Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and...

29
Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking Ramp Structures Gabriel A. Jimenez, Ph.D., P.E., S.E. Principal/Managing Director Walter P Moore

Transcript of Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and...

Page 1: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Assessment and Restoration of

Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking

Ramp Structures

Gabriel A. Jimenez, Ph.D., P.E., S.E.

Principal/Managing Director

Walter P Moore

Page 2: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Longer spans and/or heavier loads requires increasing the slab thickness in order to limit deflections

• Dead load becomes the major portion of the design load

• Economical reasons: rib the slab in both directions to provide greater stiffness with less weight

Motivation

Page 3: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Rows of concrete ribs at right angles to each other with solid heads at the columns.

• Square pans or dome forms to create the void, or recess, between the ribs.

• Standard dome forms: 24-inch or 36-inch module with sloping sides forming a bevel of 1 ½-inch/ft from the vertical.

• Use: Office buildings, parking structures, warehouses

Waffle slabs

Page 4: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Top of slab reinforcement: WWF or conventional reinforcement

• PT reinforcement started in the 1960s – Monostrand

Post-tensioned waffle slabs

Susceptible to corrosion

Courtesy of Adapt technical note

Page 5: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Concrete deterioration generally signals the onset of accelerated distress

• Symptoms of concrete deterioration: – spalling, cracking, scaling, rust staining and abrasion

• Deterioration mechanisms primarily responsible: – Corrosion Related Distress – Cracking – Material Related Degradation – Others

Concrete deterioration

Page 6: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Concrete is a naturally porous material

• Concrete pores have diameters ranging from 15 - 1,000 A (10 millionths of mm)

• Chloride ion diameter is less than 2 A

• All concrete is susceptible to chloride ion contamination by virtue of its natural porosity

Chloride contamination

MOISTURE AND

CHLORIDE ION

ROAD SALT

RUST BUILD-UP

CAUSING

PRESSURE

DELAMINATION

OR FRACTUREOPEN SPALL

SALT WATER

CONTINUOUS

CORROSION

Page 7: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

• Corrosion - dynamic electro-chemical process & induces progressive deterioration

• Corrosion by-products (rust) - 5 to 8 times larger (volume) than the parent metal

Corrosion

MOISTURE AND

CHLORIDE ION

ROAD SALT

RUST BUILD-UP

CAUSING

PRESSURE

DELAMINATION

OR FRACTUREOPEN SPALL

SALT WATER

CONTINUOUS

CORROSION

Page 8: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Areas of vulnerability

Page 9: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Areas of vulnerability

Page 10: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Typical deterioration

Page 11: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Testing

Instrumental Testing Acoustic testing/hammer sounding Impact-echo Impulse response Covermeter Ground-penetrating radar Rebound hammer Corrosion potential testing Acoustic monitoring

Material Testing Compressive strength Petrographic examination Chloride content Carbonation Metallurgical and physical examination of the prestressing steel strand

Page 12: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Ground Penetrating Radar

Page 13: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Screwdriver penetration test

Page 14: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Exploratory openings

Page 15: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Exploratory openings

Page 16: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Core sampling and corrosion potential

Page 17: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Analysis

Page 18: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Repair strategies • No tendon repair

Insignificant strand deterioration no loss of prestressing force

• Selective abandonment Tendon is severely

deteriorated/damaged No repair needed based

on a design having greater design capacity than current code

• Repair Severe deterioration –

loss of prestressing force

• Tendon supplement/replacement

Existing tendons insufficient for current code/use

Requires installation new tendons

• Selective/Full structure replacement

Insufficient capacity or significant deterioration

• Stabilization/Strengthening

Restoration of structural capacity by external post-tensioning

Page 19: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Drawings and specifications

Page 20: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Repairs

Page 21: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Punching shear

Page 22: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Tendon splice repair

• Connects 2 sections

• Steel cylinder with spring-loaded wedges

Page 23: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Center stressing splice • Stressing/splicing from an intermediate location

• Sometimes in combination with splice coupler

• Cast metal with pre-molded wedges

Page 24: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Center stressing splice

Page 25: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Sheathing repair • All damaged sheathing must be repaired

• Sleeves/waterproofing tape/coatings suitable for PT applications

Page 26: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Drying and regreasing

Procedure developed for the push-through system

Dries annular space between tendon and sheathing

Page 27: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Drying and regreasing

Page 28: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...

Thank you for your attention

Gabriel A. Jimenez, Ph.D., P.E., S.E.

Walter P Moore

www.walterpmoore.com

713-630-7485 [email protected]

Page 29: Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle … Convention/Session... · Assessment and Restoration of Post-tensioned Waffle Slabs in Parking ... rib the slab in both ...