CHLT-#127382-v1-Siskey Initial application for compensation … · 2018. 3. 26. · Case 17-30132...

38
1 IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA Charlotte Division In re: TSI Holdings, LLC, WSC Holdings, LLC, SouthPark Partners, LLC and Sharon Road Properties, LLC. DEBTORS. CASE NO. 17-30132 (LEAD) CASE NO. 17-30338 CASE NO. 17-30339 CASE NO. 17-30363 CHAPTER 7 Jointly Administered INITIAL APPLICATION FOR COMPENSATION TO EDWARD P. BOWERS AND MIDDLESWARTH BOWERS & COMPANY, ACCOUNTANTS TO THE CHAPTER 7 TRUSTEE Joseph W. Grier, III, the trustee in the above-referenced cases (the “Trustee”), hereby files this Initial Application for Compensation to Edward P. Bowers and Middleswarth Bowers & Company (“Bowers”) as accountants to the Trustee, for the period of February 15, 2017 through February 28, 2018, and respectfully represents as follows: 1. The Court authorized the joint administration of these four cases by order entered on May 23, 2017 (D.E. 63). 2. By Order entered on February 14, 2017, Bowers was approved as the accountant for the Trustee in these cases (D.E. 22). 3. Bowers has provided valuable services to the Trustee, including but not limited to forensic accounting, tax return preparation, assistance in reviewing and establishing claims and providing testimony in court hearings. No prior fee applications have been filed for Bowers. 4. Bowers has recorded professional time, fees and expenses broken down as follows: TSI Holdings, LLC (“TSI”), WSC Holdings, LLC (“WSC”), SouthPark Partners, LLC Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 1 of 38

Transcript of CHLT-#127382-v1-Siskey Initial application for compensation … · 2018. 3. 26. · Case 17-30132...

  • 1

    IN THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA

    Charlotte Division In re: TSI Holdings, LLC, WSC Holdings, LLC, SouthPark Partners, LLC and Sharon Road Properties, LLC.

    DEBTORS.

    CASE NO. 17-30132 (LEAD) CASE NO. 17-30338 CASE NO. 17-30339 CASE NO. 17-30363 CHAPTER 7 Jointly Administered

    INITIAL APPLICATION FOR COMPENSATION

    TO EDWARD P. BOWERS AND MIDDLESWARTH BOWERS & COMPANY, ACCOUNTANTS TO THE CHAPTER 7 TRUSTEE

    Joseph W. Grier, III, the trustee in the above-referenced cases (the “Trustee”), hereby

    files this Initial Application for Compensation to Edward P. Bowers and Middleswarth Bowers

    & Company (“Bowers”) as accountants to the Trustee, for the period of February 15, 2017

    through February 28, 2018, and respectfully represents as follows:

    1. The Court authorized the joint administration of these four cases by order entered

    on May 23, 2017 (D.E. 63).

    2. By Order entered on February 14, 2017, Bowers was approved as the accountant

    for the Trustee in these cases (D.E. 22).

    3. Bowers has provided valuable services to the Trustee, including but not limited to

    forensic accounting, tax return preparation, assistance in reviewing and establishing claims and

    providing testimony in court hearings. No prior fee applications have been filed for Bowers.

    4. Bowers has recorded professional time, fees and expenses broken down as

    follows: TSI Holdings, LLC (“TSI”), WSC Holdings, LLC (“WSC”), SouthPark Partners, LLC

    Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 1 of 38

  • 2

    (“SPP”) and Sharon Road Properties, LLC (“SRP”). Further, additional professional time and

    expenses have been recorded as “Other” when work was not performed for a specific case but in

    general for the Trustee in these cases.

    5. Based on the Debtor records, and other evidence, including an affidavit of

    Timothy Darin Stutheit, a Special Agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Trustee

    and his professionals are of the opinion that TSI, WSC, and SPP were each operated as part of

    the Ponzi Scheme (the “Ponzi Entities”).

    6. This Court has held that SRP is not part of a Ponzi scheme and that the assets of

    SRP shall satisfy the SRP administrative expenses (see Claim’s Order at D.E. 177).

    7. The Trustee seeks an order allowing fees and expenses whereby such fees and

    expenses would be allocated between the Ponzi Entities and SRP as fully set forth herein.

    8. Bowers’ overall User Summary of fees and expenses for the four bankruptcy

    cases is attached hereto as Exhibit A.

    9. Bowers’ User Time Summary and detail on professional services rendered on

    behalf of the Trustee related to the Ponzi Entities is attached hereto as Exhibit B.

    10. Bowers’ User Time Summary and detail on professional services rendered on

    behalf of the Trustee related to SRP is attached hereto as Exhibit C.

    11. Bowers’ User Time Summary and detail on professional services rendered on

    behalf of the Trustee categorized as “Other” and allocated as between the Ponzi Entities and SRP

    is attached hereto as Exhibit D.

    12. Based on the attached, Bowers has spent the following time in performing

    professional services, and the Trustee maintains that Bowers’ fees and expenses should be

    allowed and paid as a cost of administration of the bankruptcy cases as follows:

    Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 2 of 38

  • 3

    PONZI ENTITIES

    Fees (Recorded as to TSI/WSC/SPP – Exhibit B): Edward P. Bowers 52.65 hrs. @ $285 = $ 15,005.25 Michael T. Bowers 2.45 hrs. @ $225 = $ 551.25 Laurie LeGrand 154.55 hrs. @ $225 = $ 34,773.75 Akiko Bowers 10.95 hrs. @ $ 85 = $ 930.75 Total $ 51,261.00 Additional Allocated fees and expenses (Recorded as Other): $ 19,491.18 Detail on Exhibit D Expenses: $ 79.26 Total Fees – Ponzi Entities: $70,752.18 Total Expenses – Ponzi Entities: $ 79.26 Total Fees and Expenses related to the Ponzi Entities including allocated Fees/expenses: $ 70,831.44 SRP Fees (Recorded as to SRP – Exhibit C): Edward P. Bowers 29.20 hrs. @ $285 = $ 8,322.00 Michael T. Bowers 86.70 hrs. @ $225 = $19,507.50 Laurie LeGrand 70.30 hrs. @ $225 = $15,817.50 Akiko Bowers 0.10 hrs. @ $ 85 = $ 8.50 Total $43,655.50 Additional Allocated fees and expenses (Recorded as Other): $ 3,439.62 Detail on Exhibit D Expenses $ 0.00 Total Fees – SRP: $ 47,095.12 Total Expenses – SRP: $ 0.00 Total Fees and Expenses related to SRP including allocated Fees/expenses: $ 47,095.12

    WHEREFORE, the Trustee respectfully requests that the Court approve initial

    Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 3 of 38

  • 4

    compensation to Bowers for the period February 15, 2017 through February 28, 2018 from the

    bankruptcy estates in this matter as follows:

    1. $70,752.18 in professional fees and $79.26 in reimbursement of expenses be paid

    as a cost of administration of the bankruptcy estates of TSI, WSC and SPP; and

    2. $47,095.12 in professional fees and $0.00 in reimbursement of expenses be paid

    as a cost of administration of the bankruptcy estate of SRP.

    This the 26th day of March, 2018.

    /s/ Anna S. Gorman Anna S. Gorman (State Bar No. 20987)

    Joseph W. Grier, III (State Bar No. 7764) Grier Furr & Crisp, PA 101 North Tryon Street, Suite 1240 Charlotte, NC 28246 (704) 332-0208 Telephone (704) 332-0215 Facsimile [email protected]

    Attorneys to the Trustee

    Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 4 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 5 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 6 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 7 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 8 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 9 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 10 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 11 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 12 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 13 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 14 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 15 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 16 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 17 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 18 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 19 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 20 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 21 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 22 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 23 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 24 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 25 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 26 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 27 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 28 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 29 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 30 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 31 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 32 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 33 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 34 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 35 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 36 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 37 of 38

  • Case 17-30132 Doc 201 Filed 03/26/18 Entered 03/26/18 10:29:13 Desc Main Document Page 38 of 38