Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high...

49
Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models MOS-AK/GSA Workshop Noida (U.P.), India, March 16-18, 2012 Ehrenfried Seebacher 2011-12-15 a leap ahead in analog

Transcript of Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high...

Page 1: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models MOS-AK/GSA Workshop Noida (U.P.), India, March 16-18, 2012 Ehrenfried Seebacher 2011-12-15

a leap ahead in analog

Page 2: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

2

Presentation Overview

• Definition of model requirements • HV Transistor generally • Discussion and Benchmarking for

• BSIM3.3 Sub-circuit • HiSIM_HV • EKV HV

Page 3: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

3

General Requirements for Compact Models

–High accuracy for the description of the electrical behavior of the device and the simulation of the corresponding circuit –Short simulation time –Convergence –Availability in the important/used simulator –Parameter extraction availability –Model documentation availability –Long term management for model development and support.

Page 4: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Which HV Model to choose? Compact models are defined as models for circuit elements which are sufficiently accurate for circuit design and simple to incorporate into circuit simulators.

4

? Simplicity Universality Physical Accuracy Number of parameter Empirical Extendibility

Presenter
Presentation Notes
I found a very interesting definition of Compact models in the book “Compact Modeling” from Prof. Gildenblat. It says: …. But requirements for circuit designs are very different and not all models can cover all needs. Effort and need are mostly controversial. Specially the effort increases dremondosly if you want to make everything perfect. So what are the physical effects which should be taken into account for HV transistor models:
Page 5: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

SPICE Model Trade Off

5

Page 6: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

DIFFERENT TYPES OF HV TRANSISTOR IN CMOS TECHNOLOGY

6

Page 7: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

HV CMOS Transistor Types

7

Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between both quantities is of major interest.

The gate length is extended beyond the body-drain well junction, which increases the junction BV. The gate acts as a field plate to bends the electric field. RESURFeffect

Increased junction breakdown voltage (BV) of the drain diffusion is achieved by using a deep drain well

PWELL

PWELL

NWELL

Nwell

Nwell

Presenter
Presentation Notes
LDMOS transistor LDD, simple structure up to 10-12V also used for RF applications. HV CMOS using special drain well for increasing the D-S and D-B breakdown voltage. Isolated one HV PMOS
Page 8: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Following physical effects must be taken into account

8

• State of the art MOS transistor features • Quasi-saturation • Self-heating • Geometry-related • Graded channel • Bulk current, Impact ionization in the drift region • High-side switch • Parasitic bipolar junction transistor (BJT).

Presenter
Presentation Notes
I found a very interesting definition of Compact models in the book “Compact Modeling” from Prof. Gildenblat. It says: …. But requirements for circuit designs are very different and not all models can cover all needs. Effort and need are mostly controversial. Specially the effort increases dremondosly if you want to make everything perfect. So what are the physical effects which should be taken into account for HV transistor models:
Page 9: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

FOMs for HV Transistors

• RON (On Resistor) (high vgs, low vds, and temp.) • VT long & short (Threshold Voltage) • Cgg & Cgd (Miller Cap) • gds, gm (analog parameter for long channel length) • IDSAT (Saturation Current) • FT, FMAX RF Parameter (transit frequency and

maximum oscillation frequency).

9

Page 10: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

HV TRANSISTOR MODELING

10

Page 11: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

State of the Art HV Compact Models and new Developments BSIMx Sub-circuit Model HiSIM_HV

–CMC Standard model version 1.1.2 ;1.2.1; 2.0 EKV HV Transistor

–Under development within the EU Project COMON PSP HV – Transistor Model

–In development based on PSP surface potential model MM20

–asymmetrical, surface-potential-based LDMOS model, developed by NXP Research

11

Page 12: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

BSIMX.X SUB-CIRCUIT

12

Page 13: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Sub-circuit Modeling

13

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Simple sub-circuit can be used for LDD transistors LDPMOS with less quasi-saturation effect. Symmetrical HV PMOS, less quasi-saturation Unsymmetrical HV MOS high quasi-saturation and length scaling effect. Substrate current injection Symmetrical HV CMOS with all ugly features of HV CMOS you can imagine.
Page 14: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Sub-circuit Model Features and Limitations HV MOS Transistor Model Features: •Basic MOS FET Model Features (BSIM)

•Basic geometrical and process-related aspects such as oxide thickness, junction depth, effective channel length and width •Geometry scaling, Short-channel effects •1/f and thermal noise equation. •Temperature Modeling for RON, VT, IDSAT •Effects of doping profiles, substrate effect •Modeling of weak, moderate and strong inversion behavior

•RON modeling •Quasi saturation region and the saturation region •Bulk (Substrate) current •Parasitic bipolar junction transistor (BJT).

Model Limitations: •RF modeling •SH modeling •Cgd, Cgg …… •Graded channel •Impact ionization in the drift region •High-side switch (sub-circuit extension needed)

14

Page 15: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

BSIM3v3 Sub-Circuit (Trade Off)

15

Page 16: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

HISIM_HV 1.1.2, 1.2.1, 2.0

16

Page 17: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Consistent Modeling in Drift Region

17

Hiroshima University &

Y. Oritsuki et al., IEEE TED, 57, p. 2671, 2010.

Ldrift

Ndrift

VDDP

Potential drop in the drift region

Vds

Y. Oritsuki et al., IEEE TED, 57, p. 2671, 2010.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
VDDP Interner Knoten
Page 18: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

HiSIM_HV The following effects are also included: •Depletion effect of the gate polycrystalline silicon (poly-Si). •Quantum mechanical •CLM •Narrow channel •STI •Leakage currents (gate, substrate and gate-induced drain leakage (GIDL) currents). •Source/bulk and drain/bulk diode models. •Noise models (1/f, thermal noise, induced gate noise). •Non-quasi static (NQS) model.

18

Complete Surface potential-based: HiSIM_HV solves the Poisson equation along the MOSFET channel iteratively, including the resistance effect in the drift region.

high flexibility 20 model flags scales with the gate width, the gate length, the number of gate fingers and the drift region length. In addition, HiSIM_HV is capable of modeling symmetric and asymmetric HV devices.

Page 19: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Relatively Low Breakdown Voltage

Relatively High Breakdown Voltage

Current-Voltage Characteristics Hiroshima University &

Page 20: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

20

BSIM3v3 sub-circuit v. HiSIM_HV Hi

SIM_

HV 1.

1.2 v.

BSI

M3v3

Sub

circu

it Hiroshima University &

Page 21: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Empirical Model: Issues on HiSIM_ HV 1.1.2

Care must be taken when adjusting critical parameters describing the Vgs dependence.

Ids - Vgs

Gm vs. Vgs

Hiroshima University &

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Conditions Parameter RDVG11 und RDVG12 (extreme transistor nmos50t) unphysical behavior Result of the empirical model
Page 22: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

22

AC Modeling: Cgg BSIM3+JFETS Subckt. HiSIM_HV

• Subcircuit: bad fitting quality, especially in accumulation. • HiSIM_HV: good fitting quality in all regions.

Page 23: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

HiSIM_HV (Trade Off)

23

Page 24: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EKV HV

References [1] A. Bazigos, F. Krummenacher, J.-M. Sallese, M. Bucher, E. Seebacher, W. Posch, K. Molnar, M. Tang, “A physicsbased analytical compact model for the Drift region of the HV-MOSFET”, IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices, Volume 58, Issue 6, pp. 1710-1721, June 2011. [2] A. Bazigos, F. Krummenacher, J.-M. Sallese, “Recent Developments on the EPFL - High Voltage MOSFET Model (EPFL-HVMOS)”, Poster Presentation at MOS-AK/GSA ESSDERC/ESSCIRC, Workshop 2010, Sept. 17, Seville [3] A. Bazigos, F. Krummenacher, J.-M. Sallese, “I-V and C-V Results of the EPFL-High Voltage MOSFET Model (EPFL-HVMOS)”, Presentation at MOS-AK Workshop 2011, 7-8 April 2011, Paris.

24

Page 25: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EKV HV Model Features

• Laterally non uniform effect (inner MOS) • Mobility reduction due to vertical field effect • Quasi-saturation • First order high field mobility reduction in drift

region • Geometrical small dimension scaling • Sub-threshold barrier lowering (a.k.a. DIBL) • Reverse Short Channel Effect • Channel length modulation • Temperature effects • Self-heating effect • Impact ionization current • Dynamic Model (capacitances) • Extrinsic parasitic elements

Model Limitations

• Layout dependences • Non-quasi-static behaviour • Noise • Symmetric structures

25

Page 26: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

26

50V HV Transistors, A. Bazigos, Mingchun Tang

Page 27: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

IDVG for low VD

27

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 28: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

Log(ID)_VG for low VD

28

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 29: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

IDVG for high VD

29

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 30: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

Log(ID)_VG for high VD

30

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 31: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

IDVD

31

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 32: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

32

50V HV Transistors, A. Bazigos, Mingchun Tang

Page 33: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

CGG

33

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 34: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

34

CCG

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 35: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EPFL_HV v1.106 HiSIM_HV v1.1.2 BSIM Sub-Circuit v3.3

35

CBG

Blue: Simulation; Red: Measurement

Page 36: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

EKV HV (Trade off)

38

Page 37: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

1/F NOISE MODELING Analog design requirement

39

Page 38: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

1/f Noise Modeling for HV Transistors

40

Mobility fluctuations as well as charge carrier fluctuations

HiSIM_HV: NFALP which is applied for the mobility fluctuation phenomenon NFTRP which is applied for the ratio of trapped density to attenuation coefficient. CIT, a capacitance parameter applied for interface-trapped carriers. Normally it is fixed to zero.

The BSIM3v3 approach has a different formulation for operating regions vg > vth + 0.1V and vg < vth + 0.1V; Therefore a discontinuous flicker noise model may occur HiSIM_HV which uses one common formulation for strong and weak inversion operating regions.

Page 39: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Sid & Svg Benchmark

Sid… Output referred Noise Svg… input referred Noise IC… Inversion Coefficient • Vds=3V • short channel and a long channel

device

• Sid current noise density [A2/Hz],

41

Page 40: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

VERY HIGH VOLTAGES 120V

42

Page 41: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

BSIM sub-circuit v. HiSIM_HV 1.2.1 for 120V Transistors

43

HV NMOS output and transfer characteristic of a typical wafer. W/L=40/0.5, VGS= 2.9, 4.8, 6.7, 8.6, 10.5, 12.4, 14.3, 16.2, 18.1, 20 V, VBS=0 V. & VBS= 0, -1, -2, -3, -4 V, VDS=0.1 V. + = measured, full lines= BSIM3v3 model; dashed lines = HiSIM_HV 1.2.1

Page 42: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

44

Isolated HVMOS: High-Side Switch Modeling - HVMOS used on the low-side of a load: Source and Substrate hold at the same potential - HVMOS used on the high-side of a load: Both Source and Drain can be placed at high potential => Ron is changing with Vsub-s

Vsub=0

Vsub=-120V

Transfer Characteristics

Vd=0.1V, Vs=Vb=0

HiSIM_HV 1.2.1: Vsub modulates the effective depth of the drift region: Rdrift(Vsub,s)

Page 43: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

CAPABILITIES

45

Page 44: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Table of Model Capabilities (1/3) Physical Effects BSIM3/JFET Subcircuit HiSIM_HV EPFL-HV Technology Related Device Effects: Symmetric / Asymmetric Device asymmetric

only Quasi-Saturation RON Mobility Carrier Velocity Saturation Channel Length Modulation Impact Ionization current extrinsic model Poly-Silicon-Gate Depletion Effects Geometry Scaling: Short Channel Effects Reverse Short Channel Effects Narrow Channel Effects Drain Induced Barrier Lowering

Page 45: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Table of Model Capabilities (2/3)

Physical Effects BSIM3/JFET Subcircuit HiSIM_HV EPFL-HV Asymetric MOS Capacitances: Intrinsic Capacitance Overlap Capacitance Fringing Capacitance Bulk Diodes: Diode Current Diode Capacitance Temperature Modelling: Threshold Voltage Mobility Quasi-Saturation RON Bulk Current Self-Heating

Page 46: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Table of Model Capabilities (3/3)

Physical Effects BSIM3/JFET Subcircuit HiSIM_HV EPFL-HV

Noise: SPICE Noise model Flicker Noise Model Short Channel Thermal Noise Model Induced Noise in Gate Induced Noise in Substrate RF Modeling: Gate resistance model Substrate resistance model Multi-finger transistors Non-Quasi-Static (NQS): NQS

Page 47: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

SIMULATOR TIME

49

Page 48: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Speed comparison

Benchmark case: 27-Stage Ringoscillator, VDD=3.3V

50

BSIM based sub-circuit

HiSIM HV 1.1.2 with self-heating

HiSIM HV 2.0 without self-heating

HiSIM HV 2.0 with self-heating

Simulation Time

187s 361s 437s 501s

Peak Memory used

40.1MB 35.2MB

33.1MB

33.2MB

Fast on/off switching dramatically extend the simulation time for HiSIM HV.

Page 49: Benchmarking of HV MOS Transistor Models · HV CMOS Transistor Types 7 Small on-resistance and high BV are contrary effects. The optimization of the tradeoff between . both quantities

© 2011 austriamicrosystems

All ri

ghts

rese

rved.

©2

011 ·

austr

iamicr

osys

tems A

G.

Mater

ial m

ay no

t be r

epro

duce

d with

out w

ritten

appr

oval

of au

striam

icros

ystem

s and

may

only

be us

ed fo

r non

comm

ercia

l edu

catio

nal p

urpo

ses.

Summary

HV-Transistor Model Benchmarking: General requirements & Model trade off for • BSIM3v3 Sub-circuit • HiSIM_HV • EKV HV 51