Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
-
Upload
ten-penny-players-inc -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
1/42
I`yi`y` Jbucny
E`ynE`yn
[bqcg~q[bqcg~q
E`ynE`ynEc`pqnyEc`pqny
SBBSBB
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
2/42
I`yi`y` Jbucny
E`ynE`yn[bqcg~q[bqcg~q
E`ynE`ynEc`pqny SBB
Jbyuq p~idbucna ir @zgl Iggmu
#` abzbubgl gj Qcn Cn`yuq Egypgy`qbgl"
bl Unpqnfiny$ 02;9
02;9 I`yi`y` Jbucny
@dd ybkcqu ynunyzna,
Jgy bljgyf`qbgl `aaynuu
Qnl _nllr _d`rnyu$ Ble,
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
3/42
[n c`a qg zbubq g~qp`qbnlq qcynn qbfnu injgyn
`dd qcn uqbqecnu {nyn g~q `la qcn i`la`knu q`mnl
gjj, Bq {`u ` znyr ln`q hgi$ nznl lbeny qc`l qcn jbyuq
gpny`qbgl c`a innl, Qcn p`qec c`u lnzny yn`ddrcn`dna pygpnydr= bqu uqbdd znyr d`ykn `la pniidr bl
`yn`u, Ublen qcnr c`a gldr agln gln unp`y`qbgl
`la lg qc~fi {niiblk$ bq cn`dna nznl j`uqny qc`l
qcn jbyuq qbfn `la cn {`u ~ublk igqc c`lau {bqc
n~`d ansqnybqr bl ` ucgyq {cbdn,
Qcnr {nyn kgblk qg uecna~dn qcn lnsq gpny`qbgl`u uggl `u py`eqbe`idn, B abalq `lqbebp`qn `lr abj&
jbe~dqr ublen qcnr c`a jbl`ddr age~fnlqna cbu
~l~u~`d qnfpny`q~yn y`lkn, Lg u~ec d~em, Qcnr
e`lendna qcn gpny`qbgl q{ben ine`~un gj qnfpny`&
q~yn `la n`yu, Qcn {glanyj~d rg~lk ageqgy {bqc
jg~y rg~lk uglu {`u ygq`qna g~q `la {n abalq unn
cbf `k`bl, Bzn kgqqnl ugyq gj ~una qg qcn j`eq qc`qqcnr gldr q`dm qg qcnby g{l$ qc`q fr ageqgy$ py`eqbe&
blk jgy jgyqr rn`yu `la ynupneqna `q cny g{l cgupb&
q`d$ e`yybnu lg {nbkcq {bqc qcnf, B qcblm qcn pgdb&
er bu ucgyqubkcqna$ i~q Bf ~una qg bq, [c`q unlau
fn jdrblk gjj lg{ bu qcn j`eq qc`q qcnr aglq unnf qg
dbuqnl qg qcnby g{l egddn`k~nu$ nbqcny, B `uu~fnqc`q nznyrqcblk bu {ybqqnl blqg qcn e`uniggm=
qcnryn jgynzny ueybiidblk bl bq Cndd$ qcnr nznl
f`mn fnlqbgl gj ugfn gj fr jnndblku `la ynf`ymu$
ug rg~a qcblm qc`q qcnr c`a qcn j~dd cbuqgyr gj qcn
0
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
4/42
ybun `la j`dd gj qcn blj`lq qnfpny`q~yn, Rnq qcnr
uqbdd kbzn ~u qcn uglk `la a`len `ig~q cbu {nbya n`y
bddlnuu `la cbkc qnfpny`q~yn,
Qcnr e`lendna qcn lnsq q{g uecna~dna gpny`&qbglu$ i~q {n jbl`ddr$ qcyg~kc ucnny {bddpg{ny$ kgq
cbf blqg qcn cgupbq`d, Qcn l~yunu {nyn andbkcqna
qg unn cbf `k`bl, Cnu ` qry`lq qg fn$ i~q `{j~ddr
ec`yfblk qg qcn fblb&l~yunu, Cbu u~ykngl u`ba
qc`q cn fbkcq ueyn`f `la rndd `la egfpd`bl bl
jn`yugfn anebindu$ i~q cn `d{`ru cgdau cbu c`lag~q jgy qyn`qfnlq, Qcn ageqgy {`u gl qg cbf `la
qcn l~yunu `u {ndd, Cnu yn`ddr ` kgga$ u{nnq, dbzn&
dr$ gpblbgl`qna mba,
[n kgq cbf unqqdna `la ~lp`emna, Gln gj qcn
rg~lk ynubanlqu e`fn gzny `la `umna qg ns`fbln
cbf, B iyg~kcq @qcnd`lqbu blqg gln gj qcn qyn`q&
fnlq yggfu, Qcn ynubanlqu jbyuq ~nuqbgl gj eg~yun{`u {cr bu cn cnyn7
B qgda cbf qc`q qcnr {nyn kgblk qg gpny`qn gl
cbu dnjq c`la `k`bl$ e~qqblk qcyg~kc qcn {niiblk qg
bleyn`un qcn fgibdbqr gj qc`q jblkny, Cn unnfna
u`qbujbna {bqc qcn `lu{ny,
Cn aba qcn y~abfnlq`yr ecnem~p {cbdn@qcnd`lqbu {`bdna `la B cnda cbf ag{l, Qcbu qbfn
qcnr {g~da {`bq gldr gln a`r injgyn gpny`qblk, B
{`u yn`ddr bl ` pynqqr kgga fgga jgy fn, B dbmna qcn
`uubuq`lq u~ykngl, Bq {`u qcn u`fn gln `u qcn d`uq
9
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
5/42
gpny`qbgl, Cn {`u ugyq gj ag~y$ i~q q~ylna ` ln`q
cnf `la unnfna pynqqr cglnuq bl cbu ynpdbnu qg qcn
~nuqbglu B pguna,
Qcn jdggy {`u p`emna$ `u ~u~`d, qcnr mnpq{cnndblk qcnf bl `la g~q gj u~yknyr, Unzny`d ecbd&
aynl `dug e`fn bl {bqc `eebanlq`d iyn`mu, Qcnr
c`a qg in u~nnxna blqg qcn `dyn`ar qbkcq gpny`qblk
uecna~dn, Gln dbqqdn kbyd {cg e`fn bl {bqc ` iyg&
mnl dnk c`a c~yq bq {cbdn pd`rblk dn`pjygk, Ucn
{`u bl q{g gy qcynn a`ru, Qcnr qgda cny ucn eg~dakg cgfn bj ucn {`dmna pygpnydr gl cny ey~qecnu
`la inlq cny dnk ` enyq`bl `fg~lq gj ankynnu,
[cnl ucn jbl`ddr aba {c`q qcnr c`a `umna$ qcnr
u`ba$ gm`r$ e`dd rg~y fgqcny$ rg~yn kgblk cgfn,
Cny fgqcny c`a innl zbubqblk cny qc`q `jqnylggl
`la eg~dalq knq i`em qg pbem cny ~p ~lqbd `jqny ubs
gedgem, @ ln{ p`qbnlq {`u iyg~kcq bl$ p~q blqg qcnjbyuq dbqqdn kbydu yggf$ `la kbznl qcn u`fn ina, Qcn
ecbda jndq ug abupd`ena, Ucn {`u uqbdd qbyna$ `la
eg~dalq f`lbp~d`qn gl qcn ey~qecnu jgy qgg dglk `
pnybga, Ucn c`a p`emna cny qcblku qg ynq~yl cgfn$
i~q ucn abalq {`lq qg ubq g~q bl qcn dg~lkn, Ucn
{`lqna qg dbn ag{l, Ucn uq`yqna eyrblk ine`~unucn jndq qc`q qcnr c`a qcyg{l cny g~q `la ucn aba&
lq mlg{ {c`q qg ag, Gln gj qcn l~yunu p~q ugfn
ucnnqu gl ` uqynqecny ina `la p~q bq bl qcn c`dd{`r,
Qc`q {`u `dug ~l`eenpq`idn qg qcn dbqqdn kbyd, Ucn
5
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
6/42
jndq nspguna `la gl abupd`r, Gln gj qcn j`qcnyu
fgzna qcn uqynqecny ina blqg qcn yggf {cnyn qcnr
mnnp qcn i`ibnu$ ublen bqu pynqqr d`ykn, Ucn d`r gl
qcn uqynqecny bl qcnyn$ ynuqblk `la {`qecblk qndnzb&ubgl ~lqbd cny fgqcny jbl`ddr `yybzna,
Bq kgq ug eyg{ana qc`q qbfn qc`q qcn lbkcq
injgyn qcnr jbl`ddr yndn`una @qcnd`lqbu gln gj qcn
ecbdaynl {`u `eq~`ddr inaana bl qcn c`dd, Qcnr
yndn`una @qcnd`lqbu n`ydr ine`~un gj qcn gzny&
eyg{ablk,@qcnd`lqbu {`u `afbqqna gl F`r >, Qcnr gpny&
`qna gl F`r ;, Ba innl qgda qcn lbkcq injgyn$ `jqny
{na uey~iina ~p #qcbu qbfn qcnyn c`a innl lg
pygidnf"$ qc`q cn {`u kgblk qg in qcn unegla i`ir
q`mnl ~p, B dbmn c`zblk cbf kg ~p n`ydr bl qcn
fgylblk, Cnu lgq `ddg{na qg c`zn `lrqcblk qg n`q
gy ayblm `jqny gln gy q{g qcn lbkcq injgyn cbu gpny&`qbgl$ `la cn e`l knq pynqqr c~lkyr qcn lnsq fgyl&
blk, Bq agnulq igqcny fn `u f~ec {cnl B mlg{
cnu kgblk qg in bl qcn gpny`qblk yggf n`ydr bl qcn
fgylblk, [cnl cnu gpny`qna gl d`qny$ qcn qcbya gy
jg~yqc gpny`qbgl$ cnu {ynqecna {bqc c~lkny,
B e`ddna `ig~q lbln `la qcnr qgda fn qc`q qcnrc`a pynppna cbf qg kg ~puq`byu, B e`ddna `k`bl `q
ndnznl qg jbla g~q {cnqcny gy lgq cn {`u bl qcn
gpny`qblk yggf `la qcnr u`ba rnu, @eq~`ddr cn {`u
and`rna injgyn kgblk blqg qcn gpny`qblk yggf,
1
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
7/42
Qcnr c`a kgqqnl igkkna ag{l bl qcn gpny`qblk
`yn` `la cbu gpny`qbgl c`alq ink~l `u ~bemdr `u
qcnr qcg~kcq bq {g~da,
Qcn ageqgy c`a qgda fn qg in `q qcn cgupbq`d`ig~q q{ndzn gy gln gedgem, B e`ddna `ig~q qc`q
qbfn, Qcn l~yunu u`ba qc`q cn {`u uqbdd ~puq`byu, B
qggm fr qbfn knqqblk qcnyn `la abalq `yybzn ~lqbd
q{g, Qcn ynenpqbgl anum e`ddna `la qcn jdggy l~yun
u`ba cn uqbdd {`ulq bl qcn ynegznyr yggf, B {nlq qg
qcn egjjnn ucgp jgy ` eglq`blny gj egjjnn `la {nlq~puq`byu qcyg~kc gln gj qcn gqcny cgupbq`d {blku,
[cnl B `yybzna gl cbu jdggy qcn l~yun e`ddna `k`bl
`la cn uqbdd {`ulq ag{l bl ynegznyr, B {`bqna jgy
unzny`d cg~yu, @jqny ` {cbdn$ B ink`l qg knq znyr
{gyybna$ ine`~un `u j`y `u B {`u eglenylna bq {`u `
j`bydr ubfpdn pygena~yn, Qcnr {nynlq agblk `lr
igln {gym qcnr {nyn h~uq e~qqblk qcyg~kc qcn {ni&iblk, Egfp`yna qg qcn gqcny gpny`qbglu bq ucg~da&
lq c`zn innl q`mblk qcbu dglk,
Fr fgqcny mnpq e`ddblk `la e`ddblk `la e`ddblk,
Bl qcn inkbllblk$ {cnl cn {`u ~lanykgblk cbu jbyuq
gpny`qbglu$ ucn abalq e`dd qcn cgupbq`d, Ucn {`bq&
na ~lqbd B e`fn cgfn, I~q lg{ qc`q cn {`u kgblkbl gjqnl `la {`u gdany$ ucn e`ddna qcn cgupbq`d
fgyn$ f`bldr qg upn`m qg cbf, Cn dbmnu pcgln e`ddu
jygf cny, B dbjq cbf ~p ug qc`q cn e`l q`dm qg cny,
@q cgfn ucn e`ddu cbf ln`ydr nznyr lbkcq `la qcnr
>
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
8/42
c`zn dglk eglznyu`qbgl, Cn mlg{u qc`q ucnu lgq
qcnyn$ `la rnq cn f`mnu `dd ugyqu gj j`enu bl
ynupglun qg qcn qcblku ucn u`ru qg cbf, Cn ufbdnu
`la lgau `la idblmu cbu nrnu, Ugfnqbfnu cna`lenu bl ebyednu$ q{bydblk yg~la `la `yg~la `u
qcg~kc ucn eg~da unn cbu f`ln~znyu, Cn nlhgru cbu
lbkcqdr pcgln e`ddu, _ygi`idr ine`~un cn unnu
Nylbn `la B gl qcn pcgln ug f~ec, Cn dgznu c`z&
blk fn u`r @qcnd`lqbu$ bqu L`l` jgy rg~, Cn egfnu
y~ucblk qg qcn pcgln `la ynndu gjj cbu nlqbyn ynpny&qgbyn qg cny,
@u uggl `u cn egfnu cgfn$ fr fgqcny egfnu
ag{l qg zbubq cbf$ iyblkblk `dd ugyqu gj pynunlqu
`la jgga `la eggblk gzny cbf, Cn kgnu ybkcq qg cny
u~bqe`un `la inku jgy cny qg gpnl bq `la uq`yq abu&
pnlublk qcn kbjqu, Ucn lnzny zbubqu cbf bl qcn cgu&
pbq`d, Ucnu znyr ~punq {cnl cnu qcnyn, Cnu qggdbqqdn `la z~dlny`idn bl cgupbq`d, Ucn e`fn$ gj
eg~yun$ {cnl cn {`u igyl i~q c`ulq ynq~ylna
ublen, B qcblm bqu h~uq `u {ndd, Ucna h~uq knq ~punq
`q c`zblk qg kg gjj `la dn`zn cbf,
^u~`ddr$ gldr Nylbn `la B zbubq cbf, [cnl
I`yiy`c agnulq c`zn qg {gym$ ucn `dug egfnu `lafr lnbkcigy uqgpu gjj gl cny {`r cgfn jygf {gym
ugfnqbfnu, I~q knlny`ddr$ cn yndbnu gl Nylbn `la
fn,
[n e`ddna qcn gpny`qblk yggf `k`bl `q `ig~q
:
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
9/42
jbzn&qcbyqr `la cn {`u jbl`ddr ag{l bl ynegznyr,
Qcnr u`ba qc`q cn {g~da in ag{l bl `ig~q c`dj `l
cg~y, Qcbu qbfn B aglq mlg{ {cgf B {gyybna
`ig~q fgyn@qcnd`lqbu gy Nylbn, Nylbn {`u bl qcnjbnda qc`q a`r, Cn c`a ec`lkna hgiu, Cn {`u uqbdd
{gymblk jgy qcn Rg~qc Abzbubgl$ i~q lg dglkny bl `l
bluqbq~qbgl= lg{ cn {`u `l `jqnye`yn {gymny, Cn
c`a ynk~d`y lbln qg jbzn cg~yu$ {cbec f`an g~y
g{l dbjn n`ubny, B aglq {gyyr `ig~q cbf {cnl cnu
bl qcn gjjben, I~q B ag {gyyr {cnl cnu bl qcn jbndaeg~lundblk j`fbdbnu, Cn `d{`ru qnddu fn$ Aglq
{gyyr$ B e`l g~qy~l `lr h~lmr bl qcn ebqr, Cn ~una
qg y`en$ `la cnu pygi`idr ybkcq$ i~q bq ~punqu fn
`lr{`r,
B mlg{ qc`q cnu ibk `la id`em `la cn e`l dggm
pynqqr cguqbdn, Cnu anzndgpna ` {cgdn {`r gj
{gymblk qcn uqynnqu$ upgqqblk qcblku$ pgqnlqb`dqyg~idnf`mnyu bl uqgyn {blag{u$ `la f`mblk u~yn
qc`q lg gln bu jgddg{blk cbf ag{l idgemu gy blqg
i~bdablku, Qcn lgyf`d mblau gj qcblku qc`q gln
agnu bj glnu ` uqynnq&{gymny `la {`dmu `yg~la
~l`yfna, Cn ucg~da c`zn innl `q qcn cgupbq`d `q
gln gedgem, Nylbnu c`yadr nzny ubem, Cn c`u ugf~ec ubem `la `ll~`d dn`zn `ee~f~d`qna qc`q
{cnl qcn i`iru bl qcn cgupbq`d cn q`mnu qbfn gjj qg
upnla nsqy` qbfn {bqc ~u, Cn ucg~da c`zn innl `q
qcn cgupbq`d {bqc fn$ i~q cn {`ulq, B `umna cbu
;
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
10/42
gjjben qg c`zn cbf e`dd fn qcn lnsq qbfn cn e`ddna
bl, Cn c`alq e`ddna bl ublen lggl, Qc`q {`u znyr
~l~u~`d , Cn e`ddna bl `ig~q nznyr q{g cg~yu, B
{`u eglzblena ugfnqcblk c`a c`ppnlna qg cbf, Babalq nznl mlg{ {cnyn qg inkbl qy`emblk cbf
ag{l, Lnbqcny aba cbu gjjben, Cn {`u egznyblk `
c~kn `yn` gj Iyggmdrl qc`q a`r `la kgblk qg unn
ugfn ln{ e`unu, Qcnr fbkcq c`zn fgzna `la cn
fbkcq c`zn c`a qyg~idn qy`emblk qcnf ag{l, Qcn
{gym Nylbn agnu bu ug edgundr `ddbna qg qcn pgdben blqcn fblau gj qcn pngpdn qc`q qcnr `yn ugfnqbfnu
ynd~eq`lq qg p`uu bljgyf`qbgl gl qg cbf, _ngpdn
ed`f ~p {cnl cn `umu ~nuqbglu `ig~q j`fbdbnu,
B e`ddna nznyr cg~y gy ug, B e`ddna q jbzn la cn
uqbdd c`alq e`ddna, Ir qc`q qbfn qcn gjjben c`a
ink~l qg p`lbe, [n c`a anebana qc`q bj cn c`alq
`yybzna ir jbzn&qcbyqr {na uq`yq e`ddblk qcnpyneblequ `la c`zn qcnf unla `yg~la p`qygd e`yu,
Bf ~bem qg e`dd bl qcn pgdben, Glen {cnl B
eg~dalq yn`ec Nylbn ir pcgln `q qcn ~yi`l cgfn
bl {cbec cn {`u {gymblk$ B e`ddna qcn pgdben, Gln
gj qcn {gymnyu c`a q~ylna gjj qcn qndnpcgln inddu
jygf qcn ~puq`byu ug qcn {gymnyu eg~dalq cn`y qcnpcgln yblkblk, Qcnr abalq dbmn ebqr pgdben inblk
e`ddna blqg ` uq`qn j`ebdbqr, B qcyn`qnlna qg e`dd qcn
Uq`qn pgdben qcn lnsq qbfn B eg~dalq yn`ec Nylbn ir
pcgln, Qc`q {`u qcn d`uq qbfn bq c`ppnlna,
3
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
11/42
@dqcg~kc B dbmn mlg{blk {c`q c`ppnlu qg cbf
`q {gym$ {cnl a`lknyg~u qcblku c`ppnl B yn`ddr
aglq {`lq qg mlg{, Bqu inqqny lgq mlg{blk ugfn
qcblku, B aglq dbmn dbzblk {bqc qcn jn`y, Cnu `kgga {gymny, B u~ppgun ugfn gj cbu eglq`equ eg~da
inegfn zbgdnlq$ rnq cnu ` unlubqbzn qcny`pbuq `la
cbu qnlanler bu qg e`df pngpdn `la c`zn qcnf
yndn`un qcnby nfgqbglu znyi`ddr bluqn`a gj pcrube`d&
dr,
[cnl B {`u ` rg~qc {gymny B ~una qg in ue`ynaug f~ec, B abalq {gyyr `ig~q qcn mbau {bqc {cgf
B {gymna, Nznl qcg~kc ugfn gj qcnf {nyn znyr
fn`l$ qcnr knlny`ddr pgdbena qcnfundznu, B {gy&
ybna `ig~q qcn mbau {cg abalq indglk qg g~y pyg&
ky`f `la abalq ynd`qn qg qcn mbau {cg aba, B {`u
{gymblk {bqc c`ya&egyn k`lku, Qcnyn ~una qg in
ucggq&g~qu `la mlbjblku `q qcn ec~yec bl {cbec B{gymna, [cnl B {`u qcnyn bq {`u pynqqr f~ec ln~&
qy`d q~yj,
Qcnr abalq iyblk qcnby ibqqnylnuu blqg g~y pyg&
ky`f, Qcnr `dd jndq qc`q qcnr eg~da u`jndr egfn qg
g~y pygky`f `la p`yqbebp`qn bl qcn `yq pyghnequ, Bj
qcnr c`a ` pygidnf$ qc`q {`u c`ladna gl qcn g~q&uban, B p`lbemna glen {cnl {n c`a `ig~q qcynn
c~layna mbau bl g~y j`ebdbqr$ `dd {n eg~da c`ladn$
`la `lgqcny gln c~layna #ay~lm `la yg{ar" {`lq&
na qg egfn bluban, [n lnnana qg e`dd qcn pgdben qg
2
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
12/42
pynznlq ` ybgq, [n {nyn gldr ` idgem `{`r jygf qcn
pynebleq cg~un, Qcn u~`a e`yu c`a qg p`uu g~y
ec~yec gl qcnby {`r qg ynpgyq bl$ ug {cnl B e`ddna
jgy cndp bq `yybzna ~bemdr,Qcn mbau gjqnl {`dmna fn cgfn, B ~u~`ddr c`a
gln gy q{g `u `l nuegyq, B c`a cn`ya gj ugfn bleb&
anlqu gj rg~qc {gymnyu knqqblk uq`iina gy f~kkna$
i~q bq abalq c`ppnl gjqnl, Bq lnzny c`ppnlna qg
fn, I~q B {gyybna `ig~q Nylbn, B qybna qg `eegf&
pdbuc {gym {cbdn B {`bqna jgy igqc gj qcnf, B upnlqfguq gj fr qbfn dggmblk `q qcn edgem$ {`bqblk jgy
qcn pcgln qg yblk `la {`qecblk qcn ndnz`qgy aggyu,
Jbl`ddr$ qcnr iyg~kcq @qcnd`lqbu ag{l, Qcn
l~yunu jygf ynegznyr c`a e`ddna qcn gyqcg l~yunu
u`rblk qcnr abalq ~lanyuq`la cg{ qcnr eg~da c`l&
adn @qcnd`lqbu {cnl cn {`u {ndd$ ine`~un `u uggl
`u cn uq`yqna {`mblk$ cn qybna qg ybp `p`yq qcnblqy`znlg~u ~lbq `la edbfi g~q gj qcn eybi
Nylbn `yybzna ` jn{ fbl~qnu injgyn qcn i`ir
{`u {cnndna gjj qcn ndnz`qgy, Cn e`ddna qcn gjjben
qg e`dd gjj qcn `dnyq, Cna c`a ugfn pygidnf bl qcn
U`qn e`y$ i~q qg qcbu a`r B aglq mlg{ {c`q `eq~`d&
dr c`ppnlna, @qcnd`lqbu unnfna pn`enj~d `u qcnr{cnndna cbf g~q gj qcn ndnz`qgy, Cn {`ulq rnddblk
`la y`qqdblk cbu i`yu$ lgq ~lqbd cn u`{ fn uq`lablk
qcnyn, Qcnl cn uq`yqna {`bdblk, [cnl qcnr
{cnndna cbf blqg cbu yggf cn ine`fn cgyybidr
0?
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
13/42
nly`kna, Cbu egdgy ec`lknu {cnl cnu znyr `lkyr,
Bqu ~u~`ddr dgzndr `la eyn`fr$ i~q `lkny f`mnu
cbf iyg{l {bqc p~ypdn naknu, Cn dnq dggun ~kdr$
q`lqy~f ueyn`fu, Cn p~ddna cbfundj qg cbu jnnq$`dqcg~kc qcn blqy`znlg~u q~iblk {`u q`pna qg cbu
`yf$ `la cn y`qqdna qcn eybi {`ddu, Qcn {cgdn ~lbq
ucbjqna `la ink`l fgzblk jygf qcn {`dd, Qcn eybi
uq`yqna ygddblk, Qcn igqqdn gj blqy`znlg~u jd~ba
{`zna i`em `la jgyqc gl qcn uq`lecbgl$ h~fpblk
jygf bqu cggm$ qcyn`qnlblk qg j`dd gjj,Cn uq`yqna qg p~dd gl qcn q~iblk qc`q {`u egl&
lneqna qg cbu `yf, Cbu dnjq c`la {`u egfpdnqndr
i`la`kna jygf qcn gpny`qbgl, Cbu ybkcq c`la {`u
q`pna qg qcn blqy`znlg~u ~lbq$ rnq cn ~una cbu
i`la`kna c`la qg uq`yq q~kkblk qcn B,Z, Cn c`qnu
blqy`znlg~u cggm~pu, Cn {`u j~ybg~u, [n abalq
yn`ddr mlg{ {c`q qg ag$ lnbqcny B lgy qcn l~yun,[n qcg~kcq qc`q f`rin bj qcnr dg{nyna qcn i`yu
`la B cnda cbf gl fr d`p cn {g~da ~bnq ag{l, Lg
u~ec d~em, Cn {`u inqqny qc`l {cnl cn c`a innl
bl qcn eybi$ i~q cn {`u yn`ddr qnddblk fn ` uqgyr, B
eg~dalq ~lanyuq`la {c`q {`u igqcnyblk cbf$ i~q
cn {`u nly`kna `la dnqqblk fn mlg{ bq,Qcn u~ykngl `yybzna, Cn uq`rna znyr iybnjdr,
Cn qgda fn qc`q qcnr c`a e~q qcyg~kc qcn {niiblk
`la c`a q`mnl ` kygbl ky`jq, Cn c`a egfn qcyg~kc
qcn gpny`qbgl {ndd #gizbg~udr", Cn unnfna pnyjneq&
00
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
14/42
dr `dd ybkcq nsenpq qc`q cbu qnfpny {`u y`eblk, Cn
u`ba$ Bj `dd kgnu {ndd cn e`l kg cgfn bl ` {nnm, B
`umna bj bq {nyn pguubidn jgy cbf qg in yndn`una
n`ydr, @u ~u~`d$ cn u`ba lg, Cn dnjq, @qcnd`lqbu{`u uqbdd znyr {bda, Bq {`u nfi`yy`uublk, @d qcn
gqcny fgqcnyu mnpq dggmblk gzny `q ~u `u qcg~kc
qcnyn {nyn ugfnqcblk cgyybidr {yglk {bqc qcn
fgqcny&ecbda ynd`qbglucbp ine`~un B eg~dalq ~bnq
cbf ag{l `la f`mn cbf jnnd inqqny, Nylbn eg~da&
lq uq`la qcn q~f~dq, Cn dnjq qg kg qg qcn dg~lkn,[cbdn B {`u cgdablk cbf$ qcn rg~lk ageqgy
{bqc qcn ~ljgyq~l`qndr c`laugfn j`en `la nkg qg
f`qec `yybzna, Ba innl `zgbablk cbf, Cn c`alq
innl gl g~y qn`f gj u~yknglu, Qcnyn c`a innl lg
yn`ugl qg c`zn `lr j~yqcny egljyglq`qbglu {bqc
cbf, B u`{ cbf gl qcn jdggy ` dgq$ qcg~kc, Cna
egfn u{`kknyblk ~p `la ag{l qcn c`dd$ iynnxn bl$`d{`ru znyr i~ur$ {cbqn h`emnq jd`ppblk, Cnu
c`laugfn$ i~q cbu nrnu `yn egda, Cna {`dm ~bem&
dr gzny qg qcn p`ynlqu$ dnq dggun ` ag~idn {c`ffr$
anuqygr qcnf$ `la qcnl uqyban `{`r ag{l qcn c`dd,
Cn e`fn blqg g~y {`ya `jqny gln gj qcn fgqc&
nyu anf`lana qg unn cbf, Ucn {`u ` fbaadblk&`kna _~nyqg Ybe`l d`ar, Q`dd$ ygi~uq$ ucn {`u cn`a
gj qcn j`fbdr, B aglq mlg{ bj qcn j`qcny {`u
anen`una gy h~uq lgq dbzblk `q cgfn, Ucn c`a unz&
ny`d ecbdaynl= cny gdanuq a`~kcqny {`u bl qcn cgu&
09
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
15/42
pbq`d, Ucn {`u ` pyn`agdnuenlq$ pynegebg~u `la
qnuqblk cny g`qu `dd qcn qbfn,
Qcn fgqcny {gymna jgy gln gj qcn uecggdu `u `
qn`ecnyu `ban, Ucn {`u `idn qg egfn qg qcn cgupb&q`d `jqny uecggd, B qcblm qcnr dbzna j`y `{`r$ qgg, Bq
qggm cny ~bqn `{cbdn qg knq jygf {cnyn ucn {gymna
qg qcn cgupbq`d, Ucn abalq `yybzn ~lqbd `ig~q jbzn
gy ubs$ i~q ucn {`u qcnyn `u f~ec `u pguubidn, Cny
a`~kcqny c`a abudge`qna gln gj cny cbpu, Ucn {`u
gl ey~qecnu, Ucn {`u znyr {bda {bqc qcnf, Bj rg~u`{ cny egfblk$ bq {`u u`jnuq qg dn`p g~q gj qcn
{`r, Ucn fgzna ug ~bemdr, Ucn {`u `dug ` y`qcny
cn`zrunq kbyd `la bj ucn i`lkna blqg rg~ {cnl ucn
u{~lk gzny qcn ey~qecnu$ bq c~yq, Qcn fgqcny c`a
anf`lana qg unn qcn ageqgy ine`~un ucn c`a upg&
mnl qg qcn ugeb`d {gymny `ig~q c`zblk cny a`~kc&
qny yndn`una qg ` l~yublk cgfn bluqn`a gj cny g{lcgfn, Qcn l~yublk cgfn {g~da qcnl iyblk cny
i`em qg qcn cgupbq`d bl qbfn jgy cny lnsq gpny`qbgl,
Qcn l~yunu c`a egluq`lq qyg~idn jygf qcn
ecbda, Ucn {`lqna qg {`dm {bqcg~q cny ey~qecnu, Bq
{`u znyr a`lknyg~u, Bj ucn {`dmna {bqcg~q ey~qec&
nu qcnyn {`u ` anjblbqn pguubibdbqr gj cny abudge`qblkcny cbpu `k`bl `la ucna c`zn qg kg qcyg~kc `lgqc&
ny dglk cgupbq`d ubnkn, Bq {`u a`lknyg~u$ i~q {cnl
ucn {`u `idn qg uln`m ` qyr$ ucn aba, Ugfnigar
{`u `d{`ru `jqny cny$ f`mblk cny pbem ~p cny
05
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
16/42
ey~qecnu,
Cny fgqcny c`a `yy`lkna {bqc qcn ugeb`d {gym&
ny qg c`zn qcn a`~kcqny yndn`una `la q`mnl abyneq&
dr qg qcn l~yublk cgfn qcn lnsq a`r, Qcn fgqcnyu`ba qc`q bq {`u p`blj~d qg ag qc`q$ ublen ucn {g~da&
lq in `idn qg kg qg qcn eg~lqyr nznyr a`r `la unn
cny a`~kcqny, Ucna pygi`idr gldr knq qg unn cny gl
{nnmnlau, Rnq ucn jndq bq u`jny jgy cny ecbda qg
c`zn egluq`lq u~pnyzbubgl, Bj ucn c`a innl
yndn`una qg cny cgfn ucn {g~da c`zn innl `dgln `dda`r ublen qcn fgqcny {gymna `la `dd qcn rg~lkny
ecbdaynl {nyn bl uecggd, qcn lnsq&aggy lnbkcigy
c`a cny g{l ecbdaynl `la eg~dalq dggm bl gl qcn
a`~kcqny {bqc `lr ynk~d`ybqr, Qcn fgqcny mln{
qc`q qcn a`~kcqny {g~da qyr qg {`dm {bqcg~q qcn
ey~qecnu bj ucn {nyn dnjq `dgln, Bq {`u ` pygidnf,
Bq c`a innl ` pygidnf bl qcn cgupbq`d `la {g~daeglqbl~n qg in gln bj ucn {nlq cgfn,
Qcn ageqgy c`a eg~lqnyf`lana qcn fgqcnyu
pd`lu, Cn gyanyna qcn a`~kcqny yndn`una qg qcn
fgqcny bffnab`qndr, Qcn fgqcny `yk~na {bqc
cbf, Ucn u`ba qc`q ucn jndq bq {`u a`lknyg~u qg
c`zn cny a`~kcqny yndn`una cgfn ublen ucn$ qcnfgqcny$ {`ulq kgblk qg in qcnyn, Cn u`ba qc`q cn
{`ulq kgblk qg yndn`un qcn ecbda qg qcn l~yublk
cgfn, Cn {g~da c`zn qg ag nsqy` `afblbuqy`qbzn
{gym `la cn abalq c`zn qcn qbfn qg ag `dd qcn
01
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
17/42
p`pnyu `ig~q cny yndn`un `la yn`afbqq`len, Qcn
fgqcny u`ba qcn qy`lujny qg qcn l~yublk cgfn c`a
innl `ppygzna ir qcn ebqr j~lablk `knler, Qcn
cgfnu e`y {`u kgblk qg pbem ~p qcn a`~kcqny qcnlnsq a`r, Qcn e`y e`fn qg qcn cgupbq`d ` eg~pdn gj
qbfnu ` {nnm qg pbem ~p `la andbzny ecbdaynl, Qcn
lnsq uecna~dna a`r cny a`~kcqny {`u gl qcn dbuq,
Qcn ageqgy {`u `a`f`lq bl cbu uq`qnfnlq qc`q
cn {`u qcn ageqgy$ cn {`u qcn gln {cg mln{ qcn
e`un$ `la bq {`u cbu anebubgl {cnyn ucn {`uyndn`una, Qcn fgqcny u`ba qc`q ucn jn`yna jgy cny
a`~kcqnyu cn`dqc$ qc`q ucn {`u {bda `q cgfn$ `la
anjblbqndr lnnana u~pnyzbubgl, Qcn ageqgy ynj~una
qg yndn`un qcn ecbda qg qcn l~yublk cgfn,
Cn u`ba cbu anebubgl {`u jbl`d, Qcn fgqcny
u`ba$ [ndd unn cg{ jbl`d qc`q anebubgl bu, Ucn u`ba
qc`q ~dqbf`qndr bq fbkcq in cbu anebubgl$ i~q ucn{g~da cgda cbf `la qcn cgupbq`d ynupglubidn bj `lr&
qcblk c`ppnlna qg cny a`~kcqny$ qc`q ucn {`ulq
kgblk qg `ddg{ bq `la ucn {`u qcn fgqcny, Ucn {`u
kgblk qg upn`m qg qcn ugeb`d {gymny `la f`mn u~yn
qcn ecbda {nlq qg qcn l~yublk cgfn, Ucn abalq e`yn
{c`q qcn ageqgy jndq$ gy {c`q cbu anebubgl {`u= `uqcn fgqcny cny {gya {`u fgyn bfpgyq`lq, @u bq
q~ylna g~q$ ucn aba kg qg qcn ugeb`d {gymny `la qcn
ecbda {`u yndn`una qg qcn l~yublk cgfn,
Cn uqgyfna `{`r jygf cny `la {`u uq`yqblk qg
0>
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
18/42
dn`zn qcn {`ya {cnl B e`ddna cbf i`em, @qcnd`lqbu
{`u uqbdd cruqnybe`d, Cn {`u q~kkblk ug c`ya gl qcn
B&Z qc`q cn c`a p~ddna qcn lnnadn g~q gj cbu umbl,
[cnl qcnr blunyq qcn B&Z lnnadn$ qcnr i`la`kn qcnlnnadn qg qcn c`la, Qcnr {y`p c`la$ lnnadn$ `la
i`la`knu qgknqcny la qcnl qg ` uq~yar ig`ya, Qcn
{cgdn qcblk qcnl bu uqbjj `la bqu c`ya jgy qcn `zny&
`kn ecbda qg p~dd qcn `pp`y`q~u `p`yq,
@qcnd`lqbu c`a innl qcy`ucblk `ig~q ug c`ya
qc`q cn c`a p~ddna qcn lnnadn g~q gj qcn {`aablk,Qcn q~iblk `la ig`ya {nyn uqbdd `qq`ecna qg cbf ir
qcn i`la`knu$ i~q qcn lnnadn {`u lg dglkny blunyq&
na bl cbu c`la, Cn {`u cruqnybe`d, Cn unnfna qg
in bl `{j~d p`bl `la cn {`u idnnablk `dd gzny cbf&
undj `la fn, Bf lgq qnyybidr igqcnyna ir qcn ubkcq
gj idgga, Bqu qgg pynqqr ` egdgy, Idgga agnulq y`l&
mdn {cnl B dggm `q bq, B aglq dbmn unnblk fr ecbdabl p`bl$ cg{nzny$ `la idnnablk, Qc`q igqcnyu fn,
B u`ba qg qcn ageqgy$ _dn`un cndp ~u, Cn u`ba$ B
{`u bl qcn gpny`qblk yggf `la qcn pygena~yn {nlq
`dd ybkcq, B u`ba$ Cnu idnnablk `dd gzny ~u, Qcn
ageqgy ynupglana$ Cnu p~ddna qcn B&Z,
B `lu{nyna$ Rnu$ B mlg{ qc`q, _dn`un q~yl bqgjj `la uqgp qcn idnnablk, Cn {`u znyr `llgrna q
fn, Qy`lujnyyblk cbu kkynuubglu qg{`ya qcn gqcny
fgqcny qg fn, Lgyf`ddr$ B {g~dalq c`zn fblana
`la ynq~ylna qcn cguqbdbqr, I~q @qcnd`lqbu {`u qbdd
0:
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
19/42
idnnablk `dd gzny ~u la uqbdd ueyn`fblk, Cn q~ylna
qcn B&Z gjj `q qcn cn`a, Gln gj qcn qcblku qc`q
igqcnyna fn {`u qc`q qcnr {nyn ~ublk @iigqqu
ugd~qbgl, Qcn ln{up`pnyu c`a innl j~dd gj uqgybnu`ig~q bq$ uqynuublk cg{ e`ynj~d qcn cgupbq`du c`a qg
in lgq qg ~un ` ugd~qbgl qc`q {`u ~lun`dna gy pgu&
ubidr eglq`fbl`qna ublen qcnyn {`u ` a`lkny gj
bljneqbgl, B {`u lnyzg~u ine`~un qcn lnnadn jygf
qcn B&Z c`a innl p~ddna rnq qcn ugd~qbgl mnpq aybp&
pblk glqg fr mba, @jqny cn q~ylna gjj qcn B&Z `lauqgppna qcn aybppblk$ B u`ba$ Cnu cruqnybe`d `la
unnfu qg in bl p`bl, E`l rg~ pynueybin ugfnqcblk
jgy cbf, Cn u`ba$ Cn unnfu qg in bl p`bl, Bdd qndd
qcn l~yun qg kbzn cbf ugfnqcblk, Cn dnjq qcn
yggf$ uqybablk g~q `u ~u~`d$ `la abalq ynq~yl,
Lnbqcny aba ` l~yun `yybzn, [n {`bqna `la {`bqna,
Jbl`ddr$ gln e`fn qcyg~kc qcn yggf `la B `umna`ig~q qcn fnabe`qbgl, @qcnd`lqbu {`u uqbdd idnna&
blk, Ucn u`ba qc`q ucna kg jbla g~q {cnqcny gy lgq
qcn ageqgy c`a gyanyna `lrqcblk `la ucn dnjq `la
abalq ynq~yl, @qcnd`lqbu {`u uqbdd ueyn`fblk f`a,
Cn eglqbl~na qg idnna, Qcn ageqgy c`a q~ylna gjj
qcn B&Z$ i~q c`alq ~luqy`ppna bq jygf @qcnd`lqbu,Bq {`u bleynabidr jy~uqy`qblk, B eg~dalq h~uq pbem
cbf ~p `la {`dm `{`r {bqc cbf qg edn`l cbf ~p
frundj, B abalq c`zn `lr qggdu gy uebuugyu bl fr
p~ynn, B ugfnqbfnu e`yyr qcnf {bqc fn bj Bf
0;
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
20/42
kgblk qg in e~qqblk p`pnyu {cbdn `q qcn cgupbq`d,
Qcbu a`r$ B c`a lgqcblk i~q fruqnybnu, B {`u {gy&
ybna `ig~q qcn idnnablk `la `dug qcn pguubibdbqr gj
bljneqbgl, Cn {`u uqbdd h~fpblk `yg~la bl fr d`p`la B {`u `jy`ba qc`q cna cbq cbu i`la`kna pguqgp&
ny`qbzn c`la gl qcn i`yu gj qcn eybi, Ine`~un cn
{`u `qq`ecna qg qcn B&Z q~iblk$ B eg~dalq fgzn qgg
j`y `{`r jygf qcn ina,
Qcn gqcny fgqcnyu c`a inegfn ynuqbzn$ i~q
qcnyn {`u lgqcblk qcnr eg~da ag nbqcny, Lg age&qgyu, Lg l~yunu, Jbl`ddr$ qcn rg~lk ynubanlq {cg
c`a ns`fblna @qcnd`lqbu {cnl cn c`a jbyuq
`yybzna gl qcn jdggy e`fn blqg qcn yggf qg ecnem
qcn qy`eqbgl gj gln gj qcn gqcny ecbdaynl, Qcn fgqc&
nyu e`ddna cbf gzny qg fn, Cn qggm gln dggm `q
@qcnd`lqbu `la u`ba$ Gc$ cnu p~ddna qcn B&Z, Cn
{`u `{j~ddr `uq~qn, B u`ba qc`q qcn gqcny ageqgyc`a q~ylna bq gjj$ i~q qc`q @qcnd`lqbu {`u u~ppguna
qg c`zn innl kbznl ugfnqcblk qg ~bnq cbf ag{l
`la qcn ageqgy c`alq ynq~ylna, @qcnd`lqbu {`u
uqbdd idnnablk, B `umna bj cn eg~da ag ugfnqcblk
`ig~q qc`q, Cn u`ba$ Jbyuq {nzn kgq qg knq qcn B&Z
g~q, Cn p~ddna qcn q~iblk jygf g~q gj qcn i`la&`kn, Qcnl cn pbemna @qcnd`lqbu ~p `la {n {nlq
blqg gln gj qcn qyn`qfnlq yggfu, Cn uq`yqna e~q&
qblk `{`r `dd gj qcn k`~xn `la i`la`kn `la qcn
ig`ya aygppna gjj, Cn i`qcna @qcnd`lqbuu c`la
03
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
21/42
`la qcn ecbda {`u ~bnqny,
@u uggl `u cn {`u lg dglkny `qq`ecna qg qcn
~lbq$ cn ink`l qg e`df ag{l, Qcn ageqgy edn`lna
cbf `la p~q ` uf`dd i`la`kn gzny qcn p~leq~yn, Bqc`lmna cbf, Cn dnjq, @la B qggm @qcnd`lqbu i`em
qg cbu yggf, [n ygemna `la ygemna `la ygemna,
Qcn yg`y unqqdna ag{l blqg ` {cbfpny, Cn {`u uqbdd
`lkyr, Cn {`lqna qg knq gjj fr d`p `la {`dm g~q
gj qcn yggf, B abalq {`lq cbf qg {`dm `yg~la, B
jndq cn {`u qgg {n`m$ qc`q cn fbkcq j`dd `la c~yqcbu c`la, B qggm gln gj qcn uqygddnyu$ pgppna cbf
blqg bq$ `la uq`yqna p~ucblk,
Qcnr iyg~kcq ugfn abllny jgy cbf, Cn bklgyna
bq, Cn abalq {`lq `lrqcblk, Knlny`ddr upn`mblk$
cn {g~da c`zn innl bl qcn B&Z ~lqbd qcn {cgdn igq&
qdn c`a innl nfpqbna, Lgq nznl c`dj c`a innl
`iugyina, Cn ucg~da c`zn innl ay`blna `la {n`m,Cn {`ulq, B upgmn qg gln gj qcn l~yunu `ig~q qcn
fnabe`qbgl, Qcn ageqgy c`a gyanyna lgqcblk, Cn
{`u bl qcn uqygddny$ e`df$ uqbdd bl p`bl$ i~q lgq cg{d&
blk, B abalq pynuu qg unn qcn ageqgy$ B {`dmna cbf
i`em blqg cbu yggf, Cn c`a ` dbqqdn h~ben `la ugfn
iygqc injgyn B dnjq$ i~q lgq nbkcq g~lenu, B j~ddrnspneqna qcn lnsq a`r qg egfn i`em `la jbla cbf
cggmna ~p `k`bl qg qcn igqqdn, I~q cn {`u y~llblk
`yg~la {cnl {n `yybzna, Qcnr c`alq nznl cggmna
cbf ~p `k`bl qcn lbkcq injgyn,
02
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
22/42
[n uq`rna ` dbqqdn `jqny zbubqblk cg~yu qc`q
lbkcq$ p~ucblk cbf ~p `l ag{l qcn c`dd, Qcnr
`ddg{ ` dglkny zbubq {cnl qcn ecbda bu pguqgpny`qbzn,
B abalq uq`r qnyybidr d`qn$ ine`~un B mln{ cn {`uyn`ddr qbyna, Qcn fbl~qn B uqgppna uqygddblk cbf$
cn {nlq ybkba {bqc y`kn, Cn anf`lana qc`q B egl&
qbl~n, B jndq qc`q cn ucg~da in bl ina `la ug
iyg~kcq cbf qg cbu eybi, B ~laynuuna cbf `la qggm
gjj qcn _`fpny, B {`u u~ypybuna qg unn qc`q qcn
i`la`kn egznyblk qcn kygbl p`qec {`u inegfblku`q~y`qna {bqc ~ybln, @jqny `dd$ cn {`ulq qgbdnq&
qy`blna, B qcg~kcq qc`q qcnra ec`lkn qcn i`la`kn
ynk~d`ydr gy cgpna qc`q qcnyn {`u ` {`qnypyggj
egznyblk ~lany qcn u~ykbe`d aynuublk, Qcnyn {nyn
lg ageqgyu gl qcn jdggy `la qcn l~yunu c`a nz`pg&
y`qna blqg qcnby dbqqdn yggf&kbzblk ynpgyq, Ug B
mbuuna cbf kgga lbkcq `la B dnjq, B cn`a cbfrnddblk `u B {nlq ag{l qc`q c`dd,
Qc`qu gln gj qcn fguq cgyybidn qcblku `ig~q
qcn cgupbq`dbx`qbgl , , , cn`yblk rg~y ecbda rnddblk
`u rg~ dn`zn, Cn unqu ~p ` cg{d gj pygqnuq lgyf`d&
dr, I~q cn h~uq uq`la bl cbu eybi {`zblk `la
pygqnuqblk `u ` f`qqny gj eg~yun, Ir qcn qbfn {nznkgqqnl qg qcn ndnz`qgyu cnu `dyn`ar ~bnq, Lgq qc`q
lbkcq, Cn cg{dna `la y`lqna, Bqu ` qnyybidn jnnd&
blk$ dn`zblk ` ueyn`fblk ~lc`ppr ecbda, Rg~ jnnd
yn`ddr {ynqecna `la {bemna, Nupneb`ddr {cnl rg~
9?
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
23/42
mlg{ qcn eyrblk bu h~uqbjbna, Rnq rg~ kg ine`~un
rg~ c`zn qg, Rg~ e`lq uq`r `la qcn dglkny rg~
{`bq `yg~la qcn {gyun bq inegfnu, B eg~dalq
~lanyuq`la {cr cn {`u p~qqblk ~p ug f~ec gj `j~uu qcbu qbfn, Cn c`a c`a ` ubfbd`y gpny`qbgl
injgyn,
B `umna `ig~q qc`q `la abuegznyna qc`q qcbu
qbfn qcnr c`a blunyqna ` pbl bl cbu qc~fi qg mnnp
bq g~quqynqecna$ ug qc`q qcn {niiblk {g~da cn`d, B
aglq qcblm qc`q cn c`a c`a ` pbl bl cbu qc~fi qcnjbyuq qbfn, @q dn`uq B aglq ynfnfiny unnblk bq h~q&
qblk g~q, B aglq ynfnfiny {`qecblk qcnf ynfgzn
bq, F`rin qcn pbl {`u abuq~yiblk cbf, Gln gj qcn
ageqgyu u`ba qc`q ec`lknu bl {n`qcny {g~da e`~un
qcn pbl qg p`bl cbf,
B abalq mlg{ `q qc`q qbfn {c`q qcn pygidnf
{`u, Cn {`u fbuny`idn, B {`u fbuny`idn, Nylbn{`u fbuny`idn, [n {nlq cgfn anpynuuna, B abalq
jnnd dbmn eggmblk abllny, Nylbn c`a nsqy` fglnr
{bqc cbf `la B `umna qg in q`mnl g~q qg abllny, [n
{nlq qg ` dge`d pbxx` ynuq`~y`lq, [n igqc gyanyna
up`kcnqqb `la fn`qi`ddu, Bq {`u id`la `la qnyyb&
idn, [na ~u~`ddr gldr c`a pbxx` qcnyn$ i~q qcbuqbfn {na innl c~lkyr la {`lqna abllny, [n `qn
nznyrqcblk, [n {nlq cgfn$ {`dmna qcn agk$ jna
qcn `lbf`du$ `la `yk~na, Nylbn {gmn `q `ig~q q{g
`la cn`zna ~p qcn nlqbyn abllny, Cn {`u `lkyr
90
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
24/42
{bqc fn, Cn c`qnu n`qblk g~q$ ine`~un cn qcblmu B
eggm inqqny qc`l fguq ynuq`~y`lqu, @aablk blu~dq
qg blh~yr$ `jqny inblk jgyena qg q`mn fn g~q `la
qcnl qg p`r jgy bq$ `la c`qblk qcn fn`d$ cn cn`znubq ~p qg iggq, [n c`znlq innl i`em ublen$ lgq nznl
jgy pbxx`,
@qcnd`lqbu {`u jnndblk f~ec inqqny qcn lnsq
a`r$ uqbdd ` dbqqdn qnuqr$ i~q jybnladbny, Cn {`u n`q&
blk `k`bl `la y~ucblk `yg~la ~p `la ag{l qcn
c`ddu, Qcn gqcny ecbdaynl qgda fn cn c`a innl bl`la g~q gj qcnby yggfu ue`znlkblk jgga, Bl `aab&
qbgl qg inblk ibk gl qcn d`abnu$ cn `dug mlg{u {cnyn
`dd qcn mbau mnnp qcnby jgga `la cnu egluq`lqdr ink&
kblk,
@ dbqqdn kbyd {cg c`a innl igyl {bqc c`la& `la
`yf&igln pygidnfu c`a innl `afbqqna, Qcn jbyuq
qbfn B u`{ cny p`ynlqu$ B {`u ubqqblk bl qcn dg~lkn{bqc gln gj qcn gqcny p`ynlqu, Knlny`ddr upn`mblk$
{n abalq fnnq qcn u`fn j`fbdbnu gzny `la gzny
`k`bl$ nznl qcg~kc f`lr gj ~u `yn ynpn`qnyu, Qcn
gpny`qbglu `yn qbfna abjjnynlqdr `la {nzn c`a ug
f~ec qyg~idn qc`q {nzn kgqqnl unp`y`qna jygf qcn
gqcnyu {n fnq gybkbl`ddr, Q{g gj qcn j`fbdbnu qcbuqbfn {nyn j`fbdb`y qg ~u, Qcnyn {nyn unzny`d ecbd&
aynl bl jgy f~dqbpdn ynp`byu, [n `dd u`q `la h`{na
`ig~q qcn cgupbq`d$ gpny`qbglu$ `la qcn qy`~f`u
blzgdzna bl qcn cgupbq`d ubq~`qbgl, Bq {`u bfpgy&
99
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
25/42
q`lq, Znyr gjqnl rg~ eg~dalq q`dm `ig~q cg{ rg~
jndq qg pngpdn gl qcn g~quban, Qcnr qyr$ i~q aglq
yn`ddr ~lanyuq`la qcn pygidnfu rg~ c`zn, Qcn
q`dmblk `la uc`yblk {bqc gqcny p`ynlqu bl qcn cgu&pbq`d {`u bfpgyq`lq, Rg~ kgq qg jnndblk znyr jyn`mr
`ig~q inblk ` p`yq&qbfn p`ynlq, Qcn p`ym uenln
abalq cndp$ nbqcny, Nznyrgln unnfna ug u~pnylgy&
f`d `q qcn p`ym, Bq {`u ` qnyybidn jnndblk uc`yblk
rg~y ecbda {bqc qcn cgupbq`d$ mlg{blk rg~ {nyn lgq
jynn$ qc`q qcnr eg~da e`dd rg~ `q `lr qbfn `la abu&y~pq rg~y {cgdn dbjn$ anqnyfbln {c`q rg~y j`fbdr
agnu `la cg{ bq dbznu, Ubfpdn qcblku dbmn qgbdnq&
qy`blblk {nyn abjjbe~dq, [n c`a innl c`zblk `
lgq`idn d`em gj u~eenuu bl qc`q `yn`, G~y yg~qblnu
{nyn j~yqcny uc`qqnyna ir qcn cgupbq`d zbubq,
Gln eg~pdn qc`q {na fnq injgyn {`u bl qcbu
qbfn, Qcn ugl c`a innl igyl {bqcg~q jblknyu glgln c`la, Qcn ageqgyu {nyn ky`a~`ddr i~bdablk jbl&
knyu jgy cbf , , , q`mblk igln jy`kfnlqu jygf cbu
dnku `la qcnby igln i`lm, Cn {`u kgblk qg in egl&
jbyfna `q cbu ec~yec `u uggl `u cn {`u yndn`una
jygf qcn cgupbq`d, Cbu p`ynlqu c`a ig~kcq cbf `
upneb`d u~bq `la qcnr {nyn `dd dggmblk jgy{`ya qgqcn gee`ubgl, Qcnr {nyn pynp`yna qg q`mn qcn u~bq
qg ` q`bdgy qg gpnl qcn un`fu ug qc`q cn eg~da knq
cbu c`la$ i`la`knu `la `dd$ qcyg~kc qcn udnnzn,
Qcnr {nyn d~emr, Qcn ageqgyu yna~ena qcn i~dm gj
95
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
26/42
qcn i`la`kn la dnq cbf kg cgfn, I~q qcbu pnyjneq&
dr lgyf`d$ j`fbdr qrpn j~leqbgl {`u `dfguq abu&
y~pqna ir qcn gpny`qbgl,
B {`u ubqqblk bl qcn dg~lkn q`dmblk qg ugfn gjqcn p`ynlqu `la qcn ndnz`qgy aggyu p`yqna, @ j`f&
bdr ny~pqna, Qcnyn {`u qcn dbqqdn kbyd$ {cg gizbg~u&
dr c`a qyg~idn {bqc cny `yfu, Qcn iglnu {nyn
e~yzna `la cny c`lau {nyn unq `q `l `{m{`ya
`lkdn, Gqcny qc`l qc`q ucn {`u pynqqr$ iybkcq `la
~bem$ idglan c`by$ pbkq`bdu `la i`lku, Ucn {`u `dbqqdn ibq gdany qc`l @qcnd`lqbu, Qcn fgqcny e`fn
g~q ubl~g~udr, Bl cny d`qn qcbyqbnu$ ucn {`u ` znyr
pynqqr {gf`l kyg{l gdany , , , f~ec nrndblny `la
p`dn$ p`dn$ rnddg{$ uqbjjdr upy`rna c`by, Ucn c`a `
dgzndr jbk~yn `la {`u pg~yna blqg cny aynuu,
Nznyrqcblk f`qecna, Ucn c`a f`lr ibhg~s,
Yblku$ lnem pbnenu$ iy`endnqu$ pblu, Nznyr a`r ucn{gyn ` abjjnynlq f`qecna nlunfidn `la f~ec hn{&
ndyr$ bled~ablk ibk$ egemq`bd ygemu gl cny jblknyu,
Qcn c~ui`la {`u anigl`by, C`by {`zna$ yna znuq$
iybkcq ucbyq$ id`em h`emnq$ j~llr c`q {bqc ` dbqqdn
jn`qcny bl qcn uban i`la `la ibk ec~lmr yblku, Cn
c`a ` ibk j`q ebk`y c`lkblk g~q gj cbu fg~qc, Ucn{bkkdna$ fblena$ `la qggm dbqqdn uqnpu$ u{bzndblk
cny cbpu, Cny p`blqna c`lau {nyn pynqqr `la ugyq
gj ~llnenuu`yr, Qcnr gizbg~udr j~leqbglna$ i~q
ucn abalq dggm `u qcg~kc ucn c`la `lr ~un jgy
91
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
27/42
qcnf, Ucn cnda cny `yfu g~q d`lk~gyg~udr `la cny
c`lau h~uq aybjqna `bfdnuudr jygf cny {ybuqu, Ucn
{`u qcn cbkc&uecggd u{nnqcn`yq kyg{l gdany,
Jgddg{blk qcnf {`u ` dbqqdn id`em d`ar jygf gln gjqcn bud`lau bl {cbqn ~lbjgyf$ uqgemblku$ `la ucgnu,
Ucn {`u znyr abuqynuuna qc`q cny i`ir {`u kgblk
blqg qcn cgupbq`d,
Bq {`u qcn ecbdau jbyuq gpny`qbgl, Qcn jbyuq qbfn
ucn {`u `{`r jygf cgfn, Qcn j`qcny `iugd~qndr
`agyna cny, Qg cny fgqcny ucn {`u fgff`d`,Qcn L`l` {`u dnjq `q qcn cgupbq`d qcn jn{ qbfnu
qcnr c`a qg dn`zn, @q jbyuq {n qcg~kcq ucn {`u `
l~yun ine`~un gj qcn {cbqn g~qjbq, Qcnl {n yn`d&
bxna qc`q ucn {`ulq agblk `lr gj qcn l~yun&qrpn
qcblku `la qc`q qcn l~yunu {nyn j~leqbglblk
`yg~la cny `u ~u~`d, Ucn u`q c`{mnrna$ h~uq
{`qecblk cny pynebg~u ec`ykn `la eggblk gzny cny,I~q ucn abalq ag `lrqcblk gqcny qc`l {c`q `dd qcn
gqcny fgqcnyu `la ynd`qbznu aba, ucn unnfna abu&
pd`ena, Gizbg~udr$ `q qcnby cgfn ucn abalq c`zn qg
{`qec gzny qcn dbqqdn kbyd `q `dd qbfnu `la c`a
qcblku qg ag, I~q cnyn$ ucn c`a lgqcblk qg ag$ i~q
ubq bl ` dg{ ecbdau ec`by `q ` dg{ ecbdau q`idn `lau{bznd cny lnem `u qcn dbqqdn kbyd aybjqna `yg~la,
Qcn dbqqdn kbyd c`yadr nzny dnjq qcn {`ya, Fguq gj qcn
gqcny ecbdaynl y`l ~p `la ag{l qcn c`ddu$ ~bemdr
`eedbf`qna qg qcn ln{ `qfgupcnyn, I~q ucn uq`rna
9>
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
28/42
bl qcn {`ya `la ugfnqbfnu e`fn ag{l qg qcn
dg~lkn qg ubq gl cny j`qcnyu d`p, Knlny`ddr qcn
{cgdn j`fbdr uq`rna bl qcn {`ya$ nsenpq qcn j`qcny
{cg {`u gl qndnpcgln egluq`lqdr,[cnl qcnr `yybzna$ qcnr {nyn znyr cguqbdn qg
qcn ynuq gj ~u, Bq unnfna `u qcg~kc qcnr jndq qc`q
qcnr abalq indglk, Qcnr abalq {`lq qg in qcnyn,
Qcnr c`a egfn qg qcn cgupbq`d$ `dd qcn {`r jygf `
j`y p`yq gj Dglk Bud`la$ ine`~un gj qcn cn`a gj
gyqcgpnabe c`la u~yknyr, Qcn l`llr uq`rna jgydglk cg~yu, Ucn {`u `d{`ru qcnyn injgyn B `yybzna$
`la {`u uqbdd ubqqblk bl cny fblb&ec`by `u B dnjq,
Qcn fgqcny {`u `dug egluq`lqdr zbubqblk$ jd~q&
qnyblk `yg~la cny ecbdau eybi, Qcn l`llr {`u
inuban qcn pgblq ublen qcn fgqcny {`u c`yadr nzny
`iunlq, Qcn j`qcny {`u qcn eg~ybny, Cn {`u unlq
ag{luq`byu jgy jgga ublen qcn dbqqdn kbyd ynj~una qcncgupbq`d abnq, @dd ucn {`lqna {`u jybna ecbemnl,
Cny j`qcny {`u jgynzny a`ucblk ag{luq`byu jgy
jybna jggau$ ugjq ayblmu$ `la qcn eggmbnu `la e`l&
abnu qc`q eyg{ana cny inauban&q`idn ay`{ny,
Qcnr {nyn znyr `dggj jgy unzny`d a`ru, Qcnr
unnfna `llgrna qc`q qcnby ecbda c`a qg uc`yn `{`ya {bqc qcn gqcny i`ibnu, Qcn dbqqdn kbyd {`u dug
` ibq uq`lagjjbuc, F`rin qcnr {nyn jy`ba qc`q png&
pdn {g~da u`r ugfnqcblk `ig~q qcn ecbdau pygi&
dnfu, Qcnr {nyn ` c`laugfn eg~pdn, Qcnby gqcny
9:
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
29/42
ecbdaynl {nyn c`laugfn, _nyc`pu qcnr c`alq
`ah~uqna qg qcn j`eq qc`q ucn {`u abjjnynlq, Qcnr
ky`a~`ddr ~l{g~la, B qcblm qcnr yn`dbxna qc`q$ bl
qcn cgupbq`d$ {n {nyn `dd bl qcn u`fn pgubqbgl, [n`dd c`a qg yndr gl n`ec gqcny jgy u~ppgyq, Lg gln
h~aknu bl qcn cgupbq`d , , , lgq gl qcn in`~qr gj rg~y
ecbda$ cg{ e~qn cn bu$ {c`q cn agnu gy u`ru, Rg~
q`dm `ig~q cg{ {ndd cn ig~lenu i`em jygf qcn gpny&
`qbgl$ cg{ {ndd qcn blebubgl cn`du$ cg{ ~bemdr qcn
ecbda bu `idn qg inkbl ~ublk cbu dbfiu `la `ah~uq qgc`zblk ` ln{ jblkny,
Bl ` {`r qcn cgupbq`d bu ` fgyn jybnladr `qfgu&
pcnyn qc`l qc`q gj qcn p`ym `la gqcny p~idbe ecbda&
k`qcnyblk pd`enu, Rg~ c`zn qg h~uqbjr `la nspd`bl
lgqcblk, _ngpdn kg g~q gj qcnby {`r qg in mbla qg
n`ec gqcny, Ugfn gj qcn c~ui`la&{bjn uenlnu `yn `
ibq qnlun$ i~q qc`qu qg in nspneqna,Qcn fgqcny c`a gln gj qcgun ucbznyr$ {cbupnyr
dbqqdn kbyd zgbenu, Cbu {`u cn`zbny {bqc ` y`up$ `
Cgddr{gga qg~kc&k~r f`llny, Ucn upnlq fguq gj
cny qbfn {bqc cny dbqqdn kbyd$ qyrblk qg eg`s cny blqg
n`qblk `la egfiblk qcn qcbl c`by blqg pbkq`bdu,
Qcnr abalq uq`yq ~l{blablk ~lqbd qcn ecbda c`ainnl bl jgy unzny`d a`ru `la qcn gpny`qbgl c`a
innl egled~ana, Qcnr lnzny {nyn jybnladr$ i~q
ink`l qg `emlg{dnakn qcn ynuq gj ~u `la u`r cnddg
`u qcnr uqnppna gjj qcn ndnz`qgy, Cn uq`yqna qg q`dm
9;
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
30/42
qg fn qg{`ya qcn nla ine`~un cn abuegznyna qc`q B
{ybqn, Qc`q bfpynuuna cbf, Gln gj cbu edgun
jybnlau bu ` {ndd&mlg{l {ybqny, Cn mnpq `umblk fn
bj B mln{ cbf$ `la B c`a qcn jnndblk qc`q B aygppnaunzny`d pnku ine`~un B abalq,
Cn {`u `d{`ru gl qcn qndnpcgln, Ublen bq {`u
` p`r pcgln `la qcnyn {`u lg iggqc$ bq h~uq c~lk
jygf qcn {`dd `la nl`idna nznyrgln qg n`znuaygp,
B abalq mlg{ {c`q cbu i~ublnuu {`u$ i~q cn
unnfna pygupnyg~u, Cna e`dd bl qg cbu unyzbennznyr cg~y q`mblk ag{l l~finyu$ kbzblk fnu&
u`knu$ f`mblk e`ddu, Lg f`qqny {cgf cn upgmn qg$
cn {g~da {cnnd `la an`d `la i~r `la undd {c`qnz&
ny bq {`u qcnr {nyn abue~uublk$ jygf ynjybkny`qgyu
qg qy`eqgy qy`bdnyu, Bj cn abalq c`zn bq$ cn gjjnyna qg
kg qg Hnyunr qg knq bq,
@jqny qcn ecbda c`a cny gpny`qbgl qcn {cgdnj`fbdr c~lk `yg~la cny eybi {`bqblk jgy qcn u~y&
kngl qg `ppn`y, B qcg~kcq qcnr {nyn {`bqblk jgy `l
nspd`l`qbgl gj qcn pygena~yn, Lgq `q `dd, Bq {`u
dbmn gpnlblk lbkcq , , , nspneq`lq j`lu k`qcnyna
`yg~la qcn uq`kn aggy, Qcn u~ykngl iynnxna bl$
ufbdblk, `uu~yna, Cn u`ba qc`q qcnby a`~kcqny c`aagln jbln$ lg egfpdbe`qbglu, Nznyrgln ufbdna `la
p~fpna c`lau, Qcn ageqgy dnjq, I~q qcn p`ynlqu
unnfna fgyn ynd`sna$ yndbnzna$ qcnby nspneq`qbglu
j~djbddna,
93
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
31/42
Qcn qbfn ay`kkna ~lqbd bq {`u qbfn qg q`mn
@qcnd`lqbu cgfn, Qcnr c`a qg yni`la`kn qcn c`la
`la qcn kygbl, B abalq unn {c`q qcn c`la dggmna
dbmn$ i~q B {`u qcnyn {cnl qcnr ~laba qcn kygbl, Bq{`u ` fnuu, Q{g gj qcn u~q~ynu c`a p~ddna dggun
`la uneqbglu gj qcn ue`y {nyn bljneqna ine`~un gj
qcn ~ybln bl qcn i`la`kn, Qcnr edn`lna bq ibq$ i~q
qcnyn {`ulq f~ec qcnr eg~da ag, Qcn ageqgy u`ba
qc`q cna p~q ` pd`uqbe eg`qblk gzny bq qg pygqneq bq,
Cn upy`rna qcn pd`uqbe gzny qcn kygbl `yn` `laqcnl pd`ena ` k`~xn p`a gl qgp gj bq, Cn abalq dnq
qcn pd`uqbe ayr qcgyg~kcdr$ cg{nzny, [cnl {n kgq
cgfn `la ynfgzna qcn k`~xn p`a #`u bluqy~eqna" bq
`dug p~ddna `{`r fguq gj qcn pd`uqbe eg`qblk$ uqblk&
blk `u bq e`fn gjj, Cn {`u y`qcny ky~fp {cnl cn
{`u cgfn, B ecnemna {bqc qcn edblbe `la qcn ageqgy
u`ba qc`q cn {`u pygi`idr igqcnyna ir qcn pbl blqcn qc~fi, I~q cn {`u andbkcqna qg in i`em= cn
{nlq uqy`bkcq gzny qg cbu ygemny `la qc~fpna ~p
`la ag{l edblkblk qg cbu id`lmnq,
Qcn jbyuq qbfn {n {nlq qg g~qp`qbnlq cn {`u
znyr kyg~ecr, Cbu c`la {`u igqcnyblk cbf, Bq {`u` {`yf a`r, Cn c`a fbuuna cbu l`p bl gyany qg in
`q qcn cgupbq`d gl qbfn, [n c`a qg {`bq, [n {`bq&
na `ig~q q{g `la gln&c`dj cg~yu injgyn {n {nyn
e`ddna, B abalq unn g~y ynk~d`y u~ykngl, B aba unn
92
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
32/42
qcn pynqqr$ rg~lk ageqgy, B c`a ` jnndblk qc`q {na
in unnl ir cbf, B {`u ybkcq, B {`u f`a, Cn e`ddna
~u blqg qcn e~ibedn `la qcnl dnjq, B {`bqna `la
{`bqna,B uqgga @qcnd`lqbu gl qcn {blag{ ubdd ug cn
eg~da {`qec qcn egluqy~eqbgl ag{l indg{, Qcn age&
qgy abalq ynq~yl$ i~q cn c`a dnjq qcn e`uniggm, B
jdbppna bq qg qcn d`uq jn{ nlqybnu$ ine`~un B mln{
qcgun {g~da in qcn fguq ynenlq lgq`qbglu, B {`u
`f`xna qg unn qc`q cn c`a `eq~`ddr p`yqbebp`qna blqcn u~yknyr, B f`r c`zn fbuyn`a qcn uneqbglu$ i~q
cn c`a ubklna qcn p`y`ky`pcu anueybiblk qcn u~y&
knyr `la bq unnfna qg fn qc`q bq blabe`qna cn c`a
ugfn ynupglubibdbqr bl bqu nsne~qbgl, B {`u cgppblk
f`a, Cn jbl`ddr e`fn i`em `la u`{ fn yn`ablk
qcn e`uniggm,
Rg~ e`lq yn`a qc`q$ cn u`ba, _`qbnlqu `ynlq`ddg{na qg yn`a qcn e`uniggm,
Bf lgq qcn p`qbnlq$ B u`ba, Bf qcn p`qbnlqu
fgqcny, Bq agnulq igqcny fn qg yn`a bq,
Qc`qu pybz`qn f`qnyb`d$ `la rg~yn lgq
`ddg{na qg unn bq$ cn ynpn`qna,
Rg~ e`l f`mn bq n`ur `la dnq fn yn`a bq$ Bynupglana$ gy B e`l c`zn bq u~ipgnl`na, Nbqcny
{`r$ Bdd knq qg yn`a bq,
Rg~dd c`zn qg u~ipgnl` bq$ qcnl cn `lu{nyna$
`la ky`iina qcn iggm `u cn uq`dmna g~q,
5?
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
33/42
Bq abalq f`qqny= B c`a yn`a fguq gj qcn iggm
pynzbg~udr$ `lr{`r$ `la c`a ue`llna qcn pnyqb&
lnlq uneqbglu injgyn cn qggm bq `{`r jygf fn, @
e`uniggm bu pybz`qn f`qnyb`d `la bl`afbuubidn `ueg~yq nzbanlen, I~q qcn gldr yn`ugl qcnr mnnp qcn
e`uniggm uneynq jygf qcn p`qbnlq bu qc`q qcnr c`zn
`d{`ru mnpq qcn e`uniggm uneynq, Qcnyn #bl qcbu
uq`qn `lr{`r" bu lg uq`q~qn gl ynegya qg qc`q njjneq,
Cn jbl`ddr e`fn i`em `la uq`yqna ~l{y`ppblk
qcn i`iru c`la, @qcnd`lqbu abalq dbmn cbf, Cnmnpq ~p ` uqn`ar ubynl,
G~y g{l u~ykngl {`u bl `l `ahgblblk e~ibedn,
Cn mnpq e`ddblk bluqy~eqbglu qg qcn ynubanlq, Cn
jbl`ddr ~l{y`ppna qcn c`la, Bq dggmna qnyybidn,
U{gddnl `la iy~buna&dggmblk$ qcn pbl f`an cbu
qc~fi nznl ucgyqny `la j`qqny&dggmblk `la znyr
ybkba, Qcn ky`jqblk abalq dggm kgga, Y`qcny qc`lcn`dblk jd`q #gy nznl egndgba" bq {`u jd`ppblk, Q{g
gj qcn u~q~ynu {nyn dggun, Qcnr {nyn qbna une~yndr
qg qcnby g{l nlau$ i~q {nynlq cgdablk q{g uneqbglu
gj qcn umbl qgknqcny, G~y ageqgy e`ddna g~q$ B aglq
{`lq qcn u~q~ynu qg egfn g~q ~lqbd lnsq {nnm,
Qcn rg~lk ageqgy `kynna$ `u cn e~q g~q qcn q{gu~q~ynu qc`q {nynlq cgdablk, Cn u`ba$ Bq dggmu
jbln, Bq c`a lnzny dggmna qc`q i`a, Cn p~ddna qcn
pbl, Cn eg~dalq knq bq g~q n`ubdr$ ug cn c`a qg {bk&
kdn `la q{buq bq, @qcnd`lqbu ueyn`fna bl p`bl, I~q
50
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
34/42
qcn pbl jbl`ddr e`fn g~q, Cn yn{y`ppna qcn c`la,
Cn ~l{y`ppna qcn kygbl, Ba innl qyrblk qg
mnnp k`~xn gl bq$ i~q jg~la bq bfpguubidn, B c`a qg
mnnp ec`lkblk qcn k`~xn ine`~un gj qcn ~ybln,Jbl`ddr$ fguq gj qcn qbfn$ B dnq cbf y~l `yg~la {bqc
` znyr dgun ab`pny `la lg i`la`kn, Bq {`u `dyn`ar
bljneqna$ i~q B c`a qybna qg mnnp bq `u ayr `la edn`l
`u pguubidn, Qcn pc`yf`ebuq c`a kbznl fn `l gblq&
fnlq qg ~un qc`q {`u kgga jgy u~yj`en umbl bljne&
qbglu, [na `dug y~iina zbq`fbl N blqg qcn {g~laine`~un B jg~la qc`q bq cndpna cbf cn`d, B c`a
ecnemna {bqc cbu pnab`qybeb`l `ig~q qc`q$ `la ucn
c`alq unnl `lr yn`ugl {cr B ucg~dalq, @jqny
yn{y`ppblk @qcnd`lqbuu c`la `la kbzblk ~u `l
`ppgblqfnlq jgy qcn jgddg{blk {nnm$ qcn ageqgy dnjq,
B mln{ qc`q B c`a qg ag ugfnqcblk, B {`ulq
u~yn cg{ qg pygenna, Bq c`a innl pgblqdnuu qg rndd`la e~yun `q qcnf bl qcn edblbe, Qcnr {g~da c`zn
`dd innl `lkyr {bqc fn `la ed~iina qgknqcny, Qcn
~l{blablk$ e~qqblk gj u~q~ynu$ ynaynuublk$ c`a `dd
pygennana ug ~bemdr qc`q bq c`alq yn`ddr ynkbu&
qnyna gl fn {c`q B c`a unnl `la {c`q c`a c`p&
pnlna ~lqbd `jqny{`ya {cnl B ynfnfinyna `lanz`d~`qna, Bq {`u fr jnndblk qc`q qcn rg~lk ageqgy
{`ulq znyr umbddna, Cn qgppna qc`q ir c`zblk anj&
blbqn y`eb`d pygidnfu, F`rin bq {`ulq y`en= cn aba&
lq unnf qg dbmn qcn pggy `la qcn pggy {nyn gj nqc&
59
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
35/42
lbe i`emkyg~lau, Rg~ e`l lnzny n`ubdr pygzn qc`q
u~ppgubqbgl, B abalq mlg{ {cnqcny gy lgq qg nznl
qyr, B abalq mlg{ cg{ f~ec {`u fr l`qbzn p`y`&
lgb` `la cg{ f~ec {`u yn`ddr qy~n, B u`q i`em `lauq`yqna qcblmblk gzny qcn p`uq blebanlqu$ aynakblk
~p `dd qcn uenlnu {bqc qc`q rg~lk ageqgyuenlnu gj
frundj `la qcn rg~lk ageqgy, Bl n`ec bluq`len$ qcn
p`ynlqu {nyn gj ` fblgybqr kyg~p= bl g~y e`un
@qcnd`lqbu {`u Lnkyg&E`~e`ub`l, I~q bj B u`ba
`lrqcblk$ {c`q {g~da c`ppnl qg @qcnd`lqbu7[g~da qcnr q`mn bq g~q gl cbf7 Ageqgyu {nyn ug
ed`llbuc qc`q B {gyybna `ig~q ynpybu`du, Qcbu gpny&
`qbgl {`u lgq `u {ndd c`ladna `u qcn gqcnyu, Qc`q
{`u ` anjblbqn j`eq,
B e`ddna fr d`{rny, B qgda cbf {c`q c`a c`p&
pnlna, Cn u`ba qc`q qcn uq`la`yau gj qcbu gpny`&
qbgl anjblbqndr abalq f`qc ~p {bqc qcn gqcnyu gy{bqc g~y nspneq`qbglu, [n eg~da ed`bf lnkdbknlen=
qcnyn {nyn nlg~kc j`equ qg u~iuq`lqb`qn u~ec `
e`un, I~q B abalq yn`ddr {`lq qg kg qg eg~yq, Qc`q
{`ulq qcn pgblq, B {`ulq blqnynuqna bl {bllblk
`lr fglnr gy pgblqu, B {`lqna fr ecbda qg c`zn
kgga fnabe`d qyn`qfnlq, @la qcnl qcnyn {nyn qcngqcny ecbdaynl, Qcn ageqgy {`u {gymblk gl gqcny
ecbdaynl, Qcnyn {`u lg ecgben, Bj B mnpq fr fg~qc
uc~q B {`u h~uq `u k~bdqr `u cn, B e`ddna qcn gyqcg&
pnabe ugeb`d {gymny, Ucn u`ba qc`q ucn mln{ ugfn
55
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
36/42
gj qcn gqcny fgqcnyu {nyn ~lc`ppr {bqc qcbu age&
qgy, Ucna c`a egfpd`blqu `ig~q cbf injgyn
ine`~un cbu f`llny {`u ug egda, Lg gln c`a `eq~&
`ddr `ee~una cbf gj ib`u, Ucn k`zn fn qcn l`fnugj q{g ageqgyuqcn cn`a gj ynubanlqu `la qcn cn`a
gj qcn edblbe,
B e`ddna fr pnab`qybeb`l, B qgda cny {c`q c`a
c`ppnlna, B `umna jgy cny `azben, Ucn u`ba {ybqn
` dnqqny, Ucn abalq qcblm qcnyn {g~da in `lr gpny&
`qblk&yggf ynpnye~uubgl, Qc`q bj B {`u ybkcq$ugfngln ucg~da uqgp cbf jygf py`eqbeblk gl
fblgybqr ecbdaynl,
Gln gj qcn qcblku B jbla abuq~yiblk bu qc`q bj qcn
ageqgy agnu c`zn pygidnfu$ inrgla cbu bl`ibdbqr qg
egff~lbe`qn c~f`lndr `la `l bfpnyjneqbgl gj
umbdd$ {cr abalq cn `um qg in q`mnl gjj qcn e`un7
Cn {`u `uubklna qg ~u {bqcg~q g~y inblk qgda {n{nyn qg c`zn cbf, C`a B mlg{l qc`q cn c`a innl
`uubklna B {g~da c`zn yn~nuqna `lgqcny ageqgy,
Nznl bl ` edblbe ubq~`qbgl rg~ c`zn qcn ybkcq$ bj qgda
bl `az`len qcn l`fn gj rg~y ageqgy$ qg yn~nuq `
abjjnynlq gln, C`a {n innl ~nybna jbyuq$ {n eg~da
c`zn u`ba qc`q qcn ageqgy {`u `lq`kglbuqbe qg ~u`la abalq `d{`ru nsnyebun kgga h~akfnlq bl cbu
c`ladblk gj qcn p`qbnlq `la p`ynlq, I~q `q qc`q
cgupbq`d qcnr lnzny `um {cnqcny gy lgq rg~ knq gl
{bqc gln gj qcnby ageqgyu, @la fguq pngpdn `yn qgg
51
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
37/42
`jy`ba qg upn`m g~q, B nspneq qcnr `uu~fn qc`q `dd
qcnby ageqgyu {bdd j~leqbgl ~p qg qcnby p~idbe&ynd`&
qbglu uq`la`yau, Bl qcbu e`un qcn ageqgy abalq,
[`u bq ine`~un cn {`u lgq ` kgga ageqgy gy ine`~ungj cbu nfgqbgl`d pygidnfu7
Bj cbu pygidnfu `yn nfgqbgl`d cn ucg~da `um qg
{gym gl {cbqn ecbdaynl gldr, Qcnyn `yn enyq`bldr
nlg~kc yn~byblk qyn`qfnlq, Bj bqu j~yqcny qy`bl&
blk cn lnnau$ qcnl cn ucg~da c`zn bq$ i~q lgq `q qcn
nspnlun gj cndpdnuu ecbdaynl, Dnq cbf giunyznnspnyqu `la in fgyn j~ddr k~bana ir ~`dbjbna u~y&
knglu, B indbnzn cn {`u `ddg{na qgg f~ec jynnagf
{bqc @qcnd`lqbu, B aglq mlg{ cg{ cn j~leqbglna
{bqc gqcny p`qbnlqu$ inrgla qcn u~pnyjbeb`d eglzny&
u`qbglu B gzny cn`ya$ i~q fnabe`ddr upn`mblk$ {cnl
cn c`ladna fr ecbda$ bq {`u {yglk, qcbu B ynunlq,
B {ygqn qcn dnqqny qg qcn cgupbq`d$ anq`bdblk `ddg~y nspnybnlenu, B qybna qg yn`ec g~y ynk~d`y u~y&
kngl ir pcgln$ i~q cn abalq ynq~yl fr e`ddu, B
upgmn qg qcn ugeb`d {gymny, Ucn u`ba qc`q ucn {`u
kd`a qc`q B c`a {ybqqnl qcn dnqqny, B {`u znyr lnyz&
g~u, B jndq qc`q B c`a agln qcn ybkcq qcblk$ i~q B
{`u ue`yna,[n {nlq qg qcn cgupbq`d jgy g~y lnsq `ppgblq&
fnlq, Qcn rg~lk ageqgy {`ulq gl a~qr qc`q a`r,
[n {`bqna {ndd gzny `l cg~y injgyn {n {nyn e`ddna,
[cnl {n {nyn jbl`ddr q`mnl blqg `l ns`fblblk
5>
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
38/42
yggf ` uqy`lkn ageqgy uq`yqna qg ec`lkn i`la`knu
`la q`mn g~q u~q~ynu, B `umna qg upn`m qg g~y u~y&
kngl, Cn `yybzna, B {`u uc`mblk `la lnyzg~u, B
uq~qqny {cnl pygzgmna$ i~q B c`a qg upn`m, B qgdacbf qc`q B {`u ucgemna qg jbla qcn rg~lkny ageqgy
c`a ug f~ec eglq`eq {bqc fr ecbda$ {bqc cbu gpny&
`qbgl$ `la pguqgpny`qbzn e`yn, B u`ba qc`q B jndq qcn
{`u y`eb`ddr ib`una `la ` udgppr qneclbeb`l, B qgda
cbf ugfn gj qcn qcblku qc`q c`a c`ppnlna inq{nnl
qcn i`ir `la qcn ageqgy, Cn u`ba qc`q cn {`u`uqglbucna qg cn`y bq= cn c`alq mlg{l qcn gqcny
ageqgy c`a y`eb`d pygidnfu, Cn `umna$ [cr abalq
rg~ qndd fn ugglny7 B qgda cbf qc`q B c`a qybna qg
yn`ec cbf ir pcgln$ i~q qc`q cn abalq ynq~yl fr
e`ddu, Cn `pgdgkbxna, Ibk an`d, @la cn qgda fn
qc`q qcn gqcny ageqgy {`u inblk ygq`qna g~q gj qc`q
anp`yqfnlq `la {g~dalq in i`em bl gyqcg ~lqbd qcnlnsq rn`y= Ba pygi`idr lgq unn cbf `k`bl, B `umna
cg{ {n eg~da pynznlq qc`q ugyq gj qcblk jygf c`p&
pnlblk `k`bl, Lgigar qgda fn cn {`u kgblk qg
c`zn `lrqcblk qg ag {bqc fr ecbda, Bq `dd ugyq gj
c~lk bl qcn `by, Q{g gqcny ageqgyu {nyn dbuqnlblk
qg qcn eglznyu`qbglu y`pqdr,Nznyrgln pygjnuuna kyn`q ucgem$ i~q lg gln
unnfna qg c`zn `lr ugd~qbglu, B aglq nznl mlg{
{cnqcny gy lgq qcnr indbnzna fn, Bq abalq f`qqny,
Qcnra in a`fl e`ynj~d {cg {nlq ln`y @qcnd`lqbu
5:
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
39/42
bl qcn j~q~yn, Qcn c`la {`u cn`dblk {ndd$ qcnr
`uu~yna fn, Qcn jd`ppblk {`u uq`yqblk qg edgun
gzny, Qcnr ynfgzna qcn ynuq gj qcn u~q~ynu, Qcn
kygbl `yn` {`u uqbdd bljneqna,[n {nlq i`em gln fgyn qbfn$ `la qcnl {nyn
jynn qg {`bq jgy qcn lnsq e`dd, B {`u uqbdd {`bqblk jgy
qcn ynupglun jygf qcn cgupbq`d qg fr dnqqny, Bq
jbl`ddr `yybzna8
Qcbu bu bl ynpdr qg rg~y dnqqny gj F`r 9>$02;0 bl {cbec rg~ anueybin rg~ nspnybnlenu
igqc bl qcn Cgupbq`d `la bl qcn edblbe a~yblk
@qcnd`lqbu e`yn cnyn, Jbyuq$ dnq fn `pgdgkbxn
jgy `lr bdd jnndblku {cbec c`zn innl knlny`qna
ir `lr fnfinyu gj qcn Cgupbq`d uq`jj {cnqcny
qcnr in ageqgyu$ l~yunu$ ednybe`d pnyugllnd gy
gqcnyu, @u qcn blqnddbknlq {gf`l rg~ `yn$ rg~ug {ndd mlg{ qc`q bq bu nuunlqb`ddr bfpguubidn
jgy ` qcbya p`yqr qg nz`d~`qn {c`q {`u u`ba$
{c`q qcn fn`lblk incbla bq {`u `la {c`q qcn
ynenbznyu blqnypynq`qbgl {`u jygf qcn eglzny&
u`qbgl, B aglq mlg{ {c`q Ay, & u`ba$
lgy ag B mlg{ {c`q cbu fn`lblk {`u, B agmlg{$ cg{nzny$ {c`q rg~y blqnypynq`qbgl gj
{c`q cn u`ba {`u$ `la qcbu gj eg~yun igqcnyu
fn kyn`qdr, Qcg~kc B `f u~yn rg~y fn`lblk
jygf Ay, & uq`qnfnlqu {`u lgq {c`q cn
5;
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
40/42
blqnlana$ qcn j`eq ynf`blu qc`q cbu {`u qcn
fn`lblk cn ynd`rna qg rg~, Jgy qcbu B ublenyn&
dr `pgdgkbxn,
B `f u~yn rg~ `yn `{`yn qc`q qcn rg~lk
ageqgyu {cg egfn gl g~y uq`jj `yn nsenpqbgl`d&
dr {ndd qy`blna, Cg{nzny$ B `f jy`lm qg `afbq
qc`q qcn ns~iny`len `la zbq`dbqr gj g~y rg~qc
ugfnqbfnu dn`au qg `l bl`ibdbqr qg egff~lb&
e`qn {bqc qcnby ndanyu `la nznl {bqc qcnbypnnyu, B h~uq e`lq indbnzn qc`q Ay, &u
egffnlqu {nyn y`eb`ddr gybnlqna bl `lr {`r
jgy `u rg~ mlg{$ qcn & Cgupbq`d {`u ink~l
bl 03:3 ine`~un ` id`em {gf`l {g~da lgq in
`afbqqna qg nsbuqblk cgupbq`du `q qc`q qbfn,
@u qg qcn pygjnuubgl`d c`ladblk gj@qcnd`lqbu$ B c`zn abue~uuna qcbu {bqc unlbgy
fnfinyu gj qcn pygjnuubgl`d uq`jj, Qcnr ~lb&
jgyfdr qndd fn qc`q byynupneqbzn gj qcn `kn gj
ecbdaynl c`zblk umbl ky`jqu$ p`yqbe~d`ydr jgy
qcn c`la$ qcn kygbl `la d`qny`d qcbkc `yn` bu
qcn pynjnyyna ubqn jgy f`lr yn`uglu, Jbyuq `lrgqcny ubqn fbkcq dn`a qg abujbk~yblk ue`yu
{cbec fbkcq in nfi`yy`uublk bl dgemny yggfu$
gl in`ecnu `la ug jgyqc, Unegladr$ qcn umbl
jygf qcbu `yn` `ddg{u jgy ` qcbemny ky`jq `la `
53
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
41/42
fgyn unyzben`idn umbl gl ` c`la, Qcbyadr
qcg~kc qcnun `yn`u `yn fgyn pygln qg inegfn
bljneqna `l bljneqbgl$ bj bq anzndgpu$ e`l in n`u&
bdr an`dq {bqc `u B indbnzn bu gee~yyblk bl@qcnd`lqbu ubq~`qbgl,
@k`bl$ B `pgdgkbxn jgy {c`q rg~ anueybin `u
`l ~lpdn`u`lq nspnybnlen `la B `f znyr kd`a
qc`q rg~ e`ddna rg~y nspnybnlen qg fr `qqnl&
qbgl, B qy~uq qc`q gl rg~y ynq~yl zbubqu `laa~yblk qcn nlu~blk cgupbq`dbx`qbglu$ rg~y
nspnybnlen {bdd in f~ec fgyn pdn`u`lq,
B yn`a bq qcyg~kc q{ben, @q jbyuq B {`u `lkyr,
Qcnl B yn`dbxna h~uq cg{ bddgkbe`d qcn yn`uglblk
{`u `la B d`~kcna, Qcn dnqqny {`u ` ed`uube, U{nnq
yn`ugl qyrblk qg p`ebjr qcn yne`debqy`lq, Bq ynbl&jgyena fr ~yknlq lnna qg {ybqn qcbu iggm,
[n {nyn nspneqblk qg kg i`em blqg qcn cgupbq`d
`k`bl jgy qcn lnsq gpny`qbgl bl H~ln, B {glanyna
cg{ qcn qyn`qfnlq {g~da in$ {cnqcny gy lgq Ba in
qyn`qna pd`k~n&dbmn, [cnqcny gy lgq qcnyna inynpnye~uubglu, Cg{ f`lr pngpdn {g~da jbla g~q,
Injgyn `lr gj qc`q c`ppnlna {n c`a qyg~idn {bqc
g~y fnabe`d blu~y`len, Bq qggm qcnf qcynn fglqcu
qg uqy`bkcqnl bq g~q, Ugfngln c`a p~q qcn {yglk
52
-
8/9/2019 Care Without Care (Chapter XII)
42/42
pgdber l~finy gl @qcnd`lqbuu `afbuubgl ucnnq `la
qcn ibdd qg Id~n Eyguu, [n ~bemdr ynenbzna ` ibdd
jgddg{na ir ` dnqqny jygf qcn cgupbq`d u`rblk qc`q
Id~n Eyguu {`u lgq cglgyblk g~y ed`bf$ qc`q qcnrc`a lg ynegya gj g~y a`~kcqny$ @qcnd`lqbu$ gy gj g~y
pgdber l~finy, B e`ddna qcn cgupbq`d, [cnl B
ynenbzn ibddu B uq`yq uc`mblk, C~kn u~fu gj fglnr
`yn inrgla fr mnl, B ~bemdr abuegznyna qcn fbu&
q`mn qcn cgupbq`d c`a f`an, Qcnr u`ba qcnra {ybqn
Id~n Eyguu `la edn`y bq ~p, B ynfblana qcnf qc`qfr a`~kcqny @qcnd`lqbu {`u bl yn`dbqr ` igr, Qcn
cgupbq`d gjjbeb`d u`ba$ znyr unybg~udr$ @yn rg~
u~yn7 B u`ba$ Rnu$ Bf znyr u~yn `jqny q{g rn`yu,
Cn u`ba$ [ndd rg~yn qcn fgqcny$ B k~nuu rg~a
mlg{,
[n ynenbzna ` ibdd jygf qcn cgupbq`d nznyr q{g
{nnmu, Nylbn jbl`ddr snygsna cbu blu~y`len e`yagl cbu gjjben dnqqnycn`a `la unlq bq `dd qg qcn cgupb&
q`d, Qcn d`uq {nnm bl @~k~uq {n {nyn qgda qc`q
Id~n Eyguu jbl`ddr `ppygzna qcn ed`bf,
#Qg in eglqbl~na"