Blue Hen Investment Club · 2017-12-23 · Labor Force The unemployment rate has improved...

13
Q3 Report Blue Hen Investment Club 07/01/2016 – 09/30/2016

Transcript of Blue Hen Investment Club · 2017-12-23 · Labor Force The unemployment rate has improved...

Q3 Report

Blue Hen

Investment Club

07/01/2016 – 09/30/2016

LaborForce

Theunemploymentratehasimproveddrasticallyoverthelastfewyears,currentlysittingwellbelowits2yearaverageof5.4%,andinlinewithits1yaverageof4.9%.Medianweeklyearningsincreased2.9%overthelastyear,andsalariesareup2.5%overtheyear.Atfacevalue,thisdatasupportstheideathattheAmericaneconomyisslowly improving,andthatQEmayhavepaidoff.ThemajorhindrancetoacurrentratehikestemsfromstagnantinflationwhichhasyettoreachtheFed’s2%annualtargetrate.

InterestRates

MarketCommentary

4.8

4.85

4.9

4.95

5

5.05

62.262.362.462.562.662.762.862.963

63.1

LaborPartcipation UnemploymentRate

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

EffectiveFederalFundsRate FederalFunds(UpperTarget) US10y

TheUS10yisdownsignificantlyfromits2yaverageof2.1and1yaverageof1.8,whichmaybeevidentofalongerterminflowtogovernmentbondsresultingfromtheFed’slackofactionregardingmonetarynormalization.However, the runup fromMay toSeptember could signal investor’sunwillingness toinvestinthelongendofthecurve.Thisunwillingnessismostlikelydrivenbyconcernregardingshorttermuncertainty.CorporateDebtMarkets

Thechartaboveisevidentofayield-starvedinvestmentclimate.TheInvestmentGradeindexappreciatedonly.7%overtheperiod,whiletheHighYieldindexsawahealthy5.6%increaseinthesameamountoftime.Rightnow,thesekindsofbondsareextremelyattractiveto investors,giventheirrelativelyhighyields(IG–3.4%;HY–6.4%).

OilMarket

145

146

147

148

149

1060

1080

1100

1120

1140

1160

1180

HighYieldIndex InvestmentGradeIndex

42

44

46

48

50

52

54

56

WTISpot

Oilpriceshavestabilized.Therecoveryhaslargelybeendrivenbypoliticalpricecontrol,stagnantgrowthinthedollar,andsupplyreduction.Itisimportanttonoteoil’srelationshiptoinflation.Movingforward,whatever happens to the price of oil, inflation could be at risk of helping or hurting the currentmacroeconomiccondition.Withstagnantoilprices,inflationwillnotapproachaninflectionpoint.Ifoilmoveshigherthrough2016into2017,inflationmayincrease,supportingtheratehikeargument.USDollarIndex

WhileQ3markedarelativelystableperiodfortheUSD,theSeptember2017USDFuturesIndeximpliesmonetarynormalizationtorampupinthecomingyears.ThetailendofthequartersawtheUSDspotgrowover3%intheSeptember.Analystscontinuetonotethatarisingdollarmaydepresscorporateearnings,especiallyifglobalmonetarypoliciesstaysdovish.ThisdivergentmonetarypolicymayforcetheFedtostayaccommodative.EquityMarkets

92

93

94

95

96

97

98

USDSpot

1919.219.419.619.82020.220.420.620.8

2020204020602080210021202140216021802200

ClosingPrice PriceEarningsRatio

Q3markedaflatperiodforU.Sequityindices.TheS&P500currentlytradesatabout20xearning,aboutanaveragevaluationcomparedtoa19.8xtrailing5-yearmultiple.Thisslightovervaluationmayjustbeamanifestationofthenewlong-termlowrateenvironment.ThirdQuarterCorporateEarnings

Onaweighted-averageEPSbasis,earningsinthepastthreequartershavebeenpositivelyaffectedbyamassiveexpansioninHealthcare’sbottomline,growingat7.5%YTD.Conversely,theseearningshavebeenhurtbywaningTelecomearnings,marginallydecliningConsumerDiscretionaryearnings,andthemassivedropinEnergysectorearningsofmorethan9%YTD.

BHICvs.S&P500SectorReturn

ThirdQuarter–

PortfolioPerformanceandCommentary

-20246

ComparisontoSPXover3Q2016

BHICTotalReturn SP500TotalReturn

222324252627282930

Q22015 Q32015 Q42015 Q12016 Q22016 Q32016

WeightedEstimatedEarnings TrailingWeightedEPS

TheBHICportfoliocloselytracedtheS&P500overQ3.Movingforward,ournewly-adoptedbenchmarkapproach should change this lack of deviation. More emphasis on security analysis and subsectorallocationscombinedwithacommitmenttoreducethenumberofholdingsshouldfurtherincreaseourtrackingerror.Thesetwofactorscombinedshouldreallocateportfoliorisk,andleadtobetterreturns.

YeartoDate–

The BHIC portfolio underperformed the benchmark YTD 2016, due primarily to underperformanceamongsectorsincludingEnergy,Materials,andIndustrials.Thebenchmarkhasreturned~8%,whiletheportfolioreturned~4%.SectorContributiontoTotalReturnThirdQuarter–

ComparedtotheS&P500,theBHICportfolio’sFinancials,RealEstate,Telecomm,andUtilitiessectorsoutperformed.Mostoftheoutperformanceinthesesectorswasattributabletolossavoidance.BystayingoutofTelecomm,our IT/Telecommsectorwasabletoadd.2%totheportfolio.Theportfoliodidnot

-15

-10

-5

0

5

10

12/31/15 1/31/16 2/29/16 3/31/16 4/30/16 5/31/16 6/30/16 7/31/16 8/31/16 9/30/16

ComparisontoSPXYTD2016

BHICTotalReturn SP500TotalReturn

-10.00-5.00

--5.0010.0015.00

BHICvs.SPXSectorContributions

BHICTotalReturn SP500TotalReturn

drasticallyoutpacetheindexbecauseoflackofinvestmentinMaterialsandpoorselectioneffectfromwithin Consumer Staples, Discretionary, Healthcare, and Energy. The portfolio saw large single-stockappreciationfromnamesincludingHealthcareTrustofAmerica,BankofAmerica,Intel,Cisco,andApple.

BHICvs.S&P500YTDSectorPerformance

YeartoDate–

TheselectioneffectalsohurtusonaYTDbasis.PositionsinEnergy,ConsumerDiscretionary,Healthcare,Industrials,MaterialsandTelecommwerethestandoutmisallocations.

ConsumerDiscretionary

-10.00-5.00

--5.0010.0015.0020.00

BHICvsSPXSectorContributionsYTD2016

BHICTotalReturn SP500TotalReturn

SectorRecap&InvestmentHighlights

90

95

100

105

110

115

120

6/30/16 7/30/16 8/29/16 9/28/16

S5CONDIndex SPXIndex GNTXUSEquity

SectorPerformanceOverview

Consumer Discretionary marginally trailed the S&P over Q3. The sector started Q3 with strongperformance following beneficial macroeconomic data including surprisingly strong jobs. The sharppullback aroundSeptember9thwasdue to adecrease inpayrolls, global concerns around currencydevaluation,andfearstemmingfromwaninggrowthinAsia.Therecentuptickinglobalsystematicriskmaybeenoughforinvestorstopulloutofthishistoricallymoreriskysector.

SectorHighlight

Afteraslowstarttothequarter,Gentexwentontoconsiderablyoutperform.TheimprovementwasadirectresultofafavorableQ3earningsreportreleasedonJuly22.Gentexannounceda12%quarter-over-quarter increase in sales and a 1% boost in gross profits. The rise in revenue stemmed fromincreasedauto-dimmingmirrorshipmentsandanincreaseinlightvehicleautoproduction.Thesegainswere further sustained by rebounding car sales in Europe. The fund capitalized on Gentex’s recentoutperformance,andliquidatedthepositionforanoverallreturnof23%.

Energy&Utilities

SectorPerformanceOverview

TheEnergySectorperformedpoorly inQ3.Froma subsectorperspective,drilling&explorationandintegratedcompaniesobservedabriefrebound,giventhepositiveOPECdecisioninearlyOctober.Theagreementwastopreliminarilyhaltproductionanddecreasethedailyoutputbyslightlyoveramillionbarrelsperdayfromtrendingaverages.WTIpricesrealizedamodestgainasthenewsbecamepublic,butoverallthepriceofabarrelofcrudehasremainedunderthe$50threshold.

SectorHighlight

HollyFrontier isarelativelysmallplayercomparedto itsGulfCoastpeers,however, itsrefineriesarecompetitively positioned.HollyFrontier is the largest independent refiner that has all of its facilitieslocatedintheRockiesandSouthwestregion.Asaresult,ithasbenefitedfromthedifferenceinpricebetweenWestTexasIntermediateandotherhigh-qualitywaterbornecrudesuchasBrentoverthethirdquarter.WithaccesstoabundantsuppliesofWTI,HollyFrontierrefineriesleveragedthemarginthatthe

9095

100105110115120

6/30/2016 7/30/2016 8/29/2016 9/28/2016

S5ENRSIndex SPXIndex HFCUSEquity

spreadoffered.Howeverasthequarterconcluded,elevatedcrudeinventoriesandoversupplyweighedinonthecompany’svaluationasinvestorssoldshares.

Financials&RealEstate

SectorPerformanceOverviewFollowingBrexit,theFinancialssectorregainedmostof itspreviouslyexperiencedlosses. ValuationsweresupportedbytheFed’scontinuedaccommodativepolicyaswellaspositivestresstestresultswhichsawmostbankspasstheFed’stest.WhilecommercialbankingispoisedtobenefitfromaFedratehike,thenewlydivestedREITsectorwouldbeimpactednegatively.Movingforward,theFOMCmeetinginDecemberandanymajoreventsinvolvingtheUK’ssecessionfromtheEUwillhelpdefineadirectionforfinancialcompaniesinthenearfuture.

SectorHighlight

EvercorePartnersmanagedtooutperformtheS&P500,aswellasalltheotherfinancialsubsectorsthisquarter.Thestocksawa17%increaseinprice,comparedto3%fortheS&P500and4%fortheFinancialsSectorIndex.Themainreasonforitsoutperformancewasduetothecompany’sQ2Earningsreport,inwhichthecompanymanagedtosurpassearningsbyover10%aswellasrevenuebycloseto6%duetoincreaseddealvolumeandnormalizationafterBrexit.

9095

100105110115120125

EVRUSEquity SPXIndex S5FINLIndex

Industrials&Materials

SectorPerformanceOverview

TheIndustrialssectorindextrackedtheS&Pfortheperiod,endinginlinewiththebenchmark.Frommid-August onwards, the sector traded down on interest-rate-increase speculation. New York FedPresidentWilliamDudleystokedthisfearbysuggestingborrowingcostscouldbeboostedassoonasOctober. The strong U.S. dollar continues to be a major headwind for many industrial companies.Overseas demand for US manufactured machinery continues to feel pressure with lagging worldeconomicgrowthforecasts.Asianeconomichealthcomesasaprimaryconcernformachinery,astheyrepresentalargepartofthemarket.

SectorHighlight

Acuityoutperformed the sector, asmanagement continued to invest inareaswith significant futuregrowthpotential.Byexpandingtheirdigitallightingandbuildingmanagementsolutionsportfolio,theyarebuildingabackboneforadditionalInternetofThings(IoT)applications.Digitallightingisexpectedtoshowstronggrowthasconnected lighting isbecomingacommon industrytheme.DuringtheperiodAquity acquired the IoT application platform, Dglogik, further illustrating this grow strategy. Aquitymissedearningsduringtheperiod,resultingfromaone-timecostrelatedtostreamliningtheirsupplychain,andclosingmanufacturinglocationaheadofschedule.Thisactionresultedinshort-termlaborissues,causingalossofnetsalesequalto$25M.Netsalesforthequarterwerearecord$926M(+21.9%Y/Y),missingby$22.7M.

90

95

100

105

110

115

7/1/2016 7/15/2016 7/29/2016 8/12/2016 8/26/2016 9/9/2016 9/23/2016

S5INDUIndex SPXIndex AYIUSEquity

Healthcare

SectorPerformanceOverviewBoththepresidentialelectionandcongressionalelectionswillhavesignificantimplicationsonthefateofTheAffordableCareAct,aswellas taxes levieduponthepharmaceutical space.ShouldSecretaryClintonbe elected, biotechnology companies such asRoche,Amgen, andAbbViemay suffermarginpressuresfromtheFDA’sbiosimiliarpathway.Medicaldevicesmanufacturerscontinuetorebelagainstthe2.3%excisetaximposedviaObamacare.TheHousepassedlegislationin2015torepealObamacare;thebillcurrentlysitsintheSenate.DeviceproviderssuchasMedtronic,Johnson&Johnson,andThermoFisher Scientificwould seemarginboosts across theboard should the legislationpass.Obamacare’staxationonnamebranddrugswilltop$4.1billionby2018,affectingpharmaceuticalcompanieswithexposuresuchasGilead,Amgen,andPfizer.Congresspassedbudgetreconciliationlegislationtorepealmanyofthetaxmeasuresagainstthehealthcareindustry,butthebillwasvetoedbyPresidentObama.ShouldtheNovemberelectionsplaceRepublicansinboththepresidencyandCongress,suchlegislationcouldbeenactedby2017.SectorHighlight

Icon PLC significantly outperformed the S&P500 Index despite the bearish overall outlook on thehealthcaresector.IconcontinuestoseerobusttoplinegrowthduetorenewedcontractswithPfizer.Thefirm’scompetitiveadvantagecontinuestobeafunctionof its fullscopeofserviceofferingsandinternationalreach.Inaddition,thecompany’spartnershipwithIBMWatsonlendsthemuniqueaccesstohighpowerdataprocessingandanalytics, agrowingnecessity in the clinical trialprocess.Capitaldeploymenthascentralizedaroundbolt-on,M&A,andsharerepurchases.Q3earningsestimatestargetrevenueof$1.6millionwithmodestmargingrowth.

90

95

100

105

110

115

7/5/2016 8/4/2016 9/3/2016

S5HLTHIndex SPXIndex ICLRUSEquity

InformationTechnology&Telecommunications

SectorPerformanceOverview

TheITindexsignificantlyoutperformedtheS&Pfortheperiod.TheinitialdropinvaluationswastheculminationofglobalconcernscombinedwithweakperformanceofAsianmarkets.HoweverfollowingtheSeptembercorrection,techwasabletorally,ledmostlybyApple’sreleaseoftheiPhone7.

SectorHighlight

ApplesignificantlyoutperformedthesectorduringQ3,mostlyduetothereleaseoftheiPhone7andSamsung’sGalaxyissues.Samsungwasforcedtodroptheproductentirelyafterthefirstroundofrecalls,becausethephonescontinuedtoexplode.TherearenoofficialnumbersforiPhone7sales,butsuppliershavehintedthattheycouldbeintherangeof70Mto75Minthefirstmonthand100Mbyyearend.

ConsumerStaples

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

AAPLUSEquity SPXIndex S5INFTIndex

90

95

100

105

7/1/2016 7/31/2016 8/30/2016 9/29/2016Walmart XLP SPX

SectorPerformanceOverviewAfterslightlyoutperformingtheS&PinQ2,theConsumerStaplesIndexwasbeatenbytheS&P500inQ3.Thetwoindexesbegantodivergeinthesecondweekofthequarter,andXLPneverwasabletoclosethegapbetweenthetwofortheremainderofthequarter. Both indexesremainedflatduringAugust.ThisuneventfulquartercouldbeduetothedisappointingjobsreportonSeptember2nd,aswellasthelackofstrongdirectionregardingtheUSeconomy.

SectorHighlight

AlthoughWalmartInc.(WMT)underperformedtheS&PinQ3, itslightlyoutperformedthesector. Inearly July, the stockdroppedas employee’sprotestedat someof their stores inChinaandanalystsbecameskepticalofWalmart’snewpaymentapp.InlateAugust,thestockexperiencedvolatilityamidnewsoftheacquisitionofJet.com,aswellasWarrenBuffet’sdecisiontosellhispositioninWMT.

WeexpectWalmarttospendmuchofthenextfiscalyearworkingonthequalityoftheirstoresratherthanincreasingvolume.ThisstrategymayhelpboosttheirSameStoreSalesfiguresinQ4.WhiletheirrevenueoutlookfortherestofQ4andmostof2017isrelativelyflat,theymayhavealowerprofitmarginduetolastyear’semployeewageincreases.