Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
-
Upload
coralations -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 1/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
!"#$%&'&'( *+,%- .//0 1/,&/# +0 3"/,$+ .&4+
"#$%&' () *+&,- (,#.#/ 0) (12,3- 4%,3%/ 5) 6%+73%/- 4%,%&2% 8+$93#$
:/2.#$;2,< => ?2%12
5=;#/;,2#& (93==& => ?%$2/# %/' *,1=;@3#$29 (92#/9#
ABCC 529D#/E%9D#$ F%+;#G%<
?2%12- HI JJKAL :(*
M=$D;3=@ N#93/29%& 5#@=$,
O9,=E#$ PCKJ
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 2/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1/,&/# 5/42'&4%- 6+,7#2+8
9:/'($2;<%#/= !$+47 >##/##?/'$ +0 3"/,$+ .&4+ .//0 1/#
@ *+?8"$/,;A%#/= 5++-# :%A+,%$+,BC
*+'D/'/,#E Q$;) "#$$< *+&, %/' (,#.# (12,3- ?$ 4%,3%/ 6%+73%/- %/' ?; 4%,%&2% 8+$93#$-:/2.#$;2,< => ?2%12R; 5=;#/;,2#& (93==& => ?%$2/# %/' *,1=;@3#$29 (92#/9#)
:+4%- F+#$E Q$) F$%27 I2&<#;,$=1- S+#$,= 529= Q#@,) => 4%,+$%& %/' T/.2$=/1#/,%& 5#;=+$9#;
:+4%$&+'E GHI. 1/,&/# ./#/%,42 :%A+,%$+,BJ K+B"=%E (#@,#1E#$ AU B- PCKJ- CLCCUKBCC)
6+,7#2+8 L+%-#M; N3# 7=%&; => ,32; JU'%< ,#93/29%& G=$D;3=@; G2&& E# ,= VKW @$#;#/, $#;#%$93
$#;+&,; =/ ,3# '#.#&=@1#/, %/' %@@&29%,2=/ => &#/7,3UE%;#' %@@$=%93#; ,= ;+;,%2/%E2&2,<
%/%&<;2; => S+#$,= 529= $##> >2;3#;- %/' VPW ,= 9=/'+9, 3%/';U=/ ,$%2/2/7 2/ ,3# +;# => 9=1@+,#$
,==&; >=$ &#/7,3UE%;#' ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, %/' >=$ 1%/%7#1#/, >=$#9%;,2/7) O/ G=$D;3=@ Q%< K-
$#;#%$93 $#;+&,; G2&& E# @$#;#/,#' =/ '%,% %;;212&%,2=/- %/%&<;2;- %/' 1='#&2/7 %;@#9,; =>&#/7,3UE%;#' %;;#;;1#/,; => S+#$,= 529= $##> >2;3#;) O/ G=$D;3=@ Q%< P- % &%E=$%,=$< G2&& E#
9=/'+9,#' >=$ ,$%2/2/7 2/ ,3# +;# => ,3# ?*(N 9=1@+,#$ ,==& >=$ 9%$$<2/7 =+, &#/7,3UE%;#'
%;;#;;1#/,;) O/ G=$D;3=@ Q%< J- @%$,292@%/,; G2&& E+2&' +@ ,3# $#;+&,; ,3#< >=+/' =/ '%< P E<
E$%2/;,=$12/7 1%/%7#1#/, %9,2=/; G3293 9=+&' E# 21@#/,#' 72.#/ ,3# %;;#;;1#/, $#;+&,;)
N3#< G2&& ,3#/ $+/ ;21+&%,2=/; ,= 2/.#;,27%,# ,3# @=,#/,2%& =+,9=1#; => ,3#2$ 1%/%7#1#/, 2'#%;
+;2/7 ,3# ?*(N @&%,>=$1)
5%,(/$ >"=&/'4/M; N32; G=$D;3=@ 2; 2/,#/'#' >=$ $##> >2;3#$2#; ;92#/,2;,; %/' 1%/%7#$; >$=1
7=.#$/1#/, %/' %9%'#12%- %; G#&& %; $#@$#;#/,%,2.#; >$=1 ,3# 9=11#$92%& %/' $#9$#%,2=/%&
>2;32/7 9=11+/2,2#; %/' /=/U7=.#$/1#/,%& =$7%/2X%,2=/; 2/ S+#$,= 529=) N32; G=$D;3=@ G2&&
%99=11='%,# @%$,292@%/,; E%;#' 2/ ,3# ?%<%7+#X $#72=/;)
<%47(,+"'=M; N3# 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#; => ,3# S+#$,= 529= $##> #9=;<;,#1 ;+@@=$, 1+&,212&&2=/U
'=&&%$ >2;32/7 %/' ,=+$2;1 2/'+;,$2#;) N3# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => ,3#;# >2;3#$2#; 2; % D#< 9=/;#$.%,2=/
9=/9#$/ 72.#/ ,3#2$ #9=/=129 %/' #9=&=729%& 21@=$,%/9#- ,3# ;27/2>29%/, '#@#/'#/9# =>
;+E;2;,#/9# %/' %$,2;%/%& >2;3#$; =/ $##> >2;3#$2#; >=$ ,3#2$ &2.#&23==';- %/' ,3# 9=/;2'#$%E&# %/'
7$=G2/7 ,3$#%,; ,= 9=$%& $##> 3%E2,%,; V2)#) 9=$%& E&#%932/7 %/' '2;#%;#- @=&&+,2=/ %/' 9&21%,#
93%/7#W) (+;,%2/%E2&2,< $#>#$; ,= ,3# %E2&2,< => %/ #Y@&=2,#' ;,=9D ,= @$='+9# 7=='; %/' ;#$.29#;-
2/9&+'2/7 <2#&'; %, ;+2,%E&# &#.#&; 2/ ,3# ;3=$, ,#$1- G32&# 1%2/,%2/2/7 ;+>>292#/, ;,=9D
$#@$='+9,2.# 9%@%92,< ,= 9=/,2/+# @$=.2'2/7 ,3#;# 7=='; %/' ;#$.29#; 2/,= ,3# 2/'#>2/2,# >+,+$#)
N3# '%,%U %/' 1='#&U&212,#' ;2,+%,2=/; 9=/>$=/,2/7 1=;, 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#;- 2/9&+'2/7 ,3=;# =>
S+#$,= 529=- 3%.# 3%1@#$#' %@@&29%,2=/ => 1='#$/ ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, ,#93/2Z+#; ,3%, 1##, ,3#
%& 1%/'%,# => ,3# ?%7/+;=/U(,#.#/; H2;3#$< F=/;#$.%,2=/ %/' ?%/%7#1#/, *9,
V?(HF?*W) M# 3%.# '#.#&=@#' % 9&%;; => &#/7,3UE%;#' 1#,3='; >=$ ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, => '%,%U
&212,#' >2;3#$2#; V*+&, #, %&) PCC[W) N3#;# %@@$=%93#; 3%.# $#&%,2.#&< ;21@&# '%,% $#Z+2$#1#/,;-
@$=.2'# % 9=11+/2,<U&#.#& @#$;@#9,2.# =/ #Y@&=2,%,2=/ #>>#9,;- %/' %&;= #/%E&# #.%&+%,2=/ =>
;,=9DU;@#92>29 ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< ,3%, 9=/>=$1; ,= ,3# %& $#Z+2$#1#/,; => ,3# ?(HF?*)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 3/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5><:I N1 *NH5IH5!
ND/,D&/O @ P'$,+="4$&+' MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMQ
RMS G%$% !+",4/# @ 3,+4/##&'( MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMT
UMS :<%, I#$&?%$&+' V/$2+=+-+(B MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMUS
WMS 52/+,B +0 :/'($2;A%#/= !$+47 >##/##?/'$ MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMWS
QMS 3+8"-%$&+';GB'%?&4# G%$% @ !+",4/# MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMWU
XMS H"?/,&4%- 3+8"-%$&+' V+=/-&'( MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMWY
ZMS !"#$%&'%A&-&$B </'42?%,7# @ ./#+",4/ . >'%-B#/# MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMWT
ZMR G/#4,&8$&+' MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMWT
ZMU *",,/'$ !$%$"# +0 $2/ 1/,B MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMQS
ZMW F&#$+,&4 I[8-+&$%$&+' @ !"#$%&'%A&-&$B </'42?%,7# +0 1+4"# !8/4&/# MMMMQW
ZMWMR ./= F&'=
ZMWMU G+( !'%88/,
ZMWMW !42++-?%#$/,
ZMWMQ <-"/#$,&8/= L,"'$
ZMWMX :%'/ !'%88/,
ZMWMZ ./=$%&- 3%,,+$0
ZMWMY !$+8-&(2$ 3%,,+$0
YMS G"##&+' %'= V%'%(/?/'$ ./4+??/'=%$&+'# MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMZR
>47'+O-/=(?/'$# MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMZQ
./0/,/'4/# MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMZX
>33IHGP\E V>!5 G/#4,&8$&+' @ ]#/,^# L"&=/ MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMZY
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 4/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
N_I._PI6
N3# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#; => ,3# S+#$,= 529= $##> #9=;<;,#1 2; % 9$2,29%&
#9=&=729%& %/' #9=/=129 9=/9#$/ %; 2, 2;- 2/3%E2,#' E< 3+/'$#'; => $##> >2;3#; %/'
1%9$=2/.#$,#E$%,#;- %/' ;+@@=$,; 1+&,212&&2=/U'=&&%$ >2;32/7 %/' ,=+$2;1 2/'+;,$2#;)
N=G%$'; ,32; #/' %/' G2,3 %;;2;,%/9# >$=1 Q4T5 @#$;=//#&- &#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,%
G#$# =E,%2/#' >$=1 &=/7U,#$1 >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, %/' >2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7
@$=7$%1; G2,3 >=9+; =/ ,3# ,G= @$2/92@%& >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7 @$=7$%1;- ,3#
N$2@ \/,#$.2#G S$=7$%1 VN\SW ,3%, ;%1@&#; 9=11#$92%& 9%,93#; %/' ,3# ?%$2/#
5#9$#%,2=/%& H2;3#$2#; (,%,2;,29%& (+$.#< V?5H((W ,3%, ;%1@&#; $#9$#%,2=/%& 9%,93#;)
:/2Z+# 9%@%92,< 3%; E##/ E+2&, G2,32/ ,3# *+&, &%E %, ,3# :/2.#$;2,< => ?2%12 ,= +,2&2X#
,3#;# '%,% ;=+$9#; >=$ $27=$=+; ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, G3#/ ,3#< G#$# ,$%'2,2=/%&&<
9=/;2'#$#' 2/;+>>292#/,) N= ;+@@=$, ,32; G=$D E=,3 >+/'%1#/,%& %'.%/9#; 2/
'#.#&=@1#/, => %/%&<,29%& 1='#&; >=$ &#/7,3 E%;#' 1=$,%&2,< %;;#;;1#/, %/' ,3#
9=/;,$+9,2=/ => % 9=1@+,%,2=/%& @&%,>=$1 >=$ >2;3#$< ;21+&%,2=/ V?*(NW 3%; E##/
%932#.#') N3# $#;+&,; => ,32; &%,#;, %;;#;;1#/, 9=/,2/+# ,= ;+@@=$, ,3# 9=/9&+;2=/ ,3%,
,3# 1%]=$2,< => ;@#92#; 2/ ,3# S+#$,= 529%/ >2;3#$< %$# ;27/2>29%/,&< =.#$ #Y@&=2,#') N3#$#
2; #.2'#/9# ,3%, =$7%/29 ,$%/;2,2=/ 2; =99+$$2/7 G2,32/ ,3# 9=11#$92%& >2;3#$< ,= $#'+9#
#>>=$, %/' 2/9$#%;# 12/21+1 9%@,+$# ;2X# %; ;##/ 2/ ,3# N\S '%,%) ^=G#.#$
1%/%7#1#/, %9,2=/ 2; ;,2&& $#Z+2$#' %; % E+''2/7 $#9$#%,2=/%& >2;3#$< @=;;#;;#; ,3#
@=,#/,2%& >=$ $%@2' #Y@%/;2=/ G3293 G=+&' /#7%,# %/' @=;;2E&< $#.#$;# ,3# @=;2,2.#
,$#/'; E#2/7 ;##/ >$=1 ,3# 93%/72/7 9=11#$92%& >2;3#$<) S%$,29+&%$ 9=/9#$/ ;3=+&' E#
72.#/ ,= ,3# @%$$=,>2;3 9=1@&#Y G3293 '2;@&%< #Y,$#1# =.#$#Y@&=2,%,2=/ %/' ,3#
7$=+@#$ 9=1@&#Y G3293 G32&# .2$,+%&&< %E;#/, ;,2&& 1%D# 2/,#$12,,#/, %@@#%$%/9# 2/ ,3#
9%,93 '%,% ;+77#;,2/7 ,3%, ,3#2$ @=@+&%,2=/; 1%< 3%.# %&$#%'< +/'#$7=/# 9=&&%@;#)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 5/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
PH5.NG]*5PNH
N3# 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#; => ,3# S+#$,= 529= $##> #9=;<;,#1- 2/3%E2,#' E< 3+/'$#'; =>
$##> >2;3#; %/' 1%9$=2/.#$,#E$%,#;- ;+@@=$,; 1+&,212&&2=/U'=&&%$ >2;32/7 %/' ,=+$2;1
2/'+;,$2#; V1&(M RW) N3# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => 1+&,2;@#92#; 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#; 2/ S+#$,= 529=
2; % D#< 9=/;#$.%,2=/ 9=/9#$/ 72.#/ ,3#2$ #9=/=129 %/' #9=&=729%& 21@=$,%/9#- ,3#
;27/2>29%/, '#@#/'#/9# => ;+E;2;,#/9# %/' %$,2;%/%& >2;3#$; =/ $##> >2;3#$2#; >=$ ,3#2$
&2.#&23==';- %/' ,3# 9=/;2'#$%E&# %/' 7$=G2/7 ,3$#%,; ,= 9=$%& $##> 3%E2,%,; V2)#) 9=$%&
E&#%932/7 %/' '2;#%;#- @=&&+,2=/ %/' 9&21%,# 93%/7#W)
1&(",/ RM; ?%@ => ,3# /=$,3#$/ F%$2EE#%/ (#%- G2,3 2/;#, ;3=G2/7 ,3# 2;&%/' %$932@#&%7= => S+#$,= 529=
%/' ,3# I% S%$7+#$% $#72=/)
(+;,%2/%E2&2,< $#>#$; ,= ,3# %E2&2,< => %/ #Y@&=2,#' ;,=9D ,= @$='+9# 7=='; %/'
;#$.29#;- 2/9&+'2/7 <2#&'; %, ;+2,%E&# &#.#&; 2/ ,3# ;3=$, ,#$1- G32&# 1%2/,%2/2/7
;+>>292#/, ;,=9D $#@$='+9,2.# 9%@%92,< ,= 9=/,2/+# @$=.2'2/7 ,3#;# 7=='; %/' ;#$.29#;
2/,= ,3# 2/'#>2/2,# >+,+$#) N3# '%,%U %/' 1='#&U&212,#' ;2,+%,2=/; 9=/>$=/,2/7 1=;,
9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#;- 2/9&+'2/7 ,3=;# => S+#$,= 529=- 3%.# 3%1@#$#' %@@&29%,2=/ =>
1='#$/ ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, ,#93/2Z+#; ,3%, 1##, ,3# %& 1%/'%,# => ,3# ?%7/+;=/U
(,#.#/; H2;3#$< F=/;#$.%,2=/ %/' ?%/%7#1#/, *9, V?(HF?*W) N3# =E]#9,2.# => ,32;
$#;#%$93 2; ,= '#.#&=@ % Z+%/,2,%,2.# ,==&E=Y => '%,% %;;212&%,2=/ %/' &#/7,3UE%;#'
>2;3#$< %;;#;;1#/, 1#,3='; ,= 9=1@+,# $#>#$#/9# @=2/,; >=$ ,3# 1+&,2;@#92#; 9=$%& $##>>2;3#$2#; ,3%, G2&& >%92&2,%,# ,3# 9=/;#$.%,2=/ #>>=$,; => ;,%,# %/' >#'#$%& 1%/%7#$; %/'
2/9$#%;# $#72=/%& 9%@%92,< ,= E+2&' ;+;,%2/%E&# $##> >2;3#$2#; 2/ S+#$,= 529=) O+$
@$=@=;#' %@@$=%93 2; /=.#& 2/ ,3%, 2, 3%; $#&%,2.#&< ;21@&# '%,% $#Z+2$#1#/,; %/'
@$=.2'#; % 9=11+/2,<U&#.#& @#$;@#9,2.# =/ #Y@&=2,%,2=/ #>>#9,;- <#, %&;= #/%E&#;
#.%&+%,2=/ => ;,=9DU;@#92>29 ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< ,3%, 9=/>=$1; ,= ,3# %& $#Z+2$#1#/,; => ,3#
!"#$
%&'()*+($(),
-$'(' ./0'&'1$&2)3"#4'1
56)7$6$0$,
8$0$'1$
9"):(/ 2'1/<%=+=>
?':@'& A,4$&*,<%=+= B %=C=>
Caribbean Sea
Atlantic
Ocean
Gulf
of Mexico
Inset
DE
EFEGHIE
EFEGHJE
EFEGH
KE EFEGL
MN
EFEGL
ME EFEGL
ON
EFEGL
9"):(/ 2'1/<%=+=>
P$ 9$:@"):$+("*Q R:)$
?')S"),
!"4)#:$
.),)16)/
T/&$
T/&'(/
!$U$ *)T"):(/,
!/:*'44):$*) V$U$:*/
E MNE NEEOMN W0
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 6/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
?(HF?*) N3# &=/7U,#$1 9=/;#$.%,2=/ =+,9=1# 2; ,= %932#.# ;+;,%2/%E&# &#.#&; =>
>2;32/7 >=$ #Y@&=2,#' 7$=+@#$;- ;/%@@#$;- %/' @%$$=,>2;3#; 2/ S+#$,= 529= ,3$=+73
'#.#&=@1#/, => /#G >$%1#G=$D => %;;212&%,2=/ %/' 1='#&2/7 1#,3='; %/' E< G=$D2/7
9&=;#&< G2,3 $#72=/%& 1%/%7#$; %/' ;92#/,2;,; ,= 21@#/, ,3# >$%1#G=$D)
V%`+, 52,/%$# %'= N88+,$"'&$&/#
\/,#/;2.# #Y@&=2,%,2=/ %/' =.#$>2;32/7 %$# @#$3%@; ,3# 1%]=$ ,3$#%,; ,= ,32;
#9=;<;,#1) O.#$>2;32/7 3%; E##/ 2'#/,2>2#' %; =/# => ,3# ,=@ ,3$## 7&=E%& ,3$#%,; E< ,3#
4O** F=$%& 5##> F=/;#$.%,2=/ S$=7$%1) (+E;,%/,2%& $#'+9,2=/; 2/ 9=11#$92%& $##>
>2;3 9%,93#; 2/ S+#$,= 529= =.#$ ,3# @%;, ;#.#$%& '#9%'#; 3%.# E##/ =E;#$.#'- $#;+&,2/7
2/ 3%$.#;, 1=$%,=$2% =/ ;#.#$%& ;@#92#; V>=$ #Y%1@&# 4%;;%+ 7$=+@#$ %/' 7=&2%,3
7$=+@#$W) *, $2;D %$# ,3# #9=/=129 G#&&UE#2/7 => 9=%;,%& 3+1%/ 9=11+/2,2#; %; G#&& %;
,3# #9=&=729%& $#;2&2#/9# %/' ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => ,3# 9=$%& $##> #9=;<;,#1) 5##> >2;3#$2#; 2/
S+#$,= 529= ,%$7#, 21@=$,%/, 7+2&'; => >2;3 ;@#92#; 2/9&+'2/7 ,=@ @$#'%,=$; V#)7)-
7$=+@#$; %/' ;/%@@#$;W %/' 3#$E2.=$#; V#)7)- @%$$=,>2;3#;W) O.#$>2;32/7 /=, =/&<
,3$#%,#/; ,3# &=/7U,#$1 .2%E2&2,< => 2/'2.2'+%& ;@#92#;- E+, %&;= 21@%9,; ,3# =.#$%&&
3#%&,3 => ,3# 9=$%& $##> #9=;<;,#1) H=$ #Y%1@&#- '#@&#,2=/ => ,=@ @$#'%,=$; 9%/ '2;$+@,
,3# #9=;<;,#1 >==' G#E- %/' '#@&#,2=/ => 3#$E2.=$#; 9%/ 72.# % 9=1@#,2,2.# %'.%/,%7#
,= %&7%# =.#$ 9=$%& >=$ %.%2&%E&# ;+E;,$%,#- 2/ ,+$/ &#%'2/7 ,= &=;; => 9=$%& 9=.#$ %/'
7#/#$%& '#7$%'%,2=/ => 9=$%& $##>;) N3# #/' $#;+&, => ,3#;# 21@%9,; 1%< E# % 7#/#$%&
'#9&2/# 2/ ,3# @$='+9,2.# 9%@%92,< => ,3# 9=$%& $##> #9=;<;,#1 ,= @$='+9# >2;3#$< <2#&';
%/' %/ 2/9$#%;#' .+&/#$%E2&2,< ,= 9&21%,# 93%/7#)
\/;+>>292#/, %/' @==$ Z+%&2,< '%,%- %/' &%9D => %/ %@@$=@$2%,# 1='#&2/7 >$%1#G=$D
3%.# @$#.#/,#' ;=@32;,29%,#' #.%&+%,2=/; => ,3# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => $##> >2;3#$2#;)
0#/#$%&&< &%9D2/7 %$# ,3# '%,% /##'#' ,= 9=/'+9, 1='#$/ ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/,;- 2/9&+'2/7
'#1=7$%@329 $%,#; %/' 32;,=$29%& ,21#U;#$2#; => %7#U;2X# ;,$+9,+$#' 9%,93#; E< ;@#92#;-
%/' ,3# %;;=92%,#' >2;32/7 #>>=$, E< 7#%$ %/' ;#9,=$) M32&# ,3# Z+%&2,< %/' ;9=@# => $##>
>2;3#$< 9%,93U#>>=$, '%,% 3%.# 7#/#$%&&< 21@$=.#' 2/ S+#$,= 529= =.#$ ,3# @%;, ,G=
'#9%'#; >=$ ,3# 9=11#$92%& >&##,- 9=1@%$%E&# '%,% >$=1 ,3# $#9$#%,2=/%& >&##, %$# /=,
%.%2&%E&# @$2=$ ,= PCCC) N3#$# 2; %/ =E.2=+; &%9D => % Z+%/,2,%,2.# >$%1#G=$D ,= %;;#;;
,3# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => $##> >2;3#; 2/ S+#$,= 529= %/' ,= 7+2'# 1%/%7#1#/, '#92;2=/U
1%D2/7)
*/ =@@=$,+/2,< ,= =.#$9=1# ,3#;# '%,% %/' 1='#& &212,%,2=/; 3%; $#9#/,&< E##/
@$=.2'#' E< *+&, #, %&) VPCC[W- G3= '#.#&=@#' % /#G Z+%/,2,%,2.# ;<;,#1 => &#/7,3U
E%;#' #1@2$29%& #;,21%,2=/ %/' /+1#$29%& 1='#& %/%&<;#; ,= #.%&+%,# #Y@&=2,%,2=/
;,%,+; .2% $#;=+$9# $#>#$#/9# @=2/,; V=$ ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< E#/931%$D;W >=$ 9=$%& $##> >2;3#;
=> ,3# ;/%@@#$U7$=+@#$ 9=1@&#Y 2/ S+#$,= 529=) O> ,3# P_ $##> >2;3 ;@#92#; %;;#;;#'- KB
G#$# =.#$>2;3#' %99=$'2/7 ,= >#'#$%& E#/931%$D; >=$ ;+;,%2/%E2&2,<- ;2Y G#$# >2;3#'
;+;,%2/%E&<- %/' ,3$## 9=+&' /=, E# $#&2%E&< '#,#$12/#' '+# ,= 2/;+>>292#/, '%,%) N3#;#
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 7/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
>2/'2/7; 2/'29%,# ,3%, % 1%]=$2,< => ;/%@@#$U7$=+@#$ ;@#92#; 2/ S+#$,= 529= %$# 9+$$#/,&<
>2;3#' %, +/;+;,%2/%E&# &#.#&;)
O.#$ ,3# @%;, '#9%'#- $#Z+2$#1#/,; >=$ >2;3#$< %;;#;;1#/, %/' 1%/%7#1#/, 2/ ,3#
:(* 3%.# 1=.#' ,=G%$'; % 1=$# @$#9%+,2=/%$< %@@$=%93 ,3%, ;,$2.#; ,= `@$#.#/,
=.#$>2;32/7 G32&# %932#.2/7- =/ % 9=/,2/+2/7 E%;2;- ,3# =@,21%& <2#&' >$=1 #%93 >2;3#$<
>=$ ,3# :/2,#' (,%,#; >2;32/7 2/'+;,$<R V?(HF?* a?%7/+;=/U(,#.#/; H2;3#$<
F=/;#$.%,2=/ %/' ?%/%7#1#/, *9,b) :/'#$ ,32; %& >$%1#G=$D- '#,#$12/%,2=/ => ,3#
;+;,%2/%E2&2,< => % >2;3#$< 1+;, %&;= 9=/;2'#$ $#&#.%/, ;=92=#9=/=129 %/' #9=&=729%&
>%9,=$;- @%$,29+&%$&< G3#,3#$ >2;32/7 9=+&' '#&#,#$2=+;&< 21@%9, ,3# $#@$='+9,2.#
9%@%92,< => ,3# $#;=+$9#) N32; /#G @$=9#;; 2/.=&.#; $#7+&%,2=/ => >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< $%,#-
=.#$ G3293 1%/%7#1#/, 3%; ;=1# '2$#9, 9=/,$=&- %/' 3=G 2, ;3=+&' 93%/7# '#@#/'2/7
+@=/ ;,=9D $#@$='+9,2.# @=,#/,2%& %/' %;;=92%,#' >2;3#$< <2#&';) N3# '%,% &212,#'
;2,+%,2=/; 9=/>$=/,2/7 9=$%& $##> >2;3#$2#; 2/ S+#$,= 529= 3%.# 3%1@#$#' %@@&29%,2=/ =>
1='#$/ ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, ,#93/2Z+#; ,3%, 1##, ,3# %& 1%/'%,# => ,3# ?(HF?*)
N3# +;# => &#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,% %/' %;;=92%,#' 1='#&; ,= %;;#;; F%$2EE#%/ $##>
>2;3#$2#; 2; $#&%,2.#&< /=.#&- %/' ,3# %/%&<;2; => *+&, #, %&) VPCC[W $#@$#;#/,#' % >2$;,
%,,#1@, ,= %@@&< ,3#;# %;;#;;1#/, 1#,3='; %9$=;; ,3# #Y@&=2,#' $##> >2;3 9=11+/2,< 2/
S+#$,= 529=) N3#$# %$# ;=1# %'.%/,%7#; ,= ,32; &#/7,3UE%;#' %;;#;;1#/, 1#,3=' >=$
#;,21%,2/7 ,=,%& 1=$,%&2,< E#9%+;# 2, 3%; $#&%,2.#&< ;21@&# '%,% $#Z+2$#1#/,; %/' 3%;
E##/ ;3=G/ ,= 3%.# $#&%,2.#&< $=E+;, @$=@#$,2#; >=$ %;;#;;2/7 #Y@&=2,%,2=/ 21@%9,; =/
9=$%& $##> >2;3#;) :/2Z+# =G2/7 ,= 2,; X#$=UE2%; @$=@#$,2#; %, #Z+2&2E$2+1- ,3# 1#,3=' 2;
%&;= $#&%,2.#&< 2/;#/;2,2.# ,= ,$#/'; 2/ $#9$+2,1#/, %/' #Y32E2,; '#;2$%E&# @$=@#$,2#; >=$
'#,#9,2/7 ;,%,2;,29%& '2>>#$#/9#; E#,G##/ ;+;,%2/%E&# %/' /=/U;+;,%2/%E&# $%,#; VT3$3%$',
%/' *+&, KLLPc *+&, #, %&) PCC_W) \, %&;= #/%E&#; #.%&+%,2=/ => ;,=9DU;@#92>29
;+;,%2/%E2&2,< ,3%, 9=/>=$1; ,= ,3# %& $#Z+2$#1#/,; => ,3# ?(HF?*)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 8/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% >
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
RMS G>5> !N].*I! >HG 3.N*I!!PHL
I#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,% G#$# =E,%2/#' >$=1 &=/7U,#$1 >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, %/'
>2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7 @$=7$%1; G2,3 ,3# %;;2;,%/9# => Q4T5 @#$;=//#& V5%A-/
RMRW) \/2,2%& %/%&<;#; >=9+;#' =/ ,3# ,G= @$2/92@%& >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7
@$=7$%1;- ,3# N$2@ \/,#$.2#G S$=7$%1 VN\SW ,3%, ;%1@&#; 9=11#$92%& 9%,93#; %/' ,3#
?%$2/# 5#9$#%,2=/%& H2;3#$2#; (,%,2;,29%& (+$.#< V?5H((W ,3%, ;%1@&#; $#9$#%,2=/%&
9%,93#;) Q%,% @$=9#;;2/7 @$=9#'+$#; G#$# '#.#&=@#' +;2/7 (*( ;,%,2;,29%& ;=>,G%$# ,=
9$#%,# %/%&<;2;U$#%'< &#/7,3U9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,%;#,; >=$ E=,3 ,3# N\S %/' ?5H((
'%,%E%;#;- 2/9&+'2/7 9$#%,2/7 +/2>=$1 '%,% 9='#; >=$ ;@#92#;- ,21#- ;@%9#- 7#%$;- #,9)- ,=
>%92&2,%,# 9=1@%$%,2.# %/%&<;#; %1=/7 '%,% ;=+$9#; V1&(M RMRW G2,3 %//+%& ;%1@&# ;2X#
E< ;@#92#; 2/9&+'#' >=$ N\S V5%A-/ RMUW %/' ?5H(( V5%A-/ RMWW) ?%@; ;3=G2/7
E%,3<1#,$29 %/' 3%E2,%, >#%,+$#; => ,3# 9=%;,%& $#72=/ => S+#$,= 529= %&=/7 G2,3 ,3#
/+1E#$2/7 ;93#1# >=$ 9=%;,%& 1+/292@2=; %$# @$=.2'#' 2/ 1&(#M RMU>;<)
5%A-/ RMRE Q%,% ;=+$9#; %/%&<X#' >=$ ;@#92#; &#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/)
Database Description Years
TIPCommercial Trip InterceptsReconstructed, DNER Files
1983-20101988-2010
MRFSS Sport Trip Intercepts 2000-2010
SEAMAP Fishery-independent, trap & hook-line gears 1991-2006
NOAA BioGeo Fishery-Independent, diver visual surveys 2000-2010
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 9/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE OE;#$.%,2=/ ;%1@&# ;2X# E< ;@#92#; %/' <#%$ >=$ N\S '%,%;#, VKL[[UPCKCW)
0$##/ 3273&273,#' ;@#92#; 3%.# ;+>>292#/, &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% %/' &2># 32;,=$< '%,% >=$
#Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# %/%&<;2;) d&+# 3273&273,#' ;@#92#; 3%.# ;+>>292#/, &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9<
'%,% E+, %$# &%9D2/7 &2># 32;,=$< @%$%1#,#$;)
>4),/ -*99*/ <?@@ <?@? <??; <??< <??: <??= <??A <??B <??C <??D <??@ <???
!"#$%&'(%&#) + ',)#- 62#/* $)(@-%) : 99 7? 7= &; && & &< = A 7 <
.%(/)0'(/'0-1 2304) /(0%B ;:8 9<7 7&7 &789 &&8& ;;? &7< &>> ?> =& 77; 797
5(-,%(/%031 -$)6 )&) $(21#4, $)(@-%) 7 > &8 & = < & A & A A &
.%(/)0'(/'0-1 #&3%,$)$) $)#B+6B =8 ?7 78> 7&= 7=: &87 =: ;: ; 98 > 7<
5(-,%(/%031 7"1$)#-, 31 C1+4B $)(@-%) = 7 7 : ? ; A A A A & A
5(-,%(/%031 1$&-)$ 31 D#++ #@ $)(@-%) 7; 7; 98 ;7 :; < && : < A = &9
5(-,%(/%031 7'&- ' )%E $)(@-%) 7 A 7 & : 7 A A A & A ;
5(-,%(/%031 83$$) $31 )%E ,10E =:8 :?< ;:> &&7: =>9 :7= 9;7 998 &&? &?; ;&= >=:
5(-,%(/%031 )91#%,1-',-1 )(/* ,10E &87 =? 7= :> < &= A : &8 9 < &8
!"#$%&'(%&#) $- 8&-1 41$%) $)(@-%) 7 ; A :> A A 9; >9> ;?> :88 ::; ;;
!"#$%&'(%&#) 4%,%,'1) B%22(FG10 $)(@-%) &9 &; > ; : 9 & < A &: 7 &&!"#$%&'(%&#) -,$%&1$-$-)0- 1 B%22(FC(@4, $)(@-%) & 7 & 7 & A A A A A A A
:(1-031 9%,$)$3 1 62#/* +0#--%) A 7 &? A & A A A A A 7 <
;3$6),31 +3##),%00) 62#/*G10 +0#--%) <; ?< &&< :8: &9; >? ;> &< 9= A <7 ;=
;3$6),31 #"),'($%&31 /@6%)# +0#--%) &: &= ? == =8 :? 7< ;8 ? A A A
;3$6),31 6'#3 E($ +0#--%) &&8 7? 9< >> =< ;: :8 :7 ; 9 79 <7
;3$6),31 8&-1%31 $)#B +0#--%) &7; 9= ? :8 ? A <8 < A A 9> ;
;)#/,'0)-731 7)<-731 ,($G1+, &>8 7&? &?> 79= &>; &8: == =< <9 :< &&9 7:;
;3$6),31 1",)8&-1 2#0% +0#--%) &8&& &=:= &;?< 7::? 7:7& =&< :=7 <?& &=: &?9 ::: >=<
;3$6),31 7)/'8',- C#,($#0B +0#--%) :8 &7 ? &<; &?9 &:7 &8: <; &8 ; 99 :>
;3$6),31 ),)0-1 C@44(0 +0#--%) &:9 &9= &?; 9>< 9<= &<= 78; &8> 7& 9? &>= 7&:
5$%0-1 '#30)$3 1 H@%%0 +0#--%) &78 :?; 7=> 9&; ?> :< 7 9 ?< : ;7 &&&
;3$6),31 )('931 +/,((2C#+4%) &;< &77 &>; 9;9 7;8 &9> &=< 789 :& 9: &>> 99:
;3$6),31 4-4),31 +12* +0#--%) <;> :>> ;:= &<>: <8> 9?& ;:: 7=? 7?; &;< 9?> =9&
=/'7+'(0-$%1 )3&'&3+%,1 I%)C121(0 +0#--%) <7: 7=< ;:9 7:<: &87; &&&7 :87 <> 7 =8 &:9 &>8
>&-1$-('7'-9%1 )?3-0',)&-1 F%0/,C#0 :; =; =& &&: 9? &? &7 A 78 &8 > &<
@#"3&31 #/&"13&31 B%22(F4#12 +0#--%) &&&; <;< &9>& =>:; =8:8 ;87& 9>7& 9=<= :?< ;=: &=:7 78<7
A#)&31 #'%&30%31 62@% -#))(4G1+, A ; < A ; 9 A 9 ; & && &
A#)&31 #'%0%1$-,31 C1E01$,4 -#))(4G1+, : & 7 A & A A A A 7 A 9
A#)&31 $)%,-'($%&31 -)10/%++ -#))(4G1+, &? :9 :9 >8 <; 9= 77 &8 9 A ? 9;
A#)&31 4%$30) H@%%0 -#))(4G1+, 9> 99 => 78 ;> :8 A A & &= &< <;
A#)&31 83)#)7)-) )#106(F -#))(4G1+, A < < : & A A A = & A ;
A()&-1'7) )3&'2&%,)$37 )%E6#0E -#))(4G1+, 9: 99 ;8 99 7& &9 7< A A 7 > &:
A()&-1'7) &3+&-(-,,% B%22(F4#1 2 -#))(4G1+, ; A &: A A A A A A A A &A()&-1'7) #/&"1'($%&37 )%E4#12 -#))(4G1+, 9=: :7& ;;= <7< :8: :&? 77= 7;= 97< &=; ;89 >&7
A()&-1'7) 4-&-9% +4(-21 $,4 -#))(4G1+, <:? :;< =7? =<= ;>= :=& 7<: &?& 979 7&; ;=8 ?8>
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 10/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &8
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE F=/,)>4),/ -*99*/ :;;; :;;< :;;: :;;= :;;A :;;B :;;C :;;D :;;@ :;;? :;<; )*)4> .45) = E'4(5
!"#$%&'(%&#) + ',)#- 62#/* $)(@-%) : 7 & > 7 A & A A < & 7; =
.%(/)0'(/'0-1 2304) /(0%B &>7 :9? 7=; 98& 79< >& <8 &? &&8 &7& :: &><> 7=;
5(-,%(/%031 -$)6 )&) $(21#4, $)(@-%) A < & 9 & A A A A A A && 8.%(/)0'(/'0-1 #&3%,$)$) $)#B+6B ? >& 79 78 79 &7 && 7; < 9= 78 7<= <9
5(-,%(/%031 7"1$)#-,31 C1+4B $)(@-%) & & : & && > && : = ; A ;9 &7
5(-,%(/%031 1$&-)$31 D#++#@ $)(@-%) = &? : 9 ? & A A A A & :: &
5(-,%(/%031 7'&- ' )%E $)(@-%) A 9 & 9 A 7 7 A & 7 A &: 9
5(-,%(/%031 83$$)$31 )%E ,10E =9< ?>8 >:7 ?7> ??& <>: >9= :8> <?? <88 =;< >:<& 78;;
5(-,%(/%031 )91#%,1-',-1 )(/* ,10E ? 9 && &8 A 7 A & A & A 9= &
!"#$%&'(%&#) $-8&- 1 41$%) $)(@-%) 7& 7& & ; &8& &> & A A A A &<> 8
!"#$%&'(%&#) 4%,%,'1) B%22(FG10 $)(@-%) 9> 9 : 7 & & ; & : < & << &&
!"#$%&'(%&#) -,$%&1$-$-)0- 1 B%22(FC(@4, $)(@-%) A A & & A & & A A A A : 8
:(1-031 9%,$)$3 1 62#/* +0#--%) A A A A & & A A A 79 A 7; 79
;3$6),31 +3##),%00) 62#/*G10 +0#--%) &&> &&8 ;< &&& 7:& &=& &9? &=? &>; 7&< &;; &<>& ;;<
;3$6),31 #"),'($%&31 /@6%)# +0#--%) A & & 7 9 & 9 &; 7: 9< ; ?& <;
;3$6),31 6'#3 E($ +0#--%) :& ;; ;> ;= :> <& =9 &78 &89 &8< ;= ==? 7<<
;3$6),31 8&-1%31 $)#B +0#--%) && > > 7 = ; &< <7 >< => 9; 9&> &??
;)#/,'0)-731 7)<-731 ,($G1+, 7&= :7& &=; &>7 &:= &<7 &<< ?7 ?9 999 7<: 77;7 <?8
;3$6),31 1",)8&-1 2#0% +0#--%) :=< &7== &9:: =9= &9:7 :7: ><7 &&<= <=; 78&= &>8? &7&98 :;8&
;3$6),31 7)/'8',- C#,($#0B +0#--%) :: 9? 7? 7> 7? 7& 7< &; &8 &< &< 7=9 :7
;3$6),31 ),)0-1 C@44(0 +0#--%) 7<= 79> 9?? ;7& 99& 77< :?< 97> &<> 7&< &>? 99=? ;=9
5$%0-1 '#30)$31 H@%%0 +0#--%) &?9 &<8 7&: 7>> :&& ;;> <&8 &<9 9;= 9:= 7?& 9;?7 ??;
;3$6),31 )('931 +/,((2C#+4%) &?< &7= &;9 &79 &&= &7& &;7 <& &=? 98> 9<= &?8: >;:
;3$6),31 4-4),31 +12* +0#--%) &;77 79?= &:=9 &>:& 7&&> =99 &7&= ?:? &;:< &:9& <<7 &;>>? 9<9?
=/'7+'(0-$%1 )3&'&3+%,1 I%)C121(0 +0#--%) &<& 7<> 7;& &7> &>& &&> ?< &:? 7&8 7>& &8= &?;8 ;?>
>&-1$-('7'-9%1 )?3-0',)&-1 F%0/,C#0 7 7& 9 &8 :8 :: <: ;; &=? <? 9? ;7< 7>=
@#"3&31 #/&"13&31 B%22(F4#12 +0#--%) :8<9 7>88 9<98 :9&8 79?< 7&<: 7<<9 97<; 7:>9 7=>7 788; 97;<& =7=8
A#)&31 #'%&30%31 62@% -#))(4G1+, 9 A A A A A 7 A A & A < &
A#)&31 #'%0%1$-,31 C1E01$,4 -#))(4G1+, A & A A A A A & A A A 7 8
A#)&31 $)%,-'($%&31 -)10/%++ -#))(4G1+, &8= 77: >9 7? <9 <: <7 &8 9: >? :& >8< &<:
A#)&31 4%$30) H@%%0 -#))(4G1+, =< &:< >< <7 &&= :> =8 &7 7< 9= :; =7; &8>
A#)&31 83)#)7)-) )#106(F -#))(4G1+, & &9 & ; A 9 & 7 ; < & 9> &7
A()&-1'7) )3&'2&%,)$37 )%E6#0E -#))(4G1+, & ; & = ; && ? A A ? A :> ?
A()&-1'7) &3+&-(-,,% B%22(F4#12 -#))(4G1+, :< &8 : &? 7& 78 77 A 78 ; A &<= 7;
A()&-1'7) # /&"1'($%&37 )%E4#12 -#))(4G1+, =>= >;< &8&: <?< :7? :&? :?= ?= 7;< 7:7 98& ;;?: =??
A()&-1'7) 4-&-9% +4(-21$,4 -#))(4G1+, ??9 ?>< &&9= ;=8 >&: >;? <&8 77: ::& ;8< 9== =;&= &97:
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 11/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE F=/,)>4),/ -*99*/ <?@@ <?@? <??; <??< <??: <??= <??A <??B <??C <??D <??@ <???
.','9', ,'+-0-1 6#))%E $)@04 A &?< :? & & A A A A A A A
B)%730', +',)&-%,1% 62#/* $)@04 9 & 9 & A A A A A A A A
:,-1'1$&%731 13&-,)7%,1-1 62#/* C#)$#4% 78 : 7& 79 ? < 7 A & & : ?B)%730', 1#-3&31 62@%+4)1-% E $)@04 <9> 79; 7<= :<9 <& =; =? ?? ;9 7; &?9 7;7
>'7)9)1"1 #&'#&' 6@))( $)@04 A A & A A A A A A A A &
B)%730', #)&+',)&-37 /%#+# ) $)@04 :: & &= &9 &<= &&8 A &: A A ; A
B)%730', 20)4'0-,%)$37 J)%0/, $)@04 :9 > ? 9; ? &< > ;8 &9 && 98 ?:
B)%730', )0+37 C#)$#4% &7 &< > 78 < &; : 9 9 7 < &&
:,-1'$&%73 1 4-&8-, -#3 1 -()*G1+, &9> >? <& 99 7> 77 = 78 &8 = :7 9&
B)%730', ()&&) +#12()+ /,(1/% &7= ?8 <& 9& & 7 A A A A ; 7&
B)%730', #/&"1)&8"&%37 +C#22 C(@4, $)@04 & && 7 < 9 & A & A A A A
B)%730', 7)#&'1$'737 K-#01+, $)@04 :< = ? &9 A A A A A A A A
B)%730', )3&'0-,%)$37 4(C4#4% <8 9> 79 <& >8 :< > 78 A A A A
B)%730', (037-%&-- F,14% $)@04 7:=> 77&9 &?8> 98:; 7=8& &>9> <<? &9?& 7&> 7:? ?7& &&;?
>)&),$/-) 1 23&#-2%& L42#041/ /)%(2%G1+, 7 < &8 & A & A 7 A A A A
./)%$'9-($%&31 2)+%& L42#041/ +-#E%G1+, < &: & & 9 A A 9 A A A A
.)&),< &3+%& 6#) M#/* &<= &;8 &>? &<< &>8 >> 7> 98 =: =& 9>7 7>;
C"(/'131 1%#$)$&-< N%)C@E# /,@6 A A A A A A A A A A > ;
>&-)#),$/31 )&%,)$31 61$%B% & A A &> :> 7< 7 7 A A ? 9
!%0-#/$/ "1 ,-8%& 62#/* E@)$(0 A A A A > & A ? & A A A
.)&),< 0383+&-1 62#/* M#/* A 7; 9: 7 A A A A & A A A
!"&-(&-1$-1 6)#'+3 1 62#/*6#) +(2E1%)G1+, 7 A A & 9> &> : = A A A &
.)&),< #&"1'1 62@% )@00%) ;7 ;= &88 ?& << &>7 ;8 7: 7 A 7; &=
:#),$/3&31 #'%&30%31 62@% 4#0$ : A A 9 A A A A A A A A
D-1$30)&-) $)+)#)&-) 62@%+-(44% E /()0%4G1+, A A A : A A A A A A A A
./&'7-1 730$-0-,%)$) 6)(F0 /,)(C1+ A A & A 7 A A A A A 7 A
.)&),< /-(('1 /)%I#22% M#/* 7: <& &9 := 9 A A A 7 & & &
:#),$/3&31 #/-&3& 831 E(/4()G1+, &8 A A A A A A A > A A A
>'7)#),$/31 ()&3 J)%0/, #0$%2G1+, ; 9 A A & A A A : A & A
>'7)#),$/31 ))$31 $)#B #0$%2G1+, 9 7 & & : A A A = A &; >
E)0-1$%1 #)(&-1#31 $)#B 4)1$$%)G1+, A A A A 7 A A A A A : &8
A(/"&)%,) +)&&)#39) $)%#4 6#))#/@E# : ; 7 : ; 7 A A A A : A
A(/"&)%,) 83)#/),#/' $@#$@#0/,% A A 9 7= :9 78 & A A A A A
:#),$/ '1$&)# -', ('0"8',-) ,(0%B/(C6 /(FG1+, =: :? >< <; <7 ?8 9; &> A &8 <= :;
.)&),< 0)$31 ,()+%O%B% M#/* 9> = ;& ;< =? 7= &? 7? ; 9 &: <8
.)0)731 +)6',)9' M(24,%#E -()$B &:= &?? 9&: 7>; &9< 79> &&; ;? 99 9& 9> ?;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 12/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE F=/,)>4),/ -*99*/ :;;; :;;< :;;: :;;= :;;A :;;B :;;C :;;D :;;@ :;;? :;<; )*)4> .45) = E'4(5
.','9', ,'+-0-1 6#))%E $)@04 &8 9 A A A 9 A 79 A A A 9? 8
B)%730', +',)&-%,1% 62#/* $)@04 A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
:,-1'1$&%73 1 13&-,)7 %,1-1 62#/* C#)$#4% &8 = 7 9 7 ; = A & ; ; := &&
B)%730', 1#-3&31 62@%+4)1-%E $)@04 7:7 ;:& 98; 7?: 9&> ;8: 9>< &&7 &<: 78= 7?= 99=8 <<>
>'7)9)1"1 #&'#&' 6@))( $)@04 ; &< A A A A A A A A & 77 &
B)%730', #)&+',)&-37 /%#+# ) $)@04 &: = A : 98 9 7? A A = A ?: =
B)%730', 20)4'0-,%)$37 J)%0/, $)@04 ?: ;& 9= := 7? 7: 7: 9 7 &? < 99< 7=
B)%730', )0+37 C#)$#4% ? 9: = ? 9 7< A &8 & :8 : &:9 :;
:,-1'$&%73 1 4-&8-, -#3 1 -()*G1+, =; =< <7 9> 98 =& 99 77 &8 7= 9? :>9 =<
B)%730', ()&&) +#12()+ /,(1/% &< &; :< &? ? ; &= 7 &8 &; A &;: 7;
B)%730', #/&"1)&8"&%37 +C#22C(@4 , $)@04 A A 9 A A A : A A A A = 8
B)%730', 7)#&'1$'737 K-#01+, $)@04 A A A A A A A A A &? 7:? 7<> 7<>
B)%730', )3&'0-,%)$37 4(C4#4% A A > A A & 9 A A A & &9 &
B)%730', (037-%&-- F,14% $)@04 &9<9 &9;? &;;: &7:8 =>? <>? <<? 7<9 7:> <&7 <7> ?:&: &:>>
>)&),$/-) 1 23&#-2%& L42#041/ /)%(2%G1+, A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
./)%$'9-($%&31 2)+%& L42#041/ +-#E%G1+, A A A A A A A A A & A & &
.)&),< &3+%& 6#) M#/* ;<7 :&; :;> 9?8 7:: &8< :&; 787 7:9 78< &=< 9:&= <7;
C"(/'131 1%#$)$&-< N%)C@E# /,@6 A & A A A A &9 A & : A &? ;
>&-)#),$/31 )&%,)$31 61$%B% 9 A A A && A : A 7& A A 9? 7&
!%0-#/$/"1 ,-8%& 62#/* E@)$(0 78 A &7 A A : : A A A 9 :9 9
.)&),< 0383+&-1 62#/* M#/* A A A A A A A A 7 7 A : :
!"&-(&-1$-1 6)#'+31 62#/*6#) +(2E1%)G1+, A A A A A A & A A A A & 8
.)&),< #&"1'1 62@% )@00%) A A && 7= 7=< &:: >8 :7 :& &97 &9 =<< &><
:#),$/ 3&31 #' %&30%31 62@% 4#0$ & A A A A &8 == A && 9 A &87 &:
D-1$30)&-) $)+)#)&-) 62@%+-(44%E /()0%4G1+, A A > A 7 A A A A A A &8 8
./&'7-1 730$-0-,%)$) 6)(F0 /,)(C1+ A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
.)&),< /-(('1 /)%I#22% M#/* ; < A A 7: & A A A & A 9= &
:#),$/ 3&31 #/ -&3& 831 E(/4()G1+, A A A A A 98 :& A &: 98 & &&< :;
>'7)#),$/31 ()&3 J)%0/, #0$%2G1+, A > A 9 7 7 &8 A & A A 7< &
>'7)#),$/31 ))$31 $)#B #0$%2G1+, 9 7? & A A < A A && > A ;> &?
E)0-1$%1 #)(&-1#31 $)#B 4)1$$%)G1+, A >9 A A 78 A A A A & A &8: &
A(/"&)%,) +)&&)#39) $)%#4 6#))#/@E# A & A A 9 & & A A A A < 8
A(/"&)%,) 83)#/),#/' $@#$@#0/,% A A A A A ? > A 7& & A 9? 77
:#),$/ '1$&)# -', (' 0"8' ,-) ,(0%B/(C6 /(FG1+, 9; 9: &? >9 ?= == >& 99 7= <& 9> ;>; &7<
.)&),< 0)$31 ,()+%O%B% M#/* &> ;& = &: :9 97 &< 7; &: 9& & 7;7 :<
.)0)731 +)6',)9' M(24,%#E -()$B ;? &<; &79 &7> ;8 ?& &9& =7 :9 78 < >>> <?
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 13/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE F=/,)>4),/ -*99*/ <?@@ <?@? <??; <??< <??: <??= <??A <??B <??C <??D <??@ <???
B'0'#%,$&31 &3231 2(0$+-10% +H@1))%2G1+, & > & &? =7 9& A 7 A 9 A A
:0(/%1$%1 )2%& C@44(0 ,#C2%4 &< &> & : & & A A & 7 A &
:#),$/3 &31 +)/-),31 (/%#0 +@)$%(0 7 A & A 9 A 9 A = & &= 78.),$/-9%&7-1 13220)7%, (/%#0 4)1$$%)G1+, ; A A & & A A ; A & A 9
.),$/%&/-,%1 (30031 ()#0$%+-(44%E G12%G1+, 9 A A A A A A A A A A &
.)0)731 (%,,)$30) -2@C# -()$B ;:> =; >; :7? &>? =8 <> 9< <: <> 79= 7=<
B)0-#/'%&%1 &)9-)$31 -@EE10$F1G% &< && & 7> &? < 9 7 A A A &
B'0)#),$/31 #-0-)&-1 H@%%0 #0$%2G1+, 7 & A A A A & A A A = 9:
E)0-1$%1 4%$30) H@%%0 4)1$$%)G1+, 9&> &=: &8: 9&= 7;; &=& ?? &&: := :: &>; 798
50)8)$-1 +-(-,,30)$) )#106(F )@00%) ; ? & 7 A & < A A A A &
@9',$'1#-', 9%,$%< )%%G /)(#*%) &8 &; : : 9 & A 7 A A 78 7=<
A",'931 -,$%&7%9-31 +#0E E1I%) A A A & & A & A A A A A
!)0)#),$/31 (037-%&- +#0E 412%G1+, > A A A A A A A & A 7 7
:#),$/'1$&)#- ', ?3)9 &-#'&,-1 +/)#F2%E /(FG1+, 7?; <: 9< 98> &&9 >9 9< :: && 7< &8; <:
:03$%&31 1#&-($3 1 +/)#F2%E G12%G1+, A 9 A A A A A A A A A A.)0)731 (%,,) +,%%-+,%#E -()$B ;? && A 7 A A A A A A 7 A
;)8'#%(/)031 0)%4-8)$31 +C((4, -@GG%) A A A & A A A A A A & A
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-?3%$%& +C((4, 4)@0*G1+, ;8 &? 7& &87 :7 ;8 &= && = < 7> 79
A(/"&)%,) (-#39-00) +(@4,%)0 +%00%4 & &> A 9? ;8 & A A & & ; 9<
E'9-),31 &3231 K-#01+, ,($G1+, && < > && > ; : 7 7 & A <
5?3%$31 (3,#$)$31 +-(44%E E)@C A A A A A A A A 9 A A A
>1%393(%,%31 7)#30 )$31 +-(44%E $(#4G1+, :=: ;9: :7> 7&< &== 7<: 7&= <; &? ;? 999 77:
;)#$'(/&"1 +-#)39)0-1 +-(44%E 4)@0*G1+, => :7 &> &88 :9 :8 &; ? 7 ; << &>
B'0'#%,$&31 )91#%,1-',-1 +H@1))%2G1+, 9; & &7 9&7 ::7 &;7 ;8 =8 && A 9 :?
A%&&),31 (/'%+% 4#442%) A A A A A A A A A 9 ; A
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-8',31 4)@0*G1+, 9 = A 78 := > 7 > A ; & 9
.),$/%&/-,%1 7)#&'#%&31 F,14%+-(44%E G12%G1+, A 7 & 7 A ; A A A A A 7
C"(/'131 -,#-1'& B%22(F /,@6 A & & A & 7 A A A A A A
!300'-9-#/$/"1 7)&$-,-#31 B%22(F $(#4G1+, &:8 &8& >= >& =; :9 9? 7= 9: &> 9= 7<
.)&),< +)&$/'0'7)%- B%22(F M#/* 98 &: ?; 9< &< < 7 A :& & &8 9;
:0%#$-1 #-0 -)&- 1 LG)1/#0 -(C-#0( & ? ; = & ; A A 7 A A 7
!%8)0'(1 )$0),$-#3 1 4#)-(0 9 < 77 &: A A A A A A A 7&
:0+30) 43 0(%1 6(0%G1+, ; & : = 7 9 A A A A A A
F&)#/-,'$31 2)0#)$31 -%)C14 &9 &> ; = ; 7 78 7 &? A A 9
A%&-'0) &-4'0-),) #2C#/( M#/* 7 A &8 A A A A A A A A A
A#'7+%&'7'&31 &%8)0-1 /%)( ;= &?9 &== &?< :&? >; &9: &8: 9> 9& 7>8 &>8
A%&-'0) 937%&-0- $)%#4%) #C6%)M#/* ; ? < &8 > < 7 & 7 A 7 7
A#'7+%&'7'&31 #)4)00) *10$ C#/*%)%2 ?& :> &>8 9=7 &8= 7=; == &:: :< &;< ?7 &>8
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 14/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMUE F=/,) >4),/ -*99*/ :;;; :;;< :;;: :;;= :;;A :;;B :;;C :;;D :;;@ :;;? :;<; )*)4> .45) = E'4(5
B'0'#%,$&31 &3231 2(0$+-10% +H@1))%2G1+, & A A A A &; A A A A A &< 8
:0(/%1$%1 )2%& C@44(0 ,#C2%4 A A A : A A 7 A & = A &: >
:#),$/3 &31 +)/- ),31 (/%#0 +@)$%(0 77 < && &: = 7 A A A A A <7 8
.),$/-9%&7-1 13220)7%, (/%#0 4)1$$%)G1+, & A A & & < : 7 7 &< A 99 &>
.),$/%&/-,%1 (30031 ()#0$%+-(44%E G12%G1+, A A A A A A = A A A & > &
.)0)731 (%,,)$30) -2@C# -()$B 77> =&8 9;& :79 7?: &=> :>9 >= &?? == ;8 98>8 97<
B)0-#/'%&%1 &)9-)$31 -@EE10$F1G% A A A A A & 9 & A A 7 = 7
B'0)#),$/31 #-0-)&-1 H@%%0 #0$%2G1+, 7; &: 97 7< ? 7 A A A 7 A &&8 7
E)0-1$%1 4%$30) H@%%0 4)1$$%)G1+, &>< &<8 7&7 7&> 778 7?; 9&? &7> 7&? 78> 7>7 7::= =8?
50)8)$-1 +-(-,,30)$) )#106(F )@00%) 7 : ;: 7 &? : 7& & & &7 A &78 &9
@9',$'1#-', 9%,$%< )%%G /)(#*%) A >9 > ;> 9; 9 ; 99 =8 &&? 7 :&< &?&
A",'931 -,$%&7%9-31 +#0E E1I%) A > A A A A A A A A A > 8
!)0)#),$/31 (037-%&- +#0E 412%G1+, & &7 7 > A 7 &9 > A A A :< 8
:#),$/' 1$&)#- ', ?3) 9&-# '&,- 1 +/)#F2%E /(FG1+, 7> <8 :> :; >; >> &9< 9= 7< 7> =8 <;& &7:
:03$%&31 1#&-($3 1 +/)#F2%E G12%G1+, A A A A & A A A A A 9 : 9
.)0)731 (%,,) +,%%-+,%# E -()$B A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
;)8'#%(/)031 0)%4-8)$31 +C((4, -@GG%) & A A A A A & A A A A 7 8
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-?3%$%& +C((4, 4)@0*G1+, < &< : &9 && 77 ;< ? && && 9> &?= <8
A(/"&)%,) (-#39-00) +(@4,%)0 +%00%4 &9 &= &8 A >7 :& 7? 78 A 7? A 7:& 7?
E'9-),31 &3231 K-#01+, ,($G1+, = < 9 7 ? & > A 7 & A 9? 9
5?3%$31 (3,#$)$31 +-(44%E E)@C & A A & A A A A A A A 7 8
>1%393(%,%31 7)#30 )$31 +-(44%E $(#4G1+, 7;9 &9& == &87 &>8 <> 7:= &8< &9& 7?& &: &<88 :9<
;)#$'(/&"1 +-#)39)0-1 +-(44%E 4)@0*G1+, && 9; && 77 98 :? :? 7: &> 7= 7< 987 =&
B'0'#%,$&31 )91#%,1-',-1 +H@1))%2G1+, =; <? 7> &: &< 77 :9 7 A = A 7=< =
A%&&),31 (/'%+% 4#442%) A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-8',31 4)@0*G1+, 78 79 :< ?? :9 &>= 9;= 7& A A A =?< 8
.),$/%&/-,%1 7)#&'#%&31 F,14%+-(44%E G12%G1+, A A A A A A && & A A & &9 &
C"(/'131 -,#-1'& B%22(F /,@6 A A A A A A A A A A A 8 8
!300'-9-#/$/"1 7)&$-,-#31 B%22(F $(#4G1+, &= ;> 9: 7= &7 7: 7: < & &= 7 777 78
.)&),< +)&$/'0'7)%- B%22(F M#/* &: ?; 7= 7; <9 7= :7 9< : = 9 9:9 &: :0%#$-1 #-0-) &-1 LG)1/#0 -(C-#0( A A & A A : A A ; > A &> &9
!%8)0'(1 )$0),$-#3 1 4#)-(0 A 9< && & &8 A A A A & & <8 7
:0+30) 430 (%1 6(0%G1+, A A A A A A A A A ; A ; ;
F&)#/-,'$31 2)0#)$31 -%)C14 9 & 9: 7< &; A && 7 & 9 & ?= ;
A%&-'0) &-4'0-),) #2C#/( M#/* A A A A A A < A A A A < 8
A#'7+%&'7'&31 &%8)0-1 /%)( &&7 &8? &79 ?= &?? 9:& 7<? ?9 &9; <? <? &<&< 7=9
A%&-'0) 937%&-0- $)%#4%) #C6%)M#/* : : A A ; 9 9 : 7 A A 7; 7
A#'7+%&'7'&31 #)4)00) *10$ C#/*%)%2 =?? &7>? &&>; :&< 7<: 9=9 <7< 7&& 9&? 7=7 &<8 ;?&: =;&
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 15/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMWE OE;#$.%,2=/ ;%1@&# ;2X# E< ;@#92#; %/' <#%$ >=$ ?5H(( '%,%;#, VPCCCUPCKCW)
0$##/ 3273&273,#' ;@#92#; 3%.# ;+>>292#/, &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% %/' &2># 32;,=$< '%,% >=$
#Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# %/%&<;2;) d&+# 3273&273,#' ;@#92#; 3%.# ;+>>292#/, &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9<
'%,% E+, %$# &%9D2/7 &2># 32;,=$< @%$%1#,#$;)>4) ,/ -*99*/ :;;; :;;< :;;: :;;= :;;A :;;B :;;C :;;D :;;@ :;;? :;<; F*)4> .45) = E'4(5
!"#$%&'(%&#) +',) #- 62#/* $)(@-%) A A A A A A A & A A A & 8
.%(/)0'(/'0-1 2304) /(0%B 9& 98 : =& >: 97 < &9 &< &9 ? 98? 9>
5(-,%(/%031 -$)6)&) $(21#4, $)(@-%) 9 A & A A A A A A A A : 8
.%(/)0'(/'0-1 #&3%,$)$) $)#B+6B &8 : A 9 = 7 A & 7 7 = 9> &&
5(-,%(/%031 7"1$)#-,31 C1+4B $)(@-%) A A A A & A A A & A & 9 7
5(-,%(/%031 1$&-)$31 D#++#@ $)(@-%) & A A < & A & & A A A &8 8
5(-,%(/%031 7'&-' )%E $)(@-%) A A A A A & A & A A A 7 8
5(-,%(/%031 83$$)$31 )%E ,10E &= := 7& 7? 7& <7 ; &7 &8 ? 77 7;; :&
5(-,%(/%031 )91#%,1-',-1 )(/* ,10E 7 & A A A A 7 9 & & & && 9
!"#$%&'(%&#) 4%,%,'1) B%22(FG10 $)(@-%) A & A : A A 7 A A 7 A ? 7
:(1-031 9%,$) $31 62#/* +0#--%) A & A A A A A A A A A & 8
;3$6),31 +3##),%00) 62#/*G10 +0#--%) : = A 79 7 7 A 7 ; &8 7 ;= &=
;3$6),31 #"),'($%&31 /@6%)# +0#--%) 7 7 A & A A & & A A A = 8
;3$6),31 6'#3 E($ +0#--%) ; &; & ; & 9 A ? ; = 7 ;9 &:
;3$6),31 8&-1%31 $)#B +0#--%) 7 & & : A A : &8 & A A 79 &
;)#/,'0)-731 7)<-731 ,($G1+, A 9 A 7 A A A & A A 7 > 7
;3$6),31 1",)8&-1 2#0% +0#--%) &< 7< 7 9< 7= &> &7 :& 7> : := 7;= =?
;3$6),31 7)/'8',- C#,($#0B +0#--%) 7 A A A A A A 7 A & & < 7
;3$6),31 ),)0-1 C@44(0 +0#--%) && > > 79 7: &< ? &> &7 > &7 &:? 97
5$%0-1 '#30)$31 H@%%0 +0#--%) 7 &: &? &7 > &= 7 ? ? & = &88 &=
;3$6),31 )('931 +/,((2C#+4%) < &8 & &> ; > < ; 9 & < <? &8
;3$6),31 4-4),31 +12* +0#--%) ;7 ;: &> ;< :7 9> && 7< 7& 7; ? 9;7 ;;
=/'7+'(0-$%1 )3&'&3+%,1 I%)C121(0 +0#--%) &; &8 &< ; & 9 A && < & && =? &>
>&-1$-('7'-9%1 )?3-0',)&-1 F%0/,C#0 9 &7 < 7; > && A 78 9 : 9 ?; &8
@#"3&31 #/&"13&31 B%22(F4#12 +0#--%) &: &? 7& 9& 9? &? > &; 77 77 &> 77> <7
.','9', ,'+-0-1 6#))%E $)@04 A A A A & A A A A A A & 8
:,-1'1$&%731 13&-, )7%,1-1 62#/* C#)$#4% : 9 9 &9 A A A A A 7 A 7; 7
B)%730', 1#-3&31 62@%+4)1-%E $)@04 ? < A 7 A A A 7 & A A 78 &
B)%730', #)&+',)&-37 /%#+# ) $)@04 & < A & A & A A A A A ? 8
B)%730', 20)4'0-,%)$37 J)%0/, $)@04 7 A & & & A A A A A A ; 8
B)%730', )0+37 C#)$#4% A A A A A A A A & A & 7 7
:,-1'$&%731 4-&8 -,- #31 -()*G1+, & & & 7 A & A A A 7 A > 7
B)%730', ()&&) +#12()+ /,(1/% 7 A A < & A A & A 9 A &9 9
B)%730', #/&"1)&8"&%37 +C#22C(@4, $)@04 A A 7 7 A A A A A A A : 8
B)%730', 7)#&'1$'737 K-#01+, $)@04 A & A & A & & A A A A : 8
B)%730', )3&'0-,%)$37 4(C4#4% & A A 7 = A 7 A A A & &9 &
B)%730', (037-%&-- F,14% $)@04 &8 &: > ? ; 9 9 7 A 9 ; <7 >
A#)&31 #'%&30%31 62@% -#))(4G1+, 7 A A A A A A A A A A 7 8
A#)&31 $)%,-'($%&31 -)10/%++ -#))(4G1+, A A A 7 A 7 A A & A A ; &A#)&31 4%$30) H@%%0 -#))(4G1+, 7 : 7 A A A A A A 7 A &8 7
A#)&31 83)#)7)-) )#106(F -#))(4G1+, A A A & A A A A A A A & 8
A()&-1'7) )3&'2&%,)$37 )%E6#0E -#))(4G1+, A 9 A : & A A A A A A > 8
A()&-1'7) &3+&-(-,,% B%22(F4#12 -#))(4G1+, 7 = A > A A A A A ; A 77 ;
A()&-1'7) #/&"1'($%&37 )%E4#12 -#))(4G1+, & : = : A A A A A 7 A &> 7
A()&-1'7) 4-&-9% +4(-21$,4 -#))(4G1+, A &? A &; A A A < > &; 7 <; 7;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 16/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ RMWE F=/,)>4),/ -*99*/ 7888 788& 7887 7889 788: 788; 788< 788= 788> 788? 78&8 .(4#2 P#+4 9 Q%#)+
./)%$'9-($%&31 2)+%& L42#041/ +-#E%G1+, A & A A A A A & & A A 9 &
.)&),< &3+%& 6#) M#/* : < &: 7< ; : 7 < < ? & >9 &<
C"(/'131 1%#$)$&-< N%)C@E# /,@6 A & A & A A A A A & A 9 &
>&-)#),$/31 )&%,)$31 61$%B% A & A 7 & A A A A A A : 8
!%0-#/$/"1 ,-8%& 62#/* E@)$(0 ; ;7 && :& 7 78 7 7 A & A &9< &
.)&),< 0383+&-1 62#/* M#/* : > A 7 A A A A 7 < A 77 >
.)&),< #&"1'1 62@% )@00%) ; :: &9 ;8 79 &7 ; ? &; &; && 787 :&
:#),$/3 &31 #'%&30 %31 62@% 4#0$ A & A & A A A A A A A 7 8
.)&),< /-(('1 /)%I#22% M#/* : 77 &8 7: &8 < > < = ; : &8< &<
:#),$/3 &31 #/-& 3&83 1 E(/4()G1+, 7 A A A A A A A A A A 7 8
>'7)#),$/31 ()&3 J)%0/, #0$%2G1+, A 7 A 9 A A A A A 7 A = 7
>'7)#),$/31 ))$31 $)#B #0$%2G1+, A & A A A A A A A A A & 8
E)0-1$%1 #)(&-1#31 $)#B 4)1$$%)G1+, && & A &9 : A A A A A A 7? 8
A(/"&)%,) +)&&)#39) $)%#4 6#))#/@E# 78 9> ? ;7 7< 7< &: ? &: &> &7 79> ::
A(/"&)%,) 83)#/),#/' $@#$@#0/,% & A A A A A A 7 &9 &7 & 7? 7<
:#),$/' 1$&)#- ', ('0 "8',- ) ,(0%B/(C6 /(FG1+, A & A & A A A A A A A 7 8
.)&),< 0)$31 ,()+%O%B% M#/* ; ; & A 9 A & 7 A 7 9 77 ;
.)0)731 +)6',)9' M(24,%#E -()$B 9 A A A A A A 7 & A A < &
B'0'#%,$&31 &3231 2(0$+-10% +H@1))%2G1+, & A A : A A A A 7 A A = 7
:#),$/3 &31 +)/- ),31 (/%#0 +@)$%(0 & A A A A A A A A A A & 8
.),$/-9%&7-1 13220)7%, (/%#0 4)1$$%)G1+, &7 & A 7 & : A A A 7 A 77 7
.)0)731 (%,,)$30) -2@C# -()$B A & A &> ? : & & & A A 9; &
B)0-#/'%&%1 &)9-)$31 -@EE10$F1G% 7 &8 & &; 7 7 A A & A & 9: 7
E)0-1$%1 4%$30) H@%%0 4)1$$%)G1+, < &< 7 : 7 : 7 9 = 9 = ;< &=
50)8)$-1 +-(-,,30)$) )#106(F )@00%) & 7 A 9 A & A & ; A & &: <
!)0)#),$/31 (037-%&- +#0E 412%G1+, A = 9 = < & A A A A A 7: 8
:#),$/' 1$&)#- ', ?3)9 &-#' &,-1 +/)#F2%E /(FG1+, A & A A A A A A A A A & 8
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-?3%$%& +C((4, 4)@0*G1+, A 7 A & A & A A A A A : 8
A(/"&)%,) (-#39-00) +(@4,%)0 +%00%4 = 7 7 9 A A 7 & A & A &> &
E'9-),31 &3231 K-#01+, ,($G1+, A 7 7 A A A A A A 7 & = 9
>1%393(%,%31 7)#30) $31 +-(44%E $(#4G1+, & 7 A A 7 A A A A A A ; 8
;)#$'(/&"1 +-#)39)0-1 +-(44%E 4)@0*G1+, A & A A A & & A A A A 9 8
B'0'#%,$&31 )91#%,1-',-1 +H@1))%2G1+, < > 9 = = & A & : A A 9= :
;)#$'(/&"1 $&-8',31 4)@0*G1+, 7 7 7 &? &> A & & A A A :; 8
!300'-9-#/$/"1 7)&$-,-#31 B%22(F $(#4G1+, & 9 & A : A A & A & A && &
.)&),< +)&$/'0'7)%- B%22(F M#/* & > A & & 7 && 9 & 9 : 9; >
:0%#$-1 #-0-) &-1 LG)1/#0 -(C-#0( A A A & A A A 7 A & A : &
!%8)0'(1 )$0),$-#3 1 4#)-(0 7 7 A & 9 & A & 7 A A &7 7
:0+30) 430 (%1 6(0%G1+, A & 7 & & 9 A 7 A A A &8 8
F&)#/-,'$31 2)0#)$31 -%)C14 7 7 & 7 & & &8 A & & & 77 9
A#'7+%&'7'&31 &%8)0-1 /%)( &8 7& &8 &> &7 &= &9 7: &: &= 7 &;> 99
A%&-'0) 937%&-0- $)%#4%) #C6%)M#/* = & 9 & & 7 A & A A & &= &
A#'7+%&'7'&31 #)4)00) *10$ C#/*%)%2 &8 &7 = > < &7 &; &; ? &7 < &&7 7=
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 17/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ RMRE Q%,%E%;# @$=9#;;2/7 >&=G 93%$,)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 18/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ RMUE >M d%,3<1#,$< 1%@ ;3=G2/7 ,3# J_1 9=/,=+$ &2/#- <M ?%@ => S+#$,= 529=
;3=G2/7 ,3# 1+/292@2=; %/' E#/,329 3%E2,%, ,<@#;)
8
3
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 19/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% &?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ RMWE ?%@ => S+#$,= 529= ;3=G2/7 ,3# >=+$ >2;32/7 $#72=/; %/' 9=$$#;@=/'2/7 @$2/92@%& 1+/292@2=; >=$ ,3# '2>>#$#/,
'%,%E%;#;)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 20/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 78
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
UMS :<>. I!5PV>5PNH VI5FNGN:NLa
T;,21%,2=/ => IE%$- ,3# %.#$%7# &#/7,3 2/ ,3# #Y@&=2,#' @3%;#- $#Z+2$#; '#;27/%,2=/
=> ,3# 12/21+1 9%@,+$# &#/7,3- I9- %E=.# G3293 >2;3#; %$# 7#/#$%&&< $#,%2/#' 2/ ,3#
9%,93 %/' E$=+73, E%9D ,= ,3# '=9D >=$ ;%&#- 9=/;+1@,2=/- #,9) \/ 9%;#; G3#$# >2;3#$<$#7+&%,2=/; ;@#92>< % 12/21+1 %& ;2X#- I9 2; ;#, ,= ,32; ;2X#) \/ 9%;#; G3#$# %
12/21+1 ;2X# 2; /=, $#7+&%,#'- I9 1+;, E# #;,21%,#' >$=1 ,3# 9%,93 '%,%) 1&(",/# UMR;
UMY 2&&+;,$%,# ;%1@&# >$#Z+#/9< '2;,$2E+,2=/; G2,3 I9- IE%$- %/' I2/>eI1%Y >=$ ;#.#/
>=9+; ;@#92#;f $#' 32/'- '=7 ;/%@@#$- ;93==&1%;,#$- E&+#;,$2@#' 7$+/,- &%/# ;/%@@#$-
$#',%2& @%$$=,>2;3- %/' ;,=@&273, @%$$=,>2;3) N3# .%&+#; => I9 G#$# 9%&9+&%,#' >=$ %&&
<#%$; => '%,%- G32&# ,3# &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< $#@$#;#/,; ]+;, ,3# &%;, ,3$## <#%$; VPCC[UPCKCW
E#2/7 ,3# 9+$$#/, ;,%,+;)
TY@&=2,#' @3%;# &#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,% G#$# #Y,$%9,#' >$=1 ,3# ,G= 1%2/ >2;3#$<U
2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7 @$=7$%1;- ,3# (T*?*S @$=7$%1 +,2&2X2/7 ,$%@ %/' E=,,=1 &2/#
7#%$; %/' ,3# 4O** d2=7#=7$%@3< N#%1 '2.#$ .2;+%& ;+$.#<- >=$ ,3# $##> ;@#92#;@$#;#/, 2/ ,3# N\S %/' ?5H(( 9%,93 ;%1@&2/7) d=,3 >2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7
@$=7$%1; G#$# @$#'=12/%,#&< 9=/'+9,#' 2/ ,3# M#;,U(=+,3G#;, $#72=/ V1&(M UMTW)
F=1@%$%E2&2,< => IE%$ #;,21%,#; %1=/7 ,3# .%$2=+; >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, %/' U
2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7 @$=7$%1; G%; #.%&+%,#')
T;,21%,#; => %.#$%7# &#/7,3 ! G#$# 9=1@+,#' +;2/7 ,3# 7#/#$%& $%,2=U=>U1#%/;
#;,21%,=$
==
"
"
"
"
#
$
#
$ % ˆ - VP)KW
G3#$#
! % = ˆ
"# g /+1E#$ => >2;3 1#%;+$#' 2/ ,$2@ # -
$# g ;+11#' &#/7,3 => %&& >2;3 1#%;+$#' 2/ ,$2@ #)
% g /+1E#$ => ,$2@;-
&
# # "
"
= g ;%1@&# 1#%/ => /+1E#$ => >2;3 1#%;+$#'- %/'
&
$
$ "
"= g ;%1@&# 1#%/ => ;+11#' &#/7,3 => 1#%;+$#' >2;3)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 21/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
N3# $%,2= #;,21%,# % ˆ V2)#)- ,3# #;,21%,# => %.#$%7# &#/7,3W G%; ,3#/ +;#' ,= 9=1@+,# ,3#
;%1@&# .%$2%/9#
( )1
ˆ 2
2
−
−
=
& # % $ ' "" - VP)PW
.%$2%/9# => ,3# #;,21%,#-
2
2
) ˆvar( #&
' % = - VP)JW
%/' ;,%/'%$' #$$=$
) ˆvar() ˆ( % %() = ) VP)AW
\&&+;,$%,2.# $#;+&,; => ,3#;# %/%&<;#; %$# ;3=G/ 2/ 1&(",/# UMR;UMY) 5#' 32/'- &%/#
;/%@@#$- %/' ;,=@&273, @%$$=,>2;3 IE%$ #;,21%,#; >=$ ,3# ,3$## 9=/;#9+,2.# <#%$; G#$#
9=1@%$%E&# >=$ ,3# N\S %/' ?5H(( 9%,93 ;%1@&2/7- %/' 2/'29%,#' /= '2$#9,2=/%& E2%; 2/
IE%$ E< '%,% ;=+$9# V1&(",/# UMRJ UMXJ UMYW) \/ 9=/,$%;,- IE%$ #;,21%,#; >=$ '=7 ;/%@@#$
G#$# 3273#$ 2/ N\S 9%,93 ;%1@&2/7 9=1@%$#' ,= ?5H(( 9%,93 ;%1@&2/7 V1&(",/ UMUW
;+77#;,2/7 % '2>>#$#/9# 2/ ;#	,2.2,< @%,,#$/; E#,G##/ ,3# ,G= >&##,;- &2D#&< '+# ,=
.%$2%,2=/ 2/ ,3# @$21%$< 7#%$; +;#')
O+$ %/%&<;#; ;+77#;, ,3%, ,3# 9=11#$92%& %/' ;@=$, >&##,; 2/ S+#$,= 529= %$#
;%1@&2/7 ,3# ;%1# @=@+&%,2=/ => % 72.#/ $##> >2;3 ;@#92#;- %/' ,3%, ;&273, '2>>#$#/9#; 2/
&#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ E#,G##/ ,3# ,G= ;%1@&2/7 @$=7$%1; %$# 1=;,&< % >+/9,2=/ => 3=G
'2>>#$#/, 7#%$; %$# '#@&=<#' 2/ '2>>#$#/, $#72=/; %/' '#@,3 $%/7#;)
*//+%& #;,21%,#; => IE%$ E%;#' ;=&#&< =/ ,3# 9=11#$92%& >&##, '%,%- ,3# &%$7#;, %/'
&=/7#;, ;=+$9# => &#/7,3 9=1@=;2,2=/ '%,%- G#$# /#%$&< 2'#/,29%& ,= IE%$ #;,21%,#; +;2/7
,3# 9=1E2/#' '%,% >$=1 %&& ;=+$9#; %/' %; ;+93 G#$# +;#' %; $#@$#;#/,%,2.# >=$ ,3#
,21#U;#$2#; #;,21%,#; => IE%$) N3#;# G#$# 9=1@+,#' >=$ %&& $##>U>2;3 ;@#92#; +;2/7 ,3#
>=&&=G2/7 @$=9#'+$# >=$ 9%;#; G2,3 ;1%&& ;%1@&# ;2X#;f V2W '%,% G#$# @==&#' >=$ +@ ,=
>=+$ 9=/;#9+,2.# <#%$; 2> ,3#< #%93 9=/,%2/#' &#;; ,3%/ K_ =E;#$.%,2=/; >$=1 &#;; ,3%/ _
,$2@; +/,2& ,3#2$ %77$#7%,# #Y9##'#' ,3#;# ,3$#;3=&';c V22W 2/'2.2'+%& <#%$; G2,3 @==$
'%,% G#$# $#,%2/#' %; 2/'#@#/'#/, #;,21%,#; G2,3 3273 +/9#$,%2/,<- V222W \> &%$7#$ E&=9D;
=> ,21# ;,2&& @=;;#;;#' 2/;+>>292#/, ;%1@&2/7 ,3# ;@#92#; G%; /=, 9=/;2'#$#' >=$ >+&& ,21#U
;#$2#; %/%&<;2;- V2.W 9+$$#/, ;,%,+; #;,21%,#; G#$# ;,2&& 9=1@+,#' 2> @=;;2E&#) (@#92#;
;%1@&# ;2X#; E< <#%$ %$# @$=.2'#' >=$ N\S V5%A-/ RMUW %/' ?5H(( V5%A-/ RMWW '%,%)
N21#U;#$2#; #;,21%,#; => IE%$ >=$ P[ $##>U>2;3 ;@#92#; %$# 72.#/ 2/ 5%A-/ UMR) N3# 9+$$#/,
;,%,+; VPCC[UPCKCW IE%$ #;,21%,#; >=$ JA $##>U>2;3 ;@#92#; %$# 72.#/ 2/ 5%A-/ UMU)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 22/74
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 23/74
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 24/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
5%A-/ UMUE F+$$#/, ;,%,+; VPCC[UPCKCW IE%$ #;,21%,#; >=$ %&& ;@#92#; G2,3 ;+>>292#/,
;%1@&# '%,% >$=1 E=,3 ,3# N\S %/' ?5H(( ;+$.#<;)
H*9G>'I species common a
LC Lmax LbarTIP
LbarMRFSS
!"#$%&"' .%(/)0'(/'0-1 230431 H*/'J 17 220 648.10 255.41 275.87
!"#$%&"' 5(-,%(/%031 #&3%,$)$31 K(4J5LJ 15 200 362.75 262.18
!"#$%&"' 5(-,%(/%031 83$$)$31 +'6 M,/6 17 260 461.66 344.29 336.54
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 +3##),%00) 3>4-N7,/ 9 220 460.10 297.42 293.53
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 #"),'($%&31 H&L'(4 25 240 1179.05 617.00
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ M(/@ O*0 20 250 759.37 399.43 344.21
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ $)1+%@+ K(4J 28 240 708.05 334.21
)*+%%&"' P#/,0(2#1C@+ C#R1C@+ M*07,51 23 240 786.21 368.09
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ +B0#$)1+ .4/' 19 210 534.82 269.78 266.97
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ C#,($#01 P41*0*/J 10 250 420.08 299.60
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ #0#21+ P&))*/ 29 240 918.49 435.20 433.13
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ #-(E@+ Q-1**>945)'( 12 220 504.26 303.45
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 4-4),31 Q,>N 9 220 505.13 332.66 337.15
)*+%%&"' 3,(C6(-214%+ #@)()@6%0+ R'(9,>,*/ 14 200 566.35 253.99 235.06
)*+%%&"' @#"3&31 #/&"13&31 E'>>*S)4,> 14 240 451.22 324.17 314.32
!"$*,' B)%730', 1#-3&31 3>&'5)(,G'6 8 200 375.53 240.34
!"$*,' B)%730', 20)4'0-,%)$37 "('/-1 12 190 259.69 200.82
!"$*,' B)%730', )0+37 P4(04)' 20 210 731.16 316.63
!"$*,' :,-1'$&%731 4-&8-,-#31 %*(N7,51 7 210 381.36 225.28
!"$*,' B)%730', (037-%&- #1,)' 18 200 496.25 250.01-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' .)&),< &3+%& 34( T4-N 20 250 515.72 313.09 316.63-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' .)&),< #&"1'1 3>&' +&//'( 11 220 687.40 357.63 295.49-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' .)&),< /-(('1 H('U4>>' T4-N 18 190 1207.11 520.50-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' :#),$/3&31 #/-&3&831 O*-)*(7,51 11 180 314.69 202.43-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' A(/"&)%,) +)&&)#39) K('4) 34((4-&64 32 350 1690.23 647.73-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' .)&),< 0)$31 M*(5'2'J' T4-N 12 320 784.97 461.70-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' .)0)731 +)6',)9' T*>)1'46 %*(0J 13 180 668.51 253.44-,.&" /&&0
12'.&' E)0-1$%1 4%$30)
V&''/
F(,00'(7,51 13 230 725.52 309.13 337.53
3+""#,02'. A#)&31 $)%,-'($%&31 %(,/-'55 6 240 348.30 255.00
3+""#,02'. A#)&31 4%$30) V&''/ 5 250 527.10 291.76
3+""#,02'. A()&-1'7) #/&"1'($%&37 +'6)4,> 8 240 440.00 270.28
3+""#,02'. A()&-1'7) 4-&-9% Q)*G>,01) 12 220 600.23 274.90 271.00
3&4+526' A#'7+%&'7'&31 &%8)0-1 H'(* 17 380 1770.13 481.97 529.91
3&4+526' A#'7+%&'7'&31 #)4)00) W,/0 P4-N'('> 19.3 450 1302.30 775.23 798.00
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 25/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ UMRE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S h ?5H((- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ $#' 32/')
1&(",/ UMUE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S h ?5H((- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ '=7 ;/%@@#$)
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"
P6#) T3JKK
8
78
:8
<8
>8
&88
&78
&:8
&<8
&>8
788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8 ;88 ;;8 <88 <;8 =88
('6 1,/6X FY%X :;;@2<;
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"P6#) T3JKK
8
7
:
<
>
&8
&7
&:
&<
&>
788 988 :88 ;88 <88 =88 >88 ?88
6*0 5/4GG'(X FY%X :;;@2<;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 26/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ UMWE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ ;93==&1%;,#$)
1&(",/ UMQE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ E&+#;,$2@#' 7$+/,)
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"
8
&8
78
98
:8
;8
<8
=8
>8
?8
788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8 ;88 ;;8 <88 <;8 =88
5-1**>945)'(X FY%X :;;@2<;
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"
8
78
:8
<8
>8
&88
&78
&;8 788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8
L>&'5)(,G'6 0(&/)X FY%X :;;@2<;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 27/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ UMXE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S h ?5H((- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ &%/# ;/%@@#$)
1&(",/ UMZE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ $#',%2& @%$$=,>2;3)
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"
P6#) T3JKK
8
&88
788
988
:88
;88
<88
=88
&;8 788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8 ;88 ;;8 <88 <;8
>4/' 5/4GG'(X FY%X :;;@2<;
P/ P10G PC#RP6#) .S"
8
78
:8
<8
>8
&88
&78
&:8
&<8
&>8
788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8 ;88 ;;8 <88
+'6)4,> %4((*)7,51X FY%X :;;@2<;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 28/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ UMYE I#/7,3 >$#Z+#/9< '%,% VN\S- PCC[UPCKCW- E=+/'2/7 I9UI1%Y $%/7#- %/'
9%&9+&%,#' IE%$ VN\S h ?5H((- PCC[UPCKCW >=$ $#',%2& @%$$=,>2;3)
P/ P10G PC#R
P6#) .S"
P6#) T3JKK
8
78
:8
<8
>8
&88
&78
&:8
&<8
788 7;8 988 9;8 :88 :;8 ;88 ;;8 <88 <;8
Q)*G>,01) %4((*)7,51X FY%X :;;@2<;
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 29/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 7?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ UMTE ?%@ => S+#$,= 529= ;3=G2/7 >2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, ;%1@&2/7 ;2,#;) 5#' '=,;
2/'29%,# (T*?*S ;2,#; %/' 7$##/ '=,; 2/'29%,# 4O** d2=0#= ;2,#;)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 30/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 98
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
WMS 5FIN.a N1 :IHL5F;<>!IG !5N*b >!!I!!VIH5
\/'29%,=$; %$# /##'#' ,= %;;#;; $##> >2;3#$2#; %/' ,= ;+@@=$, ,3# 21@#/,%,2=/ =>
%/ #9=;<;,#1 %@@$=%93 ,= >2;3#$2#; V"#//2/7; PCC_c F+$< h F3$2;,#/;#/ PCC_W) N3#
@$2/92@%& ;,=9D %;;#;;1#/, 2/'29%,=$ .%$2%E&# G# +;#' ,= Z+%/,2>< @=@+&%,2=/ ;,%,+; >=$,3# 9=11+/2,< => S+#$,= 529%/ $##> >2;3#; G%; %.#$%7# &#/7,3 V ! W => ,3# #Y@&=2,#' @%$,
=> ,3# @=@+&%,2=/- G3293 2; % 1#,%E=&29UE%;#' 2/'29%,=$ ,3%, 2; 3273&< 9=$$#&%,#' G2,3
@=@+&%,2=/ ;2X# Vd#.#$,=/ h ^=&, KL_ic 529D#$ KLBJc S%+&< h ?=$7%/ KL[ic T3$3%$', h
*+&, KLLPc j#$$ h Q29D2# PCCKc "#//2/7; &' ()* PCCiW) H=$ #Y@&=2,#' ;@#92#;- ! '2$#9,&<
$#>	,; ,3# $%,# => >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< ,3$=+73 %&,#$%,2=/; => ,3# @=@+&%,2=/ ;2X# ;,$+9,+$#
Vd#.#$,=/ h ^=&, KL_ic k+2// h Q#$2;= KLLLW) N3#=$#,29%&&<- ! %, ,21# ' 2; #Y@$#;;#' %;
=
*
*
+
+
+
+
,+- + . /0-1
,+- + !- + . - /
- !),(
),(),()(
)(
λ
- aKb
G3#$# *+ 2; ,3# 12/21+1 %7# %, >2$;, 9%@,+$#- λ + ,3# =&'#;, %7# 2/ ,3# ;,=9D- +,(- '. ,3#
%E+/'%/9# >=$ %7# 9&%;; ( - /,(- '. ,3# &#/7,3 %, %7# ( %/' 0,'. 2; ,3# 2/;,%/,%/#=+; >2;32/7
1=$,%&2,< $%,# %, ,21# ') \/ @$%9,29#- ! 2; +;+%&&< #;,21%,#' >$=1 &#/7,3; 2/ ,3# $%/7# =>
&#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# * ! V=$ $#9$+2,1#/, ,= ,3# #Y@&=2,#' @3%;# => ,3# ;,=9DW ,= ,3#
1%Y21+1 =E;#$.#' &#/7,3 λ ! - ,3# &#/7,3 => % >2;3 %, λ + ) 0,'. 9=+&' %&;= E# ,3# .2#G2/7
@=G#$ => '2.#$; 2/ >2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, .2;+%& ;+$.#<; => $##> >2;3 @=@+&%,2=/; V*+&, &'
()* KLL[W):;2/7 #;,21%,#; => ! 2/ ,21# ' - ,=,%& 2/;,%/,%/#=+; 1=$,%&2,< $%,# )( ˆ - 2 %$#
#;,21%,#' +;2/7 ,3# 1#,3=' => T3$3%$', %/' *+&, VKLLPW
( ) ( )( ) ( ))()()( ˆ
)()()( ˆ)( ˆ
- ! !- ! !- 2
- ! ! 3 - ! !- 2
! !
! ! * 3
- 2
* −+−
−+−=
−
−
∞
∞
∞
∞
λ
λ - aPb
G3#$# j %/'∞
! %$# @%$%1#,#$; => ,3# .=/ d#$,%&%/>>< 7$=G,3 #Z+%,2=/) T;,21%,#; =>
8 %$# 9=1@+,#' +;2/7 %/ 2,#$%,2.# /+1#$29%& %&7=$2,31 V9=1@+,#$ @$=7$%1 Id*5c
*+&, &' ()* KLLBc H*O aH==' %/' *7$29+&,+$# O$7%/2X%,2=/ => ,3# :/2,#' 4%,2=/;b
PCCJW) */ 2&&+;,$%,2.# 7$%@3 => ,3# $#&%,2=/;32@ E#,G##/ %.#$%7# ;2X# 2/ ,3#
#Y@&=2,#' @3%;# VIE%$W %/' >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< $%,# VHW 2; ;3=G/ 2/ 1&(M WMR)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 31/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ WMRM; TY@#9,#' @$=7$#;;2=/ => %.#$%7# ;2X# 2/ ,3# #Y@&=2,#' @3%;# '#@#/'#/, => 2/;,%/,%/#=+;
>2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< $%,#)
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2
!"#$"%& ()*+,-"+. /,+0
1 2 0 * , & 0
3 " 4 0
5 6 7 8 9 9 :
0.00
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
486 556 626 696 766 836 906 976 1046 1116 1186 1256
70%&+$ 599:
! * 0 ; < 0 % = .
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
4 86 5 56 6 26 6 96 7 66 8 36 9 06 9 76 1 0 4 6 1 11 6 1 18 6 1 25 6
6)+,- -0%&+$ 599:
! * 0 ; < 0 % = .
0.000
0.005
0.010
0.015
0.020
486 556 626 696 766 836 906 976 1046 1116 1186 1256
70%&+$ 599:
! * 0 ; < 0 % = .
7"&$+-. >?@-)"+0A
(3B >?@-)"+,+")%
C<**0%+ >?@-)"+,+")%
DEF#0*2,F-0G 1##0##90%+ H%A"=,+)* I,*",F-0
!"#$%& !(#) *+,-./ 0 1""2
(3#4%& 1(#) *+,-./ 0 5 62
7$#!%& 7"#1 *+,-./ 0 76#12
=
*
*
+
+
+
+
,+ .0+4-1 /0-1
,+- + !- + . - /
- !
λ
),(),()(
)(
89:9;<; =>?@* -9A>B(! 9:CD>,E
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 32/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 97
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
QMS 3N3]:>5PNH;GaH>VP*! G>5> @ !N].*I!
I2># 32;,=$< @%$%1#,#$; >=$ 1%Y21+1 %7#- 7$=G,3 %/' 1%,+$2,< >=$ ,3# $##> >2;3
;@#92#; 9=/;2'#$#' V5%A-/ QMRW G#$# =E,%2/#' >$=1 ,3# &2,#$%,+$# ;</,3#;#; => *+&, &' ()*
VKLL[- PCC_1W %/' F&%$= &' ()* VPCCKW)
5%A-/ QMRf I2>#U32;,=$< ,$%2, 2/@+, @%$%1#,#$; >$=1 &2,#$%,+$# ;</,3#;#; => *+&, &' ()* VKLL[- PCC_1W %/'
F&%$= &' ()* VPCCKW- %/' $#;+&,2/7 @=@+&%,2=/ 1=$,%&2,< %/' ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< E#/931%$D; #;,21%,#' >$=1
/+1#$29%& 1='#&; >=$ #Y@&=2,#' S+#$,= 529%/ $##> >2;3#;)
TY%1@&# 7$=G,3 %/' ;+$.2.=$;32@ >+/9,2=/; %$# ;3=G/ 2/ 1&(M QMR) *7#U;@#92>29>+/9,2=/; => &#/7,3- G#273,- E2=1%;;- %/' >#9+/'2,< %$# ;3=G/ >=$ $#' 32/' 2/ 1&(M QMU)
5#&%,2=/;32@; E#,G##/ ,3# ;@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= %/' ,3# >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< $%,# %,
1%Y21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %$# @&=,,#' >=$ % .%$2#,< => $##>U>2;3 ;@#92#; 2/ 1&(M QMW)
5#&%,2=/;32@; E#,G##/ 1%Y21+1 ;2X# %/' /%,+$%& 1=$,%&2,< $%,# %/' 7$=G,3 $%,# %$#
;3=G/ 2/ 1&(M QMQ)
H*9G>'I species common a
K Linf a0 Winf Lm tm LC tc Lmax β
M M/K SPRmsy
!"#$%&"' .%(/)0'(/'0 -1 230431 H*/'J 17 0.145 698.9 - 1.080 1.489 185 13 220 18 648.1 7.29E- 05 2.570 0.176 1.215 36.16
!"#$%&"' 5(-,%(/%031 #&3%,$)$31 K(4J5LJ 1 5 0 .1 30 4 15 .0 - 0. 94 0 1 .1 36 1 65 2 00 4 9 3 62 .7 1 .2 2E- 05 3 .0 44 0 .2 00 1 .5 36 4 7. 42
!"#$%&"' 5(-,%(/%031 83$$)$31 +'6 M,/6 17 0.200 471.4 - 2.397 1.752 329 44 260 19 461.7 1.80E- 04 2.614 0.176 0.881 34.16
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 +3##),%00) 3>4-N7,/ 9 0.084 729.7 - 2.896 2.755 260 29 220 17 460.1 4.07E- 05 2.735 0.333 3.977 32.08
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 #"),'($%&31 H&L'(4 25 0.160 1200.0 - 0.300 34.928 28 240 13 1179.1 1.32E- 05 3.060 0.120 0.749 20.94
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ M(/@ O*0 20 0.100 854.0 - 2.000 10.181 229 14 250 18 759.4 4.28E- 05 2.857 0.150 1.498 33.30
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ $)1+%@+ K(4J 28 0.136 722.3 - 0.863 5.248 230 24 240 25 708.0 3.05E- 08 2.881 0.107 0.787 35.21
)*+%%&"' P#/,0(2#1C@+ C#R1C@+ M*07,51 23 0.080 912.6 - 1.776 14.101 249 240 25 786.2 3.44E- 05 2.910 0.130 1.632 31.51
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ +B0#$)1+ .4/' 19 0.097 618.3 - 1.728 3.245 206 30 210 31 534.8 4.52E- 05 2.815 0.158 1.632 36.26
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ C#,($#01 P41*0*/J 1 0 0 .0 97 6 18 .3 - 1. 72 8 3 . 17 7 1 30 2 50 43 4 20 .1 8 .1 8E- 05 2. 71 9 0 .3 00 3 .0 88 6 1. 92
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ #0#21+ P&))*/ 29 0.129 938.7 - 0.738 14.023 276 24 240 19 918.5 1.57E- 05 3.011 0.103 0.801 31.91
)*+%%&"' P@4M#0@+ #-(E@+ Q-1**>945)'( 12 0.180 570.0 0.000 4.061 246 20 220 33 504.3 8.16E- 04 2.430 0.250 1.387 38.90
)*+%%&"' ;3$6),31 4-4),31 Q,>N 9 0.092 781.1 - 2.309 4.100 304 37 220 15 505.1 3.70E- 05 2.781 0.333 3.618 26.25
)*+%%&"' 3,(C6(-214%+ #@)()@6%0+ R'(9,>,*/ 1 4 0 .1 44 6 50 .0 - 0. 23 8 3 .3 98 2 73 2 00 28 5 66 .3 9 .5 5E- 09 3. 04 0 0 .2 14 1 .4 86 3 1. 02
)*+%%&"' @#"3&31 #/&"13&31 E'>>*S)4,> 14 0.170 483.8 - 1.870 1.535 199 16 240 26 451.2 7.75E- 05 2.718 0.214 1.259 45.58
!"$*,' B)%730', 1#-3&31 3>&'5)(,G'6 8 0 .3 00 4 1 3. 0 0 .0 00 1 .4 96 2 0 5 2 00 2 6 3 75 .5 2 .0 0E- 05 3 .0 10 0 .3 74 1 .2 48 4 2. 12
!"$*,' B)%730', 20)4'0-,%)$3 7 "('/-1 1 2 0 .1 79 2 9 4. 0 0 .0 00 0 .5 65 1 77 1 90 7 0 2 59 .7 9 .0 6E- 06 3 .1 58 0 .2 50 1 .3 95 5 8. 96
!"$*,' B)%730', )0+37 P4(04)' 20 0.174 752.6 - 0.450 8.575 428 53 210 17 731.2 1.52E- 05 3.042 0.150 0.861 28.07
!"$*,' :,-1'$&%731 4-&8-, -#31 %*(N7,51 7 0 .4 40 3 9 7. 0 - 0. 35 0 1 .7 21 2 3 1 2 10 1 6 3 81 .4 1 .0 1E- 05 3 .1 67 0 .4 28 0 .9 73 3 9. 05
!"$*,' B)%730', (037-%&- #1,)' 1 8 0 .1 86 5 1 1. 9 - 0. 77 6 3 .0 62 1 8 0 2 00 2 3 4 96 .2 8 .3 5E- 06 3 .1 61 0 .1 66 0 .8 95 3 6. 14
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' . )&),< &3+%& 34( T4-N 20 0.240 520.0 0.000 2.649 240 31 250 33 515.7 4.28E- 06 3.237 0.150 0.624 39.76
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' . )&),< #&"1'1 3>&' +&//'( 11 0.260 724.0 - 0.480 5.282 391 30 220 11 687.4 1.07E- 04 2.690 0.272 1.047 28.89
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' .)&),< /-(('1 H('U4>>' T4-N 18 0.160 1271.0 - 0.690 29.368 648 45 190 4 1207.1 9.55E- 05 2.734 0.166 1.040 24.15
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' :#),$/3&31 #/-&3&831 O*-)*(7,51 11 0.254 332.0 - 0.630 0.960 194 32 180 29 314.7 1.19E- 06 3.533 0.272 1.072 39.31
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' A(/"&) %,) +)&&)#3 9) K('4) 34((4-&64 32 0.090 1780.0 -1.190 42.946 877 77 350 15 1690.2 4.11E-06 3.083 0.094 1.040 25.32
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' .)&),< 0)$31 M*(5'2'J' T4-N 12 0.240 826.0 - 0.510 20.118 440 31 320 18 785.0 4.76E- 06 3.300 0.250 1.040 31.68
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' .)0)731 +)6',)9' T*>)1'46 %*(0J 13 0.220 704.0 - 0.580 7.035 381 36 180 9 668.5 6.67E- 05 2.818 0.230 1.047 26.49
-,.&" /&&0 12'.&' E)0-1$%1 4%$30) V&''/ F(,00'(7,51 13 0.230 759.0 - 0.570 11.194 408 33 230 12 725.5 2.73E- 05 2.990 0.230 1.002 28.36
3+""#,02'. A#)&31 $)%,-'($%&31 %(,/-'55 6 0.480 366.0 - 0.310 0.575 212 18 240 23 348.3 6.55E- 05 2.709 0.499 1.040 55.63
3+""#,02'. A#)&31 4%$30) V&''/ 5 0.600 551.0 - 0.230 2.258 306 13 250 9 527.1 1.35E- 05 3.000 0.599 0.999 35.19
3+""#,02'. A()&-1'7) #/&"1'($%&37 +'6)4,> 8 0 .6 24 4 43 .0 0 .0 00 1 .4 66 2 51 2 40 1 5 44 0. 0 1. 07 E- 05 3 .1 00 0 .3 74 0 .6 00 4 1. 65
3+""#,02'. A()&-1'7) 4-&-9% Q)*G>,01) 1 2 0 .3 45 6 1 0. 0 0 .0 00 3 .8 44 3 3 7 2 20 1 6 6 00 .2 3 . 80 E- 05 2. 90 0 0 .2 50 0 .7 25 3 3. 45
3&4+526' A#'7+%&'7'&31 &%8)0-1 H'(* 17 0.170 1864.0 -0.580 45.986 914 41 380 9 1770.1 3.20E- 05 2.800 0.176 1.037 26.41
3&4+526' A#'7+%&'7'&31 #)4)00) W,/0 P4-N'('> 19.3 0.150 1370.0 -0.750 18.706 693 47 450 23 1302.3 8.83E-06 2.973 0.155 1.035 30.56
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 33/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 99
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ QMRE 0$=G,3 %/' 1=$,%&2,< '#@#/'#/, =/ %7# @=@+&%,2=/ '#1=7$%@329 $#&%,2=/;32@; >=$ % ,<@29%& S+#$,= 529= $##> >2;3)
0
50
100
150
200
250
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
0 50 100 150 200 250
F o r k L e n g t h ( c m
)
Fork Length (cm) Age (years)
Reef Fish Population Demographics
W e i g h t ( k g )
8A88
8A7;
8A;8
8A=;
&A88
& ; ? &9 &= 7 & 7 ; 7? 99 9 = :& :; :? ;9
Age (years)
A b u n d a n c e F r e q u e n c y
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 34/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ QMUE \/,#$U$#&%,2=/;32@; => 7$=G,3 %/' 1=$,%&2,< '#@#/'#/, =/ %7# 2/ ,3# 9=/,#Y, =>@=@+&%,2=/ E2=1%;; %/' >#9+/'2,< V$#@$='+9,2.# @=,#/,2%&W >=$ $#' 32/'- % ,<@29%& S+#$,= 529=
$##> >2;3)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 35/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ QMWE T;,21%,#' ;@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= V(S5W %, 1%Y21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' V?(lW '#@#/'#/, =/ H1;< >=$ P_ #Y@&=2,#'
;@#92#; V7$=+@#$; g '%$D 92$9&#;- ;/%@@#$; g ;3%'#' 92$9&#; %/' 7$+/,; g =@#/ 92$9&#;W >$=1 S+#$,= 529=) N3# 3=$2X=/,%& '%;3#' &2/# 2;
,3# JCm (S5 :(* >#'#$%& ;,%/'%$' >=$ ;+;,%2/%E2&2,<)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 36/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ QMQE 5#&%,2=/;32@; E#,G##/ 1%Y21+1 ;2X# VG#273, 2/ D7W %/' V(W /%,+$%& 1=$,%&2,< $%,# 2
V<UKW- %/' V1W d$='< 7$=G,3 9=#>>292#/, 3 V<UKW >=$ P_ ;@#92#; V7$=+@#$; g '%$D 92$9&#;- ;/%@@#$; g
;3%'#' 92$9&#; %/' 7$+/,; g =@#/ 92$9&#;W => S+#$,= 529%/ 9=$%& $##> >2;3)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 37/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
XMS H]VI.P*>: 3N3]:>5PNH VNGI:PHL
M# +;#' % ;,=93%;,29 &#/7,3UE%;#' /+1#$29%& @=@+&%,2=/ 1='#& V*+&, h O&;=/ KLLBc
*+&, &' ()* KLL[W ,= 9%&9+&%,# #/;#1E&# /+1E#$; %, 72.#/ &#/7,3; γ . ~
=.#$ ,21# >=$ %
72.#/ 9=3=$, γ - 7#/#$%&2X#' %;~
)|()()()(),(~
−=λ
θ τ γ γ γ
+
+5
,++ ! 6 ++( + %- ! . - aJb
G3#$# )( + % −τ γ 2; 9=3=$, $#9$+2,1#/, &%77#' E%9D ,= E2$,3 '%,#- 4,(. 2; ;+$.2.=$;32@ ,=
%7# ( - θ ,(. 2; % &=72;,29 1='#& => ;#Y $%,2= %, %7# ,= %99=+/, >=$ 3#$1%@3$='2,29 &2>#
32;,=$2#; 9=11=/ ,= ,$=@29%& $##> >2;3#;- %/' 5,/6(. 2; ,3# @$=E%E2&2,< => E#2/7 &#/7,3 /
72.#/ ,3# >2;3 2; %7# () N32; @=@+&%,2=/ 1='#& ;21+&%,#; ,3# ,21#U,$%/;2,2=/ => $#9$+2,; ,=
1%,+$# %'+&,; ,= 1%Y21+1 ;2X#U%7# +;2/7 % /+1E#$ => '</%129 >+/9,2=/; ,= $#7+&%,#
@=@+&%,2=/ E2$,3- 7$=G,3- %/' ;+$.2.=$;32@ @$=9#;;#;- 2/9&+'2/7 >2;3#$< 3%$.#;,;
V'#,%2&; 2/ *+&, &' ()) KLL[W) * 9=/9#@,+%& >&=G93%$, => ,3# 5TTH( 1='#& 2; ;3=G/ 2/ 1&(M
XMR)
1&(",/ XMRE H&=G93%$, => ,3# 5TTH( V5##> T9=;<;,#1 TY@&=2,#' H2;3#$< (21+&%,2=/W 1='#&)
M# 9%&2E$%,#' ,3# /+1#$29%& 1='#& VTZ) JW ,3$=+73 % 9=/;2;,#/9< 93#9D E#,G##/
1='#& #;,21%,#; => ! - +;2/7 2 ˆ >$=1 TZ) VPW %; ,3# 2/@+,- %/' ,3# ! ˆ #;,21%,#' >$=1
'%,%) *''2,2=/%&&<- G# #.%&+%,#' ,3# ,G= 1%]=$ 9=1@=/#/,; => 7 - /%1#&< >2;32/71=$,%&2,< $%,# 0 %/' /%,+$%& 1=$,%&2,< $%,# 2) \/ ,32; @$=9#;;- G# #;,21%,#' 2 >$=1
&2>#;@%/ %@@&<2/7 ,3# @$=9#'+$# => *&%7%$%]% VKL[Ac 8&%89 ^=#/27 KL[JW %;;+12/7 ,3%,
_m => % 9=3=$, ;+$.2.#; ,= ,3# 1%Y21+1 %7#e;2X#- %/' 0 G%; #;,21%,#' E< ;+E,$%9,2/7
2 >$=1 7 V*+&, &' ()) KLL[W) M# +;#' ,3# 9%&2E$%,#' 1='#& ,= 9=1@+,# 1%/%7#1#/,
E#/931%$D; => ;,=9D ;,%,+; ,= #.%&+%,# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< 2/ ,3# >=&&=G2/7 %/%&<,29%& @$=9#;;)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 38/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
ZMS !]!5>PH><P:P5a <IH*FV>.b! >HG .I!N].*I .P!b >H>:a!I!
ZMR G/#4,&8$&+'
(+;,%2/%E2&2,< %/%&<;#; 2/.=&.#' 9=1@%$2;=/ => .%$2=+; @=@+&%,2=/ 1#,$29; %,9+$$#/, &#.#&; => >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,< %7%2/;, ;,%/'%$' >2;3#$< 1%/%7#1#/, ;+;,%2/%E2&2,<
E#/931%$D;) M# 9=/>27+$#' ,3# ;21+&%,2=/ 1='#& ,= %;;#;; ;#.#$%& $#>#$#/9# @=2/,; ,=
%''$#;; ;#.#$%& ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< $2;D;- 2/9&+'2/7 >2;3#$< <2#&';- ;@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2=
V(S5c F&%$D KLLKW %/' @$#9%+,2=/%$< 9=/,$=& $+&#; V>=$ #Y%1@&# 5#;,$#@= h S=G#$;
KLLLW) (2/9# @=@+&%,2=/ E2=1%;; :,(-'. 2; ,3# @$='+9, => /+1E#$;U%,U%7# ,21#; G#273,U%,U
%7# ;,(-'. - <2#&' 2/ G#273, 78 >$=1 % ;@#92#; '+$2/7 %/ 2/;,%/, ' G%; 9%&9+&%,#' %;
==
λ λ !
!
!
!
*7
* *
,!- + !9 - + ! . - / ,!- + ! :- / - ! / 8 ),|(),|()(),|()(),,( ) aAb
M# =E,%2/#' %/ 21@=$,%/, 1#%;+$# => ;,=9D $#@$='+9,2.# @=,#/,2%&- ;@%G/2/7 ;,=9D
E2=1%;; V((dW %, % 72.#/ &#.#& => >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,<- E< 2/,#7$%,2/7 =.#$ 2/'2.2'+%&; 2/ ,3#
@=@+&%,2=/ E#,G##/ ,3# ;2X# => ;#Y+%& 1%,+$2,< V ; ! c _Cm 1%,+$2,<- %;;+1#' D/2>#U
#'7#'W %/' ,3# 1%Y21+1 ;2X# V λ ! W
=
λ !
!;
,!- + ! :- ((: ),|()( ) a_b
?%Y21+1 ;@%G/2/7 E2=1%;; 2; =E,%2/#' +/'#$ 9=/'2,2=/; => /= >2;32/7 1=$,%&2,<)
(@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= V(S5W 2; % 1%/%7#1#/, E#/931%$D ,3%, 1#%;+$#; % ;,=9DR;
@=,#/,2%& ,= @$='+9# <2#&'; =/ % ;+;,%2/%E&# E%;2;- %/' 2; 9=1@+,#' %; ,3# $%,2= =>
9+$$#/, 44:,'. $#&%,2.# ,= ,3%, => %/ +/#Y@&=2,#' ;,=9D)
dunexploite
exploited
((:
((:(6% = ) aBb
T;,21%,#' (S5; G#$# 9=1@%$#' ,= :(* H#'#$%& ;,%/'%$'; G3293 '#>2/# JCm (S5 %; ,3#
,3$#;3=&' E#&=G G3293 % ;,=9D 2; /= &=/7#$ ;+;,%2/%E&# %, 9+$$#/, #Y@&=2,%,2=/ &#.#&; V;##
0%E$2#& &' ()* KL[Lc 5#;,$#@= &' ()) KLL[W) T.%&+%,2=/ => 9=/,$=& $+&#; 2/.=&.#'
'#,#$12/%,2=/ => H1;< VH 7#/#$%,2/7 1%Y21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&'- ?(lW %/' d1;< V@=@+&%,2=/ E2=1%;; %, ?(lW V1&(M ZMRMRW) M# '#>2/#' H g ? %; % @$=Y< >=$ H1;< Vk+2// h
Q#$2;= KLLLc 5#;,$#@= h S=G#$; KLLLW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 39/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% 9?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMRMRE F=/9#@,+%& '2%7$%1 ;3=G2/7 &212, %/' ,%$7#, 9=/,$=& $+&#;) N%$7#, 9=/,$=&
$+&#; ;@#92>< '#;2$%E&# &#.#&; => >2;32/7 >=$ ;+;,%2/%E&# ;,=9D; V>=$ #Y%1@&# HVOlW ,3%,
@$='+9#; =@,21%& <2#&' OlW) I212, 9=/,$=& $+&#; '#>2/# ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< E#/931%$D; =$ %
9+,U=>> %E=.# G3293 ,3#$# 2; %/ +/%99#@,%E&# $2;D => ;#$2=+; =$ 2$$#.#$;2E&# 3%$1 ,= ,3#$#;=+$9# %/' $#Z+2$#; ;,$=/7 1%/%7#1#/, 2/,#$.#/,2=/) \> ,3# 1%Y21+1 >2;32/7
1=$,%&2,< ,3$#;3=&' V?H?N- #Z+2.%&#/, ,= ,3# HV?(lW &212, 2/ =+$ %/%&<;2;W 2; #Y9##'#'-
,3#/ 1%/%7#1#/, %9,2=/; 2/ ,3# >=$1 => $#'+9,2=/; 2/ H V=$ $#E+2&'2/7 @&%/;W 1+;, E#
21@#/,#' ,= $#.#$;# ,3# ;2,+%,2=/ %/' 1=.# ,3# ;,=9D ,= ,3# &=G#$ $273, Z+%'$%/,
Vded1;< n K %/' HeH1;< o KW) * 1=$# @$#9%+,2=/%$< 9=/,$=& $+&#- %; ;+77#;,#' E< 5#;,$#@=
%/' S=G#$; VKLLLW- 2; ,= ;#, ,3# ,3$#;3=&' ?H?N `;%>#&< E#&=GR ,3# ?(l &212, V>=$
#Y%1@&# HVOlWg ?H?N g C)i_ × HV?(lWW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 40/74
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 41/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMUMRE F+$$#/, ;,%,+; VPCC[UPCKCW >=$ %&& %;;#;;%E&# ;@#92#; 2/ ,3# VN\SW '%,%E%;#)
H27) B)P)Pf (S5 +/'#$ #Z+2&2E$2+1 #Y@&=2,%,2=/ %, HgH1;< >=$ %&& %;;#;;%E&# ;@#92#; 2/ ,3#)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 42/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMUMWE F+$$#/, ;,%,+; VPCC[UPCKCW ;@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= >=$ %&& ;@#92#; G2,3
%.%2&%E&# '%,%)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 43/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
ZMW F&#$+,&4 I[8-+&$%$&+' @ !"#$%&'%A&-&$B </'42?%,7# +0 1+4"# !8/4&/#
* +;#$U>$2#/'&< ;=>,G%$# @%9D%7#- ?=$,%&2,< %/' *;;#;;1#/, %/' (,=9D (21+&%,2=/
N==& V?*(NW- G%; '#.#&=@#' ,= >%92&2,%,# ,$%2/2/7 => Q4T5 @#$;=//#& 2/ %@@&<2/7
;+;,%2/%E2&2,< E#/931%$D %/%&<;#; ,= S+#$,= 529= $##>U>2;3#; V>88/'=&[ >W) H=&&=G2/7%$# ?*(N =+,@+, 7$%@329; >$=1 &#/7,3UE%;#' ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< %/%&<;#; %@@&2#' ,= ;#.#/
>=9+; ;@#92#;f $#' 32/'- '=7 ;/%@@#$- ;93==&1%;,#$- E&+#;,$2@#' 7$+/,- &%/# ;/%@@#$-
$#',%2& @%$$=,>2;3- %/' ;,=@&273, @%$$=,>2;3)
ZMWMR ./= 2&'=
1&(",/ ZMWMRMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/'
I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 44/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ::
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMRMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMRMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 45/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMRMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMRMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 46/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
ZMWMU G+( #'%88/,
1&(",/ ZMWMUMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMUMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 47/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMUMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
1&(",/ ZMWMUMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 48/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMUMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
ZMWMW !42++-?%#$/,
1&(",/ ZMWMWMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 49/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% :?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMWMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMWMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 50/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;8
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMWMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMWMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,= =@,21+1
;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 51/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
ZMWMQ <-"/#$,&8/= L,"'$
1&(",/ ZMWMQMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMQMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 52/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMQMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
1&(",/ ZMWMQMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 53/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMQMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
ZMWMX :%'/ #'%88/,
1&(",/ ZMWMXMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 54/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMXMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMXMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 55/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMXMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMXMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 56/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
ZMWMZ ./=$%&- 3%,,+$0
1&(",/ ZMWMZMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMZMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 57/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMZMWE T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
1&(",/ ZMWMZMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 58/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMZMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
ZMWMY !$+8-&(2$ 3%,,+$0
1&(",/ ZMWMYMRE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ /+1E#$; +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 59/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% ;?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMYMUE l2#&' @#$ $#9$+2, 2/ G#273, +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMYMWf T+1#,$29 &2/#) F%&9+&%,#; ,3# &#/7,3 %, >2$;, 9%@,+$# ,3%, =E,%2/; ,3#
1%Y21+1 <2#&' >=$ #.#$< @=,#/,2%& .%&+# => H)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 60/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <8
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ ZMWMYMQE (@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= +/'#$ %&& 9=/'2,2=/; => #Z+2&2E$2+1 H %/' I9)
1&(",/ ZMWMYMXE *//+%& #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,# G2,3 L_m 9=/>2'#/9# E=+/'; $#&%,2.# ,=
=@,21+1 ;+;,%2/%E&# <2#&' %, Hg? +;2/7 VN\SW '%,% >$=1 VKL[[UPCKCW)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 61/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
YMS GP!*]!!PNH @ 1]5].I N33N.5]HP5PI! c .I*NVVIHG>5PNH!
N3# $#;+&,; => ,32; %;;#;;1#/, 9=/,2/+# ,= ;+@@=$, ,3# 9=/9&+;2=/ ,3%, ,3# 1%]=$2,< =>
;@#92#; 2/ ,3# S+#$,= 529%/ >2;3#$< %$# ;27/2>29%/,&< =.#$ #Y@&=2,#') N3#;# @=@+&%,2=/;
G2&& E#/#>2, 7$#%,&< >$=1 '#9$#%;#' >2;32/7 @$#;;+$# %/' 2/9$#%;#' 12/21+1 ;2X# =>#Y@&=2,%,2=/) N3#$# '=#; %@@#%$ ,= E# #.2'#/9# ,3%, ,32; 2; =99+$$2/7 =$7%/29%&&< G2,32/
,3# 9=11#$92%& >2;3#$< %; ;##/ 2/ ,3# N\S '%,%) N3# $#,2$#1#/, => =&'#$ 9=11#$92%&
>2;3#$; 3%; /=, E##/ 1%,93#' E< /#G #/,$2#; &#%'2/7 ,= % 9=/;2;,#/, '#9$#%;# 2/ #>>=$,- 2/
9=/9#$, G2,3 ,32; % ;32>, 2/ 7#%$; >$=1 ,$%@ ,= 3==D %/' &2/#e;@#%$ 3%; ,%D#/ ;27/2>29%/,
@$#;;+$# =>> => ,3# ;1%&&#;, 2/'2.2'+%&; ,3$=+73 ,3# 2/3#$#/, '2>>#$#/9#; 2/ 7#%$
;#	,2.2,< @%,,#$/) ^=G#.#$ 1%/%7#1#/, %9,2=/ 2; ;,2&& $#Z+2$#' %; 1%/< ;@#92#; %$#
;,2&& 3273&< =.#$#Y@&=2,#') *&;= => 1%]=$ 9=/9#$/ 2; ,3# $#9$#%,2=/%& >2;32/7 >&##,- G3293
%, @$#;#/, 3%; &212,#' 21@%9, E+, @=;;#;;#; ,3# @=,#/,2%& >=$ $%@2' #Y@%/;2=/ G3293
G=+&' /#7%,# %/' @=;;2E&< $#.#$;# ,3# @=;2,2.# ,$#/'; E#2/7 ;##/ >$=1 ,3# 93%/72/7
9=11#$92%& >2;3#$<) S%$,29+&%$ 9=/9#$/ ;3=+&' E# 72.#/ ,= ,3# @%$$=,>2;3 9=1@&#Y G3293'2;@&%< #Y,$#1# =.#$#Y@&=2,%,2=/ %/' ,3# 7$=+@#$ 9=1@&#Y G3293 G32&# .2$,+%&&< %E;#/,
;,2&& 1%D# 2/,#$12,,#/, %@@#%$%/9# 2/ ,3# 9%,93 '%,% ;+77#;,2/7 ,3%, ,3#2$ @=@+&%,2=/;
3%.# %&$#%'< +/'#$7=/# 9=&&%@;# E+, 1%< =/9# 3%.# E##/ %; @$=&2>29 %; ,3#< %$# %, =,3#$
&=9%,2=/; 2/ ,3# F%$2EE#%/)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 62/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
N3# >=&&=G2/7 >27+$#; V1&(#M YMR;YMWW G2&& >%92&2,%,# '2;9+;;2=/ => %@@&29%,2=/; =>
&#/7,3UE%;#' %;;#;;1#/, 1#,3='; ,= S+#$,= 529= $##>U>2;3#; %/' >+,+$# 9=&&%E=$%,2.#
$#;#%$93 =@@=$,+/2,2#;)
1&(",/ YMRf lS5 %/' (S5 %; % >+/9,2=/ => H)
!"#$0*. 3<#+,"%,F"-"+. J0="#")% (0+*"=#
FG>HI9,D9:? B7"2 -./E
J,K9;@K> H@:?>1443 L (""3
. H M N M H K 9 M :
M I 8 @ O 9 ; < ;
P9>*Q
-./R8-P
8-P
S9,D9:? 8MHK@*9KT /@K> BSE
P;@O
S;,T
)0(
)(
= / ((:
/ ((:-./0
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 63/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
1&(",/ YMUE F=1@%$%,2.# ;@%G/2/7 @=,#/,2%& $%,2= V(S5W %/%&<;2; >=$ JP #Y@&=2,#' $##> >2;3 ;@#92#; >$=1
,3# S+#$,= 529%/ 9=$%& $##> #9=;<;,#1 >=$ ,3# @#$2=' PCC[pPCKC) 5#' E%$; 2/'29%,# =.#$>2;3#' ;,=9D;- E&+#
E%$; 2/'29%,# ;,=9D; ,3%, %$# %E=.# ,3# _Cm (S5- %/' <#&&=G E%$; 2/'29%,# ,3%, ;,=9D; %$# E#,G##/ PCU_Cm
(S5)
1&(",/ YMWE HeH1;< $%,2= .#$;+; ded1;< $%,2= >=$ ,3# JP ;@#92#; %/%&<;#' >=$ ,3# <#%$; PCC[pPCKC)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 64/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
>*bHN6:IGLIVI5H!
M# ,3%/D F$%27 I2&<#;,$=1- S+#$,= 529= Q#@, => 4%,+$%& %/' T/.2$=/1#/,%&
5#;=+$9#;- %/' *2'% 5=;%$2= %/' Q%/2#& ?%,=;- Q4T5 H2;3#$2#; 5#;#%$93 I%E=$%,=$<-
>=$ ,3#2$ %;,+,# ,#93/29%& %;;2;,%/9# 2/ =E,%2/2/7 >2;3#$<U2/'#@#/'#/, %/' >2;3#$<U'#@#/'#/, '%,%E%;#; %/' >=$ 1%/%72/7 &=72;,29; => ,3# ,G= ;#,; => $#72=/%& G=$D;3=@;)
M# %&;= ,3%/D N=/< F3%,G2/- ?293#&&# S29= %/' T$2/ Q+77%/ => ,3# 4%,2=/%& H2;3 %/'
M2&'&2># H=+/'%,2=/ V4HMHW >=$ ,3#2$ ;+@@=$, %/' #/9=+$%7#1#/, => ,32; @$=]#9,) N32;
$#;#%$93 G%; ;+@@=$,#' E< 4HMH 0$%/, qPCKCUCCAUPCCC)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 65/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <;
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
.I1I.IH*I!
*&%7%$%]%- j) VKL[AW (21@&# 1#,3='; >=$ #;,21%,2=/ => @%$%1#,#$; >=$ %;;#;;2/7
#Y@&=2,#' >2;3 ;,=9D;) <%=#(% >?9@%() ?A 0#8B&@#&8 WRf KiipPC[)
*+&,- ") () h O&;=/- Q) d) VKLLBW * 1+&,29=3=$, ;,=9D @$='+9,2=/ 1='#&) C@(%8(D'#?%8 ?A'B& EF&@#D(% 0#8B&@#&8 4?D#&'$ RUXf JAJpJBJ)
*+&,- ") ()- ?90%$.#<- 5) 4)- 5=,3;932&'- d) ") h F3%.%$$2%- ") VKLLBW (,=9D %;;#;;1#/,
9=1@+,#$ %&7=$2,31;) \/f 4'?DG E88&88F&%'H I9(%'#'('#J& 2&'B?=8 (%= EKK)#D('#?%8 A?@
4F()) 4D()& 0#8B&@#&8 - #') 6) H) 0%&&+992- (%2&%- ()- 0+;,%>;=/- Q) h 5=,3;932&'- d) ")- @@)
_CKp_K_) I#G2; S+E&2;3#$; VQ2.2;2=/ => F5F S$#;;W- F3#&;#%- ?\)
*+&,- ") ()- d=3/;%9D- ") *) h ?##;,#$- 0)) VKLL[W * $#,$=;@#9,2.# VKLiLpKLLBW 1+&,2;@#92#;
%;;#;;1#/, => 9=$%& $##> >2;3 ;,=9D; 2/ ,3# H&=$2'% j#<;) 0#8B&@$ :9))&'#%- L4 - dZf JL_p
AKA)
*+&,- ") ()- (12,3- () 0) h d=3/;%9D- ") *) VPCC_EW T.%&+%,2=/ => %.#$%7# &#/7,3 %; %/
2/'29%,=$ => #Y@&=2,%,2=/ ;,%,+; >=$ ,3# H&=$2'% 9=$%& $##> >2;3 9=11+/2,<) <MN4
>?9@%() ?A 2(@#%& 4D#&%D& ZUf AKiUAPJ)
*+&,- ") ()- ()0) (12,3- %/' ")*) d=3/;%9D) PCC_) T.%&+%,2=/ => %.#$%7# &#/7,3 %; %/
2/'29%,=$ => #Y@&=2,%,2=/ ;,%,+; >=$ ,3# H&=$2'% 9=$%& $##> >2;3 9=11+/2,<) \FT(
"=+$/%& => ?%$2/# (92#/9# BPf AKiUAPJ)
*+&,- ")()- ()0) (12,3- ") I+=- ?)T) ?=/%9=- %/' 5)() *@@#&'==$/) PCC[) I#/7,3UE%;#'
%;;#;;1#/, => ;+;,%2/%E2&2,< E#/931%$D; >=$ 9=$%& $##> >2;3#; 2/ S+#$,= 529=)T/.2$=/1#/,%& F=/;#$.%,2=/ J_VJWf PPKUPJK)
d#.#$,=/- 5) ") ^) h ^=&,- () ") VKL_iW O% 'B& P$%(F#D8 ?A N"K)?#'&= 0#8B 5?K9)('#?%8)
?2/2;,$< => *7$29+&,+$#- H2;3#$2#; %/' H=='- H2;3#$< \/.#;,27%,2=/; (#$2#; \\- 6=&+1#
KL) I=G#;,=>,- T/7&%/') _JJ @@)
F&%$D- M) 0) VKLLKW 0$=+/'>2;3 #Y@&=2,%,2=/ $%,#; E%;#' =/ &2># 32;,=$< @%$%1#,#$;)
M(%(=#(% >?9@%() ?A 0#8B (%= EQ9('#D 4D#&%D&8 QTf iJAUi_C
F&%$=- 5)- I2/'#1%/- j) F) h S%$#/,2- I) 5) VPCCKW ND?)?R$ ?A 'B& 2(@#%& 0#8B&8 ?A M91()
(12,3;=/2%/ \/;,2,+,2=/ S$#;;- M%;32/7,=/- Q)F) P_J @@)
F+$<- S) ?) h 6) F3$2;,#/;#/ VPCC_W k+%/,2,%,2.# #9=;<;,#1 2/'29%,=$; >=$ >2;3#$2#;
1%/%7#1#/,) <MN4 >?9@%() ?A 2(@#%& 4D#&%D& ZUeWff JCiUJKC)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 66/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <<
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
T3$3%$',- 4) ?) h *+&,- ") () VKLLPW */%&<;2; => ,G= &#/7,3UE%;#' 1=$,%&2,< 1='#&;
%@@&2#' ,= E=+/'#' 9%,93 &#/7,3 >$#Z+#/92#;) C@(%8(D'#?%8 ?A 'B& EF&@#D(% 0#8B&@#&8
4?D#&'$ RURf KK_pKPP)
H*O VH==' %/' *7$29+&,+$# O$7%/2X%,2=/W) VPCCJW 0#4EC <<H 0EOS<M/ET2 8'?DG(88&88F&%' '??)8* L8&@U8 R9#=& - #') H) F) 0%<%/2&=- S) (@%$$#- %/' Q) S%+&<) H*O- 5=1#)
^=#/27- ")?) VKL[JW T1@2$29%& +;# => &=/7#.2,< '%,% ,= #;,21%,# 1=$,%&2,< $%,#;) 0#8B&@$
:9))&'#% TUeRff [L[ULCJ)
"#//2/7;- () VPCC_W \/'29%,=$; ,= ;+@@=$, %/ #9=;<;,#1 %@@$=%93 ,= >2;3#$2#;) 0#8B (%=
0#8B&@#&8 Zf PKPUPJP)
"#//2/7;- ()- Q# O&2.#2$%- ")*)*) h M%$$- j)") VPCCiW ?#%;+$#1#/, => E='< ;2X# %/'
%E+/'%/9# 2/ ,#;,; => 1%9$=#9=&=729%& %/' >==' G#E ,3#=$<) >?9@%() ?A E%#F() ND?)?R$
YZf iPU[P)
j#$$- () 5) h Q29D2#- I) ?) VPCCKW CB& :#?F(88 4K&D'@9FH ( 5@&=('?@V5@&$ CB&?@$ ?A EQ9('#D
5@?=9D'#?%) F=&+1E2% :/2.#$;2,< S$#;;) 4#G l=$D)
k+2//- N) ") h Q#$2;=- 5) d) VKLLLW I9(%'#'('#J& 0#8B P$%(F#D8) OY>=$' :/2.#$;2,< S$#;;)
_AP @@)
5#;,$#@=- 6) 5) h S=G#$;- ") T) VKLLLW S$#9%+,2=/%$< 9=/,$=& $+&#; 2/ :)() >2;3#$2#;
1%/%7#1#/,f ;@#92>29%,2=/; %/' @#$>=$1%/9#) <MN4 >?9@%() ?A 2(@#%& 4D#&%D& XZf [ABp
[_P)
529D#$- M) T) VKLBJW d27 #>>#9,; >$=1 ;1%&& 9%+;#;f ,G= #Y%1@&#; >$=1 >2;3 @=@+&%,2=/
'</%129;) >?9@%() ?A 'B& 0#8B&@#&8 T&8&(@DB :?(@= ?A M(%(=( USf P_ipPBA)
S%+&<- Q) h ?=$7%/- 05)- #'; VKL[iW /&%R'BV:(8&= 2&'B?=8 #% 0#8B&@#&8 T&8&(@DB*
\FI*5? F=/>#$#/9# S$=9##'2/7; 6=&+1# KJ) ?%/2&%- S32&2@@2/#;f \/,#$/%,2=/%&
F#/,#$ >=$ I2.2/7 *Z+%,29 $#;=+$9#; 1%/%7#1#/,f AB[@@)
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 67/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <=
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
>33IHGP\E ?*(N ?='#& Q#;9$2@,2=/ h :;#$R; 0+2'#
P8!Z8. "[+ P[+F8.YFE 8QQ\QQP\!F 8!O QF[HW QYPZ.8FY[! F[[.
]P8QF^
U%)+1(0 &A8 O L@$@+4 784,
V 78&&
L@4,()+W T#)/ D#E(0V D#4,#0 U#@$,#0V X%))B L@24
")($)#CC%)+W DA U#@$,#0V TA D#E(0
Y01I%)+14B (G T1#C1V 3(+%0+41%2 K/,((2 (G T#)10% #0E L4C(+-,%)1/ K/1%0/%
SD.35ZY[.S5D
TLK.#$$)%$#4%+ #22 #0#2B41/#2 4((2+ 0%/%++#)B G() 4,% C#0#$%C%04 (G %R-2(14%E G1+, -(-@2#41(0+ 6#+%E
(0 2%0$4, C()4#214B %+41C#4%+ #0E -)%+%04+ 4,%+% 10 # @+%)OG)1%0E2B I1+@#2 104%)G#/%A TLK. 1+ /(E%E 10
XLUL =AS4 1+ /(C-(+%E (G 9 $%0%)#2 +%/41(0+W &\ 2%0$4,O6#+%E C()4#214B %+41C#41(0V 7\ 4,%()%41/#2 C(E%2+
4( G10E (-41C#2 G1+,10$ )%$@2#41(0+V #0E 9\ %R-2(14%E -(-@2#41(0 +1C@2#4()A S4 F122 #2+( +((0 ,#I% 4,%
/#-#61214B (G )@0010$ +4(/,#+41/ -)(/%++%+ 4,)(@$, T(04% [#)2( +1C@2#41(0 10 ()E%) 4( %I#2@#4%
@0/%)4#104B #0E )1+* #++(/1#4%E F14, C#0#$%C%04 +/%0#)1(+A
T()4#214BV C#4@)#41(0V #0E $)(F4,O)#4%+ #)% E%0+14BO10E%-%0E%04 ](0 4,% )%/)@14%E
-(-@2#41(0\A3%/)@14C%04 /#0 6% %14,%) E%0+14BO10E%-%0E%04 () OE%-%0E%04 ]4,)(@$, # +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04
)%2#41(0+,1-\A
.,% @+%) 104%)G#/% #0E C()4#214B %+41C#4()+ F%)% /(E%E 6B DA U#@$,#0 F,12% 4,% -(-@2#41(0 EB0#C1/+
C(E%2+ #0E +1C@2#41(0 4((2F%)% C#102B /(E%E 6B TA D#E(0V #22 @0E%) 4,% +@-%)I1+1(0 #0E $@1E#0/% (G
Z)A X%))B L@24A
& O^_D_3LP SDJ53TL.S5D
.STSD^
L22 41C% +4%- /(C-@4#41(0+ 10 TLK. #)% 10 E#B+ ]1A%A G1+, #$%+ #0E +1C@2#4%E 41C%+\A L22 B%#)2B
-#)#C%4%)+ ]%A$A `V TV %4/A\ #)% #@4(C#41/#22B /(0I%)4%E 104( E#12B -#)#C%4%)+ 6B E1I1E10$ 6B 9<; ]()
(4,%) /(0I%)+1(0 +4%-+\A "#)#C%4%)+ )%2#4%E 4( 4)#0+141(0#2 C#0#$%C%04 +/%0#)1(+ ]%A$A 4)#0+141(0#2
G1+,10$ C()4#214B () C101C@C +1a%O#4OG1)+4O/#-4@)%\ #)% #2+( /(0I%)4%E 104( E#12B 41C% +4%-+A .,% E#12B
41C% +4%-+ #22(F G() $)%#4 G2%R161214B 10 4,% +-%/1G1/#41(0 (G C#4@)14BV )%/)@14C%04V #0E C()4#214B 4%C-()#2
-#44%)0+ ]%A$A +%#+(0#2 /2(+@)%V -%)1(E1/ )%/)@14C%04\A b(F%I%)V TLK. (02B /@))%042B #22(F+ 10-@4+ 10
B%#)2B 10/)%C%04+A
T53.LPS.Q
J1+, /(,()4+ %04%) #22 /(C-@4#41(0#2 C#4)1/%+ #4 +%442%C%04 ]1A%A 4)#0+141(0 G)(C -%2#$1/ 2#)I#% 4(
6(44(CO () )%%GO#++(/1#4%E G1+,\A .,% 0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+ /#0 %14,%) 6% +-%/1G1%E 4,)(@$, # +4(/*O
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 68/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <>
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
)%/)@14C%04 )%2#41(0+,1- () /#0 6% G1R%E #4 # +-%/1G1/ I#2@% ]+%% &%#&3-$7%,$ +%/41(0 6%2(F\A 50/% 4,%
10141#2 0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+ 1+ +-%/1G1%EV TLK./#2/@2#4%+ 10141#2 0@C6%) 10 %#/, E#12B #$% $)(@- @+10$ #0
%R-(0%041#2 C()4#214B G()C@2#W
.,%+%+4#)410$ D I#2@%+ /#0 6% /(0I%)4%E 4(#I%)#$% 0@C6%)+V F,%0 0%%E%EV@+10$ 4,% G(22(F10$
%H@#41(0W
D#4@)#2 C()4#214B )#4%+ #)% %14,%) +-%/1G1%E 6B 4,% @+%) () #)% E%)1I%E G)(C %+41C#4%+ (G 2(0$%I14B @+10$
%14,%) # )@2%O(GO4,@C6+ #--)(#/, 4,#4 #++@C%+ 4,#4 &c () ;c (G -(-@2#41(0 0@C6%)+ #)% 2%G4 #4
C#R1C@CA .,1+ 4)#0+2#4%+ 104( 4,% G(22(F10$ $%0%)#2 %H@#41(0W
F,%)% K 1+ 4,% +@)I1I()+,1- 4( #$% 4 ]8A8& () 8A8;\A L ;c +@)I1I()+,1- 1+ # C()% /(0+%)I#41I% %+41C#4% (G
0#4@)#2 C()4#214B #0E 1+ +%4 #+ 4,% E%G#@24 10 TLK.A
J1+,10$ C()4#214B D 1+ (64#10%E 6B C@241-2B10$ 4,% ('$%,$-)0 G1+,10$ C()4#214B )#4% ]1A%A 4,% 10+4#04#0%(@+
C()4#214B /(%GG1/1%04 (G # G@22B #I#12#62% #$% $)(@-V F,1/, 1+ -)(I1E%E 6B @+%)+\ 6B 4,% $%#) +%2%/41I14B A
F,1/, )%-)%+%04+ 4,% G)#/41(0 (G #0 #$% $)(@- 4,#4 1+ I@20%)#62% 4( G1+,10$A
',%)% H 1+ 4,% /#4/,#61214B /(%GG1/1%04 ]1A%A -)(-()41(0 (G +4(/* /#@$,4 6B # +10$2% @014 (G G1+,10$ %GG()4\V G
1+ 4,% G1+,10$ %GG()4V #0E K 1+ +%2%/41I14B #4 #$% $ AJ1+,10$ C()4#2141%+ 6%2(F C101C@C #$%O#4OG1)+4O/#-4@)%
#0E #6(I% C#R1C@C (6+%)I%EO#$% ]1A%A 4\ #)% #@4(C#41/#22B +%4 4( a%)( ]*01G%O%E$% +%2%/41(0 1G
+%2%/41I14B 1+ +%4 4( & G() #22 #$% $)(@-+\A
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 69/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% <?
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
^35'.b
TLK. /@))%042B (02B ,#+ 4,% (-41(0 (G @+10$ 4,% U(0 N%)4#2#0GGB $)(F4, %H@#41(0 4( E%4%)C10% 2%0$4,O
#4O#$%A
'%1$,4O#4O#$% ]'4\ 1+ (64#10%E G)(C /(0I%)410$ 2%0$4,+ 104( F%1$,4+ @+10$ 4,% %H@#41(0W
SC-()4#04W 14 1+ /)141/#2 4( @+% 4,% -)(-%) L #0E N /(%GG1/1%04 G() +-%/1G1/ 2%0$4, #0E F%1$,4 @014+A T(+4
-@621+,%E L #0E N I#2@%+ /(0I%)4 2%0$4, 10 -9 104( F%1$,4 10 0(495A TLK. F122 /(0I%)4 4,(+% F%1$,4+
104( *12($)#C+ 6B E1I1E10$ 6B &888 ]#22 F%1$,4V 61(C#++ (@4-@4+ #)% 10 *$\A '% 4,%)%G()% ,1$,2B
)%/(CC%0E 10-@4410$ #22 2%0$4, 10G()C#41(0 10 /C ]%A$A P 10G V P/V PC#RV %4/A\A S4 1+ -(++162% 4( 10-@4 2%0$4,
10G()C#41(0 10 (4,%) @014+ ]%A$A CC\ 1G 4,% -)(-%) L #0E N /(%GG1/1%04 #)% @+%E ]1A%A 4,(+% 4,#4 F122 (@4-@4
F%1$,4 10 $)#C+\A
S4 1+ #2+( /)141/#2 4( @+% 4,% +#C% C%#+@)%C%04 (G G1+, 2%0$4, G() #22 10-@44%E E#4# ]%A$A G()*V +4#0E#)EV ()4(4#2 2%0$4,\A
TL.Y3S.Q
Y+%)+ /#0 %04%) %14,%) #$%O () +1a%O#4OC#4@)14B ]TLK. F122 #@4(C#41/#22B /(0I%)4 (0% 4( 4,% (4,%)\A
T#4@)14B 1+ /@))%042B +%4 4( 6% *01G%O%E$%E ]1A%A &88c (G # /(,()4 )%#/,%+ C#4@)14B #4 # +-%/1G1/ #$% ()
+1a%\A L 2($1+41/ /@)I% C#B 6% #I#12#62% 10 G@4@)% I%)+1(0+V 1G 4,% 0%%E #)1+%+A
3_[3YS.T_D.
J() +1C-21/14BV )%/)@14C%04 2%I%2+ #)% (G4%0 +%4 #4 # G1R I#2@% #0E #++@C%E 4( 6% E%0+14BO10E%-%0E%04V
%+-%/1#22B 1G +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ 1+ *0(F0 4( 6% #4 # +#G% 2%I%2 ]K"3 d 98c\AL24%)0#41I%2BV )%/)@14C%04
/#0 6% E%-%0E%04 (0 +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ ]KKN\A[@))%04 )%/)@14C%04 ]34\ 1+ $%0%)#22B #++@C% 4( 6% #
G@0/41(0 (G 4,% +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ ]KKN\ #4 # /%)4#10 41C% 10 4,% -#+4 %H@1I#2%04 4( ,#4/,10$ 41C% e
-%2#$1/ 2#)I#2 +4#$% E@)#41(0 ]E\A
.,% N%I%)4(0Ob(24 I%)+1(0 (G 4,1+ $%0%)#2 %H@#41(0 ]31/*%)f+ %H@#41(0 F122 6% #I#12#62% +((0\ 1+W
Y+10$ J)#0/1+ ]&??7\f+ )%O-#)#C%4%)1a#41(0V4,% 4F( -#)#C%4%)+ (G 4,1+ %H@#41(0 /#0 6% E%G10%E #+
F,%)%N8 1+ #0 %+41C#4% (G -)1+410% +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++V 38 1+ 0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+ #4 N8V/1+ 4,%
+4%%-0%++ (G 4,% 10141#2 +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04 /@)I% ]1A%A G)#/41(0 (G 38 /())%+-(0E10$ 4( +-#F010$ +4(/*
61(C#++ #4 78c N8\A .( @+% 4,1+ +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04 )%2#41(0+,1-V @+%)+ 0%%E 4( E%G10% 6(4, N8 #0E /A .,%B
#2+( 0%%E 4( 10-@4 4,% 2#)I#2 E@)#41(0 10 E#B+ ]1A%A 41C% 6%4F%%0 +-#F010$ %I%04 #0E +%442%C%04\A
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 70/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =8
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
K-#F010$ +/,%E@2% 1+ /@))%042B +%4 4( 6% /(0410@(@+ 4,)(@$,(@4 4,% B%#)V 6@4 %R4)# G@0/41(0#214B F122 6%
#EE%E 2#4%)V F14, 4,% /#-#61214B 4( E%G10% )%/)@14C%04 +%#+(0#214B C()% -)%/1+%2BA
N%2(F #)% %R#C-2%+ (G N%I%)4(0Ob(24 +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04 /@)I%+ F14, I#)B10$ +4%%-0%++ /A
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 71/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =&
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
7 O P_D^.bONLK_Z T53.LPS.Q _K.STL.S5D
N_U_3.5DOb5P. T5Z_P
N%I%)4(0 #0E b(24 ]&?;:\ F%)% 4,% G1)+4 4( E%)1I% #0 %H@#41(0 )%2#410$ #I%)#$% 2%0$4, 10 4,% /#4/, ]P6#)\4( 4(4#2 C()4#214B ]g\A
b(F%I%)V _,),#)E4 #0E L@24 ]&??7\ G(@0E 4,1+ C(E%2 4( 6% 61#+%E 6%/#@+% (G 4,% 104%$)#41(0 4( 10G1014%
#$% ]1A%A 10G2@%0/%E 6B 4,%()%41/#2V I%)B (2EV G1+, 4,#4 #)% 0%I%) -)%+%04 10 /#4/, )%/()E+\A .,1+ C(E%2 1+
0(4 #I#12#62% 10 TLK. E@% 4( 4,1+ -)(62%CA
LYP.O_b3bL3Z. T5Z_P
L@24 #0E _,),#)E4 ]&??&\ -)(-(+%E # 4)@0/#4%E I%)+1(0 (G 4,% N%I%)4(0Ob(24 C(E%2 4,#4 +%4+ # )%#21+41/
@--%) 21C14 G() C#R1C@C 2%0$4,+ ]PC#R () P\A L+ +@/,V 4,1+ C(E%2 4#*%+ #0 %R4)# -#)#C%4%) ]4 () P\A
.,1+ C(E%2 E(%+ 0(4 ,#I% 4,% +#C% 61#+ #+ 4,% N%I%)4(0Ob(24 C(E%2V 6@4V #+ F14, 4,% NOb C(E%2V 14 E(%+
#++@C% %H@1216)1@C /(0E141(0+ ]1A%A +4#62% )%/)@14C%04 #0E C()4#2141%+ E@)10$ # 41C% -%)1(E 2(0$ %0(@$,
G() +4(/* #$% +4)@/4@)% 4( 6% +4#62%\A
ULY^bLDOLYP. T5Z_P
L0 1C-)(I%E C(E%2 1+ /@))%042B @0E%) E%I%2(-C%04 4,#4 F122 6% #62% 4( E%#2 F14, 0(0O%H@1216)1@C
C()4#214B /(0E141(0+A .,1+ C(E%2 F122 C%)$% 4,% +1a%O4)@0/#4%E C(E%2 (G _,),#)E4 #0E L@24 ]&??7\ F14,
4,% 0(0O%H@1216)1@C C(E%2 E%I%2(- 6B ^%E%C*%Ob(%01$ ]F,1/, 1+ 6#+%E (0 4,% N%I%)4(0Ob(24 C(E%2
#0E 4,@+ +@GG%)+ G)(C 4,% +#C% -(4%041#2 61#+\A .,1+ 4((2 1+ 0(4 /@))%042B #I#12#62% 10 TLK. &A8A
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 72/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =7
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
9 O .b_53_.S[LP T5Z_PK YK_Z .5 _K.STL._ 5".STLP TLDL^_T_D.
3_^YPL.S5DK
50/% /@))%04 G1+,10$ C()4#214B )#4%+ #)% %+41C#4%EV 14 1+ -(++162% 4( -#)#C%4%)1a% I#)1(@+ C(E%2+ 10 ()E%)
4( %+41C#4% /@))%04 +4(/* +4#4@+ #0E -)%G%)#62% C#0#$%C%04 4#)$%4+A SG )%/)@14C%04 1+ +%4 #4 # G1R 2%I%2V
@+%)+ /#0 )@0 B1%2EO-%)O)%/)@14 ]Q"3\ #0E +-#F010$ -(4%041#2 )#41( ]K"3\ #0#2B+%+A SG # +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04
G@0/41(0 1+ E%G10%EV @+%)+ /#0 )@0 C(E%2+ 10 4%)C+ (G #6+(2@4% B1%2EV F,1/, 4#*% 4,% %GG%/4 (G )%E@/%E
+-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ (0 )%/)@14C%04 ]#0E B1%2E\ 104( #//(@04A .,%+% C(E%2+ #22 #++@C% 4,#4 #
-(-@2#41(0 ,#+ )%#/,%E %H@1216)1@CA
QS_PZO"_3O3_[3YS.
TLK. /#2/@2#4%+ Q"3 10 h-1%/%OF1+%i G#+,1(0 6B #--2B10$ 4,% C()4#214B %H@#41(0+ E%G10%E #6(I% 4( #
G1R%E 0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+ ]%A$A &888\ #22 4,% F#B 4( C#R1C@C #$% ]4\V @+10$ E#12B 10/)%C%04+A Q"3 1+
/#2/@2#4%E #4 %#/, E#12B #$% 6B C@241-2B10$ #I%)#$% 61(C#++ 6B G1+,10$ C()4#214B JV +@CC10$ #22 E#12B
B1%2E+V #0E E1I1E10$ 6B 4,% ()1$10#2 0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+A
Q"3 1+ /#2/@2#4%E G() # 2#)$% 0@C6%) (G /(C610#41(0+ (G 2%0$4,O#4OG1)+4O/#-4@)% ]P/\ #0E G1+,10$ C()4#214B
)#4%+ ]J\A K-%/1G1/#22BV Q"3+#)% /#2/@2#4%E G)(C P/ j & /C 4( PC#R 10 PC#Rk&88 10/)%C%04+V #0E G)(C J j 8 4(
7A; 10 10/)%C%04+ (G 8A87;A .,% Q"3+ G() #22 4,%+% /(C610#41(0+ #)% %R-()4%E G)(C TLK. #0E /#0 6%
-2(44%E 10 _R/%2 () (4,%) +(G4F#)% ]+%% %R#C-2%+ #4 4,% %0E (G 4,1+ +%/41(0\A
K"3
TLK. /#2/@2#4%+ +-#F010$ -(4%041#2 )#41( ]K"3\ 10 # +1C12#) F#B #+ G() Q"3A N1(C#++ 1+ /#2/@2#4%E #4 %#/,
E#12B #$% #0E +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ 1+ +1C-2B 4,% +@C (G #22 61(C#++ #6(I% 4,% #$% #4
C#4@)14BAK-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ 1+ /#2/@2#4%E #+
F,%)%'4 1+ 4,% #I%)#$% F%1$,4O#4O#$%A K-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ 1+ /#2/@2#4%E#4 -)1+410% 2%I%2+ ]N8\ #0E
@0E%) I#)1(@+ C#0#$%C%04 +/%0#)1(+ ]P/V J\V +1C12#)2B 4( Q"3A K"3 1+ 4,%0 /#2/@2#4%E G() E1GG%)%04 2%I%2+
(G P/ #0E J 6B E1I1E10$ +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ @0E%) %R-2(14#41(0 6B -)1+410% +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++A
K"3 1+(-2%4, $)#-,+ /#0 6% -)(E@/%E G)(C 4,% TLK. (@4-@4V +1C12#)2B 4( Q"3 1+(-2%4, ]+%% %R#C-2%
6%2(F\A
LNK5PY._ QS_PZ 'S.b UL3SLNP_ 3_[3YS.T_D.
SG # )%/)@14C%04 G@0/41(0 1+ E%G10%EV B1%2E /#0 6% /#2/@2#4%E 10 #6+(2@4% 4%)C+A TLK. G1)+4 /#2/@2#4%+ 4,%
0@C6%) (G )%/)@14+ %04%)10$ 4,% -(-@2#41(0 @0E%) %H@1216)1@C /(0E141(0+ ]1A%A G() +-%/1G1/ P/ #0E J
I#2@%+\A .,% G(22(F10$ %H@#41(0 1+ @+%E
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 73/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =9
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
F,%)% #0E #)% -#)#C%4%)+ (G 4,% N%I%)4(0Ob(24 +4(/*O)%/)@14C%04 %H@#41(0A J)(C 4,% %H@1216)1@C
)%/)@14C%04 2%I%2V 4,% +4)@/4@)% (G 4,% -(-@2#41(0 #4 %H@1216)1@C 1+ E%)1I%E G)(C F,1/, #6+(2@4% B1%2E
/#0 6% /#2/@2#4%EAL+ G() Q"3 #0E K"3V #6+(2@4% B1%2E 1+ /#2/@2#4%E G() I#)1(@+ /(C610#41(0+ (G P/ #0E J
#0E /#0 6% -2(44%E 10 _R/%2A
N%2(F #)% %R#C-2%+ (G K"3 ]2%G4\ #0E #6+(2@4% B1%2E ])1$,4\ $)#-,+ /)%#4%E 10 K1$C#"2(4A
8/21/2019 Ault Et Al_Stock Assessment Report2013
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ault-et-alstock-assessment-report2013 74/74
!"#" %&'()* +,-* .'/0)12345'6 +''7 ",51'(,'5 855'559'/) :;<= "#$% =:
'()*+,(- .%/,01/#2 3%-()4 5/4(6%) 78&9
: O _l"P5S._Z "5"YPL.S5D KSTYPL.S5D
TLK. 10/2@E%+ -(-@2#41(0 +1C@2#41(0 /#-#612141%+ F,1/, #22(F @+%)+ 4( 4)#/* P6#)V B1%2EV () K"3 G()F#)E
4,)(@$, 41C% 10 E#12B 41C% +4%-+ #//()E10$ 4( I#)1(@+ C#0#$%C%04 +/%0#)1(+ ]1A%A P/ #0Ek() J /,#0$10$ #4
I#)1(@+ 41C%+\A .( @+% 4,1+ 4((2V @+%)+ 0%%E 4( -)(I1E% I%/4()+ (G %R-%/4%E mG@4@)%f B%#)2B /,#0$%+ 10 J
#0E P/A
.,% +1C@2#41(0 /#0 6% )@0 F14, G1R%E )%/)@14C%04V +%4 #4 # +-%/1G1%E 2%I%2A S4 /#0 #2+( 6% )@0 F14, # +4(/*O
)%/)@14C%04 G@0/41(0 #G4%) +-%/1GB10$ -)1+410% +-#F010$ +4(/* 61(C#++ ]N8\V+4%%-0%++ ],\V #0E -%2#$1/
2#)I#% E@)#41(0A
D(4%W TLK. 1+ /#-#62% (G )@0010$ -(-@2#41(0 +1C@2#41(0+ G()F#)E 4,)(@$, 41C% G() # ]4,%()%41/#22B\
@021C14%E 0@C6%) (G E#12B 41C% +4%-+V $1I%0 +(C% 6#+1/ /(C-@4%) C%C()B /#-#/14B ]1A%A #4 2%#+4 7;<
C6\A TLK. E%4%)C10%+ #I#12#62% C%C()B 4( XLUL #0E E1I1E%+ 4,% +1C@2#41(0 4#+* 10 C#0#$%#62% 62(/*+A
.,% C()% C%C()B # /(C-@4%) ,#+V 4,% 2#)$%) 4,% 41C% 62(/*+ #0E 4,% G#+4%) 4,% +1C@2#41(0 F122 )@0
4,)(@$, /(C-2%41(0A
N%2(F 1+ #0 %R#C-2% (G # TLK.+1C@2#41(0 (@4-@4 6#+%E (0 T@44(0 +0#--%) 21G% ,1+4()B ]P/ j 988 CC\A
J 8 &
Jj8A:
J 8 =