Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

46

Transcript of Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 1/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 2/45

This is ALI-ABA  www.ali-aba.orgA nonprot endeavor providing continuing professional education for lawyers since 1947

How It All Started

In 1947 the American Bar Association (ABA) asked

the American Law Institute (ALI) to collaborate inorganizing a national program of continuing edu-

cation of the bar. ALI, founded in 1923 in part “to

promote the clarication and simplication of the

law,” was engaged in restating the law and drafting 

codes and model laws. ALI agreed to take on the

task. The rst of a series of Memoranda of Under

standing between the parent organizations placed

primary responsibility with ALI and provided for

a joint committee to oversee ALI-ABA activities.

An initial Carnegie grant carried the operation for

about eight years when the program becameas it

remainsself-sustaining.

What It Does Today

ALI-ABA’s multimedia approach to continuing legal

education comprises a comprehensive range of edu-

cational materials and services described below.

ALI-ABA Online

ALI-ABA makes its programs and publications avail-able directly to the ofce, laptop, and portable devices from

www.ali-aba.orgwith the added conveniences of 

licensing, browsability, sampling, and downloadable

forms.  Subscriptions to libraries are available, orga-

nized by areas of practice.

Live Courses and Programs by Webcast

and Telephone

ALI-ABA’s more than 200 courses of study and pro-

grams via live webcast are attended each year bytens of thousands of lawyers and others in related

professions. The faculties for these courses consist

primarily of practicing lawyers who volunteer their

time and expertise and, in many cases, forgo reim-

bursement of their out-of-pocket expenses to lecture

and prepare written materials for the benet of their

professional colleagues. Although concentrated in

the areas of business and commercial law, securities,

taxation and estate planning, real estate, and gov-

ernment regulation, ALI-ABA’s course curriculum

includes a broad range of practice-oriented subjects

from skills courses to trial evidence and civil practice

to criminal law and legal issues in subjects of cur-

rent public interest. ALI-ABA also offers courses via

the telephone and online. Education in professional

responsibility and ethics is a concern in each course

and of special programs. Approximately 10% of the

courses are new each year, the others being updates

of core curriculum subjects. Week-long summer

courses, some on university campuses, offer an aca-

demic retreat for study of a subject in depth.

Many ALI ABA programs are cosponsored

with law schools, sections of the ABA, the Federa

Bar Association, the Environmental Law Institutestate and local CLE organizations, and other legal

entities, as well as The Smithsonian Institution, the

American Association of Museums, and others.

Electronic and Print Publications

ALI-ABA publishes seven traditional periodicals

four electronic periodicals, and a variety of books

in both traditional and electronic formats. Practice

Texts provide comprehensive coverage of a subject

and are published as hardbound books of severahundred pages. Formbooks are published in a

looseleaf binder format. Formbooks also are avail

able on CD ROMs to enable lawyers to download

and adapt forms to their clients’ needs. Practice

Checklist Manuals are paperbound compilations

of helpful articles on individual subjects selected

from the pages of The Practical Lawyer® and

other ALI-ABA magazines. CD-ROMs of selected

ALI-ABA texts are also produced.

Additionally, study materials prepared for ALI-ABA Courses of Study are offered as a resource for

further research.

Among ALI-ABA’s periodicals are The

Practical Lawyer®, which features concise, how-

to-do-it articles for general practitioners; The

Practical Real Estate Lawyer®, which treats

similarly materials concerned with real property

(forms and checklists from this magazine are avail-

able in a separate oppy disk subscription service)

The Practical Tax Lawyer®, published with the

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 3/45

cooperation of the Section of Taxation of the ABA;

and The Practical Litigator®.

All of ALI-ABA’s periodicals and selected course

materials are available online at www.ali-aba.org.

Lawyers can subscribe to an entire year’s worth of 

online issues, or purchase and access just the online

issue, single article, or course paper that they need.

To advise lawyers of its wealth of CLE products,

ALI-ABA issues a quarterly booklet, the ALI-ABA 

CLE Review Catalog. The ALI-ABA Business

Law Course Materials Journal selects and re-

publishes the best of the business law outlines and

forms originally prepared for ALI-ABA Courses

of Study, while the ALI-ABA Estate Planning 

Course Materials Journal does the same with

materials from ALI-ABA estate planning courses.

Audio and Video Recordings

ALI-ABA offers recordings of virtually all of its live

presentations in a growing number of convenient

formats. The library of more than 2,000 programs

includes courses of study, ALI-ABA Video Law 

Review ® webcasts, telephone seminars, specially

prepared lectures, and webcasts produced in ALI-

ABA’s studio. Also available are DVDs, audio mp3

CD ROMs, and online programs.

ALI-ABA In-House

ALI-ABA In-House offers personal consulting and

training assistance to law rms, corporate law depart-

ments, and government agencies for their in-house

professional development programs. ALI-ABA’s

in-house training programs cover a wide range of 

skills areas, as well as areas of substantive law upon

request. In addition, the almost 300 members of 

ALI-ABA In-House receive a quarterly newsletter,

access to e-mail information and discussion forums,

discounts on ALI-ABA programs, products, and ser-

vices, and regular mailings of related information.ALI-ABA In-House also develops materials for law-

yer training and regularly presents conferences on

professional development topics.

Advancement o the Proession

ALI-ABA subsidizes a variety of activities to ad-

vance the quality and content of post-admission

legal education and to enhance professional compe-

tence and professional responsibility. Among them

are sponsorship of national conferences and studies

of adult education and its unique characteristics, of

mandatory CLE, of law practice quality evaluation

methodologies, of bridge-the-gap transition train

ing for the newly admitted lawyer, and of the quality

of continuing legal education and the methods of

measuring it. Most recently, ALI ABA has publisheda guide for applying adult education techniques to

continuing legal education and, as a public service

effort, is developing new training materials to en-

courage and train lawyers to represent immigrants

in asylum cases.

In addition, ALI-ABA has developed training

materials for lawyers in the areas of negotiation

skills, real estate transactions, and corporate trans-

actions.

A CLE Resource

One of ALI-ABA’s primary functions, from its very

beginning, has been to serve as a resource for na-

tional, state, and local agencies involved in continu-

ing legal education. ALI-ABA was a founding mem-

ber of ACLEA, which, through the interchange of

knowledge and techniques, advances the prociency

of continuing legal education professionals.

ALI-ABA’s course materials and programs areavailable to all who plan and conduct post-admis-

sion legal education activities, and senior staff mem-

bers, whose average tenure is in excess of 15 years

are always ready to work with and assist others.

Governance and Stafng

ALI ABA operates under a Memorandum of Un

derstanding between the American Law Institute

and the American Bar Association and is governedby a Board of Directors composed of 13 persons

including 12 regular members and the President

In addition, the ALI Director, the ABA Executive

Director, and the ALI Treasurer are non-voting ex

ofcio members of the Board.

The ALI-ABA staff consists of 80 employees, in-

cluding 19 lawyers.Rev. October 2007

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 4/45

As of December 2008

American Law InstituteAmerican Bar Association

Continuing Professional Education

Board of DirectorsPresidentThomas Z. Hayward, Jr. Chicago Illinois

Honorary ChairsRoberta Cooper Ramo Albuquerque New MexicoPresident, American Law Institute

H. Thomas Wells, Jr. Birmingham AlabamaPresident, American Bar Association

Tsan Abrahamson Berkeley CaliforniaBrooksley E. Born Washington District of ColumbiaBennett Boskey* Washington District of ColumbiaJennifer Busby Birmingham AlabamaCorinne Cooper Tucson ArizonaMichael E. Flowers Columbus OhioRoy A. Hammer Boston MassachusettsPeter M. LaSorsa Mapleton IllinoisLance Liebman* New York New York John J. McKetta, III Austin TexasLeslie B. Miller Tucson ArizonaBettina B. Plevan New York New York Maury B. Poscover St. Louis Missouri

Barbara J. Rothstein Washington District of ColumbiaHenry F. White, Jr.* Chicago Illinois

*Ex Officio

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 5/45

4025 Chestnut Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-3099 • www.ali-aba.org

Executive OfficeExecutive Director: Julene Franki

Executive Assistant: Donna K. MaropisDeputy Executive Director: Lawrence F. Meehan

Program DepartmentsALI-ABA In-House

Director: Howard B. KleinAudio and Video Special Projects

Director: Susan L. TomitaSenior Administrative Assistant: Linda J. Smith

Courses of Study

Director: Nancy A. KaneDirector Emeritus: Alexander Hart

Senior Assistant Director: Kevin J. O’ConnorAssistant Directors: Thomas M. Hennessey;

Amy S. WeinbergCourse Manager: Suzanne E. McCarthyAdministrative Assistants: Pamela McC. DeLarge;

Carole Findley; Charlotte RiceElectronic and Print Publications

Director: Mark T. CarrollDirector of Books: John B. SpitzerAssistant Director: Joseph L. DiPietroEditorial Assistant: Susan Hader-GoldenResearch Assistant:  Michael Jacobs

Research and Development and

ALI-ABA In-House

Director: Leslie A. BelascoR&D Manager: Crystal FinchAdministrative Assistant: Jasalyn Fernandez

Topical ProgramsDirector: Nancy Mulloy-Bonn

Administrative Assistant: Kathleen Montgomery

Service DepartmentsAccounting

Director: William J. McCormick Accountant: Hong LuPayroll/Accounting Coordinator: Tim MayhughAccounts Payable Assistant: Mary SheridanAccounting Supervisor: Debra FoleyAccounting Specialist: Beth BowersAccounting Assistant: Regenea JamesAccounting Clerk:  Chanthou Duong

Administrative Services

Director: Joseph A. Mendicino, Jr.

Assistant Director, Information Services:Stephen Dushkowich

Data Entry Supervisor: Dwight DeLarge

Data Entry Clerks: Betty Bayliss, Angela Hughes,

Charlotta Blanden

Database Administrator: Teri Y. Broadnax

PC Specialist: Marykay Hamilton

Administrative Assistant: Margaret E. Arndt

Mailroom Administrator: David Dougherty

Administrative Clerk: Chanthou Duong

Business Development

Director: Frank Paul Tomasello

Account Manager: Thomas Fogerty

Supervisor, Accountant Maintenance:

John P. Delaney III

Customer Service

Director: Frank Paul Tomasello

Customer Service Manager: Nancy ClineSr. CS Rep: Dennis L. Snipes,

CS Reps:   Michael P. Montgomery,

Deborah Valentine, Jeff Weatherbe

Receptionist:  Pattye Stringer

Human Resources 

Director: Diane E. Schnitzer

Librarian: Harry G. Kyriakodis

Mandatory CLE

MCLE Coordinator: Jeanette McCarver

MCLE Assistant: Dionne Brooks

Marketing

Director of Research and Communications:

Kathleen H. Lawner

Research & Communications Specialist:

Cynthia Keichline

Director of Strategic Marketing:Amy Danziger Shapiro

Manager of Marketing and Communications:

Danielle Harkins

Media Production

Director: Edan Cohen

Media Specialist: Catherine M. Lowe

Meetings and Travel

Director: Kathleen C. Peters

Production and Design

Director: Herbert J. Powell, Jr.

Artistic Director: Matthew Born

Graphic Design Specialist: Catherine A. Lhulier

Web Technology

Director: John V. Ceci

Assistant Director: Jonathan A. ShinaultWeb Designer: Mary Welsch

Programmer:  Jacob Drecksage

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 6/45

2

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 7/45

ALI-ABA Audio Seminar 

Attorney's Role in LEED Construction 

May 29, 2009

Telephone Seminar/Audio Webcast

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

PROGRAM SCHEDULE ix

FACULTY PARTICIPANTS xi

FACULTY BIOGRAPHIES xiii

STUDY MATERIALS

1.   Attorney’s Role in LEED Construction--PowerPoint Presentation

by Shari Shapiro and Chris Cheatham 

1

vii

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 8/45

2

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 9/45

PROGRAM SCHEDULE

for May 29, 2009

 

Program Schedule  Eastern  Central  Mountain  Pacific/Arizona  Alaska Hawaii 

NationalTeleseminar/Webcast  12:30 p.m.  11:30 a.m.  10:30 a.m.  9:30 a.m.  8:30 a.m.  6:30 a.m. 

Adjournment  1:30 p.m.  12:30 p.m.  11:30 a.m.  10:30 a.m.  9:30 a.m.  7:30 a.m. 

 Scope and Purpose: Green design and construction and the potential for inclusion

of “LEED” certification requirements present opportunities for clients of construction

and real estate attorneys. Counsel must know and outline the best practices for

incorporating these requirements into construction contracts and obtaining LEED

certification. This teleconference and live audio webcast will provide an overview of 

LEED certification for green buildings and offer practical advice for negotiating green

construction projects. Our speakers will discuss the current status of the

requirements and the attorney’s role as well as look to what may be next as interest

in LEED certification increases.

Topics include:

• What is the LEED rating system and what other standards exist?• Will one system be the preferred standard?

• What are the risks to Green Building and how do I manage these risks for my

clients?

• What are the benefits to LEED certification?• What does the future hold for Green Building?

• What legal issues are unique to Green Building and LEED certification? Faculty

Shari Shapiro, Obermayer, Rebmann, Maxwell & Hippel LLP, Philadelphia, PA

Chris Cheatham, Watt, Tieder, Hoffar & Fitzgerald, LLP, Washington, D.C.

Program (All Times EDT)

12:30 p.m.   Attorney’s Role in LEED Construction – panel discussion

Questions and Answers 1:30 p.m. Adjournment

* Questions and Answers will be integrated into the program. Questions are welcomein advance of and during the seminar by e-mail to [email protected] (Subjectline: Faculty question).

ix

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 10/45

 

Total 60-minute hours of instruction: 1.0; Total 50-minute hours: 1.2

Suggested Prerequisite: Limited experience in legal practice in subject matter.

Educational Objective: Development of proficiency in performance of intricate and

complex legal tasks within a narrow area, provision of information on recent legaldevelopments; maintenance of professional competence as a practitioner.

Level of Instruction: Intermediate

 

x

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 11/45

ALI-ABA Audio Seminar

Attorney's Role in LEED Construction 

May 29, 2009

Telephone Seminar/Audio Webcast

PLANNING CHAIR

Shari Shapiro

Obermayer Rebmann Maxwell & Hippel LLP

1617 John F Kennedy Blvd

Philadelphia, PA 19103-1821

FACULTY

Chris CheathamWatt Tieder Hoffar & Fitzgerald, LLP

8405 Greensboro Dr Ste 100

Mc Lean, VA 22102-5106

xi

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 12/45

2

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 13/45

 ALI-ABA Telephone and Audio-Only Webcast

 

Attorney’s Role in LEED Construction  

TSPX06/TWPX06

 

Faculty Biographies

 

 

Speakers

Shari Shapiro

Obermayer, Rebmann, Maxwell & Hippel LLP

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Shari Shapiro is an associate with Obermayer Rebmann Maxwell & Hippel LLP.  She is a

member of the Environmental Department.

 

Ms. Shapiro is a LEED Accredited Professional.  Ms. Shapiro focuses her practice on

green building law, which includes sustainable project financing, regulatory drafting,

land use approvals, contracts, and conflict resolution.  Ms. Shapiro is the Sustainability

Coordinator for Obermayer’s Sustainability Initiative.

Ms. Shapiro maintains a blog on legal issues related to Green Building, available at

www.greenbuildinglawblog.com.

 

Ms. Shapiro is the Co-Chair of the ABA State and Local Government Section

Subcommittee on Land Use/Environmental Law, and is on the Board of Directors of the

Delaware Valley Green Building Council.

Ms. Shapiro recently coordinated a seminar entitled “Getting Green Done…Right,”

exploring the nuts and bolts of environmentally sustainable and economically viable

development projects.  Ms. Shapiro made a presentation on “Local Regulation of Green

Building Projects” at the seminar.

 

Ms. Shapiro earned her Juris Doctorate degree from the University of Pennsylvania

where she received the Milton C. Sharp Award for Best Grades/Best Research in Urban

Renewal or Land Use Planning.  While attending the University of Pennsylvania, she

obtained a Certificate in Business and Public Policy from the Wharton School of 

Business.

 

Ms. Shapiro received her Bachelor of Arts Degree in Development Studies and Modern

British History from Brown University.

 

Ms. Shapiro is admitted to practice in the states of Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

 

 

 

 

 

xiii

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 14/45

Chris Cheatham

Watt, Tieder, Hoffar & Fitzgerald, LLP

Washington, D.C. 

 

Chris focuses his practice on suretyship, construction, government contracts, and

commercial contract law. He also holds a Leadership in Energy and EnvironmentalDesign® Accredited Professional (LEED AP) designation. The LEED rating system is

the nationally recognized benchmark for design, construction and operation of high-

performance green buildings. As a LEED AP, Chris is part of a select group of attorneys

nationwide who have recognized the significance of “green” building trends and he is the

first Virginia practicing attorney to attain the designation. Chris possesses an

understanding of green building strategies to assist clients through the LEED certification

process, from startup to final verification of a project’s green measures, as well as

navigating clients through the evolving green building regulatory requirements.

 

Chris has assisted clients in disputes arising from a variety of construction projects,

including locks and dams, complex levee systems, housing complexes, airports andresidential homes. In addition to his litigation experience, Chris has drafted and

negotiated contract documents, provided advice in contract administration, and prepared

claims on behalf of sureties and contractors.

 

Memberships and Affiliations

•  American Bar Association

o Forum on the Construction Industry

o Tort Trial & Insurance Practice Section

o Fidelity & Surety Law Committee

•  AGC of Metropolitan Washington D.C.

o Young Contractors Forum

•  Virginia Bar Association

o Construction and Public Contracts Law Section

o Civil Litigation Section

o Young Lawyers Division

o DC Habitat for Humanity

  Environmental Community

•  USGBC National Capital Region Chapter

 

Publications and Presentations

•  Author, "White Paper: Virginia's Green Building Battle," U.S. Green Building

Council National Captial Regional Chapter, Website Resources, April 2008.

•  Author, "Virginia's Green Building Battle," Virginia State Bar, Construction Law

and Public Contracts News, Spring 2008.

•  Author, "Does Your Arbitration Agreement Have Holes Making Rulings Less

than Final?" Watt, Tieder, Hoffar & Fitzgerald Newsletter , Summer 2007.

•  Contributor, American Bar Association Forum on the Construction Industry,

Construction Law Glossary, 2008.

xiv

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 15/45

•  Author, "Does Your Arbitration Agreement Have Holes Making Rulings Less

than Final?" Watt, Tieder, Hoffar & Fitzgerald Newsletter , Summer 2007.

•  Contributor, Construction Law Glossary, American Bar Association Forum on the

Construction Industry, 2008.

xv

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 16/45

2

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 17/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 18/45

Shari Shap

iro, LEED A

P, Esq.

Chris Cheatham, LEED AP, Esq.

Attorne

y’s Role in

L

EED C

onstruction

M

ay 29, 2009

2

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 19/45

Wha

t is “green”building

?

•A g

reen building, also known as a 

sustainable building, is a stru

cture that is 

des

igned, built, renovated, operated, or 

reused in an eco

logical and r

esource-

efficient manner. Green buildings are 

des

igned to mee

t certain objectives such as 

pro

tecting occupant health; improving 

employee produ

ctivity; using energy, water, 

and

 other resources more efficiently; and 

reducing the overall impact to the 

env

ironment.

3

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 20/45

Why build green

the green reason 

•The

 built environm

ent has a profound impact on 

our natural environment, econom

y, health, and 

productivity. 

•In the United States alone, buildings account for: 

•7

2% of electricity consumption,

•3

9% of energy use,

•3

8% of all carbon dioxide (CO

2) emissions,

•4

0% of raw materials use,

•3

0% of waste output (136 million tons 

annually), and

•1

4% of potable water consump

tion.

4

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 21/45

Why build greenth

e OTHER 

gree

n reason

The overall green building market (both non-residential and residential) 

is likely

 to more than double from today’s $36-49 billionto $96-140 

billion

by 2013 (Source: McGraw Hill Construction (2009). G

reen 

Outlook 2009: Trends Driving Change.)

The value of green building construction is projected to increa

se to $60 

billion by 2010(Source: McGraw-Hill Construction (2008). K

ey 

Trends in the European and U.S. Construction Marketplace: 

SmartM

arketReport.)

The construction market accounts for 13.4%

 of the $13.2 trillion U.S. 

GDP(S

ource: Departmen

t of Commerce (2008). Annual Valu

e of 

Constru

ction Put in Place.)

The gre

en building products market is proje

cted to be worth $30-$40 

billion annually by 2010

(Source: Green Building Alliance (2

006). 

Green B

uilding Products: Positioning South

western Pennsylvania as 

the U.S. Manufacturing C

enter.)

5

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 22/45

Un

ited States Green 

Bu

ilding Council 

(USGBC)

Un

ited Stat

es Green

 

Building Co

uncil 

(USGBC)

Founded in 1993

Non-pro

fit trade

 org

Develop

s LEED

USGBC 

Chapters

Founded

 in 1993

Non-pro

fit trade

 org

Develops LEED

USGBC Chapters

6

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 23/45

Leadership

 in Energy 

and Enviro

nmental 

De

sign (LE

ED)

Leadership

 in Energy 

and Environmental

 

Design (LE

ED)

Established in 2000

Green building r

ating system

Develop

ed by US

GBC

Established in 2000

Green building rating sys

tem

Developed by US

GBC

7

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 24/45

8

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 25/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 26/45

Other Ra

ting Sy

stems

•Gre

en Globes 

•Ene

rgy Star 

•NA

HB 

•Earthcraft

10

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 27/45

Ben

efits of Green Building

 

Certification

•Verification

•Ma

rketing

•Regulation

•Incentives

11

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 28/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 29/45

Green Building Risks 

•Parties and Risk

•Owner –choose green building approa

ch

•Architect –in

corporate green design

•Contractor –build to plans and 

specifications

•Sub-contractors –same as

 contractor 

•Sureties –bond the green contractor 

•LEED consultant –???

13

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 30/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 31/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 32/45

Lega

l Issues: LEEDigatio

n

•Sha

w Developm

ent v. Southe

rn Builders

•The

 Contract:  

16

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 33/45

Lega

l Issues: LEEDigatio

n

•Sha

w Developm

ent v. Southe

rn Builders

•Damages

17

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 34/45

Legal Issues: Defects

•“Don’t Let Gree

n Design Cause Red Ink”

•Frank Musica, Victor O. S

chinnerer an

Co. 

•AIA Convention –2007

•21 green building claims

18

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 35/45

Legal Issues: Defects

•Ene

rgy Use Abo

ve Promise

“Architects and consulting engineers signed 

contract that stated

 that projects w

ould ‘reduce 

operating costs by 50 percent’over schools of 

similar size.  Energy usage is com

parable to other 

schools recently designed and constructed. Scho

ol 

system is publicly embarrassed, d

isappointed an

blam

ed as being ‘h

oodwinked’by architect and 

engineers.  School system brings claim.”

“D

on’t Let Green Design Cause Red Ink,”Frank Musica

19

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 36/45

Legal Issues: Defects

•Guarantee of Indoor Air Qua

lity

“Lu

red by the promise of ‘he

althier and 

more productive

 occupants’basic to LEED 

pub

licity, tenant rents space in Silver 

certified building. At end of first year, 

tenant’s records indicated greater use of 

sick

 leave. . . . T

enant deman

ds rent rebate 

from project bas

ed on promise of a 

healthful workplace and tena

nt sues 

architect.”

“D

on’t Let Green Design Cause Red Ink,”Frank Musica

20

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 37/45

Leg

al Issues: Reg

ulation

•Gre

en practices are being incorporated into state 

and

 local zoning a

nd building codes and 

ordinances

•1

4 percent of U.S. cities with p

opulations of 

m

ore than 50,00

0 have green b

uilding programs

•T

he number of counties with g

reen building 

p

rograms has grown by nearly 400 percent since 

2

003

•Fed

eral statutes require federal agencies to proc

ure 

recycled material, reduce energy consumption a

nd 

prevent pollution.

21

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 38/45

Ty

pes of G

reen Building 

Reg

ulations

•Command and Control Type Reg

ulations

•July 17, 2008

California adopts green build

ing 

code for all new

 construction s

tatewide 

•2

007Boston, Washington, S

an Francisco, L

os 

A

ngeles mandate green building requirements 

for new construction above a s

pecified square 

footage

•Financial Incentives

•2

008Portland

 enacts “feebate”structure

•Non-Financial Inc

entives

•E

xpedited perm

itting; increase

d FAR, buildin

h

eight or density for green buildings

22

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 39/45

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 40/45

AHRI v. City

 of Albuquerque

•October 3, 2008, C

hief District C

ourt Judge Ma

rtha 

Vazquez granted the preliminary injunction, and laid 

out her opinion that the Albuquerque Code was indeed 

preempted.  

•“There is no doubt that Congress intended to 

p

reempt state re

gulation of the energy efficiency of 

certain building appliances in order to have 

u

niform, express, national energy efficiency 

standards.”

•“At the time the

 Code was drafted the Green 

B

uilding Manag

er, by his own admission, wa

u

naware of fede

ral statutes governing the ene

rgy 

efficiency of HV

AC products and water heaters and 

the City attorneys who reviewed the Code did not 

raise the preemption issue.”

24

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 41/45

Other Regulatory Pitfalls

•Sta

te preemption

•Rational relationship require

ment

•Void for vaguen

ess

•Confiscatory takings/Reason

able Fees

•Improper delegation of authority

25

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 42/45

The

 Future

The Stimulus a

nd Green Bu

ilding: Funding

General Ser

vices Administration 

$4.5 billion

Department of Defense 

$3.6 billion

States 

$3.1 billion a

nd $3.2 billion

26

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 43/45

The

 Future

The Stimulus a

nd Green Bu

ilding: Risks

LEED Certifica

tion Guarante

es

-www.fedbizopps.g

ov

27

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 44/45

Cap & Trad

e

•Wh

at is Cap and Trade? 

•How might it effect buildings? 

•Wa

xman-Markey Bill

28

8/7/2019 Attorney's Role in LEED Construction

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/attorneys-role-in-leed-construction 45/45

New Model Building Cod

es

•ASHRAE 

Standard 189

•ICC

 

Commercial 

Green Building 

Code

•CalGreenCode

29