CABI Redevelpment Document

26
CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE SUMMARY DOCUMENT KNOWLEDGE FOR LIFE

description

CABI Redevelpment Document

Transcript of CABI Redevelpment Document

Page 1: CABI Redevelpment Document

CABIREDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITESUMMARY DOCUMENT

KNOWLEDGE FOR LIFE

Page 2: CABI Redevelpment Document

2 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Contents1.0 Introduction 3

2.0 What is CABI? 4

3.0 Why do CABI wish to develop? 8

4.0 Alternative Site 9

5.0 CABI’sAspirationsforanewofficebuilding 10

6.0 The Team 16

7.0 TheCareVillage 17

8.0 ExamplesofCareVillageDesigns 21

9.0 The Business Case 22

10.0 Policy 23

11.0 CommunicationStrategy 25

12.0 Community Liaison 26

Page 3: CABI Redevelpment Document

3OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

1.0IntroductionThis document is intended to provide a summary of the redevelopment proposals for CABI at its headquarters site in Wallingford in the context of its role as an international not-for-profit organisation working in agriculture and the environment.

CAB International is an important international development and information organisation and a major local employer. Its worldwide headquarters are in the UK and there are 135 full time staff based in Wallingford. Almost half of these people currently live in South Oxfordshire District. Having looked at other sites and faced with an inadequate and ageing headquarters building, CABI has been working on a proposal to build a new office on their existing site and now wishes to submit an outline planning application. To fund the new office, CABI is proposing a care village to be built on part of the remaining land. This will help meet the requirements of the District as it considers how to meet the challenges of housing an ageing population.

The current proposals are a result of extensive discussions with SODC, which have been ongoingsince 2010. Development is proposed on land that is currently occupied by the curtilage ofexisting buildings, car parking and formal grounds, with the remaining land left open. The new officewill be constructed while CABI continues to operate from its existing buildings. Once the new office iscomplete, the care village will be built.

Both CABI and SODC have high ambitions for a sustainable development which does not cause harm to the AONB. Views into the site of the proposed development area are, fortunately, very limited. Both the new office and the care village will incorporate energy saving measures that are significantly in excess of current building regulations, as well as high levels of thermal insulation.

Page 4: CABI Redevelpment Document

4 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

2.0What is CABI?What is CABI? CABI is a not-for-profit science-based development and information organization.

CABI’s history Scientific endeavour for over a century

1909: Winston Churchill at the British Colonial Office establishes Entomological Research Committee to research agricultural pests in the Commonwealth

1929: Fleming discovers Penicillium – now deposited and curated in the CABI collection

1942: Publication of first plant pest distribution maps

1973: Journal production is computerised

1987: New constitution creating CAB International as UN Treaty-level organisation; formal opening of head office in Wallingford by HRH the Prince of Wales

1999: 12 years of research results in Green Muscle, a fungal product to control locust plagues

2010: Plantwise initiative is announced and CABI celebrates 100 years

Our Mission? CABI improves people’s lives worldwide by providing information and applying scientific expertise to solve problems in agriculture and the environment.

WhatareCABI’soperatingprinciples? CABI operates as an efficient organization so as to be financially self-sustaining whilst delivering benefits to its members through not-for-profit development projects.

How is CABI funded? CABI receives revenue from its publishing activities and project grants for development work, as well as contributions from member countries.

Globalreach We have around 400 staff across 17 locations worldwide

What activities does CABI undertake? • Publishing

• Development projects and research

• Microbial services

• Plantwise

Page 5: CABI Redevelpment Document

5OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

2.0Publishing

Development projects and research

Project work

CABI publishes high quality scientific resources within the applied life sciences

• Bibliographic databases, including CAB Abstracts• Full text electronic resources • Multimedia compendia• Books and eBooks

Our staff research and find solutions to agricultural and environmental problems

What problems are we solving?

• Improving food security in order to help alleviate poverty• Providing information and improving access to agricultural and scientific knowledge• Supporting farmers through training and advice on good agricultural practice• Protecting biodiversity by managing pests and diseases

Map showing countries where CABI projects are located

ZimbabweZambiaVietnam

United KingdomUgandaTrinidad & TobagoTanzania

SwitzerlandSt HelenaSri LankaSouth Africa

Solomon IslandsSierra LeoneRwandaPhilippines

Papua New Guinea

PakistanNigeriaNetherlands

MyanmarMontserratMauritiusMalaysia

MalawiKenyaJamaicaIndia

GuyanaGrenadaGhanaGambia

DPR KoreaCyprusCote d’IvoireColombia

ChinaChileCanadaBurundi

BruneiBritish Virgin Islands

BotswanaBermuda

BangladeshBahamasAustraliaAnguilla

Page 6: CABI Redevelpment Document

6 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Microbial services

Who does CABI work for and with?

CABI offers a range of professional microbial services

• microorganism supply

• testing and consultancy services

• microbiological identifications

• preservation & patenting

• collection screening

• Farmers

• Extension workers

• Member country governments

• Non-governmental organizations

• Charities and foundations

• Research agencies

• National donor agencies

• Development agencies

• Universities

• Corporate organizations

We work in partnership with others to achieve our objectives; building the capacity of our partners is an integral part of all our activities.

2.0

Page 7: CABI Redevelpment Document

7OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

2.0Jobs CABI Staff

Currently around 400 worldwide, approximately half in the UK

Wallingford staff total 135:

• 60 living in South Oxfordshire District

• Average length of service over 10 years

• 28 staff of over 20 years service

Other Tenants in Wallingford Office

• c. 20 jobs

Care Village Staff

• 64 full time jobs in the care home

• 6 other full time jobs

Total of around 220 jobs would make the redeveloped site one of the largest employers in the area. The growing global importance of South Oxfordshire as a science based economy will be enhanced by CABI’s decision to rebuild its offices in the district to the highest level of sustainability.

Page 8: CABI Redevelpment Document

8 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

3.0Why do CABI wish to develop?TheBuildingisunfitforpurpose

• Poor image

• The building was designed as a school – not the headquarters for an international organisation

• It is nearly 50 years old and at the end of its design life

• There are serious problems in use

• Staff comfort is a major concern – poor working conditions

• Maintenance is now very expensive

• Sustainability is very poor with very high energy costs

Air gaps around doors

Problems with flat roofs

Ineffecient temporary buildings

Water ingress

Poor lightingGreenhouse effects Not built for office purposes Deterioriating infrastructure Heating system repairs

Page 9: CABI Redevelpment Document

9OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

• Originally CABI envisaged relocating from Wallingford to either Culham Science Park or HR Wallingford and building new office premises at one of these locations. Both sites have been evaluated and discussions have taken place with the sites’ owners and agents. In addition, SODC has identified potential undeveloped land at Hithercroft. All of these sites have difficulties.

• Any relocation of CABI from their current site would require acquisition of land that would incur a cost as well as greater construction and development costs from developing on two separate sites. These costs would need to be offset by increasing the size of the care village development.

• Alternative sites have been considered but found unsuitable.

• Developing on a separate site would increase construction and development costs requiring a larger care village.

• A new international headquarters building on the current site is CABI’s favoured option.

4.0Alternative Site

Page 10: CABI Redevelpment Document

10 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Aims and Aspirations

The objective is to deliver an A- rated, BREEAM Excellent HQ Building for an international organisa-tion which:

• Is an office development which sits in harmony with the landscape;

• With the care village, provides a symbiotic development with shared facilities such as the lecture theatre, leisure building and landscaped gardens;

• Creates a delightful, collaborative, flexible and productive environment;

• Promotes and celebrates biodiversity, supporting the decade on biodiversity, having a minimal impact on the environment (energy, water, waste, materials) and a positive contribution to the site;

• Is designed for low carbon, ‘passive’ design, which minimises energy requirements and minimises its reliance on fossil fuels for this reduced requirement;

• Uses sustainably sourced materials with low embodied carbon wherever possible;

• Is a building of which both CABI and Wallingford can be proud – truly exemplary.

The architects Scott Brownrigg are an international practice with a proven record for sustainable design including the award winning Red Kite House at HR Wallingford. The CABI HQ will be a low impact two- storey office with a gross internal area of approximately 3,108 sq m. The accommodation will provide a range of associated amenities such as a café restaurant, meeting rooms and a lecture theatre. These will be able to provide facilities to the local community in the evenings and at week-ends and will become a valuable resource within the area.

Orientation Strategy

The unique form is derived from passive solar design principles. The plan is orientated East-West, which minimises the exposure to low-level morning and afternoon sun which is difficult to screen. The southern elevation incorporates horizontal blades that provide screening and harvest energy from the sun. The ‘Loggia Street’ which runs North-South is also shaded using solar photovoltaic panels incor-porated into the roof. The orientation as illustrated on the master plan is the most energy efficient and has been one of the drivers for the master plan.

Passive Ventilation Strategy

The narrow floor-plate wings are combined with a 3.4 m high clear exposed soffit. Cross ventilation can enter and exit the building via full height openings in the elevations. However, during hot, still days when there is limited air movement, ventilation is encouraged via fan- assisted extract. The open floor plates and light wells allow air to rise up through the building where it is extracted to the air handling plant at the rear of the core; this air movement provides a cooling effect.

5.0CABI’s Aspiration for the New Office Building

Page 11: CABI Redevelpment Document

11OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

Siting the building away from the road has allowed the design team to major on passive ventilation as road noise has been a diminutive factor, although noise attenuation will still be required in some cir-cumstances.

Daylight Strategy

Natural day-lighting principles have been adopted throughout the design, which will reduce the re-quirement for artificial lighting and minimise energy consumption. The narrow 14m wide floor plate ensures that no desks are further than 7m from a window. Generous floor to ceiling height and roof lights located above the centre of the floors allow natural light to enter the centre of the plan.

Structural Strategy

This is provided by a 9m x 9m offset column grid containing the concrete required for foundations and structure generally. The first floor is supported by a concrete flat slab, which is post tensioned to reduce materials and provides thermal mass to the ground floor ceiling. A hybrid system has been envisaged for the roof construction, with steel beams for the large spans and timber for smaller dis-tances to reduce the amount of steel required. Internal partitions provide additional thermal mass to both floors. Double height spaces encourage light to flow throughout the floor plates and encourage a sense of community and communication.

Water Strategy

Water mitigation is also approached in an integrated manner, green roofs, swales, and permeable paving provide a mitigating effect. These are combined with the balancing pond, which provides an integrated sustainable drainage solution with the care village.

Travel

The project will also incorporate electric car charging points, a green travel plan, drop-off for a mini-bus, and cycling and changing facilities.

Landscaping

With an organisation such as CABI, one of the principles for the design team was to strive for was in-creasing biodiversity wherever possible. The existing grounds are maintained lawns and provide poor biodiversity. The proposed office green roofs and the surrounding landscaping will be designed with the CABI scientific team to create a biodiverse landscape in keeping with the natural habitat.

5.0

Page 12: CABI Redevelpment Document

12 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Energy Performance

One of the primary goals set by CABI for the design team was to create a building with very low in-use energy consumption far in excess of any current regulations. The Design is inherently energy efficient and enables the achievement of the highest sustainability targets. The Energy Performance Certificate rating will be very close to an A-rating even before the introduction of low carbon technolo-gies (i.e. Combined Heat and Power plant and Photovoltaics). A flexible and future-proofed approach has been adopted, enabling several increments to ensure that the CABI office will be an exemplar design which will enhance CABI’s international standing as a world leader in agricultural and environ-mental scientific research. This strategy can provide a low carbon building matched to performance and operation.

5.0

Page 13: CABI Redevelpment Document

13OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

The design team’s approach is to target a building with passive technologies which result in a building with low energy use. The energy which will be required will be used sparingly and the target is to gen-erate energy on site with photovoltaics and a Combined Heat and Power plant, where the heat will be used to warm the care village and the electricity used for the office building.

Where possible the materials selected to construct the building will be low in embodied energy and will be from the A rated list, as defined by the Green Guide.

During the detailed design process every element of the building will be scrutinised to reduce energy consumption in construction and operation.

5.0

Page 14: CABI Redevelpment Document

14 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

5.0

Page 15: CABI Redevelpment Document

15OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

ProposedViewofnewoffice

Design Elevation

5.0

Page 16: CABI Redevelpment Document

16 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

In order to realise CABI’s ambition for a new Headquarters they have had to ‘hand-pick’ the correct team. Over a period of nine months through a series of competitions CABI have selected a highly qualified team of award winning companies with proven track records in delivering exemplar develop-ments. While selecting the design team for the office development, CABI undertook a design com-petition where the designs were marked on a number of categories which included; environmental sustainable design with low carbon technologies; previous work in the Wallingford area; sympathetic design to the surrounding environment; longevity of the built form; a building which CABI and Walling-ford could be proud of. We outline the core members of the team below with a brief synopsis.

• Project Manager – Ridge & Partners LLP An international award winning property consultancy based in Oxford established in 1946 with extensive experience of delivering projects in SODC and in developing sustainable mixed use developments. Ridge were selected to bring the team together and produce a CABI HQ of exemplar design.

• Architect for CABI HQ – Scott Brownrigg An international architectural practice with a heritage spanning almost 100 years. In recent years the practice has consistently been rated in the top 20 of the UK’s top 100 practices. Scott Brownrigg are one of the leading design practices for sustainable office design. Local examples include the award winning Red Kite House at H R Wallingford.

• Landscape Architects – Portus & Whitton The landscape architecture will be key to the success of the master plan and as a result CABI have employed award winning Portus & Whitton to work as part of the team right from the outset.

Based in the Cotswolds they have worked on over 15 Care Village projects and were awarded the prestigious ‘New Homes Garden Awards 2010 – Gold Award’.

• Planning Consultant – Nigel Moor Planning Originally based in Wallingford for more than twenty years, the practice has acted on a large number of major projects in South Oxfordshire, and has advised CABI on their redevelopment plans since their inception. Won first prize in the TCPA New Communities competition in 1991.

• Property Adviser – John Hayward FRICS A chartered surveyor with 35 years experience in development and investment, John Hayward has advised CABI on its UK property strategy for the last ten years.

6.0The Team

Page 17: CABI Redevelpment Document

17OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

7.0The Care VillageVision

The vision for the Wallingford care village is an integrated community for older people that provides a range of services designed to meet their current and future care needs.

• The care village layout is entirely located within the existing footprint and curtilage of the existing buildings;

• The care village will be run by a specialist operator and will include a small shop, hairdressing salon, restaurant and laundry to encourage a community environment;

• The assisted living apartments are designed to meet the requirements of older people. Every prospective resident will be subject to an independent care needs assessment on entry and a care package will be offered to them to meet their individual needs and requirements;

• The provision of services from the care home will be secured through a S.106 Unilateral Undertaking which will bind the operator of the care home to make services available to the assisted living units. As a consequence, both the care home and assisted living units are classified as Use Class C2;

• The retirement housing units are predominantly targeted at people with a lower level of dependency and there will be no requirement for residents to undertake an individual care needs assessment or for the care home to make services available to the occupiers of these units. They are classified as Use Class C3;

• The key worker units will be offered through an RSL to people working in the care home. The care village will generate approximately 70 full-time jobs;

• It is intended that the buildings will be designed as a contemporary interpretation of the local vernacular. Materials will reflect the Chilterns character of the area;

• In conjunction with CABI, there will be a mini-bus to bring residents and staff into Wallingford and to Cholsey Station. Public transport access is described in the Access and Public Transport section;

• The gardens will be managed as a single entity, which means that the site will take on an open appearance rather than being segregated with fencing and the external appearance will be carefully controlled to ensure that the development is not compromised by unsympathetic future additions.

Wallingford Option 1 Aerial View

Page 18: CABI Redevelpment Document

18 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

7.0The Care Village – Constraints

Page 19: CABI Redevelpment Document

19OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

The Care Village – Opportunities 7.0

Page 20: CABI Redevelpment Document

20 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Page 21: CABI Redevelpment Document

21OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

8.0Examples of Care Village Designs

Page 22: CABI Redevelpment Document

22 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

CABI NOSWORTHY WAY RETIREMENT VILLAGE SUMMARY DEVELOPMENT APPRAISAL

APRIL 2012

56 Retirement units and 49 Assisted Living units

115,000 sq ft net sales area 39,100,000

64 Bed Care Home 5,760,00024 Affordable Housing Apartments 12,000 sq ft net sales area 1,800,000

TOTAL SALES REVENUE 46,660,000

DEVELOPMENT COSTSCost of constructing and fitting out CABI’s Offices

8,485,000

Site Stamp Duty, legal, agency, survey and finance fees

734,250 9,219,250

Build cost of Retirement and Assisted Living units

126,500 sq ft gross internal

15,179,976

Build cost of Care Home 32,000 sq ft gross internal 4,480,000Build cost of Affordable Housing 13,200 sq ft gross internal 1,320,000Demolition 350,000Off Site Works – e.g. utilities 500,000Additional costs to achieve Code 4 sustainability

967,500

Build cost of Leisure Building 350,000Contingency at 2.50% 578,687Prof Fees for Village planning application 100,000Prof Design fees for Village 1,115,500

Build Costs 24,941,663Direct Sale Agents Fee at 2.00% 782,001Direct Sale Legal Fees at 0.50% 195,501

Disposal Fees 977,502Marketing 375,000S106 Payments 500,000

End Payments 875,000

INTERESTfromstartofOfficebuildtocompletionofVillage

[email protected]%over42 month period

2,875,413

TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS 38,888,828Developer’soverheadandprofit 7,771,172

MarginOnCost 19.98%MarginOnSales 16.67%

Although at this stage these figures are only illustrative, they are based on a possible scheme considered by an experienced team and demonstrate that a viable care village development would generate a sufficient land value to meet the cost of CABI’s new office.

9.0The Business CaseThe case for CABI’s need for a new headquarters building is made elsewhere in this document. The financial business case for the proposed redevelopment is as follows:

CABI does not have the financial resources to build new premises even if we could we justify using funds, which should be used for relieving poverty and improving global food security, for that purpose. We intend to enable the construction of a modern, environmentally efficient office building by the development of part of the present site as a care village. This would meet an urgent and growing need in the area for top quality care facilities for the elderly as well as providing additional employment opportunities.

In order to keep the care village development to the minimum size necessary to fund the new office, it would be co-located on the present site with the new office, almost entirely within the already-developed portion of the site (which represents around one quarter of the whole site). A number of alternative sites were considered and early in 2011 the proposal to develop the offices adjacent to the care village was discussed and confirmed as the preferred option, the attraction being that the land was already owned by CABI. This meant that money that would otherwise have to be allocated to site acquisition costs could be re-allocated by building a less dense care scheme and building a better, “greener”, office building. The saving was likely to be in the order of £750,000 to £1,000,000.

The Business Case needs to establish a land value which will provide CABI with the requisite quan-tum and quality of office space, the cost of which is calculated as follows:

Construction cost: £6,340,000 incl. inflation to 3Q 2013.

Design fees: £800,000 (circa 12.5%).

Fit out: £500,000 (auditorium, furniture, IT, catering) from Ridge

Photovoltaic panels £545,000 to achieve BREEAM Excellent

Professional fees: £300,000 (legal, planning, property, local authority).

This gives a total realisation requirement of: £8,485,000

To generate the equivalent of £8,485,000 in land value, a care village development of the following characteristics is required:

Retirement and assisted living apartments. For these purposes we have assumed that although each of these will have different entry age/needs thresholds, the sales values will be the same. In the appraisal, the split is 56 retirement units and 49 assisted living units.

Care Home. We have assumed 64 beds.

Affordable Housing. We have assumed that this will generally take the form of key worker accommodation. We have allowed for 24 units, which is about 43% of the retirement housing. We have slightly over provided on the number to allow for flexibility as between the retirement and assisted living designations.

This will generate the required revenue and cash flow, as well as provide a total return for the developer of 16.7%, as follows:

Page 23: CABI Redevelpment Document

23OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

PolicyNational Framework

The National Planning Policy Framework published on the 27th March 2012 sets out the need to build a strong competitive economy:

“18. The Government is committed to securing economic growth in order to create jobs and prosper-ity, building on the country’s inherent strengths, and to meeting the twin challenges of global competi-tion and of a low-carbon future.”

“19. The Government is committed to ensuring that the planning system does everything it can to support sustainable economic growth. Planning should operate to encourage and not act as an im-pediment to sustainable growth. Therefore significant weight should be placed on the need to support economic growth through the planning system.”

“20. To help achieve economic growth, local planning authorities should plan proactively to meet the development needs of business and support an economy fit for the 21st century.”

Local Context

The CABI site is located on the western edge of the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) adjacent to the River Thames. It is not identified on the proposals Map of the South Oxford-shire Local Plan (adopted January 2006) but benefits from planning permissions granted in 1985 for change of use to scientific research, review and training, and in 1989 for a journal store and despatch centre. Access to the site was subsequently substantially improved by the construction of the link road past the site from the A4074 across the River Thames to the A329. Therefore since the desig-nation of the AONB in 1965, there has been substantial additional development on the site, and the immediate character of the site was significantly changed by the construction of the link road past the site. The area that has not changed is that adjacent to the River Thames, and this area is excluded from the development proposals.

Saved Policy D1 of the South Oxfordshire Local Plan 2011 advises that the principles of good design and the protection and reinforcement of local distinctiveness should be taken into account in all devel-opment through :

(i) the provision of a clear structure of spaces;

(ii) respecting existing settlement patterns;

(iii) providing for a choice of routes and transport modes to, from and within the development;

(iv) providing a development that users find easy to understand through the use of landmarks, vistas and focal points;

(v) providing landscape structure as a framework for new development;

(vi) respecting the character of the existing landscape;

(vii) respecting distinctive settlement types and their character;

(viii) providing good quality site and building design and appropriate materials; and

(ix) providing well-designed external areas.

We will use these criteria subsequently to describe the scheme. In designing the new office building and Care Village regard has been paid to the South Oxfordshire Design Guide published in July 2008. The bulk of the advice relates to residential buildings but one of the exemplar buildings in the South Oxfordshire District is the Henley Rowing Pavilion and Museum shown at page 44 of the Design Guide. Such contemporary design can also be a feature of an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty. The Carmel College site contains a number of buildings built more than forty years ago in a modernist style that are now protected by being statutorily listed.

The Chilterns Buildings Design Guide acknowledges (para. 3.31) that there is a place for contem-porary and innovative architecture that demonstrates adherence to the basic principle of being in harmony with the site and surrounding buildings and countryside. Such buildings should also demon-strate the highest principles of sustainability in terms of design, use of materials and renewable energy provision. As expanded on in this document, this has been our approach to this development.

Policy E6 of the Local Plan 2011 seeks to retain employment sites in the District, whilst the South Oxfordshire Core Strategy March 2011 is supportive of the growth of local businesses and recognises the need for additional specialised accommodation for the elderly in the District. Meetings between CABI and members and officers of SODC have demonstrated support for CABI’s preferred option, which is the subject of the planning application.

CABI proposal

The NPPF at paragraph 116 sets out the criteria to be considered concerning major developments in the AONB, although there is no definition of what constitutes major development in this context. Given that much of the proposed development will be contained within the area of previously devel-oped land on the site, it is questionable whether the development should be regarded as a major development within the AONB, but in any event the public interest benefit of CABI remaining on the site is significant. Dealing with the criteria:

(i) the need for the development, including in terms of any national considerations, and the impact of permitting it, or refusing it, upon the local economy:

Through its Business Plan CABI has demonstrated the importance of the organisation, interna-tionally, nationally and locally. Its relocation from South Oxfordshire District would have a signifi-cant adverse impact on the local economy. The proposals enable not only the retention of an existing employment site but also its expansion. Enabling development is required to facilitate the rebuilding of CABI’s existing offices and ancillary buildings.

(ii) the cost of, and scope for, developing elsewhere outside the designated area, or meeting the need for it in some other way:

CABI has examined alternative sites at HR Wallingford, Culham and Hithercroft Estate, Walling-ford, and these have been discarded on grounds of cost and other factors. CABI remaining “in situ” together with enabling development represents the optimum solution.

(iii) any detrimental effect on the environment, the landscape and recreational opportunities, and the extent to which that could be moderated:

10.0

Page 24: CABI Redevelpment Document

24 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

The Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment has demonstrated the opportunities within the site for mitigation of the impacts. We have examined a number of appeal decisions in the AONBs involving residential and extra care development so as to identify the factors that appeal Inspectors thought significant to their decision making. Other than the appeal involving the former airbase at Rissington (APP/ F1610/ A/ 09/ 2112497, 25th February 2010 involving 368 dwellings and 12, 290 sq m com-mercial floorspace) in the Cotswolds AONB, Inspectors have not sought to categorise residential or extra care development as ‘Major Developments’. The five appeals examined involved four green-field sites and one brownfield site, which was also in the Green Belt. At Ebley Wharf, Stroud Gloucs (APP/ C1625/ A/ 04/ 1168808, 20th October 2005), 52 dwellings were proposed; at Marley Mead, Ridgeway Road, Dorking (APP/ C3620/ A/ 10/ 2138907, 4th March 2011), 38 dwellings were in-volved; at Blackbrook Hill, Dedham, Colchester (APP/ A1530/ 04/ 1170339, 12th December 2005), a 42 bedroom care home was involved; at Manor Farm, Dunstable Road, Markyate, St. Albans (APP/ A1910/A/ 09/ 2107771, 2nd December 2009) 40 dwellings were involved, whilst on the brownfield site at Ryarsh Park, Roughetts Road, West Malling, Kent 91 dwellings and 768 sq m business space was proposed (APP/ H2265/ V/ 05/ 1187599, 25th April 2006).

In all the cases the determining issue was the visual impact on the AONB and at paragraph 29 of the Dedham appeal decision the Inspector succinctly summed up the policy test as “Planning policies at a local and national level give the highest protection to the natural environment within nationally desig-nated areas such as AONBs. However, they do not preclude developments which do not have an ad-verse effect upon them and have a justified need to locate in them, particularly those directly serving the local community.” In all the cases the appeals were successful and planning permission granted.

Summary

The NPPF does not change the statutory status of the development plan as the starting point for decision- making. A one-year transitional arrangement permits Development Plan policies adopted since 2004 to continue to have weight. In this case the adopted Local Plan has no specific policies in relation to specialised accommodation for the elderly, but the subject is covered in the Core Strategy as proposed for modification by the EiP Inspector.

This analysis demonstrates that national, regional and local planning policies all support the integrat-ed, sustainable development that is represented by the proposed scheme.

10.0

Page 25: CABI Redevelpment Document

25OUTLINE PLANNING APPLICATION PLANNING PRESENTATION

11.0Communication StrategyDraft CABI Planning Time Line

31 Nov-11 31 4-Nov-11 Meeting SODC Officers

7 7 10-Nov-11 Meeting SODC Cabinet

14 14

21 21

28 28

5 Dec-11 5

12 12

19 19

26 26

2 Jan-11 2

9 9

16 16

Meeting with Oxford County Council 22-Jan-12 23 23

30 30

6 Feb-12 6

13 13

20 20

27 27

Wallingford Town Council 5-Mar-12 5 Mar-12 5

Cholsey Parish Council 7-Mar-12 12 12

19 19

26 26

2 Apr-12 2

9 9

16 16 18-Apr-12 Target planning submission

Crowmarsh Gifford Parish Council 24-Apr-12 23 23

Public exhibition at CABI (2-8pm) 27-Apr-12 30 30 30-Apr-12 Planning application registered*

Consultation starts 30-Apr-12 7 May-12 7

14 14

21 21

Consultation ends 31-May-12 28 28

4 Jun-12 4

11 11

18 18

25 25

2 Jul-12 2 2-Jul-12 Target determination date*

9 9 11-Jul-12 Planning committee*

16 16

23 23

30 30

* to be confirmed

Page 26: CABI Redevelpment Document

26 CABI REDEVELOPMENT OF WALLINGFORD SITE

Community LiaisonCommunity Liaison Strategy

The development team is committed to engaging with all stakeholders and the local community throughout the development and construction of the CABI site. This will include preapplication meet-ings, meetings with Wallingford Town Council, Crowmarsh Gifford Parish Council and Cholsey Parish Council.

Public exhibition

The purpose of the public exhibition is to provide members of the local community with information on the concept and evolving design of the proposed new office and care village, and to provide the op-portunity for feedback. It will take place at the CABI offices on 27 April 2012.

Information point

Details of the proposed development, as it progresses through the planning process and throughout its construction, will be available for members of the public to see in the reception of CABI’s office and on CABI’s website.

Promotion/Press

Press releases will be made regularly to draw attention to key information, for example the public exhi-bitions and planning application.

Contact

There will be a single point of contact for all questions regarding the development which will be adver-tised on the website.

12.0