“Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für...

25
Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen, Simon Glover (Heidelberg, Germany) Dominik Schleicher, Stefano Bovino (Göttingen, Germany) Christoph Federrath (Melbourne, Australia) Robi Banerjee (Hamburg, Germany) MFU IV, Playa del Carmen 2013

Transcript of “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für...

Page 1: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg

“Magnetic Fieldsin Young Galaxies”

Collaborators:

Ralf Klessen, Simon Glover (Heidelberg, Germany)Dominik Schleicher, Stefano Bovino (Göttingen, Germany)

Christoph Federrath (Melbourne, Australia)Robi Banerjee (Hamburg, Germany)

MFU IV, Playa del Carmen 2013

Page 2: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

1. Introduction

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 3: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

The First Stars and Galaxies

[http://www.wpclipart.com/space/stars_universe/universe_timeline_light.jpg.html]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 4: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

● turbulence driven by accretion and SN explosions

● weak magnetic seed fields

- phase transitions in the early Universe: [QCD phase transition, 10 Mpc comoving scale,e.g. Sigl et al. 1997]

- battery processes: [Biermann battery, kpc scale, e.g. Xu et al. 2008]

The First Stars and Galaxies

Fig.: Mach number in Primordial Halo[Greif et al. 2008]

=> dynamo action is possible

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 5: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

2. The Small-Scale Dynamo

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 6: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Small-Scale Dynamo

● definition: “small-scale dynamo”

Mechanism that converts turbulent kinetic energy into magnetic energy.

● depends strongly on environment:

- magnetic Prandtl number

- type of turbulence (in inertial range)

Kolmogorov Burgers (incompressible) (highly compressible)

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 7: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Stretch-Twist-Fold Dynamo

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

→ fastest on length scale with shortest eddy time scale = viscous scale (smallest scale of inertial range)

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 8: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 9: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 10: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 11: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

● magnetic field growth:

(from Kazantsev theory)

● growth rate on :

[see also: Bovino et al. 2013]

Kinematic Phase

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

[Schober et al. 2012a]

[Schober et al. 2012c]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 12: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 13: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 14: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 15: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● evolution of the spectrum (schematically):

● Fokker-Planck model (see e.g. Schekochihin 2002) with assumption that peak scale shifts on eddy time scale

● no more dependence on

● magnetic field growth:

[Schleicher et al. 2013]

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 16: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

3. Magnetic Fieldsin Young Galaxies

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 17: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● spherical core

● radius:

● density:

● temperature:

→ gas is ionised

● sources of turbulence:

- accretion

- SNe (not in this talk)

worst case assumption: compressive turbulence ( )

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Simple Model for Primordial Halo

Fig.: Density in the center of a protogalaxy. [Latif et al. 2012]

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 18: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

● viscosity:

● resistivity:

● sound speed:

● turbulent velocity:

Mach number percentage that goes into turbulence

(motivated by simulation of protogalaxies by Latif et al. 2012)

● Reynolds numbers:

(hydrodynamic)

(magnetic)

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

Simple Model for Primordial Halo“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 19: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Kinematic Phase

● kinematic growth of magnetic energy (on viscous scale):

● maximum field strength:

from equipartition efficiency factor for with kinetic energy Mach 2 and compressive forcing (Federrath et al. 2011) scaling velocity down to viscous scale

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 20: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Kinematic Phase

● kinematic growth of magnetic energy (on viscous scale):

● maximum field strength:

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

Page 21: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● non-linear growth of magnetic energy :

● maximum field strength on forcing scale:

from equipartition efficiency factor for with kinetic energy Mach 2 and compressive

forcing (Federrath et al. 2011)

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 22: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Non-Linear Phase

● non-linear growth of magnetic energy :

● maximum field strength on forcing scale:

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 23: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

4. Conclusions

“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 24: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

1. Introduction

2. Small-Scale Dynamo - Theory

3. Magnetic Fields in Primordial Halos

4. Conclusion

● dynamo amplification in kinematic phase:

● dynamo amplification in non-linear phase:

● small-scale dynamo in formation of first stars & galaxies:

Dynamical important magnetic fields can be generated on small time scales compared to free-fall time.

=> magnetisation of the primordial ISM

Conclusion“ B-Fields in Young

Galaxies”

J. Schober(ZAH Heidelberg)

Page 25: “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” · 2013. 3. 14. · Jennifer Schober Zentrum für Astronomie Heidelberg “Magnetic Fields in Young Galaxies” Collaborators: Ralf Klessen,

Thanks for your attention!

Further questions/comments?→ [email protected]