CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

download CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

of 16

Transcript of CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    1/16

    CHAPTER II

    ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING AND ECOSYSTEM

    RESTORATION

    A. Definition of ecological engineering

    Ecological engineering is defined as the design of sustainable ecosystems that

    integrate human society with its natural environment for the benefit of both (Mitsch

    and Jrgensen, 2004). It involves the restoration of ecosystems that have been

    substantially disturbed by human activities such as environmental pollution or land

    disturbance; and the development of new sustainable ecosystems that have both human

    and ecological value. While there was some early discussion of ecological engineering

    in the 1960s, its development was spawned later by several factors, including loss ofconfidence in the view that all pollution problems can be solved through technological

    means and the realization that with technological means, pollutants are just being

    moved from one form to another. Such approaches require massive resources to solve

    problems, that, in turn, perpetuate carbon and nitrogen cycle problems, for example.

    Restoration ecology was described as the full or partial [re]placement of structural or

    functional characteristics that have been extinguished or diminished and the

    substitution of alternative qualities or characteristics than the ones originally present

    with the proviso that they have more social, economic, or ecological value than existed

    in the disturbed or displaced state (Cairns, 1988). A definition of ecological restoration

    established as part of a National Academy of Science study in the early 1990s was thereturn of an ecosystem to a close approximation of its condition prior to disturbance

    (NRC, 1992). Several restoration fields have developed somewhat independently, and

    all appear to have the design of ecosystems as their theme. Although related to

    ecological engineering or even a part of it, several of these approaches seem to lack one

    of the two important cornerstones of ecological engineering, namely: 1) recognizing the

    self-designing ability of ecosystems, or 2) basing the approaches on a theoretical base,

    not just empiricism.

    The development of ecological engineering was given strong impetus in the last decade

    with the publication of a textbook, the publication of the journal Ecological

    Engineering and the formation of two professional ecological engineering societies.

    The five principles defining ecological engineering are: 1) It is based on the self-

    designing capacity of ecosystems; 2) It can be the acid test of ecological theories; 3)

    It relies on system approaches; 4) It conserves non-renewable energy sources; and 5) It

    supports biological conservation. Ecology as a science is not routinely integrated into

    engineering curricula, even in environmental engineering programs. Likewise,

    ecologists, environmental scientists, and managers are missing important training in

    their professionproblem solving. These two deficiencies were addressed in the

    integrated field of ecological engineering.

    One way to view ecological engineering and ecosystem restoration, since they coversuch a wide varieties of fields, is to consider the various fields on a spectrum of how

    20

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    2/16

    much conventional engineering (and, hence, reliance on human structures and our

    fossil fuel economy are involved; see Figure 2.1). On the right side of this spectrum are

    traditional ecological approaches such as prairie restoration or wetland restoration

    where quite often only a small effort of conventional engineering is needed. In some

    cases, wetlands (at least the hydrology) can almost be restored in a few hours or days if

    a drainage tile is broken or blocked, allowing the return of the original hydrology. Inthe middle of the spectrum are approaches such as biomanipulation or wetland creation

    where clearly more management and engineering are required. This is probably also

    true for wetlands built for wastewater or nonpoint source pollution control or for

    developing multi-species agroecosystems. At the far left of the theoretical spectrum are

    examples that involve significant amounts of energy and engineering. Intensely

    engineered systems such as Biosphere 2, clearly ecological engineering in the sense

    that ecosystems are being created, quite often are enormously subsidized, yet might fall

    within the definition of ecological engineering.

    Biosphere 2 Biomanipulation Prairie Restoration

    Soil Bioremediation Wetland Restoration

    Solar Aquatics Mineland Restoration

    Agroecological Engineering

    Wastewater Wetlands

    Wetland Creation

    more lesshuman engineering

    highlowreliance on self-design

    sustainability potential

    low high

    Fig. 2.1. Spectrum of ecological engineering and ecosystem restoration (Mitsch

    and Jrgensen, 2004)

    B. Principles of ecological engineering

    While ecological engineering and ecosystem restoration might prove that some

    ecological theories are not rigorous enough to survive real world tests, the principles

    below are based on ecological concepts that have a strong record of field verification.

    Principle 1Ecosystem structure and function are determined by the forcing

    functions of the system.

    Principle 2Energy inputs to the ecosystems and available storage of matter

    are limited.

    Principle 3Ecosystems are open and dissipative systems.

    21

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    3/16

    Principle 4Attention to a limited number of factors is most strategic in

    preventing pollution or restoring ecosystems.

    Principle 5Ecosystems have some homeostatic capability that results in

    smoothing out and depressing the effects of strongly variable inputs.

    Principle 6Recycling pathways must be matched to the loading rates to

    ecosystems to reduce the effect of pollution.

    Principle 7Design for pulsing systems wherever possible.

    Principle 8Ecosystems are self-designing systems.

    Principle 9Processes of ecosystems have characteristic time and space scales

    that should be accounted for in environmental management.

    Principle 10Biodiversity should be championed to maintain an ecosystems

    self-design capacity.

    Principle 11Ecotones, or transition zones, are as important for the ecosystems

    as the membranes are for cells.

    Principle 12Couplings between ecosystems should be utilized wherever

    possible.

    Principle 13 The components of an ecosystem are interconnected, interrelated

    and form a network, implying that direct as well as indirect effects of ecosystemdevelopment need to be considered.

    Principle 14An ecosystem has a history of development.

    Principle 15Ecosystems and species are most vulnerable at their geographical

    edges.

    Principle 16Ecosystems are hierarchical systems and are parts of a larger

    landscape.

    Principle 17Physical and biological processes are interactive. It is important

    to know both physical and biological interactions and interpret them properly.

    Principle 18Ecotechnology requires a holistic approach that integrates as far

    as possible all the interacting parts and processes.

    Principle 19Information in ecosystems is stored in structures.

    References:

    Cairns, J., Jr. 1988. Restoration ecology: The new frontier. Pages 1-11 In: J. Cairns, Jr.,ed.,Rehabilitating Damaged Ecosystems, Volume I. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.

    22

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    4/16

    Mitsch, W. J., S. E. Jrgensen. 1989. Ecological Engineering: An Introduction to

    Ecotechnology. John Wiley & Sons, New York. 472 pp.

    Mitsch, W. J. 1993. Ecological engineeringa cooperative role with the planetary life

    support systems. Environmental Science & Technology 27:438-445.

    Mitsch, W. J. 1998. Ecological engineeringthe seven-year itch. Ecological

    Engineering 10: 119-138.

    Mitsch, W. J., S. E. Jrgensen. 2003. Ecological engineering: A field whose time has

    come.Ecological Engineering 20: 363-377.

    Mitsch, W. J., S. E. Jorgensen. 2004. Ecological Engineering and Ecosystem

    Restoration. Wiley, New York.

    National Research Council. 1992. Restoration of Aquatic Ecosystems. NationalAcademy Press, Washington, DC.

    Internet resources:

    Ecological Engineering (the journal), Volumes 1-23 (1991 present) published by

    Elsevier. Journal content and other journal information published at:

    http://www.elsevier.com/locate/ecoleng.

    23

    http://www.elsevier.com/locate/ecolenghttp://www.elsevier.com/locate/ecoleng
  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    5/16

    Slides

    1 & 4

    Madan, or Marsh Arabs,Mesopotamian Marshlandssouthern Iraq

    With permission from National Geographic; first published

    in textbook: Mitschand Gosselink, 1986, Wetlands. Van

    Nostrand Reinhold, New York Richardson 2004

    Drainage of the Mesopotamian Marshlands

    Slides2 & 5Drainage of the Mesopotamian Marshlands

    Slides

    3 & 6Drainage of the Mesopotamian Marshlands

    Olentangy River Wetland Research Park

    The Ohio State University

    ExperimentalWetlands

    Oxbow Wetland

    Bottomland Hardwood ForestRestoration

    MesocosmCompound Sandefur

    Wetland Pavilion

    Heffner Wetland

    Building

    CityBikepath

    OlentangyRiver

    24

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    6/16

    Slides

    7 & 10

    EDUCATION AND RESEARCH ARE

    MOST IMPORTANT TO ENHANCE OUR KNOWLEDGE AND

    WISE USE OF WETLANDS

    Slides

    8 &11

    Olentangy River Wetland Research Park, Ohio S tate University

    Slides

    9 & 12

    Ecological Engineering

    and

    Ecosystem Restoration

    Restoring the Florida Everglades

    25

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    7/16

    Slides

    13 & 16

    Restoring the Florida Everglades

    Treatment Wetlands

    Slides

    14 & 17

    restoredbottomland

    forest

    createdwetlandinterceptingtiledrainage

    Restoring the Mississippi River Basin

    Restoring Coastal Marshes in New J ersey

    Slides

    15 & 18

    Restoring the Skjern River, Denmark

    Restoring Coastal Marshes in New J ersey

    26

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    8/16

    Slides

    19 & 22

    Biosphere 2 - the most costly ecological engineering of all

    impacts andemissions

    ECOSYSTEMSIndustrialization

    andurbanization

    ECOSYSTEMS

    Environmentaltechnology

    Ecologicalmodelling

    Strategy for environmental managementEarly 1970s

    Slides

    20 & 23

    Biosphere 2 - the most costly ecological engineering of all

    Ecologicalmodelling

    ECOSYSTEMS

    Environmentaltechnology

    HUMANS

    Environmentallegislation

    Ecologicalengineering

    and

    ecosystemrestoration

    Global environmental problems

    Climate change

    Ozone depletion

    Acid deposition Rain forestl oss

    Cleanertechnology;

    Sustainabledevelopment

    Strategy for environmental managementtoday

    Slides

    21 & 24

    Biosphere 2 - the most costly ecological engineering of all

    CLEANERTECHNOLOGY

    CLIFE CYCLEANALYSIS

    L

    RAW MATERIAL ENERGY

    TRANSPORT

    APPLICATION

    DISPOSAL

    ECOSYSTEMS

    E

    ENVIRONMENTALTECHNOLOGY

    T

    ECOLOGICALENGINEERING

    ANDECOSYSTEM

    RESTORATION

    E

    RECYCLINGC

    RECYCLINGC T

    E

    T

    E

    L

    L

    L

    T

    E

    T

    E

    USE OF WASTE HEATC

    PRODUCTIONC

    PRODUCT

    27

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    9/16

    Slides

    25 & 28

    21002000190018000

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    Change in population 1805-1999 and an op-

    timistic (but realistic) prognosis 1999-2050

    Human

    population(billions)

    Year

    Goals of Ecological Engineering

    1. the restoration of ecosystems that have beensubstantially disturbed by human activitiessuch as environmental pollution or landdisturbance; and

    2. the development of new sustainableecosystems that have both human andecological value.

    Slides

    26 & 29

    100

    80

    60

    40

    20

    01900 1920 1940

    Year

    Atmospheric CO2

    Global Nitrogen Fixation

    1960 1980 2000

    PercentChange

    Ecological Restoration

    the return of an ecosystem to a

    close approximation of its

    condition prior to disturbance

    Source: NRC, 1992

    Slides

    27 & 30 Ecological Engineering

    the design of sustainable

    ecosystems that integrate

    human society with its natural

    environment for the benefit of

    both

    Source: Mitsch and Jrgensen, 2004

    Termsthatare synonyms, subdisciplines, or fields similar toecological engineering______ ________ ______ _______ _______ _______ _______ ______

    synthetic ecology biomanipulation

    restoration ecology riverand lake restoration

    bioengineering wetland restoration

    sustainableagroecology reclamation ecology

    habitat reconstruction nature engineering

    ecohydrology ecotechnology

    ecosystem rehabilitation engineering ecology

    biospherics solar aquatics

    ______ ________ ______ _______ _______ _______ _______ ______

    28

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    10/16

    Slides

    31 & 34 History of Ecological Engineering

    H.T. Odum(1960s) mention of ecological engineering inseveral publications

    Ma Shijun (1960s-70s in China; 1985 in Westernliterature) father of ecological engineering in China

    Mitsch -t aught course at IIT in 1975 called Ecologicalengineering and systems ecology

    Ecotechnology of Uhlmann, Straskraba and Gnauek(1983-1985)

    Mitsch and Jrgensen ecological engineering book (1989)

    ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERINGECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING

    ANNUAL MEETINGANNUAL MEETING

    MAY 1, 2001MAY 1, 2001

    UNIVERSITY OF GEORGIAUNIVERSITY OF GEORGIA

    ATHENSATHENS

    Slides

    32 & 35 History of Ecological Engineering First ecological engineering meeting in Trosa Sweden (1991)

    followed by Etnier and Guterstambook (1991, 1997)

    Ecological Engineeringjournal started (1992)

    Ecological engineering workshop in Washington DC atNational Academy of Sciences (1993)

    IEES started in 1993 in Utrecht, The Netherlands

    SCOPE project in ecological engineering and ecosystemrestoration established in Paris, 1994 - 2002

    Discussions of American ecological engineering society inColumbus, 1999; AEES first meeting April 2001 Athens, GA

    Mitsch and Jrgensen (2004) and Kangas (2004) textbookscompleted

    Seriesof 4 workshops andsubsequent specialissue publicationsof SCOPE(ScientificCommittee on Problemsof the Environment) project EcologicalEngineering and EcosystemRestoration

    ______________________________________________________________________________Workshop Title Workshop Location Special Issue

    And Date Publication of Ecol Eng______________________________________________________________________________Ecological engineeringin Tallin,Estonia Mitsch andMander (1997)Ce ntra l a nd Ea ste rn Europ e: No vember 6 -8, 1 995Remediationof ecosystemsdamaged by environmentalcontamination

    Ecologicalengineer ingin developing Beijing,China R.Wanget al. (1998)countries October 7-11, 1996

    Ecologicalengineer ingapplied tor iver Par is,France Lefeuvre et al. (2002)and wetland restoration July 29-31, 1998

    Ecology ofpost-mining landscapes Cottbus, Germany HttlandBradshaw(2001)March 15-19,1999

    ______________________________________________________________________________

    Slides

    33 & 36

    ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERINGECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING

    WORKSHOPWORKSHOP

    MARCH 15MARCH 15--16, 199916, 1999

    THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITTHE OHIO STATE UNIVERSIT

    COLUMBUSCOLUMBUS

    Self-design

    The application of self-organization

    in the design of ecosystems

    29

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    11/16

    Slides

    37 & 40Systems categorized by types of organization (modified from Pahl-Wostl, 1995)

    ____ _____ _____ ____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ ____ _____ ___Characteris tic Imposed organization Self-organization

    ____ _____ _____ ____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ ____ _____ ___

    Control externally imposed; endogenously imposed;

    centralized control distributed control

    Rigidity rigid networks flexible networks

    Potential for adaptation little potential high potential

    Application conventional engineering ecological engineering

    Examples machine organism

    fascist or socialist society democratic society

    agriculture natural ecosystem

    ____ _____ _____ ____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ ____ _____ ___

    A Systems Approach

    Slides

    38 & 41

    Nonrenewable Resource

    Conservation

    Slides

    39 & 42

    The Acid Test

    ConventionalEngineer

    FossilFuels

    Natu ralEnergies

    Servicesto Societ

    Conventional EngineeringConventional Engineering

    30

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    12/16

    Slides

    43 & 46

    Na tur alEnergies

    self

    design

    FossilFuels

    Servicesto Societ

    EcologicalEngineer

    Mitsch (1998)

    Ecological EngineeringEcological Engineering

    Comparison of ecotechnology and biotechnology

    _____________________________________________________________

    Characteristi c Ecotechnology Biot echno logy

    _____________________________________________________________Basic unit Ecosystem Cell

    Basic principles Ecology Genetics; cell biology

    Control Forcing fun ctions, Genetic structure

    organisms

    Design Self-design with some Human design

    human help

    Biotic diversity Protected Changed

    Maintenance and Reasonable Enormousdevelopment costs

    Energy b asis Solar based Fossil fuel based

    ________________________ _______________________________ ______

    Slides

    44 & 47

    Ecosystem Conservation

    To keep every cog and wheel is the first precaution

    of intellegent tinkering.

    Aldo Leopold

    Contrasts with Other Fields

    Environmental engineering

    Biotechnology

    Ecology

    Slides

    45 & 48 Contrasts with Other Fields

    Environmental engineering

    Biotechnology

    TheoreticalEco logy

    Ap pl ie dEco logy

    Eco log ica lEngineering

    The design, restoration andcreat ion o f ecosys tems

    Resource Mgt.

    Ecotoxicology

    Environ. Monitoring

    Ecosystems

    Community

    EcologicalEconomics

    Landscape Eco logy Ri sk Ass es sm en t

    Impact AssessmentPopulation

    Evolutionary

    The design, restoration, and creation of ecosystems

    31

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    13/16

    Slides

    49 & 52 Contrasts with Other Fields

    Environmental engineering

    Biotechnology

    Ecology

    Ecotechniques/Cleaner Technology

    Industrial Ecology

    Functional classification

    Ecosystems are used to reduce or solve a pollutionproblem

    Ecosystems are imitated or copied to reduce aresource problem

    The recover of ecosystems is supported

    Existing ecosystems are modified in anecologically sound way

    Ecosystems are used for the benefit of humankindwithout destroying the ecological balance

    Slides

    50 & 53

    Classification of Ecological

    Engineering

    Examples of ecological engineering approaches for terrestrial and aquatic systemsaccordingtotypesof applications.

    ________________________ ______________________________ _____________________EcologicalEngineering Approaches Terrestrial Examples Aquatic Examples________________________ ______________________________ _____________________1 .Ecosystemsareusedtosolvea pollu tion Phytoremediation Wastewaterwetlandproblem

    2.Ecosystemsare imitated or copied to Forest restoration

    3 .Th e re co very o fan ec os ys tem is Mine lan d res to ra tion Lak e r es to rat io nsupportedafter disturbance

    4.Existing ecosystems are modified Selectivetimber harvest Biomanipulationin an ecologicallysound way

    5. Ecosystems are used for b enefit Sustainable Multi-specieswithoutdestroyingecological balance a gr oe cosys tem s aq uacu lt ur e________________________ _______________________________ ____________________

    Replacement wetland

    reduce or solve a problem

    Slides

    51 & 54

    Biosphere 2 Biomanipulation Prairie Restoration

    Soil Bioremediation Wetland Restoration

    Solar Aquatics Mineland Restoration

    Agroecological Engineering

    Wastewater Wetlands

    Wetland Creation

    more lesshuman engineering

    highlowreliance on self-design

    sustainability potentiallow high

    Solving or reducing a pollution problem

    32

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    14/16

    Slides

    55 & 58Solving or reducing a pollution problem

    Imitating or copying

    ecosystems

    Slides

    56 & 59

    Solving or reducing a pollution problem

    Supporting ecosystem recovery

    Slides

    57 & 60

    Imitating or copying ecosystems

    Supporting ecosystem recovery

    33

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    15/16

    Slides

    61 & 64Modifying

    existing

    ecosystems in an

    ecologically

    sound way

    Biomanipulation

    Source: Hosper

    and Meijer, 1992

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________Ecological Engineering Project Location Purpose References

    _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Createdflow-through riverine Columbus, Ohio to experimentallydeterminethelong-termeffects Mitsch et al.,1998;wetlands of planting on ecosystem function in progress

    Root -zon ewetlan ds f o r S no ger d, S weden to inv es tiga te u se o f r o ot -zon ewetlan ds to G um br icht , 1 99 2wastewater treatment provide tertiary treatment of wastewater from

    smalltown

    Non-pointsource control central and southern to estimate theinteraction betweenwetland retention Braskerud,2002a,bwetlands Norway efficiencyand nutrient loss from agricultural

    watersheds

    Surface-waterwetlandsfor HoughtonLake,Michigan to use natural peatlandstotreat wastewater Kadlecand Knight,wastewater treatment from municipality to prevent lake pollution 1996

    Renovation ofcoal-minedrainage AthensCounty,Ohio to studyiron retention fromcoal mine drainage Mitsch andWise,1998

    withTypha wetland

    R iv er p oll ut io n co nt rol S uz hou, C hi na t o us e wat er h ya ci nt hs (Eichhornia crassipes) Ma a nd Ya n, 198 9systemsforwaterpollution controland

    production offodder

    Nonpointsource pollution control central Illinois to create wetlandstoremove nutrientsfromMidwest Kovacicet al., 2000agricultural runoff Larsonet al., 2000

    Intertidal sediment fences southern Louisiana to constructintertidal fencesmadefromrecycled Boumanset al.,1997Christmast reestorevegetationon mudflatsandincreasedsedimenttrapping

    Examples of ecological engineering at different scales (cont.)

    Ecosystem Scale

    Slides

    62 & 65

    Classification According to Scale

    ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________Ecological Engineering Project Location Purpose References

    ______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Restoration ofriparianlandscape Lake County,Illinois to restoreMidwestern U.S.riverfloodplain Heyetal., 1989anddeterminedesign proceduresforrestored Mitsch,1992wetlands Sanville andMitsch,

    1994

    Reg io na l lan ds cape r es to ra tion Cen tr al F lo rida to r econs tr uc tw et land /u plan d land scape Bro wn e ta l. , 1 99 2at phosphate mine

    Agro-ecologicalengineering severalthousandsites to havemultiple-product farmingwithextensive R.Zhanget al.,1998in China recycling

    Fishproduction/wetlandsystems YixingCounty, to producefisheriessynchronizedto Phragmites Mitsch,1991JiangsuProvince,China wetlandproductionandharvesting

    Sa lt m ar sh c re at io n C hi na s e as t coa st , es p, t o de ve lo pSpartinama rs he s o nf or me r C hu ng, 1 98 5, 1 98 9Wenling,Zhejiang barrencoastline forshorelineprotection and Qinetal. ,1997Province food and fuel product ion

    Saltmarshrestoration Delaware Bay, NewJerseyto restoresaltmarshesfromsalthayfarmsand Weinstein et al. ,1997,AndPhragmites- domi na te d ma rs he s 20 01; T eal an d

    Weinstein,2002

    River backwater restoration RhoneRiver,central to restoreandenhanceriver andriverbackwater Henry andAmoros,France connectivity 1995; Henry et al.,

    2002______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Examples of ecological engineering at different scales (cont.)

    RegionalScale

    Slides

    63 & 66_____________________ ________________________ __________________________ ___________________________ ________________Ecological Engineering Project Location Purpose References

    _____________________ ________________________ __________________________ ___________________________ ________________

    Treatmentofseptagewastes Harwich,Massachuset ts to producecleanwater(drinkingwater standards) Guterstam andTodd,

    f rom s e pt age i na n un li ned l a nd fi ll l a goon 1990 ; Te a l and Peterson,1991

    S ca le m ode ls o f E ve r gl ade s W as hi ngt on , D C t o s im u la te phys ic a l andb io log ic al f unc ti on A de ya ndL ove la nd ,

    and Chesapeake Bay of large-scale ecosystems 1991

    Bi os ph er e 2 C at alin a Mo un ta in s, 1 .5 h a gl as s-e nc lo se ds ys te m to in ve sti ga te Ma ri no a nd O du m,

    Arizona ecology and humans in enclosed systems 1999

    W et la nd m es oc os ms S an D ie go , C al if or ni a t o i nv es ti ga te t h e ro le o f h yd ro pe ri od s on B us na rd o e t a l. , 19 92m a rs h r et en ti ono f nu tr ie nt s a ndme ta ls S in i cr ope e t a l. , 1992

    W et la nd m es oc os ms C ol um bu s, O h io t o c om pa re c o mp et it iv e gr ow th o f tw o w et la nd S ve ng so uk a nd M it sc h,macrophytespeciesinlowandhigh nutr ients 2001

    W et la nd m es oc os ms C ol um bu s, O h io t o i nv es ti ga te t he u s e o f su lf ur s cr ub be r ma te ri al A hn e t a l. , 20 01 ;

    A s lin er s fo r tr eat me nt w et la nd s Ah n an d Mit sc h, 2 00 2b

    Peat landrestorationplots Waikatoregion,North to determinethe roleoffer t il izer ,seedaddit ions Schipperetal . ,2002

    Island,NewZealand andcult ivat ion techniquesforpeat landrestorat ion

    E xpe ri me nt al e s tuar ine ponds M or ehe adC i ty , N or th t o i nves ti ga te e st uar ine ponds r ec ei v inga O dum, 1985 , 1989bC ar ol in a m ix tu re o f wa st ew ate r a nd s alt wa te r

    Forestedwet landsforrecycling Gainesvi lle,F lorida to experimental lyinvest igateforested cypress Odum etal. ,1974;domesforwastewaterrecyclingand conservation EwelandOdum,1984;

    Dierbergand Brezonik,

    Mesocosm Scale

    Ecosystem Scale

    Examples of ecological engineering at different scales

    When to Use Ecotechnology

    1. The parts of nature affected, directly and indirectly, mustbe determined.

    2. Quantitative assessment of impact of all alternatives mustbe carried out.

    3. Project needs to include entire system, including humanimpacts and affected ecosystem.

    4. Optimization should include short and long-term effects.

    5. Renewable and nonrenewable resource use should bequantified.

    6. Uncertainty should be accounted for in ecological andeconomic components.

    34

  • 7/28/2019 CH2_ECOLOGY ENGINEERING rev.pdf

    16/16

    Slides

    67 & 69

    Ecological Design Principles

    Ecological Design Principles

    _________________________________________________ _____

    7. Design for pulsing systems whenever possible.

    8. Ecosystems are self-designing systems.

    9. Processes of ecosystems have characteristic time and sp acescales that should be accounted for in environmental

    management.

    10.Biodiversity should be championed to maintain an

    ecosystems self-design capacity.

    11.Ecotones, transition zones, are as important for ecosystems asmembranes are for cells.

    12.Coupling between ecosystems should be utilized whereverpossible.

    Slides

    68 & 70

    Ecological Design Principles______________________________________________________

    1.Ecosystem structure and function are determined by theforcing functions of the system.

    2.Energy inputs to the ecosystem and available storage ofmatter are limited.

    3.Ecosystems are open and dissipative systems.

    4.Attention to a limited number of factors is most strategic inpreventing pollution or restoring ecosystems.

    5.Ecosystems have some homeostatic capability that results insmoothing out and depressing the effects of strongly variableinputs.

    6.Match recycling pathways to the rates to ecosystems toreduce the effect of pollution.

    Ecological Design Principles__________________________________________________________

    13. The components of an ecosystem are interconnected, interrelated,

    and form a network, implying that di rect as well as indirecteffects of ecosystem development need to be considered.

    14. An ecosystem has a history of development.

    15. Ecosystems and species are most vulnerable at their geographicaledges.

    16. Ecosystems are hierarchical systems and are parts of a largerlandscape.

    17. Physical and biol ogical processes are interactive. It is importantto know both physical and biological interactions and to interpre tthem properly.

    18. Ecotechnology requires a holistic approach that integrates allinteracting parts and processes as far as possible.

    19. Information in eco systems is stored in structures.

    35