Barriers to Care

41
Barriers to Care Barriers to Care Barrier Barrier Percentage Responding “Most Percentage Responding “Most of Time” and “Often” of Time” and “Often” RDs (n=441 ) PNPs (n=293 ) Pediatrician s (n=201 Lack of parent motivation 61.9* 78.2* 85.7* Lack of parent involvement 71.8* 82.5* 81.2* Lack of clinician time 31.2* 45.9* 58.0* Lack of reimbursement 68.1* 46.8* 45.8* Lack of clinician knowledge 23.8* 32.2* 44.0* Lack of treatment skills 27.3* 32.2* 45.0* Lack of support 55.5 57.0 60.0 Story, Neumark-Stzainer, Story, Neumark-Stzainer, Sherwood, et al., 2002 Sherwood, et al., 2002 1

description

Barriers to Care. Story, Neumark-Stzainer , Sherwood, et al., 2002. Expert Committee Recommendations, (AMA, HRSA, and CDC) June 2005. Current Recommendations & Guidelines. Expert Committee Recommendations - 2007 An Implementation Guide Childhood Obesity Action Network, NICHQ, 2007. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Barriers to Care

Page 1: Barriers to Care

Barriers to CareBarriers to CareBarrierBarrier Percentage Responding “Most of Percentage Responding “Most of

Time” and “Often”Time” and “Often”

RDs(n=44

1)

PNPs(n=29

3)

Pediatricians(n=201

Lack of parent motivation

61.9* 78.2* 85.7*

Lack of parent involvement

71.8* 82.5* 81.2*

Lack of clinician time 31.2* 45.9* 58.0*

Lack of reimbursement 68.1* 46.8* 45.8*

Lack of clinician knowledge

23.8* 32.2* 44.0*

Lack of treatment skills 27.3* 32.2* 45.0*

Lack of support services 55.5 57.0 60.0

Treatment futility 37.4* 52.6* 53.0*

Eating disorder concerns

17.2* 12.9* 10.0*

* * Percentages are significantly different from one another; p≤ .05Percentages are significantly different from one another; p≤ .05.

Story, Neumark-Stzainer, Story, Neumark-Stzainer, Sherwood, et al., 2002Sherwood, et al., 2002 1

Page 2: Barriers to Care

Current Recommendations & Guidelines

Expert Committee Recommendations - 2007 An Implementation GuideChildhood Obesity Action

Network, NICHQ, 2007

Expert CommitteeRecommendations, (AMA, HRSA, and CDC) June 2005

PediatricMetabolic Syndrome Working GroupRecommendations, 2008

2

Page 3: Barriers to Care

NASBHC CQI Tool Sentinel ConditionsNASBHC CQI Tool Sentinel Conditions

Elementary School-Aged Middle School-Aged High School-Aged

Risk assessment and physical exam

Risk assessment and physical exam

Risk assessment and physical exam

Asthma Asthma Asthma

Risk for type 2 diabetes Risk for type 2 diabetes Risk for type 2 diabetes

Poor school performance Poor school performance Poor school performance

Depression Depression Depression

Psychological trauma Psychological trauma Psychological trauma

Oral health Oral health Oral health

Tobacco use Tobacco use

Substance use Substance use

Chlamydia screening Chlamydia screening

Immunizations

Page 4: Barriers to Care
Page 5: Barriers to Care

Prevention and Treatment

AMA Expert Panel RecommendationsAMA Expert Panel Recommendations

BMI 85-95%BMI 85-95%

BMI ≥ 95%BMI ≥ 95%

AssessmentAssessment

AssessmentAssessment

PreventionPrevention

Stage 1Stage 1

Stage 2Stage 2

Stage 3Stage 3

StageStage 4

5

Page 7: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Assess all children for obesity at all well care visits 2-18

• Physician and allied health professional should perform at a minimum a yearly assessment

Page 8: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Use Body Mass Index (BMI) to screen for obesity

• Accurately measure height and weight

• Calculate BMI• Plot BMI on BMI

growth chart

**Skinfold thickness, and waist circumference Skinfold thickness, and waist circumference are not recommenededare not recommeneded

Page 9: Barriers to Care

Measurement of GrowthBody Mass Index (BMI)

Surrogate measure of body fat • Correlates well with specific measures of

adiposity• BMI = Weight in Kilograms (Height in Meters)2

• Chart BMI percentile

http://www.cdc.gov/growthchartshttp://www.cdc.gov/growthcharts/

9

Page 10: Barriers to Care

http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/dnpabmi/Calculator.aspx

10

Page 11: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Action Steps and RecommendationsRecommendations

• Make a weight category diagnosis using a BMI percentile

BMI 95% - Obese BMI 85-94% - OverweightBMI 5-84% - Normal weightBMI < 5% - Underweight

Page 12: Barriers to Care

Early Identification of ObesityEarly Identification of Obesity

• BP BP >> 3 yrs-chart % for age, sex, ht 3 yrs-chart % for age, sex, ht

• Determine BMI and BP risk statusDetermine BMI and BP risk status

• Chart & discuss findings with parentsChart & discuss findings with parents

• AR = point of maximal leanness or minimal BMIAR = point of maximal leanness or minimal BMI

• Number of adipose cells established around ARNumber of adipose cells established around AR

• AR usually age 5-6AR usually age 5-6

• The earlier AR occurs, the greater the risk of adult obesityThe earlier AR occurs, the greater the risk of adult obesity

Skinner et al (2004). Int Jnl Obes Relat Met Disor 28(4):476-82 Whitaker RC et al. (1998). Pediatrics ,101(3) e5Wisemandle W et al (2000). Pediatrics,106(1) e1-8

12

Page 13: Barriers to Care

“Adiposity” Rebound

Boys: 2 to 20 Years

Boys: 2 to 20 yearsBoys: 2 to 20 years

BMI BMI

BMIBMI

13

Page 14: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Measure Blood Pressure Annually– Use a cuff large enough

to cover 80% of the arm

– Diagnose hypertension using NHLBI tables http://www.nhlbi.nih.gohttp://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/prof/heart/hbpv/health/prof/heart/hbp/hbp_ped.htm/hbp_ped.htm

14

Page 15: Barriers to Care

Recommended Dimensions for BP Cuff Bladders

Small cuffs may overestimate BP

Large cuffs may underestimate BP

15

Page 16: Barriers to Care

Hypertension: How to Screen

• Ideal conditions– Manual measurement with cuff and stethoscope – Child is resting for 5 mins– Right antecubital fossa at heart level– Properly fitting cuff– Child is not on sympathomimetic medications

• Can bill as “elevated BP” (796.2) until dx of HTN is established

The fourth report on the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of high blood The fourth report on the diagnosis, evaluation, and treatment of high blood pressure in children and adolescents. pressure in children and adolescents. Pediatrics 2004; Pediatrics 2004; 114(2): 555-576114(2): 555-576

16

Page 17: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Take a Focused Family History– Using a clinical

documentation tool

Obesity Type 2 diabetes Cardiovascular disease

(hypertension, cholesterol Early deaths from heart

disease or stroke

Page 18: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Take a focused review of systems– Using a clinical documentation tool

• Assess behaviors and attitudes– (attitudes, diet an physical activity behaviors)– Using behavioral risk assessment

• Perform a thorough physical examination– Using a clinical documentation tool

Page 19: Barriers to Care

Symptoms of Conditions Associated with ObesitySymptoms of Conditions Associated with Obesity Anxiety, school avoidance, social isolation ( Depression) Polyuria, polydipsia, weight loss (Type 2 diabetes mellitus) Headaches (Pseudotumor cerebri) Night breathing difficulties (Sleep apnea, hypoventilation syndrome, asthma) Daytime sleepiness (Sleep apnea, hypoventilation syndrome, depression) Abdominal pain (Gastroesophageal reflux, Gall bladder disease, Constipation) Hip or knee pain (Slipped capital femoral epiphysis) Oligomenorrhea or amenorrhea (Polycystic ovary syndrome)

Page 20: Barriers to Care

Signs of Conditions Associated with ObesitySigns of Conditions Associated with Obesity

Poor linear growth (Hypothyroidism, Cushing’s, Prader- Willi syndrome) Dysmorphic features (Genetic disorders, including Prader–Willi syndrome) Acanthosis nigricans (NIDDM, insulin resistance) Hirsutism and Excessive Acne (Polycystic ovary syndrome) Violaceous striae (Cushing’s syndrome) Papilledema, cranial nerve VI paralysis (Pseudotumor-cerebri) Tonsillar hypertrophy (Sleep apnea) Abdominal tenderness (Gall bladder disease, GERD, NAFLD) Hepatomegaly (Nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD)) Undescended testicle (Prader-Willi syndrome) Limited hip range of motion (Slipped capital femoral epiphysis) Lower leg bowing (Blount’s disease)

Page 21: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations• Order the appropriate laboratory tests

– BMI 85-94% without risk factors• Fasting Lipid Profile

– BMI ≥ 85 - 94% age 10 or older with risk factors • Fasting Lipid Profile• ALT and AST• Fasting Glucose

– BMI ≥ 95% age 10 and older• Fasting Lipid profile • Fasting Glucose• Other tests as indicated by

health risks 21

Page 22: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Give consistent evidence-based messages for all children regardless of weight5 fruits and vegetables3 structured meals a day2 hours or less of TV per day1 hour or more of physical activity0 servings of sweetened beverages

Page 23: Barriers to Care

http://www.eatsmartmovemorenc.com/programs_tools/http://www.eatsmartmovemorenc.com/programs_tools/PediatricObesityTools.htmlPediatricObesityTools.html

23

Page 24: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

UseUse• Empathize/ElicitEmpathize/Elicit

ReflectWhat is your

understanding?What do you want to

know?How ready are you to

make a change on a (1-10 scale)

• ProvideProvideAdvice or informationChoices or options

• ElicitElicitWhat do you make of

that ?Where does that leave

you?

Page 25: Barriers to Care

ResourcesResources

25

Page 26: Barriers to Care

Other Resources…

• NICHQ Implementation Guidehttp://www.letsgo.org/For_You/documents/http://www.letsgo.org/For_You/documents/NICHQImplementationGuide.pdfNICHQImplementationGuide.pdf

• Expert Committee Recommendations Regarding the Prevention, Assessment, and Treatment of Child and Adolescent Overweight and Obesity: Summary Report http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/120/Suphttp://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/120/Supplement_4/S164 plement_4/S164

• Eat Smart, Move More – www.eatsmartmovemorenc.com www.eatsmartmovemorenc.com

Page 27: Barriers to Care

Other Resources…

• NASBHC CQI Tool – http://www.nasbhc.org/site/c.jsJPKWPFJrH/b.271935http://www.nasbhc.org/site/c.jsJPKWPFJrH/b.2719357/k.6312/EQ_Quality_Improvement.htm7/k.6312/EQ_Quality_Improvement.htm

• CDC BMI Calculator for Children & Teens http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/dnpabmi/ http://apps.nccd.cdc.gov/dnpabmi/

• NICHQ Website http://www.nichq.org/NICHQ/Programs/Conferenceshttp://www.nichq.org/NICHQ/Programs/ConferencesAndTraining/ChildhoodObesityActionNetwork.htmAndTraining/ChildhoodObesityActionNetwork.htm

Page 28: Barriers to Care

Step Two: Prevention Plus Visit (Treatment)

28

Page 29: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations• Stage 1 – Prevention PlusStage 1 – Prevention Plus

– Family visits with physician or health professional trained in pediatric weight management /behavioral counseling

– Can be individual or group visits– Frequency – individualized to family neds and risk

factors, consider monthly

Page 30: Barriers to Care

Stage 1- Prevention Plus

Behavioral GoalsBehavioral Goals• ≥ 5 servings of fruits and vegetables

per day• ≤ 2hrs of television per day• no television in bedroom• ↓ sugar sweetened beverages• Portion control• Daily breakfast• ↓ eating out• Family meals• ≥ 60 minutes of physical activity per

day

Weight GoalsWeight Goals• Weight maintenance or a decrease in

BMI velocity. • Long term BMI goal <85 % tile. • Some children healthy with a BMI 85-

94 tile• Visits- based upon readiness to

change & severity of condition• Advance stage based upon progress,

medical condition, risks, length of time, & readiness to change.

30

Page 31: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Use patient centered counseling - Use patient centered counseling - motivational interviewing (MI) at motivational interviewing (MI) at Prevention Plus visits Prevention Plus visits – For ambivalent families and – To improve the success of action planning

Page 32: Barriers to Care

Action Steps and Recommendations

• Develop a reimbursement strategy for Develop a reimbursement strategy for Prevention Plus visits Prevention Plus visits – Coding strategies can helpCoding strategies can help– Advocacy through professional organization to Advocacy through professional organization to

address reimbursement policiesaddress reimbursement policies

Page 33: Barriers to Care

BREAK

Page 34: Barriers to Care

Motivational InterviewingMotivational Interviewing

Creating a Working Partnership Creating a Working Partnership Using Motivational InterviewingUsing Motivational Interviewing

34

Page 35: Barriers to Care

Traditional Counseling Traditional Counseling Behavioral Counseling Behavioral Counseling

Motivational Interviewing Motivational Interviewing Problem Solving Problem Solving

Confrontational and Confrontational and ArgumentativeArgumentative

↓↓

Resistance Resistance

Denial of Need to Change Denial of Need to Change BehaviorBehavior

Miller, WR, Benefield, RG, Tonigan JS, 1993, J Miller, WR, Benefield, RG, Tonigan JS, 1993, J Consult Clin Psychol 61, 455-61.Consult Clin Psychol 61, 455-61.

Identify BarriersIdentify BarriersPatient Generated SolutionsPatient Generated Solutions

Select Solution to TestSelect Solution to TestEvaluate SolutionEvaluate Solution

Page 36: Barriers to Care

Transtheoretical Model: Stages of Change

Prochaska and DiClemente, 1983Prochaska and DiClemente, 1983

Precontemplation Contemplation

Preparation

ActionMaintenance

Relapse

36

Page 37: Barriers to Care

Basic PrinciplesBasic Principles

• Express empathy• Avoid argumentation• Support self-efficacy• Roll with resistance• Develop discrepancy

37

Page 38: Barriers to Care

Components of MIComponents of MI

• Establishing a relationship

• Data gathering

• Setting a collaborative agenda

• Exploring ambivalence

• Assess individual change potential

• Summary and next steps38

Page 39: Barriers to Care

Components of Motivational Components of Motivational InterviewingInterviewing

• Establishing a relationship

39

Page 40: Barriers to Care

Components of Motivational Components of Motivational InterviewingInterviewing

• Data gathering Family history Patient history Physical assessment

The part we areThe part we are most practiced at!most practiced at!

40

Page 41: Barriers to Care

Components of Motivational Components of Motivational InterviewingInterviewing

• Setting a collaborative agenda– Showing the data (i.e., family data)

– Asking them “what they make of this”

– Options tool to assist with agenda setting

– Reflective summarizing

41