BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

36
Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis [email protected] www.linkedin.com BIM CASE STUDY: BEREWOOD PRIMARY SCHOOL HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL PROPERTY SERVICES

description

BIM Show Live 2014 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school by Allister Lewis, Hampshire County Council Property Services

Transcript of BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Page 1: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

BIM CASE STUDY: BEREWOOD PRIMARY SCHOOL HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL PROPERTY SERVICES

Page 2: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

1. AIMS OF THIS TALK

Page 3: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

2. INTRODUCTION

Page 4: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

3. HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL

Page 5: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

3. HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL

Page 6: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

3. HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL

Page 7: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

4. BIM

Page 8: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

4. HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL & BIM

Page 9: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

4. HAMPSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL & BIM

Page 10: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

5. 2D CAD WORKFLOW

Page 11: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

5. BIM WORKFLOW

Page 12: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

5. BIM MATURITY

Page 13: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

6. TWO SCHOOLS

QEB Infants School

Berewood Primary School

Contract Type

Traditional Traditional

Construction Value (approx.)

£5.0m £5.5m

Type

1 Form Entry Infant 2 Form Entry Primary

Start date

September 2010 March 2011

Design Team

HCC Architect

HCC Building Services

WSP Structures

HCC Quantity Surveyor

HCC Interiors

HCC Landscape

HCC Architect

WSP Building Services

Curtins Structures

HCC Quantity Surveyor

HCC Interiors

HCC Landscape

CAD Programmes used

Independent authoring:

Vectorworks

AutoCAD

Federated authoring:

Revit

Navisworks

Page 14: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

6. QEB INFANT SCHOOL

Page 15: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

6. BEREWOOD PRIMARY

Page 16: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

6. SCHOOL MASSING

Page 17: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

7. BEREWOOD BIM STAGE A-D

Electrical Engineer – WSP Group

Interior Designer - HCC

Contractor - Mansell

Architect - HCC

Structural Engineer – Curtins

Mechanical Engineer – WSP Group

Model

Landscape Architect - HCC

Quantity Surveyor -HCC

Page 18: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

7. BEREWOOD BIM STAGE A-D

Page 19: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. BEREWOOD BIM STAGE E & F

Page 20: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. BEREWOOD BIM STAGE E & F

Page 21: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. BEREWOOD BIM STAGE E & F

Page 22: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. PROJECT COMPARISON

QEB Infants School

Berewood Primary School

Information

2D coordinated drawings 3D federated models

Output

2D drawings and specification 2D drawings, specification and

3D model

Contractor

Early engagement and review

of drawings

Early engagement and review

of drawings and model

Programme

Developed from information

received

Developed from information

received and model used to

inform decisions

M&E strategy

Services to pass through holes

in beams above ceiling level.

Complex drawings required to

illustrate strategy

Services to pass through a 350

void above ceiling level. All

service runs modelled in 3D

prior to Tender

Tender Outcome

Above available funding

Value engineering required

Within available funding

Target Net Rate + above

achieved

Page 23: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. EXTENDING THE MODEL USE

Page 24: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

8. EXTENDING THE MODEL USE

Page 25: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. BEREWOOD BIM ON SITE

Page 26: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. BEREWOOD BIM ON SITE

Page 27: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. BEREWOOD BIM ON SITE

Page 28: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. BEREWOOD BIM ON SITE

Page 29: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. QEB ON SITE

Page 30: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. QEB ON SITE

Page 31: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. SERVICES STRATEGY COMPARISON

QEB Infant Berewood Primary

Page 32: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

9. PROJECT COMPARISON

QEB Infants School

Berewood Primary School

Information

2D coordinated drawings 3D federated models

Progress Behind programme On programme

Information requests High number of RFIs Low number of RFIs

Services Coordination Additional resource required

to resolve

No clashes reported

Resource 2 individuals full time 1 individual part time

Page 33: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

10. PILOT OUTCOMES

Asset Management integration

Catagory Information Required Format? Why use the information?

Wall Types Project Plans,CBR Plans, Record Drawings Condition Surveys, Proposed Works, Fire Safety

Roof Construction Project Specification, Project Plans, Record Drawings Condition Surveys, Proposed Works

Internal Finishes Project Specification, Project Plans Condition Surveys, Proposed Works

Floor Coverings Project Specification, Project Plans, Record drawings Risk assesments,Cleaning Contracts,Proposed Works

Door Types Door Schedules, Record Drawings Health & Safety, Fire Safety, Maintenance, Access requirements,Proposed Works

Window Types Window Schedules, Record Drawings Health & Safety, Fire Safety,Proposed Works

Construction Levels Project Plans,Record drawings Health & Safety, Proposed Works,Site Maintenance

Fixtures & fittings Fittings Schedules, Manufacturer Spec,Record drawings Health & Safety, Maintenance,Proposed Works

Stairs, ramp gradient, step levels Project Plans, Manufacturer spec,Record drawings Health & Safety ,Proposed Works,, Site Maintenance,Access requiremnts

Water Supply Schematic Layout, O&M Manual,Record drawings Proposed Works, Site Maintenance

Gas Supply Schematic Layout, O&M Manual,Record drawings Proposed Works, Meter Location , Site Maintenance

Electrical Supply Schematic Layout,Ceiling Grid Layouts,Record drawings Proposed Works,Health & Safety, Site Maintenance

Heating & Ventilation Schematic Layout. Manufacturer Spec ,O&M Manual Health & Safety, Fire Safety, Site Maintenance

Lifts Manufacturers Spec ,O&M Manual Site Maintenance

Communication Schematic Layout, Record Drawings Proposed seating layouts, Site Maintenance

Construction Fire Safety Manual, Record Drawings,Door Schedules Fire Safety Manual & Site Management,Proposed Works

Equipment Fire Safety Manual, Record Drawings Fire Safety Manual, Site Management, Proposed Works

Detection Fire Safety Manual, Record Drawings Fire Safety Manual, Site Management, Proposed Works

Fire Safety Manual, Record Drawings Fire Safety Manual, Site Management, Proposed Works

Fire Safety Manual, Record Drawings Fire Safety Manual, Site Management, Proposed Works

Construction

M&E

Fire

Strategy

Page 34: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

10. PILOT OUTCOMES

Benefits Challenges

1 Improved productivity due to easy retrieval of information

Internal IT system requirements

2 Increased coordination of construction documents

Management Support & Understanding

3 Team management communication is increased

Investment required

4 Increased speed of delivery and improved visualisation

Research and training

5 Greater cost and design understanding

Page 35: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

10. PILOT OUTCOMES

Page 36: BIM SHOW LIVE 14 - Local Authority BIM: A standardised primary school

Allister Lewis | Architect @allisterlewis

[email protected] www.linkedin.com

QUESTIONS?

“You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.”

Richard Buckminster Fuller