Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind...

10
Book Review: The Organized Mind by Daniel Levitin 2018 © Knut K. Wimberger 1 “In preparing for a battle I have always found that plans are useless, but planning is indispensable.” General David D. Eisenhower’s famous quote could well be the bottom line of Daniel Levitin’s brilliant treaties on how we are supposed to organize our minds in the face of drowning in the 21 st century sea of information. Reading this book is indispensable, but you might very well find it useless. As the author notes by rephrasing Neil Postman’s famous quote: Information has become separated from meaning. The sheer volume of available information and it being rendered in a message not comprehensible to the hunter & gatherer brain which longs for storytelling and physical experiences instead of STEM examinations and binary codes, make information useless. The same is true for this book and the author misjudges the reality of what his readership is capable of. Despite confirming that small libraries are much

Transcript of Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind...

Page 1: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

1

“InpreparingforabattleIhavealwaysfoundthatplansareuseless,butplanningisindispensable.”GeneralDavidD.Eisenhower’sfamousquotecouldwellbethebottomlineofDanielLevitin’sbrillianttreatiesonhowwearesupposedtoorganizeourmindsinthefaceofdrowninginthe21stcenturyseaofinformation.Readingthisbookisindispensable,butyoumightverywellfindituseless.AstheauthornotesbyrephrasingNeilPostman’sfamousquote:Informationhasbecomeseparatedfrommeaning.Thesheervolumeofavailableinformationanditbeingrenderedinamessagenotcomprehensibletothehunter&gathererbrainwhichlongsforstorytellingandphysicalexperiencesinsteadofSTEMexaminationsandbinarycodes,makeinformationuseless.Thesameistrueforthisbookandtheauthormisjudgestherealityofwhathisreadershipiscapableof.Despiteconfirmingthatsmalllibrariesaremuch

Page 2: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

2

moreusefulthanlargerones,heconcludesthispopularsciencetitlewithmorethan400endnotesandthiscomment:ListingeverypaperIreadwouldmaketheendnotessectiontentimeslonger,andfarlessusefultothegeneralreader.IthinkitwasHuxleywhosaidthatcompletenessisnotnothingtoadd,butnothingtotakeaway.Levitinisoneoftheforemostcognitivepsychologistsonthisplanet,anaccomplishedmusician,ahighendbusinessconsultantandingeneralapolymath.Helaysoutaplaninthisbookonhowwearesupposedtoorganizeourlivesanddoessowithastonishingeloquenceanderudition.Strangelythough,hewritesalreadyinhisintroductionthatweorganizeourmindsindifferenteducationaldisciplinestodelivereverhigherlevelsofachievement,toprovideanedgeinaworldthatisincreasinglycompetitive.TheOrganizedMindLacksWisdomIhonestlyenjoyedreadingthisbookdespiteitsscholarlystyle,becauseitisthrobbingwithsomuchinformationandknowledge.ButatacertainpointIkeptaskingmyselfifitdoesn’tlackessentialwisdom.Aquestionkeptrecurringtome:CanwereallyburdenallofhumanitywiththeinformationstructuringtechniquesofCEOs,extremeathletesorgeniusmusicians,oristhisjusttoomuchforanaverageperson?Shouldn’tweshiftthefocusfrombeingapsychologistwhoanalysestheimprovedfunctionalityofthehumanbraintotheperspectiveofthesociologistwhocapturesthepictureatlargetounderstandwhatcausestheinformationoverloadandifthissufferingisindeednecessary?Levitinappearsasaphysicianormechanicapplyingtheperfectunderstandingofamachine(inthiscasethebrain)toconductacomplexsurgeryonthesickmind,butfailstounderstandtheetiologyofthisepidemicinformationoverload.IwishLevitinwouldhavewrittenabookwhichtakestheburdenofftheaverageperson(likeTomHodkinsontooktheburdenofparentingfrommyshoulders)insteadofwritingabookwhichtellspeoplehowtobecomeaseffectiveasafortune500CEO.Ittunesintothegeneraldissonanceofourcompetitiveknowledgeeconomies,whichlackharmonyandcooperation.Levitinsetsatonewhichgoadsthereaderintoamindsetofwantingbetterbrainsdespiteconfirmingthatourbrainsarenotmadeforsuchenormousamountsofinformation:Itshelpfultounderstandthatourmodesofthinkinganddecisionmakingevolvedoverthetensofthousandsofyearsthathumanslivedashunter-gatherers.Ourgeneshaven’tfullycaughtupwiththedemandsofmoderncivilization,butfortunatelyhumanknowledgehas–wenowbetterunderstandhowtoovercomeevolutionarylimitations.Levitincomesthusacrossasyetanotherscientistwhoseemstopreferatranshumanistfutureoverhumankindatpeacewithitsmammalnature.Heputshisreaderontrackto

Page 3: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

3

desireagadgethereandanimplanttheretobecomeatleastbymeansofartificialimprovementascompetitiveasthemostsuccessfulmembersofsociety.BydoingsohejoinstheatheistvisioningofacademicwriterslikehistorianYuvalHarari,whodescribedthefutureofneuralenhancementinhislastbookHomoDeus.Thefirsthumanswhofiguredouthowtowritethingsdownaround5000yearsagowereinessencetryingtoincreasethecapacityoftheirhippocampus,partofthebrain’smemorysystem.[…]Weare[sincethen]off-loadingagreatdealoftheprocessingthatourneuronswouldnormallydotoanexternaldevicethatthenbecomesanextensionofourownbrains,aneuralenhancer.[…]Oncememoriesbecameexternalizedwithwrittenlanguage,thewriter’sbrainandattentionalsystemwerefreeduptofocusonsomethingelse.HenryKissingermentionedinWorldOrderwhichwaswritteninthesameyearasTheOrganizedMind,thatphilosophersandpoetshavelongseparatedthemind’spurviewintothreecomponents:information,knowledge,andwisdom.TheInternetfocusesontherealmofinformation,whosespreaditfacilitatesexponentially.Evermorecomplexfunctionsaredevised,particularlycapableofrespondingtoquestionsoffact,whicharenotthemselvesalteredbythepassageoftime.Searchenginesareabletohandleincreasingspeed.Yetasurfeitofinformationmayparadoxicallyinhibittheacquisitionofknowledgeandpushwisdomevenfurtherawaythanitwasbefore.Levitinfailstoacknowledgethatitismorewisdomwhatweneednow,notmoresuccessfulpeoplewhocanorganizemoreinformationinashortertimetosurviveinanevercompetitivesociety.MissingaSolutionforhowtoTeachChildrenAcloselookintoLevitin’stableofcontentrevealsthatthereisalackoforganization,ablindspotorevenabigquestionwhichhewasnotabletoanswerwhenstructuringhiswork.Idon’twanttosoundcritical.IwouldhaveneverbeenabletobringtogetherthisvastamounttodataandstudieswhichLevitinhasmanagedtopackintothisbook.Hedeservesfullcredittherefore.Thethreepartstructurerevealsthoughthatthereissomethingmissing.PartIprovidesabrilliantintroductiontothehistoryofcognitiveoverloadoverthelast5000yearsandexplainstheneuroscienceofattentionandmemory.PartIIexplainsinfivechaptershowtoorganizeourhomes,oursocialworld,ourtime,ourdecisionsinmomentsofthreatanddanger,andthebusinessworld.Sofarsogood.Icouldn’tthinkofabetterwaytostructurethesetwoparts.ButwhileLevitingoesintoverydetailsofhowtoorganizeourlives,e.g.byexplainingatextremelengthhowemailscanbeefficientlyhandled,hecoversinpartIIIwhatwehavetoteachourchildrenand“everythingelse”superficially.Itstellingthathewritesaboutthepowerof

Page 4: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

4

thejunkdrawerinthesamesection,whichaddressesinmyhumbleopinionthemostpressingquestionofall:howtosaveourchildrenfromthisinsanity.PartOne

1. Toomuchinformation,toomanydecisions:theinsidehistoryofcognitiveoverload2. Thefirstthingstogetstraight:howattentionandmemorywork

PartTwo3. Organizingourhomes:wherethingscanstarttogetbetter4. Organizingoursocialworld:howhumansconnectnow5. Organizingourtime:whatisthemystery?6. Organizinginformationforthehardestdecisions:whenlifeisontheline7. Organizingthebusinessworld:howwecreatevalue

PartThree8. Whattoteachourchildren:thefutureoftheorganizedmind9. Everythingelse:thepowerofthejunkdrawer

EducatorNeilPostmanunderstoodthetruechallengewithsocietiessufferingfrominformationoverloadinallitsclarityalreadybackinthe1980s.Ina1990speechtitledInformingOurselvestoDeathhearguedthatoursocietyreliestooheavilyoninformationtofixourproblems,especiallythefundamentalproblemsofhumanphilosophyandsurvival,thatinformation,eversincetheprintingpress,hasbecomeaburdenandgarbageinsteadofarareblessing.AccordingtoPostman’sspeech,"thetiebetweeninformationandactionhasbeensevered.Informationisnowacommoditythatcanbeboughtandsold,orusedasaformofentertainment,orwornlikeagarmenttoenhanceone'sstatus.Itcomesindiscriminately,directedatnooneinparticular,disconnectedfromusefulness;wearegluttedwithinformation,drowningininformation,havenocontroloverit,don'tknowwhattodowithit."Levitinaddsthechapterofwhatweoughttoteachourchildrentothejunkdrawer,becausehehasonthecontrarytoorganizingourbusinessworldorourhomesnoanswertothisquestion.Heunderstandstheneurologicalscience,butisn’tabletoconnectthedots.Hewritesthatchildrenaremorelikelytowantimmediategratification,andtheyarelesslikelytobeabletoforeseethefutureconsequencesofpresentinaction;bothofthesearetiedtotheirunderdevelopedprefrontalcortices,whichdon’tfullymatureuntilaftertheageoftwenty(!).Thisalsomakesthemmorevulnerabletoaddiction.

Page 5: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

5

Educationisthoughnotonlyaboutwhatweteachchildreninschool,butabouttheframeconditionsinwhichwebringthemup.Raisingouroffspringinanaddictionculturewillresultinlotsofaddictedadults.Levitinrecommendstostrengthenso-calledfoundationalconceptsandhabitsofmind.Theyarementalhabitsandreflexesthatshouldbetaughttoallchildrenandreinforcesthroughouttheirhighschoolandcollegeyears.Trainingchildreninthesehabits,butlettingthemgrowupinaculturewhichisanaddictionminefieldmakesLevitinlooklikeaDonQuixoteandmakesmerecallTheMatrix:weneedtobetaughtcriticalthinkingandsoundhabitsofmind,thereisnodoubtaboutit,butaslongasweliveinaculturewhichplaceseachindividualalreadyinitsearlychildhoodyearsintoanaddictioncocoon,whichgrowsthickeraswegrowolder,itwon’tbepossibletoconstructasanesociety.Levitincontradictshisrecommendationofteachingfoundationalconceptsandhabitsofmindintheverysamebook,wherehewritesonlyafewparagraphsearlierthattheprimarymissionofteachersmustshiftfromthedisseminationofrawinformationtotrainingaclusterofmentalskillsthatrevolvearoundcriticalthinking.Teacherswhosucceedindoingsomustbewizardsofneurologyabletochangethehumanbraindevelopment.Howarewesupposedtoteachchildrencriticalthinking,iftheverybrainregionforcriticalthinking,theprefrontalcortex,isnotyetfullyevolvedandisunderpermanentattacktoberendereduselessbyexcessivescreentime,sugarfloodsandmanyotherhabitsofconsumptionwhichcivilizationpressuresusinto?NeilPostmancomparedcontemporarysociety[ofthe1980sandthat’sevenmoresotruetoday]totheMiddleAges,whereinsteadofindividualsbelievingeverythingtoldtothembyreligiousleaders,nowindividualsbelieveeverythingtoldtothembyscience,makingpeoplemorenaivethaninMiddleAges.Individualsinacontemporarysociety,onethatismediatedbytechnology,couldpossiblybelieveinanythingandeverything,whereasintheMiddleAgesthepopulacebelievedinthebenevolentdesigntheywereallpartofandtherewasordertotheirbeliefs.CriticalThinkingvs.SubtleTrustIwroteinthebeginningthatLevitinisapolymath.ReadinghisbiographyIwastrulyinaweabouthislifetrajectoryandtheself-confidentdecisionshemade.HeisineveryaspecthimselfanorganizedmindandanexemplaryCEO–atleastinregardtoshapinghisidentityandself.HestudiedappliedmathematicsatMIT,droppedout,pursuedacareerasmusician,soundengineerandrecordproducer,onlytoreturntouniversityinhisthirties.HecompletedafasttrackPhDincognitivescienceatStanfordandonemustwonderwhere

Page 6: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

6

theenergy,motivationandaboveallthefinancialsupportcamefrom.ItmighthavehelpedthatLevitinisthesonofanaccomplishedbusinessmananduniversityprofessor,andahyper-productivenovelist,whosurvivedtheholocaust;indicatinganupbringinginannon-religiousJewish-AmericanenvironmentwhichendowedLevitinwithanexcellingnatureandoutstandingconditionsofnurturing.TheOrganizedMindwasdedicatedtoLevitin’sparents“foralltheytaughtme.”WheneverIreadnowadaysanon-fictionbook,Iaskmyselfbywhattheauthorsweredrivenandfromwhatperspectivedidtheystartoff.Whydidtheyspendliterallyhundredsofhoursresearchingandwritingandfromwhichpointofviewdidtheylookattheverysubjectofthebook?Levitinwaswithoutdoubtbornintooneofthesunniestplacesonthisplanet.HedidnotonlygrowupinsunnyCaliforniaintheboonyearsofUSeconomicgrowth,butwasblessedwithabundantmaterialsupport.Startingfromsuchahighleveloflivingstandardandaccomplishment,oneiseasilytemptedtoraiseexpectationsanddesiremore.Ican’tsayanythingabouttheemotionalandspiritualsupportLevitinreceivedfromhisparentsandhisextendedfamily,butitseemstoacertainextentthathissearchfortheperfectlyorganizedmindistheresultofgrowingupinanatheistenvironment,whichmusthavebeeninfluenceddeeplybytheordealhisBerlinbornJewishmotherunderwentafterfleeingEuropeandstartinganewlifeintheUS.Ibelieveit’simportanttoobservethatLevitinmakesnotasinglereferencetohowthespiritualoutlookofapersonortheemotionalbaggageofone’sfamilyaffectsthestructureofthemind;neitherdoeshementionwithasinglewordhowournutritionalhabitsshapewhatwethink,andyes,whatweare.Afewmonthsago,Iwroteanessayabouttheneurologyoffaith,loveandhopeandarrivedatthesomehowmysticinterpretationofJuvenal’squotationmenssanaincorporesano,i.e.ahealthymindrestsinahealthybody.Myinterpretationwasspiritussanctusincorporesano,i.e.asaintspiritrestsinahealthybody-if,andonlyif,themindopensitselftotheguidingforceofGod.IrecallnowyetanotherquotationfromwritingteacherJuliaCameron,whichisrelatedtothistrainofthought:Bealert,always,forthepresenceoftheGreatCreatorleadingandhelpingmyartist.Bothquotationsindicatethatthereisyetanotherforceatworkinorganizinginformationandmakingitavailableatone’sfingertip.It’saforcewhichisbeyondtheunderstandingofourlittlemindswhicharerestrictedbythelimitationsofourpettyandfearfulegos.ItisthemindatlargeasAldousHuxleycalleditinTheDoorsofPerception.LevitinsomewhatknowsaboutthismindatlargeashequotesAlbertEinsteinwhosaid“Thegreatestscientistsare

Page 7: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

7

artistsaswell.”,butheaddsittothelastchapterinhisbook:EverythingElse–ThePoweroftheJunkDrawer.

Tomanypeople,beingorganizedmeans“aplaceforeverythingandeverythinginitsplace.”Thisisanimportantprinciplefororganizingfiles,tools,objectsinthehomeandoffice,andsoon.Butitsequallyimportantforourorganizationalsystemsandinfrastructuretoallowforfuzzycategories,forthingsthatfallthroughthecracks–themiscellaneousfolderinyourfilingsystem,thejunkdrawerinyourkitchen.ThisindicatesthatLevitindoesn’tknowwhattodowithGodorspiritualorganizationinthesamewayashehasnoideaofwhatweneedtoteachourchildren.Eitherhedoesn’tknoworthescientificdogmadoesn’tallowhimtowriteexplicitlyaboutit.ThismightallsoundasifIdon’tappreciateLevitin’swork.Isincerelydo,butIdon’tthinkthathisconclusionswillsolvetheproblemswhichhumanitycurrentlyfaces,inparticularitwon’tsolvethemostcrucialquestion:whattoteachourchildren?Isaythis,assumingthatthereaderagreesthatwehavedonesomethingwronginthepast,lookingatenvironmentalandsocialdestructionallovertheplanet.Trainingouroffspringtobeevenmorecompetitivewon’tbethesolution.AsHisHoliness,theDalaiLamasaid:Theplanetdoesnotneedmoresuccessfulpeople.Theplanetdesperatelyneedsmorepeacemakers,healers,restorers,storytellersandloversofallkind.

Page 8: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

8

Whilesuccessfulpeopletendtoneuroticallyorganizetheirintellectualmindandtheirmaterialenvironment,whiletheyholdtightontotheircriticallinearthinking,healers,storytellersandloversareguidedbysubtletrustandtheabilityoflettinggo.Levitinknowsaboutthisandstrangelyenoughconcludeshisbook-afterdissectinglikenobodyelsebeforehimhowweorganizethephenomenalworld–withfaith:Thekeytochangeishavingfaiththatifwegetridoftheold,someoneorsomethingevenmoremagnificentwilltakeitsplace.Mywisewifeputsthisintoevensimplerterms:旧的不去新的不来,i.e.iftheolddoesn’tgothenewwon’tarrive.Manyoftheworld’sproblems–cancer,genocide,repression,poverty,violence,grossinequitiesinthedistributionofresourcesandwealth,climatechange–willrequiregreatcreativitytosolve.Levitinsuggestsnon-linearthinkingandthedaydreamingmodearemuchunderestimatedqualitiesofhumanproblemsolvingandoneisagaintemptedtoreadbetweenthelinesthatthisisthewayhowacognitivepsychologistwritesscientificallyabouthowGodmanifestshimselfinourminds.LevitinquotesonceagainEinsteinsayingImaginationismoreimportantthanknowledgeandcontinueseverywriterwonderswherefictionalideascomefrom,butavoidsananswertothequestionwhichispregnantthroughouthislastjunkdrawerchapter:whatisthesourceofcreativityandimagination?ItisstronglyrecommendtoreadonthisaccountMyStrokeofInsightbyneurologistJillBolte-Taylor.Theaccomplishedbrainscientistexperiencedabrainstrokeatage37andwitnessedhowherlefthemisphere,theonewhichisresponsibleforourlinear,task-positivethinkingandwhichisthoroughlyanalyzedbyLevitin,shutsdown.Whatsheisleftwithisherrighthemisphereandalthoughsheentersaneardeathexperiencesherealizesthatthereissomethingmoreatworkthanhersmallmindandfearfulego.Ifwewanttosolvetheworld’smostpressingproblems,weneedtoremembertwothings.Firstly,Levitin’smostcentralthesis,thatthetwenty-firstcentury’sinformationproblemisoneofselection.Secondly,thatitisnotuswhocanmakethisselection.Levitinwrites,thattherearereallyonlytwostrategiesforselectioninthefaceofthis[informationflood]–searchingandfiltering.Togetherthesecanbemoreparsimoniouslythoughtofasonestrategy,filtering.Andtheonlyvariableiswhodoesthefiltering,youorsomeoneelse.Whenyousearchforsomething,youstartoutwithanideaofwhatyouwant,andyougooutandtrytofindit.IhavecometotheconclusionthatwheneverIgooutandtrytofindsomethingthatIendupbeingoverwhelmedbythemultitudeofchoicestomakeandtheamountofinformationtodigest.SinceIhavesubmittedmylifetoGodandthegreatfilteringsystemofthemindatlarge,IfeellikeIhaveenteredasmoothoperationmodewhichreducestheamountof

Page 9: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

9

informationorganization.Iorganizeonlywhatisnecessaryforthenextdays,becauseIcantrustthatsomebodyelsetakescareofthejourneyanditsdestination.Levitin’sworkhasscientificallyconfirmedthatIamontherighttrack.Subtletrustrulesovercriticalthinking;butweneedboth.Otherwiseweeitherturnparanoidorsuperstitiousandnaïve.OnemightaddtothisonacynicalnotethatLevitinisnotaverycriticalthinker.Hewrites400pagesinsmallprint,whichwouldturnouttobeatleast600pagesinstandardfontsize,aboutmanyinterestingdetails.Heiscompletelyignorantthoughofpoliticalrealities,whenhereferstothe9/11incidentortheIraqwar.OnewondersifheisnaïveorifhispositioninoneofthemostrespecteduniversitiesontheNorthAmericancontinentforcehimtoavoidthetruthabouttheUSwaragainstitsowncitizensandtheeconomicgrowthparadigmbehindwaragainstothercountries.UselessButIndispensableIfIstartedwiththisreviewbysayingthatreadingthisbookisindispensable,butyoumightverywellfindituseless,Iwouldliketoconfirmforthosewhoarenotinterestedincognitivepsychologythatthisismostlikelytrue.Levitinmakesthoughafewverywiseremarksonthelasttwopages,whichareusefultoeverybody.Hewrites:One’sjunkdrawer,likeone’slife,undergoesanaturalsortofentropy.Everysooften,weshouldperhapstaketimeoutandaskourselvesthefollowingquestions:

- DoIreallyneedtoholdontothisthingorthisrelationshipanymore?Doesitfillmewithenergyandhappiness?Doesitserveme?

- Aremycommunicationsfilledwithclutter?AmIdirect?DoIaskforwhatIwantandneed,ordoIhopemypartner/friend/coworkerwillpsychicallyfigureitout?

- MustIaccumulateseveralofthesamethingseventhoughthey’reidentical?Aremyfriends,habits,andideasalltoosimilar,oramIopentonewpeople’sideasandexperiences?

Gettingorganizedcanbringusalltothenextlevelinourlives.It’sthehumanconditiontofallpreytooldhabits.Wemustconsciouslylookatareasofourlivesthatneedcleaningup,andthenmethodicallyandproactivelydoso.Andthenkeepdoingit.Everyoftenso,theuniversehasawayofdoingthisforus.Weunexpectedlyloseafriend,abelovedpet,abusinessdeal,oranentireglobaleconomycollapses.Thebestwaytoimproveuponthebrainsthatnaturegaveusistoadjustagreeablytonewcircumstances.MyownexperienceisthatwhenI’velostsomethingIthoughtwasirreplaceable,it’susuallyreplacedwithsomethingmuchbetter.Thekeytochangeishavingfaiththatifwegetridoftheold,someoneorsomethingevenmoremagnificentwilltakeitsplace.

Page 10: Book Review - The Organized Mind...8. What to teach our children: the future of the organized mind 9. Everything else: the power of the junk drawer Educator Neil Postman understood

BookReview:TheOrganizedMindbyDanielLevitin

2018©KnutK.Wimberger

10

Let’shopethatwefindthatkeytogetridofgreed,capitalismandeconomicgrowth.Thereissomethingmuchbetterwaitingforus.Tofindthekeyithelpstodeclutterradicallyinthematerial,intellectualandtheemotionalworld.Freeourchildrenfromforce-fededucationandtrustthatthelasttwodecadesofresearchonthescienceoflearninghaveshownconclusivelythatwerememberthingsbetter,andlonger,ifwediscoverthemourselvesratherthanbeingtoldthemexplicitly.Zenmastersspeakinriddlesbecausetheyletthedisciplesetneuro-markersonhisown;andthusthecupmustbeemptytobefilled.

Levitinwritesintheintroductionthatthisisthestoryofhowhumanshavecopedwithinformationandorganizationfromthebeginningofcivilization.Ifinformationselectionisthechallengeofthe21stcenturyasheconcludesinchapter9,weneedtoaskhowwecanresetourwayofthinkingfromlineartononlinear;frommanyindividualizedandisolatedtoonecentralizedandconnectedcomputingunit.Itisinparticularchapter8,whichrequiresafollowup,becauseitdoesnotanswerwhatitsetouttodo:describingthefutureoftheorganizedmindandwhattoteachchildren.Andaboveall,itwon’tbeenoughtofollowupwithyetanotheracademicanalysis.Whathumanityneedsisastoryitunderstands.