Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... –...

35
Case Study: Added Value of Contaminant Mapping Using Capacitively Coupled Resistivity in Pseudo3D form Combined with FrequencyDomain Electromagnetics Presenter: Adam Peake, P.Geo. DMT Geosciences Ltd. In Collaboration With: Christian Lavallee, Environmental Specialist. Precision Drilling Corporation

Transcript of Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... –...

Page 1: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Case Study: Added Value of Contaminant Mapping Using 

Capacitively Coupled Resistivity in Pseudo‐ 3D form Combined with 

Frequency‐Domain ElectromagneticsPresenter: Adam Peake, P.Geo. 

DMT Geosciences Ltd. 

In Collaboration With: Christian Lavallee, Environmental Specialist.

Precision Drilling Corporation 

Page 2: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Overview• Site Description• Objectives• Methods / Instruments

– Advantages and Disadvantages• Survey Design• Acquisition• Results• Challenges• Added Value for Client• Conclusions

Page 3: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Fence

150m

120m

EM31 Survey Extents

Well Location

Looking NW Looking NE

Looking SW Looking SE

Site Description

Page 4: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

• Objectives– Identify and map contaminated zone

• EM31 and OhmMapper– Pseudo‐3D OhmMapper data

Page 5: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Methods / InstrumentsEM31  OhmMapper

Page 6: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

• Geonics EM31 MK II Conductivity Meter• GPS integrated in real time• Average over exploration extents.

• 5‐6 metres• High data density – 1 reading / second.

GPSEM31

Tx

Rx

Image from: http://asstgroup.com/techniques.html

Page 7: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Advantages/Disadvantages of EM31

Advantages:• Quick• Ease of use• Site overview

Disadvantages:• Limited depth info.• Higher conductivity reduces depth of investigation. 

Page 8: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Conventional Resistivity

• Labour and equipment intensive.• Stationary.• Time intensive.

• Electrical Resistivity Imaging (ERI)

Page 9: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Geometrics OhmMapperCapacitively Coupled Resistivity

Data Acquisition• GPS linked

Many configurations• Cable lengths• Rope lengths

GPS

Weight to preventlifting cable

Rx 5Rx 4

Rx 3Rx 2Rx 1Tx

Page 10: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

OhmMapper Vs. ERIDipole‐Dipole Array

http://geoscixyz.readthedocs.org/en/latest/content/DC_resistivity/DC_measurements_and_data.html

• Conventional ERI

• OhmMapper

Page 11: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Advantages/Disadvantages of OhmMapper

Advantages:• Depth information • Quick ‐ Dragged• Efficient ‐ Limited personnel • Very high horizontal resolution

– 2 readings/second

Disadvantages:• Shallower depth than ERI• Higher conductivity reduces 

ability to receive data • Only water resistant• Difficult to drag by hand 

and/or rough terrain

Page 12: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Survey design

• Reconnaissance style EM31– Identify targets and background

• Targeted Pseudo‐3D OhmMapper survey– Characterize target

Page 13: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

EM31 Acquisition

• EM31 = one continuous traverse, approx. 3m apart

Page 14: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Short RopeLong Rope

Short Rope

Long Rope

OhmMapper Acquisition• 25 Lines ‐ 2 passes per line

– Different rope lengths• 0.625m and 2.5m

• Lines approx. 3‐5 metres apart.– Pin‐flagged.

Page 15: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Results• EM31 Results• Expectation Vs. Reality• OhmMapper Results

– Challenges

• Added Value for Client• Pseudo 3D

– Possible Subsurface Propagation 

Page 16: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

EM31 Results –With Snow

Page 17: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

EM31 Results – No Snow

Page 18: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

EM31 Results – CompareWith Snow

No Snow

Page 19: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Expectation vs. RealityExample 1

Example 2

Example 3

Example 4

Page 20: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

OhmMapper Results• 3 Attempts – 3rd was successful. 

Page 21: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Challenges

• Improper coupling possibility.– Thick crust– Granular snow– Air pockets?

• Increased distance from ground surface– Capacitance inversely related to distance

Air/Loose Snow?

Loose Snow?Compact/Drifted

Interconnected Snow?

Crust Surface

Page 22: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Added Value for Client

• Accurate borehole locations• Volume estimates• Possible subsurface propagation

Page 23: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

• Before GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Accurate Borehole Locations

Page 24: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Accurate Borehole Locations• After GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Page 25: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Accurate Borehole Locations• Before GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

• After GeophysicsSuggestedBoreholes

Page 26: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Accurate Borehole Locations• After Actually Drilled

Page 27: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Pseudo‐3D • 75 to 325mS/m• Vertical Ex. = x3

Page 28: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Psuedo 3D ‐Volume Estimates• Any Conductivity (Confined depth)

Iso‐Surface Value 

Volume within Iso‐Surface (m3) – Limited to 4m depth

125 mS/m  1640m3

185 mS/m  350m3

250 mS/m 129m3

300 mS/m 52m3

Page 29: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Evaluation• Revisit Conductivity Iso‐surfaces• 108mS/m appears 

to closer match exceeding salinity

• Upper 0.5 to 1m stockpiled in some places?

New Iso‐Surface Value  Volume within Iso‐Surface (m3) –Limited to 4m depth

108 mS/m  3150m3

Page 30: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Evaluation• Stockpile material?

Looking Northwest

• 108mS/m• Vertical Ex. = x3

Page 31: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

ckpile material?Evaluation • 108mS/m

• Vertical Ex. = x3

Page 32: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

ssible Subsurface PropagationEM31 OhmMapper Depth Slice – Near Surface

SouthNorth X‐section

Page 33: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

ssible Subsurface Propagation

Page 34: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Conclusion

QuickEasyTargeted borehole locationsPossible volume savingsAnother perspective to understand all dataMight not work correctly in certain snow situations.

Page 35: Case Study: Added Value of Coupled Resistivity in 3D ... · Case Study: Added Value of ... – Advantages and Disadvantages • Survey Design • Acquisition • Results • Challenges

Wolf

Rx 4

Rx 3

Rx 2

Rx 1

Thank you!

DMT Geosciences Ltd.Suite 415, 708-11th Ave. S.W.Calgary, Alberta,Canada, T2R 0E4403-264-9496

Suite 1030, 789 West Pender St.Vancouver, British ColumbiaCanada, V6H 1H2604-293-2800