Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler,...

38
Optics considerations for ERL test facilities Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, H. Owen, B. Shepherd, S. Smith, N. Thompson, E. Wooldridge, N. Wyles)

Transcript of Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler,...

Page 1: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Optics considerations for ERL test facilities Bruno Muratori

ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory

(M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, H. Owen, B. Shepherd, S. Smith, N. Thompson, E. Wooldridge, N. Wyles)

Page 2: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Overview

Optics Layout strategy for ERLP MAD8

Space Charge for the ERLP Analytical ASTRA GPT

Start to End (S2E) models for the ERLP MAD8 ELEGANT GENESIS

Beam Breakup for the ERLP BI

Page 3: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

ERLP Building Layout

Page 4: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Energy Recovery Linac Prototype

Page 5: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Parameters for ERLP

4 ps long bunches, 80 pC

8.35 MeV Injection line (TL2) between 10 m and 15 m

35 MeV Beam Transfer System (BTS)

Initial emittance (norm) between 1 mm mrad and 2 mm mrad

Transverse beam size ~ 1-16 mm

Page 6: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Beta Functions for ERLP

Page 7: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Dispersion for the ERLP

Page 8: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Injection & Extraction Chicanes (from JLab with thanks)

Page 9: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Alignment: Arc Dipole Magnet with Chamber

EBPMs

Survey Target Holders

30 deg. extraction port

Arc Dipole Magnet

0 deg. extraction port

Page 10: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Compression Chicane (from JLab with thanks)

Page 11: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

JLab Wiggler

Page 12: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

JLab Wiggler – Testing

Page 13: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

JLab Wiggler Model – Beta Functions

Page 14: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

ASTRA & Drifts - Analytical Approach

Horizontal focusing given by (equivalent for vertical)

Sigma matrix transformation

New emittance

Gaussian bunch (in s)

Page 15: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Results & Comparisons for ASTRA & Drifts – 1 mm mrad

Page 16: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

ASTRA & Quadrupoles for TL2 – Long model

Page 17: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

ASTRA & Quadrupoles for TL2 – Short model

Page 18: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

GPT & Quadrupoles for TL2 – Short model

Page 19: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

ASTRA & Quadrupoles for TL2 – Short model

ASTRA distribution from gun and booster (CG & FH)

Emittance outside transverse plane

Gaussian good approximation for emittance growth estimate

Page 20: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

GPT

All results so far in good agreement

Different algorithms also agree

Emittance increase appears to be comparable to the analytical estimate in all cases considered

Dispersion may be left out for a rough estimate

Next: Include bends …

Page 21: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

GPT & TL2 with dipoles (short model) – first results

Page 22: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

GPT & Quadrupoles for TL2 – Short model

Page 23: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Problem: Fringe Fields, Solution: Enge Function

Page 24: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Transfer Line 2 / Linac

Lattice matching with MAD8- keep Twiss parameters at reasonable values (e.g. β < 50m)- Dispersion free after injection/extraction bends and arcs- 1st arc: isochronous- 2nd arc: R56 = -R56 bunch compressor- Only exact matching point in transverse and longitudinal phase space is at the entrance of the FEL

Tracking with elegant (TL2: E = 8.35MeV, l = 15m, 4 dipoles, 12 quads)Space charge effects ignored

Page 25: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Start to End Model

Booster to FEL8.35/35MeV

Elegant

FEL to Dump8.35/35MeV

Elegant

FEL Interaction

GENESIS250k particles

Gun to Booster0 to 8.35MeV

ASTRA250k particles 250k particles106 particles

Lattice MatchingMAD8

Lattice MatchingMAD8

Page 26: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

1

23

4

S2E Simulation

Page 27: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Sextupole Linearisation

• Sextupoles in the outward arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

• Can actually make bunch length too short for lasing! (in theory)

• Adjustable in real machine to optimise lasing properties

• In practice we are likely to see disruptive effects not apparent in the model

Page 28: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Beam Breakup and the ERLP

Initial calculations & running the code BI (E. Wooldridge)

Assume TESLA HOM’s

Threshold current 5.12 mA

Beam Breakup not a problem for ERLP at this low current

Page 29: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Conclusions

Optics with no real problems so far Good agreement between ASTRA and GPT and analytical

result for drifts (provided flow is laminar) All to be redone with dipoles correctly modelled Can analytical estimate be used as an upper bound in all

cases ? or at least a reasonable 'rough guess' ? Try to take into account space charge by rematching at

several stages in injector line. However, this cannot take into account transverse & longitudinal coupling

BBU not a problem Start to end simulations only real answer to see if bunch is

acceptable for lasing at FEL (to be redone with dipoles)

Page 30: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Daresbury Laboratory - Tower Building

Page 31: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Internal shielding complete

Page 32: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

External shielding in construction

Page 33: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Inside Control Room

Page 34: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Assembly Building

Page 35: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Class 100 (ISO 5) Clean Room

Page 36: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Magnet Test Room

Page 37: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

Control Room

Page 38: Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory · Bruno Muratori ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory (M. Bowler, C. Gerth, F. Hannon, ... arc help to achieve the shortest possible bunch length

TRACE-3D

Include z component for E field Update continuously (no

averaging) Would be nice to take into

account longitudinal dispersion 1) Match transfer matrix cpt.

R16 (dispersion) to zero 2) Match R26 (angular

dispersion) to zero 3) Match R15 (bunch spatial

width) to zero 4) Match R25 (bunch angular spread) to zero Usually only first two done (e.g. in MAD8)