Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

14
Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010 Exploring quality criteria for practitioner research as a tool for the professional development of teachers

description

Exploring quality criteria for practitioner research as a tool for the professional development of teachers. Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010. Introduction. Research orientation Definition of practitioner research in schools A reflective attitude - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Page 1: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der DonkATEE Conference 2010

Exploring quality criteria for practitioner research as a tool for the professional

development of teachers

Page 2: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Introduction

Research orientationDefinition of practitioner research in schoolsA reflective attitudeDilemmas in tutoring and assessmentContact

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 3: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Motives for practitioner research

Individual development– New knowledge and insights– Research skills– Reflective attitude– Vision on teaching and learning

School developmentSolving the problem

Improving school practice

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 4: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Research orientation

ATEE Conference 2010

Generalized knowledge

Contextualized knowledge

Developing theoryImproving

school practice

Page 5: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

A definition of practitioner research in schools

Practitioner research in schools is research carried by teachers, by which, in a systematic way and in interaction with the environment - answers are obtained to questions from one’s own school practice and directed towards improving this practice.

(Van der Donk & Van Lanen, 2009)

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 6: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Does research improve school practice?

Praktijkonderzoek in de school

Page 7: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

The reflective attitude of the teacher researcher

The combining factor is the reflective

attitude of the teacher researcher:The skills to design and carry out

researchA positive attitude towards researchAn inquiring, critical view of one’s own

school practice in connection with one’s ideal of what good education is

(Leeman en Wardekker, 2010)

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 8: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Dilemmas in tutoring and assessment

Problem definition Ownership Ethics and the researcher’s double role Methodology Theoretical framework

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 9: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Problem definition

The often normative and biased character of the problem definition

Need for exploration and deepeningResearch question is researchable and doableIt is not too narrow and not too general

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 10: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Ownership

The research activities contribute to:The student teacher’s development of

competenciesSchool development

(Informatiedossier Startbekwaam ILS-HAN 2009-2010)

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 11: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Methodology

How to choose between different methods?There are always dilemmasWhat is deciding?

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 12: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Ethics and the researcher’s double role

The vulnerable position of student teachersThe teacher’s role versus the researcher’s roleDissemination of results

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 13: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

The theoretical framework

Which criteria?How to assess its quality?

How to bridge the gap between theory and data collection and analysis?

ATEE Conference 2010

Page 14: Arjan Dieleman and Cyrilla van der Donk ATEE Conference 2010

Contact

[email protected]

[email protected]

www.praktijkonderzoekindeschool.nl

Linkedin groep praktijkonderzoek in de school

ATEE Conference 2010