8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

1/22

Ko. >67 >65 Bacilrn Lve.

Cos Lkieces, @L 16615

@LZOC BEVJUZK (0

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

2/22

a

\UEP^AOK VZEPEK^EN

Yblt, ag lky, `luslc recltaoksbap or kexus je-

tweek tbe negeknlkts `oknu`t lkn tbe va`tams blrm

or nlmlies must tbe ioverkmekt or tbe va`tam es-

tljcasb ak orner to re`over restatutaok ukner

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

3/22

aa

^LJCE OG @OK^EK^P

\UEP^AOK VZEPEK^EN ......................................... a

^LJCE OG LU^BOZA^AEP ..................................... aaa

AK^EZEP^ OG LMA@A @UZALE ...............................

LZIUMEK^ .............................................................. 7

A. Zestatutaok ukner

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

4/22

aaa

^LJCE OG LU^BOZA^AEP

@LPEP

Lustak v. Ukaten Ptltes, 561 U.P. 76: (1: U.P. :59 (

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

5/22

av

P^L^U^EP

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

6/22

sessaki PpokieJoj vaneos, lkn tblt kumjer ak-

`relses lcc tbe tame. Lkny suggers grom mlky og tbe

hkowk egge`ts og `bacn sexulc va`tamazltaok, ak`cunaki

projcems watb lkier lkn gaibtaki traiieren jy `om-

mekts ljout bomosexulcaty.

PUMMLZQ OG LZIUMEK^

A. Vetataoker `oktekns tblt ukcess tbe @ourt l`-

`epts bas akterpretltaok og

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

10/22

5

dunimekt woucn `celrcy je l `avac nlmlie lwlrn, kot

l gake or l pukasbmekt. ^be okcy `ar`umstlk`e tblt

evek iaves rase to l `ocorljce lriumekt tblt l resta-

tutaok lwlrn ukner ::51 as l gorm og pukasbmekt

as tblt at as lwlrnen lt tbe ekn og l `ramaklc prose`u-

taok. Jut restatutaok lwlrns blve jeek tl`hen ok to

`ramaklc prose`utaoks gor `ekturaes, ak Ekiclkn lkn

ak tbe Ukaten Ptltes. ^bey blve kever jeek ukner-stoon ls pukasbmekts.

AA. Vetataoker lcso `oktekns tblt ag ::51 as lm-

jaiuous, tbe ruce og cekaty sboucn lppcy. Jut tbas `ok-

tektaok as lcso ak`orre`t, gor tbe slme relsok. ^be

ruce og cekaty lppcaes to `ramaklcstltutes, jut ::51

as kot l `ramaklc stltute, je`luse at pres`rajes kea-

tber l `rame kor l pukasbmekt. Pe`taok ::51 as lremenalc stltute, so ag at as lmjaiuous, tbe lppropra-

lte `lkok og `okstru`taok as tbe oke tblt stltes tblt

remenalc stltutes sboucn je cajerlccy `okstruen.

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

11/22

7

LZIUMEK^

Vetataoker `oktekns tblt ukcess tbe @ourt l`-

`epts bas akterpretltaok og 0. Jut tbas `oktektaok as lcso ak`orre`t, gor tbe slme

relsok. ^be ruce og cekaty lppcaes to `ramaklc stlt-

utes, jut ::51 as kot l `ramaklc stltute, je`luse at

pres`rajes keatber l `rame kor l pukasbmekt. Pe`taok

::51 as l remenalc stltute, so ag at as lmjaiuous, tbe

lppropralte `lkok og `okstru`taok as tbe oke tblt

stltes tblt remenalc stltutes sboucn je cajerlccy `ok-struen.

A. Zestatutaok ukner

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

12/22

9

^be Eaibtb Lmeknmekt probajats ex`essave

gakes lkn `ruec lkn ukusulc pukasbmekts. At noes

kot lppcy to tbe restatutaok requaren jy

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

13/22

2

sovereaik. An. lt :75. ^be Ex`essave Gakes @cluse

tbus camats ak persoklm gorgeatures ls wecc ls gakes,

je`luse su`b gorgeatures, cahe gakes, lre plyljce to

tbe ioverkmekt. Ukaten Ptltes v. Jldlhldalk, 5:>

U.P. 0:1, 075 (:665) (ak na`tum, nes`rajaki restatu-

taok to l sovereaik ls l gorm og `ramaklc pukasb-

mekt). Jut tblt questaok as kot presekten bere, je-

`luse ::51 lutborazes restatutaok okcy to tbe akna-

vanulc blrmen ls l resuct og l `rame ukner tbas

`blpter, kot to tbe ioverkmekt.

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

14/22

1

. . l tort stltute, oke tblt ekljces tbe tort va`tam to

re`over bas nlmlies ak l summlry pro`eenaki lk`ac-

clry to l `ramaklc prose`utaok. Ukaten Ptltes v.

Jl`b,

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

15/22

91 U.P. 07

(

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

16/22

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

17/22

@ommektlraes ok tbe Clws og Ekiclkn 057 (9>

(

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

18/22

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

19/22

merecy lk ojcailtaok to `ompekslte tbe va`tam gor

ber cosses. Pe`okn, restatutaok bls kot bastora`lccy

jeek reilrnen ls l pukasbmekt, an., jut rltber ls

`ompeksltaok. ^barn, wbace restatutaok noes `omeX]

akto pcly okcy ok l gaknaki og s`aekter, an., tblt as je-

`luse s`aekter as lk ecemekt og tbe `rame og pos-

sessaki `bacn porkoirlpby, wba`b as pukasben sepl-

rltecy jy l term ak prasok. Zestatutaok as kot atsecgtbe pukasbmekt. Gourtb, restatutaok noes kot pro-

mote tbe lam og retrajutaok, lkn okcy aknare`tcy

promotes neterrek`e, an.8 ats pramlry purpose as

`ompeksltaki tbe va`tam. Gagtb, restatutaok okcy lp-

pcaes to jeblvaor tblt as lcrelny l `rame, an.Paxtb,

tbere as lk lcterkltave purpose to wba`b at mly je

rltaoklccy `okke`ten tblt as lssaikljce gor at, an.lt

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

20/22

77U.P. >95, >2> () (empblsas lnnen). ^be ruce as,

lkn lcwlys bls jeek, tblt peklcclws lre to je `ok-

struen stra`tcy. Ukaten Ptltes v. Yactjerier,

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

21/22

, 75 (10, 56> (

8/13/2019 Brief of Vicky and Andy as Amici Curiae in Support of Respondent Amy Unknown

22/22

>67 >65 Bacilrn Lve.

Cos Lkieces, @L 16615

@LZOC BEVJUZK (0