Catherine McIlwain ([email protected]) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October...

22
Connections in Action Catherine McIlwain ([email protected]) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012

Transcript of Catherine McIlwain ([email protected]) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October...

Page 1: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Connections in Action

Catherine McIlwain ([email protected])20th Annual Cochrane Colloquium

Auckland, 3rd October 2012

Page 2: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Improving plain language summaries

Supporting consumer involvement

Getting the word out

Cochrane Consumer Connections

Page 3: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Improving Plain Language Summaries

Page 4: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Random sample of 243 plain language summaries (PLS)

24% of the plain language summaries and abstracts didn’t match

*German Cochrane Centre survey– 2004

Quality of Plain Language Summaries

Page 5: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Accuracy of PLS Information

Page 6: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Plain Language Standards

Page 7: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Use of Statistics

Explaining Bias

Quality of Evidence

Imprecision

Standards for Plain Language Summaries

Page 8: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Consumer Understanding of PLS Messages

*Excerpt from Glenton and Santesso presentation to the Co-ordinating Editors Board in 2010 October.

Page 9: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Sentence length

Reading level

Headers and paragraphs

Use of complex terms

Format for Plain Language Summaries

Page 10: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Supporting Consumer Involvement

Page 11: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Consumer Growth

Page 12: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Training New Consumers

Page 13: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Consumer Roles

Page 14: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Consumer Feedback Essential

Consumer developed

ERC refined

Adherence to MECIR and PLS standards

Pilot phase in progress

Consumer Referee Checklists

Page 15: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Supporting Managing EditorsIncluding an explanatory guide to accompany the Consumer Referee

Checklist

Page 16: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.
Page 17: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Reaching New Consumerssummaries.cochrane.org

Page 18: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Moving in the Right Direction

European Commission ECRAN Project

Communicating the

benefits of European research to the general public”

Page 19: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

European Communication on Research Awareness Needs“Communicating the benefits of European research to the general public”

To develop tools to:

communicate key messages to citizens, patients, patients organizations, healthcare professionals, researchers, policymakers and society about independent, multinational clinical research

First key message:

The importance of public understanding of the need for, and basic principles of clinical trials, fostering active involvement of citizens and patients in trials and of their representatives in trial design

Involving Consumers from the Start

Page 20: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Accessible for Everyone

Page 21: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Consumer Involvement Could Be...

Page 22: Catherine McIlwain (cmcilwain@cochrane.org) 20 th Annual Cochrane Colloquium Auckland, 3 rd October 2012.

Planning for the Future