Annexure a Chart of Annexures Updated July 2010

8/6/2019 Annexure a Chart of Annexures Updated July 2010

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/annexure-a-chart-of-annexures-updated-july-2010 1/11

Annexure A: Independent Sources Corroborating Vigilante Violence of Salwa Judum

Y= confirms presence of violence etc. NA – not applicable, not focus of reportI = Nandini Sundar and ors (WP 250/2007), II= Kartam Joga and ors (WP 119/2007), Vol. 1 & Vol. 2 refer to paperbooks in 250/2007

Statutory Bodies and Commissions Appointed by Government

S.No. Name of Source Type Annexure/Pages Nos

Statesponsorshi

p

Violence(deaths,

rapes etc.)

ForcedInternment

in Camps

Minor SPOs &Other Violations

of internationalhumanitarian

laws

Recommendations

1. National Human

Rights

Commission

Report toSupreme

Court 2008

See full index Y Y Y Y Rehabilitation,compensation, further

enquiry

2. National

Commission forProtection of

Child Rights

NCPCR

factfinding

Report 2007by Shanta

Sinha, JM

Lyngdoh,

I, P/25, pg. 417,

Vol.2

II, P/14, Sept2007, pg. 107

NA p. 112 plus

testimonies

119-138

SJ burnt

villages,

forced peopleinto camps

Want adherence

to UNHCR

principles oninternal

displacement, II/

111

Recommendations related

to children; sent

testimonies on killing andrape to NHRC for action

3. National

Commission for

Women

Report and

covering

letter 2007

I, P/7, 239-246,

Vol. 1

Y Govt has

identified

itself with

SJ (p. 239)

People

caught in

between

SPOs look like

minors

Independent investigations

into violence against

women

4. NCW News reportcovering

NCW report

2007

II, P/15, Sept2007, pg. 147

Violationsagainst

women

Don’t recruit

youth as SPOs,

disrupts edu.

“

5. AP High Court Order

StayingForest

I, P/38, Feb

2008, pg. 491,Vol. 2

NA NA Shows

refugee prob.in AP

NA



department

burning of

IDP huts2007

6. Planning

Commission

Report of

the Expert

Group on

Development

Challenges

in Extremist

AffectedAreas, 2008

I, P/43, Oct

2008, pgs 49,

84

State

sponsorshi

p of

vigilantes

Y Y Y Calls it an abdication of

state responsibility, should

be undone immediately

7. Administrative

Reforms

Commission

7th report of

Admin

Reforms

CommissionVeerappa

Moily,

Chairman,

2008

II, P/27, March

2008, pg 234

Policy of

raising

local

resistancegroups

NA Camps

indicate

failure of

policy

NA Recommended disbanding

SJ, pg. 236

8. Ministry of Rural

Development

Cttee onState Agr.

Relations &

Unfinished

Task of Land

Reforms,

2009,

Chairman,Minister,

RD

Pg 160-161 of report, report

not annexed

Points tostate and

corporate

involveme

nt in SalwaJudum

Y Displacementbecause

corporate

want to grab

land

NA Tribal communities in SJ

camps must be resettled intheir occupied

land irrespective of the cutoff date under FRA (2006).

pg 15, recommendation 8.12



Annexed Documents showing Government sponsorship of Salwa Judum

S. No Name of document Annexure/page nos Remarks

1 Dantewada Collector’s Monthly Returns

and Police Daily Diaries

I, March 2009 aff.,

quoting NHRCannexures, pages 24-

30.

Shows participation by top ministers in SJ Rallies, funding of SJ etc.

2 NHRC Report Paras 1.37, 1.38,

5.04, 6.09

Shows participation of security forces in SJ rallies

2 Ministry of Home Affairs Annual Report I, P/ 1, May 2007, pg.

30, Vol. 1

States have been advised to form local resistance groups

3 MHA Status Paper on Naxal problem,

2006

I, P/2, May 2007, pg

10, Vol. 1

Govt advised to ensure safety of SJ activists

4. Minutes of Co-ordination Centre I, P/2, May 2007, pg.44, Vol. 1

CG Chief Secretary: will gear up SJ in 2 blocks before spreading; stateswill promote local resistance groups

5. Collector’s Work Proposal, 2005 I, P/3, May 2007, p.

44-75, Vol. 1; also in

NHRC annexures

Complete blueprint for Salwa Judum, with financial proposals; if

excesses take place, higher ups must keep silent (p. 58)

6. Hindu News Report, 14.7.2006 I, P/8, May 2007, pg247, Vol. 1

Raman Singh lauds Salwa Judum, calls it Gandhian movement

7. Gulf Times news report, 16.8.2007 II, P/1, Sept 2007, pg.

21

Raman Singh calls Salwa Judum holy battle; reiterates support to it

8. UNI report quoting DGP Chhattisgarh,

7.7.2007

II, P/7, Sept. 2007, pg

62-63

DGP describes SJ as success

9. Force magazine interview with Home

Minister, CG, Ram Vichar Netam, Aug.

2007

II, P/7, Sept 2007, pg

64-66

Describes SJ as non-violent war; says people are warned against leaving

camps

10. NewKerala News Report, 11.4.06 I, P/8, May 2007, pg248, Vol. 1

CG government temporarily suspends Salwa Judum

11. Lists of camps I, P/15, May 2007, pg Shows attempt to make camps permanent



271-286

12. Indian Express, 24.4.07 I, P/12, May 2007,

pg. 266, Vol. 1

CG police fudging data to project win, get rewards

13. Indian Express, 8.1.07 I, P/14, May 2007, pg

270, Vol. 1

CG police encouraging fake surrenders

14. Letter from CG PIO, 4.4.07 I, P/30, Feb 2008, pg.

462, Vol. 2

States that no criminal case has been filed against any SPO

15. Letter from Collector, Dantewada, 3.5.07 I, P/41, Feb. 2008, pg497, Vol. 2

Shows services to villages stopped after SJ, refers to SJ camps as ‘basecamps’

16. Zee News quoting CM supporting SJ,

26.1.09,

I, P/1, March 2009,

pg 41-43

CG Govt extends full support to SJ

17. Photos of SJ rally held at Konta, 24.2.06 I, P/11, March 2009,

pg 162-164

Shows participation of Senior Police/CRPF/Collector and MLA in SJ

rally

18. Hindu, News Report. 24.9.09 I, Anx A, Nov 2009,pg. 615-616

National Security Advisor defending Salwa Judum



Reported Statements and Interviews with Senior Ministers and Officials critical of Salwa Judum

S.No. Name of Source

Type Annexure/Pages Nos

StateSponsors

hip

Violence

(deaths,

rapes

etc.)

ForcedInternme

nt in

Camps

Minor SPOs& Other

Violations of

internationa

l

humanitarian laws

Recommendations

1. KPS Gill,

Former Security

Advisor toChhattisgarh

Government

Interview in

Tehelka, Oct

24, 2009

Not annexed Opposes Operation Green

Hunt, criticizes CG leadership

for wrong vision

2. Jairam Ramesh,

Union Minister

Hindu news

report, 9.9.07

I, P/22, Feb.,

2008, pg. 406,

Vol. 2II, P/11, March

2008, pg. 97

SJ formed

as an

outfitaimed at

people’s

participati

on

People

running

awayfrom SJ

Review SJ

3. PR Kyndiah,Minister Tribal

Affairs

News report,The

Telegraph,

22.7.06

I, P/23, Feb2008, pg. 408,

Vol. 2

II, P/12, March

2008, pg. 98

Armingtribals to

fight

tribals

wrong

Called for end to SJ

4. Ajit Jogi, former

CM

Signed article,

Indian

Express,30.6.06

I, P/24, Feb

2008, pg. 410,

Vol. 2II, P/13, March

2008, pg. 102

Mention

s large

scaleviolence

Compares

it to

Hitlerslebensrau

m

Stop SJ, disband camps



Fact-finding Reports by Independent Civil Society Organisations Annexed


Type Annexure/ Pages Nos

Statesponsor

ship

Violence(deaths,

rapes etc.)

ForcedInternment

in Camps

Minor SPOs& Other

Violations of

internationa

l

humanitarian laws

Recommendations

1. Human Rights

Watch

Being Neutral is

our Biggest

Crime, 2008

I, A-2, Oct

2008, p.

184-367

Y Y Y Y End Govt support to SJ, address impunity for

SJ and police abuses, protect and assista

persons displaced etc.

2. PUCL-PUDRreport

FactfindingReport, 2006

I, P/4, May2007, pg 76-

117, Vol. 1

92, 100-104

94-97 99-100 Minor SPOs End to SJ, enquiry, disband camps

3. IndependentCitizens

Initiative (BGVerghese and

ors)

Fact-findingreport, 2006

I,P/5, May2007, pg

118-189,Vol. 1

134-135 144-150 151-157 Minor SPOs;Violation of

GenevaConventions,

pg 162

End SJ, disband camps, enquiry, norecruitment of minors

4. All India

Women’s team

Factfinding report I, P/6, May

2007, pg.

190-238,Vol. 1

215-222 199-201 Minor SPOs End SJ, independent enquiry, disband SPOs

5. International

Association of

People’s

Lawyers

Factfinding

report, 2007

I, P/36, Feb.

2008, pg.

476, Vol. 2

Y 116 117 118 End SJ, dismantle camps, allow enquiry

6.. Medico FriendsCircle and Jan

Swasthya

Abhiyan

Factfinding reporton medical

conditions, 2007

II, P/17,March

2008, pg.

159

171 162-3, 167 Close camps, restore services to villages,public health enquiry



7. Independent

team of Women

Professionals

Factfinding on

rapes and violence

against women,Oct 7-10, 2008

I, P/9,

March 2009

affidavit,pg. 127-158

Y Y Y Y Immediate closure of SJ camps, disbanding

of SPOs, enquiry into all deaths etc.



Some News Reports on Salwa Judum which have been annexed


Type Annexure/PagesNos

Statesponsorship

Violence(deaths,

rapes

etc.)

ForcedInternment

in Camps

Minor SPOs& Other

Violations of

international

humanitarian

laws

Recommendations

1 BBC Detailed news

coverage,

30.6.06

I, P/31, Feb.

2008, pg. 463,

Vol. 2

Y Y Y SJ forcing people to camps

2 Guardian Detailed

reportage, 9.5.06

I, P/32, Feb.

2008, pg. 467,Vol. 2

Y Y Y SJ violent

3 Le Monde

Diplomatique

Reportage,

1.2.08

II, P/16, March

2008, pg. 149

Y Y Y Y SJ - state terrorism

4 Economist Reportage,

17.8.06

II, P/19, March

2008, pg. 185

Y Y Y Y SJ - scorched earth policy

5. Outlook Reportage,

15.5.06

II, P/18, March

2008, pg. 181

Y Y Y SJ led to displacement

6. Down to Earth Reportage,31.10.06

II, P/20, March2008, pg. 192

Y Y Y Y SJ causing displacement

7. Siddharth

Varadarajan,

The Hindu

Editorial Article,

8.9.07

II/P10, Sept.

2007, pg 72

Y Y Y Y End SJ

8. Pratap Mehta,

President,Centre for

Policy

Research

Indian Express,

Op-Ed article,8.2.08

I, P/28, Feb.

2008, pg 454,Vol. 2

II, P/23, pg, 209

Y Y Y Y End SJ

9. Ajay Sahni,

Inst. for Conf.Management

Indian Express,

Op-ed Article,2.3.06

I, P/26, Feb.

2008, pg. 447,Vol 2

Y Y Y End SJ



10. Bijo Francis,

UPIAsiaonline

Op-ed article,

29.1.08

I, P/29,

Feb.2008, pg.

458, Vol. 2

Y Y Y End SJ

11. Times of IndiaEditorial

Editorial, 8.2.08 II, P/21, March2008, pg 206

SG is vigilantism

12. The Hindu Editorial,

30.5.07

II, P/22, March

2008, pg. 208

Enormous social damage

13. The Hindu News report,10.1.09

I, P 8, March2009, p. 111

Y Y Exposes SPOs killing of civilians inSingaram, 8.1.09

14. Mail Today News Report,

7.12.08

I, P 8, March

2009, p. 113

Y Y False encounter in Singaram

15. HindustanTimes

News Report,11.1.09

I, P 8, March2009, p. 115

Y Y Fake encounter in Singaram

16. Tehelka News Report,

7.2.09

I, March 2009,

P 8, pg. 117

Y Y Fake encounter in Singaram

17. The Hindu News Report,

24.3.10

I, 31 March

2010, Anx A

Schools occupied by CRPF

18. Outlook News report,

22.2.10

I, March 2010, p

44-45

Y Y Y Y Bloodbath in Bastar

19. Tehelka Interviews/news,

6.2.10

I, March 2010, p

52-61

Y Y Y Y We the non-people

20. Tehelka News/interviews,

13.2.10

I, March 2010, p

62-65

Y Y Y Y A struggle to find new memories

21. The Hindu News/analysis,

6.2.10

I, March 2010,

pg. 66

Y Y Y Y Green Hunt killings

22. New Indian

Express

News report,

25.11.09

I, March 2010,

pg. 67-68

Y Y Y Y Attack on village and arson

23. Nai Duniya News, 6.1.10 I, March 2010,

pg. 76

Shows state support for absconding

SJ leader



Photos which have been annexed as evidence

S.No. Type of Photo and date taken Annexure/page nos Remarks

1 SPOs and Salwa Judum (SJ), Feb. 2006 I, P/9, Sept 2007, p. 250,Vol. 1

Armed with guns

2 SPOs and Salwa Judum, Feb. 2006 I, P/9, Sept. 2007, p. 251,

Vol. 1

Armed with guns

3 SPOs and memorials to them, May 2006, 2008 I, p/9, Sept 2007, p. 252,

Vol.1;

I, P/33, Feb. 2008, 470,

P/34, 471, Vol. 2

Photos of minor SPOs; Police memorials to SPOs

revealing real age contra to fudged data

4 Women displaying SJ style of beating, May2006

I, P/13, May 2007, pg 268,Vol. 1

Violence against women

5 Women in Mookabelli village, 2005 I, P/13, May 2007, pg 269,

Vol. 1

Women killed by SJ

6 Burnt houses, 2007 I, P/16, May 2007, pg 287,

288, Vol. 1II, P/5, Sept. 2007, pg 53-54

Arson by SJ

7 Condition of relief camps, 2007 I, P/16, May 2007, pg. 289-

290, Vol. 1

Internal Displacement

8 Refugee settlements in AP, 2007 II, P/5, Sept. 2007, pg 55 Internal Displacement

9. SJ rally held at Konta, 24.2.06 I, P/11, March 2009, pg 162-

164

Shows participation of Senior Police/CRPF/Collector

and MLA in SJ rally, SPO mob armed with guns

10. Houses burnt at Vechapal village, June 2009 I, Aug 09, P/7-8, pg. 597,

Vol. 2

Houses burnt by CRPF and SPOs/SJ, June 2009

11. Attack on village Tatemadagu, 9.11.09 I, March 2010, P/3, pg. 69-70

Houses burnt by security forces and SPOs, November2009

12. Absconding Salwa Judum leader Soyam Mooka

openly leading a demonstration, Jan 2010

I, March 2010, P/4, pg 76 Shows police refusal to implement court orders against

Salwa Judum accused

13. School and ashram in village Bhatpal occupied

by security forces, Feb 2010

I, March 2010, P/5, pg. 77 Shows CG perjury before SC, refusal to vacate schools

despite claiming this in Court

14. Malnourished children, AP, March 2010 I, March 2010, P/6, p. 78 Condition of IDPs in AP

Annexure a Chart of Annexures Updated July 2010

Documents

Transcript of Annexure a Chart of Annexures Updated July 2010