Big Data/Little Data Big Team/Little...
41
Transcript of Big Data/Little Data Big Team/Little...
Do you operate like this?
2
Should you continue?
3
This is NOT the answer?
4
What would be better?
5
Big DATA + Little DATA = A better approach
BIG Data
• The entire readmissions population
• Dice and slice by payer, REaL, etc.
• Learn which groups are readmitted at a higher rate
• These are the groups you will TARGET with special effort
Little Data
• What you are learning on a day-to-day basis
• From patients, providers, case review
• Help you understand where the gaps are in your current processes and program
• Helps you decide WHAT to prioritize from a PI perspective
6
Why use big data?
• Medicare readmission penalties drive many approaches
• But these DRGs are not the top reasons for readmissions in all populations
• Focusing on these DRGs only will not reduce hospital-wide readmission rates and leaves many needs unmet
7
Let’s drill down
8
9
30-Day Potentially Preventable Readmission (PPR) Rates by Race and
Ethnicity
Little data provide a different perspective
• Why ask the patients and providers?
– Gain their perspectives
– Understand reasons
– Identify gaps
– Develop a better plan for the specific patient
– Design a more effective program
• Why do case reviews (focus on quick returns)?
– Determine care gaps
– Look at plans overtime
– Prioritize repeated issues
11
“I RAN OUT OF LASIX”
51 year old male with 3 acute care admissions and 2 ED visits in the past 180 days.
When asked why he thought he was readmitted said…
12
Aggregate and prioritize
13
Ongoing data
• Monitor what matters to you
• If you aren’t where you need to be - adjust
14
Other data to consider
• Inventory your efforts
– Across departments
– Coordination of activities
– Check for duplication
– Look for gaps
• Inventory community resources
– Clinical
– Non-clinical
15
Framing or Reframing Your Approach
Care Continuum
Ris
k fo
r R
ead
mis
sio
n
Now that you’ve reviewed your data take a look at your current approach. One way to think about it is along the lines of risk of readmission and along the care continuum. Build out the blank slide to show a picture of your overall approach. Does the current approach match the needs you identified in your analysis? If not, how do you want to modify your approach?
Risk Community ED Hospital Based Immediate Post Hospitalization
Ris
k fo
r R
ead
mis
sio
n
Risk Community ED Hospital Based Immediate Post Hospitalization
Ris
k fo
r R
ead
mis
sio
n
Special programs such as:• Complex Care
Management (CCM)• Social programs
Highestutilizer care
plans
BASIC bundle +moderate to high bundle• Palliative care
BASIC post discharge bundle + moderate to high bundleANDstronger linkage with community programs
PCP/care team management per patient needs with prioritized post discharge visit or outreach• Disease specific
programs
BASIC bundle + moderate to high bundle:• Care transitions
nurse• Pharmacy
intervention
BASIC post discharge bundle + moderate to high bundle:• 7 day f/u
appointment• f/u call(s)/visits
Routine PCP/care team management per patient needs
Admit BASIC bundle:• Maximize PFE in
discharge planning• Inc. meds, f/u, signs
& symptoms and what to do
• Education using
BASIC post discharge bundle:• Referrals• Instructions
Example to get you started framing your
approach
1. Partnering with other hospitals in the local area to reduce readmissions2. Tracking % of patients discharged with a follow-up appointment already scheduled within 7 days3. Tracking % of patients readmitted to another hospital4. Estimating risk of readmission in a formal way and using it to guide clinical care during hospitalization5. Having electronic medical record or web-based forms in place to facilitate medication reconciliation6. Using teach-back techniques for patient and family education7. At discharge, providing patients with heart failure written action plans for managing changes8. Regularly calling patients after discharge to follow up on post-discharge needs9. Discharging patients with an outpatient follow-up appointment already scheduled
Yale Global Health LD Institute
• Hospitals that took up any 3 or more strategies had significantly greater reductions in RSRR compared with hospitals that took up only 0-2 strategies.
• -93 different combinations of strategies
• High and low performing groups both used recommended clinical practices.
• Four specific approaches distinguished high performers– Collaboration across
departments/ disciplines
– Working with post-hospital providers
– Learning and problem solving
– Senior leadership support
What works?
Operationalizing your plan
Little team
• Individuals within the hospital who contribute to effective care transitions
• Who are they?– CM, SS, Nursing, IT, Physician,
Therapy Services, Pharmacy, Palliative Care, ED, navigators, a pt or family caregiver
• Work on highest priority issues– Basic services for all
– Enhanced services for selected populations
Big team
• Individuals across the continuum who receive/manage your patients
• Who are they?– SNFs, HH, LTAC, PCPs, BH
clinics, post discharge clinics, insurance providers, ssagencies, ACOs, medical homes, complex cm, EMS
• Work to understand and improve gaps in services for shared patients
21
• Get people in the same room
• Learn what everyone has to offer
• Learn what everyone's frustrations are
• Start with one issue and go from there
Simple but effective
• http://interact2.net/tools.html
– Free tools for:• Nursing homes
• Home health
• Assisted living
• LTAC
Encourage your partners to use
• Shadow program
• ED & SNF
• Experience a day in the life
• Stronger understanding and empathy
25
Walk a mile in my shoes
• http://ctb.ku.edu/en/table-of-contents/assessment/assessing-community-needs-and-resources/identify-community-assets/main
26
Community Asset Mapping
• At WVU Hospitals, in Morgantown, W.V., physicians and medical residents teamed up to see their patients at the hospital’s outpatient clinic, within 7 to 14 days after discharge. – A psychologist, pharmacist and nurse case manager soon joined the team.
– Medical residents talk with patients before discharge, explaining the follow-up process and ensuring patients have a pre-scheduled appointment.
– The nurse case manager tracks all appointments, contacting patients until they are seen.
– On clinic days, the team huddles in the early afternoon and sees patients afterward.
– With this team-based follow-up care, 80-85 percent of patients are seen within 14 days
of discharge.
• One additional benefit: discharge summaries have improved now that residents use their own summaries for the follow-up.
• Karen Fitzpatrick, M.D., quality director, WVU
Teams
Next Steps!
• Perform an analysis of your big data
• Aggregate your little data
• Evaluate your little and big team membership
• What changes are needed?
– Your approach
– Team(s)
28
Any questions?
29
Skill Building
CMS discharge planning checklist
Practice interviewing your readmitted patients
30
• Patients and caregivers
CMS Discharge Planning Checklist
Instructions
What’s ahead
• Download the CMS discharge planning checklist
• https://www.medicare.gov/Pubs/pdf/11376.pdf
• If you’re not already using it, make a plan to start
How are you using it?
Learning from our patients
35
Why & How
• To get the story behind the chief complaint
• Ask open ended questions
– Why do you think you were readmitted?
– What do you think needs to happen differently when you go home this time?
• Drill down with why, why, why to get to the causes
• Explore non-clinical reasons as well - $, access, housing, etc.
• Note all causes36
Listen for themes
• Leaving the hospital unprepared, or inadequately informed, without specific instructions on what to do
• A lack of coordination - Challenges in accessing services: appointments, transportation, medications, equipment
• Changing circumstances after discharge
• PCP instructions to return to the ED
• Readmissions are O.K., expected, or very frustrating
37
Barb-Interviewer, Pat-Pt., You-Observers
38
Time to practice
• Get into groups of three
– Interviewer
– Interviewee
– Observer
• Conduct a mock interview (5 minutes)
• Debrief
• Switch and repeat
• Discuss themes & observations
39
