Captain Pamela Barnett, et al v. Barack Hussein Obama, et al, Central District of California, Case...

7/31/2019 Captain Pamela Barnett, et al v. Barack Hussein Obama, et al, Central District of California, Case #: 8:09-cv-00082-DOC-AN;

1/38


2/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +3 +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP

3>073 LH WH_ PTAYD 388

KAPPABJ ÂDOB, @HLANBSJAH 13>18

-191! >=0+4988

D+KHAL? ISRYHAY_GQHMBB*@BK

@kis* Ibtelhp Dhsl Pybdwwdludsym Ymbkhp O Yhqlbs, Sdwsdpdjyhya~d Dsa` Puhnnbsi, Ydjjdppdd @hwyhaj Jdal C* Ytsjds, Sa`mhsi D* ^djhcld, L@IS Odnn Eshmhk Uajymsbwd, hji Ly* @blbjdl Khsf Usaeeld,

Wlhajyannp,

~*

Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh, Ka`mdlld L*S* Bchkh, Mallhsq Sbimhk @lajybj, Pd`sdyhsq bn Pyhyd, Sbcdsy K* Ehydp, Pd`sdyhsq bn Idndjpd, Obpdwm S* Caidj, a`d+Wsdpaidjy hji

Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Pdjhyd, Idndjihjyp*

NASPY HKDJIDI @BKWLHAJY

Wlhajyannp csaje ymap lhuptay yb pddf, hcb~d hll, h id`lhshybsq otiekdjy wtspthjy

yb 3= T*P*@* 3378+3373, idàiaje umdymds Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh `hj

pmbu cq `ldhs hji `bj~ajàje d~aidj`d ymhy md ap h jhytshl cbsj àyazdj bn ymd Tjaydi

Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`h uaymaj ymd kdhjaje bn Hsya`ld AA, Pd`yabj A bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj bn

ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, hji ymdsdnbsd umdymds md ap xthlanadi, bs tjxthlanadi, nbs ymd

wbpayabj uma`m md mhp mdli, id nh`yb an jby id otsd paj`d Ohjthsq 37, 3771*

Ymd whym yb ymap Naspy Hkdjidi @bkwlhajy mhp cddj ybsytbtp, hp ymd Mbjbshcld

Otied bn ymap @btsy iap`tppdi hji bcpds~di aj wsb`ddiajep bj Kbjihq, Otlq 80,

3771* Khjq bn ymd ajia~aithl wlhajyannp aj ymap Naspy Hkdjidi @bkwlhajy mh~d hp

ajia~aithlp hyydkwydi yb tpd pyhyd hji ndidshl Nsddibk bn Ajnbskhyabj H`yp hji bymds

wsb`ditsdp aj hj hyydkwy, uma`m mhp pb nhs cddj nstpyshydi hji aj ~haj, yb hjpuds ymap

pddkajelq pakwld hji iasd`y xtdpyabj* Ay ap nbs ymap sdhpbj, hji nbs khjq bymdsp, ymhy

Wlhajyannp mh~d bwydi yb d}whji ymd p`bwd bn ymdas bsaeajhl bjd `btjy `bkwlhajy nbs

ymd nbllbuaje kbsd bkwsdmdjpa~d hji bkwld} bkwlhajy, b~dsaje khjq wsdia`hyd

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed 3 bn 0= Whed AI #?879


3/38


4/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Pwdàna`hllq, cty uaymbty lakayhyabj, Wlhajyannp hpf ymap @btsy yb djyds h

id`lhshybsq otiekdjy aj bswds xtb uhsshjyb `bj`dsjaje ymd Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi

Pyhydp, ymd Pd`sdyhsq bn Pyhyd, ymd Pd`sdyhsq bn Idndjpd, hji ymd â`d+Wsdpaidjy hjiWsdpaidjy bn ymd Pdjhyd, yb djobaj ymd hwwbajykdjy hji"bs pdjhybsahl `bjnaskhyabj bn

jdu Hsya`ld AAA -landyakd ydjtsd(! ndidshl otiedp bs otpya`dp hji kdhjumald yb djyds h

Wsdlakajhsq Ajotj`yabj hehajpy ymd d}dsàpd bn `dsyhaj `saya`hl `bjpyaytyabjhl ntj`yabjp

cq ymd id nh`yb Wsdpaidjy itsaje ymd idydskajhyabj bn ymap h`yabj aj bswds xtb

uhsshjyb, jhkdlq -8! ymd hwwbajykdjy bn hjq wdspbj yb pds~d hp ymd TP hyybsjdq nbs

ymd Iapysa`y bn @bltkcah hji -3! hwwbajykdjy hji ymd `bjnaskhyabj bn hjq wdspbj hp h

jdu Ptwsdkd @btsy Otpya`d yb sdwlh`d sdyasaje Ks* Otpya`d Ih~ai Pbtyds tjyal

dlaeacalayq"ldeayakh`q bn Ks* Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh hfh Chssq Pbdybsb nbs ymd

wbpayabj bn ymd wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp hji -0! h Wsdlakajhsq Ajotj`yabj hehajpy

jdu idwlbqkdjyp bs hppaejkdjyp bn hskdi nbs`dp yb pdjpaya~d hji ~blhyald hsdhp bn

ymd ubsli pt`m hp ymd Jdhs hji Kaiild Dhpy, Wdspahj Etln, Udpy @djyshl Hpahj,

Udpydsj Makhlhqhj, bs Ajiahj B`dhj hsdhp tjyal ymd `bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabjp bn

ymd @bkkhjids+aj+@madn `hj dpyhclapmdi cq `ldhs+hji+`bj~ajàje d~aidj`d hp h

khyyds bn `bjpyaytyabjhl lhu*

Najhllq, ymd Wlhajyannp pddf h id`lhshybsq otiekdjy nsbk ymap btsy idydskajaje

umdymds `dsyhaj `sakdp bn nshti sdlhyaje yb aidjyayq bs nshtitldjy tpd bn pdjpaya~d

ajia~aithllq aidjyanqaje ajnbskhyabj -pt`m hp pbàhl pd`tsayq jtkcdsp bs pdld`ya~d

pds~a`d hwwla`hyabjp! mh~d cddj `bkkayydi hji `bj`dhldi cq pbkd bn ymd

idndjihjyp, h`yaje obajylq bs pd~dshllq umdymds bs jby aj nbskhl `bjpwash`q, uma`mubtli `bjpyaytyd wsdia`hyd h`yp bn sh`fdyddsaje uaymaj ymd kdhjaje bn 8= T*P*@*

81>8 dy pdx*, hji ymtp umdymds ymd Wsdpaidj`q bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, aj 377=, uhp

ib`tkdjy yb ptpyhaj ymd htymdjyaàyq, `bkwldydjdpp, hji jbj+kapldhiaje jhytsd bn ymhy ib`tkdjycq `ldhs hji`bj~ajàje d~aidj`d*

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed 9 bn 0= Whed AI #?87>


5/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


wsb`tsdi cq hji ymsbtem h whyydsj bn sh`fdydds ajnltdj`di hji `bsstwylq bsehjazdi

h`ya~ayadp* Ajotj`ya~d sdladn `bj`dsjaje pt`m h`ya~ayadp uall hlpb cd pbtemy, hlymbtem

ymd Wlhajyannp Naspy Hkdjidi @bkwlhajy ibdp jby aj`ltid hjq wshqds nbs ihkhedphlymbtem ymd Wlhajyannp sdpds~d ymdas saemy ntsymds yb hkdji ymdas wldhiajep hp ymap `hpd

wsbesdppdp, dpwdàhllq bj`d NBAH iap`lbptsdp hji iap`b~dsq cdeajp*

WHSYADP, OTSAPIA@YABJ, HJI ^DJTD

8* Ymap @btsy mhp otsapia`yabj wtspthjy yb 3= T*P*@* 8008 -ndidshl xtdpyabj!, 3=T*P*@* 8090 -à~al saemyp!, 8= T*P*@* 81>9-`! -SA@B!, 4 T*P*@* 443 -NBAH!, hji

93 T*P*@* 81=0, 81== -à~al saemyp h`yabj pddfaje id`lhshybsq bs ajotj`ya~d sdladn!*

Wlhajyannp pddf id`lhshybsq sdladn tjids 3= T*P*@* 3378+3373 hp udll hp 81==-h!*

3* ^djtd ap wsbwds tjids NBAH hji 93 T*P*@* 81==-h! cd`htpd pd~dshlwlhajyannp, aj`ltiaje Wlhajyann Ualdq P* Ishfd, la~d aj Bshjed @btjyq uaymaj ymd

Pbtymdsj Ia~apabj bn ymd @djyshl Iapysa`y bn @hlanbsjah*

0* ^djtd khq hlpb cd wsbwds cd`htpd Wlhajyannp mh~d d~aidj`d ymhy pd~dshlhiisdppdp tpdi cq Idndjihjyp Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh hji"bs Ka`mdlld Bchkh pmbu

ymhy ymdpd yub idndjihjyp hsd daymds whsy yakd sdpaidjyp aj ymd @djyshl Iapysa`y bn

@hlanbsjah bs dlpd khajyhaj ctpajdpp bnna`dp aj ymap iapysa`y, hp nbllbup?

9* Idndjihjyp Chsh`f-hfh Chshf2! hji Ka`mhdl Bchkh hwwdhs bj wtcla`sd`bsip sdysad~di nsbk Ld}ap+Jd}ap hji bymds pbts`dp yb mh~d lapydi hp wdskhjdjy bs

whsy+yakd sdpaidjyp bn ymd Pyhyd bn @hlanbsjah, Lbp Hjedldp hji Bshjed @btjyadp, uaym

nhaslq sd`djy hji wtcla`hllq sd`bsidi sdpaidj`dp hji"bs bnna`dp hy ymd nbllbuaje

hiisdppdp uaymaj ymd @djyshl Iapysa`y bn @hlanbsjah?-8!Jhkd + BCHKH, CHSHF

Pysddy Hiisdpp + 8>81 P CDJYLDQ H^D@ayq, Pyhyd, _aw + LBP HJEDLDP @H 17734+04=>Wsbchcld @tssdjy Hiisdpp + JbYdldwmbjd +Ydldwmbjd H``btjymblids +



6/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +> +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Pbàhl Pd`tsayq +Hed +Ihyd bn Casym +Id`dhpdi + JbIhyd Sd`bsi ^dsanadi + Id` 7= + Ohj 71////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////-3!

Jhkd + BCHKH, CHSHFPysddy Hiisdpp + 8771 IAEAYHL MUQ@ayq, Pyhyd, _aw + LBP HJEDLDP @H 17794Wsbchcld @tssdjy Hiisdpp + JbYdldwmbjd +Ydldwmbjd H``btjymblids +Pbàhl Pd`tsayq + 111+>8+}}}}Hed +Ihyd bn Casym +

Id`dhpdi + JbIhyd Sd`bsi ^dsanadi + Id` 74 + Hws 7>////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////-0!

Jhkd + BCHKH, CHSHFPysddy Hiisdpp + 8>=7 ÂIDB IS@ayq, Pyhyd, _aw + LBP HJEDLDP @H 17794Wsbchcld @tssdjy Hiisdpp + JbYdldwmbjd +Ydldwmbjd H``btjymblids +Pbàhl Pd`tsayq + 111+11+}}}}Hed +

Ihyd bn Casym +Id`dhpdi + JbIhyd Sd`bsi ^dsanadi + Jb~ 74 + Khs 7>

-9!CM BCHKHCb} >501=

Lbp Hjedldp, @H 177>5Wmbjd TjwtclapmdiObc Yayld?Jd}y Wsdpaidjy@bkwhjq?NsbjyWhed khehzajd*`bk

////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////-4!Ka`mdlld Bchkh8=8= J ^dskbjy H~d

Lbp Hjedldp, @H 17735Wmbjd TjwtclapmdiObc Yayld?Wsdpaidjy

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed > bn 0= Whed AI #?87=
http://www.addresses.com/results.php?ReportType=34&qf=Michelle&qi=40&qk=10&qn=Obama&MoreInfoResult=1&RecID=6http://www.addresses.com/results.php?ReportType=34&qf=Michelle&qi=40&qk=10&qn=Obama&MoreInfoResult=1&RecID=6


7/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


@bkwhjq?Shiab Nsdd Kafd

->!Ka`mdlld Bchkh

0>49 Chsmhk Cl~i X078Lbp Hjedldp, @H 177>=Wmbjd Tjwtclapmdi@bkwhjq?NbsEdj Wsbit`yabjp

-5!Ka`mdlld Bchkh8794 J Hskhjib Py H~d E

Hjhmdak, @H 13=7>Wmbjd Tjwtclapmdi@bkwhjq?@hkwtpcte

-=!Ka`mdlld Bchkh5704 Whlk Is

Shj`mb @t`hkbjeh, @H 18578Wmbjd Tjwtclapmdi@bkwhjq?Ktplak Ubsli Ybihq

-1!Ka`mdlld Bchkh477 P Ctdjh ^apyh Py

Ctschjf, @H 18438

Wmbjd Tjwtclapmdi@bkwhjq?Ymd Uhly Iapjdq @b*

-87!Ka`mdlld C* Bchkh373 U 8py Py

Lbp Hjedldp, @H 17783Wmbjd Tjwtclapmdi@bkwhjq?Lbp Hjedldp Yakdp

Ymdsd hsd, aj nh`y, hjbymds 87 bs kbsd sd`bsidi hiisdppdp nbs ymd Bchkhp aj

Jbsymdsj @hlanbsjah, `djydsdi hsbtji Phj Nshj`ap`b hji ymd Pala`bj ^hlldq hsdh

-Phj Khydb, Phj Shnhdl, dy`*!*

4* Wlhajyannp uaym tjaxtd wblaya`hl pyhjiaje aj`ltid Ualdq P* Ishfd, Hlhj Fdqdp,Ehal Laemynbby, hji Khsfmhk Sbcajpbj umb hll hwwdhsdi bj ymd @hlanbsjah chllby hp



8/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ += +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


`hjiaihydp nbs Wsdpaidjy bs a`d+Wsdpaidjy aj ymd 377= jhyabjhl Wsdpaidjyahl dld`yabjp6

an Idndjihjyp Chsh`f M* Bchkh hji hjq bn map `b+idndjihjyp djehedi aj h whyydsj bn

sh`fdyddsaje hp hlldedi hcb~d, ymdpd Wlhajyannp udsd ajotsdi aj ymdas ctpajdpp ajydsdpypcd`htpd ymdq mh~d ctpajdpp ajydsdpyp aj ymdas `hjiaihàdp nbs Wsdpaidjy bs a`d+

Wsdpaidjy*

>* Wlhajyann Ohpbj Nsddpd ap bj h`ya~d kalayhsq ityq aj Hlhpfh, hji ymtp mhppyhjiaje yb mhlldjed hji idkhji ldhs+hji+`bj~ajàje wsbbn bn ymd `bjpyaytyabjhl

xthlana`hyabjp bn ymd @bkkhjids+aj+@madn hji ymd ldehlayq bn ymd `tssdjy `mhaj bn

`bkkhji, hji khq xthlanq hp h `lhpp sdwsdpdjyhya~d bj cdmhln bn hll `tssdjylq h`ya~d

kdkcdsp bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp Hskdi Nbs`dp*

5* Hll ajh`ya~d bs sdyasdi kalayhsq wdspbjjdl umb hsd Wlhajyannp, ptcod`y yb sd`hll,mh~d pyhjiaje yb `mhlldjed hji idkhji `ldhs+hji+`bj~ajàje wsbbn nbs ymd phkd

sdhpbjp+++aj ymhy ymdq hsd ptcod`y yb sd`hll hji pds~a`d hy hjq yakd tjids hji ptcod`y

yb ymd id nh`yb `mhaj bn bkkhji*

=* Wlhajyannp umb hsd pyhyd sdwsdpdjyhya~dp mh~d tjaxtd pyhjiaje aj ymhy ymd Pyhydphsd sdpwbjpacld nbs pwdjiaje lhsed ptkp bn ndidshl sd~djtd pmhsaje kbjdq ymsbtem

~hsabtp wsbeshkp hikajapydsdi cq ymd D}d`tya~d Cshj`m bs xthpa+d}d`tya~d

Ajidwdjidjy @bkkappabjp pt`m hp ymd Pbàhl Pd`tsayq @bkkappabj uma`m bwdshydp

tjids ymd iasd`yabj bn h Wsdpaidjyahl hwwbajydd uaym na}di ydjtsd -jby iap`mhsedhcld

hy uall cty bjlq nbs `htpd!* Wlhajyann Pyhyd Sdwsdpdjyhya~dp ptckay hji `bjydji

ymhy ymdq mh~d h pwdàhl jbj+idldehcld `bjpyaytyabjhl saemy hji sdpwbjpacalayq yb ~dsanq

ymd xthlana`hyabjp bn ymd @madn D}d`tya~d Bnna`ds bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`humb ap sdpwbjpacld nbs hllb`hyaje lhsed ptkp bn ntjip, paj`d sd`dawy bn ntjip nsbk hjq

bnna`ds uaymbty ldehl htymbsayq ubtli cd `bkwlaàyq aj ymdny bs `bj~dspabj*

XTDPYABJP WSDPDJYDI NBS ID@LHSHYBSQ OTIEKDJY3= T*P*@*3378+3373

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed = bn 0= Whed AI #?887


9/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


1* Wlhajyannp sdhllded 8+= hji ymd wsdhkctlhs ch`fesbtji bn ymap `hpd hp an ntllq`bwadi hji sdpyhydi mdsdaj cdlbu, hji aj`bswbshyd ymd phkd cq sdndsdj`d*

87*

Hj h`ythl `bjysb~dspq d}apyp cdyuddj ymd Wlhajyannp hji ymd idndjihjyp`bj`dsjaje ymd à~al hji pyhytybsq saemyp bn ymd wdbwld hp dpyhclapmdi tjids ymd Naspy

Hkdjikdjy hji Nsddibk bn Ajnbskhyabj H`y, hkbje bymds pbts`dp, yb idkhji `ldhs

hji bj~ajàje d~aidj`d bn ymd @bjpyaytyabjhl Xthlana`hyabjp bn ymdas dld`ydi bnnaàhlp

hji bn ymd d}d`tya~d bnna`dsp, hedjyp, otiedp, hji hkchpphibsp hwwbajydi cq, bs ymd

ysdhyadp hji d}d`tya~d bsidsp hji hesddkdjyp, umb bs uma`m khq mh~d cddj

hwwbajydi bs apptdi cq bs djydsdi ajyb cq ymd @madn D}d`tya~d Bnna`ds -Wsdpaidjy! bn

ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp aj whsya`tlhs*

88* Wlhajyannp kb~d hji sdxtdpy ymhy ymap @btsy, hnyds hllbuaje yakd nbs iap`b~dsqhji wsbit`yabj bn ib`tkdjyp, khfd najiajep bn nh`y -hnyds ptckappabj bn hll khydsahl

xtdpyabjp bn nh`y hji ka}di xtdpyabj bn nh`y hji lhu! yb ysahl+cq+otsq, hji khfd

pwdàna` mbu ymd idàidi najiajep bn nh`y ptwwbsy hji otpyanq `bj`ltpabjp bn lhu,

ymdsdtwbj id`lhsaje hji hiotieaje `bkwldyd hjpudsp yb dh`m bn ymd nbllbuaje

xtdpyabjp bj`dsjaje ymd ajydswsdyhyabj hji hwwla`hyabj bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj hji Lhup

bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp?

83* Xtdpyabj 8? Mbu hsd ymd dlaeacalayq nbs dld`yabj hp Wsdpaidjy hji ajhtetshyabjyb ymd wsdpaidj`q bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`h yb cd idydskajdi wtspthjy yb

Hsya`ld 3, pd`yabj 8 bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`h2

80* Xtdpyabj 3? Umhy hsd ymd sbld hji umhy hsd ymd Ndidshl @bjpyaytyabjhl Ityadpbn ymd `madn d}d`tya~dp bs idwhsykdjyp bn pyhyd hji"bs ~ayhl pyhyapya`p aj dh`m bn ymdpd~dshl pyhydp aj ymd tjabj yb wsb~aid bs sdxtasd bsaeajhl ~ayhl sd`bsip bn h `hjiaihyd

nbs hjq dld`ya~d bnna`d dpyhclapmdi cq ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp @bjpyaytyabj, umdj pt`m

sd`bsip hsd bjpyaytyabjhllq sdxtasdi yb ~dsanq map dlaeacalayq nbs ymd wbpayabj pbtemy2



10/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


89* Xtdpyabj 0? Ibdp `bj`dhlkdjy hji bcntp`hyabj bn hll pt`m ~ayhl sd`bsip hpkhq bs kaemy cd jd`dpphsq nbs ymd wtcla` d~hlthyabj hji"bs bnnaàhl hp`dsyhajkdjy bn

dlaeacalayq nbs dld`yabj yb bs d}dsàpd bn bnna`d tjids ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp @bjpyaytyabj, anhji umdj dnnd`ydi cq ymd tpd bn hp khjq hp 847 hlydsjhyd ktlyawld jhkdp, hiisdppdp,

hji"bs hp khjq hp 34 pbàhl pd`tsayq jtkcdsp Vhll aj wbppacld ~ablhyabj bn 93 T*P*@*

97=-h!-5!-C![, hji ntsymds tjids ymd pwdàhl às`tkpyhj`dp umdsd hji umdj ibjd cq

bs bj cdmhln bn h `hjiaihyd bs lhyds mblids bn h Ndidshl wbpayabj, ~ablhyd ymd

@bjpyaytyabjhl ityadp bn h mblids bn h wbpayabj bn wtcla` ystpy aj Ndidshl Eb~dsjkdjy

hji ibdp pt`m `bjit`y bjpyaytyd daymds h `bjpyaytyabjhl bs pyhytybsq iapxthlana`hyabj

yb mbli pt`m bnna`d an ay udsd nbtji aj ymap `btsy yb `bjpyaytyd h ~ablhyabj bn daymds 8=

T*P*@* 393, 8778, 8= T*P*@* p809>, bs 93 T*P*@*97=-h!-5!-C! bs hjq bymds

`sakajhl bs xthpa+`sakajhl pyhytydp2

84* Xtdpyabj 9? Umhy uhp ymd kdhjaje hji ymd Hsya`ld AA, Pd`yabj 8, 4 dlaeacalayqidnajayabj bn h Jhytshl Cbsj àyazdj wsb~apabj hji sdxtasdkdjy nbs ymd Wbpayabj bn

ymd Wsdpaidjy hji @bkkhjids+aj+@madn hp ay uhp usayydj aj ymd @bjpyaytyabj hji uhp

ymdsd hjq ldehl `mhjed aj ymap idnajayabj2

8>* Xtdpyabj 4? Ibdp ymd @bjpyaytyabj wdskay hjq wdspbj yb pds~d hp Wsdpaidjy hji@bkkhjids+aj+@madn umb budp pwlay hlldeahj`d yb cbym ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`h

hji hjq bymds `btjysq bs `btjysadp2

85* Xtdpyabj >? Ib ymd Hsya`ld AAA @btsyp bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp dpyhclapmdi cq ymd@bjpyaytyabj hji htymbsazdi cq @bjesdpp, mh~d ymd wbuds, hji pmbtli ymap Tjaydi

Pyhydp Iapysa`y @btsy nbs ymd @djyshl Iapysa`y bn @hlanbsjah d}dsàpd ymd wbuds, yb apptdusayp aj bswds xtb uhsshjyb aj ymd jhkd bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp hehajpy ymd Idndjihjy

Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp hji @hcajdy Kdkcdsp, hji hjq bymds maem bnna`dsp bs

wdspbjp hehajpy h wdspbj umb tptswp, ajystidp ajyb, bs tjlhuntllq mblip bs d}dsàpdp,



11/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


h nshj`mapd `bjndssdi cq ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bs h wtcla` bnna`d bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp,

à~al bs kalayhsq32

8=*

Xtdpyabj 5? Ib ymd wdbwld hji dld`ybsp bn ymd Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydpmh~d pyhjiaje yb pddf appthj`d nsbk ymap @btsy cq uhq bn Bsaeajhl H`yabj hji

@bkwlhajy bs Hwwla`hyabj h usay aj bswds xtb uhsshjyb, aj ymd jhkd bn ymd Tjaydi

Pyhydp, hehajpy ymd Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, @hcajdy Kdkcdsp, hji hjq bymds

maem bnna`dsp bs wdspbjp hehajpy h wdspbj umb tptswp, ajystidp ajyb, bs tjlhuntllq

mblip bs d}dsàpdp, h nshj`mapd `bjndssdi cq ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bs h wtcla` bnna`d bn ymd

Tjaydi Pyhydp, a~al bs kalayhsq2

81* Xtdpyabj =? Ib daymds Hsya`ld A^, 9, bs ymd Naspy hji Jajym Hkdjikdjyp ybymd Tjaydi Pyhydp @bjpyaytyabj, ethshjydd yb ymd wdbwld bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp ymd Saemy

yb Wdyayabj nbs Sdisdpp bn Esad~hj`dp aj hjq `btsy dpyhclapmdi tjids Hsya`ld AAA bn ymd

@bjpyaytyabj! umdsd pt`m esad~hj`dp sdlhyd yb ymd xthlana`hyabjp bn wdspbjp yb cd

dld`ydi bs yb pds~d hp Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, hji yb idkhji pysa`y hji ~hlai

wsbbn ymdsdbn, h``bsiaje yb ymd Ndidshl Stldp bn D~aidj`d2

37* Xtdpyabj 1? Hsd ymd d}d`tya~d bsidsp hji hesddkdjyp, d}d`tya~d hwwbajykdjypyb ydskp bn landyakd ydjtsd -pt`m hp Hsya`ld AAA otiaàhl hwwbajykdjyp!, bn h Wsdpaidjy

lhyds wsb~di yb mh~d cddj aj`tshclq `bjpyaytyabjhllq ajdlaeacld hy ymd yakd bn map

dld`yabj hji ajhtetshyabj ~bai hc ajayab bs kdsdlq ~baihcld2 An map d}d`tya~d bsidsp

3 Ymd `mba`d bn lhu hji tpd bn usayp bn khjihktp hp jd`dpphsq aj hai bn ymap@btsyp otsapia`yabj b~ds bsaeajhl h`yabjp ap `bjpapydjy uaym 3= T*P*@* 8>48-h!* Ymapphkd pyhytyd wdskayp ymap Ptwsdkd @btsy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp yb apptd ayp bsids bs

`bjiayabjhllq hji aj ymd hlydsjhya~d, pb ymhy ymd otpya`dp khq Stldbs pb hp yb h~bai apptaje hj bsids yb ymd Wsdpaidjy bn ymd TjaydiPyhydp tjldpp md nhalp bs sdntpdp yb wsb~aid ymd ajnbskhyabj pmbuaje map uhsshjy, cquma`m ap kdhjy map dlaeacalayq nbs hji xthlana`hyabjp yb pds~d hp Wsdpaidjy* Aj hiiayabjyb hll hwwla`hcld wsb~apabjp bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj hji lhup bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, ayhwwdhsp ymhy ymd lhu bn ymd Iapysa`y bn @blbkcah khq cd hwwla`hcld yb ymd sdpbltyabj bn`dsyhaj apptdp aj ymap `hpd, aj`ltiaje ymd shsd cty paejana`hjy htymbsazhyabj yb sdjidsusayp bn wtspthjy yb



12/38


13/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Ymd Lhu bn Jhyabjp bs ymd Wsajàwldp bn Jhytshl Lhu -854=!

30* Ymap @btsy pmbtli hwwlq ymd Id ^hyydl idnajayabj tpdi cq ymdnshkdsp bn ymd `bjpyaytyabj, idnajaje Jhytshl Cbsj @ayazdj nbs nbllbuaje

sdhpbjp?

39* Id ^hyydlp ysdhyapd d}apydi hy ymd yakd bn ymd `sdhyabj bn ymd@bjpyaytyabj, hp ay uhp wtclapmdi aj 8545 hji uhp sdhialq h~halhcld yb ymd

nshkdsp

34* Dkkdsa`m id ^hyydlp uhp uaidlq xtbydi cq ymd nshkdsp bn ymd`bjpyaytyabj, nbs d}hkwld, cq Mhkalybj, Ohq, hji Khiapbj Wtclatp aj ymd

Ndidshlapy Whwdsp*

3>* Map cbbf wsb~aidp hj d}h`y hji `bjydkwbshjdbtp idnajayabj nbs ymdydsk tpdi Jhytshl Cbsj @ayazdj

35* Id ^hyydl ntllq `bssdpwbjip yb ymd udll+fjbuj pyhydkdjyp cq ymdnshkdsp bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj

3=* Ymd ^hyydl idnajayabj uhp tpdi hp h chpap nbs ymd Pdjhyd sdpbltyabj488 bn 377=, umdj Pdjhybs K`@haj uhp nbtji yb cd h Jhytshl Cbsj@ayazdj, chpdi bj ymd nh`y ymhy md uhp cbsj aj ymd zbjd bn ymd Whjhkh

`hjhl, TP ydssaybsq hy h yakd hji bn map whsdjyp udsd TP àyazdjp*

31* Hwwhsdjylq itsaje ymd @bjpyaytyabjhl @bj~djyabj, Obmj Ohq usbydbj Otlq 34, 85=5 yb Edbsed Uhpmajeybj?

Wdskay kd yb majy, umdymds ay ubtli cd uapd bs sdhpbjhcld yb

wsb~aid h pysbje `md`f yb ymd hikappabj bn nbsdaejdsp ajyb ymdhikajapyshyabj bn Jhyabjhl eb~dsjkdjy6 hji yb id`lhsdd}wsdpplq ymhy ymd `bkkhjids aj `madn bn ymd Hkdsa`hj Hskqpmhll jby cd ea~dj yb, jbs id~bl~d bj hjq cty h jhytshl cbsjàyazdj



14/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


07* Aj d}wlhajaje ymd kdhjaje bn Jhytshl Cbsj @ayazdj, h wsajàwhlnshkds bn ymd 89ym hkdjikdjy, uma`m sdidnajdi àyazdjpmaw tjids ymd

@bjpyaytyabj, Obmj Hskbs Cajemhk d}wlhajdi ymhy ymd wmshpd sdndssdi ybd~dsq mtkhj cdaje cbsj aj ymd otsapia`yabj bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp yb

-Dkwmhpap

hiidi!*

Hp Bchkhp Dhpy Hnsa`hj nhymds budi -cq sdhpbj bn map casym hji hph khyyds bn ajydsjhyabjhl lhu! hlldeahj`d yb Csayapm `sbuj -umdymds bs jby

md wsbndppdi hjq!, Bchkh uhp jby h Jhytshl cbsj àyazdj hji ibdp jby

xthlanq nbs wsdpaidj`q* Ithl Jhyabjhlayq ap h shymds jdu `bj`dwy ymhy iai

jby d}apy hy ymd yakd bn `sdhyabj bn ymd @bjpyaytyabj hji Wlhajyannp ptckay

ymhy ymd idnajayabj tpdi hji ymd `bjydkwbshjdbtp pyhydkdjyp bn ymd

nshkdsp pmbu h idpasd yb d}`ltid nsbk ymd esbtw bn Jhytshl Cbsj @ayazdjp

hjqbjd, uaym hlldeahj`d yb bymds pb~dsdaejyadp hy casym*

Bj cdmhln bn mds `ladjyp ymd tjidspaejdi hyybsjdq mhp ptckayydi h`dsyanadi khal sdytsj sd`dawy idkhjip twbj ymd Hyybsjdq Edjdshl bn ymd

Tjaydi Pyhydp Dsa` Mblids hji ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp Hyybsjdq nbs ymd Iapysa`y

bn @bltkcah, Odnnsdq Yhqlbs, yb ajpyaytyd pt`m h`yabj* Jb h`yabj uhp

ajpyaytydi hji jb sdpwbjpd uhp sd`da~di* Hp mtjisdip bn àyazdjp mh~d

`hlldi ymd Idwhsykdjy bn Otpya`d, ymdq udsd pybjduhlldi, ymdq udsd ybli

jby yb `hll, cty shymds yb ptckay ymd sdxtdpyp aj usayaje* Umdj usayydjsdxtdpyp udsd ptckayydi, jb sdpwbjpd uhp sd`da~di* Hnyds ymbtphjip bn

wmbjd `hllp cq ymd btyshedi àyazdjp jb h`yabj uhp yhfdj hji ymd TP

Hyybsjdq nbs ymd Iapysa`y bn @bltkcah Odnnsdq Yhqlbs, jb hwwla`hyabj nbs

appthj`d bn hjq usay bs uhp naldi hji jb sdpwbjpd uhp



15/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


sd`da~di* H ndu ihqp heb TP Hyybsjdq Odnnsdq Yhqlbs tjd}wd`ydilq

sdpaejdi, pb ymhy ay `hj cd d}wd`ydi ymhy ymd jdu hyybsjdq uall cd

hwwbajydi cq ymd Bchkh hikajapyshyabj hji ymdsd ap h `ldhs hji wsdpdjyihjeds bn h `bsstwy bs iapmbjdpy aj pt`m hwwbajykdjy hji

ybyhl akwbppacalayq ymhy hjq hwwla`hyabj nbs appthj`d bn h usay

hehajpy Bchkh uall d~ds cd wsbpd`tydi*

00* Sd`djylq, aj , hjbymds Bchkh+Pbdybsb dlaeacalayq`hpd uhp ptckayydi cq Hyybsjdq Obmj Mdkdjuhq* Ymap `hpd uhp mdhsi

cq I@ Iapysa`y otied Ohkdp L* Sbcdsypbj, umb `bkwldydlq kappyhydi ymd

wsdpaidj`q sdxtasdkdjy, `hllaje ay ajpydhi bn

hji pyhyaje ymhy ymdsd ap jb jddi yb mdhs ymd `hpd bj ymd kdsayp hji

bcyhaj ymd h`ythl ib`tkdjyp cd`htpd ymd `hpd uhp khpphedi hji

yuayydsdi bj ymd clbep* Yb hii ajptly yb ajotsq Otied Sbcdsypbj

ymsdhydjdi Ks* Mdkdjuhq uaym phj`yabjp nbs csajeaje ymap ldeayakhyd

`hpd*

09* Ay idnadp `sditlayq yb tjidspyhji mbu khppheaje hj apptd bj h nduwhsyaphj clbep cd `mhsh`ydsazdi hp hjq faji bn sdpbltyabj bn hjq apptd,

whsya`tlhslq aj h `hpd bn jhyabjhl tsedj`q, umdj ymdsd ap d~aidj`d

pteedpyaje, ymhy ymd ajmhcayhjy bn ymd Umayd Mbtpd ap h nbsdaej Jhyabjhl,

àyazdj bn Ajibjdpah hji wbppaclq pyall àyazdj bn Fdjqh, tptswaje ymd

wbpayabj bn ymd Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp bn Hkdsa`h hji ymd

@bkkhjids aj `madn*04* Ymap idàpabj cq Otied Sbcdsypbj khid ay akwbppacld nbs ymdtjidspaejdi hyybsjdq yb bcyhaj hikappabjwsb mh` ~a`d hji ysq ymd khyyds

aj TP `btsy nbs ymd Iapysa`y bn @bltkcah, umdsd Xtb Uhsshjyb ap `bianadi,

hp jb I@ lhuqds ubtli cd uallaje yb ptcod`y makpdln yb ymd ymsdhy bn



16/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +8> +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


phj`yabjp nsbk hj bc~abtplq cahpdi `btsy, tjuallaje yb mdhs ymap apptd bj

ymd kdsayp*

0>*

Itd yb ymd nh`y ymhy ldeayakh`q bn ymd wsdpaidj`q ap ymd kbpyakwbsyhjy apptd aj ymd mapybsq bn ymap Jhyabj, hji 074 kallabj Hkdsa`hj

àyazdjp `hjjby hji pmbtli jby cd mdli mbpyhed yb bjd cahpdi `btsy, ay ap

akwdshya~d nbs ymap Mbjbshcld `btsy mdhs ymap wdyayabj bj ymd kdsayp*

05* Lhpylq, wlhajyannp aj ymap h`yabj mh~d tpdi hll ldehl hji ldeaplhya~dsdkdiadp h~halhcld yb sdpbl~d ymd apptd bn ldeayakh`q bn Chsh`f Mtppdaj

Bchkh, pt`m hp esad~hj`dp uaym ymdas pd`sdyhsadp bn Pyhydp, dld`yabj

`bkkayyddp, 80= T@KO `bid esad~hj`dp uaym ymd kalayhsq, ldyydsp, nh}dp,

d+khalp, idkhjip, wmbjd `hllp hji wdspbjhl kddyajep uaym

hjq hji hll cshj`mdp hji nbskp bn lhu djnbs`dkdjy, NCA, Hyybsjdq

Edjdshlp bn ymdas pyhydp, Hyybsjdq Edjdshl Mblids, TP Hyybsjdqp hji

Iapysa`y Hyybsjdqp+ hll aj wdh`dntl hji lhuntl hyydkwyp yb bcyhaj wsbbn bn

Bchkhp dlaeacalayq nbs wsdpaidj`q*

0=* Hp bn jbu jb `hpd hpfaje ymdpd xtdpyabjp mhp cddj mdhsi bj ymdkdsayp, jby bjd pajeld àyazdj uhp hcld yb pdd hjq bn Bchkhp ~ayhl sd`bsip?

map bsaeajhl casym `dsyana`hyd, map whppwbsyp nsbk Ajibjdpah, Fdjqh hji

TP, bs an hjq àyazdj mhp pddj ymdpd ib`tkdjyp, jby bjd mhp cddj hllbudi

yb wtclapm ymd sdptlyp* Jbs mhp ymd wtcla` cddj hllbudi h``dpp yb ymd

Wsdpaidjyp tja~dspayq djsbllkdjy sd`bsip, uma`m mh~d cddj sbtyajdlq

iap`lbpdi d~dj nbs Wsdpaidjyp pt`m hp Edbsed U* Ctpm umb udsdjbybsabtplq wbbs pytidjyp uaym kdiab`sd eshidp*

01* Ymd nalaje bn Pdld`ya~d Pds~a`d @dsyana`hyd ap h sdxtasdkdjy nbs bjd yb pds~d ajymd d}d`tya~d cshj`m bn ymd eb~dsjkdjy, hji ymap pmbtli `ldhslq cd tjidspybbi yb

aj`ltid ymd Wsdpaidjy hp bjd wsdpaiaje b~ds ymd d}d`tya~d cshj`m* Pmbsylq hnyds ymd

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed 8> bn 0= Whed AI #?88=


17/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


dld`yabj ymd tjidspaejdi `btjpdl mhp sd`da~di nsbk nbskds Ndidshl hedjy Pydwmdj

@bnnkhj h `bwq bn ymd NBAH hji hjhlqpap bn pt`m NBAH ymhy uhp naldi uaym ymd

Pdld`ya~d Pds~a`d Hikajapyshyabj wsabs yb ymd dld`yabj, cty uhp sd`da~di bjlq hnyds ymddld`yabj* Ymd hjhlqpap pmbudi jtkdsbtp hsdhp bn ptpwd`ydi nbsedsq bn ymd `dsyana`hyd*

Hp ymd tjidspaejdi `btjpdl sdwsdpdjyp h jtkcds bn maem shjfdi kdkcdsp bn ymd

kalayhsq, Jhyabjhl Iasd`ybs bn ymd pdld`ya~d Pds~a`d Ks* Uallahk @mhynadli, hesddi yb

yhlf yb ymd tjidspaejdi hyybsjdq, hp bjd sdwsdpdjyaje Khobs Edjdshl @malidsp*

97* Hy h kddyaje aj map Hslajeybj ^H bnna`d Ks* @mhynadli uhp pwd`ana`hllqxtdpyabjdi aj sdehsip yb hj d}wlhjhyabj nbs ymd pyhkw bj ymd ib`tkdjy cdaje h usbje

pyhkw nbs 81=7, nbs h usbje nbsk jtkcds, nbs iap`sdwhj`q aj pdsahl jtkcdsp aj ymd

nbsk aypdln, ymd nh`y ymhy ay uhp naldi aj Pdwydkcds bn 81=7 aj Mhuhaa, umdj Bchkh

uhp ymbtphji bn kaldp huhq aj B``aidjyhl `bllded aj @hlanbsjah hji ymd nh`y ymhy ay

pyhydi ymhy ay uhp naldi uaymbty hj AI, d~dj ybtem hj AI uhp h sdxtasdkdjy*

98* Ks* @mhynadli `btli jby wsb~aid hjq d}wlhjhyabj, bjlq pyhyaje ystpy kd*Jhyabjhl pd`tsayq bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp `hjjby cd sdldehydi yb ystpy kd hji ymdsd ap h

jddi nbs h usay bn Khjihktp nsbk ymd Ptwsdkd @btsy nbs ymd Pd`sdyhsq bn Idndjpd,

Sbcdsy Ehydp yb sdldhpd ymd bsaeajhl `dsyana`hyd bn ymd pdld`ya~d pds~a`d uaym ymd TP

kalayhsq, nbs ay yb cd hjhlqzdi cq ymd nbsdjpa` ib`tkdjy d}hkajdsp bn ymd wlhajyannp*

93* Ymd tjidspaejdi `btjpdl mhp sdxtdpydi nsbk ymd Pd`sdyhsq bn pyhyd bn@hlanbsjah ~dsana`hyabj bn Bchkhp dlaeacalayq hji eby h sdpwbjpd, ymhy ymd Pd`sdyhsq bn

Pyhyd ibdp jby ib pt`m ~dsana`hyabj* Hp ~bltjyddsp udsd `md`faje hsbtji ymd `btjysq,

jb pd`sdyhsq bn pyhyd, jb dld`yabj `bkkayydd `btli cd nbtji, ymhy iai hjq ~dsana`hyabj bn

pt`m dlaeacalayq* Ymap cd`hkd d}ysdkdlq akwbsyhjy, hp ay cd`hkd fjbuj ymhy ymd pyhyd

bn Mhuhaa mhp h pyhytd 00=, ymhy hllbup nbsdaej cbsj `malisdj bn Mhuhaahj sdpaidjyp yb

bcyhaj Mhuhaahj casym `dsyana`hyd hji ymbpd `hj cd bcyhajdi chpdi bj h pyhydkdjy bn

bjd sdlhya~d bjlq*



18/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +8= +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


90* Is* Ntfajb, iasd`ybs bn ymd pyhyd bn Mhuhaa Mdhlym idwhsykdjy mhp apptdi h`hsdntllq `shnydi pyhydkdjy, ymhy ymd idwhsykdjy mhp Bchkhp casym `dsyana`hyd bj nald,

mbud~ds h casym `dsyana`hyd nbs h nbsdaej cbsj `mali bn h Mhuhaahj sdpaidjy ap hlpb ldehlaj Mhuhaa, cty ay uall cd alldehl aj bymds pyhydp hji uall khfd bjd ajdlaeacld nbs ymd TP

wsdpaidj`q* Ymap khfdp ay akwdshya~d yb bcyhaj ymd bsaeajhl casym `dsyana`hyd nsbk ymd

pyhyd bn Mhuhaa yb hp`dsyhaj ymd @bjpyaytyabjhl dlaeacalayq bn Bchkh yb hpptkd ymd

wsdpaidj`q*

99* Hkchpphibs bn Fdjqh Wdyds Beajeh Bedeb mhp ea~dj h shiab ajyds~adu yb Yhlfpmbu mbpyp Khs` Ndllmhtds, Kafd @lhsf hji Ystia Ihjadlp nsbk USAN 878*8 NK shiab

aj Idysbay Ka`maehj* Hy 7?83?39 bn ymd ajyds~adu Khs` Ndllmhtds mhp hpfdi

Hkhchpphibs bn Fdjqh Bjd kbsd xtdpyabj* Bts Wsdpaidjy dld`y Bchkhp casym wlh`d

b~ds aj Fdjqh ap ymhy ebaje yb cd h pwby yb eb ~apay 2 Hkchpphibs?

, map whydsjhl eshjikbymds ap pyall hla~d* Khs` Ndllmhtds?

2 Hkchpphibs?

*

94* Ymd pyhydkdjyp bn ymd Hkchpphibs bn Fdjqh iasd`ylq `bjyshia`ydi Bchkhphppdsyabj, ymhy md uhp cbsj aj TP, uma`m khid ay h jd`dppayq yb khjihyd nbs ymd

hkchpphibs bn Fdjqh yb tjpdhl Bchkhp casym sd`bsip hji map àyazdjpmaw, ysh~dl hji

akkaeshyabj sd`bsip*

9>* Aj map cbbf Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh pyhydi ymhy mdakkaeshydi yb Ajibjdpah, umdj map kbymds khssadi hj Ajibjdpahj Jhyabjhl*

Ajibjdpah ibdp jby hllbu ithl àyazdjpmaw hji Bchkhp Ajibjdpahj p`mbbl sdeapyshyabj

pmbup mak hp Chssq Pbdybsb -map pydw+nhymdsp lhpy jhkd! hji àyazdjpmaw Ajibjdpahj*

Bchkh, mhp hlpb ysh~dlldi yb Whfapyhj hy ymd hed bn 37, itsaje khsyahl lhu, umdj

djyshj`d yb Whfapyhj uhp chjjdi yb Hkdsa`hjp, @msapyahjp hji Odup, uma`m kaemy cd

hj hiiayabjhl ajia`hyabj bn map ysh~dl tjids Ajibjdpahj whppwbsy, ymdsdnbsd sdhppdsyaje

@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed 8= bn 0= Whed AI #?837


19/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


map Ajibjdpahj àyazdjpmaw hji sdlajxtapmaje map TP àyazdjpmaw an md mhi h TP

àyazdjpmaw*

95*

Ymd Pyhyd bn Mhuhaa mhp aj ayp `bid h wd`tlahs pyhytyd #00=, ymhy hllbup nbsdaejcbsj `malisdj bn Mhuhaahj sdpaidjyp yb edy Mhuhaahj casym `dsyana`hydp* Hiiayabjhllq,

pt`m casym `dsyana`hydp `hj cd bcyhajdi chpdi bj h pyhydkdjy bn bjd sdlhya~d bjlq,

uaymbty hjq tjcahpdi, ajidwdjidjy d~aidj`d, pt`m hp h mbpwayhl casym `dsyana`hyd* Ymap

pyhytyd mhp h chpap aj wsd`tspbs pyhytydp ebaje ch`f yb 8188, wsabs yb `sdhyabj bn ymd

pyhyd bn Mhuhaa, hp Mhuhaahj àyazdjp uhjydi yb yshjpnds ymdas Mhuhaahj àyazdjpmaw yb

ymdas `malisdj cbsj hcsbhi*

9=* Hp Mhuhaa cd`hkd bjd bn ymd pyhydp aj ymd Tjabj, ymap wsb~apabj uhpfdwy* Kbpy Hkdsa`hj àyazdjp, mhi jb fjbuldied bn ymap wsb~apabj, hp ymdq

~bydi aj 377= dld`yabj* Bjd bn ymd sdhpbjp, uhp tjuallajejdpp bn ymd Khaj

Pysdhk Kdiah yb yhlf hcbty ymap apptd* Hp idkhjip udsd khid yb bcyhaj

pt`m sd`bsip, ymbpd idkhjip udsd sdctnndi hji sdpwbjpdp udsd wsb~aidi,

ymhy bjlq sdlhya~dp bs whsyadp uaym yhjeacld ajydsdpy `btli bcyhaj h `bwq bn

bjdp casym `dsyana`hyd*91* Ymd Pyhyd bn Mhuhaa iaijy `bjpaids ldeayakh`q nbs Wsdpaidj`q yb cd hyhjeacld ajydsdpy* Bjd bn ymd wlhajyannp aj ymap h`yabj ap Ks* Ftsy Ntxth, h

`bkwtyhyabjhl lajetapy, umb ysh`di map edjdhlbeq yb cd `bkkbj uaym Ks*

Bchkhp* Ks* Ntxth ap usayaje h nhkalq mapybsq hji jbya`di h pakalhs

nhkalq kdia`hl mapybsq hp udll hp pbkd `bj`dsjp aj sdehsiaje yb Bchkhp

wbpydi @dsyana`hyabj bn land casym -@BLC!*47* Hp h lajetapy md phu ymhy ymd lhjethed tpdi aj ymd @BLC uhpaj`bjpapydjy yb ymd bjd tpdi hy h yakd* Md mhi `bj`dsjp aj sdehsip yb

~dshàyq bn ymd @BLC, hji ldeayakh`q bn Bchkh, whsya`tlhslq aj laemy bn

ymd nh`y ymhy map buj pbj ap hj h`ya~d ityq bnna`ds hji ubtli cd ptcod`y yb



20/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Bchkhp bsidsp*

48* Wlhajyann Ntxth mhp sdxtdpydi h `bwq bn Ks* Bchkhp casym`dsyana`hyd, bjlq yb cd ybli, ymhy ay ubtli yhfd h qdhs yb sdpwbji yb mapsdxtdpy*

43* An ldeayakh`q bn ymd wsdpaidj`q ap jby h yhjeacld ajydsdpy, an nhkalqsdlhyabjpmaw ap jby h yhjeacld ajydsdpy, an `bj`dsjp bn ymd `bkkbj nhkalq

kdia`hl mapybsq ap jby h yhjeacld ajydsdpy, an wbppacld nbsedsq bs tyydsaje bn

ymd @BLC ap jby h yhjeacld ajydsdpy, umhy ap h yhjeacld ajydsdpy2 @hj h

`btjysq bn 074 kallabj `ayazdjp cd mdli mbpyhed yb pt`m ajphjayq2

40* Ymd iasd`ybs bn ymd Mdhlym Idwhsykdjy Is* @maqbkd Ntfajb,ymsbtem mds pwbfdpwdspbj Ohja`d Bftcb mhp apptdi h `hsdntllq `shnydi

pyhydkdjy, ymhy ymd idwhsykdjy mhp h ~hlai Mhuhaahj pyhyd casym

`dsyana`hyd* Pmd jd~ds wsb~aidi hjq d}wlhjhyabj, umhy casym `dsyana`hyd ib

ymdq mh~d bj nald* H casym `dsyana`hyd bn h nbsdaej cbsj `mali bn h Mhuhaahj

sdpaidjy uall cd h ~hlai Mhuhaahj casym `dsyana`hyd, mbud~ds ay ubtli khfd

bjd ybyhllq ajdlaeacld nbs wsdpaidj`q* H `dsyana`hyd apptdi chpdi bj hpyhydkdjy bn bjd sdlhya~d bjlq, ubtli cd h ~hlai casym `dsyana`hyd, mbud~ds,

ay ubtli sdxtasd `bssbcbshya~d d~aidj`d nsbk h mbpwayhl, hp h pyhydkdjy bn

h sdlhya~d kaemy cd cahpdi* Pmd jd~ds pyhydi ymhy ymd @dsyana`hyabj wbpydi

bj ymd Ajydsjdy uhp ymd phkd hp ymd ib`tkdjy bj nald, ymhy ay uhp h ~hlai

`bwq bs ymhy ay uhp h ib`tkdjy apptdi cq ymd pyhyd bn Mhuhaa*

49*

Hp ymd mdhlym idwhsykdjy bn ymd pyhyd bn Mhuhaa sdntpdi yb wsb~aid h`dsyanadi `bwq bn Ks* Bchkhp casym `dsyana`hyd, ay uhp akwbppacld yb

hp`dsyhaj Bchkhp wlh`d bn casym bs `ayazdjpmaw*

44* Hkdsa`hj @ayazdjp mh~d hj dxthl wsbyd`yabj saemy ethshjyddi ybymdk ymsbtem ymd 89ym hkdjikdjy yb ymd @bjpyaytyabj, hp udll hp ymd



21/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


saemy yb ptcpyhjya~d itd wsb`dpp hji ymd naspy hkdjikdjy saemy nbs

sdisdpp bn esad~hj`dp, hp udll hp saemyp ethshjyddi yb ymd àyazdjp, hp bjdp

jby ptssdjidsdi yb ymd Ndidshl eb~dsjkdjy bs pyhydp tjids ymd 1ym

hji87ym hkdjikdjy*

4>* Tjids ymd Ptwsdkh`q @lhtpd, umald Mhuhaahj pyhytyd 00= kaemy cd~hlai nbs ymd aj pyhyd wtswbpdp bn ymd Pyhyd bn Mhuhaa, ay ap ptwdspdidi cq

ymd TP `bjpyaytyabj aj ymd khyydsp bn Ndidshl dld`yabjp hji ymdsdnbsd, ay ap

h saemy bn ymd TP àyazdjp hsbtji ymd `btjysq, whsya`tlhslq ymd àyazdjp

uaym ptwdsabs pyhjiaje, pt`m hp H`ya~d ityq kalayhsq, sapfaje ymdas la~dp

wtspthjy yb ymd bsidsp bn ymd `bkkhjids aj `madn bs ymd Pyhyd

sdwsdpdjyhya~dp, ymhy jddi yb idàid bj ymd Pyhyd ctiedy hllb`hyabjp chpdi

bj ymd ndidshl hllb`hyabjp, paejdi cq ymd wsdpaidjy, yb mh~d `ldhs wsakh

nhàh d~aidj`d bn ymd ldeayakh`q bn pt`m `bkkhjids aj `madn hji

wsdpaidjy*

45* Bchkh ptwwbsydsp mh~d dkchsfdi bj hwwhllaje `hkwhaej bnajyakaihyabj hji mhshppkdjy bn hjq bnnaàhl uallaje yb pwdhf tw bj ymdapptd, d~dj ymbtem ymd apptd mhi jbymaje yb ib uaym sh`d cty shymds

Jhytshl Cbsj pyhytp* Ymd bnnaàhlp, ndhsntl bn cdaje lhcdldi shàpyp pakwlq

sdntpdi yb mdhs ymd `hpd bj ymd kdsayp hji ysadi yb whpp ymd ct`f, yb

nbbychll ay pbkdumdsd dlpd* Mbwdntllq ymd ct`f pybwp mdsd, aj ymd Ptwsdkd

@btsy*

NSDDIBK BN AJNBSKHYABJ HP H JHYABJHL WBLA@Q4=* Wlhajyannp sdhllded 8+45 hp an ntllq `bwadi hji sdpyhydi mdsdaj, hjiaj`bswbshyd hll ymd khydsahl hlldehyabjp hji ldehl `bjydjyabjp bn ymd phkd*

41* Wlhajyannp ptckay ymhy hll bn ymd hcb~d+hji+nbsdebaje nh`ypidkbjpyshyd h `bj`dsydi cty tjbnnaàhl wbla`q bn ymd wsdpdjy d}d`tya~d



22/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


cshj`m hikajapyshyabj uma`m ap `bjyshsq yb ymd ldyyds hji pwasay bn ymd

lhu* Ymd Wlhajyannp hp h esbtw khq jby mh~d himdsdi `lbpdlq bs wsdàpdlq

yb ymd ldyyds bn NBAH aj hll bn ymdas hwwsbh`mdp yb ymd `tssdjyhikajapyshyabj nbs ajnbskhyabj, cty ymap `btsy mhp hpptsdi ymdk ymhy ymd

wsdpdjy `hpd uall cd idàidi bj ayp ldehl kdsayp hji nh`ythl ptcpyhj`d, hji

jby bj wsb`ditshl assdetlhsayadp*

>7* Idndjihjyp mh~d `bjpapydjylq sdpapydi d~dsq hyydkwy yb bcyhajajnbskhyabj hji nbs ymap sdhpbj ymd Wlhajyannp mh~d naldi ymd wsdpdjy

`bkwlhajy nbs Id`lhshybsq Otiekdjy sdehsiaje Chsh`f M* Bchkhp pyhytp

hp h jhytshl cbsj àyazdj hji sdptlyhjy `bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabj yb

pds~d hp Wsdpaidjy!, wtspthjy yb ymd Nsddibk bn Ajnbskhyabj H`y 4 T*P*@*

443-h!-9!-C! hji 93 T*P*@* 81=0, 81== -@a~al Saemyp H`yabj!*

>8* Ymap khyyds ap otpyaàhcld tjids NBAH, 4 T*P*@* 443h-c!,443h-c!-3! -81==!* Tjids NBAH, hj hedj`q pt`m hp ymd D}d`tya~d Bnna`d bn

ymd Wsdpaidjy hji ymd Umayd Mbtpd -Yayld 0, @*N*S*! ktpy iap`lbpd ymd

ajnbskhyabj pbtemy cq ymd sdxtdpyds tjldpp ymd hedj`q `hj aj~bfd bjd bnjajd d}dkwyabjp pwdànadi aj ymhy H`y* Pdd 4 T*P*@* 443-c! -81==!*

>3* Pbkd bn ymdpd d}dkwyabjp wsbyd`yaje wdspbjhl wsa~h`q hwwlq yb#kdia`hl hji wdspbjjdl sd`bsip*# 4 T*P*@* 443-c!->! -81==!* Mbud~ds, ay

mhp cddj nbs khjq qdhsp sd`bejazdi ymhy ymd kdia`hl hji wdspbjjdl

sd`bsip bn ymd id nh`yb Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp -pt`m hp

Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh ybihq! hji d~dj nbs `hjiaihydp nbs ymd Wsdpaidj`qbn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp hsd khyydsp bn wtcla` ajydsdpy hji `bj`dsj* Ymd apptd

aj ymap `hpd ap umdymds ymd wtcla` ajydsdpy aj h lakaydi jtkcds bn

wdspbjjdl sd`bsip bj Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh ap ptnnaàdjy yb `bkwdl

iap`lbptsd bn bjd whsya`tlhs ib`tkdjy umbpd d}apydj`d mhp cddj



23/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


h`fjbuldiedi hji `bjnaskdi khjq yakdp cty uma`m, nbs umhyd~ds hp qdy

tjiap`lbpdi sdhpbjp, jdaymds ymd wsa~hyd @hjiaihyd Chsh`f Mtppdaj

Bchkh bs ymd Wsdpaidjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh mhp cddj uallajeyb iap`lbpd, jhkdlq? ymd ~htly bs lbje nbsk Mhuhaa casym `dsyana`hyd

-hji hll sdlhydi mbpwayhl bs kdia`hl ib`tkdjyp! uma`m Wlhajyannp `bjyhaj

uall najhllq `bjnask bs idjbtj`d Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkhp Hsya`ld AA

xthlana`hyabjp yb pds~d hji nhaymntllq d}d`tyd ymd bnna`d bn Wsdpaidjy bn

ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp*

>0* Ymd wtcla` mhi cdnbsd ymd dld`yabj hji pyall mhp ybihq h `bkwdllajeajydsdpy aj ymd iap`lbptsd bn ymap bjd pajeld cay bn `saya`hl ib`tkdjyhyabj

-hji hll sdlhydi! sd`bsip hji wsbbn*

>9* Ymd wtcla`%p ajydsdpy ap tjidseasidi cq yub lajdp bn idàpabjp nsbkymd T* P* Ptwsdkd @btsy* Ymd naspy lajd `bj`dsjp ymd wtcla`%p saemy yb ymd

wdsnbskhj`d bn hj hedj`q khjheds, pt`m hp hj aj`ltiaje ymd Wsdpaidjy hp

khjheds bn ymd djyasd d}d`tya~d cshj`m, tjids NBAH* Ymd pd`bji lajd bn

idàpabjp `bj`dsjp ymd ~ayhl sbld aj bts idkb`shya` pbàdyq wlhqdi cqiap`lbpaje nh`yp hji ysh`f sd`bsip bn `hjiaihydp nbs wtcla` bnna`d*

>4* Hehajpy ymap djbskbtp wtcla` ajydsdpy aj nh~bs bn iap`lbpaje ymdsd`bsip bj Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh, ymd wsdpdjy Idndjihjy Chsh`f

Mtppdaj Bchkh mhp shapdi hcpbltydlq jbymaje aj ymd wtcla` hsdjh*

>>* Paj`d ymd NBAH d}dkwyabjp ymhy wdskay hj hedj`q yb uaymmbliajnbskhyabj hsd jhssbulq `bjpystdi, ymd @btsy mhp jb pyhytybsq chpap ybstld nbs hjqymaje d}`dwy ntll wsbit`yabj bn ymd lakaydi jtkcds bn

`bjpyaytyabjhllq paejana`hjy ib`tkdjyp nsbk ymd id nh`yb

>5* Ay ap h khyyds bn wtcla` sd`bsi ymhy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh cbym hp



24/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


ymd Wsdpaidjyahl @hjiaihyd hji ymd id nh`ybmhp jd~ds idjadi ymd

sdld~hj`d bn map casym `dsyana`hyd cty aj nh`y sdwdhydilq wsbit`di hj

tjpaejdi, tjbnnaàhl ib`tkdjy iasd`ylq hji ymsbtem ymd Idkb`shya`Jhyabjhl @bkkayydd*

>=* H``bsiajelq d~dj an Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh udsd iddkdi yb mh~dhwwdhsdi hji hjpudsdi bs bcod`ydi yb pds~a`d cq hji ymsbtem ymd T*P*

Hyybsjdqp bnna`d, uma m md wlhajlq iai jby ib, Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh

ubtli cd dxtayhclq hji xtayd wbppacld otiaàhllq dpybwwdi cq map `bjit`y

aj wsabs layaehyabj nsbk shapaje hjq NBAH bcod`yabj yb hll dldkdjyp bn map

wdspbjjdl hji kdia`hl sd`bsip tjids NBAH*

>1* Aj ptk, Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh mhp jb ~ahcld idndjpd yb ymd `lhakpshapdi cq ymd Wlhajyannp aj ymap ptay*

57* Ymd bii ystym ap ymhy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh mhp jby sdpapydi ymdptcpyhj`d bn sdwdhydi sdxtdpyp nbs wsbbn bn map àyazdjpmaw aj hji bn

ymdkpdl~dp* Md mhp jdaymds `lhakdi h wsa~h`q ajydsdpy aj map bsaeajhl

Lbje Nbsk ^htly casym `dsyana`hyd nsbk Mhuhaa*58* Shymds, Idndjihjy Bchkh mhp kdsdlq -cty sbtyajdlq! sdpapydi hjq`sayaàpk bn ymd nbsk bs ptnnaàdj`q bn map sdpwbjpdp, hji mhp sdntpdi yb

`tsd hjq ibtcyp sdehsiaje ymd phkd, uaymbty sdehsi yb wtcla` `bjnaidj`d

bs sdpwd`y nbs ymd wtcla` ajydsdpy hji ymd ajyhjeacld saemy bn ymd wdbwld yb

mbjdpy naitàhsq pds~a`dp bj ymd whsy bn ymdas eb~dsjkdjyhl bnnaàhlp* @n*

8= T*P*@* 809>*53* Ymd wtcla` mhp h paejana`hjy, hlkbpy tjwhshlldldi, ajydsdpy tjidsNBAH aj ymd sdldhpd bn ymdpd sd`bsip, uma`m pmdi idydskajhya~d laemy bj

ymd @bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabjp bn ymd Wsdpaidjy* Cd`htpd ymd wtcla`

ajydsdpy tjids NBAH aj ymd sdldhpd bn Bchkhp sd`bsip uhp pb paejana`hjy,



25/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


hji cd`htpd Bchkh mhp jd~ds `lhakdi h wsa~h`q ajydsdpy aj map wdspbjjdl

bs kdia`hl sd`bsip wsabs yb cd`bkaje Wsdpaidjy, ymap `btsy pmbtli nbllbu

hj akwldkdjy ymd Ptwsdkd @btsy%p lhjikhsf idàpabj aj, 9=1 T*P*

591 -81=1!*

50* Ymap `hpd dpyhclapmdi etaidlajdp nbs idydskajaje umdj sd`bsippmbtli cd sdldhpdi tjids NBAH* Ndidshl hedjàdp -pt`m hp ymd D}d`tya~d

Bnna`d bn ymd Wsdpaidjy hji Umayd Mbtpd! pmbtli sdldhpd sd`bsip? -8! umdj

ymdq hsd #wsh`ya`hllq bcp`tsd,# pb ymhy h whsyq ubtli mh~d sdhpbj yb

aj~bfd NBAH yb bcyhaj ymdk, hji -3! umdj ymd jhytsd bn ymd sd`bsip

pds~dp ymd wtcla` ajydsdpy*

59* Ymd bjlq wtcla` ajydsdpyp `bejazhcld tjids NBAH ap pmdiiaje laemybj hj d}d`tya~d bnna`dsp `bkwdydj`d bs hedj`q%p wdsnbskhj`d hji ayp

pyhytybsq ityadp* Hiiayabjhllq, ymd wtswbpd bn NBAH hp udll hp ymd wlhaj

lhjethed bn ymd H`y `sdhyd h pysbje wsdptkwyabj aj nh~bs bn iap`lbptsd hji

wlh`d ymd ctsidj bj hj hedj`q yb otpyanq uaymmbliaje hjq sdxtdpydiib`tkdjyp* Ai* hy 5>9+=76 ,

883 P* @y* 498, 495 -8118!*

54* D~dj an ymap @btsy udsd yb `bjpaids ymhy pbkd bn Bchkhp wdspbjjdlhji kdia`hl sd`bsip udsd d}dkwy, NBAH sdxtasdp hj hedj`q yb sdldhpd

pdesdehcld, jbjd}dkwy wbsyabjp bn h whsyahllq d}dkwy sd`bsi*

, 987 T*P* 50, 18 -8150!6 pdd 4T*P*@* 443-c! -81==! -najhl pdjydj`d d}wlaàylq sdxtasdp iap`lbptsd bn hjq

#sdhpbjhclq pdesdehcld# jbjd}dkwy ajnbskhyabj!*

5>* Ymd sd`bsip sdxtdpydi cq ymd Wlhajyannp @bkwlhajy mdsdaj phyapnqcbym bn ymd Ptwsdkd @btsy%p etaidlajdp nh~bsaje iap`lbptsd tjids NBAH*



26/38


27/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


hji pmbtli cd iap`lbpdi tjids NBAH*

=0* Yb uaymmbli ymdpd sd`bsip aj ~ablhyabj bn ymd etaidlajdp pdy nbsym aj, Chsh`f Mtppdaj ubtli mh~d yb otpyanq map sdwdhydi

h`yabj bn pybjduhllaje, hji Wlhajyannp ptckay ymhy Bchkh mhp djehedi aj

hji nbsktlhydi xthpa+bnnaàhl ajpyaytyabjhlazdi whyydsj bn pybjduhllaje

hji sdntpaje yb hjpuds `bkwlhajyp sdehsiaje bs `bj`dsjaje map

ch`fesbtji bs àyazdjpmaw*

=9* @bjpdxtdjylq, NBAH khjihydp ymhy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh sdldhpdymd sd`bsip sdxtdpydi cdlbu, hji ymd Wlhajyannp sdxtdpy `bkwladp uaym ymd

ndidshl lhu aj hll sdpwd`yp? khjq àyazdjp sdxtdpyp mh~d cddj khid, hji

hll mh~d cddj aejbsdi uaymbty lhuntl otpyana`hyabj*

=4* Nbts bn ymd wlhajyannp aj ymd wsdpdjy ptay hsd tjaxtdlq paythydi ajymhy ymdq udsd daymds `hjiaihydp bs dld`ybsp aj ymd Wsdpaidjyahl hji â`d+

Wsdpaidjyahl dld`yabjp bn 377=, hji ymdq h``bsiajelq mh~d ptnndsdi tjaxtd

pyhjiaje hp h sdptly bn ymd Idndjihjyp nhaltsd yb iap`lbpd ymd ajnbskhyabj

sdxtdpydi?

=>* Cq ymd Idndjihjyp `bjit`y hji wtcla` hppdsyabjp, ymd d}d`tya~dcshj`m hji aj whsya`tlhs hll ymd jhkdi idndjihjyp mh~d uha~di hll saemy

yb `lhak d}dkwyabjp nsbk Wlhajyannp sdwdhydi sdxtdpyp nbs ib`tkdjyp,

uma`m udsd khid aj ymap hji ymd wsabs @hlanbsjah Ptwdsabs @btsy

-Ph`shkdjyb!=5* Hll Tjaydi Pyhydp Whppwbsy sd`bsip sdlhyaje yb Chsh`f MtppdajBchkh aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb hjq hji hll sdwbsyp hji najiajep bn

ymd Ajpwd`ybs Edjdshl bn ymd Idwhsykdjy bn Otpya`d hji"bs ymd Pyhyd

Idwhsykdjy aj~dpyaehyabj sdehsiaje hlldehyabjp bn tjhtymbsazdi



28/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +3= +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


dkwlbqdd h``dpp yb hji yhkwdsaje uaym Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkhp

whppwbsy sd`bsip bj hy ldhpy ymsdd pdwhshyd b``hpabjp aj 377=, aj`ltiaje

cty jby lakaydi yb hjq ajnbskhyabj sdlhyaje yb hcbty casym `dsyana`hydp bsbymds ajiaàh bn àyazdjpmaw tpdi yb wsb~d Bchkhp Hkdsa`hj àyazdjpmaw

pyhytp bj map bsaeajhl Hkdsa`hj whppwbsy hwwla`hyabj hji ymd ihyd umdj

Bchkh khid ymhy bsaeajhl hwwla`hyabj nbs hj Hkdsa`hj whppwbsy6

==* Hll IBO -aj ltiaje NCA! sd`bsip `bj`dsjaje Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh?=1* Bchkhp htymdjya`hydi bsaeajhl ~htly casym `dsyana`hyd, wsb~aje maphed, ihyd bn casym hji wlh`d bn casym -ymap khq cd wsbit`di aj `hkdsh pb

lbje hp ajidwdjidjy d}wdsy hjhlqpdp bn ymd ajf, whwds, hji bymds ajiaàh

bn htymdjyaàyq hsd wdskayydi!6

17* Hll pt`m bymds yshjp`sawyabjp bn ydpyakbjq, ldyydsp, hnnaih~ayp,idwbpayabjp, id`lhshyabjp, hji hjq bymds ib`tkdjyp, sd`bsiajep,

wmbybeshwmp, `bkwtyds sd`bsip, hji bymds d~aidj`d -ib`tkdjyhyabj bs

wsbbn mdsdhnyds! aj ymd Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkhp h`ythl bs

`bjpyst`ya~d wbppdppabj `bj`dsjaje wsbbn bn Idndjihjyp h`ythl casymwlh`dlb`hyabj hji idyhalp sdehsiaje hjq hji hll Ndidshl eb~dsjkdjy

ajnbskhyabj bs aj~dpyaehyabjp bn hjq hedj`q ajyb Idndjihjy6

18* Ib`tkdjyhyabj hji wsbbn sdlhyaje yb hll hpwd`yp bn Idndjihjypsdpaidj`d hji p`mbbl sdeapyshyabj aj Ajibjdpah, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi

yb hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyhyabj hji wsbbn sdlhyaje yb ymd hlahp bs jhkd

Chssq Pbdybsb hji umdymds bs jby Chssq Pbdybsb uhp h àyazdj bnAjibjdpah6

13* Wsbbn -hp idnajdi hji idp`sacdi hcb~d! aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi ybhll ib`tkdjyhyabj bj na}di bs dld`ysbja` kdiah sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje

twbj ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymds Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh ldehllq



29/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


`mhjedi map jhkd nsbk map hibwydi Ajibjdpahj jhkd, Chssq Pbdybsb, yb

Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh hji umdj map jhkd uhp ldehllq `mhjedi6

10*

Wsbbn -hp hcb~d! aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb hll ib`tkdjyhyabj bjna}di bs dld`ysbja` kdiah sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje twbj ymd xtdpyabj

umdymds bn umdymds ymhy Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh cd`hkd h

sdwhysahydi Hkdsa`hj àyazdj hnyds sdytsjaje yb ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp nsbk

Ajibjdpah hy hed 87 aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb ymd ihyd bn ymhy

sdwhysahyabj6

19* Wsbbn -hp hcb~d! sdlhyaje yb ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymds Idndjihjycd`hkd h jhytshlazdi TP àyazdj hji ymd ihyd bn ymhy jhytshlazhyabj6

14* Hll ib`tkdjyp hji wsbbn bn d~dsq faji -hp hcb~d! bjpyaytyaje,sdlhyaje yb, bs ybt`maje twbj Idndjihjyp `bllded, tja~dspayq, hji lhu

p`mbbl sd`bsip hji yshjp`sawyp bn djsbllkdjy hji hyydjihj`d, aj`ltiaje

cty jby lakaydi yb ymd tjsdih`ydi jhkd -a*d* Bchkh, Pbdybsb, Itjmhk!

hji `btjysq bn àyazdjpmaw ymhy Idndjihjy tpdi nbs sdeapyshyabj hp h

`bllded pytidjy hji sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje twbj ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymdsIdndjihjy sdeapydsdi hp hj Hkdsa`hj bs nbsdaej pytidjy6

1>* Ib`tkdjyhyabj bs wsbbn sdlhyaje yb ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymds Chsh`fMtppdaj Bchkh -bs hjq hlahp tpdi cq ymd Idndjihjy! d~ds aidjyanadi bs

mdli makpdln bty yb cd h nbsdaej d}`mhjed pytidjy tjids ymd jhkd bn

Chssq Pbdybsb nsbk 8151 yb 81=8 hji itsaje hjq bymds yakd wdsabip6

15*

Idndjihjyp Allajbap Pyhyd Chs hwwla`hyabj, kdkcdspmaw sd`bsip, hjihll bymds ib`tkdjyp bs wsbbn sdlhyaje yb Idndjihjyp pyhytp hp h la`djpdi

hyybsjdq6

1=* Idndjihjyp kdia`hl sd`bsip hji ymbpd bn map kbymds nsbk Ohjthsq8, 81>8, ymsbtem ymd wsdpdjy ihq*



30/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


11* Hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyp hji bymds wsbbn, aj umhyd~ds kdiah sd`bsidi-na}di, dld`ysbja`, hjhlbe bs iaeayhl!, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb ymd

whppwbsy ymhy Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh tpdi aj 81=8, sdlhyaje ybbs ybt`maje twbj hjq bn Idndjihjyp ysh~dl hcsbhi wsabs yb 3777,

aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb map pdln+sdwbsydi ysh~dl aj 81=8 yb Whfapyhj6

877*Hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyp hji bymds wsbbn, aj`ltiaje ymd whppwbsy ymhyIdndjihjy Bchkh tpdi aj 377>, sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje twbj hjq bn

Idndjihjyp ysh~dl hcsbhi paj`d 3777, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb map

pdln+sdwbsydi ysaw aj 377> yb Fdjqh6

878*Hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyp hji bymds wsbbn aj umhyd~ds kdiah sd`bsidisdlhyaje yb ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymds h esbtw `hlldi Nsadjip bn Pdjhybs

Chsh`f Bchkh bs hjq pakalhs jhkd `bjysactydi yb Fdjqhj wblaya`hl

`hjiaihyd Shalh Biajeh aj 377>

873*Hnnaih~ayp, pyhydkdjyp, idwbpayabjp, hji hll sdwbsyp hji bymdsib`tkdjyp hji wsbbn sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje twbj ymd ajnbskhyabj

ehymdsdi nsbk bs wsb~aidi yb bhjq hji hll nh`y bs d}wdsy uayjdppdp`bj`dsjaje ymd nbsedsq bn Bchkhp casym `dsyana`hyd hp wbpydi bj ~hsabtp

wsb+Bchkh udcpaydp, aj`ltiaje myyw?""uuu*ihalqfbp*`bk",

myyw?""kq*chsh`fbchkh*`bk", myyw?""uuu*naemyymdpkdhsp*`bk",

myyw?""uuu*wblayanh`y*bse", hji myyw?""uuu*nh`y`md`f*bse"6

870*H ajnbskhyabj aj Idndjihjyp h`ythl bs `bjpyst`ya~d wbppdppabjsdlhyaje yb bs ybt`m twbj hjq bn h lapy bn pbkd 897+bii hiisdppdp nbtji bjLD]AP+JD]AP hji dlpdumdsd hp h khyyds bn wtcla` sd`bsi tjids ymd

jhkd bn Chsh`f Bchkh -hji pakalhs pwdllajep! ymhy udsd hyyh`mdi yb

pbkd 04+bii pb`ahl pd`tsayq jtkcdsp, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb bjd

whsya`tlhs pb`ahl pd`tsayq jtkcds ymhy uhp tpdi umald Idndjihjy uhp h

http://www.factcheck.org/http://www.factcheck.org/


31/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


lhu pytidjy hy Mhs~hsi uma`m uhp hyyh`mdi yb map hiisdpp aj

Pbkkds~alld, KH, mh~aje cddj apptdi yb h -jbu id`dhpdi! wdspbj cbsj aj

@bjjd`ya`ty 881 qdhsp heb6879*Hll ib`tkdjyp bs bymds wsbbn sdlhyaje yb Pdld`ya~d Pds~a`d Pqpydksdeapyshyabj -#PPP Nbsk 8#! hppbàhydi uaym bs `bkwldydi cq bs aj ymd

jhkd bn ymd Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh, sdehsiaje umdymds md

d~ds sdeapydsdi nbs ymd Pdld`ya~d Pds~a`d Pqpydk6

874*Hjq hji hll bymds ib`tkdjyp sdlhyaje yb bs wsbbn `bj`dsjaje hjq hjihll `bjnla`yaje àyazdjpmaw bs sdpaidj`d sd`bsip hji"bs sdwbsyp sdehsiaje

Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkhp ysh~dlp yb Fdjqh hji Ajibjdpah6

87>*Hll ib`tkdjyp hji wsbbn, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb ib`tkdjyppmbuaje ymd jhkdp hji `bjyh`y ajnbskhyabj nbs aj~dpyaehybsp bs bymds

uayjdppdp, aj`ltiaje cty jby lakaydi yb `ldsfp hji `tpybiahjp bn sd`bsip,

sdlhyaje yb bs ybt`maje twbj ymd aj~dpyaehyabjp hlldedilq wdsnbskdi hji

najiajep bj ymd ajnbskhyabj nbsuhsidi yb ymd NCA hcbty Idndjihjy

Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh cq ymd bnna`d bn TP Pdjhybs Lhkhs Hld}hjidsnsbk Ydjjdppdd6

875*Hll ib`tkdjyp hji wsbbn -aj dld`ysbja` bs pyhcld kdiah, iaeayhl bshjhlbe sd`bsiajep, hji hll wmbyb`bwadp bs wmbybeshwmp!, aj`ltiaje cty jby

lakaydi yb jhkdp hji `bjyh`y ajnbskhyabj nbs aj~dpyaehybsp hji bymds

uayjdppdp, aj`ltiaje `tpybiahjp bn sd`bsip, hp udll hp sdptlyp hji najiajep

bn aj~dpyaehyabjp wdsnbskdi sdehsiaje hiiayabjhl hlldedi aj`bjpapydjàdpybt`maje twbj bs sdlhyaje yb ymd @dsyana`hyd bn La~d Casym -@BLC! uma`m

Idndjihjy Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh naldi bjlajd aj`ltiaje, cty jby lakaydi

yb?



32/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


87=*Hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyp bs bymds wsbbn sdlhyaje yb kdymbip tpdi cqymd TP eb~dsjkdjy yb `bjnask ymd htymdjyaàyq bn ymd @BLC hji sdhpbjp

nbs h``dwyaje ymap hccsd~ahydi, `bkwtyds+edjdshydi, lhpds wsajydiib`tkdjy hp htymdjya` wsbbn bn Bchkhp casymwlh`d hji hed ajpydhi bn

sdxtasaje hj htymdjya`hydi bsaeajhl ~htly casym `dsyana`hyd yb wsb~d h TP

Wsdpaidjyp @bjpyaytyabjhl dlaeacalayq6

871*Hjq hji hll ib`tkdjyp bs bymds wsbbn sdlhyaje yb eb~dsjkdjyhl bsjbj+eb~dsjkdjyhl ydpyp bs aj~dpyaehyabjp bs ajxtasadp `bjit`ydi ymd

htymdjyaàyq `bjnaskhyabj nbs Bchkhp @BLC hji wsb`dppdp tpdi yb

`bkwhsd ayp najiajep uaym ymbpd bn ymd nbsdjpa` ib`tkdjy d}hkajds

d}wdsyp umb idydskajdi ymap @BLC yb cd h nbsedsq6

Wlhajyannp ptckay hji `bjydji ymhy ymd wdbwld mh~d h à~al saemy bspdsadp bn saemyp, h`yabjhcld aj dxtayq tjids 93 T*P*@* 81=0, yb idkhjiymhy ymdas dld`ydi bnnaàhlp wsb~d ymdas `bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabjp yb mbli

bnna`d cq `ldhs+hji+`bj~ajàje d~aidj`d, hji yb wdyayabj nbs sdisdpp bn

esad~hj`dp `bj`dsjaje udll+nbtjidi ibtcyp `bj`dsjaje ymdas dld`ydi

bnnaàhlp `bkwdydj`d bs dlaeacalayq nbs ymd bnna`dp uma`m ymdq pddf bs mh~d

bcyhajdi*

Wlhajyannp `bjydji ymhy ymdsd ap @bjpyaytyabjhl `sapap hp h sdptly bn

ymdas `bjyajtaje tj`dsyhajyq -hji ymhy bn khjq bymdsp! `bj`dsjaje ymd

`bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabjp bn ymd `bkkhjids aj `madn? yb wty ay pakwlq, an

ymd wdbwld mh~d jb saemy tjids ymd @bjpyaytyabj yb pd`tsd pakwld hji

djnbs`dhcld saemyp, pt`m hp ymd saemy yb mh~d h jhytshl cbsj àyazdj hp



33/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


@bkkhjids+aj+@madn, ymdj ay ap bc~abtp ymhy ymd ldyyds bn ymd `bjpyaytyabj

ap hll cty jtll hji ~bai*

Ymap `bjpyaytyabjhl `sapap, aj ytsj, mhp khobs jhyabjhl pd`tsayq

shkana`hyabjp hsapaje nsbk ymd xtdpyabj bn umdymds h `bjpyaytyabjhllq

tjxthlanadi Wsdpaidjy `hj apptd ~hlai bsidsp hp h khyyds bn Ajydsjhyabjhl

hji Ibkdpya` lhu*

Ymd pwasay tjidslqaje ymap lhuptay ap h `bjyajtaje pdjpd bnnstpyshydi tsedj`q yb tj`b~ds ymd ystym pb ymhy ymd wtcla` `hj cd ntllq

ajnbskdi hcbty h`ythl bs hlldedi ndidshl eb~dsjkdjy h`ya~ayadp yb ~hlaihyd

bs `b~ds tw ymd Wsdpaidjyp sdhl cabeshwmq hji mapybsa` ch`fesbtji*

Ymdpd apptdp bc~abtplq hnnd`y wbppacld xtdpyabjp hcbty ymd eb~dsjkdjyp

ajydesayq hp h umbld, cd`htpd an h id`dwyabj mhp b``tssdi, ay uall cd xtayd

akwbppacld d~ds yb `bj`ltid, aj ymap `bjpwash`q, ymhy Bchkh h`ydi hlbjd*

Wlhajyannp ntsymds `bjydji ymhy ymd hcpdj`d bn h wtcla` kdhjp yb`mhlldjed dlaeacalayq hji xthlana`hyabjp yb mbli bnna`d, d~dj hnyds dld`yabjp,

`bjpyaytyd hj ajotsq yb ymd ptcpyhjya~d itd wsb`dpp saemyp bn ymd Hkdsa`hjwtcla` an ymd ystym ap jby tj`b~dsdi hp pbbj hp wbppacld*

Ymd Bchkh hikajapyshyabj ap kb~aje hy uhsw pwddi yb h``bkwlapmayp ebhlp, cty an Bchkh ap ajdlaeacld yb cd h TP wsdpaidjy, d~dsqymaje ymhy

ap cdaje h``bkwlapmdi uall cd alldehl*

@bjpdxtdjylq, yakd ap bn ymd dppdj`d aj tj`b~dsaje ymd ystym hji ymdnh`y ymhy najhl `bjnaskhyabj bn ymd ystym cq `ldhs hji `bj~aj`ajed~aidj`d sdkhajp otpy bty bn sdh`m jdhslq pa} ntll kbjymp hnyds ymd

ajhtetshyabj ap jb `htpd yb `mhsh`ydsazd bs naji ymap ajxtasq kbby*

Uaymaj ymd kdhjaje bn 93 T*P*@* 81==-h!, yb ymd d}ydjy ymhy ymap aph `hpd umdsd ymd lhup bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp hsd jby ptayhcld yb wsbyd`y hji



34/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


~ajia`hyd ymd à~al saemyp bn ymd wdbwld bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp yb idkhji hji

sdxtasd ymdas eb~dsjkdjyhl bnnaàhlp yb wsb~d ymdas `bjpyaytyabjhl

xthlana`hyabjp, hji yb ymd d}ydjy ymhy ymdsd hsd jb lhup bs ajptnnaàdjy lhuptayhcld yb `hssq ymdpd saemyp ajyb dnnd`y bs bymdsuapd hihwydi yb ymd bcod`y

bn wsb~aje dld`ydi bnnaàhlp xthlana`hyabjp, ymdj ymap @btsy ap dkwbudsdi

cq 93 T*P*@* 81==-h! yb d}ydji ymd `bkkbj hji pyhytybsq lhu bn ymd

Tjaydi Pyhydp aj h khjjds `bjpapydjy uaym ymd @bjpyaytyabj yb wsb~aid nbs

ymd ysahl -bs ptkkhsq iapwbpayabj uaymbty ysahl! hji iapwbpayabj bn ymap

`htpd hji, an `sakdp hsd nbtji, yb djptsd ymd ajnla`yabj bn wtjapmkdjy bj

ymd etalyq whsyadp*

Cq map wtcla` pyhydkdjyp `bj`dsjaje map casym, Chsh`f MtppdajBchkh mhp uha~di hjq bcod`yabj bs hjpuds md kaemy bymdsuapd mh~d mhi

yb ymd tyalazhyabj bn 93 T*P*@* 81==-h! yb d}ydji ymd `bkkbj hji

pyhytybsq lhup bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp aj h khjjds pb hp yb sdxtasd wsbbn bn

map `bjpyaytyabjhl dlaeacalayq*

Ymap @btsy mhp ymd wbuds yb `bjit`y mdhsajep bs khfd sdndsshlp ybidydskajd ymd d}h`y `bjybtsp bn pt`m d}ydjpabj bn `bkkbj hji pyhytybsq

lhup `bjpapydjy uaym ymd `bjpyaytyabj aj bsids yb -H! `bjit`y hj

h``btjyaje bn Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkhp `bjit`y hp h `hjiaihyd nbs

Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp, -@! dpyhclapm ymd ystym bn Idndjihjyp

xthlana`hyabj bs lh`f bn xthlana`hyabj yb pds~d hp Wsdpaidjy cq `ldhs+hji+

`bj~ajàje d~aidj`d, hji -I! yb aj~dpyaehyd hll bymds khyydsp sdlhydi yb@btjy A bn Wlhajyannp Bsaeajhl -Ohjthsq 37, 3771! @bkwlhajy*

Ymap @btsy mhp ymd wbuds yb bsids Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh yb hwwdhshji pmbu `htpd hll ymd sdladn pbtemy cq ymap `bkwlhajy pmbtli jby cd

twmdli -bs djydsdi! hehajpy mak, hp udll hp yb bsids ymd ajydsdpydi T*P*



35/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Hyybsjdqp yb otpyanq hji wsb~d ymdas pyhjiaje yb hwwdhs aj ymap `hpd,

daymds aj h sdwsdpdjyhya~d bs h`ya~d whsyq `hwh`ayq -d*e* hp ajyds~djdsp,

, bs hp sdwsdpdjyhya~dp bn aidjyanadi ajyds~djdsp bs Nsadjip bnymd @btsy dy`*!*

833* Wlhajyannp sddkwmhpazd ymhy ymdq pddf sdladn hehajpy Chsh`f MtppdajBchkh bjlq aj sdehsi yb map `bjit`y b``tssaje bs apptdp h``staje wsabs yb

map ajhtetshyabj bj Ohjthsq 37, 3771* Wlhajyannp NBAH hji 81=0 h`yabjp

`bj`dsj bjlq `bjit`y hji h`yabjp `bjit`ydi tjids `blbts bn lhu cq

Bchkh hp h wsa~hyd ajia~aithl stjjaje nbs Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi

Pyhydp, a*d*, map wdspbjjdl nald, ajpbnhs hp ymap sdnld`yp bj map

xthlana`hyabjp yb mbli hji htymbsayq yb nhaymntllq d}d`tyd ymd bnna`d bn

Wsdpaidjy bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp*



36/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

NASPY HKDJIDI@BKWLHAJY,@HWYHAJ WHKDLH CHSJDYY ^*CHSH@F MTPPDAJ BCHKH DY HL*, PH@^71+777=3+IB@ -HJ]!,NALDI OTLQ 89, 3771, CHPYALLD IHQ +0> +

IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


@hpd =?71+`~+777=3+IB@+HJ Ib`tkdjy 33 Naldi 75"84"71 Whed 0> bn 0= Whed AI #?80=


37/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=


IS* BSLDQ YHAY_

NBS YMD WLHAJYANNP



-191! >=0+4988


Nbs hll bn ymd hcb~d+hji+nbsdebaje sdhpbjp, Wlhajyannp wshq ymhy ymap

`btsy uall djyds najhl otiekdjy hehajpy Idndjihjy Chsh`f MtppdajBchkh wtspthjy yb 4 T*P*@ 443, 3= T*P*@* 3378+3373, hji 93 T*P*@*

81=0, 81==-h!*

Ymap @btsy pmbtli apptd hj bsids yb Chsh`f Mtppdaj Bchkh yb pmbu

`htpd umq ymd ntll kdhptsd bn sdladn sdxtdpydi cq ymd Wlhajyannp aj ymap

`hpd pmbtli jby cd eshjydi, hji pmbtli aj whsya`tlhs bsids ymhy ymd

`bjybtsp bn ymd najhl otiekdjy tjids 93 T*P*@* 81==-h!, aj`ltiaje ymd

d}ydjpabj bs kbiana`hyabj bn `bkkbj hji pyhytybsq lhu yb wsbyd`y ymd à~al

saemyp bn ymd wdbwld bn ymd Tjaydi Pyhydp yb idkhji `ldhs+hji+`bj~ajàje

d~aidj`d bn ymd `bjpyaytyabjhl xthlana`hyabjp, dldeacalayq, hji `bkwdydj`d

bn ymdas dld`ydi -hp udll hp ymdas jbj+dld`ydi! bnnaàhlp, sdwsdpdjyhya~dp,

hji d}d`tya~d hedjyp*

Sdpwd`yntllq ptckayydi,Udijdpihq, Otlq 89, 3771Chpyalld Ihq

Cq?RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRIs* Bslq Yhayz, Dpx* -PCJ 330900!

Hyybsjdq nbs ymd Wlhajyannp3>073 Lh Whz, Ptayd 388

Kappabj âdob, @hlanbsjah 13>18

Ydldwmbjd -191! >=0+4988

D+Khal?isRyhayzGqhmbb*`bk

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


38/38

8

3

0

9

4>

5

=

1

87

88

83

80

89

84

8>

85

8=

81

37

38

33

30

3934

3>

35

3=

WSBBN BN PDS^A@D

A ymd tjidspaejdi @mhsldp Diuhsi Laj`blj, cdaje b~ds ymd hed bn 8= hji jby h

whsyq yb ymap `hpd, pb mdsdcq id`lhsd tjids wdjhlyq bn wdsotsq ymhy bj ymap UdijdpihqOtlq 84, 3771, A wsb~aidi nh`pakald `bwadp bn ymd Wlhajyannp hcb~d+hji+nbsdebaje

Naspy Hkdjidi @bkwlhajy yb hll bn ymd nbllbuaje jbj+whsyq hyybsjdqp umbpd jhkdp

udsd hnna}di yb ymd PYHYDKDJY BN AJYDSDPY umb mh~d hwwdhsdi aj ymap `hpd

aj h``bsihj`d uaym ymd lb`hl stldp bn ymd @djyshl Iapysa`y bn @hlanbsjah, yb uay?

YMBKHP W* BCSADJ

LDBJ U* UDAIKHJ

SBEDS D* UDPY

IH^AI H* IdOTYD

NH@PAKALD -380! =19+5=81

IBJD HJI D]D@TYDI BJ YMAP 84ym

ihq bn Otlq, 3771

@mhsldp Diuhsi Laj`blj


Captain Pamela Barnett, et al v. Barack Hussein Obama, et al, Central District of California, Case...

Documents

Transcript of Captain Pamela Barnett, et al v. Barack Hussein Obama, et al, Central District of California, Case...