Choosing Our

34

Transcript of Choosing Our

Page 1: Choosing Our
Page 2: Choosing Our

Choosing Our Community’s Future

Choosing Our Choosing Our

Community’s FutureCommunity’s Future

A Citizen’s Guide to Getting the A Citizen’s Guide to Getting the

Most out of DevelopmentMost out of Development

Rail-Volution Tool Box SessionSept. 9, 2005Presented by:David Goldberg, Communications DirectorSmart Growth America

Lisa Nisenson, YIMBYU.S. Neighborhood Protection Agency

Page 3: Choosing Our

Why this guidebook?Why this guidebook?Why this guidebook?

Communities can be Communities can be

shaped by choice, or shaped by choice, or

they can be shaped by they can be shaped by

chance. We can keep on chance. We can keep on

accepting the kind of accepting the kind of

communities we get, or communities we get, or

we can start creating the we can start creating the

kind of communities we kind of communities we

want. want. —— Richard Moe, Richard Moe,

National Trust for National Trust for

Historic PreservationHistoric Preservation

Page 4: Choosing Our

Why this guidebook?Why this guidebook?Why this guidebook?

The surest way to create The surest way to create

neighborhoods, towns and metro neighborhoods, towns and metro

areas worthy of passing on to our areas worthy of passing on to our

children is to engage the full, children is to engage the full,

informed participation of the people informed participation of the people

who live in them.who live in them.

It is our hope that, by leveling the playing It is our hope that, by leveling the playing

field for citizens even a little bit, we can field for citizens even a little bit, we can

help make planning and development help make planning and development

more collaborative and less adversarial.more collaborative and less adversarial.

Page 5: Choosing Our

Why this guidebook?Why this guidebook?

Page 6: Choosing Our

Help for citizens on:Help for citizens on:Help for citizens on:

•• BigBig--box developmentsbox developments

•• InfillInfill

•• Mixed useMixed use

•• Mixed housing typesMixed housing types

•• RedevelopmentRedevelopment

•• Greenfield developmentGreenfield development

•• Community planningCommunity planning

Page 7: Choosing Our

What citizens say they wantWhat citizens say they wantWhat citizens say they want

•• A seat at the table for everyone with A seat at the table for everyone with

a stake in the community.a stake in the community.

•• Plentiful choices among safe, Plentiful choices among safe,

convenient and attractive convenient and attractive

neighborhoods.neighborhoods.

•• Ready access to jobs, daily Ready access to jobs, daily

necessities and fun, with less time in necessities and fun, with less time in

traffic.traffic.

Page 8: Choosing Our

What citizens say they wantWhat citizens say they wantWhat citizens say they want

•• Thriving cities, suburbs and towns. Thriving cities, suburbs and towns.

(Fix it first, invest where we live.)(Fix it first, invest where we live.)

•• Preserving what’s best about the Preserving what’s best about the

places we live.places we live.

•• Lower personal costs and efficient Lower personal costs and efficient

use of tax money.use of tax money.

•• A shot at the America dream of A shot at the America dream of

opportunity for all.opportunity for all.

Page 9: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Make development Make development decisions decisions predictable, fair predictable, fair and cost effective.and cost effective.

Fair to:Fair to:

CitizensCitizens

DevelopersDevelopers

Public officialsPublic officials

Page 10: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Create a range of housing opportunities and Create a range of housing opportunities and

choiceschoices

The Kentlands, Gaithersburg, MD

Page 11: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Provide a variety of Provide a variety of

transportation transportation

options.options.

Light rail in Denver

Page 12: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Strengthen existing communities and steer Strengthen existing communities and steer

development toward them.development toward them.

Riverfront redevelopment in Providence, RI

Page 13: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Preserve natural Preserve natural

beauty, parks, beauty, parks,

farmland and farmland and

environmentally environmentally

critical areas.critical areas.

Barton Springs, Austin, TX

Page 14: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Create complete Create complete

neighborhoods neighborhoods

where daily need where daily need

are close at are close at

hand.hand.

Page 15: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Create a safe, Create a safe,

inviting inviting

environment environment

for walking.for walking.

Page 16: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Foster distinctive Foster distinctive

communities communities

with a strong with a strong

sense of place.sense of place.

New town centerSmyrna, GA

Page 17: Choosing Our

Key Principles for Managing Change

Key Principles Key Principles

for Managing Changefor Managing Change

Make efficient use Make efficient use

of public of public

investments in investments in

infrastructure, infrastructure,

schools and schools and

services.services.

Page 18: Choosing Our

Chapter 2. A citizen’s intro to planning

Chapter 2. A citizen’s Chapter 2. A citizen’s

intro to planningintro to planning

•• Steps in the P&Z processSteps in the P&Z process

•• Zoning and development Zoning and development regsregs

•• Key players and their rolesKey players and their roles

•• Understanding developersUnderstanding developers

•• Key questions to get answeredKey questions to get answered

•• What to say in your 2 minutesWhat to say in your 2 minutes

Page 19: Choosing Our

Chapter 3. Evaluating potential impacts of development

Chapter 3. Evaluating Chapter 3. Evaluating potential potential

impacts of developmentimpacts of development

•• Evaluating density Evaluating density

(gross, net, FAR, (gross, net, FAR,

benefits of, key ?s)benefits of, key ?s)

•• Assessing traffic impacts Assessing traffic impacts

(real (real vsvs. feared, . feared,

mitigating, parking and)mitigating, parking and)

•• Impacts of big box Impacts of big box

centerscenters

“Given the poor

planning

associated with

much recent

development,

many people

have a rational

suspicion of new

projects.”

Page 20: Choosing Our

Chapter 3. Evaluating potential impacts of development

Chapter 3. Evaluating potential Chapter 3. Evaluating potential

impacts of developmentimpacts of development

•• Rental and affordable housingRental and affordable housing

(design solutions, economic and (design solutions, economic and

traffic considerations)traffic considerations)

•• Security and safety (eyes on the Security and safety (eyes on the

street, calm streets, etc.)street, calm streets, etc.)

•• Property values and market Property values and market

demanddemand

Page 21: Choosing Our

Chapter 4. Gauging the enviro impact of development

Chapter 4. Gauging the Chapter 4. Gauging the enviro enviro

impact of developmentimpact of development

•• Using, not abusing, Using, not abusing, enviro enviro lawslaws

•• Growth and air quality (air facts, Growth and air quality (air facts,

checking impacts of development)checking impacts of development)

•• Water quality, Water quality, stormwaterstormwater mgmt.mgmt.

•• Natural areas and endangered species Natural areas and endangered species

(pertinent (pertinent regsregs, strategic conservation, , strategic conservation,

techniques)techniques)

Page 22: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• Case studies in which readers can Case studies in which readers can

see themselves and their own see themselves and their own

situationssituations

•• Lessons on constructive Lessons on constructive

engagement that brings benefit to engagement that brings benefit to

the communitythe community

•• CharettesCharettes, how they work, and an , how they work, and an

example of success example of success

Page 23: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

Atlantic Station,Atlantic Station,

Atlanta, GAAtlanta, GA

•• BrownfieldBrownfield

•• Adjacent to Adjacent to

singlesingle--family family

neighborhoodneighborhood

Page 24: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

Atlantic Station,Atlantic Station,

Atlanta, GAAtlanta, GA

•• BrownfieldBrownfield

•• Adjacent to Adjacent to singlesingle--family family neighborhoodneighborhood

Page 25: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• The The I’On I’On

storystory

Making it legal to Making it legal to

build build

Charleston in Charleston in

metro metro

CharlestonCharleston

Page 26: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• The The I’On I’On

storystory

Making it legal to Making it legal to

build build

Charleston in Charleston in

metro metro

CharlestonCharleston

Page 27: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• Pleasant Hill BART TOD planPleasant Hill BART TOD plan

How airing concerns in a How airing concerns in a charette charette

created a better plancreated a better plan

Page 28: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• Envision UtahEnvision Utah

When the metro region is your When the metro region is your

neighborhoodneighborhood

Page 29: Choosing Our

Chapter 5. True stories from the development front

Chapter 5. True stories from Chapter 5. True stories from

the development frontthe development front

•• Envision UtahEnvision Utah

When the metro region is your When the metro region is your

neighborhoodneighborhood

Page 30: Choosing Our

Chapater 6. Lessons from local heroes

Chapater Chapater 6. Lessons from 6. Lessons from

local heroeslocal heroes

•• ProfilesProfiles of of

citizens who citizens who

engaged engaged

“In my opinion everybody

is a NIMBY. None of us

likes change. The solution

is master planning as a

community. Predictability

greatly reduces fear and

opposition.”

Kay Beynart

Page 31: Choosing Our

If being called NIMBYdrives you BANANAs, just say …

Page 32: Choosing Our

Might

Accept

You if

Bargained

Effectively

M A Y B E !

Page 33: Choosing Our
Page 34: Choosing Our

To order:SmartGrowthAmerica.org

To order:To order:

SmartGrowthAmericaSmartGrowthAmerica.org.org

For information on nonFor information on non--profit and profit and

bulkbulk--order discounts:order discounts:

DgoldbergDgoldberg@@smartgrowthamericasmartgrowthamerica.org.org