BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca)...
Transcript of BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca)...
![Page 1: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
BOTTOMFEEDING
• Scavenging• How a Wall Street Investment Banker Described the
Current State of the U.S. Industry
![Page 2: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
NIGERIA FARM-IN
r = 28%
A Consulting Project Example
![Page 3: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Political Uncertainty in Project Economics – A Case Study: ConocoPhillips in Venezuela
DeAnn Craig
![Page 4: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Goal: A THOUGHT PROCESS
• TECHNICAL
• FINANCIAL
• POLITICAL
Left Brain Right Brain
NB oi= (N
-N p)Bo
WAR
STRIKESRIOTS
KIDNAPPING
Sw
rr
![Page 5: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
GOAL – Convince the Project Evaluator
• Political events can be accounted for in Project Economic Evaluation just like Technical or Financial issues.– Changes in production volumes– Changes in net revenue– Increases in cost
• Accounting for political uncertainties in the discount factor will distort the analysis.
![Page 6: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
DEFINITIONS
• POLITICAL : relating to stakeholders
• This includes– populations of home and host countries
directly or indirectly affected by the project– governments that represent them– shareholders of the corporation
![Page 7: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
DEFINITIONS
UNCERTAINTY
KNOWN
UNKNOWN
Assign Probability
riskup
down
???
![Page 8: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Political Uncertainty MatrixPotential Outcomes
(selected industries) (kidnapping)
Micro (selected industries or firms)
(creeping expropriation) (strikes, bribery, corruption, pipeline theft)
Expropriation/Nationalization Personnel safety
(including environmental) Contract repudiationContract terms altered Process deterioration
Legal Extra-legalRegulatory changes Terrorism/Sabotage
Trade Sanctions Expropriation/NationalizationEconomic instability (all foreign entities)
(operations risk) (ownership in question)
Regulatory Changes Riots Damage
Transfer risk (inconvertibility) Civil War/Revolution DamagesNegative government actions Border conflicts
Macro (nearly all firms)Unwanted
![Page 9: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
CASE STUDY: ConocoPhillips-
Venezuelan StrikeAn Example of Process
Deterioration
![Page 10: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Source: Alvarez, C.E., C Marciano, C Pereira, K. Larrauri, F. Morros, P. Bauduhin. “The Orinoco Oil Belt Targets Light/Medium Crude Oil and Product Market Opportunities,” SPE 69734, 2001, p 10.
The Orinoco Oil Belt
![Page 11: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Project Name (New
Name)
Petrozuata (Junin)
Cerro Negro
(Carabobo)
Sincor (Boyaca)
Hamaca (Ayacucho)
Partners (percent)
PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips
(50.1)
PdVSA (41.67),
ExxonMobil (41.67), BP
PdVSA (38), Total (47), Statoil (15)
PdVSA (30), ConocoPhillips (40), Chevron
(30)
Startup Date October 1998 November 1999
December 2000 October 2001
Extra-Heavy Crude
Production (bpd; API)
120,000; 9.3° 120,000; 8.5° 200,000; 8-8.5° 190,000; 8.7°
Syncrude Production (bpd: API)
104,000; 19-25° 105,000; 16° 180,000; 32° 180,000; 26°
Orinoco Belt Strategic Associations
Source: http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Venezuela/Full.html, (16 September 2005)/.
![Page 12: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
10/10
5/30
5/1
4/234/3
3/253/18
2/25
2/61/16
1/271/9
1/612/20
12/16
12/912/5
12/2
10/1710/2
8/30
10/10
5/30
5/1
4/234/33/253/18
2/25
2/6
1/16
1/27
1/9
1/6
12/2012/16
12/912/5
12/2
10/1710/2
8/30
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
8/30/02 10/19/02 12/8/02 1/27/03 3/18/03 5/7/03
Date
$/sh
are
WTI COP
TIMELINE including VENEZUELAN NATIONAL STRIKE
![Page 13: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Project December 2002
January 2003
February 2003
March 2003
PetrozuataSyncrude Net, Daily Production, mbopd 58 58 58 58Estimated Days Shut-in 25 31 28 15Estimated monthly shut-in cost ($mm/month) 29.1 39.4 38.1 19.3
Estimated total cost of shut-in ($mm) $126Estimated per share cost of shut-in ($/share) $0.19 Assumes 676.8 mm sharesEstimated average, daily cost of shut-in production ($000 per day) $1,272
HamacaNet, Daily Production, mbopd 20 20 20 20Estimated Days Shut-in 25 31 28 15Estimated monthly shut-in cost ($m/month) 311 348 378 354Estimated total cost of shut-in ($mm) $35Estimated per share cost of shut-in ($/share) $0.05 Assumes 676.8 mm sharesEstimated average, daily cost of shut-in production ($000 per day) $348
TOTALEstimated total cost of shut-in ($mm) $161Estimated per share cost of shut-in ($/share) $0.24 Assumes 676.8 mm sharesEstimated average, daily cost of shut-in production ($000 per day) $1,620
Estimated, Actual Cost of Shut-in Production
![Page 14: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Market Model
C(COP/WTI)t = {[(COP/WTI)t – (COP/WTI)t-1]/(COP/WTI)t-1}
C(INDEX/WTI)t = {[(INDEX/WTI)t – (INDEX/WTI)t-1]/(INDEX/WTI)t-1}
C(COP/WTI)t = b0 + b1 * C(INDEX/WTI)t + εt
![Page 15: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
REGRESSION RESULTS
• bo = .000457, b1 = .910049
• adjusted-R2 = .88
• No autocorrelation, heteroskedasticity, multicollinearity.
• Residuals stationary and normally distributed.
![Page 16: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
- .0 3
-.0 2
-.0 1
.0 0
.0 1
.0 2
.0 3
-.10
-.05
.0 0
.0 5
.1 0
.1 5
25 5 0 75 10 0 1 25 15 0
Residu al A ctu al Fitted
F igure 1 : A ctua l vs . F itte d and Re s idua ls
![Page 17: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
SUMMARY
• Actual Cost– Small in relation to parent corporation– About 1/4 – 1/3 of region (country’s) profits
• Market Model– No distorting spike– Not ‘fine’ enough– Day-to-day share price changes > Actual per
share cost
![Page 18: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Potential Outcomes
Macro (nearly all firms)Unwanted
ConocoPhillips -Venezuela Political Uncertainty Matrix
Civil War/Revolution DamagesBorder conflicts
Transfer risk (inconvertibility)Negative government actions
(operations risk) (ownership in question)
Regulatory Changes Riots DamageTrade Sanctions Expropriation/Nationalization
Economic instability (all foreign entities)
Legal Extra-legalRegulatory changes Terrorism/Sabotage(including environmental) Contract repudiation
Contract terms altered Process deterioration
(selected industries) (kidnapping)
Micro (selected industries or firms)
(creeping expropriation) (strikes, bribery, corruption, pipeline theft)
Expropriation/Nationalization Personnel safety
![Page 19: BOTTOMFEEDINGProject Name (New Name) Petrozuata (Junin) Cerro Negro (Carabobo) Sincor (Boyaca) Hamaca (Ayacucho) Partners (percent) PdVSA (49.9), ConocoPhillips](https://reader033.fdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022041700/5e4121e7c3c38c030b173de4/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
GOAL: A Thought Process
• TECHNICAL
• POLITICAL
• FINANCIAL– Internally financed
• Corporate funds• Funds generated in-country
– Externally financed
Left Brain Right Brain
Production Interru
ption
Insurance
Micro-credit
Schools
Jobs
Health & Medical