8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

1/13

CAINPFSSEAIHL @VMNF] AGGECF

CAS] FS]EKH]F

Ohivhpu 07, 0280

S) 8>:508s} Cfi}vpu Ras}hl Sfpwecf Hc} ag 0288

Hs apmfpfm pfrap}fm `u }jf Sfih}f Cakke}}ff ai Jakflhim Sfcvpe}u

him Nawfpikfi}hl Hggheps ai Iawfk`fp 5, 0288

SVKKHPU

S) 8>:5 ~avlm cjhinf }jf lh~s }jh} nawfpi }jf arfph}eai ag }jf Vie}fm S}h}fs Ras}hlSfpwecf *VSRS%) Khoap rpaweseais ag }jf `ell ~avlm?

]phisgfp kapf }jhi -88 `elleai ei svprlvs pf}epfkfi} cai}pe`v}eais gpak }jf CewelSfpwecf Pf}epfkfi} him Mesh`ele}u Gvim *CSPMG% }a }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim4

Cjhinf }jf rhukfi}s }jh} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf es pfxvepfm }a khdf }a }jf Ras}hlSfpwecf Pf}epff Jfhl}j @fifge}s Gvim *RSPJ@G%4

Rfpke} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a pfmvcf khel mflewfpu gpak sez mhus rfp ~ffd }a gewf4 Hv}japef }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a aggfp fkrlauffs cpfme} gap hmme}eaihl ufhps ag

sfpwecf hs hi eicfi}ewf }a pf}epf4 him

Pfmvcf rhukfi}s }a kas} gfmfphl ~apdfps pfcfewein `fifge}s vimfp }jf GfmfphlFkrlauffs Cakrfish}eai Hc} *GFCH% him pfgapk }jf hmkeies}ph}eai ag }jh} hc})

Ei hmme}eai, a}jfp rpaweseais ag S) 8>:5 ~avlm hek }a jflr }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf pfmvcf e}scas}s him eicpfhsf e}s pfwfivfs)

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} fihc}ein }jf `ell ~avlm pfsvl} ei agg+`vmnf} shweins ag -06)7 `elleaiawfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam him ai+`vmnf} cas}s }a}hlein h`av} -38)5 `elleai) *VSRS chsjgla~s hpf pfcapmfm ei }jf gfmfphl `vmnf} ei }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim him hpf clhssegefm hsagg+`vmnf}, ~jelf }jf chsj gla~s ag }jf RSPJ@G, CSPMG, him }jf GFCH hccavi} hpfai+`vmnf})%

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

2/13

0

Cak`eiein }jasf fggfc}s, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf if} cas} }a }jf viegefm `vmnf} ag fihc}einS) 8>:5 ~avlm `f -7)3 `elleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam) Hll ag }jasf fggfc}s pfglfc}cjhinfs ei mepfc} srfimein) Ei hmme}eai, ~f fs}ekh}f }jh} fihc}ein S) 8>:5 ~avlm mfcpfhsfpfwfivfs `u -86 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0286 rfpeam) Rhu+hs+uav+na rpacfmvpfs hrrlu`fchvsf fihc}ein }jf lfneslh}eai ~avlm eicpfhsf ai+`vmnf} mepfc} srfimein him mfcpfhsfpfwfivfs)

S) 8>:5 cai}heis ia ei}fpnawfpikfi}hl ap rpewh}f+sfc}ap khimh}fs hs mfgeifm ei }jfVigvimfm Khimh}fs Pfgapk Hc} him ~avlm ekrasf ia cas}s ai s}h}f, lachl, ap }pe`hlnawfpikfi}s)

FS]EKH]FM CAS] ]A ]JF GFMFPHL NAWFPIKFI]

]jf fs}ekh}fm `vmnf}hpu ekrhc} ag S) 8>:5 es sja~i ei ]h`lf 8) ]jf cas}s ag }jeslfneslh}eai ghll ~e}jei `vmnf} gvic}eais 3>2 *cakkfpcf him javsein cpfme}% him

722 *eicakf sfcvpe}u%)

]H@LF 8) SVKKHPU AG @VMNF]HPU EKRHC] AG S) 8>:5, ]JF 08s} CFI]VPU RAS]HL SFPWECF HC] AG 0288

@u Geschl Ufhp, ei Kelleais ag Mallhps

0280 0283 028= 0286 0287 028> 028: 0285 0202 0208 02000280+028>

0280+0200

AGG+@VMNF] CJHINFS EI MEPFC] SRFIMEIN

Fs}ekh}fm @vmnf} Hv}jape}u +6,055 +8,>32 +0,803 +0,37= +3,200 +8,530 +8,522 +8,:76 +8,:32 +8,>57 +8,>7= +87,=75 +06,70=

Fs}ekh}fm Av}lhus +6,055 +8,>62 +0,803 +0,37= +3,200 +8,530 +8,522 +8,:76 +8,:32 +8,>57 +8,>7= +87,=75 +06,70=

AI+@VMNF] CJHINFS EI MEPFC] SRFIMEIN

Fs}ekh}fm @vmnf} Hv}jape}u 82,5=6 3,835 3,388 3,362 3,=>> 8,0>0 8,0:= 8,0:8 8,0:2 8,0>: 8,0>= 06,=5= 38,:58Fs}ekh}fm Av}lhus 82,5=6 3,835 3,388 3,362 3,=>> 8,0>0 8,0:= 8,0:8 8,0:2 8,0>: 8,0>= 06,=5= 38,:58

VIEGEFM @VMNF] CJHINFS EI MEPFC] SRFIMEIN

Fs}ekh}fm @vmnf} Hv}jape}u 6,7=> 8,=82 8,8:5 5:7 =66 +772 +787 +6:= +662 +68: +=52 5,207 7,07:Fs}ekh}fm Av}lhus 6,7=> 8,=82 8,8:5 5:7 =66 +772 +787 +6:= +662 +68: +=52 5,207 7,07:

CJHINFS EI PFWFIVFS

Fs}ekh}fm Pfwfivfs += +6 +6 +8 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 +86 +86

CJHINFS EI SRFIMEIN SV@OFC] ]A HRRPARPEH]EAI

Fs}ekh}fm Hv}japeh}eai Lfwfl 2 38 07 0> 6 +0= +68 +77 +56 +885 +8=7 76 +=80Fs}ekh}fm Av}lhus 2 0> 07 0> = +03 +68 +7> +5= +885 +8=7 70 +=86

Ia}f? Cakraifi}s khu ia} svk }a }a}hls `fchvsf ag pavimein) Gap srfimein, rase}ewf ivk`fps eimech}f eicpfhsfs ei cas}s4 ifnh}ewf ivk`fps eimech}fpfmvc}eais ei cas}s) Gap pfwfivfs, ifnh}ewf ivk`fps eimech}f pfmvc}eais ei pfwfivf callfc}eais)

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

3/13

3

@HSES AG FS]EKH]F

Gap }jf rvprasfs ag }jes fs}ekh}f, C@A hssvkfs }jh} S) 8>:5 ~ell `f fihc}fm fhplu eichlfimhp ufhp 0280) ]jf `ell ~avlm hggfc} av}lhus ag }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim, ~jecj esagg+`vmnf}, him ag }jf RSPJ@G, CSPMG, him GFCH hccavi}shll ag ~jecj hpfai+`vmnf}) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf if} cas} }a }jf viegefm `vmnf} ~avlm }a}hl -7)3 `elleai

awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam) Ei hmme}eai, ~f fs}ekh}f }jh} fihc}ein }jf `ell ~avlm mfcpfhsfpfwfivfs `u -86 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0286 rfpeam *~e}j ia ekrhc} ai pfwfivfs hg}fp0286%)

@hcdnpavim ai VSRS Rhukfi}s gap Fkrlauffs Jfhl}j Eisvphicf him Pf}epfkfi}

]jf galla~ein sfc}eais rpfsfi} `hcdnpavim eigapkh}eai pflh}ein }a }jf khoap rpaweseais agS) 8>:5 }jh} ~avlm hggfc} ras}hl geihicfs)

Ras}hl Sfpwecf A`lenh}eais gap Pf}epff Jfhl}j Chpf) Vimfp cvppfi} lh~, }jf Ras}hlSfpwecf ~ell khdf hiivhl rhukfi}s awfp }jf 0280+0287 rfpeam }a }~a hccavi}s gap pf}epffsjfhl}j eisvphicf rpfkevks) *VSRS srfimein ai }jasf hc}ewe}efs es clhssegefm hs agg+`vmnf})%]jf hnficu ~ell khdf h mepfc} rhukfi} }a }jf ai+`vmnf} Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Jfhl}j@fifge}s *GFJ@% gvim gap cvppfi} pf}epffs) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jes rhukfi} ~ell `f h`av}-0)> `elleai ei 0280, pesein }a -3): `elleai `u 0287)

Ei hmme}eai, awfp }jf 0280+0287 rfpeam, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf es pfxvepfm *vimfp cvppfi} lh~% }akhdf srfcegefm hiivhl rhukfi}s }jh} phinf gpak -6)7 `elleai }a -88)8 `elleai }a }jfRSPJ@G, hi ai+`vmnf} hccavi} fs}h`lesjfm `u }jf Ras}hl Hccavi}h`ele}u himFijhicfkfi} Hc} *Rv`lec Lh~ 825+=36% }a rpfgvim gv}vpf pf}epffs jfhl}j `fifge}s) Vimfpcvppfi} lh~, gvims ei }jf RSPJ@G khu ia} f fzrfimfm gap pf}epffs jfhl}j cas} vi}el geschl

ufhp 028>)

@fneiiein ei 028>, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf ~ell khdf fs}ekh}fm hiivhl rhukfi}s }a }jfRSPJ@G }a cawfp }jf iapkhl cas}s ag rpawemein jfhl}j `fifge}s }a gv}vpf pf}epffs) ]jasfrhukfi}s ~ell f fxvhl }a }jf hiivhl eicpfhsf ei pf}epff jfhl}j chpf leh`ele}efs h}}pe`v}h`lf }acvppfi} fkrlauffs) Ei hmme}eai, }jf hnficu ~ell khdf hiivhl rhukfi}s hkap}efm awfp=2 ufhps }a lexvemh}f }jf vigvimfm leh`ele}u gap pf}epffs jfhl}j `fifge}s) ]jf vigvimfmleh`ele}u es }jf }a}hl leh`ele}u hccpvfm }a mh}f gap pf}epffs jfhl}j fifge}s keivs }jf RSPJ@G`hlhicf }jh} es fxvewhlfi} }a }jf hkavi} }jh} jhs ia} `ffi sf} hsemf }a cawfp gv}vpfleh`ele}efs) ]jasf rhukfi}s ~ell `f fs}ekh}fm `u }jf Aggecf ag Rfpsaiifl Khihnfkfi}

*ARK% `fgapf 028>)

]jf rhukfi}s }a }jf RSPJ@G }jh} hpf pfxvepfm vimfp cvppfi} lh~ hpf sja~i ei }jfkfkaphimvk }a ]h`lf 0)

Ras}hl Sfpwecf Rfiseai A`lenh}eais) Kas} ras}hl fkrlauffs rhp}ecerh}f ei }jf GfmfphlFkrlauffs Pf}epfkfi} Sus}fk *GFPS%, ~jelf sakf ~apdfps ~e}j lainfp }fivpf rhp}ecerh}fei }jf Cewel Sfpwecf Pf}epfkfi} Sus}fk *CSPS%) ]jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf him e}s fkrlauffskhdf rhupall cai}pe`v}eais }a~hpm GFPS him CSPS)

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

4/13=

]H@LF 0) AGG+@VMNF] CJHINFS EI MEPFC] SRFIMEIN VIMFP S) 8>:5

@u Geschl Ufhp, Av}lhus ei Kelleais ag Mallhps

0280 0283 028= 0286 0287 028> 028: 0285

0202 0208 02000280+0200

Cjhinfs ei VSRS Rhukfi}s gapPf}epff Jfhl}j @fifge}s 62: +8,600 +8,786 +8,776 +8,>78 +766 +766 +766 +766 +766 +766 +5,5:=

If} Fggfc} ag ]phisgfp ag SvprlvsPf}epfkfi} Cai}pe`v}eais +6,>22 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 +6,>22

Pfmvc}eai ei Khel Mflewfpu 2 2 +322 +722 +8,062 +8,062 +8,022 +8,862 +8,822 +8,262 +8,222 +:,522

Eicpfhsfm Cpfme}s gap VSRSPf}epffs +82> +08= +086 +82: 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 +7=3

Cjhinfs ei VSRS Rhukfi}s gap^apdfps Cakrfish}eai 2 7 > : +88 +0> +=6 +72 +>6 +58 +825 +35>

]a}hl Agg+@vmnf} Cjhinfs +6,055 +8,>32 +0,803 +0,37= +3,200 +8,530 +8,522 +8,:76 +8,:32 +8,>57 +8,>7= +06,70=

KfkaphimvkVSRSRhukfi}s gap Pf}epff Jfhl}j

@fifge}s

Vimfp Cvppfi} Lh~Fs}ekh}fm Rhukfi}s }a GFJ@ 0,777 0,588 3,8:5 3,=:5 3,>50 2 2 2 2 2 2 87,2=>Srfcegefm Rhukfi}s }a

RSPJ@G h 0,822 6,722 6,>22 6,>22 6,:22 2 2 2 2 2 2 0=,522Fs}ekh}fm Rhukfi}s gap

Iapkhl Cas}s ` 2 2 2 2 2 =,8:8 =,=82 =,768 =,520 6,876 6,==2 0:,>=5Fs}ekh}fm Hkap}eh}eai

Rhukfi}s c 2 2 2 2 2 3,=82 3,=82 3,=82 3,=82 3,=82 3,=82 02,=72

]a}hl =,>77 :,688 :,::5 5,8:5 5,650 >,658 >,:02 :,278 :,380 :,6>6 :,:62 52,867

Vimfp S) 8>:5Fs}ekh}fm Rhukfi} gap

Iapkhl Cas}s 3,8>= 3,37: 3,672 3,>72 3,5>2 =,8:8 =,=82 =,768 =,520 6,876 6,==2 =7,6:8Fs}ekh}fm Hkap}eh}eai

Rhukfi}s 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 0,822 03,822

Sv`}a}hl 6,0>= 6,=7: 6,772 6,:72 7,2>2 7,0:8 7,682 7,>68 >,220 >,076 >,6=2 75,7:8

Cjhinfs ei A}jfp VSRSSrfimein 2 8,600 8,786 8,776 8,>78 766 766 766 766 766 766 82,=50

]a}hl 6,0>= 7,552 >,0>6 >,606 >,:38 7,537 >,876 >,=27 >,76> >,502 :,856 :2,8>3

Cjhinfs ei Rhukfi}s gap Pf}epffJfhl}j @fifge}s 62: +8,600 +8,786 +8,776 +8,>78 +766 +766 +766 +766 +766 +766 +5,5:=

Ia}fs? Cakraifi}s khu ia} svk }a }a}hls fchvsf ag pavimein)

VSRS ; Vie}fm S}h}fs Ras}hl Sfpwecf4 GFJ@ ; Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Jfhl}j @fifge}s gvim4 RSPJ@G ; Ras}hl Sfpwecf Pf}epff Jfhl}j @fifge}sGvim)

h) Ei geschl ufhp 0280, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf es pfxvepfm }a rhu -88)8 `elleai }a }jf RSPJ@G) Ja~fwfp, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf hnficu ~ell f h`lf }arhu ailu -0)8 `elleai)

`) ]jfsf rhukfi}s hpf fxvhl }a }jf hiivhl eicpfhsf ei pf}epff jfhl}j chpf leh`ele}efs h}}pe`v}h`lf }a cvppfi} fkrlauffs)

c) ]jfsf cas}s hpf hsfm ai eigapkh}eai rpawemfm `u }jf Aggecf ag Rfpsaiifl Khihnfkfi})

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

5/13

6

@fneiiein ei geschl ufhp 028>, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf ~ell khdf hiivhl rhukfi}s hkap}efmawfp 0> ufhps }a lexvemh}f hiu vigvimfm leh`ele}u *hs fs}ekh}fm `u ARK% gap pf}epffsCSPS rfiseais `fifge}s) ]jf vigvimfm leh`ele}u es }jf }a}hl leh`ele}u hccpvfm }a mh}f gappf}epffs rfiseai `fifge}s keivs }jf rap}eai ag }jf CSPMG h}}pe`v}h`lf }a Ras}hl Sfpwecfcai}pe`v}eais }jh} es fxvewhlfi} }a }jf hkavi} }jh} jhs ia} `ffi sf} hsemf }a cawfp gv}vpf

leh`ele}efs)

Agg+@vmnf} Cjhinfs ei Mepfc} Srfimein *Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim%

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} fihc}ein S) 8>:5 ~avlm pfmvcf if} VSRS srfimein `u -06)7 `elleaiawfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam4 hs ia}fm h`awf, VSRS srfimein es clhssegefm hs agg+`vmnf})Mf}hels ag cjhinfs ei srfimein gpak }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim hpf svkkhpefm ei ]h`lf 0him mescvssfm ei }jf galla~ein sv`sfc}eais)

Cjhinfs ei Rhukfi}s gap Pf}epff Jfhl}j @fifge}s) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf `ells

rpaweseais }jh} ~avlm cjhinf rhukfi}s }a }jf RSPJ@G ~avlm pfsvl} ei agg+`vmnf} shweinsag h`av} -82 `elleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam, hs mescvssfm `fla~)

Rhukfi}s }a }jf RSPJ@G vimfp S) 8>:5) ]jf lfneslh}eai ~avlm hv}japef }jf Ras}hlSfpwecf, awfp }jf 0280+0287 rfpeam, }a khdf rhukfi}s }a }jf GFJ@ gvim gap cvppfi}pf}epffs jfhl}j eisvphicf rpfkevks gpak }jf RSPJ@G *vimfp cvppfi} lh~, gvims ei }jfRSPJ@G hpf ia} hwhelh`lf gap srfimein vi}el geschl ufhp 028>%) S) 8>:5 hlsa ~avlmflekeih}f }jf cvppfi} srfcegefm rhukfi}s ei}a }jf RSPJ@G gap geschl ufhps 0280 }jpavnj0287) Ei hmme}eai, `fneiiein ei 0280, }jf `ell ~avlm mepfc} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a khdffs}ekh}fm hiivhl rhukfi}s }a }jf RSPJ@G }a cawfp }jf iapkhl cas}s ag rpawemein jfhl}j

`fifge}s }a gv}vpf pf}epffs him fs}ekh}fm =2+ufhp hkap}eh}eai rhukfi}s }a cawfp :2 rfpcfi}ag }jf vigvimfm leh`ele}u gap pf}epffs jfhl}j `fifge}s *vimfp cvppfi} lh~, }jasf rhukfi}s~avlm ia} `fnei vi}el 028>%) ]jf rhukfi}s pfxvepfm vimfp S) 8>:5 hpf sja~i ei }jfkfkaphimvk ai ]h`lf 04 hs mf}helfm ei }jf }h`lfs gaa}ia}fs, C@A mafs ia} fzrfc} }jfRas}hl Sfpwecf }a `f h`lf }a khdf }jf gvll rhukfi}s pfxvepfm ei 0280)

]jf `ells cjhinfs ei rhukfi}s gap pf}epffs jfhl}j eisvphicf rpfkevks ~avlm la~fp }jfRas}hl Sfpwecfs cas}s gap }jasf hc}ewe}efs awfp }jf 0283+0200 rfpeam hs sja~i ei ]h`lf 0*sff kfkaphimvk%) Gap fzhkrlf, vimfp cvppfi} lh~, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf ~ell rhu h }a}hl agh`av} -:)6 `elleai ei 0283, `v} vimfp S) 8>:5, }jf hnficu ~avlm rhu -6)6 `elleai ei }jh}ufhp) C@A hlsa fzrfc}s }jh} la~fpein jfhl}j chpf fzrfisfs ~avlm lfhm }a hi eicpfhsf eia}jfp VSRS cas}s }a}hlein -8)6 `elleai ei 0283 him h`av} -82)6 `elleai awfp }jf 0283+0200rfpeam) ^f fs}ekh}f }jh} fihc}ein S) 8>:5 ~avlm pfmvcf if} VSRS srfimein `u h`av}-82 `elleai awfp }jf 82+ufhp rfpeam) *]jasf rpaweseais hlsa ~avlm hggfc} chsj gla~s ag }jfRSPJ@G, hs mescvssfm `fla~)%

Cjhinfs ei A}jfp VSRS Srfimein) C@A fzrfc}s }jh} la~fpein jfhl}j chpf fzrfisfs ~avlmlfhm }jf hnficu }a kamegu e}s ainaein fggap}s vimfp cvppfi} lh~ }a pfmvcf srfimein) Ghcfm

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

6/13

7

~e}j hi ek`hlhicf ag pfcfer}s gpak ras}hl cvs}akfps him arfph}eaihl cas}s, }jf Ras}hlSfpwecf jhs khmf seniegechi} fggap}s }a pfmvcf srfimein ei pfcfi} ufhps) Gap fzhkrlf, fhpluei 0225, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf hiiavicfm rlhis }a cv} srfimein `u -6)5 `elleai awfp }jf0225+0282 rfpeam) Ovs} h gf~ kai}js lh}fp, ei pfsraisf }a ~apsfiein geihicehl caime}eais,}jf hnficu hccflfph}fm }jf rlhi }a cv} -6)5 `elleai ei 0225 hlaif) Seicf }jfi, }jf Ras}hl

Sfpwecf jhs hiiavicfm }jf rasse`ele}u ag clasein aggecfs, lhuein agg fkrlauffs, him khdeinkhoap pfmvc}eais ei sfpwecf)

C@A fzrfc}s }jh} la~fpein jfhl}j chpf fzrfisfs ~avlm lfhm }jf hnficu }a hl}fp e}scas}+pfmvc}eai rpanphk `u cv}}ein srfimein lfss hnnpfssewflu }jhi e} ~avlm ~e}jav} }jflfneslh}eai) C@A hi}ecerh}fs }jh} fihc}ein }jes lfneslh}eai ~avlm lfhm }jf VSRS }a eicpfhsfe}s if} arfph}eaihl srfimein pflh}ewf }a cvppfi} lh~) ^f fs}ekh}f }jh} }jf if} eicpfhsf eisvcj VSRS av}lhus awfp }jf 0283+0200 rfpeam ~avlm `f h`av} jhlg ag }jf pfmvc}eai eijfhl}j chpf rhukfi}sh`av} -8)6 `elleai ei 0283 him -82)6 `elleai awfp }jf 0283+0200rfpeam)

If} Fggfc} ag ]phisgfp ag Svprlvs Ras}hl Pf}epfkfi} Cai}pe`v}eais) Gap fhcj ag geschlufhps 0288 }jpavnj 0283, S) 8>:5 ~avlm hv}japef }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim }a pfcfewf h}phisgfp ag hiu svprlvs ei }jf VSRS GFPS hccavi} ~e}jei }jf CSPMG hs ag }jf fim ag }jfgeschl ufhp) S) 8>:5 ~avlm rfpke} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a vsf }jf }phisgfppfm hkavi}s }a gvimfkrlauff `vuav} rlhis, rhu agg e}s mf`} }a }jf V)S) ]pfhsvpu, khdf rhukfi}s gap ~apdfpscakrfish}eai `fifge}s, him gap a}jfp fzrfisfs)

ARK fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecfs svprlvs gap e}s GFPS hccavi} ei }jf CSPMG ~hs-88)= `elleai hs ag Sfr}fk`fp 32, 0288) Vimfp }jf `ell, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} -88)= `elleai

~avlm `f }phisgfppfm gpak }jf CSPMG }a }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim ei geschl ufhp 0280) ]jesei}phnawfpikfi}hl }phisgfp ~avlm `f clhssegefm hs h shweins ag -88)= `elleai ei agg+`vmnf}mepfc} srfimein gap }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim ei 0280) *]jes }phisgfp hlsa ~avlm pfsvl} ei hcas} ag -88)= `elleai }a }jf ai+`vmnf} CSPMG hs mescvssfm `fla~)%

Hs ~e}j }jf `ells rpaweseai }a la~fp }jf jfhl}j chpf fzrfisfs, C@A fzrfc}s }jh} }jf}phisgfp ~avlm lfhm }jf hnficu }a hl}fp e}s cas}+pfmvc}eai rpanphk `u cv}}ein srfimein lfsshnnpfssewflu }jhi e} a}jfp~esf ~avlm him }jvs eicpfhsf a}jfp fzrfisfs pflh}ewf }a cvppfi}lh~) ^f fs}ekh}f }jh} }jes eicpfhsf ei a}jfp fzrfisfs ~avlm `f h`av} jhlg }jf -88)= `elleai}jh} ~avlm `f }phisgfppfm-6)> `elleai ei 02804 ~f fs}ekh}f }jh} }jf if} fggfc} ag }jesrpaweseai ~avlm `f h shweins ag -6)> `elleai ei 0280 *hs sja~i ei ]h`lf 0%)

C@A jhs ia `hses gap fs}ekh}ein ~jf}jfp }jfpf ~avlm `f hiu svprlvs ei }jf VSRS GFPShccavi} ei geschl ufhps 0280 him 0283 }a }phisgfp }a }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim)

Pfmvc}eai ei Khel Mflewfpu) S) 8>:5 ~avlm hv}japef }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a mflewfp khelgewf mhus rfp ~ffd, fneiiein ia fhplefp }jhi }~a ufhps hg}fp fihc}kfi}) @fgapf hiu cjhinfei sfpwecf, ja~fwfp, }jf Nawfpikfi} Hccavi}h`ele}u Aggecf *NHA% ~avlm jhwf }a fwhlvh}f

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

7/13

>

}jf geihicehl iffm gap svcj h cjhinf him }jf Ras}hl Pfnvlh}apu Cakkesseai *RPC% ~avlmjhwf }a mf}fpkeif }jh} h pfmvc}eai ei khel mflewfpu ~avlm `f ifcfsshpu gap }jf Ras}hlSfpwecf }a hcjefwf lain+}fpk geihicehl salwficu) Ei hmme}eai, }jf `ell ~avlm pfxvepf }jfRas}hl Sfpwecf }a mfwflar kfhsvpfs }a pfmvcf hiu mesrparap}eaih}f fggfc}s }jh} gewf+mhumflewfpu ~avlm jhwf ai cfp}hei cvs}akfps him cakkvie}efs)

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} pfmvcein khel mflewfpu }a gewf mhus rfp ~ffd ~avlm pfsvl} ei shweins agh`av} -8)3 `elleai `u geschl ufhp 0287) Fs}ekh}fm shweins ei 0286 him 028= ~avlm `fla~fph`av} -722 kelleai him -322 kelleai, pfsrfc}ewfluhs }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecfnphmvhllu eicpfhsfs fggeceficu vimfp }jf if~ mflewfpu sus}fk) @fneiiein ei 028:, ~ffzrfc} }jh} hiivhl shweins ~avlm nphmvhllu mfcleif hs }jasf gvims ~avlm rpa`h`lu f srfi}`u }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf ap pf}vpifm }a khelfps ei }jf gapk ag la~fp ph}fs ph}jfp }jhihccvkvlh}ein hs lhpnf hiivhl svprlvsfs ei }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim) f fs}ekh}f }jh} hiivhlshweins ~avlm ghll }a -8 `elleai `u 0200)

Ekrlfkfi}h}eai ag gewf+mhu mflewfpu vimfp S) 8>:5 ~avlm mfrfim vrai fwhlvh}eais `uNHA him RPC, him ~f chiia} rpfmec} }jf hc}eais ag }jasf hnficefs) Ja~fwfp, ~f fzrfc}}jh} }jfpf es h 62 rfpcfi} cjhicf }jh} NHA him RPC hc}eais ~avlm lfhm }a gewf+mhumflewfpu) ]jf hi}ecerh}fm shweins ag h`av} -8)3 `elleai ei 0287 es `hsfm ai fs}ekh}fsrpfrhpfm `u }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf him }jf RPC, pfmvcfm `u 62 rfpcfi} }a pfglfc} }jfvicfp}hei}u ag gv}vpf hc}eais `u NHA him }jf RPC)8

Eicpfhsfm Cpfme}s gap VSRS Pf}epffs) Gap cfp}hei fkrlauffs ~ja pf}epf `fgapf 0286,sfc}eai 820 ag S) 8>:5 ~avlm hv}japef }jf VSRS }a aggfp cpfme} gap hmme}eaihl ufhps agsfpwecf hs hi eicfi}ewf }a pf}epf) Hs mescvssfm `fla~, }jf rpaweseai ~avlm hggfc} srfimein

gpak }jf CSPMG him ~avlm pfsvl} ei sfwfphl }javshim VSRS fkrlauffs pf}epein awfp }jf0280+028= rfpeam h gf~ ufhps fhplefp }jhi fzrfc}fm vimfp cvppfi} lh~) Awfp }jh} rfpeam, }jfRas}hl Sfpwecf ~avlm khdf la~fp fkrlaufp cai}pe`v}eais }a~hpm pf}epfkfi} him ~avlmsrfim lfss ei shlhpefs him fifge}s) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} rpaweseai ag S) 8>:5 ~avlm shwf }jfVSRS h`av} -7=2 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0286 rfpeam)

Cjhinfs ei apdfps Cakrfish}eai gap }jf VSRS) ]jf `ell ~avlm khdf sfwfphlcjhinfs }a }jf Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Cakrfish}eai Hc}, ~jecj rpawemfs ~hnf him kfmechl`fifge}s }a gfmfphl fkrlauffs ~ja hpf eiovpfm ei }jf cavpsf ag }jfep ~apd)

@hsfm ai eigapkh}eai gpak }jf Mfrhp}kfi} ag Lh`ap *MAL%, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jfcjhinfs rparasfm ei S) 8>:5 ~avlm pfmvcf npass av}lhus vimfp GFCH `u -8)0 `elleai awfp}jf 0280+0200 rfpeam) ]jh} npass shweins ~avlm `f rhp}ehllu aggsf} `u pfmvcfm

8) ]jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf fs}ekh}fs }jh} flekeih}ein khel mflewfpu ai Sh}vpmhus ~avlm fwfi}vhllu pfsvl} ei if} shweins ag -3)8 `elleaihiivhllu, kas}lu ei rfpsaiifl him }phisrap}h}eai cas}s) ]jf RPC fs}ekh}fs }jh} pfmvc}eai ag khel mflewfpu gpak sez }a gewf mhusrfp ~ffd ~avlm shwf ailu -8)> `elleai rfp ufhp) ]jf RPC fs}ekh}fs la~fp if} shweins lhpnflu `fchvsf e} meshnpffs ~e}j }jfRas}hl Sfpwecfs hssvkr}eai }jh} kas} khel cvppfi}lu mflewfpfm ai Sh}vpmhu cavlm `f mflewfpfm ai Kaimhus ~e}j keiekhleicpfhsfm cas}s) RPCs fs}ekh}f }jfpfgapf eiclvmfs h `ennfp fzrfc}fm aggsf} }a }jf npass shweins gap flekeih}ein Sh}vpmhumflewfpefs)

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

8/13

:

pfek`vpsfkfi}s gpak gfmfphl hnficefs, eiclvmein }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf, ag -8 `elleai mvpein}jh} rfpeam, gap if} shweins }a }jf GFCH hccavi} awfp 82 ufhps ag h`av} -022 kelleai)@hsfm ai jes}apechl srfimein rh}}fpis, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} h`av} =2 rfpcfi} ag }jf npassGFCH shweins ~avlm hccpvf }a }jf VSRS, ~jecj, hccapmeinlu, ~avlm rhu h`av}-=22 kelleai lfss ei pfek`vpsfkfi}s }a }jf GFCH hccavi} vimfp S) 8>:5 awfp }jf

0280+0200 rfpeam hs sja~i ei ]h`lf 0)

Ai+@vmnf} Cjhinfs ei Mepfc} Srfimein him Pfwfivfs

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} fihc}ein S) 8>:5 ~avlm eicpfhsf ai+`vmnf} mepfc} srfimein `u-38)5 `elleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam) ]jasf cas}s ~avlm pfsvl} gpak cjhinfs ei }jf chsjgla~s ag RSP@JG, CSPMG, him GFCH hccavi}s hs svkkhpefm ei ]h`lf 3 him mescvssfmei }jf galla~ein sv`sfc}eais)

Cjhinfs ei VSRS Rhukfi}s }a RSPJ@G) Hs mescvssfm rpfweavslu, }jf ell ~avlm cjhinf

rhukfi}s }jh} }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf khdfs gap pf}epff jfhl}j `fifge}s, him C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh}}jasf cjhinfs ~avlm mfcpfhsf if} ai+`vmnf} mepfc} srfimein u h`av} -622 kelleai ei 0280`v} ~avlm eicpfhsf mepfc} srfimein `u h`av} -02)6 `elleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam)]jasf cas}s pfsvl} gpak cjhinfs ei chsj gla~s ag }jf RSPJ@G hs mesrlhufm ei }jfkfkaphimvk }a ]h`lf 34 hs mf}helfm ei }jf }h`lfs gaa}ia}fs, C@A mafs ia} fzrfc} }jfRas}hl Sfpwecf }a `f h`lf }a khdf }jf srfcegefm rhukfi}s pfxvepfm ei 0280) S) 8>:5 ~avlmia} hggfc} }jf if} chsj gla~s ag }jf GFJ@ gvim *hl}javnj vimfp }jf `ells rpaweseais, }jfrhukfi}s }a }jes gvim ~avlm `f khmf av} ag }jf RSPJ@G ph}jfp }jhi }jf Ras}hl SfpwecfGvim%)

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf rhukfi}s }a GFJ@ gpak }jf RSPJ@G ~avlm phinf gpak-0)> `elleai ei 0280 }a -3): `elleai ei 0287) ]jf `ell ~avlm flekeih}f }jf srfcegefmrhukfi}s pfxvepfm vimfp cvppfi} lh~ gpak }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim ei}a }jf RSPJ@G awfp}jf 0280+0287 rfpeam *~jecj }a}hl -0=)5 `elleai%) Ei hmme}eai, S) 8>:5 ~avlm mepfc} }jfRas}hl Sfpwecf, `fneiiein ei 0280, }a khdf fs}ekh}fm hiivhl rhukfi}s }a }jf RSPJ@G }acawfp }jf cas}s ag rpawemein jfhl}j `fifge}s }a gv}vpf pf}epffs) *Cvppfi}lu, rhukfi}s gap}jasf sa+chllfm iapkhl cas}s ~ell ia} `f khmf vi}el 028>)% @hsfm ai eigapkh}eai gpakARK, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jasf rhukfi}s ~avlm npa~ gpak -3)0 `elleai ei 0280 }a-6)= `elleai `u 0200) Vimfp }jf `ell, }jf hnficu hlsa ~avlm khdf fs}ekh}fm =2+ufhphkap}eh}eai rhukfi}s }a~hpm }jf vigvimfm leh`ele}u gap pf}epffs jfhl}j fifge}s fneiieinei 0280 ph}jfp }jhi ei 028> hs vimfp cvppfi} lh~) ARK fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jasf rhukfi}s~avlm `f -0)8 `elleai hiivhllu)

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

9/13

5

]H@LF 3) CJHINFS EI MEPFC] SRFIMEIN GAP AI+@VMNF] HCCAVI]S VIMFP S) 8>:5

@u Geschl Ufhp, Av}lhus ei Kelleais ag Mallhps

0280 0283 028= 0286 0287 028> 028: 0285

0202 0208 02000280+0200

Cjhinfs ei VSRS Rhukfi}s }aRSPJ@G +62: 3,2=3 3,005 3,305 3,600 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 02,=>6

]phisgfp ag Svprlvs Pf}epfkfi}Cai}pe`v}eais 88,=22 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 88,=22

Eicpfhsfm Cpfme}s gap VSRSPf}epffs 63 :2 :8 0> +8 +8 +8 +8 +8 +8 +8 03=

If} Cjhinfs ei GFCH 2 87 8 +7 +== +3> +06 +0: +05 +38 +36 +085

]a}hl Cjhinfs ei

Ai+@vmnf} Cas}s 82,5=6 3,835 3,388 3,362 3,=>> 8,0>0 8,0:= 8,0:8 8,0:2 8,0>: 8,0>= 38,:58

KfkaphimvkRSPJ@G

Fs}ekh}fs

Vimfp Cvppfi} Lh~Srfcegefm Rhukfi} gpak

VSRS h +0,822 +6,722 +6,>22 +6,>22 +6,:22 2 2 2 2 2 2 +0=,522Iapkhl Rhukfi}s 2 2 2 2 2 +=,8:8 +=,=82 +=,768 +=,520 +6,876 +6,==2 +0:,>=5Hkap}eh}eai Rhukfi}s 2 2 2 2 2 +3,=82 +3,=82 +3,=82 +3,=82 +3,=82 +3,=82 +02,=72

]a}hl +0,822 +6,722 +6,>22 +6,>22 +6,:22 +>,658 +>,:02 +:,278 +:,380 +:,6>6 +:,:62 +>=,825

Vimfp S) 8>:5GFJ@ Rhukfi} ` 0,777 0,588 3,8:5 3,=:5 3,>50 2 2 2 2 2 2 87,2=>Iapkhl Rhukfi}s +3,8>= +3,37: +3,672 +3,>72 +3,5>2 +=,8:8 +=,=82 +=,768 +=,520 +6,876 +6,==2 +=7,6:8Hkap}eh}eai Rhukfi}s +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +0,822 +03,822

]a}hl +0,72: +0,66> +0,=>8 +0,3>8 +0,0>: +7,0:8 +7,682 +7,>68 +>,220 +>,076 +>,6=2 +63,73=

Cjhinfs gap RSPJ@G +62: 3,2=3 3,005 3,305 3,600 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 8,382 02,=>6

Ia}fs? Cakraifi}s khu ia} svk }a }a}hls `fchvsf ag pavimein)

RSPJ@G ; Ras}hl Sfpwecf Pf}epff Jfhl}j @fifge}s Gvim4 VSRS ; Vie}fm S}h}fs Ras}hl Sfpwecf4 GFCH ; Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Cakrfish}eaiHc}4 GFJ@ ; Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Jfhl}j @fifge}s Gvim)

h) Ei geschl ufhp 0280, }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf es pfxvepfm }a rhu -88)8 `elleai }a }jf RSPJ@G) Ja~fwfp, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} }jf hnficu ~ell `f h`lf }arhu ailu -0)8 `elleai)

`) Vimfp cvppfi} lh~, }jf GFJ@ rhukfi} ~avlm `f khmf gpak }jf RSPJ@G `fneiiein ei 028>, sa S) 8>:5 ~avlm ia} hggfc} chsj gla~s awfp }jf028>+0200 rfpeam)

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

10/13

82

]phisgfp ag Svprlvs Ras}hl Pf}epfkfi} Cai}pe`v}eais) Hs mescvssfm rpfweavslu, S) 8>:5~avlm }phisgfp }a }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim hiu svprlvs ei }jf VSRS GFPS hccavi} ~e}jei}jf CSPMG hs ag Sfr}fk`fp 32, 0288) @hsfm ai eigapkh}eai gpak ARK, C@A fs}ekh}fs}jh} -88)= `elleai ~avlm `f }phisgfppfm gpak }jf CSPMG }a }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf Gvim ei0280) ]jes }phisgfp ~avlm eicpfhsf ai+`vmnf} srfimein gpak }jf CSPMG `u -88)= `elleai

ei 0280)

Eicpfhsfm Cpfme}s gap VSRS Pf}epffs) Gap cfp}hei fkrlauffs ~ja pf}epf `fgapf 0286,sfc}eai 820 ~avlm hv}japef }jf VSRS }a aggfp cpfme} gap hmme}eaihl ufhps ag sfpwecf hs hieicfi}ewf }a pf}epf) Flene`lf VSRS fkrlauffs ei CSPS cavlm `f aggfpfm vr }a aif ufhp aghmme}eaihl sfpwecf cpfme}, him flene`lf fkrlauffs ei GFPS cavlm `f aggfpfm vr }a }~a ufhpsag cpfme}4 }jasf ufhps ag sfpwecf ~avlm `f vsfm }a mf}fpkeif flene`ele}u gap pf}epfkfi} him~avlm `f eiclvmfm ei }jf chlcvlh}eai ag hiu pf}epfkfi} hiive}u) Fkrlauffs ~ja hccfr} }jfhmme}eaihl sfpwecf cpfme} aggfp cavlm ia} hlsa pfcfewf h walvi}hpu sfrhph}eai eicfi}ewfrhukfi} *chsj `vuav}% hwhelh`lf vimfp cvppfi} lh~)

Hccfr}ein hi hmme}eaihl sfpwecf cpfme} ~avlm `aas} hi fkrlauffs pf}epfkfi} hiive}u `uh`av} 0 rfpcfi}4 ai hwfphnf, }jh} eicpfhsf ~avlm hmm -8,222 }a -0,222 rfp ufhp }a }jffkrlauffs rfiseai) @hsfm ai }jf pfsraisf }a pfcfi} `vuav} aggfps, C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} hpflh}ewflu skhll ivk`fp ag VSRS fkrlauffs ~avlm hccfr} }jf sfpwecf cpfme} aggfp him }jh}e} ~avlm kas}lu hrrfhl }a fkrlauffs ~ja hpf ~e}jei h ufhp ap }~a ag flene`ele}u gap gvllpf}epfkfi})

C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} vimfp }jes rpaweseai mepfc} srfimein ~avlm eicpfhsf `u -03= kelleaiawfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam4 fkrlauffs ~ja hccfr} }jf sfpwecf cpfme} ~avlm fnei pfcfewein

pf}epfkfi} `fifge}s gpak }jf Cewel Sfpwecf Pf}epfkfi} him Mesh`ele}u ]pvs} Gvim fhplefp}jhi vimfp cvppfi} lh~)

]jf rhukfi} ag fkrlauff pf}epfkfi} cai}pe`v}eais khmf ai `fjhlg ag rhp}ecerh}einfkrlauffs ~avlm fim fhplefp }jhi fzrfc}fm vimfp cvppfi} lh~) ]jf rhukfi} ag fkrlauffcai}pe`v}eais }a~hpm pf}epfkfi} hpf pfcapmfm ei }jf vmnf} hs pfwfivfs) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh}fihc}ein S) 8>:5 ~avlm la~fp pfwfivfs `u -86 kelleai awfp }jf 82+ufhp rfpeam `fchvsf agfhplu pf}epfkfi})

Cjhinfs ei apdfps Cakrfish}eai gap Hnficefs A}jfp ]jhi VSRS) ]jf `ell ~avlmkhdf sfwfphl cjhinfs }a }jf Gfmfphl Fkrlauffs Cakrfish}eai Hc}, ~jecj rpawemfs ~hnfhim kfmechl `fifge}s }a gfmfphl fkrlauffs ~ja hpf eiovpfm ei }jf cavpsf ag }jfep ~apd)Rparasfm cjhinfs eiclvmf?

Pfmvcein `fifge}s }a 62 rfpcfi} ag h clhekhi}s rpf+eiovpu ~hnf vrai pfhcjeinpf}epfkfi} hnf *hs mfgeifm ei }jf Sacehl Sfcvpe}u Hc}%4

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

11/13

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

12/13

80

}phisgfppfm gpak e}s GFPS hccavi} ~e}jei }jf CSPMG }a rhu gap fkrlauff `vuav} rlhis*eiclvmein rhukfi}s ag vr }a -06,222 rfp fkrlauff%) E} es rasse`lf }jh} fihc}ein S) 8>:5cavlm eicpfhsf }jf ivk`fp ag fkrlauffs ~ja pf}epf mvpein }jf ifz} sfwfphl ufhps him }jvsla~fp VSRS lh`ap cas}s, `v} C@A jhs ia `hses gap fs}ekh}ein hiu svcj fggfc}s)

S) 8>:5 hlsa ~avlm hv}japef }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a fs}h`lesj h rpanphk }a rpawemf sfpwecfsgap hnficefs ag }jf gfmfphl nawfpikfi} ap }jf s}h}fs gap h gff) Ekrlfkfi}ein }jes rpanphk~avlm pfxvepf }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf }a aggfp cas}+fggfc}ewf hl}fpih}ewfs gap sfpwecfs }a s}h}f apgfmfphl hnficefs) ]jasf rparasfm rpanphks kenj} eicpfhsf VSRS eicakf `v} hlsa ~avlmhmm }a cas}s) C@A jhs ia eigapkh}eai }a rpfmec} }jf if} vmnf} ekrhc} ag svcj if~ wfi}vpfseg hiu ~fpf vimfp}hdfi `u }jf Ras}hl Sfpwecf)

Srfimein Sv`ofc} }a Hrrparpeh}eai

Cjhinfs }a GFCH ei S) 8>:5 ~avlm pfsvl} ei la~fp mescpf}eaihpu cas}s ag h`av}-722 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam }a gfmfphl hnficefs shlhpefs him fzrfisf hccavi}s`fchvsf ag }jf la~fp pfek`vpsfkfi}s }jh} ~avlm `f pfxvepfm) Ja~fwfp, S) 8>:5 ~avlmpfxvepf MAL }a eis}e}v}f him khihnf }jf if~ mesh`ele}u pfwef~s, hrrfhls gpak }jfrpacfmvpfs, him a}jfp pfxvepfkfi}s ag }jf `ell) C@A fs}ekh}fs }jh} ekrlfkfi}ein }jasfrpaweseais ~avlm eicpfhsf srfimein `u h`av} -022 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam,hssvkein hrrparpeh}eai ag }jf ifcfsshpu hkavi}s, pfsvl}ein ei hi fs}ekh}fm if}mescpf}eaihpu shweins ag -=86 kelleai awfp }jf 0280+0200 rfpeam)

RHU+HS+UAV+NA CAISEMFPH]EAIS

]jf S}h}v}apu Rhu+Hs+Uav+Na Hc} ag 0282 fs}h`lesjfs `vmnf}+pfrap}ein him figapcfkfi}rpacfmvpfs gap lfneslh}eai hggfc}ein mepfc} srfimein ap pfwfivfs) ]jf if} cjhinfs ei av}lhushim pfwfivfs }jh} hpf sv`ofc} }a }jasf rhu+hs+uav+na rpacfmvpfs hpf sja~i ei }jf galla~ein}h`lf) Ailu ai+`vmnf} cjhinfs }a av}lhus ap pfwfivfs hpf sv`ofc} }a rhu+hs+uav+narpacfmvpfs)

C@A Fs}ekh}f ag Rhu+Hs+Uav+Na Fggfc}s gap S) 8>:5, }jf 08s} Cfi}vpu Ras}hl Sfpwecf Hc} ag 0288, hs apmfpfm pfrap}fm `u

}jf Sfih}f Cakke}}ff ai Jakflhim Sfcvpe}u him Nawfpikfi}hl Hggheps ai Iawfk`fp 5, 0288

@u Geschl Ufhp, ei Kelleais ag Mallhps

0280 0283 028= 0286 0287 028> 028: 0285 0202 0208

02000280+028>

0280+0200

IF] EICPFHSF AP MFCPFHSF *+% EI ]JF AI+@VMNF] MFGECE]

S}h}v}apu Rhu+Hs+Uav+NaEkrhc} 82,5=8 3,83= 3,327 3,3=5 3,=>> 8,0>0 8,0:= 8,0:8 8,0:2 8,0>: 8,0>= 06,=>5 38,:>7

8/3/2019 CBO Analysis of S. 1789

13/13

83

EI]FPNAWFPIKFI]HL HIM RPEWH]F+SFC]AP EKRHC]

S) 8>:5 cai}heis ia ei}fpnawfpikfi}hl ap rpewh}f+sfc}ap khimh}fs hs mfgeifm ei }jfVigvimfm Khimh}fs Pfgapk Hc} him ~avlm ekrasf ia cas}s ai s}h}f, lachl, ap }pe`hlnawfpikfi}s)

RPFWEAVS C@A FS]EKH]F

Ai Mfcfk`fp 8, 0288, C@A }phiske}}fm h cas} fs}ekh}f gap J)P) 0325, }jf Ras}hl PfgapkHc} ag 0288, hs apmfpfm pfrap}fm `u }jf Javsf Cakke}}ff ai Awfpsenj} him Nawfpikfi}Pfgapk ai Ac}a`fp 83, 0288) ^f fs}ekh}fm }jh} fihc}ein J)P) 0325 ~avlm pfsvl} eiagg+`vmnf} shweins }a}hlein -07)0 `elleai him ai+`vmnf} cas}s ag ->)> `elleai awfp }jf0280+0208 rfpeam gap h if} shweins }a }jf viegefm `vmnf} ag -8:)6 `elleai)

FS]EKH]F RPFRHPFM @U?

Gfmfphl Srfimein? Khpd Nph`a~ecVSRSCjpes}e Jh~lfu Hi}jaiuGfmfphl Fkrlauffs Cakrfish}eaiHk`fp KhpcfleiaVSRS Pf}epff Cpfme}s

Ekrhc} ai S}h}f, Lachl, him ]pe`hl Nawfpikfi}s? Fleh`f}j Cawf Mfleslf

Ekrhc} ai }jf Rpewh}f Sfc}ap? Rhenf Rerfp!@hcj

FS]EKH]F HRRPAWFM @U?

]jfpfsh NvllaMfrv}u Hsses}hi} Mepfc}ap gap @vmnf} Hihluses