CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but...

12
Quarterly Newsletter - July 2017 THE OPTIONS PLAYBOOK Playing the Retracement on Imperial Oil (TSX: IMO) Cash-Covered Put on BCE Inc. (TSX: BCE) p.7 MANAGER’S COMMENTAR Y p.3 CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVES

Transcript of CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but...

Page 1: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

Quarterly Newsletter - July 2017

THE OPTIONS PLAYBOOK

Playing the Retracementon Imperial Oil (TSX: IMO)

Cash-Covered Puton BCE Inc. (TSX: BCE)

p.7

MANAGER’SCOMMENTARY

p.3

CANADIAN EQUITYDERIVATIVES

Page 2: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

2

2017 Trading Calendar

Patrick CeresnaPatrick Ceresna is the Chief Derivative Market Strategist for Learn To Trade Global (LTTG) and optionsource.net and has been a content provider and speaker for the Montreal Exchange for over 5 years. Patrick is a Chartered Market Technician (CMT), Derivative Market Specialist (DMS) and Canadian Investment Manager (CIM) by designation. Prior to becoming a partner at LTTG, Patrick spent ten years working at key financial firms in numerous trading roles including the trading of a large fund dedicated exclusively to options writing. Patrick specializes in analyzing the intermarket relationships of the broader derivatives market and the impact those trends have on trading and investment decision making.

GENERAL INFORMATION

For more information, please contactJosiane Lanoue, Senior Manager, Business Development, Equity Derivatives [email protected] or 514 871-3539

Expiration

Last trading day

Listing

Equity & ETFs options

Weekly options

Options on the US Dollar (USX)

J U L Y A U G U S T S E P T E M B E R

S M T W T F SM T W T F SS S M T W T F S

S&P/TSX 60 Index Options (SXO)

17 18 19 20 21 22 23

2 3 4 5 6 7 8

1

16 17 18 19 20 21 22

23 24 25 26 27 28 29

13 14 15 16 17 18 19

6 7 8 9 10 11 12

1 2 3 4 5

20 21 22 23 24 25 26

10 11 12 13 14 15 16

3 4 5 6 7 8 9

1 2

24 25 26 27 28 29 3027 28 29 30 31

9 10 11 12 13 14 15

30 31

Page 3: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

By Patrick Ceresna

“Learn how to see. Realize that everything connects to everything else.” Leonardo da Vinci

Amongst the broad Canadian population, there is no greater perceived truth than the following: “Real estate provides the highest returns, the greatest values and the least risk.” This belief has led to almost a decade-long increase in real estate prices across Canada following the 2008 crisis (mainly in Vancouver and Toronto) to levels that far exceed macro fundamental justification.

Should we consider this phenomenon a real estate bubble? To paraphrase a quote that I have heard long ago, “It is easy to spot a bubble, but it is very hard to market time when the bubble will burst.” That is largely due to the bizarre phenomenon that irrational and overvalued prices have the ability to become more irrational and even more mispriced. Above all, prices can remain high for extended periods. Many traders, myself included, often preemptively attempt to identify the turning points, only to experience humility in the face of the steadfast herd of bulls.

Over a long enough time horizon, the macro fundamentals will prevail and any mispricing eventually has a mean reverting moment. The only question is what catalysts could drive a mean reverting event? The most obvious catalyst would be a recession. Would a drop in real estate be the catalyst for a recession or would a normal business cycle style recession be the catalyst for a correction in real estate (cart before the horse)?

I unequivocally accept that business cycles are real and every economic expansion ends with an economic contraction, namely a recession. While we have had a short lull in Canadian GDP growth back when oil prices precipitously declined through 2015, our last material economic recession occurred during the Global Financial Crisis. While this is already one of the longest economic expansions on record, it does not guarantee it is ending. So, what can turn this business cycle? In the past, often a hawkish shift in monetary policy and the tightening of credit conditions have led to that turn.

History has shown that central banks often play an important role in turning the business cycle. As the economic data strengthens, it opens the window for central banks to begin increasing interest rates, which tightens credit conditions and provide less liquidity to drive asset prices. As the Bank of Canada made the decision to raise overnight rate target for the first time in seven year by 25 basis points, the stability of the financial system could be impacted. However, it may also represent an opportunity for investors.

3

THE MANAGER’S COMMENTARY

3

Page 4: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

Trading a Directional Bias on Real Estate

There are many risks in trying to time the turning point of real estate, which makes outright short selling of financials a speculative trade. Not only do you tie up your trading capital, it comes with a negative carry as many of these institutions have dividends in the 3-5% range. Hence, buying a put option becomes an interesting consideration for expressing the trade.

Genworth (TSX:MIC) is a publicly traded mortgage insurance company. Very similar to Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) , the company primarily insures the banks from losses on mortgage loans. However, unlike CMHC, Genworth is not in a position to be bailed out by the government if they become financially challenged.

The stock price has recently vaulted higher in association with the Berkshire bailout of Home Capital. It is now trading just a few dollars from its all-time highs. While the options are not cheap, this is a very interesting price level to be positioning for a speculation that it is the turning point.

5

10

35

15

20

25

30

40

20172016201520142013

Genworth MI Canada (TSX: MIC)

Genworth was trading at $36.23 on July 7. The January 2018 $36.00 put option can be purchased at around $3.00. To put the asymmetry into context, the risk component to the trade is limited to the cost of the option, which is $3.00. If Genworth returned to the January 2016 lows of $22.00, the intrinsic value of the put could be $14.00. If an investor has the conviction that real estate will deteriorate this year, this may be an interesting trade.

44

THE MANAGER’S COMMENTARY

Page 5: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

Hedging Canadian Bank Risk with Debit Spreads

To stay within the narrative of the emerging stresses in real estate likely to weigh heavily on the Canadian banking system, we explore a few methods of hedging a long bank stock position. In this particular case, we look at Royal Bank (TSX:RY). While it appears to be a simple exercise of buying a protective put, investors need to consider some idiosyncrasy to the existing option chains. The most obvious is the significant skew in the implied volatility (IV). I would speculate that one of the precipitating factors in creating the lopsided skew, particularly the low implied in the $95-$105 range, is likely attributable to the increased popularity in premium selling strategies like covered call

Relatively expensive tail risk

908580757065605550 12045Strike: 100 105 110 11595

35

10

15

20

25

30

40

50

45

60

55

%

Royal Bank (RY) Implied volatility Skew

January 2018 options

With above average dividends being discounted in the pricing, there is almost no attractiveness to implementing strategies like collars and outright protective put buying. So what is a more prudent approach to hedging downside risk? One strategy that naturally complements lopsided skew involves put debit spreads. Structurally, investors are buying the lower IV and selling the lower strike with a higher IV. This strategy allows the spreads to be open with favorable risk/reward propositions. Let’s look at the current pricing of a downside hedge using a debit spread:

55

THE MANAGER’S COMMENTARY

5

Page 6: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

Here is the breakdown:

• Royal Bank (TSX:RY) is trading at $95.26 on July 6.

• Royal Bank has a 52-week range of $79.75 - $99.90.

• The January $90.00 put option is trading $2.20-$2.70.

• The January $80.00 put option is trading $0.50-$1.05.

• The bid/ask spread is $1.20-$2.20.

• Royal Bank is scheduled to pay $0.87 quarterly dividends in July, October and January 2018.

An investor who overlays the put debit spread over a long stock position has hedged the downside risk of Royal Bank below $90.00 down to its 52-week lows at $80.00. Assuming a fill price on the spread under $2.00, the investor still has a positive cash flow carry net of the dividend stream. For investors looking to hold their bank stocks in the long-term but wish to hedge out intermediate risks, this approach is worth considering.

It is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure speculation. Options offer a valuable tool to control and define the risk component of the trade and to hedge the risk associated with financial institutions most vulnerable to a potential downturn in housing.

THE MANAGER’S COMMENTARY

66

Page 7: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

THE OPTIONS PLAYBOOK

Playing the Retracement on Imperial Oil (TSX: IMO)

The entire energy sector has been in contraction since the start of the year mainly due to the persistent deterioration of oil prices. While it is very premature to speculate that the major macro turning point in oil is afoot, many energy companies are approaching notable support lines with some increasingly oversold indicators. Selling of this magnitude is often accompanied by some distinctly bearish news. In the case of Imperial Oil, it has been associated with a number of downgrades concerning their Kearl and Cold Lake projects. While I would not dispute the disappointing news, high-quality stocks are typically quick to bounce as soon as the weak hands are shaken out and the value investors buy the dip. In this case, Imperial Oil is approaching decade lows in the mid to low 30’s. Investors attempting to catch the proverbial falling knife can do so with a risk-defined trade.

Breaking down the strategy• IMO was trading at $36.17 on July 7.• IMO has a 52-week range of $35.85-$48.72.• The August 18, 2017 $36.00 put is asking $1.01.

One could consider buying the shares at $36.17 and buying a short-term (40-day) protective put at the $36.00 strike price, which offers a very simple binary outcome:

• The stock bounces back toward $40.00. Under this scenario, the protective put would expire worthless and the investor remains long the stock position.

• The stock continues to decline. Under this scenario, if Imperial Oil falls below $36.00, the investor would exercise their right to sell the stock at the $36.00 strike price. The maximum potential loss is limited $1.18, $0.17 on the stock and the $1.01 cost of the option.

7

36

43

37

38

39

40

41

42

44

46

45

48

47

AprMarFeb2017DecNovOctSepAug JulJul JunMay

Imperial Oil (TSX: IMO)

Aug $36.00 protective put

Page 8: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

THE OPTIONS PLAYBOOK

Cash-Covered Put on BCE Inc. (TSX: BCE)

After a strong start to the year, BCE Inc. has been consolidating at a lower level with much of the broader Canadian market. With its large and relatively stable dividend, investors sometimes use short-term dips in the stock as an opportunity to accumulate a new position at more favourable prices. BCE’s support lies around $57.00 where it consolidated for close to five months. With the stock trading at $58.49 on July 6, we are a stone’s throw away from key support lines. If investors view these price levels as an attractive accumulation level, they can use short-term put options as a way to potentially acquire additional stocks while generating an income in the meanwhile.

Breaking down the strategy:• BCE Inc. (TSX:BCE) is trading at $58.49 on July 6.• BCE has a 52-week range of $56.80 - $63.41.• The August 18, 2017 $58.00 put option is bidding $0.65.• Every put sold represents an obligation to buy 100 shares or $5,800.00 ($58.00 x 100)

by the expiration date.

8

The $0.65 premium represents a 1.11% income in just 43 days, which is earned for undertaking the obligation to buy the stock at $58.

• If the stock declines below $58.00 The investor’s adjusted cost base (break-even) becomes $57.35 ($58.00 - $0.65), which is relatively close to its 52-week low of $56.80.

• If the stock remains range-bound or bullish The investor generates a respectable income return on a blue-chip stock without buying additional shares.

BCE Inc.

56

61

57

58

59

60

62

63

$58.00 strike

$57.35 ACB if assigned

AprMarFeb2017DecNovOctSepAug JulJul JunMay

Page 9: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

9

A COMPLIMENTARY OFFER FOR YOU AND YOUR CLIENTS FROM THE MONTRÉAL EXCHANGE

Are you and your clients seeking actionable ideas for trading and income strategies?

OptionsPlay, an educational tool, provides ideas on individual stocks and indices, whether you are bullish, bearish, or neutral.

Trade Strategy Visualization Analytics For Everyone Covered Call Ideas

m-x.ca/optionsplay

Check out OptionsPlay today and feel free to pass this offer on, as a value-added service,to your clients.

To find out more and sign up today, visit:

Page 10: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

10

Top 10 Most Active Option Classes (Q2 2017)

Options Trading Volume by Sector Q2 2017

Most Crossed Option Classes

RANK SYMBOL VOLUME INSTITUTIONAL RETAIL INSTITUTIONAL % RETAIL %1 XIU 1,605,730 1,376,510 229,220 86% 14%

2 XEG 384,169 362,787 21,382 94% 6%

3 RY 213,814 74,209 139,605 35% 65%

4 CVE 206,555 117,170 89,385 57% 43%

5 TD 200,869 60,087 140,782 30% 70%

6 CM 155,615 52,677 102,938 34% 66%

7 XGD 143,762 104,210 39,552 72% 28%

8 ZEB 141,396 139,800 1,596 99% 1%

9 TECK.B 135,821 44,106 91,715 32% 68%

10 BNS 135,534 36,983 98,551 27% 73%

RANK SYMBOL CROSS VOLUME

1 XIU 1,376,510

2 XEG 362,787

3 ZEB 139,800

4 CVE 117,170

5 XGD 104,210

6 ZSP 80,000

7 RY 74,209

8 VSN 72,169

9 CNQ 66,195

10 TX60 66,190

11 TD 60,087

12 DGC 57,085

13 AKG 56,811

14 SLF 54,781

15 CM 52,677

16 TA 49,492

17 MFC 48,536

18 FM 44,220

19 TECK.B 44,106

20 NA 42,667

Source: Bloomberg Note: Options volume from delisted or acquired companies are excluded.

MARKET STATISTICS

28%Financials

26%Energy

23%Materials

4% Consumer Discretionary

3% Telecommunication Services

5% Industrials

3% Utilities2% ConsumerStaples

2% InformationTechnology

1% RealEstate

1% HealthCare

Page 11: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

July Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May. Jun.

500,000

750,000

1,000,000

1,250,000

1,500,000

1,750,000

2,000,000

20,000

30,000

40,000

50,000

60,000

70,000

80,000

2,250,00090,000

Average Daily Volume Open Interest

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017YTD

Average Daily Volume Open Interest

60,000

70,000

80,000

90,000

100,000

110,000

120,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

3,000,000

3,500,000

4,000,000

2017YTD

2013 2014 2015 2016July Aug. Sept. Oct. Nov. Dec. Jan. Feb. Mar. Apr. May Jun.

11

Equity Average Daily Volume and Open Interest

ETF Average Daily Volume and Open Interest

MARKET STATISTICS

OVER A 5 YEAR PERIOD

OVER A 5 YEAR PERIOD

OVER A 12 MONTH PERIOD (2016-2017)

OVER A 12 MONTH PERIOD (2016-2017)

Page 12: CANADIAN EQUITY DERIVATIVESIt is not rocket science to know Canadian real estate is in a bubble, but timing its eventual burst and mean reversion is still, over the short term, pure

© 2017 Bourse de Montréal Inc.

This document is sent to you on a general information basis only. The information provided in this document, including financial and economic data, quotes and any analysis or interpretation thereof, is provided solely on an information basis and shall not be interpreted in any jurisdiction as an advice or a recommendation with respect to the purchase or sale of any derivative instrument, underlying security or any other financial instrument or as a legal, accounting, tax, financial or investment advice. Bourse de Montréal Inc. recommends that you consult your own advisors in accordance with your needs. All references in this document to specifications, rules and obligations concerning a product are subject to the Rules and Policies of Bourse de Montréal Inc. and its clearinghouse, the Canadian Derivatives Clearing Corporation. Although care has been taken in the preparation of this document, Bourse de Montréal Inc. and/or its affiliates take no responsibility for errors or omissions and reserve the right to amend or review, at any time and without prior notice, the content of this document. Bourse de Montréal Inc., its affiliates, directors, officers, employees and agents will not be liable for damages, losses or costs incurred as a result of the use of any information appearing in this document.

Standard & Poor’s and S&P are registered trademarks of Standard & Poor’s Financial Services LLC (“S&P”) and have been licensed for use by S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and sublicensed for certain purposes by Bourse de Montréal Inc. TSX is a registered trademark of TSX Inc., and has been licensed for use by S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and Bourse de Montréal Inc. The S&P/TSX 60 Index is a product of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, and has been licensed for use by Bourse de Montréal Inc. The products mentioned in this document are not sponsored, endorsed, sold or promoted by S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, Dow Jones, S&P, their respective affiliates, or TSX Inc. and neither S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC, Dow Jones, S&P, their respective affiliates or TSX Inc., make any representation regarding the advisability of investing in such product(s).

“BAX®”, “OBX®”, “ONX®”, “OIS-MX™”, “CGZ®”, “CGF®”, “CGB®”, “LGB®”, “OGB®”, “SXO™”, “SXF™”, “SXM™”, “SCF™”, “SXA™”, “SXB™”, “SXH™”, and “SXY™” are trademarks of Bourse de Montréal Inc.

Montréal Exchange, Montréal Exchange logo, Converge, and Converge logo are trademarks of Bourse de Montréal Inc.

OptionMatters.ca

m-x.ca/rssm-x.ca/linkedinm-x.ca/facebook

m-x.ca/twitterm-x.tv

Trading Tools

Useful Links

GUIDES MX INDICES OTHERS

» Equity derivatives

» Index derivatives

» Currency derivatives

» Equity options tax regime

» S&P/TSX 60 VIX Index (VIXC)

» MX Covered Straddle Writers’ Index (MPCX)

» MX Covered Call Writers’ Index (MCWX)

» Options List

» Put/Call Ratios