Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

8
Bulletin ofthe World Health Organization, 61 (3): 517-524 (1983) © World Health Organization 1983 Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates from hospital patients in Cairo, 1977-78* N. GUIRGUIS,l K. HAFEZ,1 M. A. EL KHOLY,2 J. B. ROBBINS,3 & E. C. GOTSCHLICH4 Bacterial meningitis remains a major cause of mortality and morbidity in many countries of the world despite effective antimicrobial therapy. Studies of the etiology and some laboratory characteristics of bacterial meningitis in Egypt were conducted during 1977-1978. Allpatients suspected of having bacterial meningitis were studied at the time of admission to the two fever hospitals of Cairo. Direct culture, serological identification of the capsular type, and countercurrent-immunoelectrophoresis of 1627 CSFspecimens were done. Of these, 276 had bacteria identified either by culture or Gram stain. Pneumococci were the most common and the serotype distribution was similar to that reported from other parts of Africa; second were meningococci with groups C and B predominating; in third place was Haemophilus influenzae type b which caused the highest mortality and had an unusually young age distribution. There were 77 bacterial isolates (22%o), including 11 species, designated as "other" because there was no predominant species. There were many "clear" CSFspecimens that werefound to contain pneumococci, meningococci or H. influ- enzae type b, confirming the needfor more comprehensive laboratory facilities for accurate diagnosis of the etiology of bacterial meningitis. A revival of interest in the study of encapsulated bacterial diseases, especially meningitis caused by these organisms, is due to (1) the occurrence of several severe epidemics of meningococcal menin- gitis, even after the use of antibiotics, in the "menin- gitis belt" of central Africa, in Brazil, Finland and Norway (1-5); (2) the unacceptable level of mortality and morbidity for bacterial meningitis despite effec- tive antibiotic therapy (6, 7); (3) increasing antibiotic resistance among isolates of meningococci, pneumo- cocci, and Haemophilus influenzae type b from patients (1, 8, 9); and (4) the possibility of more effec- tive control of diseases caused by encapsulated bacteria as a result of the recent development of licensed and experimental vaccines for prevention of infections due to meningococcal groups A, B, C, Y, and W135, fourteen of the most common pneumo- coccal capsular types, H. influenzae type b, and group B streptococci (10). * From the Biomedical Research Center for Infectious Diseases (BRCID), P.O. Box 424, Cairo, Egypt. ' Research microbiologist, Rheumatic Fever Project, BRCID, Cairo, Egypt. 2 Director, Rheumatic Fever Project, BRCID, Cairo, Egypt. 3 Director, Division of Bacterial Products, Office of Biologics, Food and Drug Administration, United States Department of Health and Human Services, 8800 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20205, USA. Requests for reprints should be addressed to this author. 4 Professor and Physician, the Rockefeller University, New York, NY 10021, USA. Studies of bacterial meningitis in Egypt and ad- jacent countries have been largely confined to infec- tions caused by meningococci and Mycobacterium tuberculosis (11-13). Little attention has been directed towards bacterial meningitis caused by other encapsulated bacteria such as H. influenzae type b and pneumococci. In 1975, a laboratory was established in Cairo, under the auspices of the US National Institutes of Health and the Food and Drug Administration, to study in greater detail the epidemiology, antigenic and antibiotic sensitivity characteristics, and immu- nity status of disease caused by H. influenzae and the other common causes of acute bacterial meningitis in Egypt. MATERIALS AND METHODS Laboratory The Biomedical Research Center for Infectious Diseases (BRCID) is located in Cairo and assists the Ministry of Health with research programmes in public health problems. Patients Individuals seeking medical care for suspected meningitis or for fever-accompanied diseases from 4308 -517-

Transcript of Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

Page 1: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

Bulletin ofthe World Health Organization, 61 (3): 517-524 (1983) © World Health Organization 1983

Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolatesfrom hospital patients in Cairo, 1977-78*

N. GUIRGUIS,l K. HAFEZ,1 M. A. EL KHOLY,2 J. B. ROBBINS,3 & E. C. GOTSCHLICH4

Bacterial meningitis remains a major cause of mortality and morbidity in manycountries of the world despite effective antimicrobial therapy. Studies of the etiology andsome laboratory characteristics of bacterial meningitis in Egypt were conducted during1977-1978. Allpatients suspected ofhaving bacterial meningitis were studied at the time ofadmission to the two fever hospitals of Cairo. Direct culture, serological identification ofthe capsular type, and countercurrent-immunoelectrophoresis of1627 CSFspecimens weredone. Of these, 276 had bacteria identified either by culture or Gram stain. Pneumococciwere the most common and the serotype distribution was similar to that reported fromother parts ofAfrica; second were meningococci with groups C and B predominating; inthirdplace was Haemophilus influenzae type b which caused the highest mortality and hadan unusually young age distribution. There were 77 bacterial isolates (22%o), including 11species, designated as "other" because there was nopredominant species. There were many"clear" CSFspecimens that werefound to contain pneumococci, meningococci or H. influ-enzae type b, confirming the needfor more comprehensive laboratoryfacilitiesfor accuratediagnosis of the etiology of bacterial meningitis.

A revival of interest in the study of encapsulatedbacterial diseases, especially meningitis caused bythese organisms, is due to (1) the occurrence ofseveral severe epidemics of meningococcal menin-gitis, even after the use of antibiotics, in the "menin-gitis belt" of central Africa, in Brazil, Finland andNorway (1-5); (2) the unacceptable level of mortalityand morbidity for bacterial meningitis despite effec-tive antibiotic therapy (6, 7); (3) increasing antibioticresistance among isolates of meningococci, pneumo-cocci, and Haemophilus influenzae type b frompatients (1, 8, 9); and (4) the possibility of more effec-tive control of diseases caused by encapsulatedbacteria as a result of the recent development oflicensed and experimental vaccines for prevention ofinfections due to meningococcal groups A, B, C, Y,and W135, fourteen of the most common pneumo-coccal capsular types, H. influenzae type b, and groupB streptococci (10).

* From the Biomedical Research Center for Infectious Diseases(BRCID), P.O. Box 424, Cairo, Egypt.

' Research microbiologist, Rheumatic Fever Project, BRCID,Cairo, Egypt.

2 Director, Rheumatic Fever Project, BRCID, Cairo, Egypt.3 Director, Division of Bacterial Products, Office of Biologics,

Food and Drug Administration, United States Department of Healthand Human Services, 8800 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, MD 20205,USA. Requests for reprints should be addressed to this author.

4 Professor and Physician, the Rockefeller University, NewYork, NY 10021, USA.

Studies of bacterial meningitis in Egypt and ad-jacent countries have been largely confined to infec-tions caused by meningococci and Mycobacteriumtuberculosis (11-13). Little attention has beendirected towards bacterial meningitis caused by otherencapsulated bacteria such as H. influenzae type band pneumococci.

In 1975, a laboratory was established in Cairo,under the auspices of the US National Institutes ofHealth and the Food and Drug Administration, tostudy in greater detail the epidemiology, antigenicand antibiotic sensitivity characteristics, and immu-nity status of disease caused by H. influenzae and theother common causes of acute bacterial meningitis inEgypt.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Laboratory

The Biomedical Research Center for InfectiousDiseases (BRCID) is located in Cairo and assists theMinistry of Health with research programmes inpublic health problems.

Patients

Individuals seeking medical care for suspectedmeningitis or for fever-accompanied diseases from

4308 -517-

Page 2: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

N. GUIRGUIS ET AL.

the Cairo region and Giza (population 10.2 million)go directly, or are referred by health care authorities,to the Abassia and Imbaba Communicable DiseaseHospitals (14). All patients suspected or diagnosed ashaving meningitis in the Greater Cairo area arecompelled to be referred to these two hospitals. Thepatients were examined by the hospital physicians andblood and/or CSF specimens were taken according totheir judgement.

CSF specimens

The cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) specimens weredivided and an aliquot sent to the BRCID chemistrylaboratory for determination of their cellular content,protein and glucose. The other aliquot was placedinto a sterile container and stored at 37 °C untilpicked up by BRCID personnel. The specimens werecollected within a few hours of the lumbar puncture.When received at the BRCID, an aliquot wasdelivered for primary culture on sheep blood, Muller-Hinton and Levinthal agars at 37 °C in a 5% C02moist chamber, and an aliquot was centrifuged at4 °C for 15 min. The resultant sediment was stainedby Gram's method and the supernatant was studiedby countercurrent-immunoelectrophoresis (CIE) forpneumococcal, meningococcal and H.influenzaetype b capsular polysaccharide antigens as described(14, 15).

Identification of the bacterial isolates

Bacterial colonies from their primary culture werereviewed. They were transferred to specific mediabased upon their colonial morphology and analysedfor their haemolytic property, bile-solubility, andoptochin sensitivity for pneumococci. Pneumococcalserotyping utilized the Quellung reaction with rabbittyping antisera from the WHO Pneumococcal Refer-ence Laboratory, Statens Seruminstitut, Copenhagen(17). For meningococci, the colonies were cultivatedon Mueller-Hinton media at 37 °C in a 50/o CO2environment. Catalase, peroxidase reactions, anddextrose, maltose, lactose and sucrose fermentationassays were used to confirm their identity as meningo-cocci. Meningococci were serogrouped by both slideagglutination and halo formation on meningococcalgroup A, B, C, W135, Y and 29E antiserum agar(17-19). All H. influenzae disease isolates yieldprecipitin haloes using burro type b antiserum-agar(18, 20, 21). The other bacterial isolates wereidentified according to common bacteriologicalprocedures.

Countercurrent-immunoelectrophoresis (CIE)CIE was performed with 10 Al CSF samples using

1 0/o Special Noble Agar (Difco, Detroit, MI) in

0.05 mol/l veronal-acetate buffer, pH 8.6, 1 V/cm(15). The electrophoresis was conducted at roomtemperature for 2 h and the glass slides equilibratedat refrigerator temperature before being visuallyinspected. Then, the slides were soaked in 0.15mmol/l NaCl at refrigerator temperature for 3 days,rinsed in distilled water, air dried, and stained withCoomassie brilliant blue. CSF specimens were runinitially against Omniserum (20) for pneumococci,meningococci groups A, B, C, Y, 29E and W135, andH. influenzae type b antisera. In cases with sufficientCSF, samples from patients whose pneumococcalisolate had been typed, were run again with thespecific typing antiserum that had yielded a positiveQuellung reaction.

Antisera

Pneumococcal typing sera were obtained from theWHO Pneumococcal Laboratory, Statens Serum-institut, Copenhagen, Denmark. Meningococcal andH. influenzae typing antisera were prepared in horsesand burros according to published methods (21).

RESULTS

CSF specimens

During the two study years 1977 and 1978(excluding the month of August), 1627 CSF speci-mens were collected for investigation. Turbidity,defined as more than 1000 polymorphonuclearneutrophil leukocytes per cu. mm., was observed in589 specimens. From these specimens, presumed to becharacteristic of bacterial meningitis, 276 (47/o) hadbacteria identified by direct culture, Gram stainand/or CIE. Of these 276 specimens, 236 (85.5%)were identified as pneumococci, meningococci orH.influenzae type b and 40 (14.5O/o) as "other".Similarly, a bacterial agent was found in 74 Qf the"clear" CSF specimens (7.1 %), of which 29 (39.1 bo)were meningococci, 8 (10%) were pneumococci, andthe remaining 37 were classified as "other".Pneumococci were the most common bacteria

detected (in 142 CSF specimens) and comprised40.6% of all the bacterial isolates and 8.7Go of all CSFspecimens. Next most common were the meningo-cocci (in 89 specimens), comprising 25.4%o of all theCSF bacteria and 5.5% of the CSF specimens.H. influenzae type b (in 42 specimens) comprised12.Oo of the CSF bacterial isolates and 2.6% of allthe CSF specimens. There were 77 bacterial isolates(22.0%o), including 11 species, designated as "other"because there was no predominant species. The abovefindings are summarized in Table 1.

518

Page 3: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

BACTERIAL MENINGITIS IN EGYPT

Table 1. Analysis of cerebrospinal fluid isolates from patients at the Abassia and Imbaba Communicable DiseaseHospitals, 1977-1978

TotalTurbid a Clear

No. %

No. of CSF specimens studied 589 1038 1627 100.0

No. positive for bacteria 276 74 350 21.0 (100%)bPneumococci 134 8 142 8.7 (40.6%)Meningococci 60 29 89 5.5 (25.4%)H. influenzae type b 42 0 42 2.6 (12.0%)"Other" bacteria 40 37 77 4.7 (22.0%)

a Turbidity is defined as more than 1000 polymorphonuclear neutrophil leukocytes per cu. mm.b Percentage of total bacterial isolates.

Seasonal distribution gitides. Turbid CSF, without demonstrable bacteria,

Table 2 shows that the summer months of July and showed a peak incidence in March and May, whereashad the lowest number of bacterial menin- clear CSF without bacteria showed a high incidenceSeptemberhateoetubrratramnn from February till July. These findings ar

gitis cases. The peak months for pneumococci wereJanuary to May, for meningococci from November summarized in Table 2.till April, and for H. influenzae type b in Decemberand January. The number of cases, divided on amonthly basis, are too few for statistical evaluation.However, a more even distribution throughout the The age and sex distribution of patients withyear was observed with the "other" bacterial menin- bacterial meningitis is shown in Table 3. It can be seen

Table 2. Average number of bacterial meningitis cases by month from the Abassia and Imbaba CommunicableDisease Hospitals, 1977-1978a

Turbid CSF Clear CSFH. influenzae "Other" without without

Month Pneumococci Meningococci type b bacteria bacteria bacteria

January 1 1 6 5 4 19 49

February 7 6 1 3 16 69March 16 5 3 4 26 66

April 10 5 3 4 15 46.May 8 1 2 6 25 64

June 3 4 3 5 11 71

July 5 1 2 1 10 65August b

September 6 3 0 3 3 26October 5 2 1 8 15 38November 6 11 2 5 8 39December 5 6 4 1 11 32

Total 82 50 26 44 159 585

a The number of cases of bacterial meningitis under each category diagnosed at the Abassia and Imbaba Hospitals during the two-year period, 1977-1978, were averaged for each month. The total number of CSF with bacteria was 202 during this study period.

b No cases were diagnosed during August when the Biomedical Research Center for Infectious Diseases was closed.

519

Page 4: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

N. GUIRGUIS ET AL.

Table 3. Age distribution of bacterial meningitis cases according to etiology, Abassia and Imbaba CommunicableDisease Hospitals, 1977-1978

H. influenzae "Other"Age of Pneumococci Meningococci type b bacteria Totalpatient(years) No. % No. % No. % No. % No. %

0-1 35 25 16 18 35 83 13 17 99 281-4 25 18 18 20 7 17 18 23 68 19

5-9 17 12 16 18 0 15 20 48 14

10-14 26 18 9 10 0 9 12 44 13

15-34 28 20 19 21 14 18 61 17

>35 11 8 11 12 0 0 8 10 30 9

Total 142 89 42 77 350

that the attack rate, considering the total population,was highest in the infants (0-1 year) for all threemajor causes of bacterial meningitis. For pneumo-coccus, there was also an increased number of cases inthe 10-34-year age group. Infants and children com-prised most of the meningococcal meningitis patients.In contrast, most of the H. influenzae type b caseswere in infants, with 83% (35 cases) occurring in thoseunder 1 year old, 6 cases aged 1-2 years, and 1 case ina 4 year old. With the exception of meningococcalmeningitis cases in the 10-14-year age group, therewere more male (200) than female (150) cases. Theoverall mortality (fatality rate) of pneumococcalmeningitis patients was 44.4% with the highest ratesin those under 1 year old (60.0%) and over the age of35 years (72.7%) (Table 4). The lowest overall

mortality was observed in meningococcal meningitiscases (21.3%), the 5-14-year age group being the leastaffected (8.0%). The highest overall mortality in thebacterial meningitis cases in this study was due toH. influenzae type b (57%), the fatality rate being thesame for the under-I-year age group and for the 7cases aged 1-4 years.

Pneumococcal meningitis

Initially, inexperience in the storage of pneumo-cocci and unavailability of all serotyping sera fromthe Statens Seruminstitut resulted in our inability todefine the capsular types of the first pneumococcalisolates. There were 43 specimens in which the Gramstain revealed Gram-positive lancet-shaped diplo-

Table 4. Bacterial meningitis fatality rates (F.R.) related to etiology and age of patients at the Abassia and ImbabaCommunicable Disease Hospitals, 1977-1978

Bacterial etiologyAge of Overallpatient Pneumococci Meningococci H. influenzae "Other" fatality(years) type b bacteria rate (%)

No.of F.R. No. of F.R. No. of F.R. No. of F.R.patients (%) patients (%) patients (%) patients (%)

(No. dead) (No. dead) (No. dead) (No. dead)

0-1 35 (21) 60 16 (3) 1 9 35 (20) 57 13 (9) 69 54

1-4 25 (12) 48 18 (6) 33 7 (4) 57 18 (7) 39 435-14 43 (13) 30 25 (2) 8 0 (0) 0 24 (0) 0 1 615-34 28 (9) 32 19 (5) 26 0 (0) 0 14 (0) 0 23)35 1 1 (8) 73 1 1 (3) 27 0 (0) 0 8 (3) 38 47

Total 142 (63) 44 89 (19) 21 42 (24) 57 77 (19) 25 36

520

Page 5: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

BACTERIAL MENINGITIS IN EGYPT

cocci in CSF specimens that did not yield a positiveculture. Among the total of 142 CSF isolatesconsidered as pneumococci, the capsular type wasestablished by the Quellung reaction in 99 (Table 5).Two strains yielded a definite reaction with more thanone typing antisera (see Table 5). Type 1 was the mostfrequent capsular type observed (34 out of 99, or34%), and there were two or more isolates of types 2,4, 6, 7, 9, 10, 12, 14, 18, 19, 20, 34, 36, 45 and 46. Ofthe 99 strains in this survey, 69 (70%) were rep-

resented by the current USA-licensed 14-valentpneumococcal vaccine. There were no special fea-tures in the distribution of capsular types among theage groups.

Meningococcal meningitis

Table 6 shows that group C was the predominantserogroup (20 cases) followed by group B (15 cases).Group A (3 isolates) and groups 29E and W135 (one

Table 5. Age distribution and serotypes of pneumococci isolated from CSF of patients with bacterial meningitis,Abassia and Imbaba Communicable Disease Hospitals, 1977-1978

Capsular Ages of patients (years)typea < 1 1-4 5-9 10-14 15-34 >35 Total

23

4

5

67

8

9

1011

12

14

15181920

2324

29

33

34

35

36

38

3945

46

(29, 42)b(29, 35, 42) b

32

8 7 6 7

2

2

1 22

3 343

3

53

64

4

2

3

34

2

2

2 4

32

Total 24 16 12 20 17 10 99

a Italicized capsular types indicate those components in the current US licensed vaccine.b Quellung reactions were observed with several typing antisera.

521

l

1

11

1

1

1

11

1

1 1

Page 6: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

N. GUIRGUIS ET AL.

Table 6. Serogroups and CSF turbidity of meningo-coccal meningitis cases, Abassia and Imbaba Communi-cable Disease Hospitals, 1977-1978

No. of casesMeningococcal Totalserogroups CSF turbid' CSF clear

A 3 0 3

B 15 3 18C 20 16 36Other groupsb 5 6 11

Undetermined' 1 7 4 21

Total 60 29 89

° Defined as having more than 1000 polymorphonuclearneutrophil leukocytes per cu. mm.

b Other groups included one each of 29E and Wi 35; three iso-lates could not be serogrouped.

' These organisms were identified as meningococci by theGram-stain method only.

of each) were also observed. Of interest was the find-ing of "clear" CSF (less than 1000 polymorpho-nuclear neutrophil leukocytes per cu. mm.) in 16 ofthe 36 CSF specimens with demonstrable group Corganisms and/or positive CIE. There were also"clear" CSF specimens noted with group B and otherminor serogroups.

H. influenzae type b meningitisAll H. influenzae isolates yielded a specific pre-

cipitin halo with type b antisera upon initial isolation.There was one case in which the diagnosis was estab-lished by CIE only. H. influenzae type b meningitiswas characteristically distributed among the veryyoung, had a high mortality rate (57%) (Table 4), andwas relatively infrequent among the major CSFbacterial isolates (Table 1).

DISCUSSION

At the time of the study, the estimate of the totalnumber of cases of bacterial meningitis was limited byour incomplete knowledge of the etiology of un-explained deaths in the Abassia and Imbaba hospitalsand by the probability that many patients were treatedoutside with antibiotics and were not brought to thesehospitals for diagnosis. Another factor that may haveinfluenced the results of this study is that the BRIDlaboratories were not located in the grounds of thesetwo hospitals; in the absence of independent diag-nostic facilities in both hospitals, no surveillance was

carried out in August when the BRID was closed forvacation.A considerable number of CSF isolates were turbid

and had a cellular and chemical profile suggesting abacterial infection. Yet, with the available techniqueswe could not establish an etiological diagnosis. Ourbest explanation for this observation is based uponthe knowledge about the widespread use of chloram-phenicol and ampicillin; it is likely that many of ourpatients had received these or other antibiotics beforethe CSF was obtained. Similar findings of manyunexplained turbid CSF specimens without a demon-strable bacterial etiology have been reported (22, 23).We plan to increase the sensitivity of our CIE tech-nique to include sulfonated boric acid buffers forneutral pneumococcal capsular polysaccharides, ana-lysis of serum and urine for the capsular antigens, andserological techniques to assay recent or active infec-tions (14, 24). Another approach under considerationis the use of gas-liquid chromatography to identifyspecific compounds elaborated by the bacterial path-ogens (25, 26).An estimate of the population involved in this study

may be derived from published demographic reports(14). During the study years, the population of Cairoand surrounding communities was estimated to beabout ten million. Based upon the number of bac-terial meningitis cases in our survey, the numberof cases due to pneumococci, meningococci andH. influenzae type b may be estimated to be at least1.5 per 100 000 population. This number must beconsidered as a minimal estimate owing to the factorscited above.

There were some surprising findings in our study.First, the high mortality of all cases of bacterialmeningitis, especially that induced by pneumococci,was unexpected. The high morbidity of pneumo-coccal meningitis, which is about 50%o in Nigeria and15-2507o in the USA and Europe, has been reviewed(6, 7). These findings indicate that more effectivecontrol of bacterial meningitis should be sought andsuggests that immunoprophylaxis with our currentvaccines should be considered. Second, pneumo-coccal capsular types among the disease isolates hadsome unusual characteristics and similarities to pre-vious studies. The predominance of types 6, 14, 18, 19and 23 among young patients, as reported from othercountries, was not observed (26-28). The detection oftypes 45 and 46 in Egypt is important as these capsularpolysaccharides have only been identified in diseaseisolates in southern and central Africa and NewGuinea (26-29). This indicates that additional types,perhaps with a geographically specific formulation,to supplement the primary 14-valent vaccine, mayhave to be devised in order to account for thisdifference between these African and Asian areas andthe USA and Europe.

522

Page 7: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

BACTERIAL MENINGITIS IN EGYPT

The high mortality of meningococcal meningitiscases described here, compared to previous analysesfrom areas with endemic and epidemic disease, wasunexpected. As there was no unusual pattern in theserogroups and age and sex distribution among themeningococcal disease isolates, as compared withdata from other countries with endemic disease,further studies are planned to identify those factorsthat might be responsible for the high mortality.Another unusual feature in our meningococcalmeningitis cases was the high proportion with a"clear" CSF. Of the 89 meningococcal cases, 29 hadclear CSF; this was highest in the 0-1-year age groupwith 8 out of 16 (500o) showing clear CSF. Most ofthese cases with clear CSF were due to group Cmeningococci.An unexpected finding was the comparatively low

frequency, high mortality, and young age distributionof patients with H. influenzae type b meningitis, in

contrast to that observed in other parts of the world(31-33). We have presumed that the unusually highmortality connected with this disease was primarilyrelated to the young age of the patients; thus, therewere 20 deaths among the 35 patients less than 1 yearold (57%) and 4 deaths from 7 patients aged 1-5 years(57%). Existing H. influenzae type b capsularpolysaccharide vaccines do not confer protection inchildren under the age of 18 months (33, 34).Accordingly, control measures for this disease cannotyet be based on immunoprophylaxis. In anotherpaper we hope to show that the carrier rate ofH. influ-enzae type b is higher in Egypt than in other countriesaccording to their reports. This finding could accountfor the lower age distribution and higher death rate ofH. influenzae type b meningitis cases in Egypt. Thereasons for this high carrier rate and its possiblerelation to the young age of the patients and theacquisition of immunity will also be discussed.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Mr Abdel Razik and Mr M. Hassouna provided expert technical assistance in culturing, serotyping and storing the diseaseisolates and in preparing the serological reagents for this study.The work described here was supported by the US Public Law 480 Program, Agreement Number 03-034-N.

RISUMt

LA MtNINGITE BACTtRIENNE EN EGYPTE:ANALYSE D'ISOLATS DE LCR VENANT DE MALADES HOSPITALIStS AU CAIRE, 1977-1978

Des chercheurs en Egypte se sont penches sur le problemede la meningite bacterienne qui, malgre une chimiotherapieantimicrobienne efficace, continue A faire des victimes.Meningocoques, pneumocoques et H. influenzae type bmanifestent une resistance de plus en plus grande A l'6garddes antibiotiques, ce qui complique evidemment l'institu-tion d'un traitement adequat. La mise au point de vaccinsagrees ou experimentaux pour la prevention des maladiescaus6es par des bact6ries encapsulees exige que l'on disposed'informations plus precises sur l'epidemiologie, 1'etiologieet la fr6quence des affections dues A ces organismes, et de lameningite bacterienne en particulier. En 1975 un laboratoirea e ouvert au Centre de Recherche biomedicale sur lesMaladies infectieuses, au Caire, avec la collaboration dedeux institutions americaines (US Food and Drug Adminis-tration, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Dis-eases) et le soutien de l'US Public Law 480 Program. Lesetudes sur la meningite bacterienne men&es en Egypte etdans les pays voisins s'etaient jusque lA interessees surtoutaux epidemies caus&es par les meningocoques du groupe Aou Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Des prelevements de LCRvenant de 1627 patients chez qui l'on suspectait une menin-gite bacterienne ont e etudies par culture directe, colo-

ration de Gram et electrosynerese. Le typage des isolats ae fait par reaction de Quellung pour les pneumocoques etpar la technique de l'antiserum sur gelose pour les meningo-coques et H. influenzae type b. On a ainsi, dans 276 cas ou leLCR etait trouble, identifie une m6ningite d'origine bacte-rienne, due le plus souvent (40,6%) au pneumocoque. Lesserotypes des pneumocoques isoles au cours de cette etudecorrespondent A ce que l'on retrouve en d'autres pointsde l'Afrique. Les meningocoques representaient 25,4% desorganismes isoles, le groupe C venant en tete suivi par legroupe B. Les meningites A H. influenzae type b (12,0% desisolats) se caracterisent par leur distribution- elles frappentparticulierement les tres jeunes enfants-et leur mortaliteelevee (40%). Les echantillons de LCR, dont beaucoupetaient <<clairs>>, ont donne A la culture ou A l'examen serolo-gique la preuve d'une infection par les m6ningocoques (leplus souvent), les pneumocoques ou H. influenzae type b.Enfin, 77 isolats bacteriens ont e classes sous la rubrique<autres> du fait qu'ils ne comportaient pas d'espece pre-dominante; on ne trouve pas avec ces <<autres>> organismesl'habituelle distribution saisonniere ou par Age caracteris-tique des trois principaux agents de la meningite bact6-rienne.

523

Page 8: Bacterial meningitis in Egypt: analysis of CSF isolates

524 N. GUIRGUIS ET AL.

REFERENCES1. WHO Technical Report Series No. 588, 1976 (Cerebro-

spinal meningitis control: report of a WHO StudyGroup).

2. PELTOLA, H. ET AL. Vaccination against meningococcalgroup A in Finland 1974-1975. Scandinavian journal ofinfectious diseases, 8: 169-174 (1976).

3. LAPEYSSONNIE, L. La meningite c6r6bro-spinale enAfrique. Bulletin of the World Health Organization,Supplement to Vol. 28 (1963).

4. MORAIS, J. S. ET AL. Epidemic disease due to serogroupC Neisseria meningitidis in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Journalof infectious diseases, 129: 568-571 (1974).

5. BoVRE, K. ET AL. Neisseria meningitidis infections innorthern Norway: an epidemic in 1974-1975 due mainlyto group B organisms. Journal of infectious diseases,135: 669-672 (1977).

6. BAIRD, D. R. ET AL. Mortality from pneumococcalmeningitis, Lancet, I: 1344-1346 (1976).

7. CDC Surveillance Summary. Bacterial meningitis andmeningococcemia. Morbidity and mortality weeklyreport, 28: 277-278 (1979).

8. WARD, J. L. ET AL. Prevalence of ampicillin- andchloramphenicol-resistant strains of Haemophilus in-fluenzae causing meningitis and bacteremia: nationalsurvey of hospital laboratories. Journal of infectiousdiseases, 138: 421-426 (1978).

9. APPLEBAUM, P. C. ET AL. Streptococcus pneumoniaeresistant to penicillin and chloramphenicol. Lancet, fi:995-997 (1977).

10. ROBBINS, J. B. Vaccines for the prevention of encap-sulated bacterial diseases: current status and prospectsfor the future. Immunochemistry, 15: 839-854 (1978).

11. BOCTOR, W. M. Statistical analysis of bacterial menin-gitis at Embaba Fever Hospital. Journal ofthe EgyptianPublic Health Association, 44 (4): 253-259 (1969).

12. HASSAN, A. & ABDEL WAHAB, M. F. Tuberculousmeningitis in UAR. Journal of the Egyptian PublicHealth Association, 44 (4): 303-308 (1969).

13. WAHDAN, M. H. ET AL. Surveillance of meningitis inAlexandria. Journal of the Egyptian Public HealthAssociation, 47 (1 and 2): 72-93 (1973).

14. MINER, W. F. & EDMAN, D. C. Acute bacterial menin-gitis in Cairo, Arab Republic of Egypt, 1 January 1971through 31 December 1975. American journal oftropical medicine and hygiene, 27 (5): 986-994 (1978).

15. COLDING, H. & LIND, I. Countercurrent-immuno-electrophoresis in the diagnosis of bacterial meningitis.Journal of clinical microbiology, 5: 405-409 (1977).

16. SIPPEL, J. E. & GIRGIS, N. I. Meningococcal infectionin Egypt: laboratory findings in meningitis patients andthe prevalence of pharyngeal infection in patients andcontacts. American journal of tropical medicine andhygiene, 27 (5): 980-985 (1978).

17. AUSTRIAN, R. The Quellung reaction, a neglected micro-biologic technique. Mount Sinai journal of medicine,43: 699-703 (1976).

18. SIVONEN, A. 0. ET AL. Use of antiserum agar plates forserogrouping of meningococci. Journal ofclinicalpath-ology, 30: 834-838 (1977).

19. EVANS, R. ET AL. Prevalence of meningococcal sero-groups and description of three new groups. Americanjournal of epidemiology, 87: 643-651 (1968).

20. CRAVEN, D. E. ET AL. Serogroup identification of Neis-seria meningitidis: comparison of an antiserum agarmethod with bacterial slide agglutination. Journal ofclinical microbiology, 7: 410-415 (1979).

21. MICHAEL, R. H. ET AL. Use of antiserum agar for detec-tion of Haemophilus influenzae type b in the pharynx.Pediatric research, 9: 513-515 (1975).

22. LUND, E. & RASMUSSEN, P. Omni-Serum. A diagnosticpneumococcus serum reacting with the 82 known typesof pneumococcus. Acta pathologica et microbiologicaScandinavica, 68: 458-460 (1966).

23. ALEXANDER, H. E. Production of Haemophilus influ-enzae type a, b, c, d, e and f antiserum for diagnosticpurposes. Journal of immunology, 54: 207-222(1946).

24. FEIGIN, R. D. ET AL. Countercurrent-immunoelectro-phoresis of urine as well as of CSF and blood for diag-nosis of bacterial meningitis. Journal ofpediatrics, 89:773-775 (1976).

25. GASTRIN, B. & BRIEM, H. Rapid diagnosis of meningitisin selected clinical data and gas-liquid chromatographicdetermination of lactate concentration in cerebrospinalfluid. Journal of infectious diseases, 139: 529-533(1979).

26. FINLAND, M. & BARNES, M. W. Changes in occurrenceof capsular serotypes of Streptococcus pneumoniae atBoston City Hospital during selected years between1935-1974. Journal ofclinical microbiology. 5:154-166(1977).

27. DEVITT, L. & DOUGLAS, R. M. Pneumonia in NewGuinea. II. Pneumococcal serotypes and the possibleutility of polyvalent vaccines of capsular polysac-charides. Medical journal of Australia, 1: 49-52(1973).

28. BROOME, C. V. ET AL. Epidemiology of pneumococcalserotypes in the United States, 1978-1979. Journal ofinfectious diseases, 141: 119-123 (1980).

29. GREENWOOD, B. M. ET AL. Pneumococcal serotypes inWest Africa. Lancet, i: 360 (1980).

30. MADJID, S. & MADJID, A. The etiology of meningitis inchildren of Jakarta. Pediatrics Indonesia, 5 (suppl.):743-747 (1965).

31. JOHNSON, M. & ALVIN, A. A 12-year review of bacterialmeningitis in Stockholm, 1956-1967. Scandinavianjournal of infectious diseases, 3: 141-145 (1971).

32. PARKE, J. C. JR ET AL. The attack rate, racial distri-bution, age incidence and case fatality rate of Haemo-philus influenzae type b meningitis in MecklenburgCounty, N.C. Journal of pediatrics, 81: 765-769(1972).

33. PARKE, J. C. JR ET AL. Interim report of a controlledfield trial of immunization with Haemophilus influ-enzae type b and meningococcus group C capsular poly-saccharide in Mecklenburg County, N.C., March1974-March 1976. Journal of infectious diseases, 136:SS1-56 (1977).

34. PELTOLA, H. ET AL. The Haemophilus influenzae type bcapsular polysaccharide in children. A double-blindfield study of 100 000 vaccinees 3 months to 5 years ofage in Finland. Pediatrics, 60: 730-737 (1977).