Cases for Civil Procedure

2
State the facts, issue/s & ruling of the following cases. (Handwritten, separate notebook) 1. SINDICO V DIAZ, 440 SCRA 50, OCTOBER 1, 2004. 2. MANILA RAILROAD V ATTY. GENERAL, 20 PHIL 523, DECEMBER 11, 1911. 3. ABBAIN V. CHUA, 22 SCRA 748, FEBRUARY 26, 1968. 4. SEAFDEC V NLRC (LAZAGA) 5. SOLIVEN VS FASTFORMS PHILS., 440 SCRA 389, OCTOBER 18, 2004. 6. SOUTHERN FOOD SALES CORPORATION VS. SALAS, 206 SCRA 333, FEB 18, 1992. 7. BOTICANO V CHU, JR, 148 SCRA 541, MARCH 16, 1987. 8. RODRIGUEZ VS ALIKPALA, 57 SCRA 455, JUNE 25, 1974. ACQUIRED JURISDICTION OVER THE RES: EL BANCO ESPAÑOL-FILINO V. PALANCA, 37 PHIL. 921, MARCH 26, 1918. ACQUIRED JURISDICTION OVER THE ISSUES: SPS GONZAGA V CA (SPS ABAGAT), OCTOBER 18, 2004. COMMENCEMENT OF ACTION: GO V TONG, G.R. NO. 151942, NOVEMBER 27, 2003. CAUSE OF ACTION: FELIPE V LEUTERIO, 91 PHIL 482, MAY 30, 1952. MISJOINDER: UNION GLASS V SEC (HOFILEÑA), 126 SCRA 32, NOVEMBER 28, 1983. PARTIES: JUASING HARDWARE V MENDOZA, 115 SCRA 783, JULY 30, 1982. PARTIES IN INTEREST: CARILLO, GUYOT, SENOY, RISONAR, GONZALES V. CA (DABON AND DABON) GR NO. 121165, SEPTEMBER 26, 2006. CLASS SUIT: OPOSA V FACTORAN, 224 SCRA 792, JULY 30, 1993. KINDS OF PARTIES/COMPULSORY JOINDER OF INDISPENSABLE PARTIES: ARCELONA V. CA (FARNACIO), G.R. NO. 102900, OCT. 2, 1997. PERMISSIVE JOINDER: FLORES V MALLARE-PHILLIPS, 144 SCRA 377, SEPTEMBER 24,1986. VENUE: TIME, INC. VS. REYES, 39 SCRA 303, MAY 31, 1971. PLEADINGS (IN GENERAL: MANNER OF MAKING ALLEGATIONS IN PLEADINGS, ACTIONABLE DOCUMENT): SANTIAGO VS DE LOS SANTOS, 61 SCRA 146, NOVEMBER 22, 1974. CLAIM, COUNTERCLAIM/CROSS-CLAIM AFTER ANSWER: NAMARCO V. FEDERACION, 49 SCRA 238, JANUARY 31, 1972. AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADINGS: YOUNG VS SPOUSES SY, GR NO. 157745, SEPTEMBER 26, 2006. THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT: REPUBLIC V CENTRAL SURETY & INSURANCE COMPANY, 26 SCRA 741, OCTOBER 26, 1968. COMPULSORY COUNTERCLAIM/CROSS-CLAIM: CALO VS. AJAX INTERNATIONAL, INC, 22 SCRA 996, MARCH 13, 1968. THE ANSWER, ON DEFENSES (RULE 8, ALLEGATIONS DEEMED ADMITTED): TEC BI & CO V CHARTERED BANK OF INDIA, AUSTRALIA AND CHINA, 41 PHIL 596, FEB 5, 1916. HOW TO CONTEST DOCUMENT: PHILIPPINE BANKING CORPORATION V CA (AMALIO L. SARMIENTO), JANUARY 13, 2004. DEFENSE/OBJECTION WAIVED: KATON V PALANCA, G.R. NO. 151149, SEPTEMBER 7, 2004. COMMON PROVISIONS (RE PARTS OF PLEADING): FIL-ESTATE GOLF AND DEVELOPMENT, INC. V CA (CABUCO- ANDRES), 265 SCRA 614, DECEMBER 16, 1996. RE: MANNER OF MAKING ALLEGATIONS: PERPETUAL SAVINGS V FAJARDO, 223 SCRA 720, JUNE28,1993. RE: EFFECT OF FAILURE TO PLEAD: SPOUSES DELOS SANTOS VS RTC (HON. EMMANUEL C. CARPIO), G.R. NO. 153696, SEPTEMBER 11, 2006. STRIKING OUT PLEADINGS: DAUDEN-HERNAEZ V ANGELES, HOLLYWOOD FAR EAST PRODUCTIONS, INC., AND VALENZUELA, 27 SCRA 1276, APRIL 30, 1969. FILING/ SERVICE OF PLEADINGS, JUDGMENTS AND OTHER PAPERS: BAUTISTA V MAYA-MAYA COTTAGES INC., G.R. NO. 148361, NOV. 29, 2005. COMPUTATION OF TIME: SPS. CONRADO AND MA. CORONA ROMERO VS. CA, SATURNINO S. ORDEN, G.R. NO. 142406, MAY 16, 2005. SUMMONS: TOYOTA CUBAO V. CA (GUEVARRA), G.R. NO. 126321, OCTOBER 23, 1997. SUBSTITUTED SERVICE: QUELNAN V. VHF PHIL., G.R. NO. 138500, SEPTEMBER 16, 2005. SUMMONS (CONTENTS, WHEN ISSUED, BY WHOM ISSUED, MODES OF SERVICE): GUIGUINTO CREDIT COOPERATIVE, INC V TORRES, G. R. NO. 170926, SEPTEMBER 15, 2006. MODE OF SERVICE UPON CERTAIN DEFENDANTS (UPON DOMESTIC PRIVATE JURIDICAL ENTITY): PALUWAGAN NG BAYAN SAVINGS BANK VS. KING, 172 SCRA 131, APRIL 12, 1989. MODE OF SERVICE UPON CERTAIN DEFENDANTS (UPON FOREIGN PRIVATE JURIDICAL ENTITY): FACILITIES MANAGEMENT V DELA OSA, 89 SCRA 131, MARCH 26, 1979.

Transcript of Cases for Civil Procedure

Page 1: Cases for Civil Procedure

State the facts, issue/s & ruling of the following cases. (Handwritten, separate notebook)

1. SINDICO V DIAZ, 440 SCRA 50, OCTOBER 1, 2004.2. MANILA RAILROAD V ATTY. GENERAL, 20 PHIL 523, DECEMBER 11, 1911.3. ABBAIN V. CHUA, 22 SCRA 748, FEBRUARY 26, 1968.4. SEAFDEC V NLRC (LAZAGA)5. SOLIVEN VS FASTFORMS PHILS., 440 SCRA 389, OCTOBER 18, 2004.6. SOUTHERN FOOD SALES CORPORATION VS. SALAS, 206 SCRA 333, FEB 18, 1992.7. BOTICANO V CHU, JR, 148 SCRA 541, MARCH 16, 1987.8. RODRIGUEZ VS ALIKPALA, 57 SCRA 455, JUNE 25, 1974.

ACQUIRED JURISDICTION OVER THE RES: EL BANCO ESPAÑOL-FILINO V. PALANCA, 37 PHIL. 921, MARCH 26, 1918.ACQUIRED JURISDICTION OVER THE ISSUES: SPS GONZAGA V CA (SPS ABAGAT), OCTOBER 18, 2004.COMMENCEMENT OF ACTION: GO V TONG, G.R. NO. 151942, NOVEMBER 27, 2003.CAUSE OF ACTION: FELIPE V LEUTERIO, 91 PHIL 482, MAY 30, 1952.MISJOINDER: UNION GLASS V SEC (HOFILEÑA), 126 SCRA 32, NOVEMBER 28, 1983.PARTIES: JUASING HARDWARE V MENDOZA, 115 SCRA 783, JULY 30, 1982.PARTIES IN INTEREST: CARILLO, GUYOT, SENOY, RISONAR, GONZALES V. CA (DABON AND DABON) GR NO. 121165, SEPTEMBER 26, 2006.CLASS SUIT: OPOSA V FACTORAN, 224 SCRA 792, JULY 30, 1993.KINDS OF PARTIES/COMPULSORY JOINDER OF INDISPENSABLE PARTIES: ARCELONA V. CA (FARNACIO), G.R. NO. 102900, OCT. 2, 1997.PERMISSIVE JOINDER: FLORES V MALLARE-PHILLIPS, 144 SCRA 377, SEPTEMBER 24,1986.VENUE: TIME, INC. VS. REYES, 39 SCRA 303, MAY 31, 1971.PLEADINGS (IN GENERAL: MANNER OF MAKING ALLEGATIONS IN PLEADINGS, ACTIONABLE DOCUMENT): SANTIAGO VS DE LOS SANTOS, 61 SCRA 146, NOVEMBER 22, 1974.CLAIM, COUNTERCLAIM/CROSS-CLAIM AFTER ANSWER: NAMARCO V. FEDERACION, 49 SCRA 238, JANUARY 31, 1972.AMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL PLEADINGS: YOUNG VS SPOUSES SY, GR NO. 157745, SEPTEMBER 26, 2006.THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT: REPUBLIC V CENTRAL SURETY & INSURANCE COMPANY, 26 SCRA 741, OCTOBER 26, 1968.COMPULSORY COUNTERCLAIM/CROSS-CLAIM: CALO VS. AJAX INTERNATIONAL, INC, 22 SCRA 996, MARCH 13, 1968.THE ANSWER, ON DEFENSES (RULE 8, ALLEGATIONS DEEMED ADMITTED): TEC BI & CO V CHARTERED BANK OF INDIA, AUSTRALIA AND CHINA, 41 PHIL 596, FEB 5, 1916.HOW TO CONTEST DOCUMENT: PHILIPPINE BANKING CORPORATION V CA (AMALIO L. SARMIENTO), JANUARY 13, 2004.DEFENSE/OBJECTION WAIVED: KATON V PALANCA, G.R. NO. 151149, SEPTEMBER 7, 2004.COMMON PROVISIONS (RE PARTS OF PLEADING): FIL-ESTATE GOLF AND DEVELOPMENT, INC. V CA (CABUCO-ANDRES), 265 SCRA 614, DECEMBER 16, 1996.RE: MANNER OF MAKING ALLEGATIONS: PERPETUAL SAVINGS V FAJARDO, 223 SCRA 720, JUNE28,1993.RE: EFFECT OF FAILURE TO PLEAD: SPOUSES DELOS SANTOS VS RTC (HON. EMMANUEL C. CARPIO), G.R. NO. 153696, SEPTEMBER 11, 2006.STRIKING OUT PLEADINGS: DAUDEN-HERNAEZ V ANGELES, HOLLYWOOD FAR EAST PRODUCTIONS, INC., AND VALENZUELA, 27 SCRA 1276, APRIL 30, 1969.FILING/ SERVICE OF PLEADINGS, JUDGMENTS AND OTHER PAPERS: BAUTISTA V MAYA-MAYA COTTAGES INC., G.R. NO. 148361, NOV. 29, 2005.COMPUTATION OF TIME: SPS. CONRADO AND MA. CORONA ROMERO VS. CA, SATURNINO S. ORDEN, G.R. NO. 142406, MAY 16, 2005.SUMMONS: TOYOTA CUBAO V. CA (GUEVARRA), G.R. NO. 126321, OCTOBER 23, 1997.SUBSTITUTED SERVICE: QUELNAN V. VHF PHIL., G.R. NO. 138500, SEPTEMBER 16, 2005.SUMMONS (CONTENTS, WHEN ISSUED, BY WHOM ISSUED, MODES OF SERVICE): GUIGUINTO CREDIT COOPERATIVE, INC V TORRES, G. R. NO. 170926, SEPTEMBER 15, 2006.MODE OF SERVICE UPON CERTAIN DEFENDANTS (UPON DOMESTIC PRIVATE JURIDICAL ENTITY): PALUWAGAN NG BAYAN SAVINGS BANK VS. KING, 172 SCRA 131, APRIL 12, 1989.MODE OF SERVICE UPON CERTAIN DEFENDANTS (UPON FOREIGN PRIVATE JURIDICAL ENTITY): FACILITIES MANAGEMENT V DELA OSA, 89 SCRA 131, MARCH 26, 1979.MODE OF SERVICE UPON CERTAIN DEFENDANTS (UPON DEFENDANT WHOSE IDENTITY/WHEREABOUTS UNKNOWN): BALTAZAR VS CA (GOOD EARTH ENTERPRISES), G.R. NO. 78728, DECEMBER 8, 1988.MOTIONS IN GENERAL/MOTION TO DISMISS UNDER RULE 16:

-US V. RUIZ, 136 SCRA 487, MAY 22, 1985.-NATIONAL UNION VS STOLT-NIELSEN, 184 SCRA 682, APRIL 26, 1990.-BALO V CA (JUDGE ASIS, GARRIDO), GR NO. 129704, SEPTEMBER 30, 2005.-SEA-LAND SERVICE INC V CA (A.P. MOLLER/ MAERSK LINE), MARCH 2, 2000.-SWAGMAN HOTELS V. CA, G.R. 161135, APRIL 8, 2005.-GOODYEAR V. SY, G.R. 154554, NOV 9, 2005.-ANGELITA MORCAL VS. ANTONIO LAVIÑA ET. AL., 476 SCRA 508 (2005).-PASCUAL VS PASCUAL, G.R. NO 157830, NOVEMBER 17, 2005.-DIU V CA (BUSHNELL AND PAGBA), G.R. NO. 115213, DEC.19, 1995.