apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data...

121
A0 A119 4&96 NAVAL SURFACE WEAPONS CENTER DAHLGAEN VA F/6 4/1 METHODTO CORRELATE THE UPPER AIR DENSITY WITH SURFACE DENSIT--ETC(U) I JUL 82 L J MCANELLT. UNCLASSIFIED NSWC/TR-82-81 NL E1"EhhEEE ELE~hEEE i IEhh~~E

Transcript of apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data...

Page 1: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

A0 A119 4&96 NAVAL SURFACE WEAPONS CENTER DAHLGAEN VA F/6 4/1METHOD TO CORRELATE THE UPPER AIR DENSITY WITH SURFACE DENSIT--ETC(U)I JUL 82 L J MCANELLT.

UNCLASSIFIED NSWC/TR-82-81 NL

E1"EhhEEEELE~hEEE

i IEhh~~E

Page 2: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

.,.u *~-*1

Page 3: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

UNCLASSIFIED

SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)

REPORT DOCUMENTATION PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS

I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBER

NSWC TR 82-81

4. TITLE (and Subtitle) S. TYPE OF REPORT & PERIOD COVERED

A METHOD TO CORRELATE THE UPPER AIR DENSITY FinalWITH SURFACE DENSITY AND ESTIMATE THEBALLISTIC DENSITY FOR AIR OR SURFACE LAUNCHED S. PERFORMING ORG. REPORT NUMBER

ISSILES7. AUTHOR(,) 6. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBER(e)

Loren J. McAnelly

9. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND ADDRESS 10. PROGRAM ELEMENT. PROJECT. TASKAREA 6 WORK UNIT NUMBERS

Naval Surface Weapons Center (KI) SF 32-391-694Dahlgren, VA 22448 SF 32-399-694

11. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME AND ADDRESS 12 R PORTDATE

Naval Surface Weapons Center

Dahlgren, VA 22448 13.ir MBER OF PAGES

14. MONITORING AGENCY NAME & ADDRESS(Il different from Controlfing Office) IS. SECURITY CLASS. (of thie report)

UNCLASSIFIED

150. DECLASSIFICATION/DOWNGRADINGSCHEDULE

16. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of this Report)

Approved for public release; distribution unlimited.

17. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of the abetract entered in Block 20, it different from Report)

18. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

19. KEY WORDS (Continue on reverse side If neceeery end Identify by block number)

Atmospheric densityBallistic densityExponential functions of altitudeLeast-squares techniqueNomograms

20. ABSTRACT (Continue on reverse aide if neceeeary and Identify by block number)

Atmospheric data collected twice daily from five ocean stations over aperiod of I years were used in a study to correlate ballistic densities at vari-ous levels. The st-idy indicates that a good correlation does exist and thattables, nomograms, or data in a suitable format should be produced for use withnew and existing fire control computers and range tables prepiared for theFleet.

DD , o, 1473 EDITION OF NOV is OSOETE UNCLASSIFIEDS 'N 0102-_ F-014.6601_ UNLASSIFED

SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PA~t (men Date fntered)

Page 4: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

UNCLASSIFIEDSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE (When Deem Entered)

20 ABSTRACT (Cont.)

Two exponential functions of altitude were used to express the density-onefrom surface to 36,000 ft, the other from 36,000 to 65,000 ft. The coefficientiwere selected in a manner that produces a continuous function from sea level to65,000 ft. The coefficients of the two functions were determined using a non-linear least-squares technique.--

\ Fluctuations in the density profiles below 5,000 ft altitude were noted andwere investigated by fitting a sample of temperature and pressure data with aleast-squares technique.

Ballistic densities for firing at surface targets were computed foraltitudes to 50,000 ft. While the current projectiles in the Fleet may notreach an altitude of 50,000 ft, this may become a reality in the near future.The procedure presented in this report could very easily be modified to computeballistic density when firing at air targets at altitudes up to 50,000 ft.

UNCLASSIFIEDSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAOE( men Dae anteroed.

Page 5: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

r

TR 82-81

FOREWORD

The range tables for Navy guns include a nomogram for computing ballistic

density, which may be used when only the surface density is known. While these

nomograms are intended for use when better estimates of ballistic density are not

available, they are based on data prepared in 1922, despite the advent of radio-

sondes and the establishment of ocean weather stations.

Since there frequently are times when a radiosonde observation cannot be made

in the immediate operating area just before firing, or a timely and applicable

meteorological message from the Fleet Numerical Weather Center (FNWC) is not avail-

able, another method for obtaining ballistic densities would serve a useful

purpose.

This report documents a study that shows that ballistic densities can be

estimated from the surface density with a reasonable degree of accuracy. Data are

also presented about the upper atmosphere which may be useful when further studies

pertaining to the atmosphere are conducted.

The study was funded by the Naval Sea Systems Command Surface Weapons

Aerodynamics and Structures Research and Development Block Program.

Released by:

0. F. BRAXTON, Head

Strategic Systems Department

DTIc

COPY

INSETE

Page 6: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The author would like to thank Dr. W. A. Kemper and Mr. Henry E. Castro for

their help in preparing this report. Dr. Kemper provided valuable assistance in

preparing the text of this report. Mr. Castro derived a nonlinear least-squares

technique which was used to fit the observed density data. The technique is

described in Appendix A.

v

Page 7: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

CONTENTS

Page

INTRODUCTION ................................................................. 1

DETAILED PROCEDURE ........................................................... 4

FITTING A SAMPLE SET OF DATA WITH AN ALTERNATE PROCEDURE ........................ 7

FITTING THE U.S. STANDARD ATMOSPHERE ......................................... 9

RESULTS ...................................................................... 13

DISCUSSION OF RESULTS ........................................................ 14

CONCLUSIONS .................................................................. 17

RECOMMENDATIONS .............................................................. 18

REFERENCES ................................................................... 19

APPENDIX A - A NONLINEAR LEAST-SQUARES TECHNIQUE .............................. A-i

APPENDIX B - AN ALTERNATE METHOD FOR COMPUTING DENSITY ........................ B-i

APPENDIX C - COEFFICIENTS OBTAINED BY FITTING OBSERVED DENSITY .............. C-i

APPENDIX D - DENSITY RATIO PROFILES FOR STATION E ............................. D-1

APPENDIX E - BALLISTIC DENSITY PROFILES FOR STATION .......................... E-I

APPENDIX F - SELECTED BALLISTIC DENSITIES FOR STATIONS E, V, D, N, AND C ..... F-I

DISTRIBUTION ................................................................... (1)

vii

Page 8: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

INTRODUCTION

One of the basic premises of fire control systems in use in the Fleet today is

a "Standard Atmosphere." Obviously, the same premise is also used in the prepara-

tion of ballistic tables for the Fleet. Since the conditions used as a basis for a

standard atmosphere are rarely encountered on earth, corrections for nonstandard

conditions are always in order. A procedure frequently used to correct for a non-

standard density involves a ballistic air density in the zolution of fire control

problems. The ballistic air density may be defined as a scale factor that, when

multiplied by the standard air density at each altitude, produces a density struc-

ture that would cause the same displacement of a projectile impact point as the

actual density structure.

The most reliable method of determining ballistic density is to use accurate,

representative, and timelj meteorological observations in the computation. There

are, however, occasions when these measurements are not available, and alternate

methods are necessary to provide the requisite information. It is a standard pro-

cedure to include a nomogram in the ballistic tables for the Fleet. The use of the

nomogram is an alternative that is available to the Fleet for estimating the upper

air density for naval gunfire when a ballistic meteorological forecast is not

available. The nomograms may be used to estimate the ballistic density when the

air temperature, pressure, and relative humidity at the surface are known.

The basic data used to prepare the nomograms were obtained from Table IV, The

Ballistic Density Factor,1 which was published in 1935. A footnote to this table

states, "This table has been extracted from Table C of a pamphlet entitled Method

for Determining Air Temperature and Ballistic Air Density, published by the Signal

Corps (Meteorological Service), U.S. Army in 1922."

Fire control systems have been improved to the point where an accurate deter-

mination of the upper air density is required if the potential of the systems is to

be fully utilized. The need for improving the nomograms or providing an alternate

prncedure to determine the ballistic density has long been recognized.

The work described in this report, stated briefly, consisted of (1) obtaining

Rawinsonde data from ;, rious weather stations, (2) sorting the data according to

LI

Page 9: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

surface densities and seasons, (3) fitting the upper air densities with a least-

squares technique, and (4) computing ballistic densities.

Rawinsonde data used in the study were obtained from five maritime stations

which took soundings daily at 0000 and 1200 hr G.m.t. over a period from 1968 to

1973. The data, consisting of both significant and mandatory levels, were provided

by the National Climatic Center, Asheville, North Carolina. Mandatory levels are

specified pressure altitudes, which are obtained by interpolation. Significant

levels are the altitudes that are considered essential in defining a weather pro-

file. Soundings that did not include surface density were not used in the study.

Some of the obvious errors were eliminated in processing the data prior to perform-

ing the least-squares fit, but no attempt was made to eliminate errors in the basic

data beyond ttai point.

The geodetic coordinates of the five stations used in the study are listed

below:

Station Name Latitude Longitude

E 350 0' N 48" 0' WV 340 0' N 1640 0' EC 520 45' N 350 30' WD 440 0' N 41" 0' WN 300 0' N 140" 0'W

A map of the stations is shown in Figure 1.

No land-based stations were used in the analysis, even though naval gunfire

support is conducted on beach areas. Since the density correlations are markedly

affected by the nature of the terrain,2 there is more than a probability that

somewhat different results would be obtained for different littoral areas of the

earth.

All computer programs used in the study were coded in FORTRAN EXTENDED and

were executed with a Control Data Corporation (CDC) 6700 computer.

The purpose of performing the work described in this report was to establish a

procedure to determine the correlation between upper air and surface densities and

2

Page 10: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

U3)

UUzf

w I%-

cin

0Z 1-4

ciI cn

Lz

ci -

rz4

OL s 0 SZ- as- SL-

3

Page 11: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

to devise a method for estimating the ballistic air density based on surface

conditions.

DETAILED PROCEDURE

The first step in the procedure was to compute the air density using the tem-

perature, pressure, and relative humidity. The geopotential altitudes were con-

verted to geometric altitudes. Sondes that did not include surface conditions were

omitted. The data for each station were sorted into two groups according to the

time of day and stored in permanent files with the Indexed-Sequential File

Organization. This procedure permits accessing the data in either a sequential or

random order. The sondes were assigned indices which were stored in separate

sequential files. One file of indices was created with the corresponding surface

densities in ascending numerical order, and a second file was created with the sur-

face densities also sorted into the four seasons. A follow-up program was designed

to skip specified segments when the files were read. This made it convenient to

group the data in various ways without rearranging the Indexed-Sequential files.

The data were then selected in groups where the median surface density of each

group varied by a percentage point from the U.S. Standard surface density as

defined in Reference 3 (i.e., into classes by surface density ratios where the

class interval was one percent). Since large variations were encountered in the

frequency of the surface densities, it was necessary to eliminate some of the

sondes in the mid-ranges. Several fits were made using various numbers of samples

in each fit. No significant differences were obtained by using more than 25 sam-

ples; consequently, a further restriction was placed on each group that limited the

number of sondes to 25. While some of the groups outside the mid-ranges had varia-

tions in surface densities of one percent, the actual number of samples was, in

some cases, less than 25. In contrast, some of the groups of 25 samples in the

mid-ranges had variations in surface densities of only a fraction of one percent.

Various functions were investigated to represent a mean density profile for

each group of data, Comparisons were made of three different functions for rep-

resenting the density in the altitude range from 0 to 36,089 ft:

4

Page 12: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

1. a third-degree polynomial

2. a third-degree polynomial for the ratio of the observed density to the

U.S. Standard density

3. an exponential function plus a linear term

While these three functions produced similar results, the exponential function was

selected. The fitting technique is described in Appendix A. The following expres-

sion was used in the altitude range from 0 to 36,089 ft:

P ce(c 2h) +CP ficle 2 + ch (I)

wmere,

p is the density (lb/ft 3 )

h is the altitude (ft)

ci, c 2 , and c3 are constants determined by the fit

A similar expression was used to fit the data in the region from 36,089- to

65,000-ft altitude:

Cc4*(h - 36089))

P = P36089 e + c 5*(h - 36089) (2)

where,

P36089 is the density at 36,089 ft, computed using equation (1) and the

data up to 36,089 ft

c 4 and c5 are coefficients determined in the fit above 36,089 ft

A bias was noted in the lower altitudes with each of the three methods. After

some experimenting, data below 3,500 ft were excluded from the fit to determine the

coefficients. The fit was then extrapolated to mean sea level, and a linear cor-

rection was added from 0 to 3,500 ft, which made P equal to PO at the surface:

5

Page 13: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

(c h)

P= c1 e 2 + c3h + (P0 - c1 )(3500 - h)/3500 (3)

where,

P is the density (lb/ft3 )

ci, c2, and c3 are the coefficients obtained with equation (1)

h is the altitude (ft)

p0 is the median of the observed surface densities (lb/ft3 )

Although this procedure does not use any of the available data between surface

and 3,500 ft in the least-squares fit to determine the coefficients cl, c2, and

c residuals from the fit in this region are included in the analysis. Adding the

linear correction made a significant improvement in the residuals from surface to

3,500 ft.

The upper boundary of 36,089 ft was selected from the zone where equation (1)

was used in order to coincide with the breakpoint in the U.S. Standard atmosphere.

While there are some seasonal, latitudinal, and diurnal variations in the isopycnic

level where the density remains nearly constant, no attempt was made to explore

this facet.

After fitting the observed density data, using equations (1) Men (2), density

profiles were computed using equations (2) and (3) with the coefficients obtained

in the least-squares fit. Ballistic densities for each profile were computed with

the equation,

nBallistic Density = (WF. * R.) (4)

i= I 1

where,

n is the number of zones

WF. is the density weighting factor for the ith zone1

| " II • - . .. i _ " : rr .. . - • . ..

Page 14: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

R. is the ratio of the mean density of the ith zone of the profile to the U.S.IStandard density at that altitude, which is the mid-point of the ith zone.

The density weighting factors used to compute the ballistic density were

obtained by computing trajectories with ballistic parameters for the 5-Inch High

Fragmentation Projectile fired with a Mk 73 charge, which produces an initial

velocity of 2,950 ft/sec. The altitudes covered by each zone are presented in

Table 1, and a tabulation of the weighting factors are presented in Table 2.

TABLE 1. ALTITUDE OF ZONES

Zone Altitude (ft) Zone Altitude (ft) Zone Altitude (ft)

1 0 - 1,000 10 9,000 - 10,000 19 26,000 - 28,0002 1,000 - 2,000 11 10,000 - 12,000 20 28,000 - 30,0003 2,000 - 3,000 12 12,000 - 14,000 21 30,000 - 32,0004 3,000 - 4,000 13 14,000 - 16,000 22 32,000 - 34,000

5 4,000 - 5,000 14 16,000 - 18,000 23 34,000 - 36,0006 5,000 - 6,000 ]5 18,000 - 20,000 24 36,000 - 38,0007 6,000 - 7,000 16 20,000 - 22,000 25 38,000 - 40,0008 7,000 - 8,000 17 22,000 - 24,000 26 40,000 - 45,0009 8,000 - 9,000 18 24,000 - 26,000, 27 45,000 - 50,000

FITTING A SAMPLE SET OF DATA WITH AN ALTERNATE PROCEDURE

An alternate method was used to fit a sample set of data in the region from

surface to 36,000 ft. In this procedure, the virtual temperature was computed,

using the observed temperature and relative humidity. Separate least-squares fits

were then made to the virtual temperatures and pressures. The temperature and

pressure profiles obtained in this manner were then used to compute the density.

This procedure and the results are described in detail in Appendix B. The sample

set of data was obtained from 25 sondes that had been selected previously for fit-

ting with equation (1). The sondes were observed at Station E during the spring

season, 1200 hr G.m.t., on days that had a surface density close to the U.S.

Standard density at mean sea level.

7

Page 15: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

o 0i

t 0 0

NC

0000

00 1 0000009 .

c; o o

N >o40

0090000

N 00000000 ; ; ;C eC C c ; ;c0 000

C; C c 0 c 0000000 C C C

0 ON~~ C~N9C; oee1 oC00;(sC0000;C; c

0; c ;c saC ;d ;c ;c ;c ; C

i-f ONC ; c 6c ;c ; ;c ;c ;c ;c

C;C; c;c;c c c 00000000000s ; ; ;c;c;c;c

C;~~ ~ ~ NON o C 30C ;3 s ' ;4 C N N;

Z; Nc; 0; c N -0 C; NO43c

N~1 8 0 0 N

s-f 0000000000000sc c c c c c .

Page 16: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

The purpose of using the alternate method was to evaluate the method described

in the section Procedure and to provide additional information about the atmo-

sphere, particularly in the lower altitudes.

While this method is a good procedure for providing temperature, pressure, and

density profiles, it is a more time-consuming method for obtaining density profiles

than the method of making a least-squares fit to the densities.

The density profile obtained with this method did not result in a noticeably

different profile, but it did provide additional information about the temperature

and pressure. The pressure data from surface to 36,000-ft altitude were fit with a

single function that has a continuous derivative. The temperature data were

divided into three altitude zones. Separate least-squares fits were made to each

zone in a manner that made the curve continuous but with a different lapse rate in

each zone. The improvement in using the correction term in equation (3) to fit the

density is largely due to the variations in the temperature lapse rate at the lower

altitudes.

FITTING THE U.S. STANDARD ATMOSPHERE

In order to further test the least-squares method and the exponential repre-

sentation of the density, a fit was made to the U.S. Standard density, using equa-

tions (1) and (2). Since the U.S. Standard temperature has a constant lapse rate

from surface to 36,089-ft altitude, the correction term in equation (3) was not

used. It should be noted that equations (1) and (2) were not intended to define

the U.S. Standard density but were selected to fit the observed data. However, the

standard deviations in the fit were only 0.14 and 0.28 percent in the zones from 0-

to 36,089-ft, and 36,089- to 65,000-ft altitude, respectively. Since the density

varies with altitude, the residuals were expressed as ratios of the U.S. Standard

density at the corresponding altitude. A tabulation of the fit is presented in

Tables 3 and 4.

9

Page 17: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TABLE 3. LEAST-SQUARES FIT OF U.S. STANDARD DENSITY0 - 36,000 ft

1 2 3 4U.S. Standard L. S. Fit Col. 2 - Cal. 3

Altitude Density Density Col. 3

(ft) (lb/ft3) (ib/3) _ _

0. 0.076474 0.07665845 -0.00240610500. 0.075362 0.07551388 -0.00201122

1,000. 0.074262 0.07438439 -0.001645331,500. 0.073174 0.07326977 -0.001307122,000. 0.072098 0.07216982 -0.00099517

2,500. 0.071035 0.07108433 -0.000693953,000. 0.069984 0.07001309 -0.000415533,500. 0.068945 0.06895591 -0.000158244,000. 0.067917 0.06791259 0.000064944,500. 0.066902 0.06688293 0.00028510

5,000. 0.065898 0.06586675 0.000474505,500. 0.064906 0.06486384 0.000649916,000. 0.063925 0.06387404 0.000797836,500. 0.062956 0.06289715 0.000935687,000. 0.061998 0.06193299 0.00104969

7,500. 0.061051 0.06098138 0.001141598,000. 0.060116 0.06004216 0.001229868,500. 0.059191 0.05911513 0.001283389,000. 0.058278 0.05820014 0.001337769,500. 0.057375 0.05729702 0.00136106

10,000. 0.056483 0.05640559 0.0013724510,500. 0.055602 0.05552569 0.0013743111,000. 0.054731 0.05465717 0.0013508511,500. 0.053871 0.05379985 0.0013224112,000. 0.053022 0.05295360 0.00129174

12,500. 0.052182 0.05211824 0.0012233613,000. 0.051353 0.05129363 0.0011574513,500. 0.050534 0.05047962 0.0010773414,000. 0.049725 0.04967605 0.0009853914,500. 0.048926 0.04888278 0.00088407

15,000. 0.048137 0.04809968 0.0007759815,500. 0.047358 0.04732658 0.0006638916,000. 0.046589 0.04656336 0.0005506716,500. 0.045829 0.04580987 0.0004175417,000. 0.045079 0.04506598 0.00028881

17,500. 0.044338 0.04433156 0.0001452618,000. 0.043606 0.04360647 -0.0000107218,500. 0.042884 0.04289057 -0.00015329

10

Page 18: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

TABLE 3. LEAST-SQUARES FIT OF U.S. STANDARD DENSITY

0 - 36,000 ft (Continued)

1 2 3 4U.S. Standard L. S. Fit Col. 2 - Col. 3

Altitude Density Density Col. 3

(ft) b/ft3) (lb/ft 3 )

19,000. 0.042171 0.04218375 -0.0003023219,500. 0.041468 0.04148588 -0.00043087

20,000. 0.040773 0.04079682 -0.0005837620,500. 0.040087 0.04011645 -0.0007341321,000. 0.039410 0.03944466 -0.0008786721,500. 0.038742 0.03878132 -0.0010138722,000. 0.038083 0.03812631 -0.00113606

22,500. 0.037432 0.03747953 -0.0012680323,000. 0.036790 0.03684084 -0.0013799523,500. 0.036156 0.03621014 -0.0014951624,000. 0.035531 0.03558732 -0.0015825124,500. 0.034914 0.03497226 -0.00166590

25,000. 0.034306 0.03436486 -0.0017127925,500. 0.033705 0.03376501 -0.0017772426,000. 0.033113 0.03317260 -0.0017966826,500. 0.032529 0.03258753 -0.0017961427,000. 0.031952 0.03200970 -0.00180254

27,500. 0.031384 0.03143900 -0.0017494228,000. 0.030823 0.03087534 -0.0016950828,500. 0.030270 0.03031861 -0.0016032329,000. 0.029725 0.02976872 -0.0014685829,500. 0.029187 0.02922557 -0.00131974

30,000. 0.028657 0.02868907 -0.0011178630,500. 0.028134 0.02815913 -0.0008922731,000. 0.027619 0.02763564 -0.0006022431,500. 0.027110 0.02711853 -0.0003146632,000. 0.026610 0.02660771 0.00008623

32,500. 0.026116 0.02610307 0.0004952433,000. 0.025629 0.02560455 0.0009550133,500. 0.025149 0.02511204 0.0014716534,000. 0.024676 0.02462548 0.0020516134,500. 0.024210 0.02414477 0.00270177

35,000. 0.023751 0.02366983 0.0034294036,000. 0.022853 0.02273694 0.00510442

Mean of Column 4 -0.00000178

Standard Deviation of Column 4 0.00140643

11

Page 19: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

TABLE 4. LEAST-SQUARES FIT OF U.S. STANDARD DENSITY36,200 - 65,000 ft

1 2 3 4U.S. Standard L. S. Fit Col. 2 - Col. 3

Altitude Density Density Col. 3

(ft) (lb/ft3) (lb/ft3)

36200. 0.022666 0.02253574 0.0057803237000. 0.021814 0.02169457 0.0055049038000. 0.020794 0.02068713 0.0051658239000. 0.019822 0.01972648 0.0048423340000. 0.018895 0.01881043 0.00449577

41000. 0.018012 0.01793693 0.0041854142000. 0.017170 0.01710398 0.0038596843000. 0.016367 0.01630972 0.0035119044000. 0.015602 0.01555234 0.0031928745000. 0.014873 0.01483014 0.00289033

46000. 0.014178 0.01414147 0.0025834447000. 0.013516 0.01348478 0.0023154148000. 0.012884 0.01285858 0.0019766449000. 0.012282 0.01226147 0.0016744750000. 0.011709 0.01169208 0.00144691

51000. 0.011162 0.01114914 0.0011536652000. 0.010641 0.01063141 0.0009024053000. 0.010144 0.01013772 0.0006197654000. 0.0096701 0.00966695 0.0003254555000. 0.0092186 0.00921805 0.00005944

56000. 0.0087882 0.00879000 -0.0002043757000. 0.0083780 0.00838182 -0.0004556158000. 0.0079870 0.00799260 -0.0007001859000. 0.0076142 0.00762145 -0.0009510560000. 0.0072589 0.00726754 -0.00118830

61000. 0.0069202 0.00693006 -0.0014226062000. 0.0065973 0.00660825 -0.0016575163000. 0.0062895 0.00630139 -0.0018871964000. 0.0059961 0.00600878 -0.0021103565000. 0.0057164 0.00572976 -0.00233130

Mean of Column 4 0.00003016

Standard Deviation of Coltmn 4 0.00284086

The following equations were used in the least-squares fit of the U.S.

Standard density:

12

Page 20: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

0 h 36089

(c2 h)p =cle + c3 h

36,089 _ h 65,000

(c * (h - 36089)S.36089 e + c * (h - 36089)

where

h is the altitude (ft)

The coefficients obtained in the least-squares fit are:

c1 0.0766584476 (lb/ft3)

c 2 -0.282539693789 E-4 (ft - 1 )

c 3 -0.138466611596 E-6 (lb/ft4 )

P360 89 " 0.0226549960 (lb/ft3)

c 4 -0.475504250122 E-4 (ft- 1 )

c5 0.459663274698 E-11 (lb/ft 3)

RESULTS

The coefficients that were obtained by fitting the density data, and the root

mean squares (rms) or standard deviation of the residuals and their algebraic means

are given in Appendix C for the five stations analyzed. Data are presented for two

times of day (0000 and 1200 hr G.m.t.) for the four seasons and for the seasons

combined for each station.

Profiles of the density ratios for station E are given in Appendix D. The

ratios were obtained by evaluating the least-squares fit of the observed densities

at specified altitudes and dividing the density in each case by the U.S. Standard

13

Page 21: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

density for the sane altitude. Profiles are shown for the two times of day for

each of the four seasons and for the seasons combined.

Profiles of the ballistic densities obtained by multiplying the ratios with

the density weighting factors using equation (4) are shown in Appendix E for sta-

tion E for the same conditions. Density ratios and ballistic densities were com-

puted for each of the five stations, but the profiles are shown only for station E

in Appendixes D and E.

While the ballistic densities were computed for the 27 zones listed in

Table 1, only an abbreviated tabulation is given in Appendix F. Data are presented

for only two zones, 30,000 and 50,000 ft. The ballistic densities were computed

with equation (4), using the density weighting factors given in Table 2. Data for

the two zones are given for each of the five stations and for each surface condi-

tion where sufficient data were available to make a least-squares fit to the

observed data.

DISCUSSION OF RESULTS

One question is of primary interest-is there sufficient correlation between

surface density and that of the upper atmosphere to accurately predict the bal-

listic density for various altitudes from surface measurements? To answer this

question, we first note that the density ratio curves given in Appendix D for sta-

tion E are families of very similiar curves. If some of the curves were missing,

we could do a fair job of reproducing the curves by interpolation. This would seem

to indicate, qualitatively at least, that one could predict the density ratios

aloft from the starting point of the curve on the x-axis, which is the surface

density ratio. The same is true of the curves given for ballistic density in

Appendix E. It deserves mentioning that the points plotted in Appendix D are not

the mean values of individual sondes but are values corresponding to the functional

fit.

The sondes were groupe.1 in order that a more reliable mean and standard devia-

tion could be established. It is recognized that the curves in Appendix D do not

reflect the errors of the means or the variations in the upper atmosphere within a

14

Page 22: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

group of sondes. A total of 14,800 sondes were processed in this study in an

attempt to establish reliable means and standard deviations. In every fit, the

mean and standard deviation were computed. These are tabulated in Appendix C. A

large majority of the means are only a small fraction of one percent.

The standard deviations of the residuals are given in Table 5 according to percen-

tiles. A total of 300 fits was made in each of the two altitude zones, 0 to 36,000

and 36,000 to 65,000 ft. The standard deviations of the residuals were arranged in

numerical order without regard to station, season, or time of day. The standard

deviation of the 50th percentile is 1.114 percent in the lower altitude zone.

TABLE 5. STANDARD DEVIATIONS OF THE RESIDUALS

Altitude Altitude0 - 36,000 (ft) 36,000 - 65,000 (ft)

Percenttle (%) (%)

10 0.675 2.01920 0.799 2.29330 0.908 2.58640 1.000 2.83250 1.114 3.067

60 1.227 3.29570 1.424 3.58480 1.577 3.95990 1.703 4.298100 2.257 6.377

Note: The standard deviations in this table were obtained by multiplying thestandard deviations (SIQMA) in Appendix C by 100 in order to express them as apercentage instead of as a ratio.

It should also be remembered that there are variations in the surface densi-

ties because of grouping the data, which probably has a neglible effect on the means

but makes a small contribution to the standard deviations. The noise level in the

data appears to increase with altitude, which is to be expected. The residuals are

much larger in the fits above 36,000 ft than they are at the lower altitudes, while

the density should be more stable at the higher altitudes.

It may be noted that the ballistic density represents a weighted average of

the density ratios. Accordingly, any fluctuations that are random, and that may be

15 I

Page 23: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

present in the ratios of the true density to the mean density, would tend to aver-

age out in computing the ballistic density.

Another question that deserves consideration is-how important is geographic

location, season, and time of day? Only five stations used in the study are

located in wide ocean areas, far from land, and between 30@ and 50* N latitude.

Data were available for only two times of day, 0000 and 1200 hr G.m.t., which makes

it difficult to determine the diurnal variations. Based on the data available,

there does not seem to be much payoff for preparing separate tables for different

times of day and different seasons for the geographic areas that might be repre-

sented by the five stations.

There does appear to be a significant difference between the correlates of

stations E, N, and C, North latitudes 35, 50, and 52* 45', respectively. The

ballistic density at 30,000 ft, corresponding to the same surface density, is about

one-half percent higher at the lower latitude stations than at station C. The sur-

face densities run higher at station C. The upper air density may decrease more

rapidly than it does at the other stations, resulting in lower ballistic densities

for the same surface density.

Data by season do not appear to correlate differently, except at station C.

The largest difference noted here was for surface density 1.03, where the ballistic

density at 30,000 ft was about one percent lower in summer than in other seasons.

While the procedure presented in this report has been used on only five sta-

tions that have an oceanic climate, it should be possible to use essentially the

same procedure for processing data from stations where the climate is more affected

by land masses. Some modifications might be required, since the temperature lapse

rate might be quite different. The diurnal and seasonal variations in pressure and

temperature are normally much larger over land masses than they are over large

bodies of water.

A similar but earlier study 2 was made by the Army Electronics Command, Fort

Monmouth, New Jersey. Data from land-based stations were used in this study and a

number of tables were prepared for each geographic area, season, and time of day.

16

4

Page 24: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

CONCLUSIONS

1. There does appear to be a good correlation between the surface density and

the density at various altitudes over the mid-ocean areas studied.

2. The resulting correlations are different for different latitudes. They do

not change appreciably with diurnal time or season over the areas studied.

3. The differences between surface and upper atmospheric conditions are much

larger over littoral areas.

4. The procedure described in this report for determining the correlation

between upper air density and the surface density may be used for a variety of

stations with only minor modifications to the procedure.

5. While the procedure for estimating ballistic density was developed prima-

rily for firing Navy guns, it may also be useful to predict the ballistic den-

sity for air-launched missiles.

6. It is estimated that the density ratios at altitudes not to exceed

36,000 ft may be predicted with an error not to exceed 1.0 percent, using the

correlation between the surface density and the density of the upper atmo-

sphere.

7. It is estimated that the ballistic density may be predicted with an error

not to exceed 0.5 percent in 90 percent of the cases where the altitude does

not exceed 36,000 ft.

8. It is estimated that the ballistic density may be predicted with an error

between one and two percent where the altitude is between 36,000 and

50,000 ft. This error could be reduced somewhat if the data used in the study

had been collected with present day equipment.

17

• I

Page 25: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Correlations should be obtained for other latitudes, including both mari-

time and beach areas of strategic importance.

2. More data should be obtained for the extremely low and high surface densi-

ties.

3. A further study should be conducted to determine how the procedure of

estimating the ballistic density, as described in this report, could be imple-

mented in fire control systems and in preparation of range tables.

4. Consideration should be given to using the analytic expression for density

in computer programs that simulate the trajectories of unguided missiles.

18

Page 26: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

REFERENCES

1. U.S. Naval Academy, Range and Ballistic Tables, 1935, p. 84.

2. Marvin J. Lowenthal, The Accuracy of Ballistic Density Departure Tables 1934-

1972, ECOM-5436, OSD 1366 (April 1972).

3. Committee on Extension to the Standard Atmosphere, U.S. Standard Atmosphere,

1976, (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1976).

19

Page 27: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

APPENDIX A

A NONLINEAR LEAST-SQUARES TECHNIQUE

A-I

Page 28: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

A NONLINEAR LEAST-SQUARES TECHNIQUE

Statement of the Problem

Let (xi, yi), i = 1,2, ..., N be a set of N data points and

f(x, al, a2 , ... , al4) (A-1)

be a function with x as the independent variable. (a.), j = 1,2, ... , M are

parameters of the function and the function may not be linear in these parameters.

We would like to determine values of the M parameters such that

i=N 2F(aI , a2 , .... aM) i Wi[Y i - f(xi, a a 2, ..., a (A-2)

is a minimum. This is the least-squares solution, which is the same as minimizing

the sum of the squares of the residuals. A weight W. is assigned to each data1

point.

For simplicity of notation, we let

fi(a) = f(xi, a,, a2 1 .... , aM), i = 1,2, ..., N (A-3)

where a = (al. a2, ... , aM). The only restriction on the function fi(a) is that

the partial derivatives of the function with respect to the M parameters be

continuous in all of the arguments.

This implies that f.(a) is a function that can be differentiated.1

We assume that these partial derivatives exist at a point 1, and in some

neighborhood about i, which includes the point a. Let

3= + Aa (A-4)

A-3*1.li E

Page 29: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

where i (31, a 23 ' am) and Aa- (Aal, Aa2, ..., AaM).

If f.(a) can be differentiated at 1, then the differential at 3 is an1

approximation to f.(a) - f.(i) and f.(a) - f.-) O(Aa)(a-i).

Thus, j=M af.(i)

fiC(a) f f(a) I Aa. + E(Aa) (A-5)j. i

where E(Aa)-*O as Aa+O for i = 1,2, ... , N.

If the approximation i is close enough to the solution a, then the problem is

considered solved when

tj - ! I j T, j - 1,2, ... ', (A-6)

where T - desired precision for the solution.

Formulation of Solution

We now derive the formulation for finding Aa. The solution a is then equal to

1 + Aa.

Using equation (A-5), we form the overdetermined system of equations (N>M)

Y jinM afi(M)f+ I Da. aa. (A-7)

for data points i = 1,2, ... , N.

A--4

I

Page 30: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

The system of equations used to find a becomes

a f ( ) f( ) f ( )a-1 Aa + - -a + + - Aa = Y - fC) CA-8)

a1 1 a 2 ... 14 i

(i f 1,2, ... , N).

The system of observational equations (A-8) can now be written in matrix form

as given by

AX = Y (A-9)

where,

aa I 3a2 ... 3aM

f 2(a) f 2(a) af2(i)a aa2 .. a

f N (a) af N () af N()a 3a 2 ...

Aa1

A2

XA-

A-5

Page 31: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Yl - fl (I

Y2 - f 2

YN- fN(a)

The column matrix Y is called the residual matrix. Solving matrix equation

(A-9) yields the normal equations in matrix form

AT Ax ATY (A-10)

If the residuals are to be weighted, we can include the weight matrix W

where,

'W1

W2

o20w .(A-Il)

WN

Completing the solution to the matrix equation (A-10) and upon including the

weight matrix, we have

X- (AT WA) - 1 ATWY (A-12)

X is the least-squares solution to the system of equations (A-8) with the

weights includ. Elements of the X matrix are now tested in absolute value

against the tolerance T. If the tolerance test is satisfied, we are done and the

least-square solution to equation (A-2) is given by

a. a. + ta, j - 1,2, ... , M (A-13)

A-6

Page 32: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Whenever the tolerance test fails, equation (A-13) gives the next approxima-

tion and the iteration process is repeated with matrix equation (A-12) until the

tolerance test is satisfied.

Remarks

Once an acceptable solution has been found, it may be desirable to know how

well the function fits the given data. Analysis for how well the solution fits can

usually be made by examining the residuals for each observation.

The variances for the solution (a) can be found from the variance, covariance

matrix.

If the variances and residuals are large, a different approximating function

f.(a) may be tested.1~

When polynomials are used for testing, the residuals will drop off rapidly as

the degree of the polynomial increases from one. Further increase in the degree of

the polynomial will show little improvement of the residuals.

A-7

Page 33: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

APPENDIX B

AN~ ALTERNATE METHOD FOR COMPUTING DENSITY

B-1

Page 34: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

AN ALTERNATE METHOD FOR COMPUTING DENSITY

Since the procedure used to fit the observed densities provided little infor-

mation as to why the correction term for altitudes below 3,500 ft improved the fit,

an investigation was made using a sample set of data obtained from 25 sondes. The

sondes were taken consecutively from the group that had been sorted according to

season after the surface densities were arranged in numerical order. The median of

the surface densities in the sample was equal to the U.S. Standard density at mean

sea level. The sondes were released at station E during the spring season,

1200 hr G.m.t.

Separate least-squares fits were made to the pressure and temperature in the

altitude range from 0 to 36,089 ft. No attempt was made to fit the temperature or

pressure above 36,089-ft altitude.

The equation used to fit the pressure is similar to equation (1)

( P2h)(-)P = p 1 e + p 3h (B-1)

where

P is the pressure (mb)

h is the altitude (ft)

Pit P21 and p3 are constants determined in the least-squares fit

The observed temperatures were first converted to virtual temperatures with

the equation

TV T (B-2)

1.0 -0.3783*RH*V P

where

TV is the virtual temperature (°K)

T is the observed temperature (K)

RH is the observed relative humidity (dimensionless)

B-3

Page 35: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

V is the saturation vapor pressure (mb)

P is the observed pressure (mb)

Several least-squares fits were made with the virtual temperature in the alti-

tude range from 0 to 36,089 ft using polynomials that, in every case, produced

large residuals below 5,000 ft. A big improvement was made by segmenting the data

into three zones, 0 to 3,500, 3,501 to 6,000, and 6,001 to 36,089 ft. A one-degree

polynomial least-squares fit was used in the two lower zones and a third-degree

polynomial was used in the upper zone. The intersections of the equations are

located at 3,731 and 5,270 ft which were used to define the boundaries of the

zones.

The density was computed with the equation

p - P/(R*T) (B-3)

where

p is the density (lb/ft3 )

P is the pressure determined by a least-squares fit (mb)

T is the temperature determined by a least-squares fit (OK)

R is a constant, 45.981610868

Computing the density in this manner made a small reduction in the mean of the

residuals but no improvement in the standard deviation. While a single function

fits the pressure from sea level to 36,089 ft, the nonlinearity in the temperature

profile is quite apparent. The lapse rate in the temperature based on the least-

squares fit from sea level to 3,731 ft is 2.60"C per 1,000 ft and 0.358C per

1,000 ft from 3,731 to 5,270 ft using the intersections of the equations to define

the zone boundaries. The average lapse rate based on the least-squares fit in the

zone from 5,270 to 36,089 ft is 1.99"C per 1,000 ft. The latter value is in good

agreement with the lapse rate of 1.98C per 1,000 ft from sea level to 36,089 ft

that was used to define the U.S. Standard atmosphere.

Profiles of the temperature and pressure obtained with the least-squares fit

are shown in Figures B-1 and B-2, respectively. A profile of the density computed

B-4

Page 36: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

0CD0 __________

(0

CD~

CDC0

C3.

LJ

0: C

I-C3 ___ __ _ _ _

C)0

C)

(0D:

!2

03C)_ __ _ __ _ __ _

C'J

C

C) _ ___ _ _ _

C0

03

C300 290 280 270 260 250 240 2310 220 21'0 200'

TEMPERATURE DEC K

FIGURE B-1. STATION F SPRING 1200 hr G.m.t.Temperature profile based on three least-squares fits, linear 0 -3,500, linear3,500 - 6,000, and third-degree polynomial 6,000 -3,600 ft. The equations werespliced at 3,730 and 5,270 ft.

B-5

Page 37: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

00

0

00

C7

CD0 1

C

o ',

c)

o

200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 110OO 1200

PRESSURE MB

FIGURE B-2. STATION E 1200 hr G.m.t.Pressure profile based on a least-squares fit with an exponential function.

B-6

Page 38: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

with equation (7) is shown in Figure B-3. For comparison, Figure B-4 is a profile

of the density computed with equations (1) and (3) where the coefficients were

obtained by making a least-squares fit to the observed densities. Very little dif-

ference can be seen when curves of Figures B-3 and B-4 are superimposed.

From these results-(l) the small difference in the residuals between the two

methods of calculating densities, and (2) indiscernible difference in the two

curves obtained-it appears that there is no advantage in computing density from

smoothed temperature and pressure data versus smoothed density data. It may be

noted that the first method requires 11 undetermined constants, the latter

only 4.

The method of making separate least-squares fits to the temperature and

pressure does provide a much clearer explanation as to why the correction term in

equation (3) improved the fit to the density. The reason is the large variations

in the lapse rate of the temperature at the lower altitudes.

The equations used to fit the temperature are

Altitude (ft)

0 - 3,500 Temperature = a0 + a h

3,500 - 6,000 Temperature = a; + a'h

6,000 - 36,000 Temperature = a" + a"h +a"h +0 1 2 3

where

temperature is the virtual temperature °K

h is the altitude in feet

The altitudes of intersections are 3,731 and 5,270 ft.

B-7

W

Page 39: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

T1 82-81

10

C3w

(n

0

0

0 C__ __

w(i,

0L

0

CD

t-0

(0

0D0

Co

0.80 0.74 0.68 0.62 0.56 0.50 0.44 0.38 0.32 0.26 0.20

DENSITY LB/CU FT M10-1

FIGURE B-3.Density profile computed from the data of Figures B-1 and B-2.

B-8

Page 40: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

C30)

C)

C)4

CD4

C-)

4

LUC0

C!

- oi l

CD C-J

CD

C!

C3

CD_ __ _ __ _ _ _ _C30r

0DOD__

0.8 0.4 0680.62 0.56 0.50 0.44 0.38 0.32 0.26 0.20

OENSIT% LB/CU FT *10-

FIGURE B-4. STATION E SPRING 1200 h~r G.m.t.Density profile computed directly from a least-squares fit to the density.

B-9

Page 41: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

The coefficients obtained in the least-squares fit are

a0 = 0.29098019920169 E+3

a, = -0.26010921095663 E-2

a; = 0.28261034232183 E+3

a' = -0.35814511053088 E-3

a" = 0.28474414363984 E+30a" = -0.42144325442356 E-31

a" = -0.69303432938534 E-72a" = 0.85246672752231 E-123

The mean and standard deviations of the residuals divided by the computed

values are

Altitude (ft) Mean Sigma N

0 - 3,500 -0.00000002 0.00603867 983,500 - 6,000 0.00000000 0.01019354 766,000 - 36,000 -0.00000008 0.01654041 357

0 - 36,000 -0.00000362 0.01433263 531

N is the number of data points in the fit.

The temperature profile is shown in Figure B-i.

The equation used to fit the pressure is

P = c 1* e(c 2h)*e1 +c 3 h

where

P is pressure in mb

h is the altitude in feet

The coefficients obtained in the least-squares fit are

B-10

Page 42: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

cI = 0.1025894426895 E+4

c2 = -0.3512226501974 E-4

c3 = -0.1469124958633 E-2

The mean and standard deviation of the residuals divided by the computed

values are

Altitude (ft) Mean Sigma N

0 - 36,000 -0.00000270 0.01171363 531

N is the number of data points in the fit.

The pressure profile is shown in Figure B-2.

The density profile shown in Figure B-3 was computed with the equation

p = P/(R*t)

where

p is the density (lb/ft3)

P is the pressure (mb)

T is the virtual temperature (°K)

R is a constant, 45.981610868

The mean and standard deviation of the residuals divided by the computed value

are

Altitude (ft) Mean SigmaN

0 - 36,000 0.00009937 0.01129087 531

The density profile shown in Figure B-4 for altitudes below 3,500 ft was com-

puted with the equation,

B-l

mi - l I n r " :" ,' ... -- I II .. . I II iii - • . . . . .. . '" " . . ..

Page 43: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

(c2 h)

2 3500-P =cle +ch +(0 C) 3500-h

and for altitudes equal to or greater than 3,500 ft was computed with the equation

(c h)p = cle + c3h

which is the same procedure described preyiously in the report. The coefficients

used to create the profile are

cI = 0.076640263730 (lb/ft3 )

c2 = -0.304780287061 E-4 (ft-1 )

P0 = 0.076474 (lb/ft3 )

c3 = -0.517405589378 E-7 (lb/ft4 )

The mean and standard deviation of the residuals divided by the computed value

are

Altitude (ft) Mean Sigma

0 - 36,000 0.00048651 0.01160715

B-12

Page 44: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

APPENDIX C

COEFFICIENTS OBTAINED BY FITTING OBSERVED DENSITY

C-1 im . .111 1 Illl~llllimt . .. . " --

Page 45: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

In this appendix, four lines of data appear for each group of sondes that were

used in the least-squares fit.

Lines 1 and 2:

Item Identification Description

1 N Number of data points that met toler-ances

2 JE Number of points used in fit3 AMEAN Mean of the residuals4 SIGMA Standard deviation of the residuals

Line I is for the altitude range from 0 to 36,089 ft, and Line 2 is for the alti-

tude range 36,089 to 65,000 ft. The first five items in Lines 3 and 4 are coef-

ficients CI, C2, and C3 for equation (1), which were obtained by making a least-

squares fit in the altitude range 3,500 to 36,089 ft, and coefficients C4 and C5

for equation (2), which were obtained by making a least-squares fit in the altitude

range 36,089 to 65,000. The coefficients are listed in the order of their sub-

scripts. The next item on Line 4 is the median of the surface densities of the

sondes used in the fit. The last item is a counter and has no significance.

Data points refer to the individual altitudes where temperature, pressure, and

humidity were recorded. The residuals were expressed as a ratio of the residual to

the density obtained with the least-squares fit as stated previously. No data

points were eliminated in the least-squares fit; but tolerances on the residuals

were specified, and the number of points that met the tolerances were recorded.

The tolerance used in the lower altitude region was 0.025, and in the higher region

it was 0.150. A few tests were made to eliminate bad data points before the least-

squares fit was performed.

C-3

4i

Page 46: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

w w w wto 0 - .V 4 1 N k0

'0U% N m' No 9%0 4D In Iw. 0Y t0 0

5N T4 9%Nr4 P2 t. 1- W 4P

N 09 49 913 49 44U V 4 KC d* ta a V%

E C X:5 Z .4 0. x ~r0, X Z P. wE X aLD .4 U% o LD to U% Lo LDW% QL 9%Di Lo Lo WLD w bL J0%6-4 " * ".4* " .4 4 " " -4 614 $-4 ""U on-%f H.9P -4In(A (A. (A (n ( ( ( Aif (AIf (Aif CAif i/f 19(AtA CA(

t-* N' 4nS 4' is P.. 041 N% c N V- ntP.% NU 4k .4p C2L %a ca Na= 4 a sc C pC2 0 ,

0.* 1 W100% g.to U t Iu'mn * 1 40 SD4 we408 1 Nee0 inW N f" W 40 t W 0' O W 9iJ L'n w t. %V 1a wcm N C .4P2 0 P a . PP aNo c; F

f% a0 * 4D 0e 6.9% 0%10 InO * .* . 4P.) N0 v4 V4 (lJ _Y

U1% l P *0N-

44 14 so P74m1 V1 % a,% 0N4

9,, w 4 off of w0 of 96ao)9m Md - 0O r # - f3 0 it 0' P1 96):T 0 X r- 0 Z0 0

ot 4 1 49 49 d d 14 1409 1 5 8 taCd I q i

.4 t 0 tN .4% N 01 0at c.4 m2 C3 "N 11% .4N% .4 0D-t i'0 WciO m .40 N M I W%

III *N ONe .4N P0"I .4* NNS I 2Ito0D

e C, co a2 -* . Fuj 40 W 960C2 W C = *4 # C W4 1 4 0a %Da W D 4 * M O ) 3 m 00a OO2 on4 @CN% 0 0%

=(P ca 4014 Wca 4 0a C 0 aOa a00N c aV 0@ 42 004. 0 0 .0 4 * N a% * 04's * *o ' UN .) * o * .9LA

(AU o 1*0*v V40 e~ d 146 941um . 440 1040 %Dz '4 in' 0 oC2r.. If% N% 100 N..Y4 %a

OD Nt 0* U9% C20 %aN -# 0 UN. doCV' ofN .. -tN SN# o l wo 'ON W). V4

4 f 0 10 W 0 to to 0

a MP 4 N iiPO (P m WP24 93 409 .w1 4 If% V4 91.4 L9%C %C' tv PN

00 cm 0' c 0 = 1%0 10a 0 0 91%%a8 I1 do I NII* I 2 NI 91%iV-4LIW W4 w mW NW =W 0% w I1% W N

a 00 PON. do (P 0440 wN 40 0 tNO .4D 0%?N. 50% 86)0' *cj00 C2

W do 0 0: 0' ~ N P21 -tmUN f

InAi )L 2N o4 nmC . 4N Q- cc% U% %0 % 24 J4 W21) %D.4

1.- .-4 042 % .4 4 I .cmNA N - QN C3C24 t- S- 2 0 P.N 2Z Wk1 e N .0 0 wt*4 ce fn

8.. Cm4 C2 5% N 0I-if co 91 *010% CfN

94 V4 0'% V4N

c-4

Page 47: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

I P I I I I S Iw w Ww W W W

5. 4 p1.. 0%e N :1 0%

V-t 4 0% V.. 0%NN 0 UN f n51V4 4 5..15%l

in m o w% 0 to

C Y I I c m I

NN 00Q 1 r, 0Mt' * 0l *01) o1cP€: .4N Ot) olwP ! 4 I Am o .4.40 o o, I at 4 a w N NU 9. t= v 1. v r 40 m i In% r %0 v x 0r v. =a X% xiLo @ 0Jt Wca Lo IS w J0O Lo1 J I .44i. #aL0 W U% L N

N-* .0 "1 , 4" 0 n "S .. " W6 " , t " In.e e ,.

O0%W o 0% • • 1 NL- 5 • ,UJ *t..W'P •*0W,,tl U% •, o • .4.J 0% .O

( A N (A40 (A t( A(A 1 A A( C0 V)N*(

* *4 N 4 N ..o 0 .N' . do C C2 w N qD .1

go W) c 0 N .4 " Nw 40 al c 4

.9N N W-4 N. Na 3 t . ,r 1 CN N ,.% N 0 N N * goI 1 %a % I to PP. N I P IN 1 . = !

m0 w N N l f W 4 F. w * to W' * W

C4u, c p.. ey 40= a M 51 "0sc mN0 mC

V4 U% V4 40 a 1D * o %

ZZ~~~tW NZ %oI ZZAZ0%ZW ZOZ.rn 4*~411 00. 0 *0 00 p(

S I I, % CD I O3

do AV4 Wb %atIi3Wnt-

0 O If ait LfWlit Nt v4 01( 1(1 *0 N Gt e aJ U NII M%

004 *h3- %0* co a n F. * C3 L esN Goh~ F% oV451 MIC% f4 ba- ) ou V g N % N *M+ M.4 , IP

MV4g 0 %40. * N I IMo UtoS I 1(1C21 4b 3 - 1% ICUm w -* C W d o4 w aM w c w00W No w 93 #- w rrWcowe40 CD0m.4 92 s *4 4 % M~ .4 N C @4M fn a.4 %

00It0 *NUN W4Oto In0 00 000ONW% N 0 % MM N.tt 0%. *0 0* C30% 0

N% cmP I * ONN 0. M . M4 400 * %at f11 llt .. mN UI0 M * T -4 Goat

m. Nt. N0 . % tot, N " .. do NP .4 o.. co 1.fa D a0 Mo oP o 0 ro fn 0 00 &MO

wwC, W w 4 wWWV.4 sj w 0% wW0 WW0 M wo wa wNC

W% a w0 L N511 P4 1 0 o) I N..NI MN ,4. '42CN o aO W4* M. % N. $ao 00 foMPtw t AN CY 4 w% V4 1514 %0 q4

.06 1 0 16 NYI At1 V45 t 1W .W N W % to w 1 -4 .W r W 4 w

I to 4 m~ Mw v4.%4 0% 1^ * to 04%0 * go%%9o Il.O MO *- r 100 C W) MM I to W .ca fP. t-o NtP cm W 4 eN tot N. 0 ")o%Z Z sN zZ"M0Z in o Z ZMNZ Z 4OZZZZ qcZino% Z24V4 N-S NO *YI 0% 0m a d 4 944 M gntgo t? o % LN 1%I P.- aI *0 4 40M* P N*N~49VotAM.%oip

")0%T P%. co .aN0% .0% r 1so ". nV 4 NNNt0 %0 N. 0 0 eMInNaesM 51 CMc In to C2 40 V4 4 x C 0 U0 .4 1 MV pa DW 3t ot

Ny N t N Wf V 4 a 40 a%V .4 V 4 W Vq .40 4

c-5

Page 48: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Wi W W W W WIN . at -S

M 00 0% tA P. c9 0 0 N4C#A .9 M4 0 V4P.

94 N M %,

K0 z r 1 z z za r r cmzz o X o Zz~ Z zz V" z00%0 00%0' t0 LL0 EiI.Z woo oo 4 000D~ 0D6-4 1.4 M -4U M " " " " " t " t~ 4 "g " Y "bm N4iP " .4(A W (A CAc 4A 4(A * (A (A (A M (An CA CM (A (A, (A

0 q4 4P 0% V4 0%0 0 a 0~ U% %D 0P. P... 4 tAN t.v4 M M 9IAN fft 9-0 I%., on M%

.* N %a 0 P% 94 rP. .0 N. C9*P. = V94P N Og. %DAP =* i0cmo w a c a N %a = u w a 040 ca V4 U% 14N 0y r00 O 94MI *I&6 0 O IS iA 0 1 ~ g, In U I c V4 t1 4p%094 W 1In W N .4W so to W WOMW ftt"IW U%.4 W WNW N.=M 0% C m~ 00 :Nm ag = # U%V4 TOa ''0 ml- w :usse

* Y *Gv 0O' 0 4 Mo 0 W*. N * **I- Ny I NU 43 W.4 V494 P. NY 0% -4 % 0 U0 V 4 OD0 No N V40% NY *S0%0t P.cm W4 1.. 0' V.4 t9 a N

ZZ= ZZM ZZ.* ZZO' ZZP- ZZD Zzzo zz" Z6aIWIAP-W %0 WWO0'WWCemYjW"9 jWA4SW%~IITZ 094ZT *v4WZ 0,4rZ ONUEX OSN 226 0 2 22. Z r

9w I It4 0 O Ih dW 9 . 1 fl O P. :h I4 0W 4 9 4 t j 4

4=. VAa.. W4 to. Mb (I C2e t-. .4 caUIt M .Nto N1 94 W)6M0 t P-U~ r0.'c

Cy a V446I % Vfl. 1 o 01gb es Mn I z I fP ty * 06 1 %M doW cm UJ 4 94.9 %D W N9 4 W "-494mAW =ww M NW =

-4 m0 009@4 C V4 CO=V D =V % c 000M w0 aOaa40 a mZ a a w a wdmO am*'9 0. M 000 * *4S Ul e M * N~t Q~ 0 go= . 0 M U * 910-c

40 . P.9a4 y4 1 nc Nto N96. 0* v4( iA P. o0%ApO .94 .* atA D ZN " tIA,%OPt ( 4.&5 *1. t r AU . 0 #P. O N. 0 soN * N. MP.P.0 00 to NC CC 0, F4C *0w 0 %D 0

WWO' WWO' wya 9 WW94 WW.4 www0m WWO' ww0 W

%D 6a P m 1 0 1 V40 - 01 n9 0 0 .44 0

N. inO 40 O 4 do P N4 .1A %a %aP. 0UN9 v A 4 U%. CI&PA'V W 4 *a

ca '40 Mo 14. Na 40 40 PC ina0taD I. 6.6 N YI r9 I xg " a'eI Lr0'a P N W v4 W U% W %QW C2 * W %DW 0% WW4~ h" ON %a9 461 U% hoIa%.D e 0 in.UN m0 0 N *a = ~ %V N. N 0j % i 4 0 VcI

2210l-ZzI*ZOZ*Zzo mzzaO ZZdwzz0oqrzzoDdo~ M C00'r NO 40 " " 0r0 v4 v4 %Oft NNU% WMt 'O'94N 04 94V 0 MV4 M D N 0 4 v4 t N a %

N. N U ma . % a-0 Pw N F. N l0pO p.P.*0 v4A kA U0' N .% t9 48 %

go. a0 0 lo- ML9 4 v4 4

4094 P'.

c-6

Page 49: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

N P* p46%6 *6

%0 W 0 0 0a

* IA 0 % NaNY N 4 C4 ina

it TZ4 z xcm N N. r m iU% z M 0

't 4 -+4 8-4 *4 44 ""ft I- "44U S-* 640 -U). tA (A ( (A) (A 0) (A1w CAU) (A(A9 A n (A (A

U% v W4 4@ NF' N.V4 P4 %a *U%U% ") 4 %0 a 04 N a V4 C N - ff W.4

wA w UN U %NN*00 = ~ t a-D q4- U =0 t- W9

W cm N-W goW -0 c NW em LW W4 94 Wawe *Y aWfo 14 g n wl"IA (Y u t W.4D %0 tym .4 pa

so aCA 0 N 0 *jE 0o .0 & A S.0 C: 0m 6% I%. W 4 tn N

%0 N0 IA NV 4 NY C.4 0 A

0% o %0 in

C .4 4 A

ZO 4 ZD ZZ %aO zzT z0Z Z N ZZN ZZos ZZW44a.4 . + 4uN .6 Y w0 4 v W m- W4 4U% de r c

i. Two Mrs ii. ur. Xw. rue ur.

.6 I'n a'aM' ~ fn) %f0 N 0 1" 5soC 4 W4us. % W 04 IL W o% m~. tD -# 06.4 + .* s*

43 N = 4 N wCD a V~4 .*N @ N~C clC *42 0N I It 49 0 U UI %W ~ 0 U% NI NtDo I0ato6 UI

ON C3 C N w C in0 N.6 z 0"4a' a0%

cl "U% c N4 OwD go0 g a %an *# rn 1 5 0Na' NN F. 4P* NN '0 N CA Nq N. w

=. P.~ C3 0 %ON CD. 0D c 0 of "* Cs N6%C NC UV40 *0 0%0 Na w C, Fn

wO WD w o Ww V4 WWN UW' WW" u'o (A w w w w c

I* aV 0 0Y w I 0n A0 2wi

in V% % CO N IAN WN 41 q4 0F lAN q~4NY U%1 LnN IAN W4 wi q4 m A

WN tN -*N U% N I..N 0'a aNa'o cm c C2 40 ca " C c a1P) w tW N W W4 W %W 0% w N NW toW-4 4 r 04 M 6%. " %N K. ~ N4 U% 0% U%

0%N t6 ON 4 d N 0 t* 04 NA W4 N0"% 10 C 0 1%P. m % w * .40 IaL U wZ C )zNOz z 0Cz z -*.4 z a wzz 4 N z z 0*f-z zcm - %0%0 in 4 %0%0 fmN .4 " p P) W4 %%D 0 0 - %QAn % N % WU%00 y4U%=CM0v4WCD 0 0 ceUN .nN U%0 %0 N

'n #-% ION40*t% No-0%1%N00y4n ao w U% V. % W.. @ S NO.N.0 eN -tA tn .0 cN 4 61 0- 3WeNN=" 4$-. V q

42 a 0 40 0 - -a C0 0 0 N C)n 40IAq 4 '% U% IAUNI

0 0 0 00 100

C-7

Page 50: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

,.9 .* .9 .9 ,, .9 ..9 ,.91

* O O S I S S

w W W , W w wU0 in a N

NN cm -& .9 c9Na

a0 0% 0s U% CP P N N00% 0' V4 a, W% 2

0 0l i, 0 n % 0

a .. .. o.m ..o9 NK 0% al of F'1 -31

Z.4 ZN Z) Z x C Z N " xNX 7 N Zz= r zm*Lb~i 40 Q m LDE bOQ WD.4 LO LO co o D 4 LOLF' 0 o

S" 4* . -[ b.4 • - t1 14 -i " 4-4" * [ .9 • 4 .* 1.9-4 . ,(A W). CMl(A Il C (Aid ( A CA A (6L g (A ( (AA

I I S I o N[ [ I r N -

1 i N P..- - N.4 , w. w' . t . -.m mr 9 . • z m 0P roft,'m • o% * N • 0, 1' 0 .N 'I?. t- 0* 400 I m 40' a 'O V4 o%0 C3 40 wo,4 . a = W4. C.3"0m N I oN I NN U% 11 K W) 0 M 6 %D U% 1 .4 atIP •.W 4' w m % N *W t" w .III N U w

= J W* .. 0 %D s Wo V4 N D Vad

s m r I 0 a c4 N C3 = a W4 w C2 P- C2w

o 0 IlP0 0t, 40 a d 9 D OMt l0 o P

4 0 0' 0% .* 1N' N N%N %D %D In in&A '

w W' %. 4'0 .Z z 0zzt ZZ# ZIn Z In z ") Z Z N ZZ9' ZZo~o

w wN w0 w ') atwwv4 D ag ON 00o'- '. dm 4W4 in9 wt

o I'), , o Z ,O -4 ;C-8 'O7D% 0

q.in -9N 1 ~') oxUf4.r44 1 .441 a - I a 4 0* 41114

900 Naj ")~ U wN w4O m'0 4N In WI, es -Ia '4 0 0 4'N wa' mw+' 0+ %40

94atI % *q60 I m M,0 I UN a *4 In *P.0 I go' I *-V

V40 e mino w' =NP.4. 14 * %.9 wi - 0' .45.UN=NP Is? t a ao =wo P. .ca- 04 C a D C W'P. %A Imco* V4C*4

a a a tam to aC m AC Wc' 3IA=C 3%D=C cm cmi =D .0 ca .a. C) .m *o N aa4"a 2a0ca * .9 ca, a D0aU%==aWe

WW. WW'q.p aq4JWF' 0 ' W WWO ca~ PWW *.0 &,. f

*% cm 40 N I 6u " 16% 0- 4 4N

0* 142.9 ,4in r0 N- N4 %')0% aNN0%tWnN UY N N N inNmA inN %00 4 4

P.- NP. cc' fl- NP mN NOP. WNca Ww C3 m U% 400 D a cm CI %D C3 4

ant p-t 0 ' =g on U% in N *0N 4W w 4 wIn NW OWI .9W r', NL a w m W OWm

ON~ ~~~ 00 0b 0' nl O ~ .N U I4) Fwni I -a. 1E, NO '.4 r U% N )

NO C 0 0 .4 2. aN OW) UP CFUN UY V

am *. N)atN N ca N~ gom *0% P.

in I I o% I I In I N I UN I0i ~ * ' ai ~ . @%a IeyN PN w 4 .0 .0 W0 W Z t

a ~ fu to f. 0 fu 4% m4nc 4 N +9N ~ ' ca "LCA 0 V4) N o4N% w nI

W *D c 0 0 d on + cm N0sm P.- m%

*Z M Z N Z~k S 8 S S S S S~zz"

CD % OS P4 w 01 40 o 0 c - m-8I

,4 O 0 *0 m 4 4M 9% 0 mIn A UN wU% 4 4%0 N N "V4 0

Page 51: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

aF a al clCW W W 1!j W W W

on 0' U% at

a, .4 C o t*~~V 404N '

4c4 f 4 99- 4 N 4K N a 44 0%WWqz ' v. m0 z' xi V4 x U c M t- X Z

6-1 " m " .4 Pz)w Z N4r v "zs 1. "it " * I10n n f~l (AI~ (A 0~ n (ni(A (Ain (A * A

a* NP. #" 01# ca to ca N P.O a 0%00 N O 0%U % 0N "* I*4 UP. a% 0 NN4MW tNNh. 1 IP V44p N .Wu I~* * m.PP I NO1w. 1 %

U% 4W U W ev.4 W hJ t MO 40 W 0 91W CD M W 04tWC,~ 04hi NNI4 .440 asNN N 14 v * .4 Pe4

= 0 a C)O C3ca wc OCN C U %aN cm m a~

'.4V 0 4000

N4 '.4 00 a,0P Ny 0 0' 0) 0It go 00 ca W 0'

ZZ4t ZZiD Zze ZZ'0 ZZ= zz14 ZZm Zz'0

IW 10 % W0 " W 0%0WW wm m'0W %D WW#EXT *14YE 0.4:ZY My. *-ivy O"MIC 0.4mm . 1 .erZ *.r

.9..4 ad c m 0 00 cm 6' 01v m .fM es:F g CN * p.cm mN I9 * 0. m9 '0* -,*%U 0 C 14 0 c f.-a% a atV4 0 14r ca NW~ w 0- wMp~ N I C% D 006 10o %a I I wI to I Ua0 .4.4 0 z:OW NOU = mw W fu aW NN.W MNW a*h 4 W

@.%a a wq.* 0l ,10% %'40 a14 V4 a' to 14 aC a a ceamlaoi- maw0.4m O N ~ ~ 0 ~ C 0 1

C! a!O'= a w ===Nma ac 0 C 'a Ot0 UN a a a-4. a0,.M9. w JO *a um 0 W 0 a0 O a0 a P. ' ,n

M C2 - P.* 0%r %0*4 NJ 0W 0 zC3flN c N.- n~ r- .4. P..h ONPDl. V4 P.. a

NE 0 0% 04 P.D % ~ %D '.4 0%0 0Wi .a0' w W 0 W W 0 W W 4 uWWca WW a WWcm WW"~ W

C56c I c .4I 0 F.WgI p') 4 1 LIN P M~' go41 N y.41 1.-'04 wp V4' ON w15 c ' wN q' m

lAN C2 t C.3 . m .4 CZ y C U N'. a fN' 1 Mt Io %D4 C ca 0'9

I,..I m0 I. o N 1 V49 49 *N W 0% W 0 W U% 1W N W 0%W .4 W N WK W 10 C3 *+a A. 4 111* 't M14 Oi doU% doM 0 M0 VN w0 V4. 0't OD1M4 tIA" N* 6. O 00 %0 NA.O 00 C% to Z

NN*P.N14lN*0WI z 140 * z P -f 0% z z' 14'. z0M t@IAI14NU9If4CNa .514 OI N a 1U. me a * .

0tNNV 4 W U. N4 v4 0' M &NM0 M" .. OM 4 Vw 'am4 4= 0 ,4 0' V4 C N mNa w p.. a 0 % 4 a

C-9

Page 52: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

CN N CY toCC

'o 4Y N1Non44 0 V N 4C*1*k N, ONrN

U% N* N *%

en -a r- to 4w N) .4 u O

6 N 6.1 on 0 V4

L( C 0 (Al (A U (A (Al 0 (Af (A (Af (A (A~ tA (AfLn 0 CA~ 0

m*NU -~A V4N fr "a W4 * '0 go agNOa NV 4 NCa W U % V4 o C)F %a in~

C N P 'O' m * . 4 N Lf M N. p WN. to N # m P' c N N

0 .Ia co II P. I0 eoN * I % t *'a 0 0%4N P-V w % 4 N '4w0- NV 040W ,1

C NP. "". N S .5 4 '4 NC =a 0# a' N n c lt lClI aaI.

U% LAN'4I '

%a Ig 3' T'C ItN WUN %a'I *'te,** zO'4* Ob..* 0552. Nz b. 4 ZZ ma. S

Nlw W4 INAJ '4O' NNU 55O'a w ^ a jui w 4 WW M w w M WN

%* 00 # toS& I% *O 00 " U & oNO' - * " N *4 aC o o%'IPS a n"c C3I N4 C N V4 40 4 n m *C . **n f*C'C=M

.IC PD F. %) DI 15) .4' 0C h.. IA -t 40 1 C n ICN 4 cD55 =57 P-* wU N'a 0% w 55 m)M. w V 4w 0.m N CN IAN C5 94C 3c 2at 3c N 1 N IA3 " tNN c YU

No .4c 3C nma lt DaaS c Cs.c N. Uo ae too N co

*44 0 ONCl00 6C 0 6 N S00C 9U 0

0%6 'aN V4 N 4 1 IAt N cmS -t C I NNI %c

C . P A - 0a P4, 'aN t-1 UN P.N 00 ON

r-s 0 ' C6 57 1%-. e~ NonItt 0S4 '4ww 0 W 537W wC W4 wUJ 0W 4W

l o' O' n C M 's ' N' *%C N 0 M A 0u"N

W nC V DU 4 D% NUO W4' F" t.M4 & - ON A.4 'YO40 04 MrN

It em esa 40 so fN I eIMAI olt

to aC% 0% 14 0r w " n

4 C '4 * o NMT 0 Nm 1%.0Dr.0""0cm4' 0.0L - k -V NNV m P W NN' a V4

In 0 0 do 0 N 0 0 M-r 5P 0% S

CD~c- 04 4

94 A v

Page 53: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

w I w w w Ii w

N 0 10' a10 14 0N U% um0C, ON % NO 0M tyqN 42 U% IA a *

F') q') a

Lo~n lA0 9% LO ta P cnL 0 l k- LD 0 M In 0 (Lo. 0%~ LoL0. b- I " " " t- $4% 964 .

*N N14 UW4 Oa U 100 10%0ON I40 ON UN PNN 40 0 " CN 0'F'A 0W) on tM to P%. 0N %D U% fN 40N %D do It1 - V*NaaN P. PNNIAO 6n C F' n N 0 a P)F) pq= o *a F-wCP LAN C *p atN*0W W %0 P. .W 4 esw N Mw IANU toW '6 %aC 'oDw

.4 14 eIu .4 WN .4t 4 .r4 0' fts 4 N N.

%.1 a0 *P 0 4 0 .0 in .4 *.4 IA .Nr V- 4 94 r U

14~% V4NNV4 CY N N 0' I

0% %V %D & ~ ty T4 94)zZ0" ZZ ZZ %aO z Yzz z z ZZF) z0% ZZ94

XE. TX. XE. r~ W I XE. T-. XE.

00 ~ ow a' -C94 "tFE 494 #4 00 4

%a)9 Ng.. %!5 ~ to to fn4' to *0* 0%m~ do stoo CU P- cuN Nt~ at- a .0 a .0 at V f.

on 0' 1 4 I I P N- w4 t %0.0 1 ~ cs.i'1" mI CNOmIaauJ wc N w q 0W w IyU% 94ca w 0 14W NtP-.i NOW002 0:0 aOCN 0141 ,- aa 4 M001 4 w @M - IWO m 1a *N3 Fn 40 I = sO = .0* Veta' *14W a .aa a

CommSA 04 lAS 94)0mu a"Dt OWLUW)C Na IYC 0, = F' a9 o Nl 9 Ao' o N a%9 0 tN 9 P.0% 0 *14 @U% 0

Io l * &A 40u N.%+ )= D . Ity to N. w 0* 0z % 14. N 0% F.- 1*.I %0t YN 9) ca-tN4 P

(Ai 94.t N a. N t. N 0 P. m .o PA. M

(A W 0' W W 4 wha whia wW q4 w wNg WiW= hwO

"55 M.t- .. 5 n.,; nW) t-Q' to 11 "5IA n *49 $

O ON %a~ fl-N 9)on P. -t- NCW) 04) IAN Clb *4 U% N #A 14 U% 4 W4 In q4 IAN

40 Pw %aN NyI.. V41. 14~N V4 4)to0 MM4) w a 'Do M'J CM~ %0= C Da m'941 0 %G 0 01 4? aS I DI A9

ca ca W 14)& w ) in wA OW lA% a 0wUNwM) NI A L9%M % on0 0 lAN 4~0' h

CZ SAW U% %a VW) %0 U% N.$V% %NO ~ ~ t 04 4D9i- 4'~ .4 % 0 .. l

cy4zz P W0NN'N)N) z z $Oam% z zNW)ON -4zW)W)W)IA1.z - ". 0l*40 NUIP.NoO4m4OW4aW) toW S-NWI.P)0AN

W MZ r 0 v %U 0 o 4 0* = Vn -I,.t0%M1 4 .40 at 0 4 n 0 UU) 40 N A 041 a. 14 .0 Pk W)(4YNI 0NNc MNNU yr oC ) W)I."U * %

b.N:% 4C yt y 0g 4c aW VA *4 P) N ca 4044 z0 f0 0 0 0 4a 0 CDI- b4I 6% In U% Fi L %

W% I%. W4 c-V)l

to tv c

C-11

Page 54: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81 -W w w M SM w w hi

i' q4 UN 4 0 mA V4N Nh Ny P' IA'nA

49I aZ lyg ZZP 49 -nV 494 cl t44w 19W c.4 0% I ot4 a o

cf~l z nn U% ~ n (fif XAn M WACAM m MV . U vffe iwo SiaN WON 0OI 04 P.9 anoo woo 00 ,to(A ( (AC (A' IA' EON (A(CA(A iC IA (A 4 C

%Do a1f 4 N P..' NNN C3C 40 %aN 94JIn 0*. MS.N Cmlk NU% *m % * w kn 6 IDyt 0A QN V04 0 %0=C %a.90 = -Nm C'0% # to I U ffIA w4 %D I f 0 P O 'D I ty 4S 0

V. w i 0%w U%.4W w %wmU gw A%'Lw 40 rw P. 4W w

, ~ ~ ~ Cl ga mC~ CWC N 0U NN2Zv4f

01. C. cm C m4 %D -m 40ON o 0 0' U% CD0

4 ID go -v'~ DCzZ ZZI zz0zz V4 Z -4 Z z 0 Z 0 Z FnzZxN Z

doww e ow w w fuqw w 4 4W h. w 1A Wf )W .9wW If t W WJ4 U% W N toxx 0 VIC o.4rz owwr~ 0.4 ME *,43TT *q.IZx *y4X *v4M49 EwI q 4 w 4 4 4 c . -a 1~ 4- 1 4 qgd 1 44a0

a0U100 **C 'oN -tN .*0' V4O( N-C U 4011%.1 0%U 1 0 'IA 1'A V4iA6 aI ,I% 4.44I 40 1 43 C I m%D 4U W t % P 'Vw P4 tW 4ow 4V4 w V4 aW N% IAw V4

1qC C CC p V4 :0' aCI q 4 0 V4= 0W4 0 V4

-P V- C %D.. IN PCC toA 1 IMAYU% U 4 P.C 40 .PC% at. do ON 'D %N'YD IAlt aD. IJ-f aCLA cmD %a 0'0 m AN 40 0%*9w. %01% r4p P. P IAPS.. NP. f- fn C.C NC NC CC -.0 tCoC C C

N0' 0. Call CM* It. , MY N.ww V4 wwW4 LAJWNC wLLJP Ww 0 wha w 0%WCa WWV4 SM

0'm .4 I 0'6 w ~ -TSNo 94 a 00N go P. IN 4 N 4W N) P o Y4

P. N N 4P.N 4 YON N V4 a D %n y n D r CaD00 Y W)

M CS v 4I 1 D NI I *t I ohi lAW OW %OW OW %AW NW C)w41 gW N Won fb M P. f *ug oW ty - P- %D at tA 0% a

" V 4 = wo * %. -DN aDS. NO4 4 p.

UPvz "zz'zz;, zz!zz'mzz" zu'Fz" 4 IC on m 4 q4 IA 4C It. O 9'

rn to a 94

.4 4 ..

* 0 0 0 0C0 12

Page 55: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

C D C * .4 4 4 ,4 4to ca 10a aM to.

ca V4 aW)N c" C2 V4

*P w. N% 0 a0 In %10 N NY I' a' a

4* o 4 4 449N Ol a 4 OROfV 4 Ca al.9N q4M n d

Ein n ZE ZTD mZ m 4 mZ x xm 4 r z Ztp D CY I.D CY Lo Lo V

4 LCDU% %~D % LD L0 #.D a,-@' LoI-M .4 " " "W) .4.4M "44 p.m 1-4 " M " 4F 0-.4 N

(A e (An 0 (Ai CA CA(n ( (A 0 fA (A (A 0 (Aw (A 0 0

doa $M 0V In 4 4 42 D* (J0 In

wo tra tat V) C r- a a g 0% = 4%a C %a ni *U% 1 4006I I 0% 1 4 t I N 4D wN 1 0I 0%a G~oI toM U V4 .4 ul .. W4N mt UO 4 toW .4~Oi M*DI WO "j+ d

V4 cu + C aN 4 M. 4 ..4N w 4M IN4Nh.~4 V4~ ma. OON aau *4O cm @ 0

C2 N %2 . *r 0C en m * N. ee3 cm eO =e *0 W 34 C D

W4.4 -4 0 00N 9 '0 4u.P. %- 0 040 0%

zN ZZU4 Zz4* ZZI- Zz* ZZIA ZZw zzG% Z49 IM t- 4 P A 49 1 o r40 4o 440 4P O i a lof 4 o c 49

0% *% -. 4 U%~er *N Z U% Y U% Z - ( j cc 0% &M. of%. 44+ w44. "a1 N4 441 44+ 443 N4omI 9 I +

C i 'N wI NIA I N~O %o0 4*+1 Cma C21 n DI z t -+I 0CY w 40 P . W iAN w * mW r n NI- L" %n " W "*4D w W~)

aa, CaN UNO aa. c 4 a tCDc QC CD toi a

to0 s..P- % Uft 4 ") 4D * Na % . UN .01% .. OD 0 40 -t . 4 C"0 Mt- UN* A %'D

N. r-U 0. V4 . LP N N M C2 t- 4 Dr

W* O 0 * 0 0 r- -M 0J

-w N I0 % M N IAN 0 NO ID m0. wo 14 I aN Dc oC NO W% =-' 00' mO to 4 =x y4 UN

4N cy LnN in V4 UN -4 N 94 I.N v4 tN.D toD P.). to 0.0 uot. 4t P-V4%.

N1 00 1 0 g 1 i f dI x NYIlAN MW mW MW = UJ M~ - )W C2 0 W

NM NM Fn M* atJ W4 2 a N"

IAODCD z N. '.4P w 0 MaC @0'~ z Zt 0N

M+ Fn an %Q a*a - n( e D 4 N N-.

* N C P. .4 1, 01 U .-4 vmN0 W N UN "* P -N4cm Go4 .i a 3- N4C % N- m 4 'W.* IA CD W.4I

* e 0 ok * = e9 0% ox(

W4 V4 VI 40 UNI

C-1 3

Page 56: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

am 10 ca 003

v4I 4 4

40 00 N0 0% 11.

g' N V4 oov4 4 %a Z %I

x"V ZXV4 ZZ40 XWN. WXN ME"P Emp. Z

J..4fE" I-.4 " I.49 " ~ 44' .f~t) 4-4 .S

(A. (A IA C (A C (4n Cn n n~, nn

5- I '40 -#0 .1* ON00o

C2 I U% -4N P, n NF P) U% N f % P. 4*5 tONS- N~'ua '400 v .0 N 5. t0% a U %Vca oa% .W aF

UN 1 0% goI -* r1 W4PS W) I'o a'=I )% Pl0 0

cc 4 w so V - 0 % = w ' O . W 0 ~ kot t0 00C3 w U w"V4 .P4 eoly d N W 4 e o .N % F * % a 0Y 0

C3 v4 am a0 a a 0 % w 0 2w%0 ty 0y I D 0e0

.W4% . U % cm Cd

0* V40 V& %4 0 4 NOJy 4v C03

49 U% '44 -aNn W r w P soff NO& 9W go 4W4 9Vx~ 0.4. 00 X X00 x'U oa0 Ta'4P!ryX

o'I go e 40 * &a6g 0% -40 ** W o0 *4 + -tV4 3 , 4 "- *4 .* coW g f (Ja (AP . 0 0I

%D .IA ON 1N 4+h CN #N Pl) N nU f g 1 % -o

a o C2V . I=CD40.se 0. Ca o N. -, C C5 o 0. q

WCD w W =c Nw wm =" a~v =W aW WW4 = A = = o

V4 0%0 q c 0 *1' 0 &N 0% % 0 O SU

0% P-. do m4 4nL S I =P- 100e W- ' a Sn 5 N *

U% 0 v oN m% 0N N% N0 ca0 0 '40

N s U%. r N .N N D .. 4 t.. 4 N - CAw4 40 0 NO '40 rz -i2 M cl qwC%

N 0 IN oS LS *S % 0 w 90'40% W 3W WU '0tJ .IU WW W4 w% N NWu C w 0 w

I~ '4 . V 4 m ls " tI N.' p- IA p--U 0 N atN ,= . V% Wp) 0% C2 N V4

m I = IANWO 40 1 0%~ % % * p 0 V4 g I x a'v4

fu . r 0% 4 mD 40 - %0ftd 0 - . MW

p)t N ooC 9.%&t 0 UN (A 0 0

CY4 U' 0LAl - N 5'0 lk -FNN- q%

000 0 0 %0 0A 0m 4 z

ON ~~- 44P 4

W) CY 4

Page 57: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

*l .t. .I. .5 , ,.5 .5. *

C S I S C I S

W W W J ~ W W w

* t".. a - 3 a r .r i,,.. r p,. a 1: . 1 J 1,'0rr !:1

%. , . ' V4 , ,D .moN40 a a, a

.,1 0 N' .IP eO 0' 0' P-1

AO4 04 % 4-cN 4ofV4 a 0 o 91 1q 2 9M o tr 4c of .4WW

S 0 N ZE X V v0r. t~. 6-4 E l E Ejz

0% V [A (A to• CA (A 0 (A (A ( (A (A 91" (AI I C 8 I 4 I I

0 V4 40 N 4.. C3 P.) 4 VI 0 ~ ) SASA UN 0 m. P.- I.UN 0%4* V4N P-Y Ub VN t4a% * n 94 W4

P a , on ,,. -* '. .0 ,. % N -F e P. A N eto aP.- 0s

M v' V4) o,- N. V,%. = Ot " 3 1 ==a= MWa % WC2 t aM 4 a

in W %0 %W SA" W N.4w M'a P.P FnW N PW at) on tNh. .4N0 ;g N4) mN N9)- a' NO -0 .4 em

sI 7a car %a~ a, a o~@*ee.0 n eS 6.3 eN 0g * 40 e go0 c eon) V4 0% C3 C3 S- A

W Pa 7 40

i - N 0% V4 NNzz in z zu zzZZ* z z ZZN ZZ* ZZ-W W ty 11 ga E4W qn q.4 4W n 0 ma 4W W. 4 qJW W 11m U W44e S II SA w la " .1 W WOIA W 4 uswr. W I.6

WE0 Zz 0 Vz 0' .4 0 xe~ Itr. 0h ZEaW Ea

4.0' NOD o' 0%' .. It0 P* N. -4* Fa f0'Iev ' 0%- o N D : P g M4 40 g.4 Q to Jo NCD s *Fai m0 %40 P v 0P. 0 9 1o. I U% 0% 0d 9.S 1 0.5 pn* nCM =W ca 4 W caW acm~ NIN W 00 aW M 40W N A W wOSinM V4.t N1. V4~ a V4.. cu m 04 ae

a v4eome~aav t Oeer o= 0 ea400a000NPON a* m I~0 I..J & P* I #c . % 0a .- * I NO -* a tO N

CY 1. f0 4. NaCYc .1V4 mat P) K 0P.I s-O o%. U%0 .4 .4 %A 0

ile .4o %. aaurkl.em *0.42 94 2 IA. 0. P. to A 0 0' C:

O 00 G0 0 G G

1 0, 0'NI r'A 4* W0SA tom oe 1i winN % V- UN NOa, 00' to It O't a% *4 QOU W4 Mv4 Fn '0.% 4 w l.N 9%. I%0 ANC M% .0 94 a MIU yN . UIA

% cm 442 A. a #. ca 0a rn% C2 P 2 mC

a W q4W 40W SW caW SA W 0-fW .4 W

N.1 W44 40 1" z AM. ?.O z O P.S " P UNlp" z z NZ S z %% zx4 0 I.4 N ' '.1. am.O 04

UNtO 040 mt. 10)0 low do- 0

M v M 4 =M A v4 00 94 a' m * MI NW 4v M0N SM O. UO N N

e. op.. NP Of on. .0 eNIA 0)V4 94 '. a .

a~ ~ N" V4 0) I ~

IC 1

Page 58: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

to % N N SA% .ma ' 4NN '.4

* N ' 0* V4 oncoNa . IA w4 Ny a'

IA fn N WNCNY P) a' ON 04 M 1

V4 '.4 a' C

44. . b S 4 S*4 9*4N -4S4t-'454W #1- 4S.4 W cm 4ic fife z x me zfv0 xff v ~ f (fif Zff v oIfU zC

%0 0 % 0ow wo 000 '4oO O0 0 s WO aO. e I- Nmn "~ " W "N " " 64: " o

%o94c% mi "N )N 0*6. fn~Nca * 0 o rninC On~ VA4a cm N Mliaft a Q'ea'a V4 at = A

W, w p* w O.4 w r-V4W w onw ~ o0': C

N0 U% a 04'0 0 0 0p o ' 04 0 0to

NM mY V- N %a

NY 0 4 N ai N a% U

U% z z z4 zzagiZU Zzo ZZN- ZZN ZZ' zDz%a WIN tya W W 4 Mww-on Im ~awIN w do .0% W W e.4 wkaONwWSwmus t*Wb. w tatA .Wtj,* us

oo4 a'* 0%(MJ MA e* '4. - O b04 ob Pi '4.48 Ca 2~ '0: 1407 TV 0 410a V4P " 0) '4D"I I ~ a'.4 to4I so4 NO' aaO 1 a 94%0 4

%DA lyw 0 W w w aIA a j w CV4w P FUN5~ W r W es

Da9mOIm %.am aa =a'aa' maa~ *@ a a'0Ca' * 0~ *p Pe a 0%S UN9* m 0 &%la % MNI 4 40

aSm I~ &l ftC2U V-.4 P)ae I * CNJ.4 '.0doN 00 a'4 N4 cm 00' N* v 94Ce. a' N am Cl tn4 mm M 2 P)C

N WW WWO 1 atWWO wwo wlaJT4 w wa' ww= W"5 11~ (Y -' Inm CY 11 -m

9-.4 0N P, 0. w wN4 N I ma'94 94 -N ey' UN' 4 N in W4 U%

Neit. P. 0 N % o No %OIA '40 NoP-%maC2 U SC SA:C IA:c N a M e Na00 4 Cl

0, o0 *6 I S N= I I SnI' I mNW Ci OW NW OW 'w-a.4 W .4W SAknW

N.. z %. z 'tI z.4 mm e'M z'.40'zz %zz - z loxNa m. I" ey mm 04 I* ONN

Cm 0ii SAC zA. mN m *N CA UNm in mo Ne. I

U%'C 40 V U -C0 N D D t h D A A U. 4 Ne.99% NN q4 94

NN4S N0 NCN a'4N'*N i~a*N.4NN~c0016S

Page 59: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

VV

Ti 82-Si

%D N %0 W aa aat 4 0 4p 0 0 itP W hi W W v4 W h

-t 0 60 a aO 1 N -Yac 94 OK ,4 ga 49 at 9 4 Ie

vo 0 XN tvo 94w X 94 wrt z O Z o.

o woo . 0% N N wo 004 I00% N Q% 60 ' I5 N tdO *1

6-4 "- " f " 0--4 a-4 0 " b-4 to 6.) - 0 4 0-4 P -4 04 MN. a N 4 LA 60 N N4 i N N

.0 th fl qy !Y UN wl %a P t e

No 9 WIP. * a ,n I.o N. N o M kaO% =0 o 0 a 9N 0 * 0 r40 F3 = N

%D I a P o CIS w o o = 0 ,,t v, ,, o o.4to I P C O 1 0 a,4 w 4 N w U% = w N 16 11N N M w Uaon I a tc Ze"4 0 .4N 4 W Z0 N 4 "14B Z.g M0 . MM .4MW

y W -6 0 pa * 0 s P.

O NO 605 N 4 4" -04" 05 -W N tl

00 00 000 *600 9400 Fo.M6 a W Sn %DC OnWl% q OaW 0M P00Wl *wOW ~W,

z0o .4 Z .4 ;0 in50Z 0 mN5 W r9 * 50 9405 945060

09 '~l • 90 aO • c. 3•oi o o OrI O •ee• .050li OC o a@*

eN. 0 0 ,,, *p,. *05* e Nv' * i ..1 *ot. .. 5 . t.

f60 M 0% ., N on *= It. 0N " N N * + M t- 4, N+

al tO * 1 0 o 5 i 50 N O 5

60 aw a% 92 00 N% Na 60 V44 4 VN a - s 9

ca 0% ca es tN 60l 0: 94 aM 10= 44 : US.,

.0 , ,D N N N ,a ON

ZO ZZ 1 ZZUN Z N w4 Z0% Z.l o 4M tU D Z a Z Z 4 Z.0 Y Z Z

o•U N ,-t ot (A0 Po o N oI0 at O

to.& 9% W % J% D z q4iW 4SAJWN W * W Fn soW- t a% .CZe.N M N v4 N 0~ 4 E NZ I". tE. PI NN.

En .0 N0 % 5 . • 5 C2 * C0D

U% 10 N00 o a Sm4 C2500 40 M0. 0 900

0yI U I t1 -500 1 06 1 4a t c0 10

004 0 N T4 V4 0i946 0to. N 0n94. maO 00 % 0o940ON %0 clk. 4. aD% pq %0eoN UtsD Naa N so0

c0 a CD coa N cm 40 00 00es00 a aO*60 *.40% 0 .4* I .x e0 .40 low 'i .503 M. OUNawN*W N wo wC SoO ONO N94 NO 600* amteW

940 Ne4 -4 LA 40 4 4 1 in 6094 NU% %. 50QO M% U%0 at W4 .. 0 ca* 0C 0N 0%

V0wlx0 MNo 0 Pa% O LO O" 04in NO 02 = %ON N 94%Ne 60 Nr. N. U% N~ N 0MNN%. OMM 604Ct. M=M %.q ON=W4 W'4 M WV4 WW)0 WMO WWO WW0 NW MWW.M94 MMv4 NMv

~~10 4 ~ ) NN N v4 ~5M U6 N 6 4 0% 0 0

94 94 4 .D9 tO 4 W4 0. 09

C-17

ido

Page 60: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-Si

* w

W WU%

a og4

" 4 " n "$c ' (A $A 0

914l0 (IV44 1 t I

'P 40 N

N* I*cacyUk ol

N

zzm r

aiW Sb. W hiu I'mEwr TVr

'a~ SN q

q4 o~ I f

POIs. inm4onm

a 0l*f

NO NYqto ma

a 0.o 4Win. N .. N s..

CA pfi, i.~

IA ZZQ@2 218

Page 61: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

V4 4 U% Nto 0% %D 04 on6

a F4 0' to0 NWU% go. 0 WIt

Ig ~ 6 0 40 a0vu .9 0 to to m Ps.

4w4 o rd 4 % ro ~0% 49 a4 4 * 1- 0 V% 494994v m W4 ZKG w 2a 2. x10 x~ z. %20 mEW z)z m M

1-4 " -t ""4.t 6-4 6.4 * 0.4 't " 4 r 141* %d " .44 ".4"4I(nA CAt# (A n) * 0 0 ~ f CA (AI~ (A I CA (A ( (

*6 0 0 4 US 0N 1 p. AJV4 N6 a lI. 66q4 m P T4 .a N6V46 'W0 n N m* cai % i0 Nt N at#k

lk- A W N UNW UN 0OW m sow Pf W w FMW U% o W *l. W

ty 4 ? 4 .0 .4F A .4 .40 .4 "4 'a.4a

a' D %D a N CS 0 IVA 0 4 0' 0 F7 0% v4 V4 W 1

atO CDN V4O U% ~ UW %Z- Z '

w .8* -oU% t tl*94 MLj* W94 04m tiUW D J sf)6 %no% SnG.*P?0 TV 0 6 TJ 0 '0 TV0 TVP) a U Z 6

4da 4 d IO'@ 49 49 l AJ4 1 6 4a .4s5w 44

P* *81 N I* Ln ma. I $A 0 P, I lW N v40

1 *C Ok.-v I # q4

ea A 504 Scm. wS~d 0@9m4 ? a 0 m N 0 = oP N 6a* 0

ZO 640' elp 4+* 640 0 A 0'Y so M NP1*goo V4 0% % - &. 94 .. i C2 ~ 0 NO %D U

N% .4% GO q4P. 0 4: goo 94F.-C N. V4 I. Ne t- %t. 0N 0 l

Cl, NWO Wi4i Lim O ca i9 o% w es6 rWN Li 40 V

w 03 N0e 0 0* 0 40 U%

(A ~ '~ W .0W 3 W W % O6 4 WD W O W iOV4 N 64 m

a 6U 4 U V41. W . 6P 94?.- . %D 05. -A .U. e A D0 Y 0v .40 %0 (Y 4o P6 l o

0 crW t W NYW NYW to W (PW t W exW0 (P .4 du : 0* - V4 o 01 d m4A .4W mdi .4

9440 00 4 M. 400 , 4 t % a* 0.94 1,-iCD w40 V I 4m. fu 0 " 4 tu 1. *do fum to 4

Z- N4=N0I N N U%. qN .0. N1 M *4N 6 0 0

ZY qN.4 *at +4 M 0% h.do 1.% N U% V.4 is U I

Y) 2 N mI NY a V4 NY a r.V4 .4 V4 V 4 to 94 1*

C-19

Page 62: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

W~~ ~ W Wh

4p1 11% 0%i

* iaD o,,4 o'4 oN oN5 o4 oa ••a

w, .o .0 ,,,wu . .4., , ,, 0 ,., 11 %

N~% %0 'O N0 4

a 0 wo"0 WP 4 Io a W ly a a 0 W W ' W

0 N 0o . OWN 000 W 0 0 4

W 1.4 . W "o " 1 0-.4) 4- " €:4 4o UN

N D 0 94 , n.a

i0O 4 I* ! * I ,0l EgO EN I O I a !

4p Pa EO V4. VE' V4e In )o o In ~ 94 W.

M N 0 4N % V4 4 to aM 4" lif O=N 0 4 0ot4in i In ani M in I MM InA. nih (nn 4nAn n1M ! 4

San 92X 9S4 so" B a g S

9 4 won 0 P,, oO ,V4•a 0 a €

*1% 040 0 V0 a € N Oe o 0* 0

04 % NN

N 4 10

Z N z 0 z ' % . . . . ... ...................

4,40 %. ww a w 4 49 aIN a~o uIea eyD a0 OW 'Z V9 T r* 05 1(0 *t4z .. os 0, WE 045 04,z0.4w

or .99 WW W 494 1 0 aci IW NEW 1m 0f 991 4

.0 *4 p' & .0A f. e# s 0.* ceONO NS "9 ,Ml - n a m a C$*o 4p I0 ty M # al1 *0 % 1 N U',%0

:V NO WN .4w No 0 a W 04 M NtI.ag a 43 N a 9P4. N a .4 4 a '4

;l M v0-o P-P0 N0 *MM N 0t" %o%aN vN N M a V4 9' 109 -t0% 4 ,

Z (t ZVZ a O.N ZZ6 N~u 4DI N't Zz.. zz

OEO 1 b D a EE:q CYp NE 0 0 0 0WWM WW4 W W 4 WW%JrWWN WWM *W C3 tttW =

iDn 141 ON I1~ ON1 I . ,P. OI N Om I 0 I

m aI % %40 a g0o a -t aP*

a W NOW do W to 'W a DW 4 W U% W gow W

N %i V%4' %Na OWN 41P i a@'O*a W@00p aeNe

* % co N N* N 4 0 a PW 0 MN 0% %ao CK %aOU *y a0 0oM.Vz 0 ON Nm .40N a50 6 0 4 O

*p. 04N NW 0 '4 0 N*M0 0 NMNSA 60 .N O0 N .4 04 a D

CL . ON M I ON a N*..

w wo (him WW.S w w WNW a W wN 0 0 0 90S

1(10 ~N5 O~l 'o5 mg N S N~5 0, P%t0o 0 * ON N

NW 'O 'OW 511W N NW 'ONCSJ20

Page 63: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

L n .1P - i m ,

%a r 4 4 N + Uaoaa 0a N V

Ul w a wY w Is 10v N 04 z' M. V zM0 0w M Ma

b D w4 LOk O4 0 .Lb L aNWL 9 pk 4 4

V% 0 to a ' 14 a doMIA "40 * l V4 N C4 91t 0 M 0 4 q4 "0' N NU %. U - N 0%Ik. U 94Na

(Y NN q IA N ' 4 U o " 14 1 4

tof N V4 is 0 N-* U 0 Ne O ON qt0a ON

M,4C' 4 %a -r 4* 4 4 %0CSt c Uu to 0 N~ Z U% 'o Z 4c

40 toN 0. M,'t N 004 N az 4 z 1- 00 Z ~ 490 XU X4 4N z 0o'Z Z,too %. WwtWo 140 0 p N C, IA W IAWW14 N *0N IA4

49 491 049 t0 1.7W4I me9e0 N1 c 4a 1 4 4*9 1 Ige

Nm40 M4 1449 14%b UN 4 f0 %0.0 000 "0 g0Vae + M00 % st

.0 0% 63 0 c49 .0 * %C2 .' a N a *4 4 0.41..aU' M 14 0% f d to 0 Nto k I +I I z%

N N 0 4to a N t' M v04 4l N0 aM4 c

1.7 1.7 , 0 a M 0'ONO 0%0' -tU 2 -0 Y % 0 49 0 ON

qq v4 -A 0 a 4h q4*tK, N0. C to t- ( P- v N 14 N 0oP. C

vZ* o Z M Z Z % 400to 02 4TA 24

UNP 41 &A4 14 %0 4f 0 4 a4 aro 01N to V142 42 102 .C.J2 W N2 f ON Z445v 44N 446 N4 446 a4 44 %, 4' o

4 CU* KN ifw th. %04 N A'040%* 9 Ooa 40 ' V4 .49ca M * a 's~~4

40 N Q~ NO f4. 0 44 toIWNIA W M14W 0W *0W 4Iw Nwo 1440W a4

f% v0q4 aTo fm V 4 0 4 N0 r~t 049 P 04p0 00 v 00 %w .% y0 to 00 to 009 90 IA 00 14 0 I 00

* % UNo Y eat . Y .00 C* ty4 * 0 PNO .l 0170 zIAN 06*10 P4% 94 4 *%NN Oq % 0m N494" %aM9 N~4 4.N0

Ty n 4 i 1414 y %40 0 OPN 14* v t %0 Naw w4 a N v4oot o N 0 0IA 4. ON 00 0 2

00 49 0 Na uta 00 0 P0) 0 #V4. U. w. N' a. NM q P)

W NW 0 W ' W W W O4 W N V" UW

949 9N 9N 99.7 949 949 949C-21n

Page 64: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

a ?aIS I cm N

0% N tN' 0Y 0% 94 P%. P.

-00 wo 0' Np W '0 ' 4 Ny 94 t. 94

w1 t a 0Y N ') 94W. 0' N In) U% NI

x0 Z.Z* z WZ 0ZI z Nz MN w m 4 ZZI) z01%. oo wooi0 W ~0 0-4 wonP ~woo woo womD0 wW@' L

" "4n " "- 4 8-14 -4 "-t"* .4-W4 N4 " &* -416 " . g"-"* 0-8-4 0Cf. A CA(A ( Aif (A 0 V (A o M (nf CA (A (AiCA (A (A CA

04 'in 'O OW0 P . 0VI UN Q NO Nm P.

IA 0' m le " NP- o ' 4940 N .g W-t *W NI~ 94. a

0'e NP) " 'oS9 W.4 1 m g *I0 0e CD' in1 41,.1 iMbI U 940D @'w m.A Uw %w %W NO'PW 0% crW -*.4 W 0 v4 W UA%W wq : i -* :- v4 "N ON If .4 t w * .4 fa0a V4

.5 *.0 6.4ccA a m 4 w.C " NI w9 cain wgO *PP400U a N V4) IA Ole 00

UN 1') Nan'.Ze ZZ4 z ZZ N ZZO zzO zzwol) ZZIAZZ Z

hiv o w4 hi hi in N -V mi ) w AiD. w, h Ui I N Sw wi m 0 w ih 4 . w iii 0 in~ u i w'h

.* 0 D IC vD IA X0 0' ME. ** X a Ea Z E'4 9atI 4 0*4 10944 1). .9 OK9 .4* 0'... 1NO.e f 9 ow.. If

I~ I t 40 941 URD 4 40 P.N #IA I ~i t~f) I

N W 00W 94 W Vq w q4 rqW *0W Nw UNW IP) w A' N%( w c

4 in0 4t 00 Y %0 0 V 0 094 t035V.0%0 3N: in 00 094o iM

Cs 4 0Do v4 . gNn S0% ON4 **p **p N Y 4 3 i

P.O 0e 0 U% =in 00 0 1-k40JoY goe go .0TA too 0 .. V N. iN N 0 N6 *e N N

WO hiW w wW WW h2 wmW W-4 WWN W w e WWN wi

0 0Y w0YN14 f. 0 Y 0 6Y 6yWN V

an inN 0 .. NN iaN N an to N = ON 9N.01- OP. f1 4.1 a 1 0

LAW toW ad w .1W toW 6W mA N W inOISO IAN 00 N CN Old =D 00i v440

zZmzOZ~zzZN0'zz~yzzp..ZZzO@n"ZZ@Dzz*NZZOOZ

at 'IAWO 4 W " 00 a U% NIAP.O9400mli.1 o4 9 0.0 WON .0 *in,4 Ow0 69~m~4Q

0 in % %4N .N 0% 0 0 N INa V 0=NOW IA N iN MNN V% NN v94

N 0* V6 00 0 0m 0 go6

C-22

Page 65: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Ww wL w Wi W wW

m NE OkaN*~~4 4p ' YEN8

to 40 N SI 00 a m0 aO P0 NV 4*

fN aN ' 'Y

%Dt00 L L % to) Lo 0 0' w 4 0

ly N %a m %00 F)

gO' 94%lN KE a D ft ) N N 94U N 4. NU N m a.V.4 Z3a -t I a 330 IZ edof I wI c al 4V

m W J9 0wD0P w i N~ twp~ %aW' tDOw 4 t n 0 wY4455 W~ V 4-4* ;Z as4* .14. .fa .4 -4.ft. .4 P) m

ca *N N'a 't 0'D ME a0 NN )@ON NE% w4 E0 YEY

0%a~o ~ CY E N-a %0 a *Y 00P.W NW0 .405 goP) IIN 40 N W U

ot t 4 wEY q4w N w r wA 6 4w YCR ~ .wE w o wa' ) af f

.14 * oN *% V 0' .0 UW l. .* W. .oW 0 .W.14)N.v li YE Y .44 3c30v Z C r w

No VA% N IA'aN.0 "' "N 4 tv N

le d in Y* e= 0 0 f4 YE O 2 P 04 90 aZI4) 1Z Z0 h 0 = % 1 ZY ZZY ZZN. IZNZOP'" 0C-N 0' .14ff w55% 0 Wff 0505 4=w, 0P% 5.E

05 0S "t05 (p05 0 50P 0505 0 ft 0 a%"94CD- IU u44. 0 0 44 P I Y a o V a 4Pf44 on)* z)E * i (P~0 %Do. NP) .IV N N I0 cm 0 N*a 'at 40% 5o ~ %aO N%0 P. 4 0%

mff 4955 at 55 cs~ ON 0.ff =.. af

to w 0 %D 0 4 0D aN 0t fO .4

t. o C5 a No C 0o w m Y% NaDo Ii. Do mo in N e u .do to *

W.I P C m%C i C WWO% WWO WIAJlaWLY WWO WW In WYm

W9 w Y P w9 9 9 %D) 9fn) r w94 994t 99cmf*YP.t at t- 6% 40 U% aN0 at

4D PA IAN zw 0'E 01 lb. m A ft' N )OI

IA. #a Ia ft AN w4 N % ON %ON 04a YEP') NO rEO% aD0 V.- TEO P.. 0 S - 4NNa 0P.0am0aN.40 z 0a .40 0' 0 00 NM

NI1 AD "40 4WD 0' lS YE I

NW N 4)W EW tW ff) P)C-W2N

.4~~~ .i ........ E a

Page 66: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

0Y 0 61a

. N 0Y N .4N W4 -N a~ 0

to0 94 V4 @*P) %N oo

49 19 U% w 19 : 9a W wot 6

zz* mzo zzlb. zzm zzr" ZZ4 ZZN.M80 6.D36 UU' 60681 6040W 0440& 1818

14,A-AeA A A A A4-4 (A.4 (A44 (A14 14A 4 (A -(A (A (A (A4Inw on do~f . fIft C%%Dl c U% 4pn tot ai a f

cr40 "Mo N ah. N0 N m NI N ~ 44 11 9 40%c 0toroa 0 ) C a01 Nd' 4P. 0 WWW *a W 0 a 0%0 v4MaeP461 tA ~ N1 *0 00-o# , 0 %. 1OhS .4S .*NCYI Ne A I IoIAS1 .4 .46 1aM 1

V4 t maw mP) t rinw aUwW NNCYw N% w U%-4 w.yW 4* it I0 w CDft O .4 m .4 .42%. .4U1 N 'a

0* 00 =a aa O N a %6 0040 *.W .0% I gA 0% 0o 00

4'0 pi r" NY %D Nv4 to In in m1 P1%a 00% N. w4 vi N NN. to o9 % W4 40 a %a10 0% N V4 N. N P1F4 U% we % U% w9 U% P.-

Zz9 ZZ4 ZZF* zZW ZZP UP z" Nzz 4 zz 4w o Dw o D* . 4 Wwt4a w w a.*N~i w Lia.#% of -w:mrz rZ .E TZ e4Z= *94ZZ o.4EE *-4zr .4 Zr *V4

IOU%*~U mu~ at* .90%i 01*fp. ~ to =P 0%0 ID N4 0%cm *

cm~ 0.t4 I m~ N.4 mO2 9.- . %I V1400 1 4 U%4I

40a F4. a aa W. 4D= 4 Ucma 0 % a a a a C) to a 0 o ao .a a 0%a a0% 0 aaC0N Yaa q4 a a % aa1a a09 *P. a* = gao% * C * *10% * 040 0 **0% * or,1 m .1900 CM VW1S40a I6at.45 Ua t- I Sa Po Iw 01 40% @1

C% " .4at V4W N 4 4N M Pcm Op. tov4m a a 0% %o 011 NI. V40 do %00 -*PN. 1 9 P 4. N *W. a P. Nh.N 0% P. UWNP)0 cmm I.ca N t m 0= al m oaP%.0 40 0 4D . V4. N* 0 %Ww* ww WW0WIO WW .4 WW WW1 WW 0%wl

1.0 cy I . 19. I. m P.. 1 . *I NtaU .42N4 0.Fnpi.T419N woP IAP fhb N Y 4 U%

V1. 4W 4W. OhaP. low t P)1. %a.

") P. P10 4% I %o I a soa I m4W 01W aW 0 W 01W 1 mw aW NyW

do oN to. V.9 14 wU "dP M40

UZON% zz$ z zzz:3z ZZNP*ztP1ZzA0% ZZ4.70.a 4 N %4 " C at.S in Nc" C0 Na

U% 0 c 0 0"mm w1 wOW.P .. W0 P.4. N0a Q .- .4 a (p W M a 4 1,.0%M a 0 - 94A M e-NU %9 4NMMI-N M N N4 VI IA 04

N m 4al.-0M4 0 M P.V 0 I M 0 N9 m9w IL 1% N aV 4 I 4

V4 4 10 9 .4Pv 4 9 56

C-24

Page 67: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

W W W i~ W W Wa% to) if f)I0 ON.

IV) 14% NV *I5%% W%*0N0N5

49 41 V 14s was w- 4 0 IV of)5% Om 0 IV) wow wo 0 0 4p W n WO14 V bL

"" 4 -I* ""M "- 6. I"o " oV" "o

w 9 0 61 p Pt 4Y f 4N%,44 4 4 o f"9 V4 % P) f) " o 0

oh wN busN 224 N ZU = Z*.gN "~ M ~ f 6Z 0%9.t. 20 %a

ONO Nl 94 =f~ " nf*- 0* N11 0 0A(J a%= C toU 0 0%00) * t 0dY w to qV.. I UP I No S f I V40 M 4 I

%a* onW *.0 w 4 VPW11a 0.4Wa w~f P15 %0

ON m -4 ft o?-% PO m ccmNmP mi a,0 .400 .Q4

a N =ON cm a~ toc U " aw*t * 1 q.& M 0 0.t5 to U% ifu a-1VA NY * 6% C N 1o pV W V4 .

ZW~ z z 14 z zo z N ZZN ZI Z? Zzm z z

22.1422 ov422 0,422 *14 22 ONEEZ *(*EE ONZE *NEE

00w itif. 499 49I 0 1 m4 d 49IA 1 .91 d I 0%

1141 a,%D 000 ft,1 V- 4 mo* Nto N4A Now=- a0 =%O m 4W% P N. a %~ 0%* ND .142 c 4c 4i y

ey 4W P IV)5%W NIW P- S- W a W V4to W V4 W W *omw U~%j

4.. m .45% CaA m aa C? 00% ca0 M03

*too0 0WU %0 4-to~ a@OO 4DU%0m 0000ON

Ph. a* mO 0? St0 = am P. -941 m45 ID?0 N 1 0%, 61P5 N. NV*9

V4 * u :m 0 0& 14* J+ o% U%0%r- w~ Na Na P.a am P0 V4 %

w4 .9o P1. 0.. C3 c N eq

*P f 0 0 % 0 K6 0 6

wON o U% m N a.. N1 aN in 9 P N 0ON t oN~

-t- P-h. *. 0? f- in)? 0go N PhofU16 P1a lAO ?-9 ja Co P* i 1 O

P* W pVW 4 W P1 W PW N W PW UAWN 4 :- 405% 01 4 to N to f P10) U% e %05N NO 14% 4014 t 0% W4t W V4 . 9*

N tO tO5% 014 o4 ~ N? Ph.tO 5

0% 5% -t* 09 NN ?P) WO D =a "10Om* "INf"SAwf =P m01A4 NN 0 q 4 m W 0 m N 0 0 0 4 Pin 4 V4

00 ol) . j .0 * 05% eN.4 le 0% * 10 40 0

0 5 iV 4 IL Nt .4 4%402. t In ~if

C-2 5

Page 68: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TIS-l

W W W WWSl h W h%D 9 N it %0o

* N f0 to aa% NMoi i) s

*9 at I 40'i)otst a 4N0 o1 a0tomf to towo I Kso 19 ON tO 464 10949 a O o to 94m

m4 MMN Mis Z94 MEW ZV MEW Zz ccW' 03W 000 00 Ph9wo 004 a 0 3 0 92 0 I

" H-464 046* "it ""p) " " P I.@ * " .1. & " o 6.o4 * IW (AU6 (Aflfl (in t i(A ((Aln CA 46 (A CA (A (Ae

NOV IA - m N4 'u a NMA NyooP) m('N ist V4 low Q~f t0M a (N W4* 4P a-toON 0 ffN Om N W4 NN %a 40N m ifiP-a* ) P)~ mfe a 00 0 a * t-4% 9440 a V0 ok 94O O ka 4lsmm I w 94b. 10 4 aI a*. W4ON m 9t04 M 46 eNSlyN N W b6 orW 0 oow N 0%W a yW V4 yW at 4pW NV4 W

fac 42o. ID a * . a an a k

,a t

04 N% & Aa ON 0l t 0% aPi)

W4 Zz t o ZZN zzm Zz ZZO ZZN ZZN MZBm# NW9IWPI Ww wam 9W mJJ m W*W gwWWAN

tvzwZmzz M MEc Io 0 Zr. 0 2 ME3'Z

tois U %J U% .. 0U Um 11y' m *toP) % 0 M o % JAJ 4O to* Na -t in inV4

W U Wmw t 0aw 6N 0W NIAW a q4W P* 4W W to WOWZ 94 a 9% rn=nn 1 * g :aaggIA94 CNOOY " ~NaN~~O~aO~ -4I

0 d 1000.4 NO to " PmP* 00 f. I at*)V4 N Ma OlN 0( -t 4p P) 4 00% 4, V. 40 * to N

v46. ms .0 z mm N - v4* .IA Ma~ W a4f. lb.. N 0 F~. O- 0t. 1N 0P N *Nft

v4) 940 o'a in (A a s UN CS O No Co1.! w 4 6 m 0 ox N 0 C: -t o sC 9N WW") wwP) Iaww WW= W WW , WW u4 WW-4

ty a% .0 .o vy 9% - 0Y4 4tf

U% v4 N Ls v4 %aN 'N %aY ON WU Cy 0in mat v4. N(( ON of Mt. %N NP $a N t% NNa Na a o m 0o to v40 a 0 InO

me q46 Pa. I NS I 6 -f I -1 0S NCNYW t"W doW ev (PW mnW NW P)W U W 94 W

luV q4 atz .a 9~ Wi ac. ats oi *la . 4V 4. "P .iN 4 94 N = . aV. No 0. 40 IAN wo

a~ e : (f PN 0 a 4 NmP N aaNe a 0 0* totNO .- MN

wo V4

C-26

-4

Page 69: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 52-81

P*

00

N UC.cU% Fn 0

x =~ 40 zov V Z z U" "-t 4 10 & DI " 4 6. U4n~f (A IA C9 C (A 0b (Alb

ev wo In r MiV4' MN l04. Na

NV4 eyP N A VO= Ito~. ")g. cr N. I t.

g a aot .* . u

C* tn a

pW..-w o N IA 1 tOc

vj. vi . vti W t 0 Wr hiP. Ijr ri 0~ C4

-V r -0* Z * T .

IAn .0Ww OOti'OW

* 4~~* tOD 0 4DM OMINyCD 1 0%0 a*onM a CD

w 0 go N.0 C2

a% v .* q4 * t a

WW= WW94 WWN WW4

*% 0 00 62W t%0~ Cw.4 %a'V tv %0YP)V

NO inO 0 0 0 NP0c 40 Na C*0NI 0 0 N yI NIlA% w '& G2w&aW .W

fuN. P-iY.tZ z onU% zZ'' z *'Ozaz

N 0 m 0, ON c n N 9-..N

.0 0.4 0 94 toNv 0 ID

C-2 7

Page 70: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 32-81

hi hi w hi w w w0% 0 10 4 to g

we U% in t-o%D o Vo 10 fu0

a8 aat '

z 94 V4 N 940401 44' 44 Pl.t 0~ 44W V4. 44"" 4 "~' 6- 04 P 1-4 .rK t. Z

CA (A (AhP (AD' 4I (A CAbsg CAD' 0I' u

mfU % s afc AD tk*u 04 £nnf N mw sY fi n nn b%

Pk 0 I% N 5N ONO m 4t4IOV% f M%% ldiPJv w P. N NP OWN M a N 4 a t. 4 PO'. M ft

1# M a *oo Vi4o 4 m to a .e~ W4t 'V==400 =~ w.ee

#ft. mN 1~t 9%14 1 CNIONC WNIW nI 0 M .tsfu .4 W P "*u ca i e . 50 V* w0 ft*WU *w * .

*o " 4 lfn a ft 4 : m Sa 4 0= N= ;: a' " o0 f. 0 0m 0 0 Ut0 0 d fn S O 9

N V 4 f *WO V4 Vq 4 rC2 N N o %D tO ' N

ZZP. ZZO' ZN ZZmf zZO z % zZxN Z z4 Z z 41wO f4t0 r0 o -IS 44 m 4f of.I fu - o %1 o . 44N 49 l wPU o w w ot UWW4 mww 4 I.LwellrU% S W.a4.0w w nM.dw w446 44Z 0 44 0 E40 e 4.0 445 4 T0 44T

*a ..rJ o4 U% VN 01 IMi '4. *O fP.Sot N -,.. U% % m~ai 01- Ma Os. Oa'

Imla 0 T toa' 0% " CDa Wm=o V, =0 U% F - IM IV0 O.4 0 g %IMo *li N~N ~ I0 VI- a.r w Otn ~ W 0 I W 4 *0%w 94Mfnw MW t w tOlW e 0w

a01m ma " a a V4O au4 I, maO coO '4a a Inwo aoagimaar V% c 040 0 e q4 0 40 0% CiOUO P.- OO%

oat..0 CY am ? O ON ca 0 1 P. I a fn? CD fu #

z 0o.4 ISO O0N to -t N'C t 4 ca0 NvO 4* * ~ " cU1% hID W llN so* r~ 4(A too.. tPN LA N CPN V N iN ON li%4 W a N C - U% 0%t O'2 V40 Nmta IWw at. * .r. M C3 % 0m a 0. *(n bWao hiwo W -4 W w 4 w w UJ w w4 WWO WWN

a CYi n 44 00 O4 NM 0'I in 0%4a V1 44 UOC% N Oi (iJ 4 on 4 .

V4t. ON MN N' ON a ~ FlN V

.4 O45 ao N= a l O* MI ca MW V4 MW 1i MW I

am 1 * Cm1 eb i 0 w0 %don* .00. thlIr 11 0 t2 ft) t4 I%-~ N. .M) 0%

z fuM ?a O~ 0 -&* IN.4- 00a . Nat 4DZZMWZZNMZZPI-14ZZMNZZN4 zzmoazxamoz 11

0 tM 0' O AN0 0- IN- f ''4 iD% Na 94MU % c0- W4im N aI~~D D SUN l o t h a

fe 2 o4 CN 0 4 s W0 of e so1 4 NY wi so 0% a' a. 2 Vol

V4 It ' (n N1 '44 oV5 40

C-2 8

Page 71: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

10 c a W mWW W W WW

4Da W- N ao U'ka 40 0% 0

M' 0 0 to 9% 0z 'A *z 0'" zIA "4W IA Z 4

'A0 0' W4 0OW OW aO wo - o o

ZZ'At aZW WE NE V4O ZE*

lk. NAU N fQI 141. f 0 ee Cf MM EflCJ " "AU we m 0

4040 1*r 0 % 0 'A I Oto1S I I No m" 49i

I A W O* w o w 4N P-m 0q PCD" W04p =N a W.* 0I N= CYP

*P 0P0 N 01.0 U% O *0P *soP mP0% o.g p

* P. 0' 10 a, 0 4 a'A N N. A tv -a

a P. N% IA 0 N a.

m' 0' Ny N 0 4 0%94 0' at P. N IS

zz V4 Z z % ZZ."4 ZZ"4 ZZP- ZZ4 z z ZZ4

QWW m out mg aw1o .1 fN W W4 m W i ul *AW94 U% WW Nxr v zE 0,4=z *".4zE 9.4zz *4 v "4mZ *"4Tz 0

a f 9 rI a @ 49 1g ag w 90 f4 4 91 4

N~ %a V "W N % NP N 'W to11 AA LnM f'A 4 WN.* .. IA m 4 4a 0A.4d M'N&

tyco I Nm NCj - gia CD ~ a% *l424% V0 % NiN"4 aMI U% %a I P.. W)S 'AmS 11 mNr 0. *4 I

F* W Ln J IA"4 W MW to W N.M W M 'W V% dsW mA~

=C=, =* am *P.0mm Uaasmozo~ = a a Uoa N 0 a(P0W mo a Go Wa' 04404 a OY =O N CD OWP- am,. m4

00 .P- * uu 0I~5 9400 * ell *% V"4o *% .o:.V:ulon O=IP). 1 0' I4 NC 'A4 %D-& Mm 10A0 Nu* 0'

P. M) 4A 0. C 4 "t P ' NP ("4 i *0 "4IA M D N f SAW Nt Nt V4 In V4* 0'" P.

top- m1 pf) P. N P- CD *~ % PN.%D ca'm M' Wco ota Wm mam N%

*: N.* 0'. 0 A "4 o "4 NA **D0 -WW") W WO WW v4 W WN WWN W Wac W W 4 W .,f%

N WI N~ U% I NIA O I N-A in* I .0sON. 4 WW @"4 "N 0* "4 V4 "

aAt V AN I%. N I&M ota V* aa ma 40 m 'Am = a)

* @ SS 0 0I I0 C- 40 Iw a W 0 W NW SAUW 4 W N W "4 W %10 *N oA0 OP- NSA ct. UAPNM No a, 4

N 0% b%4 PP. aoo 40aW 1%- "4= V4

N P." 4PN-P- WOMN woo 4'"-M NP-)*- 'A oPft N4 fP-N'a 4 WPNCs cy 4 z ="44NO*IAN@I 094 .j 9AN 4 mN 0 U 14No'A .0 r q4 0W " * 4 0'M .j 04P .P-. 0' t - N P3 49 '

40 L t ..

C--29

Page 72: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

a 0 0 0 0 a

wa W I w wjU%9 N 0 cr

4 In tv w 0 04 ow to NY a% 94N v4 v4 Y a, U%

in UN N N*

IA 0 W4 * ' 4deP 49 a r0 44 4 t 4 4 9N 440% 4 . t

z z01 Z ZNF ZZ 4 EZ XC ZZ 4 EZ X0 Z NQ ~ ~ PU QW 94 to0in 00 .0 D Q to 0 WO4N Q *

" 44 0-44W " M s. " P " m.44 -4.".M4P " "-4. " 1.4 -*Wfu CA (A CA 10 COC(A 0 ((A CAC t4 (ACA 0 CA~e W (4h

W4O to4 wN 4

940% inO 0% aN.09m V40 NN me P e a o P4 N a

10 4 0M P. N f *N O'4NO- y0 aO P) U% N aN.o owa ONO N a F a P orU U0 we= qQ U%

cp V4 V.- W 40 -Y NF4 D aL ,4ff 9 4 W '44uD%9: 40W N a 4 O 0 0 624 %0 4

A! of" 0 0 U% .00 40 . P) 0aI4* NY Nk Ny 0 0%

a0 0 U% N% VA NNt 42 W 4 0 N.

U% 7 PV0 ca* L9% v4 N di Nyw

z zP)~ ZZ ZZ ZQ ZzW ZZ Mz 4z z WofofSD O 4wm to * ww: w 424ww% 4 w u

iDWww0.. WWN 94wwNww.I#S"wwt- WU* U% Iw w tto.4EK ov4 ZE. XE Z * XX. 0 E XX *lef 446 1 4 4 96 446t 4OSI o 49 6

,w4 i 0-* Ca O %Dm mst It~ ewm vb aw N f- Now IA'D 0 o'w NOW

aCm a qwm,4.ag :C*,'m=:a: w~s6%00504D~

P-* 64 L) 0 0 0% * *U0 .nc e u * .l * 0% 0 0 .t. 0* ,0O4 6"1. M9 I 666 N4 w wN I(Dl. I4t

,4f~ It '4* 0 Q m' V46 N* 0 0 N zU% %0%0 z P) P4*4 0* N-1In ~ 94 Ow 0

N NP. P0 *6- IAN 6-N ft 0-. CA9T ma wA em "o m a Wa ca W

WWN wWW W r ,ww v4 w w N ww v4 ww 4 U)

.40 60.46 IA 54 .~ 046 '40 M AOM0 v4 z 06 a N aD N%0 1% cy we% 0

P) q4 0 V4 n y . P0 *N 4N N YI * 4 taa ~ Na a a0 Om O aamm

NI U%' 1A W46 ") NI M zi V4 W 0 LAW t'w m LAW 94W IAJ toW ew N

40a m NO Ow ft.W -0 MN Ncu ON P Z NI% of) ON 06% o' .in*N 0W94 * Z vuN94r wzzV60*NIOC QLA

0%0 4 o0 'p a N N 994 CN z

v4 V) N N W i

* 60 0 000

c-30

Page 73: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 52-81

0 .0 0

hi hi hi W ih i* wo 1N N N

W4 a C0' N N *0aF) 0 N a 0 '

U' 0' N NY UNV4 1' 0 V4 4 44*

P)' c" M 0

ZZ7 Z=N EZZ4 ZEN EZr VZO ZEN EKo' cz004WOV4 0OtD4 won5 owe5 woo5 OWIN 00-54 wo1

W(A (Al(CA ; (A CA ; CAf CA (A (A * fl( W tA CA W OIA 0 (ACA

fut N a ftI *4 0 CO S4A NIn 0 4 4t NOaIt14J M~ (Y utW "p1 N' atut" NO M 4 "ItN0fome 0% m ON 9 a N Pro W pa WN m m N wo M N U% m N m4 N a no= a 4W vow M 4a W to a 0 940 NN NN$.VNI .401 n U 1* .4 "I OiNI .4A NO% NO' 0000 1 w

omwh V0W 40 W WNW W4 M W U, " W V - W WNW V.-400 caa m wo 0 ca a ) 0a0 004

osO .0 .f OnO *6 00 * 0 eN 00 s 0 0.'4 060NY N~ g U% VA4 0

In 0% m 0% 0 Pan IA Ii 0o aa

m' 0 V4 N 0 oZZN zza ZZt_ ZZ* ZZ$ ZZ"f zzo ZZN Zz

W LL04W4 NwaftN WMnW.,4*WW on M WW4 %DWW V4 .W W 4 aW WZE. Z. cc. CZ. Y. Z. EZe ZE. ir

Ua 0l 0Mo C" (% .40 %a Wl.4 04'. fuN 141 U

wi 0*0 tA~ S W%9M144 YdWa to WNa I t*0 # ** o 0i v wi f ' ok c I ",o LA c In VAL I NOV4 IN W N=W " " W V-4 94.4 .U W m " W NO'w MmIW a q4W 42 4 N 4 c ma 9. C V.4I UN a4S U% W 40 ca a 9 CA a@c

.000 * M m 00 *3 m '. do .00 or Mjt * 0 11*74 o 140 so) I O' N. IF MP V4* 4 ta PO -

goo LA q4 IA V40 to "N V4* oI atU% et40 1. oP. *p.t . V4NP w .4N P.. C A. doNP

%a Dc V4a 0a 0a0a 0aN 4.04 N. 'o 0 No V4 C:

WWN WW= W JW'4 WW(U WW V4 W W 4 WW 4 WWN hih

*1 01 m 60 P 0 m a 0b 0 W 4c

N 44 kIAV4 in.4 UN 4. 4 ,4 V4 Nb.N *P.. NN Pw") NN iE0 0N N m N

M~ Nacya '4 a % ca 00a N a 0D a % cN 6 401 NI1 0 1 5 %D 1A M m1 ASmAU W bW NYW caW 4 W 42W 40W O0W0. -0 4 u " 9 NV4 Umw~ 400 lb. t U% %'.4 NOr to 1A N %a fu .P * W-V4 a IA

N 0 W N N N4 W A 00 '4 z ll z zaz 0P~N***LAU'I0*4I0N,00O' 4 W 4IA0N w 44N 0 M 4

ey p V 11M* N a% V4 NA M4 N' V4 N0 0 0 N0 0

C-3 1

Page 74: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

a 0 0 00 00 0

* N N m Vt Iw.V4 *0 0 mA * 4 V4M N 0. 0 A0 0 94

4 P a t N *V4 An Ny V40tOa

~~0~ 221 U%~Z ~ Z N 224 ZI ~IA VtDI t5bP- 0 0 %. WO owe 0 tID@ OWN

044M-" " b 0-. M.1 q' " 4W M . W " M " 't " 41*

(A. 4 PA M ~ 0 (A' 9AA4A A CACA fA(

N* 0*e loot m* 4&' a~O we

1.i Vt4.~ SANO a*t 0% toN 4D 01. 0

V4 0 a0%.0a 4 N #b,. a a V*4= 400 a m = 0 C,

IY a%1* I5* 06*1 40 U%1 I') 9pt *0 Iw 94*0 4

Ni T0 001 .4I wog N00t g ; vG0 4 00*11 0.49 0N9 *EbN

0NP 0 1. 94t In r.4K U% -S V 0% N1 Ii

V4 N~ N 0 4 1& 'aPP ZZI 220 220* Zzzm Zz4 2261* ZZ*8

a a4w 0 4 g4 E E*-. 4t*.Jn WW -~.4W W41* WWPPPPWP "*WWV.I% W t U%

x z 0 .94m z '42 x z 4 x m *94r 094zx 1 .942 r6944* 1 C C1 4 eo f4 .441 0 4 -C. 1 . 9 W

.4 U% UN 940 *0 11*04 0% fs a P1-Ono* 040 M P* M 9P4* *9'4* -# m os 4

C3 0% vi f .4 " M-v4 y oC P%4 aO aO 010% U 000

I ON I Nuoi 9.wi 40 01 m US 1 au 0 PI"NI zhi to~N *IYu w U oCy CuJin NPPI4 N W M V W

*0 @00 a09 goS1 O 0% o 04 @4pOW *0% a 0IA% o 41 0.00 * :0 N8 alNm"0a 9 0Cl14Ra T

*00% 'D .0m 0 91g U% .4 a% *Y eN . w94 10 9 e o P 0 0 94* 4 Q04P ie a 60 1 P . mf 6 44 1 110 CD a* %*0A.

aN ty N.4 v4 0* 941 0.%94 *00% N P- V4* It01*. V4* .* 40 94Wd* ** 4 *1 C%0 m2 %

Np.94 V. . l- t 0% V. in I. N N. 0% N 01,) em tAo Cp% 00 4w V4 't0 me

pq wwa goWwV4 WWN WWm wW" WWN WWN hi

N N *41 U%*. tNI l I lol I I.Pi 0% 0094 NO 0's QP. M wW% V94 IA% CY N 4 *094 VN IAN * N .

00 a1 PUN a0 0* U%* 0a 61NYI Vt. I1 ofP %1 I6 in I z

V4 w q4W Q W N W gJ v4 W v4 W to N C

NO f 4*w 0 D"- ON N1 N) 4* %a* 10 mt* a161 N** 0%5 t- O 05 a** '0 m

20% 940 v4 0 0U% & 10 at0 at N 4 O0* mC0o C V94 0*IAU% . 0P4 D* %D 4 N O"aNUC* 4 (3%t.InPPNt.0 0%.4 wm %P 4 % PW** NA f5-NIA 14409got.JU% 940 4 f N@941AN

0 6A44 "N MW~

94 X aN a0 . a 00 a.%0 * .4 0 4T1~ I 4 *0 4 v4 4r 'ADP I-

C-32

Page 75: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

LI W W W W

at #a ify 10'

aY m4W 40 4a 4a W4 4 c

z XZO z M a zC

" 4 4Sa "g P* " " 4 CA * 0Z CA CA E (ACA (AC

tn afu In tfyf %a fee ca (fl$%. Mi N A '. W 4 U a

in I SI Na% U% 1 0 UI [email protected] v4 Nt ".9N v4 M94 U~0

6 4 *a PO e. %D0 009

N 4 W%

N i) int Pzz"f ZZN ZZP) ZZN ZZ&A

46W W dl) IC toJ W a N3 if 9 ofl tJ of W W %Wr XT mr .x ME*Z E

NP). of* N** I~fa W9

IAUn C24 cs0 M'0.* fn Coi IA0 Ino Oat

cu (YLU I%.W NIq4W Pf) oLWAJ W~4 W::Y~ UpV3 ,cO~aall Ka A 00 to.a0 .if a 0 SDU *l 0 0 * 4 00

0* 4* cy4p r4 L U%460 v PftN 0 O. %. %. asr-N I%.%

N. -t 0 If% U% tn~W W c W W4 WIAJW4 W WNC WWNC

4 Qa dos N,% 04U%~ CY in 94 IAN C P* 94

tU%, 0)N %a N. ON t%14 ca Na Lf to m= to ft=aI NI of 0 1 09

v4 W PoW -f W N W doW%040 tNIA *Ia% 40toI %bt

P. F* W4 NI t ' *tOo

M 9 0 4 *4 ft=U0NW0- 94 ft

94 c94 ifiOy 2P940

94 t 0 N94

C-33

Page 76: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

C3 ca 0 aa

W Id W Id Id Id WP2 40% U%

in NY N 0'0 '

,a %0 0 N onNV4 a p- %0 do0

ZZ2 MEMO vrt WE* Era Eva ZZ'4 ZENLDD' to owe 0o Lb LD = 000%0 owl- oom 0 LD4"rb4 " 4.4 W44U " t ""t -44U 0-4 " * " 1-4. 4 .4" 4 " N4I

CA (A * (flu (A U(A V)U CA (Alu 6 0 ( CA 0 (AV (A (AC

;= MW0 o"0 me0 "N I N I P-' 0w.I@'N " V4 IA'V4 N m UNO lAp *0% Na 0 % %

40 - o 0*oD coo0 c'oo 0'IA N "0 NN'0 4 N P.NP- N V'. 4.4 vqa WW tA C W% aO LAP- V,. a4fP -- I NqV4I 1 U ")I .*V4 1 V4 NI in 4 1 -* 0'I %a..e.. UuW U% 0W *0MW N vy W ONW 0% ONW I,-NcyW *N W

N VA '% %NV q% -N .4,919C0 ON a C-2 CP2 IA is4 4 0t'P 4 aaI. = e C

0% 0 N 0 q00 0't 0 N NV

NN IA94 00N0

C2 mg*~ g2~

V-40 P2 3 *0 NO 0. 1-0 '4P. 0 U% 4 (%i0 NA- N

- 9 4 * 49 ' Wm. " fu." 0 o * 49 or to N Fcm Q KN'W 1(10W '4W V N q W up 4 U 4 DWOO W 4I% U'uW

fuN % 04 do4 W'. p0 aN2 .0. cma n.*~~~ N 0 0 a W% N0 a

0 1. F4 a 4 aa 00 3OO AO O0 0 1 " %oo~ o I #D 400 P- 40

eNII CY C* *.40 -40 00 0 m N O2**4

Z2C N0 =2 40 t4 a~ *N .Dl aNOa N% = 5u a. M41 0= 0 04 N U 0 0 NO

ty U V4ON0 0 0 V 10, 0 0 *"a P . 4D0 =" aId lA* 0F *#. p.m IA. V4 N 4C3 4. Na LA .t

0 CY0 U6 n t0 V6P. 40s 400 0%% CM

o * n 'a '4% '2 ON EN * N 00cn W ..Wi '4 '4 040 IA W i0 WA' IAN ww WW

-5N n*N IAN -N OY - Y " 5N "1 0 00 P-N15"11

9 ~ N NI 01 to 0,1 %% N I t O 0% 14 inWI O I Ua 00 0 U 4( mA 4W MW SA *W 0 N W OW=

W0 wu %2* v4 0 4.4 OCl 0* *V4 UV NWP.- * U N.4 '40 P.u 40 a0 ON4 N Pal

0Z co* P-'d mca .4S a i OSA a4P .4 a C.. q I*' P.. 1 S~ 'S40 cy I % I U% NO'4 0 ,4 PZ % eN W0 e N eN UW # '4

(%j N 0+ 0e as a go m4 Pm# -20 nIfi cy V) 94 v 0 IAU d * cm40 40 ItoA

I-- ~' v4 M*' 4 "U 4 .4 M M N 0 M 4 409 0 0D Ca N 0q

C-34

Page 77: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

a CW SM W W SM SM SM

UN W4 U% %

Co W q4 10 n 4pNY V4 iS 0 N V4 6

a1 % V4 in I& AN~ to V 0o 4

Vo6 4 %D r. kA lb IW s 0 ot40 0 491 on 440K 4 WN WWN 4 a 4 446Og% WVZv4 WE"W KMN zv"f MEN WZOM ZEN CEO E00si IDbO W0 D WW 0 0 00 m Lwoe OWN 40DS 0 IDL

IflnA CA CA V (A (A.(Ai CA (fC (C l CM CAW (A We (l

to% 40%0 0 6%* 00, VSI tn p0 NN NP w P) 4 0%D W N~i f4p. N p %iS LiN 4 00 %o N C ' a% mo P*N r mcmN v4 NNlk V4 N Pl. % N

%010S @00 ON 1 9 S*6 I iO a,10 10 W U% M% I N 14 a,

NOon w66 aI* q 0W caW NC3 CDO aN t

U% 0 In A1N 10 in v4 0% pn a NWA 0 NY U% 4 CT Nat v4 %0 Nm W 4 61%94 V4 N a, a% re0v4 N W0 0 0% 6N to

zZ zfz z 4 ZZv Zzo xZ ZZI W I utZ 4 ZZ-0 z449a 4 *a4W94 Of 440 la W L 40 a 0 4494w 409 444r 49W W Nm WW 4 mW W 4 q4W W ul ne % f*LoWWN *WW A W.0U JW 4 %aWrm a z rr 2.4mv 0.4r eqiKE e.4rz* Zz qv42

440 4c 445 446 o 4K.6 1 495 1 .4 As4 09

.O 06 %Da iin f"0 co 4 0 0%% v4t #ANSA a* a a do = 00 am LA% =m v4i v4.. CD94 0cNO@Y NO I 4A we ~ Wey C3N I IrIfvOm

0 0 v'q4 %0W V4 ItW *0 W =4W 4 PW 0% cW MDC3W CNPtoW v4

v4 w4O@m v OeN"m N 2 QQ in c W0a o~ON a v4 Mm as

ca* I 0N I61 0go 0 SNO =* I6% temIaoI("N NC 4p UN Nko= T 4. UN % U% fr.Inaa 0%40 04. 0 ma % m% Na MinPN 0%N r.. v%1 N%. P. 0. NO aNNo C w uC 0% m N2 C 0 c 0 OC *-* v NP. at. o6 Fn. N 40.a

WW%* W W 0 W W % WW T4 WW v4 WWN WWN Wwo W

*% 1 0n# N 0 1 kn 0- 0 4av4 1 n % at=0 Nfn $a6 NuI ~ 0 S 94 a 06 a,94 ,t, v4 V% 4 1%V SS% 4 1Ov4 4 W4 %

N0 0% N Nh 0. NO ON a PIMe N PIe040 %0 *m0t o ca @ a m M0%*40 *6 NpOCY1 0 16 r0 r INYW N W ow 0% W 0%W N W 0%Wu q4 W

a1on m&I N64% ca m *0 m ouN ty $

tv N1 N aI o% to% ON*6zz*94zz""Pzz"Wzzu%z*O zisq zzOw ZZ-*PZ

0% 6% W N m = mh 0 4 LAO W1".

z q4 & %. NIN %.6N oh. 4PI"1%. .%N% at 0 0 0 494 a0 W * o N 4N"vI4 =OM 9400IA94O4N099*940NI9O OE wn qSOz p 4 t%

ee N N 00 .0 a" .0 0%0 N z .0I. 61% 94 61% %Q v4 0 UNI

IA 04 Wfl U%

C-35

Page 78: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

*, 4 *d 4 * 4 *f I* *

O s e e S

%0 U% W 0 16- tN

I ,l ~~t .9 oru I Pg (fJ I0 k I - 94 l S. .'4 . @ d 41. 0 * Ih P,. I' .1,

Ny N W a

14. o f,,trI el o.I18 . ! eu ! i t C t le

M a N4 NyP tat 0 N.- t o

4 0 0 .1,: 0 0 P. a 0

, ft. , .. own own 00 0 0 ,o wow 0 0A

Wt cm (Aa. CA (A W (Mj,

(A.. W ( C 4 a

16EZ. weZ azo 4fo Ino MZ9 ZEaN 400

o 0l. wlID Wo W p4WP o N Nf.. 0 o o M Ola t- M IDW NeW .. N o N . 1 * • 4W .0 N •M 1.49 a = oo* °

IW IP'. 0 Wto I I to I t N 1 ,4.00 1 W6 I InA I NAo,

N.. P..Po. .0 go g , NN ,. . ,

,* *4, o , 9 . . .- ,,. 0 .Na.., U.,,' .

N mao a tN 0 ON aNS 9. #A q4 .09 *o t * OM ee .

9. p 9. .. "0 -1 . . 9. •

N V4 N4 4 0 N

i N • . . • W. .

z* z* z Z v zz4 ZUzz= ZZ M zZ Zz 0~ ZZNW w M.WWOWW*0WNO w WW9..W 9 . CW IAI9V4 W .WWWMZ Ov.TT *0T1Z OV.. OZZ *N XE ONEEeN ONZX ONEE 0

*9 1wl! 09 4. 1 a a!NM 30% .4 W.0 MaM on-3e.. d s 0 MO .0 w- 0 1.00 Nb 0 * .4*0 M M.*

"tW M9.W 04W N UW e*w w I s~aw WOW v.0 W Now

9.v94 aa* @00 0 ne1 Wa 0 * 9to

a.o oftn~ m9 00~ e o mPoat @ 0P. 9N090* 0 . tu b.m M t-o lb .*o 0% N.' * 1%0. .0

IAP PM -t a N a oo., WP1 a n ca P. 3 01. IPv4 O N 0 *0 0 . t. Nt*.. 0 P- P

WaM W9 IAW9 4w wN wwo WW .- WWO wwa WWa

1if 94 941 U% m Is, I9 M u.cy1 'N I -,N I 9P M IOy Qo 0 0Y t v49 4 0 0 NP.6 a.. in 5 14.l P-r4N N N on- 0 0NY Na a 9 a =a 0 Mo *0 *9o ON 4 0N I 9 o N *9. V4 9. V4 *N 141 .NU

NW *W -tw W oW Inw w W to W N-w MM%(0 MP IVb 66. 0 fu t-. 4%b~ "l 0 iP O" MGoo "a 4 * * ItN NO V-P. 40 aP. I 4 at &A IA 9. 0 4Z*NZZ@NZZONZZQM z zOOZZ q4Z9WZV%9.Z

N .NM P F.0 oN nj 0 "1 N o0 P. 4q4N0.4aN 04v N 0 v40NM mU 0 N 9. *% 4N0NNN04

v4 0 0 o j4 = qon 0 ON 0 %

C-36

Page 79: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

W I W W W W Wto 1.% *l 4%N M M 14 W) a 0% 11

ft' N a V40M 000

000t, woeP LD W t 004 alO'. woo. *4t 00 9's' t- 0

0-4 W * 14 "-t 0.41"4* ".4"44 ".1.4 * " " -* 14 " # 114t 1.4

N. QM ad c M~. P.4 M ..N 40 t- f.- .amco oD N0 a 0 - . 0 . 4 a 0 on. W0 Y40w Pf o I N IA1 V40 toI t..I M1,S sI I'* we$9 I0 N ~*I q4

I 0 W &c O'C me M*W *NW o"'W 0 4W M N W00n a . 0. a M "~ .4. -

eoN *' a aO** **E *~ a 40. W*0 M 0 0 0

f' 0% N2 W4 0

40 NY %* 4 a 0ZZ4 ZZ4t ZZN Zz0' Zzm ZZIN.. zzQ ZZ0 z

agl4W fu. OW NP'.S WW 0- r W J4M Ioff 4WrP.. W . W W'.:ilW W tfi 4

95m a W" t J\ V%4 Na fa f" U% 40 .00 W

I0 oP* 1 2 61% l'S N f 0 06 at to0 0.4 I faIA W ;W " 0 4W NWWW = o W v D 0Wt PN W*aV4 a 1040. W CO.4 % I ta( 0.49 O N 0.49 o'49 c '4~ P)

a~ . .1 a ft 40'P C. a z *'40C C o40 40 a =~ ") e a a =0~ *y a .60 taa c% ameo%= a 04aaaa *OD go a V'4I a 9.a4 a0 a V0a0

in m~'. NO in vO M 9 0% 904 e N o0 CY0%9 s'. 9 0

ca a to * I a t'o Ia.+ 0 W= IM'-I..n0 4 s I A%

o W' I%. ) I. w % n W) % * tWP NO %ao a' WW4 PW

do a 400 0 6P * %M o0 N 0aV uts

N. to P. . I%. @ a0. 4 N t16 NO %.4 N'. ~

%D 0 -t * NC 09 %0 v4 M- 0W W 4 WW W 9'WW 0.r~ OW N 4 W*v4W

0. 0 m Oft x .. a a~i V4 s P.. a '40 .

M 0 00 4 0)i NO 0 %a 40 ama W 4 q a Ci % c W4 42 aP. P40 a *o 4 m

.v ak01 IZZNOZZOP9'ZZ*.UZO*ZmZ*N ph. ZZ0 pd Z0 f -t 0 W ow. 00 00 '4.4 lAOm M M M 0=N 0 94M4ON MMO W4NOO4'49'494 NO0 owe0'4

P) eta .' e M0 go 00M e aBA 0 090o at to 10 0' V4 NY 94P) U' N in I.. .. * %aN I,- NY v4 0 NO M W 4

c-37

Page 80: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

W W i hi W h w wNo 6 0* 0% IN. #a 010 ' P. 4p

l ' In IA 0 .4to v. a& a' 6 0%

N 6 49 P. 0'" ww 0 oc Na N4 94 P 4 a

wwwo~r Zz10 Zwo Zza =me Zz Zzwrta t Chi own 004 0 IN. woo. woo 4AWo

VA0 CA #A e (All CA CA ( (Ain Wf(A f (A4 ( C

0% 5p 94 9 to we5Ny 1%. 0*4 F4* * AP %P- at1 #a t40P- P-Sb NMW1 -P1 Now oo wM M'01 Wso 040ca M m 40 '00 P = t W.44a6 *PIa

iti .4O NP 10,W gag 1.4W Nax V .s.ca Fa aD =p U%

em~~I eof..0 . *p eON 0 On *eP

4& to 4 N t4V 4 40 %0 U' 000I

* N 0' % P.90~~V N$A' .. .

zat P5 10 U% .4w IA z -40MZzp.

Z'ZZ 0% ZZ1 ZZ 0 IP' ZZp Z Z1 ZZW

A. pe 94 CD WW WNcu to in wo % Ns. 1

10 1 .P .40 C2( In 1 % w% .t4P al sU NP-* l %0 c

%Dw 10P-W MM0W MN 9',1ww NO'W mtow V4-W1.s* Oa 1 .4 w o 0s 0 a @P = ~ = amO 2:M0P-aa@PMM a0060 ama. mame=m aO ao =O "o~emwo w0 a ==a@10===a e=m'4a0 Po K 0 Oin .0 * 0 *.t% 0 .1s* tw*o% . O* r 0 *I %o aF'5 I N 0 ( P50# to C.w.v 1 0* 1 *"IN M1 .1.

aG 02 %a #0 %D U% %0%0 It S Na NCw.0P P-Wnt. 0% .. U%P' N AP P%-. Na.Non0 M' so 5o %m tD P-a %Dr po M

C2 W. to a. M. %1. 2 0.i. *W N W W t" iM W WN WW i ww W wWat WWa w w m

ipQ I 45V coP s5N I9 Ni N 5 1P 9 410 100 4 0 V 0 4 to W4 a U= e

0 0 am .6 O' %a t4 0'% N4 lA% TV4ft o % % tON M. Pw inN IAN I pa

NSI - I0 lZ NI V4 P- 06 V41owW ow N MW ODW inW 6W 10W vw tW

W 40 N* P0% *0 M t % Ma W 4 W W tooIn0 P0' 40IA NP" NO ca 1 .o% 40% t P0

00 atP. zI.a " 04 P-W PPw5' 9 N a~ -tP 6

et 0 0 wP ae1 4N wm .. D DN4 .4 MeP- - fM5 M 4 " .- 1.4 MO ". o N- 4r tV 4 U' 4 p%

U% 0' in N 10 04 a N*.DM 4 I- %P N4 it

C-38

Page 81: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

0 0 61 90 0 C0I I I S I S S I

W W W W LJ W W W0%t ACl 0 P. Y A.,

.4 5. N *g 0D *ma a to. to(

S.,4 c 0 U% 0 IWa- a .4 .. % N p

z~~~a w~ 0Zu Z0ED 0 P-..Z(AZ

5.4i 41 -,A -* *-I. ll ). ,- .1 ,4 I,4* M,.-4 t,,,4 P 4- 1.4 . t% I,4I I .4 *I4

S I I S S I Sz cz N W W D1 53 WN 1-a = t, zWN m v

LoNt L oQ lL PU I'oP aN CD O. cat .4 toW Lot

C.4A.. 0 0 (A -) 0, .1 0 CA, (A W ( (A (A CA A IA . . (A

N S 090 1 0 iolaV440 1 N & 1 %6I N.4S 1

@0D =W i@Wa 4 , "WW W40O .4 W0 .,o U% W .4

%0 W= .f 0 =0Y =d f ) mo W4s " W4 " 4 c. 4 = i M.. ov

a iO o1 o 0 40 W) a N 3 ca in eo a10~

lA IA IA so %A

. .0 . .0 . . . Ng',I I,,P I O, .40 I r 0 N ft 4N I v 0 * '

do 0 . 0 % NZZN uN = 4ZZ o Z Z U% ZZ.. z=4 z z Zzo z zW Oa1 N 4W 4c.#' d -a M me.0 C2 -4N W Q OcCID P WWW U 0 toJJ W l 40 to o a, N W Wv4 M WW0 ,. W W M, 0 Ni WW.UW*WLWT~ * o~ x TT *r MsZ 0..ZZ *..4TT *.r4ZZ * 'M Q,4

V 0 4 t% U% .4 1..- 00 tA.W4~U toA 0.* r00 W40 C.4** ** I*NtI St .40 a. I p2.?--S1 N V4 ?5 0. 4

NOW 44 W 0 C2W NO0%W M10W N oLJ 40 W UtoW Pft %a a N a a C.M a10 =a C30 =.4. C 0s.. a00

OF-" row 0om~y 4 CPo *a o O M N 0 0p, V4P

~s 6N.In 0 @*% * 0 4 OAn m= 1 %0 % 0. 1 N "%0 N0n c C U%. OO Ph. 00 .- W 0

WoK nto U 4na va - 0% 1 N t * 1Cs W A %a es a0 a. P.. a .c

W W 4 W W4 WWI W 4 WW 0b AW a Wwa W W V4 WW to W W

I P 0 in I a 0- * i o i os 0 N 0 0,f * F

m Cu % 60 W%0 .4. %9.. .0 N N NP. VUB Na 4 0. t40 oft4 I 4. .A N .4fa .I ft. 4 OSa I 0 t-. I41 in.5I.a

o W %D0W NW iW uW V4 W SA W t WNm m~ M 0 to4 at N.

*%I 00% -S4 00% 0%0 N4b ob. OP. Bmo 944 t- O' 0 OP. ION 4094 y%

@1U 0 51%f *e .4 W. 14 4 0P-0m00 N N%"1-V 0. N m N %000 Nm N V %.4" -N0 =AB rD4III'O B B ~ -.- N"10NIfu

001I00.C A [email protected]=% 400WOt.=S. CP 0N=OMV4.tA M455 *.4OPNa4NNCD

0 0l CL fl- p. 1 %u% 4 N% a) %0 94D

.4 V0 0 4 v0 4 .4

C-3 9

Page 82: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

., .. ., ,= .9 .9 .9

WW W W

o0 N w V.-

iV, N 3' 4W

= N 0Z v4 .9o N 0 =ZF- U% a

4p I-4,- ,,1 4, 9c m a -4 %- a -1 INK -

* I I 1 6 0 5P O zP 0'P U'ff .44 x z a 0m

U ldoom woo ODN 00A. o1N OWN W 0

* IrNS NNS I 0OI 0*6r 00,m i,,,, a*i 41, N*IW " * " " .. "" 4 OwW ".0 ""W *W "' ". ."D

ap o . .40 •0 .N.• U% to .2 •t

N. fl.~ b 0 , 0a4. %041 Fwino P i%DWN0P MN 4 p. 4p U% N 411 D %oU o a

P- C9 a. %00 N0 04 Pfta ya aV a .

N I N 0N

P. M t 0" Mr0 N . . .4 "

oN0 4 O a0 . , ' N ou ON

NE U% WO F-UN

* N0 zZ eD - zo Ze %

10% UN W W V40W N ..- W U) # uW M0'W N O W W 4.d&W wN W W6,4 TX .4EE *.-4K *v4Ez *,g N Z oNEEz ONZZ*9 da 1 S 49w 1 9ql 49* 49 1 W 6 491 ot

0 Euo a0% %o = U%* .4., 0,% aNN. P % .4 a • m-.4 0 P o?- * 0 • '0%.0 W - * o* O aIC Y0 a o N cm 421 a a 1o 0 W4 0 U 0= 00

O N I O F s N4 I 0.96 0 ' *0 ".P.Al m.. I q YN& M In W 4) V P .40W a W N PW =MWJ 940

V4 ca 0 N 0 *0U @ D O 0 iI wa 0a0w'mm WNz9=1noum 4IS000..1m 0 o 0% 0 *0' % ONO% o lD t * 0 M 4.,t 0 0* t0 0.64%m m I I l6 t. e m I* 0' O a %D .. * 0m2 1l

Vm 0 1%N cl0 o 0 4 %oUm 0 N#. 11% k- P.. %o. I. -* 1. V4 r.Foc V4 c ' S C 1 N0 N0 tIM 0m 0a 00

NY W W 0 'W m WW V4 WWN WW t~ Y WWo WWO WW

"=N a t- = cy =0 in

" i 0.o 1"N to

* i 0 %° 10s.0' 04 %ID ty. 00 0'' %I 0I 4C o oo.t4 N %0N Oa1b N a. NDNV ON

%D I %o 1 0% 1 111ow 0% W %OW N W -t W 0%U W 0W UWNO11 0% %"0t 0.4 P-N a %00% PNo ("IIN, m0 .9% -ta 0 I 0 00 m o 4N ON

4: O NW % OP. *0 0% W* fNVlY IoNP Z M aZ Z 0 MZ Z 0 1xz N -t x ZMin zzfNNzzo94z

gn000 P)00N I % m WOO"-O*.aP-m0F-.4:4P ON. A V 0 0 0= =OxF- NOe W9 2 0 0 04N V p l 40 9 N 0 P %N 09N4OFON=.0 Z . 0 M * N m V NoF-i =p CY .' . 0

go z U% N 0 so% 0'0P z1 0% al 41 44 6& N

C-40

Page 83: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

CD aa ca Cp C30

00% 0o -S 0 fn %10% UN . P.- N ty .0 a a a3 a a

94 W% so %a N pl. so #k-ey.9 a% 4 V 4 ot a cWt 9% f 9 Kd0 09 at

N 00 00'. owN .oo= WOM 0oDo W

to in ' 4p I-,. Pa. P. %D P. 0%Vl C.I.9 aVN ~. D0 q0 00 W CY9 on 4 0 V4~f W4. N NN o N~U fn O & Z, INN -&v =z %Do wdP a Df% NP tNI

ca. C3.D t0 l % a W. c rDS (D0 = W4 0% V 4 D

* I k I Sr % 4 0 % I kl 1 4 % O I P. S

.90 * -4-#I q40& N'. .4C. -S. mA~ we9 N%0 P.Oc 0oo c' 40 C* 0 o mC . V40% 940

'.0. 0~' 0 0 00 0 015%Oa UU 00% 00

Ft. 00 0% U%. '.0 V4wo %. 0 N 94 N9 '-t 0% Cl9 L '

0Y %a0 N ' 5.1

F~ZZD zz* ZzoA ZZOr z z I- za' Z4 zz"4

I.9n4 J ieW0% Ill w. UWW JAiI CY P- WWuN -4 w .4at wUP. F U) %D0*Nrm *1'.TE ONEE ONwT ON xv M E * ZE * Tz *

r'. 4 ~ 4m P. 05.r 9940 U's. 05'.Le '.* -+ VF '. tN 0S2 .4.4 - W P P0 a.mt f

%O'N I lC Dq 9'4 in~ I.p~ Fn00 oN I C InI 000

SM T4 lw N 4w UN .lh W u's - W N w 9r4 CDW C U No m W4 W%. 40949N'. ro1% 394o % 0~U. 04 caP D NO 0% 0.40 C N 0015'm c . .

CD'. o .a, '.0QI0 OKdo0 0 mm 0-0 0 %0 US u' 0 S&W 0OD&0 0 ONcPON P' n I c I- aN co. cc t I ILUN 0%N- 1 '1

In %D C %.0 o N o CID 40 '. 0 0 . 4 0 0 .UCP 4'.0.~C- 942 P. in0 N LAS N# 4 o'.

C2. ca %D cm .4 WC3 J cm W Z3WW3 0 C3 D VW0 W 0.

%a 0 9 0 0 0, CA a4 * NC

%aO CY Q %a v WN UN.94 0 V4. U% 94 w CN &A Vo00 LA1%. NO 0 94 so .N W 4 U%0 0 0 to 4

CX 00 40 C3 o C3 ~ W) =0 cm 0m GoCP 0c

C3oW t OW %0W '0 %Dw tW N NW u'.w -4 W OW94* NP- rl' M0 -tm Sb- 04 N o 94* f M to .6%bf.90- OD. P- NP. *0 9 00 LA%' I 4%P. N0 P4 -V '.0 too NO. CD W m 04%0

wlNZZLA0ZZ'oNZzLA,4zZwm z NZ4 2 2ZZ% N ZZ P,-0z z r- 094m NO CD 9Y pn~. '.0%aP. Z w440 In~ 4 NY* m'.

094 omr0 .94r 0* MQ M 1h. w1 at so 40MNMC .

NY CY N40 1.- W% Vol4UA c0 In mA V) U%' t 94 NY

C-4 1

Page 84: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-8i

w w wU w

0' w N0lP.. 4 NY 0 NY

cN we 0

3cI c"z Z.* ZE z E za z z t

",c, b- -* " - * I"lU " V%~ f " %4 f "U%

aD'% BU UN %0 %D1 04pv w 94,0 t- %o D 00P. in PW. 0'01P. 0% UN N t.a w 0Pt-" "I0 a 44 VA.p Pft = a-r= 0%

U% UN g W'a irU' m u 1W 04 4Wg-t".4 wt0 to? .4 g in u

0 P.. q O 0 0

%o N0 '0 %D

zZiD Zzo Z %D zz"~ Z z v

w Wl %U% DwWjNp..w~w440ww m'Ir * zZ *r ZE 0 VE I* x a

0%N w N I~n w 2N .4 m%aW* n& nN **M A -1 V4.4 -U% 94 C 0%iO w = tU'o %~v APcm N0YcW) c U D 4p'0 0'* %D F,a I in a,V4 0%W '4 W 4 V-w w w -W~ *0l

,4~ " .4 4 oNUm =Pf4 m 00=d

C24005 in ~ 0 M0 ID000n N 3 V NI Io f * *a1 4o I top " *N' m * t%

0' 0 F'P. Fn UN UN " %0 40 cmE~ mO V40

BFa 96. go CD0 w.U0 .a U% cm C2 *a . C3

GO* C, 0 6D 0

~, CO 0'0 00 NgoQ NN =N I c N

to V4 %a' U N c BAN fnN -'4

00m P.0 a P- Ot3 P ~.. 16

0u w~a lA% W% 6% mw

%D0 fN fuO V% 0%0% P.. 0v wZ a. M' Zo Z' M0 ZA Z 0 -4 .4 .0 N- 0%a - 0% Z 0 M PN 4D U% 0 LA' P4 0 MO 0' Y 0a A. a a CY w- Ny CY 0 N D 400 N% ca40 40

* ' 4 0 0%

C-42

Page 85: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

APPENDIX D

DENSITY RATIO PROFILES FROM STATION E

D-1

Page 86: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

DENSITY RATIO PROFILES FOR STATION E

Station E is in the mid-Atlantic east of Bermuda. The uniformity and the

shape of the density profiles indicate that the U.S. Standard atmosphere does not

represent the atmosphere over station E too well for the period sampled. Almost

all the curves above 3,500 ft are fishhook shaped. Below 3,500 ft, the density

ratios increase with altitude. The lapse rate is larger than standard, which is

referred to in meteorology as a "superadiabat." From 3,500 to 35,000 ft, the den-

sity ratio curves are all concave, as seen from the right. That is, density to

about 15,000 ft decreases with altitude more than in the standard atmosphere.

Above 15,000 ft, the density ratios increase with altitude. Density ratios are all

greater than one above 30,000 ft, and they grow larger, regardless of surface den-

sity ratios. Overall, when density is two percent below standard at the surface,

it averages three percent above standard at 35,000 ft. Above 35,000 ft, the

curves are more erratic, which is probably due to the higher noise level in the

observations.

Some seasonal differences are apparent in this region. For example, in sum-

mer, both at 2100 hr and 0900 hr local time, the density ratios increase linearly

from 35,000 to 45,000 ft to a value of 11 percent above standard. This seasonal

behavior may be associated with the seasonal change in the height and temperature

of the tropopause.

The diurnal differences are very small. When the 9 a.m. and 9 p.m. curves are

superimposed, the coincidence of the curves is remarkable. This could mean that

there are no diurnal changes in density; or that, as the surface temperature and

density change diurnally, the density aloft changes in a corresponding manner, and

the correlation is preserved. It could also be due to the fact that 9 a.m. and

9 p.m. temperatures are nearly the same. At stations N and V, the sonde times

would likely correspond to greater differences in surface temperature and density.

The values for surface density reflect the seasonal changes in temperature.

Surface density class medians ranged from 0.95 to 0.98 in summer; in winter, they

-anged from 0.97 to 1.02.

D-3

Page 87: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR S2-81

C

-

.. b ...d

0

CLs

.- 4 D-4

Page 88: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-41

as

C?

$4(0A0

00

to -4

Aj 0 -:-4W0 o L

4J0 -4 _ __ _ ___

to(0 n

____ 0

to

D0O09 00Ost 0000* Doosc 0000C OOOSZ 00o 00091 00001 DOOS 0

3ani 1118

D-5

Page 89: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

ca 0

£0

D-6C

Page 90: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

C?

________ ___ ___ ___ _ __ _ __ _ La

cc

s__ 0_ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _

C)

00

*.X4 0 ZJJ 0 4 ___ _co

uc.Jto

~J - -

0000 000t 000t 009C000C 00sa 000a000s 0001 00S

3oniiou___

U3 D-7

Page 91: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

co

to

0

41 0. -

NNNU0 AL 0 i

4 ~0

o co

0

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 0

0009 00st000t 00se000C 009a000z 00sl0001 00S 0

3oniiou

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _D-8

Page 92: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 62-81

0 c0

aoa

* r-AJ4J - -

1~C;

k~C~ u____

-V4

Page 93: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

0

C.-

CD

u C)

* 4

Cr)

00*..0 c N

~a0 - ___ ___ ___ 0 ?

000009 ____t 000 __9__0Cooz 0 09100100 0

D-10

Page 94: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Ci

sw 0

0

0 & w

CD

0000 -0s 00 0S 00 osz00z00l00100

*D-1

Page 95: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

46E

000

" CD.

co4.0- -\

00

00 00 -0s 00 OE00Cooz00z001001 00

3oni0ii

4.10 _____D-12_

Page 96: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

000

k__ 00

0(0

Go-o5~~.4 low_ _

-4;

rz~ ___ ___ ___00

zD 1

Page 97: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

APPENDIX E

BALLISTIC DENSITY PROFILES FOR STATION E

Page 98: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

A AII9 496 NAVAL SURFACE WEAPONS CENTER DAHLOREN VA FIR 4/1I A METHOD TO CORRELATE THE UPPER AIR DENSITY WITH SURFACE DENSIT -ETCtU)I~ UL 82 L J MCANELLY.

UNCLASSIFIED NSWCITRA82-8 NL

2ffffffffffffmlmhmmhhhhhjo

Page 99: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station ESpring 0000 hr G.m.t.

(20 hr 48 min local time)0 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

00 U-3

CD

0D0w

I*

CDCDa0 .

0DQ

Mw

03M

M~~

02Qy

C4J

CC

0 L

0.94 .S 09 .7 09 .9Jo .1 10 .3 10 .5 10

BALSI0EST

0-

Page 100: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station ESpring 1200 hr G.m.t.

(8 hr 48 min local time)

C3C3

CD

U)

V

0C3~~0M

00*

QU3

(n,

0D

Li

no

04

0. CDCDCD

C3

0D0CD ___ _

C3

w

Q0 _3__

U3

0-940.95 0.96 0.97 0.96 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06.

BALLISTIC DENSITY

E-4

Page 101: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station EStmer 0000 hr G.m.t.

(20 hr 48 =in local time)

C

Lo

0OV,

U)

0.0j

Cc _D-

CD)

0I

Lii

-4-

Page 102: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Station ESumer 1200 hr G.s.t.

(8 hr 48 win local time)a _ _ _ _ _ __ __3_ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _C3C5-------------------------------

CM0 'I I

to-e

C2C3m. __ )__- 103

42

03CD

C02

Li

C3oC-U2

C3LO0W

cli

C)

0303

UO

-----------------------------0.940.96 0.96 0.97 0.96 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.06

BALLISTIC DENSITY

1-6

Page 103: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Station EFall 0000 hr G.m.t.

(20 hr 48 mini local time)0 _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _

0

U3

C3

0-01

4.

0C3W,

C,,

D 0 CQ. . - .

W-.

C)CD0

0

0C3-Q

03

0O

0.4 95 09 0.7 09 0.9 t0 1.1 10 103 10 1.6 t0

BALSTCDEST

E-

Page 104: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station 3Fall 1200 hr G.m.t.

(8 hr 48 min local time)

a _ _ _ _ __ __2_ _ __ _ _ _ _ _

C3C3 _ - - -ao

Q)

VM

C _ _ - -

M)0

M

0

C3CM

C20

0.409 0._09_.8 09 .0 1-0 . .3 10 -S 10

BRLSTCDEST

Page 105: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station EWinter 0000 hr G.m.t.

(20 hr 48 =in local tine)o10

U , 3C

I

0 - -, _- - -"0I

0 --- -

- -CDc0

w

o I

o I

C3,

D

I-c'J

-3Q

0-0lC'I

C3m

U,

0

0.940 .96 0.96 0.9 '7 0.9 8 u.99 t.00 t.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.05 1.05BALLISTIC DENSITY

R-9

...'... ... ' . .. . '" ' . .. " " ..

.. .. . ...

0

. . ..

0

Page 106: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Station BWinter 1200 hr G.u.t.(8 hr 48 mini local time)

C

C

Q0- - - - -

0

0

0

CDI-U.3 .

-J C

03Q.--

0

40

0.9A0."6 0.96 0.97 0.96 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1.01 1.06

BALLISTIC DENSITY

9-10

Page 107: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Station E

All Seasons 0000 hr G.m.t.(20 hr 48 min local time)

C3

U3

CID'

CD i i/iQ

0o

0a0

0r

0. - - --- - -•

0D

.J

0,,- -.- -

M c

CD

0 -

CD

C)

Q

a.. . 96 09 6 . ..B SENC3-1

.D .

0.940.96 0.96 0.9'7 0.0 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.;4 1-05 1-;G

BALLISTIC DENSITY

Page 108: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Station EAll Seasons 1200 hr G.m.t.(8 hr 48 min local time)

0Q -

C3

Q0O

Q ---

030D

(w~

U)

-LJ

0

CcCC3

0Sn

0

0.94 0.95 0.96 0.97 0.90 0.99 1.00 1.01 1.02 1.03 1.04 1 .05 1 .06

BALLISTIC DENSITY

1-12

Page 109: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

APPENDIX F

SELECTED BALLISTIC DENSITIES FOR STATIONS E. - N, AND C

F-1

Page 110: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

Local time corresponding to:

Station 0000 hr G.m.t. 1200 hr G.m.t.

E 20 hr 48min 06 hr 48minV 10 hr 54 min 22 hr 54 minC 21 hr 38min 09 hr 38minD 21 hr16 min 09 hr16 minN 14 hr 40 min 02 hr 20 min

(To be used with the following tables.)

F-3

- - - - -

Page 111: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

0%00 a k 00 Go1 0-4 0% -4 0 4r-r- %C II 1rS%VI Go r- Ir0 PG oao r- aoa

u~0%0% a% 0% 0% 0%0% 0%% m %0%0%0%0%

%OC %0E 00co DC4 * 00I II I -- I I I W r- Ir- 00 co0001-0Go00

0y 0

00D Go 00 %0 ON-. NC IN%0IO1I 1I Ir - 1 %0 00 1-1I1-0G 0% OD1 00 00

Ch 0% m 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% (% 0% ON

0 0; 00 0 00 00 00 0

04%

CD C ~0 0 cJ0

1110 31t1 01Il 0000400

00oII % % 00 00

0% 0% m0% 0%%0% 0%

>4 44

1-4 0 0 00 0%U 1- .. 0% %D~f 1--PCN4 0C'JUA'4MIU) 0- 1%D I I I r- F- I%D - l.It- 0-100 0% co 1- go00

0 o~0%% 0%0% ON 0% 0% 0% 0%0% 0%0%0%0%0%

1-4

1-4 1-3 00 r- I I I OD01- 1 00 00 0% co - co000%% ON m0% 0% ON 0% 0%C% 0% 0%

a 000 co UI Go4 %V~ coC4 cn % 1-4-1-0'1o1 1I r-- I 1 00 co 01-11-0M0r 0I co 00

64 c 7%O 0%0% 0% 0% 0% 0%0% 0% as 0% 0%

00 00 0 - 00 00 00 1 00

cn C0 0% 0% '0

00 0 00 c 0c

0 000 00000

0%0 00 00%00

4.41ON 0 0% 0%

0

4.1 k>UOZ WZJ>umz W U Z > M

F-4

Page 112: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

%00%O' 0 o C4onr c -4o 00 e 0% 0Im. % m m0% 0O0% 0%O 0 I0% 00

00 C-10 0%a --qcnO% cC4 CACm 0a% 0% 00 co0% 0 081

Iz % mON0% 0% 0 0 m0%0 018

c -4 0 tn0 0p%w.. I I r-00% 0 I 1 1OD0% 1 1 0% 1 1 10% 1

m 00 1 0%00 0000%0% 0 0% 0 0%ON

04 0 0%0 0 N0% 0 0%0 00%

CA0% 00 0% 0 0% 000% 0 000%0 -41000 1%0

00 00 0 -4 0: -40.4 -0C!

OD .I0c D 0f 0t0iI~ 0%4 nC44 0%0 oc00co a % r000a% 0 m co0% 0 0 00% 0 1-000 1~ %%%%% 0c%a%0%0 0 00% 0 0 0000

w- 0 00 cn0 4'4 0 4 ' -000 It M0 00'0

) 0 0 co r- 0%0% 0% 000% -1 c 001%O11I0 w r 0% 0% 0% 0%% m 00 % Ch%0 CA0%0

0' % 0D 0 000 U400 L00 -40-4 4r 0 in

%D-4r 00f00. C'O %C 0 0% n4 0% -4 40%

0% 00000 c-400C.4 0..C -440% (Y-4a

0000C o0 00 0 0

0

w Q z ba0 0000 0 000 z I u 00

U)00066% 06000 000,6

0000 .- 000 4.4.4F-5~

Page 113: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Ln In cn C4 0"40 %0 0o

-4 0 -4 1 -4 04 - 4 -4

00

000 0%LA0

'00 C1 0cc0-4 1 1 1-41 41 1 1-4 11 1 1 1z 00D 00

tot~ 0 %141 10 4II-C I II-(4II( I I

00 00 000

t4 4

j-440a ul z0~ D. D.0%l

11 -4 1'1 I J(.I 11 1

00 00F00

Page 114: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 82-81

%C044-4 0% Go0t04 % 0 O( C4 -44 o III 0%0C% I r- I m 0% 1 CO 0% 0O%D 0% 0

4 l lc 0:0 0%0 ci O%% OZ%0% 0! l%0%0

00 00 0 00 00 -4000-4

-4 CO % ( c ~%0 4G o-0% II 00% 1 1 0% 0% I Go0% 00%ON*0%0

j,0%Oc% 0%% 0%0% 0%O%0%0

m -4 -4 ciC en 4I %or P l%4Iwd 10 1 0% 0%10c 0 0% 10%0% 0 0% 1 m.0u cc 0% M 0% 400% 0% 0% 00C% 0%0

00 00 0; -0 00 C; 0.

(n 0 0%4 rs.-41 11 1111 0?% ChI I 1 0% %1 coo

00 0%% 0%% 0%0

t~- 0% -4 C4 CA

0 0% 000 00 0

>4 4.4

0-4 t 0 0

00 00 coI1I1 0%0% 1 go0% 0 CA 100 0% 00%%00%00 0%01. 0%0 m %% 00%o 0%0c% 00%0%0%0

Ln

w0 400 '- cn an &M N 00 0% -4 C4-4 I co11 I0% I I1 0%0% 100 m 0 %0 ~0% 0

ON m 00 0 0 a C>0% 0% ON

G0o 4'c. C14 ( n .00 I&A 00co 00001 11 0% CNI 1 0% 00%l1 0% 0 00%I10%0

w.0 cn , O 0%0 Ch 0CA 0%%s a 00% 0%0

004 00 0 0 00 -40 0-t

11a1 1 1 0%00 1 10C% 00% 1 1

00 0 -40 -4

Cden c- c 0c %C %

00 0o m 00 0 00

444 0% a! 0%l 0 0 3

0 0 0 aQt

F-

Page 115: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

Un 00co 0 n OC4 r- - cn* in ~%0r = %0 Q% 0000t 0% 80 .- i000- -400%0-4 .- i80091~~oo o00 0 0 00 000%00 0000

. . . .. . . .. .. .

r- 00 r- m -o 0%00 C" e 0D -i -4

a0 rsom 0 o0o00-4 1 I0% 1 I I0 -*Irle 000.0. 000%00 0

1J 1 080 00 84 1. 0 1 0%11 11o I

0CA.4 0%- 0%

00 h00 a 8 P 0." 4 0 00 0 4 1 -0%8100 00 0%0 ao00 000.00 00.0

m 0 0% r- 0 4 . 00 0 -4 1 00%

rn0 0 '.O00 .I.- -4000 0-4 1M0 . 4000100000 000 000%000.

1 .4 *0 0 0 %0 " -00 0 -4 .. 1 0%0-4-0-

cn w oor.oo 000%00 O -e 0 CI-0

0 ~ 000.00 0000 0.0 000

C.C)

-4 tn 00%O'0 'tA. (n0 tn0 4 0 00000% r m 0 A0 -0 4 - 4 1M001 10r%-4 1

we 0 000.0h 000.00 00.0 00

-40 0 N -40 4Noc n% m0 n%

a 00 0 1 00 q 0.10 I "1081

QW 0000 0. 044 fa0- .40 i

00 jD0v

0-

----------- ~ 0 U, 0- '. 4 0

Page 116: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

C4 t0 I 0-4 1 I -C14 1 1 1 C41

-. 0

>44

cad 11 1 -1111 1 1 -141 1 111.zC 000

0 -4P0

-4

00 00 00 0-4 -4 -4 o-4 444

0- 0 -4 .-

CF-9

j-4

Page 117: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

Ti 82-81

DISTRIBUTION

copies copies

Commander CommanderNaval Sea Systems Command Naval Avionics CenterAttn: SEA-62R I Indianapolis, IN 46216 1

SEA-62R42 1SEA-62R3 1 CommanderSEA-62Y13C 1 Naval Coastal Systems LaboratoryLibrary 1 Panama City, FL 32401 1

Washington, DC 20361Commanding Officer

Chief of Naval Material Naval Mine Engineering FacilityWashington, DC 20360 1 Yorktown, VA 23691 1

Chief of Naval Operations Commanding OfficerWashington, DC 20350 1 Fleet Numerical Oceanography

CenterCommander Monterey, CA 93940Naval Air Systems CommandAttn: AIR-5411 1 Naval Environmental Predication

AIR-5411C 1 Research FacilityLibrary I Monterey, CA 95076 1

Washington, DC 20361Commander

Commander Naval Ship Missile SystemNaval Underwater Warfare Engineering Station

Engineering Station Port Hueneme, CA 93043 1Keyport, WA 98345

Commanding OfficerDirector Naval Ordnance StationNaval Research Laboratory Louisville, KY 40214 1Washington, DC 20390

CommanderCommanding Officer Naval eapons CenterNaval Ordnance Station Attn: Code 6224 1Indian Head, MD 20640 1 Code 319 2

Library 3Commanding Officer China Lake, CA 93555Naval Wapons Support CenterAttn: Code 5041 (J. Wildridge) I Commander

Library I Naval Air Development CenterCrane, IN 47522 Warminster, PA 18974 1

Commander CommanderNaval Air Test Center Naval Oceans Systems CenterAttn: SA-80 1 San Diego, CA 92135 1

CS-31 (R. Nelson) 1SY-40 1

Patuxtent River, MD 20670

(1)

Page 118: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

DISTRIBUTION (Continued)

Copies Copies

Comnander CommanderDavid W. Taylor Naval Ship Operational Test and Evaluation

Research and Development Center ForceBethesda, MD 20084 1 U.S. Naval Base

Norfolk, VA 23511 1CommanderPacific Missile Test Center CommanderPoint Mugu, CA 93041 1 Mine Warfare Comand

U.S. Naval BaseCo mander Charleston, SC 29408 1Naval Underwater Systems CenterNewport, RI 02480 1 Commanding Officer

Naval Ocean Research andCommanding Officer Development ActivityNaval Weapons Evaluation Facility NSTL Station, MS 39529 1Kirtland Air Force UsseAlbuquerque, NN 87117 1 Armament Division

Eglin Air Force Base, FL 32542 1Commanding OfficerWeapons Quality Engineering Center Armament DivisionNaval Weapons Station Air Force Armament LaboratoryAttn: WQEC/Code F32 1 Attn: DLYW 2Seal Beach, CA 91720 Library 1

Eglin Air Force Base, FL 32542SuperintendentNaval Postgraduate School Aeronautical Systems DivisionMonterey, CA 93940 1 Wright-Patterson Air Force Base,

OH 45433 1PresidentNaval War College Air Force Weapons LaboratoryNewport, RI 02840 1 Kirtland Air Force Base

Albuquerque, NK 87117 1SuperintendentNaval Academy Air Force Flight Test CenterAnnapolis, MD 21402 1 Edwards Air Force Base, CA 93523 1

Center for Naval Analysis Air Force Eastern Test RangeArlington, VA 22209 1 Patrick Air Force Base, FL 32925 1

Strategic Analysis Support Group Air Force Geophysics LaboratoryApplied Physics Laboratory Hanscom Air Force Base, MA 01731 1Johns Hopkins University8621 Georgia Avenue SuperintendentSilver Spring, MD 20910 1 U.S. Air Force Academy

Colorado Springs, CO 80912 1

(2)

" I " .. .° .... .i.. ... .. .. . . ...

Page 119: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TR 82-81

DISTRIBUTION (Continued)

CCopies

Air Force Weather Service Sandia National LaboratoriesScott Air Force Base, IL 62226 1 P.O. Box 5800

Albuquerque, NN 87115Air Force Western Test RangeVandenburg Air Force Base, CA 93437 1 Physical Science Laboratory

New Mexico State UniversityDirector Box 3548U.S. Army Ballistics Research Attn: Stan Needham

Laboratory Las Cruces, N4 88001Attn: AMXRD/BEL/FT 1

Library 1 National Aeronautics and SpaceAberdeelt Proving Ground, MD 21005 Agency

Washington, DC 20546Comanc ArU.S. Army Armament Research and National Bureau of Standards

Development Command Washington, DC 20234Dover, NJ 07801 1

Oklahoma State UniversityCommander Box 1925White Sands Missile Range Eglin Air Force Base, FL 32542White Sands, Nf 88002 1

National Climatic CenterCommander Federal BuildingU.S. Army Proving Ground Asheville, NC 28801Yuma, AZ 85364 1

Applied Physics LaboratoryCommander Johns Hopkins UniversityU.S. Army Missile Research and 8621 Georgia Avenue

Development Command Silver Spring, MD 20910Redstone Arsenal, AL 35809 1

Defense Technical InformationComander CenterU.S. Army Electronics Research and Cameron Station

Development Coand Alexandria, VA 22314 2Fort Monmouth, NJ 07703 1

Library of CongressAtmospheric Science Laboratory Attn: Gift and Exchange Division 4U.S. Army Electronics Research and Washington, DC 20540

Development CoumandWaite Sands Missile Range Gidep Operations OfficeWhite Sands, R 88001 1 Corona, CA 91720

Sandia National Laboratories NASA Scientific and TechnicalP.O. Box 969 Information FacilityAttn: Division 8152 (R. Everett) 1 P.O. Box 33

Library I College Park, MD 20740Livermore, CA 94550

(3)

4

Page 120: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S

TI 62-i

DISTRIBUTION (Continued)

Copies copies

The Rand Corporation Local:1600 Main StreetSanta Monica, CA 90406 1 E411 1

National Technical Information K 1Service

Springfield, VA 22151 1 KIO I

Director KII 25Ordnance Research LaboratoryPennsylvanig State University K40 5Box 30State College, PA 16801 1 K43 (Manrique) 1

University of Dayton Research K44 (Masters) IInstitute

Dayton, OH 45409 1 K50 5

National Weather Service G 18060 13th StreetSilver Spring, MD 20910 1 GlO 1

Metropolitan State College G12 1014th and AraphoeAttn: Dr. W. A. Kemper (Box 69) 1 N20 IDenver, CO 80203

N30 IMr. Loren J. McAnelly209 Walnut Drive N50 1Fredericksburg, VA 22405

N51 1

N52 1

N53 1

U 1

E431 10

(4)

Page 121: apps.dtic.milUNCLASSIFIED SECUMITY CLASSIFICATION REPORT OF DOCUMENTATION THIS PAGE (When Data Entered)PACE READ INSTRUCTIONS I. REPORT NUMBER 2. GOVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S