BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’I IN THE MATTER OF CINDY … ·...

ffLt

;; UU.Si L

IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR-CC-16-002)

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;)Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the )Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea )Science Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka, Hamakua, )Hawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 )

)

CINDY FREITAS AS FOURTHSUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBITLIST;CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

CINDY FRIETAS FOURTH SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT LIST

I Cindy Freitas, “Petitioner” submits its Fourth Supplemental Exhibit List.

Ex. No Description

S-20 DOC:256 PUEO Proposed Minute Order Granting PUEOMotion To Set Issues

S-21 DOC:297 Respond To Proposed DOC 256 All IssuesShould Also Be Considered

S-22 DOC: 220 Site Visit Proposal

S-23 DOC: 274 Minute Order No. 18

S-24 DOC: 278 Motion To Amend 274 Site Visit ToInclude Request In DOC 220

S-25 Doc: 290 Objection To September 26, 2016 Site Visit on Mauna Kea

Kailua Kona HI. November 28, 2016

Cindy FreitasP.0.4650KailuaKonaHi [email protected]

BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES

FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’I

Cindy Freitá Petitioner

Exhibit S-20

DOC: 256 PUEO Proposed Minute OrderGranting PUEO Motion to Set Issues

TORKILDSON, KATZ, MOOREHETHERINGTON & HARRISAttorneys at Law, A Law Coioration

NEWTON J. CHU 6537-0LINCOLN S T ASHIDA 4478-0120 Pauahi Street, Suite 312Hilo, Hawai’i 96720Tel. (808) 961-0406FAX (808) 961-3815

tOc 9&’

Attorneys for PERPETUATING UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES, INC.



IN THE MATTER OF

A Contested Case Hearing Re ConservationDistrict Use Permit (CDUP) HA-3 568 for theThirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna KeaScience Reserve, Kaohe Mauka, HamakuaDistrict, Island of Hawai’i, TMK (3) 4-4-015:009

Case No, BLNR-CC-16-002

PERPETUATING UNIQUEEDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES,INC.’S PROPOSED MINUTE ORDERGRANTING PERPETUATING UNIQUEEDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES,INC.’S MOTION TO SET ISSUESlDoc-991; EXHIBIT “A”; CERTIFICATEOF SERVICE

PERPETUATING UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES, INC.’S PROPOSEDMINUTE ORDER GRANTING PERPETUATING UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL

OPPORTUNITIES INC.’S MOTION TO SET ISSUES IDoc-991

COMES NOW PERPETUATiNG UNIQUE EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES, INC.

(“PUEO”), by and through its undersigned counsel, and hereby respectfully submits the

following proposed minute order granting PUEO’s Motion to Set Issues (Exhibit A).

Dated: Hilo, Hawai’i, September 9, 2016.

NEWTON 3. CHULINCOLN S. T. ASHIDA

Attorneys for PERPETUATING UNIQUEEDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES, INC.

2059679.V1 I

S-20ReceedOffice otConseivation and Coastal Lands2016 Sept 9 2 34 pmDapatement of Land and Natural ResourcesState of Hawaii

EXHIBIT A

2O59679VI 2

PROPOSED MINUTE ORDER GRANTING PERPETUATING UNIQUEEDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITIES INC.’S MOTION TO SET ISSUES IDoc-991

On July 18, 2016, Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc. (“PUEO”) filed

its Motion to Set Issues [Doc-99] (“Motion”). The following documents were filed in response

to the Motion:

• On July 20, 2016, the Temple of Lono filed its opposition to the Motion [Doe-

119].

• On August 1, 2016, the University of Hawai’i at Hilo (“UHH”) filed its

substantive joinder to the Motion [Doc-140j.

• On August 1, 2016, TMT International Observatory, LLC filed its substantive

joinder to the Motion [Doe-I 52].

• On August 1, 2016, Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, Ct at. filed its position

statement to the Motion [Doc-164].

• On August 9, 2016, Harry Fergerstrom (“Mr. Fergerstrom”) tiled his opposition to

the Motion [Doc-186].

• On August 10, 2016, Mehana Kihoi filed a joinder to Mr. Fergerstrom’s

opposition to the Motion [Doe-1951.

• On August 22,2016, UFIH filed its supplemental comments on the Motion [Doe-

242].

The Motion came on for hearing before this Hearings Officer on August 29,2016. Per

the request of this Hearings Officer at the hearing, PUEO submitted its proposed minute order

granting the Motion on September 9, 2016. The parties had until September 19, 2016 to respond

to PUEO’s proposed minute order.

This Hearings Officer having considered the Motion, all other written and oral

submissions of counsel and parties related thereto, the entire record, and for good cause shown,20$9679,VI 3

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Motion is GRANTED pursuant to Hawaii

Administrative Rules “HAR’ §13-1-36(a) and all other applicable rules of HAR Title 13,

Chapter 1, Rules ofPractice and Procedure. This Hearings Officer finds that the following

issues may be addressed during this contested case hearing:

1. Is the proposed land use, including the plans incorporated in the application,

consistent with the eight criteria in HAR § 13-5-30(c) and other applicable rules

in HAR, Title 13, Chapter 5, Conservation District?

2, is the proposed land use consistent with article XII, section 7 of the Hawai’i State

Constitution?

3. Is the proposed land use consistent with Ka Pa’akai 0 Ka’Aina V. Land Use

omm’n.. State ofHawai4i,94 HawaI’i 31, 7 P.3d 1068(2000)?

4. Is the proposed land use consistent with applicable provisions ofChapter 1 83C of

the Hawai’i Revised Statutes?

5. Does the public trust doctrine apply to the proposed land use and, if it does, is the

proposed land use consistent with the public trust doctrine?

This Hearings Officer finds that the following issues will not be addressed In this

contested case hearing:

1. The sovereignty of the Kingdom of Hawai’i or any other issues relating to the

purported existence of the Kingdom ofHawai’i.

2. Challenges to the legal status of the State ofHawai’i.

3. Challenges to the State’s ownership of and title to the lands comprising the summit

area of Mauna Kea

2059679N1 4

The above issues present non-justiciable political questions that are outside the subject

matter jurisdiction ofthis Hearings Officer and are therefore not issues for this contested case

hearing,

Dated: Honolulu, Hawai’i, September 23,2016

Judge Rika May Amano (Ret)Hearings Officer

2059679.V1 5



IN THE MATTER OF

A Contested Case Hearing Re ConservationDistrict Use Permit (CDUP) HA-3568 for theThirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna KeaScience Reserve, Kaohe Mauka, HamakuaDistrict, Island ofHawai’i, TMK (3) 4-4-015:009

Case No. BLNR-CC-16-002

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE


I hereby certify that a copy ofthe foregoing was served on the following via the manner

listed below:

Office of Conservation and CoastalLands1151 Punchbowl, Room 131Honolulu, HI 96813dlnr.maunakeahawaii.gpvCustodian ofthe Records(original + digital copy)

Carismith Ball LLPIan Sandison, Tim Lui-Kwan, John P.Manaut, Lindsay N. McAneeley1001 Bishop StreetASB Tower, Suite 2200Honolulu, III 96813isandison(äcar1smith.corntiuikwan(ãcarlsmith.cjpm([email protected] the Applicant University ofHawat i at Hue

Richard N. WurdernanAttorney at Law1003 Bishop Street, Suite 720Honolulu, HI 96813RNWurdeman@RNWLaw corncounselfor the Petitioners Máuna KeaAnalna Hou, Clarence KukauakahiClung, Flares-Case ‘Ohana, Deborah.1. Ward, Paul K. Neves, and Kahea:The EnvironmentalAlliance

Watanabe Ing LLP3. Douglas Ing, Ross T. Shinyama,Summer H. KiaweFirst Hawaiian Center 999 BishopStreet, 23’ FloorHonolulu, HI 96813rshinyama(wik.comdougina(iiwik.coniCounselfor TMTInternationalObservatoiy, LLC

Harry FergerstromP.O. Box 951Kurtistown, 11196760

Richard L DeLeon140 Manino (Dir Apt 101Kihei, HI 96753kekaukike(rnsn.eorn

Mehana KihoiP0 Box 393Honaunau, HI 96726uhiwai(Iive.corn

C. M. Kaho’okahi Kanuha77-6504 Maile StKailua Kona, Hi 96740kahookahi(gmail.com

Joseph Kuaffi Lindsey Camarakualiic(dthotmail .com

3. Leina’ala SleightholmP.O. Box 383035Waikoloa, HI 96738leina.ala.s808@gmail,com

Maelani 1.eeP0 Box 1054Waianae, 11196792mae1aniIee(yahoo.corn

Lanny Alan SinkinP.O. Box 944Hilo, HI 96721Ianny.sinkin@aiLcpmRepresentativefor The Temple ofLono

Kalikolehua KanaeIe4 Spring Streetjib, HI 96720kule1e(vahoo.com

Stephanie-Malia:TabbadaP0 Box 194,Naalehu, 11196772s.tabbada(ivhawaiianteb net

2059679.VI I

Tifihie KkaIia Dwight 3. Vicente Cindy Freitas549 E Kahaopea St. 2608 Ainaola Drive P0 Box 4650Hilo, HI 96720 HUG, Hawaiian Kingdom Kailua Koaa, HI 96745tiffiuiekakalia(ãgmaiLcom [email protected]

Brannon Kamahana Kealoha89-564 Mokiawe Street William Freitas

Glen Kila Nanakuli, HI 96792 P0 Box 465089-530 Mokiawe Street brannonkhawali.edu Kailua Kona, HI 96745Waianae, HI 96792 pohaku7(ãyahoocornmakakilacmai1.com

DATED: Hilo, Hawai’i, September 9, 2016.

NEWTONS. CHULINCOLN S. T. ASHIDA

Attorneys forPERPETUATING UNIQUE EDUCATIONALOPPORTUNITIES

20$9679N1 2

Exhibit S-2 1

DOC: 297 Respond To Proposed DOC 256 All IssuesShould Also Be Considered

‘oC- ?1]

Cindy FreitasP.O. 4650Kailua Kona HI [email protected]



IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR.-CC-16-002)

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;) RESONI) TO PROPOSED DOCUse Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the ) 256 ALL ISSUE SHOULD ALSOThirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea ) BE CONSIDERED; CERTIFICATEScience Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka, Hamakua,) OF SERVICEHawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 )

)

RESPOND TO PROPOSED DOC 256 ALL ISSUE SHOULD ALSO BE CONSIDERED

I Cindy Freitas, “Petitioner”, responding to DOC 256 on page 4 proposed issue should

also be considered in this contested hearing case, pursuant to Hawaii Administrative

Rules Title 13, Chapter 1 and all statues, act of law pertaining to this case.

Issue that should be considered as followed:

1. Is the proposed land use consistent with the U.S. Constitution-Amendment 14.

2. Is the proposed land use consistent with the protection of traditional and customary

practices and rights.

3. Is the proposed land use consistent with the DLNR and UK to enforce public access

controls contained in the Comprehensive Management Plan and Public Access Plan

without rules to establish their legal enforcement authority?

S-21

I-’

a

The above issues are the political questions that are a subject matter in this contested

case.

Kailua Kona,, HI. 9/19/16

Cindy Freitas Petitioner

cc: Parties of Record on the Certificate of Service

2

Exhibit S-22

DOC: 220 Site Visit Proposal

Cindy FreitasP.O. 4650KailuaKonalli [email protected]


FOR THE STATE OF HAWAIi

IN THE MATTER OF 3 Case No. BLNR-CC-i 6-0923

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;) SITE VISIT PROPOSALUse Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the 3Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea 3Science Reserve, K&obe Mauka, Harnakua,)Hawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 ) Certificate of Service

3

SITE V SIT PROPOSAL

I. Introduction

I Cindy Freitas, in the subject matteron the site visit to Mauna A Wakea which is

scheduled for September 26 2016.

I have deep respect for Manna A Wakea and as well for my ancestors before me for

thousands of generation. We are the living Native Hawaiian, descended of the native

inhabitants of Hawai’i.

JEi all due respect 1 cai only disclosed that what moves my na’au to inform you that

the site of the proposed area is many generational of our culture customary traditional

religious practices.

Proposal site visit at the 8.7 acre area were TMT will be built

IL Request

I Cindy Freitas humbly ask for a request for site visit as followed:

Rec&v adOffice of Conservation and Coastal Lands2018 Aug 17 3:55 pmDepatement of Land and Natural Resources

S —22 State of Hawaii

\

1. Indications for the four corners of the 8.7 acres boundary’s. (Red heliumballoon to indicate boundaries).

2. Indications/or out line for a 5,000 gallon underground lank to store hazardouschemicals and the location and a visual debt (red helium balloon indicating thedebt.)[l]

3. Indication ofwere will dynamite would be use on 8.7 acres if any.

4. Indication/or out line that can bold 1,728,000.00 cubic feet of groundmaterial and using a red helium balloon for height that will be coming out of theearth to build this TMT.

HI Conclusion

I Cindy Freitas will be joining all parties on Site Visit proposal under my reserve right

for my culture customary traditional religion practices.

Kaliua Kona HI, August 17, 2016


Cc: Parties of Record (Certificate of Service)

1. Coming from a background ofLicense Masonry Contractors we know underground isa unforeseen sight ofmany recourses and rare endanger species as well as the aquifer.Therefore no one can predict what’s under the ground until the contractors break ground.

ReceivedOffice of Conservation and Coasta’ Lands20i8Aug17 3:55pmDepatement of Ld and Naturat ResourtesState of Hawaii


FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’!

IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR-CC- 16-002)

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;)Use Application (CDUA) IIA-3568 For the )Thirty Meter Telescope at the Manna Kea )Science Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka, Hamakua,)Hawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 ) Certificate of Service

)

CERTIFICATE OP SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that the above referenced document was served uponthe following parties by the means indicated:

Michael Cain Richard L Deleon (lien KilaOCCL kekaukiki ãmsn om nakaktlaügrnat1 om1151 Pwicbbowl,Rm131Hon. HI 96813 Mehana Kihoi Dwight .1. Vicentemichael.cain.hawai.gove uhiwai(2Iive.com 2608 AinaolaDr.Custodian ofRecords Hilo, Hawaiian(original digital copy), C.M. Kaho’okahi Kingdom/mail

KanuhaCarismith Ball LLP KahoQkahi(rnaiLcom Brannon KamabanaIan Sandison9Tim Lui- wan KealohaJohn P. Manaut, Lindsay N. Joseph Kaulil Lindsey bnnnonk(hawaii.eduMeAneeley Camaraisandison(carlsmith.com kualiichoimalcç Cindy Freitasjprn(carlsmhh.com jnhanai@;hawaii.rrcomaneeley4’carlsmith om Torkddson,, Katz,

Counsel for the Applicatit Moore, Hetherinton William PreitasUHH Harris Attn: Lincoln Pohaku 7vahoocorn

S.T. AshidaRichard N. Wurdeman tsa@:torkildson.om Tiffnie KakaliaRNWurdecian(iRNW1aw.com tiffniekakaliagmaiLcomCounsel for the Petitioners 3. Leina’ala Sleightholm Maelani LeeManna Ken Anaina Hou, ieina.ala s808i1 gmat) co maelanikev,ahop tornClarence Kukauakahl ChingFlores-Case, ‘Ohana, Deborah Lanny Alan Sinldn Kaiikolehua Kanacle

ReceivedOffice of Conservation and Coastal Lands2016Mg 17 3:55pmDepaternent of Land and Natural ResourcesState of Hawa

\

\

J. Ward, Paul K. Naves, arid Ianny.sinkin@arnaiLcorn aku1e1evahoo.coml(ahea The Environmental Rep. for The Temple ofLonoAlliance

Stephank4%4aIia: Tabbada Many FergerstromWatanabe Ing LLP stabbada@thawallantcLnct P.O. 951I Douglas Ing, Ross T. TCurdstown HI 96760Summer L Kiawe Wilma FL Holirshinyama.wik.com P.O. Box 368 Ivy Mcintoshding’wikcom Hanapepe, HI 96716 3popokigmail.comTIO Witness List Witness List

Moses Keatamakia Jr. Ciystal F. WestDavid M Loule, ESQ rnkeaarna@ ahoo corn crystaltnxI Qmall cornthn1ksizlavcorn Witness List Witness ListClifford K. Higa, EXQckhksg1aw.corii Patricia P. IkedaNicholas R. Monlux, ESQ [email protected]

Kobayaslai Sugita & Goda LLPSpecial Deputy Attorneys General for AttorneyGeneral Douglas S. Chin The Department ofThe Attorney General., and Deputy AttorneysGeneral in their Capacity as Counsel forThe Board of Land & Natural Resources andHearing Officer

Name (Print):

Date: &/171I

2

ReceivedOffice of Conservation and Coastal Lands2018Aug17 3:55pmDepatement of Land and Natural ResourcesState of Hawaii

\

Exhibit S-23

DOC: 274 Minute Order No. 18

i)oc/ 7-1-

vJJ

BOARD OF LA.N1) AND NATURAL RESOURCES CJ OF OHSEHVATONAN TA. LADS

STATE OF HAWAII

ZOIb SEP jq P Ii: 08

‘.0 &HATUA JUOCES

IN THE MATTER OF ) CASE NO. BLNR-Ch-OO2)

Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation District ) Minute Order No. 18Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the ) (Site Visit to Mauna Kea -

Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea Science ) September 26, 2016)Reserve, Kaohe Mauka, Hamakua, Hawai’i )

TMK (3) 4-4-015:009 )

________________________________________

Certificate of Service

MINUTE ORDER NO.18(Site Visit to Mauna Kea — September 26, 2016)

As noted in Minute Order No. 16 (Third Pre-Hearing Conference), filed on August 23,

2016, there will be a Site Visit to Mauna Kea on Monday, September 26, 2016. The following

documents have been filed in relation to the Site Visit to Mauna Kea:

Doc 214 August 17, 2016 W Freitas Site Visit ProposalDoe 215 August 17, 2016 The University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s

Site Visit DesignationsDoe 216 August 17, 2016 Sleightholm List of Site Visit AttendeesDoe 217 August [7, 2016 TMT International Observatory, LLC’s

Proposal For Site VisitDoc 218 August 17, 2016 Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, Et.

A1.’s Site Visit RecommendationsDoe 219 August 17, 2016 Fergerstrom Correspondence Regarding

Mauna Kea Site VisitDoc 220 August 17, 2016 C Freitas Site Visit ProposalDoe 255 September 9, 2016 Perpetuating Unique Educational

(submitted August 17, 2016) Opportunities, Inc.’s Site VisitDesignation

Doc 260 September 14, 2016 Kihoi Site Visit Proposal(dated August 17, 2016)

S-23

PersonsApprovedfor Site Visit to Mauna Kea on September 26,2016. Based upon a

carefiul review ofthe positions reflected in the documents noted above, the following persons are

approved for the Site Visit:

William FreitasTam Lui-Kwan, Ian L Sandison or John P Manaut (two of three), attorneys for

the University ofHawai’i atHio; three (total) repEesentEtives from theOffice ofManna Kea Management, the Institute for Astronomy or theOffice of the General Counsel

3. Leina’ala Sleightholm and First responder/medical personnel Bimo AkionaDouglas Ing and/or Ross Shinyama, attorneys for TJO; up to two TIO

representativesRichard Wurdeman, attorney for Manna Kea Anaina Hou Petitioners, Kealoha

Pisciotta, Keomailani Van Gogh, Clarence Kukauakahi Chuig, E KalamFlores, Pualani Case, Hawane Rios, Deborah Ward, and Candace Fujikane

Harry FergerstromCindy FreitasLincoln Ashida, attorney for PUEO; Shadd Keahi Warfield, Richard Ha and Bill

BrownMehana Kihoi

Participants are asked to bring photo IDs to verify identification.

Logistics ofSite V&L The Department ofLand and Natural Resources has obtained

transportation for participants; three Aniot’s vans have been hired, one ofwhich will be

designated an emergency vehicle to drive down the mountain if needed. All approved persons

should be at the Hilo Bayfront Soccer Fields prepared to depart at 8:30 a.m. on Monday,

September26, 2016. Here is the schedule:

8:30 am.: Depart from Hilo Bayfront Soccer FIeldsAcclimatization stop at Puu Hulühuiu, 15-20 minutesAcclimatization stop at Visitor Center, 15-20 minutes10:00 a.m;: Proceed to Hale Pobaku and begin site visit2:00 p.m.: Begin descent and return to Hio Bayfront Soccer Fields

2

The Hearing Officer and her party will meet the vans and participants at the Visitor

Center or Hale Pohaku at the start of the Site Visit. Only authorized vans carrying approved

participants will be allowed on the Site Visit. There will be no unscheduled or impromptu stops

unless specifically authorized by the Hearing Officer.

Lunch will be provided for participants. However, participants are advised to brine

their own drinks: e.a. water, iuice soda.

DesignatedSites After considering the recommendations and requests in the documents

noted above and further considering that the purpose ofthe Site Visit is to see first-band the

location and observable impact of the Thirty-Meter Telescope project, the following sites will be

visited on September 26,2016:

The Batch Plant

Proposed Thirty-Meter Telescope Site

) The Sunimit Loop road near the Keck Observatory

> Possibly two or three other sites to be determined by the Hearing Officer as the

visit proceeds

Either the 110 or the UHH is requested to arrange for the illustration using a red helium

balloon attached to a rope approximately 187 feet long.

Recordation. There shall be no recordation ofthe Site Visit except for the media as

permitted under Minute Order No. 10 (Document 65), No court reporter will be present to take a

verbatim record of what is said or to produce transcripts. Notetaking by counsels and parties

using computers or electronic tablets will be allowed.

3

Communication with Hearings Officer. During the Site Visit, counsels and parties

shall have no communication with the Hearing Officer exceptfor directions, explanations and

answers to questions posited by the Hearing Officer.

DATED: Honolulu, Hawai’i, September 19, 2016

(Ret.)

4

BOARD OF LANDAND NATURAL RESOURCES

STATE OF HAWAñ

Contested Case Hearing Re ConservationDistrict Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568for the Thirty Meter Telescope at the MaunaKea Science Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka,Hãmakua, Hawai’i, TMK (3)44-015:009

BLNR Contested Case HA-16-02Document title Minute Order 18 —Site Visit toMauna Kea September26, 2016

CERTiFIcATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that the above referenced document was served upon the followingparties by the means indicated:

Carismith Ball [email protected]@[email protected])carIsmIth.comCounselsfor the applicant UniversityofHawoi? at Hilo

Richard N. [email protected] the petitioners Mauna KeaAnaina Hou, Clarence KukauakahiChing, Flores-Case ‘Ohana, Deborah J.Ward, PaulL Neves, and kohea: TheEnvironmentalAilance

Watanabe Ing [email protected]@wik.comCounsels for TMT InternationalObservatory, LLC

Harry FergerstromP.O. Box 951Kurtistown, HI 96760

Mehana KiholuhiwaiflIve.com

C. M. Kaho’okahi [email protected]

Joseph Kualii Lindsey CamarakuaIiIchotmaiI.com

Torkildson,. Katz, Moore, Hetherlngton& [email protected])torkildson.cpmCounselsfor Perpetuating UniqueEducational Opportunities (PUEO)

1. Leinaala Sleightholmleinaala.maunamail.com

Maelani [email protected]

tanny Alan SinkinIanny.sinklngmaiI.comRepresentativefor The Temple ofLana

Kalikolehua Kanaeleakulete@vahoO corn

Stephanle-Malia:[email protected]

Tiffnie Kakallatiffniekakaliagmail,com

Glen [email protected]

Dwight LVicente2608 Ainaola DriveNib, Hawaiian Kingdom

Brannon Kamahana [email protected]

Cindy [email protected]

William [email protected]

Wilma H. HallP.O. Box 368Hanapepe, HI 96716Witnessfor the Hearing Officer

Ivy McIntosh3ø[email protected] the Hearing Officer

Moses Kealamakia [email protected] the Hearing Officer

Crystal F. [email protected] the Hearing Officer

Patricia P [email protected] the Hearing Officer

Signature:i’7,L...I C——-———

Name : Michael Cain, Custodian of the RecordsDate: September 19, 2016

Exhibit S-24

DOC: 278 Motion To Amend 274 Site Visit ToInclude Request in DOC 220

Cindy FreitasP.O. 4650KaiIua Kona HI 96745hanahanai 1hawaii .rr.com


FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’ I

IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR-CCI6-002)

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;) MOTION TO AMEND DOC 274Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the ) SITE VISIT TO INCLUDE REQUESTThirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea ) IN DOC 220Science Reserve, Kaohe Mauka, Hamakua, )Hawaii TMK(3)4-4-015:009 )

) Certificate of Service

MOTION TO AMEND DOC 274 SITE VISIT TO iNCLUDEREQUEST IN DOC 220

I Cindy Freitas. “Petitioner, hereby Motion to Amend DOC 274 Site Visit to Include

Request in DOC 220. (hese request are very pertinent to the contested case hearing.

1, Indication for the four corners of the 8.7 acres boundary’s (Red helium balloon toIndicate boundaries.)

2. Indications/or out line for a 5.000 gallon underground tank to store hazardousChemicals and the location and a visual debt (red helium balloon indicating theDebt) [1]

3. Indication of where will dynamite would be use on 8.7 acres if any,

4. Indication/or out line that can hold 1 .728.000.00 cubic feet of ground material andUsing a red helium balloon br height that will be coming out of the earth to buildThis proposed TMT.

5. Private vehicle will be used to undo hardship and I will be riding with WilliamFreitas and his Driver Walter Wong.

ReceivedOffice of Conseivation and Coastal Lands2016 Sept21 245 pmDepaternent of Land and Natural RCSOL1rCCS

State of Hawaii

Kailua Kona HI. September 21, 2016

Cindy Freiias Petitioner

Cc: Parties of Records Certificate of Service

1. Coming from a background of License Masonry Contractors we know undergroundis a unforeseen sight of many recourses and rare endanger species as well as the aquifer.Therefore no one can predict what’s under the ground until the contractors hrea[ ground.

BOARD OF LAND ANI) NATURAL RESOURCES


JN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR-CC-16-002

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;)Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the )Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna KeaScience Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka, Hamakua, )Hawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 ) Certificate of Service

)



Michael Cain Richatd L Deleon Glen KilaOCCL kekaukikiimsn.com rnakakilaijimaiLcom1151 Punehbowl, Rm 131Hon. HI 96813 Mehana Kihoi Dwight 3. Vicenten,ichaeLcain&hawaii,ovc uhiwaicilivecorn 2608 Ainaola Dr.Custodian of Records Hilo. Hawaiian(original digital copy). C.M. Kaho’okahi Kingdom/mail

KanuhaCarismith Ball LLP KahookahirdrnaiLcom Brannon KamahanaIan Sandison1Tim Lui-Kwan KealohaJohn P Manaut Lindsay N Joseph Kaulii Lrndse hrdnnonk a hatti LduMcAneeiey Camaraisandisoni/earIsrnitlteom kualiic’ahotirijhcoi Cindy Freitasj.prniearlsrnith.com ahanaihawai i.rr.com

neeley acarlsmith,cm Torkildson, Katz,Counsel for the Applicatit Moore, Hetherington William FreitasUHH Harris Attn: Lincoln Pohaku 7dvahoo.coni

S.T. AshidaRichard N. Wurdeman lsa’titorkildson.com Tiffnic KakaliaRNWurdeniRNWla%.com tffnekakaiaasmaiLcomCounsel for the Petitioners 3. Lein&ala Sleightholm Maelani LeeMauna Kea Anarna Hou, IjLlis88ct’njIk.om rnIel9mlL a ‘,ahoo omClarence Kukauakahi ChingFlores-Case, ‘Ohana. Deborah Lanny Alan Sinkin Kalikoiehua Kanaele

3, Ward, Paul K. Naves, and lanisinkintginjj.cotjj akuleledahoo.comKahea: The Environmental Rep. for The Temple of LonoAlliance

Stephanie-Malia: Tabbada Harry FergerstromWatanabe big Lii’ s,tahhadahawaiiancjjiet P0. 9513. Douglas Ing, Ross T. Kurtistown, HI 96760Summer H. Kiawe Wilma H. Ilollrsjjjtnjvik.c P.O. Box 368 Ivy Mcintosh

Hanapepe. HI 96716 3popokigmaiLcomTIO Witness List Witness List

Moses Kealaniakia Jr. Crystal F. WestDavid M Louie, ESQ rnkea1amavahoocom crstal inxLurnai corndrnlksglaw.c2 Witness List Witness ListClifford K. Higa, EXQchIkgiaw.com Patricia P. [kedaNicholas R. Monlux, ESQ jj1eakeaniIw4gmall.cornnrniksjawcon

Kobayashi Sugita & Goda LU?Special Deputy Attorneys General for AttorneyGeneral Douglas S. Chin The Department ofThe Attorney GeneraL and Deputy AttorneysGeneral in their Capacity as Counsel forThe Board of Land & Natural Resources andHearing Officer

Signatur

Name (Print): ‘

\Date:

2

Exhibit S-25

DOC: 290 Objection To September 26, 2016 SiteVisit On Mauna Kea

OCF 9O

Cindy FreitasP.O. 4650Kailua Kona HI 96745hanahanaiã.hawaii, rr.corn



IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNR-CC- 16-002

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation:)Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 For the ) OBJECTION TOThirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea ) SEPTEMBER 26, 2016 SITE VISITScience Reserve. Ka’ohe Mauka. Haniakua. ) ON MAUNA KEA; CERTIFICATEHawai’i TMK(3)4-4-015:009 ) OF SERVICE

OBJECTION TOSEPTEMBER 26 2016 SITE VISIT ON MAUNA KEA

On September 19. 2016 Minute Order No. 1 8 [DOC 274] was tiled. The tiling stated

the following documents ol the Site Visit Proposal was tiled and granted [DOC 214, 215,

216. 217. 218, 219. 220. 255. and 2601 and approved the following person in the DOC

274 for site visit and a requested to arrange for the illustration using a red helium balloon

attached to a rope approximately 1 87 feet long was confirmed in DOC 274. But yet other

parties have requested toillustrate other red helium balloon in other areas of the proposed

TMT site. Neither there were no other illustrate red helium balloon that was requested by

other parties nor were there any clarification in any way or form on any minute order.

This red helium balloon would have illustrated the impact were the location of the TMT

proposed telescope would he and also the 5.000 tanks that will he stored underground as

well as the amount of material that will he unearth.ReceivedOffice ot Consei”ation and Coastal Lands2016 Sept27 47 amDepaternent of Land and Natural Resources

S—25

Therefore Minute order no. 18 violates the Due Process Rights of Cindy Freitas,

‘Petitioner” and other parties that submitted their proposal to Site Visit.

Site Visit on Mauna Ken was completely inadequate. I have requested in DOC 220’

Site Visit proposal and in DOC 278 Motion to Amend DOC 274 to include request in

D()C 220. Request as followed:

Indication for the four corners of the 8.7 acres boundary’s (Red helium balloon toIndicate boundaries.)

2. Indications/or out line [hr a 000 gallon underground tank to store hazardousChemicals and the location and a visual debt (red helium balloon indicatingThe debt.)

3. Indication of where will dynamite would be use on 8.7 acres if any.

4. lndication!or out line that can hold I .728,000.0() cubic ted of ground material andUsing a red helium balloon for height that will be coming out of the earth to buildThis proposed TMT.

The Site Visit on September 26. 2016 at 10:30 n.m. was done in a “fast track” order.

I sat in the van and cried while we pass the AHU SITE (a place of worship) and I was

told by the driver he was instructed that no one can come out of the van nor I could view

the rope that holds the helium balloon, it did not seem to be a 1 87 feet it seems to be

much shorter.

The Driver drove the van to the TMT proposed location and then to the summit loop

road near the Keck Ohsevatory and to the Batch plant’ were we could go out and use the

bathroom and back into the van and back down to Hale Pohaku. It only lasted less than 2

hours.

Petitioner could not follow my own protocol in my culture and traditional and religion

practices. Therefore the right of my culture and traditional and religion practices as a

practitioner is violated. The Scared Mountain of Mauna Kea is not to ‘fasi track it there

is proper protocols that need to be address. The Hearing Officer had the opportunity first

hand to observed in the spiritual and tradition funeticn of the important of this significant

impact of this TMT hut yet did not give the Petitioner the opportunity to see the

significant impact that will cause a substantial injustice and also the emotional and

psychological of our culture and traditional and religion practices as a Native Hawaiian,

descended of the native inhabitants of Hawai’i prior to 1778.

Therefore the right of my culture and traditional and religion practices as a practitioner is

violated, The Scared Mountain of Manna Kea is not to “fast tracks’ it there is proper

protocols that needs to he address and that the Hearing Officer had the opportunity.

My request in the DOC 220 and DOC 278 was not address therefore the contested case

hearing has violated my Due Process Right and the right of my culture and traditional

religion practices therfore this objection to the site visit on September 26, 2016 has

shown good cause to be granted.

Kailua KonaHl.,,]7/27J/fr

6 — -


Cc: All Parties on the Certificate of Service

3


FOR THE STATE OF HAWAPI

IN THE MATTER OF ) Case No. BLNRCC-I6-002)

A Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation;)Use Application (CDUA) FIA-3568 For the )Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea )Science Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka, Hamakua, )Hawai i TMK(3 )4-4-0 15:009 ) Certificate of Service

))



Michael Cain Richard L Deleon Glen KilaOCCL jukik a pkikiJau grnal con1151 Punchbowl, Rm131Hon. HI 96813 Mehana Kihoi Dwight 3. VicentemichaeL in hawwi.zove uhiwai•’ali e.com 2608 Ainaola Dr.Custodian of Records Kilo, Hawaiian(original digital copy), C.M. Kahookahi Kingdom/mail

KanuhaCarismith Ball LLP KahookahigmaiLcom Brannon KamahanaIan Sandison Tim Lui-Kwan KealohaJohn P Manaut Lindsay N Joseph Kauhi Lmdse’ hrpa hm an cduMcAneeley CamaralsandI%on a carkmith corn h&hm[cn Cindy Freitasjp(Li;earlsmithcorn , jnai iihawiiirr.corn

Torkildson, Katz,Counsel for the Applicanf Moore, Hetherington William FreitasUHH Harris Attn: Lincoln Pohaku 7vahao.corn

S.T. AshidaRichard N. Wurdeman lsacitorkildson.corn Tiffnie KakaliaRNWurdernanRNWla corn tffiuiekakaUagrnaiLcomCounsel for the Petitioners 3. Lein&ala Sleightholrn Maelani LeeMauna Kea Anarna Hou, kjji&jLi s808g,,.gpnil corn rnielanik. a ihoo cornClarence Kukauakahi ChingFlores-Case, ‘Ohana. Deborah Lanny Alan Sinkin Kaiikolehua Kanaele

0

J. Ward, Paul K. Naves, andKahea: The EnvironmentalAlliance

Iannv.srnkin’ugmaiIcornRep. for The Temple of Lono

akule Tei. ahoo.corn

Watanabe Ing liPJ. Douglas Ing, Ross T.Summer H. Kiawe

Iii nani a i k .cdoini.tc ik ,Cjfl

TTO

Stephanie-Malia: Tabbadas.tabbadaâhawaiiantcl,net

Wilma H. 1-lollP.O. Box 368Hanapepe. HI 96716Witness List

Harry FergerstromP.O. 951Kurtistown, HI 96760

Ivy Mcintosh3popokigmail .comWitness List

David M Loule, ESQdrnVcLkseIaw.comClifford K. Higa, EXQ

Nicholas R. Monlux, ESQnrrnjLksgla% .com

Moses Keatamakia .Jr.mkealamaàvahoocornWitness List

Patricia P. Ikedapeheakeani ladirnai I corn

Crystal F. Westcr stalinxa ,iniail,comWitness List

Kobayashi Sugita & Goda LLPSpecial Deputy Attorneys General for AttorneyGeneral Douglas S. Chin The Department ofThe Attorney General, and Deputy AttorneysGeneral in their Capacity as Counsel forThe Board of Land & Natural Resources andHearing Officer

‘

Signature: ---\ -1:::

Name (Print): NDate:


STATE OF HAWAI

Contested Case Hearing Re Conservation BLNR contested Case HA46-02District Use Application (CDUA) HA3568 Document title:for the Thirty Meter Telescope at the MaunaKea Science Reserve, Ka’ohe Mauka,Hãmakua, Hawai’i, TMK (3) 4-4-015:009


The undersigned hereby certifies that the above referenced document was served upon the followingparties by the means indicated on October 1O 2016:

Carismith Ball LLP Harry Fergerstrom Tiffnie l([email protected] PC. Box 951 tiffniekakalia@gmaiLcomtIuikwan@carismithcom I<urtistown, HI [email protected] Glen [email protected] Mehana Kihoi [email protected] for the applicant University [email protected] Hawai7 at Hilo Dwight i. Vicente

C. M. Kahookahi Kanuha 2608 Ainaola DriveKealoha Pisciotta and Mauna kea [email protected] Hilo, Hawaiian.KingdomAnaina [email protected] Joseph Kuaiii Lindsey Camara Brannon Kamahana Kealoha

kualiic@hptmaiLcon, [email protected] Kukauakahi [email protected] Torkildson, Katz, Moore, Hetherington Cindy Freitas

& Hams [email protected] Kalani Flares [email protected]@hawaiiantel.net [email protected] William Freitas

Counsels for Perpetuating Unique pohaku 7@yahoocomB. Pualani Case Educational Opportunities (PUEO)[email protected] Wilma H. Hall

i. L.einaala Sleightholm P. 0, Box 368Deborah). Ward [email protected] Hanapepe, HI 96716cordyiinecolor@gmaiLcom Witness for the Hearing Officer

Maelani LeePaul K, Neves [email protected] Ivy [email protected] [email protected]

Lanny Alan Sinkin Witness for the Hearing OfficerKahea: The Environmental Alliance ianny.sinkingmail.comco. Bianca lsaki Representative for The Temple of Lana Moses Kealamakia [email protected] [email protected]

Kalikoiehua Kanaeie Witness for the Hearing OfficerWatanabe Ing LLP [email protected] Patricia P. [email protected] Stephanie-Malia:Tabbada [email protected] for TMT international [email protected] Witness for the Hearing OfficerObservatory, LLC

VURLIN ALULI415-C Uluniu StreetKailua, Hawai 96734Tel. (808) 262-59001428emaiJ yuklin@kaIualaw cornDexter K. Kaiama 4249111 Hekili Street, #A 1607Kailua, Hawaii 96734Tel. (808) 284-5675email; cdexk@f,otrnail cornCo-Counsel for PetitionerKAHEA The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance.a domestic non-prof,t Corporation

Signature- £2_.iEE2&r’—. T,c,NameDate:

BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’I IN THE MATTER OF CINDY … ·...

Documents

Transcript of BOARD OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES FOR THE STATE OF HAWAI’I IN THE MATTER OF CINDY … ·...