Brand Analysis: McDonald s - WordPress.com · food category McDonald’s is still considered the...
Transcript of Brand Analysis: McDonald s - WordPress.com · food category McDonald’s is still considered the...
1 | P a g e
Brand Analysis: McDonald’s
Gina Giaquinto
June 5, 2016
Comstrat 564
2 | P a g e
Table of Contents
Introduction Page 3
Company Story Page 3
Customer Story Page 6
Brand Inventory Page 7
Brand Promise Page 7
Brand Personality Page 7
Brand Elements Page 9
Brand Portfolio Page 9
Current Brand Strategies Page 10
Competitor Analysis Page 11
Burger King Page 11
Wendy’s Page 12
Insights and Recommendations Page 14
Specific Insights and Recommendations Page 14
Appendix A Page 17
References Page 18
3 | P a g e
Introduction
Company Story
McDonald’s is a fast food restaurant chain which has evolved into a major corporation known
for selling cheap food in a fast-paced environment. McDonald’s began as McDonald’s Bar-B-Q in
San Bernardino, California in 1940. It was first run by the two McDonald’s brothers, Dick and
Maurice (Mac). In 1948, they shut down the Bar-B-Q in an effort to revamp the building into a self-
service drive-in restaurant. The menu started with a total of nine items including: hamburgers,
cheeseburgers, soft drinks, milk, coffees, potato chips and a slice of pie. Before the golden arches
became arguably one of the most recognizable logos in the world, Speedee, a miniature animated
chef, became the company symbol in December 1948.
1948 1949 1955
A major milestone in the McDonald’s history was the addition of French Fries on the menu to replace
potato chips in 1949. This choice would become one of the most valuable menu items for
McDonald’s and their brand to date (McDonald’s History n.d.).
Ray Kroc was a multimixer salesman who traveled to the San Bernardino McDonald’s in
1954. What began as a business trip to sell the McDonald’s brothers multimixers became a life-
changing journey. Kroc realized that his future was in hamburgers and became a nationwide
franchising agent for the brothers. On April 5, 1955, he opens the first McDonald’s in Des Plaines,
Illinois. The building is designed by architect Stanley Meston who utilized red and white colors and
golden arches to draw attention. In 1961, Kroc bought out the McDonald’s brother’s shares and
4 | P a g e
continued expanding the McDonald’s brand and franchise. The restaurant was so well received that
by 1965 there are over 700 McDonald’s restaurants across the United States (McDonald’s History
n.d.).
By 1958, McDonald’s has sold its 100 millionth hamburger and continues to expand their
customer base opening more and more restaurants across the country. McDonald’s has been in
existence for over 60 years with thousands of stores worldwide spanning 119 countries. Through the
60s and 70s they create menu items that would become icons of their brand.
To add to their menu item selections they introduce the Big Mac burger in 1968. This burger
becomes one of the staple items only recognizable to this major chain. That same year they continue
to refine their brand by replacing the red and white tile buildings with masard roof buildings. The
very next year they update their logo to place more emphasis on the golden arches.
They continue to expand their menu choices by creating the breakfast sandwich and later
developing the kid-friendly ‘happy meal’, complete with toy in the box for family friendly branding.
Continuing their quest to provide quality food at a low cost to the customer, McDonald’s launches the
Dollar Menu in 2002 which lists several regular menu items for only one dollar. These promotional
deals become another staple in the franchises’ arsenal (McDonald’s History n.d.).
1968 1975 1979 2002
Big Mac Breakfast Happy Meal Dollar Menu
added to Menu at McDonald’s Introduced Launches
Not only does the company provide food for its customers, McDonald’s has committed to
giving back to the community through building relationships with families. In 1974, the first Ronald
McDonald Charity house is built in Philadelphia, PA, when McDonald’s partnered with Philadelphia
5 | P a g e
Eagles football player, Fred Hill. Hill’s child was battling leukemia at the time. The Ronald
McDonald house helps provide support via emotional and financial help to families impacted by child
illnesses. Today there are 356 Ronald McDonald Houses around the country which provide grants
with the focus on the needs of children and provides scholarships to students across the United States
(McDonald’s History n.d.).
Today, according to QSR Magazine, McDonald’s is the number one burger brand with 2014
U.S. system wide sales of over $35 billion. These sales totals are four times greater than the next
biggest competitors, Burger King (roughly $8.6 billion) and Wendy’s (roughly $8.5). From a fast
food category McDonald’s is still considered the number one brand by their staggering U.S. system
wide sales numbers. The next closest competitor is Starbucks at $12.6 billion and Subway at $11.9
billion (Quality System Registrars 2015).
Top 50 burger brands
Top 50 brands in quick services and fast casual
6 | P a g e
(Quality System Registrars 2015).
Customer Story
McDonald’s does not have a specific customer group. They cater to any and every one ages 5-
100+ (if you can eat solid foods you can eat McDonald’s). The idea behind the brand is that it offers
cheap food quickly and therefore, if you have 99 cents you can afford to buy something on the
McDonald’s’ menu. McDonald’s doesn’t discriminate between targeting men, women, and children
or based on your level of wealth. However, McDonald’s has a reputation for being cheap, unhealthy
food which tends to turn off wealthier or health food conscious clientele.
Customers tend to be loyal to McDonald’s because it has upheld its promise of fast, cheap,
food. While it may not always be healthy, in a pinch, it’s an option for a quick meal on the go. With
the expansion to breakfast foods McDonald’s has also grown its brand and customer base. “Among
adults over the age of 18 who eat breakfast at a restaurant at least once a month, some 46 percent of
them say they might eat at McD's for their next meal. That's up from 39 percent in July” (Little &
Whitten, 2015). This change has certainly impacted sales, “Within McDonald's own lineup, breakfast
accounts for roughly 25 percent of sales and 40 percent of profit in the United States alone” (Little &
Whitten, 2015).
Where the customer base has a distinct separation is in regards to quality. McDonald’s doesn’t
over extend its brand or make claims that it offers overly healthy products. While it has tried to
incorporate healthier menu items (apple slices, salads, yogurt parfaits), a majority of the food options
are burger-related. Being number one in the fast food industry comes with many down falls, “Not
only has it been at the center of high-profile lawsuits, but as the preeminent leader in the fast food
industry, it's come to represent what some people consider dangerous about big corporations, fatty
foods and the spread of American culture” (McGrath, 2008).
7 | P a g e
Brand Inventory
Brand Promise
The McDonald’s brand promise revolves around quality service, cleanliness and value:
“putting people, processes and practices into place to make better food, more sustainable sourcing,
happier people, a stronger community and a healthier planet” (News n.d). The statement, found on the
McDonald’s website, encompasses four different values that McDonald’s wants to promote through
their restaurants worldwide. Their promise is to offer more balanced meal choices that are great-
tasting, high-quality, safe, affordable and more sustainable. “Since its humble beginnings, it has
succeeded due to its dedication to streamlined service, but it was an ambitious visionary who took the
idea of fast food and ran with it” (McGrath, 2008).
The biggest promise that is easily identifiable with the brand is the affordable food choices,
“Capitalizing on brand recognition, McDonald's is known for selling consistent, simple, low-priced
American food. As a result, it has become the world's largest restaurant chain (McGrath, 2008).
McDonald’s also promises to make the environment a better place by being environmental stewards
and taking responsibility to use recycled goods to extend the life of this planet. They also value their
employees, franchisees, suppliers and customers and look to find opportunities to grow and develop
these relationships. McDonald’s is more than just a fast food franchise, they are promoters of lasting
relationships that make a difference for everyone.
Brand Personality
A brand personality is made up of five main dimensions: excitement, sincerity, ruggedness,
competence and sophistication. The McDonald’s brand personality can be described using the terms
below:
8 | P a g e
Excitement: affordable, promotion/sales offerings, quality product. McDonald’s generates
excitement through the use of the multifaceted promotional deals each year.
Sincerity: Transparency in ingredients (100% real beef burgers no fillers, preservatives or additives),
strives to make a difference in communities (Ronald McDonald charity house), dedication to youth
sports, charities and giving back. McDonald’s has been quite open about the ingredients they use and
their commitment to make the world a better place.
Ruggedness: Offering an array of nutritional menu options, bringing these values to 119 different
countries for over 60 years.
Competence: The fact that they have been in business for over 60 years, serving millions of
customers daily in 119 countries with over 36 thousands outlets worldwide proves their competence
and lasting ability. The brand has sustained for many years and continues to be a powerhouse in the
burger/fast food franchise category. As they have owned this market for quite some time they have
consistently demonstrated their competence in their business.
Sophistication: Consistency in their product has lead them to become the number one fast food
franchise and burger restaurant in the world. Their product line appears to be unmatched and more
innovative than their competitors (happy meal, breakfast items, Big Mac) as indicated by their sales
numbers.
McDonald’s has clearly distinguished itself far and above all other fast food and burger
restaurants. Their points of difference fall into the excitement dimension as they continually generate
excitement for the brand through promotions of their quality and affordable products. They also
differentiate in the competency and sophistication dimensions based on their standing amongst their
competitors. They have become a staple in the fast food breakfast market, their fries and signature
9 | P a g e
burgers (Big Mac) signify their dominance. McDonald’s is a powerhouse brand as demonstrated by
its staying power and ability to evolve over the last 60 years.
Brand Elements
Logos: Packaging: McDonald’s Restaurant:
McDonald’s Characters- Ronald McDonald (Clown), Hamburglar, Grimace)
The golden arches have become one of the most iconic logos. It can be found on all their
packaging which has been reinvented over the years to include pictures of the quality ingredients used
in their products. Although McDonald’s restaurants have undergone some renovation, many continue
to exist in the red and yellow coloring that has become synonymous with the brand. In the 60s and
70s McDonald’s created several characters who appeared in their advertising campaigns. Some of the
most recognizable today include Ronald McDonald himself the McDonald’s clown.
Brand Portfolio
Product Line:
• Fast Food
o Burgers
▪ Hamburger
▪ Cheeseburger
10 | P a g e
▪ Double Cheeseburger
▪ Big Mac
▪ Quarter Pounder with Cheese
o Chicken Sandwiches
▪ Artisan Grilled Chicken Sandwich
▪ Premium Buttermilk Crispy Chicken Deluxe
▪ McChicken
o Salads
▪ Bacon Ranch Salad
▪ Southwest Salad
o Snacks/Sides
▪ French Fries
▪ Apple slices
▪ Cuties
▪ Yoplait Go-GURT
▪ Fruit ‘N Yogurt Parfait
o Breakfast Foods
▪ Egg McMuffin
▪ Hash Brown
• Drinks
o Beverages
▪ Soft Drinks
▪ Water
▪ Chocolate Milk
▪ Milk Shakes
o McCafe Collection
▪ McCafe coffee
▪ McCafe Latte
• Desserts
▪ Hot Fudge Sundae
▪ Apple Pie
Current Brand Strategies
PLATFORM USE
Social Media
- Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, YouTube
McDonald’s has a very active social media presence.
Their accessibility throughout these sites allows it to
reach a large customer base that will raise awareness
of new promotions at little to no cost. McDonald’s
can reach their customers real-time and these
mediums allow customer interaction with
McDonald’s directly.
Our Food Your Questions Campaign As part of their website promotions they include a
site specifically geared toward questions or FAQs
about McDonald’s’ products. They even had a TV
advertising campaign geared toward people on the
street asking questions about the ingredients they
11 | P a g e
use. These questions and answers highlight the
transparency in their brand to deliver quality food
and build relationships (seen in Appendix A).
Promotions
- Movie Promotion
McDonald’s utilizes advertising through, TV, radio
and print (magazine, newspaper) mediums. They
often promote deals such as the Bogo Big Mac deal
(buy one get one free) and the Monopoly game
offering chances to win prizes. These advertisements
and deals are widely popular and extend their reach
in the market place (examples shown in Appendix
A).
- McDonald’s often partners with movie
productions to promote movies as part of
their packaging. It has worked with
DreamWorks SKG and 20th Century Fox
studios and most recently Rovio Animation
(Angry Birds) (Appendix A)
Competitor Analysis
Burger King
Brand Promise: The Burger King Brand promise is to offer good food quickly made to order the way
you want it.
Product Line:
• Burgers
o Quarter Pounder (sesame seed bun, flame broiled patty)
o Flame Broiled Whopper
o Cheeseburger
o Double Cheeseburger
• Chicken
o Original Chicken Sandwich
o Flame Grilled Chicken Burger
o Chicken Fries Rings
12 | P a g e
o Crispy Chicken Jr.
• Salads
o Garden Grilled Chicken Salad
o Bacon Cheddar Ranch Chicken Salad
• Sides
o French Fries
o Onion Rings
o Hash Browns
• Hot Dogs
• Breakfast
o Supreme Breakfast Sandwich
o Bacon, Egg & Chees Croissan’wich
• Coffees
o Smooth Roast Coffee
o Smooth Roast Iced Coffee
o BK Mocha Frappe
Points of Similarities: Burger King is a similar brand to McDonald’s in that they both offer signature
burgers in a fast food setting. Burger King has been in business for 60 years, which is just around the
same time as McDonald’s. Burger King has over 15 thousand locations domestically and worldwide
and in 2014, Burger King’s revenue tipped the scales at around $8.6 billion dollars (Quality System
Registrars 2015).
Like McDonald’s, Burger King also has a big social media presence which allows it to stay connected
to its customer base. Burger King stays dedicated to giving back to the community through, The
Burger King Mclamore Foundation, a philanthropy effort to impact the advancement of education
around the world.
Points of Difference: While McDonald’s has had success with signature burgers and meals like the
Big Mac and Happy Meal, Burger King has not been able to replicate these efforts to the extent
McDonald’s has. In recent years, Burger King has tried to imitate the deals and menu items that
McDonald’s has even going so far as creating the ‘Big King’ which is supposed to replicate and
compete with the Big Mac. While Burger King offers a breakfast menu they have not yet countered
the McDonald’s brand by offering it all day.
Wendy’s
13 | P a g e
Brand Promise: The Wendy’s brand promise is about delivering quality in their recipe to provide
good food quickly.
Product Line:
• Burgers (square patty)
o Dave’s Single, Double and Triple
o Baconator
o Jr. Cheeseburger Deluxe
o Jr. Bacon Cheeseburger
• Chicken
o Asiago Ranch Chicken Club
o Spicy Chicken Sandwich
o Grilled Chicken Sandwich
o Crispy Chicken Sandwich
• Salads
o BBQ Ranch Chicken Salad
o Apple Pecan Chicken Salad
o Spicy Chicken Caesar Salad
• Sides
o Ghost Pepper Fries
o Sour Cream and Chive Baked Potato
o Rich & Meaty Chili
o Natural-Cut Fries
o Apple Slices
• Beverages
o Green Tea
o Soft Drinks (Coca-Cola, Sprite)
o All-Natural Lemonade
o Strawberry Lemonade
o Iced Coffee
o Hot Tea
o Frosty
Points of Similarity: Wendy’s was established 46 years ago which makes it a baby franchise
compared to the likes of Burger King and McDonald’s. The main menu items offered by Wendy’s are
burger related. Wendy’s, like the two burger franchises ahead of it, attempts to compete with
promotional deals and ‘dollar menu’ items. Wendy’s initiated the 4 for $4 deal, which allows you to
choose four of their ‘dollar menu’ items costing only $4. McDonald’s soon countered this deal by
offering the McPick 2.
14 | P a g e
Points of Difference: Wendy’s does not offer a breakfast menu and is not known for its coffee brand.
They do not sell a variety of morning coffee related products and are only open for lunch and dinner.
While it has distinguished itself by the use of the square burger patty, it has not had the same success
that McDonald’s and Burger King have reached over the years. In 2014 its U.S. based sales reached
roughly $8.5 billion (Quality System Registrars 2015).
Insights & Recommendations
SWOT Analysis
Strengths Weaknesses
• Very strong social media presence
• Strong brand recognition and
representation around the world.
• They have taken ownership of their
brand and put to rest questions
surrounding the ingredients they use
(combating the pink paste questions).
• Consistency of the product they offer it
may not be everyone’s choice but they
have upheld certain expectations (fast
and cheap).
• Commitment to community (Ronald
McDonald House/Charity).
• While McDonald’s has added more
healthy choices their lack of non-burger
sandwiches make them less of a threat
against the likes of other fast food
chains such as Subway/Starbucks.
• Being at the top of the fast food market
leaves it suspect to fast casual
competitors (Jersey Mikes Subs,
Chipotle, Five Guys) with customers
who will pay a little more for a better
quality product.
Opportunities Threats
• McDonald’s is always looking to
change up their menu and product
offerings. The all-day breakfast has had
a positive impact with customers.
• They continue to experiment with new
menu options such as the build your
own burger initiative which has not
launched nationwide yet
• Creating more non-burger menu items
such as artisan sandwiches might help
combat other fast casual franchises.
• Because McDonald’s is the top fast
food and burger brand out there it’s
open to criticism and backlash from
competitors and customers alike.
• As other fast food franchises work to
complete against McDonald’s (Burger
King, Wendy’s) they have to stay
relevant on prices and promotions.
• Fast Casual franchises have offered an
alternative, higher quality product than
McDonald’s.
Specific Insights & Recommendations
• Still the One: No matter your personal feelings about McDonald’s it’s undeniable that it’s
currently the number one fast food and burger franchise in the world. The brand along with its
golden arches have become one of the most recognizable images out there. Although
15 | P a g e
competitors exist and there has been a customer shift to more fast-casual (Jersey Mikes Subs,
Five Guys Burgers and Fries) food establishments, McDonald’s has continually stayed
relevant in the market.
Their promotions and deals help to stay competitive. In 2015 Wendy’s initially offered the 4
for $4 combo meal. Customers would choose four limited menu items (junior bacon
cheeseburger, soft drink, chicken nuggets and fries) for just four dollars. “McDonald's
followed Wendy's with the McPick 2 menu, a bundled deal that that company said helped
drive a 5.4% first-quarter increase in sales at US locations open more than a year” (Taylor,
2016).
• Community Impact: McDonald’s has made a name for itself by not only providing good
food quickly to their customers but they have spent a great deal of time establishing and
building their relationships with the community. McDonald’s continues to foster growth in
youth through the Ronald McDonald House Charities which have impacted millions of
families since 1974. McDonald’s also places high importance on developing and operating the
most environmentally efficient restaurants worldwide.
• Strong Social Media Presence: McDonald’s has a very strong presence on social media and
the web. The Twitter and Facebook accounts allow the brand to grow by interacting with
customers on a real-time basis. Feedback is provided directly to the company which allows it
to respond accordingly. The fact that McDonald’s partners to help promote movies (2016
Angry Birds Movie) also allows them to remain relevant in the customer’s mind.
• Competitive Edge: In order to maintain their dominance in the market, McDonald’s must
continually analyze and re-evaluate their business strategies and marketing. Aside from the
regular fast food burger competitors (Burger King, Wendy’s), McDonald’s has an ever
16 | P a g e
growing concern with the fast-casual franchises that seem to offer a higher-quality product for
slightly more money. “Stuck in a tailspin that has seen declines in domestic sales and traffic,
McDonald’s is struggling to resonate with a consumer base that is increasingly demanding a
higher-quality product” (Oches, 2015).
In order to stay competitive McDonald’s has noted a few efforts they will undertake in hopes
of gaining some momentum back, “…McDonald’s will continue to roll out more digital
ordering and payment opportunities, which it did with the partnership with Apple Pay;
reorganize the company structure; focus its marketing efforts on transparency and quality…”
(Oches, 2015). They are always looking to revamp current menu items as evidenced in 2015
when they announced the Quarter-pounder burger (one of their signature menu items) would
be getting a bigger patty. “The change "improves the taste, texture and appearance of the
burgers" since the "patties retain more moisture resulting in a juicier and more flavorful
burger,"” (Little, 2015). McDonald’s is constantly looking for ways to maintain their
competitive edge and has been successful thus far.
17 | P a g e
Appendix A
https://www.ispot.tv/ad/ATaQ/McDonald’s-the-angry-birds-movie-launch
https://www.ispot.tv/ad/A1W4/McDonald’s-money-monopoly-prizes-are-coming
18 | P a g e
References
Little, K. (2015, June 25). McDonald’s Quarter Pounder is Getting Bigger (Really!). Retrieved May
24, 2016, from http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/26/mcdonalds-quarter-pounder-is-getting-bigger-
really.html.
Little, K. & Whitten, S. (2015, October 14). Breakfast finally pulls McDonald's out of its funk.
Retrieved May 23, 2016, from http://www.cnbc.com/2015/10/14/McDonald’s-brand-perception-at-a-
two-year-high.html.
McDonald's History. (n.d.). Retrieved May 21, 2016, from
http://www.aboutMcDonald’s.com/content/mcd/our_company/McDonald’s-history.html.
McDonald's TV Commercials. (n.d.). Retrieved May 23, 2016, from
https://www.ispot.tv/brands/AoR/McDonald’s.
McGrath, J. (2008). How McDonald’s Works. Retrieved May 21, 2016, from http://money.howstuffworks.com/McDonald’s.htm.
Oches, S. (2015, January). Tale of Two Brands. QSR. Retrieved from
https://www.qsrmagazine.com/fast-casual/tale-two-brands.
Quality System Registrars. (2015) [Chart illustration listing top quick service and fast casual brands].
Retrieved from https://www.qsrmagazine.com/reports/qsr50-2015-top-50-chart.
Taylor, K. (2016, May 24). McDonald’s, Burger King, and Wendy’s Used a Simple Trick to Sell 100
Million Extra Meals. Retrieved May 24, 2016 from http://www.businessinsider.com/fast-food-boosts-
sales-with-combo-deals-2016-5.