Bharwaney BarOn MacKinlay EQ and Bottom Line

8/13/2019 Bharwaney BarOn MacKinlay EQ and Bottom Line

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bharwaney-baron-mackinlay-eq-and-bottom-line 1/39

E ; @ B<@@< ! ; :

E <@ <; I;@ ; I; > ? ? I;$ @ <; % > <> ; , ! >? ;$> ; ? @ <; %>< @ @

G B , B -% A # !

E ; @ B<@@< ! ; :E <@ <; I;@ ; I; > ? ? I;$ @ <; % > <> ; , ! >? ;

$> ; ? @ <; %>< @ @

G B , B -% A # !

F ? !

E <> ! @

4 D>> # , A<? , B > #!45 2$D

* : +44-1525-840090, F : +44-1525-840092, E< : >@ > .> , : . > .>

J B , B -% & # ! 2007, 2011

F 2007, ? 2011 E >

* > B , B -% # ! > > > > < > C>? , D A 1988.

A . E ? ? < > > ? > > < ? > <, ? , ? > < ? , ? , > , < , > >

> < > < , > ? > ? < > > >? > .

B " C > - - > D

A > > ? ? > G ? D "

A > < > < > > > ? . * > E > " < > > < > . * > <> > > ' > ,

? > <> > .

* E - K E -360 < > #H .

% #<

< C<;@ ;@?

$ > 1

@ <;1: E > ; , D ; @ <; ; ? > ;@ < E <@ <; I;@ ; 2

1. * < > <> > 2

2. D < <> >

3. * B -% #> > <> > 5

@ <; 2: E > B ? E ; <> A ; E <@ <; I;@ ; ; @ <> 7

1. * <? > E > > ? > ? > < 7

2. * <? > E > ? 8

3. * <? > E > > > ? > 9

@ <; 3:A ; E <@ <; I;@ ; ; @ <> 10

1. H> > ?? > ?? > > E > > < < > > ? >

2. - ?> - > E < 11

3. A <> > > <? > E >

A ; ? 19

A?? A: > ' G > > B >< * <

A?? B: 22

A?? C: C> 23

A?? D: 24

25

C> > ' B > ? 27

A > E > " < 35

E B> >< " 1J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : %

E ; @ B<@@< ! ; :

E <@ <; I;@ ; ; > ? ? I;$ @ <; % > <> ; , ! >? ;$> ; ? @ <; %>< @ @

G @ B > ; , ; B >-$; ; A ;

$ >T!e )+"&a+2 (b#ec-"/e (f -!", )a)e+ ", -( ,!(0 -!a- -!e de/e%()&e'- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'c+ea,e,(cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce %eade+,!") a'd (+ a'",a-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2

We 0"%% b+"ef%2 e1)%a"' 0!a- e&(-"('a% " '-e%%" e'ce EI ", !(0 "- ", &ea,.+ed 0!2 "- ", "&)(+-a'- a'd!(0 be,- -( a))%2 "- "' -!e 0(+$)%ace -( &a1"&",e (+ a'",a-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2 S-.d"e, 0"%% be de,c+"bed-!a- de&(',-+a-e -!e b(--(& %"'e "&)ac- (f EI "'-e+/e'-"(', a'd a ca,e ,-.d2 0"%% be )+e,e'-ed -("%%.,-+a-e -!e de," ' b.,"'e,, +e%e/a'ce a'd "&)ac- (f a ,)ec"f"c (+ a'",a-"('a% "'-e+/e'-"('

T!", )a)e+ ", 0+"--e' ,)ec"f"ca%%2 f(+ HR )+(fe,,"('a%, ,( -!a- -!e2 0"%% be be--e+ "'f(+&ed a'd -!.,fee% &(+e c('f"de'- "' "'f%.e'c"' $e2 ,-a$e!(%de+, "' -!e "&)%e&e'-a-"(' (f EI )+( +a&&e, )+(ce,,e,a'd "'-e+/e'-"(',

1. > ; < <@ <;

;@ ;E&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce EI !a, bec(&e a /e+2 )()\.%a+ -()"c ,"'ce -!e ).b%"ca-"(' (f a be,-,e%%e+ b2-!e ,a&e 'a&e "' Oc-(be+ 7??; G(%e&a' A%\-!(. ! -!e c(',-+.c- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ",'(- 'e0 "-, a))%"ca-"(' "' -!e 0(+$)%ace de," 'ed-( "'c+ea,e "'d"/"d.a% )e+f(+&a'ce a'd (+ a'",a\-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2 !a, be .' a- a +a-!e+ f+e'3"ed)ace d.+"' -!e )a,- decade T!e )+ec.+,(+, (f-!e,e eff(+-, e1-e'd bac$ -( -!e )(,- Sec('d W(+%dWa+ e+a 0"-! e1-e',"/e ,.+/e2, c('d.c-ed b2 -!eU'"-ed S-a-e, Off"ce (f Pe+,(''e% Ma'a e&e'-a'd 0"-! -!e )"('ee+"' 0(+$ (f Da/"d McC%e%%a'da- Ha+/a+d U'"/e+,"-2 -!a- f(c.,ed (' -!e "&)(+\-a'ce (f e&(-"('a%%2 a'd ,(c"a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- be !a /" (.+ a&(' &a 'a e+,

De,)"-e -!e !e" !-e'ed %e/e% (f "'-e+e,- "' -!", 'e0"dea ,c!(%a+, !a/e ac-.a%%2 bee' ,-.d2"' -!",c(',-+.c- f(+ -!e +ea-e+ )a+- (f -!e -0e'-"e-!

ce'-.+2 a'd "-, !",-(+"ca% +((-, ca' be -+aced bac$-( -!e '"'e-ee'-! ce'-.+2 Da+0"' 7>=8[7?<; I'c('-+a,- -( -!e,e ,c!(%a+%2 eff(+-, &a'2 +ece'-a+-"c%e, "' -!e )().%a+ HR a'd b.,"'e,, )+e,, !a/e,e+/ed -( d"%.-e -!e "&)(+-a'ce a'd +e%e/a'ce (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce Add"-"('a%%2 -!e+e a+e /e+2fe0 ,(.+ce, (f "'f(+&a-"(' 0!"c! !a/e a--e&)-ed-( b+"' -( e-!e+ a 0"de +a' e (f )e+-"'e'- EI b.,"'e,, da-a -!a- ", d"+ec-%2 a))%"cab%e "' -!e0(+$)%ace T!", )a)e+ ", a +e,)(',e -( -!e ,ca+c"-2

(f )+ac-"ca% EI $'(0%ed e a'd ", !()ed -( ,-a+-+e/e+,"' -!", .'f(+-.'a-e ,"-.a-"('

T!e 'e1- ,ec-"(' (f -!", )a)e+ def"'e, EI a'd)+e,e'-, a ,c"e'-"f"c a))+(ac! -( de,c+"b"' a'd&ea,.+"' "- We 0"%% -!e' )+e,e'- a '.&be+ (f$e2 f"'d"' , -!a- de&(',-+a-e 0!2 -!", c(',-+.c-", e,)ec"a%%2 "&)(+-a'- a'd /a%.ab%e "' -!e 0(+$\)%ace T!e ,-.d"e, d",c.,,ed 0"%% )+(/"de e&)"+"ca%e/"de'ce (f -!e b(--(&\%"'e "&)ac- (f EI"'-e+/e'-"(',

E B> >< " 2J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 1

@ <; 1: E > ; , D ; @ <; ; ? > ;@ <

E <@ <; I;@ ;

T!", ,ec-"(' (f -!e )a)e+ "'-+(d.ce, -!e e&e+ e'ce def"'"-"(' a'd &ea,.+e&e'- (f -!e c('ce)- (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce EI T!e Ba+\O' &(de% 0"%% be e1)%a"'ed a, a $e2 a))+(ac! -( def"'"' de,c+"b"' a'd&ea,.+"' -!", c('ce)- T!", ,ec-"(' ", de," 'ed -( 0!e- -!e a))e-"-e (f -!(,e 0!( a+e 'e0 -( -!e f"e%d (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce 0!"%e -!e ,ea,('ed EI )+ac-"-"('e+, 0"%% f"'d "- -( be a !e%)f.% +ef+e,!e+

2. D ; ; ; ? > ; <@ <;;@ ;

I' -!e )(,-\T!(+'d"$ea' &(de+' )e+"(d -!eeff(+-, -( def"'e a'd e/e'-.a%%2 &ea,.+e -!",c(',-+.c- be a' 0"-! -!e 0(+$ (f Ga+d'e+ ('a%-e+'a-"/e f(+&, (f "'-e%%" e'ce 7?>9 c('-"'.ed0"-! Ba+\O' , "dea (f a' EQ -!a- be a' d.+"' -!e,a&e )e+"(d a'd beca&e /e+2 f(c.,ed 0"-!Sa%(/e2 a'd Ma2e+ , ,e&"'a% ).b%"ca-"(' ('

e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce 7??6 f(%%(0ed b2G(%e&a' be,-,e%%e+ -!a- ).b%"c",ed -!", 0!(%ea+ea 7??; D.+"' -!e )a,- decade "' )a+-"c.%a+," '"f"ca'- +e,ea+c! ac-"/"-2 !a, f(c.,ed ('add+e,,"' -!e *.e,-"(' (f !(0 be,- -( def"'ea'd &ea,.+e EI Va+"(., a))+(ac!e, !a/e bee')+()(,ed a'd a '.&be+ (f d"ffe+e'- c('ce)-.\a%",a-"(', (f -!", c(',-+.c- !a/e a))ea+ed c+ea-"'

,(&e de +ee (f c('f.,"(' +e a+d"' -!e be,- 0a2 -(def"'e &ea,.+e a'd a))%2 e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce T(!e%) c%a+"f2 -!", ,"-.a-"(' -!e E#c.c!$%edia $f A%%!iedP(.ch$!$g. S)"e%be+ e+ 866: ,. e,-, -!a- -!e+e a+ec.++e'-%2 -!+ee &a#(+ EI &(de%,

a -!e Ba+\O' &(de% 7??=b 0!"c! de,c+"be,-!", c(',-+.c- a, a' a++a2 (f "'-e++e%a-ede&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% c(&)e-e'c"e, ,$"%%,a'd fac"%"-a-(+, -!a- "&)ac- "'-e%%" e'- be!a/"(.+ &ea,.+ed b2 ,e%f\+e)(+- Ba+\O'7??=a a, 0e%% a, &.%-"\+a-e+ (+ 0!a- ", a%,(+efe++ed -( a, 9<6\de +ee a,,e,,&e'- Ba+\O'

Ha'd%e2 8669a 8669b

E - ECI CEIINTRAPERSONAL SELF-AWARENESS PERCEIVING EMOTIONS

Se%f\Re a+d E&(-"('a% Se%f\A0a+e'e,, Face, E&(-"('a% Se%f\A0a+e'e,, Acc.+a-e Se%f\A,,e,,&e'- P"c-.+e, A,,e+-"/e'e,, Se%f\C('f"de'ce FACILITATING EMOTIONS

I'de)e'de'ce SELF-MANAGEMENT Fac"%"-a-"(' Se%f\Ac-.a%"3a-"(' E&(-"('a% Se%f\C('-+(% Se',a-"(',INTERPERSONAL T+a',)a+e'c2 UNDERSTANDING EMOTIONS

E&)a-!2 Ada)-ab"%"-2 C!a' e, S(c"a% Re,)(',"b"%"-2 Ac!"e/e&e'- O+"e'-a-"(' B%e'd, I'-e+)e+,('a% Re%a-"(',!") I'"-"a-"/e MANAGING EMOTIONS

STRESS MANAGEMENT O)-"&",& E&(-"(' Ma'a e&e'-

S-+e,, T(%e+a'ce SOCIAL AWARENESS E&(-"('a% Re%a-"(',!"), I&).%,e C('-+(% E&)a-!2ADAPTABILITY O+ a'"3a-"('a% A0a+e'e,, F%e1"b"%"-2 Se+/"ce O+"e'-a-"(' Rea%"-2 Te,-"' RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT

P+(b%e& S(%/"' De/e%()"' O-!e+,GENERAL MOOD I',)"+a-"('a% Leade+,!") O)-"&",& C!a' e Ca-a%2,- Ha))"'e,, I'f%.e'ce

C('f%"c- Ma'a e&e'-

Tea&0(+$ a'd C(%%ab(+a-"('

1T!e ,ca%e, (f -!e -!+ee &(,- )().%a+%2 .,ed &ea,.+e, (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce de," 'ed -( a,,e, -!",

c(',-+.c- b2 ,e%f\+e)(+- -!e EQ i &.%-"\+a-e+ ECI a'd ab"%"-2\ba,ed e/a%.a-"(' MSCEIT

E B> >< " 3J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 1

b -!e G(%e&a' &(de% 7??> 0!"c! /"e0, "- a,a' a,,(+-&e'- (f c(&)e-e'c"e, a'd ,$"%%, -!a-c('-+"b.-e ,)ec"f"ca%%2 -( &a'a e+"a% )e+f(+&\

a'ce &ea,.+ed b2 &.%-"\+a-e+ a,,e,,&e'-B(2a-3", G(%e&a' Ha2G+(.) 8667 a'd

c -!e Ma2e+\Sa%(/e2 &(de% 7??= 0!"c!def"'e, e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a, -!e ab"%"-2-( )e+ce"/e .'de+,-a'd &a'a e a'd .,ee&(-"(', -( fac"%"-a-e -!"'$"' &ea,.+ed b2a' ab"%"-2\ba,ed &ea,.+e Ma2e+ Sa%(/e2 Ca+.,( 8668

T!e ,ca%e, (f -!e,e -!+ee EI &ea,.+e, a+e %",-ed "'

Tab%e 7 -( )+(/"de -!e +eade+ 0"-! a *."c$ (/e+/"e0(f -!e /a+"(., a,)ec-, (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -!a-a+e be"' &ea,.+ed 0"-! -!e,e "',-+.&e'-,

T!e ab(/e -!+ee "',-+.&e'-, a'd -!e ,)ec"f"ca,)ec-, (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -!a- -!e2&ea,.+e a+e de,c+"bed f.+-!e+ a'd c+"-"*.ed b2B!a+0a'e2 866= )) :=\;; 7;=\7<: "' -!e ,a&e,(.+ce ,!e c(&)a+e, -!e& 0"-! (-!e+ a/a"%ab%e EI"',-+.&e'-, -!a- a+e a%,( de,c+"bed "' de-a"%

I' ,e%ec-"' a )a+-"c.%a+ def"'"-"(' (+ &ea,.+e (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce HR )+(fe,,"('a%, a+e,-+(' %2 ad/",ed -( e',.+e -!a- "- &ee-, a%% -!e"&)(+-a'- c+"-e+"a a'd be f"- f(+ ).+)(,e " e-!a- -!e "',-+.&e'- "' *.e,-"(' 0a, f(+ e1a&)%e

,-a'da+d",ed f(+ .,e (' a ,.b,-a'-"a%%2 %a+ e a'd+e)+e,e'-a-"/e ,a&)%e (f -!e %(ca% )().%a-"(' 0"-!+e,)ec- -( a e e'de+ e-!'"c a'd ,(c"(\ec('(&"c

c(',"de+a-"(', a, 0e%% a, c(',"de+ed -( be b(-! a+e%"ab%e a'd /a%"d &ea,.+e (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ba ,ed (' acce )-ab%e face c( '- e' - fac- (+"a%c(',-+.c- a'd )+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2 A))e'd"1 Ade,c+"be, -!e,e "&)(+-a'- ),2c!(&e-+"c c+"-e+"a "'de-a"% -( !e%) -!e HR )+(fe,,"('a% be--e+ .'de+,-a'd-!e de,"+ed )+()e+-"e, a'd fea-.+e, 0!e' ,e%ec-"'a' a))%"cab%e EI def"'"-"(' a'd &ea,.+e S.c!de-a"%ed "'f(+&a-"(' (' -!e ),2c!(&e-+"c )+()\e+-"e, (f EI &ea,.+e, ca' be f(.'d "' -!e &(,- +e\ce'- ed"-"(' (f B*'$( Me#)a! Mea(*'e"e#) Yea'b$$a, 0e%% a, "' ).b%"ca-"(', -!a- f(c., )+"&a+"%2 ('EI &ea,.+e&e'- ,.c! a, G%e'' Ge!e+ , Mea(*'i#gE"$)i$#a! I#)e!!ige#ce 866: a'd Va' R((2 , +ece'-+e/"e0 (f )+(&"'e'- EI &ea,.+e, 866= T!e+(. ! +.%e (f -!.&b ", -( ,e%ec- -!e EI &ea,.+e 0"-!-!e ,-+(' e,- ),2c!(&e-+"c )+()e+-"e,

F(+ -!e ).+)(,e (f -!", )a)e+ 0e !a/e dec"ded -(.,e -!e Ba+\O' &(de% f(+ def"'"' a'd &ea,.+"'EI beca.,e "- +e)+e,e'-, ('e (f -!e &(,- /a%"dc(&)+e!e',"/e a'd a))%"cab%e c('ce)-.a% a'd),2c!(&e-+"c &(de%, c.++e'-%2 a/a"%ab%e eBa+\O' 866: 866< P%a$e I&)a+a 7??? 8667 Va'R((2 V",0e,/a+a' 866=

E B> >< " 4J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 1

T!e "'d"/"d.a% , +e,)(',e, +e'de+ a -(-a% EQ ,c(+ea'd ,c(+e, (' -!e ; c(&)(,"-e ,ca%e, a'd 7; ,.b\,ca%e, %",-ed "' Tab%e 8 Sc(+e, a+e c(&).-e+\ e'\

e+a-ed a'd +a0 ,c(+e, a+e a.-(&a-"ca%%2-ab.%a-ed a'd c('/e+-ed "'-( ,-a'da+d ,c(+e, ba,ed (' a &ea' (f 766 a'd ,-a'da+d de/"a-"(',(f 7; 0!"c! &a$e, "- ", )(,,"b%e -( c(&)a+e -!e+e,)('de'- 0"-! (-!e+, f+(& -!e ,a&e )().%a-"('"++e,)ec-"/e (f a e a'd e'de+ ba,ed (' -!e '(+&,-!a- 0e+e c+ea-ed f(+ -!e /a+"(., a e[ e'de+ +(.),0!( c(&)%e-ed -!e EQ i 0!e' "- 0a, ,-a'da+d\",ed f(+ .,e T!", ,c(+"' )+(ce,, 0"-! -!e &ea',c(+e ad#.,-ed -( 766 +e,e&b%e, IQ I'-e%%" e'ceQ.(-"e'- ,c(+e, 0!"c! 0a, Ba+\O' , "'-e'-"('0!e' !e c("'ed -!e -e+& EQ E&(-"('a%Q.(-"e'- A/e+a e -( ab(/e a/e+a e EQ ,c(+e,(' -!e EQ i ,. e,- -!a- -!e +e,)('de'- ", effec-"/e"' e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% f.'c-"('"' T!e !" !e+-!e ,c(+e, -!e &(+e )(,"-"/e -!e )+ed"c-"(' f(+effec-"/e f.'c-"('"' "' &ee-"' da"%2 de&a'd,a'd c!a%%e' e, O' -!e (-!e+ !a'd %(0 EQ ,c(+e,,. e,- a' "'ab"%"-2 -( be effec-"/e a'd -!e )(,,"b%ee1",-e'ce (f e&(-"('a% ,(c"a% a'd[(+ be!a/"(.+a%)+(b%e&,

T!e EQ i !a, a b."%-\"' c(++ec-"(' fac-(+ -!a-a.-(&a-"ca%%2 ad#.,-, -!e ,ca%e ,c(+e, ba,ed (',c(+e, (b-a"'ed f+(& -0( (f -!e "',-+.&e'- , /a%"d"-2"'d"ce, P(,"-"/e I&)+e,,"(' a'd Ne a-"/e I&)+e,\,"(' T!", ", a /e+2 "&)(+-a'- fea-.+e f(+ ,e%f\+e)(+-&ea,.+e, beca.,e "- +ed.ce, -!e )(-e'-"a%%2d",-(+-"' effec-, (f -!(,e +e,)('de'-, 0!( -+2 -(

fa$e ((d f(+ e1a&)%e a'd -!e+eb2 "'c+ea,e, -!eacc.+ac2 (f -!e (/e+a%% +e,.%-, I' add"-"(' -( -!e,e-0( /a%"d"-2 ,ca%e, -!", EI "',-+.&e'- a%,( !a, a'I'c(',",-e'c2 I'de1 0!"c! "de'-"f"e, -!e de +ee -(0!"c! a +e,)('de'- &a2 be +e,)('d"' "' a!a)!a3a+d fa,!"(' b+"' "' -!e /a%"d"-2 (f -!e,c(+e, "'-( *.e,-"('

T!e EQ i 0a, -!e f"+,- EI &ea,.+e -( be ).b%",!ed b2 a ),2c!(%( "ca% -e,- ).b%",!e+ Ba+\O' 7??=aa'd -!e f"+,- ,.c! &ea,.+e -( be )ee+\+e/"e0ed "'-!e B*'$( Me#)a! Mea(*'e"e#) Yea'b$$ P%a$e I&)a+a 7??? T!e 2(.-! /e+,"(' (f -!", &ea,.+e

-!e EQ i =YV 0a, +ec(&&e'ded f(+ .,e "'

,c!((%, 'a-"('0"de "' B+"-a"' ba,ed (' -!e +ec\(&&e'da-"(', (f +e,ea+c!e+, a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (fO1f(+d 0!( +e/"e0ed ;? ,.c! "',-+.&e'-, (/e+ a

-0(\2ea+ )e+"(d ba,ed (' )e+,('a% c(&&.'"ca-"(' "'8668 be-0ee' -!e +e,ea+c!e+, a'd -0( (f -!e c(\a.-!(+, (f -!", )a)e+ I- ", -!e &(,- 0"de%2 .,ed&ea,.+e (f e&(-"('a%\,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce -( da-e

Ba+\O' 866: a'd -!e ).b%",!e+ !a, +ece'-%2+e/ea%ed -( ('e (f -!e c(\a.-!(+, -!a- a))+(1"&a-e%2!a%f a &"%%"(' -e,-, !a/e bee' c(&)%e-ed 0(+%d0"de(/e+ -!e )a,- ,e/e' 2ea+, a%('e

T!e EQ i !a, bee' ,-a'da+d",ed f(+ .,e "' &a'2c(.'-+"e, I- !a, bee' -+a',%a-ed "'-( &(+e -!a' 96%a' .a e, a'd da-a !a/e bee' c(%%ec-ed f+(& a0"de /a+"e-2 (f ,e--"' , a+(.'d 0(+%d Be"' de/e%\()ed (/e+ a )e+"(d (f 7= 2ea+, a'd e1a&"'ed "' a%a+ e '.&be+ (f /a%"d"-2 ,-.d"e, c('d.c-ed (' -e',(f -!(.,a'd, (f "'d"/"d.a%, -!", "',-+.&e'- !a, -!e&(,- e1-e',"/e e&)"+"ca% .'de+)"''"' , (f a%% a/a"%\ab%e EI "',-+.&e'-, M(+e(/e+ "- !a, bee'c+(,,\c.%-.+a%%2 /a%"da-ed "' &a'2 c(.'-+"e, a'd(' /a+"(., ,(c"(\ec('(&"c %e/e%, ba,ed (' %a+ e a'dd"/e+,e )().%a-"(' ,a&)%e, 0(+%d0"de

A))e'd"ce, B C a'd D c('-a"' ,.&&a+",ed+e,ea+c! f"'d"' , (' -!e "',-+.&e'- , +e%"ab"%"-2c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 a'd )+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2 +e,)ec\-"/e%2 T!e,e f"'d"' , "'d"ca-e -!a- -!e EQ\"Z ", a+e%"ab%e a'd /a%"d &ea,.+e (f e&(-"('a%\,(c"a%"'-e%%" e'ce " e "- ", c(',",-e'- ,-ab%e (/e+ -"&e&ea,.+e, 0!a- "- 0a, de," 'ed -( &ea,.+e a'd)+ed"c-, a 0"de /a+"e-2 (f !.&a' be!a/"(.+ a'dac-"/"-2 A &(+e de-a"%ed de,c+")-"(' (f !(0 "- 0a,de/e%()ed a'd "-, ),2c!(&e-+"c )+()e+-"e, ", f(.'d

"' -!e Ba' O# EQ i Tech#ica! Ma#*a! Ba+\O' 7??=bB*'$( Me#)a! Mea(*'e"e#) Yea'b$$ P%a$e I&)a+a7??? a'd "' G%e'' Ge!e+ , +ece'- b(($ -"-%ed Mea(*'i#g E"$)i$#a! I#)e!! ige#ce 866:

E B> >< " 6J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 1

1. @ < EI <; < @ <;> <> ;

I' a '.&be+ (f ,-.d"e, -!a- !a/e bee' ,.&&a+",ed(/e+ -!e )a,- decade e Ba+\O' 7??=b 866:866<a 866<b Ba+\O' Ha'd%e2 F.'d 866< Ha'\d%e2 7??= R.de+&a' Ba+\O' 8669 -!eEQ i!a, ,!(0' -!a- -!e+e ", a !" !%2 ," '"f"ca'- +e%a-"('\,!") be-0ee' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd (cc.)a\-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce T!e a/e+a e )+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2f(+ -!e,e ,-.d"e, ", ;; &ea'"' -!a- a))+(1"&a-e%296@ (f (cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce ", ba,ed (' EI a,

de,c+"bed b2 -!e Ba+\O' &(de% a'd 0!e' %eade+\,!") ", e1a&"'ed ,e)a+a-e%2 f+(& e'e+a% (cc.)a\-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce -!", f" .+e "'c+ea,e, -( ab(.-<=@ &ea'"' -!a- -0(\-!"+d, (f %eade+,!") ",de)e'de'- .)(' EI Ba+\O' 866<a

I' -!e f"+,- $'(0' ,-.d2 -!a- d"+ec-%2 e1a&"'ed -!e+e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' EI a'd (cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&\a'ce -!e EQ i ,c(+e, (f 7 7=7 US A"+ F(+ce+ec+."-e+, USAF 0e+e c(&)a+ed 0"-! -!e"+ ab"%"-2-( &ee- a''.a% +ec+."-&e'- *.(-a, Ha'd%e2 7??=

Ba+\O' e- a% 866< Ba,ed (' USAF c+"-e+"a -!e20e+e d"/"ded "'-( -!(,e 0!( 0e+e ab%e -( &ee- a-

%ea,- 766@ (f -!e"+ a''.a% *.(-a !" ! )e+f(+&e+,a'd -!(,e 0!( &e- %e,, -!a' >6@ %(0 )e+f(+&e+,+e)+e,e'-"' a /e+2 +(b.,- &e-!(d (f a,,e,,"' (cc.\)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce A d",c+"&"'a'- f.'c-"('a'a%2,", "'d"ca-ed -!a- EQ i ,c(+e, 0e+e ab%e -(fa"+%2 acc.+a-e%2 "de'-"f2 !" ! a'd %(0 )e+f(+&e+,de&(',-+a-"' -!a- -!e +e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' EI a'd(cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce ", !" ! ;9 ba,ed (' -!e,a&)%e ,-.d"ed P+"(+ -( 7??< "- 0a, c(,-"' -!eUSAF a))+(1"&a-e%2 -!+ee &"%%"(' d(%%a+, f(+ a'

a/e+a e 766 &",&a-c!e, a 2ea+ Af-e+ ('e 2ea+ (fc(&b"'"' )+e\e&)%(2&e'- EI ,c+ee'"' 0"-!"'-e+/"e0"' a'd c(&)a+"' EQ i ,c(+e, 0"-!-!e &(de% f(+ ,.cce,,f.% +ec+."-e+, -!e2 "'c+ea,ed-!e"+ ab"%"-2 -( )+ed"c- ,.cce,,f.% +ec+."-e+, b2 'ea+%2-!+eef(%d +ed.ced f"+,-\2ea+ -.+'(/e+ d.e -( &",\&a-c!e, a'd c.- -!e"+ f"'a'c"a% %(,,e, b2 a))+(1\"&a-e%2 ?8@ d+a&a-"ca%%2 "&)ac-"' -!e"+ b(--(&%"'e Ba,ed (' -!e,e +e,.%-, -!e US Ge'e+a%Acc(.'-"' Off"ce ,.b&"--ed a C(' +e,,"('a%

Re)(+- -( -!e Se'a-e C(&&"--ee (' A+&ed Se+/"ce,)+a","' -!e USAF , .,e (f EI ,c+ee'"' 0!"c! 0a, ba, ed (' -!e EQ \" Z U' "-ed S- a-e, Ge' e+ a%Acc(.'-"' Off"ce 7??>

T!e +e,.%-, e'e+a-ed b2 -!e EQ i c(&)a+e *."-efa/(.+ab%2 0"-! -!(,e e'e+a-ed b2 (-!e+ EI &ea,\.+e, "' )+ed"c-"' (cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce F(+e1a&)%e -!e c(++e%a-"(' be-0ee' -!e MSCEIT a'd(cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce +a' e be-0ee' 88 a'd

:< B+ac$e-- Sa%(/e2 866:

E B> >< " 7J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 2

@ <; 2: E > B ? E ; <> A ; E <@ <;

I;@ ; ; @ <>

T!", ,ec-"(' (f -!e )a)e+ )+(/"de, a ,.&&a+2 (f ,-.d"e, -!a- e&)"+"ca%%2 &a$e -!e b.,"'e,, ca,e f(+ EIT!e,e ,-.d"e, 0!"c! 0e+e c('d.c-ed "' a /a+"e-2 (f (+ a'",a-"('a% ,e--"' , a+e de,c+"bed a'd *.a'-"f2 -!e"&)ac- (f EI "'-e+/e'-"(', (' (cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce %eade+,!") a'd (+ a'",a-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2

A c(',e',., (f f"'d"' , "' -!e ,-.d"e, ,.&&a+",ed-( da-e .,"' -!e EQ i "'d"ca-e -!a- -!e &(,-)(0e+f.% EI c('-+"b.-(+, -( (cc.)a-"('a% )e+f(+&\

a'ce a+e a -!e ab"%"-2 -( be a0a+e (f a'd acce)- ('e,e%f

b -!e ab"%"-2 -( be a0a+e (f (-!e+, fee%"' , c('ce+', a'd 'eed,

c -!e ab"%"-2 -( &a'a e e&(-"(',

d -!e ab"%"-2 -( be +ea%",-"c a'd ).- -!"' , "'c(++ec- )e+,)ec-"/e a'd

e -!e ab"%"-2 -( !a/e a )(,"-"/e d",)(,"-"(' a'd(.-%(($ (' %"fe

EI )+(f"%e, ba,ed (' -!", -2)e (f "'f(+&a-"(' a+e"'c+ea,"' %2 a))%"ed "' ,e%ec-"(' -+a"'"' %eade+\,!") de/e%()&e'- a'd ,.cce,,"(' )%a''"' 0(+%d\0"de T!", a))+(ac! "'c+ea,e, -!e c!a'ce, (fe&)%(2"' a'd de/e%()"' !" !e+ )e+f(+&"'e&)%(2ee, 0!( c(%%ec-"/e%2 -e'd -( "'c+ea,e(+ a'",a-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2

2. @ < EI <; >?

T!", ,ec-"(' de,c+"be, f(.+ fa,c"'a-"' ,-.d"e, -!a-e1a&"'e -!e "&)ac- (f EI (' %eade+,!") Ba+\O'866: Ba+\O' e- a% 866< S%a,$" Ca+-0+" !- 8668T!e,e ,-.d"e, a+e )+e,e'-ed !e+e -( "%%.,-+a-e -!e .'\e*."/(ca% "&)(+-a'ce (f -!", c(',-+.c- f(+ -!ec(+)(+a-e 0(+%d

I' -!e f"+,- ,-.d2 Ba+\O' e- a% 866< 7 6?< &a%e+ec+."-, "' -!e I,+ae%" Defe',e F(+ce, IDF 0e+ea,$ed -( c!((,e -!(,e )e()%e "' 2(.+ .'"- 0!( a+e&(,- ,."-ab%e f(+ a %eade+,!") +(%e T!(,e 0!( 0e+e"de'-"f"ed b2 -!e"+ )ee+, a, !a/"' %eade+,!") )(-e'\-"a% ' ;9< 0e+e +e*.e,-ed -( c(&)%e-e -!e EQ iA -(-a% ,c(+e f(+ %eade+,!") )(-e'-"a% 0a, c+ea-ed b2 ca%c.%a-"' -!e '.&be+ (f -"&e, a +ec+."- 0a,'(&"'a-ed b2 !", )ee+, f(+ )(,,e,,"' -!", )a+-"c.\%a+ a--+"b.-e D",c+"&"'a'- f.'c-"(' a'a%2,", 0a,a))%"ed -( -!e da-a -( ,ee "f EQ\"Z ,c(+e, c(.%dd",-"' .",! be-0ee' +ec+."-, 0"-! -!e !" !e,- a'd%(0e,- +a-"' , f(+ )ee+\)e+ce"/ed %eade+,!") )(-e'-"a%T!e +e,.%-, "'d"ca-ed -!a- -!e+e ", "'deed a ,-a-",\-"ca%%2 ," '"f"ca'- c(++e%a-"(' be-0ee' EI a'd %ead\e+,!") )(-e'-"a% 9? Add"-"('a%%2 -!e f"'d"' ,

,. e,-ed -!a- -!e EI &(de% -!a- be,- "de'-"f"e,%eade+,!") )(-e'-"a% "' -!", ,)ec"f"c ,a&)%ec(&)+",e, -!e f(%%(0"' e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a%fac-(+, Se%f\Re a+d E&)a-!2 S-+e,, T(%e+a'ceRea%"-2 Te,-"' a'd F%e1"b"%"-2 T!", &ea', -!a--!(,e "'d"/"d.a%, 0!( )(,,e,,ed !" ! %e/e%, (f-!e,e )a+-"c.%a+ EI fac-(+, 0e+e )e+ce"/ed a,!a/"' !" ! %eade+,!") )(-e'-"a%

I' a ,ec('d ,-.d2 Ba+\O' e- a% 866< :=6 (ff"ce+-+a"'ee, "' -!e I,+ae%" Defe',e F(+ce, IDF 0e+ec(&)a+ed 0"-! a +a'd(&%2 ,e%ec-ed +(.) (f:=6 +ec+."- , f+(& -!e ,a&e ,a&)%e ' 8 ;79 T!",0a, -!(. !- -( +e)+e,e'- a &(+e +(b.,- a))+(ac! -(

"de'-"f2"' %eade+,!") )(-e'-"a% -!a' -!e a))+(ac!.,ed "' -!e )+e/"(., ,-.d2 beca.,e a +(.) (f IDF+ec+."-, 0!( 0e+e ac-.a%%2 e'+(%%ed "' (ff"ce+ -+a"'"'0e+e be"' c(&)a+ed 0"-! a +(.) (f +ec+."-, 0!(d"d '(- &ee- -!e &"'"&.& +e*."+e&e'-, f(+ (ff"ce+-+a"'"' d"d '(- )a,, -!e ),2c!(%( "ca% ,c+ee'"'+e*."+ed (+ d"d '(- e1)+e,, a de,"+e -( be (ff"ce+, I-0a, f(.'d -!a- -!e &ea' ,c(+e f(+ -!e (ff"ce+-+a"'ee, 0a, ," '"f"ca'-%2 !" !e+ -!a' -!a- (f-!e e'%",-ed &e' 76> /e+,., 766 +e,)ec-"/e%2

- ? <6 ) 667 D",c+"&"'a'- f.'c-"(' a'a%2,", 0a,

-!e' a))%"ed -( -!e da-a -( ,ee "f "- c(.%d d",-"' .",! be-0ee' -! e -0( +(. ), T!e +e ,.%- , (' cea a "' "' d"c a-e d -!a- EI ca' )+ed"c- %eade+,!"))(-e '-"a% a'd -!a- -!e -0( e'-"-"e, a+e ," '"f"ca'-%2+e%a-ed :? Add"-"('a%%2 -!e be,- EI )+ed"c-(+, (f%eade+,!") a))ea+ -( be -!e f(%%(0"' c(&)e-e'ce,,$"%%, a'd fac"%"-a-(+, Se%f\Re a+d E&(-"('a% Se%f\A0a+e'e,, I'de)e'de'ce E&)a-!2 I'-e+)e+,('a%Re%a-"(',!") S-+e,, T(%e+a'ce Rea%"-2 Te,-"'P+(b%e& S(%/"' a'd Ha))"'e,, Ba,ed (' -!ec%a,,"f"ca-"(' &a-+"1 (f -!e ,-a-",-"ca% a))%"ca-"('

.,ed -!e ab"%"-2 (f -!", &(de% -( )+ed"c- %eade+,!"))(-e'-"a% ", <?@ acc.+a-e T!", &ea', &(+e(/e+-!a- a))+(1"&a-e%2 = (.- (f 76 )(-e'-"a%%2 ,.cce,,f.%ca'd"da-e, f(+ (ff"ce+ -+a"'"' c(.%d be "de'-"f"ed.,"' -!", &(de%

O'e (f -!e &(,- "'f(+&a-"/e ,-.d"e, -!a- e1a&"'ed-!e +e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' EI a'd %eade+,!") 0a,c(' d.c -ed a- -!e Ce'-e+ f(+ C+ea-"/e Leade+,!")

CCL "' -!e U'"-ed S-a-e, R.de+&a' Ba+\O'8669 I' -!", %a'd&a+$ ,-.d2 966 e1ec.-"/e, (+" "\'a%%2 a +eed -( )a+-"c")a-e b2 c(&)%e-"' -!e EQ i

E B> >< " 8J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 2

C(&)%e-e da-a 0e+e (b-a"'ed f(+ 89< )a+-"c")a'-,af-e+ f(.+ e1-+e&e (.-%"e+, 0e+e e1c%.ded f+(& -!e,a&)%e T!", ,a&)%e "'c%.ded 7=; &e' a'd <70(&e' T!e,e "'d"/"d.a%, +e)+e,e'-ed e1ec.-"/e,0(+$"' "' a /a+"e-2 (f d"ffe+e'- %eade+,!"))( ," -" (' , "' /a+"(., (+ a'",a-"(' ac+(,, N(+-!A&e+"ca T!e &ea' a e 0a, :8 : 2ea+, f(+ -!e &a%e,a'd :8 > f(+ -!e fe&a%e, I' add"-"(' -( ad&"'",-e+"'-!e EQ i -( a,,e,, EI eac! "'d"/"d.a% , %eade+,!")ab"%"-2 0a, +a-ed b2 a' a/e+a e (f ,e/e' -(e" !- c(\0(+$e+, .,"' Be'c!&a+$,Z Be'c!\&a+$,Z ", a 9<6 de +ee &.%-"\+a-e+ de/e%()ed b2CCL c(',",-"' (f 7< &a#(+ c(&)('e'-, de," 'ed-( +a-e ,.cce,,f.% %eade+,!") a'd f"/e c(&)('e'-,

de," 'ed -( +a-e de+a"%&e'- 0!"c! ", -!e )(-e'-"a%f(+ /e+2 )((+ %eade+,!") T!e +a-"' , 0e+ec(&b"'ed a'd a/e+a ed -( c+ea-e a' (/e+a%% &ea'+a-"' f(+ eac! )a+-"c")a'- Ba,ed (' a d",c+"&\"'a'- f.'c-"(' a'a%2,", -!a- 0a, .,ed -( e1a&"'e-!e "&)ac- (f EI (' %eade+,!") "- 0a, f(.'d -!a- -!e(/e+a%% c(++e%a-"(' 0a, =: &ea'"' -!a- a- %ea,- ;;@(f ,.cce,,f.% %eade+,!") ", ba,ed (' e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce Acc(+d"' -( -!", &(de% -!e EI fac-(+,-!a- !a/e -!e ,-+(' e,- "&)ac- (f %eade+,!")a+e e&)a-!2 "'-e+)e+,('a% +e%a-"(',!") ,(c"a%

+e,)(',"b"%"-2 ,-+e,, -(%e+a'ce a'd )+(b%e&,(%/"' I- ", "'-e+e,-"' -( '(-e -!a- -!e f"+,- -!+eea'd ,-+(' e,- fac-(+, a+e -!(,e 0!"c! a+e (f-e'+efe++ed -( a, )e()%e ,$"%%, f(%%(0ed b2 -!e ab"%"-2-( &a'a e e&(-"(', a'd ,(%/e )+(b%e&,

I' -!e f(.+-! a'd %a,- ,-.d2 )+e,e'-ed !e+e S%a,$"a'd Ca+-0+" !- 8668 ,-.d"ed -!e +e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' EQ i ,c(+e, a'd ,e/e+a% d"ffe+e'- a,)ec-,(f %eade+,!") a&(' 88: &"dd%e &a'a e+, a-TESCO 0!"c! ", a %a+ e B+"-",! +e-a"% (+ a'",a-"('Ma'a e+"a% )e+f(+&a'ce 0a, +a-ed .,"' -!e (+ a'\",a-"(' , c(&)e-e'c2 f+a&e0(+$ 0!"c! "'c%.ded 7<fac-(+, -!(. !- -( be c+"-"ca% f(+ ,.cce,, ,.c! a, -!eab"%"-2 -( ,e- (b#ec-"/e, )%a' (+ a'",e a'd&a$e dec","(', T!e +e,ea+c!e+, a%,( c(%%ec-edda-a (' e'e+a% )!2,"ca% a'd ),2c!(%( "ca% !ea%-!a, 0e%% a, ,.b#ec-"/e &ea,.+e, (f ,-+e,, I' add"-"('-( +e/ea%"' a ," '"f"ca'-%2 !" ! c(++e%a-"(' be-0ee'EI a'd (/e+a%% &a'a e+"a% )e+f(+&a'ce "- 0a,f(.'d -!a- -!e &(+e e&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- &a'\a e+, e1)e+"e'ce ," '"f"ca'-%2 %e,, ,-+e,, a+e!ea%-!"e+ a'd e'#(2 -!e"+ 0(+$ &(+e 0!e'c(&)a+ed 0"-! %e,, e&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- &a'a e+,

3. @ < EI <; <> ; ? @ <; >< @ @

I' a +(.'d\b+ea$"' ,-.d2 c('d.c-ed b2 La' !(+'8669 a- W!"-b+ead "' -!e UK fa,c"'a-"' f"'d"' ,

0e+e +e/ea%ed "'d"ca-"' a def"'"-e +e%a-"(',!") be -0ee ' EI a'd (+ a '" ,a-" ('a% )+(d .c -" /" -2

:= M(+e ,)ec"f"ca%%2 "- 0a, f(.'d -!a- -!a--!e e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (f +e,-a.+a'- &a'\a e+, ," '"f"ca'-%2 "&)ac-, a''.a% )+(f"-

+(0-! Ba,ed (' -!e -!", ,-.d2 &(+e(/e+ -!eEI fac-(+, -!a- a+e -!e be,- )+ed"c-(+, (f )+(d.c\-"/"-2 a))ea+ -( be E&(-"('a% Se%f\A0a+e'e,,

I'-e+)e+,('a% Re%a-"(',!") S(c"a% Re,)(',"b"%"-2Rea%"-2 Te,-"' a'd Ha))"'e,,

I- 0a, a%,( f(.'d -!a- +e,-a.+a'-, &a'a ed b2&a'a e+, 0"-! !" ! e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce,!(0ed a' a''.a% )+(f"- +(0-! (f 88@ /e+,.,a' a''.a% a/e+a e +(0-! (f 7;@ f(+ -!e ,a&e)e+"(d -!", a&(.'-ed -( a' a''.a% "'c+ea,e f(+-!", )a+-"c.%a+ c(&)a'2 (f a))+(1"&a-e%2 776ML F.+-!e+&(+e +e,-a.+a'-, &a'a ed b2 fe&a%e&a'a e+, 0"-! !" ! EI e1!"b"-ed a' a''.a%

+(0-! (f 8>@ a&(.'-"' -( a' "'c+ea,e (f 866ML f(+ -!e ,a&e )e+"(d I- 0(.%d be "'-e+e,-"'-( )('de+ -!e a''.a% )+(f"- +(0-! f(+ -!e,e,a&e +e,-a.+a'-, "f -!e e&)%(2ee, a, 0e%% a, -!e&a'a e+, 0e+e ab%e -( "'c+ea,e -!e"+ EI a, -!e+e,.%- (f +(.) -+a"'"' a'd "'d"/"d.a% c(ac!"'f(c.,"' (' -!e,e ,)ec"f"c fac-(+, A'd 0!a- "f-!", 0a, c(&b"'ed 0"-! +ec+."-"' +e,-a.+a'-&a'a e+, 0"-! ab(/e a/e+a e e&(-"('a% ,e%f\a0a+e\'e,, "'-e+)e+,('a% +e%a-"(',!") ,$"%%, ,(c"a% +e,)('\,"b"%"-2 +ea%"-2 -e,-"' a'd !a))"'e,, T!e,e)(,,"b"%"-"e, a+e e1)%(+ed "' de-a"% "' -!e 'e1-,ec-"('

E B> >< " 9J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 2

1. H< @< >< @ @ <;< EI ; <> > @< ?

<> ; ? @ <; >< @ @

T!e+e a+e ,e/e' $e2 0a2, "' 0!"c! a' HR )+(fe,\,"('a% ca' "'-+(d.ce EI "'-( -!e &"1 (f HR ac-"/"-"e,"' a ,)ec"f"c (+ a'",a-"(' S(&e (f -!e,e 0"%% be&(+e "&)(+-a'- -!a' (-!e+, de)e'd"' (' -!e b.," 'e,, c('-e1- (f -!a- (+ a'",a-"('

E >< ; < $ @ <;? ; @ > % > <> >?T!e .,e (f a' EQ -((% %e'd, "-,e%f -( c+ea-"'(+ a'" ,a- "(' a% $'(0%ed e (f 0!a- c(',-"-.-e,e1ce)-"('a% )e()%e )e+f(+&a'ce I- .,.a%%2 "'/(%/e,c('d.c-"' EQ a,,e,,&e'-, b(-! 0"-!"' a'd (.-,"dea -a+ e- +(.) (f &a'a e+, (+ "'d"/"d.a%, We%% ,-+.c\-.+ed "'-e+/e'-"(', !a/e -!", a, a ,-a+-"' )("'- ,ee-!e ca,e ,-.d2 de,c+"bed "' -!", ,ec-"(' T!e .,e (f)+(f"%"' )+(/"de, a ,(%"d e&)"+"ca% ba,", a'd +(b.,-a))+(ac! f(+ ,e%ec-"(' -+a"'"' a'd ,.cce,,"(')%a''"'

> @ ;@ ; @ <;\ T!", "'/(%/e, -!e .,e(f EI a,,e,,&e'- a, )a+- (f -!e ,e%ec-"(' )+(ce,,e,e&)%(2ed a%(' ,"de (-!e+ a,,e,,&e'- -((%, a'd&e-!(d, T!e &(,- c(&)e%%"' e/"de'ce (f -!e"&)ac- (f -!", ca' be f(.'d "' -!e Ha'%e2 ,-.d2*.(-ed ea+%"e+ "' -!", )a)e+ T!", ", ba,ed )+"&a+"%2(' EI )+(f"%"' b2 c(&)a+"' -!e EQ\" +e,.%-, 0"-!-!e EI )+(f"%e (f -!e (+ a'",a-"(' , ,-a+ )e+f(+&e+,

G>< @> ; ; ; @ < ;@ \ T!e .,e(f a' EI -((% a, )a+- (f '(- ('%2 -!e de," ' (f a'"'-e+/e'-"(' (f +(.) -+a"'"' (+ -ea& de/e%()\&e'- b.- a%,( a, -!e "'-e+/e'-"(' "-,e%f T!e .,e (fa' EI &ea,.+e&e'- -((% e'c(.+a e, ,e%f\a0a+e'e,,a'd )+(/"de, a /e+2 "&)(+-a'- ,-a+-"' )("'- If 2(.d(' - $'(0 -!e ,-a+-"' )("'- !(0 d( 2(. $'(00!e+e 2(. 0a'- -( +eac! a'd 0!a- 2(. 0!a- -( ac\c(&)%",!

I; C<> <> @ C< ; \ T!e .,e (f EI&ea,.+e&e'- 0"-!"' ('e\-(\('e c(ac!"' T!",

(f-e' a))ea+, a, ('e\-(\('e "' -!e %"-e+a-.+e I- ",(.+ e1)e+"e'ce -!a- &(,- c(ac!"' "' (+ a'",a-"(',+e%"e, .)(' )e+,('a%"-"e, -!e c(ac! a'd -!e "'d"\/"d.a% be"' c(ac!ed +a-!e+ -!a' !a+d da-a EI"'-e+/e'-"(', c+ea-e a' e/"de'ce ba,e f(+ c(ac!"'

?? <; % ;; ; \ T!", "'/(%/e, "de'-"f2"' a$e2 +(.) (f c+"-"ca% )e()%e a'd de," '"' a' EI "'\-e+/e'-"(' d"+ec-%2 a,,",-"' -!", +(.) -( beeffec-"/e T!e ca,e ,-.d2 (ffe+ed "' -!", ,ec-"(')+(/"de, a' e1a&)%e (f !(0 -( d( -!", "' )+ac-"ce

@ <; 3:A ; E <@ <; I;@ ; ; @ <>

Ha/"' e1)%a"'ed a'd +e/"e0ed -!e "&)(+-a'ce (f EI "' -!e 0(+$)%ace "' -!", ,ec-"(' 0e ,!"f- -!ef(c., -( -!e HR )+ac-"-"('e+ a'd -!e *.e,-"(' (f !(0 EI "'-e+/e'-"(', ca' be %(ca-ed ,-a+-ed a'd)+()e+%2 &a'a ed 0"-!"' a' HR ,2,-e&

I <>@ ;@ @ <;? < <@ <;;@ ; ; @ <>

I E ? > > > ? > ? > I G > ? < >? ?> I > ?I L - M > / < > > > I E > > H A >

E B> >< " 10J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 3

E B> >< " 11J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

"% ? ; " <> ; @ > ; <> <>-; ? @ <; ; \ T!e .,e (f a' EI -((% -( a,,e,,

a +(.) (f )e()%e 0"-!"' a f.'c-"(' (+ ac+(,, -!e

0!(%e (+ a'",a-"(' A- -"&e, (f &a#(+ c!a' e,&e+ e+, (f de)a+-&e'-, a'd c(&)a'"e, ac*.","\-"(', +ad"ca% (+ a'",a-"('a% +e,-+.c-.+"' -!", ca')+(/"de e,,e'-"a% c%.e, a, -( !(0 -( ,-+.c-.+e -!e"'-e+/e'-"(', a'd "'"-"a-"/e, -!a- -!e HR f.'c-"(' ",-a,$ed 0"-! I- a%,( !a, a de/e%()&e'-a% f(c., -("de'-"f2 a'd a,,e,, 0!"c! c(&)('e'-, 0"%% be &(,-!e%)f.% f(+ -!e (+ a'",a-"(' -( de/e%()

E %>< < H A < @ ?\ O'e "&)(+-a'- a,)ec-(f 0(+$ "' -!e a+ea (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -!a- ",(f-e' (/e+%(($ed ", -!e EQ )+(f"%e (f -!e $e2 ad/(\ca-e, (f a' "'-e+/e'-"(' (+ (+ a'",a-"('a% c!a' eT!e EQ )+(f"%e (f HR )e()%e 0!( "&)%e&e'- -!e,e"'-e+/e'-"(', ", "&)(+-a'- -( .'de+,-a'd -!e+e\f(+e "- ", .,ef.% -( a,,e,, 2(.+ (0' e&(-"('a% "'-e%\%" e'ce a, a' HR )+(fe,,"('a% bef(+e a--e&)-"' -(a))%2 EI "' -!e 0(+$)%ace F(+ "',-a'ce a N(+-!A&e+"ca' +e,ea+c! ,-.d2 )+(d.ced -!e "'-e+e,-\"' c(',-e%%a-"(' (f EI ,-+e' -!, %",-ed "' G+a)! 70!"c! 0(.%d "'f%.e'ce !(0 a' HR )+(fe,,"('a% ",%"$e%2 -( ( ab(.- -!e -a,$ (f )e+,.ad"' (-!e+, -(e&ba+$ (' a ' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"('T!e,e ,-+e' -!, &a2 (+ &a2 '(- be -!e &(,- ()-"&a%,-+e' -!, f(+ a )a+-"c.%a+ c('-e1- I' (.+ e1)e+"e'ceHR P+(fe,,"('a%, 'e %ec- -!", %e/e% (f da-a a'd ,e%f\+ef%ec-"(' "' -!e ,)"+"- (f f(c.,"' (' -!e &(,- .+ e'-HR "'"-"a-"/e

2. %> - ; %<?@-I;@ > ;@ <; E?? ?? ;@?

Ac+(,, E.+()e a fe0 )+ac-"-"('e+, !a/e a--e&)-ed-( c(%%ec- da-a ,!(0"' -!e "&)ac- (f EI "'-e+/e'\-"(', T2)"ca%%2 a' EI a,,e,,&e'- ", .,ed a, a )+e\a'd )(,-\"'-e+/e'-"(' &ea,.+e (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%\%" e'ce a%(' ,"de (-!e+ b.,"'e,, )a+a&e-e+, 0!"c!ca' be -+ac$ed -!+(. ! -!e %"fe,)a' (f a' "'-e+\/e'-"(' T!e f(%%(0"' -0( +a)!, G+a)!, 8 a'd9 ,!(0 -!e "&)ac- (' EI f+(& a +(.) -+a"'"'"'-e+/e'-"(' a'd a' "'d"/"d.a% c(ac!"' "'-e+\/e'-"(' +e,)ec-"/e%2

G+a)! 8 +e%a-e, -( a %eade+,!") "'-e+/e'-"(' "' -!ec(',-+.c-"(' "'d.,-+2 T!e +(.) -+a"'"' 0a, ,-+.c\-.+ed a, f(.+ ('e\da2 0(+$,!(), G+a)! 9 +e%a-e,-( ,e'"(+ )+(fe,,"('a%, 0!( )a+-"c")a-ed "' a ('e\-(\('e c(ac!"' EI "'-e+/e'-"(' 0"-!"' a'

G ? 1A; E >< ? > ; H >?<;; < -

> @ @ < ;<>B -% , ? : $=469, C

G ? 2G>< @> ; ; ; ; > ? <@ <; ;-@ ;@ B <> <; ? ; <> ; >?

#. > , , 2001; ; =29,

G ? 3I; < ; ; ; > ? <@ <;

;@ ;@ <> <; @ ?G. B , 2003; E > , =47, !

E B> >< " : > 3

(+ a'",a-"(' )+(/"d"' c(',.%-a'c2 ,e+/"ce, -( &a#(+c(+)(+a-e c%"e'-, T!e c(ac!"' 0a, ,-+.c-.+ed a, a78\!(.+ "'-e+/e'-"(' de%"/e+ed a, ,"1 -0(\!(.+

,e,,"(', T!e be,- )+ac-"ce ."de%"'e, +e%a-"' -(c(ac!"' a, a ,)ec"f"c EI "'-e+/e'-"(' a+e %",-ed !e+eI- ", de,"+ab%e -( !a/e c%ea+ (a%, f(+ -!e c(ac!"')+e\ a'd )(,-\"'-e+/e'-"(' a,,e,,&e'- (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce a'd (-!e+ b.,"'e,, )a+a&e-e+, f(+e1a&)%e ac!"e/e&e'- (f +e/e'.e -a+ e-, c(&\)a+ed -( -!e )+e/"(., 2ea+ a )+edef"'ed ,-+.c\-.+e a'd acc(.'-ab"%"-2 ,( -!a- e/e+2('e ", a0a+e0!( ", +e,)(',"b%e f(+ 0!"c! a,)ec-, (f -!e "'-e+\/e'-"(' a'd f"'a%%2 "'/(%/ed ,-a$e!(%de+, M(+e

de-a"% ca' be f(.'d "' B!a+0a'e2 866< )) 7>9\7?= B(-! f(+&, (f "'-e+/e'-"(' !ad &ea,.+ab%e"&)ac- We 0"%% +e-.+' -( -!e c+"-e+"a f(+ ,.cce,,f.%"'-e+/e'-"(', a, )a+- (f -!e ca,e ,-.d2 "' Pa+- 9 be%(0

T!e,e da-a,e-, +e/ea% -!a- "- ", "'deed )(,,"b%e -("'c+ea,e EI b2 +(.) -+a"'"' a'd "'d"/"d.a%c(ac!"' a'd "- ", %( "ca% -( a,,.&e -!a- -( e-!e+0"-! -!e )+e/"(.,%2\&e'-"('ed f"'d"' , ,!(0"'

-!e +e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' EI a'd (+ a'"3a-"('a%)+(d.c-"/"-2 -!a- "- ", )(,,"b%e -( "&)ac- (+ a'",a\-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2 -!+(. ! EI "'-e+/e'-"(',

T!e,e f"'d"' , a+e ,.))(+-ed b2 a ,-.d2 c('d.c-ed b2 Ma+$ S%a,$" "' -!e UK 0!"c! "'/(%/ed +e,ea+c!0"-! 88: &a'a e+, 0"-!"' -!e Te,c( ,.)e+&a+$e-+e-a"% c!a"' He a%,( -+a"'ed <6 (f -!e,e &a'a e+,a'd f(.'d -!a- "- 0a, "'deed )(,,"b%e -( "'c+ea,ee&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce

3. A ? ?@ <;?@> @ ; <> ; ? @ <; @ < ; EI

;@ > ;@ <;

T!", ,ec-"(' (f -!e )a)e+ ,ee$, -( %a2 (.- -!ec('-e1- "' 0!"c! a ,)ec"f"c )+( +a&&e 0a,de ," 'ed a'd de%"/e+ed -!e b.,"'e,, "&)e+a-"/e-!e $e2 de," ' fea-.+e, "'/(%/ed a'd -!e )+(\

+a&&e +e,.%-, -!a- 0e+e (b-a"'ed T!e+e a+e -0((b#ec-"/e, .'de+)"''"' -!", ,ec-"(' F"+,-%2 0e0(.%d %"$e -( ,!a+e 0"-! 2(. a' a))+(ac! "'de," '"' a' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"('a'd ,ec('d%2 -( de&(',-+a-e -!e "&)ac- (f!a+'e,,"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' -!e 0(+$)%ace

D.+"' -!e -0(\2ea+ )e+"(d 8669\866; E" W(+%d"&)%e&e'-ed a' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ,e'"(+%eade+,!") de/e%()&e'- )+( +a&&e f(+ a %ead"'f"'a'c"a% ,e+/"ce, )+(/"de+ "' -!e UK -!e "&)ac-(f 0!"c! !ad a -a' "b%e a'd &ea,.+ab%e "&)ac-'(- ('%2 (' -!e )e+,('a% de/e%()&e'- (f -!e)a+-"c")a'-, b.- e*.a%%2 (' -!e P L (f -!e(+ a'",a-"('

B ? ; ?? > @

T!e EI )+( +a&&e de,c+"bed "' -!", ,ec-"('0a, de," 'ed a'd de%"/e+ed f(+ ('e (f -!e %ead"'f"'a'c"a% ,e+/"ce, (+ a'",a-"(', "' -!e UK T!",A&e+"ca'\(0'ed ba'$ 0!"c! be a' b.,"'e,, "' -!eUK "' -!e ea+%2 7??6, 0a, a&(' ,- -!e -() -!+ee

def"'ed b2 &a+$e- ,!a+e %ead"' &('(\%"'e ba'$,"' -!e UK e1)e+"e'c"' e1)('e'-"a% 2ea+ (' 2ea+

+(0-! T!e b(--(&\%"'e +(0-! !(0e/e+ !ad '(-

bee' &a-c!ed b2 a' e*."/a%e'- "'/e,-&e'- "' %ead\e+,!") de/e%()&e'- a'd +(0-! "' %(ca% %eade+,!")a'd a, -!e (+ a'",a-"(' &(/ed )a,- -!e %a.'c!decade "'-( -!e &a-.+"' )!a,e (f "-, e/(%.-"('-!e ,e'"(+ %eade+,!") "de'-"f"ed -!a- ", 0a, '( %(' e+a))+()+"a-e f(+ -!e &a#(+"-2 (f -!e UK ,e'"(+)(,"-"(' , -( be !e%d b2 e1ec.-"/e, f+(& -!e A&e+\"ca' )a+e'- ba'$ T!e+e 0a, a +ea%",a-"(' -!a-a' "'c+ea,ed "'/e,-&e'- f(c., "' %eade+,!")de/e%()&e'- 0a, c+"-"ca% a'd 0"-! -!", "'/e,-\

&e'- ca&e a c('c.++e'- c(&&"-&e'- f+(& -!e

E B> >< " 12J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 3

E B> >< " 13J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

)a+e'- (+ a'",a-"(' -!a- a, ,e'"(+ e1ec.-"/e)(,"-"(', beca&e a/a"%ab%e -!e2 0(.%d be -a$e' b2%(ca% %eade+,!") 0!e+e/e+ a))%"cab%e a'd a))+()+"a-eT!"+-2\f"/e "'d"/"d.a%, "' ,e'"(+ %eade+,!") )(\,"-"(', 0e+e "de'-"f"ed -( )a+-"c")a-e "' -!e)+( +a&&e T!e2 a%% f"%%ed -!e ,e%ec-"(' c+"-e+"a (fac!"e/"' c.++e'- !" ! )e+f(+&a'ce a, &ea,.+ed-!+(. ! -!e a''.a% +e/"e0 )+(ce,, -( e-!e+ 0"-!,e'"(+ e1ec.-"/e e'd(+,e&e'- (f -!e"+ )(-e'-"a% -(&(/e -( -!e ,e'"(+ e1ec.-"/e -ea& 0"-!"' a' 7>\8:&('-! -"&e )e+"(d

%>< > ? ;

I' 7??> -!e C(',(+-".& f(+ Re,ea+c! (' E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce "' O+ a'"3a-"(', ).b%",!ed a +e)(+-e'-"-%ed B+"' "' E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce -( -!e

W(+$)%ace "' 0!"c! "- "&)(+-a'-%2 "de'-"f"ed 88$e2 ,-e), 0!"c! "- ca%%ed T!e O)-"&a%P+(ce,, f(+ De/e%()"' E&(-"('a% I'-e%%"\

e'ce "' O+ a'"3a-"(',

T!e,e c+"-e+"a 0e+e f.+-!e+ +ef"'ed a'd a))%"ed b2

Ca''(' a'd O+&e a'd %a-e+ de,c+"bed "' a ,e+"e, (fa+-"c%e, ).b%",!ed "' C$"%e)e#c. : E"$)i$#a!I#)e!!ige#ce ('e (f -!e f"+,- ).b%"ca-"(', (' EI

ea+ed -(0a+d, a- HR )+(fe,,"('a%, W!"%,- !" !%2de,"+ab%e "- ", '(- a%0a2, )(,,"b%e (+ )+ac-"cab%e -("'c%.de a%% 88 ,-e), "' )+( +a&&e de," ' T!e+e a+e-e' ,-e), -!a- a+e !(0e/e+ "' (.+ ()"'"(' c+"-"ca%-( b."%d"' a' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"('0"-! !a+d\!"--"' P L "&)ac- a'd "- ", -!", c(',-e%\%a-"(' (f -e' ,-e), -!a- 0a, .,ed "' -!e de," ' a'dde%"/e+2 (f -!", )a+-"c.%a+ ,e'"(+ %eade+,!")de/e%()&e'- )+( +a&&e

E C<;?<>@ ? 22 @ %>< ??

E B> >< " : > 3

1. A?? ?? ; @ <> ; ? @ <;'? ; ?

T!", ,(.'d, ba,"c b.- a, a c+"-"ca% de," ' ,-e)"- ", (f-e' (/e+%(($ed (+ 'e %ec-ed 0"-! a c(',e\*.e'-"a% )(-e'-"a% +ed.c-"(' "' -!e (/e+a%% "&)ac- (fa' EI "'-e+/e'-"(' I- -a$e, -"&e -( e',.+e -!a--!e $e2 dec","(' &a$e+, a'd ,-a$e!(%de+, "'-!e (+ a'",a-"(' !a/e a ((d .'de+,-a'd"' (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd "-, )(-e'-"a% "&)ac-(' b( --(&\%" 'e +e,.%-, A, "&)(+-a'-%2 d.+"'-!", a,,e,,&e'- ,-a e "- ", "&)e+a-"/e -( "de'\-"f2 -!e )a+-"c.%a+ c(&)('e'-, (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce -!a- &a$e f(+ , .cce, , " ' - !e(+ a'"3a-"(' -!+(. ! -!e EQ )+(f"%"' (f !" !)e+f(+&a'ce a'd -( de," ' -!e )+( +a&&e 0"-!-!e de/e%()&e'- (f -!e,e c(&)('e'-, a, .'de+)"'\'"' fea-.+e, D.+"' -!", )!a,e " - ", c+"-"ca% -(,!a+e 0"-! -!e dec","('\&a$e+, -!e +e,.%-, (fda-a\d+"/e' +e,ea+c! a'd e/"de'ce a'd !(0e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ,"-, 0"-!"' -!e (+ a'",a\

-"( ' , e1",-"' %eade+,!") c.%-.+e

10 @ ?

E B> >< " 14J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 3

E B> >< " 15J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

2. D <;?@> @ ; > > ? ; ???

I- ", "&)(+-a'- -( ,e%% -!e a+ea, (f )(,,"b%e b.,"'e,,"&)ac- +a-!e+ -!a' a--e&)-"' -( ,e%% a' e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"(' -!e %a--e+ 0"-!(.- -!ef(+&e+ ", !a+d%2 a c(&)e%%"' "'/e,-&e'- c!("ceT!e dec","('\&a$e+, 'eed -( f.%%2 e'd(+,e -!e b. ," 'e ,, ca,e a'd .'de+,-a'd -!e c(',e*.e'ce, (f'('\"&)%e&e'-a-"(' "'deed "' (.+ e1)e+"e'ce -!e&(+e -!e )+( +a&&e ", ,ee' a, (0'ed b2 - !e b. ," 'e ,, %eade+, +a-!e+ -!a' ).+e%2 HR (0'ed-!e !" !e+ -!e"+ %e/e% (f e ' a e&e'- " ' -!e)+( + a&&e 0"%% be a'd -!e &(+e %"$e%2 "- 0"%% be

-( ac!"e/e a'd "'deed e1ceed -!e ,-a-ed b.,"'e,,"&)e+a-"/e, Pa+-"c")a-"(' "' -!e )a+-"c.%a+)+( +a&&e de,c+"bed !e+e 0a, )(,"-"('ed a, a)+"/"%e e a'd a +e,)(',"b"%"-2 '(- a' e'-"-%e&e'-a'd a, -!e ('%2 +(.-e -( be c(',"de+ed f(+ -!e,e '"(+ e1ec.-"/e ,.cce,,"(' )%a' T!", b(%d ,-a'ce0a, a $e2 fea-.+e (f -!e ,.cce,, (f - !", )a+-"c\.%a+ "'-e+/e'-"(' a, "- ,e- -!e -('e f(+ b(-! -!ede%"/e+ab%e, (f -!e )+( +a&&e a'd -!e %"$e %2+e-.+' (' "'/e,-&e'- -( -!e b.,"'e,, f+(& -!e/a+"(., %ea+'"' ac-"/"-"e, "'c%.ded 0"-!"' -!e"'-e+/e '-"( ' f(+ e1a&)%e -!e d(c.&e'-"' (f -!e

,-a$e!(%de+ +e,.%-,

3. A?? ?? ; >?<; ?@> ; @ ? ; @?

U'de+)"''"' -!", c+"-"ca% de," ' ,-e) ", c('f"de'\-"a%"-2 I- ", c+"-"ca%%2 "&)(+-a'- -!a- a%% )a+-"c")a'-,a'd ,e'"(+ ,)(',(+, .'de+,-a'd a'd b.2 "'-( -!ec(&&"-&e'- (f ca+e a,,(c"a-ed 0"-! )+(-ec-"')e+,('a% da-a N( )e+,('a% "'f(+&a-"(' ,!(.%d be,!a+ed .'%e,, -!e )a+-"c")a'- !"& (+ !e+,e%f c!((,e,-( d( ,( We a,,e,,ed )e+,('a% ,-+e' -!, a'd %"&"-,"' a '.&be+ (f d"ffe+e'- 0a2, We ,-a+-ed 0"-!)+(/"d"' a de-a"%ed .'de+,-a'd"' (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce a'd a )e+,('a% a,,e,,&e'- (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce .,"' -!e Ba+O' EQ\"Z We "&)%e\&e'-ed a' "'"-"a% EQ\"Z a,,e,,&e'- )+"(+ -( -!e)+( +a&&e %a.'c! 0!"c! "'c%.ded a ('e\('\('efeedbac$ ,e,,"(' a de-a"%ed "'d"/"d.a% +e)(+-c(ac!"' '(-e, a'd a' (.-%"'e de/e%()&e'- )%a'We b."%- a 9<6\de +ee e%e&e'- "'-( -!e )+( +a&&e-!+(. ! )ee+ a'd &a'a e+ feedbac$ T!e "'d"/"d.a%EQ\"Z a,,e,,&e'-, a'd -!e c(%%ec-"/e +(.))+(f"%e, 0e+e .,ed -( ,!a)e -!e ,)ec"f"c )+( +a&&ec('-e'- A /e+2 ,)ec"f"c %"'$ 0a, de/e%()ed be-0ee'"de'-"f"ed de/e%()&e'- ())(+-.'"-"e, (+ a'",a\

-"('a% 'eed a'd )+( +a&&e de," '

4. %>< ; @ >

We "'c(+)(+a-ed -!", de," ' fea-.+e "' a '.&be+ (fd"ffe+e'- 0a2, a%% .'de+)"''ed b2 a !" ! e&)a-!2%ea+'"' e'/"+('&e'- We )+(/"ded acce,, -(e1ec.-"/e c(ac!e, (.-,"de (f )%a''ed ,e,,"(', " e)e()%e !ad -"&e -( +ef%ec- (' feedbac$ a'd +e,)('d"' -!e"+ (0' -"&e Pa+-"c")a'-, 0e+e e'c(.+a ed-( ,!a+e 0"-! -!e"+ b.dd2 a %ea+'"' )a+-'e+ f+(&0"-!"' -!e )a+-"c")a-"' +(.) b.- 0e+e '(- (b%" ed-( d( ,( L"$e0",e 0e "'c(+)(+a-ed a ,e'"(+ &e'-(++e%a-"(',!") "'-( -!e )+( +a&&e a'd )a+-"c")a'-,0e+e e 'c ( .+a ed - ( , !a+e - !e"+ )e+, ( 'a%a,, e, ,&e '- , b.- 0e+e '(- (b%" ed -( d( ,(

5. E; < > ; >@ @ <;

A- "-, &(,- f.'da&e'-a% %e/e% )a+-"c")a-"('0a, e'c (.+a ed -!+(. ! -!e ,-+(' +e0a+d &ec!\a'",&, b."%- "'-( -!e )+( +a&&e \ ,.cce,,f.% c(&\)%e-"(' (f -!e )+( +a&&e ()e'ed -!e d((+ -(

E B> >< " : > 3

())(+-.'"-"e, (' -!e ,e'"(+ e1ec.-"/e -ea& I'add"-"(' -!e ,"1\&('-! )+( +a&&e 0a, de," 'ed-( e',.+e -!a- a%% %ea+'"' ,-2%e, 0e+e ca-e+ed f(+

('e$'\('e c(ac!"' &e'-(+"' 0(+$,!(), ('c+"-"ca% %eade+,!") ,$"%%, a'd $'(0%ed e b.dd"e, -(,.))(+- %ea+'"' a +e,(.+ce %"b+a+2 a'd de%"/e+2 (f b.,"'e,, c+"-"ca% "'"-"a-"/e, T!e )a+-"c")a'- , ab"%"-2-( "'f%.e'ce -!e de," ' a'd c('-e'- (f 0(+$,!(),0a, "&)(+-a'- a'd %a,-%2 -!e e'd(+,e&e'- (f -!e)+( +a&&e f+(& -!e ,e'"(+ %eade+,!") -ea& 0a,ab,(%.-e

6. @@ ; > < ?

T!e )+( +a&&e 0a, a%,( .'de+)"''ed b2 -+a',$a+e'c2 a- a%% ,-a e, a'd -!e a'-"c")a-ed (.-c(&e,0e+e e1)%"c"-%2 a+-"c.%a-ed a- -!e -"&e (f )+( +a&&e%a.'c! T!e )+( +a&&e (a%, 0e+e "'c(+)(+a-ed"'-( "'d"/"d.a% a''.a% (a%, e',.+"' -!a- -!e)a+-"c")a'-, 0e+e !e%d acc(.'-ab%e f(+ b(-! -!e+e,.%-, a'd -!e f"'a'c"a% "'/e,-&e'- De%"/e+2 (fc!a%%e' "' b.,"'e,,\c+"-"ca% "'"-"a-"/e, b2 "'d"/"d\.a%, a'd -!e +(.) 0a, a' "&)(+-a'- )+( +a&&ec(&)('e'-

7. ? ; < <>@ ; @ ? @< > @

T!e )+( +a&&e 0a, de," 'ed a+(.'d 0(+$,!(),0"-! c%ea+ a'd ,)ec"f"c ac-"(', f(+ "&)%e&e'-a-"(' be-0ee' 0(+$,!(), B.,"'e,, c+"-"ca% "'"-"a-"/e,0e+e "'c%.ded a'd -!e 0(+$,!(), +e"'f(+ced)+e/"(., %ea+'"' Eac! 0(+$,!() !ad a ,e+"e, (f-ea&\ba,ed ac-"(', -!a- eac! &a'a e+ 0a, e'c(.+\a ed -( "&)%e&e'- T!e+e 0e+e a%,( ,e%f\)aced&a-e+"a%, -( c('-"'.e -!e %ea+'"' )+(ce,, be2('d-!e -+a"'"' +((&

8. E; < > ; ? < ? ? <; @ <

T!e &a#(+"-2 (f )+( +a&&e )a+-"c")a'-, 0e+eacc(.'-ab%e f(+ ," '"f"ca'-%2 )e()%e\"'-e',"/ed"/","(' , 0"-! -2)"ca%%2 766\7;6 )e()%e "' eac! (f-!e"+ +e,)ec-"/e b.,"'e,, a+ea, T!e ())(+-.'"-2 f(+%eade+,!") )+ac-"ce 0a, -!e+ef(+e ," '"f"ca'- T!e)a+-"c")a'-, 0e+e e'c(.+a ed -( %ea+' !(0 -( %ead"' a' e&(-"('a%%2 a'd ,(c"a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- &a''e+

-!., "&)+(/"' -!e 0(+$"' e'/"+('&e'- f(+ -!e"+

)e()%e a'd )+(/"d"' ,)ec"f"c feedbac$ "' -!e0(+$,!(), (' 0!a- 0(+$ed 0e%% a'd 0!a- d"d '(-T!e )a+-"c")a'-, beca&e "'/(%/ed "' f.-.+e ed.ca\

-"(' a'd %eade+,!") de/e%()&e'- )+( +a&&e, f(+-!e"+ )e()%e -!e2 0e+e "' c!a+ e (f

9. %>< ; ; <> ; ? @ <; @ > @ @? <>@? >; ;

I' add"-"(' -( e',.+"' -!a- a%% %ea+'"' ,-2%e, 0e+eacc(&&(da-ed "- 0a, "&)(+-a'- -!a- -!e)+( +a&&e ,)(',(+ $e)- -!e )+( +a&&e !" ! ('-!e (+ a'",a-"('a% a e'da a'd -!a- -!e )a+-"c")a'-,fe%- ,.))(+-ed -!+(. !(.- -!e )+( +a&&e T!", ",(f-e' &(,- c!a%%e' ed a- -"&e, (f c('f%"c-"' b.,"\'e,, )+"(+"-"e, 0!e+e a b.,"'e,, 'eed a+",e, (' -!eda2 (f a 0(+$,!() a'd a- -!e,e -"&e, -!e +(%e (f a,e'"(+ HR ad/(ca-e ", "&)(+-a'- 0"-!"' a' EI"'-e+/e'-"(' -( e',.+e -!a- d"a+2 c('f%"c-, a+e'e (-"a-ed a'd -!a- -!e "'d"/"d.a% &a'a e+ ", ab%e-( )a+-"c")a-e a, -!e2 !ad (+" "'a%%2 )%a''ed -( d(S(&e-"&e, -!", "'/(%/e, d"+ec- "'-e+/e'-"(' (' -!e)a+- (f -!e HR ad/(ca-e (+ ,e'"(+ ,)(',(+

10. C<; @ ; <;- < ; @ <;

O.+ )+( +a&&e !ad -!+ee d"ffe+e'- c(!(+-, a'dfeedbac$ a'd %ea+'"' , f+(& -!e f"+,- c(!(+- 0e+e b."%- "'-( -!e ,ec('d a'd -!"+d )+( +a&&e, Wee/a%.a-ed -!e )+( +a&&e "' a '.&be+ (f d"ffe+e'-0a2, 0!"c! 0a, -!+(. ! ,-a$e!(%de+ +e,.%-,-!+(. ! )a+-"c")a'- a'd ,)(',(+ feedbac$ a'd-!+(. ! -!e bef(+e a'd af-e+ "'d"/"d.a% a'd +(.))+(f"%e,

E B> >< " 16J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 3

E B> >< " 17J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

> ? @?

T!e )+( +a&&e !ad fa+ +eac!"' b.,"'e,, "&)ac-a'd -!e +e,.%-, 0e+e a, f(%%(0,

S" '"f"ca'- b.,"'e,, +e,.%-, 0e+e ac!"e/ed "'-!e -0( 2ea+, -!a- ,)a''ed -!e )+( +a&&ee1ceed"' P L e1)ec-a-"(', "' a !" !%2c(&)e-"-"/e a'd +e .%a-(+2\c!a%%e' ede'/"+('&e'-

M(,- (f -!e )a+-"c")a'-, 9; e1)e+"e'ced"&)+(/e&e'- "' -!e"+ e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'cea'd a- +(.) %e/e% -!e+e 0a, a ,-a-",-"ca%%2

," '"f"ca'- "'c+ea,e "' 86 (f -!e 87 EQ\" ,c(+e,,ee )+(f"%e

F(.+ : (f -!e )a+-"c")a'-, &(/ed -( -!e,e'"(+ %eade+,!") -ea& +e)%ac"' US

e1ec.-"/e,

T!e+e 0a, a' "'c+ea,ed ,e',e (f -ea&,!")ac+(,, -!e b.,"'e,, de&(',-+a-ed b2"'c+ea,ed 'e-0(+$"' a'd "&)+(/ed

"'-e+ac-"(' "' a &.%-"\,"-e e'/"+('&e'-0"-! "&)+(/ed ,!a+ed acc(.'-ab"%"-2 f(+ b.,"'e,, +e,.%-,

%>< > - B <> /A @ > %><

E B> >< " : > 3

T!e "&)%e&e'-a-"(' (f -!e -e' ,-e), de,c+"bedab(/e 0a, -!e +e,.%- (f +" (+(., 0(+$ f+(& -!e(.-,e- a'd a %e' -!2 )+(ce,, (f e' a "' $e2

,-a$e!(%de+, We e'c(.+a e 2(. -( .,e -!e,e, -e) , a , a +(ad&a) f (+ 0!a- ' eed , - ( bead d+ e, ,e d "' 2(.+ EI "'-e+/e'-"(' Y(. &a2 a%,(0",! -( c(',.%- -!e (+" "'a% 88 c+"-e+"a f(+ ,.cce,,"' a))%2"' EI "'-e+/e'-"(', ad/(ca-ed b2 -!e E"C(',(+-".& a'd "de'-"f2 0!"c! ('e, a+e &(,-)+(b%e&a-"c "' 2(.+ (+ a'",a-"('a% ,e--"' I- ",)+(bab%2 -!(,e ('e, -!a- 2(. &" !- 0a'- -(-ac$%e f"+,-

C<; ; > > ?

T!e f"'d"' , )+e,e'-ed "' -!", )a)e+ c%ea+%2de&(',-+a-e -!a- -!e a))%"ca-"(' (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce "' -!e 0(+$)%ace "'c+ea,e, (cc.)a\-"('a% )e+f(+&a'ce %eade+,!") a'd (+ a'",a-"('a%)+(d.c-"/"-2 Add"-"('a%%2 0e !a/e e&)%(2ed ac(&)+e!e',"/e a'd +(b.,- &(de% (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce -( e1)%a"' 0!a- -!", c(',-+.c- ",!(0 "- ", &ea,.+ed 0!2 "- ", "&)(+-a'- a'd !(0 be,- -( a))%2 "- "' -!e 0(+$)%ace -( &a1"&",e(+ a'",a-"('a% )+(d.c-"/"-2 I- ", (.+ !()e -!a-

-!", )a)e+ !a, +e/ea%ed -!e b(--(&\%"'e "&)ac- (fEI "'-e+/e'-"(', a'd 0"%% e'c(.+a e &(+e HR)+(fe,,"('a%, -( .,e -!", a))+(ac! -( +ec+."-,e%ec- -+a"' a 'd )+(&(-e )(-e'-"a%%2 !" !)e+f(+&e+, 0! ( 0"%% d+"/e (+ a '" ,a-"( 'a%)+(d.c-"/"-2 -( !" !e+ %e/e%,

EI "'-e+/e'-"(', (f-e' ,e+/e -!e f.'c-"(' (f ).--"'-!e ,)(-%" !- (' "'/e,-&e'-, "' )e()%e de/e%()\

&e'- a'd c!a%%e' "' -!e %e/e% (f ROI W!"%,--!e,e )+( +a&&e, !a/e b(--(&\%"'e "&)ac- a,de&(',-+a-ed "' -!", )a)e+ -!e2 a+e '(- f(+ -!efa"'-!ea+-ed (+ f(+ HR )+(fe,,"('a%, )+e)a+ed -(,e--%e f(+ -!e ea,2 ()-"(' W!e' )+ac-"-"('e+,e&ba+$ (' a' EI "'-e+/e'-"(' -!e2 a+e (f-e'c!a+-"' 'e0 -e++"-(+2 T!", .,.a%%2 "'/(%/e, be"' acc(.'-ab%e f(+ )e()%e c(&)e-e'ce a'd be"' +e*."+ed -( *.a'-"f2 -!e c!a' e, acc(&\)%",!ed "' &(+e c('c+e-e 0a2, -!a' "' -!e )a,-F(+ )+(fe,,"('a%, 0!( c!((,e -( /e'-.+e "'-( -!",-e++"-(+2 -!e+e a+e +e,.%-, -( be a"'ed f(+"'d"/"d.a%, -ea&, a'd -!e (+ a'",a-"(' a, a0!(%e -!+(. ! "'-e%%" e'- a'd ca+ef.% )%a''"'Pe+!a), "- ", -"&e f(+ -!e ,( ca%%ed ,(f- ,$"%%,0!"c! e'c(&)a,, EI -( be c(',"de+ed a, b(-!c+ed"b%e a'd c('c+e-e We ca' '( %(' e+ +efe+ -(-!e,e ab"%"-"e, a'd ,$"%%, a, ,(f- \\ e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce ", -a' "b%e &ea,.+ab%e a'd !a, a

," '"f"ca'- "&)ac- (' -!e b(--(& %"'e

E B> >< " 18J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : > 3

A ; A: %> @ @ <; >'? G <?? > > ?

@ T!e +e%"ab"%"-2 (f a' "',-+.&e'- -e%%, ., !(0 c(',",-e'- a'd ,-ab%e "- ", a'd "f 0e ca' +e%2 (' "- -("/e ., ,"&"%a+ +e,)(',e, -( -!e ,a&e "-e&, 0"-!"' -!e ,a&e ,ca%e, (/e+ -"&e C(',",-e'c2 +e%"ab"%"-2 e1a&"'e,

-!e de +ee (f c(++e%a-"(' be-0ee' -!e "'d"/"d.a% "-e&, (' a )a+-"c.%a+ ,ca%e a'd !e+e a &"'"&.& (f =6 f(+,.b\,ca%e, >6 f(+ c(&)(,"-e ,ca%e, a'd ?6 f(+ -(-a% ,c(+e, ", +e*."+ed Re-e,- +e%"ab"%"-2 (' -!e (-!e+ !a'de1a&"'e, -!e de +ee (f c(++e%a-"(' be-0ee' +e,)(',e, -( -!e ,a&e "-e&, &ade b2 +e,)('de'-, 0!( c(&)%e-e-!e ,a&e "',-+.&e'- (' &(+e -!a' ('e (cca,"('

F @ Face /a%"d"-2 ", '(- /a%"d"-2 "' -!e -+.e ,-a-",-"ca% ,e',e "- ", +a-!e+ a' "'d"ca-"(' (f !(0 0e%%-!e "-e&, ,ca%e, a'd -e,- a, a 0!(%e a+e .'de+,-((d a'd a))ea+ -( be &ea,.+"' -!e c(',-+.c- -!e2 0e+ede," 'ed -( &ea,.+e ,.c! a, EI P((+ face /a%"d"-2 -e'd, -( !"'de+ -!e ab"%"-2 (f +e,)('de'-, -( acc.+a-e%2

()e'%2 a'd !('e,-%2 c(&)%e-e -!e "',-+.&e'- a'd )((+ face /a%"d"-2 e'e+a%%2 e&e+ e, f+(& c('f.,"' (.-(f da-e (+ )(-e'-"a%%2 ab.,"/e c('-e'- 0!"c! 'eed, -( be a/("ded

C<;@ ;@ @ L"$e face /a%"d"-2 c('-e'- /a%"d"-2 ", a%,( '(- /a%"d"-2 "' -!e ,-a-",-"ca% ,e',e "- ,"&)%2 -e%%,., ,(&e-!"' ab(.- !(0 0e%% -!e "-e&, ,ca%e, a'd -e,- a, a 0!(%e c(/e+ -!e c(',-+.c- be"' a,,e,,ed ,.c!a, EI C('-e'- /a%"d"-2 ", "&)(+-a'- beca.,e "- %a2, -!e f(.'da-"(' f(+ e,-ab%",!"' a' "',-+.&e'- , (/e+a%%+e%"ab"%"-2 a'd /a%"d"-2

F @<> @ Fac-(+"a% /a%"d"-2 ", -!e de +ee -( 0!"c! -!e ,-+.c-.+e a'd fac-(+"a% c(&)('e'-, (f a-!e(+2 (+ &ea,.+e (f -!a- -!e(+2 a+e ,-a-",-"ca%%2 c('f"+&ed ba,ed (' a ,-a-",-"ca% )+(ced.+e $'(0' a, fac-(+a'a%2,", T!", -2)e (f /a%"d"-2 ", "&)(+-a'- beca.,e "- +e)+e,e'-, a fa"+%2 acc.+a-e a))+(ac! -( -e%%"' ., "f-!e c('ce)- (+ &ea,.+e (f -!e c('ce)- 0e a+e "'-e+e,-ed "' .,"' ", 0e%%\def"'ed (+ '(- ,-+(' (+ 0ea$ a'd-!e e1-e'- -( 0!"c! "- ac-.a%%2 e1",-, "' +ea%"-2

C<;?@> @ @ C(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 -e%%, ., !(0 0e%% a ),2c!(&e-+"c "',-+.&e'- ", a,,e,,"' 0!a- "- 0a,de," 'ed -( a,,e, ,.c! a, EI O'e -2)e (f c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 +efe++ed -( a, c('/e+ e'- c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2+e/ea%, -!e e1-e'- -( 0!"c! -!e "',-+.&e'- be"' e1a&"'ed ", c(++e%a-"' 0"-! (-!e+ EI "',-+.&e'-, f(+e1a&)%e a'd /a%"d"-2 c(eff"c"e'-, (f :6 a+e -!e &"'"&a% +e*."+e&e'-, We a%,( 'eed -( e1a&"'e d"/e+ e'-

c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 -( de&(',-+a-e -!a- "- ", '(- &ea,.+"' ,(&e-!"' e%,e (-!e+ -!a' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce,.c! a, c( '"-"/e "'-e%%" e'ce (+ )e+,('a%"-2 f(+ e1a&)%e

%> @ @ : I' add"-"(' -( de&(',-+a-"' -!a- a ),2c!(&e-+"c "',-+.&e'- ", ab%e -( &ea,.+e 0!a- "-0a, de," 'ed -( &ea,.+e "- &.,- a%,( be ,!(0' -!a- "- ", ca)ab%e (f )+ed"c-"' /a+"(., a,)ec-, (f !.&a' be!a/"(.+ )e+f(+&a'ce a'd effec-"/e'e,, a'd -!", "' e,,e'ce +e)+e,e'-, -!e 'a-.+e (f e,-ab%",!"' "-,)+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2 T!", -2)e (f /a%"d"-2 ", ('e (f -!e &(,- "&)(+-a'- ),2c!(&e-+"c )+()e+-"e, (f ),2c!(\%( "ca% -e,-, beca.,e "- -e%%, ., 0!a- a' "',-+.&e'- ", ab%e -( )+ed"c- a'd !(0 0e%% T!e )+(ce,, (fe,-ab%",!"' )+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2 e'-a"%, c(++e%a-"' -!e "',-+.&e'- be"' /a%"da-ed 0"-! ,(&e ,(+- (f)e+f(+&a'ce +a-"' (+ $'(0' be'c!&a+$ (f )e+f(+&a'ce +e%e/a'- -( a ,)ec"f"c a'd 0e%%\def"'ed ac-"/"-2/a%"d"-2 c(eff"c"e'-, +ea-e+ -!a' :6 a+e +e*."+ed

E B> >< " 21J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 22J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

A ; B: @

Note T!e +e,ea+c! f"'d"' , ,.&&a+",ed "' A))e'd"1 B "'d"ca-e -!a- -!e EQ\"Z )(,,e,,e, ((d +e%"ab"%"-20e%% e1ceed"' -!e +ec(&&e'ded %e/e%, f(+ +e%"ab"%"-2 c(eff"c"e'-, ,ee A))e'd"1 A T!e,e f"'d"' , +e/ea%-!a- "- ", /e+2 c(',",-e'- a'd ,-ab%e ba,ed (' ,-.d"e, c('d.c-ed (' (/e+ < 666 ad.%-, "' B+"-a"' Ca'ada a'd-!e U'"-ed S-a-e, (/e+ -!e )a,- decade T!", &ea', -!a- "- ", a +e%"ab%e EI "',-+.&e'- a'd ca' be .,ed 0"-!c('f"de'ce

E - ? <;? ?@ ; ; > @ ?@ > @? <; @ * ;<> ?

B -% , 1997, 2004; =3,831, 40 ( 3 <> )

? C<;? ?@ ; @ @ ?@@

EQ ?= =?I'-+a)e+,('a% ?: >8I'-e+)e+,('a% >= ;?S-+e,, Ma'a e&e'- >< =7Ada)-ab"%"-2 >? =;Ge'e+a% M((d >> =6

E - ? <;? ?@ ; > @ ; ?@ ; >>><> < ? > ;@ ? <; @ * ;<> ?

#H , 2006; =2,236

? C<;? ?@ ; @ @ ; > E>><> < ? > ;@

EQ ?< ? 86I'-+a)e+,('a% ?: ; 97I'-e+)e+,('a% >? 9 :;

S-+e,, Ma'a e&e'- >9 9 =9Ada)-ab"%"-2 >> : 88Ge'e+a% M((d >? 9 6<

E B> >< " : A??

A ; C: C<;?@> @ + @

Note T!e +e,ea+c! f"'d"' , ,.&&a+",ed "' A))e'd"1 C ,. e,- -!a- -!e EQ i )(,,e,,e, ((d c(',-+.c-/a%"d"-2 Ba,ed (' 7: ,-.d"e, c('d.c-ed (' 'ea+%2 9 666 "'d"/"d.a%, 0!( c(&)%e-ed b(-! -!e EQ\"Z a'd a-

%ea,- ('e (f ,e/e' d"ffe+e'- EI &ea,.+e, -!e (/e+a%% c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 c(eff"c"e'- ", ;> T!", 0e%% e1ceed,-!e +ec(&&e'ded %e/e%, f(+ c(',-+.c- /a%"d"-2 c(eff"c"e'-, ,ee A))e'd"1 A T!e,e +e,.%-, &ea' -!a- -!eEQ\"Z ", a,,e,,"' 0!a- -!e,e (-!e+ EI "',-+.&e'-, a+e a,,e,,"' 0!"c! a+e /a+"(., a,)ec-, (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce I- ca' be c('c%.ded 0"-! c('f"de'ce -!a- -!e EQ\"Z ", &ea,.+"' 0!a- "- 0a, de," 'ed -(&ea,.+e

E - ? <;?@> @ @ ? <;14 ?@ ? (;=2,667)

B -% , 2004

E @ >; ? > ? + @ C< ;@EI Q.e,-"(''a"+e <9 $ 7 '\;?EI Sca%e <> $ 7 ' 769

T+a"- Me-a M((d Sca%e ;> $ 7 ' >686\I-e& T(+('-( A%e1"-!2&"a Sca%e \ =8 $ 7 ' =9:S-+.c-.+ed I'-e+/"e0 f(+ A%e1"-!2&"a \ :: $ 7 ' 8;6EQ \ 9<6 <? $ 7 ' 7>;Ma2e+\Sa%(/e2\Ca+.,( EI Te,- 97 $ > '\7 8;>

E B> >< " 23J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 24J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

A ; D: %> @ + @

Note T!e f"'d"' , ,.&&a+",ed "' A))e'd"1 D +e/ea% -!a- -!e EQ i ", ab%e -( )+ed"c- a 0"de /a+"e-2 (f!.&a' be!a/"(.+ a'd ac-"/"-2 ba,ed (' 8; /a%"d"-2 ,-.d"e, c('d.c-ed (' (/e+ 89 666 "'d"/"d.a%, 0(+%d0"deA' a/e+a e /a%"d"-2 c(eff"c"e'- (f ;< "'d"ca-e, -!a- -!e EQ i )(,,e,, fa"+%2 !" ! )+ed"c-"/e /a%"d"-2I' add"-"(' -( de&(',-+a-"' -!a- -!", EI "',-+.&e'- ", +e%"ab%e ,ee A))e'd"1 B a'd ca)ab%e (f &ea,.+"'/a+"(., a,)ec-, (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ,ee A))e'd"1 C -!e,e +e,.%-, ,!(0 -!a- "- ", ab%e -( )+ed"c-/a+"(., a,)ec-, (f "'d"/"d.a% )e+f(+&a'ce a'd effec-"/e'e,, +e%e/a'- -( -!e 0(+$)%ace T!", ,. e,-, -!a--!e EQ i ", a /"ab%e c(&)+e!e',"/e a'd +(b.,- "',-+.&e'- -!a- ca' be a))%"ed 0"-! c('f"de'ce "'-!e (+ a'",a-"('a% ,e--"' W"-!"' -!", ,e--"' "- ", "&)(+-a'- -( e&)!a,",e -!a- -!e EQ i , 0a, ,!(0'-( ," '"f"ca'-%2 )+ed"c- (cc.)a-"('a% &a'a e+"a% a'd %eade+,!") )e+f(+&a'ce a, 0e%% (+ a'",a-"('a%)+(d.c-"/"-2

E - ? > @ @ ? <;25 ?@ ? (;=23,049)

B -% , 2004; 2007 , 2007

< % > <> ; /B < > + @ C< ;@P!2,"ca% Hea%-! :9 $ 9 ' 9 >7<Me'-a% Hea%-! 9? $ ; ' >=:

S(c"a% I'-e+ac-"(' <? $ 7 ' ;99Acade&"c :9 $ : ' 8 9:<Occ.)a-"('a% ;; $ < ' 9 :;>G"f-ed'e,, ;6 $ 7 ' 878Se%f\Ac-.a%",a-"(' =: $ : ' > 89?S.b#ec-"/e We%%\be"' =< $ 7 ' 9 ;=7

E B> >< " : A??

> ; ?B >-$;, . 866<a EQ i !eade'(hi% *(e' ( g*ide T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, . 7??=a The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'. ?EQ i@= A )e() $f e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce; T(+('-(Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, . 866: The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'. ?EQ i@= Ra)i$#a!e< de(c'i%)i$#< a#d (*""a'. $f %(.ch$"e)'ic %'$%e')ie(; I' G%e'' Ge!e+ Ed Mea,.+"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce C(&&(' +(.'d a'dc('-+(/e+,2 Ha.))a. e NY N(/a Sc"e'ce P.b%",!e+, )) 777\:8

B >-$;, . 7??=b The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'. ?EQ i@= Tech#ica! "a#*a!T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, . 866 ,.)% 79\;

B >-$;, ., & H ; , . 8669a The Ba' O# EQ 360; T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,B >-$;, ., & H ; , . 8669b The Ba' O# EQ 360= Tech#ica! "a#*a! T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-!S2,-e&,

B >-$;, ., H ; , ., & F ; , . 866< T!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' )e+f(+&a'ceI' Va'e,,a D+.,$a- Fab"( Sa%a a'd Ge+a%d M(.'- Ed, Li# i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce a#d %e'f$'"a#ce a),$' = C*''e#) 'e(ea'ch e+ide#ce; Ma!0a! NJ La0+e'ce E+%ba.& )) 9\7?

B >-$;, ., & % > >, J. D. A. 8666 The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'.= Y$*)h Ve'(i$# ?EQ i=YV@ Tech#ica! Ma#*a!; T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&, I'c

B > ; , G. 8669 E&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce T!e c.--"' ed e (f "'-e+/e'-"(', " ' c(+)(+a-e a'ded.ca-"( 'a% ,e--"' , Pa)e+ )+e,e'-ed (' -!e 8?-! (f Ma2 8669 a- -!e Ne1., EQ C('fe+e'ce Ha%"fa1 N(/aSc(-"a Ca'ada

B > ; , G. 8667 8'd Ed"-"(' 866= E&(-"('a%%2 I'-e%%" e'- L"/"' C+(0' H(.,e P.b%",!"'

B > ; , G. 866< C(ac!"' e1ec.-"/e, -( e'!a'ce e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd "'c+ea,e )+(d.c-"/"-2 RBa+\O' J G Ma+ee M J E%"a, Ed*ca)i#g %e$%!e )$ be e"$)i$#a!!. i#)e!!ige#); J(!a''e,b.+ SA He"'e&a''Ed.ca-"('a% P.b%",!e+, 866=

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8666a E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 7 e--"' ,-a+-ed PDF \ 88;$b C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce V(%.&e N( > I,,.e

N( 7 )) 7?\8: O+" "'a%%2 ).b%",!ed a, O+&e a'd Ca''('

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, 8666b E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 8 De," ' PDF \ 876$b C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce V(%.&e N( > I,,.e N( 8 ))7>\8; O+" "'a%%2 ).b%",!ed a, O+&e a'd Ca''('

B > ; , G. & C ;;<;, . 8667a E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 9 Ta$"' -!e ,!(0 (' -!e +(ad PDF \ >?$b S)+"' 8667 V(%.&e N( > I,,.e N( 9 )) 7=\8:O+" "'a%%2 ).b%",!ed a, O+&e a'd Ca''('

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8667b E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ : A,,.+"' -!e !" !e,- ,-a'da+d, PDF \ :6$b C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce V(%.&eN( > I,,.e N( : )) 7?\8: O+" "'a%%2 ).b%",!ed a, O+&e a'd Ca''('

E B> >< " 25J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 26J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

B< @ ?, . E., G< ;, D., & H G>< 8667 The E"$)i$#a! C$"%e)e#ce I#+e#)$'. ?ECI@; B(,-('Ha2G+(.)

B> @@, . A., & < , %. 866: Mea,.+"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce 0"-! -!e Ma2e+\Sa%(/e2\Ca+.,( E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce Te,- MSCEIT I' G%e'' Ge!e+ Ed Mea(*'i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce=C$""$# g'$*#d a#d c$#)'$+e'(.; Ha.))a. e NY N(/a Sc"e'ce P.b%",!e+,

D > ;, C. 7>=8[7?<; The e-%'e((i$# $f )he e"$)i$#( i# "a# a#d a#i"a!(; C!"ca ( U'"/e+,"-2 (f C!"ca (P+e,,

G >, G. (E .) 866: Mea(*'i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce= C$""$# g'$*#d a#d c$#)'$+e'(. Ha.))a. e NYN(/a Sc"e'ce P.b%",!e+,

G< ;, D. 7??; E"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce; Ne0 Y(+$ Ba'-a& B(($,

G< ;, D. 7??> W$' i#g ,i)h e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce; Ne0 Y(+$ Ba'-a& B(($,

H ; , . 7??= A)+"% AFRS +a-e, e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce Ai' F$'ce Rec'*i)e' Ne,(;

>, J. D., & < , % 7??= W!a- ", e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce I' P Sa%(/e2 D S%.2-e+ Ed, E&(-"('a%de/e%()&e'- a'd e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce I&)%"ca-"(', f(+ ed.ca-(+, )) 9\97 Ne0 Y(+$ Ba,"c B(($,

>, J. D., < , %., & C > ?<, D. . 8668 Ma.e' Sa!$+e. Ca'*($ E"$)i$#a! I#)e!!ige#ce Te() ?MSCEIT@;T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&, I'c

% , B. ., & I > , J. C. (E ?.). 8667 F$*')ee#)h "e#)a! "ea(*'e"e#) .ea'b$$ ; L"'c(%' NE B.+(, I',-"-.-ef(+ Me'-a% Mea,.+e&e'-

% , B. ., & I > , J. C. (E ?.). 7??? S*%%!e"e#) )$ )he )hi')ee#)h "e#)a! "ea(*'e"e#) .ea'b$$ ; L"'c(%'NE B.+(, I',-"-.-e f(+ Me'-a% Mea,.+e&e'-

> ;, ., & B >-$;, . 8669 T!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' %eade+,!") U').b%",!ed&a'.,c+")-

; , ., & G ?@ ??<;, H. 8667 O.-c(&e ,-.d2 (f a %eade+,!") de/e%()&e'- a,,e,,&e'- a'd-+a"'"' )+( +a& ba,ed (' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce A' "'-e+'a% +e)(+- )+e)a+ed f(+ -!e S$a',$a Ma'a e&e'-I',-"-.-e "' S-(c$!(%& S0ede'

? , ., 8669 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce -+a"'"' a'd "-, "&)%"ca-"(', f(+ ,-+e,, !ea%-! a'd )e+f(+&a'ceS)'e(( a#d Hea!)h< 7? 899\89?

? , ., & C >@ > @, . 8668 Hea%-! )e+f(+&a'ce a'd e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce A' e1)%(+a-(+2 ,-.d2(f +e-a"% &a'a e+, S)'e(( a#d Hea!)h 7> <9\9>

> >, C. (E .) 866: E#c.c!$%edia $f A%%!ied P(.ch$!$g.; Sa' D"e ( CA Acade&"c P+e,,

*; @ ? @ @ ? G ; > A < ;@ ; $ 7??> M"%"-a+2 +ec+."-"' T!e De)a+-&e'- (f Defe',e c(.%d"&)+(/e "-, +ec+."-e+ ,e%ec-"(' a'd "'ce'-"/e ,2,-e&, A U'"-ed S-a-e, C(' +e,,"('a% Re)(+- ,.b&"--ed -(-!e C(&&"--ee (' A+&ed Se+/"ce, "' -!e U'"-ed S-a-e, Se'a-e (' -!e 96-! (f Ja'.a+2 7??> GAO[NSIAD \?> \ ;>

+ ; << , D. !., & + ? ? > ;, C. 866= A,,e,,"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' ad.%-, A +e/"e0 (f -!e &(,-)().%a+ &ea,.+e, I' R Ba+\O' J G Ma+ee M E%"a, Ed, Ed*ca)i#g %e$%!e )$ be e"$)i$#a!!. i#)e!!ige#);

We,-)(+- CT )) 8;?\=8

E B> >< " : A??

C<;@> @<>?' B < > ?G @ B > ; B (H<;?) C >@ > FCI%D D . C< ;?.

Gee-. ", F(.'d"' D"+ec-(+ (f E" W(+%d L"&"-ed S!e !a, ,)ec"a%",ed "' e&(-"('a% "'-e%\%" e'ce +e,ea+c! de/e%()&e'- a'd e/a%.a-"(' ,"'ce 7??? a'd ", c(',"de+ed a )"('ee+ "'-!e f"e%d (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce S!e ", a &e&be+ (f -!e E" C(',(+-".& a %ead"'

+(.) (f )+ac-"-"('e+, a'd acade&"c, 0!( +e,ea+c! a'd )+(&(-e be,- )+ac-"ce, "' -!ef"e%d (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce de/e%()&e'- 000 e"c(',(+-".& (+

He+ &a"' a+ea, (f "'-e+e,- a+e %eade+,!") de/e%()&e'- )+(fe,,"('a% effec-"/e'e,, a'd c(ac!"' !" !ac!"e/e+, S!e !a, b."%- e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"(', a'd !a, )+(/e' &ea,.+ab%e +e,.%-, f+(&!e+ 0(+$ 0"-! %eade+, a'd !" ! )(-e'-"a% "'d"/"d.a%, S!e %ead, %(ba% "'-e+/e'-"(', -!a- "'-e +a-ee1ec.-"/e c(ac!"' +e,ea+c! )+( +a& de%"/e+2 0+"-"' a'd $e2'(-e ,)ea$"' (' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ceS!e ,e- .) E" UK "' 7??? '(0 E" W(+%d +ef%ec-"' -!e c(&)a'2 , +(0-! "'-e+'a-"('a%%2 f+(& "-, (+" "'a%UK +((-,

Gee-. ", -+a"'ed "' ,e/e+a% e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a,,e,,&e'- -((%, ", a *.a%"f"ed -+a"'e+ (f -!e Ba+O' EQ\"a'd EQ\9<6 -((%, a'd !a, b."%- "'-e+/e'-"(', f(+ "'c+ea,"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' a /a+"e-2 (f c('-e1-,"'c%.d"' )+(fe,,"('a% ,e+/"ce, %(ba% c(&)a'"e, a'd ed.ca-"('a% (+ a'",a-"(', S!e 0a, a0a+ded !e+&a,-e+, de +ee "' P,2c!(%( 2 Hea%-! Feb+.a+2 866; 0"-! D",-"'c-"(' a- C"-2 U'"/e+,"-2 L('d(' He+.'de+ +ad.a-e de +ee 0a, "' I'-e+'a-"('a% B.,"'e,,[M(de+' La' .a e, IBML f+(& A,-(' U'"/e+,"-2

7?>? He+ &a"' "'-e+e,-, a+e Ed.ca-"(' Leade+,!") a'd Hea%-! a))%"ca-"(', (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce S!e", a Fe%%(0 (f -!e C!a+-e+ed I',-"-.-e (f Pe+,(''e% De/e%()&e'- CIPD a'd !a, bee' "'/"-ed-( c('-+"b.-e +e .%a+%2 -( CIPD f(+.&, S!e .,ed -( -.-(+ -!e CIPD , Ce+-"f"ca-e "' T+a"'"' P+ac-"ce 0"-!; &(d.%e, eac! f(c.,ed (' a )a+-"c.%a+ a,)ec- (f T+a"'"' 0(+$ a'd ,!e 0a, a T.-(+ (' -!e O)e' U'"/e+,"-2 ,MBA P+( +a&&e S!e 0+(-e -!e CIPD &(d.%e (' O)-"&","' Pe()%e f(.'ded (' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce

0"-!"' -!e d",-a'ce %ea+'"' )+( +a&&e (f CIPDS!e %ead, )+(#ec-, "'/(%/"' %eade+,!") de/e%()&e'- e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd c(ac!"' "' a c+(,,c.%-.+a% c('-e1- "' b(-! -!e c(+)(+a-e a'd ed.ca-"('a% 0(+%d, I' -!e %a,- 2ea+ ,!e !a, f(c.,ed ('"'-e+/e'-"( ', ba,ed (' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce f(+ -ec!'"ca% e1)e+-, A $e2 )a,,"(' ", -( e*.") )e()%e -(de/e%() -!e ,$"%%, a'd ca)ab"%"-"e, (f 0(+$"' 0"-! e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' -!e"+ (0' a+e'a, (f 0(+$

S!e !a, a,,e,,ed -!e e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (f ,(&e ;;66 "'d"/"d.a%, .,"' -!e Ba+O' EQ\" -((% f(+ a,,e,,"'e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce S!e ", )a+-"c.%a+%2 "'-e+e,-ed "' .,"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a,,e,,&e'-, -( .'de+\,-a'd -!e "''e+ %eade+ a'd b."%d -a+ e-ed "'-e+/e'-"(', f(+ "'c+ea,"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce

He+ 0(+$ !a, bee' fea-.+ed (' Rad"( : CNN a'd Ca'ad"a' Te%e/","(' Gee-. B!a+0a'e2 !a, a.-!(+eda'd ).b%",!ed E&(-"('a%%2 I'-e%%" e'- L"/"' 8667 866= C+(0' H(.,e P.b%",!"' a'd ,e/e+a% #(.+'a%a+-"c%e, 0!"c! a+e a/a"%ab%e f(+ d(0'%(ad -!+(. ! -!e E" W(+%d 0eb,"-e 000 e"0(+%d (+ T!e +(2a%-"e,(f !e+ 8667 +e)+"'-ed 866= b(($ E&(-"('a%%2 I'-e%%" e'- L"/"' 0e+e )%ed ed -( f.'d ed.ca-"('a% !ea%-!a'd /(%.'-a+2 ,ec-(+ "'"-"a-"/e,

Gee-. , )+e,e'- 0(+$ "'/(%/e, &ea,.+"' EQ +e,ea+c!"' -!e c!a+ac-e+",-"c, (f ,-a+ %eade+,!") )e+f(+&a'cea'd )+(/"d"' f(c.,ed a'd -a+ e-ed EQ de/e%()&e'-

S!e !(%d, %e/e% B *.a%"f"ca-"(' "' -!e .,e (f ),2c!(&e-+"c -e,-, a'd !a, *.a%"f"ed )e()%e "' b(-! -!e EQ\"a'd EQ\9<6 &ea,.+e, (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce S!e ", a%,( acc+ed"-ed "' MSCEIT -!e ab"%"-2 -e,- (f e&(-"('a%"'-e%%" e'ce

He+ )+e,e'-a-"(' ,-2%e ", f(c.,ed effec-"/e a'd c(&)e%%"' S!e ", "'-e+e,-ed "' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a, a

)ea$ )e+f(+&a'ce ,$"%% 0!"c! c(&b"'ed 0"-! ,(.'d b.,"'e,, ac.&e' !e%), !" ! ac!"e/e+, -( be effec-"/e"' b.,"'e,,

E B> >< " 27J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 28J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

% ? <>

B< ; , G 8667 866= E&(-"('a%%2 I'-e%%" e'- L"/"' C+(0' H(.,e P.b%",!"' T+a',%a-ed "'-(R.,,"a' P(%",! a'd Heb+e0 d.+"' 866=[> A%,( )+"'-ed "' I'd"a .'de+ -!e -"-%e I'c+ea,e 2(.+ E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce 866> A%% +(2a%-"e, )%ed ed -( f.'d 0(+$ "' ed.ca-"(' !ea%-! a'd /(%.'-a+2 ,ec-(+

C @ >?

B > ; , G 866? C(ac!"' f(+ e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' "'-e+'a-"('a% b.,"'e,, e'/"+('&e'-,C!a%%e' e, a'd ())(+-.'"-"e, I' G Abb(-- M M(+a% Ed, T!e R(.-%ed e C(&)a'"(' -( I'-e+'a-"('a%B.,"'e,, C(ac!"'

B > ; , G. 866? De/e%()"' !" ! ac!"e/e+, -!+(. ! e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce M(+e "'-e%%" e'- -!a'e&(-"('a% I' M H. !e, J Te++e%% D T!(&),(' Ed, T!e !a'db(($ (f de/e%()"' e&(-"('a% a'd,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce \ Be,- )+ac-"ce, ca,e ,-.d"e, -((%,

B > ; , G. 866< C(ac!"' e1ec.-"/e, -( e'!a'ce e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd "'c+ea,e )+(d.c-"/"-2 I'R Ba+\O' J G Ma+ee M J E%"a, 866= Ed, Ed.ca-"' )e()%e -( be e&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- J(!a ''e,b.+ SA He"'e&a'' Ed.ca-"('a% P.b%",!e+,

? >

B > ; , G., B >-$;, ., & ; , A 866= EQ a'd -!e b(--(& %"'e E" W(+%d UK

B > ; , G. 866; Hea%-! Leade+,!") a'd E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce D",,e+-a-"(' ,.b&"--ed -( C"-2U'"/e+,"-2 866; "' )a+- f.%f"%&e'- (f MSc P,2c!(%( 2 (f Hea%-! D",-"'c-"(' a0a+ded U').b%",!ed

E B> >< " : A??

A>@ ?

B > ; @ . 866; Ga"'"' ,e'"(+ &a'a e&e'- ,)(',(+,!") f(+ e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"(',C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce Q.a+-e+%2 78 8 ::\:>

B > ; , G. 866: E&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd 9<6\de +ee a,,e,,&e'- C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce 78 7 9?\: ; , G., & % < , C. 866: E&(-"('a% &a), (f effec-"/e a'd "'effec-"/e %eade+, C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce 77 9 :8\:=

B > ; , G. 8669 We%%be"' A %ea+'ed ,$"%% (+ G(d , 0"%% C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce 77 8

B > ; , G., & % < , C. 8669 E&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- !e%)"' C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce 77 7 8=\98

B > ; , G.8669 W!a- !a, !a))e'ed -( -!e ,!") (f %eade+,!") C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce76 9 9:\9>

B > ; , G. & ! ; <>;, . 8668 [ 8669 Le,,(', %ea+'ed f+(& "&)%e&e'-"' EQ )+( +a&&e, \ T!ec.--"' ed e (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "'-e+/e'-"(', C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce 76 8 7?\8;

B > ; , G., & A? @<;, C. 8668 E-!"c, \ A f(.'da-"(' c(&)e-e'c2 C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce 76 7 7?\8;

B > ; , G. & B >$;, . 8668 T!e c('-+"b.-"(' (f e&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce -( (+ a'",a-"('a%effec-"/e'e ,, C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce ? : 89\8>

B > ; , G., & G > <; , . 8668 E&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce "' c!a' "' -"&e, C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce ? 8 88\8=

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8667b E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ : A,,.+"' -!e !" !e,- ,-a'da+d, C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce > : 7?\8:

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8667a E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 9 Ta$"' -!e ,!(0 (' -!e +(ad C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce > 9 =\8:

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8666b E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 8 De," ' C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce > 8 7>\8;

B > ; , G., & C ;;<;, . 8666 E/e+2-!"' 2(. 0a'-ed -( $'(0 ab(.- "&)%e&e'-"' a' EQ)+( +a&&e \ 7 e--"' ,-a+-ed C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce > 7 7?\8:

B > ; , G. 8666 T!e 0(+%d (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce C(&)e-e'c2 E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce = 9 89\8=

E B> >< " 29J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 30J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

; B >-$;, % D

% >?<; >< ; :Re./e' Ba+\O' 0a, b(+' "' Ca%"f(+'"a "' 7?:: a'd c.++e'-%2 +e,"de, "' Te1a, ,"'ce 8668He ", &a++"ed -!e fa-!e+ (f -!+ee a'd +a'dfa-!e+ (f ,"1 I' add"-"(' -( -!e U'"-edS-a-e, !e !a, %"/ed "' Ca'ada I-a%2 a'd S(.-! Af+"ca a, 0e%% a, "' I,+ae% 0!e+e !e !a,+e,"ded &(,- (f !", %"fe He !(%d, A&e+"ca' a'd I,+ae%" c"-"3e',!") a'd ", f.%%2 b"%"' .a%"' b(-! E' %",! a'd Heb+e0 He ", a +e-"+ed Ma#(+ f+(& -!e IDFE&a"% Re./e' Re./e'Ba+O' (+

A >< ; ; @ <;?Af-e+ c(&)%e-"' !", BA a'd MA "' -!e U'"-ed S-a-e, !e c('-"'.ed -( ,-.d2 ),2c!(%( 2 "' S(.-! Af+"ca a-R!(de, U'"/e+,"-2 a'd +ece"/ed !", P!D "' 7?>> W!"%e c(&)%e-"' !", d(c-(+a% ,-.d"e, "' S(.-! Af+"ca !e+ece"/ed a' !('(+a+2 I *"+a 0"-c!\d(c-(+ f+(& -!e X!(,a Pe()%e f(+ c%"'"ca% 0(+$ !e )e+f(+&ed 0!"c!de&(',-+a-ed -!a- -!e c+(,,\c.%-.+a% a) be-0ee' 0e,-e+' ),2c!(%( 2 a'd %(ca% -+ad"-"('a% )+ac-"ce, c(.%d be b+"d ed He ", a &e&be+ (f -!e A&e+"ca' P,2c!(%( "ca% A,,(c"a-"(' a'd -!e I,+ae%" P,2c!(%( "ca% A,,(\c"a-"(' a, 0e%% a, a %"ce',ed c%"'"ca% ),2c!(%( ",- a'd c%"'"ca% ,.)e+/",(+ He c.++e'-%2 !(%d, a' ad#.'c-fac.%-2 a))("'-&e'- "' -!e &ed"ca% ,c!((% a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f Te1a, Med"ca% B+a'c! a, 0e%% a, a' ad#.'c-)+(fe,,(+,!") "' -!e Fac.%-2 (f Ed.ca-"(' a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f P+e-(+"a D+ Ba+\O' ", a%,( aff"%"a-ed 0"-! -!eC(%%ab(+a-"/e f(+ Acade&"c S(c"a% a'd E&(-"('a% Lea+'"' "' C!"ca ( a'd 0"-! -!e Ce'-e+ f(+ S(c"a% a'dE&(-"('a% Ed.ca-"(' "' Ne0 Y(+$ He 0a, acce)-ed "'-( -!e C(',(+-".& f(+ Re,ea+c! (' E&(-"('a%I'-e%%" e'ce "' O+ a'"3a-"(', a- R.- e+, U'"/e+,"-2 a, -!e f"+,- '('\f(.'d"' &e&be+ Add"-"('a%%2 !e ",a ,e'"(+ ad/",(+ (' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -( -!e Be,- P+ac-"ce I',-"-.-e "' -!e US F(+ !", c('-+"b.-"(' -( -!ef"e%d (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce D+ Ba+\O' 0a, acce)-ed a, a Fe%%(0 "' -!e R(2a% Acade&2 (f -!e A+-, "' -!e UK

%>< ?? <; >@ ? ; > ;I' add"-"(' -( !", 0(+$ "' -!e f"e%d (f c%"'"ca% ),2c!(%( 2 f+(& 7?=8 D+ Ba+\O' !a, bee' "'/(%/ed "'+e,ea+c!"' def"'"' a'd a))%2"' e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ,"'ce 7?>6 a'd ", ac$'(0%ed ed a, ('e (f -!e%ead"' +e,ea+c!e+, a'd )+ac-"-"('e+, "' -!", f"e%d T!e Ba+\O' &(de% (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce ", de,c+"beda, ('e (f -!+ee %ead"' a))+(ac!e, -( -!", c(',-+.c- "' -!e E'c2c%()ed"a (f A))%"ed P,2c!(%( 2 He c("'ed-!e -e+& EQ E&(-"('a% Q.(-"e'- "' 7?>; -( de,c+"be !", a))+(ac! -( a,,e,,"' e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a%c(&)e-e'ce He c+ea-ed -!e Ba+\O' E&(-"('a% Q.(-"e'- I'/e'-(+2 -!e EQ\" 0!"c! ", -!e f"+,- -e,- (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -( be ).b%",!ed b2 a ),2c!(%( "ca% -e,- ).b%",!e+ a'd )ee+\+e/"e0ed "' -!e B.+(,Me'-a% Mea,.+e&e'- Yea+b(($ T!e EQ\" !a, bee' -+a',%a-ed "'-( &(+e -!a' 96 %a' .a e, a'd )a,,ed -!e('e &"%%"(' &a+$ 0(+%d0"de 0"-!"' f"/e 2ea+, af-e+ "- 0a, ).b%",!ed &a$"' "- -!e &(,- )().%a+%2\.,ed&ea,.+e (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce T( e-!e+ 0"-! D+ Ja&e, Pa+$e+ !e ).b%",!ed -!e Ba+\O' EQ\" YV0!"c! ", -!e f"+,- c(&&e+c"a%%2 a/a"%ab%e -e,- de," 'ed -( a,,e,, e&(-"('a%%2 a'd ,(c"a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- be!a/"(+"' c!"%d+e' a'd ad(%e,ce'-, "' add"-"(' -( be"' fa/(+ab%2 +e/"e0ed "' -!e B.+(, Me'-a% Mea,.+e&e'- Yea+\ b(($ "- !a, bee' ,e%ec-ed b2 ),2c!(&e-+"c"a', a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f O1f(+d a, -!e e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -e,-(f c!("ce f(+ c!"%d+e' a'd +ec(&&e'ded f(+ .,e "' ,c!((%, "' -!e UK T( e-!e+ 0"-! D+ R"c!a+d Ha'd%e2!e ).b%",!ed -!e Ba+\O' EQ\9<6 a'd -!e Ba+\O' EQ\"'-e+/"e0 T( e-!e+ 0"-! D+ Pa+$e+ !e a%,( c(\ed"-ed-!e Ha'db(($ (f E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce "' 8666 0!"c! ", ('e (f -!e f"+,- -e1-b(($, (' -!", -()"c -( be).b%",!ed T( e-!e+ 0"-! D(c-(+, K(b., Ma+ee a'd Ma.+"ce E%"a, !e c(\ed"-ed a' add"-"('a% b(($ "' -!",a+ea "' 866= -"-%ed Ed.ca-"' Pe()%e -( Be E&(-"('a%%2 I'-e%%" e'- Ba,ed (' a -+a"'"' &a'.a% !e 0+(-e0"-! D+ Ha'd%e2 O)-"&"3"' Pe()%e !e c(\de/e%()ed -!e f"+,- 0eb\ba,ed -+a"'"' )+( +a& de," 'ed-( "&)+(/e e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce c(&)e-e'c"e, a'd ,$"%%,

D+ Ba+\O' !a, bee' "'/(%/ed "' '.&e+(., )+(#ec-, +e%a-ed -( -!e ,-.d2 a'd a))%"ca-"(' (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%\%" e'ce f(+ 'ea+%2 -!+ee decade, A' e1a&)%e "'c%.de, a -!+ee\2ea+ ,-.d2 "' -!e I,+ae%" Defe',e F(+ce, -!a-

E B> >< " : A??

e&)"+"ca%%2 de&(',-+a-ed -!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' )e+f(+&a'ce a'd "-, ab"%"-2 -( )+ed"c-c(&&a'd %eade+,!") He !a, a%,( a'a%23ed -!e f"'d"' , (f a' e1-e',"/e +e,ea+c! )+(#ec- c('d.c-ed b2 D+Ma+"a' R.de+&a' a- -!e Ce'-e+ f(+ C+ea-"/e Leade+,!") "' -!e US 0!"c! c('f"+&, -!e ab"%"-2 (f e&(-"('a%

a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce -( )+ed"c- ,.cce,,f.% c(+)(+a-e %eade+, He !a, a%,( bee' "'/(%/ed "' a 8;\2ea+%(' "-.d"'a% ,-.d2 (f 89 666 2(.-! -( de-e+&"'e -!e "'-e+\+e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%\%" e'ce a'd b"(&ed"ca% c( '"-"/e de/e%()&e'-a% a'd ed.ca-"('a% fac-(+, -!", ,-.d2 0!"c! ", be"'c('d.c-ed b2 H.&a' Re,(.+ce, a'd S$"%%, De/e%()&e'- Ca'ada +e)+e,e'-, -!e f"+,- %(' "-.d"'a% ,-.d2(f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd ", e1)ec-ed -( ,!ed %" !- (' !(0 -!", c(',-+.c- de/e%(), 0!a- affec-, "- a'd0!a- ", affec-ed b2 "- M(+e +ece'-%2 !e !a, bee' "'/"-ed -( #("' +e,ea+c!e+, a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f P+e-(+"a "'c(%%ab(+a-"(' 0"-! a +e,ea+c! -ea& "' -!e Ped"a-+"c De)a+-&e'- a- -!e Ya%e Sc!((% (f Med"c"'e 0!( a+e"'/e,-" a-"' -!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' +e,"%"e'c2 a&(' c!"%d+e' (f AIDS )a-"e'-,"' Af+"ca He !a, a%,( bee' "'/(%/ed "' +e,ea+c! )+(#ec-, e1a&"'"' -!e 'e.+(%( "ca% ,.b,-+a-e (f e&(-"('a%a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce a, 0e%% a, "-, "&)ac- (' )!2,"ca% a'd ),2c!(%( "ca% d",(+de+, T( e-!e+ 0"-!c(%%ea .e, a- -!e U'"/e+,"-2 (f I(0a C(%%e e (f Med"c"'e !e ).b%",!ed -!e f"+,- )ee+\+e/"e0ed )a)e+ ('

-!e 'e.+(%( "ca% ba,", (f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ceD+ Ba+\O' f(.'ded Ba+\O' C(',.%-"' a'd !a, bee' d("' +e,ea+c!\ba,ed c(',.%-a-"(' f(+ ).b%"c a'd)+"/a-e (+ a'"3a-"(', 0(+%d0"de (' a' (' ("' ba,", He de/e%()ed 0!a- !e +efe+, -( a, S-a+ Pe+f(+&e+P+(f"%"' Z 0!"c! "'/(%/e, c+ea-"' ,-a-",-"ca% &(de%, -!a- )+ed"c- !" ! )e+f(+&a'ce a'd a+e .,ed "'!"+"' -+a"'"' a'd )+(&(-"' effec-"/e a'd ,a-",f"ed e&)%(2ee, -!a- e'!a'ce c%"e'- ,a-",fac-"(' a'd(/e+a%% (+ a'"3a-"('a% effec-"/e'e,, T!", )+(ce,, !a, !e%)ed (+ a'"3a-"(', ,a/e (+ &a$e !.'d+ed, (f&"%%"(', (f d(%%a+, 0(+%d0"deT!", ", 0!a- D+ Da'"e% G(%e&a' -!e a.-!(+ (f E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce ,a"d ab(.- D+ Ba+\O' , c('-+"b.-"('-( e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce Y(.+ 0(+$ ", %ead"' -!e 0a2 "' &(/"' -!", f"e%d f(+0a+dI' add"-"(' -( !", e1-e',"/e 0(+$ "' -!e f"e%d (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce D+ Ba+\O' c(\de," 'ed a !a'd!e%d

de/"ce f(+ NASA -!a- &('"-(+, -!e c( '"-"/e a'd 'e.+(%( "ca% f.'c-"('"' (f a,-+('a.-, ab(a+d ,)ace,-a-"(', 0!"c! 0"%% !()ef.%%2 be .,ed "' e1-e'ded ,)ace -+a/e% He !a, &(+e +ece'-%2 de/e%()ed a 0eb\ ba,ed "'-e+ac-"/e )+( +a& de," 'ed -( e/a%.a-e )+e'a-a% a'1"e-2 a'd e'!a'ce ada)-a-"(' -( )+e 'a'c2 -(!e%) e1)ec-a'- &(-!e+, !a/e a %e,, ,-+e,,f.% !ea%-!"e+ a'd &(+e )%ea,a'- )+e 'a'c2 I' c(%%ab(+a-"(' 0"-!D+ M"c!ae% R(c$ "' Ca'ada !e ", c.++e'-%2 de/e%()"' -0( add"-"('a% 0eb\ba,ed )+( +a&, de," 'ed -(e/a%.a-e a'd e'!a'ce &(+a% c(&)e-e'ce a, 0e%% a, ,)"+"-.a% de/e%()&e'- D+ Ba+\O' ", a%,( c(%%ab(+a-"'0"-! a L('d('\ba,ed %(ba% HR[OD c(',.%-a'c2 "' de/e%()"' a ),2c!(&e-+"c "',-+.&e'- de," 'ed -(de-ec- !" ! +",$ f(+ de+a"%&e'- -!e ())(,"-e (f ,.cce,,f.% %eade+,!") "' ,e'"(+ e1ec.-"/e, a'd c(+)(+a-e%eade+,D+ Ba+\O' , 0(+$ !a, bee' de,c+"bed "' e'c2c%()ed"a, b(($, a'd )+(fe,,"('a% #(.+'a%, a, 0e%% a, "''.&e+(., 'e0,)a)e+ +ad"( a'd -e%e/","(' "'-e+/"e0, a+(.'d -!e 0(+%d He !a, :6 ).b%"ca-"(', "' -!e a+ea

(f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce a%('e a'd !e !a, de%"/e+ed &(+e -!a' 8; )+e,e'-a-"(', a- )+(fe,,"('a%c('fe+e'ce, !e%d "' (/e+ 76 c(.'-+"e, H", 0(+$ ", c"-ed "' &(+e -!a' 7 :66 )ee+\+e/"e0ed a+-"c%e, a, 0e%% a,"' (/e+ ;66 -!e,e, a'd d",,e+-a-"(', O' a' (' ("' ba,", D+ Ba+\O' +e/"e0, &a'.,c+")-, +e%a-ed -(e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce f(+ a '.&be+ (f )ee+\+e/"e0ed #(.+'a%, a'd ,e+/e, (' -!e ed"-(+"a% b(a+d, (ff(.+ #(.+'a%,

A @ <;? @ H /$ <;? @ ; ?D+ Ba+\O' ", aff"%"a-ed 0"-! EUROUS G%(ba% E1ec.-"/e Leade+,!") "' Sa' F+a'c",c( Pe''a C(',.%-"' "'L('d(' a'd FSL C(ac!"' "' S"' a)(+e A- -!e,e c(',.%-a'c"e, !e ", a ,e'"(+ ad/",(+ (' -!e a))%"ca-"(' (fe&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd (-!e+ c%(,e%2 a,,(c"a-ed c('ce)-, He a%,( c(%%ab(+a-e, 0"-! -!e& "' )+(/"d"'HR[OD c(',.%-a-"(' -( c%"e'-, 0(+%d0"de Add"-"('a%%2 D+ Ba+\O' ", a &e&be+ (f -!e G%(ba% Ma,-e+&"'d

G+(.) 0!"c! ", a -!"'$\-a'$ f(+ ad/a'c"' %eade+,!") a'd -ea& de/e%()&e'-D> ; B >-$; ] 000 Re./e'Ba+O' (+ [ Re./e' Re./e'Ba+O' (+

E B> >< " 31J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E B> >< " 32J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

D>. ; B >-$;'? % @ <;?

B >-$;, ., & > , J. G. "' )+e,, I' ,ea+c! (f e&(-"('a%\,(c"a% "f-ed'e,, A )(-e'-"a%%2 /"ab%e a'd/a%.ab%e c('ce)- I' La+",a V S!a/"'"'a Ed The Ha#db$$ $f gif)ed#e((< Ne0 Y(+$ C"-2 S)+"' e+ Sc"e'ce

B >-$;, . "' )+e,, T!e Ba+\O' &(de% (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce A /a%"d +(b.,- a'd a))%"cab%e EI &(de%O'ga#i(a)i$#( a#d Pe$%!e; T( be ).b%",!ed "' 866=

E ?, . J., & B >-$;, . "' )+e,, E)"%( .e T!e +e%a-"(',!") be-0ee' Na++a-"/e Ca+ee+ C(.',e%%"'e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce EI a'd ,(c"a%\e&(-"('a% %ea+'"' SEL I' J G Ma+ee Ed Sha%i#g )he ()$'.= A g*ide )$ faci!i)a)i#g ca'ee' c$*#(e!!i#g; P+e-(+"a SA Va' S!a"$ P.b%",!e+,

B >-$;, . 866= T!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' "f-ed'e,, Gif)ed Ed*ca)i$# I#)e'#a)i$#a!< 88 7

B >-$;, . 866<a EQ\"Z %eade+,!") .,e+ , ."de T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, . 866<b H(0 "&)(+-a'- ", "- -( ed.ca-e )e()%e -( be e&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- a'd ca' "- be d('eI' R Ba+\O' J G Ma+ee M E%"a, Ed,Ed*ca)i#g %e$%!e )$ be e"$)i$#a!!. i#)e!!ige#) J(!a''e,b.+He"'e&a'' Ed.ca-"('a% P.b%",!e+,

B >-$;, . 866<c T!e Ba+\O' &(de% (f e&(-"('a%\,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce ESIP(ic$)he"a< 7> ,.)% 79\;

B > , A., D ? <, A., & B >-$;, . 866< T!e a'a-(&2 (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd -!e "&)%"ca-"(',f(+ ed.ca-"' )e()%e -( be e&(-"('a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- I' R Ba+\O' J G Ma+ee M E%"a, Ed,Ed*ca)i#g %e$%!e )$ be e"$)i$#a!!. i#)e!!ige#); J(!a''e,b.+ SA He"'e&a'' Ed.ca-"('a% P.b%",!e+,

B >-$;, ., H ; , ., & F ; , . 866< T!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' )e+f(+&a'ceI' Va'e,,a D+.,$a- Fab"( Sa%a a'd Ge+a%d M(.'- Ed, Li# i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce a#d %e'f$'"a#ce a),$' = C*''e#) 'e(ea'ch e+ide#ce; Ma!0a! NJ La0+e'ce E+%ba.& )) 9\7?

B >-$;, ., > , J. G., E ?, . J. (E ?.), 866< Ed*ca)i#g %e$%!e )$ be e"$)i$#a!!. i#)e!!ige#); J(!a''e,b.+SA He"'e&a'' Ed.ca-"('a% P.b%",!e+,

B >-$;, . 866; T!e "&)ac- (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (' ,.b#ec-"/e 0e%%\be"' Pe'(%ec)i+e( i# Ed*ca)i$#<89 8 :7\<7

B >-$;, ., > ; , D., D ; > , #. !., & B > , A. 866; E1)%(+"' -!e 'e.+(%( "ca% ,.b,-+a-e (fe&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce I' J T Cac"())( a'd G G Be+',-(' Ed, Ke. 'eadi#g( i# ($cia! %(.ch$!$g.= S$cia! #e*'$(cie#ce; Ne0 Y(+$ NY P,2c!(%( 2 P+e,, )) 889\9=

B > , A., & B >-$;, . 866; T!e 'e.+(%( "ca% ,.b,-+a-e, (f e&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ceE/"de'ce f+(& )a-"e'-, 0"-! f(ca% b+a"' %e,"(', I' J T Cac"())( a'd G G Be+',-(' Ed, E((a.( i# ($cia!#e*'$(cie#ce; Ca&b+"d e MA MIT P+e,,

B >-$;, . 866: T!e Ba+\O' E&(-"('a% Q.(-"e'- I'/e'-(+2 EQ\"Z Ra-"('a%e de,c+")-"(' a'd,.&&a+2 (f ),2c!(&e-+"c )+()e+-"e, I' G%e'' Ge!e+ Ed Mea(*'i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce= C$""$# g'$*#d a#d c$#)'$+e'(.; Ha.))a. e NY N(/a Sc"e'ce P.b%",!e+, )) 777\:8

B >-$;, . 8669a H(0 "&)(+-a'- ", "- -( ed.ca-e )e()%e -( be e&(-"('a%%2 a'd ,(c"a%%2 "'-e%%" e'- a'dca' "- be d('e Pe'(%ec)i+e( i# Ed*ca)i$#< 21 ?4@ 9\79

B >-$;, . G.e,- Ed"-(+ S)ec"a% I,,.e (' Ed.ca-"' Pe()%e -( be E&(-"('a%%2 a'd S(c"a%%2 I'-e%%" e'-8669b Pe'(%ec)i+e( i# Ed*ca)i$#< 21 ?4@

B >-$;, ., & H ; , . 8669a The Ba' O# EQ 360; T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, ., & H ; , . 8669b The Ba' O# EQ 360= Tech#ica! "a#*a!; T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-!S2,-e&,

B >-$;, ., > ; , D., D ; > , #. !., & B > , A. 8669 E1)%(+"' -!e 'e.+(%( "ca% ,.b,-+a-e (fe&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce B'ai#< 78< 7=?6\7>66

$> , G., & B >-$;, . 8668 T!e c('-+"b.-"(' (f e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce -( "'d"/"d.a% a'd (+ a'",a-"('a%effec-"/e'e,, C$"%e)e#c. : E"$)i$#a! I#)e!!ige#ce< 9 ?4@< 89\8>

E B> >< " : A??

B >-$;, . 8667 E&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce a'd ,e%f\ac-.a%"3a-"(' I' J(,e)! C"a++(c!" J(e F(+ a, a'd J(!'D Ma2e+ Ed, E"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce i# e+e'.da. !ife= A (cie#)ific i#&*i'.; Ne0 Y(+$ P,2c!(%( 2 P+e,, ))>8\?=

B >-$;, . 8666 E&(-"('a% a'd ,(c"a% "'-e%%" e'ce I'," !-, f+(& -!e E&(-"('a% Q.(-"e'- I'/e'-(+2EQ\"Z I' Re./e' Ba+\O' a'd Ja&e, D A Pa+$e+ Ed, Ha#db$$ $f e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce= The$'.<de+e!$%"e#)< a((e(("e#) a#d a%%!ica)i$# a) h$"e< (ch$$! a#d i# )he ,$' %!ace; Sa' F+a'c",c( J(,,e2\Ba,,)) 9<9\>>

B >-$;, ., B>< ;, J. ., > , B.D., & < , E.% 8666 E&(-"('a% e1)+e,,"(' a'd "&)%"ca-"(', f(+(cc.)a-"('a% ,-+e,, A' a))%"ca-"(' (f -!e E&(-"('a% Q.(-"e'- I'/e'-(+2 EQ\" J$*'#a! $f Pe'($#a!i). a#dI#di+id*a! Diffe'e#ce(< 28< 776=\777>

B >-$;, ., & % > >, J.D.A. 8666a E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'.= Y$*)h Ve'(i$# ?EQ i=YV@; T(+('-(Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, ., & % > >, J.D.A. 8666b E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'.= Y$*)h Ve'(i$# ?EQ i=YV@= Tech#ica!"a#*a!; T(+('-( Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

B >-$;, ., & % > >, J.D.A. 8666c Ha#db$$ $f e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce= The$'.< de+e!$%"e#)< a((e(("e#)a#d a%%!ica)i$# a) h$"e< (ch$$! a#d i# )he ,$' %!ace; Sa' F+a'c",c( J(,,e2\Ba,,

> < , E., B ;-A> ? , ., & B >-$;, . 8666 C(&)a+"' -!e e&(-"('a% "'-e%%" e'ce (f ad(%e,ce'-ca'ce+ ,.+/"/(+, 0"-! a &a-c!ed ,a&)%e f+(& -!e '(+&a-"/e )().%a-"(' Medica! : Pedia)'ic O#c$!$g.< 35?3@< 9>8

>, C., & B >-$;, . 8666 Hea') ,$' ; H"%%e+ d De'&a+$ TMI P.b%",!"'

B >-$;, ., & H ; , . 7??? O%)i"i/i#g %e$%!e= A %'ac)ica! g*ide f$' a%%!.i#g e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce )$i"%'$+e %e'($#a! a#d $'ga#i/a)i$#a! effec)i+e#e((; Ne0 B+a.'fe%, TX P+(\P!"%e, P+e,,

B >-$;, . 7??=a The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'. ?EQ i@= A )e() $f e"$)i$#a! i#)e!!ige#ce; T(+('-(Ca'ada M.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,B >-$;, . 7??=b The Ba' O# E"$)i$#a! Q*$)ie#) I#+e#)$'. ?EQ i@= Tech#ica! "a#*a!; T(+('-( Ca'adaM.%-"\Hea%-! S2,-e&,

@ @ , E., B >-$;, ., D< > , $. ., & <@ >, . 7??< T+a.&a-"c 0a+ e1)e+"e'ce, affec- (.-c(&e "'a ca,e (f T(.+e--e , S2'd+(&e P(.ch$)he'a%. a#d P(.ch$($"a)ic(< 65 ?2@< 76<\>

@ @ , E., > < ;, J., B >-$;, ., & ! , A. 7??; S-" &a %abe%%"' a'd ),2c!"a-+"c &",d"a '(,",O+" "', a'd (.-c(&e, Med La,;> 7: =\> <;?\<?

@ @ , E., > < ;, J., B >-$;, ., & ! , A. 7??8 %abe%%"' a'd ,-" &a "' ),2c!"a-+"c &",d"a '(,",I('ae! J$*'#a! $f P(.chia)'. a#d Re!a)ed Scie#ce( 8? 8 ==\>>

B >-$;, . 7?>> T!e de/e%()&e'- (f a c('ce)- (f ),2c!(%( "ca% 0e%%\be"' D(c-(+a% d",,e+-a-"('R!(de, U'"/e+,"-2 S(.-! Af+"ca

B >-$;, ., < < <;, ., #< , . & # > , C. 7?>< T!e c%"'"ca% )"c-.+e (f c(&ba- ,-+e,, +eac-"(' "' -!e7?>8 0a+ "' Leba'(' C+(,,\0a+ c(&)a+",(', I' N(+&a' A M"% +a& Ed S)'e(( a#d c$%i#g i# )i"e $f ,a'= Ge#e'a!i/a)i$#( f'$" )he I('ae!i e-%e'ie#ce; Ne0 Y(+$ B+.''e+[Ma3e% P.b%",!e+,

< < <;, ., #< , ., B >-$;, . 7?><a R",$ fac-(+, "' c(&ba- ,-+e,, +eac-"(' Ð A ,-.d2 (f I,+ae%" ,(%d"e+,"' -!e 7?>8 Leba'(' Wa+ I('ae! J$*'#a! $f P(.chia)'. a#d Re!a)ed Scie#ce(< 23 ?1@ 9\>

< < <;, ., #< , . & B >-$;, . 7?>, B., G<> ;, F., & B >-$;, . 7?=8 The 1973 1974 %!a# f$' "e#)a! 'e)a'da)i$# (e'+ice(< L$( A#ge!e(;L(, A' e%e, C(.'-2 De)a+-&e'- (f Me'-a% Hea%-!

E B> >< " 33J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

A < @ E <> ! @

E" W(+%d ", a +ec( '",ed %eade+ "' -!e f"e%d (f E&(-"('a% I'-e%%" e'ce a'd 0e a+e -!e %(' e,- e,-ab%",!ed)+(/"de+ (f EQ\" a'd EQ9<6 acc+ed"-a-"(', "' -!e UK We de%"/e+ 0(+%d\c%a,, de/e%()&e'- )+( +a&&e,"' -!e UK a'd %(ba%%2 -( de/e%() a'd ,.,-a"' e&)%(2ee e' a e&e'- a'd effec-"/e'e,, We a+e %"ce',ed-( de%"/e+ -!e Hea+-Ma-! ,."-e (f )+( +a&&e, %"'$"' )!2,"(%( 2 0"-! )e+f(+&a'ce a'd )+(/"de !ea%-!,c+ee'"' 0"-!"' -!e c('-e1- (f de/e%()"' e&(-"('a% a'd )!2,"ca% +e,"%"e'ce

$ > >< > ? > ? ; @< ? <>@:

S-+a-e 2 e1ec.-"(' [ c!a' e )+( +a&&e,

Leade+,!") de/e%()&e'-

O+ a'",a-"('a% -+a',f(+&a-"('

Ta%e'- &a'a e&e'-

Tea& effec-"/e'e,,

E1ec.-"/e c(ac!"' )+( +a&&e,

> ? / %>< > ?:

Be,)($e de," ' -( 2(.+ +e*."+e&e'-, f(+ -ea&, e1ec.-"/e, a'd "'d"/"d.a%,

I'\H(.,e )+ac-"-"('e+ acc+ed"-a-"('

I'-e +a-"(' "'-( &.%-"\d",c")%"'a+2 )+(#ec-,

Re,ea+c! P+(#ec-,

A,,e,,&e'-, Acc+ed"-a-"(',

Hea%-! Sc+ee'"' f(+ "'d"/"d.a%, a'd +(.),

If 2(. 0",! -( !a/e a c('5de'-"a% d",c.,,"(' ab(.- a' EI "'-e+/e'-"(' (+ )+(#ec- )%ea,e c('-ac-G @ B > ; ] F(.'d"' D"+ec-(+ E" W(+%d ] 000 e"0(+%d (+ [ b!a+0a'e2 e"0(+%d (+

E <> ! @

: D((%"--%e M"%%A&)-!"%%Bedf(+d,!"+eMK:; 8ND

Te% ::\7;8;\>:66?6

Fa1 ::\7;8;\>:66?8

E B> >< " 35J 2007, 2011, B , B -% , # ! .F> ? < > > ? > ? > E > " < . > .> < : >@ > .>

E B> >< " : A??

E ; @ B<@@< ! ;

A <?> > > > > E<> > - <<? > > > E<> > <? > >< .

? , > ?

A > << > H ? > > > > < > <? > > . * ? ?

> > ? > > > <> > > ? > .

Bharwaney BarOn MacKinlay EQ and Bottom Line

Documents

Transcript of Bharwaney BarOn MacKinlay EQ and Bottom Line