apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition...

21
Contact American CME by email at [email protected] with any questions regarding the contents of the RACE Supplemental Skill Guide. Rapid Arterial oCclusion Exam RACE Supplemental Skill Guide Purpose: The American CME RACE Supplemental Skill Guide has been produced to enhance the EMS provider’s ability to recognize LVO strokes by practicing the necessary hands on skills associated with the Rapid Arterial oCclusion Exam (RACE) stroke severity scale. This document has been produced as a supplement to the American CME EMS video-based continuing education course, Stroke: A New Standard of Care for Large Vessel Occlusion (LVO). Visit www.AmericanCME.com to create an account and complete this video- based EMS CE. It is recommended to complete the online course prior to utilizing this guide to understand the science and the necessary background information. This guide provides step-by-step instructions that any EMS provider or EMS instructor may use for EMS training and education. In addition, multiple scenarios are included to aid in learning comprehension. Please note that this guide is not preapproved for EMS continuing education credits by any State agency. American CME encourages any EMS agency or jurisdiction to utilize this guide as they see fit.

Transcript of apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition...

Page 1: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RapidArterialoCclusionExam

RACESupplementalSkillGuide

Purpose:TheAmericanCMERACESupplementalSkillGuidehasbeenproducedtoenhancetheEMSprovider’sabilitytorecognizeLVOstrokesbypracticingthenecessaryhandsonskillsassociatedwiththeRapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE)strokeseverityscale.ThisdocumenthasbeenproducedasasupplementtotheAmericanCMEEMSvideo-basedcontinuingeducationcourse,“Stroke:ANewStandardofCareforLargeVesselOcclusion(LVO)”.Visitwww.AmericanCME.comtocreateanaccountandcompletethisvideo-basedEMSCE.Itisrecommendedtocompletetheonlinecoursepriortoutilizingthisguidetounderstandthescienceandthenecessarybackgroundinformation.Thisguideprovidesstep-by-stepinstructionsthatanyEMSproviderorEMSinstructormayuseforEMStrainingandeducation.Inaddition,multiplescenariosareincludedtoaidinlearningcomprehension.PleasenotethatthisguideisnotpreapprovedforEMScontinuingeducationcreditsbyanyStateagency.AmericanCMEencouragesanyEMSagencyorjurisdictiontoutilizethisguideastheyseefit.

Page 2: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

TableofContents

SAMPLEEMSCONTINUINGEDUCATIONLESSONPLAN..................1-2

INTRODUCTION................................................................................3

LARGEVESSELOCCLUSION(LVO)STROKES........................................3

RAPIDARTERIALOCCLUSIONEXAM(RACE).......................................4

PERFORMINGRACE........................................................................5-6

SAMPLERACEFORM.........................................................................7

EMSTRANSPORTOPTIONS................................................................8

RACESCENARIOS.........................................................................9-18

WORKSCITED................................................................................19

Page 3: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

SampleEMSContinuingEducationLessonPlan

NOTE:EMSagenciesshouldmodifythissamplelessonplantomeettheirlocalorStateEMSeducationstandards,asneeded.Title:IdentifyingLVOStrokeswithRACECreditCategory:PatientAssessmentTopic:IdentifyingLargeVesselOcclusion(LVO)StrokesusingtheRapidArterialoCclusionEvaluation(RACE)Presenter:TBDCourseDescription:RecognitionofLVOinthefieldandtriagetotheclosestappropriatestrokecenterisacriticalskillforEMSproviders.ThisCEsessionisdesignedtoallowstudentstodeveloppsychomotorcompetencyperformingRapidArterialoCclusionEvaluation,orRACE,throughscenario-basedtraining.Students(EMSproviders)willperformapatientassessmentonasimulatedpatient,quantifystrokeseverityusingRACE,andindicatetheclosestappropriatestrokecentertotransportthepatient.Competencywillbegainedthroughrepetitionandguidancefromtheinstructors.ThispracticalisdesignedtogiveEMSprofessionalstheconfidencetoperformacompletestrokeassessmentutilizingRACEinthefieldandmakequalityemergencytransportdecisionsbasedonthecapabilitiesandlimitationsofvariousstrokecenters.EMSContinuingEducationCredits:

MFR/EMR:1Hour EMT:1Hour AEMT:1HourParamedic:1Hour

CourseObjectives:● Defineanddescribelargevesselocclusion(LVO)stroke. ● DefineanddescribetheRapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE)andhowitidentifiesstrokeseverity. ● PerformapatientassessmentonasimulatedpatientandincludetheperformanceofRACE. ● IdentifytheclosestappropriatestrokecenterforthesimulatedpatientbasedontheRACEscore,aswell

asotherassessmentfindings. NOTE:AmericanCMEhasdevelopedthisCElessonplanandoutlinetobeusedormodifiedbyanyEMSproviderorinstructorfortheirspecificeducationalandtrainingneeds.Thislessonplancanbemodifiedtosuittheneedsofaninstructor'sagencyorgoverningbody.ItistheresponsibilityofanyinstructorthatutilizesthisinformationtogainapprovalfromtheirlocaljurisdictionorstatethatapprovesEMSCE.

1

Page 4: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

SampleCELessonPlanOutline

NOTE:EMSagenciesshouldmodifythissamplelessonplanoutlinetomeettheirlocalorStateEMSeducationstandards,asneeded.

1. Introductiona. StudentwillbegivenanoverviewofthisCEandinformedoftheexpectations.

2. LargeVesselOcclusion(LVO)Strokesa. Defineanddescribelargevesselocclusion(LVO)stroke.

3. RapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE)a. DefineanddescribetheRapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE)andhowitidentifiesstrokeseverity.

4. PerformingRACE:

a. List,describeanddemonstratethecomponentsofRACE.

5. EMSTransportOptionsa. IdentifytheclosestappropriatestrokecenterforthesimulatedpatientbasedontheRACEscore,aswellas

otherassessmentfindings.

6. RACEScenariosa. PerformacompletepatientassessmentonasimulatedpatientandincludetheperformanceofRACE.

b. Students(EMSproviders)will:

i. Performanassessmenton5separatesimulatedpatientsii. IdentifytheseverityofastrokeusingRACEiii. Indicatetheclosestappropriatestrokecentertotransportthepatientiv. Performasimulated“AcuteStrokeAlert”,whichcommunicatesthekeycriteriathatshouldbe

relayedtothereceivinghospital.

c. Scenario1-5i. Studentsareprovideddispatchinformationii. Studentsareprovidedasimulatedpatientthatmatchesdispatchinformationiii. Studentsperformacompletepatientassessment

1. Obtainnecessaryhistoryandvitalsigns2. PerformRACE3. Triagethepatienttoanappropriatedestination4. Providean“AcuteStrokeAlert”tothereceivingfacility

iv. Theinstructorwillobservethestudentsforstrengthsandareasthatcoulduseimprovement.Theseobservationswillbeusedtofacilitateabriefconversationbetweeneachscenario.

NOTE:AmericanCMEhasdevelopedthisCElessonplanandoutlinetobeusedormodifiedbyanyEMSproviderorinstructorfortheirspecificeducationalandtrainingneeds.Thislessonplancanbemodifiedtosuittheneedsofaninstructor'sagencyorgoverningbody.ItistheresponsibilityofanyinstructorthatutilizesthisinformationtogainapprovalfromtheirlocaljurisdictionorstatethatapprovesEMSCE.

2

Page 5: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

1. Introduction

a. StudentwillbegivenanoverviewofthisCEandinformedoftheexpectations.RecognitionofLVOinthefieldandtriagetotheclosestappropriatestrokecenterisacriticalskillforEMSproviders.ThisCEsessionisdesignedtoallowstudentstodeveloppsychomotorcompetencyperformingRapidArterialoCclusionEvaluation,orRACE,throughscenario-basedtraining.Students(EMSproviders)performapatientassessmentonasimulatedpatient,identifytheseverityofastrokeusingRACE,andindicatetheclosestappropriatestrokecentertotransportthepatient.Competencywillbegainedthroughrepetitionandguidancefromtheinstructors.ThispracticalisdesignedtogiveEMSprofessionalstheconfidencetoperformacompletestrokeassessmentutilizingRACEinthefieldandmakequalityemergencytransportdecisionsbasedonthecapabilitiesandlimitationsofvariousstrokecenters.

2. LargeVesselOcclusion(LVO)Strokes:

a. Defineanddescribelargevesselocclusion(LVO)stroke.

Allstrokesarenotequal.Justasstrokescanpresentwithdifferentsetsofsignsandsymptoms,dependingonwhatpartofthebrainisaffected,theycanalsovaryinseveritydependingonthesizeofthebloodvesselaffected.Alargevesselocclusion,orLVO,isakindofischemicstrokethataffectsanyoftheproximalbloodvesselsofthebrain,including;theinternalcarotidarteries,themiddlecerebralarteries,thebasilarartery,andtheanteriorcerebralarteries.TheobstructionofcerebralbloodflowinthepresenceofaLVOismoresevereduetotheinvolvementofthelargecerebralarteries.Greaterdeclinesincerebralbloodflowcorrelatewithmoreextensiveregionsofischemiaandincreasedbraintissuedeath.Infact,oneprospectivestudyshowedthepresenceofanLVOwasassociatedwitha5-foldincreaseindeath,anda3-folddecreaseingoodoutcomes(1).EvenmorealarmingistheprevalenceofLVOstrokes.StudieshaveshownthatnearlyhalfofallischemicstrokesareLVOs.(1)NotonlyarethestakesmuchhigherforstrokepatientswithLVOs,butstandardthrombolytictreatmentistypicallyineffective.ThelikelihoodoftPAclearingaclotdecreasesasthesizeoftheclotincreases.Asaresult,thesepatientsrequireearlyidentificationinthefieldandpriority1transporttoaninterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever.Remember,timeisbrain.Merelyidentifyingthatastrokeisoccurringinthefieldisnolongergoodenough,EMSprovidersmustnowtriagestrokepatientstoanappropriatestrokecenterthatcanprovidernecessaryinterventions.

3

Page 6: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

3. RapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE):

a. DefineanddescribetheRapidArterialoCclusionExam(RACE)andhowitidentifiesstrokeseverity.

TheroleoftheEMSproviderisnolongerlimitedtojustidentifyingstrokepatientsinthefield.NowEMSmustquantifystrokeseverityinordertoidentifythemostseverecasesofischemicstrokeandensurethatthesepatientsaretakentoaninterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever.LVOstrokesarethemostsevereformofischemicstroke,andrecognizingtheminthefieldisessentialtoachievingfunctionalindependenceforstrokepatients.tPAalonehasproventobeanunreliableandineffectivetreatmentforLVOs.Themostpopularvalidatedstrokescalesofrecognitiondesignedforprehospitaluseinclude:theCincinnatiPrehospitalStrokeScale(CPSS)andtheLosAngelesPrehospitalStrokeScreen(LAPPS).Eachofthesestrokescaleswerecreatedinthe1990sfromelementsoftheNIHstrokescaletoidentifythevarioussignsandsymptomsofstroke,andimprovestrokerecognitioninthefield.Basically,thesestrokescalesidentifythatastrokehasoccurred,buttheydon’tidentifytheseverityofastroke.Inaddition,theydonotpredictifthestrokeisanLVO.Asstroketreatmenthasevolvedoverthelast20years,theneedforfieldrecognitionofLVOshasarisen.ThenewfoundabilitytosuccessfullytreatLVOsusingmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretrieverhasestablishedtheneedforEMSproviderstotriagethesepatientstointerventionalstrokecenters.ThenextgenerationofstrokescalesdesignedforLVOrecognitioninthefieldistheRACEscale,whichisdrawingagreatdealofattentionduetoitsabilitytodetectLVOswithahighdegreeofaccuracy.RACEstandsforRapidArterialoCclusionExam.Likeotherscalesofrecognition,itisalsoderivedfromtheNIHstrokescaleandwasdesignedspecificallyforEMSproviderstodetectLVOsintheprehospitalsetting.RACEscoresapatient’sstrokebasedontheextentandseverityoftheirdeficits.Theoverallscorerangesfrom0to9.0meaningnodeficitswerepresent.Anyscoregreaterthan0meansthatastrokehasoccurred.LVOsarelikelywhenastrokepatienthasaRACEscoreofgreaterthanorequalto5(2).

4

Page 7: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

4. PerformingRACE:

a. List,describeanddemonstratethecomponentsofRACE.TheRACEscaleexamines5categories:

1. Facialpalsy2. Armmotorfunction3. Legmotorfunction4. Head&eyedeviation5. Aphasia(ifright-sideddeficitsareidentified)ORagnosia(ifleft-sideddeficitsareidentified)

Eachcategoryisscoredbasedonthepatient’sdegreeofdisability;0meaningnodeficit,1meaningamildtomoderatedeficit,and2meaningaseveredeficitispresent.TocompleteaRACEexam,conducttheassessmentsbelow:

FacialPalsy

● HOWTOASSESS:Askthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile. ● SCORINGCRITERIA:

NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical)MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical)MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

ArmMotorFunction

● HOWTOASSESS:Askthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● SCORINGCRITERIA: NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds)MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds)SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

LegMotorFunction

● HOWTOASSESS:Askthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimetoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● SCORINGCRITERIA: NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds)MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds)SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

HeadandGazeDeviationNoteifthepatient’sheadoreyesaredeviatedtooneside.Inthepresenceofseverestrokesthepatient’sheadwilloftenbeturnedtowardsthesideofthestrokeandthepatient’seyesmayalsobeturnedtowardthatside.

● HOWTOASSESS:Ifpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside. ● SCORINGCRITERIA:

○ NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ○ GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

5

Page 8: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Aftercompletingtheassessmentsoffacialpalsy,armmotorfunction,legmotorfunctionandheadandgazedeviation,performoneofthefinaltwocategoriesbasedonearlierassessmentfindings:

● Right-sideddeficits=AssessforAphasia ● Left-sideddeficits=AssessforAgnosia

Aphasia(forpatientspresentingwithright-sideddeficits)Ifright-sideddeficitswereobservedcheckforaphasia.Aphasiaisthelossofabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech.Right-sideddeficitsresultfromthelefthemisphereofthebrainbeingaffectedbyastroke.Theleftcerebralhemispherecontainstheregionofthebrainresponsibleforcomprehendinglanguage.

● HOWTOASSESS:Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1-Closeyoureyes.2-Makeafist.

● SCORINGCRITERIA: NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly)MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly)SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

Agnosia(forpatientspresentingwithleft-sideddeficits)

Ifleft-sideddeficitswereobservedcheckforagnosia.Ifthepatientpresentswithleft-sideddeficitsthatmeanstherighthemisphereofthebrainisbeingaffectedbythestroke.Therightcerebralhemispherecontainstheregionofthebrainresponsibleforinterpretingsensationsandrecognizingthings.Agnosiaistheinabilitytointerpretsensations,or“recognizethings,”typicallyasaresultofbraindamage.Basically,agnosiaistheinabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation.Thiscanresultinthepatientfailingtorecognizetheirleftarm,orthefactthatamotordeficitispresentintheirleftarm.Remember,youasanEMSproviderknowthattheyhaveleft-sideddeficits,whichiswhyyou’reassessingagnosiaatthispoint.Essentially,thispartoftheassessmentistoidentifyifthepatientrecognizestheirleftarm,andiftheyrecognizetheweaknessintheirleftarm.

● HOWTOASSESS:Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● SCORINGCRITERIA: NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness)MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

6

Page 9: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

SampleRACEForm:This1pageformwillassistEMSinutilizingRACEmoreeffectivelyintheprehospitalsetting.ThisresourcewillactasareferencetoolforthisnewandeffectivemeansofidentifyingLVOsintheprehospitalsetting.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE

TOTALSCORE

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

7

Page 10: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

5. EMSTransportOptions:

a. IdentifytheclosestappropriatestrokecenterforthesimulatedpatientbasedontheRACEscore,aswellasotherassessmentfindings.Remember,ifthepatienthasaRACEscoreof5orgreaterthereisahighprobabilityofalargevesselocclusion(LVO)(2).ThepatientshouldbetransportedtotheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenter,oraPrimaryStrokeCentercapableofperforminginterventionalstroketreatmentssuchasmechanicalthrombectomy,whenavailableandifprotocolsallow.

6. RACEScenarios:

Outlinea. PerformapatientassessmentonasimulatedpatientandincludetheperformanceofRACE.

b. Students(EMSproviders)will:

i. Performanassessmenton5separatesimulatedpatientsii. IdentifytheseverityofastrokeusingRACEiii. Indicatetheclosestappropriatestrokecentertotransportthepatient

c. Scenario1–5:

i. Studentsareprovideddispatchinformationii. Studentsareprovidedasimulatedpatientthatmatchesdispatchinformationiii. Studentsperformapatientassessment

1. PerformRACE2. Triagethepatienttoanappropriatedestination

iv. Theinstructorwillobservethestudentsforstrengthsandareasthatcoulduseimprovement.Theseobservationswillbeusedtofacilitateabriefconversationbetweeneachscenario.

8

Page 11: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Scenario#1:Dispatch:Dispatchedtoapatientwithone-sidedweakness.ArrivetoFind:A55year-oldmalepatientsittinginhislivingroom.Thepatient’sfamilystatesthepatientwasfoundinthisconditionaftertheyreturnedhomefromshopping.Thepatienthasobviousright-sidedweaknessanddifficultyspeaking.RACEStrokeScale:RACEscoreof5.SeetheRaceGuidethathasbeencompletedforScenario#1.StudentsshouldarriveatthesamescorewhencompletingtheirownRaceGuide.Symptomsdemonstratedbysimulatedpatient:

● FacialPalsy:Scoreof1.Slightlyasymmetrical. ● Armmotorfunction:Scoreof2.Unabletoliftrightarm. ● Legmotorfunction:Scoreof1.Abletoraiserightlegbutunabletoholdfor5seconds. ● Headand/oreyegazedeviation:Scoreof1.Present;unabletoshiftgazepastmidline. ● AssessforAphasia:Scoreof0.Nodeficitpatientisabletoperformbothtaskscorrectly. ● AssessforAgnosia:Notassessed.(Onlyassessedforleft-sideddeficits)

TriageDecision:ThepatientispresentingwithsignsofaLVOasdemonstratedbyaRACEscoreof5.ThispatientshouldbetriagedandrapidlytransportedtotheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever.TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

9

Page 12: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RACEScenario#1:ThecompletedRACEform.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE1

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE2

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE1

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE1

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE0

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE

N/A

TOTALSCORE 5

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

10

Page 13: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Scenario#2:Dispatch:Dispatchedtoapatientwithslurredspeech.ArrivetoFind:A70year-oldmalepatientalertandorientedtimes4sittingathiskitchentable.Thepatient’swifestatesshecamehomefrombookclubandnoticedherhusband’sspeechwasslurred.RACEStrokeScale:RACEscoreof4.SeetheRaceGuidethathasbeencompletedforScenario#2.StudentsshouldarriveatthesamescorewhencompletingtheirownRaceGuide.Symptomsdemonstratedbysimulatedpatient:

● FacialPalsy:Scoreof1.Slightlyasymmetrical. ● Armmotorfunction:Scoreof1.Abletoraiseleftarmbutunabletoholdfor10seconds. ● Legmotorfunction:Scoreof1.Abletoraiseleftlegbutunabletoholdfor5seconds. ● Headand/oreyegazedeviation:Scoreof0.Nodeficit;Noheadorgazedeviationpresent. ● AssessforAphasia:Notassessed.(Onlyassessedforright-sideddeficits) ● AssessforAgnosia:Scoreof1.Thepatientrecognizeshisleftarmbutdoesnotacknowledgetheleftarmweakness.

TriageDecision:ThepatientispresentingwithsignsofastrokeasdemonstratedbyaRACEscoreof4.ThispatientshouldbetriagedandrapidlytransportedtotheclosestStrokeCenter.TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

11

Page 14: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RACEScenario2:ThecompletedRACEform.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE1

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE1

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE1

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE0

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE

N/A

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE1

TOTALSCORE 4

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

12

Page 15: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Scenario#3:Dispatch:Dispatchedtoanunknownmedicalatalibrary.ArrivetoFind:A44year-oldfemalepatientsittinginachairwithabookinherlap.Thelibrarianstatesthepatientisnotactingappropriately.Sheinitiallythoughtthepatientwasdrowsybutimmediatelycalled911whenshenoticedthepatienthadfacialdroop.

RACEStrokeScale:RACEscoreof7.SeetheRaceGuidethathasbeencompletedforScenario#3.StudentsshouldarriveatthesamescorewhencompletingtheirownRaceGuide.Symptomsdemonstratedbysimulatedpatient:

● FacialPalsy:Scoreof2.Completelyasymmetrical. ● Armmotorfunction:Scoreof2.Unabletoliftrightarm. ● Legmotorfunction:Scoreof2.Unabletoliftrightleg. ● Headand/oreyegazedeviation:Scoreof1.Present;unabletoshiftgazepastmidline. ● AssessforAphasia:Scoreof0.Patientisabletoperformbothtaskscorrectly. ● AssessforAgnosia:Notassessed(Onlyassessedforleft-sideddeficits)

TriageDecision:ThepatientispresentingwithsignsofaLVOasdemonstratedbyaRACEscoreof7.ThispatientshouldbetriagedandrapidlytransportedtotheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever.TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

13

Page 16: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RACEScenario#3:ThecompletedRACEform.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE2

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE2

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE2

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE1

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE0

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE

N/A

TOTALSCORE 7

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

14

Page 17: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Scenario#4:Dispatch:Dispatchedtoapatientwithdifficultywalking.

ArrivetoFind:A59year-oldmalepatientalertandorientedtimes4sittingonaparkbench.Thepatientstatesthathewaswalkingwhenhedevelopedweaknessinhisleftarmandleftleg.Thepatientstatesthisbegan15minutespriorandhecalled911immediatelyaftertheonset.

RACEStrokeScale:RACEscoreof3.SeetheRaceGuidethathasbeencompletedforScenario#4.StudentsshouldarriveatthesamescorewhencompletingtheirownRaceGuide.

Symptomsdemonstratedbysimulatedpatient:● FacialPalsy:Scoreof1.Slightlyasymmetrical. ● Armmotorfunction:Scoreof1.Abletoraiseleftarmbutunabletoholdfor10seconds. ● Legmotorfunction:Scoreof1.Abletoraiseleftlegbutunabletoholdfor5seconds. ● Headand/oreyegazedeviation:Scoreof0.Nodeficit;Noheadorgazedeviationpresent. ● AssessforAphasia:Notassessed.(Onlyassessedforright-sideddeficits) ● AssessforAgnosia:Scoreof0.Patientrecognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness.

TriageDecision:ThepatientispresentingwithsignsofastrokeasdemonstratedbyaRACEscoreof3.ThispatientshouldbetriagedandrapidlytransportedtotheclosestStrokeCenter.TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

15

Page 18: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RACEScenario#4:ThecompletedRACEform.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE1

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE1

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE1

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE0

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE0

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE0

TOTALSCORE 3

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

16

Page 19: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

Scenario#5:Dispatch:Dispatchedtoanursinghomeforapossiblestroke.

ArrivetoFind:A69year-oldfemalepatientalerttopersonlyingsupineinahospitalbed.Thepatientstatesthatherrightarmisweak.Staffstatestheynoticedasuddenonsetofweaknessinthepatient’srightarm.Thisbeganwhilethepatientwaseatinglunch20minutesprior.Staffassistedthepatienttoherroom.

RACEStrokeScale:RACEscoreof8.SeetheRaceGuidethathasbeencompletedforScenario#5.StudentsshouldarriveatthesamescorewhencompletingtheirownRaceGuide.

Symptomsdemonstratedbysimulatedpatient:

● FacialPalsy:Scoreof2.Completelyasymmetrical. ● Armmotorfunction:Scoreof2.Unabletoliftleftarm. ● Legmotorfunction:Scoreof2.Unabletoliftleftleg. ● Headand/oreyegazedeviation:Scoreof0.Nodeficit;Noheadorgazedeviationpresent. ● AssessforAphasia:Notassessed.(Onlyassessedforright-sideddeficits) ● AssessforAgnosia:Scoreof2.PatientdoesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness.

TriageDecision:ThepatientispresentingwithsignsofaLVOasdemonstratedbyaRACEscoreof8.ThispatientshouldbetriagedandrapidlytransportedtotheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever.TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

17

Page 20: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

RACEScenario5:ThecompletedRACEform.

RapidoCclusionArterialExam(RACE)Form

FACIALPALSYAskthepatienttoshowyoutheirteethorsmile.

● NODEFICIT=0(faceissymmetrical) ● MILD=1(slightlyasymmetrical) ● MODERATETOSEVERE=2(completelyasymmetrical)

SCORE2

ARMMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoclosetheireyesandextendtheirarmsat90degreesandholdthemforacountoftenwiththeirpalmsup.Theirarmanglecanbemodifiedto45degreesifthepatientissupine.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraisearmandholdfor10seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraisearm,butunabletoholdfor10seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoliftanarm)

SCORE2

LEGMOTORFUNCTIONAskthepatienttoraiseonelegatatimeuptoa30-degreeangleandholditupfor5seconds.

● NODEFICIT=0(abletoraiselegandholdfor5seconds) ● MODERATE=1(abletoraiseleg,butunabletoholdfor5seconds) ● SEVERE=2(unabletoraisealeg)

SCORE2

HEADANDGAZEDEVIATIONIfpatient’sheadoreyesaretowardsoneside,askthemtolooktowardstheotherside.

● NODEFICIT=0(noheadorgazedeviation) ● GAZEPRESENT=1(unabletoshiftgazepastmidline)

SCORE0

APHASIA(Inabilitytounderstandorexpressspeech)Ifright-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatienttodothefollowing:1)Closeyoureyes.2)Makeafist.

● NODEFICIT=0(performsbothtaskscorrectly) ● MODERATE=1(performsonetaskcorrectly) ● SEVERE=2(performsneithertask)

SCORE

N/A

AGNOSIA(Inabilitytoprocesssensoryinformation)Ifleft-sideddeficitsarefound,askthepatientthefollowing:1-“Whosearmisthis”,whileshowingthemtheirleftarm.2-“Canyoumoveyourarm?”

● NODEFICIT=0(recognizesleftarmandacknowledgesleftarmweakness) ● MODERATE=1(doesnotrecognizeleftarmORdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness) ● SEVERE=2(doesnotrecognizeleftarmANDdoesnotacknowledgeleftarmweakness)

SCORE2

TOTALSCORE 8

TransportanypatientwithaRACEscore>5totheclosestComprehensiveStrokeCenterorinterventionalstrokecentercapableofmechanicalthrombectomywithastentretriever,ifprotocolsallow.

18

Page 21: apid rterial o clusion xam RACE - AmericanCME...symptoms of stroke, and improve stroke recognition in the field. Basically, these stroke scales identify that a stroke has occurred,

ContactAmericanCMEbyemailatAmericanCME@AmericanCME.comwithanyquestionsregardingthecontentsoftheRACESupplementalSkillGuide.

CitedReferences1. WadeS.Smith,MD,PhD;MichaelH.Lev,MD,FAHA;JoeyD.English,MD,PhD;EricaC.Camargo,MD,MMSc;Maggie

Chou;S.ClaiborneJohnston,MD,PhD;GilbertoGonzalez,MD,PhD;PamelaW.Schaefer,MD;WilliamP.Dillon,MD;WalterJ.Koroshetz,MD;KarenL.Furie,MD,MPH"SignificanceofLargeVesselIntracranialOcclusionCausingAcuteIschemicStrokeandTIA."Stroke(December,2009).Web.

2. Ossa,Natalia,MD,andDavidCarrera,MD."DesignandValidationofaPrehospitalStrokeScaletoPredictLargeArterialOcclusion."Stroke.AmericanHeartAssociation,26Nov.2013.Web.1Feb.2016.

19