Chapter 5 eng economics
Transcript of Chapter 5 eng economics
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
1/61
1 of 61
Sources ofFunds and Cost
of Capital
5
CHA
P
TE
R
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
2/61
2 of 61
CHAPTER 5 OUTLINE
5.1 Sources of funds
5.2 Debt and Equity: Long-term sources
5.3 Medium and short-term sources
5.4 Cost of Capital
5.5 Cost of individual sources
5.6 Capital structure
5.7 Weighted cost of all sources
5.8 Examples
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
3/61
3 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
3. Short-term Sources (temporary)Accounts Payable Bank Margin Account
2. Medium-term Sources (temporary) Leasing Term Debt (e.g. notes payable)
1. Long-term Sources (permanent)
DEBT Bonds Debentures Bank Loans
EQUITY Common Shares Preferred Shares
Retained Earnings
SOURCES OF FUNDS5.1
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
4/61
4 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Face Value
Coupon
Coupon Rate
7.75 %
Semi-annualpayment$968.75
MaturityDate
First coupon
5 August, 1993
Last coupon5 February, 1998
SOURCES OF FUNDS5.1
Bond
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
5/61
5 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Professor BilodeauMining EngineeringMcGill University
Number of shares
No Par Valueindicated
SOURCES OF FUNDS5.1
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
6/61
6 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
SOURCES OF FUNDS5.1
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
7/617 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Consists of borrowing funds by:
Issuing
Bonds, using specific assets as collateral Debentures, secured by good credit rating of company
Obtaining
Bank loan or mortgage, using specific assets as collateral
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Debt
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
8/618 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Issued privately or publicly (by investment brokers) Issuing expenses Characteristics
Face Value Nominal amount written on bond or debenture; representsprincipal, i.e. investment by purchaser, unless a discount was given
Maturity Date End of bond life, i.e. date at which Face Value becomesdue to owner
Coupon Rate Pre-established interest rate (nominal) paid on Face Value
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Bonds and Debentures
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
9/619 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Interest payments made by company are tax deductible, i.e. consideredan expense of carrying-out business; the after-tax cost is thereforelower than the actual coupon rate
Coupon rate depends on financial rating of company if potentialinvestors view company as risky, it will have to offer a higher coupon rate
and current market interest rate
Bonds and debentures are a relatively low risk type of investment
Interest must be paid
If company cannot service its debt payments, the principal becomes
due In case of bankruptcy, bondholders have priority over other creditors
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Bonds and Debentures
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
10/6110 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Maturity date
Interest and principal repayment schedule
Interest payments are tax deductible
Interest rate depends on rating of company
Bank has priority over all other creditors
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Bank Loans and Mortgages
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
11/6111 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Part of equity capital, but have particular characteristics setting them apartfrom common shares (e.g. no voting power in company management)
Issued privately or publicly (by investment brokers) Issuing expenses Characteristics
Face Value Nominal value written on certificate, also known as Parvalue
No Maturity Date Assumed to be issued indefinitely
Fixed Dividend
Paid on Face Value, specified as nominal rate; dividendis always payable
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Preferred Shares
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
12/6112 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Dividends are not tax deductible, i.e. not considered operating expenses;disbursement is therefore more costly to company
Dividend depends on financial rating of company and market interest rateat time of issue
Preferred shares allow the expansion of the companys equity baserequired for debt financing, without diluting the position of the common
shareholders
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Preferred Shares
f
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
13/6113 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Preferred shares are considered an intermediate risk type of investment
In case of bankruptcy, preferred shareholders recover theirinvestment after creditors, but before common shareholders.
The market price of preferred shares is much less volatile than thatof common shares, varies with current interest rates, and maydecrease if company is in difficulty
Dividends are always payable
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Preferred Shares
P f R J i E i i E
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
14/6114 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Nortel Preferred Shares
P f R J i E i i E
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
15/6115 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Ford Preferred Shares
P f R J i E i i E
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
16/6116 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Common shareholders are the owners of the company, and have access toall of the profits of the business, after preferred dividends have beendistributed.
Common shareholders elect the Board of Directors, vote in majordecisions, and examine and approve the companys books and financial
statements. Shareholder liability is restricted to the amount of money invested
Issued privately or publicly (by investment broker)
Issuing expenses
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Common Shares
P f R J i E i i E
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
17/61
17 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Characteristics
Par Value Nominal amount that may be written on certificate; this is theoriginal issue price
No Maturity Date Assumed to be issued indefinitely
Dividends may be variable, and are not necessarily paid; declared bymanagement and based on profits and company policy. Therefore, nofixed commitment from the company.
Dividends are not tax deductible; disbursement is therefore more costly tocompany
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Common Shares
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
18/61
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
19/61
19 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Market Pricea common sharesmarket price has very little relationshipwith its Parvalue. The market value reflects the companyseconomicperformance and success, and responds to the law of supply anddemand (and sometimes speculation!)
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Common Shares
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
20/61
20 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Bombardier Common Shares
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
21/61
21 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Ford Common Shares
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
22/61
22 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
That part of net income reinvested in the business, i.e. to finance newprojects within the company
Considered part of common equity financing
No fixed cost, like common shares
There is however an implicit opportunity cost, like that of commonshares
The sum of common dividends and retained earnings (i.e.earnings per share) must be maintained at a level such that itwill keep current shareholders satisfied, and attract potential
investors. If not, the market price of the shares will decreasebecause investors will loose interest and sell their shares, i.e.supply will exceed demand on the market place.
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Retained Earnings
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
23/61
23 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
A spot measure of the cost of common equity is the ratio EPS / P(earnings per share to market price*). Thus, for a business maintaining aconstant EPS, the cost of equity will increase if P decreases due to a
change in supply/demand conditions.
Retained earnings policy guided by:
Availability of new projects within the company Investment options available to individual shareholders Tax rate on dividends received by shareholders
* The reciprocal of the price to earnings ratio
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Retained Earnings
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
24/61
24 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
BondsThe nomenclature generally used for bonds is face value(price at which abond is normally sold, and amount received by bondholder when bond isredeemed at maturity) and market price(value at which a bond trades onthe market at a particular time in its life, a function of time to maturity,coupon rate and market rate). The interest payment is determined by
multiplying the face value by the coupon rate. The face value of a bondmay be referred to aspar value.
Common SharesThe par value of a common share in the context of the stock market isirrelevant. The par value represents the price at which a common share
was originally issued, and has no direct relation with the shares actualmarket price(the value at which the share is traded on the stock market).The common stock entry in the balance sheet represents the par value ofall outstanding common shares.
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Notes on Bond and Share Terminology
Professor R Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
25/61
25 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Preferred Shares
Thepar valueof preferred shares is important because it is used to calculatethe preferred dividend (the dividend rate times the par value). The preferredshare is originally issued at par, but its market price may vary below or abovepar as a function of prevailing market rates.
Net ProceedsThe net proceedsare relevant only when a firm issues new bonds or shares.They represents the net monetary amount that the firm receives after issuingexpenses have been paid to the stock broker responsible for the issue. Aswell, because of unexpected short-term changes in the market, a firm maybe forced in issuing bonds below par (i.e. at a discount). Thus, the net
proceeds to the firm are always lower than the prices at which the newsecurities are sold.
DEBT AND EQUITY: LONG TERM SOURCES5.2
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
26/61
26 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
Agreement whereby a financial institution purchases an asset and rents itto a business firm on a long-term basis. Thus, the institution owns theasset and the firm operates the asset.
The leasing expense is similar to a rental expense and is tax deductible
(usually beginning-of-period payments)
Operating costs are paid by the lessee
Maintenance costs may be paid either by the lessor or lessee, dependingon the contract terms (of course, the lease payments will reflect this)
MEDIUM AND SHORT-TERM SOURCES5.3
Medium-term Sources
Leases
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
27/61
27 of 61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
The advantage of a leasing arrangement is the lowering of debt and equityfrom the balance sheet, i.e., funds need not be raised to purchase the asset
The disadvantage is the higher annual fixed operating cost to the firm,leading to increased financial risk
Consists of one- to two-year loans from financial institutions
May be in the form of a revolving fund, i.e. line of credit, to finance short-term capital requirements
MEDIUM AND SHORT-TERM SOURCES5.3
Leasing
Term Debt
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
28/61
28 of 61
o esso Jass g ee g co o y
Many businesses offer discounts if their clients pay their bills within 10 daysof invoicing. Otherwise, the full amount is typically due within 30 days. If acompany does not take advantage of this discount, it has the use of theamount due for the extra period of time. This is usually a costly short-term
source of funds.
Bank account in which the balance can become negative, i.e. the bankextends credit to the account owner. In this case, interest is charged onthe balance. This type of account is useful to finance working capitalrequirements.
MEDIUM AND SHORT-TERM SOURCES5.3
Short-term Sources
Accounts Payable
Line of Credit
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
29/61
29 of 61
g g y
Borrow $1000 today Pay interest of $100 per year Repay principal 8 years later
$100
$1000
$1000
$1000 = $100 (P/A, i, 8) + $1000 (P/F, i, 8)The value of i that satisfies the equation below is the cost of money.
The value obtained for any N is 10 % because the interest rate paidon the loan is 10 %. This represents the cost associated withborrowing the $1000.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
0
PV=1000, PMT=-100, FV=-1000, N=8, CPT I/Y 10%
COST OF CAPITAL5.4
The Concept of the Cost of Money
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
30/61
30 of 61
g g y
A company obtains investment funds from various sources, each with itsparticular cost.
The cost of capital, i.e. the cost of these investment funds, is theweighted-average cost of the total amount of money obtained by thecompany from all permanent sources.
The particular mixture of debt and equity sources is referred to as capitalstructure. The capital structure is based on market values, not parvalues.
By convention, the cost of capital is stated as an effective annual interestrate.
The cost of capital can be determined for a companysexistingcapital orfor raising additionalcapital through the issue of new debt and/or equity.In the latter case, the result is a marginalcost of capital.
COST OF CAPITAL5.4
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
31/61
31 of 61
g g y
*Net Proceeds = Face Value - Issuing Expenses Discount in which thediscount is a reduction in price that may be offered by issuer to buyer dueto unforeseen short-term changes in the market.
Elements
Face value F
Net proceeds* NP (for new issue)
Market Price P (for existing debt)
Annual interest payment I (Coupon rate F)
Maturity n years
Cost of long-term debt capital Kd
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
32/61
32 of 61
g g y
I
NP
F
1 2 n
0
NP = I (P/A, i, n) + F (P/F, i, n)
Solve for i, which is Kdon a before-tax basis.
If interest payments are made more than once per year, determine i on thebasis of actual payment interval and convert to an effective annual rate.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures- Before-tax case for new issue
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
33/61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
34/61
34 of 61
If there are issuing expenses (and perhaps a discount), then Kdmust be
found by solving the general time value relationship.
NP = 1000 - 75 - 25 = 900
Then, Kdis such that:
900 = 100 (P/A, Kd, 8) + 1000 (P/F, Kd, 8)
With financial calculator (PV=900, PMT= -100 and FV= -1000) or by trialand error, we find that Kd = 12 %.
In our example, assume that issuing expenses are $75 per bond and adiscount of $25 per bond is offered.
For cost of existing debt, determine yield-to-maturity and express as aneffective annual rate. I/ Pis referred to as a bondsyield.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
35/61
35 of 61
- Interest payments as they are paid- Issuing expenses at time of issue- Discount at time of redemption
Tax deductible
NP: F - Issuing Expenses (1 - t) - Discount Interest Payment: I (1 - t)
Amount sold for: F - DiscountAmount paid to bondholder at maturity: F Tax deductible at
maturityF = (F - Discount) + Discount
Kd on an after-tax basis is found by solving the general relationship with afinancial calculator or by trial and error. Same comment concerning interestpayments made more than once per year.
Thus, after-tax payment is: (F - Discount) + Discount (1 - t) = F - Discount (t)
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures- After-tax case for new issue
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
36/61
36 of 61
If there are neither issuing expenses nor a discount, then
Kd= I (1 - t) / F
In our example, say t = 40%.
Kd= 100 (1 - 0.4) / 1000 = 0.06 = 6 %
Note: This relationship applies to a new issue only. The bonds are sold atpar (i.e. F).
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures
After-tax Cost
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
37/61
37 of 61
NP: 1000 - 75 (1 - 0.4) - 25 = 930
Interest payment: 100 (1 - 0.4) = 60
After-tax amount paid to bondholder at maturity: 1000 - 25 (0.4)= 990
Tax credit
Then, Kdis such that:
930 = 60 (P/A, Kd, 8) + 990 (P/F, Kd, 8)
With financial calculator or by trial and error, we find that Kd= 7.1 %
In our example with issuing expenses and discount of $75 and $25,respectively,
If there are issuing expenses, Kdmust be found by solving the general timevalue relationship
For cost of existing debt, use current market price and after-tax interestpayments, ignore discount unless known, and express as an effectiveannual rate.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
38/61
38 of 61
Approximation for maturity periods greaterthan 20
Kd = I (1 - t) / NP (for existing debt: I (1t) / P)
In our example,
Kd = 100 (1 - 0.4) / 930 = 6.5 % (Not so accurate comparedto 7.1 % because n is muchless than 20)
There is no need to use this approximation when a financial calculator isavailable.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Bonds and Debentures
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
39/61
39 of 61
Par value F
Net proceeds* NP (for new issue)
Annual dividend D (Annual dividend rate F)
Cost of preferred equity capital Kp
* Net Proceeds = Par Value - Issuing Expenses (1 - t)
For after-tax case
Elements
Market Price P (for existing equity)
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Preferred Shares
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
40/61
40 of 61
D
NP
NP = D (P/A, i,)
Solve for i, which is Kp.
As (P/A, i, ) = 1 / i, i = D / NP.
Kp= D / NP (for existing preferred: D / P, i.e. the shares dividend yield)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 80
If dividend payments are made more than once per year, determine i on thebasis of actual payment interval and convert to an effective annual rate.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Preferred Shares- New Issue
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
41/61
41 of 61
As with other sources of funds, the cost of common equity is based on thepremise that investors pay for what they expect to get
Par value F
Net proceeds* NP (for new issue)
Market price P (for existing equity)
Annual dividend D (variable)
Cost of common equity capital Ke
* Net Proceeds = Market Price - Issuing Expenses (1 - t)
For after-tax case
Elements
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Common Shares
Dividend Evaluation Model
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
42/61
42 of 61
No growth in dividends and price expectedKe= D / NP (for existing common: D / P)
Geometric growth in dividends and price expected (compound growth rateof g per year)
D0: Current dividend (assumed paid)
D1: Expected year-end dividend (D0[1 + g])
Ke= [D1/ NP] + g (for existing common: [D1/ P]*+ g
If dividend payments are made more than once per year, determine i on thebasis of actual payment interval and convert to an effective annual rate.
* D1/ P is referred to as the shares dividend yield.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Common Shares
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
43/61
43 of 61
Shareholders expect that profits retained in the business will earn at leastthe same return as their current investment
Implicit cost the same as that of existing common equity, i.e.:
Kre= D / P Kre= [D1/ P] + g
If dividend payments are made more than once per year, determine i onthe basis of actual payment interval and convert to an effective annualrate.
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Cost of Retained Earnings
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
44/61
44 of 61
As indicated earlier, an alternate measure of the overall cost of commonequity (i.e. initial shareholder investment plus retained earningscombined) is:
Ke= Earnings per shareP
RetainedEarnings
Market controlled
This relationship measures the cost of existing equity in the absence ofdividend payments (a growth rate assumption is built into EPS1).
Expected
Business
performance
Value based
on investor
expectations
1
COST OF INDIVIDUAL SOURCES5.5
Overall Cost of Common Equity
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
45/61
45 of 61
Consists of the proportions of the different sources of funds in a firmspermanent financing structure.
Long-term Debt
Preferred Equity
Common Equity (initial shareholder investment plus retained earnings)
Most companies have a policy of maintaining a particular capital structureover the long-term. The objective of this strategy is to minimize thecompanys cost of capital, which is a function of its capital structure andbusiness risk.
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
46/61
46 of 61
Ke
Kaverage
Kd
To maintain overthe long term
100% equityMore debt
Debt/Equity
After-taxCost
The optimal capital structure is conceptualized in the diagram below:
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
47/61
47 of 61
Increase return on equity (high cost source of funds) by including long-termdebt (lower cost source of funds) in capital structure.
$Return onequity withall equityfinancing
Return on equity withpartial debt financing
Debt
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Leverage
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
48/61
48 of 61
Purchase of an apartment building for $500 000Two financing options:
Use $500 000 of equity earning 15 % elsewhere
Use bank loan of $400 000 at 12 %, and $100 000 of equity earning
15 % elsewhere
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Example 5.1-Leverage
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
49/61
49 of 61
Scenario 1: Sell building for $600 000 one year later
Using all equity financing
Profit: 600 000 - 500 000 = 100 000
Time Value Return on Equity: 100 000 / 500 000 = 20 %
Using debt and equity financing
Profit: 600 000 - 500 000 - 48 000 = 52 000
Time Value Return on Equity: 52 000 / 100 000 = 52 %
Interest payment
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Solution
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
50/61
50 of 61
Scenario 2: Sell building for $400 000 one year later
Using all equity financing
Profit:400 000 - 500 000 = (100 000)
Time Value Return on Equity: (100 000) / 500 000 = -20 %
Using debt and equity financing
Profit: 400 000 - 500 000 - 48 000 = (148 000)
Time Value Return on Equity:(148 000) / 100 000 = -148 %
Interest payment
CAPITAL STRUCTURE5.6
Solution
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
51/61
51 of 61
The cost of capital is the weighted-average cost of all permanent (i.e. long-term)
sources of funds.
Weighted average cost of capital (WACC or COC):n
WACC = (Kj Propj)j=1
in which Kj is the cost of each source, Propj is the proportion of source jrelative to the total sources, and nis the number of sources.
This relationship is applied to assess either the existing cost of capital or thecost of raising new capital (i.e. marginal cost of capital). In either case, boththe costs and the weights must be based on market value, and not onface/par value, except for new issues sold at par.
WEIGHTED COST OF ALL SOURCES5.7
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
52/61
52 of 61
A firm has a capital structure with the following characteristics:
40% debt with Kd= 8 % (B-T) 10% preferred equity with Kp= 9 % 50% common equity with Ke = 10.5 %
Tax rate: 45%
B-TWACC = 8% (0.4) + 9% (0.1) + 10.5% (0.5) = 9.3 %
A-TWACC = 8% (1 - 0.45)*(0.4) + 9% (0.1) + 10.5% (0.5) = 7.9 %
*This is an approximation. The exact after-tax cost must be determinedfrom the current market price, the coupon rate, the maturity period, the
corporate income tax rate, and the discount given at purchase, ifapplicable and known.
WEIGHTED COST OF ALL SOURCES5.7
Example 5.2- Existing Cost of Capital
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
53/61
53 of 61
Retained Earnings $1.5 mil.
Bonds $9.5 mil.
Face value: $100Issuing expense: $10
Maturity: 10 yearsCoupon rate: 8 % paid quarterlyDiscount: $2
A firm has financed a new project with the following:
Preferred Shares $2.0 mil.
Par value: $100Issuing expense: $10
Dividend: 7 % paid annually
Common Shares $20.0 mil.
Current market price: $25Issuing expense: $2Current dividend: $1.75
(paid annually)Annual growth rate: 6.2 %
The firmstax rate is 45 %. What isthe weighted-average after-tax costof capital associated with raisingthese funds?
EXAMPLES5.8
Example 5.3- Cost of Capital Associated with Raising New Funds
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
54/61
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
55/61
55 of 61
Cost of Common Shares (new issue)
Ke= 1.75 (1 + 0.062) + 0.062 = 13.98 %[25 - 2 (1 - 0.45)]
Cost of Retained Earnings
Kre= 1.75 (1 + 0.062) + 0.062 = 13.63 %25
WACC = 5.41(9.5/33) + 7.41(2.0/33) + 13.98(20/33) + 13.63(1.5/33) = 11.1 %
Cost of Capital or WACC
EXAMPLES5.8
Solution
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
56/61
56 of 61
Kuipers, Inc.Balance Sheet as of 31 December, 2003
(million $)
Cash 121 Accounts payable 350Accounts receivable 425 Notes payable 370Inventory 410 Total 720
Total 956 Long-term debt 550Shareholders equity
Net fixed assets 1804 Common stock 580Retained earnings 910Total 1490
Total assets 2760 Total Liab. & S.E. 2760
Bonds: Par value of $1000, market price of $900, Kdof 5 %Common shares: Par value of $20, market price of $60, Keof 12 %
EXAMPLES5.8
Example 5.4- Existing Cost of Capital
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
57/61
57 of 61
Using balance sheet values as weights:
Debt + Equity: 550 + (580 + 910) = 550 + 1490 = 2040
WACC: 5% (550/2040) + 12% (1490/2040) = 10.1 %
WACC based on market values (correct method)
Retained earnings are included implicitly in the market value of the shares.
WACC based on book values
Using market values as weights:
Debt + Equity: 900 (550 / 1000) + 60 (580 / 20)
900 (0.55 mil. bonds) + 60 (29 mil. shares)
495 + 1740 = 2235
WACC: 5% (495/2235) + 12% (1740/2235) = 10.4 %
EXAMPLES5.8
Solution
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
58/61
58 of 61
Byron Inc. needs $50 million for a new project. As all of its retainedearnings have been used, the firm plans to issue new equity and debt toobtain the additional funds required, while maintaining its current capitalstructure of 60 % equity and 40 % debt. On an after-tax basis, Byron willnet 90 % of selling price for the common equity issued and 95 % for thedebt issued. The common shares are to be issued at the current market
price of $50 per share and the new bonds will be sold at their par value of$1000 per bond.
How many shares and bonds does Byron Inc. need to issue?
To maintain the current capital structure, the following relationship must be
respected with respect to the total monetary amount (T) of equity and debtissued:
(0.90) 0.6 T + (0.95) 0.4 T = 50 million0.54 T + 0.38 T = 50 million
T = $54.348 million
EXAMPLES5.8
Example 5.5- Raising Capital for a New Project
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
59/61
59 of 61
Number of common shares to be issued:
(0.6) 54.348 = $32.609 in common sharesNumber of shares 32.609 (106) / 50 = 652 176
Number of bonds to be issued:
(0.4) 54.348 = $21.739 million in bondsNumber of bonds 21.739 (106) / 1000 = 21 740
EXAMPLES5.8
Solution
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
60/61
60 of 61
The analysis of a firm's capital markets and associated costs has producedthe following information:
Given that the cost of debt and equity are specified on a before-tax basisand that the firm is subject to a corporate income tax rate of 45 percent,determine the optimal capital structure, i.e. the debt to equity ratio thatminimises the after-tax cost of capital.
Debt/EquityCost of debt
(%)
Cost of equity
(%)
0.2 10.0 16.0
0.6 10.0 16.3
1.0 10.4 17.0
1.5 11.1 18.0
2.0 12.3 19.4
2.5 13.8 21.2
3.0 15.6 23.3
EXAMPLES5.8
Example 5.6- Optimal Capital Structure
Professor R. Jassim Engineering Economy
-
8/10/2019 Chapter 5 eng economics
61/61
The proportion of debt for each debt to equity ratio is:Debt/Equity Debt Equity Debt + Equity Debt/Total
0.2 0.2 1.0 1.2 0.167
0.6 0.6 1.0 1.6 0.375
1.0 1.0 1.0 2.0 0.500
1.5 1.5 1.0 2.5 0.600
2.0 2.0 1.0 3.0 0.667
2.5 2.5 1.0 3.5 0.714
3.0 3.0 1.0 4.0 0.750
The weighted-average after-tax cost of capital for each debt to equity ratio is:
Debt/Equity Cost of Capital0.2 10% (1 - 0.45) 0.167 + 16% (1 - 0.167) = 14.2%0.6 10% (1 - 0.45) 0.375 + 16.3% (1 - 0.375) = 12.2%1.0 10.4% (1 - 0.45) 0.5 + 17% (1 - 0.5) = 11.4%1.5 11.1% (1 - 0.45) 0.6 + 18% (1 - 0.6) = 10.9%2.0 12.3% (1 - 0.45) 0.667 + 19.4% (1 - 0.667) = 11.0%2.5 13.8% (1 - 0.45) 0.714 + 21.2% (1 - 0.714) = 11.5%3.0 15.6% (1 - 0.45) 0.75 + 23.3% (1 - 0.75) = 12.3%
EXAMPLES5.8
Solution