C13 !3/67531/metadc696763/... · DOE/PC/91 008-0291 (OSTI ID: 6048) C13 itfl!3!? NATIVE AMERICAN...

DOE/PC/91 008-0291(OSTI ID: 6048)

C13itfl !3!?NATIVE AMERICAN CONFERENCE ON PETROLEUM ENERGY > ‘

NOVEMBER 16-17, 1996, BARTLESVILLE, OKLAHOMA w:

Ill

Zoz

April 1999

Performed Under Contract No. DE-AC22-94PC9 1008(Original Report Number NIPER/BDM-0297)

BDM-Okiahoma, Inc.

Bartlesville, Oklahoma

National Petroleum Technology OfficU.S. DEPARTMENTOF ENERGY

Tulsa, Oklahoma

DISCLAIMER

This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of theUnited States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agencythereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, expressed or implied, orassumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, orusefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, orrepresents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference hereinto any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark,manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement,recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agencythereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarilystate or reflect those of the United StatesGovernment.

This reporthasbeenreproduceddirectlyfromthebestavailablecopy.

Available to DOE and DOE contractors from the Office ofScientific and Technical Information, P.O. Box 62, Oak Ridge, TN3783 1; prices available from (423) 576-8401.

Available to the public from the National Technical Information Service, U.S.Department of Commerce, 5285 Port Royal Rd., Springfield, VA 22161

DOE/PC/91008-0291DistributionCategory UC-122

Native American Conference on Petroleum EnergyNovember 16-17, 1996, Bartlesville, Oklahoma

April 1999

Work Performed Under Contract DE-AC22-94PC91OO8(Original Report Number NIPERLBDM-0291)

Prepared forU.S. Department of Energy

Assistant Secretary for Fossil Energy

National Petroleum Technology OffIceP.O. BOX 3628

Tulsz OK 74101

Prepared by:BDM-Oklahom~ Inc.

P.O. BOX 2565Bartlesville, OK 73005

DISCLAIMER

Portions of this document may be illegiblein electronic image products. Images areproduced from the best available originaldocument.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1.0 INTRODUCTION ..........*..... ...........................................................................................*.... ..1

1.1 PLANNING/ PRE-CONFERENCE ACTIVITIES..........................................................1

1.2 THE CONFERENCE .....................................................................................................1

2.0 INTRODUCTION TO PETROLEUM GEOLOGY ...............................................................2

3.0 OIL AND GAS PRODUCTION ...........................................................................................3

4.0 FEDERAL ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS IMPACTING HYDROCARBONEXPLORATION, DRILLING, AND PRODUCTION OPEMTIONS ...............................4

5.0 HOW TO DO BUSINESS WITH THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY .......................5

6.0 EVALUATION/FOLLOW-UP ...............................................................................................6

7.0 FUTURE PLANS ...................................................................................................................8

APPENDICES

A ............................................................................................................................................ ..... 9

B .................................................................................................................................*............. 15

c ............................................................................................................................................. 109

TABLES

6–1 Tabulation of Workshop Evaluation Responses.................................................................7

...Ill

NATIVE AMERICAN CONFERENCEON PETROLEUM ENERGYNOVEMBER 16-17, 1996,

BARTLESVILLE, OKLAHOMA

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Thirty-three Native American tribal members, council members, and other interested partiesgathered in Bartlesville, Oklahoma, to attend the Native American Conference on PetroleumEnergy on October 16 and 17, 1996, sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy and BDM-Oklahoma, Inc. Tribes represented at the workshop included the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Hopi,Jicarilla Apache, Osage, Seminole, and Ute. Representatives of the Bureau of Indian Affairs031A), the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), and the Minerals Management Service (MMS)also attended. A list of Attendees is listed in Appendix A.

BDM-Oklahoma developed and organized the native American Conference on PetroleumEnergy to help meet the goals of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Domestic Gas and OilInitiative to help Native American Tribes become more self-sufficient in developing andmanaging petroleum resources.

1.1 PLANNING/PRE-CONFERENCE ACTIVITIES

A flyer describing the conference was developed and mailed to Native American tribal leadersand tribal offices in targeted states (Oklahoma, New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado, Utah, andNorth Dakota). Flyers were available at the sixth annual native Indian Energy and MineralsConference in Denver in August. Follow-up telephone calls to tribal offices also were made.Information about the conference was made available on the BPO home page, and a pressrelease was sent to all major cities in the targeted states.

1.2 THE CONFERENCE

The conference provided introductory training in petroleum energy topics to members of NativeAmerican Tribes who manage tribal mineral holdings, set policy, or work in the oil and gas

1

industry. Participants gained a broad perspective in petroleum geology hydrocarbonexploration and technologies that enhance hydrocarbon production.

Presentations by BDM-Oklahoma and BDM Petroleum Technologies technical staff included anoverview of petroleum geology focusing on how oil is formed, trapped, and discovered. Geologictools and technologies employed in the discovery and recovery of petroleum were discussedusing field data and examples. An introductory session on production technology included ahistorical perspective, oil field terminology, information about leasing and owners’ rights, andan overview of primary and secondary production methods and new technologies.

On the second day of the conference, a workshop on managing and complying with federalenvironmental regulations that impact hydrocarbon exploration, drillin~ and productionoperations generated a great deal of interest. The final session on doing business with the U.S.Department of Energy included information on how to identify, evaluate, and respond tocontracting or subcontracting opportunities and an introduction to resources on the Internet.

BDM-Oklahoma supported the conference with a tabletop exhibit and several tables of reportsof technical work funded by BPO and conducted on Native lands. The technical reports andother materials were well received by participants.

2.0 INTRODUCTION TO PETROLEUM GEOLOGY

The first session of the two-day Native American Conference on Petroleum Energy wasconducted as an introduction to petroleum geology in exploration and exploitation operations.Development of oil and gas prospects for drilling were discussed by introducing partiapants tothe process that geologists use to generate and confirm prospects. Exploration prospectdevelopment begins with subsurface mapping of formation tops from geological data or electriclogs. The prospective area is confirmed with 2D seismic data and detailed with 3D seismicdata if economics justify the cost of conducting a 3D seismic survey. Examples of correlatedelectric logs and seismic profiles were presented by viewgraph to give participants an idea ofthe types of data that geologist evaluate and map. Potential targets for various areas are eitherknown from geology of hydrocarbon-producing formations in nearby fields or in frontier areas,by projecting surface geology into the subsurface from surface outcrops. Viewgraphs wereshown to the partiapants of schematic diagrams of seismic wave propagation from a surfacesource to a reflector bed in the subsurface back to surface geophones and recording devices.Photographs of Vibroseis vibrator trucks and recording trucks in the field were shown tofamiliarize participants with noninvasive methods of acquiring seismic data.

The NIPER reservoir characterization program that includes Patrick Draw field and Bell Creekfield, both deposited in a barrier island environment, were discussed. The process forcorrelating subsurface reservoir cores with surface outcrops for characterization of hydrocarbonreservoirs was presented. The value of integrating reservoir characterization data with structure

2

and isopach maps, 3D seismic data interpretation, and “4D” seismic data to predict flowpathways of hydrocarbons, development of recovery strategies, and recovery predictions bysimulation was presented. The concept of “4D seismic data collection is defined with thefourth dimension being time. A new 3D seismic survey taken a 3 to 5 years after discove~ andstart-up of production sometimes allows geologists and engineers to see the movement ofhydrocarbons through the reservoir in order to identify potential areas where bypassedoil can berecovered by additional driUingor placement of injectionwells while the oil is still economicallyrecoverable. During the presentation, time was allowed for questioning and discussion of topicsincluded in the workshop. Viewgraphs were shown of land and offshore drilling rigs during thepresentation.

The final portion of the introduction to geology focused on developing a reservoir managementprogram for new and old hydrocarbon reservoirs. It was pointed out to all participants that thesooner in the life of an oil and/or gas field that a reservoir management strategy is developedand periodically revised as new data is collected, the better the potential for higher recovery.All of the data gathered during exploration, drillin~ loggin~ corina reservoir analysis/reservoircharacterization, and production operations are used in development of a reservoirmanagement strate~ and update of it. BDM/DOE /NIPER reservoir management projects werebriefly discussed in the final portion of the first session. The introduction to geology was wellreceived by participants at the workshop.

3.0 OIL AND GAS PRODUCTION

The second session on the first day of the conference opened with an overview of the oil andgas industry from Colonel Drake’s oil discovery in Pennsylvania in 1858 to current dayoperations. The overview included a history of the petroleum industry and the function of atypical oil company. It was pointed out that the majority, by far, of the wells currentlyproducing in the United States are marginal and stripper wells owned and operated by smallindependents. .

Petroleum industry practices were discussed along with examples. Government regulations,petroleum imports, exploration practices for oil and gas, drilling techniques and methodologies,production methodologies, marketin~ recent technology advances, and the future were covered.Drilling rigs, producing wells, and subsurface diagrams were shown and discussed in thecontext of how do producers find and produce petroleum. It was pointed out that well spacingon regular 5-, 10-, 20-, 40-, 80-, 160-, 320-, or 640-acre units is regulatory spacing rather thanspacing for the architecture of the reservoir. Mineral rights, drainage, and severed minerals fromthe surface were defined and described, as these pertain to non-Native American lands andNative American lands, along with some of the problems that can arise under variousconditions. The importance of insurance, bonds, and liability for regulatory control overenvironmental contamination, blow-out while drillin~ injury, abandonment of produced outwells, etc., provided areas for instruction and discussion. Petroleum and the environment were

3

touched upon as an introduction to increased regulatory control over the petroleum industry.Subsurface well construction of wells for production was described and shown on a viewgraph,along with a brief description that “oil pools” are not really pools but hydrocarbons in the porespace of rocks. The basics of petroleum production were touched upon in this session, alongwith drillingand production costs to operators and the price of domestically produced oil.

International aspects of the petroleum industry were covered in the later part of this session.U.S. and world production trends, reserves, supply and demand, consumption, and energyresources were the final topics of this session. It was pointed out that with domestic petroleumproduction declining that imports will continue to increase. Participants in this session wereinterested in how all of these factors would affect thefi tribes and/or production on tribal landsin a few years. There was a good response to this session with questioning throughout thesession and at the end of the session.

4.0 FEDERAL ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONSIMPACTING HYDROCARBON EXPLORATION, DRILLING,AND PRODUCTION OPERATIONS

Federal environmental regulations impacting hydrocarbon exploration, drillin~ and productionoperations were discussed along with examples of violations, penalties and fines for violations,and some economic impacts of implementing environmental regulations. Federal environmentalregulations covered in the workshop are the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA),Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), Clean Water Act (CWA), Comprehensive EnvironmentalResponse, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), Superfund Amendments andReauthorization Act (SARA), Clean Air Act (CAA), Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), OilPollution Act of 1990 (OPA), Migratory Bird Treaty Act, Endangered Species Act, andHazardous Materials Transportation Act (HMTA).

Regulations for Native American Tribes with oil and gas production are contained in severalCode of Federal Regulations (CFRS) for the various federal agenaes administering theseregulations. Leasin& drillin~ and production operations are regulated by the BIA, MMS, andthe BLM. BIA regulations for leasin~ drillin~ and production operations are on public record in25 CFR for various Native American Tribes (Utes, Apache, Navajo, Shashone, Arapaho, Osage,etc.). The MMS regulates and distributes royalties for Native American Tribes with oil and/orgas production other than the Osage Tribe. MMS regulations for royalties are of public record in30 CFR Part 200. The BLM regulates operations and inspection of produang and storagefacilities on Native American Tribal lands other than the Osage Tribe. BLM regulations foroperations and inspection are of public record in 43 CFR Part 3160. Water contractrequirements on Native American Tribal lands are of public record in 25 CFR Part 159.Environmental affairs and inspections are administered by the Environmental ProtectionAgency (EPA), and the regulations are found in 40 CFR. Some of the participants requested

that these regulations be included in future workshops. These could be easily incorporated intoan expanded “on the road workshop.

It is also suggested that environmental regulations for downstream operations (gas processingplants, refineries, and chemical plants) be included in an expanded environmental workshop.Some of the Native American Tribes are investigating the feasibility of downstream processingand sales from hydrocarbons produced by the Tribe or produced by operators on Tribal lands.Adding a section on downstream environmental regulations will make the workshop of interestto a larger audience. An increase in length of the workshop will allow more time for interactionwith participants, more time for questions, and time to cover an expanded curriculum. Whenthis workshop is taken “on the road,” part of a second day could be devoted to fieldinvestigationto draw on a larger audience.

5.0 HOW TO DO BUSINESS WITH THE U.S. DEPARTMENTOF ENERGY

The fourth session addressed how to do business with the federal government. It dealt withprocurements funded directly by the government or via subcontracts with prime contractors. Itconsisted of three segments. The first segment was a general overview of the federalprocurement process, including some of the special provisions and the types of soaoeconomicprograms which might be of interest to the target audience. The second was a detailed look at agovernment solicitation and how to prepare and submit proposals in response to thesolicitation in order to maximize the potential of winning an award. The third segment was anintroduction to the variety of resources available on the World Wide Web for small businessesinterested in government procurement opportunities. It included a hands-on demonstration withthe use of a laptop computer projected on the overhead screen. Each segment wasapproximately one hour in length with a 15-minute break between the first and secondsegments. The participants were encouraged to ask questions at any point in the presentationsin order to promote meaningful dialogue and increase the dissemination of useful information.

In addition to the presentations, the participants received a number of handouts for referencematerials. Each attendee received a copy of the brochure “Doing Business with BDM-Oklahoma,” a listing of regional Small Business Administration offices, and a listing of Internetprocurement search sites. In addition, there was a variety of information which was availablefor viewing at display tables due to limited quantities. This material included the DOE Guide to

Submission of Unsolicited Proposals, samples of the home pages for procurement at a number ofDOE labs, and other topical material. The attendees were able to request additional copies ofthe “view only” data for forwarding upon availability.

6.0 EVALUATION/FOLLOW=UP

Evaluation forms were passed out to participants following each workshop session. The formsare compiled in Table 6-1. In general, the participants were pleased with the content of theconference and recognized the potential to tailor presentations if the audience were morehomogeneous in its technical background or training needs. A follow-up packet with a letter,certificate, list of attendees, and handouts and other requested materials was sent to eachconference attendee. Copies of the evaluation sheets filled out by the attendees are in AppendixB, and a summary of these comments for each session is in Appendix C.

6

Table 6-1 Tabulation of Workshop Evaluation Responses

Strongly Agree* Agree* Don’t Know Disagree Strongly Disagree TOTAL

Petroleum Geology (22 forms)

Clear Communication 4 18 2 24

Appropriate Content 4 13 3 3 1 24

Handouts 8 14 1 1 1 25

Visuals 8 15 2 1 26

Questions 9 14 0 1 24

increased Understanding 5 17 2 1 25

Usefulness 3 18 1 3 25

Total 41 109 11 10 2 173

Percent of total zz.~~yo 63.01 % 6.3670 5.78% 1.16% 100%

Percent Positive. ● 86.71 %

Production (23 forms)

Clear Communication 10 13 1 24

Appropriate Content 7 15 1 1 24

Handouts o 0 4 4

Visuals 10 12 2 24

Questions 7 13 3 23

Increased Understanding 12 11 23

Use fuhess 14 8 22

Total 60 72 5 5 0 142Percent of total 42.25% 50.70% 3.52% 3.52’%. 0.00% 100%

Percent Positive* 92.96V0

Environmental (25 forms)

Clear Communication 14 11 25

Appropriate Content 15 8 2 25

Handouts 16 9 25

Visuals 11 13 24

Questions 16 9 25

Increased Understanding 12 12 1 25

Usefulness 15 8 1 1 25

Total 99 70 3 2 0 174

Percent of total 56.90% 40.237. 1.72% 1.15% 0.00’%0 100’%

Percent Positive* 97.1 3%

Doing Business (11 forms)

Clear Communication 7 4 11

Appropriate Content 61 5 11

Handouts 4 4 8

Visuals 3 8 11

Questions 4 6 1 11

Increased Understanding 4 6 1 ~ 11

Usefulness 5 5 1 17

Total 33 38 2 1 0 74

Percent of total 44.59% 51.35% 2.70% 1.35% 0.00’% 100%

Percent Positive* 9s.95%

7

7.0 FUTURE PLANS

The training offered at the conference is the first in a series of workshops that will bedeveloped. Through contacts made at the conference, BDM-Oklahoma will work closely withindividual tribes, tribal councils, and tribal energy companies to bring training tailored to theirparticular needs to them. The training team has the capability and the resources to developintroductory modules for nontechnical staff, as well as technical modules that focus on thegeological characteristics of the tribes’ holdings.

8

I

APPENDIX A

9

NativeAmericanConferenceon PetroleumEnergyParticipantList

—

Lco0ur-

)24;0Ig:=,>)g~?z+.m

1.4

—

13

APPENDIX B

15

Native American Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Form

Introduction to Petroleum Geology

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.

agree agree don’t disagree disagree comments

strongly know strongly

The speaker communicated

x

.

the information clearly.

The content of the session.. .

was at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts wereuseful.

x/

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

xThere was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry.

\ wili be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.

What did you like best about this presentation?

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?

Do you have colleagues who would benefii from this workshop?

Other comments: (use reverse side if needed)


introduction to Petroleum Geology


I agree

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.


I

There was adequate Iopportunity to ask questions Ior share ideas. I

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.


~bk’w-+~m


$C!u. W.&% Unk S&g .

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?

qe%


comments

=1

18

Native American Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvacuation Form



agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongly

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. 02The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. I 2

Tne printed handouts wereuseful. \ 2-

~la ~JM

The audio-visual matetialsenhanced the presentation. I 2

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions

I ~or share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. I z

1wiil be ableto use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. I %


/ +@27 s i~fam”~ ~~ -- -~

2- m mu WE S#!zf mc + E&a= ---&”T?Do you have colleagues who would benefit from ths workshop?

/ - y@‘J- @f


I / @!@@@JT-- F==’J*’w~




agree agree don’t disagree disagreestrongly know strongly

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly.

x

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. xThe printed handouts wereuseful.

k

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. x

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. x

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. x

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. f


comments

I I

) .,ihw

s

‘ Id+? () u.nHow can we make this course better suited to your needs.

(!lear tt Mint --b 4ptifk dtW.@.

Do you have colieagdk who would benefit from this workshop?

Ml& 1$ -4j’4 \L8(k4Vp W9 .r. ~.

20



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shofi couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.



J

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. /

The printed handouts wereuseful. /

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. /’

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. /

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. /

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. d

What did you fike best about this presentation?

Goog LW15LOF77H7 o~ &%f$&AE J@odc’eD66

77*..WS Liz &iMJ6L hkltdou?= OF otie%?t%@ r%!i?’?jti


/‘6.


21

hlative American Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Form




The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. %


x

The printed handouts wereuseful. K


There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. ,/

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and /

gas industry. A \

I wilJbe able to use the /information presented in thisworkshop. (


Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop? ‘i n ~/d

.


22

Native American Conference on Petroieum EnergyEvaluation Form




The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. /’””’


J

The printed handouts wereuseful. J

~JLJThe audio-\iisual materialsenhanced the presentation.

/


The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. v“

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. (



23



hlative American Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Form


The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shorl couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. J

The content of the session /_ Z’+-+ P6.Lwas at the appropriate level.

/ U9)V

The printed handouts were Juseful.

x+ -

/ -@G5vua v%

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. J



I will be able to use theinformation presented in this J“workshop.

What did you like best about this presentation? ~+ .~ 4=+ LJ@l * ~k~[*

How can we make this course better suited to your needs? @ .46-W- ~+1-

\ v

J yp-

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop? ~ ,1


24

i’dative American Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Form

lntroductionto Petroleum Geology



The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. V“

The content of the session !-L+. & s-c--was at the appropriate level. GA $& b c +X

5 i-1. .



v’

There was adequate r- U<54-I-CWI > Q*

opportunity to ask questions Ja5k –z -&&Aor share ideas.

be~e OG CL&&

The session increased my cm7

+km’cm - d ~

understanding of the oil and/

here?gas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. /

i5




lntroductionto Petroleum Geology


agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongiy

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. #



The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. /


The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. i

I wilJbe able to use theinformation presented in this

/workshop.

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?U/e


)-Y>



Introduction to Petroieum Geology

The evaluation process is impofiant to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fili in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedJA


The content of the sessionJ’was at the appropriate level. “

/The printed handouts wereuseful.

/’4The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

There was adequate

/opportunity to ask questions ~or share ideas.

JThe session increased my .understanding of the oil andgas industry. ..

/I will be able to use theinformation presented in this /workshop.

What did you like best about ~hispresentation?J~& Ad. $V’n#+ * ~“ti ‘ #0L*JLdLA4AL?J@ w&&

2


f&&&44

,


27

Native American Conference on Petro!eum EnergyEvaluation Form



W;, agree ::: disagree gr~ comments

9Y 9Y

The speaker communicate~ j @the information clearly.

*Z v

The content of the session i ~was at the appropriate level.

LThe printed handouts were { vuseful.

.L HThe audio-visual materials 1 &enhanced the presentation.

#There was adequate ! ~opportun-Ry to ask questionsor share ideas.

% . /

The session increased my ~ /understanding of the oil andgas industry.

% . v

1will be able to use theinformation presented in this

b ~ .

How can we make this course better sgited

r/~ h bv34Y:d+ Ju“- w---qe-~~’- +gi$?’-


yd-!j?~> .

28





agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly ,know strongly


The content of the session /was at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts were /

useful./

The audio-visual materials /

enhanced the presentation.(

There was adequate /opportunity to ask questionsor share ideas.

The session increased my I

understanding of the oil andgas industry.

,I


What did you like best about this prese tion?

(90QAzufd w ULAJQLL @&l~ V

u



‘L-@.. T


29


Introduction to Petroleum Geoiogy






d



There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. J

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this Jworkshop.


- pP@$’MiJ U4 Uby ?4G3=J


/@d’? @zLJ


ya - #31.A g

) i ~w#@4##@[email protected] / ~ -‘4. .

>


30



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. F3ease fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedthe information cleady.

/.

The content of the session /was at the appropriate level.


The audio-visual materials /enhanced the presentation.


/

or share ideas.

The session increased my /understanding of the oil andgas industry.

I will be able to use the /

information presented in thisworkshop.


‘4L ~~’ & ALA@=’@;

.’?4-

-y%+~


. .~ ~~, . &,-V’{


c+”-Other comments (use reverse side if needed)

31







/


/


d



K


1will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.

b


Slif).es wk~ck -W*p@fi:4 ‘-*WG


I)o you have colleagueswho wouldbenefitfromthis workshop?

yes

32





The speaker communicatedthe information clearly,

1

9 @

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. @ B


The audio-visual materials 6Jenhanced the presentation.

oThere was adequateopportunity to ask questions >

or share ideas. o2

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and Q -

gas industry.Q

I will be able to use the

?

2information presented in thisworkshop.

What did you like best about this presentation? @@~

G@@@ -

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?~w+ ,---






/The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts wereuseful. d


There was adequateopportunity to ask questions /or share ideas.

The session increased my /

understanding of the oil andgas industry.

/I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.


~[c~ +<+

How can we make ths course better suited to your needs?


4-P– V’-%&- ‘““ .r

Other comments (use reverse side if needed)

34





The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. /


The printed handouts wereuseful. u’



The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. v’


What did you like best about this presen tion?

& /A~hQAA” ;~$= mwS.VYMmVGL+.


mu *!


T-S,

35





36

agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrorwly know strongly



$The printed handouts wereuseful.

The audio-visual materials1

enhanced the presentation. x

There was adequateopportunity 10 ask questions ‘or share ideas. x


I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. K


Flow can we make this course better suited to your needs?








xThe content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.


xThe audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.


xThe session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry.

I wiii be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.

x




~+e- “

37






The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. d

The content of the session

was at the appropriate level. J


The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation..

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. J


1will be able to use theinformation presented in this d

workshop.


& qfk &-C4zMX=J , ti3

&yW”


Do you have colleagues who would benefit from ths workshop?

VltibtzL@QV,Y4+ X@Jj


38


Oil and Gas Production




xThe audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. xThere was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas.



x

agree don’t disagree disagree commentsknow strongly

OJOA L{*SDu [.!.Jl W&I~ G&zi t-

j’ b


HOWcan we make this course better suited to your needs?


Other comments: (use reverse side if needed) ~ * .

39




agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly .,“-know strongly

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. #g

,, ‘

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. J*’

V-



There was adequateoppofiunity to ask questionsor share ideas. /


/-”1will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.




7

495’


40



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shortcouse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.

agree agree’ don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongly

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. <

The content of the session /


The printed handouts were /

useful. ,









41




agree commentsstrong]


#The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.


/The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.


1The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. ..:-.

JI will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.


How can we make this course bettersuitedto your needs?



42




agree agree don’t disagreestrongly know

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. I b--+-++The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.

PI . !

The printed handouts wereuseful. :

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. I Id--++,There was adequate I I I Iopportunity to a-skquestionsor share ideas. IllbThe session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry.

P

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. P

disagree I comments I

wt.


1+= Qczs d-i’.

bid ALa


7 CCJ ;CL b=k ‘\ &4’r20AAA%

s+=- yy.f-. k~ 4.

C-J.-l-mA..-J-k’* L.-b.-




The evaluation process is impodant 10determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.




The printed handouts were 01’J Mluseful. *

The audio-visual matetialsenhanced the presentation. ‘

There was adequate

opportunity to ask questionsor share ideas.

/


1will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. /


K-(

AA5+YU*.


nuWUGGLJ! ~o 5kcrLQ Jua.+i-cws drtid ~

*w’vii h) -MMi! ,$kzkz, T..& -p+

L/L ,Do you have colleagues who would benefii from this workshop?


44







k


%-

The pcinted handouts wereuseful.

$

The audio-visuai materialsenhanced the presentation.



KI will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop.

$


How oan we make this course better suited to your needs?



45

I

Native American Conference on Petro/eurn ErtergyEvaluation Form





/v


Ja I



- /



/ill

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. J




46

comments





47



x


x


YThe audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

x


Y

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and

x

.

gas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. x


u 1; IA&(_ ?,,

cL5t~~LL7 , j: ]

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?+1[+’J\!iJb4J Ll-A! )Vj ill Yli( Ob ~


f <5


Id/*




agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly/ know strongly



The printed handouts wereuseful. +6 p$ /




Y


/

What did you like best about this presentation? ?

-a%~~b.

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?&%Qh~-5.

& ~&wf

+36 [1


F

.




There was adequate

opportunity to ask questions

or share ideas.I


7information presented in this

agree

V

What did You like best about this presentation?



Y&5

49




The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shoti couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. ~

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. K


,)’


x’

There was adequate


or share ideas.x

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. i


xinformation presented in this .’workshop.


J@zLLLA+@L-0f@d%7d4


4. 13+j&42=--At~Jr,-


Y <5


50



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. PIease fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.




The printed handouts wereuseful. Wol-J’5~

The audio-visual materials

/enhanced the presentation. ‘




What did you like best aboLt this presentation?

~pdu v%uvd~ L ~~& +q,

%tiOwx ‘ ,Liz?iZA *p&J) JD

How can we make t is ourse better suited to your nee s.


Y-


% k +.-d 1?.4



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shofi couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. x

k +n f m ‘ ~&%O’14

~wa$ ~l~itiW\

The content of the sessiond

1 Awl ~we &f W\tit 1was at the appropriate level. ~vzl -@ 6W’M llja$ (JAW

The printed handouts wereuseful. Ndfz

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. Y

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. xThe session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. x

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. ‘K

What did you like best about this presentation?f ~aqbwi=mo.vhw~i5b te5 o

t-low can we make this course better suited to your needs?

fiU/s JWcf” dfled -%’ rwit%L /

4-d f J!!mflk’.+wu.chu sj=f~~a~~ffl~‘nsa 0Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?

FLz lN a Wm &AL4J , fiUA%J r im


52






The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. /’




The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and /gas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this /workshop.

>

What did you like best about this presentation?ti~~ G-J@&J’-L . . 5+2= -+ Q.%&4-&. ,y.


~L l-,! “ “

Do you have colleagues who would benefii from this workshop?c’

Other comments: (use reverse side if needed) _ N GJ

53

Native American

Oil

Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Formand Gas Production



The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. \

\/

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. x

The printed handouts were

x#-

useful.


.b

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. x



P

information presented in this ‘.,workshop.


b..+ ~fl’= - (km [A)Aok



&s


T L4

4.

;s P~csen * 1(“~h~54

w-r f. . ‘i9 # ...+






AThe content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts were .useful.


There was adequatet




What did you like best about this pr sentation?

fh %%+’-{>k

.

Do you have colleagues who wouldbenefit from this workshop?


+42 p..4UlA#L H’=J Wy %/ .42’ -=- 2/ g//

55

...- ____________ ...-—...-. —.


Oil and Gas Production>



The speaker communicatedthe Information clearly. v“



do Pa-=’> A’W3@u=’

The audio-visua[ materialsenhanced the presentation. /


The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. d

I will ~ able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. J


~k~$%%-~ ~

l-tow can we make this course better suited to your needs?

422 F;&&

Do you have colleagues who wouldbenefii from this workshop?

r-


56




agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strong[y

The speaker communicated /


The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. J

The printed handouts were /useful.

The audio-visual materials /enhanced the presentation.


The session increased myunderstanding of the.oil and

/

gas industry. I

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this

/

workshop.

)


mAL~

) Wuw.-+. .

WY - 9-How can we make this course better suited to your needs?

w

57

Do you have colleagues who would benefti from this workshop?

%d #&+.




The evaluation process is important to determine the efient to which this shofi couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.

agree agreestrongly



x


The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. v

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. K

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. K



don’t disagree disagree commentsknow strongly

“WI{ k v%

* ~&il “


\ (es.

Other mmments: (use reverse side if needed)

58

Native American

Oil

Conference on Petroleum EnergyEvaluation Formand Gas Production






There was adequate





/

/

/

/

d

J

J\


g; p“~~ #RJ JM 05 l’&t’J

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?,} ({

ya


59




agree agree don’t disagreestrongly know

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. ,

i.’

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. ‘J’

1


The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. ./’

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. A/


I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. II d“

disagree comments1

strongly

l-low can we make this course better suited to your needs?

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop? -yw


60



The evaluation process is impodant to determine the extent to which this short couse has met .your needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. #

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate leveL

The printed handouts were ,

useful.


/


{

or share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and egas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this /’workshop.


J%!@-L#./ /.!


Y &&&ma- 4@Q’-fiz.-jzz i’~ v


61



Environmental Management

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desked.




The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. / \ .

The printed handouts wereuseful. /, /

> .

\The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

,/ 1-There was adequateopportunity to ask questions

/J

or share ideas.

The session increased my

/understanding of the oil and ~gas industry.


What did you like best ab this presentation?

~ L “-L+ :“& L Z&(a

Hoi can we make this course better suited to your needs?


Y4

Other commentx (use reverse side rf nepded~

TL

%5R&iu



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shoct couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.









What didyou like best about this presentation?







The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. x

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. Yi


x


x

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. X’

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and

x/

gas industty.


/!

workshop.i

What did you like best about this pr sentation?

J&+y&? h- J&Ad &&[

How can we make this course bett r suited to your needs?

+ A+2Z4.. jLA d*/ $f%


Al -~


64

. .




agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongJy know strongly



The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. <




/The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry.






65

I

Native American Conference on PetroIeum EnergyEvaluation Form




The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. d

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. d

The printed handouts wereuseful. V’”

~~t jWQAUc~sOLJ#[w5j&;


There was adequate

Joppofiunity to ask questionsor share ideas.


1will be able to use theinformation presented in this v“workshop.




Y dOther comments: (use reverse side if neededj

66








//


The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. Y

There was adequate /



1will be able to use theinformation presented in this

workshop.

What did You like best about this Presentation? 1




67



The evaluation process is impofiant to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.



The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. J

The printed handouts wereuseful. d-



J


V



/


/

Do you have colleagues who wouldbenefitfromthis workshop? ‘p( (YJ3 ~ ,

d’

Other comments (use reverse side ii needed)

68





The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate leveL



There was adequate


or share ideas.


I will be abie to use theinformation presented in this

workshop.

agree agree don’tstrongly know

x

8

/

disagree disagree commentsstrongly


& $/dp*A~”.


@y@ry &@~

69




strongly

The speaker communicated ,the information clearly. lxThe content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. K


There was adequate Iopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. lx


information presented in this Iworkshop. I k

agree don’t disagree disagree commentsknow strongly

I

t

,

I I

What did you like best abOLJJthis presentation?

\MLf-l&

Do you have colleagueswho would benefit from this workshop?

d Cs

Other comments: (use reverse side if needed).

&tit pw-eiLJL.k&’L [email protected]!#’AA-@4t



The evaluation process is importantto determinethe extent to which this shod couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.




The printed handouts wereuseful. d





Jinformation presented in this .workshop.



1 Q(2LQ b 2, “~~ d AOtAAAM.J


)&







The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. /“

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. /“

The printed handouts wereuseful. -/’


There was adequateopportunity to ask questions J’”

or share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and /“

gas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this /“workshop.

What did you Ike best about this presentation?

How can we make this course better suited to yourneeds?



72





The con~en~of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.


=d=



+

/

w’The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. J


don’tknow

disagree disagree commentsstrongly

What did You like best about this presentation?



P

. AZ4 - D.y

73






The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. ‘d

The content of the session

/was at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts wereuseful. /.

The audio-visual materials

Jenhanced the presentation. -

There was adequate


or’ share ideas./


I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. d


/----


..———————


~“

Other comments: (Use reverse side if needed)

74





The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. x“

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. x

The printed handouts wereuseful. H


There was adequateopportunity to ask questions Aor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and xgas industry.

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this xworkshop.





75




agree agree don?= disagree disagree commentsstrong}y know strong! y


The content of the session \



xThe audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.


The session increased myunderstanding of the oil andgas industry. x

I will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. F


O? Wi U k----

Do you have colleagues who wouJd benefit from this workshop?

N- 0-


@cd~ow g cu5~-5 [ UV&L-

&V~ \-P ; “’@’-Yl - ‘“L

76



The evaluation process is impotiant to determine the extent to which this short couse has met

your needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.



the information clearly. i*



The audio-visual materiaisenhanced the presentation. i/

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions J

or share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and “dgas industry.

i will be able to use theinformation presented in this /workshop.

What did you like best about ths presentation?



77

comments



Environments/ Management

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this shod couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.



The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. . /“

The printed handouts wereuseful. V/”’








v“- .Other comments: (use reverse side if needed)






/


/


#


/There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsorshare ideas.

/


/


/


‘?M%O’WM--- cm’vA4&L& LUd dL--wq*” C4Wl#ui’v&4@’d*



79








There was adequate


or share ideas.



workshop.

agree

SE?Q9!L

/

/’

//’

/

agree

/“

/“

don’tknow

disagree

F

I

What did you like best about this presentation? ma2zA’&- Azfi&52/m” a’z”=& &?<

*zfl.fA. .24 d d2

y;f -3’2&S&7227z&+.J ●,


Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?P










K



x


K


&







The evaluation process is impofiant to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.

I agree I agree\ strongly I

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. K



The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. w

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. v

1

The session increased myunderstanding of the oii andgas industry. F

~

information presented in this

don’t disagree disagree commentsknow strongly

K


b- V3@Jgw&


flmc U 65) doemfi/zzkw

Do you have colleagues who wouid benefit from this workshop?


82

.










I will be able to use theinformation presented in this’workshop.


/’

/

w $uWvUULLj C&

L“-’ TWe@vWqc M

/

/

I

v“,

v’

What did ou like best about this presentation?

JISm+v JWJXm5’\ & *<; @J-


#$ RJIUk+ -*p~+-b~-s~p ‘ -Ss

%-‘~k UII:WJW p* UX’M.lh


POther comments: (use reverse side if needed)

83





The speaker communicated ,the information clearly.

K


x

The printed handouts wereuseful. xThe audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

x


K


x

I willbe able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. T


-z=@!W-

l~~h o R ct-~~ ~k--l B Lw F.o,G.t-M

~fldn~y \, dt’r’$-tr, vfl- T.:hvj


/\ c~


84













gJ-&*Z*_2

f-low can we make this course better suited to your needs?


i 65-


85




~ agree






I will be able to use the Iinformation presented in thisworkshop.

agree

1+

u

d

+J

don’t disagreeknow

I


L’qd”d L 4’.


Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop? u o .

Other comments: (use reverse side if needed) /&~’

86






The content of the session /


The printed handouts were ,.

useful. /j

/The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation.

There was adequate /,”

opportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. /4

The session increased myunderstanding of the oil and /,

gas industry. /




Do you have colleagues ho would benefit from this workshop?4


87


Doing Business with the U.S. Department of Energy

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and addcomments as desired.




+


X.


K


x

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. %

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess.

%


%


FJAL


~ cfcYp’7-- Khou H 7 ~~~ ~“’~” -


7’P5


88.



The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please filf in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.




The printed handouts wereuseful. v ~ ~z


/


J.

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess. J

1will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. J

1

What did you iike best about this presentation? .,..----

(“


/“

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?m


89





The speaker communicatedthe information c!early.

{The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level. xThe printed handouts were (<useful. Ml- ad &(t-&


F .,

There was adequate


or share ideas..x

The session increased myunderstanding of the

x

p< Vw kmLti T

government procurement q- c~n in=, ~,$~v~sbdly ‘:+,process.G-w+- pUcLUU~

I will be able to use theinformation presented in this i

k

.~q;~ .

workshop.

What didyoulikebest about this presentation?




90.






d

The content of tiie sessionwas at the appropriate level. d


The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. d

There was adequateopportunity to ask questionsor share ideas. d

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess. d

I wiii be abie to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. d

What did you iike best about this presentation?


Do you have colleagues who wouid benefii from this workshop?


.91






the information cleariy. ,/”’””


U


J


J

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions dor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurement J

.

process.






92



The evaluation process is impotiant to determine the extent to which this short couse has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.



The” content of the sessionwas at the appropriate level.

The printed handouts were L

useful.

The audio-visual materials\

enhanced the presentation.

There was adequate J


The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess,

i will be able to use theJ



ffzzzfe YGG4 +UM AL Sz+%&A



X@f g J JoS/h SS.O

93






x


$


*

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. K

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions Kor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the xgovernment procurementprocess.


Kworkshop.


C* ‘i/’W & h[v b~ -S


U~&4C ~ qe+ @cdq 4’(4-JL + AGY=


?

.s


‘V(WM

?







The printed handouts wereusefut.

The audio-visual materialsenhanced the presentation. “

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions dor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess. i





CXhercomments: (use reverse side if needed)

.95




agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongiy

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. v“



The audio-visual matedalsenhanced the presentation. d

There was adequateopportunity to ask questions Jor share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurement Jprocess.

I wi[l be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. J

What did you [ike best about this presentation?




96






/


/

The printed handouts were ~o h&NAce+>useful.



/

The session increased myunderstanding of thegovernment procurementprocess. /

i will be able to use theinformation presented in thisworkshop. /


f-low can we make this course better suited to your needs?

.97

Do you have colleagues who would banefii from this workshop?





agree agree don’t disagree disagree comments‘“ strongly know strongly

The speaker communicatedthe information clearly. ~

The content of the sessionwas at the appropriate leveL d




/or share ideas.

The session increased myunderstanding of the /government procurementprocess.

I will be abie to use theinformation presented in this /

workshop.

What didyou like best about this presentation?

How can we make this course better suited to your needs? -

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop? -’

Other comments: (use reverse side if needed) -

98.

Native American Conference on Petro/eum Energy

Evaluation Form

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this conference has metyour needs. please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


Communication prior to the #

conference was good. xThe conference staff mademe feel welcome.

x

The meeting room was

4

.comfortable.

Refreshments were good. -

x

What were your objectives in attending this workshop?

If we were to offer other topics or more advanced topics, what would interest you?

Other comments:

99

Native American Conference on Petroleum Energy

Evaluation Form

The evaluation process is important to determine the extent to which this conference has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.


Communication prior to theconference was good. FJ m’

The conference staff mademe feel welcome.

J

The meeting room wascomfortable.

/

Refreshments were good.

J

How did you hear about this conference? $M’UJM ti,till ;

comments

What were your objectives in attending this workshop? - lQl@’7M~ti

Would you recom~end this training to your colleagues?

!*- 1

%fJ 1

T


100

Other comments:


Evaluation Form



Communication prior to theconference was good.

<The conference staff mademe feel welcome.

%-


x


x

How did you hear about this conference?

$Iy.c

Would you recommend this training to your colleagues?

7-5*


Other comments:

101


Evaluation Form



Communication prior to theconference was good. Y


f


<


/<

How did you hear about this conference? ~{ ~


Lea>n a bav~



Evaluation Form




Communication prior to the

conference was good.A

The conference staff madem-efeel welcome.


xRefreshments were good.


flz’i~z

What were your o jectives in attending this workshop?@’/ ,;.A*7G7 .b& O)Y /&.


&/x p2.p-2zzcA X *F y Z+-&

If we were to offer other to ics or more advanced t pies, what would interest you?

27// / 603 J.[/~/-.@@Jm -

Native American

The evaluation process is important to

Conference on Petroleum Energy

Evaluation Form

determine the extent to which this conference has metyour needs. Please fill in the appropriate boxes and add comments as desired.





agree agree don’t dksagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongly

J.

J

i





Other comments:

104


Evaluation Form



Communication prior to theconference was good. /


/


d




%LLti Ab+L~y<

Would you recommend this trainingto your colleagues?

Y


Other comments:

105


Evacuation Form


agree agree don’t disagree disagree commentsstrongly know strongi y


v


Y


v


v


Lef$w-n mow abeu+ +L p’o le.um Inb+’>


y55


~~c$$i~~on~, $l&U +’$J

Other comments:

106


Evacuation Form



Communication prior to the

conference was good. ‘J

The conference staff mademe feel welcome. v


(U’

Refreshments were good.J

f-low did you hear about this conference? @ ~UL~ ~~ ,

What were your objectives in attending this workshop? --l=> B.<& f&~,

Would you recommend this training to your colleagues?&----

107

If we were to offer other topics or more advanced topics, what would interest you? @s f~

Other comments:


Evaluation Form


agree agree don’t disagree disagreestrongly

commentsknow strongly


u


d


Refreshments were good. /

t-low did you hear about this conference?

%.w~ &&z’& w ~@@’1

What were your objectives in attending this workshop?A

Would you recommend this training to your colleagues? 1.

YU\


Other comments:

APPENDIX C

109

INTRODUCTION TO PETROLEUM GEOLOGY

Comments

What did you like about this presentation?●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

9

●

●

c

●

InformationGood simplification of complex subjectGeneral topics, chance to meet and talk with people.Good development of baseline knowledge/thanks for providing handouts ofoverhead materials.It was at an understandable level without being too technical for a layman.Liked the basics.Level of information, not basic.Speakers did a good job keeping the information on a level to where we couldunderstand.Good coverage in short time of a complex—broad spectrum.Overview in Petroleum Geology.Preparation was very good.The content of the discussions; reduced complex information to understandablelevel.Slideswhich accompanied lecture.1st speaker—very good; 2nd speaker—good, content was not applicable to me.Slide presentations.A lot of new information on Reservoir Management.The pace of discussion, handouts, and content.

How can we make this course better suited to vour needs?●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

.Need more workshopsInclude a specific case set of maps-isopach, etc.Be more case specific and reduce complexity.Gear it more to specificaudience/pretty general information. I wouldve liked to hearmore discussion of group issues.Sometimesused saentific/geologic terminology-it might help to simplifysome ofyour terms.Retie some of the jargon.Advertising needs to target specificaudience. The conference brochure was much toovague,Films about the subjectmatter would help.I’llbe equipped to make evaluation after gaining perspective of entire program beingpresented.Don’t know.Address nonreservoir production, e.g., fractures.1st speaker—more examples; 2nd speaker—more practical examples.Shorten the presentation-brief and concise.More depth.Haven’t deaded yet.

111

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?● Yes (11)● Maybe, if the workshop was directed towards a specific audience.● No (2)● Only if it addresses specific needs, i.e., educators vs. land managers vs. tribal

leaders.

● Yes, entry lawyers/landmen● Speaker 1 was good. Content was good. Added emphasis could have been on

logging (simplified),testins etc. But basically was good.● Maybe (2)● Yes● Not at this time, but possibly in the future.

Other Comments:● Excellent presentation● Too complex and above understanding for a fundamental level seminar.● I am unsure at what level the material was directed for/diverse group of people.● Not a lot of time to discuss, and materkd not generating discussions.● Narrow your focus. Is the purpose of the conference to educate laymen, provide

discussion opportunities for details, or promote DOE/BDM programs? I am unsure.There are a lot of industry reps. here—why?

● Two days is an excellent length for these courses. 1/4-1/2 day for each subject.● Reservoir management has major company overtone~this Native American

audience would be more in to monitofig possibly.● Speaker 2 was a good speaker, but the content was not useful to us. Exmrqdesmay

havebeen mor-ehelpful. U did NOT keep my attention.

112

OIL AND GAS PRODUCTION

Comments

What did●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

9●

●

●

●

●

●

●

you like about this presentation?Entire session was very good.Scope of topicsHe was very knowledgeable.Knowledge of instructor.Visual presentation.Everything the film.Amount of overheads and slides used.Speaker did a good job in presenting material.Speaker well versed on his subjectmatter/overall presentation well paced andefficienttime frame.Personal stories of work experience.Slidesvery thorough.Best one-useful information.The whole presentation.Again, level was appropriate/a good beginning overview.The beginning to the end presentation of an oil well very informative and interesting.Herb’s deliverance style and overheads.It was easy to understand.The information was very understandable.Knowledge of presenter.

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?●

9

b

●

●

●

●

●

●

●

Provide better introduction and transition between speakers-prepare us for what’scoming.The material on offshore operations didn’t seem relevant to Tribal interests, I suggestthat you drop it.Follow along handouts.Have handouts to follow the lecture.A bigger and louder TV.Focus and direct the material towards a specific audience instead of broad base.Need more handouts on how production takes place.Overhead handouts for taking notes during presentation would help.It’s pretty good just as it is.More emphasis on onshore production and lesson offshore.

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?● Yes (13)● In a more directed, focused fashion.● Not at this time.

Other Commen&● Very good presentation/would likesome handouts in the future● Speaker needs to be aware of body position relative to overhead projection-most of

the time he was blocking the visuals/too much information for the given time/somewere very good, others were too busy and complicated for the timeaUm=VSpe~erwas too focused on overheads, didn’t entertain guests.

● This session explained all the thing and I “wondered about.

113

● May have too much detail regarding specific production and drilling operations, i.e.,pie charts for daily AFE [authorization for expenditure]. Also, for the group presenttoday+ffshore may have limited application.

● A ton of information that was run through quick/I am unsure at what level thesession was directed.

● This presentation “was on target.”● This presentation was very helpful in the field.● Video presentation was not loud enough.

114

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT

Comments

What did you like about this presentation?● Speaker knows his subject; had a balanced presentation● Speaker spoke very clear, and presented his material well.● Handouts and speaker. The written material and presenter’s knowledge and sense of

humor.● The whole presentation.● Very good, informative● The insight gained on issues solely concerning my work● Excellent communication skills.● Organized—● Presentation conducted at level where everyone can understand.● Material understandable and presented in a good manner.● Handout very good.● Good comprehensive review.● Material and information.● Good use of humor to enhance presentation/good handouts accompanying

overheads.● Very thorough and concise.

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?● No-● Maybe show a film for a change of pace.● Appropriate● Keep getting information for the present.● Keep it updated and present at every session.● Leave as is, maybe put it on the road.● More tailored towards specific case studies and individual components of E&P

waste/Environmental mana~ement rather than a look at regulations.● Possibly add one more day or bring to tribe when requested.● More case studies, documentation.● Take an operator step-by-step through the process of compliance in drilling and

producing a lease,● Touch on CFR on BLM F.O.G.M.A. Regulation pertaining to different tribes.

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?● Yes (13)● Possibly● Everyone● Yes, BIA-Osage field personnel● No (2)

Other Comments● Well Done!!● The continued impositionof increasingly stringent sometimes onerous regulations

upon the oil industry requires constant awareness. The speaker helped make thispoint abundantly clear.

● Didn’t hear enough-to filIup an evahation form.● All information is useful to the oil and gas company.● Best presentation on Environmental I’ve heard-Good Job!

115

●

●

●

●

Enjoyed presentation, would recommend to anyone associated with oil and gas.Breakdown of costs/operations components of Environmental Management—industry-wide or case by case.This is an area where my staff and I have very limited knowledge and need moretraining and also keep up to date on changes. Hope you can do presentations of thiskind in the Southwest. I would liketo suggest that your conferences should bescheduled in other months except October. This is the time of the year thatgovernment employees have no money for trainin~ travel, etc.Very good topic of discussion, and very good presentation.

116

DOING BUSINESS WITH THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

Comments

What did you like about this presentation?● All.● Presentation was very helpful.● Content w/papers and A/V aids.

How can we make this course better suited to your needs?● I don’t know at this time.● More handouts on the subjects.● Update and get ready to “take on the road.”

Do you have colleagues who would benefit from this workshop?● Yes (2)● No

117

Other Comments● Never know if you can increase understanding of government procurement.● Web sites.● Helpful to all business.● Very well presented.

NATIVE AMERICAN CONFERENCE ON PETROLEUM ENERGY

Overall Comments

How did you hear about this conference?● Rhonda Lindsey at the BIA Conference in Denver. (2)● Brochure received in the mail. (7)

What were your objectives in attending this workshop?● Looking for interfacing with Indian lands for providing environmental services in the

O and G industry.● To learn more about the basic petroleum geology and how oil is formed.● To learn about doing business w/DOE● Get information about oil and gas.● To see what would be useful in my job.● Learn more about the petroleum industry.● Doing businesswith government.● To learn guidelines and procedures for obtaining financial assistance and to meet

w/DOE BDM personnel.

Would you recommend this training to your colleagues?● Yes (7)● Yes, 1st day.● This program is very helpful

If we were to offer other topics or more advanced topics, what would interest you?● Other DOE programs.c Gas well operation, pumpina and field operations, safety● Oil and gas field production● Negotiations, field trip● more-

118

Other Comments:● Very well presented—we will be interested in having you come to our reservation—

when it “goes on the road.”● I think the overall workshop was very helpful for anyone that is in the oil and gas

field.

C13 !3/67531/metadc696763/... · DOE/PC/91 008-0291 (OSTI ID: 6048) C13 itfl!3!? NATIVE AMERICAN...

Documents

Transcript of C13 !3/67531/metadc696763/... · DOE/PC/91 008-0291 (OSTI ID: 6048) C13 itfl!3!? NATIVE AMERICAN...