friday November 20, 2015, this letter has been prepared to request your assistance in evaluating and mitigating a potential public health concern associated within three debris piles (approximately 4,000 to 4,500 cubic yards of debris) located at the former DURA Convertible Systems facility in Adrian , Michigan. These piles contain bu ilding debris left on-site after demolition activities by a previous owner.

The property is currently owned by Lenawee County who received the property through tax reversion . The Property is, however, located in the City of Adrian , and the city has been receiving complaints about its presence and concerns over potential environmental contamination possibly included within the debris. While the site is in an industrial area, there are residential homes contiguous to the site. To address the potential for the presence of asbestos in the debris, the City of Adrian Brownfield Redevelopment Authority retained ASTI Environmental to assess the three piles. We received ASTl's report and noted numerous samples contained asbestos.

We believe the presence of this debris is both a physical and health hazard to the community, and in particular since the property is not secured, the City is requesting your assistance in assessment and removal. Neither the county nor the City of Adrian has the funding to address it, and neither participated in the demolition activities. We have attached our consultant's report for your review. Please call our city administrator, Shane Horn. (51 7.264.4831 ) at your earliest convenience to discuss the matter.

Sincerely,

ck~7-lt1 1ttA( Mayor . City of Adria'

Cc: Senator Debbie Stabenow Senator Gary Peters Mr. Robert Anderson, ASTI Environmental

"respect for the individual voice, service for the common good"

Page 2: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

A)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

November 4, 2015

Mr. Chris Miller City of Adrian 135 East Maumee Street Adrian, Michigan 49221

Investigation • Remediation Compliance • Restoration

10448 Citation Drive, Suite 100 Brighton, Ml 48116

Mailing Address: P.O. Box 2160 Brighton, Ml 48116-2160

800 395-ASTI Fax: 810.225.3800

www.asti-env.com

RE: Asbestos Sampling of Debris Piles, 1365 Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan (AST/ Project No. 9408)

Dear Mr. Miller:

ASTI Environmental (ASTI) was retained to evaluate the stock piled debris at the former Dura facility and collect discrete samples from the debris for asbestos testing. ASTI observed three debris piles on the Property. Refer to attached figure for an approximate location and volume of the debris piles observed. Refer to Attachment A for photographs of the debris piles sampled. For this evaluation, ASTI visually evaluated building materials within the piles and collected samples to identify the presence and condition of any potential asbestos-containing materials (ACMs). Visual evaluation of the debris piles revealed each of the materials sampled, as well as the other debris present, were generally in poor condition and appear to have been exposed to the elements for an extensive period of time.

During the evaluation, ASTI personnel collected a total of 19 samples for asbestos testing. Samples were collected in accordance with applicable local, state and federal regulations. The samples were collected by Robert C. Anderson, PG, EP, State of Michigan Certified Asbestos Building Inspector (Accreditation No. A22206). Mr. Anderson's resume and accreditation are provided as Attachment B.

Following collection, the bulk samples were transmitted under chain-of-custody protocol to SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. (SanAir) in Powhatan, Virginia for asbestos analysis using polarized light microscopy with dispersion staining (PLM/DS) in accordance with the US Environmental Protection Agency's (US EPA's) "Interim Method for the Determination of Asbestos in Bulk Building Materials" (EPA 600/R-93/116), December 1993).

Page 3: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

' "-· ·• A~ ENVIRONMENTAL

The fo llowing material types were identified within the debris piles and sampled during the evaluation:

• Transite paneling • Pipe insulation • Roofing materials • Various surfacing materials • Various flooring materials and associated mastics • Various floor ti les and associated mastics

On November 3, 2015 ASTI received the asbestos test resu lts. Refer to Attachment C for a copy of the laboratory test results. Review of the results revealed the following materials were identified to contain asbestos:

SAMPLE ID LOCATION MATERIAL

RESULTS DESCRIPTION

PS-1 Pile No. 1 Roofing Material 5% Chrysotile

PS-2 Pile No. 1 Surfacing Material 20% Chrysot ile

PS-4 Pile No. 1 Pipe Insulation 65% Chrysotile

PS-7 Pile No. 1 Transite 20% Chrysotile

PS-1 1 Pile No.1 Pipe Insulation 65% Chrysotile

PS-12 Pile No. 1 Pipe Insulation 70% Chrysotile

PS-1 4 Pile No. 2 Transite 20% Chrysotile Mastic 2% Chrysotile

PS-17 Pile No. 3 Roof Paper 5% Chrysoti le

PS-18 Pile No. 3 Transite 20% Chrysotile

PS-19 Pile No. 3 Transite 20% Chrysotile

Review of the asbestos sample results revealed the identification of asbestos in each of the three debris piles. Accordingly, ASTI recommends that the debris be handled as friable asbestos-contaminated waste and care should be rendered to minimize disturbance of the material and the resulting potential release of asbestos fibers , including controll ing fugitive dust. According to classification guidelines set forth in NESHAP, the pipe insulation and surfacing material are regulated materials, therefore these materials must be addressed by a licensed abatement contractor using Class I remova l techniques and engineering controls to control dust.

Page 4: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

If you have any questions regarding the contents and/or conclusions in this report, please do not hesitate to call ASTI at (800) 395-2784.

Sincerely,

ASTI ENVIRONMENTAL

Robert C. Anderson, PG, EP Asbestos Inspector No. A22206

Figure - Site Features Map

Attachments

A Photo Log B Resume and Accreditation of Mr. Anderson C Results of Sample Analysis and Chain of Custody Document

Page 5: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~ - - - Property lirie

App<oxhlate S<:ale in Fetll <D Pele-Mounl&d Transformer ~ Dumpster

Former Dura Site Adrian MI Created for: City of Adrian Site Features Map AST! Project No.: <>40S, I\JE, !'\o\·emlxr 5, 2015

Page 6: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

Attachment A

Photographs

Page 7: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

PHOTO LOG Former Dura Site, 1365 East Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan

ASTI Project No. 9408 October 27, 2015 Photographed By Robert Anderson

Photo 1. General view of stockpiled debris located on the south portion of the Property

Photo 2. General view of stockpiled debris located on the south portion of the Property

Photo 3. Close-up view of stock­piled debris on south portion of Property. Note pipe insulation in central portion of photograph.

.l)ii r NVIRO NMr N'f /\t

Page 8: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

PHOTO LOG Former Dura Site, 1365 East Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan

ASTI Project No. 9408 October 27, 2015 Photographed By Robert Anderson

Photo 4. General view of pipe wrap on original pipe collected from southern debris pile.

Photo 5. General view of stockpiled debris located on the western portion of the Property

Photo 6. General view of floor tile material and mastic observed in western debris pile

I NVIRC>NMrNJAI

Page 9: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

PHOTO LOG Former Dura Site, 1365 East Beecher Street, Adrian, Michigan

ASTI Project No. 9408 October 27, 2015 Photographed By Robert Anderson

Photo 7. General view of surfacing material found in western debris pi le

Photo 8. General view of floor ti le in western debris pile

rNVIRO NMr N T/\ I

Page 10: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

A_)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

Attachment B

Credentials of Robert C. Anderson, PG, EP State of Michigan Asbestos Inspector

Accreditation Number A22206

Page 11: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

RESUME A S TI E NVIRONM E N T AL

ROBERT C. ANDERSON , P.G. Director - Site Redevelopment Services

PROFILE

Certifications/Licenses Environmental Professional (AAI) OSHA 29 CFR 1910.120 HAZWOPER OSHA 29 CFR 1910.120 HAZWOPER - Recertification (2014) Certified State of Michigan Lead Inspector and Lead Risk Assessor (P-05969) Asbestos Building Inspector Certificate (Certification No. 1063) Certified UST Professional - Michigan (Certification No. 584) Certified Industrial Storm Water Operator (Certification No. 09370) Certified Construction Site Storm Water Operator (Certification No. 10574) Licensed Geologist - Indiana (License No. IN2156) ASTM Risk-Based Corrective Action Applied to Petroleum Sites Certified Radon Measurement Specialist (Certification No. NRSB13SS043)

Education Old Dominion University (Graduate Studies - Geophysics) 1984 -1986 Lake Superior State College, B.S., Geology, 1983

Experience History Director - Site Redevelopment Services, ASTI ENVIRONMENTAL Vice-President- Environmental Services, Yeoman Group Team Leader -Atwell-Hicks, LLC Director - Environmental Services, CTI and Associates

Professional Memberships and Service Michigan Association of Environmental Professionals

Professional Background Mr. Anderson has more than 25 years experience in the environmental industry including environmental due diligence, due care evaluation and planning, soil/groundwater investigation and remediation programs for the f inancial and legal clients. Mr. Anderson has also coordinated numerous hazardous material and pre-demolition surveys which included evaluations of lead-based paint, asbestos, mold and radon for commercial and residential developments. In addition, Mr. Anderson has developed and coordinated various MSHDA and HUD environmental submittals for multi-family residential developments including Phase I and II Environmental Site Assessments, Baseline Environmental Assessments and Due Care Plans, asbestos, lead-based paint and mold surveys and management programs.

Years Experience: 2 - - ASTI Environmental

25 --- other firms

.l)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

Page 12: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

ENVIRONMENTAL DUE DILIGENCE AND SITE INVESTIGATION PROJECTS

Environmental Site Assessments Investigator and project manager for numerous projects (vacant land, agricultural, residential, commercial, and industrial) to determine the environmental condition of sites for real estate transactions. Projects involved both surface and subsurface evaluations of the sites for hazardous substances and petroleum products. Responsibilities include the preparation and/or review of ASTM Phase I and Transaction Screen ESAs, Baseline Environmental Assessments (BEAs), and Due Care Plans. Mr. Anderson is also knowledgeable with All Appropriate Inquiries (AAI) per 40 CFR Part 312 and meets the requirements of an Environmental Professional per AAI.

Site Assessment of 26 Automobile Dealerships in Michigan and Florida Project manager for environmental due diligence on transaction involving 26 automobile dealerships including completion of Phase I ESA, Phase II testing, as well as hazardous material survey. Audit included evaluation of facility compliance and cleaning and inspection of drainage structures. Project completed in 6 weeks and allowed client to close prior to end of year as required by the bank.

Vapor Intrusion Evaluation. Flint. Michigan Conducted multiple vapor intrusion studies at commercial properties to assess potential vapor migration. Scope of work included coordination of vapor intrusion points, vapor sample collection and coordination of chemical testing. Following receipt of the chemical test results, potential vapor intrusion issues were addressed.

ASBESTOS, LEAD-BASED PAINT AND HAZARDOUS MATERIALS SURVEYS

Responsible for quality control and coordination of field activities for hazardous material survey, asbestos, lead-based paint and mold related testing. Acted as resource to staff regarding implementation of company's asbestos, lead-based paint, mold assessment program. In addition to the above, coordinated clearance sampling following lead dust hazard, following completion of lead, asbestos and mold remediation projects.

Former Redford High School. Redford, Michigan Project coordinator for asbestos abatement, hazardous material removal, hydraulic hoist and UST removal activities. Worked with on-site industrial hygienist to document .asbestos abatement and demolition activities. Provided air

Page 2 - Resume of Robert C. Anderson, May 2012

monitoring assistance during building demolition activities.

Former LTV Steel Facility, Ferndale, Michigan Project coordinator for environmental due diligence for property acquisition including completion of Phase I, Phase II, asbestos and hazardous material survey. Assisted certified building asbestos inspector with asbestos survey and quantification, as well as hazardous material survey.

Former Brighton Athletic Center, Brighton, Michigan Project coordinator for asbestos, hazardous material and lead inspection. Assisted certified building asbestos inspector with asbestos survey and quantification, as well as hazardous material survey. Coordinated with industrial hygienist during abatement and clearance sampling.

PETROLEUM REMEDIATION PROJECTS

Private Oil Company Divestiture Project manager for major oil company divestiture for 42 petroleum service stations located in southeastern Michigan. Work included completion of Phase I and II site evaluations including review of tank monitoring data, review of historical corrective actions conducted on-site, and completion of soil and groundwater testing. Following completion of field studies cost-to­close evaluations were conducted at each location where release was identified. Work was completed with no delays or injuries

Hoist Decommissioning Program - Automobile Dealership. Southeastern Michigan Project manager for environmental due diligence and hoist decommissioning at a large automobile dealership. Work included completion of a Phase I ESA and Phase II testing, followed by the removal of 26 in-ground hydraulic hoists, one oil/water separator and approximately 1,200 cubic yards of petroleum impacted soil. Following soil removal soil verification samples were collected for chemical testing and the site was restored.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Mr. Anderson can be reached at ASTI Environmental (ASTI), 10448 Citation Drive, Suite 100, Brighton, Ml 48116, or by calling 810.225.2800 (Toll-Free 800.395.ASTI). His email address is randerson@asti ­env.com. More information about ASTI is available on the web at www.asti-env.com.

.l)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

Page 13: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

,

State of ?tl1cfuean _. •• \'Y .. ' • • • • ' • • • • ,,. '

... I !it•'" ,J , Ul•I,(,.,. !.•l•Tt &, "•• '' .. <! .. ' "'•I ' "'~I~· p loo• ..

Asbestos lnsJ)ector

Robert C. Anderson 5066 Wishing Well Drive Grand Blanc, Ml 48439

Accreditation Number A22206

Expiration Date '09/iS/2016

Ths 1n~~I hn $Al1s1'C:Cot1ly met °' e11.ceeded the raquire~s ot Mich'gan P\Jbll'c Act 440 of 1988, H atModed lo b4 .acc:t.a:ted as an Afibesto-. Inspector

DOB: 04/0Sl1959

11 8372

Page 14: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

..l)ii ENVIRONMENTAL

Attachment C

Laboratory Report and Chain of Custody Document

Page 15: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

SanAir Technologies Laboratory

Analysis Report

prepared for

ASTI Environmental

Report Date: 11 /3/2015 Project Name: Dura Site Assessment Project # : 9408 SanAir ID#: 15034307

NVLAP LAB CODE 200870·0 Certification t 652931 License# LA80166 ~Air

Technol0ijies Laboratory

www.sana1r.com

Page 16: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

--... SanA1r lo. -.·•L.oWo .. ,

SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. 1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 804.897.1 177 Toll Free: 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070 Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail: iaq@sanair. com

ASTI Environmental 10448 Citation Dr. Suite 100 Brighton, MI 48116

November 3, 2015

SanAir ID# Project Name: Project Number:

15034307 Dura Site Assessment 9408

Dear Robert Anderson,

We at SanAir would like to thank you for the work you recently submitted. The 19 sample(s) were received on Friday, October 30, 2015 via FedEx. The final report(s) is enclosed for the following sample(s): PS-1 , PS-2, PS-3, PS-4, PS-5, PS-6, PS-7, PS-8, PS-9, PS-10, PS-11, PS-12, PS-13, PS-14, PS-1 5, PS-1 6, PS-17, PS-18, PS-19.

These results only pertain to th is job and should not be used in the interpretation of any other job. This report is only complete in its entirety. Refer to the listing below of the pages included in a complete final report.

Sincerely,

Sandra Sobrino Asbestos & Materials Laboratory Manager SanAir Technolog ies Laboratory

Final Report Includes: - Cover Letter

- Analysis Pages - Disclaimers and Additional Information

sample conditions : 19 sample(s) in Good cond ition

Page 17: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

Qir SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. SanAir ID Number

~·~·-· 1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 15034307 804.897.1177 Toll Free: 888.895. 1177 Fax: 804.897.0070 Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail: [email protected] FINAL REPORT

Name: Address:

ASTI Environmental 10448 Citation Dr. Suite 100 Brighton, Ml 48116

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116

Project Number: P.O. Number:

Project Name:

Collected Date: Received Date:

Report Date: Analyst:

9408

Dura Site Assessment

10/27/2015 10/30/2015 10:50:00 AM 11/3/2015 4:24:48 PM Sobrino, Sandra

Stereoscopic Comp__Qnents Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS - 1 I 15034 307 - 001 Stockpiled Deb r i s

Black Non - Fibrous Heterogeneous

95% Other 5% Chrysotile

Stereoscopic Components Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS- 2 I 15034 307-002 Stockpi led Debr i s

Grey Non-Fibrous Het erogen eous

25% Cellulose 55% Other 20% Chrysotile

Stereoscopic ~onents Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-3 I 15034307-003 S t ockp i l ed Debris

Brown Fi b r ou s Heter ogeneous

85% Cellulose 15% Other Non e Detected

Stereoscopic ComQQ.llfil11§ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-4 I 1 503 4307 - 00 4 Stockpil ed Debris

White Fibrou s Homoge neous

35% Other 65% Chrysot ile

Stereoscopic CompQ~nts Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS - 5 I 15034307-005 Stockpile d Debris , Plaster

PS - 5 I 1503 4307- 005 Stockpiled Debr is , Dr ywal l

Whi te Non- Fi brous Heterogeneous

Wh it e Non- Fibrous Homogene ous

100% Ot h e r None Detect ed

1 00% Oth er None De t e c ted

Stereoscopic ~onents Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS - 6 I 1 5034307- 006 Stockpiled Debris , Fla s hing

PS - 6 I 15034307 - 006 St o ckp i l ed Debri s , Fe lt

Certification

Black No n -Fibr ous He t erogeneous

Bl ac k Fibrou s Homoge neous

Analyst: - JI?!.~~ '9--t, · n.:v:­Ana lys is~ cll / 3 /2015

1 00% Ot he r None Detect ed

85% Cel l u l ose 15% Oth er None Detected

Approved Signatory:

Date: 11 / 3 /2015 Page 1 of 4

Page 18: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~ff SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. SanAir ID Number

1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 804.897.1177 Toll Free: 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070

15034307 Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail: [email protected] FINAL REPORT

Name: Address:

ASTI Environmental 10448 Citation Dr. Suite 100 Brighton, Ml 48116

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116

Project Number: P.O. Number:

Project Name:

Collected Date: Received Date:

Report Date: Analyst:

9408

Dura Site Assessment

10/27/2015 10/30/2015 10:50:00 AM 11 /3/2015 4:24:48 PM Sobrino, Sandra

Stereoscopic Comnonent!:! Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-7 I 15034307-007 Stockpiled Debris

Grey Non - Fibrous Homogeneous

80% Other 20% Chrysotile

Stereoscopic COlllPQDerit~ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-8 I 1503430 7-008 Stockpil ed Debris, Insulation

Grey Fibrous Homogeneous

White Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

100% Cellulose < 1% Other None Detected

PS-8 I 15034307-008 Stockpiled Debris, Cover

100% Other None Detected

Stereoscopic ~ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS - 9 I 15034307-009 Stockpiled Debris

Black Non- Fibrous Heterogeneous

100% Other None Detected

Stereoscopic Components Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-10 I 15034307-010 Stockpiled Debris

Black 85% Cellulose 15% Other None Detected Fibrous Homogeneous

Stereoscopic ~ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS-11 I 15034307-011 Stockpiled Debris

Grey Fibrous Homogeneous

35% Other 65% Chrysotil e

Stereoscopic Comgonents Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers

PS - 12 I 15034307-012 Stockpiled Debris

Grey Fibrous Homogeneous

30% Other 70% Chrysotile

Certification

Analyst: , Jt?t.~ ~ ~ ,·~ Analysis~ c:ll/3/2015

Approved Signatory:

Date: 11/3/2015 Page 2 of 4

Page 19: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~if SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. SanAir ID Number

15034307 1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 804.897.1177 Toll Free: 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070 Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail: [email protected] FINAL REPORT

Name: Address:

ASTI Environmental 10448 Citation Dr. Suite 100 Brighton, Ml 48116

Project Number: P.O. Number:

Project Name:

Collected Date: Received Date:

Report Date: Analyst:

9408

Dura Site Assessment

1012712015 1013012015 10:50:00 AM 1113/2015 4:24:48 PM Sobrino, Sandra

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116 Stereoscopic Comp,onents Asbestos

SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS- 1 3 I 15034307-013 Stockpi led Debri s

White Non-Fibrous Heterogeneous

100% Ot her None Detected

Stereoscopic Compor:ients Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS - 14 I 1503 4307-014 From Stockpile, Transite

PS-14 I 15034307-014 From Stockpil e , Adh esive

Grey Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

Black Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

80% Other

98% Other

20% Chrysotile

2% Chrysotile

Stereoscopic Comp_gnents Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS - 15 I 15034307-015 FT And Mastic From Stockpile, Floor Tile

PS-15 I 1 5034307-015 FT And Mastic From Stockpile , Mastic

Brown Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

Bl ack Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

100% Other None Detecte d

100% Other None Detected

Stereoscopic Components Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS- 16 I 15034307 - 0 16 Stockpiled Debris, Paper

PS-16 I 15034307-016 Stockpil ed Debris, Plaster

Brown Fibrous Homogeneous

Wh ite Non-Fibrous Heterogeneous

100% Cellulose < 1% Other None Detected

100% Other None Detected

Stereoscopic ~ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS-17 I 15034307-017 Stockpiled Debris

Certification

Various Non-Fibrous Heterogeneous

Analyst: , }"""~ ~ k-t··~ Analysis~ cll /3/20 15

45% Cellulose 50% Other 5% Chrysotile

Approved Signatory:

Date: 11/3/2015 Page 3 of 4

Page 20: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

~r SanAir Technologies Laboratory, Inc. SanAir ID Nw:nber

15034307 1551 Oakbridge Drive, Suite B, Powhatan, VA 23139 804.897.1177 Toll Free: 888.895.1177 Fax: 804.897.0070 Web: http://www.sanair.com E-mail : [email protected]

Name: ASTI Environmental Address: 10448 Citation Dr.

Suite 100 Brighton, Ml 48116

Asbestos Bulk PLM EPA 600/R-93/116

FINAL REPORT

Project Number: 9408 P.O. Number:

Project Name: Dura Site Assessment

Collected Date: Received Date:

Report Date: Analyst:

10/27/2015 10/30/2015 10:50:00 AM 11/3/2015 4:24:48 PM Sobrino, Sandra

Stereoscopic ~ Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS-18 I 15034307 - 018 Stockpiled Debris

Grey Non-Fibrous Heter ogeneous

80% Other 20% Chrysotile

Stereoscopic Co!llpon~nls Asbestos SanAir ID I Description Appearance % Fibrous % Non-Fibrous Fibers PS-19 I 15034307 -019 Stockpiled Debris, Transite

PS-19 I 1 503 4307-019 Stockpiled Debris, Fiber Board

Certification

Grey Non-Fibrous Homogeneous

Brown Fibrous Homogeneous

Analyst: . Jt?t.~ ~ ~, · n.:\1-" Analysis~ cll /3/201 5

80% Othe r 20% Chrysotile

98% Cellulose 2% Other None Detected

Approved Signatory:

Date: 11/ 3 / 2015 Page 4 of 4

Page 21: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

Disclaimer

The final report cannot be reproduced, except in full, without written authorization from SanAir. Fibers smaller than 5 microns cannot be seen with this method due to scope limitations. The accuracy of the results is dependent upon the client's sampling procedure and information provided to the laboratory by the client. SanAir assumes no responsibility for the sampling procedure and will provide evaluation reports based solely on the sample and information provided by the client. This report may not be used by the client to claim product endorsement by NVLAP or any other agency of the U.S. government.

For NY state samples, method EPA 600/M4-82-020 is performed.

Polarized- light microscopy is not consistently reliable in detecting asbestos in floor covering and similar non-friable organically bound materials. Quantitative transmission electron microscopy is currently the only method that can be used to determine if this material can be considered or treated as non-asbestos containing.

NY ELAP lab ID 11983

Page 22: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

I

1551 Oak:bridge Drive Suite B SanAir ID Number

Sa11A1r Powhatan, VA 23139

'I(' 804-897-11771888-895-1177

1553~301-Fax 804-897-0070

Technologies Laboratory www.sanair.com

-

Comoanv: AS.T";C. £>--V•e.."......c'-'~"'"I I Proiect#: 4.A..oe Collected by: JZ. A..Ol6"1..So .::>

Address: IC~4*:. c..L ...... ·' (\_ ..,cz: Proiect Name: Cl,rA S,-l, A hone#: ~10, ZZ..S'. 'Z.160~

Citv. Sl Zio: Br-L..! ...... i...-{-:z: .4St11- Date Collected: 101 .. .., I,.., Fax#: "'11~. z.:z.'5. lrl!e><o . . State of CoUection: µ:r: Account#: P.O. Number: Email: iA~'"""-"-.-<!f' .a.s-t: -OErY

Bulk Air Soil/llermlcullte ABB PLM EPA 600/R-93/116 fVI ABA PCM NIOSH 7400 D ABSE PLM EPA 600/R-93/116 (Qual. D

Positive Stop n ABA-2 OSHAw/TWA' D ABSP PLM CARB 435 (LOD <1%) n AB EPA PLM EPA 400 Point Count D ABTEM TEMAHERA D ABSP1 PLM CARB 435 (LOO 0.25%) r ABB1K PLM EPA 1000 Point Count D ABATN TEM NIOSH 7402 D ABSP2 PLM CARS 435 (LOD 0.1%) n ABB EN PLMEPANOB D ABT2 TEM Level II D ABBCH TEM Chatfield D Dust

ABB TM TEMEPANOB r1 New York ELAP IABWA TEM Wipe ASTM D-8480 0 PLMNY PLM EPA 600/M4-82-Q20 n ABDMV TEM Microvac ASTM D-5755 D

Water ABEPA2 NY ELAP 198.1 0 ASHE I EPA 100.2 !DI ABENY NY ELAP 198.6 PLM NOB D Matrix Other

ABB NY NY ELAP 198.4 TEM NOB D I I !DI \um Around 3 HR (4 HR TEM) D 6 HR (BHR TEM) 0 I 12 HR D 24 HR D

TI mes 2 Days D 3 Days D I 4 Days D 5 Days D

Special Instructions I

Sample# Sample Identification/location Volume Sample Flow Time" or Area; Typo Rate"' 5!>111-Slop

ps- l 5-\-...._."-. I:>, \e:b D0cbr1 <::'. - BLA.t.. ~

Ps- z " ' ,, - (,,n,,,.,

'f's.· 3 ll !l - iS """"'"' ,_, Ps-4 I• " - &1"""1

P>- s 11 ,, - & ..... /--g-.....;, \:'.A;;-&, ,. .. - BL~"-

P'S- I It " - {,,r,_, / S'-""-~

es-s , , ,, - l...-1.... i._ Ps - "'l ,, ti - i?~ P~-10 II

, , ... BL~C:"-1 f3 Le).....,. ..:

f's;- ( \ \I h - Gr...., -ps- 12--- tl " - &r ,_,

Date Time

Unless sched\,ded, the turn around time for an samples received after 3 pm EST Friday will begin at 8 am Monday morning. Weekend or Hoiidey work must be sched1;iled ahead! of time and ls charged for rush tum around time. Work with standard turn around time sent Priority Overnight and BU!ed to Recipient MU be charged a $10 shipping fee.

Page _l_of ...h_

Page 23: CITY OF ADRIAN LETTER RE: REQUEST FOR U.S. EPA …December 9, 2015 Mr. Mathew Mankowski United States Environmental Protection Agency Region 5 77 West Jackson Boulevard Chicago, Illinois

Sample Identification/Location Sample Flow Time*

Sample# Type Rate• Start-Stop

pS-\~ 5-todc..-::., \-.:= ~ t>e:::br. s. - L-l.. ~~ F's -14

I i-k,lc7 ~ 1-"T ~c frl.-'\A-S '"'\" ' '- -Ps-~s 1 ... 13ro~v J s.--,. l.-Ps.- '"=' 5-te:>~f". I~ c..,.b '"' $. - 'B 12..o '---'

PS.-\I S+.,x_lt.- f', I~ ~r•.S. - 13.~

f's.- \e I\ I• - '-r~ I

B-14 \• I• - B~-

I Special Instructions j

Date Time

Unless scheduled, the tum around time for all samples received after 3 pm Friday wiH begin at 8 am Monday morning. Weekend or Holiday work must be scheduled ahead of time and is. charged for .rush tum around time. Work with standard tum around time sent Priority Overnight and BIAed to Recipient will be charged a $10 shipping fee.

Page -Zof l..-.