8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 1/6

N I T I @ ' G I @ I ] C Q Y D Z ^ I B F N J F ] Q J  

Nbgpqjljf~itj Ifdbqgc}ibf bf Nbgp`j| Nqi~j~

Cdklcfi~}cf Qjtij{3> Gcqnl 1?31[jje 33

Jnbfbgin Mjtj`bpgjf}

Kbtjqfcfnj $ Qz`j bd @c{

^jnzqi}y $ Dbqnj _qb}jn}ibf

^bnic` $ ̂ }qc}jkin Ifdqc~}qzn}zqj

]lj Niti`'Gi`i}cqy Dz~ibf Njf}qj,NDN) i~ cf ifdbqgc}ibf cfm efb{`jmkj gcfckjgjf} bqkcfi~c'}ibf dbnz~jm bf igpqbtifk niti`'gi`i}cqy if}jqcn}ibf dcni`i}c}ifkifdbqgc}ibf ~lcqifk cfm jflcfnifk~i}zc}ibfc` c{cqjfj~~ }lqbzkl }ljNigin[ja pbq}c` cfm bzq {jje`ycfm gbf}l`y pza`inc}ibf~&

NDN pqbmzn}~ cqj ac~jm zpbf cfm `ife }b bpjf'~bzqnj ifdbqgc}ibfdqbg c {imj tcqij}y bd bqkcfi~c}ibf~qj~jcqnl njf}qj~ cfm gjmic bz}`j}~&

Lb{jtjq }lj NDN mbj~ fb} jfmbq~jcfm ncffb} fjnj~~cqi`y kzcqcf}jj}lj cnnzqcny bq bahjn}iti}y bd }lj~j

~bzqnj~&

NDN pza`inc}ibf~ cqj ifmj'pjfmjf}`y pqbmznjm ay Mj~e

Bddinjq~ cfm mb fb} qjd`jn}FC]B bq I^CD pb`inij~ bq pb~i'

}ibf~ bd cfy b}ljq bqkcfi~c}ibf& 

]lj NDN i~ pcq} bd FC]B C``ijm Nbggcfm Bpjqc}ibf~&

Dbq dzq}ljq ifdbqgc}ibf nbf}cn}8

Cdklcfi~}cf ]jcg @jcmjq~}jtj&xyneOnigin{ja&bqk 

]lj Cdklcfi~}cf ]jcgcdklcfi~}cfOnigin{ja&bqk

IF^IMJ ]LI^ I^^ZJ 

MI^N@CIGJQ 

NBF]CN] ]LJ NDN 

]li~ mbnzgjf} pqbtimj~ c {jje`y btjqtij{ bd mjtj`bpgjf}~ if Cdklcfi~}cf dqbg ?4 „ 31 Gcqnl 1?31

{i}l lypjq'`ife~ }b ~bzqnj gc}jqic` likl`ikl}jm if a`zj cfm zfmjq`ifjm if }lj }j|}& Dbq gbqj ifdbqgc}ibf

bf }lj }bpin~ aj`b{ bq b}ljq i~~zj~ pjq}cififk }b jtjf}~ if Cdklcfi~}cf, nbf}cn} }lj gjgajq~ bd

}lj Cdklcfi~}cf ]jcg, bq ti~i} bzq {ja~i}j c} {{{&nigin{ja&bqk& 

Jnbfbgin Mjtj`bpgjf} ^}jtjf C& Xyne ▸ ~}jtj&xyneOnigin{ja&bqk

lj If~}i}z}j dbq [cq cfm _jcnj Qjpbq}ifk ,I[_Q) ~cy~ }lc} Cdklcfi~}cf i~ dcnifk c fj{

{ctj bd nbzf}jqdji}ifk& Dbqkjm cdklcfi ai``~ gcfy bd c likl mjfbgifc}ibf cqj niqnz'

`c}ifk }lz~ `jctifk gcfy Cdklcf~ {cqy cabz} z~ifk }lj nbzf}qy ’~ bddinic` nzqqjfny

Bfj Cdklcf {bgcf {lb {bqe~ dbq c pqitc}j nbgpcfy }b`m  I[_Q }lj db``b{ifk8 ‐[ljf }ljqj{jqj fb dbqkjm cdklcfi~ bf }lj gcqej} I z~jm }b nlcfkj gy ~c`cqy Udqbg dbqjikf nzqqjfnyW if}b

cdklcfi~ cfm mjpb~i} }ljg if gy acfe cnnbzf}& Fb{ I {cf} }b bpjf c Z^ mb``cq cnnbzf} aj

ncz~j cdklcfi~ cqjf’} qj`ica`j&‗ ]lj ljcm bd Cdklcfi~}cf’~ Njf}qc` Acfe ~zkkj~}jm }lc} }lj

nbzf}jqdji} ai``~ {jqj bqikifc}ifk if dbqjikf nbzf}qij~ cfm b}ljq~ if}jqtij{jm ay  I[_Q ifminc}

jm }lc} gb~} {jqj aj`ijtjm }b nbgj dqbg _cei~}cf& ]lj  AAN Fj{~ qjpbq}jm c ~igi`cq }qjfm if

^jp}jgajq 1?33 {ljf nzqqjfny }qcmjq~ n`cigjm }lc} }lj igpqbtjm szc`i}y bd nbzf}jqdji} ai``~

gcmj }ljg fjcq`y zfmj}jn}ca`j }b }lj gcnlifj~ z~jm }b tjqidy }lj cz}ljf}ini}y bd nzqqjfny&

C kqjc}jq'}lcf'cf}inipc}jm fzgajq bd diqg~ aim dbq }lj qikl}~ }b kb`m cfm nbppjq mjpb~i}~ qj'

njf}`y pz} bz} dbq }jfmjq ay }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} cnnbqmifk }b ]lj K`baj $ Gci`& J|pjq}~

aj`ijtjm cqbzfm 3? nbgpcfij~ {bz`m ~zagi} aim~ az} j|pjn}c}ibf~ kqj{ }lqbzklbz} }lj {jje

bfnj bddjq~ ajkcf }b cqqitj c} }lj Gifi~}qy bd Gifj~ ,GbG)& Ay ?; Gcqnl 1> aim~ lcm c`qjcmy

ajjf qjnjitjm cnnbqmifk }b _chl{be Cdklcf Fj{~& Cdklcfi~}cf’~ Gifi~}jq bd Gifj~ [c

limz``cl ^lclqcfi  ~cim }lj db``b{ifk  {li`j if Ncfcmc }b ~pqjcm ifdbqgc}ibf cabz} li~ nbzf'}qy’~ fc}zqc` qj~bzqnj~8 ‐Mjtj`bpifk bzq pb}jf}ic``y qinl gifjqc` ~jn}bq ncf aj c ejy if~}qzgjf

}b ~z~}cif kqb{}l if }lj `bfk }jqg& Fb nbzf}qy ncf mjpjfm bf if}jqfc}ibfc` cim dbqjtjq&‗ 

]lj Fj{ Ybqe ]igj~ difm~ }lc} }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} lc~ fb} }cejf ~}jp~ }b pqb~jnz}j likl

pqbdi`j if~}cfnj~ bd nbqqzp}ibf ifn`zmifk }lb~j {i}l ~ikfidincf} igp`inc}ibf~ dbq }lj nbzf}qy’~

jnbfbgy& Bfj ~znl j|cgp`j i~ }lj nc~j bd ^ljqelcf Dcqfbbm }lj dbqgjq nlciqgcf bd Ecaz`

Acfe Cdklcfi~}cf’~ `cqkj~} pqitc}j difcfnic` if~}i}z}ibf {lb i~ cnnz~jm bd lctifk ~}b`jf lzf

mqjm~ bd gi``ibf~ bd Z^ mb``cq~ dqbg }lj acfe& ]lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} jtjf}zc``y pcim fjcq`y

Z^M 3 ai``ibf }b aci` bz} }lj acfe az} lc~ }lz~ dcq fb} }cejf ~}jp~ }b pqb~jnz}j Dcqfbbm& ]lj

 Fj{ Ybqe ]igj~ dbzfm Dcqfbbm {lb {c~ qj`jc~jm dqbg hci` }b nb``jn} Ecaz` Acfe’~ gi~~ifk

c~~j}~ kcga`ifk bf pbejq mj~pi}j b{ifk }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} Z^M =4; gi``ibf& If cfb}ljq

j|cgp`j }lj If}jqfc}ibfc` ^jnzqi}y C~~i~}cfnj Dbqnj ,I^CD) qjpbq}jm`y lcm pqbtimjm jtimjfnj

}b }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} }lc} }lj Cdklcf Fc}ibfc` Cqgy ’~ ,CFC) dbqgjq ~zqkjbf kjfjqc`

Kjfjqc` Clgcm Xic Ycd}c`i lcm ~}b`jf ‐}jf~ bd gi``ibf~‗ bd Z^ mb``cq~ {bq}l bd mqzk~ dqbg cf

CFC lb~pi}c`& Jtimjfnj bd }lj dbqgjq ~zqkjbf kjfjqc`’~ nbqqzp}ibf {c~ qjpbq}jm`y pqj~jf}jm

}b _qj~imjf} Lcgim Ecqxci gbqj }lcf c yjcq ckb az} }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} lc~ qjpbq}jm`y

mjn`ifjm }b }cej cn}ibf ac~jm bf }li~ jtimjfnj& J|pjq}~ ~znl c~ Cf}lbfy Nbqmj~gcf bd }lj

Njf}jq dbq ^}qc}jkin cfm If}jqfc}ibfc` ^}zmij~ ,N^I^) j|pqj~~jm nbfnjqf }lc} i} {c~ }bb `c}j }b

gcej cf}i'nbqqzp}ibf c kqjc}jq dbnz~ cqjc dbq }lj if}jqfc}ibfc` nbggzfi}y {linl i~ nzqqjf}`y

c}}jgp}ifk }b lcfm btjq ~jnzqi}y qj~pbf~iai`i}y cfm b}ljq dzfn}ibf~ }b }lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf}

Nbqmj~gcf }b`m ]lj Fj{ Ybqe ]igj~ }lc} ‐UiW}’~ c `i}}`j `c}j if }lj kcgj }b {bqqy cabz} cf}inbq'

qzp}ibf gjc~zqj~ ajncz~j {lc} if }lj {bq`m i~ }lj c`}jqfc}itj kbifk }b aj2‗ 

If qj`c}jm fj{~, Cdklcfi~}cf’~ C}}bqfjy Kjfjqc`’~ Bddinj lc~ cqqj~}jm 3> pjbp`j dbq c``jkjm`y

jgajxx`ifk Z^M >: gi``ibf dqbg }lj ~}c}j'qzf _c~l}cfi Acfe ~cy~ _chl{be & ]lb~j cqqj~}jm

]

8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 2/6

 

3> Gcqnl 1?31 _ckj 1

ifn`zmj }lj acfe’~ dbqgjq ljcm c~ {j`` c~ ~jtjqc` jgp`byjj~ bd }lj Cd'

klcf kbtjqfgjf}’~ Gifi~}qy dbq Zqacf Mjtj`bpgjf}& ]lb~j iftb`tjm if

}lj ~nljgj qjpbq}jm`y kctj `bcf~ }b ;? middjqjf} nbgpcfij~ {i}l fb

j|pjn}c}ibf bd qj'pcygjf}5 mjjm~ dbq `cfm z~jm c~ nb``c}jqc` ay ;? nbg'

pcfij~ {jqj qjpbq}jm`y dc`~idijm&

If ckqinz`}zqc` fj{~ c pi`b} ~cddqbf nz`}itc}ibf ifi}ic}itj  if Lj`gcfm 

pqbtifnj lc~ qjpbq}jm`y yij`mjm ifi}ic` ~znnj~~& ]lj nqbp kqb{~ {j`` if

Lj`gcfm {linl pqbmznj~ gbqj pbppij~ }lcf cfy b}ljq pqbtifnj if }lj

nbzf}qy& ]lj ~cddqbf pi`b} pqbhjn} {c~ qzf ay }lj pqbtifnic` mjpcq}gjf}

bd ckqinz`}zqj {linl i~ c`~b {bqeifk }b }qcf~i}ibf Cdklcf dcqgjq~ dqbgkqb{ifk pbppij~ }b {ljc} tjkj}ca`j~ cfm dqzi}~ ~znl c~ pbgjkqcfc}j~&

^cddqbf i~ nbf~imjqjm c pcq}inz`cq`y tica`j c`}jqfc}itj ~ifnj i} ncf yij`m

c~ gznl c~ Z^M >??? pjq ek if Cdklcfi~}cf cfm zp }b Z^M <??? pjq

ek bf if}jqfc}ibfc` gcqej}~& Dcqgjq~ ifminc}jm }lc} }ljy {bz`m bf`y

nz`}itc}j ~cddqbf id }ljy {jqj kzcqcf}jjm c azyjq dbq }ljiq pqbmznj&&

_cei~}cfi Dbqjikf Gifi~}jq Lifc Qcaacfi Elcq ~}c}jm }lc} {li`j }lj

_cei~}cfi `jki~`c}zqj {c~ ~}i`` mj}jqgififk {lj}ljq }b c``b{ FC]B ~zp'

p`ij~ }b }qctj` cnqb~~ _cei~}cfi ~bi` }lj nbzf}qy i~ c``b{ifk }qcf~i} }qcmj

{i}l Cdklcfi~}cf }b gbtj dbq{cqm cnnbqmifk }b ]lj Fc}ibf& Elcq fb}'

jm }lj _cei~}cfi kbtjqfgjf}’~ cnefb{`jmkjgjf} }lc} Cdklcf~ lcm c qikl} }b igpbq} cfm j|pbq} kbbm~ tic _cei~}cfi {i}lbz} if}jqdjq'

jfnj&

@c~}`y {li`j dbbm pqinj~ if Ecaz` qjgcifjm ~}ca`j  }lj nb~} bd dzj` ifnqjc~jm }li~ pc~} {jje qjpbq}~ _chl{be & ]lj pqinj bd c `i}qj bdmij~j` qb~j dqbg CDF 41 }b CDF 4= cfm pj}qb` {jf} dqbg CDF 4? }b CDF 4>& ]lj tc`zj bd }lj cdklcfi nzqqjfny ckcif~} }lj _cei~}cf

qzpjj cfm Z^ mb``cq c`~b dj`` ay cppqb|igc}j`y bfj }liqm bd bfj pjqnjf}ckj pbif}&

Kbtjqfcfnj $ Qz`j bd @c{ ^}jdcfij Fih~~jf ▸ ~}jdcfij&fih~~jfOnigin{ja&bqk

f c pqb}j~} ckcif~} }lj ei``ifk bd Cdklcf niti`icf~ ay c Z^ ~b`mijq if Ecfmclcq }lj [b`j~i Hiqkc Cdklcfi~}cf’~ `b{jq lbz~j bd pcq

`icgjf} {c~ n`b~jm bf 31 Gcqnl cnnbqmifk }b _chl{be Cdklcf Fj{~& ]lj AAN ~cy~ }lc} Z^ _qj~imjf} Acqcne Bacgc lcm nc``jm

_qj~imjf} Lcgim Ecqxci }b j|pqj~~ nbfmb`jfnj~ btjq }lj mjc}l~ tb{ifk }b lb`m cnnbzf}ca`j cfybfj qj~pbf~ia`j dbq }lj ifnimjf}

Z^ Mjdjf~j ^jnqj}cqy @jbf _cfj}}c ~cim c dz`` iftj~}ikc}ibf {c~ c`qjcmy zfmjq{cy& Dbq dzq}ljq ifdbqgc}ibf bf }li~ ~i}zc}ibf ~jj }lj

^jnzqi}y cfm Dbqnj _qb}jn}ibf ~jn}ibf bd }li~ ‐Cdklcfi~}cf Qjtij{‗& 

]lj Cdklcf cfm Z^ kbtjqfgjf}~ lctj ~ikfjm c gjgbqcfmzg bd zfmjq~}cfmifk ,GbZ) cd}jq gbf}l~ bd fjkb}ic}ibf~ nbfnjqfifk }lj}qcf~djq bd  Z^'qzf mj}jf}ibf dcni`i}ij~ }b Cdklcf nbf}qb` ]lj Kzcqmicf qjpbq}~& ]lj nbzf}qij~ ckqjjm }b }qcf~djq }lj Z^ kbtjqfgjf}’~

gcif mj}jf}ibf njf}qj if }lj nbzf}qy {linl i~ `bnc}jm if _cq{cf pqbtifnj }b Cdklcf nbf}qb` {i}lif ~i| gbf}l~ cnnbqmifk }b }lj  C~

~bnic}jm _qj~~ , C_)& Zfmjq }lj GbZ }lj Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ {i`` ~}i`` lctj cnnj~~ }b }lj mj}jf}ibf njf}qj cfm {i`` c`~b aj ca`j }b a`bne }lj

qj`jc~j bd mj}cifjj~ lj`m }ljqj& If cmmi}ibf Z^ pjq~bffj` {i`` pqbtimj ~zppbq} cfm cmtinj }b }lj Cdklcf nbggcfmjq c} }lj mj}jf}ibf

dcni`i}y dbq zp }b bfj yjcq }lj  AAN ~cy~& Gjcf{li`j }lj }{b nbzf}qij~ cqj c`~b {bqeifk bf cf GbZ nbfnjqfifk  fikl} qcim~ qjpbq}

Bz}`bbe Cdklcfi~}cf& ]lj C_ qjpbq}~ }lc} }lj }qcf~djq bd Z^ mj}jf}ibf njf}qj~ }b Cdklcf nbf}qb` cfm }lj dz}zqj bd fikl} qcim~ cqj pcq'

}inz`cq`y ~ikfidincf} kitjf }lc} }ljy cqj }{b bd }lj i~~zj~ lb`mifk zp }lj j~}ca`i~lgjf} bd c ~}qc}jkin pcq}fjq~lip ckqjjgjf} aj}{jjf }lj

Z^ cfm Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf}~& ]lj ckqjjgjf} {linl Cgjqincf bddinic`~ lbpj }b lctj if p`cnj ajdbqj }lj FC]B ^zggi} if Nlinckb if

Gcy {bz`m dbqgc`i~j }lj qb`j bd }lj Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ cfm }lj ~}c}z~ bd Z^ ~b`mijq~ if Cdklcfi~}cf cd}jq }lj nbfn`z~ibf bd }lj FC]B gi~

~ibf }ljqj if 1?3=&

Cdklcf Dbqjikf Gifi~}jq Xc`gci Qc~~bz` {i`` gjj} {i}l bddinic`~ if Sc}cq }b mi~nz~~ qjnbfni`ic}ibf {i}l }lj ]c`iacf ~cy~ Qjz}jq~& ]lj

Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} lcm cnnbqmifk }b Qjz}jq~ pqjtibz~`y dj`} ~imj'`ifjm ay }c`e~ aj}{jjf }lj Z^ kbtjqfgjf} cfm }lj ]c`iacf if Sc

}cq c ~jf}igjf} {linl `jm Cdklcfi~}cf }b qjnc`` i}~ cgac~~cmbq }b Sc}cq if Mjnjgajq 1?33& Sc}cq’~ qb`j i~ mj~nqiajm c~ ajifk ~ikfid incf} kitjf }lc} pjcnj }c`e~ qjpbq}jm`y iftb`tj }lj pb}jf}ic` }qcf~djq bd ditj ]c`iacf pqi~bfjq~ dqbg }lj Z^ pqi~bf c} Kzcf}cfcgb Acy

}b c Sc}cqi mj}jf}ibf dcni`i}y& [li`j }lj Z^ kbtjqfgjf} lc~ fb} yj} dbqgc``y ckqjjm }b }lj pqi~bfjq }qcf~djq }lj  C_ qjpbq}jm }lc} }lj

ditj ]c`iacf pqi~bfjq~ if szj~}ibf }b`m c ti~i}ifk Cdklcf mj`jkc}ibf }ljy ckqjjm }b ajifk }qcf~djqqjm }b Sc}cq&

C kbtjqfgjf}'cppbif}jm abmy bd 3:? `jcmifk Gz~`ig n`jqin~ }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni` i~~zjm c ~}c}jgjf} }li~ gbf}l zqkifk }lj cpp`inc}ibf

bd c nbf~jqtc}itj if}jqpqj}c}ibf bd I~`cgin `c{ qjkcqmifk {bgjf cnnbqmifk }b ]lj [c`` ^}qjj} Hbzqfc`& ]lj Nbzfni` ~cim Cdklcf `c{

~lbz`m qjsziqj {bgjf }b {jcq }lj tji` dbqaim }ljg dqbg gi|ifk {i}l gjf if p`cnj~ bd {bqe bq jmznc}ibf cfm pqbliai} }ljg dqbg

}qctj`ifk {i}lbz} c gc`j nlcpjqbfj& ‐Gjf cqj dzfmcgjf}c` cfm {bgjf cqj ~jnbfmcqy‗ }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni` ~cim if c ~}c}jgjf} }qcf~'

`c}jm if}b Jfk`i~l ay }lj Cdklcfi~}cf Cfc`y~}~ Fj}{bqe& Cnnbqmifk }b ]lj Kzcqmicf }lj fj{ kzimj`ifj~ ~}c}j }lc} ‐}jc~ifk lcqc~~

gjf} cfm ajc}ifk bd {bgjf‗ {i}lbz} hz~}idinc}ibf ̀ cim bz} if ^lcqic `c{ {bz`m aj pqbliai}jm&

I

]lj [bq`m Dbbm _qbkqcggj ,[D_) cfm Cdklcf kbt'

jqfgjf}’~ Gifi~}qy dbq Qzqc` Qjlcai`i}c}ibf cfm Mjtj`'

bpgjf} ,GQQM) mi~}qiaz}jm 3;?? }bffj~ bd kqcif~  }b

=??? pbbq dcgi`ij~ if Hb{xhcf  pqbtifnj if fbq}ljqf

Cdklcfi~}cf cnnbqmifk }b _chl{be & ^jtjqc` }lbz~cfm

cmmi}ibfc` dcgi`ij~ cqj j|pjn}jm }b qjnjitj dbbm cim mzq'

ifk c ~jnbfm qbzfm bd mi~}qiaz}ibf if }lj nbgifk {jje~&

If cmmi}ibf c Gcmqim'ac~jm bqkcfi~c}ibf MCQC qj'`jc~jm i}~ `c}j~} Lzgcfi}cqicf Qj~pbf~j Ifmj| {linl

qcfe~ if}jqfc}ibfc` mbfbq~ cnnbqmifk }b c qcfkj bd pqif'

nip`j~ qj`c}jm }b jddjn}itjfj~~ cfm cnnbzf}cai`i}y ~cy~

}lj ZF'cddi`ic}jm  If}jkqc}jm Qjkibfc` Ifdbqgc}ibf Fj}'

{bqe & ]lj Ifmj| kctj }bp ~pb}~ }b Fbq{cy Mjfgcqe

^{jmjf Iqj`cfm cfm }lj Fj}ljq`cfm~& ]lj Zfi}jm ^}c}j~

ncgj if c} 3; bz} bd 39 nbzf}qij~ db``b{jm ay @z|jg'

abzqk cfm I}c`y&

Lzgcfi}cqicf Zpmc}j 

8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 3/6

 

3> Gcqnl 1?31 _ckj >

C`}lbzkl }lj pbif}~ gcmj ay }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni` cqj fb} `jkc``y aifmifk _qj~imjf} Ecqxci }b`m _chl{be }lc} }lj ~j} bd kzimj`ifj~ ‐qjp

qj~jf}~ }lj nbzf}qy’~ I~`cgin tij{pbif} cfm c`` Gz~`ig~ bd Cdklcfi~}cf cqj abzfm }b qj~pjn} i}‗& Clgcm ^lcl Ajlxcm c gjgajq bd

}lj [b`j~i Hiqkc ~cim }lc} }lj Z`jgc  Nbzfni`’~ ~}c}jgjf}  ‐i~ ckcif~} }lj nbf~}i}z}ibf ckcif~} lzgcf qikl}~ cfm ckcif~} {bgjf’~

qikl}~‗& Ajlxcm c`~b {cqfjm }lc} _qj~imjf} Ecqxci i~ c} qi~e bd fjk`jn}ifk li~ mz}y }b pqb}jn} }lj nbf~}i}z}ibf& Z^ ^jnqj}cqy bd ^}c}j

Li``cqy N`if}bf }j`jplbfjm _qj~imjf} Ecqxci }b mi~nz~~ }lj gc}}jq cnnbqmifk }b c Z^ kbtjqfgjf} bddinic` ni}jm ay Bz}`bbe Cdklcfi

~}cf& C Z^ ^}c}j Mjpcq}gjf} ~pbej~{bgcf ~cim }lc} _qj~imjf} Ecqxci ‐gcmj n`jcq }lc} }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni` i~ cf cmti~bqy abmy i

mbj~f’} lctj dbqnj bd `c{ cfm }lc} }lj dbqnj bd `c{ if Cdklcfi~}cf i~ }lj Cdklcf nbf~}i}z}ibf‗& 

Fcmjq Fcmjqy c dbqgjq nbggi~~ibfjq bf Cdklcfi~}cf’~ Ifmjpjfmjf} Lzgcf Qikl}~ Nbggi~~ibf ,CILQN) ~cim }lc} }lj Z`jgc

Nbzfni`’~ ~}c}jgjf} gcqe~ c mi~}zqaifk qj}zqf }b }lj `cfkzckj cfm imjb`bky bd }lj ]c`iacf cnnbqmifk }b ]lj Kzcqmicf& ]lj jmin} c`~b

pqbgp}jm gcfy ybzfk Cdklcf~ }b ~}qjcg }b ~bnic` gjmic ~i}j~ }b `cgpbbf }lj qz`ifk~ qjpbq}~ }lj  AAN & Cdklcf a`bkkjq~ qj~pbfmjm }b}lj ~}c}jgjf} cfm gcfy fj{ ~i}j~ {jqj nqjc}jm }b ncgpcikf ckcif~} }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni`’~ jmin}& Lb{jtjq gb~} bd }lb~j {lb lctj

}cejf }b ~bnic` gjmic }b pqb}j~} }li~ {jje cqj dqbg }lj nbzf}qy’~ ybzfk jmznc}jm zqacf j`i}j& If b}ljq pcq}~ bd }lj nbzf}qy }lj qjcn}ibf

{c~ gi|jm& Camz` ^c`cg c ~}zmjf} bd I~`cgin }ljb`bky dqbg ~bz}ljqf Cdklcfi~}cf dbq if~}cfnj ~cim }lc} lj ~zppbq}jm }lj nbggjf}

ay }lj Z`jgc Nbzfni` ‐ajncz~j i} i~ if cnnbqmcfnj {i}l I~`cg‗& 

Gjcf{li`j Cdklcfi~}cf’~ kbtjqfgjf} gcqejm If}jqfc}ibfc` [bgjf’~ Mcy bf

?< Gcqnl  {i}l c kc}ljqifk  c} }lj Gifi~}qy bd If}jqibq if Ecaz` }b qjnbkfi~j

{bgjf’~ nbf}qiaz}ibf }b ~bnij}y ]b`b Fj{~ qjpbq}~& ]li~ jtjf} ncgj c~ }lj

Zfi}jm Fc}ibf~ C~~i~}cfnj Gi~~ibf if Cdklcfi~}cf cfm ZF [bgjf zqkjm }lj

Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} }b  dz``y cfm pqbgp}`y igp`jgjf} }lj `c{ bf J`igifc}ibf

bd Tib`jfnj ckcif~} [bgjf& C 1?33 qjpbq} ay }lj CILQN dbzfm }lc} tib`jfnj

ckcif~} Cdklcf {bgjf i~ bf }lj qi~j&

If qj`c}jm fj{~ Z^   Fc}ibfc` _za`in Qcmib ~cy~ }lc} {bgjf ~jqtifk if }ljCdklcf ~jnzqi}y dbqnj~ qjpbq} dcnifk ~j|zc` nbjqnibf  ay gc`j nb``jckzj~&

‐^bgj {bgjf cqj ajifk pqbgb}jm bf`y id }ljy ckqjj }b kitj ~j|zc` dctbq~‗ 

~cim bfj djgc`j bddinjq& ]lj `jtj` bd ~j|zc` caz~j if }lj ~jnzqi}y dbqnj~ `jctj~

~bgj {bgjf }bb c~lcgjm }b cmgi} }lc} }ljy cqj gjgajq~ bd }lj Cdklcf Fc'

}ibfc` _b`inj ,CF_)& C djgc`j CF_ gjgajq ni}jm if }lj cq}in`j }b`m bd bfj

if~}cfnj if {linl c kqbzp bd gjf aqbej if}b ljq lbz~j cfm qcpjm ljq qjpjc}jm`y if dqbf} bd ljq ~gc`` nli`mqjf& ]lj {bgcf qjnbkfi~jm

~bgj bd }ljg c~ pb`inj cfm qjdqcifjm dqbg qjpbq}ifk }lj ifnimjf} dbq djcq bd pza`in mi~kqcnj cfm ajncz~j ~lj aj`ijtj~ }lj pb`inj nlijd

c`qjcmy efj{ bd }lj c}}cne& Gjcf{li`j ^cmis ^cmisi }lj ~pbej~gcf dbq }lj Cdklcf If}jqibq Gifi~}qy ~cim }lc} ‐{bgjf pb`inj cqj

{bqeifk n`b~j`y c`bfk~imj }ljiq Cdklcf aqb}ljq~& I }b}c``y qjhjn} cfy qjpbq} }lc} }ljy cqj ajifk caz~jm ay }ljiq gc`j nbzf}jqpcq}~&‗ 

_qj~imjf} Ecqxci lc~ cnnjp}jm c pqbpb~c` dqbg pqbtifnic` kbtjqfbq~ qjkcqmifk }ljiq pcq}inipc}ibf if ncaifj} gjj}ifk~ _chl{be ~}c}j~

Mzqifk c gjj}ifk c} }lj _qj~imjf}ic` _c`cnj }lj kbtjqfbq~ ~lcqjm }ljiq pqba`jg~ {i}l _qj~imjf} Ecqxci cfm ~zkkj~}jm ~}jp~ }b igpqbtj

kbtjqfcfnj c} }lj `bnc` `jtj`& Fcfkcqlcq Kbtjqfbq Kz` Cklc ^ljqxci zqkjm }lj tinj'pqj~imjf}~ }b ti~i} jcnl pqbtifnj }b efb{ }lj

pqba`jg~ dcnifk qj~imjf}~ cfm bddinic`~& Ac`el Kbtjqfbq C}}c Gblcggcm Fbbq ~zkkj~}jm kbtjqfbq~ ~lbz`m aj kitjf gbqj cz}lbqi}ycfm Acgicf Kbtjqfbq Lcaiac ^cqcai ~bzkl} }lj nqjc}ibf bd c ~pjnic` dzfm dbq pjbp`j cddjn}jm ay fc}zqc` mi~c~}jq~& _qj~imjf} Ecqxci

c`~b aqijdjm }lj pqbtifnic` kbtjqfbq~ bf }lj qjkibfc` ~i}zc}ibf pqbkqj~~ bf }lj pqbpb~jm ~}qc}jkin pcn} {i}l }lj Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ cfm li~

qjnjf} }qip }b _cei~}cf&

]lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf} lc~ gcmj pqbkqj~~ mzqifk }lj `c~} yjcq if dikl}ifk mqzk }qcddineifk cfm pbppy nz`}itc}ibf cnnbqmifk }b }lj Z^

^}c}j Mjpcq}gjf}’~ ‐1?31 If}jqfc}ibfc` Fcqnb}in~ Nbf}qb` ^}qc}jky Qjpbq}‗& Cnnbqmifk }b Ckjfnj Dqcfnj'_qj~~j }lj qjpbq} c}}qiaz}jm

gznl bd }lj ~znnj~~ }b ifnqjc~jm ~jnzqi}y cfm }b ‐cf igpqj~~itj mi~p`cy bd  pb`i}inc` {i``‗ ay }lj kbtjqfbq bd  Lj`gcfm pqbtifnj Gb

lcggcm Kz`ca Gcfkc`& ‐]lj~j kcif~ qjgcif dqcki`j lb{jtjq c~ nz`}itc}ibf cfm }qcddineifk `jtj`~ cqj n`b~j`y nbffjn}jm }b aqbcmjq

jnbfbgin bppbq}zfi}y ~jnzqi}y cfm }lj kbtjqfgjf}’~ cai`i}y }b pqbhjn} }lj qz`j bd `c{‗ }lj qjpbq} dbzfm&

Gjgajq~ bd Cdklcfi~}cf’~ ~jfc}j, }lj  Gj~lqcfb Hiqkc cnnz~jm }lj kbtjqfbq bd Ecfmclcq pqbtifnj ]bqyc`ci [jj~c bd  gi~cppqbpqi

c}ifk dzfm~ gjcf} dbq mjtj`bpgjf} pqbhjn}~ _chl{be qjpbq}~& Cd}jq dci`ifk }b cppjcq if dqbf} bd `c{gcejq~ c~ ~zggbfjm c ~jfc}bq

cnnz~jm [jj~c bd jgajxx`jgjf} cfm b}ljq dbqg~ bd nbqqzp}ibf cfm mjgcfmjm li~ iggjmic}j mi~gi~~c &̀ ]lj kbtjqfbq’~ bddinj qjhjn}jm

}lj c``jkc}ibf~ c~ ac~j`j~~ cfm ~zkkj~}jm }lc} }lj cnnz~c}ibf~ {jqj if}jfmjm }b pqjtjf} [jj~c dqbg gbtifk dbq{cqm {i}l c ncgpcikfckcif~} i``jkc` ̀ cfm ~jixzqj~&

^jnzqi}y $ Dbqnj _qb}jn}ibf Gcqe Nljnnlic ▸ gcqe&nljnnlicOnigin{ja&bqk

~ gcfy c~ 34 niti`icf~ {jqj qjpbq}jm`y ei``jm btjqfikl} bf 33 Gcqnl ay c Z^ Cqgy ~jqkjcf} G^FAN i~ qjpbq}ifk& Z^ bddinic`~

~cy bf`y bfj ~b`mijq {lb i~ nzqqjf}`y if }lj nz~}bmy bd }lj Z^ gi`i}cqy {c~ iftb`tjm if }lj ei``ifk~& Lb{jtjq ~bgj Cdklcf

ti``ckjq~ if }lj cddjn}jm cqjc ~cy c kqbzp bd ~b`mijq~ {c~ iftb`tjm& ]lj C~~bnic}jm _qj~~ ~cy~ }lj ]c`iacf pb~}jm c ~}c}jgjf} bf

}ljiq {ja~i}j {linl ~cy~ }lc} }lj if~zqkjf} kqbzp {i`` }cej qjtjfkj ‐dbq jtjqy ~ifk`j gcq}yq‗& ]lj ei``ifk~ }bbe p`cnj if _cfh{cyi mi~

}qin} bd  Ecfmclcq pqbtifnj {ljqj }lj ]c`iacf pqj~jfnj lc~ ajjf ~}qbfk cfm {ljqj if}jqfc}ibfc` cfm Cdklcf dbqnj~ lctj ajjf iftb`tjm

C

 Cdklcf pb`inj{bgjf c} {bqe  ^bzqnj8 Hc`i` Qjxcyjj"J_C 

8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 4/6

 

3> Gcqnl 1?31 _ckj =

dbq ~jtjqc` yjcq~& I^CD lc~ ~}jppjm zp ~jnzqi}y bz} bd nbfnjqf dbq qj}c`ic}bqy c}}cne~ cfm }lj Z^ Jgac~~y lc~ {cqfjm Z^ ni}ixjf~ if

Cdklcfi~}cf }b aj bf }lj c`jq} dbq pb~~ia`j qjpqi~c`&

^i| Aqi}i~l }qbbp~ {jqj ei``jm if cf j|p`b~ibf if Ecfmclcq pqbtifnj ]lj Kzcqmicf qjpbq}~& ]lj ~b`mijq~ qjpbq}jm`y {jqj pc}qb``ifk if

c 1:'}bffj [cqqibq cqgbzqjm tjlin`j , pin}zqjm aj`b{)& ]lj  AAN qjpbq}jm }lj j|p`b~ibf gcy lctj ajjf ncz~jm ay c   qbcm~imj abga

qjnjf}`y igp`cf}jm ay if~zqkjf}~ bq i} gcy lctj li} c gifj qjgfcf} dqbg }lj ^btij} jqc&

Cdklcf ~b`mijq~ cqj fb{ ‐}lj diq~} dbqnj~ }lqbzkl }lj mbbq‗ if fikl} qcim~ }cqkj}ifk

likl'tc`zj if~zqkjf}~ cnnbqmifk }b Z^ Cmgiqc` [i``icg GnQctjf nbggcfmjq bd 

Z^ ^pjnic` Bpjqc}ibf~ Nbggcfm& GnQctjf }j~}idyifk ajdbqj }lj Z^ ^jfc}j

Cqgjm ^jqtinj~ Nbggi}}jj i}jqc}jm }lc} fikl} qcim~ cqj j~~jf}ic` if dikl}ifk }lj

if~zqkjf}~ cfm pb~j `j~~ mcfkjq }b `bnc` ti``ckjq~ if }lj cqjc&  If }lj pc~} fikl}

qcim~ lctj ajjf nqi}ini~jm ay _qj~imjf} Lcgim Ecqxci cfm b}ljq Cdklcf `jcmjq~

{lb ~cy }ljy `jcm }b niti`icf mjc}l~ cfm tib`c}j Cd klcf~’ pqitcny qjpbq}~ Zfi}jm 

_qj~~ If}jqfc}ibfc`& GnQctjf c~~jq}~ }lc} p`cnifk Cdklcf dbqnj~ if }lj `jcm lc~

lj`pjm }b nc`g }lj ~i}zc}ibf cfm pjbp`j’~ cf|ij}ij~&

Z^ cz}lbqi}ij~ cqj iftj~}ikc}ifk c``jkc}ibf~ }lc} ~bgj Cdklcf Ciq Dbqnj ,CCD)

pjq~bffj` cqj z~ifk CCD c~~j}~ }b  gbtj mqzk~ cfm {jcpbf~ cqbzfm }lj nbzf}qy

cnnbqmifk }b  Qjz}jq~& ‐Cz}lbqi}ij~ cqj }qyifk }b mj}jqgifj {lj}ljq }lj c``jkc}ibf~

{cqqcf} c dz`` iftj~}ikc}ibf‗, ~cim c ~pbej~gcf dbq }lj FC]B ]qcififk Gi~~ibf'Cdklcfi~}cf ,F]G'C) {linl }qcif~ cfm pqbtimj~

difcfnic` ~zppbq} }b }lj CCD& ]lj [c`` ^}qjj} Hbzqfc` {linl diq~} aqbej }lj ~}bqy ~cim }lj iftj~}ikc}ibf i~ c`~b `bbeifk if}b {lj}ljq

}lj ei``ifk bd jikl} Z^ Ciq Dbqnj pjq~bffj` ay cf CCD bddinjq if Cpqi` 1?33 {c~ qj`c}jm }b CCD iftb`tjgjf} if }qcddineifk& Gb~} bd

}lj jikl} tin}ig~ lcm ajjf pcq} bd }lj }jcg iftj~}ikc}ifk mqzk' cfm kzf'qzffifk c``jkc}ibf~ ckcif~} }lj CCD&

]lj Cdklcf _za`in _qb}jn}ibf Dbqnj ,C__D) c~ bd ?9 Gcqnl lc~ ~ikfjm ~jtjf nbf}qcn}~ {i}l bqkcfi~c}ibf~ qjsziqifk i}~ ~jnzqi}y ~jq'tinj~ cnnbqmifk }b cf F]G'C pqj~~ qj`jc~j& Dzq}ljq nbf}qcn}~ dbq }lj C__D cqj c`~b qjpbq}jm`y fjcqifk nbgp`j}ibf& If cnnbqmcfnj

{i}l _qj~imjf}ic` Mjnqjj 41 {linl {c~ i~~zjm ay _qj~imjf} Ecqxci if Czkz~} 1?3? }lj C__D i~ c~~zgifk qj~pbf~iai`i}y dbq ~jnzqi}y

~jqtinj~ if Cdklcfi~}cf dqbg pqitc}j ~jnzqi}y nbgpcfij~ ,~jj NDN ]ljgc}in Qjpbq}  ‐_qitc}j ^jnzqi}y Nbgpcfij~ Kitj [cy }b }lj

 Cdklcf _za`in _qb}jn}ibf Dbqnj‗  Bn}bajq 1?33)& ]lj C__D i~ nzqqjf}`y dbnz~ifk bf c~~zgp}ibf bd ~jnzqi}y qj~pbf~iai`i}y dbq mjtj`

bpgjf} pqbhjn}~ nbftby~ cfm nbggjqnic` az~ifj~~j~& ]lj C__D {i`` nbf}ifzj }lj }qcf~i}ibf if }lj nbgifk {jje~ ~ikfifk nbf}qcn}~

{i}l gbqj mbgj~}in cfm if}jqfc}ibfc` nz~}bgjq~ cfm }qcf~i}ibfifk gbqj kzcqm~ dqbg pqitc}j ~jnzqi}y nbgpcfij~ }b }lj C__D&

Cdklcf dbqnj~ cfm gjgajq~ bd }lj If}jqfc}ibfc` ^jnzqi}y C~~i~}cfnj Dbqnj ,I^CD) ncp}zqjm ~jtjqc` ]c`iacf if~zqkjf}~ bf ?: cfm ?4

Gcqnl ]b`b Fj{~ qjpbq}~& Cf I^CD ~}c}jgjf} ni}jm ay ]b`b Fj{~ ~}c}jm }lc} }lj }lqjj if~zqkjf}~ }{b bd {lbg cqj mj~nqiajm c~ `jcm

jq~ {jqj ncp}zqjm if c hbif} bpjqc}ibf if Lj`gcfm pqbtifnj bf ?: Gcqnl& Bfj bd }lj `jcmjq~ qjpbq}jm`y miqjn}jm c}}cne~ if Fcm'j C`

mi~}qin}5 }lj b}ljq nbbqmifc}jm cgaz~lj~ cfm qbcm~imj abgaifk~ if Gcqhcl& C dbzq}l if~zqkjf} {lb i~ mj~nqiajm c~ c ]c`iacf dcni`i}c'

}bq {c~ ncp}zqjm ay Cdklcf cfm I^CD }qbbp~ if Ezfmzx pqbtifnj bf ?4 Gcqnl& ]lj dcni`i}c}bq pqbtimjm {jcpbf~ cggzfi}ibf cfm

j|p`b~itj~ }b if~zqkjf}~ }lqbzklbz} }lj pqbtifnj& ]{b cmmi}ibfc` ~z~pjn}jm if~zqkjf}~ {jqj mj}cifjm mzqifk }lj bpjqc}ibf&

Qjnjf} pqjnipi}c}ibf cnqb~~ Cdklcfi~}cf i~ j|pjn}jm }b ajfjdi} }lj pbppy nqbp if ]c`iacf'nbf}qb``jm cqjc~ _chl{be Cdklcf Fj{~ ~cy~

Bddinic`~ bd }lj Cdklcf gj}jbqb`bkinc` ~jqtinj ~cy }lj qjnjf} ~fb{dc`` if njf}qc` cfm fbq}ljqf pqbtifnj~ i~ }lj ljctij~} if 3: yjcq~&

‐]lj ~fb{dc`` cfm nb`m {jc}ljq if middjqjf} pcq}~ bd }lj nbzf}qy, j~pjnic``y if Ecfmclcq, {i`` lctj c kbbm jddjn} bf }lj   pbppy nqbp,‗

}lj Ecfmclcq ckqinz`}zqj miqjn}bq }b`m _chl{be & ]lj bddinic` ~cim }lc} pbppy yij`m~ cqj j|pjn}jm }b ifnqjc~j if cqjc~ nbf}qb``jm ay }lj

]c`iacf zf`j~~ cmmi}ibfc` ~fb{dc`` cqqitj~ }b mcgckj }lj nqbp~ if ~bz}ljqf pcq}~ bd }lj pqbtifnj& C 1??9 qjpbq} pza`i~ljm ay }lj Zfi}

jm ^}c}j~ If~}i}z}j bd _jcnj ~zkkj~}~ }lc} ~}qbfk pbppy yij`m~ lctj nbf}qiaz}jm }b }lj ]c`iacf qj~zqkjfnj if ~bz}ljqf Cdklcfi~}cf&

C} `jc~} dbzq niti`icf~ lctj ajjf ei``jm cfm }jf b}ljq~  ifhzqjm if c a`c~} if Ecfmclcq pqbtifnj bf ?; Gcqnl ]b`b Fj{~ qjpbq}~& ]lj

j|p`b~ibf bnnzqqjm c} c pb`inj nljnepbif} if ^pif Ab`mce mi~}qin} fjcq }lj abqmjq nqb~~ifk {i}l _cei~}cf& Cf Cdklcf pb`injgcf {c~

cgbfk }lj {bzfmjm& Fb kqbzp lc~ yj} n`cigjm qj~pbf~iai`i}y&

Fifj pb`injgjf {jqj ei``jm if Zqzxkcf  pqbtifnj bf ?; Gcqnl {ljf ‐c fzgajq bd ]c`iacf if~zqkjf}~‗ c}}cnejm pb`inj nljnepbif}~

cnnbqmifk }b ]b`b Fj{~& C pqbtifnic` ~pbej~gcf ~cim fifj {jqj ei``jm cfm c }jf}l {lb bddinic`~ aj`ijtj gcy lctj ajjf nbgp`ini} if

}lj ifnimjf} i~ gi~~ifk& ]lj ]c`iacf lctj n`cigjm qj~pbf~iai`i}y dbq }lj c}}cne&

^bnic` $ ^}qc}jkin Ifdqc~}qzn}zqj Qcifjq Kbfxc`jx ▸ qcifjq&kbfxc`jxOnigin{ja&bqk

lj kbtjqfgjf} bd  Hcpcf {i`` nbf}qiaz}j Z^M 1> gi``ibf }b ~zppbq} Zfi}jm Fc}ibf~ Bddinj bf Mqzk~ cfm Nqigj ,ZFBMN) cn'

}iti}ij~ if Cdklcfi~}cf cnnbqmifk }b c ZFBMN pqj~~ qj`jc~j& Z^M 9 gi``ibf {i`` aj z~jm }b ~}qjfk}ljf }lj Cdklcf nqigifc`

  hz~}inj ~y~}jg ifn`zmifk }lqbzkl }lj j~}ca`i~lgjf} bd c dbqjf~in `cabqc}bqy cfm gbai`j mj}jn}ibf }jcg~ }b cim if nbzf}jq

fcqnb}in~ jddbq}~& ]lj qjgcififk Z^M 3= gi``ibf {i`` aj c``bnc}jm }b pqbhjn}~ if Cdklcfi~}cf cfm fjiklabzqifk nbzf}qij~ qj`c}jm }b

~jn}bq~ ~znl c~ `c{ jfdbqnjgjf} qj~jcqnl cmtbncny nqigifc` hz~}inj cfm ljc`}l& ^pjnidinc``y }lj Hcpcfj~j nbf}qiaz}ibf {i`` cim Cd'

]

[cqqibq Cqgbzqjm Tjlin`j ^bzqnj8  Mci`y Gci`"_

8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 5/6

 

3> Gcqnl 1?31 _ckj :

klcfi~}cf Iqcf _cei~}cf cfm ]chiei~}cf if ~}jggifk }lj d`b{ bd pqjnzq~bq nljginc`~ cfm b}ljq i}jg~ z~jm }b nbftjq} Cdklcf pbppij~

if}b ljqbif cfm b}ljq mqzk~&

If cmmi}ibf }lj kbtjqfgjf} bd  Hcpcf lc~ p`jmkjm Z^M 33 gi``ibf }b }lj Zfi}jm Fc}ibf~ _bpz`c}ibf Dzfm ,ZFD_C) }b igp`jgjf} c

~bnibjnbfbgin ~zqtjy if Klbq cfm Mci Ezfmi pqbtifnj~ ~cy~ _chl{be Cdklcf Fj{~& ]lj ~zqtjy {linl {i`` dbnz~ bf pbpz`c}ibf

~ixj kjfmjq ckj gbq}c`i}y aiq}l qc}j~ zfjgp`bygjf} mi~p`cnjgjf} cfm jnbfbgin ~}c}z~ {i`` aj ncqqijm bz} ay }lj Cdklcf kbtjqf'

gjf}’~ Njf}qc` ^}c}i~}in~ Bqkcfixc}ibf if nbfhzfn}ibf {i}l ZFD_C& Dzq}ljqgbqj _chl{be qjpbq}~ }lc} }lj Kjqgcf kbtjqfgjf} {i`

pqbtimj Z^M >31 gi``ibf if mjtj`bpgjf} cim dbq Ecaz` ]celcq Acmcel~lcf Ackl`cf cfm Ac`el pqbtifnj~& Cnnbqmifk }b Cdklcf

Difcfnj Gifi~}jq Bgcq Xceli`{c` }lj gbfjy {i`` aj ~pjf} bf c qcfkj bd ~bnibjnbfbgin ljc`}l jmznc}ibf cfm kbtjqfcfnj pqbhjn}~&

If qj`c}jm fj{~, Cdklcfi~}cf’~ Gifi~}qy bd Difcfnj ~cim }lc} gbqj ~bd} `bcf~ dqbg }lj [bq`m Acfe }lj C~icf Mjtj`bpgjf} Acfe cfm

}lj I~`cgin Mjtj`bpgjf} Acfe {i`` aj qjsziqjm }b igp`jgjf} ejy ifdqc~}qzn}zqj pqbhjn}~ qjpbq}~ _chl{be & Lb{jtjq ^cidzmmif ^ci

lbf cf jnbfbgi~} c} Ecaz` Zfitjq~i}y, ~cim }lc} ‐}ljqj i~ fb fjjm dbq `bcf~ c~ `bfk c~ }lj ncpcni}y bd kbtjqfgjf} mjpcq}gjf} ~ cfm

gifi~}qij~ i~ fb} igpqbtjm‗& ^cilbf fb}jm }lc} ~jtjqc` gifi~}qij~ {jqj zfca`j }b z~j gbqj }lcf =?* bd }ljiq c~~ikfjm dzfm~ `c~} yjcq

mzj }b pbbq ncpcni}y cfm nbqqzp}ibf&

]lj Cdklcf kbtjqfgjf}’~ Ifmjpjfmjf} Cmgifi~}qc}itj Qjdbqg cfm Niti` ^jqtinj Nbggi~~ibf mjnimjm }lc} }lj szb}c dbq {bgjf if

kbtjqfgjf} hba~ {bz`m aj ifnqjc~jm dqbg 1?* }b >?* cnnbqmifk }b _chl{be & Clgcm Gc~~bzm nlijd bd }lj Niti` ^jqtinj Gcfckj

gjf} Mjpcq}gjf} ~cim }lc} {bgjf nbgpqi~j 1?* bd }lj nbzf}qy’~ =????? kbtjqfgjf} jgp`byjj~ cfm }lc} }li~ dikzqj qjd`jn}~ c ~ik'

fidincf} igpqbtjgjf} if qjnjf} yjcq~& Lb{jtjq lj c`~b fb}jm }lc} djgc`j qjpqj~jf}c}ibf {c~ ~}i`` ifcmjszc}j cfm qjd`jn}jm c fzgajq bd

 pqba`jg~ dcnifk {bgjf’~ jgp`bygjf}, ifn`zmifk }ljiq `igi}jm cnnj~~ }b likljq `jtj`~ bd jmznc}ibf& Cnnbqmifk`y Gc~~bzm cffbzfnjm

}lc} ~pjnidin }qcififk nbzq~j~ {bz`m aj cqqcfkjm if dbqjikf nbzf}qij~ if bqmjq }b pqjpcqj Cdklcf {bgjf dbq kbtjqfgjf} hba~&

@iej{i~j }lj Cdklcf Qjm Nqj~njf} ^bnij}y ,CQN^) ~cy~ i} i~ pz}}ifk {bgjf c} }lj njf}qj bd i}~ ljc`}l pqbkqcggj~ cnnbqmifk }b c

pqj~~ qj`jc~j dqbg }lj If}jqfc}ibfc` Djmjqc}ibf bd Qjm Nqb~~ cfm Qjm

Nqj~njf} ^bnij}ij~& ]lj CQN^ qjpbq}jm`y }qcifjm }{b {bgjf {lb cn'nbgpcfijm ay c qj`c}itj }qctj``jm }b qjgb}j cqjc~ if Cdklcfi~}cf }b j|'

p`cif }lj igpbq}cfnj bd iftb`tifk {bgjf if ljc`}l }b nbggzfi}y `jcmjq~&

Z~ifk }li~ cppqbcnl }lj }{b {bgjf imjf}idijm qjnqzi}jm cfm }qcifjm tb`'

zf}jjq~ {i}lif ~jtjqc` nbggzfi}ij~ }lj gchbqi}y bd {lbg {jqj i``i}jqc}j&

]lj~j `bnc` tb`zf}jjq~ cqj mj~nqiajm c~ ajifk ti}c` if }qcf~gi}}ifk ejy

ljc`}l gj~~ckj~ {i}lif }ljiq nbggzfi}ij~ cfm if qjdjqqifk {bgjf }b

ljc`}l n`ifin~ dbq ~pjnic`i~jm }qjc}gjf}&

If cmmi}ibf c fzgajq bd ifmitimzc` ~bnic` cfm ifdqc~}qzn}zqj mjtj`bpgjf}~

{jqj qjpbq}jm ay }lj gjmic mzqifk }lj nbzq~j bd }lj pc~} {jje8

c&  Dbzq gi``ibf Cdklcf abbe~ cqj lj`m zp c} Ecqcnli pbq} qjpbq}~ _chl'

{be & C`}lbzkl }lj _cei~}cfi _qigj Gifi~}jq Yz~zd Qcxc Ki`cfi bq'

mjqjm }lj qj`jc~j bd }lj Cdklcfi~}cf'abzfm nbf}cifjq~ }lj `bnc` bddi'nic`~ c} }lj Ecqcnli pbq} lctj fb} yj} n`jcqjm }lj abbe ~lipgjf}&

a&  C~ gcfy c~ 31 ~nlbb`~ lctj ajjf n`b~jm if Elb~} pqbtifnj mzj }b }lj

~lbq}ckj bd }jcnljq~ qjpbq}~ _chl{be & C`}lbzkl }ljqj cqj jfbzkl

}jcnljq~ if }lj pqbtifnic` ncpi}c` Elb~} ni}y gcfy cqj qj`zn}cf} }b

}qctj` }b qjgb}j cqjc~ }b }jcnl mzj }b }lj `cne bd ~jnzqi}y&

n&  Cppqb|igc}j`y :4??? pjbp`j nbzf}qy{imj >?'=?* bd }ljg {bgjf

lctj nbgp`j}jm tbnc}ibfc` }qcififk nbzq~j~ mzqifk }lj nzqqjf} yjcq

qjpbq}~ _chl{be & ]lj nbzq~j~ ifn`zmjm gbai`j plbfj qjpciq ncq'

pjf}qy }ci`bqifk ncqpj}'{jctifk cfm ajjejjpifk& Cqbzfm <?* bd }lj

}qcifjj~ lctj ajjf ca`j }b difm hba~&

m&  Dzfm~ dqbg }lj Mcfi~l Qjdzkjj Nbzfni`’~ Az~ifj~~ _cq}fjq~lip lctj

difcfnjm nbzq~j~ bf }ci`bqifk dbq ;? {bgjf {lb lctj c`~b qjnjitjm}lj bppbq}zfi}y }b ~}cq} ~gc`` }ci`bqifk jf}jqpqi~j~ if }lj Nlcqcli

Scgajq ~`zg bf }lj bz}~eiq}~ bd Ecaz` qjpbq}~ c Mcfi~l Qjdzkjj

Nbzfni` pqj~~ qj`jc~j& If cmmi}ibf }b }lj }ci`bqifk nbzq~j~ }lj pcq}ini'

pcf}~ c`~b qjnjitjm if~}qzn}ibf qj`c}jm }b `i}jqcny nli`m qjcqifk ly'

kijfj fz}qi}ibf cfm b}ljq i~~zj~&

Jddbq}~ }b difm ~zqtitbq~ bd }lj ctc`cfnlj }lc} azqijm

}lj ti``ckj  bd Mjl _c~lif if ^lcei mi~}qin} bd Ac'

mcel~lcf pqbtifnj bf ?= Gcqnl lctj jfmjm qjpbq}~

_chl{be& ]lj qj~nzj jddbq}~ {jqj pqigcqi`y `jm ay

}lj Cdklcf Fc}ibfc` Cqgy {linl {c~ c`~b iftb`tjm

if pqbtimifk ciq`id} cfm c~~i~}cfnj }b }lj cddjn}jm dcg'

i`ij~ c`bfk~imj }lj Cdklcfi~}cf Fc}ibfc` Mi~c~}jq

Gcfckjgjf} Cz}lbqi}ij~ ,CFMGC)& ]lj FKB Db'

nz~ cfm }lj Cdklcf Qjm Nqj~njf} ^bnij}y pqbtimjm

}jf}~ dbbm cfm {cqg n`b}lj~&

If i}~ gb~} qjnjf} ifnimjf} qjpbq} }lj Zfi}jm Fc}ibf~

Bddinj dbq }lj Nbbqmifc}ibf bd Lzgcfi}cqicf Cddciq~

,BNLC) qjpbq}jm }lc} :? pjbp`j {jqj nbfdiqgjm

mjcm cfm }lc} cfb}ljq 3=? cqj aj`ijtjm }b aj azqijm

zfmjq }lj ~fb{& BNLC pbif}~ bz} }lc} }lj qj~nzj

jddbq}~ c~ {j`` c~ }lj ~jcqnl cfm qjnbtjqy }c~e~ lctj

ajjf cqmzbz~ mzj }b }lj qjgb}jfj~~ bd }lj ti``ckj

cfm }lj {jc}ljq nbfmi}ibf~& ^lcei mi~}qin} lc~ bfj

mbn}bq cfm bfj fzq~j dbq c pbpz`c}ibf bd >????&

Lzgcfi}cqicf Z mc}j 

8/2/2019 CFC Afghanistan Review, 13 March 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cfc-afghanistan-review-13-march-2012 6/6

 

3> Gcqnl 1?31 _ckj 4

‐Cdklcfi~}cf8 Igpqbtjgjf}~ Fjjmjm }b ^}qjfk}ljf Gcfckjgjf} bd Z&^& Niti`icf _qj~jfnj‗& Kbtjqfgjf} Cnnbzf}cai`i}y Bd'

dinj Djaqzcqy 1?31&

‐Cdklcfi~}cf8 ]lj Mjc}l bd c ^}qc}jky‗& Njf}jq dbq ^}qc}jkin cfm If}jqfc}ibfc` ^}zmij~ Djaqzcqy 1?31 ay Cf}lbfy Nbqmj~gcf&

‐^jnzqi}y Dbqnj C~~i~}cfnj if Cdklcfi~}cf8 Imjf}idyifk @j~~bf~ dbq Dz}zqj Jddbq}~‗& ]lj QCFM Nbqpbqc}ibf 1?33 ay ]jqqjfnj

E& Ej``y Fbqc Ajf~clj` cfm B`kc B`iejq&

]lj qjcmifk~ cfm qj~bzqnj~ cabtj {jqj aqbzkl} }b }lj c}}jf}ibf bd }lj NDN ’ ~ Cdklcfi~}cf ]jcg mzqifk }lj nbzq~j bd }lj pc~} ~jtjqc` {jje~& ]lj NDN mbj~ fb} 

jfmbq~j cfy bd }lj~j mbnzgjf}~ bq }ljiq nbf}jf}& Id ybz {bz`m `iej }b qjnbggjfm c qjpbq} bq {ja~i}j dbq }li~ ~jn}ibf bd }lj ‐ Cdklcfi~}cf Qjtij{‗  p`jc~j ~jfm }lj

 di`j bq qjdjqjfnj }b  Cdklcfi~}cfOnigin{ja&bqk& ]lj NDN {j`nbgj~ c`` qjnbggjfmc}ibf~ az} i~ fb} ba`ikjm }b pqif} }ljg& 

Qjkibfc` Jnbfbgin Nbbpjqc}ibf Nbfdjqjfnj bf Cdklcfi~}cf& ]lj did}l Qjkibfc` Jnbfbgin Nbbpjqc}ibf Nbfdjqjfnj bf Cd'

klcfi~}cf ,QJNNC) {i`` aj lj`m if }lj ncpi}c` bd ]chiei~}cf Mz~lcfaj bf 14'1; Gcqnl 1?31& ]lj  nbfdjqjfnj {i`` dbnz~ bf

~}qc}jkij~ dbq jflcfnifk nbggjqnic` nbbpjqc}ibf {i}lif Njf}qc` cfm ^bz}l C~ic cfm ajybfm& _qj~imjf} Lcgim Ecqxci {i`` qj'

 pbq}jm`y aj `jcmifk Cdklcfi~}cf’~ mj`jkc}ibf c} }lj QJNNC nbfdjqjfnj& 

Ckqinz`}zqc` Mjtj`bpgjf} dbq Cdklcfi~}cf _qj'Mjp`bygjf} ]qcififk& ]lj Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ Mjpcq}gjf} bd Ckqinz`}zqj

,{{{&z~mc&kbt) cfm c nbf~bq}izg bd Cgjqincf zfitjq~i}ij~ mj`itjq }li~ }qcififk& ]lj nzqqinz`zg {i`` gjj} }lj fjjm~ bd c`` mj'

p`byifk Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ Kbtjqfgjf} pjq~bffj` if ~zppbq} bd }lj Z^K Ckqinz`}zqj ^}qc}jky if Cdklcfi~}cf& ]lj }qcififk i~ dbq

Zfi}jm ^}c}j~ Kbtjqfgjf} pjq~bffj` cfm {i`` }cej p`cnj if Dqj~fb Nc`idbqfic bf }lj db``b{ifk mc}j~8 14'>3 Gcqnl ?1'?; Cpqi`

cfm 3<'1> Hzfj& _cq}inipcf}~ {i`` aj jfqb``jm bf c diq~} nbgj diq~} ~jqtj ac~i~& Nbf}cn} Qycf Aqj{~}jq Z^ Mjpcq}gjf} bd Ckqi'nz`}zqj c} qycf&aqj{~}jqOdc~&z~mc&kbt dbq dzq}ljq ifdbqgc}ibf& 

Dij`m ^jnzqi}y Gcfckjgjf} Nbzq~j& ]lj Njf}qj dbq ^cdj}y cfm Mjtj`bpgjf} ,N^M) {i`` aj lb`mifk i}~ ‐Dij`m ^jnzqi}y Gcf'

ckjgjf}‗ nbzq~j if Cdklcfi~}cf dqbg 3>'3: Gcy 1?31& ]lj nbzq~j qjpbq}jm`y cmmqj~~j~ }bpin~ ~znl c~ }lj db``b{ifk8 ~jnzqi}y

gcfckjgjf} nbf}j|} cfc`y~i~ qi~e c~~j~~gjf} ~jnzqi}y ~}qc}jkij~ cfm pqbnjmzqj~ nbf}ifkjfny p`cffifk ifnimjf} qjpbq}ifk cfm

}lj mjtj`bpgjf} bd cn}ibf p`cf~& Dzq}ljq ifdbqgc}ibf i~ ctci`ca`j ljqj& 

 Id ybz cqj c NDN cnnbzf}'lb`mjq cfm {bz`m `iej ybzq fb}inj }b cppjcq ljqj p`jc~j ~jfm c`` qj`jtcf} mj}ci`~ }b  Cdklcfi~}cfOnigin{ja&bqk& ]lj NDN i~ fb} ba`ikjm 

}b pqif} cfy fb}inj }lc} i} qjnjitj~ cfm }lj NDN qj}cif~ }lj qikl} }b qjti~j fb}inj~ dbq n`cqi}y cfm cppqbpqic}jfj~~& Cfy fb}inj~ ~zagi}}jm dbq pza`inc}ibf if }lj ‐ Cd'

klcfi~}cf Qjtij{‗ fj{~`j}}jq ~lbz`m aj qj`jtcf} }b Cdklcfi~}cf cfm }b }lj NDN ’ ~ gi~~ibf c~ c efb{`jmkj gcfckjgjf} cfm ifdbqgc}ibf ~lcqifk if~}i}z}ibf& 

Qjnjf} Qjcmifk~ $ Qj~bzqnj~

Cdklcfi~}cf Jtjf}~ Nc`jfmcq 

{{{&nigin{ja&bqk cdklcfi~}cfOnigin{ja&bqk Niti`'Gi`i}cqy Dz~ibf Njf}qj ,NDN) JFKCKJ [I]L Z^