ChinaNews Vol 5-12.pdf · DQY rules the roost in modern poultry industry p.49 Origin Agritech...
Transcript of ChinaNews Vol 5-12.pdf · DQY rules the roost in modern poultry industry p.49 Origin Agritech...
ChinaNews
FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Sept/Oct 2012
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com
p.1 Editorial
Food Industry News
p.3 Producers see red over ‘wine subsidies’
p.4 China’s thirst for wine boosts European
producers
Imported wine consumption up
Average wine consumption
p.5 Females emerge as key fast food
consumer in China
Australian cows to China
p.6 China’s food safety is a major problem
p.7 China fattens pig farms to tame pork
prices
p.8 Scottish food ambassadors target China
p.10 What are the ecological costs of China’s
future food imports?
p.12 Chinese firms ramp up presence in
Thailand
p.15 China’s import of Chilean fruit on the rise
p.16 Want to grow a pig?
p.17 Chinese restaurant chains face challenges p.18 Pesticide puts crab food safety at issue
China- Market Access
p.19 Green fingers and green houses
p.21 China overtakes US as largest crop
importer
p.23 China is UN’s valuable partner for food
security
p.24 Jumbo shrimp on the block
p.25 Food packaging fails safety tests failed in
China
Functional and Organic Foods
p.26 Nutrition information obligatory
p.28 S. Korean ginseng producer to open Jilin
plant
p.31 Haute herbs experience
Ingredient News
p.32 New ingredients approved
CP Kelco appoints Azelis as exclusive
distributor for China
Firmenich opens R&D center for
fragrances, flavors and ingredients in
Shanghai
p.33 Ingredient prices
Regional News
Ningxia
p.35 Helan emerging wine region
Company News
p.36 Wahaha runs to buy British snack brand
KPU
Wuliangye invests in expansion
Distell buys majority stake in Chinese
liquor distributor
p.38 Lenovo acquires third distillery
From IT to distilled
Qingdao to start new plant in Jiangxi
China’s first wine entrepreneur
Maotai, the national liquor?
Bright’s Guo complains and needs to
recant immediately
p.40 Menguiu to increase sourcing raw milk
Chinese eye Tasmanian dairy farms
p.41 Bright Dairy removes cheese with banned
additinve from shelves
Bright Dairy recalls baby product for
banned additive in latest goof
p.43 Synutra to invest in French dairy project
p.44 Darfield’s first shipment off to China
(Table of Contents continued on next page)
ChinaNews
FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Sept/Oct 2012
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com
Company News (Contd)
p.45 Yili launches breakfast cheese
Wantwant becomes dairy company
Nestle launches nationwide health
education programme for elderly people
Nestle sees 20% growth in China
p.46 Danone to be settled in Sichuan
Pepsico funding 16 schools in 15 Chinese
cities
Chef Kong divests from Weiquan
Maclean’s targets international growth
DQY rules the roost in modern poultry
industry
p.49 Origin Agritech inaugurates Xinjiang corn
seeds processing centre
p.50 Cargill finds a sweet spot in China
p.51 Kellogg Company and Wilmar
International announce China joint
venture
p.53 KFC vows to pursue expansion in smaller
markets
Traditional News
p.54 Top soy sauce producers 2012
p.55 Soy sauce production
Over 30% of Chinese consume too much
aluminium
Delicacy is no longer a piece of cake
Focus Topic
p.57 Shocking trials
p.60 Hunan denies kids used in GM food test
Scientists decry rice experiment on
children
p.61 GM rice test researcher suspended from
work
Upcoming Event
Glossary
mio '000 000
bio '000 000 000
crore '0 000 000
k '000
lakh '00 000
t tons
kt '000 tons
lpd litres per day
klpd kilo litres per day
tpa tons per annum
tpd tons per day
tph tons per hour
tpm tons per month
cpd cases per day
JV Joint Venture
M&A Merger & Acquisition
pa per annum
Sensex Stock exchange index
p.62 Upcoming events
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 1
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Editorial
The period covered by this issue of ChinaNews has been one characterised by public outrage. The first
outrage was caused by a publication by Greenpeace about tests on the digestion of genetically
engineered rice in children, supposedly having been conducted in Hunan, backed by the American
USDA. When we read the rapidly growing news stream about this issue, we decided to make it a
Special Focus topic, as we often do with issues that are extensively discussed in the media. Very much
to our surprise, the publication stream stopped quite suddenly, never to be resumed. As can be read in
the Special Focus (we do not easily come back on a decision like that), the cause of events was
exceptionally quick, from the first publication, to public outcry, official denial, investigation to putting
someone under investigation. Then this topic became very quiet. It is obvious that organisations
involved want to bury this incident as quickly as possible and the news that someone may be charged
seems like an easy way out by pinpointing a scapegoat, rather than fully investigating the course of
events.
The second bout of outrage lasted much longer, and has still not subsided at the time of writing these
lines. Bright’s CEO, Mr. Guo Benheng, has given an interview in the media in which he ventured to
complain about what he believed to be excessive quality checks by the health authorities. Such checks
have become standard in the wake of the never ending stream of food safety incidents in China.
Mr. Guo made a bold statement during that interview, stating that ‘they [the authorities] may check
you to death’. This statement itself already aroused indignation in the media and the public. However,
the story quickly evolved as a classic Greek drama, and Mr. Guo saw his hubris punished by two food
safety incidents involving products by Bright. We do not know what happened to Mr. Guo (he is
probably hiding on a far away island, in the deepest cave of China, or in a monastery in the
Himalayas), but it must be a nightmare for Bright’s PR officers. This is so bad that no apology can
suffice. Mr. Guo will have to resign, but we are still waiting for that news, so we need to keep up the
suspense until the next issue. The photograph still shows Mr. Guo in all his glory, but the cartoon
depicts him as ‘blowing up a cow’ (chui niu), which is a Chinese slang expression for boasting. It is as
if this expression was coined with Mr. Guo in mind.
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 2
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Editorial
The sad conclusion of both incidents is that in spite of all the rhetoric about improvements in food
safety, the fundamental structural problems are still unsolved. A semi-government research institute is
implicated in a scandal involving trials on children and the CEO of a huge state owned enterprise
behaves as if he cannot be touched by law. Money seems to be the big motivating force in both cases,
as is illustrated by one of the cartoons with this Editorial. The entrepreneur is milking the cow for
money, while ‘dairy specifications’ has to sit aside as an old man who has nobody’s attention. The
trials with the engineered rice will undoubtedly have been accepted with a substantial fee. Bright is
one of China’s top food companies, with a growing international presence. In particular, Bright’s
recent international acquisitions have made it the pride of the nation. However, that is not enough to
justify the lax attitude to food quality and arrogant attitude towards quality inspections.
This may be a small, but still significant, ‘bright’ spot in all this misery: Chinese consumers and
journalists are no longer the sheep that follow their leader or can be made to follow the dog. They are
aware of their rights and articulate of their indignation. Even before the problematic products, Mr. Guo
was fiercely criticised for his remarks. Although the Hunan authorities tried to mitigate the accusations
at first, they at least had to make a gesture by ‘finding’ a culprit. Chinese leaders need to appease
public opinion, lest it turn against them.
Is this then a lost period in the history of the Chinese food industry? Absolutely not. It is booming as
usual and the remainder of these pages are dedicated to reporting all this to our readers.
ChinaNews is published every 2 months
by:
GIRACT 24 Pré Colomb
1290 Versoix-Geneva
Switzerland
Tel +41 22 779 0500
Fax +41 22 779 0505
www.giract.com
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 3
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Producers see red over 'wine subsidies'
The government has been asked to investigate if
European winemakers are being subsidized and
dumping their produce in China, a move analysts
said is Beijing’s latest response to the European
Union’s rising trade protectionism against China.
The China Alcoholic Drinks Association asked
the Ministry of Commerce to launch an
investigation into wine imports from the EU, said
Wang Zuming, secretary-general of the
association’s wine sub-branch, on Monday.
"We have noticed a clear intention to sell
European wines in the Chinese market at below-
cost price", Wang said.
"There is also sufficient evidence to show that the
EU has heavily subsidized its wine industry and
exporters”.
Some analysts view the move as a series of
responses to the EU’s possible probe of China’s
solar panel exports.
European solar companies recently asked the
European Commission, the executive arm of the
EU, to probe Chinese exports to the EU. The
commission will decide in September whether to
launch the probe.
China’s wine complaint came after its four major
solar companies, including New York-listed LDK
Solar Co, asked the government last week to start
anti-dumping and anti-subsidy probes into
polysilicon exports from the EU.
The EU produces about 16 mio t of wine a year
and accounts for 69% of global output.
Wine imports from the EU to China in 2008 were
35.9 mio litres, but the figure rose to 169 mio
litres in 2011, the association said.
(Continued in next column)
Producers see red over 'wine subsidies' (Contd)
European wine producers increased their share of
the Chinese market to 14.32% last year, from
4.94% in 2008. During the first quarter, wine
imports from the EU, mainly from France, Spain,
and Italy, surged by 24% from a year earlier.
A source from the Ministry of Commerce told
China Daily, on condition of anonymity, that the
government will probably start an investigation
"very soon”.
"China has the capacity to fight back if the EU
launches an investigation into China’s solar
products”, Zhou Shijian, a senior trade expert at
Tsinghua University, said.
"Such an investigation will do more harm than
good to the EU”, he said, without elaborating.
The United States and the EU have been
aggressive in launching trade probes into Chinese
goods amid the global financial crisis but China is
learning to fight back, Zhou said. "China is
getting wiser and more mature in protecting its
own commercial interests under the World Trade
Organization framework”.
US solar power manufacturers, including
SolarWorld USA, accused Chinese solar
companies last year of selling panels in the US
market at prices that were far below what US-
made panels could be sold for. In May, the US
announced anti-dumping duties on Chinese solar
makers ranging from 31% to 250%.
China then announced it would launch an
investigation into US polysilicon exports.
Conflicts grow As the debt crisis worsens and unemployment
rises, the EU is targeting Chinese exports, an
analyst said.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 4
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Conflicts grow (Contd)
Jonathan Holslag, research director at the Brussels
Institute of Contemporary China Studies, said
trade conflicts are "inevitable” but a spiral of
retaliation is in no one’s interests. "It is time for
China and the EU to sit down to hold candid and
straightforward discussions on where we are and
where we need to go”, Holslag said.
The EU joined the US and Japan in March to
launch an appeal to the WTO against China’s
export policy on rare earths. The European
Commission said it was considering charging
duties on made-in-China products to offset
alleged subsidies. The commission believed that
European companies were hesitant about asking
Brussels to take protective measures for fear that
China would retaliate against their business
interests. Reports in May said the European
Commission also prepared a case against China’s
telecom equipment companies including Huawei
and ZTE Corp. (cd 21/8/2012)
Imported wine consumption up
According to Wine Intelligence, China has
already 19 mio people who regularly consume
imported wine. 22% of the respondents, good for
41% of the market value, indicated that they
drank imported wine for business purpose.
(tjkx 24/8/2012)
This means that most of them will not pick up the
tabs themselves; their employer will.
Average wine consumption
According to insiders, the per capita wine
consumption in China is currently 0.38 litres. For
urban dwellers this figure is 0.7 litres. These
statistics are much lower than the global average.
This, combined with the growing interest in wine
among Chinese consumers, indicates that the
growth potential of this market is huge.
(tjkx 6/9/2012)
China's thirst for wine boosts European producers
China's thirst for fine wines is buoying European
producers as domestic consumption dries up. As
the Eurozone debt crisis squeezes household
spending, Europeans have less to splurge on life's
little pleasures, and wine producers have felt the
pinch. Exporters are now looking to new markets
like China -- home to 1.3 bio people -- to boost
sales.
Richard Halstead, co-founder of Wine
Intelligence, a consultancy on wine branding, says
that China is a huge growth market for producers
and there is a scramble for quality European
brands. "China represents effectively the biggest
growth prospect that the wine industry has had
probably for a generation", said Halstead.
For Greek wine producers China represents a ray
of hope. Greece is suffering under a harsh
government austerity program and businesses are
being crippled by a lack of competitiveness. But
Greek-wine importer Mary Paternas believes it
could play a big role in the future of Greek
exports. "Their (Greek) wines have got better and
better and are doing really well”, she said. "They
managed to get into China, doing well in America
and Canada and exporting to Australia".
European exports to non-EU countries rose 12.7%
in 2011, with exports to China seeing the biggest
increase, up 49%, according to Eurostat, the
statistics division for the European Union.
Exports to Hong Kong were up 28%.
Halstead says the European crisis might even
provide a boost in exports for wine producers as
they seek new markets. He said: "If the Euro
weakens significantly, if there is loss of
confidence, actually that is something that wine
producers might find positive because they'll be
instantly more competitive in third party markets
like the U.S. and Asia". (cnn 6/9/2012)
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 5
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China's thirst for wine boosts European producers (Contd)
One-stop shops to showcase South Australia's top
food and wine in China South Australian food and
wine will be showcased in two "one-stop-shop"
outlets to be built in China, giving local producers
and exporters direct access to a market of more
than 7.6 mio Chinese consumers.
The SA produce centres are expected to open in
about 18 months and will give visitors the
opportunity to eat, buy and order the state’s food
and wine. Agriculture, Food and Fisheries
Minister Gail Gago, who recently made her first
ministerial visit to China, said the centres would
give SA producers and exporters more direct
access to markets in China. Ms Gago said they
would likely feature restaurants, shops and
information and marketing on regions of South
Australia while also operating as a wholesaler to
Chinese outlets. They would focus on food quality
and safety and would also provide accreditation to
available products.
The centres will be based in Nanping, with a
population of 3.06 mio, and Zhangzhou, with a
population of 4.6 mio, both in Fujian province on
China's east coast. The State Government is
expected to begin discussions with local
producers about their potential involvement in
coming weeks.
(Continued in next column)
China's thirst for wine boosts European producers (Contd)
"Fujian Province has recognised South Australia's
competitive advantage of premium food and
wine, grown and produced in a clean and safe
environment”, Ms Gago said. "The Chinese have
a burgeoning economy, a burgeoning middle class
that are very interested in quality food ... (and)
want assurances and reliability about the quality
and safety of those products”.
They're interested in basically all our primary
produce and also processed foods. "They love our
seafood; fresh fish, abalone and lobster".
The centres would be paid for and run by the
Chinese, in consultation with SA officials.
Ms. Gago said there was scope to build more
stores if the first two proved successful.
Her visit to China also explored opportunities for
SA university researchers to partner with the
Chinese on food quality, hygiene training and
technology. "They're very interested in research
links to support food quality and hygiene safety
standards”, she said. (dailytelegraph 5/9/2012)
Australian cows to China
China is not only a major destination for
Australian dairy products; recently published
statistics indicate that almost 80% of dairy cattle
exported by Australia are destined for China.
(chinafeed 18/8/2012)
Females emerge as key fast food consumer in China Not only do more female consumers in China eat
out at fast food restaurants than men, they also
seem to be more adventurous eaters, according to
a new market research report released this week.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 6
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Females emerge as key fast food consumer in China (Contd)
It is a gender divide that reveals differing
consumer patterns between men and women, says
the Mintel report released this week. For Chinese
females, dining out is treated as a social occasion,
shared with friends, kids, colleagues and family
members, points out the report. That may be why
71% of women said they eat out at foreign fast
food restaurants, compared to 66% of men.
Throw in a coupon, promotion or meal voucher,
and Chinese females are more likely to patronize
the restaurant given that they're "always on the
lookout" for a good deal, analysts say. This is
especially true of women in their 20s and 30s,
also known as the "coupon generation" who are
particularly savvy when it comes to clipping e-
coupons from group buying sites and
downloading discounts onto mobile devices. On
the other hand, analysts also found that women in
China are more likely to pack their own meals
from home: 30% of females’ brown-bag it
compared to 19% of men. While overall, three-
quarters of Chinese consumers indicated the
willingness to try new fast food products, that
number is higher for women – 79% -- compared
to men, 72%. (mysinchew 28/8/2012)
China’s food safety is a major problem
Last month, in the 2012 FIVB World Grand Prix
Finals, China’s women’s volleyball team fell to
countries that did not even qualify for the 2008
Olympics, where China won Bronze. The coach
blamed his team’s abysmal performance on their
vegetarian diet, saying that the athletes had not
had any meat for three weeks. The players were
certainly not vegetarians: they abstained from
meat lest contamination of chemicals such as
clenbuterol interfere with their urine tests. The
excuse was not as lousy as it initially sounded:
early this year,
(Continued in next column)
China’s food safety is a major problem (Contd)
China’s State General Administration of Sports
issued a document forbidding its athletes from
consuming meat outside of official training
facilities. The sports incidence epitomizes the
rapidly rising concerns about food safety in
China. Twenty years ago, with the exception of
the few expats living in China, few there would
consider food safety a problem. Today, almost
everybody I spoke with in China – people I knew
well and those I did not – expressed their concern
about adulterated food. My speculation that food
safety problems in China have worsened is
substantiated by the website “Throw out of
window” created by Wu Heng, a postgraduate of
Fudan University, to track China’s food safety
incidents from 2004 to 2011. In the spring of
2012, a survey carried out in 16 major Chinese
cities asked urban residents to list “the most
worrisome safety concerns”. Food safety topped
the list (81.8%), followed by public security
(49%), medical care safety (36.4%),
transportation safety (34.3%), and environmental
safety (20.1%).
Due to government incentives to cover up or
downplay problems associated with social-
political stability, it is difficult to gauge the full
extent of food safety problems in China. An Asian
Development Bank report released in 2007 (prior
to the tainted baby formula scandal) estimated
that 300 mio Chinese might be affected by food
borne disease annually. Food borne disease can
result from consumption of food contaminated by
toxins, pathogenic bacteria, viruses, or parasites.
While it is relatively easy to link a health problem
(e.g., acute diarrhoea) to infections resulting from
the consumption of contaminated food or water, it
is unlikely for chronic health conditions (e.g.,
cancer) caused by food tainted with toxic
chemicals to be included in annual statistics, even
though illegal food additives or noxious
substances in food are becoming a major health
hazard in China. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 7
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China’s food safety is a major problem (Contd) A 2011 study published in the Chinese Journal of
Food Hygiene suggests that more than 94 mio
people become ill annually from bacterial food
borne diseases alone, which led to approximately
3.4 mio hospitalizations and more than 8 500
deaths. By way of comparison, the CDC estimates
that food borne bacteria, viruses, and microbes
combined cause forty eight mio Americans to fall
ill, 128 000 hospitalizations, and 3 000 deaths a
year.
What is to blame for China’s food safety crisis? In
an opinion piece published in the International
Herald Tribune this month, I argued that the crisis
highlighted China’s failure to establish a code of
business ethics as its market economy expands
faster than government regulators can keep pace.
In the absence of effective regulations and moral
constraints, private profit too often trumps public
good. Ironically, what is happening in China is
exactly what Karl Marx described 150 years ago.
He said that with adequate profit “there is not a
crime at which [capital] will [not] scruple, nor a
risk it will not run, even to the chance of its owner
being hanged.” In a country where serving God is
still suppressed, and “serving the people” is no
longer in vogue, serving money seems to be the
main attractive option”. In an October 2011
nationwide online survey of nearly 23 000 adults,
more than half of the respondents did not think
complying with ethical standards was a necessary
condition for success in Chinese society (again,
by way of comparison, only 24% of financial
executives in the U.S. say illegal or unethical
conduct may be necessary for success).
As a Tsinghua University professor said, since
counterfeiters and adulterers are also victims of
other unsafe food, “this is a society where
everybody intoxicates everybody.” Wu Heng
echoed this by warning that Chinese are
“exchanging faeces to eat”.
(Continued in next column)
China’s food safety is a major problem (Contd)
A neo-Hobbesian world of everyone against
everyone is probably an overstatement. However,
a functioning society needs basic moral codes in
order to restrain dangerous behaviors. In a make
believe world where that baseline morality is
suffering a great leap backward, a social
breakdown may not be a far-fetched scenario.
(cnn 28/8/2012)
China fattens pig farms to tame pork prices
The Jiahua pig farm in eastern Zhejiang province
is on the frontline of China's battle with food
inflation, a prime example of how a shift in
farming practices may someday stabilize the price
of the nation's favorite meat - and soothe a
perennial headache for Beijing. Pork prices are so
volatile and have such an influence on inflation in
the world's second-largest economy that many
Chinese joke that CPI stands for the "China Pork
Index". Annual inflation ticked up slightly to 2%
in August from a 30-month low in July, reflecting
in part a turnaround in pork prices, which climbed
after a summer dip, returning to levels last seen in
May. For the moment, pork supplies are ample.
Record profit margins for pork last year meant
that people of all stripes, from peasants to coal
millionaires, invested in pigs. That's good news
for the Communist Party, which is sensitive to
any potential for public unrest ahead of a once-in-
a-decade leadership transition later this year. The
Party blames inflation for demonstrations in
Tiananmen Square over 20 years ago, and keeps a
lid on prices by fiat if necessary.
But while headline inflation has trended unusually
low in China this summer, pork prices and food
inflation risk exploding higher in coming quarters,
testing the government's resolve to keep a lid on
prices even as it faces a cooling economy.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 8
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China fattens pig farms to tame pork prices (Contd)
In the long run, China's move from small
backyard pig pens to industrial mega-farms could
help calm volatile boom-bust pork cycles and help
bring inflation more under control. With their
economies of scale and more stable production
plans, bigger farms such as the Jiahua Pig
Breeding Co are expected to help curb sharp
moves in pork prices. "The faster the trend to
scale-up and the faster that backyard breeding is
phased out, the more volatility will be
dampened”, Hua Jianqing, Jiahua's president and
principle investor, told Reuters from his
headquarters in rural Zhejiang. "It won't be a year
or two. My analysis is that it will take three to five
years to reach the balancing point". Jiahua keeps
5 000 breeding sows at a time, and raises 100 000
pigs a year.
Squirming and oinking, young sows are lined up
daily for buyers peering through a glass window.
Those that are picked are shipped hundreds of
miles to help seed yet another mega-farm. Large-
scale operations with more than 3 000 pigs now
account for about 20% of China's herd, but huge,
North American-style farms of Jiahua's size
account for only about 2%. Record-high margins
last summer created a classic boom in investment
in pigs, but now a drought in the U.S. is pushing
up the price of grain used for feed, prompting
small farmers to slaughter their animals and
setting the stage for a possible supply shortage in
months to come.
Small farmers still raise enough hogs - about one-
third of the national herd - that their decisions to
buy more piglets or sit out a season can make a
big difference in prices. "If fewer choose to rise,
in the third quarter of 2013 we see a shortage of
pork and a run-up in prices", said Andy Rothman,
China strategist for CLSA in Shanghai.
(Continued in next column)
China fattens pig farms to tame pork prices (Contd)
The latent risk of a spike in food inflation is one
of the concerns keeping Beijing from loosening
policy too much, even as the vast manufacturing
sector shows signs of contracting. Although a
dramatic, 18.5% drop in pork prices in the year to
August helped bring food inflation to 3.4% last
month, food prices are still up 5.9% so far this
year, running above Beijing's overall inflation
target of 4%. The huge investment necessary to
create a large commercial operation means the
larger farms will stay in business even during a
downturn, unlike many smallholders. "If the price
is not good, we can sell off some piglets. But we
wouldn't sell them all", said Manager Xu at a
cooperative farm with a few hundred pigs in
Luohe in Henan Province. Jiahua, for example,
cost RMB 110 mio to set up in its 73-hectare site,
which includes 32 long brick pens. The farm
employs 200 people.
Hua is investing RMB 300 mio in a newer farm
three times the size under construction north of
Shanghai. "We think of pig rising as
supplementing farm household income but
nowadays you need to be rich to raise pigs", said
Shi Tao, analyst for eFeedlink in Shanghai. Still,
while larger farms are, in theory, better able to
weather rising costs, few have gotten to the scale
where they can hedge grain prices on China's
notoriously volatile futures markets. Jiahua
sources grains from a regular supplier in the
North, buying more when it looks like prices are
rising. To cut costs, the farm has its own feed
mill. "This year prices have not been too stable,
but we buy in scale to hold down costs. We buy
corn by the container and buy medicines
wholesale", said Zhong Dongshan, a manager of a
farm with 3 000 pigs in Jiangsu Province, North
of Shanghai. But while the march to scale may
benefit Chinese consumers and Beijing by
capping pork prices, investors may find it takes
longer than expected to turn a profit.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 9
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China fattens pig farms to tame pork prices (Contd)
What is currently a short, sharp cycle in pork
prices will lengthen as farms get larger, with each
downturn in the future becoming longer and more
severe as low-cost producers tough it out, said Shi
Tao, analyst with eFeedlink in Shanghai. In the
past, "peasants reacted immediately to price drops
by selling the pigs they had and not raising more",
he said."Now the larger-scale farms won't cull
sows, they can absorb losses longer while smaller
producers drop out”. (reuters 9/9/2012)
Scottish food ambassadors target China
Scotland is planning to establish a network of
food ambassadors in China as the country
switches increasingly to a western-style diet.
A campaign run by Scotland Food and Drink
(SFD), has already installed an ambassador in
Shanghai, whose role is half-funded by its
members in the salmon and seafood industry.
But James Withers, the chief executive of SFD,
believes there is an increasing demand for
western-style produce in the Far East,including
meat and milk, which are not traditionally part of
their cuisine. Withers pointed out that 500g tins of
powdered milk from Ireland were retailing for the
equivalent of GBP 40 in China, a legacy of the
tainted baby-milk scandal which caused the death
of six children four years ago.
“Ireland is selling skimmed milk powder at a
huge premium, based on the fact that there is very
little limit on what Chinese parents will spend on
their children in terms of food and health. Also
there is a distrust of domestic production”, he
said. He added there was also scope for small
artisan cheese makers to target Asia. “In more
affluent parts of the big cities in China, there is a
demand for these new types of products”, he said.
(Continued in next column)
Scottish food ambassadors target China (Contd)
The group will enlist the services of an export
manager in Germany, who was hired in April by
Quality Meat Scotland to promote Scottish beef
and lamb but who will also dedicate his time to
other sectors. Withers said the move to create a
global network dedicated to food and drink will
help Scottish producers “catch up” with rivals in
Denmark, Ireland and New Zealand whose food
exports far surpass those of Scotland despite
being similar in “size and clout”. He said overseas
agency Scottish Development International (SDI)
has offices in 25 countries, but not all of them are
key export markets. He said: “The Irish Food
Board has ten offices around the world dedicated
to food and drink alone.
“We have the first person on the ground in
Shanghai, but Ireland is putting four more people
in Shanghai alone dedicated to food and drink.
“New Zealand is also very active and so is
Denmark – we need to catch up. “SDI does a
fantastic job for us in food and drink, but the
reality is it has to cover every other sector of the
economy as well”. He insisted the new model
would not be a burden on Scottish public sector
budgets, as the new roles would be part-funded by
industry. A spokesman for SDI said: “Although
food specialists would be independent of SDI,
they would still work closely with SDI on the
opportunities we identify”.
Margaret McGinlay, director of food and drink at
Scottish Enterprise, said: “Key to Scotland’s
economic success in exporting is the collaborative
approach and, working closely with a range of
key partners including Scotland Food and Drink,
we have seen food and drink exports hit a record
high of GBP 5.6 bio in the last year, exceeding the
industry’s targets six years ahead of schedule.
“We continue to work closely with the industry to
explore opportunities for further dedicated
support through overseas specialists”.
(scotsman 2/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 10
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
What are the ecological costs of China’s future food imports?
China’s growing agribusinesses and demand for
soybeans and meat is bringing intensive farming
and the risk of further deforestation in Brazil and
beyond. Tom Levitt reports. “We believe that
Chinese investments shouldn’t be too different
and should respect the environment”. The
dynamics of Chinese agriculture are changing.
While it may still be largely self-sufficient in
food, the country is expected to enter an era of
rising food imports and in particular, animal feed.
But how ready is China to take responsibility for
the environmental impact of this growing
overseas food footprint?
Over the past two decades, China has seen a
monumental surge in soybean imports. By 2030,
China is expected to consume 72 mio t of
soybeans from overseas – more than one-quarter
of the world’s total soybean production today.
The impact, environmentalists fear, is greater
pressure on uncultivated forested land in Brazil,
the world’s second largest soybean producer after
the United States and a major exporter to China.
In 2011, more than 67% of Brazil’s soybean
exports were sent to China. By no coincidence,
the South American country is now emerging as a
major focus of investment for China’s expanding
agribusinesses.
Inside China, the country is fast approaching the
limit of its own available farmland resources – the
so-called “red line” for food security of 120 mio
hectares of arable land, set by the government.
China’s solution, according to Deborah
Brautigam, a professor at American University
and senior research fellow at the International
Food Policy Research Institute, has been to import
cheaper agriculture commodities like soybeans
and maize while saving its farmland for higher-
value exports like fish and vegetables. The other
force driving the rise in soybean and maize
imports is a corresponding rise in meat
consumption in China.(Continued in next column)
What are the ecological costs of China’s future food imports? (Contd)
Increasingly that meat is coming from large-scale
commercial farms – not small-scale or household
farmers – and dependent on animal feed rather
than food waste. In a detailed assessment of likely
trends for Chinese agriculture in 2030, Laixiang
Sun, professor at the School of Oriental and
African Studies in London, says he expects to see
pig and poultry numbers in intensive farms
increase by “at least 2.5 times between 2000 and
2030”. This type of intensive livestock farming
relies on cheap agricultural crops. What this
means, says Sun, is that while China will still be
able to feed itself with domestic supplies of grain,
overall self-sufficiency in food in China was
likely to fall. He expects imports of maize to
reach 16 mio t by 2030 and imports of soybean to
rise to around 72 mio t by 2030.
The rapid expansion of soybean cultivation in
Brazil over the past two decades has contributed
to huge increases in the rate of deforestation in the
Amazon – one of the world’s most biodiverse
regions and home to 10% of all species known to
scientists. Soy production accounted for about
10% of total deforestation in the Amazon between
2000 and 2005, according to estimates from
Columbia University. In the next five years, that
figure dropped to 2% as new production moved to
previously cleared cattle pasture. While it may not
always be a direct cause of deforestation, soybean
production can still be an indirect driver, suggest
observers, by raising land prices, pushing land
users into forested areas and creating impetus for
infrastructure improvements like roads which,
then promote further forest clearance. "The
agribusiness sector wants more. The hunger for
development made Brazil the third largest
exporter of agricultural products...but the
economic model chosen for the region ignores the
Amazon environment and its people", says
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 11
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
What are the ecological costs of China’s future food imports? (Contd)
Greenpeace Brazil, which is campaigning for zero
deforestation in the Amazon by 2015. Tragically,
the competition for lucrative farmland and
resources in the Amazon region is also linked to
violence and death. The Brazilian land rights
group Catholic Land Pastoral estimate 1 600
activists have been murdered in the Amazon state
of Para over the past 25 years. It says the killings
– mostly targeted at small subsistence farmers and
indigenous peoples - are usually carried out by
gunman hired by loggers, ranchers and farmers,
just 1% of murder cases have led to convictions.
“A battle has been declared that is expressed in
the violence against those considered obstacles to
development and progress”, say the Catholic Land
Pastoral. Deforestation has another globally
significant impact. As well as being home to
critically endangered and unique wildlife and
other biodiversity, the Amazon rainforest is also a
major carbon sink, absorbing carbon dioxide and
helping to stem global warming.
Further deforestation could reverse that, with
forest clearance resulting in the release of carbon
held in the soil and trees. China’s link to
deforestation in the Amazon may not end with
imports of Brazilian soybeans, thanks to the
growing expansion of Chinese agribusiness
companies at home and abroad. Although still
relatively small in comparison to US commodity
giants like Cargill, the companies have the
support of the Chinese government as they seek to
buy agricultural assets. One of China’s largest
state-owned feed importers, the Chongqing Grain
Group, announced last year it was spending USD
500 mio to build a soybean plant in Brazil, which
reportedly, could be followed by a further multi-
mio-dollar investment in soybean plantations.
Another, Sanhe Hopefull Grain & Oil, is reported
to be putting USD 7.5 bio into soybean processing
facilities in Brazil (Continued in next column)
What are the ecological costs of China’s future food imports? (Contd)
in a deal that also includes constructing a railroad.
Greenpeace’s Amazon spokesperson Marcio
Astrini toldChina dialogue he still hoped China’s
growing influence in Brazil would not lead to a
fall in environmental standards in the country.
“We believe that Chinese investments shouldn’t
be too different and should respect the
environment”. As they expand their global reach,
Chinese agribusinesses are also changing the
landscape of farming back home. The new face of
agriculture in China is no longer the household
farmer but people like Liu Yonghao, president of
the USD 8.8 bio agribusiness New Hope Group
and China's fourth richest person. His company
claims to process 750 mio fowl and 8.5 mio pigs a
year and already owns 16 feed factories outside of
the country.
Professor Sun still expects small-scale livestock
farms to persist, taking advantage of support for
their use of local labour in rural areas, where
intensive farms have comparatively less need for
workers. But others suggest the incentives for
such types of farming are fast disappearing. “I
anticipate that large-scale corporations will soon
take over the vast majority of China's household
pork production (probably in a decade or two)”,
says professor Li Jian, from the University of
Iowa, who has studied the decline of rural pig
farming in China. “Major traditional values of pig
farming are vanishing, for example, few farmers
now depend on pig manure for farming and fewer
and fewer families depend on raising pigs for
holiday feasts etc. Under such new socioeconomic
conditions, fewer and fewer farmers will find pig
farming a profitable and attractive production”.
The accelerated exodus of rural livestock farmers
will not only see more large-scale intensive farms
with associated problems of pollution and reliance
on imported animal feed - but also bring more
people into urban areas, worsening existing urban
environmental problems such as air pollution and
congestion.(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 12
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
What are the ecological costs of China’s future food imports? (Contd)
The World Bank estimates agriculture’s share of
employment will continue to fall, from around
30% today to 12% by 2030. “Smallholder farmers
are capable of producing the food necessary to
feed their country, but face increasingly difficult
barriers” concludes a recent report, from the
international NGO Grain, which campaigns for
farmers’ rights. “Government decisions to rely on
agricultural commodity imports serve the interests
of agribusiness and its need for cheap sources of
feed but threaten the land, livelihoods and local
food systems of communities across the globe”, it
adds.
After the Brazilian Amazon, Chinese agribusiness
is expected to join other international speculators
in exploiting forested and biodiversity-rich land
across Africa. But, despite a glut of media
coverage about “land-grabbing” deals, (some of
which has been reported in China dialogue)
Chinese involvement in land deals in Africa is, so
far at least, minimal. “I had an expectation to see
much more Chinese involvement in African
agriculture. Basically it hasn’t happened. They
have been going to Asia and South America
instead”, says professor Brautigam. She says
high-profile land deals involving sugar plantations
in Ethiopia and bio fuels in the Democratic
Republic of Congo have not progressed, with
China sticking to smaller deals, driven by
commercial interests rather than food security.
While Chinese interest in agriculture in Africa
remains unfulfilled in the eyes of some observers,
its investments elsewhere, particularly in Brazil,
are growing. It must now decide whether feeding
its citizens at home can be achieved without
leading to environmental damage overseas.
(China dialogue 11/9/2012)
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand
The Second Thai-Lao Friendship Bridge connects
the Mukdahan Province in Thailand with
Savannakhet in Laos. A fourth bridge connecting
Chiang Rai Province in Thailand with Ban
Houayxay in Laos has been approved by
authorities and will be partly financed by China.
Investors view the Southeast Asian nation as a
springboard into the rest of the region, as Wei
Tian reports from Bangkok. In the second act of
Siam Niramit, a historical cultural performance
about ancient Thailand, popular among foreign
tourists in Bangkok, a 16th-century Chinese
trading boat docks at a port on stage. Fully loaded
with delicate silks, porcelain and other treasures
from China, the arriving outsider quickly wins
over the hearts and minds of local residents.
Today, the humble trading vessel has been
replaced by thousands of planes and cargo ships
transporting goods between the two countries
worth bio, ensuring ties between the two nations
are strong and deep-rooted, both socially and
economically.
According to the latest statistics from the
Thailand Board of Investment (BOI), for instance,
China was the country's second-largest source of
foreign direct investment in 2011. Chinese
companies have applied to take part in more than
180 investment projects in the last five years,
worth a total investment of USD 4.15 bio. Data
from Thailand's travel bureau show China has
become the largest source of visitors to its famous
southern seaside resort of Phuket. The importance
given to links with China is clearly illustrated at
the newly built multimillion dollar Bangkok
Suvarnabhumi International Airport, where notice
boards and signs are in Thai, English and Chinese.
Liang Wanshan is among the new generation of
Chinese coming to Thailand. As general manager
of COFCO (China National Cereals, Oils and
Foodstuffs Corp) Biochemical (Thailand) Co Ltd,
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 13
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand (Contd)
Liang was sent to establish a local team after
China's largest food processor, manufacturer and
trader spend RMB 100 mio to buy a local citrate
factory last year. Eight months after Liang first
arrived in Thailand, a modern factory is taking
shape in the east of the country's Rayong
Province. "At first, I was shocked by how simple
and crude the factory was", Liang said. Apart
from investing in the site, the company spent
another RMB 100 mio on upgrading and
overhauling the equipment on site, 20% of which
was in the necessary environmental protection
systems. "Maintaining a good relationship with
local residents is vital for foreign investors in
Thailand, and environmental protection was
always a sensitive issue", he said, adding that the
previous owner had issues with local residents
over the factory's environmental record. COFCO
decided right from the start it needed to play a key
role in the local community.
Having already hired 80 employees locally, Liang
said he expects to have a full capacity of 300
people when fully operational next year. "We are
keen to employ as many local people as possible
in senior management positions", he said.
According to a recent report from global
management consulting company McKinney &
Co, one of the biggest issues facing Chinese
companies looking for international expansion
remains being able to find enough managers with
overseas experience. It said creating the perfect
balance between local people and incoming
Chinese has to be carefully planned, and success
can often depend on whether that balance is right.
Liang said that he insists his Chinese managers
employed to work in Thailand have been fully
trained, not only in the local language and laws,
but also in local culture and customs. "We also
provide Chinese lessons for our local staff", he
added. Within his workforce there are also
Chinese managers hired locally, such as
(Continued in next column)
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand (Contd)
Jing Jing, a Chinese graduate who has been
working and living in Thailand for more than five
years. "It is actually been quite easy to knit myself
into the local community”, said Jing, a graduate
from Guangxi Zhuang autonomous region who
speaks fluent Thai, "because we don't actually
look that different, which helps too". After
generations of immigration, the Chinese are the
second-largest ethnic group in Thailand,
accounting for 14% of the country's total
population. "I also like the fact that most things
are cheaper here, the lifestyle is very easy going,
plus flight tickets from Nanning (the capital city
of Guangxi Zhuang autonomous region) to here
are actually cheaper than to many Chinese cities,
making Bangkok closer to home than Beijing or
Shanghai”, added the 30-year-old office worker.
"I know many like me who have married local
people and others who have bought property or
become successful entrepreneurs”. "Many are
now being hired by Chinese companies who have
established an office or factory in Thailand", she
said, adding that she knows of around 100 of her
college friends working for Chinese companies in
Bangkok, including for some big names such as
Huawei and Haier. Since 2007, nearly 30 Chinese
companies have established a presence in the
Rayong Industrial Zone, involved in industries
ranging from electronics and auto parts, to rubber
and metal. COFCO Biochemical said that one of
the reasons for its acquisition of a local factory
was to secure a better supply of raw materials,
particularly cassava, and a crop grown for its
edible starchy root which is a major source of
carbohydrates, of which Thailand is a main
producing area. "The acquisition will help
diversify our raw material supply, and contribute
to the expansion of our citrate business, further
improving regional distribution and enhancing
economic benefits", the company said.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 14
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand (Contd)
Apipong Khunakornbodintr, director of the
investment promotion section at the Royal Thai
Embassy in Beijing, said a major benefit for
companies like COFCO building facilities in
Thailand is to avoid tariff barriers. Holley Group
Electric (Thailand) is an example - a power meter
maker subsidiary of Holley Group China which
has made great use of its factory in Thailand. It
used to face a 30% special tariff when trying to
export to Peru, for instance, from the Chinese
mainland. The establishment of a factory in
Thailand helped it get around that tax barrier, as
no such barriers exist between Thailand and Peru,
and some other countries. "That's the initial
reason for many Chinese investors coming to
Thailand, but once they are here, they discover
there are many more advantages", Apipong said.
According to information from BOI, foreign
investors are also exempt from corporate income
tax for a maximum of eight years, followed by a
50% reduction for another five years. As a result
of those kinds of incentives, the number of
approved investment projects from the Chinese
mainland increased from 16 in 2006 to 36 in
2011, with the total investment volume up from
THB 2.5 bio (USD 79 mio) to THB 16.9 bio.
"Compared with domestic workers, local
employees are more mannered, but at the same
time, less flexible", said Liang. Although salaries
in Thailand are lower than in China, the efficiency
may not be as high either, because local workers
often need to manage more closely, can lack
initiative, and working overtime is just
"unimaginable". "But on the other hand, the
quality is good, and a high standard can be
guaranteed”, he said. Meanwhile, another major
issue being reported by Chinese companies is an
overcapacity of firms in some sectors, leading to
vicious price competition among rival investors.
COFCO has to share the market with two other
Chinese-funded citrate producers in Thailand,
including privately funded Sunshine Biotech
International. (Continued in next column)
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand (Contd)
According to Apipong, there is no surplus in
production in this case, yet, but elsewhere he said
some Chinese investors are exploiting the local
market, by simply using their operations in the
country as export bases. "Price competition is
unlikely, as we will normally ask investors to
detail their pricing structures within their
investment contract", he said. However, with
more Chinese companies entering the local
market, favorable conditions such as tax
reductions compared to China for exporters could
be cancelled for certain industries over the next
five years, to avoid any possible overcapacity.
"Chinese companies should work closely with
organizations such as the Chinese-Thai
Enterprises Association to build relations and
discuss their competitiveness and common
practices to avoid issues such as over-capacity",
he adds.
According to the BOI, the majority of Chinese
companies investing in Thailand are still centred
on the manufacturing, whereas higher-value
added industries such as alternative energy are
target sectors that Thailand is hoping will attract
more overseas investment. During a meeting with
his Thai counterpart Yingluck Shinawatra in
Beijing in April, Premier Wen Jiabao proposed
expanding bilateral trade between the two
countries to USD 100 bio annually before 2015,
enhancing cooperation particularly in
telecommunications, technology, energy and
agriculture. Yingluck said her country would play
a positive role in boosting ASEAN-China
cooperation.
According to Wang Jian, an officer with the
ASEAN-China Centre, established last year to
promote trade and investment exchanges within
the area, the trade volume between China and
ASEAN countries is expected to reach USD 500
bio in 2015 from the current level of USD 360
bio. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 15
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Chinese firms ramp up presence in Thailand (Contd)
During a visit to China in August, Thai Industry
Minister Chaiwuti Bannawat was quoted by
Guangxi Daily as saying that investment from
China, worth another 20 bio baht this year, is
likely. The Thai government is actively pushing
construction of traffic networks, including a high-
speed railway linking south-western China's
Yunnan province to the northeast of Thailand.
"The northeast of Thailand will be a transport hub
for the ASEAN region after the network is
established", said Wiboon Khusakul, Thailand's
ambassador to China. "Chinese businessmen are
more familiar with the coastal region in east
Thailand, but know very little about the north
where there are abundant opportunities".
Although the project is still at the discussion
stage, Wiboon said it would only be "cost-
efficient" if the railway finally reaches Singapore,
suggesting speeds could reach 250-300 km/hour.
(cd 11/9/2012)
In earlier issues of ChinaNews we have indicated
that COFCO seems to be developing into a major
challenger for Nestlé. The increasing
internationalisation of COFCO is corroborating
this prediction.
China's import of Chilean fruit on the rise
Food exports from Chile to China saw a strong
increase of 35% year-on-year to USD 438 mio in
2011; according to Chilean government figures
underscore the South American country's position
as one of the major fruit suppliers to China.
Chilean fruit take up a substantial share of China's
fruit imports. According to data from ProChile, a
trade promotion organization at the Chile's
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Chilean cherry
exports in 2011 accounted for 75% of China's
total cherry imports, while plums accounted for
71%; grapes, 58%; and apples, 54%.
(Continued in next column)
China's import of Chilean fruit on the rise (Contd)
China overtook the United States to become
Chile's largest trading partner in 2009. Bilateral
trade between the two countries increased in 2011
to USD 29 bio from USD 24.7 bio a year ago,
Chinese data showed. During the first half of the
year, trade between China and Chile increased
14.8% year-on-year to USD 14.7 bio, Chilean
customs data showed. (cd 13/9/2012)
China to scrutinize food safety at tourist attractions
China's food and drug watchdog and tourism
administration will jointly launch a food safety
inspection in restaurants located in tourist
attractions. The inspection, initiated by the State
Food and Drug Administration (SFDA) and the
National Tourism Administration, will be carried
out later this month ahead of the Mid-Autumn
Festival and National Day holidays, according to
a Friday statement from the SFDA.
Operators of tourist sites should ensure the safety
of catering services, ban unlicensed businesses
and give timely reports on the catering services'
business operations to local food safety and
tourism authorities, the statement said.
Authorities will check restaurants for unlicensed
operation and ensure that regulations concerning
restaurant workers' health management are strictly
observed, the statement said. Restaurants must
carefully check the sources of their ingredients
keep records of their purchases and refrain from
using unsafe ingredients, such as inedible herbs,
poisoned animals and expired food, the statement
said. Authorities will check to make sure food is
prepared hygienically and ensure the proper use
of food additives, the statement said. Six
inspection teams will be sent to the provinces of
Liaoning, Jiangsu, Zhejiang, Hainan, Sichuan and
Guizhou, respectively, the statement said.
(cd 14/9/2012) (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 16
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China to scrutinize food safety at tourist attractions (Contd)
Return of food inflation makes easing from China
even less likely. Despite having no inflationary
pressure in non-food items owing to massive
overcapacity, one can never say the same thing
for food prices in China. Food prices in China are
volatile, and they are the main drivers for the
overall headline inflation for most of the time. In
August CPI data, vegetables prices have increased
very sharply on bad weather. But for months
now, we have pointed to the possibility of an
increase in meat prices, in part due to the drought
in US, pushing up prices of commodities like
corn. While it still seems to us unlikely that pork
prices alone can drive the full-year CPI inflation
above the full-year target of 4% with only 4
months left for the year, which could kill off any
prospect of monetary easing at once, the rise of
pork prices in the coming months is quite certain
now. We have suggested for quite a while now,
the central government seems to be reluctant to
embark of massive stimulus, and a pick-up of
inflation at this moment is unfortunate. With
ECB and Fed both easing, there is even less
justification for China to ease monetary policy,
and quite possibly China does not need to ease for
the time being because ECB and Fed are helping.
(aslosprachanalyst 17/9/2012)
This analysis draws heavily on the following item
by Standard Chartered.
Want to grow a pig?
We are concerned about the recent landing and
imminent take-off of the pig cycle. Pork is the
largest single component in the food part of the
CPI basket, accounting for 9.4%, followed by
grain (about 8.7%). Pork prices rose by 1% m/m
in August, but this was the first rise since October
2011 (pork prices fell by an aggregate of 23%
from October 2011 to July 2012). We believe the
downtrend in pork prices is over. The pig-to-
feedstuff ratio, at 5.7 in August (Figure 6), is now
in loss-making territory (the key level is 6.0),
meaning that farmers will now be exiting the
sector. These things take a while to feed through,
but we suspect that strong pork price increases are
now being roasted into CPI for Q2-2013. In 2013,
CPI inflation will be driven by the pig cycle
(prices are now rising), easy money in the US and
Europe, and utility price reform… We think it
will breach 5% y/y in H2-2012 and that this will
trigger a new round of hikes from the PBoC. We
no longer look for another cut in 2012. Indeed, we
believe that the next move will be up, in late
2013, as official CPI inflation pushes above 5%
y/y. After one hike in Q4-2013, we look for four
more hikes in 2014… we now look for only one
more RRR cut in 2012 (versus three cuts
previously). We expect no RRR cuts in 2013.
(standardchartered 17/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 17
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Chinese restaurant chains face challenges
The need for quality control makes the recipe for
expansion very problematic. For a Chinese
restaurant, expanding across the country or even
outside the country can be much harder than
starting from zero. "I have five Chinese
restaurants in Beijing but I am finding it very
difficult to expand further because making sure
every dish at every restaurant is exactly the same
is problematic", said Liu Tao, general manager of
a Yunnan cuisine restaurant in Beijing. Take the
famous General Tso's chicken or Kung Pao
chicken as an example. Cooks have to mix the
chicken, salt and egg white before heating the
wok. Then dozens of seasonings are added to
enrich the flavor, such as pepper, garlic, soy
sauce, cooking wine, monosodium glutamate,
vinegar, starch, sesame oil, Chinese onions and
peanuts.
The dishes will taste very different if the cooks
add fewer or more seasonings or if it is cooked at
a different temperature. "In Chinese cuisine, one
dish can taste totally different if it is made by
different chefs", said Jia Guolong, board chairman
of Xibei Restaurant. Another Chinese fast food
chain, Xinshang Fast Food in Qingdao, also
struggled to satisfy customers while expanding
locally. "Ensuring customers at each store have
the same quality fast food is a major task", said
Zhang Hongji, board chairman of the chain.
"Many problems lie in the way of the fast
expansion of the Chinese catering industry", said
Su Qiucheng, president of the China Cuisine
Association. "These include the lack of
specifications in the supply of raw materials, the
lack of standards for kitchen jobs, and the lack of
logistics and distribution outlets, fragile
franchisee management and vague brand
development strategies, which Western fast food
giants have already established". Jia said one
effective way to expand and develop Chinese
restaurants is to learn from the experience of -
(Continued in next column)
Chinese restaurant chains face challenges (Contd)
Western restaurant chains and to standardize the
whole cooking process. Zhang said Xinshang
learnt a lot from the success of the United States
fast food giant McDonald's Corp by strictly
controlling the food's standardization, including
the preparation of raw materials. McDonald's, the
world largest fast food chain, now has more than
33 000 outlets in 119 countries across the world.
They have their secrets to make sure every burger
in every restaurant is of the same quality, whether
it's in a small Chinese city or a big United States
metropolis.
"McDonald's burgers are made from 100% whole
cuts of beef from British and Irish farms, with
nothing added apart from a pinch of salt and
pepper after cooking. The meat is then minced,
shaped and frozen to make McDonald's beef
patties. All beef is checked for bone and gristle to
ensure that none finds its way into patties", said
Joy Clachan, Agricultural Assurance Manager at
McDonald's UK. After checking, the beef will be
minced and frozen. Then the patties are hand-
packed into boxes and a final quality check takes
place before they are dispatched. Inside a
McDonald's restaurant, a burger will be fully
cooked after being heated for more than 37
seconds. The buns are toasted and the meal is
finished off by adding onion and pickle, said the
company. Chen Jie, Kitchen Assistant General
Manager of Jindingxuan, a famous Guangdong-
style restaurant in Beijing, said: "standardizing
our cooking procedure can improve the efficiency
of professional chefs as well as cutting down
costs. Our customers will be happy because they
will spend less time waiting at their table".
McDonald's not only standardizes kitchen work
but also its food resources. They can trace beef
back to the farms where it was produced so the
company knows exactly how the animal was
reared. Industry experts said traceability benefits
the company's food management system.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 18
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Chinese restaurant chains face challenges (Contd)
It is also essential because it ensures customer
confidence in the company's food safety
arrangements. "Each Chinese restaurant operator
should fully understand the importance of
transforming and upgrading the industry”, said
vice-minister of Commerce Jiang Zengwei.
"(They) should learn from the experience of
foreign counterparts to improve their own
conditions, including the processing and
distribution of food". Xibei Restaurant's Jia said
he will push forward the standardization of Xibei
before opening about 30 restaurants next year in
first tier cities in China, such as Beijing, Shanghai
and Guangzhou. "The future of the Chinese food
chain industry will be prosperous," said Su
Qiucheng, president of the China Cuisine
Association. "Look at Haidilao Hot Pot, XE
Flavor and the Quanjude (Group) Co: They have
all shown momentum in the rapid and sound
development of their Chinese restaurant chains
over the past years". Last year, revenues of the
Chinese catering industry topped RMB 2 trillion.
The figure is expected to reach RMB 3.7 trio by
the end of 2015, according to the Ministry of
Commerce. (cd 18/9/2012)
Pesticide puts crab food safety at issue
An expert suggesting people wash hairy crabs
with a sodium bicarbonate solution to avoid
pesticide residues has sparked a heated discussion
online concerning food safety, with the best
season for crabs just around the corner. Modern
Express, a Jiangsu-based newspaper, yesterday
reported hairy crabs are likely to contain sodium
pentachlorophenol, a pesticide "often" used in
aquaculture to kill leeches and oncomelania
snails. Liu Hualing, deputy director of the
physical and chemical inspection department of
the Jiangsu Provincial Centre for Disease
Prevention and Control, told the newspaper that
hairy crabs may have sodium pentachlorophenol
in their flesh. (Continued in next column)
Pesticide puts crab food safety at issue (Contd)
An easy and effective way to get rid of such
pesticide is to soak the crabs in a sodium
bicarbonate solution, Liu told the newspaper.
Local crab experts say that's "groundless" because
sodium pentachlorophenol has been banned from
agricultural use for many years. Fan Shoulin,
secretary to the Shanghai Fisheries Trade
Association, said the Ministry of Agriculture
issued a fishery pesticide use standard in July
2007 that banned fishery pesticides that are highly
poisonous or residual, or that cause cancer, birth
defects or other mutations. "Sodium
pentachlorophenol is on the banned list. It shall
not be used in fishery production," Fan told
Shanghai Daily yesterday. Once ingested or
touched, it can be a strong irritant for people's
skin, eyes and respiratory tract. Crab farmers on
Shanghai's Chongming Island said they never
used any pesticide to kill trash fish. Wang Wu, a
crab professional with Shanghai Ocean
University, said people should not panic about
rumors. "If sodium bicarbonate solutions can be
so effective, why did the country bother to require
farmers not to use the pesticide"? Wang said. He
said the rumor could hurt farmers and hairy crab
sales. (sd 18/9/2012)
China – Market Access
The Chinese Quarantine Inspection authority
(AQSIQ) has implemented Decree 55 under the
new Food Safety Laws. The measures require that
importers and exporters register with the AQSIQ
via an online form. The measures will come into
force on 1 October 2012 but the registration
process is open now. Only shipments from
registered companies and agents will be allowed
into China from this date.In order to ensure that
trade is not impeded, Australian exporters who
currently export to China and those who plan to
export to China in future should lodge an online
registration as a matter of priority.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 19
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
China – Market Access (Contd)
The online form is available in English and
Mandarin and can be found at this location -
http://ire.eciq.cn/ (see page two for an example).
Click ‘Login’ on the Exporter side and then
‘Initial Registration’. This is an administrative
listing for exporters and their agents. It is not a
listing of manufacturers or producers (although in
many cases the company responsible for
manufacturing will also be the exporter).
The AQSIQ will publish the list of registered
importers and exporters on their website.
Some important points:
- The name of the registered exporter will need to
match the information on any accompanying
export documentation. It is therefore critical that
export applications submitted to Wine Australia
match the information submitted on the Chinese
registration.
- If you export to multiple consignees, each one
must be listed on the registration.
- Consignee names and addresses must be entered
in Chinese characters. Exporters are advised to
contact their Chinese agents for assistance.
- Upon submitting the application you will obtain
a registration number and a query number
generated by the system. The two numbers can be
used to check the progress of the application or
modify any information as necessary. It is
important to keep a record of these numbers.
- The registration information must be maintained
and any change in an exporter’s circumstances
should be promptly updated in the system.
- The registration number will be needed by the
consignee when submitting their entry inspection
form. (wineaustralia 19/9/2012)
Green fingers and green houses
A growing number of people have taken to "urban
farming" in the wake of a series of food safety
scandals. And, as He Na reports from Beijing, it is
not just healthy, it is fun. Han Qunhui's home in
Changsha, Hunan province is situated in a large
community where most of the buildings look the
same. Even friends who've visited several times
before have been apt to get lost in the "maze" of
houses. But that's all changed recently. Now,
visitors can find Han's home quickly, even if they
still have no idea of her building and room
number. The change is due to Han's balcony: It
resembles a green tent hanging outside the fifth
floor, with towel gourd vines, rows of beans and
agaric vegetables overflowing the open balcony,
where large bowls of endive, lettuce and shallots
also grow. "My balcony is the best signpost”, said
the 28-year-old network designer. "I haven't been
to the market for vegetables for several days
because the ones that grow on my balcony are
enough for the daily needs of my husband and
me", said Han, proudly. "I often share some with
my neighbors, and they all like them."
It's hard to connect the fashionable-looking
woman with vegetable planting, which is often
seen as hard, dirty work. Han said she derives
great enjoyment from her vegetables, but that's
not the only reason she plants them. A couple of
overriding concerns led her to become an "urban
farmer". "First, I'm tired of the rapid rhythm of
work and often dream of getting back to the land.
Second - and this is more serious - food safety is a
big concern”, she said. In recent years, a number
of incidents concerning food safety have shaken
public confidence: Melamine-contaminated milk;
pork containing high amounts of illegally added
thin carnosine, a steroid that can make human
sick; fake salty duck eggs, where food colorants
have been added to produce red yolks; illegally
recycled cooking oils; and vegetables with levels
of pesticide residue well above legal limits. The
list goes on. "The cases really made me uneasy”,
said Han, who is planning to start a family very
soon. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 20
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Green fingers and green houses (Contd)
He stressed that people must be sure that the food
they eat is safe. "The vegetables I grow are
genuinely organic and don't contain pesticides. I
spend a lot of time removing worms from the
pots", she joked. "The vegetables are really tender
and refreshing and taste better than those bought
at the market. My baby will be very healthy if she
or he grows up eating the vegetables I grow", she
said. Like Han, an increasing number of people
living in the cement-and-steel-made cities, young
and old, have started urban farming and have
become addicted to growing vegetables on their
balconies. According to Peng Kuo, the founder of
www.52caiyuan - one of China's largest platforms
for balcony vegetable growers - since the website
was established in June 2010, the number of
registered members has increased from roughly
100 to more than 40 000. "The idea for the
website came from those "vegetable-stealing"
games that are popular online. I began to plant
vegetables on the balcony in 2009 and often share
my experiences and consult with others in our
dedicated Internet group. To my surprise, many
people have the same hobby as me. I am a website
designer and it made sense to establish a larger
platform so friends across the country could
exchange views, experiences and improve our
gardening skills”, he said.
"New members register every day and I am fully
confident that the site can be developed into a
professional platform providing full service, from
seeds, tools, seedlings, cultivation tips, making
organic fertilizers, worm prevention, and
harvesting", he said. The popularity of urban
farming has led to a boom in sales of seeds, tools,
organic fertilizers and technical books, both
online and in brick-and-mortar stores. A search
for related topics on Taobao, one of China's
leading online retail portals, reveals 29 278 items
for sale, covering pretty much every requirement
for the enthusiastic balcony horticulturalist.
(Continued in next column)
Green fingers and green houses (Contd)
Yu Fei, a project manager of Beijing Zhongnong
Luyuan Engineering Technology Co in the
capital's Fengtai district, said the company
designed a range of equipment to help enthusiasts
and sales have risen sevenfold since it was
launched in 2010. "The devices and technology
promote cultivation via soil substitutes and
hydroponics, which are clean and easy to use. Our
sales keep increasing month by month. With the
increasing concerns about food safety and greater
attention on health, I am confident about the
company's future", she said.
In recognition of the market potential, agricultural
expert Feng Jie, director of the Beijing Green
Science Technology Centre, also plans to extend
cultivation spaces from balconies to rooftops and
benefit more communities and companies. She
highlighted the importance of choosing the right
type of soil and suggested using soil from the
suburbs or rural areas, which is less likely to have
been polluted by chemical waste from factories or
the overuse of pesticide and chemical fertilizers.
"Seventy-five% of our members’ plant vegetables
on balconies because of concerns over food
safety, especially families with elders and kids,"
Peng Kuo said. "If people are able to make
rational use of their space and choose the right
varieties of plants, the produce can satisfy part of
the daily vegetable requirement for small
families", Peng said. "Since our bureau began to
promote planting vegetables on balconies in 2007,
the number of people consulting our hotline has
increased greatly. Our nine operators receive an
average of around 40 phone calls a day. As
demand for consultations has grown, our team of
experts has also expanded and currently we have
150 providing instructions", said Lu Tiangang,
Deputy Director of the 12 316 agriculture service
hotline of the Beijing Agriculture Bureau. "Two
years ago we regularly took tools and samples to
communities for promotional purposes, but now,
we're invited to lots of communities to organize
activities", he said (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 21
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Green fingers and green houses (Contd)
Planting in soil requires a high level of
technology, but the cost of the soilless cultivation
method is also on the high side, so we suggest that
residents plant bud seedlings, which only need
water. Not only is the cost low, but the skills
required are easy to acquire, he added. Lu Jinhua,
67, a retired media worker from Beijing's
Chaoyang district, is hooked on urban farming,
and planting bud seedlings on her balcony is now
her favorite hobby. "As soon as I wake in the
morning, the first thing I do is go to the balcony to
see how my vegetables have grown. I take photos
and write notes every day. It has made my retired
life more meaningful", she said. "After about a
week, the seedlings grow to a height of about 10
cm. If it is the right time to harvest them, I will
wash them and then add some salt and vinegar.
The taste is just like the vegetables I had many
years ago", she said. Lu admitted having great
concerns about food safety and said she doesn't
dare to eat vegetables and fruit bought in the
market without immersing them in water for a
long period and then washing them thoroughly.
"Many years ago, we didn't have so many
varieties of food, but at least it was safe.
However, nowadays, we have a greater choice,
but we dare not eat the food", she said. According
to Peng Kuo, urban farming has a number of
advantages, such as environmental protection and
improvement, plus a healthier diet.
The popularity of urban farming indicates that
people's awareness of health issues and food
safety has increased and the practice should be
encouraged, said Feng Jie. However, in some
senses, it is the choice of the helpless, but can also
be seen as silent protest against those who violate
food safety and as a complaint to the government,
Feng said. "Though urban farming has many
advantages, many people simply don't have the
right conditions to do so. Even if everybody
followed suit, it would still be impossible to grow
every variety of vegetable. (Continued in next
column)
Green fingers and green houses (Contd)
Solving the problem of food safety will require a
greater effort from society as a whole, especially
the law enforcement departments", she said.
(cd 19/9/2012)
China overtakes US as largest crop importer
China passed the US last year for the first time to
become the biggest importer of agricultural
products, while also increasing its exports,
according to data by the World Trade
Organization. Imports, including food and
beverages, rose 34% to USD 144.7 bio in 2011
from USD 108.3 bio in 2010, according to
Bloomberg calculations based on data released by
the Geneva-based trade body.
Exports gained 25% to USD 64.6 bio, beating
Canada to become the sixth largest, the data show.
The country's rising population was highlighted as
the reason for growth demand from soybeans,
corn, feed livestock, powdered milk and sugar to
make beverages. Urbanization widened China's
water and land shortages, further fuelling a global
rally in crops amplified by drought-reduced
supply. (cd 21/9/2012)
More farmers sign up to food chains
More Chinese farmers are resorting to food chain
partnership projects to improve their agricultural
yields and raise the quality of their harvest, say
industry experts.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 22
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
More farmers sign up to food chains (Contd)
The projects, equipping farmers with technology
and instructions on agricultural practices, guide
them in reducing pesticides for safer and better
products and cuts costs by helping them to sell
directly to wholesalers. According to Chen
Jianmin, managing director of the Jubaowan
Agriculture Technology Co in East China's
Zhejiang province, which joined the food chain
partnership in 2010, the output of an eggplant
farm under the project, is 66% higher than those
under traditional cultivation.
The income of the eggplant field has also more
than doubled in two years. "Informing the public
of where the products are from and how they are
grown better guarantees the marketing and sale of
the fruit, especially as scandals of excessive
pesticide residue grab the headlines now and
then", he said. By scanning the traceability code
on the package of the products, customers will
know where they were produced, the farmer
responsible, how much and how often fertilizers
were used, where and how the goods were
transported and whether it is genetically modified
food, he said. Chen's farmland is one of the 16
food chain projects of Bayer CropScience China
in the country, according to Lu Yuanding, food
chain partnership manager of the company.
The partnership is involved in about 240 projects
in 30 countries, covering 40 different fruit and
vegetable crops. Recent years have witnessed a
clear increase. He added they will include more
Chinese farmers in the project over the next five
years after more showed an interest when they
saw some of the experimental projects helped to
increase yields. "It's estimated the number of food
chain projects in China will hit 100 in five years",
said Lu. "China is of the utmost importance
because a food safety issue, especially the
pesticide overuse by China’s individual farmers
has become a major concern in recent years".
(Continued in next column)
More farmers sign up to food chains (Contd)
The food chain partnership will further expand in
the country within first- and second-tier cities in
the coming years, according to Rob Hulme,
country head of Bayer CropScience China. (cd
24/9/2012)
Seven lean years for instant noodles
Although China is a top producer of instant
noodles, production has not increased
significantly during the past 7 years. The industry
sold a total of RMB 48 bio packages in 2005,
while the sales volume of 2011 was a mere 50
bio. This means that the per capita consumption
of instant noodles has been decreasing in China.
Some industry experts ascribe this negative
development to a lack of innovation in the
industry, while others believe that Chinese
consumers currently have more types of
convenience food to choose from.
(tjkx 24/9/2012)
Vietnam becomes China's largest coffee supplier
Vietnam has become China's largest coffee
supplier as China has seen an increase in coffee
import in recent years, according to a Chinese
official at the ongoing ninth Expo of China and
the Association of Southeast Asian Nations on
Saturday. China mainly imports coffee from
ASEAN countries, especially from Vietnam and
Malaysia, said Wang Lei, deputy secretary-
general of the ASEAN Secretariat at the expo
which opened on Friday in Nanning, capital of
south China's Guangxi Zhuang autonomous
region. Customs data shows that China had
imported 137 000 t of coffee from 2007 to 2011,
totalling USD 365 mio. In 2011, China imported a
total of 43 000 t of coffee, a year-on-year increase
of 41.9%. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 23
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Vietnam becomes China's largest coffee supplier (Contd)
China imported 103 900 t of coffee from Vietnam
from 2007 to 2011, which amounted for USD 195
mio, accounting for 90% of the total coffee
imports from ASEAN countries, Wang said.
China imported a total of 15 000 t of coffee from
Vietnam, amounting for USD 31.88 mio in the
first half of 2012, which accounted for 96.2% of
the total coffee imports from ASEAN countries,
Wang said. Moreover, statistics from China
Coffee Association shows that there are about
13 600 cafes and 2 200 coffee-related enterprises
in China with a total of 500 000 employee
involved in the industry. At present, China's
annual coffee consumption stands between 30 000
to 40 000 t with annual growth rate of 10% to
15%. It is estimated that China's coffee
consumption will continue to rise and reach
120 000 t in 2012, Wang said. (cd 24/9/2012)
China is UN's valuable partner for food security
Speaking ahead of a five-day trip to China, the
head of the United Nations Food and Agriculture
Organization said China is playing a key role in
the effort to reduce worldwide hunger, and called
on the country to play an equally important role in
helping to stabilize food prices. The two topics,
which FAO general director Jose Graziano da
Silva said are inextricably linked, are among the
central issues of focus for the Rome-based
organization under Graziano's leadership.
Graziano, who spoke to Xinhua in an exclusive
interview recently in his FAO office, will travel to
China end-September after attending UN
meetings in New York. He said the timing of the
China visit is important to him because FAO's
founding month was October, 67 years ago.
"October has always been an important month
here at FAO”, Graziano said. "It is significant that
October will start this year with the trip to China”.
(Continued in next column)
China is UN's valuable partner for food security (Contd)
Graziano said the world was on its way to
reaching the Millennium Goal of reducing by half
the number of people in the world suffering from
hunger, thanks in no small part to steps taken in
China. Graziano said China had been able to
reduce the number of people suffering from
hunger by 40 percent and the number of under
nourished people by 50%. "Because China's
population is so big, progress made in China has a
big impact on the world", Graziano said. Now,
Graziano says he wants to ask China to help with
another problem that will help further reduce the
number of hungry people in the world --
stabilizing food prices and improving world food
security. "We have seen a growing contribution
from China in these areas and we would like to
see the contribution grow still further," he said. "I
think the issue of South-South cooperation is
essential in the world, and for it to work China
must play a big role". By "South-South”,
Graziano was referring to shorthand for countries
in the developing world to cooperate among them.
The 62-year-old agronomist is a native of Brazil,
another key South economy.
"We are moving from the old paradigm of donor
nations and nations that receive aid”, he said.
"Developing countries have a role to play in their
own efforts to move forward and no country has a
bigger role than China, which is already playing a
role elsewhere in Asia, in Africa, and in Latin
America. I would like to see that continue”.
Graziano called on countries to build up food
stocks to help smooth out periods where prices
might temporarily jump, and to work to curb
reactionary changes in import or export policy
that might have an impact on world markets.
"China has been very supportive of food security
issues, and we want China to do more", Graziano
said. "What we have learned is that you cannot
have food security in only one country. It is not a
national problem in any country. It's a regional
and international problem". (cd 28/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 24
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Jumbo shrimp on the block
Long Tujin is in an industry that many might not
take seriously. For one thing, its main product is
the humble prawn. At the same time, no
government agency been able to properly regulate
the market, making it notoriously complicated.
But the global operation that Long has created and
now controls shows just what a massive earner
prawns can be, and how efficiently the industry
can be run. Long's Xiashan Seafood Wholesale
Market is the largest prawn trading market in Asia
and provides 40% of the white leg shrimps sold in
the United States.
It currently accounts for two-thirds of China's and
one-third of the world's prawn produce. Similar to
how market conditions in the Netherlands
determine the price of tulips and in Japan the
price of tuna, Long's Xiashan Seafood Market is
the most accurate weather vane for the global
price of prawns, experts suggest.
So how can this one man, whose surname means
"dragon" in Chinese, manage to make himself the
dragon of the prawn market? His answer is
simple. He says that since he set up his company,
Zhanjiang Zhongxin Co Ltd, the one main thing
he has done is "remove the obstacles to a free
market". It was in the early 1990s that Long -
working as a mid-level manager at a local
construction company after failing to make any
real money as a crab dealer - turned his attention
to the prawn market, then a growing, but poorly
regulated, business. At the time, Long remembers,
it was a market being run without "rule of law,
nor rule of man".
Prawn dealers would spare no effort to con
farmers, forcing them to lower their prices to
unbearable levels by telling them that there was
an oversupply in the market, and their prawns
were not selling. The dealers, in turn, would tell
the buyers - many of whom had surprisingly little
knowledge of the market - that prawns were in
short supply, marking them up to unreasonable
highs. (Continued in next column)
Jumbo shrimp on the block (Contd)
Dealers at that time made money "just by taking
advantage of information asymmetry, and that
was their business model", says Long, the 49-
year-old farmer-turned-entrepreneur whose family
was too poor to send him to college after he
finished high school.. "When the interests of both
sellers and buyers are hurt, by either inflated or
deflated prices, trade volume is the victim”.
"Everyone will go looking for reasonable prices
elsewhere or just quit the business". Someone had
to stand up and redress the situation, and Long
took it on, launching his own market. For the first
few years, all he did, except for building the
market itself, was developing relationships. He
made friends with as many dealers and buyers as
possible: talking with them, offering them free
advice, and linking trustworthy dealers with out-
of-town buyers. Friendships and reputation
brought in business.
As he became someone known and liked, he built
a prawn-trading exchange where dealers, farmers
and buyers met face-to-face. Dealers received a
commission of RMB 0.4/kg, while Long collected
his dues from rentals. But most importantly, all
who came to his market had to go by his "Long
rules": no fraud, no fakes, strictly open and honest
business. His market was a game-changer. It
provided incentives for the dealers to process as
much volume as possible and no longer depended
on unreasonably high mark-ups. And since all the
transactions were openly negotiated in his
marketplace, involving huge volumes on a daily
basis, people did not have to work excessively
hard for a reasonable profit. His being
"reasonable" has had a formidable effect.
The Xiashan market's annual trading volume has
grown from RMB 3.5 bio in 2002 to about RMB
10 bio last year. Its turnover would hit RMB 30
bio, if other aquaculture products were counted.
Long's employees, he says, work hard to remain
"reasonable". (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 25
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Jumbo shrimp on the block (Contd)
They send mobile text messages, for instance, to
prawn farmers who have registered for his
service, feeding them information about the
industry and his market, and most importantly,
supply and demand around the world for shrimps.
"You are wrong if you think this marketplace is
only a trading centre," Long says. "It is also a
logistics and information centre and connects
numerous stakeholders in numerous ways".
Based on its huge and growing daily volumes, and
soaring credit standing, Long's market is now
offering financial plans to help its registered
buyers. Traditionally, prawns have been a strictly-
cash business, demanding huge cash payments
from purchasers. If they could not make the
payments, they sometimes resorted to private
lenders, usually at much higher interest rates to
regular bank loans. Seeing the problem, Long
successfully persuaded commercial banks to
extend their services to the market, equipping it
with a modern payment system. With the
agreement of the market, three to five registered
buyers can provide a group guarantee for one
small buyer's credit standing.
Of the 320 loans that have been extended so far,
not one single default has been reported. By May
2012, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China,
the country's largest bank by market value, had
issued RMB 1.13 bio in loans to Long's members.
Long is not the least bit worried about his
methods being imitated by others? Smoking
tobacco at his newly completed holiday home on
the coast, the short, dark, slim man speaks in a
heavy local accent. "They may try to copy my
methods in other industries. But in the prawn
industry, once a trading centre like this is
established, it would take a hell of a lot of effort
to replicate it”. (cd 28/9/2012)
China raises state purchasing price for wheat
China will lift the government purchasing price
for wheat in 2013 by about 10% from this year,
the country's top economic planner said Saturday.
The move is intended to stimulate grain
production, the National Development and
Reform Commission (NDRC) said in a statement.
The minimum purchase price for wheat in the
country's major wheat-producing areas will be
increased to RMB 112/50 kg, up RMB 10 from
the 2012 price, the NDRC said.
Most of China's 1.3 bio people are fed by
domestically produced grain, making wheat a
major crop in the country. The move will help
stabilize the domestic market amid a volatile
global market, analysts said, adding that
stabilizing food supplies will be crucial in
checking inflation, as food prices account for
about one-third of the prices used to calculate it.
China has set minimum purchasing prices for
grain, including wheat and rice, since 2004. Under
the scheme, the government buys grain from
farmers at the state-set price when the market
price drops below it. (cd 29/9/2012)
Food Packaging Fails Safety Tests Failed in China China is failing to meet national safety standards
for external packaging, according to new research
by the International Food Packaging Association
Dong Jinshi, executive vice-president of the
International Food Packaging Association, said its
tests found many paper cups for instant noodles
and milk tea have excessive fluorescent whitening
agent on their outside packaging. This agent is
also known as Optical Brightening Agent (OBA).
His conclusion was based on the association’s
three-month study, which ended this month. The
study looked at 84 well-known food products
purchased from local supermarkets and
convenience stores in (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 26
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Food Industry News
Functional and Organic Foods
Food Packaging Fails Safety Tests Failed in China (Contd)
Beijing and Shanghai, as well as Guangdong,
Zhejiang and Jiangsu provinces. It found that a
total of 24 food products, or 80% of the total
samples taken in Beijing, were found to have
excessive fluorescent whitening agent, according
to the study. Many popular products that have
been on supermarket shelves for many years were
listed as being substandard, it said. Fluorescent
whitening agent is a type of organic compound
used to make paper white, but it may cause cancer
after people ingest it over time. “Although the
inner packages of the samples were all right,
consumers still are at risk of absorbing the
chemical, when they touch the packages outside”,
he said. No food enterprises involved in the study
said they plan to pull their products off store
shelves. (haccpeuropa 29/9/2012)
Nutrition information obligatory
Food and beverage producers will be obliged to
indicate nutrition information on the packaging
starting January 1, 2013. (ncna 28/8/2012)
China allows cultivated ginseng in food
China's Ministry of Health has allowed cultivated
ginseng to be used in food products across the
nation, a move seen as a good opportunity for the
development of the country's ginseng industry.
(Continued in next column)
China allows cultivated ginseng in food (Contd)
"Many ginseng growers are expected to benefit
from the new policy that will help China's ginseng
industry to develop further and enhance its
international competitiveness”, said Zhang
Lianxue, a ginseng expert at Jilin Agricultural
University (Changchun, Jilin) [1], on the
International Conference on Ginseng held
Wednesday in Changchun, capital of northeast
China's Jilin province. Dubbed the "king of
herbs”, ginseng is considered to be nutritious and
to have great medical value in traditional Chinese
medicine. It has been used as a tonic in TCM for
over 3 000 years. Ginseng is mainly grown in
eastern Asia. Historical records show that China
has a 1 660-year history of cultivating ginseng.
More than 98% of ginseng in Jilin is currently
cultivated, not grown in the wild.
Though China's health authority had previously
restricted the use of the plant to medicines only,
people used to use ginseng as an ingredient in
chicken, porridge and soup recipes or soaked it in
liquor. In 2009, the 32nd conference of the Codex
Alimentarius Commission approved the
international standard of ginseng-derived food
products and allowed planted ginseng to be put
into food.
The Ministry of Health chose Jilin as a pilot
location for adding cultivated ginseng to food
products in March 2011. It has been proven that
ginseng is less toxic than garlic, said Zhang Hui,
an official with the ginseng and antler office of
the Jilin provincial government, on the
conference. Wang Zhihong, president of the
Changchun University of Traditional Chinese
Medicine, said the policy recognizing ginseng as a
food would likely increase ginseng cultivation as
well as research and development on ginseng
products. More and more enterprises have sensed
business opportunities and started to invest in the
ginseng industry in Jilin since the province was
made the pilot location for adding ginseng to food
products’. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 27
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Functional and Organic Foods
China allows cultivated ginseng in food (Contd)
Food products including cookies, jam, coffee
and candies made with ginseng can currently be
found in markets in Jilin. (cd 6/9/2012)
S. Korean ginseng producer to open Jilin plant
South Korea's largest ginseng company Korea
Tomorrow & Global will open its first
production plant in Yanji (Jilin) [2], in October,
to cash in on China's booming healthcare market.
Korea Tomorrow & Global, the parent company
of the well-known red ginseng producer, Cheong
Kwan Jang, is investing USD 800 mio in the
project.The plant will have a designed annual
production capacity of 4 000 t, and its output
will only supply the Chinese market, said Hong
Seong-pyo, a manager from the company who is
responsible for the plant's construction.
"China enjoys not only abundant raw materials
but also huge domestic market”, said Hong.
Ginseng is considered an all-round tonic in Asia
and is consumed as a health product worldwide.
It has been used in traditional Chinese medicine
for more than 3 000 years. Jilin province is the
area with the largest output of ginseng in Asia.
Ginseng production on Changbai Mountain in
Jilin accounts for 85% of China's output and
70% of the world's total output. Around 100 000
local residents have jobs related to the industry,
whose output was worth USD 2.1 bio last year.
Despite China's absolute advantages in ginseng
production, South Korean companies now take
the lion's share of the market. (Continued in next
column)
S. Korean ginseng producer to open Jilin plant (Contd)
According to Yonhap News Agency, Cheong
Kwan Jang plans to open more than 50 stores in
China in 2012. Data from Jilin bureau of quality
and technology supervision shows that the
province's annual ginseng exports are 20 times
that of South Korea but its sales revenue is 5% of
the latter. After years of lobbying, the Ministry of
Health allowed cultivated ginseng to be used in
food products across China early this month, a
move seen as a good opportunity for the
development of the country's ginseng industry.
Zheng Yinan, a professor at Jilin Agricultural
University, praised the new regulation and said
that local ginseng growers and companies would
benefit. "This will help China's ginseng industry
to enhance its international competitiveness”, he
said. The ministry had previously limited the use
of the plant to medicines. People could only use
ginseng as an ingredient in chicken, porridge and
soup recipes or soaked it in liquor. (cd 18/9/2012)
Key Amway health food plant for Guangdong
Direct-selling giant Amway China announced it
will build its largest overseas production base in
South China, aiming to serve the country's fast-
growing health food market. The new base will be
located in the Economic and Technology
Development District in Luogang, Guangzhou
(Guangdong) [3], which will be completed in
2016. The 78 000 sq mts facility will produce the
company's top selling Nutrilite products. "Amway
China will invest RMB 600 mio to build the
Guangzhou production base and a botanical
research centre in Wuxi”, said Audie Wong,
president of Amway China. (cd 6/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 28
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Functional and Organic Foods
Infant formulae no longer ‘good for brain’
The Ministry of Public Health has issued a
statement that it will be no longer allowed for
suppliers of infant formulae to advertise their
products as ‘good for the development of the
brain’. (hcfood 6/9/2012)
Nutritioneer: 3 bad food habits I encountered in China
Too much salt
Salt is habit-forming. New arrivals to China often
remark how salty the food is here, then after a few
weeks or days even of eating out regularly, the
complains trickle down and stop. The food is
suddenly not that salty anymore. Why? Simply
put, the taste buds have readjusted their threshold
for salt. The more salt one gets, the less salty the
food tastes. In other words, the more salt
(especially plain salt) you eat, the more you will
end up needing. I won’t go too much into why
here. Safe to say that when cutting back on salt
intake, it might make things taste bland for a
while, but the body the amazing at readjusting
when given a chance. How to avoid it? Eat home-
cooked food as much as possible and use salt very
sparingly at home. Eating out? Ask for no MSG
and less salt, please. You get strange looks,
mumblings about it being buhaochi, but it is your
heart and kidneys we need to take care of, yes?
Too Much Oil
Ok, some dishes really do not need the swimming
pool of oil at the bottom of the dish. Oils are
great. I am a big fan of oils and fats – of the
healthy kind. With restaurants here, they really do
like using a lot of oil. This is totally
understandable, of course. It makes the food look
good and carries flavor molecules to your nostrils
better. Now, with recycled gutter oil possibly
being used in your meal, it just ups the health risk
ante a little more in this country. What to do?
Again, eat at home during the week, bring
leftovers to work, and eat out only when you
really have to for work or social reasons.
(Continued in next column)
Nutritioneer: 3 bad food habits I encountered in China (Contd)
Attributing Everything to Heat vs. Cold Theory
of Food
There is nothing wrong with viewing the link
between food and health through the Traditional
Chinese Medicine (TCM) lens. It does encourage
people to diversify food intake and the use of
whole foods rather than processed foods. What
gets my goat is that sometimes I get people
attributing clear-cut medical and scientific causes
of certain illnesses to the cold and heat of food.
For example: Food-borne diseases do indeed
typically cause symptoms of vomiting and
diarrhoea. However, some symptoms such as
weakness and sore throat can be caused by
specific types of food bacteria (or their resulting
toxins), too. Most people associate food poisoning
with dirty hands, meat, milk and eggs. However,
if cooked rice or pasta were to be left out for too
long, even if they were well-covered, they could
still get a nice colony of Bacillus Cereus growing
on them. Watch that innocent sore throat, too. It
may not be a case of shanghuo le (a TCM term
for excessive heat). What seems like a simple sore
throat could be an easy way to spread the
Streptococcus bacteria into food if the handler
does not practice good hygiene. Most cases of
food poisoning tend to resolve on their own, but
some types need a little extra medical help. Here
is more info on food poisoning and what to do.
(beijingkids 11/9/2012)
Haute herbs experience
It is a bold chef who dares to add unfamiliar
ingredients to a whole season's menu, but the
experiment seems to have brought the dining
experience up a notch. Fan Zhen and C.J.
Henderson look at Huang Ting's new herbal menu
from two perspectives. Great traditions never die.
Connoisseurs will always savor, harbor and
reinvent, just like Chef Xu Chiping of the
Peninsula Hotel in Beijing.(Continued on next
page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 29
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Functional and Organic Foods
Haute herbs experience (Contd)
In his autumn menu, the chef attempts to realize
his long-cherished dream of using Chinese
medicinal herbs in haute cuisine. On a cool
autumn night when we arrived at the restaurant,
we were greeted at the entrance by a vintage
Chinese medicine cabinet with colorful dried
herbs in its numerous drawers. That was our first
hint of what was to come. The six-course dinner
was delicately presented in bite-sized portions.
The herbs used in the dishes were not only shown
off in small saucers accompanying each course,
but also vividly illustrated in a handmade sepia-
toned menu. Herbs are mostly used as medicine in
the northern cities of China, whereas in the south,
we use them in dishes, drinks or even snacks. The
southern part of the country has a more humid
climate, and people believe that toxins accumulate
in the body because of the heat and damp. Herbs
are often used in mild doses in meals to cleanse
livers, enhance digestion and above all, maintain
the inner balance of our bodies.
As a young child, my grandmother never fed me
Western medicines because she thought they were
far too strong for me. Instead, she picked
yuxingcao (Herba houttuyniae) from our
backyard, and boiled the pulp. That was my cough
syrup. She also fed me the herbs, using them in a
salad with sweet peppers, seasoned with aged
vinegar and crushed garlic. My throat always felt
better immediately, and my appetite certainly
improved. The appetizer at Huang Ting set me off
on a journey of rediscovery. The flavor of the
Chinese red dates or jujubes was enhanced by a
slow-simmered sauce of heshouwu - a common
herb in the Chinese pharmacology, and osmanthus
flowers - the floral herald of autumn. Topped with
fresh lily bulbs, the dates took on delightfully
sweet notes from the two fragrant flowers. Along
the way, we were also treated to plump poached
scallops simmered in a broth of chuanxiong and
baizhi, steamed diced chicken in danggui sauce
accentuated by a vegetable "blossom", chewy
braised (Continued in next column)
Haute herbs experience (Contd)
Bean curd sticks which sang in chorus with
crisped huaishan and lotus seeds. Finally, a jelly
dessert dotted with orange wolfberries wrapped
up a night of indulgence. At the end of the meal,
we were definitely warmed by both the herbal
tonics and the cozy ambience. We would go away
with more lustrous hair, thanks to the heshouwu,
stronger kidneys thanks to the huaishan, and
better circulation and digestion, thanks to the
danggui.
The inspiration for the herbal dinner came to Chef
Xu a long time ago, when he was still a novice to
cooking. He became fascinated with the concept,
and was determined to refine and elevate herbal
dishes to haute cuisine, thereby broadening their
appeal. "I left Shanghai with my family for
America when I was a kid. But I was always
curious about Chinese traditions. The herbal meal
is one of the traditions that come with an
interesting history", he says.
More than 5000 years ago, the legendary Shen
Nong, the father of agriculture, was the first to
study the healing properties of plants. He also
established the theory of yin and yang, which
became the foundation of Chinese culture and
philosophy. These opposing, yet complimentary
forces make up the whole. So when illness occurs,
Chinese doctors believe there is an imbalance in
the body. Food can then play a role in correcting
and maintaining this balance.
"The herbs we use are very mild, not like 'real
medicine ", the chef says.”They don't have a
strong taste or unpleasant smell. Traditional
Chinese herbal cuisine is not only a science but an
art. It will definitely be the next culinary trend”.
These are not the sort of herbs we use to flavor
dishes in Western cooking. The familiar flavors
such as parsley, basil and thyme were all gone,
and there was not even the familiarity of chilli,
garlic and coriander. In their place were baizhi,
ginseng, and heshouwu. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 30
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Functional and Organic Foods
Haute herbs experience (Contd)
This was one dining experience that was like
falling through the other side of the herbal world,
somewhere unfamiliar and strange, where my
taste buds were put through quite a challenge.
Trying to identify different flavors - flavors never
before encountered - really gave my palate a
workout. It was great to be able to taste an
entirely different culinary world. While I would
certainly eat here again, I think I'll stick to
parsley, sage, and rosemary in my own kitchen.
Huang Ting is artfully decorated in the style of
ancient hutong homes, with a specialized tea
counter, herbal storage, stone lions, original
marble and wooden fixtures, and private rooms
off the main dining room for entertaining parties
as large as 24.
We are welcomed with cups of babaocha (Eight
Treasures Tea) that were sweet, yet thick and
grounded and made from eight different
ingredients, we were told. Executive Chef Xu
Chiping explains he has used TCM to improve the
balance and nutrition of his menu. Any
nervousness we felt was assuaged when he said
there was no animal parts used, nor was this menu
some wild foray into food as medicine. The whole
atmosphere has a feel of authenticity coupled with
anticipation: What will these herbal dishes be
like? The setting brackets our thoughts on
traditional Chinese living and we imagine we are
in for something very different.
The six-course tasting menu begins with
marinated dates with heshouwu, an herb that is
meant to aid digestion. It is a clever way to begin,
preparing us for the feast ahead as the following
courses tantalize and intrigue our Western taste
buds.The steamed chicken is a textual feast,
incorporating crunchy danggui, tart ginseng,
cordyceps, soft brown mushrooms, sweet, plump
wolfberries (also known as goji berries, an
antioxidant-rich super food) and succulent
chicken thigh.
(Continued in next column)
Haute herbs experience (Contd)
One bite of this colorful, multi-layered palate
teaser is in itself a completely new experience.
Sweet, salty, and both homey and unfamiliar, this
dish was a standout. Who knew steamed chicken
could be so transformed? Those on a low-fat diet
will rejoice. We hear so much about traditional
Chinese medicine in the West, but there is little
chance to experience it.
Having the opportunity to get to know their
flavors, see their shapes, learn where they come
from, and hear from Xu about his childhood days
of drinking the ghastly (but healthy) herbal soup
prepared by his grandmother, was the perfect
introduction to Chinese herbal cooking.
For Xu, this new autumn menu is a chance to
introduce TCM herbs to both Western and
Chinese diners in a holistic but natural way. We
don't get the feeling we are eating medicine -
instead, we feel energized, refreshed and satisfied
at the end of the meal. Huang Ting's new menu is
ambitious, but they have paid a lot of attention to
detail, which means their quest for perfection is
not an overreach. And I am not overreaching
when I say their mushroom parcels with black
truffle are a religious experience. Do not miss
them. (cd 24/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 31
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Ingredient News
New ingredients approved
The Ministry of Health has approved 5 new food
ingredients: Trisodium monohydrogen
diphosphate, Nitrous Oxide, lactase, calcium
citrate trihydrate, and dextranase.
(jinghua 28/8/2012)
LycoRed's China premix plant gains full approval
LycoRed Ltd., Israel, announces today that its
new premix plant in Changzhou (Jiangsu) [1], one
of the largest premix factories in Asia is fully
approved. The new plant will serve processors of
infant formula, beverage, baby food and other
food products in Asia Pacific. This new site is
now fully operational. LycoRed will exhibit
innovative concepts of vitamin and mineral
premixes designed specifically for Asia-based
processors at Vitafoods Asia, September 5 to 7,
Booth No. 120. The LycoRed team will be on
hand to discuss nutrition trends and new
opportunities in premixes.
“We recently received our Halal MUI certificate
for our new vitamins D3, E and K1 formulations”,
adds Ilan Ron, vice president of sales and
marketing for LycoRed. “These vitamins are
made with a proprietary spray-drying process to
ensure completely solubility of vitamins. They
can be used in premixes for infant formula and
baby food, as well as in dry blends for beverages.
Our formulations are manufactured under the
most stringent specifications in the market for
delivering the safest premixes. We are proud to
have received all necessary certifications and can
ensure our customers will receive the highest
quality blends possible”. Concurrently, LycoRed
appointed Jason Foo sales and business
development manager. "Jason will handle all sales
and business development in Malaysia,
Singapore, Indonesia, Vietnam and the
Philippines”, notes Ron. (newhope 4/9/2012)
CP Kelco appoints Azelis as exclusive distributor for China
CP Kelco recently appointed Azelis as exclusive
distributor in the People’s Republic of China and
Hong Kong SAR, representing the entire product
portfolio into the for Food, Beverage, Consumer
and Industrial application segments. ”China is a
strategic growth market for CP Kelco’s nature-
based products. As the market matures, there has
been a distinct shift into high-quality and eco-
friendly manufacturing, generating a rapid
increase in demand for specialty ingredients—
particularly within the food, beverage and other
consumer sectors”, says Don Rubright, President
CP Kelco.
“With its specialty mindset, we are confident that
the Azelis’ team of experienced professionals in
China is well placed to capture this demand,
providing enhanced service, technical knowhow
and efficient logistic solutions to our existing and
growing base of customers”. Joris Coppye, CEO
of Azelis, adds, “This appointment marks a
significant milestone in Azelis’ expansion into the
major growth markets of Asia Pacific, as CP
Kelco’s product range has a perfect fit with the
key growth segments food and beverages,
personal care and coatings. It is a significant
addition to the successful strategic partnership
between both companies that dates back to 1996.
We will use our expertise, combined with in-
depth local knowledge and an intimate
understanding of distinct customer needs in
China, to deliver effective market penetration and
ongoing support for CP Kelco’s unique, advanced
product range”.
In addition to providing world-class service that
includes dedicated local technical and commercial
support, CP Kelco and Azelis expect to create
added value for customers by jointly developing
innovative solutions and formulations that meet
customer needs, anticipate market trends, improve
food safety and quality, and deliver superior end-
product performance. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 32
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Ingredient News
CP Kelco appoints Azelis as exclusive distributor for China (Contd)
Leveraging Azelis’ strong relationships with
prime chemicals manufacturers and geographical
reach, CP Kelco will continue supporting its key
accounts to meet their ambitious growth targets.
Azelis will work with CP Kelco incumbent
distributor partners to optimize existing
distribution channels. (fif 13/9/2012)
Firmenich opens R&D centre for fragrances, flavours and ingredients in Shanghai
Firmenich, a Swiss developer of fragrances,
flavours and ingredients, has inaugurated a state-
of-the art Research and Development (R&D)
facility in Shanghai, China. This new facility will
integrate laboratories cutting across the Group’s
leading scientific disciplines, including the
discovery and development of ingredients, as well
as technologies to improve fragrance and flavour
performance, perception and delivery. Its
scientists will be dedicated to expanding the
Group’s innovation pipeline to best meet demand
in China and the extended Asia Pacific region,
while also contributing to the Group’s global
innovation programmes. ‘Following the success
of our first R&D facility in China in 2006, we
decided to step up our innovation foothold here to
further accelerate and expand our development
pipeline’, said chief executive Patrick Firmenich.
‘Our teams here are dedicated to developing
cutting edge ingredients and technologies that are
fully aligned with the specific needs of our clients
in China and the Asia Pacific region’. He added:
‘By deepening our understanding of the
innovation needs in these markets, we are
committed to supporting our clients’ growth in
this dynamic region’. Dr Dong Fang Chen,
President China, Firmenich, added: ‘China has
over two thousand years of rich heritage in
flavours and fragrances. (Continued in next
column)
Firmenich opens R&D centre for fragrances, flavours and ingredients in Shanghai (Contd)
By expanding our R&D strength here, we are
committed to understanding the diverse tastes and
needs of Chinese consumers in order to design
and create products that will delight them’. The
R&D building in China is the company’s third
innovation hub worldwide, working closely with
other centres in Europe (Geneva, Switzerland)
and North America (Princeton, New Jersey). Its
scientists also collaborate extensively with
external partners, including start-ups and
academic institutions. (manchem 18/9/2012)
More stable chilli red
Researchers from the West China University
(Sichuan) [2] in cooperation with Zhongda
Biotech Co., Ltd. (Zhengzhou, Henan) [3] have
developed a production process for a more stable
type of red food color derived from chili. The
project has been approved by experts assigned by
the Science & Technology Department of Sichuan
Province. (hcfood 27/9/2012)
Top flour maker in trouble because of borax
China’s largest flour producer, Wudeli (Daming,
Hebei) [4], with a current market share of 9.36%
and an annual turnover of RMB 12.1 billion, has
made the news in a negative way. Traces of borax
have been found in during quality checks. In the
past, borax has been used as a whitener for flour,
but has been prohibited for health reasons.
(jinandaily 21/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 33
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Ingredient News
Top flour maker in trouble because of borax (Contd)
Ingredients prices Two times a year China News collects reference
prices of common food ingredients for the
Ingredients section. We are doing so again in this
issue. As always the prices are provided as
RMB/kg and have been extracted from reliable
Antioxidant RMB/kg
Tea polyphenol 360
BHA 160
BHT 48
TBHQ 170
Sodium iso-ascorbate 68
Dodecyl gallate 240
Colorants RMB/kg
Tartrazine 17
B-carotene 60
Red koji 18
Chili red 45
Fruit green 35
Carmine 24
(Continued in next column)
Ingredients prices (Contd)
Preservatives RMB/kg
Sodium benzoate 16
Benzoic acid 35
Nisin 645
Natamycin 1195
ethyl paraben 85
Propyl paraben 77
Methyl paraben 75
Sodium diacetate 12
Potassium sorbate 31
Lysozyme 2200
Sweeteners RMB/kg
Sucralose 1180
Lactose 15
Mannitol 28
Lactitol 165
Aspartame 160
D-xylose 14
Enzymes RMB/kg
Papaine 210
Pancreatine 406
Glucose isomerase 270
B-glucanase 1245
Lactase 150
Hemicellulase 550
Pepsin 455
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 34
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Ingredient News
Ingredients prices (Contd)
Thickeners/stabilisers RMB/kg
Konjak 82
Calcium stearate 26
Arabinogalactan 48
Sodium caseinate 120
PGA 126
Gellan 345
Potassium alginate 68
Agar 128
Sodium alginate 90
CMC 28
Carrageenan 38
Guar gum 35
Gum arabic 70
Xanthan 42
Sodium caseinate 80
Emulsifiers RMB/kg
Tween 80 22
PGFE 40
GMS 21
CSL-S 22
Span 80 22
Sucrose ester 15
Lecthin 40
(Continued in next column)
Ingredients prices (Contd)
Nutrients RMB/kg
Copper gluconate 80
Sodium gluconate 9
Zinc gluconate 40
Calcium gluconate 25
Vitamin A 340
Vitamin C 70
Vitamin E 360
L-carnitine 315
Serine 255
Glutamic acid 35
Histidine 270
Methionine 115
Arginine 315
Isoleucine 210
Leucine 150
Taurine 32
Theonine 35
Taste enhancers RMB/kg
HAP 28
Potassium chloride 9.5
Sodium succinate 35
Disodium inosine 160
Disodium 5’-ribonucleotide 160
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 35
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Regional News
Company News
Ningxia
Helan emerging wine region
The Helan Mountain region of Ningxia is rapidly
developing as one of China’s most promising new
wine regions. The local government is actively
supporting this industry. The region is the home
of 27 wineries with a combined capacity of 995
000 hls of wine p.a. (tjkx 6/9/2012)
Wahaha runs to buy British snack brand KPU Wahaha Group (Hangzhou, Zhejiang) [1], China's
biggest beverage producer, is in pole position to
buy UK-based United Biscuits' 520-mio-GBP
snack business KP Snacks, according to a report
in the British newspaper The Sunday Telegraph.
If successful, it will be the second major
acquisition by a Chinese food and drink giant of
an overseas brand. Shanghai-based Bright Food
Group, also Wahaha's biggest rival in China, in
May purchased a controlling interest in Weetabix
Ltd, a major maker of breakfast cereals in the
United Kingdom, making it the Chinese industry's
biggest overseas acquisition so far.
Wahaha was unavailable for comment on
Monday. "No doubt, Wahaha has its advantages.
As it is a leader in the food and drink business in
China, and has successful experience of retailing
in China, the world's largest market”, said Zhang
Huiming, head of the Enterprise Research
Institute at Fudan University in Shanghai.
(Continued in next column)
Wahaha runs to buy British snack brand KPU (Contd)
The Chinese market, with its huge consumption
potential, will strongly support Wahaha, he added.
But he added that it is not the proper time to go
into a deep analysis of Wahaha's advantages and
disadvantages, as it is still in competition with
other companies for the deal. Wahaha Chairman
Zong Qinghou, 66, listed as the richest man in
China by the Hurun Report this year, said earlier
that his company "has abundant cash", and is
willing to participate in sectors including oil
exploration and the dairy business in Australia.
The Sunday Telegraph said that KP Snacks,
which owns household brands in the UK such as
McCoy's, Hula Hoops, KP Nuts and Skips, is
being put up for sale by its private-equity owners,
Blackstone Group LP and PAI.
The pair, being advised by Credit Suisse, has sent
a four-page sales "teaser" to six potential buyers,
including Wahaha The teaser was also sent to
cereal maker Kellogg's, which recently paid USD
2.7 bio for crisp company Pringles; Kraft, where
KP's new chief executive formerly worked; and a
series of private-equity firms, including Permira.
The final information memorandum will be sent
out on September 3, the newspaper said. "The
international expansion of Chinese companies and
their brands is now one of the most influential
trends across the global business environment,
and the Chinese companies have revealed a huge
surge in confidence, ambition and determination
to conquer global markets”, said Mike Bastin, a
researcher at Nottingham University's School of
Contemporary Chinese Studies.
In 2010, Bright Foods was reported to be in talks
with United Biscuits over an acquisition deal
worth RMB 21.7 bio. But the company later
denied the reports. Zong is reported to have
invested RMB 1 bio to build a department store in
Hangzhou, Zhejiang province. This is the first
time the self-made billionaire has ventured
outside the food and beverage sector.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 36
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Wahaha runs to buy British snack brand KPU (Contd)
Zong has recently returned from a 10-day
European tour, during which the Hangzhou native
met a score of fashion suppliers from cities like
Paris, Milan, and Madrid, and invited them to join
his business empire, said Shan Qining, a
spokesman for Zong and Wahaha. WAOU Plaza,
the name of the store, meaning an exclamation of
surprise in Chinese, will be a shopping destination
offering exclusive European merchandise and
situated in the outskirts of Zhejiang. "What will
be sold at my place will be affordable, quality,
value-for-money products from Europe, nothing
like the RMB-1000-a-piece luxuries that Chinese
customers are familiar with”, said Zong, during
interviews with local newspapers in Hangzhou.
Zong called his entry into the retail sector "the
first step of the company's multi-element
operation" and "an important strategic decision
made after careful thinking".
Founded in 1987 from a small school-run
business, Wahaha Group now has more than 30
000 employees and assets of RMB 31.8 bio. In
2011, it achieved annual sales of RMB 67.9 bio
and a profit of RMB 12.3 bio, ranking it eighth
among the nation's non-State-owned enterprises.
(cd 21/8/2012)
Bright Food said to offer fees on Weetabix deal loan
Bright Food Group (Shanghai) is believed to be
changing the financing arrangements on its
planned acquisition of a majority stake in
Weetabix Ltd. According to industry sources, the
company now plans to pay fees on a loan backing
the acquisition plus a margin totalling about 230
basis points, the sources said. The company
originally offered to pay zero fees to potential
lenders and a margin of 230 basis points. Calls
made to confirm the new arrangement, to the
offices of Bright Food in Shanghai, went
unanswered. (Continued in next column)
Bright Food said to offer fees on Weetabix deal loan (Contd)
The Shanghai-based food manufacturer, which is
seeking about USD 800 mio in financing to back
the deal, is believed to be considering issuing a
USD 300 mio bond as part of the financing and
fund the remainder with bank loans.
(cd 21/9/2012)
Wuliangye invests in expansion
China’s top distiller Wuliangye (Yibin, Sichuan)
[2] is investing RMB 12 bio in a new expansion
project. The new plant will add 1 mio hls of
distilled liquor to the company’s capacity. (tjkx
21/8/2012)
New winery in Xinjiang
Wangzhong Winery (Xinjiang) and the
government of Yanqi County (same) [3] have
signed an agreement under which Wangzhong
will establish a winery in Yanqi with a capacity of
5 000 hls p.a. The project will involve an
investment of RMB 180 mio. (tjkx 5/9/2012)
Distell buys majority stake in Chinese liquor distributor
South African liquor company Distell is
expanding its presence in the East with the
acquisition of a 60% share in fast-growing liquor
distribution company CJ Wines & Spirits, for an
undisclosed amount. Privately owned CJ is based
in Zhongshan [4] (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 37
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Distell buys majority stake in Chinese liquor distributor (Contd)
in the Pearl Valley Delta of Guandong province,
and has operations in Hong Kong, Macau and
Mainland China. Rody Wong, who previously ran
CJ Wines & Spirits, will head the new venture,
which is now trading as Distell China. Wong, a
former Apple and Seagram executive, who has
worked in the US and Asia, has established a
strong support base for Cognac brand Bisquit,
which Distell bought in 2009. Wong says that
Distell China’s focus would be on building the
presence of Bisquit in the southern part of the
country initially, which is referred to as the
country’s ‘cognac belt’.
According to French trade body Bureau National
Interprofessionel du Cognac (BNIC), cognac
exports to China are “surging”. The BNIC
reported that for the 12 months to June 2012,
year-on-year volume and value levels exceeded
all past records, with producers shipping the
equivalent of 168.5-mio bottles of cognac, worth
USD 2.8-bio. Demand in the Far East has
outpaced other regions, where volumes rose 9.9%
and value, by 21.4%. Asian countries imported
61.8-mio bottles of Cognac during the period,
with China’s consumption, in particular, surging.
The Far East is now the world's biggest importer
of Cognac, with turnover exceeding USD 1.25
bio. “CJ’s conversancy with the cognac market is
an important asset, and we plan to bring this
expertise in marketing to retail and on-
consumption channels to Amarula, which is
currently one of the fastest-growing spirits brands
worldwide”, Wong said.
According to Distell Group MD Jan Scannell, the
plan is to capitalise on the strong market potential
of South China and then address markets such as
Beijing, Shanghai and Chengdu. “The new
venture would carry spirits and wines from
around the world, and that obviously gives us the
scope to explore avenues for some of our other
brands”. (engineeringnews 3/9/2012)
Zhujiang Brewing profits
Zhujiang Brewing (Guangzhou, Guangdong) [5]
has filed a net profit of RMB 44 220 700 for the
first half of 2012, down 25.39% compared to the
same period of 2011. The turnover of that period
was RMB 1.464 bio up 0.65%. (tjkx 11/9/2012)
Zhujiang’s situation reflects the general trend in
the Chinese brewing industry at this moment.
Yanjing Brewing (Beijing) has announced an
extensive refinancing programme for 8 of its
subsidiaries through an additional emission of
shares. (tjkx 13/9/2012 and 17/9/2012)
Qingdao to start new plant in Jiangxi
The plan of Qingdao Brewing (Qingdao,
Shandong) [6] to build a new plant in Jiujiang
(Jiangxi) has been approved by the provincial
authorities. The new brewery will have a capacity
of 6 mio hls p.a. It is expected to be ready for
production in the first half of 2013.
(tjkx 13/9/2012)
From IT to distilled
IT giant Lenovo has acquired a 100% stake in the
Confucius Family (Kongfu) Distillery (Qufu,
Shandong) [7]. The transaction has a value of
RMB 400 mio. The distillery is one of China’s
more famous producers of traditional distilled
liquor. However, the company has been suffering
from financial problems for a number of years, in
spite of several attempts to reorganise. However,
the company’s brand carries a heavy cultural
value. Qufu is the birthplace of Confucius and the
home of the Kong Family graveyard (Confucius is
the Latinisation of Kong Fuzi, Master Kong =
Confucius). The local government was set to
continue this tradition and actively supported the
search for a buyer. This is how finally Lenovo
was found interested in acquiring this distillery.
(hcfood 17/9/2012)
It will be interesting to see, whether Lenovo will
be able to revive this fledgling company.
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 38
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Lenovo acquires third distillery
IT giant Lenovo has acquired all shares of Wuling
Distillery (Changde, Hunan) [8]. This is the third
distillery acquired by Lenovo in a relatively short
period. The company manages this business
through a special subsidiary.
(tjkx 28/9/2012)
This move by Lenovo clearly indicates that
Chinese corporations have confidence in the
distilling business. However, the cartoon also
shows that the general public in China still has to
grow accustomed to such investments in non-core
business
Tontine Wines acquires Baiyanghe
Hong Kong based Tontine Wines Group has
acquired a 60% stake in Baiyanghe Winery
(Yantai, Shandong) [9]. The transaction involves
an amount of RMB 130 mio. Baiyanghe’s
products are mainly sold in the richer coastal
provinces of China. (tjkx 27/9/2012)
China’s first wine entrepreneur incubator
The Yantai Student Entrepreneur Park has joined
forces with the wine industry in Yantai
(Shandong) and the China branch of ISNAB
(Institut des Sciences de la Naturee t de l'Agroali
mentaire de Bordeaux) to establish a special
incubator facility for young entrepreneurs in the
wine business. (tjkx 28//9/2012)
ISNAB (China) Institute was established in China
Agricultural University (Yantai) on March 7,
2011. (Continued in next column)
China’s first wine entrepreneur incubator (Contd)
It is the first sommelier marketing training course
of China.
Maotai, the national liquor? Maotai (Zunyi, Guizhou) [10], Chinese most
famous distilled liquor after President Nixon’s
seminal visit to China, has stated that it should be
recognised as China’s ‘national liquor’. However,
that statement immediately drew violent
opposition from the other well known brands.
(hcfood 20/9/2012)
Bright’s Guo complains and needs to recant immediately
Shanghai Bright’s CEO, Mr. Guo Benheng, has
given a rather feisty interview with Beijing
Commerce recently. During the interview he
stated that technology and management of
Chinese dairy companies is probably not that
much worse that in major dairy countries like
New Zealand. He claimed that the main problem
in China was the raw milk.
There is still too little and the quality is still too
bad. He ended the interview by criticising the
number of quality inspections, stating that a
company like Bright was almost ‘inspected to
death’. This interview, and especially his final
statement, already created a stir in the media.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 39
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Bright’s Guo complains and needs to recant immediately (Contd)
The melamine scandal and other quality problems
in the Chinese dairy industry are still fresh in
people’s memories and putting all the blame on
the dairy production struck most people as
arrogant.Only some days later, a batch of spoiled
Bright milk was discovered, and both Bright and
Mr. Guo were attacked mercilessly. The favorite
slogan became: ‘Bright should be inspected to
death’. (Several sources September 2012)
This item is not only entered to reflect that the
problems in the Chinese dairy industry still are
far from having been solved. It also provides a
look at the cultural mechanisms behind the
problems. Mr Guo is the CEO of one of the
country’s top 3 dairy companies. In that capacity
he feels he is entitled to express himself as he did
during that infamous interview. It is ‘I’m too high
to be touched by anyone or anything’ kind of
attitude. It is like the hubris in ancient Greek
philosophy. It gets you up high in the air for a
while, but then it creates myopia and lets you
make fatal mistakes. The various parts in the
Chinese dairy chain, dairy farmers, milk
processors, government agencies, etc. have been
finger pointing for years, blaming the problems
on everybody but themselves. If this does not stop,
the problems will remain unsolved.
Mengniu to increase sourcing raw milk
Mengniu Dairy Co Ltd. (Huhhot, Inner Mongolia)
[10], the largest dairy products distributor in the
country, hopes to source 100% of its raw milk
supply from large-scale farms, up from the 85%
currently, as part of its efforts to ensure product
quality. The company also plans to spend around
RMB 4 bio on building wholly owned large
ranches in China to meet part of its raw milk
supply requirements.
(Continued in next column)
Mengniu to increase sourcing raw milk (Contd)
Bai Ying, executive director at Mengniu, in
announcing the company's interim results at a
press conference in Hong Kong on Tuesday, said
large-scale ranches were already under
construction in Northeast China, North China and
Northwest China. "Currently, about 84 to 85% of
our raw milk (supply) is from large-scale farms”,
Bai said, adding that by the year 2015, the
proportion will be increased to 100%.
This is one of the company's moves to improve its
product quality and safety by working on the raw
milk supply sources, said Sun Yiping, chief
executive officer at Mengniu.
In December 2011, products from Mengniu's
Meishan plant were found to contain high levels
of cancer-causing Aflatoxin M1. "Following the
detection of M1, our sales volume plunged 30%”,
said Sun, adding that despite the company's
efforts in promotion and marketing, its sales
volume in the first half of this year still contracted
5% from the same period a year ago.
Sun said that since the incident's impact has been
gradually disappearing, Mengniu's sales volume
has recovered to the levels before the December
2011 incident.
Wu Jingshui, chief financial officer at Mengniu,
said that in order to protect its market share after
the scandal, Mengniu had launched a series of
promotions and discounts in the first half, causing
its gross profit margin to contract 0.3% age point
from a year ago to 25.7%. "There will be less
discounts and promotions in the second half,
which is good for the profit margin, but the cost
of raw milk is likely to increase”, said Wu, adding
that its gross profit margin in the second half may
stay flat or see a "slight decrease" from the first
half. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 40
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Mengniu to increase sourcing raw milk (Contd)
Jacqueline KO, analyst at Kim Eng Securities,
told China Daily that she is optimistic about
Mengniu's performance in the second half. "The
management team told us that their sales were
back to normal and as the company will reduce its
promotions in the second half. Its gross profit
margin will be increased from its first half level”,
said KO. KO also said she believes that the
company's commitment to constructing ranches in
China is a positive gesture, as food quality is a
major concern in the country, and the market will
be happy to see the company's efforts on
improving its quality control. She added the
company's valuation is cheap. (cd 29/8/2012)
Chinese eye Tasmanian dairy farms
Just as the hullaballoo surrounding the sale of the
giant cotton farm Cubbie Station starts to wither,
another big Chinese investment group is eyeing
off Australian farmland. The state-owned China
Investment Corp is considering investing in a
Tasmanian-based dairy company. It is an idea that
is split the local community. From Tasmania,
Martin Cuddihy reports.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: At this time of the year in
Tasmania's north-west you can't stray too far off
the bitumen before you get bogged. The rich red
soils and high rainfall are perfect for growing
vegetables, and grass. There are scores of dairy
farms turning that grass into milk.
The head of the Tasmanian Farmers and Graziers
Association is Jan Davis.
JAN DAVIS: Most of Tassie's looking pretty
good at the moment. We're coming into spring off
a fairly moderate winter. We've had a lot of rain
in some spots but so far, so good.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: Today, Tasmania's
Premier Lara Giddings revealed foreign investors
are again looking to capitalise on Australian
agriculture. (Continued in next column)
Chinese eye Tasmanian dairy farms (Contd)
Ms Giddings has just returned from a trade
mission to China. She's told ABC radio she met
with executives from the China Investment
Corporation.
LARA GIDDINGS: A corporation that I met with
the highest level of executives to discuss those
sorts of initiatives and areas that they could invest
in. And there's some keen interest in that.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: Given Tasmania's
struggling finances, she says this is an opportunity
that shouldn't be left begging.
LARA GIDDINGS: We want their investment
because we want to be able to expand our
industry. We want to be able to meet the demand
or some of the demand in China for dairy product,
particularly dried milk product.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: The wealth fund is
interested in the Van Diemen's Land Company. It
was founded by royal decree in 1825 when King
George IV granted 325 000 hectares of land.
Today Van Diemen's Land is almost wholly New
Zealand owned, operating more than 20 dairies
across north-western Tasmania and producing
almost six mio kg of milk products. It is in the
final stages of raising USD 180 mio to double its
milk production and earlier this month four
Chinese executives visited some of the properties.
The company's chief executive is Michael Guerin.
MICHAEL GUERIN: These equity-raising
processes can conclude very quickly when we get
our stage or it can take some time.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: Does the company have
any preference for where the money comes from?
Would you rather see it come locally or does
foreign investment not matter?
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 41
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Chinese eye Tasmanian dairy farms (Contd)
MICHAEL GUERIN: Any important thing for
organisations like ours is to attract the right sort of
equity.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: But you don't have any
preference, or you do?
MICHAEL GUERIN: Well our preference all the
way through and started with the IM is to bring in
capital that's interested in dairy farming in
Tasmania and indeed globally.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: A lot of these farms lie
within the Circular Head council based in
Tasmania's far north-west. Deputy Mayor John
Oldaker is a farmer, and a former chairman of the
Farmers and Graziers Dairy Council. He says this
issue has split the community.
JOHN OLDAKER: This is no different to what it
was in the late '90s when we've seen a whole lot
of country gets planted out to trees. It divides
communities. Now the community all took
different stands on that sort of thing and at the end
of the day it'll be the farmers that will make the
final decision.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: The current chief of the
Farmers and Graziers Association, Jan Davis says
foreign investment is always welcome in other
industries and there should not be another set of
rules for agriculture.
JAN DAVIS: We have strong foreign investment
in all our other industries - in mining, in
manufacturing. And nobody seems particularly
concerned about it.
MARTIN CUDDIHY: So do you think concern
about Chinese investment in Tasmanian dairies is
warranted?
(Continued in next column)
Chinese eye Tasmanian dairy farms (Contd)
JAN DAVIS: No I don't. Firstly, there is yet, I
certainly am not aware yet, of any single dollar
changing hands. We've got a lot of talk but
nobody's put their money down on the table yet.
ASHLEY HALL: Tasmanian Farmers and
Graziers chief Jan Davis ending that report by
Martin Cuddihy. (abc 24/9/2012)
Bright Dairy removes cheese with banned additive from shelves
A cheese product made by Bright Dairy
(Shanghai) for babies was pulled from shelves
nationwide after it was tested to contain a banned
additive, Beijing Times reported today. The
additive, milk mineral, was not allowed for babies
according to regulations issued by the Ministry of
Health in 2009 as it is a newly extracted
compound with unproven effects on babies.
The ingredient was printed on the package of the
cheese product designed for children aged one to
three. However, Shanghai-based Bright Dairy &
Food Co claimed the product is safe and has
passed all quality tests. It pulled the cheese from
shelves to avoid consumer misunderstanding. The
product will reach the market again in October
with a new package. Bright Dairy admitted the
ingredient has been added since 2009, before the
ministry adopted the new regulations. But it didn't
say whether it will be removed after package
redesign, the paper reported. (sd 18/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 42
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Bright Dairy recalls baby product for banned additive in latest goof
Bright Dairy (Shanghai) has taken a cheese
product for babies off the shelves nationwide after
it was found to contain a banned additive, the
dairy giant said yesterday.
"Bright Dairy has recalled all of the products on
the market and apologizes over the misleading
packages”, it said in a statement. The additive,
milk mineral, is not allowed for babies according
to regulations issued by the Ministry of Health in
2009 as it is a newly extracted compound with
unproven effects on babies.
The ingredient was printed on the package of the
cheese product designed for children aged one to
three. Compared with adults, babies are more
vulnerable and sensitive to additives like
colostrums, which may have potential risks to
their health and development; therefore some
additives are banned from being used on dairy
products for babies in China, Cao Mingshi,
Deputy Secretary General of the Shanghai Dairy
Association, told Shanghai Daily.
Dietician Li Dongye said whether milk mineral is
safe or not, or will hinder children's development,
is unknown and different people may react
differently even if no adverse reaction had been
detected. Bright Dairy, however, insisted the
product is safe and has passed all quality tests.
"Milk mineral is a natural and safe source of
calcium”, it said in the statement. It said the
ingredient has been added since 2009, before the
ministry adopted the new regulations.
The formula of the cheese was made before 2009,
an official with Bright Dairy's quality division
surnamed Ju said. Bright Dairy said it pulled the
cheese off shelves nationwide in early September
to avoid consumer misunderstandings, and the
product will reach the market again in October
with a new package.
(Continued in next column)
Bright Dairy recalls baby product for banned additive in latest goof (Contd)
However, some big chain supermarkets in the city
said they didn't know about the recall until
yesterday, when Beijing Times reported its
readers found the banned additive on the package
of the cheese product. The NGS supermarket
chain said all of its supermarkets were still selling
the products, one of original flavor and one of
coconut milk flavor, yesterday until its staff
members saw the Beijing Time report online. "We
did not receive any notification from Bright Dairy
and we called the company to ask about the
situation after we saw the report”, said Gan
Pingzhong, an official with NGS quality
monitoring division.
The Shanghai Industrial and Commercial
Administrative Bureau said it ordered all
supermarkets and convenience stores in the city to
remove the cheese products from shelves
yesterday. The time-honored dairy brand has been
entangled in a number of safety scandals recently.
Early this month, nearly 1 000 households in
Shanghai received sour milk produced by the
dairy giant. It blamed the quality problem on
transport tricycles. In June, its Ubest milk was
found to be contaminated with an alkaline
solution. An automatic valve didn't switch on at
one of Bright's factories. "There is no safe
domestic milk, but what can we do?” says a
consumer, Zhang Baojuan, at a supermarket as
she was picking up some yoghurt products.
(sd 19/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 43
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Synutra to invest in French dairy project
Synutra (Qingdao, Shandong) [6] a leading infant
formula company in China and a producer,
marketer and seller of nutritional products for
infants, children and adults, today announced the
signing of a long-term industrial and commercial
partnership agreement with Sodiaal, the leading
dairy cooperative in France, and its subsidiary,
Euroserum, the world leader in demineralised
whey powders. Under this partnership agreement,
Synutra will build a new drying facility in
Carhaix, France (located in the Brittany region),
intended to manufacture powdered milk and fat-
enriched demineralised whey for the needs of the
Synutra group.
Located in the heart of the central Brittany milk-
collection basin, this new drying facility will meet
the strictest European quality and hygiene
standards and will be capable of producing
60 000 t of powder per year initially, with a
designed capacity of up to 100 000 t annually.
Synutra anticipates spending approximately 90
mio Euros to build and operate this drying facility
with the majority of funding for this project
expected to come from PRC bank loans.
The operational commissioning of the drying
facility is expected to take place by year-end 2014,
subject to full PRC government approval and,
once completed, is expected to employ
approximately 75-100 employees.
Upon commissioning of the drying facility,
Euroserum and Sodiaal will supply the facility
with demineralised liquid whey and milk. This
agreement and the construction of the drying
facility in Carhaix remains subject to the
approvals of the government of the People's
Republic of China, granted by (i) the National
Development and Reform Commission, (ii) the
Ministry of Commerce and (iii) the State
Administration of Foreign Exchange (SAFE).
(Continued in next column)
Synutra to invest in French dairy project (Contd)
Mr. Liang Zhang, Chairman and CEO of Synutra
said, "We are very pleased with this industrial and
commercial partnership with Sodiaal and
Euroserum. This opportunity allows Synutra to
secure its long-term supply of high quality raw
materials and fuel Synutra's future growth while
maintaining the highest quality standard for our
products. We are confident this collaborative
effort can further increase consumer confidence
and trust in our premium nutritional products”.
Mr. Francois Iches, Chairman of Sodiaal said,
"We are delighted with this long term partnership
agreement with Synutra and its investment of a
new drying facility in the Brittany region. This
commitment is a strong signal for Sodiaal and our
farmers of the long-term commercial relationship
between the two groups”.
Synutra International, Inc. is a leading infant
formula company in China. It principally
produces markets and sells its products through its
operating subsidiaries under the "Shengyuan" or
"Synutra" name, together with other
complementary brands.
It focuses on selling premium infant formula
products, which are supplemented by more
affordable infant formulas targeting the mass
market as well as other nutritional products and
ingredients. It sells its products through an
extensive nationwide sales and distribution
network covering all provinces and provincial-
level municipalities in mainland China.
As of June 30, 2012, this network comprised over
650 independent distributors and over 800
independent sub-distributors who sell Synutra
products in over 66 000 retail outlets.
(msn 18/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 44
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Darfield's first shipment off to China
The first 37 containers filled with 940 t of high
quality whole milk powder have left Fonterra’s
new manufacturing site at Darfield, headed for a
customer in China. Canterbury operations
manager Richard Gray says the site has
progressed from bare paddock to producing high-
quality milk powder in just over 18 months.
"Our first milk powder is off to China for use in
dairy beverages. It’s a proud moment for the
whole team”, says Mr Gray. "To date we’ve
produced over 6 000 t, and our quality tests have
come back 100% first time.”The first month of
operation is all about testing the plant under a
range of operating conditions and ensuring a
smooth transition between our contractors and the
operations team. We’re happy with the progress”,
he says. "At peak, our milk tankers deliver 2.2
mio litres of milk to Darfield Drier 1 every day.
This is turned into whole milk powder at a rate of
15 t per hour. "Once the milk is processed into
powder, it is packed into 25 kg bags, placed on
pallets by a robot arm and then in containers and
onto Lyttleton port”.
From the outset, the Darfield team has maintained
an exceptional standard of health and safety and
product quality, says Mr Gray. "About 1 500
people have been involved in construction. By
working together with a proactive approach to
health and safety, we’ve achieved a big step up on
our safety performance”, he says. The site’s
operation team continues to work with key
contractors to ensure all design requirements are
met as the season heads towards its peak in
October. (voxy 24/9/2012)
Chinese contract causes Arinco expansion in Denmark In June Arla entered a ten-year contract with
Chinese food company Biostime to produce up to
20 000 t of Danish milk powder for the infant
formula market p.a. (Continued in next column)
Chinese contract causes Arinco expansion in Denmark (Contd)
Consequently, Arla is now looking to expand its
milk powder facility Arinco in Denmark. In June,
Biostime International Holdings Limited, which
sells high-quality products for the infant formula
and baby care sector in China, chose Arla to
supply milk powder produced from Danish milk.
The order is for about 20 000 t a year for the next
ten years and involves an investment of about 165
mio DKK to expand Arla’s Arinco milk powder
facility in Denmark, of which Biostime will
finance half. Arla’s Board of Directors has now
approved the investment in Arinco, and expansion
will be under way from as early as October.
“We expect that this increased production for the
Chinese market will create about 30 new jobs at
our facility between now and 2014. The
investment also means that we can introduce more
automated processes and thus make production at
Arinco even more efficient. So we will produce
more, and in a more efficient manner”, says
Mogens Bøgh Pedersen, Arinco site director.
Arla already exports very refined milk powder
and infant nutrition products to China and the
high quality of the Scandinavian products was one
of the main reasons that Arla was chosen as
supplier. “We are proud to supply the Chinese
market with our high-quality Scandinavian
products, which have an excellent food safety
record.
The agreement rubber-stamps Arla’s outstanding
skills in producing dairy products, and the
agreement is a good one for us because these
products are at the more profitable end of our
product range”, says Senior Vice President Frede
Juulsen, who is responsible for Arla’s business in
China and globally responsible for milk powder in
Arla.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 45
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Chinese contract causes Arinco expansion in Denmark (Contd)
The contract with Biostime came in the wake of
Arla’s strategic agreement with the leading
Chinese food company, COFCO, on joint
ownership of China’s largest dairy company,
Mengniu Dairy Group. The agreements are
intended to strengthen Arla’s presence and long-
term profitability in the Chinese market, which is
defines as a strategic growth market in the Arla
Group strategy. (globaldairy 27/9/2012)
Yili launches breakfast cheese
Yili Dairy (Huhhot, Inner Mongolia) [10] has
launched a series of what it refers to as breakfast
cheese. The range includes: plain, high calcium,
cheddar and low fat. (hcfood 27/9/2012)
The original news item does not specify how
breakfast cheese differs from regular cheese. We
presume it is regular cheese, marketed as a
Western lifestyle product.
Wantwant becomes dairy company
The most recent profit and loss account of
Wantwant, which has long been known as one of
China’s top candy producers, shows that dairy
products now contribute to more than half of the
company’s profit: 52.1%.
This makes Wantwant de facto a dairy company.
However, Wantwant’s main dairy products are
flavored milk which is also heavily sweetened in
China. In this respect, Wantwant’s image of
confectionary company still stands.
(tjkx 29/9/2012)
Nestlé launches nationwide health education programme for elderly people
Elderly people across China will be able to
receive free heart checks and health consultations
as part of a new nationwide education programme
launched by Nestlé. The company is working with
China’s Organizing Committee of the National
Community Care Campaign to raise awareness
among senior and middle-aged citizens about
conditions such as cardiovascular disease and of
the importance of a healthy diet and lifestyle. The
‘Elderly Care - Health Project’ will be rolled out
in 10 cities including Beijing, Shanghai,
Guangzhou, Changsha, Chengdu, and Nanjing in
the first phase starting this month. It will provide
heart checks and professional health consultations
to people in urban communities, as well as
lectures addressing some of the most important
health concerns of the country’s ageing
population. More than one mio households with
elderly members will also receive health
education brochures within the first year. The
programme eventually aims to reach a total of ten
mio households. (Nestle 19/9/2012)
Nestlé sees 20% growth in China
Nestlé said China sales will probably grow about
20% this year because of rising wages and
government efforts to boost local consumption.
The slowing growth of Asia's biggest economy
hasn't affected the local operations of the Vevey,
Switzerland-based Company, which has seen
expansion in most of its businesses, including
dairy products and coffee, Roland Decorvet, its
chairman in China, said on Thursday. Nestlé’s
China sales increased by more than 20% last year
and will grow by at least 10% in 2013, he said.
"There are a lot of initiatives done by the
government to promote the local economy,
domestic economy and local consumption”, said
Decorvet, who was attending the World
Economic Forum in Tianjin. "Wage inflation
means more purchasing power”. (cd 14/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 46
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Huiyuan reportedly in dire straits
After the Chinese government halted Coca Cola’s
acquisition of Huiyuan Fruit Juice (Beijing), the
company’s net profit has been decreasing and
recently it has even filed a loss. The Chinese fruit
juice industry in general is in a bad shape, with
fierce competition from multinational players.
However, insiders are also reporting management
problems within Huiyuan. (hcfood 4/9/2012)
Danone to be settled in Sichuan
On February 29th, Danone Asia-Pacific
Management Company and Qionglai People’s
Government (Qionglai, Sichuan) [11] signed an
agreement on the Qionglai investment project of
Danone Drink, which marks Danone Group, the
Europe’s third largest food group having many
international brands such as DANONE and
EVIAN as well as a Fortune Global 500
Company, has entered Qionglai.
It is reported that the project is located in the
Linqiong Industrial Park of Qionglai (Sichuan),
which will be engaged mainly in producing the
beverage Cube and potable water. The total
investment surpasses RMB 500 mio. The
construction will start in the first half of this year
with the first instalment of investment of RMB
215 mio, and be completed in 2013, and an annual
production capacity of 2.5 mio hls of beverage
will be formed then. (cei 11/9/2012)
PepsiCo funding 16 schools in 15 Chinese cities
Beverage and food giant PepsiCo Greater China
Region is financing Chinese schools in the
country's remote areas.
As of the end of 2011, PepsiCo had provided
funding for 16 schools in 15 Chinese cities,
including Beijing, Jinan, Chongqing, Nanchang,
Changchun, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen,
(Continued in next column)
PepsiCo funding 16 schools in 15 Chinese cities (Contd)
Tianjin, Xi'an, Nanjing, Heyuan, Wuhan,
Chengdu and Zhengzhou, benefiting 16 200
students in total, including 3500 PepsiCo Love
Scholarship beneficiaries.
Up to 2012, PepsiCo GCR had invested more than
RMB 4 mio in the aforementioned two education
programs, covering 26 schools of migrant
workers' children and rural schools in several
Chinese provinces and municipalities with
benefits shared by more than 20 000 primary and
secondary school students across the country. On
September 7, PepsiCo donated RMB 200 000 to
several outstanding students and teachers in
Beijing to help improve the educational
environment and boost the education development
of the local community. While providing
sustained funding for these education support
programs, PepsiCo Foundation and PepsiCo GCR
are also actively engaged in other public welfare
programs, including Mother Water Cellar, an 11-
year project aimed at providing safe drinking
water for regions suffering water shortages in
central and western China, charity campaigns
initiated by the associates of PepsiCo factories
and farms across the country that directly benefit
local communities and emergency assistance and
support offered by the company and associates in
the wake of natural disasters.
To date, public welfare donations made by
PepsiCo Foundation, PepsiCo GCR and PepsiCo
associates in China have already exceeded RMB
75 mio. PepsiCo Greater China Region built a
new library in Wulanhua town No 6 Primary
School in Siziwang Banner, Inner Mongolia,
which opened this month. It confirmed the
company's pledge to generate healthy financial
returns while giving back to the communities that
it serves. The new library, under the PepsiCo
Library program, gives the school access to
computers, book shelves, book cabinets, desks
and chairs and other learning facilities.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 47
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
PepsiCo funding 16 schools in 15 Chinese cities (Contd)
PepsiCo GCR has handed over more than 3 000
new books and its associates have donated more
than 1 000 to the library. The PepsiCo Library
program is part of PepsiCo's "Performance with
Purposes" strategy, which aims to profit from and
give back to communities.
Since its launch in 2007, the program has been
committed to building PepsiCo libraries for
schools in the countryside around PepsiCo farms,
donating books, desks, chairs and other library
facilities and offering scholarships for school
students.
To date, PepsiCo and its Greater China Region
associates have already invested nearly RMB 1.9
mio in this endeavor, building a total of 10
PepsiCo libraries in Inner Mongolia, Hebei,
Guangxi, Shandong, Guangdong, Hubei and
Gansu. More than 4 500 students have benefited.
"Siziwang Banner is a shining pearl on the Inner
Mongolia prairie with a time-honored history. I
feel deeply honored to be able to represent
PepsiCo here in declaring the inauguration of the
PepsiCo library and witnessing the small
contribution PepsiCo has made to the education
development on this Grand Prairie”, said Katty
Lam, president of PepsiCo GCR Foods OpCo.
Wulanhua town No 6 Primary School is the 10th
school sponsored by the PepsiCo Library
program. As the teachers and students began their
new semester, PepsiCo GCR specially organized
a volunteer campaign for its associates to get
personally involved in the public welfare
program.
During the volunteer campaign, PepsiCo
volunteers from across the country gathered at the
No 6 primary school to help with the set-up of the
library, joining reading games, holding "mini
Olympics" and other activities with the students
and teachers. (Continued in next column)
PepsiCo funding 16 schools in 15 Chinese cities (Contd)
The active participation of PepsiCo associates has
broadened the school curriculum and injected new
impetus to the teaching activities.
"PepsiCo is one of the most successful consumer
goods companies in the world. Its products are
known and liked by hundreds of mio of Chinese
consumers. On behalf of the teachers and students
of the school, I want to thank PepsiCo for the
support and assistance offered to us as we enter
this new semester”, said Wu Ying, principal of the
school.
"I also want to thank PepsiCo volunteers for their
efforts in improving our teaching curriculum and
enriching the extracurricular activities of the
students. I am confident that under the motivation
of PepsiCo, our students will make more
dedicated efforts and study even harder for the
prosperity of their homeland on this Grand
Prairie”.
In addition to the PepsiCo Library, the maker of
Pepsi Cola and 7up is sponsoring another
education support program for the children of
migrant workers called PepsiCo Better
Tomorrow. Since the start of the program in 2008,
PepsiCo has followed a region-by-region and
step-by-step approach to improve the education
environment of migrant workers' children by
offering scholarships, building libraries and
providing sports equipment and other material
support for their schools. (CD 17/9/2012)
Chef Kong divests from Weiquan
Chef Kong Holding has sold its 11.61% stake in
seasoning producer Weiquan to the latter’s mother
company Tinghsin Group. This is the second time
that Chef Kong has sold part of its holdings in
Weiquan. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 48
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Chef Kong divests from Weiquan (Contd)
Observers believe that Chef Kong is concentrating
its efforts on instant noodles and soft drinks,
markets with a relatively high profit margin.
(bjc 5/9/2012)
It is interesting to see that a top producer of
instant noodles sheds its stake in a major player
in the seasoning business, which includes
seasoning packs for instant noodle.
Maclean's targets international growth Scottish family-owned bakery Maclean's has
secured new investment that will enable the firm
to expand its international business and add 15
new staff to its team of 130.
The GBP 3 mio turnover Forres-based business
will invest GBP 365k in new equipment,
marketing and other tools to support its global
ambitions. Maclean's, which makes oatcakes,
shortbread, and sweet biscuits, is focusing on the
investment in the Far East and is already active in
China.
The firm also takes orders from Australia and the
United States and recently diversified its offer to
include gift and premium bakery products.
The new machinery, brand development and trade
fair attendance is all part of our growth plan
which will allow the company to expand as new
opportunities arise.
(Continued in next column)
Maclean's targets international growth (Contd)
"A key element of this is increasing our export
sales and developing new premium products”,
said Lewis Maclean' Maclean's managing
director. "This expansion in activity will put us in
a great position to explore further new markets as
well as introduce some new additions to our
range”. (ingredientsnetwork 30/8/2012)
DQY rules the roost in modern poultry industry
"If you enjoy eating an egg, why bother to find
the hen that laid it?" Such was the rejoinder
famously used by renowned Chinese writer Qian
Zhongshu to decline a journalist's interview. But
in the poultry business, it is not a superfluous
question. Domestic egg companies should have
inked codes on egg shells identifying farm and
production dates to guarantee quality and even
help trace an egg to its hen if need be, said Zhang
Xuan, marketing director of Beijing DQY
Agriculture Technology Co Ltd, the capital city's
leading organic egg producer.
Twelve years ago, when Chinese consumers were
still buying eggs in bulk without trademarks or
dates or standards, DQY became the first Chinese
company to produce and sell packaged, branded
eggs with expiry dates. "A product as small as a
screw has a standard, but for eggs, such an
important everyday food, there were no
production standards at that time”, Zhang said.
Things have only changed significantly following
DQY's pioneering efforts. In supermarkets across
the capital city, customers can easily find various
brands of packed eggs, but the ratio of such
products among all eggs in the market are still
less than 5%, Zhang said. "It is a 'blue ocean'
market”, said Zhang, referring to the open range
of opportunities available.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 49
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
DQY rules the roost in modern poultry industry (Contd)
He joined DQY six years ago with firm
expectations for the promising prospects of the
fast-growing industry. "The proportion of high-
standard eggs is estimated to increase by 7 to 10%
by 2015 and before 2050, it will reach 95%”.
Urban residents with their changing lifestyle
increasingly want fresh agricultural products, he
said, citing growing demand for clean, packaged
vegetables that are ready to cook. DQY now runs
a farm in Yanqing county of Beijing where it has
3 mio chickens and produces 1.6 mio eggs every
day. Due to capacity constraints, the majority of
eggs - about 80% - supply the Beijing market,
Zhang said.
DQY's advanced way of converting chicken
manure into biogas for power generation also
makes it stand out in the poultry industry. The
company's plant near its Beijing farm can now
generate 14 mio kwh electricity from the biogas.
It is part of the company's vision of the farm of
the future, Zhang said. Producing quality foods
while protecting the environment, which can be
realized by operating both a farm and an energy
company simultaneously, he said. "In the US new
farm projects won't be approved if they don't have
wholesome solutions for waste, and China will
certainly walk this road," Zhang said.
DQY has also started to export its technology in
bio energy overseas. Earlier this year, the
company inked a deal with American meat
supplier Smithfield Foods to jointly set up biofuel
plants to use waste from more than 20 mio pigs on
Smithfield's farms to generate electricity.
"We are basically a company built on
technology”, Zhang said, adding that it benefited
greatly from the science tradition and research
strength at the Zhongguancun Haidian Science
Park.
(Continued in next column)
DQY rules the roost in modern poultry industry (Contd)
As one of the enterprises in the park, DQY is
eligible for preferential human resource policies
that could make life easier for its backbone
employees. The company has also received strong
funding support from the park, Zhang said. He
added that DQY will go public in the next two to
three years and the park also offers consultancy in
related laws and policies to facilitate the process.
(CD 11/9/2012)
Origin Agritech inaugurates Xinjiang corn seed processing centre
Origin Agritech Limited ("Origin" or the
"Company"), a technology-focused supplier of
hybrid and genetically modified crop seeds in
China, today announced that Xinjiang Origin, a
subsidiary of Origin Agritech, held an opening
ceremony for its regional facility at Bole
(Xinjiang) [13] on September 9, 2012.
Dr. Gengchen Han, Chairman and Chief
Executive Officer and Dr. James Chen, Chief
Financial Officer of Origin hosted the ribbon-
cutting ceremony. Senior officials from the
Ministry of Agriculture as well as the Fifth
Agricultural Construction Division of Xinjiang
Production and Construction Corps attended the
event as honorary guests.
Established in June, 2011, Xinjiang Origin is a
joint venture seed company between Origin and
Xinjiang Jinbo Seed ("Jinbo"). Jinbo is a
prominent local seed company affiliated with the
Fifth Agricultural Construction Division of the
Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps.
Origin holds a 51% ownership stake of the
RMB100 mio registered capital investment and
retains the exclusive joint venture partnership
with Jinbo in Xinjiang.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 50
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Origin Agritech inaugurates Xinjiang corn seed processing centre (Contd) With a total investment of RMB170 mio, the
state-of-the-art facility will mainly produce,
process, package, and sell high-quality hybrid
corn seeds to the domestic Chinese market.
The joint venture will increase the Company's
total seed processing capacity and expand
marketing channels to distribute Origin's hybrid
products to the northwest region in China. The
Xinjiang Origin's facility, along with the seed
production land of the Fifth Agricultural
Construction Division, deploys modern
technologies and full mechanization throughout
the entire production process from land
preparation and seeding to product packaging.
The processing facility employs advanced corn
husker system, which is one of the largest corn
huskers in the world. The production base uses
modern drip irrigation systems and advanced
farming equipment for corn seed production.
Dr. Gengchen Han, Chairman and CEO of Origin,
commented, "Xinjiang Origin not only addresses
the increasing demand for our superior hybrid
seed products, but diversifies our cost structure
and production base, and expands our sales
channels into a new market. With our new
management team, leaner corporate structure and
the new facility, we are now poised for the next
stage of growth”.
"We are excited to work with Jinbo. By
integrating our local partner's advantages in
natural resources and operational experience with
our robust research capability, quality
management and services, Origin's strategic
vision to build a world-class modern seed
processing centre is in the making”, Dr. Han
concluded. (originseed 12/9/2012)
Cargill finds a sweet spot in China
Cargill implements Hazard Analysis Critical
Control Points systems in all plants across the
country to ensure food safety. Provided to China
Daily Diversified food demand keeps the growth
engine chugging for US Agribusiness Company
US agribusiness giant Cargill Inc is looking to
further expand its presence in China as the
country's demand for diversified food products
continues to be on the upswing. The multinational
company is looking to expand all lines of its
business in China, with particular emphases on
animal protein, animal nutrition, food ingredients
and health-promotion businesses.
The company is also building a new USD 67 mio
high fructose plant in Luohe, a city in Central
China's Henan province. Slated for completion by
June 2013, the new project will help Cargill
provide better services to its customers in China.
Cargill posted lower earnings of USD 1.17 bio
from its continuing operations across the globe
during fiscal 2012, which ended on May 31 this
year. In contrast, the company has posted record
earnings of USD 2.69 bio during the same period
in 2011. Though not in line with its expectations,
the fiscal 2012 performance was still one of its
better years for earnings and ninth in the
company's history. Revenues for the period were
USD 133.9 bio, up 12% from a year ago.
The food-ingredient business posted a third
consecutive year of record earnings in fiscal 2012.
The company invested over USD 4 bio to support
its customers and on global growth plans,
including acquisitions, joint ventures, and new or
expanded facilities.
Robert Aspell, president of Cargill Investment
(China) Ltd, says a significant amount of Cargill's
global capital expenditure was focused on China
as the nation had an integral role to play in the
company's overall growth plans.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 51
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Cargill finds a sweet spot in China (Contd)
"Rising incomes and accelerating urbanization in
China are driving demand for more diversified
and convenient diets.
Higher income has also increased the
consumption of meat proteins and vegetable oils.
Cargill still sees the upside on the daily caloric
intake of consumers in China, especially on
proteins”, Aspell says. "Packaged foods and
beverage companies are also expected to reap
robust returns from China”.
To feed a population of more than a 1.3 bio, more
agricultural products are now produced and sold
in China than anywhere else, and this has boosted
the overall food consumption in China during the
past 10 years. China, India and Brazil have all
become fast growing markets for international
agricultural product marketers and producers from
the US and Europe.
In 2011, China imported USD 95 billion worth of
agricultural products, compared with just USD 12
bio in 2001. The 2011 figures also represented a
30% year-on-year growth, according to the
Agriculture Ministry.
Ding Shengjun, a food supply and security
researcher at the Academy of State
Administration of Grain, says processed foods
such as canned foods, especially those related
with cooking and restaurants, have grown fast in
China. "The demand for juices, soft drinks, yogurt
and milk will provide all sorts of opportunities for
the food and ingredient business. The sector has
been showing excellent potential”, Ding says.
According to the National Bureau of Statistics, in
recent years the average person in China has been
consuming 5% more meat, 10% more milk, and
8% more cooking oil than five years ago.
(Continued in next column)
Cargill finds a sweet spot in China (Contd)
Affected by the global economic environment,
extreme climate and unstable international food
prices, Cargill saw lower margins from its
oilseed-processing and beef-processing businesses
in fiscal 2012. Aspell says that Cargill views the
current economic slowdown in China as "a bump
on the road".
"Cargill believes that China will continue to be a
sweet spot for investment. During our interactions
with food, feed and meat companies, our main
customers, we realized that all of them anticipate
explosive growth in China.
We plan to grow side by side with them”. At the
same time, Aspell says this is also good news
from a consumer perspective as it means
"responsible companies making serious
investments to produce affordable and safe food
in China".
Cargill entered China in 1972, and has since
ventured into different products ranging from
animal proteins and grains to oilseeds. Cargill
(China) currently has more than 7 000 employees
and 52 plants across the country.
The company has partnered with the World
Wildlife Fund to train 25 000 corn farmers in
China by the end of 2014. Its goal is to improve
yields by 20%, reduce waste by 10 to 15%,
conserve water and reduce its overall
environmental impact, including its carbon
footprint, through fertilizer optimization. Ten
demonstrations farms are currently underway in
Northeast China's Jilin province. For new growth
drivers, Aspell says the most obvious is the
modernization of livestock and the food supply
chain, which is a big area in which there are lots
of investments.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 52
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Cargill finds a sweet spot in China (Contd)
Cargill has also made significant long-term
investments in China's agriculture supply chain
such as oilseeds processing, animal feeds, refined
oil, fully integrated poultry business, starch and
sweetener business, food specialty and health
promotion products. In 2011, Cargill launched a
fully integrated project covering each part of the
poultry supply chain in East China's Anhui
province to minimize food disruption, from feed
production, chicken breeding, raising, hatching,
slaughtering and processing.
Aspell says the company will continue to
introduce new technologies in food safety, poultry
rising, animal nutrition, disease prevention,
environmental protection and energy savings. The
total investment in the project is expected to be
around USD 200 mio.
According to Aspell, China has more or less
progressed in the right direction when it comes to
improving agricultural production capacity and
quality. On the grain production side, the county's
overall output has grown substantially since 2005.
Corn production alone has seen a 40% increase
since 2005. The better yields have led to higher
rural incomes and stable food production.
"At Cargill, we believe that to meet the growing
global food needs, one of the key essentials is an
open global market where countries grow what
they are really good at, export their surpluses and
buy what others can produce more efficiently”, he
says. "China's entrance into the WTO was a
critical step that ensured that China could use the
global food system efficiently to fill in the gaps in
its overall supply”.
"We would like to see responsible investments in
terms of investing in the right parts of the supply
chain.
(Continued in next column)
Cargill finds a sweet spot in China (Contd)
Too often we see too much money move into
parts of the supply chain that already have more
than sufficient capacity. We see this in many
industries in China”. In addition to agricultural
investments, Cargill is also working with its key
customers to deliver innovation in areas like
nutrition, new menu item, and risk-management
solutions. These innovations will help to bring
increased menu and product diversity, while
ensuring a sustainable source of food at a fair
value. Food consumption is normally a good
indicator of the economy and the population size.
In China, food consumption is rising and so are
the types of food that people are eating. Foods
have become more sophisticated and people now
look more for convenience, Aspell says.
Ding from the Academy of State Administration
of Grain says foreign food traders and their
investment in China's agriculture business can
help the nation ease the pressure on natural
resources and ensure the country's food supplies,
because they are proficient in the international
food trade, green agricultural technologies and
producing food with better quality.
"The participation of foreign food companies and
growing demand for agricultural products in
China have brought more choices to consumers,
as they have better and more options to pick
products that they think are cheaper, safer and
better in taste”, Ding says. (cd 14/9/2012)
Kellogg Company and Wilmar International announce China joint venture
Kellogg Company (K) and Wilmar International
Limited (SGX:WIL) today announced a 50:50
joint venture between Kellogg and Wilmar for the
manufacture, sale and distribution of cereal,
wholesome snacks and savory snacks in China.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 53
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Kellogg Company and Wilmar International announce China joint venture (Contd)
Wilmar's wholly-owned subsidiary in China,
Yihai Kerry Investments Co., Ltd, will participate
in the joint venture. Wilmar will contribute
infrastructure, supply chain scale, an extensive
sales and distribution network in China, as well as
local China market expertise to the joint venture.
Kellogg will contribute a portfolio of globally
recognized brands and products, along with deep
cereal and snacks category expertise. The Joint
Venture will use the Kellogg's® and Pringles®
brands. Together, Kellogg and Wilmar will
leverage this complementary expertise to
maximize marketing and manufacturing
synergies.
China is expected to become the largest food and
beverage market globally within the next five
years, driven both by the growth of a middle class
consumer base in large cities and an increased
desire for a wide range of packaged and branded
foods. Cereal consumption is currently being
driven by rapid growth in milk consumption,
along with consumers' desire for healthy and
convenient breakfast foods. Snack foods also
represent a very large growth opportunity.
"China's snack-food market alone is expected to
reach an estimated USD 12 bio by year-end, up 44
% from 2008”, said John Bryant, Kellogg
Company's president and chief executive officer.
"To capture this growth, we will leverage the key
strengths Kellogg and Wilmar bring to the
partnership – the globally recognized Kellogg's®
and Pringles® brands and deep category
knowledge; scale and local market experience;
and our mutual commitment to consumer-focused
innovation”.
"This joint venture positions our China business
for growth and fundamentally changes our game
in China. Our organizations have developed a
strong working relationship and trust.
(Continued in next column)
I am pleased to be working together with Kuok
Khoon Hong and his talented team, and have
every confidence that our partnership will be a
long-term success”, concluded Bryant.
Kellogg Company and Wilmar International announce China joint venture (Contd)
I am pleased to be working together with Kuok
Khoon Hong and his talented team, and have
every confidence that our partnership will be a
long-term success”, concluded Bryant.
Wilmar's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer,
Kuok Khoon Hong, added, "This joint venture
with Kellogg will complement our existing
Consumer Product business and leverage on our
extensive distribution network and support
infrastructure in China. With our joint strength
and shared vision, I am confident that we will be
able to develop a leading cereal and snacks
business together”. The joint venture company
will be headquartered in Shanghai, China.
Launch of the joint venture is subject to
customary conditions, including regulatory
approvals by the Chinese government and anti-
trust approvals. (yahoofinance 24/9/2012)
KFC vows to pursue expansion in smaller markets KFC Corp, the largest foreign fast-food chain in
China, said it will accelerate its expansion in
smaller cities despite the global economic
slowdown. "KFC will open more than 500
restaurants each year in the future, compared with
400 annually over the past two years”, said Mark
Chu, president and chief operating officer of Yum
Brands' China Division. "In addition to the first-
and second-tier cities, there is broader room for
development in the fourth- and fifth-tier cities”.
Earlier this year, KFC's parent company, Yum
Brands, signed an agreement with Suning
Appliance Co Ltd in which Yum agreed to open
150 restaurants, including KFCs and Pizza Huts,
in Suning stores over the next five years.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 54
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Company News
Traditional News
KFC vows to pursue expansion in smaller markets (Contd)
KFC entered the Chinese mainland market in
1987. It had 400 restaurants in 2000. Four years
later, the figure had jumped to 1 000, and it went
to 3 000 restaurants in 2010. It now has 4 000
restaurants across the mainland.
"KFC's system and management model have
provided the best possible way to ensure each
KFC restaurant has the same quality. Even
though the economic environment has brought
considerable pressure, KFC has maintained
growth momentum”, Chu said.
KFC's biggest rival, McDonald's Corp, the
world's biggest restaurant chain, said it plans to
open 225 to 250 outlets in China this year, after
promising last year to increase its investment by
50%. McDonald's, which entered the Chinese
mainland in 1990, has more than 1 500 stores on
the Chinese mainland. It aims to expand its China
network to more than 2 000 outlets by 2013.
According to Euromonitor International, Yum led
the market with a 40% share, compared with 16%
for McDonald's. "Many problems lie in the way
of the fast expansion of the catering industry”,
said Su Qiucheng, president of the China Cuisine
Association.
"These include the lack of specifications in the
supply of raw materials, the lack of standards for
kitchen jobs, the lack of logistics and distribution
outlets, fragile franchisee management, and vague
brand development strategies, which Western
fast-food giants have already established”, Su
said.
Guo Geping, president of the China Chain Store
and Franchise Association, added: "After putting
every aspect under good control, such as talent,
supply chain and quality control, chain-store
enterprises can see an explosive growth.
(Continued in next column)
KFC vows to pursue expansion in smaller markets (Contd)
Since the foundation has been set up, each store is
a training base for the enterprise. So, the bigger
the store numbers, the faster it develops”.
(cd 27/9/2012)
Top soy sauce producers 2012
According to the China Top Brands Net, the top
soy sauce producers of this moment are:
Rank Brand Region
1 Haitian Guangdong
2 Jiajia Hunan
3 Lee Kum Kee Guangdong
4 Chubang Guangdong
5 Pearl River Bridge Guangdong
6 Jinshi Beijing
7 Zhenji Hebei
8 Xifu Shandong
9 Xinhe Shandong
10 Donggu Guangdong
This list is not simply compiled on the basis of
one particular indicator like turnover or volume,
but on a mix of traits, including brand awareness.
(ctc 26/9/2012)
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 55
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Traditional News
Top soy sauce producers 2012 (Contd)
Soy sauce production
According to insiders, China produced 4.41 mio t
of soy sauce, up 5.96% compared to the same
period of 2011. Guangdong remains the top
region with a volume of 1.892 mio t, or 42.9% of
the national volume. Guangdong’s growth also
exceeded the national figure: 16.32%.
(cti29/9/2012)
Over 30% of Chinese consume too much aluminium Over 30% of Chinese have too much aluminium
in their diets, according to a Friday report in
Health News, a newspaper run by the Ministry of
Health. Chen Junshi, a researcher with the
National Expert Committee for Food Safety Risk
Assessment, was quoted as saying that 32.5% of
Chinese consume an amount of aluminium that
exceeds the PTWI (provisional tolerable weekly
intake) level. Chen said Thursday at an
international food safety risk assessment
symposium that aluminium-containing additives
are the major cause of the problem, as many
Chinese staple foods, such as noodles and
steamed buns, are made with additives that
contain aluminium. Chen said northern Chinese,
who tend eat noodles as a main dish for most
meals, have an average aluminium intake of
5.1 mg/kg of body weight, 2.6 times the amount
recommended by the World Health Organization.
(Continued in next column)
Over 30% of Chinese consume too much aluminium (Contd)
High aluminium intake is believed to be harmful
to the central nervous system. It is known to have
an effect on the development of children's nervous
systems, which can affect their mental
development. Chen said curbing the use of
containing-containing additives is the key to
solving the problem. (cd 28/9/2012)
Alum is still often used in producing such
traditional products as fried dough sticks
(youtiao). The reason why this is now emerging as
a problem is that while such products used to be
prepared and consumed at home, Chinese city
dwellers now prefer to buy from street vendors.
These use additives like alum to speed up the
process, while preserving the texture the
consumers are used to.
Delicacy is no longer a piece of cake
It is no longer a case of the longer the shelf life the
higher the price. That was true of moon cakes
until last year. Rules have changed, so have
perceptions. The norm this year is, the shorter the
shelf life the higher the price. Some supermarkets
are even promoting their products through slogans
such as "our moon cakes go off soon”.
The new Food Additives Usage Standards
implemented last year banned 27 food additives.
The new rules allow the use of only 10 kinds of
milder additives in moon cakes. More importantly,
they stipulate the ceilings for the use of additives.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 56
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Traditional News
Delicacy is no longer a piece of cake (Contd)
As a result, the shelf life of moon cakes,
representative of Mid-Autumn Festival, has been
reduced from 120 to 60 days this year.
Moon cakes with a shorter shelf life should be
good news for consumers. A woman in
Chongqing, for example, reportedly found a dust-
covered packet of moon cakes in her storeroom
last year. Their tender crust and fillings looked no
different from the fresh ones. The only difference
was they were made in 2003, which means moon
cakes with stronger additives can actually be
stored and sold a year or two later with consumers
tasting little or no difference.
But consumers have reason to believe that even
the new regulation cannot ensure all moon cakes
are safe to eat, especially the ones with longer
shelf lives. Now it is up to the food safety
authorities to explain to consumers how harmful
an additive is to people's health so as to raise their
awareness.
This is important because food producers give the
scientific names of the additives they use and
people have no idea how harmful they are. In
previous years, the shelf lives of moon cakes
depended on the amount of additives used. There
is no specific regulation on quality guarantee
periods for moon cakes with different fillings. For
example, many moon cakes with fruit fillings -
from coconut to lotus seeds - are actually stuffed
with pureed wax gourd with additives of different
fruit flavors, because bakeries have found that
wax gourd is not only cheap and easy to preserve,
but also mixes well with different food additives.
Such fraudulent practices, a by-product of
outdated standards and slack supervision, have
continued for long. So despite the list of additives
and limits of their use, the shelf lives of some
moon cakes can be long enough to harm people's
health. (Continued in next column)
Delicacy is no longer a piece of cake (Contd)
Until now, the authorities have relied on random
checks to supervise moon cake makers and ensure
that they abide by the new standards. But that is not
enough to solve the problem.
Some bakeries and dealers recycle the moon cakes
that were made years ago. These moon cakes taste
no different from the fresh ones, because of their
sugar and fat content. Eating such moon cakes with
high doses of food additives may not cause
immediate discomfort. Yet they can be toxic.
About 280 000 t of moon cakes were produced in
China last year. Hence, food safety authorities
should take stronger measures to protect
consumers' health and regulate the moon cake
industry. They must chalk out and enforce more
detailed and well-targeted rules for the use of food
additives, and carry out more frequent and
intensive checks.
Since moon cakes are made in several stages and
require many ingredients that are bought from
different sources, the food safety inspections
should not be limited to only bakeries.
Companies and individuals that supply the fillings
and other ingredients should also come under the
purview of food safety checks. In fact, each link in
the production chain has to be monitored and
supervised.
The new standards have brought about some
positive changes. But the moon cake sector's
problems have developed over the years and cannot
be solved overnight. If effective supervision is
carried out, the new rules could cause a real change
in the moon cake sector. And the change would be
conducive to promoting a healthy market and
weeding out unscrupulous moon cake makers,
which will benefit consumers and enterprises both.
(cd 28/9/2012) (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 57
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Traditional News
Focus Topic
Delicacy is no longer a piece of cake (Contd)
Shocking trials
A piece of shocking news released during the
period covered by this issue. However, although it
attracted intense media attention for a short
period, it also disappeared from the media very
quickly.
As people in China lost their job, it seems that the
accusations were more or less true, but
apparently it was regarded as so embarrassing,
that the government preferred to handle it soon
and then close the door. We have collated a few
items from sources in and outside China for our
readers to compare.
Chinese children used in US-backed GE food trial
How would you feel if I told you that a group of
scientists had come to the United States, and fed a
group of 24 children aged between six and eight
years of age a potentially dangerous product that
had yet to be tested on animals?
(Continued in next column)
Shocking trials (Contd)
What if I told you that state authorities had come
out publically with clear directives against this very
experiment, and yet the experiment had continued
regardless? You'd be pretty outraged, right?
Well, this is what we believe is happening, except
that it is happening on Chinese soil and on Chinese
children (and I hope you've managed to maintain
that outrage). We discovered this in The American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition that published a study
backed by the US Department of Agriculture
(USDA) and that involved feeding genetically
engineered (GE) Golden Rice to a group of 24 boys
and girls in Hunan province, China, aged between
six and eight years old. It was actually back in
2008 that we first heard of this experiment and
immediately informed the Chinese Ministry of
Agriculture. The Ministry came back and assured
us no Golden Rice had been imported and the trial
had been stopped – something that unfortunately
appears not to be the case.
Gambling with the health of these 24 children isn't
the only travesty here. From the bigger picture
we're also seeing a huge amount of time, energy
and talent being wasted on what is essentially yet
another example of big business hustling in of one
the world's most sacred things: our food supply.
The study hopes to propose that this genetically
engineered rice is a solution to vitamin A
deficiency among malnourished child populations.
Fact is, we don't need this "silver bullet" rice,
because: (1) we have a solution – it is called
overcoming poverty and accessing a more diverse
diet; and (2) like so many silver bullets it is going
to cause more trouble and potential harm than
existing solutions.
Here are some of the big "cons" behind this so-
called magic rice, according to our food and
agriculture team:
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 58
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Focus Topic
Shocking trials (Contd)
By promoting GE rice you encourage a diet based
on one staple rather than an increase in access to
the many vitamin-rich food plants. These plants
would address a wide variety of micronutrient
deficiencies, not just vitamin A deficiency
(VAD). We simply do not know if GE crops,
including GE rice, are safe for human or animal
consumption. GE crops certainly have the
potential to cause allergenic reactions. The majori
ty of patents for genetically engineered plants are
held by a few large multinational companies. So it
is in their financial interest – and not ours, the
public – to get us hooked on their seed.
After 20 years of development, this not so-Golden
Rice is still just a shadowy research project with
no applications for commercialization anywhere
in the world. Tens of mio of dollars have been
spent on what is a smoke and mirrors product, and
that could have been better spent on programs that
have actually proven to make a lasting and
meaningful difference: programs that combine
supplementation with home gardening in order to
give the poverty-stricken access to a more diverse
diet (something that has been successful in
Bangladesh). The battle to keep GE rice out of
China has been a long, seven year struggle, and
clearly it is not over yet. (Greenpeace 31/8/2012)
Hunan denies kids used in GM food test
Authorities in Hunan province on Saturday denied
that children in a rural school were guinea pigs in
a US research project on the effects of genetically
modified rice. A research paper involving 68
Chinese primary-school children in the province
was published by the American Journal of
Clinical Nutrition on August 1, with Guangwen
Tang at Tufts University in the US named as the
lead author.
(Continued in next column)
Hunan denies kids used in GM food test (Contd)
The unapproved experimental GM rice, widely
referred to as "golden rice" and genetically
engineered to produce provitamin A, was created
by Ingo Potrykus at the Institute of Plant Sciences
in the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology and
Peter Beyer at the University of Freiburg more than
10 years ago.
Chen Peihou, deputy director of the Hunan Centre
for Disease Control and Prevention, confirmed that
the second author of the paper, listed as Hu
Yuming, is a researcher for the centre. "I was
aware of the project in Hengyang in 2008, which
involved children and was mainly testing for beta-
carotene bioavailability and bioconversion to
retinol”, or vitamin A, Chen said Sunday. "But as
far as I know, no GM rice was used, and all the
food involved was locally produced”. He also said
that Hu was not asked by the journal to sign the
paper before its publication.
"In the project, we just provided the site and
assistance to the Chinese Centre for Disease
Control and Prevention, and we have not dealt with
any US institution”, he added.
According to Chen, Yin Shi'an, listed in the paper
as the third author, is with the China CDC. Wang
Lin, information director of the China CDC,
declined to comment. Chen said his centre will
continue its investigation and contact the journal
about the issue.
Andrea Grossman, a public-relations officer for
Tufts University's Human Nutrition Research
Centre on Aging, however, was quoted by Beijing
Youth Daily on Saturday as saying that the month
long research on golden rice was approved by
authorities in both countries after an examination
by ethics committees.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 59
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Focus Topic
Hunan denies kids used in GM food test (Contd)
Feeding trials with human adults in China have
also been carried out to measure the effect of fat
in the diet, on bioconversion and bioavailability,
according to the Golden Rice Project website, the
official golden-rice homepage supported by the
Rockefeller Foundation. On Thursday,
Greenpeace, the international environmental
campaign group, reported the study, backed by
the US Department of Agriculture, which
involved feeding golden rice to 6- to 8-year-old
children in Hunan.
The study, assigned to the Hunan CDC by the
China CDC in 2008, selected 68 primary-school
children in a school in Hankou township of
Hengyang city. According to the Hunan CDC, the
study was listed as on the Program of National
Natural Science Foundation of China. After the
discovery was posted on Sina Weibo, a Chinese
micro-blogging website, the news received
massive attention online.
After an investigation, the publicity department of
Hengyang said on Saturday that there had been no
such research project on golden rice. It said on its
micro blog there was instead a study on the
transformation of carotene in vegetables to
vitamin A in children's bodies.
According to Chen Peihou, all results were
submitted to the China CDC immediately after the
experiment ended, and no paper on that has been
published within the country. Worldwide, debates
on long-term safety for GM food continue.
In China, the Ministry of Agriculture in 2009
issued biosafety certificates to two strains of pest-
resistant genetically modified rice and corn in
what was considered a major development in
promoting the research and planting of GM crops.
(Continued in next column)
Hunan denies kids used in GM food test (Contd)
The strains still need registration and production
trial - which will take three to five years - before
commercial planting could begin, according to the
ministry. The certificates triggered concern among
the public and professionals since there is still no
consensus on whether GM food is harmful to
humans. As early as 2001, the State Council
introduced a regulation to ensure the safety of GM
food, with strict provisions of its research, testing,
production and marketing.
At present, the only three kinds of GM food crops
that have been approved for commercial planting in
China are sweet peppers, tomatoes and papayas,
Shi Yanquan, an official at the ministry, was
quoted as saying by china.com.cn during an online
interview in April.
Also, the country has imported other GM crops,
including soybean, corn and rape, from overseas
market to satisfy domestic need. For instance,
China imported more than 50 mio t of GM
soybeans in 2011, most of which were processed to
edible oil, he said. "The country has launched strict
transgenic safety and quality assessment system to
ensure GM food in the market is as safe as
conventional food”, he added. Yang Xiaoguang, a
researcher at China CDC, was quoted in April as
saying: "So far, we have received no report to show
any GM food on the market is harmful to human
health. GM food that consumers purchase from the
market is safe to eat”. (cd 9/3/2012)
Scientists decry rice experiment on children
US scientists have denounced a 2008 nutrition
research project that allegedly fed genetically
modified rice to a group of Chinese primary school
students. (Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 60
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Focus Topic
Scientists decry rice experiment on children (Contd)
The study involving 68 Chinese children aged 6
to 8 has generated public anxiety about potential
harm to the children and controversy over ethics
and rules. The study's lead author Tang
Guangwen of Tufts University in Boston,
Massachusetts, published a report on August 1 in
the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
showing that 100-150 g of so-called golden rice
could provide 60% of the daily intake of
Vitamin A.
However, the three listed authors from the
university's Chinese partners, Hu Yuming, Yin
Shi'an and Wang Yin, all denied the use of
golden rice in the study in Hengyang, Hunan
province. Dave R. Schubert, professor and
laboratory head of the Salk Institute for
Biological Studies in San Diego, California, said
the test was done among Chinese children "most
likely because they could not pass the review
process required for doing this type of clinical
trial in the US".
Schubert was among the 22 scientists from all
over the world who wrote an open letter to
caution Tufts' research on golden rice in 2009.
He said this kind of experiment "should not have
been done unless there was extensive safety
testing of the rice". According to a report
commissioned by non-profit organization
Foodwatch in Germany, a sample of the golden
rice grains was sent to Germany in 2001 for a
feeding trial with mice. But when the grains
were tested for carotenoid content, the scientists
were "surprised to find it contained less than 1%
of the amount expected". After the rice was
cooked, this was reduced another 50%, so the
trial was abandoned. Schubert also said there
was clearly "potential for harm in the children"
when feeding them the rice. "Since there has
been no animal or human safety testing of the
golden rice, I believe that it was exceptionally
foolish to feed this golden rice to children”.
(Continued in next column)
Scientists decry rice experiment on children (Contd)
"Their brains are still developing and it is well
known that molecules related to those made by
golden rice can be harmful”, Schubert said. "There
should have been some good safety testing before
doing the experiment, but as far as I know, there
was not”, he added.
The 2009 letter also expressed concerns that such
testing is against the Nuremberg Code a set of
research ethics for human experimentation set as a
result of the Subsequent Nuremberg Trials at the
end of World War II. The code states that children
under 10 are not legally capable of giving consent
to participate in experiments.
Marion Nestle, professor of nutrition, food studies
and public health at New York University, thinks
getting beta carotene from the rice is
"unnecessary". "Plenty of sources of beta carotene
are available in fruits and vegetables without
having to go to genetically modified rice”, Nestle
said.
Nestle added that research rules in the US require
human subjects to give informed consent to being
experimented on. Neither Tang nor a spokesperson
from Tufts University could be reached for
comments. Last week, Greenpeace issued a
statement in response to the report's findings.
Fang Lifeng, sustainable agriculture campaigner at
Greenpeace East Asia, said it is "incredibly
disturbing to think that an American research body
used Chinese children as guinea pigs for
genetically engineered food, despite a clear
directive against this very experiment issued by
Chinese authorities in 2008”.
Greenpeace East Asia first heard of this experiment
in 2008 and immediately informed the Chinese
Ministry of Agriculture.
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 61
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Focus Topic
Scientists decry rice experiment on children (Contd)
"Research and development of a new generation
of GM crops like golden rice, which can function
to improve consumers' nutrition, is now a global
trend in agriculture”, said Huang Dafang, a
member of the biosafety committee in charge of
agricultural GM organisms, which is affiliated
with the Ministry of Agriculture. But he also
expressed confusion about regulations and
procedures of such a trial in Hengyang if it indeed
involved GM golden rice. It might be a regulatory
loophole for such GM crops to enter the nation in
the name of a scientific research, he said.
(cd 6/9/2012)
GM rice test researcher suspended from work A Chinese researcher involved in the
controversial testing of genetically modified
(GM) rice has been suspended from his work and
put under investigation, the Chinese Centre for
Disease Control and Prevention (China CDC)
reported on Monday evening.
China CDC, under orders from the Ministry of
Health, is investigating whether dozens of
children in central China's Hunan province were
used in 2008 as test subjects in a US-China joint
research project that included GM food Golden
Rice.
Greenpeace broke the news on the controversial
test in late August, saying that the joint research
involved feeding Golden Rice, which is
genetically modified to be rich in beta carotene, to
24 children aged between six and eight years old
in Hunan.
It cited a paper published in the August edition of
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. The
paper claimed that Golden Rice is effective in
providing vitamin A to kids.
(Continued in next column)
GM rice test researcher suspended from work (Contd)
China CDC reported the latest progress of the
investigation, saying its fellow researcher Yin
Shi'an, the third author of the paper, was
inconsistent in his accounts during the
investigation. As a result, China CDC has
suspended his work and put him under further
investigation.
Also according to China CDC, none of its affiliate
institutes had ever approved or participated in the
research of Golden Rice. The paper has not been
submitted to the Ministry of Health for ethic
examination or approval.
Its lead author, Tang Guangwen, director of the
Carotenoid and Health Laboratory of Tufts
University in the United States, insisted that the
study had been conducted with all regulatory
approval required by each country.
China CDC stated that its scientific review
committee had asked Tang to provide supporting
materials and a detailed report of the research, and
also asked Tufts University to investigate the
matter and offer a detailed report. GM food is
controversial, as there is still no consensus on
whether or not it is harmful to the human body.
According to the Greenpeace website, it is simply
not known whether genetically engineered crops
are safe for human or animal consumption.
Independent scientific studies on the matter are
severely lacking, it said. (cd 11/9/2012)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 62
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Upcoming Events
Upcoming events
2012 Autumn China (Guangzhou) Int’l Wine
& Spirits Trade Fair
2012 China (Guangzhou) Int’l Food Impex
Trade Fair
2012 China (Guangzhou) Int’l Food Processing
& Packaging Equipment Exhibition.
2012 China Int’l TCM Health Foods
Trade Fair
Location: Canton Fair Bazhou Hall
Dates: Nov. 1 - 3
Telephone: 020-85509129 020-85518106
Fax: 38109210
Email: [email protected]
4th China International Capsicum Industry
Expo 2012
Location: Changsha Hongxing Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Nov. 1 - 3
Telephone: 0731-89781005
Fax: 84148719
Email: [email protected]
17th
China Int’l Fishery Trade Fair
Location: Dalian World Expo
Dates: Nov. 6 - 8
Telephone: 010-59194697
Fax: 65918986
Email: [email protected]
(Continued in next column
Upcoming events (Contd)
2012 China Int’l Fruit & Vegetables Processing
& Trading Expo
Location: Beijing Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Nov. 9 - 11
Telephone: 010- 88102255、88102346
Fax: 88102269
Email: [email protected], [email protected]
2012 Shanghai Int’l Food, Beverage and
Catering Exhibition
Interwine China 2012
Location: Shanghai Intex
Dates: Nov. 16 - 18
Telephone: 021-6209 5209*31
Fax: 6209 5210
Email: [email protected]
2012 6th
China (Shandong) Int’l Food Fair.
Location: Ji’nan Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Nov. 15 - 18
Telephone: 0531-82611560
Fax: n.a.
Email: [email protected]
2012 FruVEg Expo
Location: Shanghai World Expo
Dates: Nov. 15 - 17
Telephone: 021-60909581
Fax: 60909591
Email: [email protected]
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 63
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Upcoming Events
Upcoming events (Contd)
2012 9th
China (Beijing) Int’l Nutrition &
Health Products Exhibition
2012 9th
Beijing Int’l Organic & Eco Food
Exhibition
2012 9th
China (Beijing) Edible & Olive Oil
Fair
Location: Old Beijing Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Nov. 21 - 23
Telephone: 010- 59574362、2697 - 809
Fax: 58850889
Email: [email protected]
2012 Cina (Zhejiang) Int’l Food & Beverage
Exhibition
Location: Hangzhou World Trade Centre
Dates: Nov. 22 - 24
Telephone: 0571-89738372/89738388
Fax: 89738368
Email: [email protected]
Shanghai International Import and Export
Food Exhibition 2012
Location: Shanghai Intex
Dates: Nov. 28 - 30
Telephone: 021-31276884
Fax: 50131761
Email: [email protected]
(Continued in next column)
Upcoming events (Contd)
2012 10th
Shanghai Int’l Wine & Spirits
Exhibition
FBIE CHINA 2012
Location: Shanghai Intex
Dates: Nov. 28 - 30
Telephone: 021-31276818, 50131760
Fax: 50131761
Email: [email protected]
2012 Guangzhou Int’l Special Food &
Beverage Exhibition
Location: Poly World Trade Centre
Dates: Nov. 29 – Dec. 1
Telephone: 020-83276772
Fax: 83276765
Email: [email protected]
2012 China Int’l Wine & Distilled Exhibition
Location: Ji’nan Shungeng Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Nov. 30 – Dec. 2
Telephone: 0531-85598289
Fax: 85598289
Email: [email protected]
2012 Tianjin Int’l Nutritional Products
Exhibition
Location: Tianjin Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Dec. 6 - 8
Telephone: 022-23772599
Fax: 23772599
Email: [email protected]
(Continued on next page)
Sept/Oct 2012 www.giract.com Page | 64
ChinaNews FOOD & FOOD INGREDIENTS REVIEW
Upcoming Events
Upcoming events (Contd)
2012 7th Shanghai International Fisheries &
Seafood Exhibition
Location: Shanghai Everbright
Dates: Dec. 7 - 9
Telephone: 021-37821152
Fax: 37821409
Email: [email protected]
2012 China (Kunming) Pan Asia Food
Exhibition
Location: Kunmin Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Dec. 7 - 9
Telephone: 0871-3210411 3382003
Fax: 3164897
Email: [email protected]
2012 2nd
China (Wuhu) Rice Industry
Exhibition
Location: Wuhu Int’l Exhibition Centre
Dates: Dec. 8 -10
Telephone: 010-88115241
Fax: 51524897
Email: [email protected]
(Continued in next column)
Upcoming events (Contd)
10th
China (Tianjin) Ice Cream & Dairy Raw
Materials Exhibition
Location: 32 Youyi Rd, Tianjin
Dates: Oct. 18 - 20
Telephone: 022-283624482836246713752519366
Fax: 28362448,28362467
Email: [email protected]
2012 3rd
China (Chongqing) High End
Beverage & Wine Exhibition
Location: Chongqing
Dates: Dec. 21 - 23
Telephone: 023-86376000/86376228
Fax: 86376218
Email: [email protected]