CFA Presentation UVU 2014

37
Extra Space Storage Salt Lake City, February 2014

description

Slides presented by Third Place team in Utah CFA Research Challenge.

Transcript of CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Page 1: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Extra Space Storage

Salt Lake City, February 2014

Page 2: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Main Features• 2nd largest self-storage operator• Largest self-storage management company

Introduction

Wholly-Owned;

51%Joint

Venture; 25%

Managed; 24%

Market Profile52-week Price Range 36.50-49.29

Avg. Daily Volume (3mths)

922,567

Shares Outstanding 111.25M

Market Capitalization 4.85B

% Held by Insiders 5%

% Held by Institutions 95%

FFO Multiple 2013E 23.539

Page 3: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

4166341639

4161441591

4156941547

4152341500

4147841453

4143141408

4138641361

4133941316

4129130

35

40

45

50

55

60

29.2%upside

Target price: $54.44 Upside: 29.2% BUY

Recommendation

Target PriceCurrent PriceClosing Price

Page 4: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Tenant Insurance• 80% profit margin• $10 or $35 for $2,000 or $10,000

coverage, respectively

Management

Lease-up Properties• Avg. sq. ft. occupancy at 82.5% as

of Sept. 2013, up from 73.5%• Redeveloping properties

Big Data

Page 5: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

• Signs of continual aggressive acquisitions• January 8, 2014 announced acquisition of 17 properties in Virginia for

$200 million

Acquisitions

Page 6: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Page 7: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Industry & Competitors

Page 8: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Industry & Competitors

Key self storage marketcharacteristics:• High barriers to entry• Low product differentiation• Lack of substitute products• Internet enables both buyer and seller

Page 9: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Industry & Competitors

Source: FTSE NAREIT U.S. Real Estate Index Series

Source: Cushman & Wakerfield Storage Business Briefing – August 2013

High returns compared to other REITs

Market resilience & increasing rental rates

Page 10: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

EXR vs. Competitors

Competitive Advantage:•Management Team •Extensive stats & analytics

Page 11: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Risk Analysis

Page 12: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Risk Analysis Market Economic

Operational Political

IMPACT

PRO

BABI

LITY

Page 13: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Conditional Upside Drivers

• Constant upward trend of rental prices

• EXR’s occupancy rates for same-store properties were at 88.6 percent compared to the national average of 79.7 percent, according to EXR’s 2012 10k filing

• More acquisitions mean more revenue from tenant insurance

Page 14: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Financial Analysis

Page 15: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• EXR’s stock price follows the SPY with a 67% coefficient of determination.

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

EXR’s Stock Growth Compared to S&P

Page 16: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• Over the last two years, the 100-day stock price moving average is below the 50-day stock price moving average until the effects of the November stock price drop become dominant.

• Long-term the stock has shown strong growth in price.• The stock price is still recovering from the November drop.

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Technical Analysis

Page 17: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• The six month chart shows the possible rebounding from that November drop.

• The 10-day moving average shows that there may be a possibility of a short-term holding profit.

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Moving Averages

Page 18: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Year 31-Dec-08 31-Dec-09 31-Dec-10 31-Dec-11 31-Dec-12 31-Dec-13Assets: Real estate assets, net $ 1,938,922 $ 2,015,432 $ 1,935,319 $ 2,263,795 $ 2,991,722 $ 3,265,292 Investments in real estate ventures $ 136,791 $ 130,449 $ 140,560 $ 130,410 $ 106,313 $ 116,035 Cash and Cash equivalents $ 63,972 $ 131,950 $ 46,750 $ 26,484 $ 30,785 $ 33,600 Restricted Cash $ 38,678 $ 39,208 $ 30,498 $ 25,768 $ 16,976 $ 18,528 Receivables from related parties and affiliated real estate joint ventures $ 11,335 $ 5,114 $ 10,061 $ 18,517 $ 11,078 $ 12,091 Other assets, net $ 42,576 $ 50,976 $ 49,549 $ 52,550 $ 66,603 $ 72,693 Total Assets $ 2,291,008 $ 2,407,556 $ 2,249,820 $ 2,517,524 $ 3,223,477 $ 3,518,239 Growth 11.5% 5.1% -6.6% 11.9% 28.0% 9.1%

Historical data was taken from SEC filings and Internet resources, run through statistical software, and used for forecasting.

became

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Data Conversion

Page 19: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• Total Assets = 20983 + (Years Since IPO x 257534)• Total Revenue = -50060 + (Total Assets x 0.143243)• Net Income = -84716 + (Total Assets x 0.059286)

Asset Regression Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P-value

Intercept 20983.16 243118.3 0.086308 0.933342

Year 257533.7 27096.91 9.504174 1.24E-05

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019$0

$1,000,000

$2,000,000

$3,000,000

$4,000,000

$5,000,000

$6,000,000

Year

Tota

l Ass

ets

(tho

usan

ds)

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Regression Equations for Forecasting

Page 20: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Valuation

Page 21: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Valuation Using FFO

• Constant FFO growth• Market cap projected at 5.619 billion

Years 2013 2014

FFO 199.356 M 239.117 M

FFO Multiple 23.539 23.5

Market Cap 4,687 M 5,619 M

Shares Outstanding 111.250 M 113.750 M

Price Per Share 42.1349.40

Page 22: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Valuation Using FFO

• Arbitrage Opportunities• Historically low cap rates• Increasing interest rates

Page 23: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

NAV Valuation

• Historically low cap rates• Strong rental revenue growth

Year 2013 2014

Rental Revenue 426.841 M 239.117 M

Cap Rates 6.4% 23.5

NAV 5,243 M 6,335 M

Price Per Share 47.1355.70

Page 24: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

Target Price

Target = 54.44

Holding period return = 29%

NAV Valuation FFO Valuation

$55.70 $49.40

80% 20%

Page 25: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Company Overview

Industry & Competitors

Risk Analysis

Financial Analysis Valuation Conclusion

4166341639

4161441591

4156941547

4152341500

4147841453

4143141408

4138641361

4133941316

4129130

35

40

45

50

55

60

29.2%upside

Target price: $54.44 Upside: 29.2% BUY

Conclusion

Target PriceCurrent PriceClosing Price

Page 26: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Questions?

Page 27: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Data Source: Cushman & Wakefield Storage Business Briefing – August 2013

Average Demand per Person

Page 28: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Virtually No New Supply

Page 29: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Source: Adelante Capital Management, Wilshire Associates, and FactSet

Annual Returns: Ranked By Property SectorWilshire US REIT Index

Page 30: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Rental Trends

Page 31: CFA Presentation UVU 2014
Page 32: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 $-

$500,000

$1,000,000

$1,500,000

$2,000,000

$2,500,000

$3,000,000

$3,500,000

$4,000,000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 $-

$1,000,000

$2,000,000

$3,000,000

$4,000,000

$5,000,000

$6,000,000

Total Assets Forecast

Since EXR’s IPO, there has been a steady increase of total assets. In all the regressions run, time showed the most direct correlation with an R Squared of 0.919, t Statistic of 9.5, and P-value of less than 0.0001.

By using the regression model, we were able to forecast total assets using the following equation:Total Assets = 20983 + (257534 x Years since IPO)

Total Assets Since IPO

Page 33: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

The correlation between revenue and assets proved exceptionally high for past periods with an R Squared of 0.99, a t Statistic of 28.34, and a P-Value lower than 0.000000003.

Total

Assets

$748,484

$1,420,192

$1,669,825

$2,054,075

$2,291,008

$2,407,556

$2,249,820

$2,517,524

$3,223,477

$3,518,239 $-

$50,000 $100,000 $150,000 $200,000 $250,000 $300,000 $350,000 $400,000 $450,000 $500,000

Total

Assets

$748,484

$1,420,192

$1,669,825

$2,054,075

$2,291,008

$2,407,556

$2,249,820

$2,517,524

$3,223,477

$3,518,239

$3,626,456

$3,883,989

$4,141,523

$4,399,057

$4,656,591

$4,914,124

$5,171,658 $-

$100,000

$200,000

$300,000

$400,000

$500,000

$600,000

$700,000

$800,000

Revenue Forecast

We were able to forecast Revenue for upcoming years by using the following equation: Total Revenue = -50060 + (Total Assets x 0.143243).

Revenue and Asset Correlation

Page 34: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

Net Income’s Correlation Coefficient in regards to Assets for historical data was 0.9226, t Statistic is 9.766, and P-Value is than 0.00001.

$748,484

$1,420,192

$1,669,825

$2,054,075

$2,291,008

$2,407,556

$2,249,820

$2,517,524

$3,223,477

$3,518,239

$3,626,456

$3,883,989

$4,141,523

$4,399,057

$4,656,591

$4,914,124

$5,171,658

$(50,000)

$-

$50,000

$100,000

$150,000

$200,000

$250,000

Net Income Forecasted $748,484

$1,420,192

$1,669,825

$2,054,075

$2,291,008

$2,407,556

$2,249,820

$2,517,524

$3,223,477

$3,518,239 $(40,000) $(20,000)

$- $20,000 $40,000 $60,000 $80,000

$100,000 $120,000 $140,000 $160,000

Net Income = -84716 + (Total Assets x 0.059286)

Net Income and Asset Correlation

Page 35: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• Regression models similar to the one used for assets were used to forecast liabilities and equity.

• Growth rates were calculated each year, including forecasted years, for assets, liabilities and equity.

• Those growth rates were used to forecast individual accounts within each section of the balance sheet.

• Example: Cash and Cash Equivalents historical data was input, the last reported number was then multiplied by 1+calculated growth rate for assets.

Balance Sheet Equations

Page 36: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• The correlation coefficient for historic operational cash flows and net income is 0.923, t Statistic of 6.9, and P-Value of 0.002.

• Thus, forecasted net income was used to forecast operational cash flows.

• Those forecasted values were used to determine the growth rate for operational cash flows.

• Those growth rates were applied to individual accounts within the operational cash flows section of the Summary of Cash Flows Statement.

Operational Cash Flow Calculations

Page 37: CFA Presentation UVU 2014

• The regression process used to forecast revenue was also used to expenses and income from operations.

• The calculated growth rates from those forecasted accounts was again used to forecast the relevant subordinate accounts.

• Example: 2015 Acquisition Related Expense = forecasted 2014 Acquisition Related Expense x Calculated growth rate for 2015 Total Expenses.

Statement of Operations Calculations