-_Etu THE SUPREME COURTSTRTE OF FloR\% .

ROBERT MO(\MMoh\111,PETmowER , CASE Mo.,: S613-383

\/.

STATE of FloR\MRESPONbEMI

OM f\event FROM ßE flR5T bl5TR\CT C00ff OF_{lFPERL 5TATE of FloEi%1M TALLAi¼s2E,FloRifA

PETmowERS Immt. Ju8%\cBoMAL MEF

oUTGOING LEGAL MAIL NPROVIDED TO TAYLOR C.LFØR

MAIUNG ON

í oe Coended sk A»

PeeepFlo%A 3m8

. . . . ... ~IAPJE DE CO¼TEMTS ..__...._

E .

T%LE of CO)KEMTS

TELE DELíWioWS

SWEMEWT' OE fRCT5____.._.___ R

SUMMMY Of E R%LLMEMT 3

GUMENT . . . .

Conctusiou

CERTIFKKfE O SEW\CE O

. . . s_. ...,..... s ... ,.. , . . . --.. . . . . . ... . . . . - .. .. , ... ...- . .... . . ..,, . - - ........s .. ... _ . , , , ..... s, s ... ...........,s..........._. , .. , ,,.+,....... .>,....... ,.,, . . .-- . ,.. ,.. ,.>. - .. s,. . , , -- ... - ,.--. -,.-- --... - . ..-. , ., s...--· +--- -.

. . _. .. . .. ,, . . .. . _.. . . .., ,. . , ., . ... . ,... __ _ . . .. . ..,., . . __ ... , __ _s.. s . . , ., _ ,. _ _. .., , . . .. ,..,,..,,..._._ , . ,,..... . . _ s.. m . ...,......., , s s. .s ,. . ,, .s _. , ,. . . . . .. ,. _ .... , .. .... - . . -.- . , s. . . . , . . . .. -- .

. . . . . . .. . , , . , . s. .. . . .. ...., . . . .. . ,... ... , .. , .. . , _ _ .,. ., . s_ ...,.. ,, . . . ., . . . . . . s . . . ss _ , . . . . _ , , s.. ,.- . . , . . s . . , . _ . . .. . .. ....,. , . . >s. .... - -.. . - - , . . , + , . - s .

._ . , s . . ... .._ _ .... .., . .. . . ., _ .,... ., .. .m....-- .. ...., s- . .. . , . . . .... .. ..... ,. . . .. ,........., .. .. .. . . ,... .. ... . .... m, . .. ,. - - - - . - - . ..-- ... . -,- - , ..._- -- -

. _ . . . ,. . .. ..,. ... . . . . .... , . . . . . . . ... . . _s .._... . .. . s.. . . . ... . - ,s ..... s. ,.... . . . .. . . - , . ,. . ...... . .. m. .. . . . . - - . . - , - - - , - . --

.... . ..... .... . . ...,.... ... --. - , , ......s . . ... . . ., ... , , . . s . . , ,. . - -, ... ., -- .. . -. - ... .,,-...,s. . . . .- ,,.. -.. ... . . . . .- - - as.s ., . - , . . -

.. . , , , ... .. . . . .. . . , , . . - , s . . - ... .. .,,.. . . . -. <- w,- . ... . , . ,.- -, - -, . ..» , - ns . ....,..--.-- - r..-.. , , s .- - - . , ·s +,.· · - . -, --- - -, , - ... .,-·,- - r«, · -+> . -- - - s - .. ··.,..

. . ., . .. .. .. . . ,.. . . . . ,, , . .. ..._... . ....... . . _ . . . .... . .... . ,, . ......... _ ........,. . .. .._ , . .. , . . s ..., , . . . .,...,., . . , . . s,.. . .. .. . . -- - - . - .

a umnaa

CRSES P E

¶\ah u. as s u.s. a s.ct \os,a uL5 es G

._ug. o

u. sh , s . ns (na ) G

blerl!çapd_fess Mu 5 2 L541 2o98,30 L£d,a e (mn) ____________ +

Bmdy v. Many\ad Sn U 1 93 5.Ct \\¶\ to ud.2d. 215 (vie) . a

Lihff \l. A t 5- 593,88 5 - S

LEd. 2d. m na 5

9.a»ø 2. oe e . esctam sue.aQue) G

L,aehm u. a&e±(ownnn) s

odelL.stslat .3 e so 24 %%%gm1 un, mi(Fl4 # DcA MfD

dine»e1 v. shk, aoos wt asgs%! (via»)

oue> vi. Lhnkd S¼e5, 30 U& 95Leo 54t D5,RLfd.

9d.A1LO*©) - - --------- -- , lo

(.ASES RGE

11agg_vd>hio,..36tu.s. e43,el 5.ct 1684, øua.X

toBl Ç%t) . 5

Mooie( V. Ho\oka9, aqq u.5. to3,55 xct34o,79 L.2d.

(%) ~+

Masbo,e v. iMk1 state2 m u.s. 3 Go s ct aø,84L a 3o7 øm) 5

..hhL .x Dept of childsed Janily ksú, ensada ¶%

(tw.# om aoo»)

ObgAA v. ShieJDG so.ad e3 (no. Weca a

endl u. shte, 2% s ad. s» OlA 3%a m3) 5

C. v. Def. oE Childeø4 FAw½ 5ews., 33 SoM3lo,M

la.»oca:2oto) .. . .

R char, v, 4hte3 2% so. ad WL (F¼WI

w v. shte, wt. aaos (tw )________ GShte_a_¼dy,..Hon.xast (0+., o o>rtnel) 4

5tate u, wedik, »s so ao aoa(na 3 me)

e v. vJillians, asy sø.ad wpM. app.a4 oc4 m3) 4

1 o s

I. STATEM&JT OF WT5felitiewee Roberì Mch9Nod¶L, feo'se- Submits +be iwikial duaisddiod Beief to

The fidida Suppere coott h Peuiew ¾e decisi69 of The fiast bisleict court of

AgeAl 5¼¼ of fiosido ßewdead ou Feb«uan$ H, Joi3. The decisio» is wi4bia ¾e

disceeMosaag dutiidic¼s of ¾¡5 ho,esable couet ia accordesce of gu\e 9.o36(4)

(2) (A) (iv) Abo futsuad to Jowe5_v. Uwiled 3htes, %Q U.5. ast, Go 54+

795, 4 L Ed. 2d GW Q%o) and 3ec¼a fi.o41 Boeide Statute., Feliliewee

souc3kt ou Octobee s', Jo)) b3 wo¼e of ¶nely appeA\ (ß: il-Mio)ia ¾e fiest

bishè cooe¥ of agea\ as Dined Agea\ geusey of øe, Judgered cowaic¼a

Awd Sedese oedes ßewdeced oa Septewbee 15,90)\ is ue Eigh¾ Judicia\ ciscuit

Couet, Riackua Couwbt, f)oeida is case wo., ot-aoto-cF-oola43-A (f:Vi\-35)

.1-G5,%). Vek¼ø was AteeAed op Ma3\¶,Jo\0(R:I-ib) awd chaeged

by infecrabod op vag 13,9o10, Coud one- Robbegy wi¾ o fiaeaerg (oud Two-

Agrauakd Asiault wah a deadly weapow, Coud ¾ace-batlegy (R:DG#)

The shte A Hewðed changer a9aiast Pek+iese in opew count ow July 17, 2010,

Coud owe- Robbeey wi¼ a fineaan, Coud Te Aggauakd Ba½ey with a figenen,

Coud Thace- Acha\ po5ressies eE a fisenew to/ao/1ife (R:149, s's)

Peti¼we wi¼ peiuate couwse\ Chaeles \laugha peaceeded to +eint by "Bench

Teini"(tvil- 35f, 351) In condu>ios ¼©tein\ Judge, Fouwd Petitioseg guilhi

and issued a se esce oE., Coud owe-(J5Švea6, Cou4 Two- (15) Sea¢s,

Coud ¾aee-(s ) yenes, couà +wo aal baëe ¾ tuù coexoteed ei}h coud'owe, including A lo yea¢ MiwiwoM Maddabey ew hawced sentence uuden he,

io/Jo/ tire schewe,(ít:\hl-531,540) Os Apeil A aola, Appellate cousselbia»n Johus6A fi\e6 aw Awdees Beief aduisin3¾e c.ogY she saw wo agguab\e

dains e-ffed belou at %e \owee ¼buna\., Puesund 4o F\a.8. A, Puedøse,

setree¼ Feb¼wee was Albwed % submit his owd fFo'se 1»ifial Beief oø

M43 30, Jo\a, aså Raised fiae issues ¼6+ he. be\ieued weøe Megitosious and

Fackalt9 clene ia violatioa or his due peacess Cosstitutional Peoeiows as

5hte. Awd Fedeeal affadea. The issues caisd Specima\\3 weee as fot)ows:

Tsrue owe whehee ¼2 hial Judge, eged ia dewgiw3 %e defesands anewaed

Mo¼a % &»i» tased o» expica¼s of Spee¼ Teial Tine., see Peoe6;I-s¥,

\.

58, 60, GR, foî41, 75, %, B548, 10-95; .I-40-49, 1o3- to 100-113)

(tM-30\) (R;I-l¼-\)5) ".1-96-\39, Na-149) (R;I-302-306)

(R;I-(os,66) (t I- \5»\54, 19-|7à, \73-171, )go-na :pt%;bt

(Ovi- 300-3%') (R:)\- do7, 208). Issue Two~ke¼ee ¾e Teint Judge

egeai is a)\owirg ¡Nfopeß AENiWiod of euidBMe ¥heGeid Oe S NoWi

ideeducel euidesce 4hat caentes a Fabe impeessiew gegasdinj A Maleeial fact,

5ee Bétoed;(\l\\- $1% vridin3tes Boc) $; vf blW14;(s=8) Isuedi3atoe weanesee

.\DI- 420 befe»ve courtsel a½aMow io eesoweous euidesc R.* Vil- 421-923, 438

Co-deteøda R:\í\\-%%-Too, fo3,foi \Jikess feed 5kgoedeg. 15sve Tk nee -

e¼ee the \owee Teibusal egeed iw dewgi»3 the Appe\laAs Motioa to suppaess

euidewe obtaiwed 4keagh A9 uweensortab)e seeech awd Se-izuae fikd ¡» oped

couet ou duwe- R, acto., See Recoed".(vl\\- Ho?, AoB cow»k while in codedq), (Ræd<i

¼¼s 4a suppee»), (CI-T¶ Titia\ coueb oe4ee desgig reh¼ees feo »e edioss to

dbwss, mppess, and co-ed discouee9), (r:.w-ExbibitAde3een e-aa tuisese

• iwuedht coDetted ¼ poiice ow Mag E, amo teow ee¼¡o,ees bone')(R'.\0l-376 Vidin\law Boo desceibe his cash regi,), (R. \h\-43Q-Wi Te*ien oE co-óefeudad

iwce¡na¾-3 fe¼ionee; R:Vi\-44\;(n-¼) Co-defeudad as the peiscipa\ )eadis$

po\ice to euidemes), (R.\l\b¼%-504 Taia\ 4e3+inen of feed sheoeden

adóig the cooet ¾e "Seaf piece oE p\astic, oe cAA gegisles dsewee showa to

w iwuoe snow» p,ee 3 s3 gice nee neie seAech ø-d seizoee os

-lflay \4,20\o was wot +be mee euider«e ,bow to bin dueie«3 feMio,eesteial ow septewiee \Çdo\\, wees skeoedee nhe gave tekism of (e-deterdad ¼adiw3

Po\ice to euide.«e-). Issue fous- whe¾ee %e teia\ couet eesed seueesaki w

bew3in Agel\ads wo¼a 4e cogel dixoueeg, Awd anow:5+).e 34de te connihege

Acts of bissueeg uio\diods., See 9ecoed°. -27-30), (R;1-34,3(o,37),

(C I-59), (t&¼oR40%), (ty)\-94¥¶½¶). Issue fiue,- wheuee

shte Adiows cosshued irysopee and Peasecutoeial W5cowduct., see Receed;I-

(of,6(o) , (CI-6,7), (tI47,Ge), (tP \-5) , (W.Vi\-375:(%o) \fidin

uøø soc +aa µwai, ee,ae41s3 -3 t; a e site $ng),(¢·.1-o7+-30,3a

5'9, 55 v isdkhue Fease:utied þq peosedoe Geooge \aci34)., To vAkk ee Fiest

Diskkt coue¥ oE ogeal is ¾e issh4'cause ow nece bec3,aola issued A pee

CuniAM AffieN, PeMiow¢ fi\ed A woh4 fat seheneig/ Reknein3 Es Basc/oe ¡w

he- A\4etsehe gegued foe A wni+)e4 opiwioA, he DideicY (ough desied he Motiod

Eon 9,ekearing ou Eebeg N ou, Petitiones. 3ubnitlea his adice to iwu6%

Dircae¼uney Jueisdidriod ow Febecaeg QR 900, '%e Dideict Count inued

Pefi¼øet A MA%date foe CA5e No., \Dil@44, LT. Mo., ÔFaol0&OOl»D-A

og Macc¼ 26g The LppeMe Count oE Etoeida Pseuided Ac¥sowledgeMedt of

wew cme % SclHD og ytAech W, Rob, Heseia Petitioca wow subnib

1e 'I4ial Jogisdic¼%el Beief.

II'. _ SUMMM AMUMEMTfekitiome asseeb wheee ½e count fiwds ¾at A MAwifiet isFûe has occused, ¡E it

Appenes to a couet oE cogteur Jueisdic¼a %d a Man is being bilegally genea»ed

of his \ibeekg, it is ¾e Respowsibilih of the cougf to bgush Aside Poewel

teckwicalaties asa issue such appaopeide ogdens As will do duue- See, ½lin

122µ¼ 08 So. Qd ¶\8, i11 (fla ¼%) A5 5uch is ¾e inikst cAre wheneis he

fiest Dideict count of Appeal is oueglooking Poids And facts oE SavJ se9andisS

• Feli+iowess diaect Appeal of he \owet Tribusal MAwiFe:‡ eggoweous Ruling ¡ø

vnola¼a of Peti¼wees Cow*ikhwn) due facce33 Ript And issued * sitest peg

cucciAn Affignasce. 'The, Fiest Dideict weelooked ¾e Petitioseer Gu A-ed

Meat Right to st€edy Teial, a subshdiut gi9hk vahkk ose. ShAll wat be- depei€d,

+ke impeopeg Admissio9 of euidence gaised at ¾e Loweß. Taiwwal Abu of

Disc¢ctiow iw vio\n¼á of ¾e exc\usiosasy psoces5 wheee cuidewe ishoduced

was c\eaely sd evidesce co\ledec{ oei$isally by ¾e po¼e is evidesce +o

which couwel foe beFe%4 objected Af he Reco¢d foe Appellde Reuiew .

AlTo whese- Pe¥i¼weg wM cowuicted os cuidesce obtaised ¼aou9h A ille9al

5eesch Awd seituse iw vio\a¼A oE his Feue¼ AsesíHest eiSht The couet

cwee\ooYea A c\eas 9,ichaedsoa v io\died of discoveeg Abuse is p¢ejadice to

tekitio.a of a n4ee\al Tractual euideKe ¾d was Favogable to Pekitiowen And

Abo of ¾e impsopeg pgosecdocial Miscowduct wheae couwe\ foe defewe

o¶ected to ¼6 FA\re euidewe that c6eded a FAle impre3Sio9 gegnading A

MAÅegiAÌ fact, iwCluded to Oe iwjecfiow of fabgickfioA of po\ice isto ¼6

Affidsi+5 A 9eaue impediMewf opod fe¥¡+iosess cows+ilu¼øal ai9hloE due.

Roce55.

3.

ones tkvi fefifiowet, P8o'se Twilial duci5dictiosal BeieE Adue&¡ The +tial

Cookt vio\akd ¾e Petitiosees Six¼ A Mewdwed eight to speerl †¢ial A suhtautie

¡$ht to which owe 3hall wat be depsiued fouwd is . Shb v, \Jillians, a87 So.

2d 75 (fia AFF. % DC4 193) Aud Applies to s4a,3 by vietue of due

p90cess CÌAuse As he\d by TugweR ¼ Oilif 28% So. ad 384 (f)4 MR \ÜDa

i¶73), %e bueded (5 ou +)e deFendaat to peoue ¼at he was costinous)

Auaiiable foe +Rial by €×ecutis$ A wAlueg of extenditied oE Shadisj gendg to

execule waiuen of ex+sedi+iew (a obeqA:4 v. 5hte, b26 ad. 83 (f¼ 1*

bCA )¶%). The fies+ Dideict (4 bese ciecuwhNces ASp\ief the guide \ist

fac+oes whe¾et A cows+ilu¼sal s peedy +gia\ has occused i w }}.yell ¢ skb

¼ So. ad i¼4, ilR iW1, 1173, t R4 (F)A i 3 DCA 1%2). The burdew (5 o9

the sh+e to peoue Petitioneg is uwauni\ab)e fog trial 5TATE u. NE5RIT,

355 so.ad Roa 3rdta \¶ ¼o¥ Jo.ad 957(f¼ APP

D¢A 490\), Na¼R eaised at the fiest bident Count heøe A geueemi

was Requined A++be Coss+iluthsel vio\atios of Pe+¡+io.gr5 due ¾ess, feti+áge¢

Asseets tha+ af 4k +gial coueY below iMppopeg AdMissio9 of euidence voa3

objected †o RAired op disect Appeal whepe c\eae ¡+se55 +cuiMosy at bee<.h

tRia\ vAs tha++he cuideae isheduced by 4ke 5 5+Ale was not e

euidesce %e po\ice de9aeke,# detec¼es co)ieded ogi<3ise))q into euidewceg

%eueEheleS5 oueR †¢ial codwSels objectiow to 4be eoidence ¾e, tgia\ couet

Allowed (H ua\awu\ Adwissioø, Pe‡i¼sen dieechd 4he fies+ bùhict Couet to

the, Recoeds of %e rhtes euide,e exb¡bàs ¾at clese)q denesskates ¾e

cuidese isboduced at teial is ciens¼ At cour\ick asd egeosews, Peti‡iosee

Cowksds ¾e fisst oideick count of tivyea\ A\.»9 wah +be 5econd biskict

CoueY hay )oss he¼¼at A fisdin3 ¾at evidewe is c)eae Awd coseiscis9

ewveys A Paesuqshow of coenedse,s> asd will wd be oueehewed o Appen

uwless c\ene¼ eeeoseous on \ac¼ euideskeg suppoet see R.C.e ¼

Deç†of chi\deep $ TAniig 5ee.u5, 33 So. ad 3d Vio,114 (flh 3-J DCA Dolo

• Quotis9 td.L. \/. t>e9t oE c¼\dae9 ¶ VAni\g ;ieev 9% so.ad 9%,%

(fi is oca aoo3). rs ne is*ast cA,e reva,ce cosw as a swe, e iiea

inkoduce sub5hdia\ cowpetent euidence to Surrogt its As5eetica that Petitioren

enoued A Pag¼u\ag cmh deawee feen % ¾e Scene of he Robbeey., euecq

MÛegiaÌ EleMetN'of offewE wa5 Mot fwed begoud a geasowable dou

he cuidesce bkgaduced v3AS iwsufficied †o SuppoßY A CowVicfiod 5ee C,A 0

v. 5hte, 213 so.aa B4 (via ¶¾A \%3); Me_weli v. Iht% 210 So.ad ns(FIA V¼ca iv3) The suspece Couer held is Tibb? v. S¼ten 39 so.ad

Hao (FM)%1) That as a egetal FRoposiHow, aw Avvellak couet should set

gek3 A case og geweigh cowE\tcting euidesce subniHed to A jury on othee

giee oE facYea¼ee , the cow¢eP4 og AypeM Must be WheOee,.A fleA All C.NfliCeMs

is the eutdence Awd All 9-esonable iwFece<«es YassNs ¾eaefeen have ipeew

Aeso\ued is fauce of ¾e ueedict aw AvveAl; +bene i3 3ub>tastid, conpeted'

evidesce to suppocY ¾e vetdict A94 d3eMewt AS ley SufficieNCY AIo"® i

¼¢ Appopeinte cowcees of As appe\\de +¢ibowa\. Thi5 cou&+ 5bouid Eisd a

MAwife+ isju»tke has occogged ubese % +gial couet Abøed its dircsetiew

• At¾e impopee evidewce awd wheee ow av9eA\ he Dishick Coud' fe&cuReiAM

AFrieséd he \owee +giwan) Cowuictios owd fd$eHedt'. Pefitiowee Asseds he

as cowichd of euiden© ob¼IN€d thR6ugh IllefÌ 5CAech And seizug6 wheøe

e foue¼ Aneudweat exc\usieuAey aute 5htes that I)\epli9 reized euidence

og wot be. ideoduced isto Evidesce iro +¢¡Al fouwd W \Jeets v. TT AT

23a u.s, 383, 39 54t W, s's L.Ed G5a (m) ; t4Avp v. Ohio ,5 M

U.S. 093, 81 54t ¼84, & L.£d. ad loB1 Ç%)) - The necords sbw wheae

Petihosee Besides he weuee Au%¢ited og cowsenkd to ¼¢ po¼e, but

¼4 se^eck was obtai-ed fooM 1htes wi¼esr who waüs po¼e cc>hdy andes

A geet fog Uw Related MA½eg 5ee- hwgel&_Maslkf.A8o\iwk i 3% ß5

88 54t Ê t?% 90MA ad M 0%B)

U.S. Me, (øo s.ct d66, B4 L.Ed.2d 3C40M) è ¼¢ illeyl seaach and seimbene peexw+19., is 9.epeds to ¾e " ½4¡a9% Petitiaiee hAs A

suf ficient stde in 4 "\ey) CodRoueery" 4hat nequiges a judiCi41 ses6lutiew.

Staudiw9 is "Coustikkiand cees" is paedicated og Ag¼Ìe E£ of ½e

constitu¼w, vubich cowFees jugisdictio os The su½ene Couttaud fedecAl

coda+5., Peti¼wee assec+s he has " 5¼-ding".+o chal\ew9e ¾e illeyl search

Awd seituse of his hoHe fßokhí ¼ the Fouch ANewdwe The Supaene couet eased

S¼udiwg kles ¡% dOMES \l.. L4JITEh 5TATE5g 362 Li.5. 25~7; So S4t. 725 4

Lfd. 2d, G47 (t%o). The clain was apppopdely addaemd ¡w Pgoceah held

below which he dù¼¿t couet euee)coked. PetitioneR is his case &c,hieE is

A cleaR Richaedson violatiow of dixouesy Atou3e And dewial of his due Fgocess

W p¢ejudice- to the Petitiocees deEewse As he date cielibecale¼ v2itheld dit.ay

that was faweaWe to Petitiosee of a staks DVD of wi+wen statewewF the

discoueeg abu>e weegaw+ed impositiews of sa-ctiews See RkhardsoMu, 5%kp%

So.ad W1(flA N71) awd Me Teial Couets failuse to gewain weuha( allowed

¾e Sh+e to violate Pek+icees due psocess in dixoueey vioia¼w3., whese is

hady v. Mae3\and, W3 U.S. 83 54t. 1Ng, lo L.f.d Dd 2W(\%3)peouided ¼at

due faccess gequiges ¾e peosecutoe 4o fuga ouee wateefal hctual euidence ¾a+ ir

fauogable to afeudawT(Bgedy Rule) 008 WL 244 5'%l

(fla 20ØÙ; Robe¢ts v. 5%fe9 w L 230001t (FlA 900%) gheg L

• Shteg 91 So. ad )\BT (AA 2oo6). e fig* Diskict couet ouee\ookd +he

impsepee. pgosecutoeia\ Miscowdu& at the Aeceeds wheae the state was ailowed

ouee defense couwsel objec¼w to ¥wawi.«3½ ¡whoduce fahe euidesce thalceeded

A fabe impRes5iou Rega¢ding a Nefegial fact % Suppewe Cous:Ÿ of florido

specifica\ly uded is d¡cton ¾at A de\ibegate decepties of count awd Joeg

b3 he Paesew¼¼a of teftinewy +o be peejosed voould uiolate ¾e

Pehtiewees due Veece» vpts., also iw M335U.S. às 78

54t 103, 2 L. Ed. 2d. 1 (Ms1) whkh held ¾at due Psocess is V io iated by

iwhoduciw3 euidewce ubick cgente5 A FA\se- iwpgessiod Regnedin$ g mategial

fAc:Y if it vias e¼ited bq ¼« Pease<,utoe wi¼ ¾wowiedge, of its iwaccusacy,

dick is c\eae¼ ¼¢ cMe bene Awd Fiwa\¼ The iujecfiod of tabeicatioa

of Po¼e into ¾e Affidauifs, A genue impedinest spos Petitiewees codithal

Riojhts of due fsocesS ¢equieéd a9 euidestiacq beagig Af %Awks V. DelewaR6,_

% U.5. 15't 48 Mt g(A9, 57 L.Ed.2d (M (1470) bo\d½¼aY if ¾e defe4a.A

denowka%S ¾e po\ice injected \ies into ¾e nFridauit, ¾e defewdant is esuled

È• A heneigg to Psevent euidence to uoid Ag€est. fe¼¾ree anects wheBe he-

€YeCClied his CowdilutiedeÌ gights the ßeconds 5how +fe f8oTecutogs \fiwÁktive

oldwfiod., bhYledge v. 7ec¢¼, 41+ U.S. 21, 44 5 ¿† 2048, 'io L&l.2d 694

H) ANd aehlia¼s of the, FgosecAos ewFøgced 5,,des ewhaweHeats

nPtee" fehWoce e×eccùed his coss+,¼µal e(ps, ne Fgæt;

Aho wespøøsible- Foe ¡»jecta:1 \ies of wi¾enes see nøøg u, y u

U.S. to3,15 5.cy 340, '79 ¿M 791 5

..l_ÈS£S_ PA GE

TugNee v. OllifF, as so.ddle f .App och m3) A

Jeeks v. shk, a3a u.s. 3e cum,sesa(n 5

UTHO8\T\ES PAGE

0304d _. \

og dA StaMes 51. 0

o ed S¼es Co e eds PRGE

s a

s

• a v .

Ÿetitiowee has been C.owuicted ¼eouø a Judicial P¢ocess whick ¡1 Defechue is

Sone fusdenewta\ nespect e$. ¡wcoesect neceipt of euidewe A buse oFExcu\pu\toe9 Peacess on Psoseutoeial e6conduct and vioia¼ø oE Petitiosees

Subdadial due teocess Cows+ikkionai giSbh affeeded and c\eae Mauirest injuece d

law at ¾e inoceduea\ teia\ Egeon, substødiue inc¥ of euideme to suppoet ¾e

vetdict Connu\diue)3. Heee is ¼6 case bebee ¼¡s ¼»eeable Supaene Couer the

Ends of dodice wou¼ wequine, appellde neulew of ¾e necih to which ¾is coud'

has doeirdichod A+ its dizeekiod ouee a99 woM be co\lateeial estoppeis

ot iwuoked hae of Re\ief ubege its App\ica¼s would gesult iw A MawiFes†

iwjustice on wheae owique cieconsh<es Eecoweously effect Petitieweer dve-

Ÿgocess feoubious Awd dewied hu (owdi+u¼wal tights fundaneda\ in østuøe

Awa dunke denawds Qeueesal of he eegoes yawiFesled. To Raae,

Ciecunstawes ¾e appe)\de couet eyeecised its iubeseet au¾och to geant

e ief to nuoid iN¢owgRuouS ArM Mawifeslly UwŸaiR ResuÌfs., Sege

WolkiNg (ou QÑe ÍÑCOÑ¢j€uou$ Nad Oe Ìoweg È9ÎbuwaÌ Allowing Oe

Adwission of euideae ¼¿ was w& Fouwd by +)e Po\ice dektiues to be

Admi½d ido euidewe - weitleg of ¼¢ \wjected fabeicMiod b3 po\ice into

affidauits., ¾eee weøe Meuee any Recoed ¶\\ cails As niiecjed, wo is

CougY idekifìc4ioa by ¾e vidia ¾at Peti¼wee cowuk$ aug cgime, wo

diaet Mdeetal euidew:e liwkiwy Peti+io-ee to ¾e c¢iMe wog ceiMe scewe; Poike

Fabeicnka accest waecadusisj as opes, actioe,, and assi3sed case woubee/

waecad wuwee be\o+«3iw3 to anotkee ofkwieg.(Medal heal¾paied¼hecePetitiewee was taYew to ¾e medal hospihl owig 4e be Retugued as the

1%†i¼l cowcidd evA\udios fetitie.ee was we 4» incompekt p4iekseywene taediw3, bdr ¾e o%ee offewdee who was assiped %e case/wagea»†

du"be% iwc\udiw9 %e ouce whe¼iw3 Pgosecutoeia\ Misconduct- gendegi.«j¾e

TeiA\ A hishial wheae it is appagedly clene. Veti¼wee Reœiued \hudictice.e.ws

FRoTecuhw fog €×eecisiw3 his cowslitu¼wal gi††ad acceid ¾e• e e es..n 5 5edewes For doiwg so. Dueiw9 Öi5 bißÊ Appe4

e.

ewfiRe ŸSocee$iø3 febfiowell f80'Te has denowsteMel 4bis case FøveA5 one

of 4hose UwcoMHoA Awd exfgno¢diseg CitCOMuawce's., Thegeface to Auoid

feli+iod bauip3 4o \i4i94e geisisj succe55iue clains at the dueß ubehiiw3

fuwdaneutnì awd eggegious act3 ja 4be CATC is 9 6 ed of %e iefiliow€£3Subdadi€ Cow•shhhowal due î¢ece33 feo siow.

A5 to we waá s rø«ewr F abee re* e a

de»ial of due %oss. F d +be Petitiewee Anewded I»i¼l Beief waecaselief due to edeeo di aev Cigcunname5 Awd <3iue hix +ke ameded

dudicial oppoeky 9equicip3 +be Ñde to %e5powd Specifkolly to theallega¼ws eni×d m ¥e inhed of Junice denowds tse5ewHg.

espeAfo su¼i¼ed.,

kL1

L NwommEn oATn

E MREBY DECLA EE u&pewa¼ies of pee a+ I±aeeM ÷he fese<plyJ«is&¼alSeieE and cjec¼eeMa!L o.deuts

A ec teue nNd coseet_..

Am-»mpe oaam

7^ÈRTinG)TE Of SER\RŒ .

T HEREBY CEßT\fY hataron ottbis deb&%4 BeieE basbee» fue-Med to Peiwomda s At Ta e c et«¼s4 A w-oc %¢×V

Mailecon to be. Maiied to .

oppa) GeweeAl - PAN boad 5†a e fl}}oesey- Wilk a

wárwno ceTAliaWte, fl ida 323 \do uniueev¼ Aue

Gai e e FL 3360L

Ÿ>y US- Ma AkiS AL_ day of Maech pon.

Robeet Neb su uamLTA@e Coegedicadf-st As9(

$6?LHapç4o4 Tpeisf foodPee¢ÇFlonda 3M%

O