Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

39
Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars Maurice Leutenegger (NASA/GSFC/CRESST/UMBC) David Cohen (Swarthmore College) Stan Owocki (Bartol Research Institute)

description

Talk given by Maurice A. Leutenegger (NASA-GSFC) at the 17th APiP, 19-22 July 2011, Queen's University, Belfast, UK.

Transcript of Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Page 1: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Maurice Leutenegger (NASA/GSFC/CRESST/UMBC)

David Cohen (Swarthmore College)

Stan Owocki (Bartol Research Institute)

Page 2: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Outline

● Background on winds of massive stars● Mechanisms for x-ray emission● Mass loss rate problem● Background on x-ray observatories● Doppler profile diagnostics● He-like triplet diagnostics● Special bonus problems: optically thick x-ray

radiative transfer in a supersonic flow; Fe XVII line ratios

Page 3: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Massive stars

● Spectral type O, early B; T ~ 30-50 kK

● M ~ 30-120 Mʘ

; L bol

~ 105 – 106 Lʘ

● Mass loss rates 10-7 – 10-5 Mʘ/year (compare to

sun at 10-14 Mʘ/year); v

∞ ~ 2000 km/s

● ½ Ṁ v∞

2 ~ 10-3 Lbol

; Lx ~ 10-7 Lbol

● TMS

~ few 10 Myr

Page 4: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Theory of radiatively driven winds

● Radiation pressure in spectral lines becomes much more effective due to deshadowing of optically thick lines in a supersonic flow

Page 5: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Importance of massive star winds

Meynet & Maeder

Townsley et al.

Page 6: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Mechanisms for x-ray emission

Okazaki et al.

Gagne et al. (model of Asif ud-Doula)

Colliding winds

Magnetically channeled winds

Page 7: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Mechanisms for x-ray emission

Feldmeier et al.

Intrinsic wind structure(embedded wind shocks)

Page 8: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Mass loss rates of O stars

Fullerton et al. (2006)

Page 9: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Chandra and XMM

Page 10: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Soft x-ray spectra of ζ Puppis

Page 11: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Comparison with Capella

Page 12: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Comparison with Capella

Page 13: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Line shape is diagnostic of optical depth

Page 14: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Profile formation

Lλ=4π∫dV ηλ e−τ

τ( p , z)=∫z

κ(λ)ρ(r' )dz '

Approximate wind as two component fluid

Page 15: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Profile formation

τ*=κ M

4 π v∞R*

ρ= M

4π r2v (r)

τ( p , z)=τ* t ( p , z )

τ( p , z)=∫z

κ(λ)ρ(r' )dz '

Page 16: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Model x-ray profiles

Page 17: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Example: Fe XVII 15.014 Å

Page 18: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

He-like triplet diagnostics

A ~ Z10

Page 19: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

He-like triplet diagnostics

Page 20: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

He-like triplet ratio and line profile

No additional free parameters!

Page 21: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Fit all lines to constrain mass loss

Page 22: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Fit all lines to constrain mass loss

τ*=κ M

4 π v∞R*

Page 23: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

An unexpected problem

Page 24: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

An unexpected problem

Page 25: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Sobolev theory: radiative transfer in a supersonic, accelerating wind

Lsob=v th(dv zdz )−1

τ sob=χ Lsob

τ0=χ v thv /r τ1=

χ v thdv /dr

Page 26: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Sobolev theory

Velocity law Anisotropy factor

σ= rvdvdr

−1

Page 27: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Angular distribution of emission

Page 28: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Effect of resonance scattering

Page 29: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Resonance scattering fits the data

Page 30: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Resonance scattering fits the data

Page 31: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Resonance scattering fits the data

Page 32: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Resonance scattering fits the data

Page 33: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Plausibility of resonance scattering

Page 34: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Summary

● X-ray emission from single O star winds can be understood in terms of the embedded wind shock paradigm

● Independent constraints can be placed on mass loss rates by x-ray line shapes, leading to downward revisions factors of 2-4 from recombination/free-free diagnostics

● He-like triplet diagnostics constrain plasma location and confirm the EWS paradigm

Page 35: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Summary

● Resonance scattering can symmetrize line profile shapes; we know it is important from comparisons of resonance and intercombination lines from the same ion

● (If there is time, ask me about Fe XVII line ratios!)

Page 36: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Fe XVII line ratio problem

τ Sco

Page 37: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Fe XVII line ratio problem

ς Ori

Page 38: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Fe XVII line ratio problem

ς Pup

Page 39: Atomic physics of shocked plasma in the winds of massive stars

Inner shell absorption in Fe