C9: Wave & Tidal Business Forum · C9: Wave & Tidal Business Forum. Lynne Bryceland Innovation...
Transcript of C9: Wave & Tidal Business Forum · C9: Wave & Tidal Business Forum. Lynne Bryceland Innovation...
C9: Wave & Tidal
Business Forum
Lynne BrycelandInnovation Development Officer,
ScottishPower Renewables
Sound of Islay –
Supply Chain Opportunities
RenewableUK
Annual Conference
6 November 2013
Lynne Bryceland,
Innovation Development Officer
4
Iberdrola
One of the largest global electricity companies
22 million supply points - over 40 countries
World’s No.1 wind operator
14,000 MW of installed wind capacity
More than 60,000 MW in development
ScottishPower Renewables
Largest UK wind operator - > 1300 MW
200 employees, growing rapidly
£1bn invested in UK over past 10 years
Diversifying into Offshore Wind & Marine
Iberdrola-ScottishPower Renewables
Sound of Islay Tidal Array
Project Update
6
Islay Tidal Demonstration Array Project
• Developer: ScottishPower Renewables
• Technology: ANDRITZ HYDRO Hammerfest
and Alstom TGL
• Local Partner: Islay Energy Trust
• Size: 10MW
• Location: Sound of Islay, Argyll, UK
7
Islay - Site Credentials
• Strong tidal flow
• Suitable depth
• Shelter from high wave and high winds
• Low environmental impact
• Grid capacity
8
Islay - Project Status
• Planning consent secured
• Agreement for Lease secured
• Grid connection secured
• Flow surveys completed, tidal regime confirmed
• Seabed surveys completed
• Turbine layout optimised
9
ANDRITZ HYDRO Hammerfest HS1000
• World’s 1st grid-connected tidal device
• Leading technology concept:
• Seabed-mounted
• Open-rotor
• Five year track record (>15,000hrs)
• Two successful installations
• Scottish base established
• First installed at EMEC Dec 2011
• Successful retrieval and thorough
inspection
• Reinstalled September 2013 for extended
reliability tests into 2014
10
ALSTOM TGL DEEPGen IV.1
• 500kW 1st generation deployed and
tested at EMEC for over 2 years
• 1MW device now installed at EMEC and
in testing
• Participating in ETI ReDAPT
• Some significant design and operational
differences between TGL and AHH
• Key learning opportunities for SPR
Tidal Generation: Future Opportunities
12
Supply Chain Opportunities
Engineering and Manufacture
• Fabrication
• Blade manufacture
• Assembly – drive train
• Component supply
O&M/Facilities
• Cabling & mooring works
• Installation, commissioning & testing
• Port & harbour facilities
• Onshore works – electrical & civil
• Vessels & barges
• Servicing & maintenance
13
Supply Chain Opportunities....continued
Support and Consultancy
• Design – conceptual and detailed
• Site surveys
• Performance assessment
• Environmental assessment & monitoring
• Servicing & maintenance
14
• SPR has developed strong working relationships with key stakeholders in
developing this project:
• Scottish Enterprise (SE)
• Highlands & Islands Enterprise (HIE)
• Scottish Development International
• Argyll & Bute Council
• Islay Energy Trust
• SPR and OEMs meet with both SE and HIE to discuss potential supply
chain opportunities the project could foster;
• Support of economic development partners is pivotal in identifying and
promoting involvement of local suppliers and infrastructure;
• Crucially, economic development partners are also working directly with
the supply chain to ensure potential firms have the infrastructure and
capabilities to offer services to future marine projects.
Capturing the Opportunities
15
Involvement of local businesses
maximised:
Spend to date ~ £450k
Partnership with Islay Energy Trust
- Full time project officer on Islay
Local promotion of:
• Employment
• Skills
• Fisheries liaison
• Education
• Supply Chain
• Infrastructure
• Tourism
• Social Investment
Local Collaboration - Islay
Fiona MacGillivrayOrnithology
Susan CampbellArchaeology
Colin Campbell, Marine SurveysIslay Energy Trust
Direct local benefits valued at up to £0.75m
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 17 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
ns AG 20XX All rights reserved. Answers for energy.
Anglesey Skerries Tidal Stream ArrayRenewable UK, NEC 6th November 2013
David Ainsworth, Business Development Director
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 18 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Project background
• 2006 identified flagship tidal current sites in Welsh
waters
Site selection
Key Milestones
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
EIA Scoping Physical &
env surveys
AFL
secured
Offshore EIA
completed
Marine licence
application submitted
SEI
submitted
Marine
Licence &
S36 awarded
Cable route
variation &
onshore planning
submitted
Pre-installation
env monitoring
started
Commissioned
Project history
All contracts
plavced
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 19 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Anglesey Skerries, Wales
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 20 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Leasing & Licensing
• Commercial Demonstration Type 3A
• Tenant - Sea Generation (Wales) Ltd
• Maximum capacity 10MW
Overview
• 2011 – AfL signed
• 2013 Feb - Marine License – WG, Marine Consents Unit
(MCU) (now NRW)
• 2013 March - Section 36 Electricity Act - DECC, MMO
• 2013 October - Town & Country planning – Isle of
Anglesey County Council (IACC)
Status
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 21 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Physical surveys
• Desk-top geotech completed in 2008
Geotech desk top
• Q2 2013 - Geotech Site Investigation
Geophys site investigation
• 2008 - Geophys completed
• 2013 - Additional geophys for L3 cable route
Geophys
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 22 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Cable routing
Original 2010 Concept Revised 2012
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 23 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Turbine
Sea Generation
(Wales) Ltd
Installation
BOP
Other
services
Construction
Manager
Other contractors & suppliers
Employer
Legend
Marine Current Turbines Ltd (MCT)
Proposed contractual set-up for Skerries – Sea Generation Wales
Others
Turbine
Services
Construction phase Operation phase
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 24 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
SPC Contractual Set Up.
Abbreviations:
DNO = Distribution Network Operator
PPA = Power Purchase Agreement
MMO = Marine Management Organization
MCU = Marine Consents Unit of the Welsh Government
TCE = The Crown Estate
DECC = Department of Energy and Climate Change
BOP = Balance of Plant
Grid AccessContract
GrantAgreement
ConstructionManagementContract
O&MContract
MCT, Installation, Switchgear etc
Consents (Marine, Sect. 36, EPS…)
Land Lease Agreements
Installation, Turbine etc.
InsurancePolicy
Operator
Consultants
Procurement
Contracts
TCE / T&C /
Land Owner
PPAInvestors
Insurance
Company
MMO / MCU
DNO
DECCConstruction
Management
SPC
SeaGeneration
(Wales) Ltd
ShareholderAgreement
Services
Supplier
Turbine Services
Agreement
BOP Service
Supplier
BOP Services Agreement
Sea Generation (Wales) Ltd Activity
Page 24
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 25 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
MCT Locations in Bristol
2012 –
Bristol & Bath
Science Park
Team currently 55+
Will grow to 70+
2013
St Philips
Assembly & Test Facility
25,000 square feet
Up to 25 jobs for initial production
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 26 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
Quayside Assembly
Frequency
Converter
GearboxGenerator
Switchgear
Transformer
Contol System
Hydraulic Power
Pack
Pitch Actuators
Pitch System
Control
Hub Casting
Pitch BearingsCrossbeam
Foundation
Tower
Blades
Crane
MCT - Manufacture/Assembly Strategy for the turbine - Turbine
2013-11-06
Restricted © Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
Page 27 David Ainsworth E HO TP BD&SD
David Ainsworth
Business Development Director
E HO TP BD&SD
Marine Current Turbines Ltd
Bristol & Bath Science Park,
1st floor, Dirac Crescent,
Bristol, UK BS16 7FR
siemens.com/energy
Lewis Wave Power – delivering local benefitsMarc Murray, Aquamarine Power
Aquamarine Power – our goal is to create a
product called Oyster which produces
electricity from ocean wave energy…..
30
…and sell the technology world wide
31
The Lewis Wave Power Project
The Project Site
Simple, Survivable, Shore based technology
35
Onshore Site
• An onshore facility comprising hydroelectric
power equipment and a site office within a
compound of approximately 10,000m2
• Temporary construction area located
adjacent to the onshore hydroelectric facility
• Permanent access route from the A857
• Access track to the shoreline.
• Onshore pipelines will be laid out in
trenches or on the surface
36
Offshore Site
• A 40MW wave energy array consisting of
between 40 and 50 Oysters attached to the
seabed.
• A spread of boats including a jack up barge,
a dive boat, a tug and a multicat will be
needed for offshore installation of pipelines
and piles.
• The Oysters will be winched into place by
mooring anchors and secured using rock
anchors.
• Pipelines to pump water from the Oysters to
the onshore hydroelectric power station
(these will be directionally drilled or surface
laid)
37
How to get onto the Aquamarine Power Supply Chain
Key Considerations
• Although an Energy Company, we’re not Oil
and Gas
• This is the first Pre-Commercial array – getting
involved is an investment in a new industry
• We are looking to build relationships not one
off purchases
• Local is important, but it is a competitive
tendering process
• Willing to work with the industry
• Willing to understand failures as a learning opportunity
• Willing to take some commercial risk
Suppliers
Rogues gallery:
“I don’t know what the problem is but it is definitely not our fault”
“No one else has ever had a problem with our product – it must be the way
you are using it”
“All our other customers are very happy and never complain”
“We’ve never had any failures before”
• We want you to supply to this industry
• The long term opportunity is huge
• You need to treat this as an investment
• You do not know it all (and neither do we!)
My message to suppliers….
Average Breakdown of a 40MW Project
Engineering services (preparation)
1%
Component manufacturing
27%
Marine services8%
Assembly8%
Plate and steel fabrication
4%Concrete fabrication
1%
Fabrication of electrical
equipment4%
Cabling services and installation
4%
Onshore infrastructure
4%
Offshore infrastructure4%
Civil engineering8%
Control systems
4%
Electrical Services8%
Monitoring services1% Freight Transport
8%
Accommodation and personal support
services4%
Other/support services
4%
Employment Statistics
Aquamarine Power's study showed that their 40MW wave energy project in the
Western Isles could generate:
• 98 to 200 jobs in the Outer Hebrides and wider Highlands and Islands during
the construction phase - generating an estimated £4.49 million to £9 million
gross value added per year;
• 23 to 37 jobs during the 20 year operations and maintenance phase -
generating £1.3 million to £2.1 million per year.
• The calculation includes all direct employees and contractors used by
Aquamarine Power, indirect jobs such as shops, hotels and local services, and
induced jobs created by the increased overall activity in the area.
What does it take to have a successful project?
Proven Technology
Supportive Government
Finance / Customer
Seabed / Resource
Permit for Plant
Harbours
Vessels
Grid
Community
Fabricators
Suppliers
What is critical now?
Lewis Wave Farm
Proven Technology
Supportive Government
Finance / Customer
Seabed / Resource
Permit for Plant
Harbours
Vessels
Grid
Community
Fabricators
Suppliers
What is critical now?
Proven Technology
Grid
Dependent on the Western Isles grid link; but current programme is:
• Component testing - 2014/15
• Oyster 801 (Lewis design) testing in EMEC – 2016
• Lewis Detailed Design – 2015/16
• On the ground works – 2016
• Energisation timescales:
o 3 -10 MW in 2018
o 10 – 20MW in 2020
o 10 - 20MW in 2021
Timescales
• Scotland is a great place to be in the marine energy
business
• 95% of our supply chain is in Europe
• We have good government / regional and local support
• We have shown we can develop the supply chain
• Investment is our immediate challenge
– EU
– Government
– Supply chain
• This is a real economic opportunity
Conclusions
What next?
47
To get onto the suppliers list, we require:
• Relevant contact details
• Brief description of the services you provide (capability statement)
• Send it to [email protected]
• Sending it anywhere else will mean it will probably get lost amongst a wider
range of suppliers details.
48
Aquamarine Power
Elder House
24 Elder Street
Edinburgh
EH1 3DX
Tel: +44 (0) 131 524 1440
Fax: +44 (0) 131 524 1444
www.aquamarinepower.com
49
Contact us
Alstom TidalKen Street – Business Development Manager
6 November 2013
Heads down and keep going!
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
Three main activities in four Sectors
Equipment & services for power generation
ALSTOM THERMAL POWER
Equipment & services for rail transport
Equipment & services for power transmission
ALSTOM TRANSPORT
ALSTOM GRIDALSTOM RENEWABLE POWER
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
1MW Turbine main features
Yaw for optimised
inflow and reduced
loads
Integrated
power
conversion
system
Pitching blades for
increased
performance and
reduced loads
Geared for low
weight
Remote
Docking
Buoyant Nacelle
to reduce O&M
costs
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
The story so far
Tripod drilling 2006
500kW
Concept2011
100MWh
Harbour deployment testing 2008 - 2009
2012
250MWh
Testing
Complete
1MW TurbineGrid connected Jan
2013
100MWh
October 2013
Aim to complete
testing 2014
06:00 09:00 12:00 15:00 18:00 21:00 00:00 03:00 06:000
100
200
300
400
500
600
D_TShortAveMeasuredPower
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
The immediate Tidal Market
• 65% of tidal resource is deeper than 30m. (Black & Veatch Consulting Ltd.,2005)
• Raz Blanchard, Fromveurand Pentland Firth, Islay is more than 35m depth.
• Need to be seabed mounted
Sound of Islay
Raz Blanchard
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
Potential Tidal Market
Global Tidal Hot Spots – 80GW ?
Factory ?
Final
Assembly
O&M
• Factory where volume justifies
investment
• Final Assembly and O&M base close
to sites
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
O&M base creates local high skilled jobs
Farm
Turbines
Utility
Vessels
Retrieval Time
Deployment Time
Dockside
Local Dockside
Workshop
Minor
Unplanned
Events
Planned &
Unplanned
Primary
Removals/year
Minor Planned &
Unplanned
Events
Major
Planned & Unplanned
Events
Minor maintenance hours
Minor maintenance period
Per arising
Maintenance labour cost/hr
Minor maintenance hours
Minor maintenance period
Per arising
Maintenance labour cost/hr
Major maintenance hours
Major maintenance period
Per arising
Maintenance labour cost/hr
Turbine
StandsTurbine
Bays (2yr overhaul location)
Turbine O&M
Facility
Turbine
Bays (10yr overhaul
location)
Turbine
Transport
Distance
& Time
SPMT
Lorry
57
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
• Politics
• Cost of Energy
• Financial challenges
• UK content
• EMR
− strike price− ring fence marine
• Binding targets for 2030
− CO2 reduction of 40% (compared to 1990)
− 35% RE electricity (national targets) presently ends 2020
• Confidence
Factors to consider
ALSTOM © 2013. We reserve all rights in this document and in the information contained therein. Reproduction, use or disclosure to third parties without express authority is strictly forbidden.
Head down and carry on!
www.alstom.com
Building the Supply ChainAndrew ScottBusiness & Project
Development Manager
Pelamis – background
• Market leading offshore wave technology
• Over 15 years, has been long & tough road
• £85m funding including £23m revenues
• Meandering course due to short term investor
goals… straightening out track now!
• Total of 6 full scale grid connected machines
• P2 machines 9000+hours, operational
procedures demonstrated.
• ETI and utility funded project on CoE
reduction has led to ‘P2e’ machine spec.
• Current pipeline of 170MW of projects,
including demo site with grid connection.
• Supply chain evolved organically & stepwise.
• ‘Big names' now engaged through P2 – we
now have a solid base for initial pre-
commercial machines.
Pelamis – current supply chain
• PWP set up like “micro-OEM”.
• Design / verification / certification /
qualification / procurement /assembly /
commission / deployment / O&M in-house.
• Critical components co-developed with single
(or double) source suppliers.
• Balance of components outsourced mainly on
competitive basis.
• Strong relationships with suppliers, but no
formal exclusive partnerships [as yet].
What do we need from the supply chain?
• Capability – new challenges need new solutions
or careful adaptation of existing systems.
• Collaboration – we need them to work with us to
deliver and ‘own the solutions’.
• Competitive/comparative advantages – so
we/they can retain the long-term benefits.
• Capacity – we need to work now with players
who can supply and stand behind commercial
volumes in due course.
• Cost reduction – 100% bought into principle that
to be successful we need to drive cost out
… and above all else …
• Commitment – this will be a long road to a fully
commercial sector, we need suppliers with staying
power and commitment.
65
Moving to volume scenarios
Thank you!
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 69
RenewableUK
6 November 2013
Dr Michael Ottaviano
Chief Executive Officer &Managing Director
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2012 70
Carnegie Snapshot
• Owner and developer of “CETO” wave energy technology
• 26 engineering, commercial, administration staff
• ASX listed, based in Fremantle, Western Australia
• 100+ Patents or patents pending globally
• $70m spent to date on CETO
• EDF EN is a CETO licensee
• Current financials
o $11.7m cash (as at 30/9/2013)
o $15.5m undrawn grants (as at 30/9/2013)
1 year shareprice snapshot
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 71
CETO Technology
• Fully submerged, point absorber
• Near-shore location or deepwater location
• Onshore or offshore power & water production
• Modular design largely using proven subsea components
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 72
CETO 1 prototype
• Proof of Concept
• Fremantle
CETO 3 prototype
• 80kW unit
• Garden Island
CETO 2 prototype
• 3 x 1kW units pilot
• Fremantle
Concept Development
• Scale models and
wave tank testing.
<2004 2011- 20142004-2006 2006-2008 2010-20132009-2011
Technology Development Road Map
CETO 4 (independent test)
• 150kW unit.
• EDF on Reunion Island
Independent testing
• Wave tank test
• EDF & DCNS unit
CETO 5 (Plant demonstration)
• 240kW units, grid connected array project.
• Power & water production
• Garden Island, WA
2014-2016
CETO 6
• Design & location
tbd
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 73
• World first multiple wave unit array
• 3 x 240kW CETO 5 units
• 100NB, 3000psi flexible pipeline 3.2km ashore
• Onshore power plant and grid connection
• Onshore reverse osmosis desalination pilot plant
• Design, approvals, off-take, funding complete
Perth Wave Energy Project
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 74
Perth Wave Energy Project – Support
• $13.1m Australian Government grant funding for power generation
• $7.3m Western Australian State Government funding
• $1.25m Australian Government grant funding for desalinated water production
• Cooperation agreement with the WA Government water utility, Water Corporation
• Offtake with the Australian Department of Defence (HMAS Stirling)
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 75
• Component manufacturing underway
• Onshore construction activities commenced
• First offshore activities is installation of foundations
in Q4, 2013
• Commissioning mid-2014
Perth Wave Energy Project – Status
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 76
CETO 6 – Next Generation Design
• At least 2 x rated capacity versus CETO 5
• Locations: either EU/UK, Australia or Island nation
• Onshore or offshore power generation options,
subject to site characterisation.
• Design, location and funding to be finalised during
2014
• Collaboration partners to be finalised during 2014
• Commissioning in 2016
© Copyright Carnegie Wave Energy Limited 2013 77
Upcoming Milestones
• 2011/12:
Single unit test (CETO 3) at project site
$22m in Government grants secured
Power offtake with Dept of Defence
• 2013:
Detailed Design of Perth power project
Environmental & planning approvals
Start procurement & construction of Perth project
• 2014:
• Power and water production from Perth project
• Finalise CETO 6 project design and funding
• 2015/16:
• Construct & commission CETO 6 project