Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all...

23
Central VS Distributed Architecture in utility PV plants

Transcript of Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all...

Page 1: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Central

VS

Distributed Architecture

in utility PV plants

Page 2: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

71%

27%

2%

FIMER INDUSTRIAL BUSINESS UNITS

Solar

Welding

Air cond.

7%

93%

REVENUES FIMER INDUSTRIAL

Domestic

Export

0 50000 100000 150000

Offices 3.800 sqm

Production areas36.000 sqm

Total land area128.000 sqm

HEADQUARTER

Main Figures

“Zero“ CO2

emitted

36.000 m2 Production area

128.000 m2 Total land area

3.800 m2 Offices and facilities

3,560 MW * Solar division production capacity/year

(String Inv. –Central Inv. - Storage Inv.)

150.000 Welding machines/year

420.000 PC Board dpt. production capacity/year

530 Conversion Units/year

15.800 Combiner Boxes production/year

6.200 Air conditioners/year

* 4,120 MW by the end of the year

Page 3: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

0

50

100

150

200

250

2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017

FimerIndustrial

FimerGroup

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

2014 2015 2016 2017

Fimer Group

FimerIndustrial

82,6 Mln € Turnover

Fimer Group

63,5 Mln € Turnover

Fimer Industrial

238 Fimer Group

Employees

195 Fimer

Employees

2017

Main figures

0

0,5

1

1,5

2

2,5

3

2010 2012 2014 2016 2017

PORTFOLIO

OPERATING

O&M

Page 4: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Central Modular Inverter FIMER architecture

VS

Standard Central solutions

Page 5: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

10 Modular Master-Slave

(Fimer VS standard

central solution)

Power Stack parallel

DC&AC side – 1 MPPT

(with internal sync – only way

to erase current leackage to earth)

Fimer VS Standard central arch.

Page 6: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

PlusEFFICIENCY DIAGRAM

MONOLITHIC INVERTER

Eff

P/Pn

100%50%

EFFICIENCY DIAGRAM

4 MODULE INVERTER

Eff

P/Pn

100%50%

EFFICIENCY DIAGRAM

10 MODULE INVERTER

Eff

P/Pn

100%50%

Page 7: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

MPS system (Modular Power System) is a particular architecture for power modules of FIMER inverters

which GUARANTEES HIGHER EFFICIENCY & Energy Production compared to conventional centralized

inverters. This Technology maximize all the advantages of the Central and Distributed configuration.

Thanks to this system our inverters’ power modules switch on gradually PRODUCING ENERGY AT ONLY < 700W

generated by the PV plant.

This means that a FIMER inverter SWITCHES ON EARLIER AND SWITCHES OFF LATER!

The result is that FIMER inverters produce on average 11% MORE than conventional PV inverters.

This highst efficiency means HIGHER GAIN already in the first working years of the machine and warranty period.

The most reliable, competitive and advanced technology available

Modular Power System

Page 8: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Modular Central solutions

VS

String Distributed architecture

Page 9: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

CE

NT

RA

L I

NV

ER

TE

R

General PV plant configurationS

TR

ING

IN

VE

RT

ER

PV PLANT DC CABLE CONNECTIONDC/AC

CONVERSION

AC PARALLEL

CONNECTION

PV PLANT DC

CABLE

CONN.

DC/AC

CONVERSION

AC PARALLEL

CONNECTION

Page 10: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

PV Plant configuration

• MPPT power from 10 kWp up to 100 kWp.

• Big number of MPPT is a plus only in case of not uniform radiation(e.g. roof, local shadow, hot spot dirty).

• MPPT power from 160 kWp up to 1,6 MWp.

• It’s enough to have uniform radiation to have a better performance with a unique MPPT.

- all PV power to a single stack.- low starting threshold.

VS

Page 11: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

DC cable connection/

Combiner box

• Direct connection between PV string and Inverter.

• Energy transport on AC side and AC losses are 150% higher than DC losses.

• Energy transport on DC voltage.

• Simple external combiner box.

• Flexibility of configuration.

VS

Page 12: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

DC/AC Conversion

• Bigger number of inverters/components

(MTBF)

• In case of inverter fault the PV subplant doesn’t produce energy.

• Limited nr. of inverters (4 or 6 per conversion unit).

• In case of fault PV generator the power to inverter is the same (only a clamp of one stack).In case of maximum indication and only in the first years of life of the PV moduls.

VS

Page 13: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

AC parallel connection

• External expensive Panel with two or three level of AC parallel Circuit Breaker. (up to 3,200 A) *very expensive and difficult to be procured

• Losses of these AC boxes are not considered with the inside inverter efficiency.

• Difficult to create a switching syncronism for a big number of inverter paralleled on AC side.

• Direct connection from Inverter to MV-LV Transformer.

• All AC power connection are verified during factory test.

VS

Page 14: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Distributed solutioncritical points in utility PV scale

Page 15: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Minus of ‘distributed’ solutions

AC Distribution

Grid code compliance

Costs

Commissioning time

False mithos and O&M Advantages

Page 16: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

AC Distribution

AC PARALLEL PANEL:

this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side.

AC panel could be splitted in two different types; one

(see picture) close to MV/LV transformer and other

panels for first parallel level distributed on field.

For central solution there is only a point to point

connection between the inverter and MV/LV transformer.

AC LOSSES:

this panel has switches and Circuit Breaker in series to

power flow and this reduce the BOS efficiency.

FAULT PROBABILITY (MTBF):

Higher number of AC connection increases the

probability of fault of PV plant.

Page 17: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Grid Code Compliance

Centralized Inverter:

They’re checked by a PLC conversion

unit that directly controls them with

digital and analog signals (very fast).

String Inverter:

They can only be checked via modbus

or wifi (slow and unsafe bus because of

the adjustment loop).

PREMISE: Connection rules and grid compliances impose much more restrictive constraints to the system

every day. And evry day we are subject to updated of the PPCs.

Very fast response times from external commands (disconnection, power limitation) or digital frequency

control loop (voltage frequency regulation).

Page 18: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Costs

ITEM MODULAR CENTRAL

SOLUTION

DISTRIBUTD SOLUTIONS ITEM

INVERTER 28,500 29,000 INVERTER

CONVERSION UNIT OR

SKIN

(TRAFO + MW SG)

30,700 29,500 LV – MV – TRAFO

+ MV SG

COMBINER BOX 4,500 12,000 LV AC

PARALLEL BOX

BOS 29,740 37,600 BOS

COMMISSIONING 3,700 5,200 COMMISSIONIG

TOTAL SOLUTION 67,400 + 29,740 75,700 + 37,600 TOTAL SOLUTION

€/MWp

Page 19: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Commissioning time

Centralized Inverter: PPC and Scada systems are

wired and tested at the factory, reducing commissioning

time due to Inverter / PPC communication.

String Inverter: Reduced number of DC connections

but increased number of AC side connections.

Page 20: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

False mithos

String Inverter

Weight 70 kg (minimum 2 technician)

Outdoor(any intervention is subject to weather conditions)

Interaction of more than one vendorfor commissioning, O&M & warranties

Longer Commissioning Time

Total setting on plant

Standard Central Inverter

1 module stack (heaviest component) 18 kg (1 technician)

Indoor(any intervention is possible in all weather conditions)

One vendor for all the issues

Shorter commissioning Time

Pre-setting on factory

Page 21: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

O&M Advantages

Modular stacks are indipendently managed from Supervisor Control Unit.

When a fault happens in one stack, the other can work fine.

Power from PV field is managed from the other nr. 9 power stacks.

The only case of convertion power loss is when PV field gives more than 9/10 of nominal power.

LOSS OF PRODUCTION

POWER PRODUCTION DURING ONE FAULT

Time

P

100%

90%

Page 22: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Local Content possibilities

STRING SOLUTION

- Production line of string

inverters only

- Difficulties on implementing,

locally, a reliable production

line for advanced electronic

- All the main components are

out of the SoW of the

inverter manufacturer

- No local people involved in

the plant construction phase

CENTRAL SOLUTION

- Local production of the main

electromechanical

components

- Assembly lines for

Conversion units or skid

- Local production of MV

power transformers

- Local production of

combiner boxes

- Local production of MV

switch gears

- Many people involved during

construction phase.

Page 23: Central VS Distributed Architecture - FEGENSOLAR.COM · AC PARALLEL PANEL: this panel connects all the inverter together on AC side. AC panel could be splitted in two different types;

Thank you for your attention.

Fimer, Inverter for Life