CBTC HPRBsummarypresent 101512 Original Transmittal

7/31/2019 CBTC HPRBsummarypresent 101512 Original Transmittal

1/42

HPRBReview October2012


2/42

DC

Streetcar

System

Plan Citywidesystem

ervesa war s

CurrentlyonPhase2oftheH/Benning Line

urrent y nt ep ann ngp ases ort e ne

CityLine(H/Benning andUnionStationto

Georgetown)and

the

Anacostia

Line

Systemmayrequireupto8carbarns


3/42

CarBarn

Siting

and

Design

Strategy

SummaryOverview

Car Barns History and Program

Evaluation of Potential Sites

Design Principles System and First Site

Preliminary Test Fits

Site Context and S ace Pro ram Guidelines

Car Barn Concept Design Building, Landscape and Infrastructure


4/42

HistoricStreetcar

Car

Barns

in

DC

EastCapitol

Benningand15th

Georgetown

14th St&DecaturNW


5/42

Modern

Streetcar

Car

Barns

CarBarnsprovidelightmaintenance

Tampa,FL(inanhistoricdistrict)

CarBarnscanbedesignedtofitany

neighborhoodcontext

Seattle,WA


6/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)

and

repair

streetcars

trainingcenter,whereDCPSstudentswillbetrainedto

joinadynamicandgrowingindustry(some70US

citieshave,

or

are,

considering

streetcar

systems)

DCCarBarn,1932

JobcreationisapriorityfortheDistrict

TheCarBarnTrainingCenterwillbeaplacetotrain

fortransitjobs

SeattleCarBarn,2011


7/42

Nine(9)SitesEvaluated

AWesternAbutmentoftheHopscotchBridge

BEasternAbutmentoftheHopscotchBridge

FNorthoftheLangstonTerraceComplexbehindPhelps

HighSchool

CEadsStreet

NE

Garage

DBlightedPropertyinthe2000BlockofBenning

Road

HPepcoSite

IOldDCTrashTransferSite

EBenning Road&26th StreetNE


8/42

CBTC

Site

Evaluation

CriteriaREQUIREMENTS

Easilyaccessiblefromthe A3car facility,approximately ConstructibleforaLateFall

Propertycurrentlyownedby

Districtgovernment

,

CapacitytoservetheOneCity

line:three

cars

inside

the

Withinbudget

futurevehicles

Employeespace offices,

,

TrainingFacility


9/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)PreferredSite: SpingarnCampus Benning Road&26th StreetNE


10/42

CarBarnSystemDesignGuidelines

,

,

,

,

DesignofbuildingsforDCStreetcarSystemshouldbesensitivetospecificsitecontextandinsupportofplanninginitiatives:

,

incorporatemixeduse;Alongmoreresidentialcorridors,buildingmaybesetbacktomatchexistingdevelopment

andto

accommodate

a

landscape

buffer.

It

is

not

the

intent

of

the

District

to

design

industrial

buildings

when

that

wouldbeinappropriatetothesite.

Designofbuildingshouldbeofhighestaestheticqualityandshouldpromoteavisionforprogressive,sustainabletransportationandcivicpresence.

Educationalopportunitiesforthetransitandbuildingprogramshouldbeconsideredindesignofthesiteandbuilding.This ma include but are not limited to: rovision of exterior and interior ublic viewin areas. buildin trans arencefficientlanduse,reductionofparking.

Sustainabledesignfeaturesofbuildingandsite(energy,lighting, watermanagementandlandscape)shouldsupporta, , .

Safetyandsecurityconsiderations,includingfencingandlighting,forbothbuildingoperationsandadjacentconditionsshouldbeintegraltothedesignapproach.

Publicartshouldbeintegratedwithsiteandbuildingdesign.

Sensitivedesignofsiteinfrastructure(suchasOCSpolelayout)isrequired.


11/42

CBTC

Design

GuidelinesSpingarnCampus(DraftDevelopedwithDDOT,DCOP,SHPO,NCPC,CFAinput)

Thelandscape/building relationshipisasignificantelementofthecampus.Thedesignofthebuilding

importantviews.

Thearchitecturaldesignofthebuildingshouldbecomplementarywiththehistoriccontext.

Thisdoesnotnecessarilyrequireanhistoricarchitecturalstyle compatibilitymaybeachievedwithacontemporary,sensitiveandappropriateuseofmaterials,scaleandproportion.


12/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)Site: SpingarnHighSchoolCampus Benning Road&26th StreetNE


13/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)oncep ua

es

ng

u es

ConceptualTestFitAStructureSetBackFromBenning Road

ConceptualTestFitBStructureFrontingBenning Road

A


14/42

CarBarn BasicBuildingProgram

BuildingSection

TwoBuildingProgramElements

high)+CarWash

Office/Lockers(2stories)

GroundFloorPlan


15/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)TestFitStudies

Test Fit A Test Fit B

Considerations Access,orientationandpresenceofbuildingtostreetandschool,visibilityofInfrastructure


16/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)TestFitStudies



17/42




18/42



Viewfrom

Benning Road

and

26th St

NE


19/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)Considerations Yard,VehicleTrackStorageandOverheadWires

Seattle,WA Tampa,FL(inanhistoricdistrict)


20/42

Car

Barn

Trainin

Center

CBTCCampusContext FacilityOrientation

Phelps

Spingarn

Brown

Young

Langston Golf Course


21/42

Car

Barn

Trainin

Center

CBTCCampusConcept BalancewithBrownEducationCampusBuilding

Spingarn Brown

CBTC

Langston Golf Course

ProjectOpportunity

Improve26th StNEwithEnhancedPedestrianSafety,CampusGatewaysandHighPerformanceLandscape


22/42

Car

Barn

Training

Center

(CBTC)CampusConcept

Rotatebuildingfootprinttomatchcampus


23/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)TrainingandPublicSpaceProgram DesignGuidelines

1.CreatePublicEntryatCornerofBenning

Roadand

26

th

StNE.

2.Developarchitecturalneighborhood

focusat

corner


24/42

PlanDevelopment FirstFloor&Mezzanine

ExteriorDesign Fenestration&Materials

SiteMaterials


25/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)ConceptualDesignDevelopment FirstFloor

Elevator/OfficeSpacesRelocatedtoEastEnd

a n o y ove o roun oor

CompressorRoomAddedtoFirstFloor

MechanicalSpaces

relocated

to

West

End

CommunicatingStairtoTrainingCenterAdded


26/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)ConceptualDesignDevelopment MezzanineFloor

CompressorRoomRelocatedtoFirstFloor

LockerRoomsRedesignedtoAllowmoreGlazing

AdditionalStorage

Room

Provided


27/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)Conceptual

Design

Development

Ground

Floor

Training

Center

OptionA OptionB


28/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)Conceptual

Design

Development

pt on

East West

Oriented

Light

transoms

from

Option

#1

IncreasedAreaofCurtainwall7Storefront CurvedFaade ncrease n ow reaw near uns a es CurtainWallCantileveredfromSoutheastCorner

CurvedCanopy


29/42

ConceptualDesignDevelopment

OptionB

CurvedSouthFaade

LargestExpanse

of

Translucent

Glazing

ConcaveTrainingCenterFaadeFacingPlazaw/Canopy

StoneBase


30/42

ConceptualDesignDevelopment


31/42

ConceptualDesignDevelopment SiteMaterials

DBTTeamtoprovide:

PHOTOEXAMPLES

OF:

POTENTIALBUILDINGMATERIALS

SITEIMPROVEMENTSSUCHASFENCING

LANDSCAPEFEATURESSUCHASGREENWALLS,BIOSWALES,ETC.


32/42



33/42



34/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)SiteAWesternAbutmentoftheHopscotchBridge


35/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)SiteBEasternAbutmentoftheHopscotchBridge


36/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)SiteCEadsStreetNEGarage


37/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)SiteDBlightedPropertyinthe2000BlockofBenning Road


38/42

CarBarnTrainin Center CBTCSiteEBenning Road&26th StreetNE


39/42

CarBarnTrainin Center CBTCSiteFNorthofLangstonTerraceComplexandbehindPhelpsHighSchool


40/42

CarBarnTrainingCenter(CBTC)SiteGRFKParkingAreaatBenning RoadandOklahomaAvenue


41/42

CarBarnTrainin Center CBTCSiteHPepco


42/42

Car

Barn

Trainin

Center

CBTCSiteIOldDCTrashTransferSite

CBTC HPRBsummarypresent 101512 Original Transmittal

Documents

Transcript of CBTC HPRBsummarypresent 101512 Original Transmittal