APPLICATION OF FUZZY BASED THREE-PHASE ...ijpres.com/pdf17/33.pdfAPPLICATION OF FUZZY BASED...
Transcript of APPLICATION OF FUZZY BASED THREE-PHASE ...ijpres.com/pdf17/33.pdfAPPLICATION OF FUZZY BASED...
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
APPLICATION OF FUZZY BASED THREE-PHASE INVERTER IN DISTRIBUTED
GENERATION BY IMPLEMENTING UNIFIED CONTROL STRATEGY
MUKKU MURALI1, DR. K VENKATESWARLU2
1PG Scholar, Malineni, Lakshmaiah Engineering College, Andhra Pradesh, India
2Assistant professor, Malineni, Lakshmaiah Engineering College, Andhra Pradesh, India
Abstract-By eliminating need of separate
controllers or critical islanding detection, this paper
proposes a fuzzy based three-phase inverter in
distributed generation which can be implemented for
both islanded and grid-tied operations. In the
proposed strategy the three-phase inverter is
regulated as just current source by inner inductor
current loop in grid-tied and for islanding mode a
voltage loop in the synchronous reference frame will
automatically regulates the load voltage. This paper
proposes a unified load current feedforward to
maintain the grid current waveforms in grid-tied
mode and load voltage waveforms in islanding mode
to be undistorted even under nonlinear local load.
The effectiveness of the proposed strategy is
validated by simulation.
Index Terms— Fuzzy Logic Controller,
unified control, islanding, load current, seamless
transfer, Distributed generation (DG), three-phase
inverter, unified control.
INTRODUCTION
The distributed generation (DG) concept
emerged as a way to integrate different power plants,
increasing the DG owner’s reliability, reducing
emissions, and providing additional power quality
benefits [4]. The cost of the distribution power
generation system using the renewable energies is on
a falling trend and is expected to fall further as
demand and production.
DG delivers power to the utility and local critical
loads in grid-connected mode. Upon outage of any
generator connected to the utility the islanding is
formed. Under these situations, DG must be tripped
and must stop to energize according to IEEE standard
929-2000. In order to continue to feed the local
critical load by disconnecting DG’s and some local
load in order to improve the power reliability. Load
voltage is fixed by the DG in the islanded mode and
by the utility in the grid mode operation. So,
maintaining the load voltage is important. In order to
reduce transients in the load DG must take over the
load as soon as possible which is challenging
operation for the DG.
In this paper voltage control mode is nothing but
Droop-based control is used widely for the sharing of
power among parallel inverters and can be applied to
DG to realize power sharing between DG and utility
in grid-tied mode [11-12]. Under this operation, load
voltage is guaranteed during transitions of operation
modes and inverter is regulated as voltage source by
voltage loop is good only steady-state performance
whereas dynamic performance is poor because
bandwidth of voltage loop is higher than of the
external power loop, realizing droop control. In
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
addition to the (phase locked loop) PLL and the
virtual inductance, the inrush grid currents during
transition from islanded mode to grid-tied mode
always exists it means grid current is not controlled
directly [13].
Better dynamic performance can be achieved by
hybrid voltage and current mode type control for DG.
In which inverter is controlled as current source by
one sets of controller in grid-tied mode, and as a
voltage source by other sets of controller in the
islanded mode. Inrush grid currents are almost
eliminated in the output by directly controlling the
output current in grid-tied mode. There is no need to
change the switch of the controller when the
operation mode of DG is changed, with the use of
hybrid voltage and current control mode.
With the occurrence of utility outage the interval
during to change it to voltage mode, the load voltage
is neither regulated by DG nor fixed by the utility but
the length of the time interval is determined by the
islanding detection process. The main issue in this
approach is that quality of load voltage can heavily
reliant on the speed islanding detection method
accuracy [7]-[10].second issue is under non-linear
local load with aforementioned approaches is the
quality waveform of the grid current and load
voltage.
The output current of DG is generally desired to be
pure in grid-tied mode [13]. The harmonic
component will fully flow into the utility when
nonlinear load is fed. The harmonic components of
the grid current can be mitigated by harmonics
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of the DG based on the proposed control strategy.
injected by single-phase DG in [4]. DG will emulate
a resistance at harmonic frequency is being controlled
by voltage mode control and then the harmonic
current flowing into the utility can be mitigated. In
the islanding mode, the nonlinear load may distort.
With the use of multi-loop control method, resonant
controllers, sliding mode control and many control
schemes have been proposed to improve the quality
of the load voltage. Existing control strategies, DG
with nonlinear local load will mainly concentrate on
grid current in the grid-tied mode and on load voltage
in island mode and improving both of them for
unified strategy is rarely used.
This paper discusses about unified control strategy
that avoids the aforementioned shortcomings. With a
given reference in the synchronous frame (SRF) the
three-phase inverter is controlled in DG act as a
current source using traditional current loop. A novel
voltage controller is presented to supply reference for
the inner inductor current loop in D-axis and Q-axis
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
proportional-plus-integral (PI) compensator and a
proportional (P) compensator are employed. The load
voltage is dominated by the utility and the voltage
compensator in D-axis is saturated, while the output
of the voltage compensator in Q-axis is forced to be
zero by the PLL. The reference of the inner current
loop cannot be regulated by the voltage loop. With
the occurrence of grid outage, the load voltage is no
more determined by the utility. The voltage controller
is automatically activated to regulate the load
voltage.
Hence proposed control strategy does not need a
forced switching between two different sets of
controllers. So, there is no need of detecting islanding
quickly and accurately is no more critical in
approach. For better dynamic performance, the
proposed control strategy utilizes the feedback
control for both current and voltage compares to
voltage control mode. And paper is enhanced by
introducing a unified load current feedforward, is
implemented by adding the load current into the
reference of the inner current loop in order to deal
with the issue caused by the nonlinear local load. The
benefits of the proposed load current feedforward can
be extended into the islanded operation mode, due to
the improved quality of the load voltage.
This paper is arranged as follows. Section II
discusses about Distributed generation (DG) and its
applications. Section III describes the proposed
unified control strategy for three phase inverter in
DG which includes the power stage, the basic idea
and control diagram. Section IV discuss about fuzzy
logic controller. The parameter design and small
signal analysis of the proposed control system are
given in Section V. The simulation results for the
proposed system are shown in Section VI. Finally,
the conclusion and remarks are given in section VII.
DISTRIBUTED GENERATION (DG)
AND IT’S APPLICATIONS Distributed generation (or DG) generally refers to
small-scale (typically 1 kW – 50 MW) electric power
generators that produce electricity at a site close to
customers or that are tied to an electric distribution
system [12]. Distributed generators include, but are
not limited to synchronous generators, induction
generators, reciprocating engines, microturbines
(combustion turbines that run on high-energy fossil
fuels such as oil, propane, natural gas, gasoline or
diesel), combustion gas turbines, fuel cells, solar
photovoltaic, and wind turbines.
There are many reasons a customer may choose to
install a distributed generator. DG can be used to
generate a customer’s entire electricity supply; for
peak shaving (generating a portion of a customer’s
electricity onsite to reduce the amount of electricity
purchased during peak price periods); for standby or
emergency generation (as a backup to Wires Owner's
power supply); as a green power source (using
renewable technology); or for increased reliability. In
some remote locations, DG can be less costly as it
eliminates the need for expensive construction of
distribution and/or transmission lines.
Islanding: Islanding occurs when a DG system is
still generating power to the distribution system when
the main breaker from the Wires Owner is open. In
this case, the DG system would be the sole supplier
of electricity to the distribution system. This is a
concern for several reasons.
i. Safety concern for system maintenance if the Wires
Owner's line workers are not aware that the DG
system is still running, they may be electrocuted
working on the line or other equipment connected to
the line.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
ii. Equipment damage to other Wires Owners
customers. If the DG is still generating while the
main breaker from the wire owner is open, the
voltage and the waveform from the DG may fluctuate
and may not meet the acceptable standard. Existing
customers who are connected to the distribution line
are then fed by very poor quality of power from the
DG. As a result, their light fixtures, motors and other
electric equipment may be damaged or its life may be
shortened. If the situation persists unnoticed for an
unacceptably long time, a fire hazard may exist. iii.
Damage to the DG owner's generator if the DG is still
generating while the main breaker from the wires
owner is open, the DG equipment may be damaged
when the wires owner’s main breaker is closed due to
closing out of synchronism.
SYSTEM PROPOSED CONTROL
STRATEGY A. Power Stage:
To operate in both grid-tied and islanded modes this
paper proposes unified control strategy for three-
phase inverter in DG. The DG is equipped with a
three-phase interface inverter with a LC filter. The
energy from prime mover is converted in electrical
energy and then into DC by front end power
converter, the DC voltage is regulated represented
by 푉 as shown in figure. Local grids are directly
connected in the ac side of the inverter. The two
switches 푆 and 푆 functions are different. DG will
control the inverter transfer switch 푆 and the utility
will control the utility protection switch 푆 . Under
normal operation, the DG in the grid-tied mode
injects power to the utility and both 푆 and 푆
switches are ON. When the utility is in fault, the
utility instantly trips the switch 푆 and then the
islanding is formed. 푆 Switch will be disconnected
after the islanding has been detected by the DG and
DG will be transferred to islanded mode from grid-
tied mode. The DG will be resynchronized with the
utility only after when the utility is restored and the
switch 푆 will be turned ON to connect the DG with
the grid.
Fig. 2. Overall block diagram of the proposed unified
control strategy. B. Basic Idea
with the proposed control modes (hybrid voltage and
current mode) the inverter is controlled as a current
source to generate reference power 푃 + 푗푄 in
grid-tied mode, output power 푃 + 푗푄 should be
the power injected into the grid 푃 + 푗푄 and load
demand can be expressed as follows by assuming the
load is represented as a parallel RLC circuit:
푃 =32 ∙푉푅
------- (1)
푄 =32 ∙ 푉 ∙
1휔퐿 − 휔퐶
--------- (2)
Where 푉 the amplitude of load voltage and f is is the
frequency of load voltage. Considering the
fundamental component still equivalent to the
parallel RLC circuit when the nonlinear local load is
fed. The load voltage will neither be fixed by the
utility nor regulated by the inverter during the time
interval the moment of switching the control to the
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
instant of islanding mode. The load voltage may drift
from the normal range.
The inverter will still controlled as current source
and kept it output power almost unchanged during
this time interval. The power injected to utility
decreases to zero rapidly, and then the power
consumed by the load will be imposed to the output
power of DG. If considered both active power and
reactive power injected into the grid is positive in the
grid-tied mode, then 푃 and 푄 will increase the
after the islanding mode. The amplitude and
frequency of the load voltage will rise and drop
according to equations (1) and (2).
Comparing to the traditional analysis, the output
power of inverter 푃 + 푗푄 can be regulated to
match the load demand by changing the current
reference before islanding is confirmed. The load
voltages excursions will be mitigated which is
implemented in this paper. By regulating the three-
phase inductor current 푖 only the output power of
the inverter is controlled in the proposed control
strategy, while the magnitude and frequency of the
load voltage 푣 are monitored. While islanding is
about to operate, the magnitude and frequency of the
load voltage may drift from normal range and then
they are controlled automatically and recovered to
normal range by regulating the output power of the
inverter.
C. proposed Control strategy:
Figure 2 shows the proposed unified overall control
block diagram. The sensed values from the block
diagram are the utility voltage 푣 , the inductor
current 푖 and the load current 푖 . The three-
phase variables of the three-phase inverter will be
represented in dc quantity is controlled in the SRF.
The main modes of the control diagram are the
inductor current loop, the PLL, and the current
reference generation module. In order to mitigate the
couplings due to the inductor, is implemented by the
PI compensator in both D- and Q-axes and
decoupling of the cross coupling 휔 퐿 /푘 .
Decoupling capacitor 1/푘 and output of inner
current loop 푑 sets the reference for the standard
space vector modulation (SVM) that control the
switches of the three-phase inverter. Where 푘
denotes the voltage gain of the inverter which equals
to half of the dc voltage in this paper.
The widely used SRF PLL in three-phase power
converter to estimate the utility frequency and phase
is also proposed in the control strategy [15], in order
to hold the frequency of the load within the normal
range in the islanded operation a limiter is inserted
between the PI compensator 퐺 and integrator.
From figure it can be concluded that the inductor
current is regulated to follow the current reference
푖 and the current phase is synchronized to the
grid voltage 푣 .
Fig 3 Block diagram of the current reference generation module. If current reference is constant, the inverter is just
controlled to be a current source, which is same with
the traditional grid-tied inverter. The new thing in
this paper is the current reference to guarantee the
power match between the DG and local load and
enables to operate in islanded mode. In this module
even unified load current feedforward to cope with
nonlinear local load is implemented. Figure 3
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
provides the current reference for the inner current
loop in both grid-tied and islanding modes. An
unsymmetrical structure is used in D- and Q-axis
where PI compensator in D-axis with an extra limiter
and P is employed in Q-axis. Load current 푖 is
being added to the final inductor current reference
푖 by the load current feedforward. The benefits
from figure 3 are represented by two parts: 1) without
critical islanding detection seamless transfer
capability; and 2) in both grid-tied and islanded
operations improving the power quality. In D and Q-
axes the current reference 푖 composes of four
parts namely: 1) controller output voltages 푖 ; 2)
the reference grid current 퐼 ; 3) the load current
푖 and 4) the current through filter capacitor 퐶 .In
grid-tied mode, the load voltage 푣 is decided by
the utility. The load voltage and current reference are
irrelevant due to saturation of PI compensator in D-
axis and the output of P compensator being zero in
Q-axis. Thus, the inverter operates as a current
source. Voltage controller takes automatically to
control the load voltage by regulating current
reference when islanding occurs and makes the
inverter to operate as a voltage source to provide
stable voltage to the local loads.
The advantage of this control scheme is that it
relieves from different control architecture. The other
distinguished function of the current generation
module is the load current feedforward. In order to
compensate the harmonic component the sensed load
current is added as a part of the inductor reference
current 푖 in the grid current under the nonlinear
local load. But in the islanded mode still the load
current feedforward operates and the disturbance
caused by the nonlinear load can be suppressed by
the fast inner inductor current loop and finally the
quality of the load voltage is improved.
In [18] the inductor current control shown in Fig 2
was proposed for grid-tied operation of DG. Inspired
from [18] this paper proposes a unified control
strategy for DG in both grid-tied and islanded modes
can be represented by the current reference
generation module in figure 3.This module can be
summarized in two aspects for this contribution.
First, PI compensator in D and P compensator Q-axis
respectively, upon occurrence of islanding voltage
controller is activated automatically and maintained
inactive during grid-tied mode. There is no need for
switching different controllers and load voltage
quality during transition from grid-tied mode to the
islanded mode can be improved. Another
contribution of this module is to provide load current
feedforward to deal with the issue caused by the
nonlinear local load, by which load voltage quality in
islanded mode is enhanced and the grid current
waveform in grid-tied can also improved.
It should be noted that the unbalance three-phase
local load currents cannot be fed by the DG with the
proposed control strategy, because there is no flow
path for the zero sequence current of unbalanced
load, and the regulation of zero sequence current is
beyond the scope of the proposed control strategy.
FUZZY LOGIC CONTROLLER
The error value of the dc-bus voltage Δvdc= v∗dc−vdc
is passed through a Fuzzy-type compensator to
regulate the voltage of dc bus (vdc) at a fixed value.
The operation of FLC is as follows. FLC contains
three basic parts: Fuzzification, Base rule, and
Defuzzification. FLC has two inputs which are: error
and the change in error, and one output. The Fuzzy
Controller structure is represented in fig.6. The role
of each block is the following:
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
Fig 2: The general structure of Fuzzy Logic Controller
Fuzzifier converts a numerical variable into
a linguistic label.. In a closed loop control system, the
error (e) between the reference voltage and the output
voltage and the rate of change of error (del e) can be
labeled as zero (ZE), positive small (PS), negative
small (NS), etc. In the real world, measured
quantities are real numbers (crisp). The FLC takes
two inputs, i.e., the error and the rate of change of
error. Based on these inputs, The FLC takes an
intelligent decision on the amount of field voltage to
be applied which is taken as the output and applied
directly to the field winding of generator. Triangular
membership functions were used for the controller.
Fig 3. Membership function of voltage
Fig 4. Membership function of voltage error
Fig 5. Membership function of output field voltage
Rule base stores the data that defines the
input and the output fuzzy sets, as well as the fuzzy
rules that describe the control strategy. Mamdani
method is used in this paper. Seven membership
functions were used leading to 49 rules in the rule
base.
Table 1
Rule base for fuzzy controller
Inference engine applies the fuzzy rules to
the input fuzzy variables to obtain the output values.
Defuzzifier achieves output signals based on the
output fuzzy sets obtained as the result of fuzzy
reasoning. Centroid defuzzifier is used here.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
PARAMETER DESIGN AND SMALL
SIGNAL ANALYSIS OF THE
PROPOSED CONTROL SYSTEM
The fuzzy based proposed unified control
strategy with operating principle of DG is illustrated
in detail in this section. The four states of DG are as
follows:1) grid-tied mode, 2) transition from the grid-
tied mode to islanded mode, 3) the islanded mode, 4)
from islanded mode to the grid-tied mode.
i. Grid-Tied mode: under normal case of utility, by
inductor current loop the DG is controlled as current
source and will supply active and reactive power
through current D- and Q- axis independently. For
that utility voltage phase angle is obtained through
PLL by park transformation, PI controller, a limiter
and an integrator.
푥푥 =
23
cos휃 cos 휃 +23휋 − cos 휃 +
23휋
− sin 휃 − sin 휃 −23휋 − sin 휃 +
23휋
×푥푥푥
-------- (3) An inductor current reference 푖 seems little
complex and compared with the instantaneous filter
inductor current which is transformed into SRF by
the park transformation. The inductor current is
regulated to track the reference 푖 by the PI
compensator 퐺 . The utility is assumed stiff, the
three-phase utility voltages are expressed as
푣 = 푉 cos휃∗
푣 = 푉 cos(휃∗ −2휋3 )
푉 cos 휃∗ −2휋3
------- (4)
The SRF transformation of the utility voltage is
expressed as
푣 = 푉 cos(휃∗ − 휃)푣 = 푉 sin(휃∗ − 휃)
----------- (5)
Where 푉 = magnitude of the grid voltage,
휃∗ = the actual phase angle.
푣 is regulated to zero by the PLL, so 푣 equals the
magnitude of the utility voltage 푉 . As the filter
capacitor voltage equals the utility voltage in the
gird-tied mode, 푣 equals the magnitude of the
utility voltage 푉 , and 푣 equals zero. In the D-axis,
the inductor current reference 푖 can be expressed
by (6) according to Fig. 3
푖 = 퐼 + 푖 − 휔 퐶 ∙ 푣
------- (6)
In steady state, the given voltage reference 푉 is
larger than the magnitude of the utility voltage 푣
and the first part is the output of the limiter. So the PI
compensator, denoted by GVD in the following part
will saturate and the limiter outputs its upper
value 퐼푔푟푒푓푑. The second part is that the
characteristics of local load will determine D-
axis 푖 load current.
The third is the proportional part −휔 퐶 ·푣 ,
where 휔 is the rated angle frequency, and 퐶 is the
capacitance of the filter capacitor. It is fixed as 푣
depends on the utility voltage. The given reference
퐼 and the load current 푖 is being imposed by
the current reference 푖 and independent of the
load voltage. In the Q-axis, the inductor current
reference 푖 consists of four parts as
푖 = 푣 ∙ 푘 + 퐼 + 푖 + 휔 퐶 ∙ 푣
------ (7)
Where 푘 = parameter of the P compensator,
denoted by 퐺 in the following part. The first part is
the output of 퐺 , which is zero as the 푣 has been
regulated to zero by the PLL. The second part is the
given current reference 퐼 , and the third part
represents the load current in Q-axis. The final part
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
is the proportional part−휔 퐶 ·푣 , which is fixed
since 푣 depends on the utility voltage.
Fig. 4. Simplified block diagram of the unified
control strategy when DG operates in the grid-tied
mode Therefore, external voltage drop will not influence
the current reference 푖 .but, the current reference
푖 will determine the given reference 퐼 and
the load current 푖 .the control diagram of the
inverter is simplified n grid-tied mode, with the
analysis of previous cases and the inverter is
controlled as a current source with inductor current
reference 퐼 and the load current 푖
determined by the inductor current loop will track the
current reference and the load current.
퐼 represents the grid currents if steady state
error is zero will be explained in next section.
ii. Transition mode from grid –tied mode to the
islanded mode: By opening utility switch 푆 , the
islanding mode begins; frequency and load voltage
will drift because of active and reactive power
mismatch between DG and the load demand. The
transition is divided into two time intervals where
first is from the instant of turning off 푆 to the instant
of turning off 푆 when islanding mode is confirmed.
The second one starts from instant of turning off
inverter switch 푆 . As switch 푆 is in ON state, in first
interval the utility voltage 푣 will be same as load
voltage 푣 because dynamic of the inductor
current loop and the voltage loop is much faster than
the PLL [15] but load voltage and current are varying
dramatically considering load voltage angle
frequency to be not varied. In the grid-tied mode, it is
assumed that the DG injects active and reactive
power into the utility, which can be expressed by (8)
and (9), and that the local critical load, shown in (10),
represented by a series connected RLC circuit with
the lagging power factor
Fig. 5. Operation sequence during the transition from
the grid-tied mode to the islanded mode.
Fig. 6. Transient process of the voltage and current
when the islanding happens.
푃 =32 ∙ 푣 푖 + 푣 푖 =
32푣 푖
------- (8)
푄 =32 ∙ 푣 푖 + 푣 푖 =
32푣 푖
--------- (9)
푍 = 푅 + 푗 휔퐿 −1휔퐶
= 푅 + 푗 휔퐿 −1휔퐶
= 푅 + 푗푋
------- (10)
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
In islanding mode, 푖 will decrease from positive to
zero, and 푖 will increase from negative to zero.
During this time load current will vary in the opposite
direction. From equations (11) and (12) it can be
concluded that D- and Q-axes load voltage each
consists of two terms. The load voltage in D-axis 푣
will increase as both terms increase. But in Q-axis
푣 is uncertain because the first term decreases and
the second term increases, and it is not concerned for
a while
푣 = 푖 ∙ 푅 − 푖 ∙ 푋
------ (11)
푣 = 푖 ∙ 푅 − 푖 ∙ 푋
------ (12)
The input of PI compensator 퐺 will become
negative with the increase of the load voltage in D-
axis 푣 , when it reaches and exceeds 푉 so its
output will decrease. Then the output of limiter will
not imposed to 퐼 any longer and the current
reference 푖 will drop. In the regulation of the
inductor current loop, D-axis푖 load current will
decrease. The load voltage in D-axis 푣 will drop
and recover to 푉 . If 푖 has almost fallen to the
normal value, the load voltage in Q-axis 푣 will
drop according to (12). The PI compensator 퐺 will
going to be negative if 푣 is decreased from zero to
negative and its output will drop. The angle
frequency ω will be reduced. If it falls to the lower
value of the limiter 휔 , the angle will be fixed
at 휔 . At the end of the first time interval the load
voltage in D-axis 푣 will increase and fix at 푉
and angle frequency of the load voltage ω will also
drop.PLL can still operate normally if the value is
higher than the lower value of the limiter 휔 , and
the load voltage in Q-axis 푣 will be zero.
If 휔 is fixed, load voltage in Q-axis 푣 will be
negative. With the help of power relationship the
variation of frequency and amplitude can be
understandable. When the islanding happens, the
local load must absorb the extra power injected to the
grid, as the output power of inverter is not changed
instantaneously. From (1) the magnitude of load
voltage 푉 will rise with the increase of 푃 . In
meanwhile the angle frequency ω should drop, in
order to consume more power with (2). Results from
power relationship coincide with the previous
analysis. The second time interval transition begins
from the instant when the switch 푆 opens after the
islanding detection method. If switch 푆 opens the
load voltage 푣 is independent with the grid
voltage 푣 . In the mean time 푣 will reduce to
zero theoretically as the switch 푆 has opened. The
angle frequency is invariable and then, input of the
compensator 퐺 becomes zero and fixed to the end
of the first time interval.
The inverter is controlled to be a voltage source
when 푣 is regulated by the voltage loop. Under
islanding operation, the load voltage is restricted to
particular range to drift the amplitude and frequency
and the inverter is transferred from the current source
operation mode to the voltage source operation mode
autonomously. With the increase in the time of delay,
the drift becomes worse in the hybrid voltage and
current mode control. So, the time delay of islanding
detection is critical to drift of the frequency and
magnitude in the load voltage. In proposed control
strategy this phenomenon is avoided.
iii. Islanded Mode: in this state switching 푆 and 푆
both in OFF state. The PLL cannot track the utility
voltage normally, and angle frequency is fixed. Since
voltage compensator 퐺 and 퐺 can regulate the
load voltage 푣 , the DG is controlled as a voltage
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
source. In D-axis the voltage reference is 푉 and in
Q-axis voltage reference is zero respectively and the
magnitude of the load voltage equals to 푉
approximately, elaborated in next section. The
control diagram of three-phase inverter for islanded
mode can be simplified and is shown in figure 7. If
there is any disturbance in the load current, it will be
suppressed quickly by the inductor current loop and a
stiff load voltage can be achieved. Finally, the load
current 푖 is partial reference of the inductor
current loop.
iv. Transition from the Islanded Mode to the Grid-
Tied Mode:
a. If the utility switch 푆 made ON after the restoring
the utility, the DG should be connected with utility
by turning ON switch 푆 . There are several steps
before preparation before turning on switch 푆 .as
soon as utility voltage is restored, the PLL will track
the phase of the utility voltage which results that the
phase angle of utility voltage 푣 will follow the
grid voltage 푣 . If the load voltage 푣 is in
phase with the utility voltage, according to equation 5
푣 will equal the magnitude of the utility voltage.
Fig 7 Simplified block diagram of the unified control
strategy when DG operates in the islanded mode.
b. The magnitude of the load voltage 푉 is larger
than the utility voltage magnitude 푉 , the reference
voltage 푉 will be changed to 푉 by toggling the
selector S from terminals 1 to 2. The load voltage
will equal t the utility voltage in both phase and
magnitude.
c. The switch 푆 is turned on, and the selector S is
reset to terminal 1 where load voltage is held by
utility. As 푉 = 푉 which is larger than the
magnitude of the utility voltage 푉 , so PI
compensator 퐺 will saturate, and the output of
limiter is its upper value 퐼 meanwhile 푣 is
regulated to zero by the PLL from equation 5. The
output of 퐺 will be zero. By inactivating
퐺 and 퐺 , DG is controlled as a current source by
inductor current loop.
Analysis and Design: This section briefs about the
proposed fuzzy based control strategy is analyzed and
designed in both steady state and transient state along
with three-phase inverter.
In the steady state, the operating points of both grid-
tied and islanded modes of DG are analyzed where
limiters and references are selected. Whereas in
transient state, compensators in both inductor current
loop and the external loop are designed based on the
small-signal model and the effect of load current
feedforward is also analyzed as well.
A. Steady State
1) Analysis of Operation Points:
2) Selection of References and Limiters
1) Analysis of Operation Points: in the grid-tied
mode, the inverter is controlled as a current source,
and the current reference for the inductor current
loop 푖 is expressed according equation (6) and
(7). The steady-state error will be zero with the Fuzzy
Logic Compensator in the inductor current loop, so
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
the inductor current in steady state can be expressed
as follows:
푖 = 퐼 − 휔 퐶 ∙ 푣 + 푖푖 = 푣 ∙ 푘 + 휔 퐶 ∙ 푣 + 퐼 + 푖
------- (13)
In the SRF, the relationship between the voltage and
the current of the filter capacitor in steady state can
be expressed by 푖 = −푣 ∙ 휔퐶푖 = 푣 ∙ 휔퐶
-------- (14)
Where 휔 represents the angle frequency of the DG
and 퐶 denotes capacitance of the filter capacitor. As a
result, the output current of the inverter 푖 can be
gained
푖 = 푖 − 푖 = 퐼 − (휔 − 휔)푖 = 푖 − 푖 = 푣 ∙ 푘 + 퐼
+(휔 −휔) ∙ 퐶 ∙ 푣 + 푖 .
------- (15)
As angle frequency ω is very close to the rated angle
frequency휔 , it can be found that the output current
follows퐼 and the load current 푖 , as 푣 equals
zero in the grid-tied mode. The active and reactive
power injected into utility can be obtained as follows.
Consequently, the active power and reactive power
flowing from the inverter to utility can be given
by 퐼 and 퐼 , respectively
⎩⎪⎪⎨
⎪⎪⎧ 푃 =
32 ∙ 푣
(푖 − 푖 ) + 푣 푖 − 푖
=32 ∙ 푣 퐼
푄 =32 ∙ 푣
(푖 − 푖 )− 푣 푖 − 푖
=32 ∙ 푣 퐼
----- (17)
In the islanded mode, the inverter is controlled as a
voltage source by the external voltage loop. In the D-
axis,푣 is regulated by the Fuzzy Logic
compensator 퐺 , so the steady state error will be
zero and 푣 can be expressed as follows:
푣 = 푉
------- (18)
Where 푉 is in D-axis. In the Q-axis, the regulator
퐺 is 푃 compensator, so the steady state error may
not be zero. As the load current is added to the
inductor reference, the condition shown as below can
be achieved
푣 ∙ 푘 + 퐼 = 0
------ (19)
And then, the load voltage in Q-axis can be expressed
by (20). It should be noted that the absolute value
of 푣 rises with the increase of the current reference
퐼 which is related to the reactive power injected
into the utility
푣 = −퐼푘
------ (20)
The magnitude of the load voltage 푉 can be
represented as follows. It equals to 푉
approximately, because 푣 should be much lower
than 푉 with proper current reference 퐼
푉 = 푉 +퐼푘 ≈ 푉
------- (21)
During islanding operation, the angle frequency is
restricted in the given range by the limiter. During
transition from grid-tied mode to the islanded mode,
In first-time interval only the angle frequency is
determined. If current reference 퐼 is set to zero,
then 푣 is zero. It means that the angle frequency 휔
does not vary in the first time interval of the
transition, and it should equal the angle frequency of
the utility before islanding happens 휔 . the angle
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
frequency of the load voltage 휔 in the islanded mode
is determined by the current reference 퐼 , where
휔 represent the upper values of the limiter and
휔 represent the lower values of the limiter shown
in fig 2
휔 =휔 , 퐼 > 0휔 , 퐼 = 0 휔 , 퐼 < 0
----- (22)
2) Selection of References and Limiters: In the grid-
tied mode, through the current reference 퐼 the
active power is injected into the grid 푃 . Therefore,
the selection of 퐼 depends on the power rating of
the inverter. According to equation 17, the current
reference 퐼 , first determines the amount of
reactive power to be injected into utility 푄 in the
grid-tied mode and even affects the magnitude of the
load voltage in the islanded mode according to
equation 21. Finally, the reactive power 푄 cannot be
very large, In order to maintain load voltage within
the normal range in the islanded mode. In grid-tied
mode, 푉 should be maintained larger than the
utility voltage 푉 . At the same time, load voltage will
be determined by 푉 in the islanded mode
according to equation 21. So 푉 should not be
much larger than 푉 . For this case only it is selected
as the maximum magnitude of the utility voltage in
this paper. As per IEEE standard 1547-2003 the
range of the normal grid voltage 0.88-1.1 p.u.
so 푉 can be selected as
푉 = 1.1 ∙ √2 ∙ 푉
--------- (23)
Where 푉 =The RMS value of the rated phase
voltage. In order to guarantee that the PLL operates
normally in the grid-tied mode, the utility angle
frequency 휔 should not touch the upper value 휔
or lower value 휔 of the limier in the PLL.
Besides, the angle frequency 휔 is restricted
between 휔 and 휔 in the islanded mode, and it
should not drift from the normal value too far. So,
휔 and 휔 are selected as the maximum and
minimum angle frequencies allowed by the utility
standard.
B. Transient State
1) Small-Signal Model of the Power Stage
2) Design and Analysis of the Current Loop
3) Design and Analysis of the Voltage Loop
4) Impact of Load Current Feedforward
1) Small-Signal Model of the Power Stage: The
transient performance is analyzed; the three-phase
inverter in the DG needs to be modeled. According to
the power stage shown in Fig. 1, by front-end
converter in DG the DC-link voltage 푉 is regulated.
By eliminating its dynamic performance in this paper
the dc voltage 푉 is assumed very stiff. The average
model of the power stage can be described by
푉2 ∙
푑푑푑
= 퐿 ∙푑푑푡
푖푖푖
+ 푅 ∙푖푖푖
+푣푣푣
(24)
푖푖푖
= 퐶 ∙푑푑푡
푣푣푣
+푖푖푖
+푖푖푖
(25)
In (24),푑 ,푑 , and 푑 = the average duty cycle of
each leg varying from −1 to 1 ,and 푅 = the
equivalent series resistance of the filter inductor.
Then, the average model in the SRF can obtained
with the Park transformation shown in (3), which is
represented by
푉2 ∙
푑푑 = 퐿 ∙
푑푑푡
푖푖 +
0 −휔퐿휔퐿 0 ∙
푖푖 + 푅
∙푖푖 +
푣푣
------- (26)
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
푖푖 = 퐶 ∙
푑푑푡
푣푣 +
0 −휔퐶휔퐶 0 ∙
푣푣 +
푖푖
+푖푖 .
(27)
Considering the dc voltage푉 as stiff, the small-
signal model will be same as the average model. In
SRF model between D and Q-axes the inductor 퐿
and capacitors 퐶 couplings are introduced and these
couplings can be mitigated by the decoupling
components and 휔 퐶 in Fig. 3. Therefore, the
small-signal model can be simplified into two
identical SISO systems, which is represented by (28)
ignoring the subscript d and q 푉푑푐2∙ 푑 = 퐿푓 ∙
푑푑푡푖̂퐿 + 푅푙 ∙ 푖̂퐿 + 푣퐶
푖̂퐿 = 퐶푓 ∙푑푑푡푣퐶 + 푖̂퐿퐿 + 푖̂푔 .
(28)
TABLE 1 PARAMETERS OF THE POWER STAGE
parameters value
DC voltage 푉
Filter inductor 퐿
Filter capacitor 퐶
Switching frequency푓
Sampling frequency 푓
Rated power of DG 푃
Rated RMS phase voltage 푉
Rated utility angle frequency 휔
Rated linear local load 푅 _
Rated nonlinear local load 푅 _
400V
3.5mH
15휇F
10kHz
20 kHz
3000W
115V
50× 2휋
rad/s
60Ω
120 Ω
2) Design and Analysis of the Current Loop:
In both islanded and grid-tied modes to regulate the
inductor current loop it should operate normally.
From 28 equation, the small-signal model of the
control-to-current can be obtained. Which is shown
as
퐺 (푠) =푖̂퐿(푠)푑(푠)
=푉2 ∙
푠퐶푠 퐿 퐶 + 푠푅 퐶 + 1
(29)
However, In the grid-tied mode, because of the stiff
utility the dynamics of the capacitor 퐶 is ignored,
and the small-signal model of the control-to-current
is described by
퐺 (푠) =푖̂퐿(푠)푑(푠)
=푉2 ∙
1푠퐿 + 푅
------- (30)
The required parameters of the power stage
implemented in this paper shown in Table I. In fig.8
for both operation modes the bode plot of the control-
to-current transfer function can be obtained. It can be
found that huge difference appears in the low and
medium frequency range and it is difficult to design
the compensator 퐺 to achieve good performance in
both of operation modes. It is because of the inductor
current is coupled with the capacitor voltage in the
islanded mode. This difference can be mitigated by
the capacitor voltage is fed forward with the
coefficient in Fig. 2, by decoupling the inductor
with the capacitor voltage.
Fig. 8. Bode plot of the loop gain of the inner current
loop.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
Fig. 9. Block diagram of the simplified voltage loop.
The transfer function of control to current in the
islanded mode is changed to be close to the one in the
grid-tied mode, and the current compensator 퐺 can
be designed based on unified transfer function shown
by (30). The loop gain of the current loop is shown in
Fig. 9, with the crossover frequency of 1100 Hz, and
the phase margin of 65°
퐺 (푠) = 푘 ∙1 + 푠
휔퐺푠
----- (31)
3) Design and Analysis of the Voltage Loop:
To regulate the load voltage, the voltage loop just
operates in the islanded mode can be seen in the
simplified block diagram Fig. 10. Where 퐺 (푠)
and퐺 (푠) denote the closed-loop transfer function of
an inductor loop and 퐶 =the impedance of the filter
capacitor, respectively. These two compensators are
designed, and the loop gain of the current loop is
shown in Fig.11.results in little difference in the low
frequency range. The phase margin is set to 55° and
crossover frequency is around 600Hz in both D- and
Q-axes.
Fig. 10 Bode plot of the loop gain of the voltage loop
in D-and Q-axes.
퐺 (푠) = 푘 ∙1 + 푠
휔퐺푠
(32)
퐺 (푠) = 푘
(33)
4) Impact of Load Current Feedforward: the
disturbance from the load current can be suppressed
by the inductor current reference and the load current
횤̂ is a part of the inductor current reference. The
transfer function of the output impedance is derived
to estimate the response of the load current
feedforward in the islanded mode. The output
impedances with and without load current
feedforward are expressed by
푍 (푠) =푣 (푠)횤̂ (푠) = −
퐺 (푠) ∙ [1− 퐺 (푠)]1 + 퐺 (푠) ∙ 퐺 (푠) ∙ 퐺 (푠)
-------- (34)
푍 (푠) =푣 (푠)횤̂ (푠) = −
퐺 (푠)1 + 퐺 (푠) ∙ 퐺 (푠) ∙ 퐺 (푠)
(35)
With load current feedforward an extra factor
[1− 퐺 (푠)] appears in the output impedance. The
magnitude of output impedance will be reduced in
the low frequency range because the gains of the
closed-loop transfer function 퐺 (푠) to unity in the
bandwidth of the current loop.
With two conditions, the output impedance of the
bode plot is shown in Fig. 12. The output impedance
is reduced from dc to 600Hz with the load current
feedforward. At the same time, the quality of the load
voltage 푣 will be improved with the load current
feedforward. The inductor current loop is regulated
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
directly by inductor current in grid-tied mode. The
incurrent reference is mainly composed by the
current reference 퐼 , and the load current 푖 .
The output current 푖 of the inverter will be fixed
by퐼 . The disturbance of the load current will be
fully injected into the utility, which can be
represented by feedforward, when DG operates in
islanded mode.
횤̂ (푠)횤̂ (푠) = −1
------- (36)
Fig. 11 Bode plot of the output impedance with and
without the load current
Fig. 12 Bode plot of the transfer function from load
current to grid current
With and without the load current feedforward DG
operates in the grid-tied mode. The disturbance of the
load current can be compensated by the inverter and
the transfer function from load current to grid current
can be explained from equation 37. The bode plots of
transfer function and the gain is mitigated upto
1050Hz with the load current feedforward and
therefore, the quality of the grid current can be
improved
횤̂ (푠)횤̂ (푠) = 퐺 (푠) − 1
(37)
SIMULATION RESULTS
The proposed control strategy is investigated
in MATLAB simulink and simulation results are
verified. For simulation purposes the three-phase
inverter power rating is considered as 3kW. The
parameters in the simulation are compared with
Tables I and II. The RMS rated phase voltage is
115V ad the voltage reference 푉 is set as
10%higher than the rated value. The utility rated
frequency is 50Hz, and the upper and the lower
values of the limiter in the PLL are given as 0.2Hz
higher and lower than the rated frequency,
respectively. By stepping down the grid current
reference from 9A to 5Ain the grid-tied mode the
conventional voltage mode control and proposed
fuzzy based unified control strategy are compared.
The simulated results for the voltage mode control
are shown in fig. 14(a). at the moment of 14s the
current reference is changed. It is found that dynamic
process lasts until around 15.2s. The simulation result
for the proposed control strategy is represented in fig
14(b). Here the time interval of the dynamic process
is less than 5ms. From the Comparison of the
simulation results above. It can be seen that the
dynamic performance of the proposed fuzzy based
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
unified control strategy is better than the
conventional voltage mode control.
TABLE II PARAMETERS IN THE CONTROL SYSTEM
parameters Value
Voltage reference 푉
Rated current reference 퐼
Rated current reference 퐼
Upper value of the limiter 휔
Lower value of the limiter 휔
179V
9A
0A
50.2× 2휋 rad/s
49.8× 2휋 rad/s
(a)
(b)
Fig 13 Simulation waveforms of load voltage 푣 ,
grid current 푖 , and inductor current 푖 when DG is
in the grid-tied mode under condition of the step
down of the grid current reference from 9 A to 5 A
with: (a) conventional voltage mode control, and (b)
proposed unified control strategy
(a)
(b)
Fig. 14. Simulation waveforms of load voltage 푣 ,
grid current 푖 ,and inductor current 푖 when DG is
transferred from the grid-tied mode to the islanded
mode with: (a) conventional hybrid voltage and
current mode control, and (b) proposed unified
control strategy.
Under transition states the grid-tied mode to
the islanded mode, the unified control strategy is
compared with the hybrid voltage and current mode
control, and the simulation scenario is shown as
follows: Initially, the utility is normal, and the DG is
connected with the utility; At 0.5s, islanding happens;
and At 0.52s, the islanding is confirmed. Simulated
results of hybrid voltage and current mode control
can be seen in figure 15(a). It can be found that the
grid current drop to zero at 0.5s, and load voltage is
seriously distorted from 0.5 to 0.52s. The load
voltage is recovered to normal value after 0.52s. Fig
15(b) presents the simulated of proposed fuzzy based
control strategy. The magnitude of the grid current is
9A and follows the current reference 퐼 . The
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
load voltage magnitude and frequency is held by the
utility. When islanding happens, to follow the voltage
reference 푉 amplitude levels of load voltage will
increase little more whereas the output current of DG
decreases autonomously to match the load power
demand. The voltage quality in the proposed control
strategy in three states (two modes and two transition
states) is no more critical.
CONCLUSION
Fuzzy based unified control strategy was
proposed for DG based three-phase inverters to
operate in both islanded and grid-tied modes, with no
need for switching between two different control
architectures or for critical islanding detection. A
novel fuzzy based voltage controller was presented.
When grid-tied mode is inactivated the DG operates
as a current source with fast dynamic performance. In
outage conditions, the controller can automatically be
activated to regulate the load voltage and even a load
current feedforward propos where it can improve the
wave form quality of the both the grid current in the
grid-tied mode and load voltage in islanded mode.
The proposed fuzzy based unified control strategy
was verified through the MATLAB simulation.
REFERENCES
[1] R. C. Dugan and T. E. McDermott, “Distributed
generation,”IEEE Ind. Appl. Mag., vol. 8, no. 2, pp.
19–25, Mar./Apr. 2002.
[2] R. H. Lasseter, “Microgrids and distributed
generation,”J. Energy Eng., vol. 133, no. 3, pp. 144–
149, Sep. 2007.
[3] C. Mozina, “Impact of green power distributed
generation,” IEEE Ind. Appl. Mag., vol. 16, no. 4, pp.
55–62, Jul./Aug. 2010.
[4] IEEE Recommended Practice for Utility Interface
of Photovoltaic(PV) Systems, IEEE Standard 929-
2000, 2000.
[5] IEEE Standard for Interconnecting Distributed
Resources with Electric Power Systems, IEEE
Standard 1547-2003, 2003.
[6] J. Stevens, R. Bonn, J. Ginn, and S. Gonzalez,
Development and Testing of an Approach to Anti-
Islanding in Utility-Interconnected Photovoltaic
Systems. Livermore, CA, USA: Sandia National
Laboratories, 2000.
[7] A. M. Massoud, K. H. Ahmed, S. J. Finney, and
B. W. Williams, “Harmonic distortion-based island
detection technique for inverter-based distributed
generation,”IET Renewable Power Gener., vol. 3, no.
4, pp. 493–507, Dec. 2009.
[8] T. Thacker, R. Burgos, F. Wang, and D.
Boroyevich, “Single-phase islanding detection based
on phase-locked loop stability,” inProc. 1st IEEE
Energy Convers. Congr. Expo., San Jose, CA, USA,
2009, pp. 3371–3377.
[9] S.-K. Kim, J.-H. Jeon, J.-B. Ahn, B. Lee, and S.-
H. Kwon, “Frequencyshift acceleration control for
anti-islanding of a distributed-generation inverter,”
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 494–
504, Feb. 2010.
[10] A. Yafaoui, B. Wu, and S. Kouro, “Improved
active frequency drift antiislanding detection method
for grid connected photovoltaic systems,” IEEE
Trans. Power Electron., vol. 27, no. 5, pp. 2367–
2375, May 2012.
[11] J. M. Guerrero, L. Hang, and J. Uceda, “Control
of distributed uninterruptible power supply
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING STUDIES Volume V /Issue 4 /SEP 2015
IJPRES
systems,”IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 55, no. 8,
pp. 2845–2859, Aug. 2008.
[12] M. C. Chandorkar, D. M. Divan, and R. Adapa,
“Control of parallel connected inverters in standalone
AC supply systems,”IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 29,
no. 1, pp. 136–143, Jan./Feb. 1993.
MUKKU MURALI Completed
B.Tech In Electrical & Electronics Engineering In
2009-2013 From QIS INSTITUTE OF
TECHNOLOGY, Ongole Affiliated To JNTUK,
Kakinada And M.Tech In Power Electronics And
Electrical Drives In 2015 From MALINENI
LAKSHMAIAH ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
Singarayakonda Affiliated To JNTUK, Kakinada.
Area Of Interest Includes Power Electronics. E-Mail
Dr K VENKATESWARLU
Completed B.Tech In Electrical & Electronics
Engineering In 1990-1994 From S V UNIVERSITY
And M.Tech In Power Systems In 1999 From
JNTUH, Hyderabad And Ph.D In Power Systems In
2015 From JNTUK, Kakinada. Working As
Professor Of EEE Department At MALINENI
LAKSHMAIAH ENGINEERING COLLEGE
Singarayakonda, Prakasam(District),Andhra Pradesh,
India. Area Of interest Includes Power Electronics
And Power System.
E-Mail Id: [email protected]