8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

1/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Can open data improve public procurement?ODI - 2014.01.24

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

2/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Size of budget

Size of budget

Probability

of failure

Risktolerance

Image credit: Clay Johnson @cjoh @dobtco

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

3/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Complexity

Frequency

Pens

Social care

Specificartworks

NHS IT system

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

4/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Complexity

Frequency

Pens

NHS IT systemSocial care

Specificartworks

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

5/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Size of budget

Size of budget

Probability

of failure

Risktolerance

Image credit: Clay Johnson @cjoh @dobtco

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

6/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

So how do you go from

complex and infrequentto

routine and frequent?

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

7/22@ianmakgill @spendnetwork Image credit: Portsmouth News

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

8/22@ianmakgill @spendnetwork Image credit: The Washington Post

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

9/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

So, what can open data do?

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

10/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

11/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Monitor tender performance

2010 2011 2012 2013

France Germany Greece Norway Poland United Kingdom

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

12/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Monitor supplier performance

0

15,000,000

30,000,000

45,000,000

60,000,000

May 2013 Jun 2013 Jul 2013 Aug 2013 Sep 2013 Oct 2013

CAPITA BUSINESS SERVICES LTDCAPITA RESOURCING LIMITEDCAPITA PROPERTY AND INFRASTRUCTURE LIMITEDCAPITA HARTSHEAD BENEFIT CONSULTANTS LIMITED

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

13/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Monitor a category

Comensura (36.4!)

Matrix SCM (13.1!)

Randstad (7.5!)

Hays (7.7!)

Manpower (6.5!)

Reed (5.7!)

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

14/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Monitor budget management

0

6,000,000

12,000,000

18,000,000

24,000,000

Apr 2011 Jul 2011 Oct 2011 Jan 2012 Apr 2012 Jul 2012 Oct 2012 Jan 2013 Apr 2013 Jul 2013

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

15/22

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

16/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

But this isnt open (yet)

and it can only have a limited impact on procurement

so we still need to do a lot more

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

17/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

CorpGroup

PublicSector

Net benefit

Contracts

Tax

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

18/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

Monitor the burn on every budget and contract

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

19/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

The ideal open financial data environment

Budgets

Projects

Tenders

Contracts

Transactions

Receipts

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

20/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

21/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork Image credit: wikimedia

8/13/2019 Can open data improve government procurement?

22/22

@ianmakgill @spendnetwork Image credit: Swiss Railways, SBB CFF FFS, 2009