Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually...

88

Transcript of Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually...

Page 1: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately
Page 2: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilms: The Expanding Threat & How to Win

Wava Truscott PhD. MBA. [email protected]

Page 3: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Disclosure statement

Wava Truscott PhD, MBA▪ I have nothing relevant to this topic to disclose

Page 4: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Learning Objectives:

▪ Explain the advantages of being a member of a biofilm rather than a lone bacterium

▪ Describe the unique opportunities for biofilm success created by the presence of implants

▪ Identify how surgical staff can reduce the opportunities for biofilm formation

▪ Communicate what’s new discoveries in the world of treating biofilm infections

Page 5: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilm Overview

Page 6: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilm….

▪ Survival mechanism for bacteria

▪ Bacteria attach to surfaces, substrates, and each other forming communities within a tough gel-like coating: the matrix

− bacteria function together as a community

− growth rate and specific gene transcriptions are altered

− share genetic information/capability with bacteria in the community

− 50-5,000X more resistant to antimicrobials than free living bacteria

6

Page 7: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Good: Harnessing Biofilms

▪ Water treatment – tremendous benefit (biological pre-treatment)

▪ Decay of dead plants and animals enabling reuse of their elements

▪ Cleanup oil & gasoline spills (bioremediation)

▪ Soil or aquifer clean up of contaminates

▪ Bio-leaching: 10 – 20% of copper mined in US extracted from low grade ore with biofilm help

▪ Microbial fuel cells to generate electricity from complex organic waste and renewable biomass

7

Page 8: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Bad Biofilms: Harm Industry & Man

▪ Swamp Coolers

▪ Water pipes Legionella

▪ Cooled air filtration

▪ Poor manufacturing maintenance

▪ Poor housekeeping

Page 9: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Impede Optimal Function

▪ Navy: Biofilm & barnacles slow ships about 10%

▪ Up to 40% increase in fuel consumption

▪ Hull BUG: Underwater robot scrubs hull to:

− increase ship speed

− reduce fuel costs

− reduce down-time in dry dock

− reduced hull damage

9

Page 10: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

10

Contact Lenses

▪ Biofilm on lens case, contaminates lenses

▪ Crystal violet used to show biofilm

▪ Can cause mild to severe eye infections

Page 11: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Examples: Biofilms In Healthcare

Page 12: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Our Largest “good-guy” Biofilm

Colon Goblet Cells: Red Colon Villi

Colon VilliBottom layer thick, sluggish, protective

Top layer more fluid; full of symbiotic bacteria: biofilm of ~100 trillion bacteria of ~500 species

Vereecke, 2012

12

Page 13: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilms Associated With Infections

Subdivided into two main categories. Those that:

▪ Form on host tissues (epithelia, mucosal surfaces, teeth, etc.).

▪ Colonize abiotic surfaces such as indwelling medical devices (catheters, implanted prostheses, heart valves, ET tubes, etc.)

Page 14: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilm Infections

▪ Sinusitis

▪ Tonsillitis

▪ Clostridium difficile

14

Page 15: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

15

Dental Disease

▪ Biofilm on the teeth is called dental plaque

1mm3 mature dental plaque contains > 108 bacteria!100,000,000 bacteria per cubic millimeter!

Page 16: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilm Progression▪ 48 hours after a good tooth brushing

▪ Dental biofilm (plaque) is mature

▪ Waste from biofilm bacteria cause gingivitis = inflammation of gums: will destroy healthy tissue

− And that food for expanding biofilm colonies into the gums

▪ 72 hours, protective crystals (calcium + phosphate = calculus, tartar)

− Only remove with hygienist’s pick

16

Page 17: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

17

Cystic Fibrosis

▪ Thick mucus perfect for biofilm formation

− 1 in 2,000 Caucasian births

Page 18: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

From Acute To Biofilm Infections: Need New Diagnostics, Prevention, Treatments

Until mid 20th CenturyAcute Infections caused hundreds of millions of deaths (tetanus, diphtheria, cholera, bubonic plague) until the new era of antibiotics that progressively conquered most acute infections

Batoni, Maisetta, Esin 2016

After mid 20th CenturyInfections characterized as alternating active symptomatic acute phases with quieter chronic phases refractive to antibiotics and causing disease by ill-defined mechanisms

Page 19: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

More Diabetes With Aging Population,Food Choices, Obesity, Lack of Exercise

Role of diabetes:

▪ Impaired blood access: − blood glucose damages vessel walls

− fewer immune cells access to wound

− RBC impaired oxygen release – reducing quality of healing

− reducing PMN oxygen burst potency

− stiffened cell membranes impair diapedesis (movement through blood vessel to injury)

Page 20: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

The Increasingly Modern Medicine Brings New Hope and More Threats

Page 21: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

21

Vascular Catheters

▪ 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually

▪ > 5% infections

▪ >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI)

▪ Approximately 20% attributable death rate

Cirioni O J Infect Dis 2006;193:180-186; CDC MMRW 2002;10:1-28

Page 22: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilm On Septum of Needless ConnectorEmphasizing The Must Do: To “Scrub The Hub”

Page 23: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

23

Vastly Increasing Threat: Implant Associated Biofilms

▪ Tissue surrounding implants-reduced blood vessels so:

− fewer white blood cells delivered to implant surface

− less antibiotics and other drugs delivered

▪ White blood cells that do make it there have:

− reduced ability to capture bacteria

− reduced ability to kill bacteria

− damage tissues surrounding implant providing:

• additional organic food source for biofilm

• creates damaged areas great for “outpost biofilm reservoirs”

▪ Unfortunately, antibiotic resistance is occurring just as just as our incoming patient population is increasingly vulnerable to infection

Page 24: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

24

Keeping Things Straight

▪ Pins, screws, wires

Page 25: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

25

So Vulnerable

• Stringent adherence to antiseptic regimens

Page 26: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

26

So Vulnerable

Page 27: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

27

Restoring Function – Relieving Pain

Page 28: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

28

Biofilm Formed On Implants Both Hands

▪ Implants in both hands acquired biofilm infection

▪ Implants had to be removed; all bacteria killed before new implants

Page 29: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

29

Foiled Immune ResponseTo Biofilm Forming On Implant Surface

Frustrated white blood cells spit out their oxygen burst that doesn’t phase the biofilm but instead hurts healthy surrounding tissue making food debris and hiding places to start off-shoot biofilms in the surrounding tissues

Page 30: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

▪ Osteomyelitis Secondary to biofilm on implant to stabilizers

▪ Predisposing:

− open fractures

− internal fixation devices

− prosthetic implant devices

− chronic soft tissue infection (secondary to implant biofilm as bacteria “burrow” into surrounding soft tissue: form biofilm pathogen reservoirs)

▪ Multiple organisms but S. aureus and S. epidermidis most prevalent

Osteomyelitis

Page 31: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilms LOVE Implants

Stent

Heart Valve

Plate & Screws

TreatedSpacers

Page 32: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

32

Dr William Costerton coined the term & delved into “Biofilm” at Univ. of Calgary, Alberta Canada & Montana State Univ., Bosman Montana

How Do Biofilms Form?What are Their Characteristics?

Page 33: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

33

Stages to a Mature Biofilm

Dirckx P. Center for Biofilm Engineering at Montana State University, Bozeman Montana

Page 34: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

34

Stage 1. Bacteria Attach to a Surface

▪ Surface conditioned with proteins, blood, dead cells

▪ If surface not favorable, will let go

▪ Mere touch of favorable surface triggers change: • fimbriae• pili• flagella• adhesion proteins

▪ Sends out signals attracting others

Page 35: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

35

Stage 2. Irreversible Adhesion

▪ Decide favorable conditions, they increase:

• production of protein adhesins & attach tenaciously

• pumping out polysaccharides (“goo!”)

• exponential cell division = rapid population growth!

Page 36: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Stage 3. Aggregation – Community Formation

▪ Function responsibility influenced by location in biofilm

− periphery = defensive

− upper levels = harvest food

− lower levels = get rid of waste

− bottom level = adherence to surface

▪ Bacteria pump out more goo: attachment & elastic stretch so strong survives outside of jet in flight!

Page 37: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Stage 4. Maturation: Complex Community

▪ Bacteria communicate changes in environment from their post and alter behavior if needed

▪ eDNA, enzymes (digesting and cutting antibiotics), food, minerals dispersed throughout the matrix during the construction and maintenance of the construction process

A.

B.

C.www.cs.Montana.edu

Page 38: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Stage 5. Dispersal

▪ Creation and release of free floating, single celled “children” called pioneer or planktonic bacteria to start

− new colonies− local infections− remote infections − systemic infections− embolic complications

▪ Planktonic bacteria are the most vulnerable to biocides▪ Recurrent symptoms (e.g. sinus; implant biofilm

infections)

7 days2 days6 hoursLegionella

Page 39: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

39Animation sequences by Biolumination Studios: http://www.bioluminationstudios.com

Putting It All Together

Page 40: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Putting It All Together

Animation sequences by Biolumination Studios: http://www.bioluminationstudios.com40

Putting It All Together

Page 41: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

41

Biofilm Infection & Treatment Profile

▪ Infections can often be low profile (mild symptoms), early on

▪ More mature biofilms: planktonic pioneers are released− symptoms surge upwards

− antibiotics may initially work (kill planktonic & periphery bacteria)

− biofilm community rebuilds

− symptoms return bacteria may grow more tolerant

▪ Mounting survivor resistance; up to 5,000X antibiotic needed

▪ Usually requires removal of associated implanted devices

Page 42: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

42

Catheters & Tubes

▪ Central Venous Catheters▪ Hemodialysis catheters▪ Pulmonary artery catheters▪ Arterial catheters▪ Urinary catheters▪ Peritoneal catheters▪ Umbilical catheters▪ Tracheostomy tubes

▪ Enteral feeding tubes

▪ Gastrostomy tubes

▪ Nasogastric tubes

▪ Endotracheal tubes

▪ Peritoneal dialysis

▪ Drainage tubes

▪ Endoscope Lumen

Endotracheal tube for patient’s on ventilation

Page 43: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

What Is The Biofilm’s Role in Antibiotic Resistance?

Page 44: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Blue dye representing antibiotic or disinfectant

diffusion through matrix gel

Biofilm Bacteria Excel In Resistance▪ Antibiotics & disinfectants diluted as diffuse through matrix

▪ Enzymes dispersed into matrix: cut & degrade antimicrobials

▪ Both encourage dormant bacterial resistance genes to express

− weak threats switch bacteria’s physiology to re-activate defensive factors and multiply them

− resistance genes passed to neighbors & next generation

− 10 to 5,000X more resistant than free pathogens

− deeper into matrix, antimicrobials encounter metabolically slow bacteria that rarely uptake food or antimicrobials

VRES. aureus

Page 45: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

45

More Resistance Strategies

▪ Incapacitates White Cells that might penetrate matrix

− Poor phagocytic (capture) capability

− Poor killing capability

WBC (Macrophages here) trying to attack biofilm bacteria

Bacteria in biofilm (stained pink here)

WBC (Neutrophil large red balls) gets in through water channels but cannot kill much

Page 46: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Bacteria: A Survival Success Story (Vertical)

Depends on many variables, but an example

Time from First survivor

Number of Bacteria

One survivor 120 minutes 240 minutes 4

1 hour 82 hours 643 hours 5124 hours 4,0965 hours 32,7686 hours 262,1447 hours 2,097,152!!

I, Peter Pathogen, survived antibiotic and found a nice surface with a wonderful organic food supply tissues and fluids! Starting my own Biofilm with all new kids!:

“Peter Pathogen’s Antibiotic-Resistant Protected Pavilion!”

Page 47: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

More Recently: Next Level of Understanding Biofilms

Page 48: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately
Page 49: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Habitat FormationFlemming 2016

Page 50: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Flemming 2016

Page 51: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Flemming 2016

VBNC: Viable But Non-Culturable Cells

Initiating VBNC state depends on species: − starvation − pH − food preservatives− light − electric field − oxygen limitation − low temperature − copper − salinity alterations− aerosolization

Page 52: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Flemming 2016

Cheaters:Quorum sensing mutants

Ex: Some Vibrio choleraDo not respond to communication to participate in the “public good”.

Some communicate only enough to force others to contribute enzymes, digested food, eDNA, etc. but do not contribute back when “instructed” to.

Page 53: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Flemming 2016

Page 54: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

54

Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infections (CAUTI): Biofilm & More

▪ 25% patients receive urinary catheter

▪ 95% urinary tract infections: catheter-associated

▪ > 800,000 hospital acquired CAUTI in US yearly

▪ Bacteria like Proteus mirabilis produce enzyme urease: − breaks down urea to to ammonia, carbonate: alkaline pH

− magnesium & calcium phosphate crystals formed; block urine flow

Sedor J. The Urologic Clinics Of North America. 1999;26:821-828

Page 55: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Current Research Activities Preventing Biofilm Formation, or

Destroying Those Formed

Page 56: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Implant Removal, Debridement, Antibiotic Depots

▪ Soft tissue surrounding implant biofilm contain bacteria encapsulated as reservoirs for future infection/biofilms

▪ Depots: spacers, beads, granules, cement: with antibiotics

▪ PMMA: poly methyl methacrylate

▪ CaSO4: calcium sulfate

▪ Antimicrobial loaded cement: − PMMA are not absorbable: beads must remove after use; not

optimal antimicrobial dispersion, lower concentration delivered; further reduced when coated with bodily fluids

Page 57: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Upper Right Arm

Implantation At 3 months At 5 months

Mirzayan

▪ CaSO4 granules, beads in cement:

▪ Absorbable

▪ Dispenses antibiotics in higher concentration

▪ No reduced dispersion if coated with bodily fluids

▪ However, does not have PMMA strength

CaSO4

Page 58: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Antimicrobial Coated Catheters, Drains, Implants; And Sprays

▪ Because of expense, usually recommended for longer indwelling patients

▪ Helpful in preventing biofilm formation and infection (e.g silver) initially

▪ Longer term, however, shows minimal prevention primarily due to coating active agents with organic fluid in use, and:

▪ Reduced antimicrobial concentration with time

▪ Some success with nebulized antibiotics at intervals (e.g. endotracheal tubes)

Page 59: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Antibodies Against Pilli

▪ Antibodies against flagella of Pseudomonas inhibited biofilm formation (Adams)

▪ Antibodies against Pili of Haemophilus influenza

▪ Note: similar success by others with anti-fimbriae and anti-flagella

Adams 2015;

Biofilm Naïve serum

Antibodies to Pilli

From above From above

Profile of biofilm

Page 60: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

60

Device Reprocessing ▪Biofilms increased in CSPD if:

– endoscopes (ES) not dried

– organic debris present (food source)

– scratched during reprocessing

– etched by harsh chemicals

– mixed metals in ultrasonic cleaner

– poorly rinsed = detergents

– hard water minerals (rinse water, steam)

– multiple reprocessing of single use items

– rough handling

– oils not removed

– poor assembly dead spaces

– particles not removed

– particles added: lint, hair

Page 61: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

61

Surface Traits That Impact Biofilms▪ shape, topography▪ rough vs smooth surface ▪ charge (bacteria are negatively charges)▪ hydrophobicity (bacteria attracted to hydrophobic)▪ hydrodynamics▪ etchings, scratches▪ crevices, edges▪ screws: continually reprocessed (start to pit)▪ stainless steel increased biofilm over titanium▪ wet vs dry lumen▪ any organic debris left on/in any device▪ lint, detergent particles, saline (becomes salt crystals)▪ any corroded portions of device

Page 62: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Incapacitating Ability of Bacteria to Communicate

▪ Pseudomonas biofilm on:

1. Standard untreated polyurethane

2. Usnic acid treated polyurethane – disrupts communication and ability to organize community

(1) (2)

Francolini I, Norris PM, Stooldley P. Montana State University, Bozeman MT62

Page 63: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Antibodies AgainstDNABII Proteins

We know eDNA:

▪ is distributed throughout biofilm matrix

▪ DNABII protein holds eDNA pieces together providing structural integrity throughout EPS matrix (like framing a house)

▪ When DNABII “king-pin” structure destroyed, bacteria released and become free-floating

▪ Add Antibiotic: sensitive bacteria killed

Novotny L, et al. Antibodies against DNA-binding tips of DNABII proteins

Mouse lung pneumonia: Pseudomonas colored green released from broken down biofilm matrix

Page 64: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Electric Field + Antibiotic

▪ Apply a safe extremely low voltage of alternating Direct Current (DC and Alternating Current (AC) while applying antimicrobial

▪ Killed all bacteria of P. aeruginosa biofilm & E. coli biofilm

Kim YW 2014 Intern Conf on Miniaturized Sys Chem & Life Sciences

Control: no treatment Antibiotic only Alternating AC & DCAntibiotic plus

Alternating AC & DC

+Antibiotic

AC - DC

Page 65: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Phage Therapy ▪ Phage aka. bacteriophage: viruses that kill bacteria, harmless to humans

▪ Like human viruses, they come in different shapes and sizes

ClassicT-Phage

Page 66: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Lytic Bacteriophage Attacking E. coli

▪ Injection of genetic code to Lysis (break open) 20-40 minutes

▪ Burst size ranges from 50-200 new bacteriophage

E. coli

E. coli

DNA protein capsid

Page 67: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

“Holie” Matrix!!

Or:▪ Attach antibiotics to phage as transporters

▪ After biofilm matrix disruption by phage-associated enzymes dispersin B or depolymerases, add antibiotic

▪ Add phage + extra sterile enzyme onto implant during surgery

▪ Add lysogenic (temperate phage) that add polymerase production gene into bacteria

Page 68: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

What Can We Do Now?

Page 69: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

69

Biofilm Formed On Implants Both Hands▪ Implants in both hands acquired biofilm infection

▪ Implants had to be removed; all bacteria killed before new implants

Culprit: Remote infection

Prevent this cause of implant biofilm by ensuring all remote infections treated and resolved before surgery

Page 70: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

▪ Mermel: 5 cardiac surgery patients with SSI − surgeon onychomycosis: fungus of nail − Pseudomonas hideout in fungus branches− nail removed, treated, infections stopped

▪ Malani: 27 sternal infections after CABG − 11 cases Candida albicans

− 16 cases Pseudomonas aeruginosa

− both from thumbnail fungus of same circulating nurseNote: 4 of these infections took 48 to 150 days to appear!

▪ McNeil: 16 of 185 median sternotomy patients: Pseudomonas from Scrub Nurse thumbnail fungus

− 7 mediastinitis− 5 deep sternal infection− 2 superficial sternal wound − 1 prosthetic valve endocarditis− 1 sepsis

Biofilm Hiding Among Fungus Branches

702-13% adults have onychomycosis (nail fungus); 90% of the elderly

Recommend coat with antiepic and cover before surgery

Page 71: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

71

Royer: Bloodstream Infections Reduced

▪ After blood draw, retained blood provided breeding ground for biofilm formation

▪ Opaque valves do not show residual blood▪ Switched to clear housing▪ 10mL flush did not clear blood; 20 mL did ▪ 5 fold reduction in BSI

Poster: Royer T: VHA MRSA Prevention Forum; Orlando FL Nov 5-6, 2007

Page 72: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Breast Implant Contractures

▪ Implant capsular contractures: hard scar tissues walling off threat

▪ Surgeon certain particles attracted onto implant surface and there − distract local immune response & hide bacteria − enable few bacteria contaminating site to form a micro-biofilm− subclinical infection

(Pajkos AB, 2003; Netscher D, 2004; Mladick RA, 2005; Netscher DT, 2005)Capsule:

Implant removed

Page 73: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Breast Implants

▪ He was still convinced in spite of disbelievers▪ Performed all breast implant surgeries:

− lint-free− powder-free gloves− no touch implant− no touch patient skin (even though prepped)

Mladick RA. Plast Reconstr Surg 2005;(14):26-27//Keller funnel

Eight years without a single capsular contraction!

▪ Little things (lint, powder, other particles matter!)▪ Principle applies to all implants!!

Implant static cling

Page 74: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

74

Distraction

Crime Of Distraction: Great Break for Biofilm• Things that strongly attract the attention of the immune system

– become the center of attention so microorganisms are ignored and can multiply

germ

Page 75: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Significantly Reduced Infection Threshold

Elek▪ Wound: no particles = 10 million bacteria (107) to cause infection▪ Wound: with suture fragment = 100 bacteria (102) to cause infection

75

1. Macrophage attention to larger lint & particulate threats2. Neutrophils deplete oxidative burst defending these larger threats3. WBCs ignore the few Pseudomonas nearby (immune distraction)4. The few contaminating bacteria become many5. Infection initiated (threshold reduced-takes fewer bacteria to infect)

Jaffray▪ Wound: no particles = 1,000 (103) = 1/10 animals infected▪ Wound: 2mg sterile particulates = 1,000 (103) = 9/10 infected

Reduced # bacteria needed for infection by 100,000X!

Increased number of “patients” infected from 10% to 90%!

Immune Distraction

Page 76: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

76

Lint & Particulate Sources▪ Poorly cleaned devices: tissues, fat, blood ▪ Linting sterilization wrap▪ Gasket seals oxidizing on containers or devices▪ Sweaters, fleece vests in SPD room▪ Devices dried with/on linting materials▪ Hair, lint, debris from staff and traffic▪ Corrugated cardboard, newspapers, tissues▪ Rigid containers not washed clear of debris▪ OR: gowns, hair, drapes, back table cover,

sterilization wrap, glove powder

Page 77: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

90% cellulose fibers10% polyester (melted edges)

White Wipe Swipe: Wrapping Table In The Sterile Processing Department

Page 78: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Inadequate Instrument Processing

Page 79: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

79

Poorly Reprocessed Electrodes ▪ Electroencephalogram electrodes not properly cleaned

▪ Residual dried on biofilm provided

− protection of entrapped virus − prevented adequate sterilization

▪ Several patients acquired hepatitis B (HBV)

▪ $27.5 million legal settlement against neurologist & hospital

Mackay B CMAJ 2002; 166(7):943

Page 80: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Stage Six: Fortified Endoscope Biofilm

▪ Studies by Pajkos, 2004; Alpha, 2010; Ofstead 2017: after following IFUs, clean results not always 100% successful

▪ Once an area of organic debris is missed: − organisms attach and multiply forming classic biofilm− endoscope is processed through disinfectant− disinfectants (esp. aldehydes) “fix” (like glue) organics to

surface along with biofilm resident bacteria inside− endoscope goes back into use− process continues with fresh organics & bacteria repeatedly− each layer increases the formidable protective shielding

▪ Fixed layered biofilm is much, much harder to remove and for disinfectants to penetrate

80

Page 81: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

If Delayed: Biofilm Starts, Expands, Layers

▪ (A) Communities (biofilm) of healthy multiplying bacteria – left over weekend before processing

▪ Bacteria, organic debris food supply + matrix dry onto surfaces “like cement” live bacteria inside

▪ (B) Dried organic debris & biofilm after reprocessed; but microorganisms still alive!!

81

B

A

Dried-out, cemented on surface, the organic debris “Like dried Jerky with live bacteria inside!”

Page 82: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

82

Pre-clean per endoscope reprocessing guidelines Using Manufacturers IFU

“Immediately after removing the endoscope from the patient, wipe the insertion tube with the wet cloth or sponge soaked in the freshly prepared

enzymatic detergent solution.”

Bolander S 2005 SGNA Standards of Infection Control in Reprocessing of Flexible Gastrointestinal Endoscopes

Also guidelines from:

AORNAAMICDC

IAHCSMMCBSPD

Page 83: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Next Critical Biofilm Prevention StepTransport: Immediately after Pre-cleaning:

▪ Place endoscope coiled in safe container free from items that could damage the unit

▪ Cover with enzyme solution/foam/spray to degrade organics so can more easily be cleaned

▪ Keep wet/moist to prevent drying onto surface (cover with towel/lid)

▪ Mark Contaminated/Biohazard

▪ Enzymes: Protease for proteins, Amylase for carbohydrates; Lipase for fats. (However appropriate detergents/surfactants do just as well for fats)

83

Protease Amylase

ProteinsBroken down To amino acids Carbohydrates

Broken down to sugars

Lipase

Fats

Broken down to lipids

Page 84: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Biofilms: Flexible Endoscopes

84

Primary causes:

▪ Not wiped/flushed at site immediately after use ▪ Left too long before SPD cleaning (dried on) ▪ Organics missed; fixed by disinfectant, layering▪ Leak test not performed (damaged seals: biofilms love)▪ Tap water used as rinse water▪ Not properly and thoroughly dried▪ Poor repair jobs▪ Automatic Endoscope Reprocessors (AER):

Biofilms contaminated scopes & caused infections

• Under trays • Tubing • Detergent tank

• Water bottles • Connectors• AER not disinfected

• Pump Contaminated

• Filter overgrown

AER Biofilms sites resulted in infections

Page 85: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Water Based Biofilm Infections

85

▪ Tap water safe to drink but not rinse endoscopes Patient infections and full outbreaks:

− Acinetobacter

− Burkholderia

− Legionella

− Mycobacterium

− Pseudomonas

− Serratia

− Stenotrophomonas

▪ Biofilms form in pipes, faucet heads, drains

33 patient 145 infection

Page 86: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

Mycobacterium, Pseudomonas, Legionella,

Acinetobacter, Serratia, Stenotrophomonas, Burkholderia

Contaminated Water: Aerosolized, Liquid or Ice have Caused SSIs

▪ Contaminated solutions for processing endoscopes

▪ Cardioplegia solutions

▪ Dialysis equipment (usually rinse water)

▪ Disinfectants

▪ Hospital tap water

▪ Hydrotherapy pools

▪ Peritoneal dialysis fluids

▪ Respiratory equipment and humidifiers

▪ Splashes after contacting contaminated sink, drain

▪ Stagnant lip of water in aeration faucet head

▪ Water dispensers

▪ Water/ice used to cool eye solutions

▪ Water-based patient warming devices (esp. + pressure)

Page 87: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

87

Summary▪ Biofilms: Highly organized, well defended, microbial communities

▪ Biofilm bacteria much more resistant to antimicrobials than individual bacteria and share resistance genetics with community

▪ There is a lot of research to prevent formation and destroy those formed

▪ Delayed cleaning, residual organics, rinsing with tap water, and incomplete drying all increase biofilm risk

▪ Lint, debris, dead biofilm chunks, increase risk of biofilm formation and infection by immune distraction

▪ Most effective way to reduce biofilm impact now is prevention

DUJS Nov 21, 2009

Page 88: Biofilms - Intermountain APIC€¦ · Vascular Catheters 5-6 million Central Lines placed annually > 5% infections >250,000 central line-associated infections (CLABSI) Approximately

88

Addressing Biofilm Prevention Now!

You’re Staff Are Proud of it

Joint Commission Approves of It!

Accounting Loves it

Patients Couldn’t Be Happier!