Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our...

54
Business Incubation Case Study

Transcript of Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our...

Page 1: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation Case Study

Page 2: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Preview

1. Intro to Business Incubation A. General

B. Northwest Regional Planning Commission

2. Virtual Incubation

3. Physical Business Incubation

4. Building Your Own Incubator

Page 3: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation: Introduction

Page 4: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Definition

Business Incubation is…

the process of accelerating the growth and success of start-up and early stage companies through an array of business support resources and services that could include:

- Physical space

- Capital

- Coaching

- Common services &

- Networking connections.

Page 5: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal.

STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business Recruitment STRATEGY 3 Downtown Redevelopment STRATEGY 4 Business Incubation

Another Tool in the Toolbox…

Page 6: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Why Businesses Fail

1. Lack of Know-How

- Little understanding of business fundamentals

- Little prior business experience

- Poor preparation, initiation and planning

2. Lack of Capital

- Many start up with too little capital

Page 7: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

About 48% of businesses are still alive by Year 5.

(52% are DEAD!)

In an incubation environment the 5-year

survival rate is 87%

Incubation significantly boosts new business survival rates.

Incubation effect

87% survival rate for

incubated companies

Survival Rates Improve

Page 8: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Average 2.5 years company starts

to take off

3-6 years company graduates

from incubator 7-10 years

things get exciting

YEARS

It’s a long term strategy

Company enters Incubator

Page 9: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

FAIL FAIL

Moderate

Struggle

Success

Home Run

Struggle

Moderate

Success

Moderate

75+ emp.

50 - 75 emp.

10 - 50 emp.

< 10 emp.

Success Varies

Page 10: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Results to date 40 Companies 373 jobs $53 Million in Annual Sales $16.8 Million Annual Payroll $42.2 Million Private Investment

Company Age Emp.

A 4 years 47

B 5 years 34

C 5 years 18

D 5 years 17

E 7 years 14

But It Really Works!

Page 11: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 12: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

20,000 sf Incubator 2 tenants

12,000 sf Incubator 3 tenants

Incubator graduates

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

20,000 sf & 12,000 sf

Grantsburg, WI

Pop. 1,200

Page 13: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Siren Enterprise Center 16,000 sf

Siren, WI

Pop. 806

Page 14: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Spooner Enterprise Center

(four facilities) 60,000 sf

Spooner, WI

Pop. 677

Page 15: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

“Virtual” Business Incubation

(Start here)

Page 16: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Too many vacancies downtown! Business Plan Contest

Round 1 – 1 page describing idea Round 2 – Business Plan Round 3 – Presentation / Q&A Prizes

$10,000 start-up capital $2,000 sign & awning grant Website Newspaper & Radio advertising Chamber membership Coaching / mentoring (SBDC & SWIF)

Partners

Page 17: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Building Renovation

Page 18: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Elena’s Bakery “The Sweet Spot”

Page 19: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy
Page 20: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

https://youtu.be/k9RX5WAxtbA

Stamp-N-Storage

Business Plan Contest

Prizes

$5,000 working capital Coaching / mentoring

Page 21: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Physical Business Incubation

Page 22: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Goals

1. Populate industrial park

2. Diversify local economy

3. Spark entrepreneurial activity

4. Build tax base

5. Additional customers for power utility

6. Create jobs

Page 23: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Location

Industrial Park

Page 24: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Building Layout

80’ wide bays Bathrooms 2 Docks 2 Docks roughed in 3 drive-in doors Utilities separately metered

Page 25: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Manufacturing

Must “Export”

Physical growth required

Admission Criteria

Page 26: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Company Requirements

Coach / mentor (SBDC and / or Initiative Foundation)

Monthly check in w/ Incubator Staff

“Drop money to bottom line”

If successful – establishing their own facility.

Page 27: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Won’t compete with private leasing.

We’re not “renting space” – we’re incubating companies.

No “lifestyle” businesses

No service businesses

Selective admission criteria

Dealing with Private Sector

Page 28: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Features

Low rents ($3.84 psf)

Education

Resources

Page 29: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 30: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 31: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Interior

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Page 32: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Grantsburg Enterprise Center

Interior

Page 33: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

20,000 sf 5 bays (each 4,000 sf) 2,000 sf offices Conference Room Work Room Break Room Guest Offices (2)

Key card entry system

SB2030 energy standard

Page 34: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 35: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 36: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 37: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 38: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 39: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 40: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 41: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Laser marking, laser etching and laser engraving Many of the products are class III implantable

devices. Obtaining ISO 9001 Certification 8,000 sf Current employment 3 Ft / 2 PT 2-Year projection 10 FT 3-year projection 15 FT

Page 42: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 43: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Manufacturer of precision cut foam, polystyrene and Styrofoam.

“If you can dream it, we can built it with foam!”

5,000 sf 3 FT employees

Page 44: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 45: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 46: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Hutchinson Enterprise Center

Page 47: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Construction Budget

Line Item Cost

Architectural & Engineering $55,000

Construction Monitoring $38,030

Site work / Parking lots / Footings & Foundations $705,140

Building / Interior SOG / etc. $1,332,860

Alternates $182,200

Miscellaneous (Key Card Entry / I-T items) $17,752

Contingency $128,681

TOTAL $2,459,663

Base bid was $2,038,000

Page 48: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Alternates Included

Alternate Cost

Offices $138,800

Concrete truck lot $11,300

Windows / Drywall $25,000

8’ Metal Liner $7,100

TOTAL $182,200

Page 49: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Funding Your Incubator

Page 50: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Funding Your Incubator

I. Tax Increment Financing A. Existing Tax Increment

B. Economic Development TIF District

II. MIF Dollars A. De-federalized

B. Federalized

III. City A. Excess Bond Fund

B. General Fund Balance

IV. Federal EDA

Page 51: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Action Steps

Join InBIA.

Attend InBIA Annual Conference.

Visit Hutchinson.

Do a “virtual” incubation project.

Page 52: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Review

1. Intro to Business Incubation A. General

B. Northwest Regional Planning Commission

2. Virtual Incubation

3. Physical Business Incubation

4. Building Your Own Incubator

Page 53: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Questions?

Page 54: Business Incubation Case StudyBusiness Incubation …one more economic development strategy at our disposal. STRATEGY 1 Business Retention & Expansion STRATEGY 2 Business RecruitmentWhy

Business Incubation Case Study