Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate...

35
National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources Cultural Resources Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate Change Intern August 23, 2016

Transcript of Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate...

Page 1: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior

Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park

Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources

Cultural Resources Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate Change Intern August 23, 2016

Page 2: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

George Melendez Wright Initiative for Young Leaders in Climate Change

The YLCC program provides paid summer internships to highly accomplished graduate and upper-level undergraduate students to work on diverse issues related to climate change and its effects in national parks.

General topic areas include resource conservation and adaptation; climate effects monitoring; park facilities adaptation; policy development; sustainable operations & mitigation; and communication, interpretation, or education.

Page 3: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

George Melendez Wright Initiative for Young Leaders in Climate Change

The park is in need of more information to develop an effective climate change response to threatened cultural resources within park borders and the Canadian portion of international Chilkoot Trail.

Geospatial layer of climate change threats to archaeological resources

Long-term monitoring plan for threatened cultural resources

Page 4: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Climate Change and Cultural Resources

Page 5: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate
Page 6: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Chilkoot Trail 1897-1899

Page 7: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Dyea

Page 8: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Kinney Bridge

Page 9: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Finnegan's Point

Page 10: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Canyon City

Page 11: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Sheep Camp

Page 12: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Scales to Summit

Page 13: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Chilkoot Trail Artifacts

Page 14: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Types of Climate Change Threats

Page 15: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Types of Climate Change Threats

Page 16: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Types of Climate Change Threats

Page 17: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Types of Climate Change Threats

Page 18: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability

Nourse and West Creek subsheds contribute most runoff to main stem of Taiya

Lower Taiya is responding to a change in base level due to isostatic rebound

Rebound rates in Dyea average 1.8 cm/yr

Page 19: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Dyea Monitoring bank

erosion since 1979 Most erosion

occurred prior to 1992

Discrepancy between 10 and 20 meters Standardize

protocol

Page 20: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Kinney Bridge

Erosion noticed in 2011

Page 21: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Kinney Bridge

Erosion noticed in 2011

Page 22: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Kinney Bridge

Erosion noticed in 2011

2-4 meters of bank loss per year

CT14 and CT3 within 5 meters of 2016 bank

Safest feature is 13 meters from 2016 bank

More threatened than Dyea

Page 23: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Finnegan's Point & Canyon City

Page 24: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Fluvial Channel Instability – Sheep Camp

1994 surveys of west Sheep Camp Not digitized

Sheep camp area is naturally prone to flooding and channel instability

Page 25: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Glacial Outburst Floods

Glacial outburst floods (GLOF) occur when a dam (ice or earthen) containing a glacial lake fails

Receding glaciers deposit their melt-water into pro-glacial lakes, increasing the lake volume and hazard risk should the dam fail

Higher summer and winter temperatures encourage the melting of ice dams and ice-cored earthen dams

TEMSCO, 2002

Page 26: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Sheep Camp Disaster - September 17, 1887

Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 1897

“A 20 foot high wall of water struck the main canyon at Stonehouse in such a way as to lift that great rock, weighing many tons, and to wash it a quarter of a mile down the canyon” (Bearss, 1970)

Damage was locally severe, but limited in extent.

No extensive

damage to Pleasant Camp and Canyon City

Page 27: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Glacial Outburst Floods

Three pro-glacial lakes with the potential to threaten cultural resources

Nourse Lake and Hanging Lake could impact resources from Canyon City to Dyea

Page 28: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

West Creek Lake

Capps, 2003

Page 29: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Hanging Lake

Separated from active glacier for at least 55 years

No ice core Overlaying bedrock

Page 30: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Nourse Lake

Lake surface is near crest of moraine dam Slopes above reservoir are subject to mass

movement Predicted discharge of 1,600 m³/s

Twice predicted 500-year flood discharge for Taiya River

3x discharge of 2002 West Creek flood

Page 31: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Earlier Snow Melt

Material culture derives its significance from the place which it was deposited

“Every Place has a Climate Story” initiative How can we see change

happening in material culture?

Page 32: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Melting Ice Patches

Page 33: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Climate Change Threats to Archaeological Resources

Archaeological Site

Taiya Channel Instability

Glacial Outburst Floods

Early Snow Melt

Melting Ice Patch

Dyea X X

Kinney Bridge X X

Finnegan's Point X

Canyon City X

Sheep Camp X

Scales to Sumitt X X

Page 34: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Recommendations Site Risk Probability Time Frame Severity Significance Recommendation Dyea Channel

Migration Possible Intermediate Marginal High Continue monitoring

Kinney Bridge

Channel Migration

Certain Short term Catastrophic Moderate Annual spring monitoring and documentation

Finnegan's Point

Outburst Flood

Possible Short term Catastrophic Low None

Canyon City

Outburst Flood

Possible Short term Catastrophic High Documentation

Sheep Camp

Channel Migration

Certain Long term Critical Moderate /High

Documentation of western site

Scales to Summit

Snow/Ice Melt

Certain Long term Marginal Moderate Documentation

Page 35: Assessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources · PDF fileAssessing Climate Change Vulnerability of Cultural Resources . Cultural Resources . Caitlin Rankin, YLCC Climate

Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park Cultural Resources

www.nps.gov/klgo

National Park Service U.S. Department of the Interior