REAL ESTATE · Real Estate Career Night Real Estate Sales Review CompuCram ...
BUSI 330: Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal Session 3 · Real Estate Division UBC Sauder School...
Transcript of BUSI 330: Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal Session 3 · Real Estate Division UBC Sauder School...
Real Estate Division
BUSI 330: Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal
Session 3
Presented by Chuck Dunn
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 3
Introduction
Welcome to the webinars for the Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal
• Session 1 Introduction. Lesson 1, 2 – August 22, 2019 Archived
• Session 2 Lesson 3, 4, 5 and 6. Discuss Project 1 – September 12, 2019 Archived
• Session 3 Lesson 7, 8 and 9 – October 10, 2019
• Session 4 Lesson 10 and11. Discuss Project 2 October 31, 2019
• Session 5 Preparation for the Final Exam November 14, 2019
NOTE: Project 1 is due October 9, 2019
Project 2 is due November 13, 2019
Exam is written December 5, 2019
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 4
Real Estate NewsNational Post September 12, 2019
• Those living alone account for 28.2% of all households, and out numbered couples with children.
• Also condominium sizes are shrinking. New strata/condominium apartments are 35% smaller than those built in the 1980’s. As household sizes become smaller so do condominiums.
• However, single house sizes are increasing, especially in the suburban areas where land is cheaper.
• Lifestyles are changing to more home based activities-staycations, BBQ, computer games, video streaming services, and home theatres.
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 5
Real Estate NewsNational Post October 3, 2019
• Headline
• “Rising construction costs affect housing affordability”
• Prices of newly built units is also sensitive to construction costs. Cost increases are not uniform across the country.
• Ottawa increase was 5.2%, Vancouver 4.8%.
• Hudson Bay Company shareholder urges appraisal of it’s “incredibly valuable” real estate and any upside potential.
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 6
Real Estate NewsNational Post October 4, 2019
• Toronto Housing Market….In September prices rose the most over the last 21
months. The benchmark price for all types of homes rose 5.2% to $805,500.
Sales jumped 22% to 7,825 units.All sectors saw double digit gains led by a 29% jump for
detached homes.
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 7
About Your Course Tutor
• Chuck Dunn is one of the four BUSI 330 tutors
• Graduated from the Faculty of Commerce, UBC
• Worked as a fee appraiser
• Taught real estate appraisal courses at Langara College.
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 8
The Three Approaches
Final Estimated
Value
Direct Comparison
Approach
Cost Approach
Income Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 9
Lesson 7
Chapter 16: Land Valuation
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 10
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7
Land Valuation
• Each parcel of land is unique, even if side by side
• Land can also be water, by way of a lease or
• Air Parcels located above other free hold sites
• Identify site by - address, legal description, survey maps
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 11
Chapter 17 - Lesson 7
• Analyze - consider size, shape, location, depth, irregular shape, corner. Any affect on the value?
• Make sure comparables have similar attributes as subject, otherwise adjustments will be required
• Read and understand any documentation regarding water leases or air parcels
• Consult other professionals if necessary
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 12
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7City GIS
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 13
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7Land Valuation – continued Value by:1. Comparison – direct comparison, bulk basis
If similar sized lots are selling for $100,000, then the subject is worth this amount
2. Allocation – land ratio to overall valueFrom previous market analysis we know that land is worth about 40% of the sale price. So a property sold for $250,000 the land portion is about 40% x $250,000=$100,000 is the estimated land value
3. Extraction – deduct improvement value from total valueCalculate the depreciated value of the house and other improvements and then deduct the total from the selling price to arrive at an estimated land value. Sale price is $250,000 less depreciated value of improvements of $145,000 indicates an estimated land value of $105,000
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 14
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7Development – estimate value of development and deduct cost of labour, capital and management• This method involves estimating the final total value of the completed
development. Next the developer will estimate all the cost necessary to complete the development-hard and soft costs. Hard costs -the actual construction costs and the soft costs -financing, permits, lawyers fees, management overhead marketing fees and contingency allowances
• After deducting all these costs from the estimated sales proceeds the remaining figure indicates what the developer should pay for the raw land
• This approach can be used for developing raw land or residential/commercial developments
• Raw land - Developing residential/commercial building sites
• Developments - Strata Titles units, retail malls, office buildings, commercial developments
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 15
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7
Land Valuation – continued Compare on the following basis:1. Dollar per front foot/metre
divide the selling price by the frontage-width. $100,000/50feet = $2,000 /front foot
2. Price per acre/hectare similar to above but use the total acreage size. $1,000,000/10acres = $100,000/acre
3. Bulk basis sale of lots that are the same dimensions, 50’ x 120’
4. Price per Apartment/Condo Unit see next slide
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 16
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7Rezoning Application
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 17
Chapter 16 - Lesson 7
Data Analysis
• The previous slide showed rezoning for 3 properties
• A search of the property records shows they were purchased for a total price of $2,298,000
• Assuming the 14 units are approved, the cost of the land per unit is $164,142
• Based on this information we know that raw land value for townhomes is around $165,000+/- at the time of the sale
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 18
Rezoning - Lesson 7
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 19
Rezoning - Lesson 7
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 20
Rezoning - Lesson 7
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 21
Rezoning - Lesson 7
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 22
Lesson 8
• Chapter 17: Cost Approach
• Chapter 18: Building Cost Estimates
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 23
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
The Cost Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 24
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
The Cost Approach
The cost approach is summarized as follows:
1. Estimate the land/site value2. Estimate the current cost of all the attached
improvements3. Estimate depreciation for all attached improvements4. Deduct 3 from 2 to arrive at the depreciated value5. Calculate the depreciated value of site improvements6. Add 1, 4 and 5 together to arrive at the final value
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 25
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
Depreciation to Date
Depreciated Value of House
Depreciated Value of Site
ImprovementsFinal Estimated
Value by the Cost Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 26
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
$350,000
Depreciation to Date
Depreciated Value of House
Depreciated Value of Site
ImprovementsFinal Estimated
Value by the Cost Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 27
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
$350,000
Depreciation to Date
- $25,000
Depreciated Value of House
Depreciated Value of Site
ImprovementsFinal Estimated
Value by the Cost Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 28
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
$350,000
Depreciation to Date
- $25,000
Depreciated Value of House
+$325,000
Depreciated Value of Site
ImprovementsFinal Estimated
Value by the Cost Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 29
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
$350,000
Depreciation to Date
- $25,000
Depreciated Value of House
+$325,000
Depreciated Value of Site
Improvements
+$ 10,000
Final Estimated Value by the Cost
Approach
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 30
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Value of Siteas if Vacant
$100,000
Cost New of House
$350,000
Depreciation to Date
- $25,000
Depreciated Value of House
+$325,000
Depreciated Value of Site
Improvements
+$ 10,000
Final Estimated Value by the Cost
Approach
$435,000(round final figure)
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 31
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
The Cost Approach
Know the Limitations of this approach and when it can be used
1. Remember cost does not equal value, it can be less or more
2. Cost is best for new or newer construction as costs are current and there is no/little depreciation
3. Depreciation calculation is very subjective4. Useful when market data is scarce or special use
buildings
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 32
Chapter 17 - Lesson 8
Reproduction and Replacement Costs
Know the difference between the two terms and when to use them
1. Reproduction is the construction of an exact duplicate
2. Replacement is the construction of one with the same utility
3. Replacement is the most commonly used method
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 33
Reproduction CostRichmond Speed Skating Oval for 2010 Olympics
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 34
Reproduction Cost
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 35
Chapter 18 - Lesson 8
Cost Estimates
1. In Canada all costs include the GST and/or the HST
2. Costs include a contractor’s and an entrepreneurial profit
3. Costs are categorized as “hard” or “soft” costs“Hard” being the direct costs - materials and labour“Soft” being permits, financing, legal, marketing costs
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 36
Chapter 18 - Lesson 8
Building Cost Estimates
Cost estimates are found by 4 methods with the Cost Estimating Services and the Comparative methods being the most common• Make sure you understand what is included/excluded in
these cost estimates• Cost Estimating Services are companies who specialize
in researching costs to construct buildings • Comparative Methods are based on actual construction
costs and are quoted on a price per square foot or square metre
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 37
Lesson 9Chapter 19: Depreciation Estimates
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 38
Chapter 19 - Lesson 9
Depreciation
• Know and understand the definitions of physical life, economic life, remaining economic life and the effective age (WB 9.5)
• Effective age is very subjective and is based on the general condition, upgrading of the property, and the appraisers experience/knowledge
• The two (2) Age-Life methods are the most commonly used methods (WB 9.7-9.8)
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 39
Chapter 19 - Lesson 9
Breakdown Method of Depreciation
This method is to help you understand how differentbuilding materials depreciate at different rates. (WB 9.9)
Physical Deterioration
1. Deferred maintenance are items that need immediate repair
2. Short Lived Items are those items that will not last as long as the structure itself, i.e. furnace, hot water tank, floor coverings, painting, roof, exterior finish
3. Long Lived is usually the structure itself, i.e., 50-70 year life span
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 40
Chapter 19 - Lesson 9Functional Obsolescence
This represents a loss of utility where an item does not perform its proper function according to today’s standards
• It can be classified as curable, meaning it pays to correct it
OR• It can be classified as incurable, where the cost to
cure is greater than the increased utility. It does not pay to correct it
In both cases this loss of utility must be accounted for when calculating the depreciation of an improvement
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 41
Chapter 19 - Lesson 9
External Obsolescence
• This form of obsolescence is external to the property and affects both the building value and the site value
• When the external obsolescence has been estimated then apply a certain percentage to the land value and the remainder as depreciation to the improvements
• Percentage is based on the land to building ratio
• Can affect value positively or negatively
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 42
Chapter 19 - Lesson 9
• External Obsolescence
• Owners have little control over this type
• Examples are an airport runway, incompatible use of adjacent property, extra busy road, i.e., all night grocery store or gas station, major highway or rapid transit system
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 43
Introduction
Welcome to the webinars for the Foundations of Real Estate Appraisal
• Session 1 Introduction. Lesson 1, 2 – August 22, 2019 Archived
• Session 2 Lesson 3, 4, 5 and 6. Discuss Project 1 – September 12, 2019 Archived
• Session 3 Lesson 7, 8 and 9 – October 10, 2019
• Session 4 Lesson 10 and11. Discuss Project 2 October 31, 2019
• Session 5 Preparation for the Final Exam November 14, 2019
NOTE: Project 1 is due October 9, 2019
Project 2 is due November 13, 2019
Exam is written December 5, 2019
UBC Sauder School of BusinessReal Estate Division 44
Question Time
Questions
Real Estate Division UBC Sauder School of Business 4545
Feedback and Questions
For further questions related to the course content presented in this session, contact your tutor (please include the course number in the subject line):
For all other feedback about the webinar please contact the Real Estate Division (please include the course number in the subject line):